Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

Section148: Reassessment — Notice — against company that has been successfully resolved under a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (“CIRP”) under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”)— effect of resolution of a corporate debtor is that the terms of resolution bind tax authorities and their enforcement actions.

16 Uttam Galva Metallics Ltd. and Mr. SubodhKarmarkar vs. Asst. CIT

WP(L) No. 9421 OF 2022

A. Y.: 2016-17

Dated: 28th August, 2024 (Bom) (HC)

Section148: Reassessment — Notice — against company that has been successfully resolved under a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (“CIRP”) under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”)— effect of resolution of a corporate debtor is that the terms of resolution bind tax authorities and their enforcement actions.

The Petitioner-Assessee was admitted into a CIRP by an order dated 11th July, 2018 passed by the National Company Law Tribunal, New Delhi (“NCLT”). Various processes under the IBC were undertaken. Eventually, the company came to be resolved pursuant to a resolution plan finalised by the Committee of Creditors, and approved by the NCLT under Section 31 of the IBC by an order dated 6th May, 2021. The resolution plan, as approved by the NCLT, entails a full waiver of all tax and tax-related interest dues pertaining to the period prior to commencement of the CIRP.

On 27th March, 2021 i.e., well after the resolution plan was approved, the Revenue issued a notice under Section 148 of the Act seeking to initiate reassessment of the Petitioner-Assessee’s income for AY 2016-17, on the premise that income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment. On 26th October, 2021, the Revenue issued a communication containing reasons for initiating the said reassessment. It was stated that the original assessment of the Petitioner-Assessee had been completed on December 28, 2018 in terms of the loss of ₹220.25 crores as returned by the Petitioner-Assessee. Thereafter, the Revenue had conducted survey proceedings against some companies and had reason to believe that dealings by the Petitioner-Assessee with those companies could have led to income in the sum of ₹111.28 crores escaping assessment.

On 19th November, 2021, the Petitioner-Assessee submitted its objections, specifically asserting that after approval of a resolution plan under Section 31 of the IBC, the Petitioner-Assessee had begun on a new slate with all past claims and dues being extinguished in terms of the resolution plan. The Petitioner-Assessee made submissions on the import of Section 31 of the IBC and various case law interpreting the IBC. The Petitioner-Assessee also called upon the Revenue to share the documents and material relating to the sanction of reassessment proceedings, under Section 151 of the Act.

Thereafter, on 15th February, 2022 the Petitioner-Assessee called for a speaking order on the objections raised by it. On 18th February, 2022, the Revenue passed an order, rejecting all the objections raised by the Petitioner-Assessee and asserted that while recovery may be impermissible, prosecution of the erstwhile management and recovery from other persons would still be permissible. On such premise, the Revenue refused to drop reassessment proceedings against the Petitioner-Assessee. Pursuant to such rejection of the objections, the Revenue issued a notice dated 12th March, 2022 calling upon the Petitioner-Assessee to furnish various details by 21st March, 2022.

Being aggrieved by the Revenue persisting with the reassessment proceedings despite the successful resolution of the Petitioner-Assessee, the Petitioner-Assessee, invoked the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, for quashing and setting aside of the impugned proceedings including all notices and communications received from the Revenue.

The Petitioner contended that Section 31 of the IBC explicitly makes the resolution plan binding on the Revenue. The Petitioner-Assessee has also submitted that the law declared by the Supreme Court, interpreting Section 31 of the IBC fully covers the position that the Petitioner-Assessee is in, namely, that a corporate debtor after being resolved, starts with a clean slate and cannot be pursued for past tax claims.

The Revenue opposing the Petition contended that once the CIRP came to an end (with the approval of the resolution plan), the moratorium on initiating and continuing proceedings against the Petitioner-Assessee too came to an end. Therefore, according to the Revenue, the power of the Revenue to continue proceedings against the Petitioner-Assessee would revive. The Revenue quoted from orders of the Supreme Court passed during the course pending CIRP proceedings, when dealing with the import of the moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC, to argue that the approval of the resolution plan can have no bearing on the power of the Revenue to pursue proceedings in relation to past tax claims. The Revenue also argued that there is nothing inconsistent between the IBC and the Act for the non-obstinate provisions in the IBC to have any relevance.

Section 31(1) of IBC and its import:

They are extracted below:

“31. (1) If the Adjudicating Authority is satisfied that the resolution plan as approved by the committee of creditors under sub-section (4) of section 30 meets the requirements as referred to in sub-section (2) of section 30, it shall by order approve the resolution plan which shall be binding on the corporate debtor and its employees, members, creditors, including the Central Government, any State Government or any local authority to whom a debt in respect of the payment of dues arising under any law for the time being in force, such as authorities to whom statutory dues are owed, guarantors and other stakeholders involved in the resolution plan.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

The court observed that even a plain reading of the foregoing would show that once the Adjudicating Authority (the NCLT) approves the resolution plan, it would be binding on, among others, the Central Government and its agencies in respect of payment of any statutory dues arising under any law for the time being in force. It is now trite law that the effect of resolution of a corporate debtor is that the terms of resolution bind tax authorities and their enforcement actions — a position in law declared in numerous judgments of the Supreme Court. The judgment in Ghanshyam Mishra and Sons Private Limited vs.. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company  Limited [(2021) 9 SCC 657](Ghanshyam Mishra) comprehensively summarises the import of various judgments on the point.

The court held that, it is crystal clear that once a resolution plan is duly approved under Section 31(1) of the IBC, the debts as provided for in the resolution plan alone shall remain payable and such position shall be binding on, among others, the Central Government and various authorities, including tax authorities. All dues which are not part of the resolution plan would stand extinguished and no person would be entitled to initiate or continue any proceedings in respect of any claim for any such due. No proceedings in respect of any dues relating to the period prior to the approval of the resolution plan can be continued or initiated.

Thus, there can be no manner of doubt that the Impugned Proceedings and their continuation against the Petitioner-Assessee are wholly misconceived and untenable. The Impugned Proceedings are essentially reassessment proceedings, and that too of AY 2016-17. Evidently, such proceedings pertain to the period prior to the approval of the resolution plan. The outcome of such proceedings, particularly if adverse to the Petitioner-Assessee, would clearly be in relation to tax claims for the period prior to the approval of the resolution plan. The resolution plan came to be approved on 6th May, 2020. Any attempt to re-agitate the assessment for AY 2016-17, evidently and squarely, constitutes pursuit of claims for the period prior to even the initiation of the CIRP. The conduct of such proceedings would be directly in conflict with the law declared in Ghanshyam Mishra, which makes it clear that continuation of existing proceedings and initiation of new proceedings that relate to operations prior to the CIRP are totally prohibited after the approval of the resolution plan. Consequently, nothing in the Impugned Proceedings can legitimately survive.

Evidently and admittedly, the reassessment proceedings pre-date the CIRP. They would relate to the period prior to the approval of the resolution plan of the Petitioner-Assessee, and therefore stand extinguished. Upon completion of the CIRP, the Petitioner-Assessee has completely changed hands and has begun on a clean slate under new ownership and management.

Consequently, all the notices and communications issued by the Revenue in connection with the Impugned Proceedings, and the consequential actions as impugned in the Writ Petition were quashed and set aside.

Section 119(2): CBDT — Condonation of delay in filing the return of income — the Chartered Accountant of assessee was in a situation of distress due to the ill-health of his wife — genuine human problems may prevent a person from achieving such compliances — sufficient cause for condonation of delay.

15 Jyotsna M. Mehta vs. Pr. CIT – 19

WP(L) No. 17939 of 2024

Dated: 4th September, 2024 (Bom) (HC).

Section 119(2): CBDT — Condonation of delay in filing the return of income — the Chartered Accountant of assessee was in a situation of distress due to the ill-health of his wife — genuine human problems may prevent a person from achieving such compliances — sufficient cause for condonation of delay.

The application filed by the Assessees / Petitioners  under section 119(2)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961  praying for condonation of delay in filing the return of income. The Petitioners are members of one family. Their accounts and all issues in relation to their income-tax returns were handled by a Chartered Accountant, who could not take timely steps on account of ill health of his spouse. For such reason, the returns of the Petitioners could not be filed within the stipulated time.

The Petitioners contended that they were fully dependent on the Chartered Accountant in all respects from the finalisation of the accounts as also in taking steps to file their respective returns. They contend that there was a genuine reason on the delay caused to the petitioners to file returns, as the Chartered Accountant was in a situation of distress due to the ill-health of his wife, keeping him away from the Petitioners professional work.

In such circumstances, the petitioners filed an application under section 119(2)(b) of the Act praying for condonation of delay in filing of their returns; setting out such reason, which according to the petitioner, was bonafide and a legitimate cause, requiring the delay to be condoned in the filing of the petitioners’ returns. The petitioners also submitted all the medical papers in support of their contentions that the case as made for condonation of delay was bonafide / genuine as reflected from the medical papers. The PCIT disbelieved the petitioners’ case and observed that the reasons are not genuine reasons preventing the petitioners from filing Income-tax returns. In recording such observations, the PCIT has not recorded any reasons as to why the documents as submitted by the petitioner were disbelieved by him, and / or the case of the petitioners was not genuine. Also, there is no contrary material on record, that the petitioner’s case on such ground was required to be rejected.

The Hon Court observed that the approach of PCIT appears to be quite mechanical, who ought to have been more sensitive to the cause which was brought before him when the petitioner prayed for condonation of delay.

The Hon Court further observed that it can never be that technicalities and rigidity of rules of law would not recognise genuine human problems of such nature, which may prevent a person from achieving such compliances. It is to cater to such situations the legislature has made a provision conferring a power to condone delay. These are all human issues and which may prevent the assessee who is otherwise diligent in filing returns, within the prescribed time. The PCIT is not consistent in the reasons when the cause which the petitioners has urged in their application for condonation of delay was common.

The Court further observed that it would have been quite different if there were reasons available on record of the PCIT that the case on delay in filing returns as urged by the petitioners was false, and / or totally unacceptable. It needs no elaboration that in matters of maintaining accounts and filing of returns, the assessees are most likely to depend on the professional services of their Chartered Accountants. Once a Chartered Accountant is engaged and there is a genuine dependence on his services, such as in the present case, whose personal difficulties had caused a delay in filing of the petitioners returns, was certainly a cause beyond the control of the petitioners / assessees. In these circumstances, the assessee, being at no fault, should have been the primary consideration of the PCIT. It also cannot be overlooked that any professional, for reasons which are not within the confines of human control, by sheer necessity of the situation can be kept away from the professional work and despite his best efforts, it may not be possible for him to attend the same. The reasons can be manifold like illness either of himself or his family members, as a result of which he was unable to timely discharge his professional obligation. There could also be a likelihood that for such reasons, of impossibility of any services being provided / performed for his clients when tested on acceptable materials. Such human factors necessarily require a due consideration when it comes to compliances of the time limits even under the Income-tax Act. The situation in hand is akin to what a Court would consider in legal proceedings before it, in condoning delay in filing of proceedings. In dealing with such situations, the Courts would not discard an empathetic /humane view of the matter in condoning the delay in filing legal proceedings, when law confers powers to condone the delay in the litigant pursuing Court proceedings. Such principles which are quite paramount and jurisprudentially accepted are certainly applicable, when the assessee seeks condonation of delay in filing income tax returns, so as to remove the prejudice being caused to him, so as to regularise his returns. In fact, in this situation, to not permit an assessee to file his returns, is quite counter-productive to the very object and purpose, the tax laws intend to achieve. In this view of the matter, the Hon court held that the delay was sufficiently explained and to be condoned.

Revision — Powers of Commissioner — Assessee inadvertently filing data of next assessment year instead of relevant assessment year — Intimation u/s. 143(1) — Application for revision rejected only on the ground that intimation is not an order — Inadvertance of the Assessee not with a malafide intention to evade tax — Orders, intimation and communication set aside — Matter remanded to Principal Commissioner for de novo enquiry and fresh consideration.

51 DiwakerTripathi vs. PCIT

[2024] 466 ITR 371 (Bom)

A. Y. 2013-14

Date of order: 29th August, 2023

S. 143(1), 154 and 264 of ITA 1961

Revision — Powers of Commissioner — Assessee inadvertently filing data of next assessment year instead of relevant assessment year — Intimation u/s. 143(1) — Application for revision rejected only on the ground that intimation is not an order — Inadvertance of the Assessee not with a malafide intention to evade tax — Orders, intimation and communication set aside — Matter remanded to Principal Commissioner for de novo enquiry and fresh consideration.

The Assessee, an individual, filed his return of income for A.Y. 2013-14 on 28th March, 2015 declaring total income at ₹12,48,160. While filing the return of income, the Assessee mistook the assessment year to be the financial year and filled in all the details of income for the A. Y. 2014-15 in the return of income for the A. Y. 2013-14. In the intimation u/s. 143(1), the AO did not grant credit for tax deducted at source by one of his two employers but granted credit of the
tax deducted at source by the employer for the A. Y. 2013-14 though not claimed by the Assessee in his return. Thereafter, the Assessee filed his return of income for the A. Y. 2014-15 showing the correct income.

The Assessee filed a revised return of income u/s. 139(4) instead of u/s. 139(5) and filed an application u/s. 264 for the A. Y. 2013-14. The application u/s. 264 was rejected only on the ground that the intimation u/s. 143(1) was not an order. According to the Principal Commissioner, the income of an assessee was dependent on the sources he had, the head under which it was assessed, special rate and applicable if any and that determination of income of any assessee was an exercise which involved deep scrutiny and could not be merely substituted by acceptance of the income claimed by the assessee and determination of total income of the assessee could not be the mandate of section 264. The Assessee filed an application u/s. 154 for rectification of the order passed u/s. 264 which was also rejected.

The Bombay High Court allowed the writ petition filed by the assessee challenging the orders and held as follows:

“i) The power conferred u/s. 264 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is wide and the Commissioner is duty bound to apply his mind to the application filed by the assessee and pass such order thereon. Section 264 also empowers the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner to call for the record of any proceedings under the Act in which any order has been passed and make such inquiry or cause such inquiry to be made and pass such order as he thinks fit. Therefore, if he is of the opinion that a detailed inquiry is necessary and he will be hard pressed for time, he may cause such inquiry made by the Assessing Officer and direct the Assessing Officer to file a report.

ii) The assessee’s inadvertence in filling the details of the A. Y. 2014-15 in his return of income for the A. Y. 2013-14 was not a deliberate mistake or an attempt to gain some unfair advantage or to evade tax. Therefore, the orders passed u/s. 264 and section 154 and the intimation issued u/s. 143(1) were quashed and set aside and the matter was remanded for de novo consideration to the Principal Commissioner to dispose of the assessee’s application u/s. 264 on the merits. He could make any inquiry as he deemed fit or cause any inquiry to be made by the Assessing Officer after giving personal hearing to the assessee for clarification or explanation and thereafter pass a speaking order considering every submission of the assessee.”

From Published Accounts

COMPILERS’ NOTE

Accounting for real estate projects, joint development agreements and related inventory is governed by Ind AS 115. Companies follow varied policies for such accounting. Looking to the nature of activities in the industry and uncertainties, auditors also mention the above matters in Key Audit Matters in their reports. Given below are illustrations of disclosures in three large companies for the year ended 31st March, 2024 for the above.

DLF LIMITED

From Auditors’ Report

From Material accounting policies (extracts)

Revenue from contracts or services with customers and other streams of revenue

Revenue from contracts with customers is recognised when control of the goods or services is transferred to the customer at an amount that reflects the consideration to which the Company expects to be entitled in exchange for those goods or services. The Company has generally concluded that it is the principal in its revenue arrangements because it typically controls the goods and services before transferring them to the customers.

The disclosures of significant accounting judgements, estimates and assumptions relating to revenue from contracts with customers are provided in note 2.2(bb).

i. Revenue from Contracts with Customers:

Revenue is measured at the fair value of the consideration received / receivable, taking into account contractually defined terms of payment and excluding taxes or duties collected on behalf of the government, and is net of rebates and discounts. The Company assesses its revenue arrangements against specific criteria to determine if it is acting as principal or agent. The Company has concluded that it is acting as a principal in all of its revenue arrangements.

Revenue is recognised in the statement of profit and loss to the extent that it is probable that the economic benefits will flow to the Company and the revenue and costs, if applicable, can be measured reliably.

The Company has applied a five-step model as per Ind AS 115 ‘Revenue from contracts with customers’ to recognise revenue in the standalone financial statements. The Company satisfies a performance obligation and recognises revenue over time, if one of the following criteria is met:

a) The customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits provided by the Company’s performance as the Company performs; or

b) The Company’s performance creates or enhances an asset that the customer controls as the asset is created or enhanced; or

c) The Company’s performance does not create an asset with an alternative use to the Company and the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date.

For performance obligations where any of the above conditions is not met, revenue is recognised at the point in time at which the performance obligation is satisfied.

Revenue is recognised either at a point of time or over a period of time based on various conditions as included in the contracts with customers.

Point of Time:

Revenue from real-estate projects

Revenue is recognised at the Point in Time w.r.t. sale of real estate units, including land, plots, apartments, commercial units, development rights including development agreements as and when the control passes on to the customer which coincides with handing over of the possession to the customer.

Incremental cost of obtaining contract

The incremental cost of obtaining a contract with a customer is recognised as an asset if the Company expects to recover those costs subject to other conditions of the standard being met. These costs are charged to statement of profit and loss in accordance with the transfer of the property to the customer.

Over a period of time:

Revenue is recognised over period of time for following stream of revenues:

Revenue from Co-development projects

Co-development projects where the Company is acting as contractor, revenue is recognised in accordance with the terms of the co-developer agreements. Under such contracts, assets created do not have an alternative use for the Company, and the Company has an enforceable right to payment. The estimated project cost includes construction cost, development and construction material, internal development cost, external development charges, borrowing cost and overheads of such project.

The estimates of the saleable area and costs are reviewed periodically and effect of any changes in such estimates is recognised in the period in which such changes are determined. However, when the total project cost is estimated to exceed total revenues from the project, the loss is recognised immediately.

Construction and fit-out projects

Construction and fit-out projects where the Company is acting as contractor, revenue is recognised in accordance with the terms of the construction agreements. Under such contracts, assets created do not have an alternative use, and the Company has an enforceable right to payment. The estimated project cost includes construction cost, development and construction material and overheads of such project.

The Company uses cost-based input method for measuring progress for performance obligation satisfied over time. Under this method, the Company recognises revenue in proportion to the actual project cost incurred as against the total estimated project cost. The management reviews and revises its measure of progress periodically and is considered as change in estimates and accordingly, the effect of such changes in estimates are recognised prospectively in the period in which such changes are determined. However, when the total project cost is estimated to exceed total revenues from the project, the loss is recognised immediately.

As the outcome of the contracts cannot be measured reliably during the early stages of the project, contract revenue is recognised only to the extent of costs incurred in the statement of profit and loss.

Revenue from golf course operations

Income from golf course operations, capitation, sponsorship, etc., is fixed and recognised as per the management agreement with the parties, as and when Company satisfies performance obligation by delivering the promised goods or services as per contractual agreed terms.

Rental and Maintenance income

Revenue in respect of rental and maintenance services is recognised on an accrual basis, in accordance with the terms of the respective contract as and when the Company satisfies performance obligations by delivering the services as per contractual agreed terms.

Other operating income

Income from forfeiture of properties and interest from banks and customers under agreements to sell is accounted for on an accrual basis except in cases where ultimate collection is considered doubtful.

ii. Volume rebates and early payment rebates

The Company provides move in rebates / early payment rebates / down payment rebates to the customers. Rebates are offset against amounts payable by the customer and revenue to be recognised. To estimate the variable consideration for the expected future rebates, the Company estimates the expected value of rebates that is likely to be incurred in future and recognises the revenue net of rebates and the refund liability for expected future rebates.

Inventories

  • Land and plots other than area transferred to constructed properties at the commencement of construction are valued at lower of cost / as re-valued on conversion to stock and net realisable value. Cost includes land (including development rights and land under agreement to purchase) acquisition cost, borrowing cost if inventorisation criteria are met, estimated internal development costs and external development charges and other directly attributable costs.
  • Construction work-in-progress of constructed properties other than Special Economic Zone (SEZ) projects includes the cost of land (including development rights and land under agreements to purchase), internal development costs, external development charges, construction costs, overheads, borrowing cost if inventorisation criteria are met, development / construction materials and is valued at lower of cost / estimated cost and net realisable value.
  • In case of SEZ projects, construction work-in-progress of constructed properties includes internal development costs, external development charges, construction costs, overheads, borrowing cost if inventorisation criteria are met, development / construction materials and is valued at lower of cost / estimated cost and net realisable value.
  • Development rights represent amount paid under agreement to purchase land / development rights and borrowing cost incurred by the Company to acquire irrevocable and exclusive licenses / development rights in the identified land and constructed properties, the acquisition of which is either completed or is at an advanced stage. These are valued at lower of cost and net realisable value.
  • Construction / development material is valued at lower of cost and net realisable value. Cost comprises purchase price and other costs incurred in bringing the inventories to their present location and condition.
  • Stocks for maintenance facilities (including stores and spares) are valued at cost or net realisable value, whichever is lower.

Cost is determined on weighted-average basis.

Net realisable value is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less estimated costs of completion and estimated costs necessary to make the sale.

MACROTECH DEVELOPERS LIMITED

From Auditors’ Report

Key audit matters How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Revenue Recognition for Real Estate Projects
Refer Note 1(III)(11) of standalone financial statements with respect to the accounting policies followed by the Company for recognising revenue from sale of residential and commercial properties. The Company applies Ind AS 115 “Revenue from contracts with customers” for recognition of revenue from sale of commercial and residential real estate, which is being recognised at a point in time / over the time depending upon the Company, satisfying its performance obligation under the contract with the customer, and the control of the underlying asset gets transferred to the customer. Significant judgement / estimation is involved in identifying performance obligations for revenue recognition under point in time and over the time methods. Determining when control of the asset underlying the performance obligation is transferred to the customer and estimating stage of completion, basis which revenue is recognised as per Ind AS 115, has been considered as a key audit matter

 

Our audit procedures in respect of this area, among others, included the following:

 

• Read the Company’s revenue recognition accounting policies and evaluated the appropriateness of the same with respect to principles of Ind AS 115 and their application to the significant customer contracts;

 

• Obtained and understood the Company’s process for revenue recognition including identification of performance obligations and determination of transfer of control of the property to the customer;

 

• Evaluated the design and implementation and verified, on a test check basis, the operating effectiveness of key internal controls over revenue recognition, including controls around transfer of control of the property and calculation of revenue recognition, which is based on various factors including contract price, total budgeted cost and actual cost incurred;

 

• Obtained and read the legal opinion taken by the Company and provided to us to determine timing when the control gets transferred in accordance with the underlying agreements.

 

• Verified the sample of revenue contract for sale of residential and commercial units to identify the performance obligations of the Company under these contracts and assessed whether these performance obligations are satisfied over time or at a point in time based on the criteria specified under Ind AS 115;

 

• Verified, on a test check basis, revenue transaction with the underlying customer contract, Occupancy Certificates (OC) and other documents evidencing the transfer of control of the asset to the customer based on which the revenue is recognised;

 

• Verified, on a test check basis, budgeted cost of certain projects, actual cost incurred, balance cost to be incurred and recomputed stage of project completion based on which the revenue is recognised; and

 

• Assessed the adequacy and appropriateness of the disclosures made in standalone financial statements in compliance with the requirements of Ind AS 115 ‘Revenue from contracts with customers’.

Inventory Valuation
Refer Note 1(III)(5) to the standalone financial statements which includes the accounting policies followed by the Company for valuation of inventory.

 

The Company’s properties under development and completed properties are stated at the lower of cost and NRV.

 

As of 31st March, 2024, the Company’s properties under development and inventory of completed properties amount to ₹2,92,454 million and ₹34,883 million, respectively.

 

Determination of the NRV involves estimates based on prevailing market conditions, current prices, and expected date of commencement and completion of the project, the estimated future selling price, cost to complete projects and selling costs.

 

The cost of the inventory is calculated using actual land acquisition costs, construction costs, development-related costs and interest capitalised for eligible project.

 

We have considered the valuation of inventory as a key audit matter on account of the significance of the balance to the standalone financial statements and involvement of significant judgement in estimating future selling prices and costs to complete the project.

Our audit procedures in respect of this area, among others, included the following:

 

• Obtained an understanding of the Management’s process and methodology of using key assumptions for determining the valuation of inventory as at the year-end;

 

• Evaluated the design and implementation and verified, on a test check basis, operating effectiveness of controls over preparation and update of NRV workings and related to the Company’s review of key estimates, including estimated future selling prices and costs of completion for property development projects;

 

• Assessed the appropriateness of the selling price estimated by the management and verified the same on a test check basis by comparing the estimated selling price to recent market prices in the same projects or comparable properties;

 

• Compared the estimated construction cost to complete the project with the Company’s updated budgets; and

 

• Assessed the adequacy and appropriateness of the disclosures made in the standalone financial statements with respect to inventory in compliance with the requirements of applicable Indian Accounting Standards and applicable financial reporting framework.

 

From Material Accounting Policies

Revenue Recognition (extracts)

The Company has applied five-step model as set out in Ind AS 115 to recognise revenue in this financial statement. The specific revenue recognition criteria are described below:

i. Income from Property Development

Revenue is recognised on satisfaction of performance obligation upon transfer of control of promised goods (residential or commercial units) or services to customers in an amount that reflects the consideration the Company expects to receive in exchange for those goods or services.

The Company satisfies the performance obligation and recognises revenue over time, if one of the following criteria is met:

  • The customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits provided by the Company’s performance as the Company performs; or
  • The Company’s performance creates or enhances an asset that the customer controls as the asset is created or enhanced; or
  • The Company’s performance does not create an asset with an alternative use to the Company and an entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date.

For performance obligations where any one of the above conditions is not met, revenue is recognised at the point in time at which the performance obligation is satisfied. Revenue is recognised either at the point of time or over a period of time based on the conditions in the contracts with customers. The Company determines the performance obligations associated with the contract with customers at contract inception and also determines whether they satisfy the performance obligation over time or at a point in time.

The Company recognises revenue for performance obligation satisfied over time only if it can reasonably measure its progress towards complete satisfaction of the performance obligation.

The Company uses cost-based input method for measuring progress for performance obligation satisfied over time. Under this method, the Company recognises revenue in proportion to the actual project cost incurred as against the total estimated project cost.

In respect of contracts with customers which do not meet the criteria to recognise revenue over a period of time, revenue is recognised at the point in time with respect to such contracts for sale of residential and commercial units as and when the control is passed on to the customers which is linked to the application and receipt of occupancy certificate.

Revenue is recognised net of discounts, rebates, credits, price concessions, incentives, etc. if any.

ii. Sale of Materials, Land and Development Rights

Revenue is recognised at the point in time with respect to contracts for sale of Materials, Land and Development Rights as and when the control is passed on to the customers.

iii. Others Operating Revenue

Revenue from facility management service is recognised at value of service on accrual basis as and when the performance obligation is satisfied

Inventories

Stock of Building Materials and Traded Goods is valued at lower of cost and NRV. Cost is generally ascertained on a weighted average basis.

Finished Stock is valued at lower of Cost and NRV.

Land and Property Development Work-in-Progress is valued at lower of estimated cost and NRV.

Cost for this purpose includes cost of land, shares with occupancy rights, Transferrable Development Rights, premium for development rights, borrowing costs, construction / development cost and other overheads incidental to the projects undertaken.

NRV is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less estimated cost of completion and the estimated cost necessary to make the sale.

SHRIRAM PROPERTIES LIMITED

From Auditors’ Report:

Key Audit Matters

Revenue recognition for real estate projects
The Company applies Ind AS 115 ‘Revenue from Contracts with Customers’ for recognition of revenue from real estate projects. Refer notes 1.2(g), 23 and 45 to the standalone financial statements for accounting policy and related disclosures.

 

For the sale of constructed properties, revenue is recognised by the Company as per the requirements of Ind AS 115 over a period of time and is being recognised in the financial year when sale deeds are registered with the revenue authorities of the prevailing State as the management considers that the contract becomes binding on both the parties only upon registering the sale deed, as until such registration, the customer has the right to cancel the contract without compensating the Company for the costs incurred along with a reasonable margin (as specified in Ind AS 115).

 

Significant judgments are required in identifying the contract obligations, determining when the obligations are completed and recognising revenue over a period of time. Further, for determining revenue using percentage of completion method, budgeted project cost is a critical estimate, which is subject to inherent uncertainty as it requires ascertainment of progress of the project, cost incurred till date and balance cost to be incurred to complete the project.

 

For revenue contract forming part of Joint Development Arrangements (JDA), the arrangement comprises sale of development rights in lieu of construction services provided by the Developer and transfer of constructed area and / or revenue sharing arrangement based on the standalone selling price, which is measured at the fair value of the estimated construction service. Significant estimates are used by the Company in determining the fair value of ‘non-cash consideration’, i.e., receipt of development rights in lieu of the construction service and recognising revenue using percentage of completion method.

 

Considering the significance of management judgement involved and the materiality of amounts involved, revenue recognition was identified as a key audit matter for the current year audit.

Our audit procedures included but were not limited to the following:

 

• Evaluated the appropriateness of accounting policy for revenue recognition of the Company in terms of principles enunciated under Ind AS 115;

 

• Evaluated the design and implementation of Company’s key financial controls in respect of revenue recognition around transfer of control and tested the operating effectiveness of such controls for a sample of transactions;

 

On sample basis, we have performed the following procedures in relation to revenue recognition from sale of constructed properties:

 

• Read, analysed and identified the distinct performance obligations in the customer contracts;

 

• Assessed management evaluation of determining revenue recognition from sale of constructed property over a period of time in accordance with the requirements under Ind AS 115;

 

• Inspected sale deeds evidencing the transfer of control of the property to the customer based on which revenue is recognised;

 

• Tested costs incurred and accrued to date on the balance sheet by examining underlying invoices and signed work orders and compared it with budgeted cost to determine percentage of completion of the project;

 

• Reviewed management’s internal budgeting approvals process, on a sample, for cost to be incurred on a project and for any changes in initial budgeted costs; and

 

• Discussed exceptions, if any, to the revenue recognition policy of the management and obtained appropriate management approvals and representations regarding the same.

 

For projects executed during the year through JDA, we have performed the following procedures on a sample basis:

 

• Evaluated estimates involved in determining the fair value of development rights in lieu of construction services in accordance with principles under Ind AS 115;

 

• Evaluated whether the accuracy of revenue recognised by the Company based on ratio of constructed area or revenue sharing arrangement as agreed in the revenue sharing arrangement as entered with the Developer over a period of time is in accordance with the requirements under Ind AS 115;

 

• Compared the fair value of the estimated construction service to the project cost estimates and mark up considered by the management; and

 

• Ensured that the disclosure requirements of Ind AS 115 have been complied with.

Revenue recognition in development management arrangements
The Company renders development management (DM) services involving multiple performance obligations such as Sales and Marketing, Project Management and Consultancy (PMC) services, Customer Relationship Management (CRM) Services and Financial Management services to other real estate developers pursuant to separate Development Management Arrangements executed with them.

 

Refer notes 1.2(g), 23 and 45 to the standalone financial statements for accounting policy and revenue recognised during the year.

 

The assessment of such services rendered to customers involves significant judgment in:

 

• Identifying different performance obligations;

 

• Allocating transaction price to these performance obligations;

 

• Assessing whether these obligations are satisfied over a period of time or at the point in time for the purposes of revenue recognition;

 

• Assessing whether the transaction price has a significant financing element; and

 

• Assessing for any liability arising on guarantee contracts entered by the Company.

 

Considering the significance of management judgements involved as mentioned above and the materiality of amounts involved, we have identified this as a key audit matter.

 

Our audit procedures included, but were not limited to the following:

 

• Evaluated the appropriateness of the accounting policy for revenue recognition of the Company in terms of principles enunciated under Ind AS 115;

 

• Evaluated the design and implementation of the Company’s key financial controls in respect of revenue recognition for DM contracts and tested the operating effectiveness of such controls for a sample of transactions;

 

On a sample of contracts, we have performed the following procedures in relation to revenue recognition in DM contracts:

 

• Read, analysed and identified the distinct performance obligations in these contracts

 

• Assessed the Management’s evaluation of identifying different performance obligations, allocating transaction price (adjusted with financing element) and determining timing of revenue recognition, i.e., over a period of time or at the point in time in accordance with the requirements under Ind AS 115;

 

• On a sample basis, inspected the sale agreements entered with respect to sale of units in DM projects;

 

• Recomputed the amount to be billed in terms of DM contract and compared that with amount billed and investigated the differences if any and held discussions with management;

 

• Reviewed communications between the Company and DM customers regarding construction progress for contract obligations that involve recognising revenue over a period of time; and

 

• For contracts modified during the period without change in the scope of services such as incentives, we have reviewed whether
the accounting for contract modification is made in accordance with the principles of Ind AS 115; and

 

• Ensured that the disclosure requirements of Ind AS 115 have been complied with.

Assessing the recoverability of advances paid for land purchase and refundable deposit paid under JDAs
As of 31st March, 2024, the carrying value of land advance is R19,602 lakhs and refundable deposit paid under JDA is ₹4,914 lakhs.

 

Advances paid by the Company to the landowner / intermediary towards purchase of land is recognised as land advance under other assets
on account of pending transfer of the legal title to the Company, post which it is recorded as inventories.

 

Further, for land acquired under joint development agreement, the Company has paid refundable deposits for acquiring the development rights.

 

The aforesaid deposits and advances are carried at the lower of the amount paid / payable and net recoverable value, which is based on the management’s assessment which includes, among other things, the likelihood when the land acquisition would be completed, expected
date of completion of the project, sale prices and construction costs of the project.

 

Considering the significance of the amount and assumptions involved in assessing the recoverability of these balances, the aforementioned areas have been determined as
a key audit matter for the current
year audit.

Our audit procedures included, but were not limited to, the following procedures:

 

• Evaluated the design and implementation of the Company’s key financial controls in respect of recoverability assessment of the advances and deposits and tested the operating effectiveness of such controls for a sample of transactions;

 

• Obtained and tested the computation involved in the assessment of carrying value of advances;

 

• Obtained status of the project / land acquisition from the management and enquired for the expected realisation of deposit amount;

 

• Assessed the appropriateness and adequacy of the disclosures made by the management in accordance with applicable Ind AS.

Assessing the recoverability of carrying values of inventories
The accounting policies for Inventories are set out in Note 1.2 (h) to the Standalone financial statements.

 

As of 31st March, 2024, inventory of the Company comprises properties held for development, properties under development, properties held for sale and as referred in note 10 to the standalone financial statements and represents 14 per cent of the Company’s total assets.

 

Inventory is valued at cost and NRV, whichever is less. In case of properties under development and properties held for sale, determination of the NRV involves estimates based on the prevailing market conditions, current prices, expected date of completion of the project, the estimated future selling price, cost to complete projects and selling costs. For NRV assessment, the estimated selling price is determined for a phase, sometimes comprising multiple units.

 

We have identified the assessment of the carrying value of inventory as a key audit matter due to the significance of the balance to the standalone financial statements as a whole and the involvement of estimates and judgement in the NRV assessment.

Our audit procedures included, but were not limited to, the following procedures:

 

• Assessed the appropriateness of the Company’s accounting policy by comparing with applicable Ind AS;

 

• Evaluated the design and implementation of the Company’s key financial internal controls related to testing recoverable amounts with carrying amount of inventory, including evaluating the Company’s management processes for estimating future costs to complete projects and tested the operating effectiveness of such controls for a sample of transactions. We carried out a combination of procedures involving inquiries and observations and inspection of evidence in respect of operation of such key controls;

 

• Performed re-computation of NRV and compared it with the recent sales or estimated selling price (usually contracted price) to test inventory units are held at the lower of cost and NRV;

 

• Compared the estimated construction costs to complete each project with the Company’s updated budgets; and

 

• Assessed the appropriateness and adequacy of the disclosures made by the management in accordance with applicable Ind AS.

FROM MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICIES

Revenue recognition (extracts)

Revenue from contracts with customers

Revenue from contracts with customers is recognised when control of the goods or services is transferred to the customer at an amount that reflects the consideration to which the Company expects to be entitled in exchange for those goods or services. Revenue is measured based on the transaction price, which is the consideration, adjusted for discounts and other credits, if any, as specified in the contract with the customer. The Company presents revenue from contracts with customers net of indirect taxes in its statement of profit and loss.

The Company considers whether there are other promises in the contract that are separate performance obligations to which a portion of the transaction price needs to be allocated. In determining the transaction price, the Company considers the effects of variable consideration, the existence of significant financing components, non-cash consideration and consideration payable to the customer (if any).

The Company has applied a five-step model as per Ind AS 115 ‘Revenue from contracts with customers’ to recognise revenue in the standalone financial statements. The Company satisfies a performance obligation and recognises revenue over time, if one of the following criteria is met:

a) The customer simultaneously receives and consumes the benefits provided by the Company’s performance as the Company performs; or

b) The Company’s performance creates or enhances an asset that the customer controls as the asset is created or enhanced; or

c) The Company’s performance does not create an asset with an alternative use to the Company, and the entity has an enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date.

For performance obligations where any of the above conditions is not met, revenue is recognised at the point in time at which the performance obligation is satisfied.

Revenue is recognised either at a point of time or over a period of time based on various conditions as included in the contracts with customers.

i. Sale of constructed / developed properties

Revenue is recognised over the time from the financial year in which the registration of sale deed is executed based on the percentage-of-completion method (POC method) of accounting with cost of project incurred (input method) for the respective projects determining the degree of completion of the performance obligation.

The revenue recognition of real estate property under development requires forecasts to be made of total budgeted costs with the outcomes of underlying construction contracts, which further require assessments and judgments to be made on changes in work scopes and other payments to the extent they are probable and they are capable of being reliably measured. In case, where the total project cost is estimated to exceed total revenues from the project, the loss is recognised immediately in the Statement of Profit and Loss.

Further, for projects executed through joint development arrangements not being jointly controlled operations, wherein the landowner / possessor provides land and the Company undertakes to develop properties on such land and in lieu of landowner providing land, the Company has agreed to transfer certain percentage of constructed area or certain percentage of the revenue proceeds, the revenue from the development and transfer of constructed area / revenue sharing arrangement in exchange of such development rights / land is being accounted on gross basis on launch of the project. Revenue is recognised over time using input method, on the basis of the inputs to the satisfaction of a performance obligation relative to the total expected inputs to the satisfaction of that performance obligation.

The revenue is measured at the fair value of the land received, adjusted by the amount of any cash or cash equivalents transferred. When the fair value of the land received cannot be measured reliably, the revenue is measured at the fair value of the estimated construction service rendered to the landowner, adjusted by the amount of any cash or cash equivalents transferred. The fair value so estimated is considered as the cost of land in the computation of percentage of completion for the purpose of revenue recognition as discussed above.

For contracts involving sale of real estate unit, the Company receives the consideration in accordance with the terms of the contract in proportion of the percentage of completion of such real estate project and represents payments made by customers to secure performance obligation of the Company under the contract enforceable by customers. Such consideration is received and utilised for specific real estate projects in accordance with the requirements of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. Consequently, the Company has concluded that such contracts with customers do not involve any financing element since the same arises for reasons explained above, which is other than for provision of finance to / from the customer.

ii. Sale of services

Development management fees

The Company renders development management services involving multiple elements such as Sales and Marketing, PMC services, CRM Services and financial management services to other real estate developers. The Company’s performance obligation is satisfied either over a period of time or at a point in time, which is evaluated for each service under development management contract separately. Revenue is recognised upon satisfaction of each such performance obligation.

Administrative income

Revenue in respect of administrative services is recognised on an accrual basis, in accordance with the terms of the respective contract as and when the Company satisfies performance obligations by delivering the services as per contractual agreed terms.

iii. Other operating income

Income from transfer / assignment of development rights

The revenue from transfer / assignment of development rights is recognised in the year in which the legal agreements are duly executed and the performance obligations thereon are duly satisfied and there exists no uncertainty in the ultimate collection of consideration from customers.

Maintenance income

Revenue in respect of maintenance services is recognised on an accrual basis, in accordance with the terms of the respective contract as and when the Company satisfies performance obligations by delivering the services as per contractual agreed terms.

Others

Interest on delayed receipts, cancellation / forfeiture income and transfer fees, etc., from customers are recognised based upon underlying agreements with customers and when reasonable certainty of collection is established.

Unbilled revenue disclosed under other financial assets represents revenue recognised over and above the amount due as per payment plans agreed with the customers. Progress billings which exceed the costs and recognised profits to date on projects under construction are disclosed under other current liabilities. Any billed amount that has not been collected is disclosed under trade receivables and is net of any provisions for amounts doubtful of recovery.

Inventories

Properties held for development

Properties held for development represent land acquired for future development and construction and is stated at cost including the cost of land, the related costs of acquisition and other costs incurred to get the properties ready for their intended use.

Properties under development

Properties under development represent construction work in progress which are stated at the lower of cost and NRV. This comprises cost of land, construction-related overhead expenditure, borrowing costs and other net costs incurred during the period of development.

Properties held for sale

Completed properties held for sale are stated at the lower of cost and NRV. Cost includes cost of land, construction-related overhead expenditure, borrowing costs and other costs incurred during the period of development.

NRV is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less estimated costs of completion and estimated costs necessary to make the sale.

Refund — Interest on refund — Refund of TDS — Scope of Article 265 — Tax deducted at source and deposited by assessee in anticipation of contract with non-resident — Cancellation of contract — No authority of law in department to retain remittance to non-resident — Assessee entitled to refund with interest.

50 Tupperware India Pvt. Ltd. vs. CIT(IT)

[2024] 465 ITR 777(Del.)

A. Y. 2012-13

Date of order: 1st February, 2024

Ss. 195 and 237of the ITA 1961; Articles 226, 227 and 265 of the Constitution of India

Refund — Interest on refund — Refund of TDS — Scope of Article 265 — Tax deducted at source and deposited by assessee in anticipation of contract with non-resident — Cancellation of contract — No authority of law in department to retain remittance to non-resident — Assessee entitled to refund with interest.

The assesse company imported molds during the assessment year under consideration from a company in USA and the payment was made according to the rental agreement between the assessee and the USA Company. As per the agreement, the Assessee had to pay lease rent for mold on the basis of actual production days.

Due to a change in the method of charging mold lease rent, deliberations were made between the Assessee and the USA Company to increase the rent. However, before the negotiations were finalised, the Assessee made a provision for higher rent in the books of account as the estimated lease rent came out to be ₹7,19,96,529. Pursuant to the revised estimate, the Assessee deducted TDS of ₹71,99,653 on the higher side and deposited the same. However, subsequently, the increase in mold lease rent did not happen and the rent was recognised to be only ₹45,80,337 which resulted in excess deposit of TDS of ₹67,41,620 as the actual TDS amounted to only ₹4,58,035.

Accordingly, the Assessee made an application to the AO for refund of higher TDS in accordance with the procedure prescribed under the CBDT Circular dated 23rd October, 2007. However, no action was taken by the AO on the said application. Thereafter, the Assessee filed second application dated 16th January, 2017 which was rejected without providing any opportunity of hearing to the Assessee. Thereafter, on 21st March, 2017, the Assessee filed an application before the senior authority, i.e. Respondent No. 2, but to no avail.

The Assessee, therefore filed writ petition before the High Court challenging the orders rejecting the Assessee’s claim for refund of TDS. The Assessee, inter alia, contended that since the negotiations between the petitioner and Dart USA never culminated into a transaction or any agreement, the Assessee is rightfully entitled for claiming the benefit envisaged in the said circular. Further, if any amount credited to the Government does not fall in the category of tax, the said amount cannot be unjustifiably retained by the Government.

On the other hand, the contention of the Department was that under the provisions of the Act, the deductor is not entitled to the refund of excess tax deducted at source deposited by it and only the payee will get the refund.

The Delhi High Court allowed the petition of the Assessee and held as follows:

“i) The cardinal duty of imposition or collection of taxes which flows from article 265 of the Constitution of India is that it can only be exercised by the authority of law and not otherwise

ii) The Department was not entitled to withhold the excess tax deducted at source deposited by the Assessee in lieu of the anticipated liability for the assessment year 2012-13 since it would amount to collection of tax without any authority of law. Regarding the enhanced mold lease rent, the Assessee while anticipating tax liability had made a bona fide payment and had deposited the tax deducted at source at the rate of 10 per cent. Those deliberations did not materialise into a transaction or a contract and thus no income had accrued qua the excess tax deducted at source paid by the Assessee. Consequently, the Department had no right to retain the deducted tax deposited. The orders denying the refund of the excess tax deducted at source deposited by the Assessee on the ground that it did not fall within the gamut of cases mentioned in the Central Board of Direct Taxes circular dated 23rd October, 2007 ([2007] 294 ITR (St.) 32) was set aside. The assessee was entitled to refund of excess tax deducted at source with interest at the applicable rate.”

Reassessment — Notice —Limitation — Amendment in law — Effect of amendment with effect from 1st April, 2021 — Notices dated 31st March, 2021 but dispatched on 1st April, 2021 or thereafter from Income-tax Business Application Portal — Notices barred by limitation.

49 KalyanChillara vs. DCIT

[2024] 465 ITR 729(Telangana)

Date of order: 14th June, 2024

Ss.147, 148, 149 and 151 of the ITA 1961

Reassessment — Notice —Limitation — Amendment in law — Effect of amendment with effect from 1st April, 2021 — Notices dated 31st March, 2021 but dispatched on 1st April, 2021 or thereafter from Income-tax Business Application Portal — Notices barred by limitation.

This judgment deals with a batch of petitions which were before the Hon’ble Telangana High Court challenging the notices issued u/s. 148 of the Act.

In all these writ petitions, the last date of service of notice and initiating proceedings for re-opening of assessment was coming to an end on 31st March, 2021. In majority of the cases, the notice issued u/s. 148 was dated 31st March, 2021. However, the notices have been issued from the office of the Department either on 1st April, 2021 or on subsequent dates. The Assessee’s main contention for challenge was that since in all the cases the notices were issued on or after 1st April, 2021, the notices were hit on the ground of limitation.

It was contended on behalf of the Assessees that under the unamended provisions, a notice u/s. 148 had to be issued and served on or before 31-03-2021 and in case the notices have been served on or after 1st April, 2021 then in view of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of UOI vs. Ashish Agarwal, the amended provisions would be applicable and the notices in the writ petitions before it would not be sustainable. It was contended that the documents maintained by the Department would indicate the date of actual dispatch and the actual date of service of the notice. Further, since the notices are mostly sent by email, the date of dispatch and the date of delivery are reflected. Even the page on the income tax portal would reflect the date and time at the originator’s place and the date and time at the recipient’s end.

On the other hand, it was the contention of the Department that there are large number of notices in the pipeline with the Income-tax Business Application Department by which the email is sent and since there is too much pressure upon the said Department, the notices are normally delayed more because of the network problem and not for any lapse or lacking on the part of officer. Therefore, probably technically, it has to be presumed that the dispatch has been made but for technicalities that arise because of the system and not because of the fault or lacking on the part of the authorities.

The Hon’ble High Court allowed the batch of petitions filed by the Assessees and held as follows:

“i) All the notices u/s. 148 had been issued (not served) on 1st April, 2021 or on a later date. The question of service of these notices and the date of service of notices upon the assessees was of no relevance or consequence since the notices had been dispatched from the Department on or after 1st April, 2021 which itself was beyond the period of limitation. All the notices issued u/s. 148, dated 31st March, 2021, were barred by limitation u/s. 148 and 149, since these notices had left the Income-tax Business Application portal on or after 1st April, 2021 and therefore, were unsustainable.

ii) The objection raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the impugned notices under challenge are barred by limitation is sustained. Therefore, the impugned notices in all these writ petitions are as a con sequence set aside / quashed on the ground of it being barred by limitation.”

Reassessment —Search and seizure —Assessment in search cases — Jurisdiction — Assessment of third person — Reassessment based on incriminating material and information collected prior to and post search — Permissible only u/s. 153C — Failure to assess within time limit for assessment u/s. 153C — Reassessment cannot be made u/s. 147 — Notices and orders set aside.

48 Tirupati Construction Co. vs. ITO

[2024] 465 ITR 611 (Raj)

A. Ys. 2016-17, 2017-18

Date of order: 21st March, 2024

Ss. 132, 147, 148, 148A, 148A(b), 153A, 153B and 153C of ITA 1961

Reassessment —Search and seizure —Assessment in search cases — Jurisdiction — Assessment of third person — Reassessment based on incriminating material and information collected prior to and post search — Permissible only u/s. 153C — Failure to assess within time limit for assessment u/s. 153C — Reassessment cannot be made u/s. 147 — Notices and orders set aside.

The assessee was a firm. The Delhi High Court allowed the writ petitions filed by the assesse against the notices for reassessment u/s. 148A and section 148 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and held as under:

“i) Where the basis for reassessment u/s. 147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is incriminating material and information collected during the search and seizure operation u/s. 132, the only legally permissible course of action is the one provided u/s. 153C and not u/s. 147.

ii) The information as contained in the annexure to the notice and the order passed in exercise of powers u/s. 148A(d) of the Act made it clear that the entire basis for reopening the assessment was nothing but the material and information collected during search conducted in the premises of another assessee. Collection of details relating to search would not mean collection of new incriminating material and information, independent of the incriminating material and information collected during search proceedings. The earlier notice, dated 31st March, 2021, issued u/s. 148 merely stated that the Assessing Officer had reasons to believe that the income chargeable to tax for the A. Y. 2016-17 had escaped assessment u/s. 147. The later notice, dated June 2, 2022, issued u/s. 148A(b) pursuant to the decision in UOI v. Ashish Agarwal [2022] 444 ITR 1 (SC), it was stated that there was information pertaining to the assessee which suggested that income chargeable to tax for the A. Y. 2016-17 had escaped assessment u/s. 147. The notice clearly showed that incriminating material and information was found during the search proceedings and not beyond that and to assume jurisdiction u/s. 148A such information was made a basis to draw inferences which were described as pre search and post search investigations. It had been assumed that the incriminating material and information collected during search followed by collection of details which were intrinsically related to such material and information would confer jurisdiction u/s. 147.

iii) The Department had the authority to reopen the assessment by invoking the powers u/s. 153C and draw reassessment proceedings u/s. 153A. That was not done within the period of limitation prescribed u/s. 153B. The Department was fully aware of the fact that proceedings u/s. 153C would be barred by limitation, and therefore, recourse was taken to the provisions u/s. 148 and section 148A which had no application in the assessee’s case. The orders passed for the A. Ys. 2016-17 and 2017-18 were unsustainable and accordingly, quashed and set aside.”

Reassessment — Notice — Sanction of prescribed authority — Sanction accorded by competent authority by merely stating “yes” — Non-application of mind — Notice and reassessment proceedings invalid.

47 Principal CIT vs. Pioneer Town Planners Pvt. Ltd.

[2024] 465 ITR 356(Del.)

A. Y. 2009-10

Date of order: 20th February, 2024

Ss. 147, 148 and 151 of ITA 1961

Reassessment — Notice — Sanction of prescribed authority — Sanction accorded by competent authority by merely stating “yes” — Non-application of mind — Notice and reassessment proceedings invalid.

Subsequent to search operations u/s. 132 of the Income-tax Act,1961 in the premises of certain group entities, of which the assessee was one, reassessment proceedings u/s. 147 were initiated against the assessee. The assessee requested the Assessing Officer to treat the original return as filed in response to the notice u/s. 148. The Assessing Officer, in his order u/s. 143(3) read with section 147, made additions on account of unexplained share premium and expenditure of commission for accommodation entries.

The Tribunal allowed the Assessees appeal and held that the Assessing Officer had initiated the reassessment proceedings on the basis of borrowed satisfaction and without any application of mind and that the prescribed authority had granted approval u/s. 151 in a mechanical manner.

On appeal by the Department the Delhi High Court upheld the decision and held as under:

“i) Section 151 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 stipulates that the Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner must be “satisfied”, on the reasons recorded by the Assessing Officer, that it is a fit case for the issuance of notice u/s. 148 to reopen the assessment u/s. 147. Thus, the satisfaction of the prescribed authority is a “sine qua non” for a valid approval. The satisfaction arrived at by the prescribed authority u/s. 151 must be clearly discernible from the expression used at the time of affixing the signature while according approval for reassessment u/s. 147. Such approval cannot be granted in a mechanical manner as it acts as a link between the facts considered and conclusion reached. Merely appending the phrase “Yes” does not appropriately align with the mandate of section 151 as it fails to set out any degree of satisfaction, much less an unassailable satisfaction, for the purpose.

ii) The Principal Commissioner had failed to satisfactorily record his concurrence. Mere penning down the expression “yes” could not be considered to be valid approval. Though the Assistant Commissioner had appended his signature by writing in his hand “Yes, I am satisfied”, the Principal Commissioner had merely written “Yes” without specifically noting his approval, while recording the satisfaction for issuance of notice u/s. 148 for reopening the assessment u/s. 147.

iii) Therefore, the order of the Tribunal holding that the Assessing Officer had initiated the reassessment proceedings on the basis of borrowed satisfaction and that the prescribed authority had granted approval u/s. 151 in a mechanical manner need not be interfered with.”

Assessment — Faceless assessment — Validity — Effect of section 144B, circulars and instructions of CBDT — Notice must be given for proposed additions to income or disallowance along with necessary evidence.

46 Inox Wind Energy Ltd. vs. ACIT

[2024] 466 ITR 463 (Guj)

A. Y. 2021-22

Date of order: 19th March, 2024

S. 144Bof ITA 1961

Assessment — Faceless assessment — Validity — Effect of section 144B, circulars and instructions of CBDT — Notice must be given for proposed additions to income or disallowance along with necessary evidence.

By this petition under articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has prayed for quashing and setting the assessment order under section 143(3) dated 29th December, 2022 passed by the respondent-Assessing Officer for the A. Y. 2021-22. It is the case of the petitioner that after the aforesaid notices and replies exchanged between the petitioner and the respondent-Assessing Officer, no further show-cause notice was issued to the petitioner on the proposed addition indicating the reasons along with necessary evidence / reasons forming the basis for such additions by the respondent-Assessing Officer and accordingly the petitioner is deprived of opportunity of personal hearing as the impugned assessment order was passed on 29th December, 2022 by assessing the income at ₹71,06,57,281 raising a demand of ₹24,30,03,540 along with a notice for penalty under section 274 read with section 271A of the Act.

The Gujarat High Court allowed the Petition and held as under:

“i) U/s. 144B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which provides for faceless assessment, the Assessing Officer is required to frame the assessment notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) of section 144B with prior approval of the Board. On a harmonious reading of the circulars, instructions and letters of the Board, it appears that since 2015 as per the desire of the Board, the Assessing Officer is mandatorily required to issue an appropriate show-cause notice duly indicating the reasons for the proposed additions and disallowances along with necessary evidence and reasons forming basis thereof before passing the final order. As a matter of fact, such position will continue even when the case is transferred to the Assessing Officer u/s. 144B(8) of the Act as per Circular No. 27 of 2019 ([2019] 417 ITR (St.) 68).

ii) The Assessing Officer had committed flagrant breach of the principles of natural justice by not issuing a show-cause notice indicating the reasons for the proposed addition or disallowance along with the necessary evidence forming the basis thereof and, therefore, the assessment order had to be quashed and set aside.

iii) The matter is remanded back to the stage of issuance of show-cause notice by the Assessing Officer to the petitioner duly indicating the reasons for the proposed addition/disallowance along with necessary evidence / reasons forming the basis of the same so as to enable the petitioner-assessee to request for personal hearing if any required in compliance of Circular No. 27 of 2019 ([2019] 417 ITR (St.) 68) read with circular dated September 6, 2021 applicable in the facts of the case. Such exercise shall be completed within a period of 12 weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”

Assessment — Eligible assessee — Procedure to be followed — Objections filed by assessee against draft assessment order before DRP but factum not intimated to AO — Final assessment order passed by AO without directions of DRP — Assessment set aside and to be framed afresh in accordance with directions of DRP.

45 DiwakerTripathi vs. PCIT

[2024] 465 ITR 622 (Del)

A. Y. 2020-21

Date of order: 1st December, 2023

S. 144Cof ITA 1961

Assessment — Eligible assessee — Procedure to be followed — Objections filed by assessee against draft assessment order before DRP but factum not intimated to AO — Final assessment order passed by AO without directions of DRP — Assessment set aside and to be framed afresh in accordance with directions of DRP.

Though the assessee had preferred its objections against the draft assessment order before the Dispute Resolution Panel(DRP) within limitation as provided u/s. 144C(2)(b)(i) read with section 144B(1)(xxiv)(b)(I) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, it inadvertently failed to intimate the Assessing Officer regarding the objections in terms of section 144C(2)(b)(ii) of the Act. The Assessing Officer passed the final assessment order in the absence of the directions of the DRP.

The assessee filed a writ petition. The Bombay High Court allowed the writ petition and held as under:

“Once the objections have been filed by the assessee against a draft assessment order within the time limit prescribed u/s. 144C(2)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the rest of the procedure should be followed as prescribed and the final assessment order ought to be passed by the Assessing Officer in accordance with the directions issued by the DRP. No prejudice would be caused to the Department if the assessment order was set aside as the Department would be well within its rights to pass a fresh assessment order post the receipt of directions from the DRP.”

Sulzer Pumps India Pvt. Ltd. vs. DY. CIT [2024] 465 ITR 619 (Bom) followed.

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Workshop on Public Speaking for Professionals: Strategies to Enhance Your Career and Influence held on 31st August, 2024, Venue: BCAS

The HRD Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised an engaging workshop conducted by faculty CA Hrudyesh Pankhania.

The workshop focused on effective communication techniques, providing practical strategies for enhancing career growth and professional influence through public speaking. It featured a range of interactive activities, including impromptu speaking exercises, role-playing, and group discussions, fostering a lively and engaging learning environment. A total of 54 participants attended the workshop, and they had the opportunity to practice their speaking skills in a supportive setting, receiving personalised feedback from the speaker.

The interactive format encouraged participants to share their experiences, helping to build confidence and improve their public speaking abilities.

2. Direct Tax Laws’ Study Circle meeting on the topic of Capital Gains Amendments in Finance (No.2) Act, 2024, held on 29th August, 2024. Venue: Zoom Platform.

Group Leader — CA Krishna Upadhya provided insights into the recent significant changes impacting the capital gains tax structure and related provisions by the Finance (No.2) Act, 2024. The discussion was attended by 54 members, and it was well received. Some key takeaways were:

  • Period of holding for various capital assets, such as listed/unlisted securities, immovable property, and debentures, comparing the rules before and after the amendments in the Finance (No.2) Act 2024.
  • Capital gains tax rates for different assets, highlighting the changes in rates before and after the amendments and their impact on long-term and short-term gains.
  • Amendment to Taxation of Buy-Back of Shares: Prior to the amendment, buy-back of shares was exempt for shareholders under section 10(34A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, with taxes paid by the company under section 115QA.
  • Post-amendment, buy-back is treated as a taxable transfer, with TDS under section 194.
  • The benefit of grandfathering provisions for land/buildings purchased before 23rd July, 2024, ensuring tax benefits for transfers of such assets.
  • New proviso to section 194-IA of TDS on sale of immovable property: The threshold of ₹50 lakhs for TDS is now based on the total property value, not per seller. If the sale value exceeds ₹50 lakh, TDS under Section 194-IA applies, regardless of the number of sellers.

3. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle on Notices u/s 73 & 74 held on 26th August, 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform.

Group leader, Adv Rushil Shah, in consultation with Group Mentor, Adv Vinaykumar Jain, prepared 6 case studies covering various contentious issues around notices under GST.

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  • Multiple tax periods under one notice.
  • Multiple notices for the same tax period.
  • Notices issued by multiple officers (parallel proceedings).
  • Issuance of the same notice on different dates and in different modes.
  • Interplay of section 75 (2) in 73 vs 74 cases.
  • Notices for fake invoices

Around 80 participants from all over India benefitted while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader & group mentor.

4. ‘CA Pariksha Pe Charcha’ held on 24th August 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform.

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organized a special program to guide and support CA students preparing for the exams. The keynote address was delivered by CA Nilesh Vikamsey, who emphasized the importance of resilience in achieving success and provided strategies for effectively dealing with failures. CA Umesh Sharma discussed various practical exam preparation strategies and clarified doubts about the ICAI evaluation process. He also highlighted the role of AI and other technological tools in enhancing study methods.

Following this, a panel discussion took place where top CA rankers from the May 2024 exams — CA Shivam Mishra, CA Ghilman Saalim Ansari, and CA Kiran Manral shared their personal experiences, detailed their study techniques, and discussed approaches to overcoming the challenges faced during their exam journey. The panel was ably moderated by CA Vedant Gada, a committee member, the session saw active participation from 76 students across the country and was well-received.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuxNHjd1s_0&t=434s

QR Code:

5. FEMA Study Circle meeting on “Bank Account & Demat of Shares Mandate for R to NR and NR to R under FEMA” held on 23rd August, 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform.

The study circle meeting was led by Group Leader — CA Divya Jokhakar. She highlighted the nuances around the topic. In the context of FEMA (Foreign Exchange Management Act), the mandate for a bank account and Demat account transition from Resident (R) to Non-Resident (NR) and back to Resident (R) involves specific regulatory requirements. When an individual’s status changes from Resident to Non-Resident, they must re-designate their savings bank account to a Non-Resident Ordinary (NRO) account or open a Non-Resident External (NRE) account. The Demat account must also be converted to a Non-Resident Demat account.

Upon becoming a Resident again, the NRO/NRE accounts should be re-designated as resident savings accounts. Similarly, the Non-Resident Demat account should be converted back to a Resident Demat account. It was also discussed that it is important to note that any investments made while being a Non-Resident must adhere to FEMA regulations, and compliance with tax laws is crucial during these transitions to avoid penalties. Proper documentation and timely communication with the bank and Depository Participants (DPs) are essential for smooth transitions. The study circle meeting was attended by 74 participants and was well received.

6. Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs of the May 2024 Batch — “प्रोfessional Career — The Road Ahead”, held on 3rd August, 2024 Venue: Walchand Hirachand Hall — IMC.

In line with the spirit of celebrating achievements while preparing for future endeavors, the Seminar, Membership & Public Relations (SMPR) Committee of the BCAS organized a special session to honor the achievers of the May 2024 CA Final examinations and provide them with valuable guidance for their professional journey. This annual event serves as both a celebration and a platform for emerging professionals to gain insights from distinguished mentors.

The session, titled “Journey to Professional Excellence: Insights from Leading Minds,” featured two prominent Chartered Accountants: CA Raman Jokhakar and CA Gautam Shah. The event was marked by a significant turnout, with 264 newly qualified Chartered Accountants attending the event, including AIR 3 — CA Ghilman Saalim Ansari.

CA Chirag Doshi, Chairman of the SMPR Committee, inspired the attendees to embrace the myriad opportunities available to them in his opening remarks. He also provided an overview of the Committee’s activities, highlighting programs where young professionals take the lead. The speakers addressed a common question among new pass-outs—whether to pursue a career in industry or practice. CA Raman Jokhakar shared valuable insights on the importance of professionalism, emphasizing that conduct often outweighs mere qualification. CA Gautam Shah offered a detailed account of his career in practice, sharing practical experiences. CA Ghilman Saalim Ansari briefly shared his inspiring CA journey. The session concluded with a celebratory cake-cutting ceremony, recognizing the achievements of the new Chartered Accountants.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f59BCkdfznw

QR Code:

7. Lecture meeting on Direct Tax Law provisions of the Finance (No.2) Bill, 2024 Held on 27th July, 2024 at Yogi Sabagrah, Dadar.

The Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2024 introduced various direct tax law provisions, including changes in tax rates, capital gains, and withholding requirements for partnerships. While it aims for simplification, concerns arise over potential complications and inequities. Notably, the withdrawal of the Equalization Levy and Angel Tax provisions reflects a shift in tax policy. This public lecture meeting is the most awaited by our members, CA Fraternity, professionals, and the public at large; we had CA Shri Pinakin Desai addressing the participants with his first-hand views on the Finance Bill. He rated the budget as a satisfactory budget overall, which contains positive aspects and points requiring further attention or simplification.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iweDyhhFqNw

QR Code:

Miscellanea

1. BUSINESS

#Indian space start-up Pixxel bags NASA contract to support Earth science research

Indian space start-up Pixxel has bagged a NASA contract to support Earth science research using the hyperspectral technology.

The Bengaluru-based company has become a part of NASA’s $476-million commercial small-sat data acquisition program — a first for an Indian start-up after the space sector was opened to private companies in 2020.

Co-founder and CEO Awais Ahmed called the award a “monumental achievement for Pixxel”.

He said the contract, valid till November 2028, “validates that hyperspectral imaging will be integral to the future of space-based Earth observation and enable us to truly build a health monitor for the planet”.

As per the contract, Pixxel will provide NASA and its US government and academic partners with hyperspectral Earth observation data. This will help empower the administration’s Earth science research and application activities.

Pixxel hyperspectral can capture data across hundreds of narrow wavelengths. Its datasets can also unravel granular insights on climate change, agriculture, biodiversity, and resource management, among others.

Building on this momentum, Pixxel is also making significant strides toward launching six satellites shortly. Fireflies — its 5-metre resolution hyperspectral satellites — will be the highest-resolution hyperspectral satellites ever launched.

These satellites will capture data across over 250 spectral bands, offering more comprehensive coverage with a 40km swath width and a 24-hour revisit frequency anywhere on the planet.

In addition, Pixxel also plans to expand its constellation to 24 satellites to make hyperspectral data commercially. This will make it more broadly available and accessible to stakeholders across industries and governments.

Pixxel has a constellation of the world’s highest-resolution hyperspectral imaging satellites that are designed for
24-hour revisits anywhere on Earth.

The satellites can help detect, monitor, and predict critical global phenomena across agriculture, oil and gas, mining, environment, and other sectors in up to 50 times richer detail.

Pixxel has also launched its in-house Earth Observation Studio, Aurora, to make satellite imagery analysis easily accessible.

The company has also raised over $70 million from Google, Lightspeed, Radical Ventures, Relativity’s Jordan Noone, Seraphim Capital, Ryan Johnson, Blume Ventures, Sparta LLC, Accenture, and others.

(Source: International Business Times –— ByIBT Business Desk — 10th September, 2024)

 

2. TECHNOLOGY

#Unlocking Success with AI-Powered CRMs: A New Era in Customer Relationship Management

AI-powered CRMs provide a crucial advantage by automating routine tasks like data entry, lead qualification, and follow-up communications, allowing employees to focus on strategic initiatives.

Integrating Artificial Intelligence (AI) into customer relationship management (CRM) systems is revolutionizing how businesses engage with customers. Vikas Reddy Penubelli highlights how AI-powered CRMs utilize machine learning, predictive analytics, and automation to enhance customer experiences, streamline operations, and drive business growth. By harnessing data insights, companies can personalize engagement, optimize resources, and remain competitive in the fast-paced, data-driven marketplace.

A Paradigm Shift in CRM

The integration of AI into CRM systems marks a significant shift in how businesses engage with their customers. AI-powered CRMs leverage machine learning, predictive analytics, and automation to deliver enhanced customer experiences. These systems enable companies to analyze vast amounts of data to predict customer behavior, personalize engagement, and optimize operations.

Enhanced Customer Understanding and Personalization

AI-powered CRMs analyze customer data from sources like transaction history, social media, and support interactions using advanced techniques such as clustering and sentiment analysis. These insights enable businesses to tailor products, services, and communications for personalized experiences. For example, retail companies can offer personalized product recommendations based on purchase history and browsing behavior, leading to increased engagement, higher conversion rates, and improved customer satisfaction.

Automation and Efficiency Gains

AI-powered CRMs provide a crucial advantage by automating routine tasks like data entry, lead qualification, and follow-up communications, allowing employees to focus on strategic initiatives. For instance, a software company can automatically classify and prioritize support tickets, addressing high-priority issues quickly. Automation optimizes resource allocation and boosts operational efficiency. Additionally, the productivity gains from AI-powered CRMs directly enhance profitability, as faster data processing and intelligent task prioritization enable sales teams to close more deals and drive revenue growth.

Predictive Capabilities and Market Trends

One of the most powerful features of AI-powered CRMs is their predictive capabilities. These systems can forecast customer behaviour, churn risk, and future market trends by analyzing complex data patterns. Vikas Reddy Penubelli highlights how businesses can leverage these insights to stay ahead of the curve and proactively address customer needs.

For example, a telecommunications company using an AI-powered CRM can predict which customers will likely churn due to poor network coverage in certain areas. By offering targeted retention incentives, the company can reduce churn and enhance customer lifetime value.

Predictive insights empower businesses to make informed decisions, optimize their strategies, and drive sustainable growth.

Challenges and Considerations

While AI-powered CRMs offer numerous benefits, their implementation comes with challenges. Businesses must address hurdles related to data privacy, employee adaptation, and technological integration. As companies collect and analyze large amounts of customer data, ensuring compliance with regulations like GDPR and the CCPA becomes essential for maintaining trust and security.

Moreover, successfully integrating AI into existing workflows requires significant employee training and adaptation. Sales teams, for example, must learn to trust AI-driven insights while applying their own expertise and judgment. Businesses that invest in upskilling their workforce and fostering a data-driven culture are better positioned to maximize the value of AI-powered CRMs.

The Future of AI-Powered CRMs

Looking ahead, the future of AI-powered CRMs looks promising, with advancements in technologies like edge computing, 5G networks, and blockchain set to enhance CRM capabilities. These innovations will enable real-time data processing and secure data sharing. As AI evolves, businesses can expect more advanced predictive modeling, natural language understanding, and autonomous decision-making, driving further growth and efficiency.

In conclusion, AI-powered CRMs represent a significant shift in customer engagement and business growth. By harnessing the power of AI, companies can gain deep insights into customer behavior, personalize experiences at scale, and automate repetitive tasks. Businesses that adopt AI-powered CRMs will be well-positioned to succeed in the increasingly competitive, data-driven marketplace.

(Source: International Business Times — By Alexander Maxwell — 18th September, 2024)

 

3. HEALTH

#India’s Health Coverage for Seniors Over 70

The Indian government has announced its decision to provide health coverage to all senior citizens aged 70 and above. This decision, approved by the Union Cabinet under the chairmanship of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in the country’s approach towards elder care. The health coverage will be provided under the flagship scheme Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY), also known as AA. This scheme will offer free treatment up to ₹5 lakh to the senior citizens, irrespective of their income.

Abhay Soi, President of NATHEALTH, has lauded this move, calling it a historic shift in the way the country approaches elder care. He emphasized that this segment of the population, which carries a high disease burden, is in urgent need of social protection. He further stated that this initiative will strengthen India’s position as a leader in inclusive healthcare”. So I also highlighted the need for the benefit package to be tailored to the population segment so that it encompasses the entire continuum of care. He assured that NATHEALTH is ready to support the government with the rollout of this scheme.

Under the new provisions, senior citizens aged 70 years and above, who belong to families already covered under the scheme, will receive an additional top-up cover up to ₹5 lakh per year. This amount will not have to be shared with the other members of the family who are below the age of 70 years. All other senior citizens of the age 70 years and above will get a cover up to ₹5 lakh per year on a family basis. The eligible senior citizens will also be issued a new distinct card under the scheme.

Dr. Sudhir Kumar, a renowned neurologist from Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals, Hyderabad, took to social media to express his approval of the government’s decision. He wrote, “Excellent move by the Govt of India to provide health coverage for all people aged 70 and above irrespective of income.” He also urged the government to extend this health coverage to citizens of other age categories. Dr. Kumar pointed out that there are about 9 crore people in the age group of 60 to 70 years. He expressed hope that they could be included in this scheme before 2029 and that by 2034, every Indian citizen would be provided health coverage.

This move by the Indian government is reminiscent of similar initiatives taken by other countries to provide comprehensive health coverage to their senior citizens. For instance, the United States has the Medicare program, which provides health insurance to people aged 65 or older. Similarly, the United Kingdom has the National Health Service, which provides free healthcare to all residents, including senior citizens

(Source: International Business Times — By Sheezan Naseer — 12th September, 2024)

 

4. SPORTS

#”Khelo India” goes global: South Africa hosts first international sports event

The inaugural international edition of the ‘Khelo India’ program, an initiative spearheaded by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has been successfully hosted in South Africa. The event, which concluded after two weeks of competitions, was a massive success.

In a significant milestone for India’s global sports outreach, the first phase of the Khelo India initiative was held outside the country and concluded successfully in South Africa. The two-week-long event united South African and Indian expatriates through competitions in volleyball, badminton, table tennis, and chess.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s vision for Khelo India, which was launched in 2017 to promote sports across India, has now taken an international leap. The event in South Africa is seen as a testament to sports diplomacy, with the initiative aiming to bring people together through athletic engagement.

“Prime Minister Modi is the driving force behind this initiative,” said South African table tennis player Revaldo Wilson. “Sports is powerful, and we enjoyed playing with our Indian brothers.”

The Khelo India event was co-hosted by the India Club and the Consulate General of India in Johannesburg. Manish Gupta, Chairman of the India Club, highlighted the collaboration between local South African associations and various Indian organizations.

“We gladly accepted Consul General Mahesh Kumar’s request to coordinate the event. We brought in a number of Indian expatriate organizations, ensuring inclusivity across the board,” Gupta said.

The tournament saw the South African Tamil Association managing the volleyball competition, while the Gauteng Malayalee Association oversaw badminton. Chess and table tennis were coordinated with local bodies like Chess South Africa and the South African Table Tennis Board. Gupta added that the chess event had international grading, while the table tennis competition was a national championship-level event, attracting top-tier players, including South Africa’s six-time national champion.

Consul General Mahesh Kumar praised the spirit of the event, emphasizing that Khelo India transcends national borders. “Sport unites people in ways that nothing else can. By hosting the first Khelo India games abroad in South Africa, we are building on the special relationship between our two nations. The support from both the Indian diaspora and local South Africans has been overwhelming,” Kumar said.

Kumar also mentioned that participants travelled from neighbouring countries such as Lesotho and Zimbabwe, further highlighting the unifying power of sports.

“This event brings non-mainstream sports into the limelight. We hope it grows into an international movement, perhaps even evolving into an event similar to the Commonwealth or Asian Games,” Kumar added.

While the first phase of the event has concluded, more traditional Indian games such as kabaddi, Kho-Kho, Carrom, and Satoliya/ Lagori will be featured in the second phase, scheduled for December 2024 to January 2025. These games aim to introduce Indian cultural sports to a wider audience in South Africa.

The event not only created a platform for Indian expatriates but also strengthened bonds with the local South African community. Gupta noted that each sport was organized in collaboration with local partners, ensuring a strong foundation for future events. For example, the volleyball competition was supported by the South African Masters’ Volleyball Association and the chess tournament by Chess South Africa and the Johannesburg Metro Chess bodies.

(Source: International Business Times – By Steven Klien – 17th September, 2024)

Letters to the Editor

Sir,

Re: Your Editorial in the September 2024 issue of the BCAJ

You have made a great effort to communicate the taxpayers’ sufferings under Direct and Indirect taxes. In fact, it is your duty to sum up the real problems taxpayers are facing. It is because an editor has a great influence on the policymakers. Whatever suggestions you make, as an editor, they are considered by the Finance Ministry as well as the Finance Minister.

Faceless proceedings give tremendous opportunity to the authorities to take fair and reasonable decisions. It is because no one can make allegations of any corruption, as the proceedings are faceless. However, the desired change in the mindset of the authorities have not taken place. At times, High Courts have to levy costs on the authorities for taking obvious unreasonable decisions.

In the end, I must appreciate your tireless effort to bring in the existing ground realities in very lucid and clear terms, in your editorial.

Regards,

Adv. R. K. Sinha

Ex – DIT and IRS


Dear Sir,

Hats off to CA Raman Jokhakar for his candid and thought-provoking article in “Chatting up about India: When a $10 Trillion Economy Won’t Make a Difference”, published in the August 2024 issue of the BCAJ. It is very well written, detailing what is mentioned in the title, in a very systematic and analytical manner. It is worth sharing, going through a number of times and deliberating on it. We sincerely hope that many, especially those who matter, do take some cues out of it and amplify further on the contents thereof to take our motherland and country to greater heights.

Once again congratulations to Ramanji and our appreciation and accolades for the excellent article.

With Best Regards,

Rakesh Parikh


Dear Editor,

I have been studying (not reading) the BCAJ for more than three decades. The articles are well-researched and thought-provoking. The BCAJ is a professional life-line for me. I do not find such kind of articles in any of the professional magazines which I read. I always ensure that all my colleagues subscribe to the BCAJ and study it.

I am highly impressed and absorbed with the INSPIRING QUOTES given in the August Journal. I am sure this will help the younger generation to know about the infinite knowledge that Bharat possessed and has in every field of mankind.

Again, there are no words to express the high quality of the BCAJ, which the Team has been maintaining for over seven decades and the future to come.

Regards,

R.S. Balasubramanyam

FCA, FCS, LLB and IP

Introspection

Once a few Indians were discussing with some friends from Western countries about the difference between the Indian culture vis-à-vis the Western culture. Indians were as usual boasting of their spiritual heritage to which the Westerners agreed. But they said, ‘We agree that spiritual principles are deeply rooted in the mind of even illiterate common man of India’. They have less greed. They are contented with small things and have no craze for hifi living. They are pious and God-fearing. These principles of detachment are not understood by even the highly educated people in Western countries.

However, they added, that even an illiterate common man from Western countries understands the importance of cleanliness. He knows disciplined behaviour and has a good civic sense of not throwing garbage anywhere in an indiscreet manner and not spitting anywhere he likes.
This understanding is not found even among the moneyed and so-called educated people in India! Indians had to keep quiet.

There is a very interesting true story about this. One Australian lady had come to watch the Asian Games held in India in the year 1982. From there, she went to Kolkata to stay with some close acquaintances. One day she was invited to a function. The Indian audience asked her as to what she felt about Kolkata city, whether she liked it etc. She said she liked it. Still, they insisted that she should express her opinion frankly. So, she said, everything is alright, but there is a lot of filth around. There is a total lack of cleanliness.

The people tried to argue and pointed out to her – “Madam, are you aware that there are as many as one crore people staying in Kolkata? They wanted, perhaps, to justify the lack of cleanliness.”

She retorted- “How many more people do you need to keep the city clean?”

This is really an eye-opener, and it underlines the fact that it is everybody’s responsibility to have civic sense and keep the surroundings clean!

I heard another very interesting story which is the height of honesty. In a village, there was a small boy who was very poor. But he had a habit that whatever little he got, he used to offer half of it to the Lord Krishna in a particular temple. Once he stole a banana from a shop; offered half of it to the God and ate the remaining half. The shopkeeper was watching all this with interest. He caught him and said, I saw you stealing the banana and also that you kept half of it in the temple. I know, you are poor but a good and innocent boy. At the same time, the theft has to be punished. So, have 3 rounds (pradakshina) around the temple. The boy started the ‘pradakshina’. The shopkeeper was amazed to notice that Bhagwan Krishna was also walking along with the boy. When he came closer, he told the shopkeeper – “haven’t I eaten the half banana? So, I also should share the punishment”.

This is our concept of God, friends. We should try to emulate all the good things stated in this short article.

Regulatory Referencer

I. DIRECT TAX: SPOTLIGHT

1. CBDT issues circular revising the monetary threshold for filing of appeals — Circular No. 09/2024 dated
17th September, 2024

Circular 5 of 2024 dated 15th March, 2024 had prescribed monetary limits for filing income tax appeals by the Income tax department. The limits are revised to ₹5 crore, ₹2 crore, and ₹60 lakhs respectively for filing appeals before the Supreme Court, High Court, and Income Tax Appellate tribunal respectively. CBDT has further clarified that the Department should not file an appeal merely because the tax effect exceeds the monetary limit but filing of an appeal should be decided based on the merits of each case.

II. COMPANIES ACT, 2013

1. C-PACE to facilitate voluntary LLP closures under new rules effective 27th August, 2024: The Hon’ble Finance Minister, in her budget speech, announced that the services of the Centre for Processing Accelerated Corporate Exit (C-PACE) would be extended to facilitate the voluntary closure of LLPs. Accordingly, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has notified the Limited Liability Partnership (Amendment) Rules, 2024. Under these amended rules, the application for voluntary closure of LLPs will now be approved by C-PACE instead of the ROC effective from the 27th August, 2024, [MCA Notification G.S.R. 475(E), dated 5th August, 2024]

2. Foreign Companies must now file Form FC-1 with CRC within 30 days of setting up business in India: MCA has notified the Companies (Registration of Foreign Companies) (Amendment) Rules, 2024. Pursuant to the amendment to Rule 3(3), a foreign company must now file Form FC-1 with the Registrar, Central Registration Centre (CRC), within thirty days of establishing its place of business in India. Further, documents for registration by a foreign company must also be delivered in Form FC-1 to the Registrar, Central Registration Centre. These rules are effective from 9th September, 2024. [Notification No. G.S.R 491(E), dated 12th August, 2024]

3. MCA introduces ‘Ind AS 117’ on Insurance Contracts: MCA has notified Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Amendment Rules, 2024. As per the amended norms, a new Ind AS 117 relating to ‘Insurance Contracts’ has been inserted. Ind AS 117 establishes principles for recognizing, measuring, presenting, and disclosing insurance contracts. The objective is to ensure that an entity provides relevant information that faithfully represents those contracts. An entity is expected to apply Ind AS 117 to insurance, reinsurance, and investment contracts. [Notification No. G.S.R 492(E), Dated 12th August, 2024]

III. SEBI

1. SEBI launches chatbot “SEVA” for investors: SEBI has launched its Virtual Assistant (SEVA) – an Artificial Intelligence (AI) based conversation platform for investors. The Beta version of the chatbot includes features like citations for generated responses, speech-to-text and text-to-speech functionality for accessibility, etc. The chatbot is presently enabled to answer questions regarding general information on the securities market, grievance redressal process, etc. The beta version is available on SEBI’s investor website and the SAARTHI mobile app. [PR NO. 14/2024, dated 29th July, 2024]

2. Stock exchanges and clearing corporations must now disclose shareholding patterns in the format as per LODR norms: SEBI has notified an amendment to the Securities Contracts (Regulation) (Stock Exchanges and Clearing Corporations) Regulations, 2018. As per the amended norms, stock exchanges and clearing corporations are now required to disclose their shareholding pattern on their respective websites every quarter as per the requirements and format specified for listed companies under LODR Regulations. [Notification No. SEBI/LAD-NRO/GN/2024/196, dated 29th July, 2024]

3. AMCs must have surveillance, controls, and escalation processes to detect and prevent potential market abuse: Earlier, SEBI carried out a public consultation on the proposal of putting in place a structured institutional mechanism at the end of AMCs, which can proactively identify and deter instances of such market abuse. Accordingly, the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996 was amended. Now, SEBI has directed that this mechanism shall consist of enhanced surveillance systems, internal control procedures, & escalation processes to effectively identify, monitor & address misconduct. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/IMD/IMD-POD-1/P/CIR/2024/107, dated 5th August, 2024]

4. SEBI issues guidelines for borrowings by Category I and Category II Alternative Investment Funds: SEBI has issued guidelines for borrowing by Category I and II Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs). As per the new norms, Category I and II AIFs are allowed to borrow to meet a temporary shortfall in the amount called from investors for making investments in investee companies (‘drawdown amount’). Further, all Category I and II AIFs must maintain a 30-day cooling-off period between two periods of borrowing as permissible under AIF Regulations. The circular shall be effective immediately. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/AFD/AFD-POD-1/P/CIR/2024/112, dated 19th August, 2024]

5. Research Analysts must be entitled to charge fees for providing research services to Clients: SEBI has notified an amendment to the SEBI (Research Analysts) Regulations, 2014. As per the newly inserted norms, a Research Analyst must be entitled to charge fees for providing research services from a client, including an accredited investor, in the manner specified by the Board. These amended norms shall come into force from the date of their publication in the Official Gazette i.e., 19th August, 2024. [Notification No. SEBI/LAD-NRO/GN/2024/199, dated 19th August, 2024]

IV. FEMA:

1. Important amendments in Non-debt Instruments Rules:

NDI Rules under FEMA have been liberalised and the following are the amendments in brief. A swap of shares leading to an ODI transaction as well as an FDI transaction is called an “ODI-FDI swap” in general parlance. While Overseas Direct Investment (ODI) has been permitted through the swap of shares of any entity vide the new Overseas Investment regime notified in August 2022, FDI through the swap of shares of a foreign entity was still under the Approval route. Hence, the FDI leg of an ODI-FDI swap required prior approval. The Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Rules, 2019 have been amended to permit FDI through the swap of shares. This has enabled full ODI-FDI swap under the automatic route. This has eased out several transactions and arrangements.

The other amendments in NDI Rules include an updation in the definition of control and start-up; clarity in the calculation of indirect foreign investment by excluding the investment made on a non-repatriation basis from the same; increase in limit on foreign portfolio investment under the automatic route from 49 per cent to the respective sectoral cap prescribed; and liberalization of norms for FDI in White Label ATM operations. Please refer to the NDI Rules for complete information.

[Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instruments) (Fourth Amendment) Rules,
2024 – Notification S.O. 3492(E) [F. NO. 1/8/2024-EM], dated 16th August, 2024]

2. Scheme notified for trading and settlement of Sovereign Green Bonds in IFSC

The FEM (Debt Regulations), 2019 were amended in August 2024 permitting persons resident outside India to purchase or sell Sovereign Green Bonds issued by the Government of India in IFSC. Now, the scheme for trading and settlement of sovereign green bonds in IFSC has been notified by the IFSCA. The operational guidelines for participation in the Scheme by entities in the IFSC shall be further issued by the IFSC Authority.

[Circular No. CO.FMRD.FMIA.NO.S242/11-01-051/2024–25, dated 29th August, 2024]

3. Listing Regulations notified in IFSC:

The IFSCA (Listing) Regulations, 2024 have been notified for IPOs, debt securities, and secondary listings in IFSC exchanges. There have already been amendments in the Companies Act and FEMA enabling provisions for Indian companies to list in IFSC exchanges. These regulations provide a comprehensive framework for the same.

[International Financial Services Centres Authority (Listing) Regulations, 2024 – Notification No. IFSCA/GN/2024/006, dated 20th August, 2024]

4. Discontinuation of monthly LRS returns to be submitted by Banks

AD Category-I banks were required to furnish information on the number of applications received and the total amount remitted under LRS on a monthly basis in the Centralised Information Management System (CIMS). This requirement has been discontinued from the reporting month of September 2024. The banks will be required to upload only transaction-wise information under LRS daily return at the close of business of the next working day. The Master Direction — Reporting under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 has also been updated to reflect this change.

[A.P. (DIR SERIES 2024–25) Circular No. 16, dated 6th September, 2024]

5. New rules notified for compounding under FEMA:

The Central Government has notified Foreign Exchange (Compounding Proceedings) Rules, 2024 in supersession of the Foreign Exchange (Compounding Proceedings) Rules, 2000. There has been an increase in the amount of fees to be paid while submitting the compounding application from INR 5,000 to 10,000 and the pecuniary limits with respect to which the powers have been delegated to the officers to compound the contravention. The non-compoundable offenses have been specifically listed and multiple forms which were required to be submitted along with the compounding application have been merged into a single form.

[Foreign Exchange (Compounding Proceedings) Rules, 2024 — Notification No. G.S.R. 566(E) [F. NO. 1/10/2023-EM], dated 12th September, 2024]

Part A | Company Law

8 In the Matter of:

M/S Lions Co-Ordination of Committee of India Association

Registrar of Companies, Chennai

Adjudication Order No. ROC/CHN/ADJ/LIONS CO/S.134(3)(b)24

Date of Order: 25th June, 2024

Adjudication Order on Company and its Directors for Non-disclosure of details of the Number of Board Meetings conducted and the Dates of Board Meetings held during the financial years 2018–19 and 2019–20. This amounts to violation of the provisions of Section 134(3) (b) with Secretarial Standard-4 of the Companies Act, 2013, and hence, penalty was imposed under Section 134(8) of the Companies Act, 2013.

FACTS

An inquiry was conducted in the matter of M/s LCCIA by officer authorised by Central Government (CG), wherein it was observed that:

M/s LCCIA had not disclosed number of Board meetings conducted and dates of Board meetings in its Director’s Report for the Financial Year (FY) 2018–19.

Further, it was observed that in the Director’s Report for the FY 2019–20, the Company had disclosed that the maximum interval between any two meetings was well within the maximum period of 120 days. However, as per provisions of Section 134(3)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013 (CA 2013), “Number of Board Meetings conducted” should be disclosed and as per Secretarial Standard-4, the company should disclose “Dates of Board Meetings” conducted by the Company during the year.

Thereafter, the officer submitted his Inspection Report to the Regional Director (RD) of Chennai, and the office of RD had directed to initiate necessary action against the defaulters.

Thereafter, the Adjudicating Authority / Officer issued a Show Cause Notice (SCN) on 8th September, 2023 to M/s LCCIA and its directors. Mr Shri VPN was the only Director of M/s LCCIA who had filed a suo-moto Adjudication application in form GNL-1 dated 25th November, 2023. Therefore, on the basis of such application received from Mr Shri VPN, the AO imposed penalty on him for violation of Section 134(3)(b) of CA 2013.

Since no reply / information was received from M/s LCCIA and its other directors, the AO decided to fix a final hearing on 8th April, 2024 to complete the adjudication proceedings and issue notice to M/s LCCIA and all its Directors except Mr Shri VPN.

Pursuant to the notice, Mr PPK, Company Secretary appeared on behalf of the directors Mr VKL, Mr JPS, Mr NJKM and Mr RS before Adjudicating Authority and submitted that violation may be adjudicated.

RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF CA 2013:

134. Financial statement, Board’s Report, etc.

(3) There shall be attached to statement laid before a company in general meeting, a report by its Board of Directors, which shall include-

(a) the web address, if any, where annual return referred to in sub-section (3) Section 92 has been placed

(b) number of meetings of the Board;

(8) If a company is in default in complying with the provisions of this section, the Company shall be liable to a penalty of three lakh rupees and every officer of the company who is in default shall be liable to a penalty of fifty thousand rupees

Part I- SS-4: Secretarial Standard on the Report of Board of Directors: Board Meetings:

The number and dates of meetings of the Board held during the year shall be disclosed in the Report.

ORDER

After considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the AO concluded that M/s LCCIA and its directors had violated Section 134(3)(b) of CA 2013 and were liable for penalty as prescribed under Section 134(8) of CA 2013 for the FYs 2018–19 and 2019–20.

AO, accordingly, imposed penalty on the Company and its Officers in default aggregating to ₹ 24 lakhs. The said amount of penalty was to be paid through online mode by using the website www.mca.gov.in (Misc. head) within 90 days of receipt of this order, and intimate with proof of penalty paid.

Contingent Features and SPPI Test

IASB has amended IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 with respect to contingent features, which will take effect from reporting periods beginning on or after 1st January, 2026. We can expect similar amendments in Ind AS in the near term, probably taking effect from 1st April, 2026. The amendments provide some leeway, such that the SPPI test will be considered met even if there are contingent features in an instrument, that alter the contractual cash flows. The amendments were introduced to provide some relief in situations where contractual cash flows are altered because of reduction in carbon emissions. The amendments will apply to all contingent features including those relating to carbon emissions. In this article, the author has provided the existing requirements and the amendments in a very simplified question and answer format.

FINANCIAL ASSETS AND AMORTISED COST

Which are the financial assets that can be classified under the ‘amortised cost’ category?

A ‘debt instrument’ can be measured at the amortised cost if both the following conditions are met:

(a) The asset is held within a business model whose objective is to hold assets for collecting contractual cash flows, and

(b) Contractual terms of the asset give rise on specified dates to cash flows that are solely payments of principal and interest (SPPI) on the principal amount outstanding.

Financial assets included within this category are initially recognised at fair value plus transaction costs that are directly attributable to the acquisition of the financial asset and subsequently measured at amortised cost. The following diagram explains the classification requirements.

FVTOCI is Fair Value through Other Comprehensive Income.

FVTPL is Fair Value through Profit and Loss.

CONTRACTUAL CASH FLOWS

ANALYSIS — SPPI TEST

After assessing the business model, the entity should assess whether the asset’s contractual cash flows represent solely payments of principal and interest (SPPI). This test is also referred to as the ‘SPPI’ test.

What is the relevance of SPPI test for deciding classification of financial assets?

SPPI test is required to decide whether an instrument structured as ‘debt instrument’ actually has the ‘basic loan features’. Ind AS 109 allows amortisation or FVTOCI measurement categories only for the debt instruments which satisfy the SPPI test. All other debt instruments need to be classified as at FVTPL, irrespective of the business model.

The SPPI is designed to weed out financial assets on which the application of the effective interest rate (EIR) method either is not viable from a pure mechanical standpoint or does not provide decision useful information. Since the EIR is a mechanism to allocate interest over time, Ind AS 109 allows measurements requiring the use of this methodology only for the instruments having low variability such as traditional unleveraged loans and receivables and ‘plain vanilla’ debt instruments. Thus, the SPPI test is based on the premise that contractual cash flows should give the holder a return which is in line with a ‘basic lending arrangement’.

Are the terms ‘principal’ and ‘interest’ defined for SPPI test?

Ind AS 109 provides the following definitions to help management in making a preliminary assessment of whether contractual cash flows represent SPPI:

Principal: is the fair value of the financial asset at initial recognition. However, that principal amount may change over the life of the financial asset, e.g., if there are repayments of principal.

Interest: Is typically the compensation for the time value of money and credit risk. However, interest can also include consideration for other basic lending risks (for example, liquidity risk) and costs (for example, servicing or administrative costs) associated with holding the financial asset for a period of time, as well as a profit margin.

Consider that contractual provisions of a debt instrument contain clauses which may modify the cash flows of an instrument. How should an entity assess the impact of modifications? Does it mean that SPPI test will not be met?

Ind AS 109 requires that if contractual provisions of an instrument contain elements that modify the time value of money, the entity should compare the financial asset under assessment to a standard/ benchmark instrument without any modification in the time value of money. If cash flows of the two instruments are significantly different, the instrument under assessment fails the SPPI test. If the cash flows of the two instruments are not significantly different, the instrument with modified cash flows will also meet the SPPI test.

The standard clarifies that it will be not necessary for an entity to perform a detailed quantitative assessment if it is clear with little or no analysis that cash flows of the instrument under assessment and those of the benchmark instrument are or are not significantly different.

The standard does not provide any specific guidance or bright-lines to be used for deciding whether cash flows of two instruments are ‘significantly different’. This will require entities to exercise judgment. For example, less than 5 per cent difference in cash flows in each reporting period as well as cumulatively over the life of the asset may not be significant. However, 20 per cent difference either in a reporting period or cumulatively over the life of the asset is likely to be significant.

Is an entity required to consider all features of the instruments while performing SPPI test?

In performing SPPI test, an entity can ignore de minimis features and non-genuine features.

The de minimis threshold is about magnitude of modification. To be considered de minimis, the impact of feature on the cash flows needs to be de minimis in each reporting period as well as cumulatively over the life of the asset. For example, a feature will not be considered de minimis if it could lead to a significant increase in cash flows in one period and a significant decrease in another period and the amounts offset each other on a cumulative basis. Similarly, if the impact of the feature on the cash flows of each individual period is always de minimis but its cumulative effect over time is more than de minimis; such a feature cannot be considered de minimis.

Ind AS 109 does not specify whether an entity should perform qualitative or quantitative analysis to determine whether a feature is de minimis. The author believes that in most cases, an entity should be able to conclude this without a quantitative analysis.

If a ₹10 million loan contains an early repayment clause which, if exercised, requires repayment of outstanding principal and interest plus ₹100, the additional ₹100 would have only a de minimis impact to cash flows in all circumstances. It is clearly trivial and negligible.

When assessing if a feature is de minimis an entity is not permitted to take into account the probability that the future event will occur, unless the contingent feature is not genuine. De minimis must be assessed at the individual financial asset level and not at some higher level, for example at a portfolio or entity level, because what is not de minimis at the financial instrument level may be de minimis at the portfolio level. Additionally, the assessment should be made by reference to all the cash flows of an instrument (principal and interest).

Non-genuine features are contingent features. A contingent feature is not genuine if it affects the instrument’s contractual cash flows only on the occurrence of an event that is extremely rare, highly abnormal and very unlikely to occur. This implies that although a non-genuine feature can potentially lead to cash flows to significant changes in cash flows, its existence in the contract provisions will not fail the SPPI test. Disregarding non-genuine features also means that classification requirements cannot be overridden by introducing a contractual non-genuine cash flow characteristic to achieve a specific accounting outcome. A clause should not be considered ‘not genuine’ just because historically the relevant event has not occurred. If a clause is ‘not genuine’ the fair value and pricing of the instrument would also be expected to be the same regardless of whether or not the clause is included.

A contract issued at par permits the issuer to repay the debt instrument, or the holder to put the debt instrument back to the issuer before maturity at par, when the BSE 100 index reaches a specific level. When the contingent event takes place, it results in a pre-payment that represents unpaid amounts of principal and interest on the principal amount outstanding. Does this always pass the SPPI test?

Yes. The contingent event (the BSE100 index reaching a specific level) changes the timing of the cash flows, but it still results in the redemption of the debt for an amount equal to par plus accrued interest. Therefore, it will always pass the SPPI test, because the cash flows still represent solely payments of principal and interest on the principal amount outstanding. If, on the other hand, the debt instrument was issued at a discount, but it is repayable at par, this may represent compensation to the issuer for the BSE 100 achieving the target level, which is inconsistent with SPPI.

Ve Co borrows ₹100 million from a bank. The borrowing agreement permits the bank to demand early repayment if Ve’s credit rating falls by more than two notches compared with the credit rating at origination. Is the SPPI test met in this case?

The contingent feature within the early repayment term is consistent with a return of principal and interest on the principal outstanding because the contingent event is directly linked to the credit risk of the borrower, i.e. the prepayment option is designed to provide the lender with the protection from the adverse changes in credit quality of the borrower. The credit risk of the borrower is a risk that is reflected in a basic lending arrangement. Therefore, SPPI test is met.

IFRS 9 AND IFRS 7 AMENDMENTS

The amendments introduce an additional test for financial assets with contingent features to meet SPPI test if contingent feature does not change in basic lending risks or costs, e.g. the interest rate on a loan is adjusted by a specified amount if the borrower achieves a contractually specified reduction in carbon emissions. Under this example, returns have changed due to a contingent event and credit risks (lending risk) of borrower will remain unchanged.

While the amendments may allow certain financial assets with contingent features to meet the SPPI criterion, companies may need to perform additional work to prove this. Judgement will be required in determining whether the new test is met.

IASB has introduced following additional SPPI test:

IASB has prescribed corresponding additional disclosures for financial instruments with a contingent feature that is not measured at fair value through profit and loss:

  • a qualitative description of the nature of the contingent event
  • quantitative information about the range of possible changes to contractual cash flows that could result from those contractual terms
  • the gross carrying amount of financial assets and the amortised cost of financial liabilities subject to those contractual terms.

Ind AS 117 – Insurance Contracts

INTRODUCTION

We have got used to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) introducing new Accounting Standards at the end of a financial year. Both Ind AS 115 — Revenue from Contracts with Customers and Ind AS 116 — Leases were announced in the end of March. One would have thought that the same pattern would play out for the implementation of Ind AS 117 — Insurance Contracts. However, the MCA pulled a surprise on 12th August, 2024 by not only announcing the Standard but also making it applicable for the Financial Year 2024–25. Ind AS 117 is a much more detailed and comprehensive standard than Ind AS 104 – Insurance Contracts. Ind AS 117 takes into account that the insurance and banking industries provide services that complement each other. Ind AS 117 acknowledges this and takes us back to Ind AS 109 wherever there is a trace of a financial instrument in an insurance contract. Ind AS 117 is a detailed standard: the standard has 132 main paragraphs, 154 paragraphs of application guidance, 22 definitions and 57 paragraphs on transition provisions.

SCOPE

Ind AS 117 defines an insurance contract as “A contract under which one party (the issuer) accepts significant insurance risk from another party (the policyholder) by agreeing to compensate the policyholder if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the policyholder”. By definition, it is clear that Ind AS 117 would apply to plain-vanilla insurance contracts such as fire, life, theft, damage, product liability, professional liability, life-contingent annuities or pensions and medical costs, etc. However, by interpretation of the definition, Ind AS 117 would also apply to product warranties issued by another party on behalf of the manufacturer, surety, fidelity and catastrophe bonds and insurance swaps. (Para B 26 of Ind AS 117).

GROUPING OF CONTRACTS

IND AS 117 requires entities to identify portfolios of insurance contracts, which comprises contracts that are subject to similar risks and managed together. Contracts within a product line would be expected to have similar risks and hence would be expected to be in the same portfolio if they are managed together. Each portfolio of insurance contracts issues shall be divided into a minimum of three cohorts: onerous contracts, contracts that could not turn onerous and a residuary category. An entity is not permitted to include contracts issued more than one year apart in the same group.

RECOGNITION

An entity shall recognise a group of insurance contracts it issues from the earliest beginning of the coverage period, the date when the first payment from a policyholder in the group becomes due or for a group of onerous contracts, when the group becomes onerous.

MEASUREMENT

Ind AS 117 provides three methods to measure insurance contracts:

1. General Measurement Model or Building Block Approach: the default method

2. Premium Allocation Approach: an optional method for certain specific type of contracts

3. Variable fee approach: a specific method for direct participating contracts.

BUILDING BLOCK APPROACH

Ind AS 117 mandates that on initial recognition, an entity shall measure a group of insurance contracts at the total of the fulfilment cash flows (FCF) and a contractual service margin (CSM). FCFs are an explicit, unbiased and probability-weighted estimate (i.e., expected value) of the present value of the future cash outflows minus the present value of the future cash inflows that will arise as the entity fulfils insurance contracts, including a risk adjustment for non-financial risk.

Risk adjustment for non-financial risk

The estimate of the present value of the future cash flows is adjusted to reflect the compensation that the entity requires for bearing the uncertainty about the amount and timing of future cash flows that arises from non-financial risk.

Contractual service margin

The CSM represents the unearned profit of the group of insurance contracts that the entity will recognise as it provides services in the future. This is measured on initial recognition of a group of insurance contracts at an amount that, unless the group of contracts is onerous, results in no income or expenses arising from:

(a) the initial recognition of an amount for the FCF,

(b) the derecognition at that date of any asset or liability recognised for insurance acquisition cash flows, and

(c) any cash flows arising from the contracts in the group at that date.

As a simple mathematical example, assume that over a three-year insurance contract, an insurance company estimates discounted cash inflows to be ₹1,000, discounted outflows to be ₹200, risk adjustment for non-financial risk to be ₹150 and the CSM to be ₹100, the value of the insurance contract at initial measurement would be ₹1,050.

Subsequent measurement

On subsequent measurement, the carrying amount of a group of insurance contracts at the end of each reporting period shall be the sum of:

(a) the liability for remaining coverage comprising:

(i) the FCF related to future services, and

(ii) the CSM of the group at that date;

(b) the liability for incurred claims, comprising the FCF related to past service allocated to the group at that date.

Onerous contracts

Taking a cue from Ind AS 37, Ind AS 117 states that an insurance contract is onerous at initial recognition if the total of the FCF, any previously recognised acquisition cash flows and any cash flows arising from the contract at that date are a net outflow. An entity shall recognise a loss in profit or loss for the net outflow, resulting in the carrying amount of the liability for the group being equal to the FCF and the CSM of the group being zero. On subsequent measurement, if a group of insurance contracts becomes onerous (or more onerous), that excess shall be recognised in profit or loss.

As a simple mathematical example, assume that over a three-year insurance contract, an insurance company estimates discounted cash inflows to be ₹1,000, discounted outflows to be ₹1,200 and risk adjustment for non-financial risk to be ₹150. The net outflow of ₹350 would be recognised in the profit or loss account. CSM would always be Nil for onerous contracts.

PREMIUM ALLOCATION APPROACH

An entity may simplify the measurement of the liability for remaining coverage of a group of insurance contracts using the Premium Allocation Approach (PAA) on the condition that at the inception of the group:

(a) the entity reasonably expects that this will be a reasonable approximation of the general model, or

(b) the coverage period of each contract in the group is one year or less.

Where, at the inception of the group, an entity expects significant variances in the FCF during the period before a claim is incurred, such contracts are not eligible to apply the PAA.

Using the PAA, the liability for remaining coverage shall be initially recognised as the premiums, if any, received at initial recognition, minus any insurance acquisition cash flows. Subsequently, the carrying amount of the liability is the carrying amount at the start of the reporting period plus the premiums received in the period, minus insurance acquisition cash flows, plus amortisation of acquisition cash flows, minus the amount recognised as insurance revenue for coverage provided in that period, and minus any investment component paid or transferred to the liability for incurred claims.

VARIABLE FEE APPROACH

The Variable Fee Approach (VFA) is a modified model for insurance contracts with direct participation features. The VFA defines a variable fee as the entity’s share of the underlying items as a fee for the services it provides. The value of the variable fee changes based on the value of the assets.

REINSURANCE CONTRACTS HELD

The requirements of the standard are modified for reinsurance contracts held.

In estimating the present value of future expected cash flows for reinsurance contracts, entities use assumptions consistent with those used for related direct insurance contracts. Additionally, estimates include the risk of reinsurer’s non-performance.

The risk adjustment for non-financial risk is estimated to represent the transfer of risk from the holder of the reinsurance contract to the reinsurer.

On initial recognition, the CSM is determined similarly to that of direct insurance contracts issued, except that the CSM represents net gain or loss on purchasing reinsurance. On initial recognition, this net gain or loss is deferred, unless the net loss relates to events that occurred before purchasing a reinsurance contract (in which case, it is expensed immediately).

Subsequently, reinsurance contracts held are accounted similarly to insurance contracts under the general model. Changes in reinsurer’s risk of non-performance are reflected in profit or loss, and do not adjust the CSM.

MODIFICATION OF AN INSURANCE CONTRACT

If the terms of an insurance contract are modified, an entity shall derecognise the original contract and recognise the modified contract as a new contract if there is a substantive modification, based on meeting any of the specified criteria.

The modification is substantive if any of the following conditions are satisfied:

(a) if, had the modified terms been included at contract’s inception, this would have led to:

(i) exclusion from the Standard’s scope;

(ii) unbundling of different embedded derivatives;

(iii) redefinition of the contract boundary; or

(iv) the reallocation to a different group of contracts; or

(b) if the original contract met the definition of direct par insurance contracts, but the modified contract no longer meets that definition, or vice versa; or

(c) the entity originally applied the PAA, but the contract’s modifications made it no longer eligible for it.

DERECOGNITION

An entity shall derecognise an insurance contract when it is extinguished, or if any of the conditions of a substantive modification of an insurance contract are met.

Presentation in the statement of financial position

An entity shall present separately in the statement of financial position the carrying amount of groups of:

(a) insurance contracts issued that are assets;

(b) insurance contracts issued that are liabilities;

(c) reinsurance contracts held that are assets; and

(d) reinsurance contracts held that are liabilities.

Recognition and presentation in the statement(s) of financial performance

An entity shall disaggregate the amounts recognised in the statement(s) of financial performance into:

(a) an insurance service result, comprising insurance revenue and insurance service expenses; and

(b) insurance finance income or expenses.

Income or expenses from reinsurance contracts held shall be presented separately from the expenses or income from insurance contracts issued.

Insurance service result

An entity shall present in profit or loss revenue arising from the groups of insurance contracts issued, and insurance service expenses arising from a group of insurance contracts it issues, comprising incurred claims and other incurred insurance service expenses. Revenue and insurance service expenses shall exclude any investment components. An entity shall not present premiums in the profit or loss if that information is inconsistent with revenue presented

Insurance finance income or expenses

Insurance finance income or expenses comprises the change in the carrying amount of the group of insurance contracts arising from:

(a) the effect of the time value of money and changes in the time value of money; and

(b) the effect of changes in assumptions that relate to financial risk; but

(c) excluding any such changes for groups of insurance contracts with direct participating insurance contracts that would instead adjust the CSM.

An entity has an accounting policy choice between including all of insurance finance income or expense for the period in profit or loss or disaggregating it between an amount presented in profit or loss and an amount presented in other comprehensive income (OCI).

Under the general model, disaggregating means presenting in profit or loss an amount determined by a systematic allocation of the expected total insurance finance income or expenses over the duration of the group of contracts. On derecognition of the groups, amounts remaining in OCI are reclassified to profit or loss.

Under the VFA, for direct par insurance contracts, only where the entity holds the underlying items, disaggregating means presenting in profit or loss as insurance finance income or expenses an amount that eliminates the accounting mismatches with the finance income or expenses arising on the underlying items. On derecognition of the groups, the amounts previously recognised in OCI remain there.

DISCLOSURES

An entity shall disclose qualitative and quantitative information about:

(a) the amounts recognised in its financial statements that arise from insurance contracts;

(b) the significant judgements, and changes in those judgements, made when applying IND AS 117; and

(c) the nature and extent of the risks that arise from insurance contracts.

IRDAI

Now that Ind AS 117 has been issued, insurance companies would be looking forward to final formats and instructions from their regulator, Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI). In the past, IRDAI has had committees to suggest formats and guidelines for the implementation of Ind AS. A report of an erstwhile Committee was received in 2018 but since there were a few revisions made to IFRS 17, a new committee was formed in early 2024. IRDAI would need to implement the suggestions made by the Committee when its report is received.

IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES

Given the short time provided to insurance companies to implement the standard, they could face a few implementation issues. The fact that most of these companies have also not implemented Ind AS 109 – Financial Instruments further adds to their implementation issues since Ind AS 117 refers to Ind AS 109 quite frequently. The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) has published a report on the impact of IFRS – 17 and the challenges in implementation of the standard. The challenges were divided into four categories: understanding the standard, getting the data, interpreting the financial statements and building the systems. In India, there could be a further challenge in terms of impact on GST and income tax. GST laws would not recognise concepts such as CSM and risk adjustments while the Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS) have still not been upgraded to deal with any of the Ind AS accounting standards. Skilling the finance and accounts team on the nuances of the Standard through training programs would probably be the first priority for insurance companies.

Bank Accounts and Repatriation Facilities for Non-Residents

In this article, we have discussed the rules and regulations related to NRO, NRE, FCNR and other accounts pertaining to Non-residents under Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA).

BANK ACCOUNTS

Opening, holding and maintaining accounts in India by a person resident outside India is regulated in terms of 6 section 6(3) of the FEMA, 1999 read with Foreign Exchange Management (Deposit) Regulations, 2016 (‘Deposit Regulations’) issued vide Notification No. FEMA 5(R)/2016-RB dated 1st April, 2016, Master Direction – Deposits and Accounts FED Master Direction No. 14/2015-16 dated 1st January, 2016 and FAQs on Accounts in India by Non-residents, updated from time to time, provides further guidance on the same.

An Authorised Dealer (AD) bank is permitted to open in India the following types of accounts for persons resident outside India:

i) Non-Resident (External) Account Scheme (NRE account) for a non-resident Indian (NRI) – Schedule 1 of the Deposit Regulations;

ii) Foreign Currency (Non-Resident) Account Banks Scheme, (FCNR(B) account) for a non-resident Indian – Schedule 2 of the Deposit Regulations;

iii) Non-Resident (Ordinary) Account Scheme (NRO account) for any person resident outside India – Schedule 3 of the Deposit Regulations;

iv) Special Non-Resident Rupee Account (SNRR account) for any person resident outside India having a business interest in India – Schedule 4 of the Deposit Regulations;

v) Escrow Account for resident or non-resident acquirers – Schedule 5 of the Deposit Regulations.

Currently, a company or a body corporate, a proprietary concern or a firm in India may accept deposits from an NRI or PIO on a non-repatriation basis only1 – Other conditions that apply to such deposits include:

  • Deposit should be for a maximum maturity period of three years.
  • Deposit can be received from NRO account only.
  • Rate of interest should not exceed the ceiling rate prescribed under the Companies (Acceptance of Deposit) Rules, 2014 / NBFC guidelines / directions issued by RBI.
  • Deposit shall not be utilised for relending (other than NBFC) or for undertaking agricultural/plantation activities or real estate business.
  • The amount of deposits accepted shall not be allowed to be repatriated outside India.

Under the current regulations, a company or a body corporate is not permitted to accept any fresh deposits on repatriation basis from an NRI or PIO. However, it is only permitted to renew the deposits which had already been accepted under the erstwhile Notification.


1 Refer Schedule 7 of the Deposit Regulations

KEY FEATURES OF NRE, FCNR (B) AND NRO ACCOUNTS

NRIs usually have majority of their earnings in foreign currency and thus their financial and investment objectives differ from residents. NRIs and PIOs are permitted to open and maintain accounts with authorised dealers and banks (including co-operative banks) authorised by the Reserve Bank to maintain such accounts. The major types of accounts that can be opened by an NRI2 or PIO3 in India include NRE, NRO and FCNR accounts. The key features of these accounts are as under:

NRE ACCOUNT

  • This account is denominated in Indian rupees, wherein proceeds of remittances to India can be deposited in any permitted currency;
  • The monies held in this account can be freely repatriated outside India;
  • Current income in India like rent, dividend, pension, interest, etc. can be deposited subject to payment of income taxes;
  • This account is subject to exchange rate fluctuations since the foreign currency earnings deposited into this account are converted into INR using the current exchange rate of the receiving bank;
  • Interest income earned from the NRE account is tax-free.

NRO ACCOUNT

  • A resident account needs to be redesignated as a NRO account when a person becomes non-resident. For this, the person becoming non-resident needs to submit the documentary evidences to prove his intentions to leave India for the purpose of employment, business or vocation or an uncertain period. Additionally, NRO account can be opened by a non-resident for any bonafide transactions. For further details, refer to the table below.
  • This account allows you to receive remittances in any permitted currency from outside India through banking channels or permitted currency tendered by the account holder during his temporary visit to India or transfers from rupee accounts of non-resident banks;
  • Repatriation from the NRO account can be done to the extent of USD 1 million for every financial year;
  • Income earned in India in the form of interest, dividend, rent, etc. can be deposited into this account;
  • This account is also subject to exchange rate fluctuations since the foreign currency deposited into this account are converted into INR using the current exchange rate of the receiving bank;
  • Interest income earned from the NRO account is not tax-free.

2 A ‘Non-resident Indian’ (NRI) is a person resident outside India who is a citizen of India.
3 ‘Person of Indian Origin (PIO)’ is a person resident outside India who is a citizen of any country other than Bangladesh or Pakistan, or such other country as may be specified by the Central Government, satisfying the following conditions: [PIO will include an OCI cardholder]
a) Who was a citizen of India by virtue of the Constitution of India or the Citizenship Act, 1955 (57 of 1955); or
b) Who belonged to a territory that became part of India after the 15th day of August, 1947; or
c) Who is a child or a grandchild or a great grandchild of a citizen of India or of a person referred to in clause (a) or (b); or
d) Who is a spouse of foreign origin of a citizen of India or spouse of foreign origin of a person referred to in clause (a) or (b) or (c)

ACCOUNT OPENED BY FOREIGN TOURISTS VISITING INDIA

In case of a current / savings account opened by a foreign tourist visiting India with funds remitted from outside India in a specified manner or by sale of foreign exchange brought by him into India, the balance in the NRO account may be paid to the account holder at the time of his departure from India provided the account has been maintained for a period not exceeding six months and the account has not been credited with any local funds, other than interest accrued thereon.

FCNR ACCOUNT

  • This is a term deposit account and not a savings account;
  • Monies can be deposited in any currency permitted by RBI i.e., a foreign currency which is freely convertible;
  • The deposits can range from a period of one to five years;
  • The principal amount and interest earned from the deposits are fully repatriable;
  • This account is not subject to exchange rate fluctuations since deposits and withdrawals are in foreign currency.
  • Income earned from FCNR account is tax-free.

A tabulated comparison of the three accounts is provided below for your reference:

Particulars NRE Account FCNR (B) Account NRO Account
NRIs and PIOs (Individuals / entities of Pakistan and Bangladesh require prior RBI approval) Any person resident outside India for putting through bonafide transactions in rupees.

Individuals / entities of Pakistan nationality / origin and entities of Bangladesh origin require prior RBI approval.

A Citizen of Bangladesh / Pakistan belonging to minority communities in those countries i.e., Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis, and Christians residing in India and who has been granted LTV* or whose application for LTV is under consideration, can open only one NRO account with an AD bank.

* Long Term Visa

Type of Account Savings, Current, Recurring, Fixed Deposit Term Deposit only Savings, Current, Recurring, Fixed Deposit
  From one to three years. However, banks are allowed to accept NRE deposits for a longer period i.e., above three years from their Asset-Liability point of view. For terms not less than 1 year and not more than 5 years. As applicable to resident accounts.
Permissible Credits i. Inward remittance from outside India.

ii. Proceeds of foreign currency/ bank notes tendered by account holder during his temporary visit to India.

iii. Interest accruing on the account

iv. Transfer from other NRE / FCNR(B) accounts.

v. Maturity or sale proceeds of investments (if such investments were made from this account or through inward remittance).

vi. Current income in India like rent, dividend, pension, interest, etc. is permissible subject to payment of taxes in India.

i. Inward remittances from outside India.

ii. Legitimate dues in India.

iii. Transfers from other NRO accounts.

iv. Rupee gift / loan made by a resident to an NRI / PIO relative within the limits prescribed under LRS may be credited to the latter’s NRO account.

As a benchmark, credits to NRE / FCNR(B) account should be repatriable in nature.
Permissible Debits

 

i. Local disbursements.

ii. Remittance outside India.

iii. Transfer to NRE / FCNR (B) accounts of the account holder or any other person eligible to maintain such account.

iv. Permissible investments in India in shares / securities / commercial paper of an Indian company or for purchase of immovable property.

i. Local payments in rupees.

ii. Transfers to other NRO accounts.

iii. Remittance of current income abroad.

iv. Settlement of charges on International Credit Cards.

v. Repatriation under USD 1 million scheme is available only to NRIs and PIOs.

vi. Funds can be transferred to NRE account within this USD 1 million facility.

Permitted Joint Holding May be held jointly in the names of two or more NRIs / PIOs.

NRIs / PIOs can hold jointly with a resident relative on ‘former or survivor’ basis. The resident relative can operate the account as a PoA holder during the lifetime of the NRI / PIO account holder.

May be held jointly in the names of two or more NRIs / PIOs.

May be held jointly with residents on ‘former or survivor’ basis.

Loans in India AD can sanction loans in India to the account holder / third parties without any limit, subject to the usual margin requirements.

The loan amount cannot be used for re-lending, carrying on agricultural / plantation activities or investment in real estate.

In case of loan to account holder the loan can be used for personal purposes or for carrying on business activities or for making direct investments in India on non-repatriation or for acquiring a flat / house in India for his own residential use.

In case of loan to third parties, loans can be given to resident individuals / firms / companies in India against the collateral

of fixed deposits held in NRE account.

The loan should be utilised for personal purposes or for carrying out business activities. Also, there should be no direct or indirect foreign exchange consideration for the non-resident depositor agreeing to pledge his deposits to enable the resident individual / firm / company to obtain such facilities.

These loans cannot be repatriated outside India and can be used in India only for the purposes specified in the regulations.

The facility for premature withdrawal of deposits will not be available where loans against such deposits are availed of.

Loans against the deposits can be granted in India to the account holder or third party subject to usual norms and margin requirement.

The loan amount cannot be used for relending, carrying on agricultural / plantation activities or investment in real estate.

The term “loan” shall include all types of fund based / non-fund-based facilities.

  Loans outsid AD may allow their branches / correspondents outside India to grant loans to or in favour of non-resident depositor or to third parties at the request of depositor for bona fide purpose against the security of funds held in the NRE / FCNR (B) accounts in India.

The term “loan” shall include all types of fund-based/ non-fund-based facilities.

 

Not permitted

 

Rate of Interest There is no restriction on the rate of interest. It varies across banks and is generally based on the repo rate of RBI.
Operations by Power of Attorney in favour of a resident Operations in the account in terms of PoA is restricted to withdrawals for permissible local payments or remittances to the account holder himself through normal banking channels.

The PoA holder cannot repatriate outside India funds held in the account under any circumstances other than to the account holder himself, nor to make payment by way of gift to a resident on behalf of the account holder nor to transfer funds from the account to another NRE or FCNR(B) account.

Operations in the account in terms of PoA is restricted to withdrawals for permissible local payments in rupees, remittance of current income to the account holder outside India or remittance to the account holder himself through normal banking channels. While making remittances, the limits and conditions of repatriability will apply.

The PoA holder cannot repatriate outside India funds held in the account under any circumstances other than to the account holder himself, nor to make payment by way of gift to a resident on behalf of the account holder nor to transfer funds from the account to another NRO account.

IMPACT OF CHANGE IN RESIDENTIAL STATUS

  • All non-resident accounts i.e., NRE / NRO (wherein, you are the primary account holder) need to be converted / re-designated as resident accounts immediately upon the return of the account holder to India for taking up employment or return of the account holder to India for any purpose indicating his intention to stay in India for an uncertain period or upon change in the residential status. The account holder should provide appropriate documentation to the bank for conversion of NRE / NRO account into resident account.
  • FCNR (B) deposits may be allowed to continue till maturity at the contracted rate of interest, if so desired by the account holder. Authorised Dealers should convert the FCNR(B) deposits on maturity into resident rupee deposit accounts or RFC accounts (if the depositor is eligible to open RFC account), at the option of the account holder.

With respect to the above, it would be relevant to refer to the compounding order C.A. No. 4578 /2017 dated 30th January, 2018 in the matter of Mr. Gaurav Bamania for compounding of contravention of the provisions of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (the FEMA) and the Regulations issued thereunder. The compounding was on account of violation on two grounds viz; payment of consideration towards investment in an Indian company by an NRI through a resident account and the applicant had not re-designated his existing account as a NRO account on becoming NRI. As per the RBI, there was a contravention of the provisions of Para 8(a) of Schedule 3 of FEMA 5 and Para 3 of Schedule 4 of FEMA 20, and applicant was required to apply for regularis ation of the contraventions subject to compounding. The RBI has quoted Para 8(a) of Schedule 3 of FEMA 5 in the compounding order which states as under:

“When a person resident in India leaves India for a country (other than Nepal or Bhutan) for taking up employment, or for carrying on business or vocation outside India or for any other purpose indicating his intention to stay outside India for an uncertain period, his existing account should be designated as a Non-Resident (Ordinary) account.”

The matter was compounded in terms of the Foreign Exchange (Compounding Proceedings) Rules, 2000 and a sum of ₹26,530/- was levied as compounding fees by RBI as the amount of contravention involved was ₹56,850/-.

Further, it would also be useful to note the compounding order C.A. No. 85 /2019 dated 18th March, 2019 in the matter of Mr. Thakorbhai Dahyabhai Patel wherein the contravention sought to be compounded related to transfer of funds from NRE account to ordinary savings account thereby resulting in contravention of the provisions under Regulation 4(C) of Schedule 1 to Notification No. FEMA.5/2000-RB dated May 3, 2000, as amended from time to time. While the contravention was with respect to transfer of funds from NRE account to ordinary savings account, the same could have been mitigated if the applicant had converted / re-designated his ordinary savings account into NRE / NRO account after becoming a non-resident since the applicant, being a non-resident, is not eligible to open or maintain an ordinary savings account as per extant FEMA guidelines.

It would also be pertinent to note that the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Basant Kumar Sharma vs. Government of India [2013] 33 taxmann.com 282 (Delhi), which has been rendered in the context of Section 2(p)(ii)(c) of the Foreign Exchange Regulations Act, 1973 (‘FERA’). In this case, the petitioner was an NRI who had returned to India for exploratory purposes and the petitioner had approached State Bank of India (‘SBI’) to convert his subsisting NRE account into NRO account and also to obtain necessary approval from RBI for sale of his investments. The SBI informed him that after becoming a resident, he was not allowed to keep a NRE account and his NRE account would have to be re-designated as a ‘Resident Account’ under Section 2(p)(ii)(c) read with Regulation A.15 of the Foreign Exchange Manual. The Petitioner did not agree with the stand adopted by SBI that he was a ‘Resident’ since he had come to India for exploring possibilities of resettlement but had also kept the doors open for overseas relocation in case, he would find a job outside India. The Petitioner wrote to various authorities, which included RBI, and requested their intercession in this matter and after a series of communications with various authorities, the Petitioner filed a writ petition with the Hon’ble Delhi High Court. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court affirmed the view adopted by SBI that the Petitioner had attained the status of a Resident in India within the meaning of Section 2(p)(ii)(c) of the FERA since his stay in India was for an uncertain period and thus his NRE account was required to be re-designated as a Resident Account due to change in residential status.

The provisions of residential status under FEMA and key differences vis a vis the Income-tax Act, 1961 (ITA) is covered in detail in earlier issue of this series titled Residential Status of Individuals — Interplay With Tax Treaty published in January 2024.

A person can be Resident or Non-Resident under both ITA and FEMA or a person can be Resident under one Act and Non-Resident under the other Act. In such a scenario, it would be pertinent to analyse the impact of taxability of an individual under the ITA where his / her residential status is different under ITA and FEMA.

The interplay of residential status under ITA and FEMA comes into light at the time of claiming income tax exemption under Section 10(4)(ii) of the ITA for a person earning interest from his NRE account in India. As per Section 10(4)(ii) of the ITA, interest received on NRE account is exempt from tax in India, if the account holder is a Person Resident Outside India as defined under Section 2(w) of the FEMA or is a person who has been permitted by the Reserve Bank of India to maintain such account. Thus, the residential status under the ITA is not required to be looked into for claiming such exemption.

Say, an individual having NRE account in India when he was a Person Resident Outside India as per FEMA and a Non-Resident as per the ITA comes to India for good during December 2023. It would be important to dwell into the change in residential status under each Act to determine eligibility for exemption u/s 10(4)(ii) of the ITA with respect to interest received from NRE account. The individual becomes a person resident in India as per FEMA from December 2023 onwards, however, he would be regarded as a Non-Resident under the ITA during Financial Year 2023-24 (assuming his stay in India was below the threshold as required under ITA). In order to claim exemption from tax u/s 10(4)(ii) of the ITA, a person has to be resident outside India under FEMA. Thus, even though the individual is a Non-Resident under the ITA, he would be entitled to claim exemption under Section 10(4)(ii) of the ITA only up to December 2023 (i.e till he was a Person Resident Outside India as per FEMA), as he would become resident of India under FEMA from the date of his return for good. Further, such individual shall be required to redesignate his NRE account to resident account on account of change in his residential status under FEMA.

On the contrary, interest earned on FCNR account by a Non-Resident or Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (‘RNOR’) under the ITA is exempt from tax under Section 10(15)(iv)(fa) of the ITA. Thus, the exemption from tax in this case is determined by a person’s residential status under the ITA and not under FEMA. If a Non-Resident holding FCNR account in India returns to India on a permanent basis in a particular financial year, he would become a Person Resident in India under FEMA immediately upon his return, but may continue to be a Non-Resident or RNOR under ITA for that particular year. Accordingly, such person can continue to claim exemption of tax for interest earned from FCNR account since the residential status under FEMA shall not impact his eligibility to claim exemption. The exemption can continue to be claimed till the residential status is RNOR and the deposit has not matured.

With respect to the above, we would like to draw your attention to the decision of the Hon’ble Chennai Tribunal in case of Baba Shankar Rajesh vs. ACIT 180 ITD 160 (Chennai ITAT) [2019] wherein Assessee was denied exemption under Section 10(4)(ii) of the ITA by the Hon’ble Tribunal on the ground that the Assessee was a ‘Person Resident in India’ under Section 2(v) of the FEMA as he was a Non-Resident who had come to India for taking up employment in India.

Another important decision was rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of K. Ramullan vs. CIT 245 ITR 417 (SC) [2000] in the context of Section 2(p) & (q) of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (‘FERA’) which was in favour of the Assessee. The Assessee was earlier denied exemption under Section 10(4A) of the ITA by the High Court with respect to interest earned from NRE account and the Supreme Court set aside the order of the Hon’ble High Court holding that under erstwhile clause (c) casual stay with spouse should not be included and hence unless the stay was for uncertain period or with some permanence the Assessee was a ‘Person Resident Outside India’ under Section 2(q) of the FERA and was thus entitled to claim exemption under Section 10(4A) [erstwhile section] of the ITA.

Of course, determination of residential status under FEMA depends upon facts and circumstances of each case.

Furthermore, the following two types of accounts are also permitted to be opened by persons resident outside India for specific purposes as explained:

i) Special Non-Resident Rupee Account (SNRR Account)

Any PROI having a business interest in India may open, hold and maintain with an Authorised Dealer (AD Banks) in India, a SNRR account for the purpose of putting through bona fide transactions in rupees. SNRR accounts shall not earn any interest.

For the purpose of SNRR account, business interest, apart from generic business interest, shall include INR transactions relating to investments permitted under FEM (NDI Rules), 2019 and FEM (DI Regulations) 2019, import and export of goods and services, trade credit and ECB and business-related transactions outside International Financial Service Centre (IFSC) by IFSC units.

AD bank may maintain a separate SNRR account for each category of transactions or a single SNRR Account as per their discretion.

The tenure of the SNRR account should be concurrent to the tenure of the contract / period of operation / the business of the account holder and in no case should exceed seven years in case of generic business transactions.

SNRR account is often used by foreign entities to obtain income tax refunds on account of earning passive income from India or foreign entities undertaking turnkey projects in India. Earlier foreign entities were required to establish project offices (as regulated by RBI) in India to execute turnkey projects awarded to joint ventures between Indian entity and foreign entity also known as unincorporated joint venture. Now, with the introduction of the SNRR account, foreign companies can execute projects without establishing a project office in India.

ii) Escrow Account

Resident or non-resident acquirers may open, hold and maintain Escrow Account with ADs in India as permitted under Notification No. FEMA 5(R)/2016-RB. The account can be opened for acquisition/transfer of capital instruments / convertible notes in accordance with Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instrument) Rules, 2019.

The accounts shall be non-interest bearing. No fund / non-fund-based facility would be permitted against the balances in the account.

PPF AND SSY ACCOUNT FOR NRIS

The Ministry of Finance has issued updated guidelines for Public Provident Fund (PPF), Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY), and other small savings schemes, effective from 1st October, 2024. One of the key changes under the new guidelines in relation to PPF accounts of NRIs are as under:

  • For NRIs, PPF accounts which were opened under the Public Provident Fund Account Scheme, 1968 where Form H did not require the residency details of the account holder and the account holder became an NRI during the account’s tenure, the Post Office Savings Account (‘POSA’) interest rate shall be granted to the account holder until 30th September, 2024. However, after this date, the interest on these accounts will drop to 0 per cent.

Further, it is pertinent to note that an NRI cannot open a new PPF account. If an account was opened by an individual while he / she was a resident who subsequently became an NRI, the account can continue until maturity. This rule has been there from quite some time, however, there have been cases where NRIs have even continued holding PPF accounts for another 5 years after completion of 15 years. In such cases, banks have denied interest in such accounts.

PPF interest is tax-free in India under Section 10(11) of the ITA for both residents and non-residents. However, the said PPF interest might be taxed in the residence country of the NRIs if it taxes its citizens / residents on their worldwide income.

Further, NRIs are not eligible to open and operate a Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana Account under the erstwhile Guidelines. There has been no change in this respect under the updated guidelines as well.

REMITTANCE FACILITIES UNDER FEMA

We have further discussed below the options available for persons resident outside in India to remit funds outside India under the Foreign Exchange Management (Remittance of Assets) Regulations, 2016 [Notification No. FEMA 13(R)/2016-RB dated 1st April, 2016]. As explained, current income in NRE and FCNR(B) account is freely repatriable outside India. For other balances and accounts pertaining to capital account transactions which are not repatriable in nature, the RBI has provided the following options:

i) Remittances by NRIs / PIOs:

Popularly known as USD 1 Million scheme / facility which covers only capital account transactions. ADs may allow NRIs / PIOs to remit up to USD one million per financial year:

  • out of balances in their NRO accounts / sale proceeds of assets / assets acquired in India by way of inheritance / legacy;
  • in respect of assets acquired under a deed of settlement made by either of his / her parents or a relative as defined in the Companies Act, 2013. The settlement should take effect on the death of the settler;
  • in case settlement is done without retaining any life interest in the property i.e., during the lifetime of the owner / parent, it would be as remittance of balance in the NRO account;

The NRI or PIO should make such remittances out of balances held in the account arising from his / her legitimate receivables in India and not by borrowing from any other person or a transfer from any other NRO account.

Further, gift by a resident individual to an NRI / PIO after turning non-resident in a particular year may not be permitted under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme (‘LRS’) since such remittances under LRS are only permissible for resident individuals. However, such remittance can be made under the 1 million Dollar scheme by the residential individual after turning non-resident.

The prescribed limit of USD 1 million is not allowed to be exceeded. In case a higher amount is required to be remitted, approval shall be required from RBI. In our experience such approvals are given in very few / rare cases based on facts.

ii) Remittances by individuals not being NRIs/ PIOs:

ADs may allow remittance of assets by a foreign national where:

  • the person has retired from employment in India (upto USD 1 million per financial year);
  • the person has inherited from a person referred to in section 6(5) of the Act4 (up to USD 1 million per financial year);
  • the person is a non-resident widow / widower and has inherited assets from her / his deceased spouse, who was an Indian national resident in India (up to USD 1 million per financial year);
  • the remittance is in respect of balances held in a bank account by a foreign student who has completed his / her studies (balance represents proceeds of remittances received from abroad through normal banking channels or out of stipend / scholarship received from the Government or any organisation in India).
  • Salary income earned in India by individuals who do not permanently reside in India5.

However, these facilities are not available for citizens of Nepal or Bhutan or a PIO.

iii) Repatriation of sale proceeds of immovable property:

A PIO/ NRI / OCI, in the event of sale of immovable property other than agricultural land / farmhouse / plantation property in India, may be allowed repatriation of the sale proceeds outside India provided:

  • the immovable property was acquired by the seller in accordance with the provisions of the foreign exchange law in force at the time of acquisition;
  • the amount for acquisition of the immovable property was paid in foreign exchange received through banking channels or out of funds held in FCNR(B) account or NRE account.

4 “person resident in India” means 
(i) a person residing in India for more than one hundred and eighty-two days during the course of the preceding financial year but does not include— 
(A) a person who has gone out of India or who stays outside India, in either case— 
   (a) for or on taking up employment outside India, or 
   (b) for carrying on outside India a business or vocation outside India, or (c) for any other purpose, in such circumstances as would indicate his intention to stay outside India for an uncertain period; 
(B) a person who has come to or stays in India, in either case, otherwise than— 
   (a) for or on taking up employment in India, or 
   (b) for carrying on in India a business or vocation in India, or (c) for any other purpose, in such circumstances as would indicate his intention to stay in India for an uncertain period; 
(ii) any person or body corporate registered or incorporated in India, 
(iii) an office, branch or agency in India owned or controlled by a person resident outside India, 
(iv) an office, branch or agency outside India owned or controlled by a person resident in India;
5 “ As per Explanation to Regulation 5 of the Remittance of Asset Regulations, 2016, ‘not permanently resident’ means a person resident in India for employment of a specified duration (irrespective of length thereof) or for a specific job or assignment, the duration of which does not exceed three years.

In the case of residential property, the repatriation of sale proceeds is restricted to a maximum of two such properties in the lifetime of the NRI / PIO. The non-resident seller shall be liable to TDS @ 20 per cent under Section 195 of the ITA on the sale consideration of the property. In such cases, non-resident sellers may apply for a Lower Deduction or Nil Deduction Certificate from the tax authorities under Section 197 of the ITA in order to minimise their tax liability and retain a higher portion of the sale proceeds. If the non-resident seller does not obtain a lower / nil deduction certificate, he / she can claim a refund by filing a return of income, in case the actual tax liability works out to be lower than the tax withheld by the buyer.

Further, the seller repatriating sale proceeds outside India may be required to obtain Form 15CB from the Chartered Account for repatriation of sale proceeds outside India.

Foreign Remittance by NRIs / OCIs — Compliances under ITA

The relevant provisions governing taxability of foreign remittances and the compliance requirements with respect to the same are provided under Section 195 of the ITA and Rule 37BB of the Income-tax Rules, 1962.

Section 195 of the ITA states that any person responsible for paying to a resident, not being a company or foreign company, any interest (excluding certain kinds of specified interest) or any other sum chargeable under the provisions of the ITA (not being the income under salaries) shall at the time of credit of such income to the payee in any specified mode, deduct income-tax thereon at the rates in force. The provisions of Section 195 of the ITA are applicable only if the payment to non-residents is chargeable to tax in India.

Further, Section 195(6) of the ITA requires reporting of any payment to a non-resident in Form 15CA / 15CB irrespective of whether such payments are chargeable to tax in India. Rule 37BB defines the manner to furnish information in Form 15CB and making declaration in Form 15CA. In terms of Rule 37BB, the information for payment to a non-resident is required to be provided in Form 15CA in four parts as under:

  • Part A – For payment or aggregate of payments during the FY not exceeding ₹5,00,000.
  • Part B – When a certificate from Assessing Officer is obtained u/s 197, or an order from an Assessing Officer is obtained u/s 195(2) or 195(3) of the ITA.
  • Part C – For other payments chargeable under the provisions of the ITA – To be filed after obtaining a certificate in Form 15CB from a practicing Chartered Accountant.
  • Part D – For payment of any sum which is not chargeable under the provisions of the ITA.

Form 15CA is a declaration by the remitter that contains all the information in respect of payments made to non-residents and Form 15CB is a Tax Determination Certificate in which the Chartered Accountant (‘CA’) examines a remittance with regard to chargeability provisions. These forms can be submitted both online and offline (bulk mode) through the e-filing portal. A CA who is registered on the e-filing portal and one who has been assigned Form 15CA, Part-C by the person responsible for making the payment is entitled to certify details in Form 15CB. The CA should also possess a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) registered with the e-filing portal for e-verification of the submitted form.

Form 15CB has six sections to be filled before submitting the form which are as under:

  1. Certificate
  2. Remittee (Recipient) Details
  3. Remittance (Fund Transfer) Details
  4. Taxability under the Income-tax Act (without DTAA)
  5. Taxability under the Income-tax act (with DTAA relief)
  6. Accountant Details (CA’s details)

The foreign remittances by NRI / OCI would generally comprise of payments to NRIs / foreign companies / OCIs / PIOs towards royalty, consultancy fees, business payments, etc., where the payment contains an income element or transfer from one’s NRO bank account to NRE / foreign bank account i.e., transfer to own account. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 37BB of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 provides a specific exclusion for certain remittances under Current Account Transaction Rules, 2000 or remittances falling under the Specified List provided thereunder6.


6. https://incometaxindia.gov.in/pages/rules/income-tax-rules-1962.aspx

The transfer from NRO to NRE / foreign bank account may fall within one of the purposes under the category of remittances which may not contain an income element and thus would not be chargeable to tax in India. Thus, there should not be any requirement of obtaining Form 15CB and reporting would only be required in Part D of Form 15CA. However, certain Authorised Dealer banks insist on furnishing Form 15CA along with Form 15CB for source of funds from which remittance is sought to be made in order to process the remittance. In such case, reporting would be required in Part C of Form 15 CA and the CA would be required to report the taxability of such remittance under Section 4 (which deals with taxability under ITA without DTAA) or Part D, Point No. 11 under Section 5 (which deals with taxability under the ITA with DTAA relief).

It may be noted that furnishing of inaccurate information or non-furnishing of Form 15CA can trigger penalty of sum of Rupees 1 lakh under section 271-I of the ITA. Thus, in order to avoid any future litigation and to be compliant from an income-tax perspective, it would be advisable to comply with the reporting obligation under Part C of Form 15CA and obtain Form 15CB from a CA at the time of making remittance from NRO account to NRE / foreign bank account.

When dealing with certification on taxability of funds from which remittance is sourced, a CA may need to bifurcate into separate certificates and also travel back several years. A CA must analyse the following aspects before issuing certificate for remittances from one’s own NRO bank account to NRE account:

  • Find out the source of funds lying in the NRO account by tracing them back to the incomes comprised therein which may trace back to several years;
  • Income-tax returns filed by the NRI in India for the period concerned;
  • Relevant year’s Form 26AS and TDS certificates;
  • Documents and issues pertaining to each type of income.

Third parties transferring money to NRE / NRO accounts of NRIs (for e.g., payment of rent or a sale consideration of an immovable property), may ask for certain documents from NRI before making transfers, such as a certificate under section 197 of the ITA from the Assessing Office (AO) of NRI, undertaking/ bond from NRI, certificate from the CA in case of certain controversial issues. Further, such third-party payers shall be required to obtain Form 15CA / Form 15CB at the time of remittance to the NRI. NRIs should pre-empt such documentation requirements of tax authorities at the time of receiving remittances from third parties in their NRI / NRO account and thus obtain such documents in advance and keep them on their records, in case required to be furnished before tax authorities at the time of remittances / transfers by NRI’s between their own accounts i.e., NRO to NRE.

Such documentation may also be helpful to CA issuing Form 15CA / CB to the NRI in future for remittance between own accounts.

It is not possible nor intended to cover all aspects of the important topic of Bank Accounts in India by non residents and Repatriation of Funds. In view of the dynamic nature of FEMA and other laws, readers are well advised to get an updated information at the time of advising their clients and / or undertaking transactions relating to bank accounts or repatriation of funds outside India.

Cross-Charge vs. Input Service Distributor (ISD)

INTRODUCTION

Notification 16/2024-CT has notified 1st April, 2025 as the date from which the proposed amendments to the provisions relating to ‘input service distributor’ will come into effect. In view of the far-reaching implications of the said amendment, this article decodes the provisions relating to ‘input service distributor’, and the interplay the said concept has with the concept of ‘cross charge’ as propounded in view of the provisions of entry 2 of Schedule I of the CGST Act, 2017.

BACKGROUND OF EARLIER LAWS

Prior to the imposition of GST, a central excise duty was imposed on the manufacture of excisable goods. The central excise law required separate registration for each of the premises from where the manufacturing activity was carried out. While the CENVAT Credit Rules as amended from time to time provided for claim of credit of inputs and capital goods used in the manufacture of final products, there was substantial emphasis laid on receipt of the goods in the registered premises and documentary evidence in the form of tax compliant invoices reflecting the said address of the registered premises.

In the said backdrop, when the said Rules were expanded to also permit the credit of input services used in the manufacture of the final products, a need was felt for implementing the existing procedural framework in a realistic manner. In the case of services, it was very common for the said services to be centrally procured at the corporate office. To enable a free flow of credit to the manufacturing locations, the concept of ‘input service distributor’ was introduced under the erstwhile CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The said concept permitted an office of the manufacturer to receive invoices towards the receipt of services (either by the said office or by the respective manufacturing units) and distribute the credit embedded in such invoices to the respective manufacturing units. Based on the said concept and registration, the corporate office of a manufacturer could pay for a customs house agent from the office receive an invoice in this regard, and distribute the credit to the concerned manufacturing unit. Similarly, it could pay for corporate services like statutory audits and distribute the credit proportionately to all manufacturing units (since the definition of input service was wide enough to cover services directly or indirectly used in the manufacture of the final product and included various activities related to business and the law also did not require the receipt of input services at the registered premises, such statutory audit services were eligible for credit at the manufacturing locations). The concept of input service distributor was therefore a blessing under the said regime permitting a free flow of credits from the corporate office to the duty-discharging manufacturing locations.

It may be noted that the definition of ‘input service distributor’ under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 laid emphasis on the office receiving an invoice and laid no emphasis on whether the services were received by the office or the manufacturing location and whether the invoice or the services were received by the office on its’ own account or ‘for or on behalf of’ the manufacturing location. This is evident on a plain reading of the definition of input service distributor as provided under 2(m) of the erstwhile CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, which is reproduced below for ready reference.

“input service distributor” means an office of the manufacturer or producer of final products or provider of output service, which receives invoices issued under rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 towards purchases of input services and issues invoice, bill or, as the case may be, challan for the purposes of distributing the credit of service tax paid on the said services to such manufacturer or producer or provider, [or an outsourced manufacturing unit] as the case may be

— Emphasis supplied

The concept of ‘input service distributor’ under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 applied to service providers as well. However, in view of the facility for centralized registration available under the service tax law, the said concept had limited applicability except in the case of taxpayers who had obtained decentralized registrations.

WELCOME GST

GST was introduced as a comprehensive indirect tax modeled on the principle of destination-based consumption tax. However, in view of the federal structure and the Constitutional mandate, the law required distinct registration in each of the States from which the taxpayer supplied taxable goods or services. This need for distinct state-level registration triggered a fundamental challenge of imbalance in input tax credits and output taxes in cases where the inward procurements are effected in one State and the outward supplies are effected from another State. Perhaps to address the said situation, Entry 2 was inserted in Schedule I to deem the supply of goods or services or both between distinct persons as liable for payment of GST even if the said supplies are made without consideration. Accordingly, an office warehouse, or factory in the State procuring the inward supplies could raise a tax invoice on a branch warehouse, or factory located in another State for effecting the deemed outward supplies to the said branch warehouse, or factory (even though there is no monetary consideration and the supply is between two units of the same legal entity). Such discharge of output tax by the first state would be eligible as input tax credit to the other state resulting in no revenue loss to the taxpayer but at the same time permitting free flow of credits from the input procuring locations to the output supplying locations. In trade parlance, such raising of internal tax invoice is referred to as ‘branch transfer’ in case of deemed supply of goods and ‘cross charge’ in case of deemed supply of services.

Despite having introduced the above deeming fiction to address the issue of imbalance in input tax credits and output taxes, the Legislature, in its wisdom deemed it fit to continue with the provisions of ‘input service distributor’ existing in the erstwhile CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The definition was amended mutatis mutandis, permitting the input service distributor to receive a tax invoice and issue an ISD Invoice for distribution of the said credit without any specific emphasis on whether the services were received by the said office or the other unit and whether the invoice or the services were received by the said office on its’ own account or ‘for or on behalf of’ the other unit. The relevant definition of ‘input service distributor’ under section 2(61) at the time of the introduction of GST is reproduced below for ready reference.

“input service distributor” means an office of the supplier of goods or services or both, which receives tax invoices issued under section 31 towards the receipt of input services and issues a prescribed document for the purposes of distributing the credit of central tax, state tax, integrated tax or Union territory tax paid on the said services to a supplier of taxable goods or services or both having the same PAN as that of the said office.

— Emphasis supplied for suitable comparison with the erstwhile definition under CCR, 2004

On a comparison of the above definition with the erstwhile definition under CCR, 2004, it is evident that both definitions are pari materia with no substantial change in the scope of the said provisions.

CONTROVERSIES GALORE!

The co-existence of Schedule I, Entry 2 (‘cross charge provision’), and Section 20 (‘input service distributor’) presented substantial confusion since apparently, both the provisions appeared to address a similar problem of ‘imbalance in input tax credit and output taxes’ in different ways. In view of the proviso to Rule 28(1) permitting flexibility in the valuation of the cross charge in case the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit and FAQ issued by the CBIC clarifying that registration as an input service distributor is optional, there was a view that a taxpayer may implement either of the two provisions to address the problem, whereas certain advance rulings canvassed a view that both the provisions operate in different set of situations and as such, both the provisions need independent implementation.

The matter was taken up by the GST Council in its’ 50th Meeting held in July 2023, wherein it was clarified that the provisions of ‘input service distributor’ are indeed optional. Further clarifications were also provided relaxing the rigors of the applicability of ‘cross charge’ provisions. At the same time, the GST Council suggested that the provisions of ‘input service distributor’ be made mandatory prospectively from a date to be notified in the future. Accordingly, suitable changes have been proposed in the CGST Act, 2017 and the CGST Rules, 2017, and the said changes are proposed to be made effective from 1st April, 2025.

KEY AMENDMENT

As stated above, there are amendments to various sections and rules. However, the fundamental amendment pertains to the definition of ‘input service distributor’ and the amended definition u/s 2(61) needs detailed scrutiny to understand the impact of the change being proposed in the correct perspective. The amended definition (as proposed to be effective from 1st April, 2025) is reproduced below for ready reference:

“Input Service Distributor” means an office of the supplier of goods or services or both that receives tax invoices towards the receipt of input services, including invoices in respect of services liable to tax under sub-section (3) or sub-section (4) of section 9, for or on behalf of distinct persons referred to in section 25, and liable to distribute the input tax credit in respect of such invoices in the manner provided in section 20

— Emphasis supplied for suitable comparison with the erstwhile definition under CCR, 2004, and the pre-amended definition under section 2(61) of the CGST Act, 2017

On a perusal of the above-amended definition, it is evident that there are two substantial amendments being carried out as compared to the erstwhile definition under CCR, 2004 and the pre-amended definition under section 2(61) of the CGST Act, 2017:

1. The phrase ‘for or on behalf of distinct persons’ is being introduced for the first time in the definition of ‘input service distributor’

2. The ‘input service distributor’ is made ‘liable’ to distribute the input tax credit, thus making the provisions of the input service distributor mandatory.

The judicial interpretation of the phrase ‘on behalf of’ is fairly settled. The said phrase connotes the existence of an agency relationship between the two parties (State of Mysore vs. Gangamma AIR 1965 Mysore 235). In the context of property, it was held that the holder of the property was only a representative of the real owner (Kripashankar vs. Commissioner of Wealth Tax AIR 1966 Patna 371). Even in the context of intermediary services under GST, the concept of agency vs. principal and the implications of the phrase ‘on behalf of’ has been exhaustively explained.

Extending the said interpretation of the phrase to the current context, it can be understood that the provisions of ‘input service distributor’ are triggered in a situation where an ISD office receives tax invoices towards the receipt of input services for or on behalf of distinct persons. As compared to the erstwhile definition under the CCR, 2004, and the pre-amended definition under the GST Law, clearly the introduction of this phrase reduces the scope of coverage under ISD post amendment. Effective from 1st April, 2025, it would therefore be important to distinguish between a situation where an input service is received by an office on behalf of a distinct person and an input service that is received by an office on its’ own account.

A few examples may illustrate the implications of this interpretation:

1. The head office in Maharashtra appoints and pays for security services procured at the factory located in Gujarat. Since the security services are received by the factory located in Gujarat, the tax invoice for the said service is received by the head office ‘for or on behalf of’ the factory in Gujarat, thus triggering the mandate of registration as an input service distribution and the consequent distribution of credit to Gujarat. Incidentally, a similar example was explained in a draft circular recommended by the Law Committee and placed before the GST Council in its’ 35th Meeting. However, the said Circular never saw the light of the day.

2. The head office in Maharashtra appoints and pays for goods transportation services procured at the factory located in Gujarat. It also pays the GST under reverse charge mechanism on such GTA services. Since the GTA services are received by the factory located in Gujarat, the tax invoice for the said service is received by the head office ‘for or on behalf of’ the factory in Gujarat, thus triggering the mandate of registration as an input service distribution and the consequent distribution of credit to Gujarat.

3. The head office in Maharashtra enters into a contract with an insurance company for insurance of assets located across the country. There are assets located in Maharashtra and also in the state of Gujarat. To the extent of assets located at the Gujarat factory, the insurance service of coverage of risk is received by the factory located in Gujarat, and the tax invoice for the said service is received by the head office ‘for or on behalf of’ the factory in Gujarat, thus triggering the mandate of registration as an input service distribution and the consequent distribution of credit to Gujarat.

While the above specific examples may look simplistic, where would one draw the line to say that the instance is that of service received ‘on behalf of’ a distinct person or a service received on ‘own account’. Let us understand this through a couple of more examples:

1. The head office in Maharashtra imports certain raw materials at the Mumbai port and transports the said goods to a warehouse in Bhiwandi. It appoints and pays for goods transportation services for the movement from Mumbai port to Bhiwandi. After some time, the said raw materials are further supplied to the factory located in Gujarat at a value prescribed under rule 28. It is obvious that in this scenario, the transportation and warehousing services are not received by the factory located in Gujarat, but are received by the head office on its’ own account. In fact, the cost of such transportation and warehousing services would become components of the cost calculation for arriving at a valuation under rule 28. Therefore, such services would not be a subject matter of input service distributor (but indirectly become a part of Schedule I, Entry 2 by way of the value of goods being ‘branch transferred’)

2. The head office in Maharashtra houses a centralized Human Relations Team. The said Team is responsible for addressing comprehensively all the HR requirements of the company including the employees at the factory located in Gujarat. If the HR Team places an advertisement in the newspaper inviting applications from prospective candidates, can it be said that the said advertisement service is received for and on behalf of the Gujarat factory? The draft circular referred to earlier suggests that through the HR Team, the head office internally generates a support service for the Gujarat factory, albeit through another circular, a relaxation in valuation has been provided to the extent of salary costs of the HR Team. If the Head Office is providing a support service to the Gujarat factory, is the advertisement service not received and consumed by the Head Office on its’ own account for further rendition of the ‘cross-charged support service’?

Based on the above examples, one may conclude that the provisions of input service distributors will get triggered only when the tax invoices for the services are received for or on behalf of distinct persons. Receipt would mean actual receipt of service and not an imaginary receipt in the form of perceived benefit. In cases where a service is received and consumed by the HO, the provisions of the input service distributor will not get triggered. It may also be possible that the service is received for self-consumption by the head office and the consumption of the said service may result in the generation of another supply of goods or service for the branch. The two examples mentioned above drive home this interpretation.

There may also be situations where the service may be self-consumed by the head office with no further supply of goods or services to the branch. For example, a research service procured by the head office may not immediately result in a further supply of support services to the branches. At the same time, in many cases, it cannot be said that the research is undertaken for or on behalf of the branches. At some future point in time, an indirect benefit of the service may be derived by the branch, but merely a derivation of some indirect benefit cannot result in the presumption that the head office procured the service on behalf of the branch.

NEXT STEPS TOWARDS IMPLEMENTATION

– Registration

With ISD becoming mandatory w.e.f. 01.04.2025, the first step towards preparing for ISD would be identifying the number of such offices that qualify as ISD. All offices that undertake centralized procurement of services / procurement of services consumed by more than one registration will have to apply for registration. Wherever possible, organizations will have to move towards decentralized procurement of services, if current procurement is centralized. Similarly, if more than one offices are engaged in centralized procurement, wherever possible, organizations should move towards a single procurement office. Once such offices are identified, the next step would be to apply for registration as an ISD.

– Vendor Communication

Though ISD is mandatory from 01.04.2025, taxpayers will have to apply beforehand for registration and communicate the ISD GSTIN to all the vendors/suppliers for existing as well as new contracts.

In case the vendor communication is not done, the vendors may continue to raise invoices under the regular GSTIN which may delay the taxpayer’s ITC claim. This is because the ITC may not be available for claim in regular GSTIN and the taxpayer will not be able to distribute the ITC under ISD in view of section 16 (2) (aa) of the CGST Act, 2017. It is therefore imperative that all the suppliers for services procured centrally are intimated to the ISD GSTIN in advance.

Vendor communication needs to be done, irrespective of whether the taxpayer is entitled to claim ITC or not. This is because the ultimate objective of making ISD mandatory is to ensure that the taxes flow to the states where the consumption takes place. Therefore, the taxpayer cannot exclude considering supplies not eligible for ITC from the purview of the ISD mechanism.

– Invoicing and Accounting

Taxpayers will also have to adapt their systems to separate accounts & identify the invoices received under ISD registration. More importantly, while accounting for such supplier invoices, care should be taken to ensure that the invoices are accounted / plotted against the ISD GSTIN and not the regular GSTIN to avoid any mismatches. If any invoice pertains to specific GSTINs, a mechanism to identify such transactions should be introduced to ensure that the ITC is distributed only to such GSTINs and not all GSTINs, as it would otherwise amount to erroneous distribution of ITC and may result in recovery proceedings at the recipient GSTIN end.

Similarly, systems will also have to be geared up to account for the ISD invoices issued to the regular GSTIN. This would be crucial in case ISD and regular GSTIN are of the same state. In such cases, the systems may not be geared up for accepting all three taxes, i.e., IGST, CGST & SGST against the same invoice/ document.

– Filing of GSTR6 based on GSTR6A

The ISD compliances lay between the accounting of the vendor invoices and the distribution of the ITC to the regular GSTIN. On the 12th of every month, based on the disclosure by the supplier, invoices will be communicated to the ISD in Form GSTR-6A.

A matching of transactions reflected in GSTR-6A (irrespective of whether ITC is eligible or not) with the corresponding invoices received by the ISD shall be undertaken and after adding, correcting, or deleting the auto-populated details, the ITC available for distribution shall be determined. The ITC so available for distribution shall then be distributed in the following manner:

a) If any ITC pertains only to a particular GSTIN, such ITC shall be distributed only to that GSTIN.

b) Similarly, any ITC that pertains to more than one GSTINs shall be distributed to such GSTINs in the ratio of turnover during the relevant period.

Separate ISD invoices are to be prepared for distribution of eligible & ineligible ITC.

– Compliances & recovery at the recipient’s end

The various compliances that apply to a claim of ITC, such as receipt of goods / services, payment of tax by the supplier, payment of consideration to the supplier, etc., in case of ISD shall apply to the receiving GSTIN. Therefore, the taxpayers will have to specifically keep track of payment to suppliers to ensure compliance u/r 37 & classification of the invoice for Rule 42 purposes and the said compliance will have to be done by the GSTIN receiving the ITC.

If the ISD receives any credit note for an invoice that has already been considered in the earlier period distribution, the ISD will have to ensure that the reduction in the distribution of the ITC on account of the credit note follows the same ratio applied for distribution of the ITC on the invoice.

Lastly, if any excess distribution by ISD is determined, the recovery shall be done at the recipient end and not at the ISD end. Therefore, an officer of the recipient GSTIN can very well demand to verify the compliances of ISD and may result in potentially multiple and in some cases, conflicting proceedings.

Disputes surrounding the applicability of ISD vs. cross-charge

The examples explained above suggest that the line of divide between ISD and cross charge is very thin. In the absence of authoritative objective guidelines in this regard, it is likely that there can be disputes on the applicability of the said provisions.

In case the taxpayer considers a particular transaction as a subject matter of ISD and the same is ultimately held to be not a subject matter of distribution but that of cross charge, there could be a risk of denial of input tax credit at the recipient’s end on account of excess distribution of credit by the input service distributor. Independently, there could be an action against the head office for undervaluation of cross charge (the action could survive only if the recipient is not eligible for full input tax credit)

In a reverse scenario where the taxpayer has considered a particular transaction as a subject matter of the cross charge, but the same is ultimately held to be a subject matter of input service distribution, the credit claimed by the head office can be denied on the grounds of non-receipt of input service (since the allegation would be that the service is received on behalf of the branches). Further, at the branch level, there could be a risk of denial of credit embedded in the cross-charge invoice by the head office to the branch again on the ground of the non-existence of a ‘cross-chargeable service’

Conclusion:

While both the concepts of ‘cross charge’ and ‘input service distributor’ attempt to address the same problem of non-alignment of input tax credits and output taxes, in terms of implementation, both of them differ significantly. With the concept of ‘input service distributor’ becoming mandatory, it will be important for taxpayers to implement the said concept with full precaution. It may also be appropriate for the Government to provide a detailed guideline on the extent of coverage of the provisions of input service distributors.

Assessment — Eligible assessee — Draft assessment order — Assessee filing its objections thereto before DRP but failing to communicate this to AO — AO unaware of pending application before DRP — Final assessment order passed during pendency of assessee’s objections to draft assessment order — Order set aside and AO directed to pass fresh order in accordance with directions of DRP.

44 Sulzer Pumps India Pvt. Ltd. vs. Dy. CIT

[2024] 465 ITR 619 (Bom)

A.Y.: 2017-18

Date of order: 27th October, 2021

Ss. 143(3), 144B, 144C(2), 144C(3), 144C(4), 156 and 270A of ITA 1961

Assessment — Eligible assessee — Draft assessment order — Assessee filing its objections thereto before DRP but failing to communicate this to AO — AO unaware of pending application before DRP — Final assessment order passed during pendency of assessee’s objections to draft assessment order — Order set aside and AO directed to pass fresh order in accordance with directions of DRP.

The assessee, under the belief that with the assessments being faceless and completely electronic, the application filed by it u/s. 144C(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 against the draft assessment order for the A. Y. 2017-18 before the Dispute Resolution Panel(DRP) would automatically be communicated to the Assessing Officer by the DRP, failed to directly communicate to the Assessing Officer. While the application was pending the Assessing Officer passed an order u/s. 143(3) read with sections 144C(3) and 144B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, issued a demand notice u/s. 156 and a penalty notice u/s. 270A.

The assessee filed a writ petition. The Bombay High Court allowed the writ petition and held as under:

“The Assessing Officer could not be faulted for passing the order in question. However, since the assessee had already filed application raising its objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel and section 144C(4) required the Assessing Officer to pass the final order according to the directions that would be issued by the Dispute Resolution Panel, the order passed u/s. 143(3) read with sections 144C(3) and 144B, the notice of demand u/s. 156 and the notice of penalty u/s. 270A were set aside. The Assessing Officer could pass a fresh order in accordance with the directions of the Dispute Resolution Panel in the pending application.”

Long-term capital loss arising from sale of quoted equity shares with STT paid was eligible to be set-off against long-term capital gain earned from sale of unquoted shares, in view of specific provisions of sections 2(14), 10(38), 45, 47 and 48.

50 Riya Gupta vs. DCIT

[2024] 113 ITR(T) 1 (Kol – Trib.)

ITA NO. 46 (KOL.) OF 2024

A.Y.: 2014-15

DATED: 6th June, 2024

Sec. 70

Long-term capital loss arising from sale of quoted equity shares with STT paid was eligible to be set-off against long-term capital gain earned from sale of unquoted shares, in view of specific provisions of sections 2(14), 10(38), 45, 47 and 48.

FACTS

The assessee filed return of income on 31st July, 2014 declaring total income of ₹18,31,980/. -During the assessment proceedings, the AO called for various information from the assessee which were supplied and replied by the assessee. The AO passed the order making various additions including the addition of ₹47,90,616/- resulting on non-allowance of set off of loss from sale of equity shares on recognised stock exchange with STT paid against the profit on sale of unquoted equity shares. The AO rejected the said action on the ground that the long-term capital gain on sale of quoted shares is exempt u/s 10(38) of the Act and similarly the loss incurred was also not liable to be set off against the other taxable income.

Aggrieved by the assessment order, the assessee filed an appeal before CIT(A). The CIT(A) dismissed the appeal of the assessee by upholding the order of the AO on this issue on the same reasoning. Aggrieved by the order, the assessee filed an appeal before the ITAT.

HELD

The undisputed facts were that during the year, the assessee had earned long term capital gain of ₹50,00,000/- from sale of unquoted shares of M/s IRC Infra and Reality Pvt. Ltd. and also incurred long term capital loss of ₹47,90,616/- from sale of quoted equity shares which was executed on the recognized stock exchange and STT was duly paid. The issue for adjudication was whether the long term capital loss suffered on sale of equity shares can be set off against the long term capital gain earned by the assessee on sale of unquoted equity shares or not.

The ITAT, after perusing provisions of section 2(14), 45, 47 and 48, observed that nowhere any exclusion or exception has been provided to the long-term capital gain resulting from sale of equity shares. The ITAT observed that it’s only the long term capital gain resulting from sale of shares / securities which was granted exemption u/s 10(38) subject to the fulfillment of certain conditions and not the entire source which was excluded from the aforesaid sections.
The ITAT relied on the following Judgments –

  • Hon’ble Kolkata High Court in the case of Royal Calcutta Turf Club vs. CIT [1983] 144 ITR 709/12 Taxman 133
  • United Investments vs. ACIT TS-379-ITAT- 2019 —Kolkata Tribunal
  • Raptakos Brett & Co. Ltd. vs. DCIT (69 SOT 383) —Kolkata Tribunal

In the result, the appeal of the assessee was allowed for the above-mentioned issue.

EDITORIAL COMMENT

The decision of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of CIT vs. Harprasad& Co. (P.) Ltd.[1975] 99 ITR 118 is distinguished on the ground that the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court that income includes negative income can be applied only when the entire source of income falls within the charging provision of Act but where the source of income is otherwise chargeable to tax but only a specific kind of income derived from such source is granted exemption, then in such case, the proposition that the term income includes loss would not be applicable. In other words, where only one of the streams of income from a source is granted exemption by the legislature upon fulfillment of specified conditions then the concept of income includes loss would not be applicable.

Commissioner (Appeals) has to decide appeal on merits by passing a speaking order and does not have any power to dismiss appeal for non-prosecution.

49 Meda Raja KishorRaghuramy Reddy

[2024] 113ITR(T)258 (Panaji – Trib.)

ITA NO. 127 (PANJ.) OF 2022

A.Y.: 2014-14

DATE: 28th February, 2024

Commissioner (Appeals) has to decide appeal on merits by passing a speaking order and does not have any power to dismiss appeal for non-prosecution.

FACTS

The assessee had filed return of income electronically on 29th November, 2014 declaring total income of ₹37,60,840/-.The assessee’s case was selected for scrutiny proceedings. The assessee had failed to comply with the notices issued by the AO. The AO passed an ex-parte assessment order making the following additions:

  • ₹6,22,72,638/- under section 68 of the Act as unproved creditors
  • ₹39,62,472/- under section 69 of the Act
  • ₹5,78,850/- on account of difference in Form 26AS and return of income.

On appeal before CIT(A), the CIT(A) in a cryptic manner dismissed the appeal of the assessee.

Aggrieved by the Order, the assessee preferred an appeal before the ITAT.

HELD

DELAY IN FILING APPEAL

There was a delay of 1330 days in filing the appeal which included the period of Covid Pandemic.

Considering the principle of substantial justice, respectfully following the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Gupta Emerald Mines (P.) Ltd. vs. Pr. CIT [2023] 156 taxmann.com 198 (SC) [25-09-2023] and Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Hindalco Industries Ltd vs. Pr. CIT Writ Petition No. 569 of 2023/ [2024] 158 taxmann.com 485, the ITAT condoned the delay in filling the appeal.

MERITS OF THE CASE

The ITAT observed that the assessee had filed written submission dated 14th August, 2017 containing following documents — Copy of confirmation of Accounts, Copy of Ledgers, Identity and Address proof of Creditors, cash books, bills, vouchers, bank statements, affidavits etc. The ITAT further observed that Form 35 which is form of appeal for filing appeal before CIT(A) was enclosed with application for admission of additional evidence under rule 46A.

The ITAT further observed the following fall outs in the assessment proceedings —

  • It was possible for AO to collect information directly from renowned companies — Jaypee cement Bangalore & JSW Steel [Sundry creditors of the assessee] u/s 133(6) or 131 of the Act.
  • Some of the creditors appeared in the balance sheet from earlier years – under section 68 the amount which was credited during the year only can be added.
  • Assessee had shown Interest income on FD of ₹1,98,487/- and the AO had merely added ₹40,063/- without discussing what was total interest as per Form 26AS statement
  • Fixed Deposit in Ratnakar Bank Account Number 3158 appeared in the balance sheet of the Assessee — the AO had worked out corresponding FD in the Ratnakar Bank at ₹507,087/- without actually calling the details from the Ratnakar Bank.
  • The AO made an addition of ₹31,700/- as receipt from Gammon India Ltd based on 26AS statement — exact amount and exact name appeared in the Balance Sheet – the AO could have called for information u/s 133(6) of the Act from Gammon India Ltd.

The ITAT held that though the assessee had failed to comply with the notices issued by AO, the AO also failed to carry out necessary investigations and to understand the facts in totality.

The ITAT held that the CIT(A) has discretion to admit the Additional evidence, if there was sufficient cause which prevented the assessee from filling the documents during the assessment proceedings. The discretion had to be used in judicious manner and one must be able to reason out. In this case the CIT(A) had not passed a speaking order for rejecting the additional evidence. The CIT(A) had failed to follow the procedure laid down in Rule 46A.

The ITAT also held that the CIT(A) had not adjudicated each and every ground raised by the Assessee on merits. The ITAT followed the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Pr. CIT (Central) vs. Premkumar Arjundas Luthra (HUF) [2016] 69 taxmann.com 407 wherein it was held that CIT(A) has to decide the appeal on merits and CIT(A) does not have any power to dismiss appeal for non-prosecution.

The ITAT set aside the order of the CIT(A) for de novo adjudication after giving opportunity to the assessee. In the result, the appeal of the assessee was allowed for statistical purpose.

Where the view taken by the AO that the assessee was eligible for deduction under section 80G for CSR expenses was approved by various decisions of Tribunal, PCIT could not invoke revisional jurisdiction under section 263 on the ground that the order of AO was erroneous.

48 American Express (India) P. Ltd. vs. PCIT

(2024) 165 taxmann.com 91 (Del Trib)

ITA No.: 2468(Delhi) of 2023

A.Y.: 2016-17

Dated: 30th August, 2024

Ss. 263, 80G

Where the view taken by the AO that the assessee was eligible for deduction under section 80G for CSR expenses was approved by various decisions of Tribunal, PCIT could not invoke revisional jurisdiction under section 263 on the ground that the order of AO was erroneous.

FACTS

The assessee had incurred expenditure amounting to ₹5,20,00,000 under section 135 of the Companies Act 2013 dealing with Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). It voluntarily disallowed the same in the computation of income; however, it claimed benefit of deduction under section 80G to the extent of ₹3,21,43,427.

During the assessment proceedings, after examining the assessee’s claim of deduction under section 80G, the Assessing Officer allowed the said deduction. PCIT initiated revision proceedings under section 263 on the ground that claim of deduction under section 80G for CSR expenses was not allowable to the assessee.

Aggrieved by order of PCIT, the assessee filed an appeal before ITAT.

HELD

The Tribunal observed that:

(a) In the past, the Tribunal has considered this issue in various cases and consistently held that though CSR expenses which are mandatory under section 135 of the Companies Act are not allowable as deduction under section 37(1), if any part of CSR contribution is otherwise eligible for deduction under Chapter VI-A, there is no bar on the companies to claim the same as deduction under section 80G.

(b) Merely because the PCIT does not agree with the view taken by the AO, the assessment order does not become erroneous. The view taken by the AO in allowing deduction under section 80G for CSR expenses was approved by various decisions of the Tribunal.

(c) The satisfaction of twin conditions set out in section 263, namely, the order is (i) erroneous; and (ii) prejudicial to the interest of Revenue is sine qua non for exercising revisional jurisdiction. If any of the said conditions are not satisfied, the revisional jurisdictional under section 263 cannot be invoked.

It noted that this view was also supported by coordinate bench in JMS Mining P Ltd. v. PCIT, (2021) 130 taxmann.com 118 (KolTrib).

Accordingly, the Tribunal allowed the appeal of the assessee and quashed the revisional order passed by PCIT.

S. 12AB –Registration under section 12AB could be denied to a trust if it had not complied with the applicable State public trusts law.

47 Gurukul Shikshan Sansthan vs. CIT

(2024) 165 taxmann.com 369(JaipurTrib)

ITA No.: 482(Jpr) of 2024

A.Ys.: 2022-23 to 2024-25

Dated: 3rd July, 2024

S. 12AB –Registration under section 12AB could be denied to a trust if it had not complied with the applicable State public trusts law.

FACTS

CIT(E) rejected the assessee-trust’s application for registration under section 12AB dated 26th September, 2023 on the ground that it was not registered under the Rajasthan Public Trusts Act, 1959, genuineness of the activities of the assessee could not be verified due to non-compliance, and that the assessee had filed incomplete Form No. 10AB.

Aggrieved, the assessee filed an appeal before ITAT.

HELD

Before the Tribunal, the assessee filed a request for adjournment stating that the assessee-trust had applied for a certificate under the Rajasthan Public Trusts Act, 1959 and was awaiting such certificate.

Rejecting the adjournment request, the Tribunal, vide an ex-parte order, observed that:

(a) As admitted in the adjournment request, as on the date of application for registration, that is, 26th September, 2023, the assessee was not registered under the Rajasthan Public Trusts Act although such registration was mandated under section 17 of the said Act.

(b) Section 12AB(1) mandates that all the applicable laws shall be followed and if any applicable law is not followed by the assessee, then it is not eligible for registration.

Following the decision of Supreme Court in New Noble Educational Society vs. CCIT, (2022) 448 ITR 594 (SC), the Tribunal held that since the assessee had not followed provisions of Rajasthan Public Trusts Act, it was not eligible for registration under section 12AB.

Additionally, the Tribunal observed that since the assessee had neither submitted the details called by CIT nor filed any document before the Tribunal to prove genuineness of its activities, it was not eligible for registration under section 12AB also on this ground.

A determinate trust with sole beneficiary was liable to be taxed at same rate as applicable to its beneficiary.

46 ITO vs. Petroleum Trust

(2024) 165 taxmann.com 504 (MumTrib)

ITA No.: 2694(Mum) of 2024; C.O. No. 133 (Mum) of 2024

A.Y.: 2021-22

Dated: 2nd August, 2024

S. 161

A determinate trust with sole beneficiary was liable to be taxed at same rate as applicable to its beneficiary.

FACTS

The assessee was a discretionary trust, which held investments mainly for its beneficiary, RIIHL. RIIHL, being a limited company, opted to be taxed under the new tax regime under section 115BAA by filing Form 10-IC claiming to be taxed @ 22 per cent (+surcharge / cess). The assessee-trust, being a representative assessee under section 161, claimed to be taxed at same rate applicable to its beneficiary in its return of income. The tax department disagreed with this position.

CIT(A) accepted the status of the assessee as a representative assessee under section 161 and held that since the assessee is a determinate trust with RIIHL as its sole and 100 per cent beneficiary and settlor and since RIIHL has opted to be taxed under the new tax regime @22 per cent, the assessee-trust was also liable to be taxed at the same rate.

Aggrieved, the tax department filed an appeal before the ITAT. The assessee also filed cross objections in support of order of CIT(A).

HELD

Noting language of section 161(1) and following the decision of Bombay High Court in Mrs. Amy F. Cama vs. CIT,(1999) 237 ITR 82 (Bom), the Tribunal held that the tax shall be levied upon and recovered from a representative assessee in like manner and to the same extent as it would be leviable upon and recoverable from the person represented by him, which meant that the assessee-trust will be subject to same rate of tax as applicable to the person represented by it, that is, RIIHL which was taxed @ 22 per cent under section 115BAA.

 

I : Capital gains is taxable in the year in which possession of constructed premises was received by the assessee and not in the earlier year when occupancy certificate was granted. II : The cost of construction given by the developer which is not supported by any particulars cannot be taken as full value of consideration. Section 50D of the Act, would be applicable and accordingly, the full value of consideration should be computed on the basis of guideline value of land or building that is transferred / received on development.

45 AlagappaMuthiah HUF vs. DCIT

ITA No. 775/Bang./2024&954/Bang./2024

AY: 2017-18

Date of Order: 12th August, 2024

Sections: 45, 48

I : Capital gains is taxable in the year in which possession of constructed premises was received by the assessee and not in the earlier year when occupancy certificate was granted.

II : The cost of construction given by the developer which is not supported by any particulars cannot be taken as full value of consideration. Section 50D of the Act, would be applicable and accordingly, the full value of consideration should be computed on the basis of guideline value of land or building that is transferred / received on development.

FACTS I

The assessee HUF along with Alagappa Annamalai HUF were co-owners of land in respect of which they entered into two development agreements dated 10th February, 2011. Under these Development agreements the properties belonging to these two persons were being developed into both residential as well as commercial units. These two persons were allotted the entire commercial unit and 6 apartment units in the residential units.

In the course of a search conducted in the case of Sri Alagappa Annamalai on 4th July, 2019, a sworn statement was recorded from Sri Alagappa Annamalai as to why the capital gain in respect of transaction of entering into development agreement has not been offered for tax in AY 2017-18. In response, it was submitted that capital gain has been offered in the year in which possession of constructed premises has been received. This was done in absence of information about occupancy certificate and cost of construction. Similar statement was recorded in the case of assessee on 5th July, 2019 under section 131. Thereafter, both the assessee and Alagappa Annamalai retracted their respective statements and stated that the possession of the properties was received by them after development on 8th May, 2017 and accordingly the liability to capital gains arose for the assessment year 2018-19 and not for the assessment year 2017-18 as admitted in their earlier statements. Accordingly, they stated that they would be offering capital gains for the assessment year 2018-19 on the above basis in course of assessment proceedings after receipt of notice.

The assessee, accordingly, filed returns in response to notice u/s.153C of the Act offering capital gains by adopting the value determined by the registered valuer. In the assessment proceedings, the A.O. held that the liability to capital gains arises for the assessment year 2017-18 as occupancy certificate was received on 1st February, 2017 for commercial portion and 17th March, 2017 for residential portion. On the other-hand both these persons contended that the liability to capital gains arose for the assessment year 2018-19 on receipt of possession vide letter dated 8th May, 2017 when simultaneous with receiving possession they have returned the deposits. The AO was of the view that the letter of possession was manipulated in collusion with the builder.

HELD I

The Tribunal observed that reason for taxing the capital gain as income of assessment year 2017-18 is that the occupancy certificate was received on 17th March, 2017. On behalf of the assessee,it was contended that section 45(5A) has been introduced w.e.f. 1.4.2018 and therefore the same does not apply to the present case. Section 45(5A) applies w.e.f. AY 2018-19 and not AY 2017-18. The Tribunal noted that section 45(5A) cannot be applied retrospectively and also that the possession has been received vide letter dated 8th May, 2017. It held that the parties to the transfer of impugned property mutually agreed to hand over the delivery of the possession vide the said letter and it is to be accepted as true unless it is proved otherwise.There is no basis for the allegation made by the AO that the letter of possession is manipulated in collusion with the builder.The Tribunal, relying upon the decision of the co-ordinate bench in the case of N A Haris in ITA No.988/Bang/2018 dated 15th February, 2021 held that the capital gain arising pursuant to development agreement dated 10th February, 2011 is to be taxed in AY 2018-19 and not AY 2017-18 as held by the AO.

FACTS II

The assessee in the retraction letter had informed the AO that it had engaged a registered Valuer to determine the value of the property received by it after development and the said value was –

Commercial portion: ₹82,26,36,541

Residential portion: ₹6,89,11,624

—————————————————————————

                        Total: ₹89,15,48,165

===========================================

The assessee computed the capital gains by adopting the above stated value. In the assessment order, the A.O. varied the computation of capital gains by adopting the full value of consideration at ₹120,03,46,357/- based on the details furnished by the Developer vide letter dated 7th January, 2022. While doing so the A.O. has taken the cost of construction reported by the Developer of ₹4,597 per sft for the commercial portion and ₹3,750 per sft. for the residential portion.

The assessee disputed the cost of construction before the CIT(A). The CIT(A) observed that except for one unsigned sheet, the Developer had not furnished any bills or documents in support of the cost claimed to be incurred by the Developer. The DVO had without giving any reasons stated that the valuation as done by the Registered Valuer is understated.

Before CIT(A), reliance was placed on the decision of the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Shankar Vittal Motor Company in ITA 653/2016 dated 1st December, 2021 as well as the decision of the jurisdictional High Court in the case of Smt. Sarojini M. Kushe in ITA 475/2016 dated 1st December, 2021. In the aforesaid cases it has been held that the cost of construction given by the developer which is not supported by any particulars cannot be taken as full value of consideration. The Hon’ble High Court has held that section 50D of the Act, would be applicable and accordingly, the full value of consideration should be computed on the basis of guideline value of land or building that is transferred / received on development.

The CIT(A) determined the full value of consideration for transfer of the undivided interest land to the developer at ₹93,80,19,968/- as against ₹120,03,46,357/- taken by the Assessing Officer. The CIT [A] has noticed that the appellant has transferred 1,94,368sft. of land to the developer. The said land has been valued at ₹4,826 per sft. after deriving the same by reducing the guideline value of the building from the guideline value of the super built-up area. This is because the super built-up area includes both undivided interest in land as well as the built-up area. In this manner the learned CIT[A] has held that the deemed value of consideration for the transfer of the undivided share of land in the project pertaining to the developer share was ₹93,80,19,968/-

HELD II

The method adopted by AO for determining the consideration of the impugned transfer of property is not correct. There is no basis for inclusion of cost of land, finance cost and administrative cost for determining the consideration received by the landlord. The Tribunal held that the most appropriate judgment to be followed is the decision of Karnataka High Court in Shankar Vittal Motor Company in ITA 653/2016 dated 1st December, 2021. It held that no fault can be found with the decision of the CIT(A) which has been rendered by following the ratio of the decision of the Karnataka High Court Shankar Vittal Motor Company in ITA 653/2016 dated 1st December, 2021 as also the decision of the Smt. Sarojini M. Kushe in ITA No.475 of 2016 dated 15th December, 2021. The Tribunal dismissed this ground of appeal of the revenue.

Section 143(1) mandates only processing the return of income to vouch for the arithmetical error, detect the incorrect claim of expenses, losses, verify and cross check the claim made in the audit report, claim of deductions, cross verify the income declared in form 26AS or form 16A etc. and the Revenue is not allowed to go beyond that. Claim not made in the return of income, which has been processed, and time for filing revised return has expired can be made only before the administrative officers or the Board and not in an appeal.

44 PasupatiAcrylon Ltd. vs. ACIT

TS-696-ITAT-2024(DEL)

ITA No. 1773/Delhi/2024

AY: 2019-20

Date of Order: 19th September, 2024

Sections: 37, 143(1)

Section 143(1) mandates only processing the return of income to vouch for the arithmetical error, detect the incorrect claim of expenses, losses, verify and cross check the claim made in the audit report, claim of deductions, cross verify the income declared in form 26AS or form 16A etc. and the Revenue is not allowed to go beyond that.

Claim not made in the return of income, which has been processed, and time for filing revised return has expired can be made only before the administrative officers or the Board and not in an appeal.

FACTS

For the year under consideration, the assessee filed its return of income declaring therein a total income of ₹28,98,24,424. The CPC processed the return of income and passed an intimation accepting the return of income as filed by the assessee.

Assessee filed an appeal to the CIT(A) raising a ground that the assessee failed to make a claim of certain business expenditures in the return filed by it, which was duly processed u/s 143(1) of the Act. The CIT(A) held that the claim of business expenses u/s 37 after processing the return of income seems an afterthought. He opined that the assessee can easily file the revised return of income if there is any discrepancy in the original return of income before the due date, which the assessee failed to do so. The due date for filing the revised return of income was 30th November, 2020. The contention of the assessee cannot be accepted by simply writing a letter to the concerned authority for allowing the business expenses which was not claimed in the return of income. The CIT(A) relied on the decision of Supreme Court in the case of Goetze (India) Ltd, wherein the issue was well-settled, any deduction stating that the assessee can revise the return of income within due date for raising any new claim which was not claimed in the original return of income. Accordingly, he dismissed the appeal.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal to the Tribunal.

HELD

All the case law relied by the assessee are relating the fresh claim made by the assessee in the regular assessment proceedings, not in the case of preliminary assessment u/s 143(1) of the Act. The mandate of the preliminary assessment u/s 143(1) of the Act is different, it is only to process the return of income to vouch for the arithmetical error, detect the incorrect claim of expenses, losses, verify and cross check the claim made in the audit report, claim of deductions, cross verify the income declared in form 26AS or form 16A etc. The AO is not allowed to go beyond the above mandate given under section 143(1) of the Act.

The Tribunal noted that the asssessee filed the return of income in which it did not make certain claims which, according to the assessee, are genuine. The return was processed accepting the return of income as filed. The time allowed for filing revised return of income having elapsed the assessee found filing an appeal to be an easy option.

The Tribunal considered the possibilities available to make the fresh claim in case the assessee fails to make the claim in the original return of income. These, according to the Tribunal, are:

i. By filing revised return of income (not possible in this case as the limitation period already elapsed);

ii. Claim in the regular assessment, in case the return is selected for scrutiny. (in this case, not selected, the avenue to go in appeal also ruled out);

iii. The assessee can proceed by filing revision application u/s 264 of the Act before the jurisdictional commissioner. The application has to be filed within one year from the date of passing of the relevant impugned order;

iv. The assessee may file an application u/s 119(2)(b) of the Act before the Board. The board may find it desirable or expedient so to do for avoiding genuine hardship to admit an application or claim for any exemption, deduction, refund or any other relief under the Act. The important thing is that there is no limitation period attached to it. The assessee can approach any time when it has genuine claim.

The Tribunal was of the view that the assessee filed the present appeal before it without there being any grievance in preliminary or intimation order in which the Assessing Officer accepted the return of income filed by the assessee. It held that, the assessee may have two types of fresh claim, which may be genuine claim which is traceable from the return filed by the assessee, which can be claimed by the assessee, the other type is debatable issues which may be claimed only upon making proper verification and assessment, this will lead to discretion of the relevant authorities including the Board. It held that the remedy for the fresh claim is not with any appellate authority and the remedy lies only with the administrative officers or with the board. In case the board rejects the application, the remedy available only in the writ proceedings. The Tribunal dismissed the appeal filed by the assessee.

For failure on the part of the payer to deduct TDS, the assessee cannot be penalised by levy of interest under section 234C.

43 Standard Chartered Bank (Singapore) Limited vs. DCIT

TS-615-ITAT-2024(Mum)

Assessment Year: 2021-22

Date of Order: 14th August, 2024

Sections: 234B, 234C

For failure on the part of the payer to deduct TDS, the assessee cannot be penalised by levy of interest under section 234C.

FACTS

The assessee, a company incorporated in Singapore, registered as a Category I Foreign Portfolio Investor (FPI) with SEBI made investments in debt securities and equity shares in India. The assessee filed return of income for the year under consideration on 15th March, declaring a total income of ₹75,66,62,391. The return of income filed by the assessee was processed under section 143(1) and a demand of ₹47,13,33,940 was raised as a result of TDS credit not been granted and interest under section 234B and 234C being levied.

During the year under consideration, the assessee had received interest on commercial papers and non-convertible debentures amounting to ₹62,10,11,200 and ₹13,68,16,712 respectively which was subject to deduction of tax at source @ 20 per cent. The Assessee had also received interest on government securities which was subject to deduction of tax at source @ 5 per cent. On some part of income received from commercial papers, non-convertible debentures and government securities the payers did not deduct tax at source, though they were liable to deduct tax at source under section 196D and 194LD of the Act. Pursuant to the failure of the payer to deduct tax at source the assessee was required to discharge tax liability by way of advance tax at the time of receipt of such interest income from commercial papers, NCDs and government securities. The assessee did pay the full tax on interest receipts as advance tax.

Levy of interest under section 234B was subsequently rectified but the levy of interest under section 234C at ₹51,75,514 stood.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal to the CIT(A) who dismissed the appeal filed by the assessee.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal to the Tribunal where, on behalf of the assessee, reliance was placed on following decisions –

i) Goldman Sachs Investment (Mauritius) Ltd. vs. DCIT [(2021) 187 ITD 184 (Mum.-Trib.)];

ii) CIT vs. Madras Fertilisers Ltd. [149 ITR 703 (Mad. HC)].

HELD

The Tribunal observed that it is an undisputed fact that on some part of interest received by the assessee on commercial papers, NCDs and Government Securities, payers have faulted in not deducting tax at source. It was observed that for the fault of the payer, the assessee cannot be held responsible. The Tribunal held that in its understanding of the law, for failure on the part of the assessee to deduct tax at source under sections 196D and 194LD of the Act, the assessee cannot be penalised by levy of interest under section 234C. The Tribunal observed that the assessee has diligently discharged its full tax liability by paying entire advance tax on interest income.

Having examined the provisions of section 234C of the Act, the Tribunal held that it can be seen that advance tax is reduced by any tax deductible or collectible which means that the legislators have taken care of liability of the payer to deduct tax at source on payments and to that extent, assessee is not required to pay any advance tax. In the present case, since the payers faulted in deducting tax at source and assessee discharged its liability by paying full tax, the assessee cannot be levied with interest under section 234C of the Act for the fault of the payers. For this proposition, the Tribunal drew support from the decision of the Bombay High Court in Director of Income-tax (International Tax) v. Ngc Network Asia LLC [(2009) 313 ITR 187 (Bom. HC)] where the court held that when a duty is cast on the payer to deduct and pay tax at source, on payer’s default to do so, no interest under section 234B can be imposed on the payee assessee.

The Tribunal held that it is not a case of deferment of advance tax on income as envisaged in section 234C of the Act. The Tribunal directed the AO to delete the interest levied under section 234C.

The Tribunal allowed the appeal filed by the assessee.

Deduction under Sections 54 and 54F can be claimed simultaneously qua investment in the same new asset. The covenants in the sale deed executed and registered are conclusive in the absence of any evidence to the contrary. The crucial date for the purpose of determination of date of purchase for the purpose of section 54 is the date when the possession and control of the property is given to the purchaser’s hands.

42 RamdasSitaramPatil vs. ACIT

TS-618-ITAT-2024(PUN)

ITA No. 621/Pune/2022

AY: 2016-17

Date of Order: 7th August, 2024

Sections: 54 and 54F

Deduction under Sections 54 and 54F can be claimed simultaneously qua investment in the same new asset.

The covenants in the sale deed executed and registered are conclusive in the absence of any evidence to the contrary.

The crucial date for the purpose of determination of date of purchase for the purpose of section 54 is the date when the possession and control of the property is given to the purchaser’s hands.

FACTS

The appellant, an individual, filed his Return of Income for the A.Y. 2016-17 on 7th March, 2017 declaring a total income of ₹96,55,810/-. The assessment was completed by the Assessing Officer (AO) vide order dated 28th December, 2018 passed u/s.143(3) of the Act at a total income of ₹2,59,13,610/-. While doing so, the AO disallowed the claim for deduction of income u/s.54F of ₹98,97,654/- and deduction u/s.54 of ₹63,60,146/-.

During the year under consideration, on 9th February, 2016, the assessee entered into a joint development agreement for a consideration of ₹25,00,000 and 7 constructed flats. On 1st November, 2015, he entered into an unregistered agreement to sell a residential flat in Kolhapur for a consideration of ₹80,00,000. The assessee purchased a bungalow at Kolhapur, whose possession was taken on  31st March, 2015, for a consideration of ₹3,06,00,000, of which ₹1,30,00,000 was paid during the period from 20th May, 2014 to 2nd December, 2014 and ₹90,00,000 was paid in cash in 2014 as per MOU dated 19th May, 2014.

In view of the fact that the possession of the bungalow purchased was received on 31st March, 2015, the assessee claimed deduction under sections 54 and 54F against the long term capital gains arising on two transfers effected by him. The said claim was denied by the AO by holding that (1) deduction u/s.54/54F cannot be claimed simultaneously in respect of the same asset; and (2) payment for purchase of new house was made prior to one year before the sale of the original asset.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal to the CIT(A) who vide impugned order confirmed the action of the AO in disallowing the claim for deduction u/s.54/54F by holding that the possession agreement dated 31st March, 2015 is a fabricated document in view of the statement made by him u/s.132(4) of the Act on 19th December, 2014 that the new residential property is in his possession.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal to the Tribunal.

HELD

The Tribunal observed that the solitary issue in the present appeal revolves around the entitlement of assessee for deduction u/s.54/54F of the Act. It noted that admittedly, the sale consideration was paid prior to the one year before the sale of original asset. The Tribunal held that there is no bar under law to claim deduction simultaneously u/s. 54 and u/s.54F in respect of the same asset. It observed that the crucial fact which needs to be determined in the present case is the date of purchase of the new residential property.

The Tribunal held that it is settled position of law that the crucial date for the purpose of determination is when the property is purchased for the purpose of section 54 and the date when the possession and control of the property is given to the purchaser’s hands.

The Tribunal applying the principle laid down by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in case of CIT vs. Shahzada Begum [(1988) 173 ITR 397] and also the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT vs. Dr. Laxmichand Narpal Nagda (deceased) [211 ITR 804] and observing that in the present case, the recital of the sale deed clearly says that possession of the property was taken on 31st March, 2015 which is within the period of one year before the date of sale of the original asset. The Tribunal held that the covenants in the sale deed executed and registered are conclusive in the absence of any evidence to the contrary; the finding of the CIT(A) that it is a fabricated document is a mere bald allegation and cannot be sustained in the eyes of law; the appellant is entitled for deduction us/.54/54F as claimed.

Whether The Gift Of A Capital Asset By A Corporate Entity Be Subjected To Income Tax?

BACKGROUND

  • Capital gains were charged for the first time via the Income Tax and Excess Profit Tax (Amendment) Act, 1947, which inserted section 12B under the Indian Income Tax Act, 1922. Indian Finance Act, of 1949, virtually abolished this levy. The levy of capital gains was revived vide Finance (No. 3) Act, 1956 w.e.f. 1st April, 1957. Whether at the time of the introduction of capital gains in 1947 or at the stage of the revival of capital gains tax in 1956, the transaction of transfer of a capital asset by way of gift or transfer under irrevocable trust was not considered a transfer for the purpose of capital gains. In other words, the transfer of capital assets by way of gift or under an irrevocable trust was exempt. Such exemption was available to all classes of taxpayers, whether individual, HUF, firm, company, etc.
  •  Even under the Income-tax Act, 1961 (ITA), section 47(iii) of ITA provided exemption from capital gains on the transfer of capital assets by way of gift or under an irrevocable transfer. Such exemption was available to all classes of taxpayers. However, vide Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024, w.e.f. 1st April, 2025 (AY 2025–26 and onwards), section 47(iii) of ITA is substituted to provide that exemption on the transfer of a capital asset by way of gift or under an irrevocable transfer available only to individuals, and HUF.
  •  Explanatory Memorandum to Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2024 provides that amendment is carried out to (a) widen the tax base and act as an anti-avoidance measure, (b) section 50CA and section 50D of ITA are on statute book providing deeming consideration aiming to bolster anti-avoidance provisions, (c) taxpayers have argued in multiple judicial precedents that transaction of gift of shares by company is exempt under section 47(iii) of ITA (d) and (iv) to target tax avoidance and erosion of India tax base.
  •  Though the Explanatory Memorandum to Finance (No. 2) Bill 2024 provides that amendment is carried out to widen the tax base and target tax avoidance, there is no express mention that a transaction of gift by taxpayers other than individual and HUF will result in capital gains taxation.

WHETHER CORPORATE ENTITY CAN MAKE A VALID GIFT?

  •  Before delving into the tax implications arising from the transfer of capital assets by way of gift by a corporate entity, it may be of utmost importance to understand the legality of the corporate entity making a gift.
  •  Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TOPA) defines gift to mean a transfer of certain existing moveable or immoveable property made voluntarily and without consideration by one person, called the donor, to another, called the donee, and accepted by or on behalf of the donee. Section 5 of TOPA provides that the transfer of property shall be carried out by a living person, and the living person includes the company. Accordingly, a corporate entity is also a person who can make a gift.
  •  In following judicial precedents, it has been held that the corporate entity can make a valid gift.

 

  • DP World (P) Ltd [2012] 103 DTR 166 (Delhi Trib.) — There is no restriction on a company to make a gift. As long as a donor company is permitted by its Articles of Association to make a ‘gift’, it can do so.
  • Nerka Chemicals [2014] 103 DTR 249 (Bombay HC) — Relied on DP World (supra). Bombay HC held that a corporate gift is a valid transaction.
  • KDA Enterprises Private Ltd [ITA No. 2662/Mum/2013] (Mumbai Trib.) — Corporates are competent to make and receive gifts, and natural love and affection are not necessary requirements for making gifts. The only requirement for a company to make gifts is to have the requisite authorization in the Memorandum of Association or Article of Association.
  • PCIT vs. Redington (India) Ltd [2021] 430 ITR 298 (Madras):
  • It seems that there is no express denial under the law for a corporate entity making the gift of its assets. So long as the Memorandum of Association and/or Article of Association authorizes the gift of its assets, a company can make the gift.

ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS FOR COMPUTATION OF CAPITAL GAINS AND ABSENCE OF ANY ELEMENT, THE CHARGE FAILS

  •  Section 45(1) of ITA is a principal charging provision for taxing capital gains income. Section 45(1) of ITA provides that any profits and gains arising from the transfer of capital assets effected in the previous year be chargeable to income-tax under the head ‘capital gains’ and shall be deemed to be income of the previous year in which the transfer took place.
  •  Section 48 of ITA provides for a mode of computation of capital gains income. Section 48 of ITA requires a reduction of expenditure in relation to the transfer of capital assets, cost of acquisition, and cost of improvement from the full value of consideration.
  •  Judicially, it is well settled that charging provision and computation provision form integrated code. In order to create an effective charge for capital gains income, the transaction shall be covered by a charging provision as well as a computation provision. Where a transaction is not covered by computation provision, the transaction falls outside the scope of the charging provision itself.

 

  •  Reference may be made to the SC ruling in the case of CIT vs. B C SrinivasaSetty [1981] 128 ITR 294. In this case, SC was concerned with the computation of gains arising on the transfer of goodwill of business. In the absence of the cost of acquisition of goodwill, SC held such asset is not covered within the fold of section 45 of ITA. Relevant observations from SC rulings are as under:

“8. Section 45 charges the profits or gains arising from the transfer of a capital asset to income tax. The asset must be one which falls within the contemplation of the section. It must bear that quality which brings section 45 into play. To determine whether the goodwill of a new business is such an asset, it is permissible, as we shall presently show, to refer to certain other section of the head “Capital gains”. Section 45 is a charging section. For the purpose of imposing the charge, Parliament has enacted detailed provisions in order to compute the profits or gains under that head. No existing principle or provision at variance with them can be applied for determining the chargeable profits and gains. All transactions encompassed by section 45 must fall under the governance of its computation provisions. A transaction to which those provisions cannot be applied must be regarded as never intended by section 45 to be the subject of the charge. This inference flows from the general arrangement of the provisions in the Income-tax Act, where under each head of income the charging provision is accompanied by a set of provisions for computing the income subject to that charge. The character of the computation provisions in each case bears a relationship to the nature of the charge. Thus, the charging section and the computation provisions together constitute an integrated code. When there is a case to which the computation provisions cannot apply at all, it is evident that such a case was not intended to fall within the charging section. Otherwise, one would be driven to conclude that while a certain income seems to fall within the charging section, there is no scheme of computation for quantifying it. The legislative pattern discernible in the Act is against such a conclusion. It must be borne in mind that the legislative intent is presumed to run uniformly through the entire conspectus of provisions pertaining to each head of income. No doubt there is a qualitative difference between a charging provision and a computation provision. Ordinarily, the operation of the charging provision cannot be affected by the construction of a particular computation provision. But the question here is whether it is possible to apply the computation provision at all if a certain interpretation is pressed on the charging provision. That pertains to the fundamental integrity of the statutory scheme provided for each head.”

  •  Reference may also be made to the SC ruling in the case of Sunil Siddharthbhai vs. CIT [1985] 156 ITR 509. In this case, SC was concerned with the determination of the full value of consideration accruing or received by a partner on the contribution of the personal asset to the firm. In the absence of a determination of consideration on the transfer of capital assets, SC held that the case of a contribution of capital assets into the firm is outside the scope of the capital gains chapter. Relevant observations from the ruling are as under:

“In CIT vs. B.C. SrinivasaSetty [1981] 128 ITR 294 this Court observed that the charging section and the computation provisions under each head of income constitute an integrated code, and when there is a case to which the computation provisions cannot apply at all, it is evident that such a case was not intended to fall within the charging section. On the basis of that proposition, the learned counsel for the assessee has urged that section 45 is not attracted in the present case because to compute the profits or gains under section 48, the value of the consideration received by the assessee or accruing to him as a result of the transfer of the capital asset must be capable of ascertainment in monetary terms. The consideration for the transfer of the personal assets is the right that arises or accrues to the partner during the subsistence of the partnership to get his share of the profits from time to time and after the dissolution of the partnership or with his retirement from the partnership, to get the value of a share in the net partnership assets as on the date of the dissolution or retirement after a deduction of liabilities and prior charges. The credit entry made in the partner’s capital account in the books of the partnership firm does not represent the true value of the consideration. It is a notional value only, intended to be taken into account at the time of determining the value of the partner’s share in the net partnership assets on the date of dissolution or on his retirement, a share which will depend upon a deduction of the liabilities and prior charges existing on the date of dissolution or retirement. It is not possible to predicate beforehand what will be the position in terms of monetary value of a partner’s share on that date. At the time when the partner transfers his personal assets to the partnership firm, there can be no reckoning of the liabilities and losses that the firm may suffer in the years to come. All that lies within the womb of the future. It is impossible to conceive of evaluating the consideration acquired by the partner when he brings his personal asset into the partnership firm when neither the date of dissolution or retirement can be envisaged nor can there be any ascertainment of liabilities and prior charges which may not have even arisen yet. In the circumstances, we are unable to hold that the consideration which a partner acquires on making over his personal asset to the partnership firm as his contribution to its capital can fall within the terms of section 48. And as that provision is fundamental to the computation machinery incorporated in the scheme relating to the determination of the charge provided in section 45, such a case must be regarded as falling outside the scope of capital gains taxation altogether.”

  •  It may also be observed that in the context of the capital gains Chapter, SC, in the case of PNB Finance Ltd vs. CIT [2008] 307 ITR 75, held that in the absence of the determination of the cost of undertaking, the amount received on compulsory acquisition of undertaking cannot fall within the scope of section 45 of ITA.
  •  Reference may also be made to the SC ruling in the case of Govind Saran Ganga Saran vs. CST [1985] 155 ITR 144 rendered under the Bengal Finance (Sales Tax) Act, 1941 (‘Sales Tax Act’) as applied to the Union Territory of Delhi. The case revolved around the interpretation of Sections 14 and 15 of the Sales Tax Act. Cotton yarn was classified as one of the goods of special importance in inter-state trade or commerce as envisaged by Section 14 of the Sales Tax Act. Section 15 of the Sales Tax Act provided that sales tax on goods of special importance should not exceed a specified rate and further that they should not be taxed at more than one stage. The issue arose because the stage itself had not been clearly specified, and accordingly, it was not clear at what stage the sales tax would be levied. The Financial Commissioner held that in the absence of any stage, there was a lacuna in the law and consequently, cotton yarn could not be taxed under the sales tax regime. The Delhi High Court reversed the decision of the Financial Commissioner. However, SC held that the single point at which the tax may be imposed must be a definite ascertainable point, and in the absence of the same, tax shall not be levied. While rendering the ruling, SC has made the following observations which are worth quoting:

“The components which enter into the concept of a tax are well known. The first is the character of the imposition known by its nature which prescribes the taxable event attracting the levy, the second is a clear indication of the person on whom the levy is imposed and who is obliged to pay the tax, the third is the rate at which the tax is imposed, and the fourth is the measure or value to which the rate will be applied for computing the tax liability. If those components are not clearly and definitely ascertainable, it is difficult to say that the levy exists in point of law. Any uncertainty or vagueness in the legislative scheme defining any of those components of the levy will be fatal to its validity.”

SC ruling in the case of Govind Saran Ganga Saran (supra) has been quoted with approval by the Constitution Bench of SC in the case of CIT vs. Vatika Township (P.) Ltd. [2014] 367 ITR 466.

  •  From the above, it is clear that, in order to create an effective charge, there shall be the presence of all the elements that go into the computation of capital gains income. The absence of any element that goes into the computation of capital gains will be fatal to the levy itself.

WHETHER THE TRANSACTION OF THE GIFT INVOLVE ANY CONSIDERATION?

  •  The term ‘gift’ is not defined under ITA. Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, of 1882 defines ‘gift’ as under:

“Gift” is the transfer of certain existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration, by one person, called the donor, to another, called the donee, and accepted by or on behalf of the donee

  •  Reference may be made to the SC ruling in the case of Sonia Bhatia vs. the State of U.P., [AIR 1981 SC 1274]. Section 5(6) of U.P. Imposition of Ceiling on Land Holdings Act, 1960 (UP Act) as it stood at the relevant time provided that in determining the ceiling area any transfer of land made after  24th January, 1971 should be ignored and not taken into account. Clause (b) of the proviso to section 5(6) of the UP Act carves out an exception and states that section 5(6) of the UP Act shall not apply to a transfer proved to the satisfaction of the Prescribed Authority to be in good faith and for adequate consideration under an irrevocable instrument. Explanation II to said proviso places the burden of proof that a case fell within clause (b) of the proviso on the party claiming its benefit. On 28th January, 1972, the donor gifted away certain lands in favor of his granddaughter, the appellant, daughter of a pre-deceased son. The gift having been made after the prescribed date; the Prescribed Authority ignored the gift for purposes of section 5(6) of the UP Act. On behalf of the appellant, it was contended that a gift could not be said to be a transfer without consideration because even love and affection may provide sufficient consideration and hence the condition regarding adequate consideration would not apply to a gift. SC held that the gift does not involve adequate consideration and hence case does not fall within the carve-out in the said proviso. The relevant extracts from the ruling are as under:

“To begin with, it may be necessary to dwell on the concept of gift as contemplated by the Transfer of Property Act and as defined in various legal dictionaries and books. To start with, Black’s Law Dictionary (Fourth Edition) defines gift thus:

“A voluntary transfer of personal property without consideration.A parting by the owner with property without pecuniary consideration. A voluntary conveyance of land, or transfer of goods, from one person to another made gratuitously, and not upon any consideration of blood or money”.

A similar definition has been given in Webster’s Third New International Dictionary (Unabridged) where the author defines gift thus:

“Something that is voluntarily transferred by one person to another without compensation; a voluntary transfer of real or personal property without any consideration or without a valuable consideration- distinguished from sale.”

Volume 18 of Words & Phrases (Permanent Edition) defines gift thus:

“A ‘gift’ is a voluntary transfer of property without compensation or any consideration. A ‘gift’ means a voluntary transfer of property from one person to another without consideration or compensation.”

In Halsbury’s Laws of England (Third Edition-Volume 18) while detailing the nature and kinds of gifts, the following statement is made.

“A gift inter vivos (a) may be defined shortly as the  transfer of any property from one person to another gratuitously. Gifts then, or grants, which are the eighth method of transferring personal property, are thus to be distinguished from each other, that gifts are always gratuitous, grants are upon some consideration or equivalent.

Thus, according to Lord Halsbury’s statement the essential distinction between a gift and a grant is that whereas a gift is absolutely gratuitous, a grant is based on some consideration or equivalent. Similarly in Volume 38 of Corpus Juris Secundum, it has been clearly stated that a gift is a transfer without consideration, and in this connection, while defining the nature and character of a gift the author states as follows:

“A gift is commonly defined as a voluntary transfer of property by one to another, without any consideration or compensation therefor. Any piece of property which is voluntarily transferred by one person to another without compensation or consideration. A gift is a gratuity, and an act of generosity, and not only does not require a consideration but there can be none; if there is a consideration for the transaction it is not a gift.”

It is, therefore, clear from the statement made in this book that the concept of gift is diametrically opposed to the presence of any consideration or compensation. A gift has aptly been described as a gratuity and an act of generosity and stress has been laid on the fact that if there is any consideration then the transaction ceases to be a gift.

Under section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, the gift is defined thus:

“‘Gift’ is the transfer of certain existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration, by one person, called the donor, to another, called the donee, and accepted by or on behalf of the donee. Such acceptance must be made during the lifetime of the donor and while he is still capable of giving. If the donee dies before acceptance, the gift is void.”

Thus, s. 122 of the Transfer of Property Act clearly postulates that a gift must have two essential characteristics-(1) that it must be made voluntarily, and (2) that it should be without consideration. This is apart from the other ingredients like acceptance, etc. Against the background of these facts and the undisputed position of law, the words, ’transfer for adequate consideration’ used in clause (b) of the proviso clearly and expressly exclude a transaction that is in the nature of a gift and which is without consideration. Love and affection, etc., may be motive for making a gift but is not a consideration in the legal sense of the term.”

  •  Reference may also be made to Shakuntala vs. the State of Haryana, [AIR 1979 SC 843] wherein the transaction of gift is explained as under:

“It is, therefore, one of the essential requirements of a gift that it should be made by the donor ‘without consideration’. The word ‘consideration’ has not been defined in the Transfer of Property Act, but we have no doubt that it has been used in that Act in the same sense as in the Indian Contract Act and excludes natural love and affection…. It would thus appear that it is of the essence of a gift as defined in the Transfer of Property Act that it should be without ‘consideration’ of the nature defined in Section 2 (d) of the Contract Act”

  •  Reference may be made to the Madras HC ruling in the case of CIT vs. ParmanandUttamchand [1984] 146 ITR 430. In this case, the taxpayer was carrying on the business of money lending. On the event of grahapravesham, taxpayer received gifts from relatives, friends, and well-wishers which included some of the borrowers of the taxpayer. Tax authorities brought this amount to tax as income. In this regard, refer following observations from the HC ruling dealing with the meaning of gift.

“Under the general law of gifts, a voluntary or gratuitous payment is a gift. The absence of quid pro quo is regarded as an essential element of a gift. For purposes of taxation on income, however, it was said that these characteristics of gifts were to be regarded as indecisive and treated with indifference. It was said that the receipt of gifts should be considered from the point of view of the recipient, more especially in the context of the recipient’s walk of life. If the recipient, it was argued, receives the so-called gift by virtue of his employment or by virtue of his vocation, profession, or calling, then the gift, it was said, must be seen in a totally different light. In such cases, it was said, the receipts cannot escape being regarded as income, even though the person who made the payments did so voluntarily and intended it to be taken as a mere bounty.”

  •  Reference may be made to the Bombay HC ruling in the case of CED vs. NarayandasGattani [1982] 138 ITR 670. In this case, there was some dispute between the deceased and two of his sons regarding the earnings and the ownership of certain properties. To end the controversy, the deceased, out of his sweet will, gave ₹31,000 to one of his sons and ₹51,000 to the other, with the condition attached that the sons would relinquish all their rights over disputed properties. The sons, on receiving the said amounts, executed relinquishment deeds in respect of the said properties. Thereafter, the deceased and his sons entered into a partnership and the sons invested the above mentioned amounts as their capital in the firm. On the deceased’s death, the Assistant Controller included the said amounts in the deceased’s estate under section 10 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953 on the ground that the deceased had gifted the money and was not entirely excluded from its enjoyment because it had been invested in the partnership firm in which the deceased was also a partner. The Appellate Controller sustained the Assistant Controller’s order. On the second appeal, the Tribunal set aside the Appellate Controller’s order on the ground that the impugned transaction was not a “gift” at all. Bombay HC held that the impugned transaction was not without consideration and hence not a gift. Relevant observations from the HC ruling are as under:

“The concept of gift is that it has to be without consideration whatsoever except the consideration of love and affection in certain cases. The moment it is demonstrated that there was some consideration for the transfer, the transaction will be anything but a gift. The consideration can be the settling of a future probable dispute or even getting an admission from the party which will preclude the raising of a dispute. In the instant case, the Tribunal had concluded that there was a certain amount of mutuality in the impugned transaction and that it was not without consideration, the consideration being to put the affairs beyond the pale of controversy by obtaining the deed of relinquishment and giving the sons funds so as to enable them to start their own business, keeping in view the circumstances of the case and the recitals contained in the two relinquishment deeds executed by the sons, the impugned transactions were not gifts.”

  •  Reference may be made to Madras HC ruling in the case of PCIT vs. Redington Ltd [2021] 430 ITR 298 dealing with a gift by a company to a step-down subsidiary the concept of gift has been explained by HC as under:

“40. As noticed above, the Tribunal in the impugned order from paragraphs 72 to 79 examined the aspect as to whether a company/corporate body can execute a valid gift and concluded that a company is a person both for the purposes of the TP Act and the Gift Tax Act, 1958 and can make a gift to another company which is valid in law and accepted the contention of the assessee that it was entitled to gift its shares in RG to RC. Having held so, the Tribunal failed to examine whether the ingredients of section 122 of the TP Act have been fulfilled to qualify as a valid gift. Section 122 of the TP Act defines “gift” to be a transfer of certain existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration by one person called the donor to another called the donee and accepted by or on behalf of the donee. The essential elements of a gift are (i) absence of consideration; (ii) the donor; (iii) the donee; (iv) to be voluntary; (v) the subject matter; (vi) transfer; and (vii) the acceptance. The concept of gift is diametrically opposed to any person’s consideration or compensation. It cannot be disputed that there can be transactions that may not amount to a gift within the meaning of section 122 of the TP Act but would qualify as a gift for the purpose of levy of tax under the Gift Tax Act owing to the definition contained in section 2(iii) read with section 4 of the Gift Tax Act. Block Stone states that “gifts” are always gratuitous, grants or upon some consideration or equivalent. In several decisions, it has been held that for proving a document of the gift was executed with the free and voluntary consent of the donor, it must be proved that the physical act of signing the deed coincides with the mental act viz., the intention to execute the gift. The principles laid down in the Indian Contract Act relating to free consent would apply in determining whether the gift is voluntary.”

  •  Reference may be made to the recent ruling of Bombay HC in the case of Jai Trust vs. Union of India [Writ Petition No. 71 of 2016, order dated 8th March 2024]. In this case, the taxpayer gifted shares of the listed company to a private limited company and claimed exemption under section 47(iii) of ITA. There was a reassessment proceeding initiated against the taxpayer. The taxpayer challenged reassessment proceedings by filing a Writ Petition. Bombay HC held that (a) transfer of capital asset under a gift is not a transfer for the purpose of section 45 of ITA (b) reading of section 48 of ITA bears out that profits or gains can be measured only when the consideration is involved (c) section 50CA is not applicable as it was inserted w.e.f. 1st April 2017 and in any case, section 50CA applies only where consideration is received on transfer of capital asset being unquoted shares and does not apply when there is no consideration (d) section 50D is not applicable as it was inserted w.e.f. 1st April, 2013 and in any case, it applies only where consideration is received on the transfer of capital asset and does not apply when there is no consideration (e) A gift is commonly known as a voluntary transfer of property by one to another without any consideration. A gift does not require a consideration and if there is a consideration for the transaction, it is not a gift. In view of the above Bombay HC quashed the notice of reassessment. Relevant observations from the ruling are as under:

“18. Mr. Sharma’s reliance on Section 50CA of the Act in this regard has to be rejected because (a) Section 50CA of the Act was inserted with effect from 1st April, 2018 by the Finance Act, 2017 and (b) it applies to a capital asset being share of a company other than a quoted share (in this case shares transferred were quoted shares) and also applies only where the consideration received or accruing as a result of such transfer. Mr. Sharma’s reliance on Section 50D of the Act also has to be rejected because (a) it was inserted by the Finance Act, 2012 with effect from 1st April, 2013 and (b) there also the Section postulates receiving consideration and not a situation where admittedly no consideration has been received.

19. A gift is commonly known as a voluntary transfer of property by one to another without any consideration. A gift does not require a consideration and if there is a consideration for the transaction, it is not a gift. Since the reason to believe it is admitted that shares were transferred by the assessee to NCPL without consideration, certainly, it is a gift. In fact, it is not even the respondents’ case that is it not a gift. Mr. Sharma submitted, as an afterthought, that the assessee being a Trust it can be reasonably presumed that the transfer was for a consideration because anything a Trust does is for the benefit of its beneficiaries. It is not the case of the Revenue in the reasons to believe or in the order disposing objections or even in the affidavit in reply. Therefore, this submission of Mr. Sharma cannot be even considered. We cannot proceed on the hypothesis and deal with such a presumptuous argument. Moreover, if the transfer is not valid, the property still remains with the Trust and in such a situation, there can be no capital gain.”

  •  Reference may also be made to the AAR ruling in the case of Deere & Co., In re [2011] 337 ITR 277. In this case, the taxpayer company incorporated in the USA gifted the shares of the Indian company to the Singapore group company. The transaction was finished by way of a gift. The taxpayer company claimed that it was not liable to pay capital gains. AAR held that the taxpayer company was not liable to pay capital gains in view of the exemption under section 47(iii) of ITA. Relevant extracts from the ruling are as under:

“4. The learned counsel for the applicant on the other hand has argued that there is no element of love and affection attached to the gift. According to the ordinary meaning, “gift” means a thing given willingly to someone without payment. The learned counsel further brought to our notice the definition of “gift” given in section 122 of the Transfer Property Act 1882, “Gift” is the transfer of certain existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration by one person called the donor to another called donee and accepted by or on behalf of the donee. The meaning of gift supra reflects no element of love and affection and therefore the contention of the Departmental representative in this regard is without substance. The gift of shares by the applicant to John Deere Asia (Singapore) is made without any consideration and therefore the transfer has to be held to be a gift.”

  •  The above rulings including SC rulings are an authority that the transaction of gift does not involve consideration. If a transaction involves consideration (whether direct or indirect), such cannot qualify as a gift. The absence of consideration is an essential characteristic of a valid gift.
  •  In the case where a corporate entity has made a valid gift, there is no involvement of consideration or the transaction can be said to be without consideration. In the absence of consideration, one of the essential elements for the computation of capital gains is not present and accordingly, there is no trigger of capital gains provision.

REFERENCE MAY BE MADE TO THE PROVISO TO ERSTWHILE SECTION 47(III) AND THE SIXTH PROVISO TO SECTION 48 OF ITA TO SUGGEST THAT ABSENT CONSIDERATION, THERE CANNOT BE AN EFFECTIVE CHARGE

  •  The erstwhile proviso to section 47(iii) of ITA provided that exemption under section 47(iii) of ITA shall not be available for transfer of capital asset by way of gift or irrevocable trust of capital asset being shares, debenture or warrants allotted under ESOP to employees. In order to back up the charge and deny exemption, a sixth proviso to section 48 of ITA was inserted to provide that market value as on the date of transfer of capital asset under a gift or irrevocable trust shall be considered as the full value of consideration.
  •  It may be noted that when the exemption was denied under section 47 of ITA, there was a backup provision under section 48 of ITA providing for deemed full value of consideration. In the present case, though the transfer under a gift or irrevocable trust by any person other than individual or HUF is not provided for exemption under section 47(iii), there is no provision providing for the full value of consideration. In the absence of full value of consideration, there is no effective charge under the capital gains chapter.

ABSENT CONSIDERATION, THERE IS NO RELEVANCE OF SECTIONS 50C, 50CA, AND SECTION 50D OF ITA

  • Section 50C of ITA provides that where the consideration received or accruing as a result of the transfer of capital asset being land or building is less than the value adopted or assessed or assessable for stamp duty purposes, the value considered for stamp duty purposes shall be deemed to be the full value of consideration. Section 50CA of ITA provides that where the consideration received or accruing as a result of the transfer of capital asset  being unquoted shares is less than Rule 11UAA value, such Rule 11UAA value shall be deemed to be the full value of consideration. Section 50D of ITA provides that where the consideration received or accruing as a result of the transfer of the capital asset is not ascertainable or cannot be determined, the fair market value of a capital asset on the date of  transfer shall be deemed to be the full value of consideration.
  •  The common thread that runs through sections 50C, 50CA, and 50D of ITA is accrual or receipt of consideration on the transfer of capital assets. In order to trigger these sections, it is the sine qua non that there shall be the presence of consideration. By definition, the transaction of a gift is without consideration, and accordingly, in the case of the transaction of a gift, there is no accrual or receipt of consideration. This proposition has been dealt with by Bombay HC ruling in the case of Jai Trust (supra) wherein HC observed that section 50CA and section 50D of ITA postulates receipt of consideration and in the case of gift transaction, there is no consideration involved.
  •  Accordingly, in absence of consideration, provisions of sections 50C, 50CA and 50D of ITA cannot be triggered.

THE ABSENCE OF AN EXEMPTION DOES NOT RESULT IN THE CREATION OF A CHARGE

  •  In order to bring the transaction within the tax net, the transaction shall be covered by the charging provision and shall be a backup computational provision. Where the transaction is not covered within the charging provision, the mere absence of exemption will not create an effective charge. In the case where the transaction is not covered by a charging provision and a specific exemption is provided, it may be construed as a draftsman’s anxiety to make the law clear beyond any doubt.
  •  In this regard, reference may be made to the SC ruling in the case of CIT vs. Madurai Mills Ltd [1973] 89 ITR 45. In this case, SC was concerned with capital gains liability in the hands of shareholders in case of liquidation of the company. It may be noted that SC held that in the absence of a charge under the India Income-tax Act, 1922, the absence of exemption does not result in the creation of a charge. Relevant extracts from the SC ruling are as under:

“If the language of sub-section (1) of section 12B of the Act is clear and does not warrant the inference that distribution of assets on liquidation of a company constitutes sale, transfer or exchange, the said transaction of distribution of assets would not, in our opinion, change its character and acquire the attributes of sale, transfer or exchange, because of the omission of a clarification in the first proviso to sub-section (1) of section 12B of the Act, even though such clarification was there in the third proviso of the section inserted by the earlier Act (Act 22 of 1947). It is well settled that considerations stemming from legislative history must not be allowed to override the plain words of a statute (see Maxwell on the Interpretation of Statutes, twelfth edition, page 65). A proviso cannot be construed as enlarging the scope of an enactment when it can be  fairly and properly construed without attributing  to it that effect. Further, if the language of the enacting part of the statute is plain and unambiguous and does not contain the provisions which are said to occur in it, one cannot derive those provisions by implication from a proviso (see page 217 of Crates on Statute Law, sixth edition)”

  •  Reference may also be made to the Privy Council1 ruling in the case of CIT vs. Shaw Wallace [AIR 1932 PC 138]. In this case, the taxpayer received compensation for cessation of the agency. Privy Council held that such an amount received cannot be considered as income of the taxpayer. Privy Council held that even where the amount received was covered by the exemption provision, such was never income of the taxpayer. Refer following extracts from the Privy Council ruling.

“Some reliance has been placed in argument upon Sec. 4(3)(v ) which appears to suggest that the word ‘income’ in this Act may have a wider significance than would ordinarily be attributed to it. The sub-section says that the Act ‘shall not apply to the following classes of income’ and in the category that follows, clause (v) runs: ‘Any capital sum received in commutation of the whole or a portion of a pension, or in the nature of consolidated compensation for death or injuries, or in payment of any insurance policy, or as the accumulated balance at the credit of subscriber or to any such Provident Fund.’ Their Lordships do not think that any of those sums, apart from their exemption, could be regarded in any scheme of taxation as income, and they think that the clause must be due to the over-anxiety of the draftsman to make this clear beyond the possibility of doubt. They cannot construe it as enlarging the word ‘income’ so as to include receipts of any kind which are not specially exempted”


1   Rulings rendered by Privy Council are binding on all Courts except SC – refer ShrinivasKrishnarao Kango vs Narayan Devji Kango and others [1954 AIR SC 379], Delhi Judicial Service Association v State of Gujarat [1991 AIR SC 2176].
  •  Reference may also be made to International Instruments (P) Ltd vs. CIT [1982] 133 ITR 283 (Karnataka) wherein the following observations are made:

“As observed by the Privy Council in CIT vs. Shaw Wallace & Co. AIR 1932 PC 138, just because an amount was exempted from tax under section 4(3) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, it was not to be treated as income when such amount could not be regarded as income under any scheme of taxation and such exemptions only indicated the over anxiety of the draftsmen to place the matter beyond any possible controversy. [See also the Full Bench judgment of the Allahabad High Court in Rani AmritKunwar vs. CIT (supra)].

On the above reasoning, with which we respectfully agree, a receipt that is income does not cease to be income even if exempted from income tax, and a receipt that is not income does not become income just because it is included as one of the items exempted from income-tax”

  •  Accordingly, in the absence of a specific exemption provision, it may be incorrect to contend that there is a charge of capital gains income.

AUTHOR’S VIEW

Considering that (a) for creation of effective charge, all elements of computation provisions have to be present, (b) the transaction of gift does not involve any consideration, (c) absent consideration, there is no trigger of deemed consideration provisions under
ITA, (d) absence of exemption does not result in creation of charge, (e) absent consideration, there cannot be computation of capital gains income, in view of the author, the taxpayer stands on a firm footing to urge that there cannot be capital gains
income in the hands of corporate entity on gift of a capital asset.

However, it may be noted that where the transaction involves some direct or indirect consideration, the transaction may itself lose the status of a gift as it involves consideration. Consequently, it may be difficult to claim non-taxability. Further, once the transaction involves consideration, sections 50C, 50CA, and 50D
of ITA, which provide for deemed consideration, may also apply.

Interview – CA Rajeev Thakkar

“WHEN YOU ARE BUYING EQUITIES, HAVE THE BUSINESS OWNER’S MINDSET, RATHER THAN TRYING TO FLIP IT EVERY NOW AND THEN”

BCAS and the CA profession have completed their 75 years of existence. In order to commemorate this special occasion, the BCAJ brings a series of interviews with people of eminence from different walks of life, the distinct ones whom we can look up to, as professionals. Readers will have an opportunity to learn from their expertise and experience, as well as get inspired by their personal stories.

Here is the text (with reasonable edits to put it into a text format) of an interview with Rajeev Thakkar.

Rajeev Thakkar is the Chief Investment Officer & Director, PPFAS Asset Management Private Limited, the asset manager of PPFAS Mutual Fund. As of March 2024, the Company has an asset under management of over ₹64,000 crores.

Rajeev Thakkar possesses over 30 years of experience in various segments of the Capital Markets such as investment banking, corporate finance, securities broking and managing clients’ investments in equities. Rajeev strongly believes in the school of “value-investing” and is heavily influenced by Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger’s approach. His keen eye for ferreting out undervalued companies by employing a diligent and disciplined approach has been instrumental in the scheme’s stellar performance ever since he assumed the mantle.

He resists the temptation of entering speculative stocks during extremely bullish times as he believes that it is not appropriate to wager on clients’ funds and faith by chasing companies that one does not have any conviction in. He strongly believes that only stocks purchased at the right valuations will provide long-term returns and is unperturbed by short-term underperformance. He is a Chartered Accountant, Cost Accountant, CFA Charter holder, and a CFP Certificant.

In this interview, Rajeev Thakkar talks to BCAJ Editor MayurNayak, past editor Raman Jokhakar and Journal Committee member Preeti Cherian about his winning equation, investor behaviour, his advice to investors, company management, auditors, directors, gold as an asset class, de-dollarisation, speculation, the regulatory framework in India, great investor habits and routines and much more…

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Welcome, CA Rajeev Thakkar. On behalf of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society and the Journal Committee of BCAS, I, together with CA Raman Jokhakar and CA Preeti Cherian, thank you for this opportunity to interact with you.

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Thank you. I have not been part of the profession formally since 1994 when I moved to the financial markets, but my formative years were spent doing my CA articleship and my interactions with Chartered Accountants started since then.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): Thank you, Rajeev. Morgan Housel has famously said that average returns for an above-average period equals extreme outperformance; he believes this is the most obvious secret in investing. What is your winning equation when you measure performance as a fund manager who is stepping into the shoes of the investors?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): We studied this one formula in high school, which, unfortunately, a lot of people do not remember in their grown-up years; that formula is the compound interest formula, A = P (1 + R/N)nt; where “A” is the final amount, “P” is the principal amount, “R” is the annual interest rate (decimal), “n” is the number of times interest is compounded per year (12 for monthly) and “t” is the time in years.

If we look at the formula, there is only one term which is exponential in the formula, and that is, the number of years. Addition, multiplication move slowly, but the exponential term moves very rapidly after a certain period. So, if you invest long enough, the number of years “t” is a bigger factor driving the returns. Something which will give you 25–35 per cent for six months will not be that meaningful of a return driver as compared to something which will, let’s say, give you 15–16 per cent over 30–40 years. That is what he means — invest for an above-average period.
In our case, we do what is commonly referred to as ‘active investing’, where instead of putting all the client’s money into stocks which are part of the indices, we identify those companies (that) we believe will outperform the index, and we invest in them. Sometimes, we succeed in this, sometimes we don’t. Our journey has been satisfactory. On average, we have managed to do better; but again, more than the return, the longevity matters. I completely agree that one should look at long-term compounding; but, if in the process, you can do better than the index, you will be even more successful.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): When you talk about the long-term, what is the horizon you look at? Is it 5, 10 or 15 years?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Look at the behaviour of our family or our friends or even our behaviour. Typically, in an Indian household, jewellery is passed from one generation to another. We add to the existing jewellery stock; very rarely do people sell jewellery which has been inherited. People buy a home and stay in the same home for 20–30 years. Even if they change the home, they sell that and buy something even more expensive by, typically, putting in some more money. An employee joining the workforce at the age of, let’s say, 25, will regularly put money in the Employees Provident Fund for 35 years till retirement. We buy LIC policies for 20–30–40 years. Yet when it comes to equity investing, the moment we buy the stock, we put it in Google Finance, Yahoo Finance, Money Control, some app or the other, and the TV channels will show you tick-by-tick price data. There is this urge to do something — sell something, buy something else. And we do not have a long-term outlook for it.

At PPFAS, we look at equity as, ‘effectively owning a part of the business’ when we buy shares of the company. When you buy TCS shares, you are partnering with the House of Tata in providing IT services. When you buy Bharti Airtel shares, you are partnering with the company in providing telecom services. Now businesses go through their ups and downs in terms of demand cycles, competition, environment-related matters, etc. Sometimes, the market sentiment will cause share prices to go up and down. We have had long periods of time where equity did nothing; we have also had periods where equities gave supernormal returns — these returns have come only to those who have had the patience to hold through the long up-and-down cycles. The mistake that people make while driving their investment vehicle is that they only look in the rear-view mirror. If the past five years have been good, they will come and invest heavily. If the past five years were bad, they will withdraw or not add money, which is precisely the wrong way to look at it.

To answer the question, “How long is long-term?” you should look at it like you look at your Employees’ Provident Fund or your insurance policies. Equity is the longest asset class; so, when you buy equity, there is no maturity date. As all Chartered Accountants know, it is the permanent capital of the company. Now, on the other hand, a bond will have a maturity date. So, when you are buying equities, have the business owner’s mindset, rather than trying to flip it every now and then.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): Managing risk is a key part of investing. Some say that even more important than return is the management of risk. What strategies do you employ to mitigate the risk of losses or the risk of permanent loss of capital during market crashes or economic downturns or, you know, black swan events like COVID, etc?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): So, one thing which is not very widely appreciated about losses and risk is that people generally tend to equate the upside and downside in their minds. If you make 10 per cent and then, you lose 10 per cent, people think they are more or less quits. Well, let me give you some vivid examples.

If you lose 50 per cent, to come back to where you started, you do not need a plus 50 per cent, you need to double your money — you need plus 100 per cent returns. Say, from 100 you go down to 50. Now, from 50 to go back to 100, you require a 100 per cent return. Then again, if you fall from 100 to 25, that is minus 75 per cent; you need to take your money up by 4X to go from 25 to reach 100.

If your return in year 1 is 25, year 2 is 15 and year 3 is 20, you cannot add the three numbers and divide by three to get the average return — you need to multiply the returns. So, in a scenario, where returns are multiplicative, if any one number is 0–100% (investment goes to 0), you get checked out. And similarly, if any one number is a big negative, coming back to par becomes very, very difficult.

Permanent loss of capital needs to be distinguished from what Warren Buffett calls ‘quotationalloss’. After you buy your share, the price could either go up or down. It is almost a 50–50 per cent probability in the near term. Market prices keep bouncing around all the time, so the permanent loss of capital comes only when the mistake is so bad that chances of recovery are either zero or the time taken to recover will be so long that effectively all capital will be gone. This can happen in a situation where the company you buy shares in goes bankrupt. That is one very clear example of permanent loss of capital. This can also happen on account of fraud, excessive leverage or very, very severe business downturns.

If you invest in debt-free businesses or minimal debt or cash-rich companies where the management has a good track record over decades, the chances of fraud are less. That is one thing to look out for while managing risk; buy into businesses which are not that prone to disruption hits. If the business environment changes every six months, then what is a very successful business model today may not work in a year. So, buying into stable businesses helps.

The second reason for permanent loss of capital could be if you have severely overpaid — where the drawdowns are 80–90 per cent. This happened in the late 1990s with what was called New Age or New Tech businesses: technology, media, telecom or internet, communication, and entertainment — the ‘new economy stocks’ as they were called. Those fell significantly after the crash, and people took almost a decade to come back to par and, in some cases, the money was completely lost. Similarly, we saw a cycle in 2007 where people were valuing companies on potential land banks and how they could get monetised. If we avoid these mistakes, the other smaller mistakes get evened out. In a portfolio where let’s say, there are 20 stocks, 10 could do reasonably well, 5 could do exceptionally well, and the other 5 may not do well at all; so, on average, you tend to do reasonably ok.

So, one, guard against fraud, excessive leverage, or disruption, and two, avoid paying very, very excessive valuations to avoid permanent loss of capital.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Very well answered. Just to take a cue from that, say in a case like Satyam, where there is a sudden or permanent loss, in that situation, how would you react because there is total uncertainty as to whether the company will revive? So, should one stop loss?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Let’s say you have invested in 20 businesses, and you have, on average, 5 per cent in each business. Any one stock going to 0 will affect your portfolio value by 5 per cent. 100 will go to 95 if a particular stock goes to 0. Now if the stock market, on average, is giving you a 12–15 per cent return, then you would have to wait for the remaining stocks to give that return to make up for the loss (that) you have suffered. What to do in a specific scenario requires (1) knowledge, (2) skill set, (3) temperament and (4) a certain amount of luck.

There have been people who have invested in downturns where they saw that whatever has happened is not fatal for the company, and they could make huge returns from buying into such a scenario. Then again, there have been scenarios where one should have sold off in that environment. Warren Buffett famously put 40 per cent of his partnership assets into American Express after a scandal broke out, and that worked out very well for him. In India, we have had banks which have gone completely bankrupt, like the Global Trust Bank, or something like Jet Airways. If something is going bankrupt, you will lose all your money. So, after a crisis hits, should you exit that stock or should one buy more? The answer depends on your understanding of the balance sheet, your understanding of the business and how you see the future playing out.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): I think you gave a very important answer, that one should diversify their portfolio as much as possible. To quote Morgan Housel again, “Things that never happened before happen all the time.” Can you share your experience of navigating previous market crises such as the 2008 financial crisis and COVID?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Both were very, very interesting in terms of that they happened during my career as a professional investment manager. An individual can choose to do what he or she wants. But a professional investment manager is answerable to a whole set of people. Luckily, we were able to navigate reasonably well during both these crises. COVID was different from the global financial crisis; the proximate causes were different. However, one common theme across both crises was that stock prices came off significantly. So, in COVID, at the lows, you saw something like a 40 per cent drop from peak levels; during the global financial crisis, it was a 60 per cent drop — this is at the index level. Individual stocks would have fallen even more.

The common theme across both these crises is that initially, a few years were / will be difficult for the business environment, economic growth could be slow and there could be losses due to hitherto unseen situations. So, in the case of the virus outbreak in China, the hospitality sector was badly affected, airlines could not operate and hotels could not operate. Or for example, the subprime crisis in the US affected the inter-bank liquidity in India. One does not know what impacts will be there, and what 2nd / 3rd / 4th order effects will be there in a crisis kind of a situation.

My advice is to firstly, go through your existing list of companies where you have invested. The key criteria to look at is, will this company survive over the next three to four years on its own without government support, without anything else? If the answer is yes, you can hold. If the company has too much leverage, if interest payments and principal payments are due, if they are going to be facing issues servicing their loans, then their assets will most likely get sold off, and as a shareholder, you will end up with nothing.

Secondly, let’s say, the next three years’ earnings are 0, but if the stock price is down 50 per cent, in most cases, it results in a ‘buy’ kind of scenario, as long as the business is going to survive because, in the life of a business, three years is a relatively short period. The inherent assets do not go away; the inherent business value does not go away. From the intrinsic value perspective, it does not have that big of an impact, maybe a 10–15–20 per cent value reduction; if the discount you are getting is much larger, it mostly results in a ‘buy’ kind of scenario.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): In the coming years, the crisis may be different, or may be of a mixed nature. For example, we had this pandemic, a financial crisis. With impending war and the volatile geopolitical situations in some areas, all these could get enmeshed and create a new form of crisis. How do you see such kind of crisis affecting us as investors?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Sure. So, several things could go wrong: you could have a meteor strike the earth, you could have a nuclear war break out, you could have cyber-attacks and/or ransomware attacks, you could have political instability or you could have a civil war kind of situation. Various things can happen in the realm of possibilities. If you are investing in equities, there must be a certain amount of optimism that the world will continue to do well. Otherwise, one gets into too much of a defensive nature. We jokingly tell people that if something strikes the earth and all the life as we know it is wiped out, will it then matter whether you invested in gold or bonds or equities? No one will be around to see the asset values decimate.

Coming to asset allocation, how much emergency money / liquid money to keep, how much to put in gold, how much to put in asset classes like REITS (Real Estate Investment Trusts) for regular cash flow, how much to put in growth assets like equity all depends on personal circumstances — personal risk tolerances, age, financial goals, all these things. But once you decide on asset allocation, it helps to tune out worrying about all the things that could go wrong. Occasionally, things will go wrong. But on average, things even out. If people were equity investors in pre-Nazi Germany, most likely, their portfolios would have been wiped out. Or if someone was an equity investor in China or Russia before communism, their holdings would be zero, but so would be everything else, including their large homes, which would be taken over by the state. There are some things you cannot do anything about, except for maybe global diversification; at the end of the day, you should not worry too much about those things.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): How do you manage customer / investor expectations and show it through your performance, because people do expect some kind of outcome from their investment?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): We see a very strange kind of investor behaviour. At one end, investors will be very, very comfortable buying insurance plus mixed investment products, where they will get maybe 5–6 per cent return over the long-term, or they will be happy with their bank fixed deposit rates; but when it comes to equity, immediately the expectations go to 20–25–30–35 per cent, the higher, the better. Our job is to communicate to the investors that equity in the short run is a risky asset class. There are periods where returns can be negative. There can be long periods where returns are subdued, and only if you hold it through a longer term, can you expect moderately good returns — ‘moderately good’ meaning something better than fixed income securities and better than inflation. We portray the different kinds of rolling returns that have been achieved over the index level in the past, so that gives some grounding to our communication. We try and explain both these factors: (1) the requirement for long-term investing and (2) we tone down the return expectations whenever we can.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): That takes me to the next important aspect from the investors’ perspective — re-balancing and re-checking the portfolio. What should an investor consider as triggers to undertake this? And the period to review the portfolio — whether it is under a mutual fund or a mix of equity, debt and mutual fund and other asset classes?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): People have different approaches to this aspect. Some people typically think of re-balancing as a tactical move, and many times, they mix it with upcoming events or their outlook on what is going to happen. I think this is where people go significantly wrong. To give you an example, people try to bet on political outcomes, and they invest accordingly, and invariably get it wrong. They end up losing not only in India but globally as well. People read the Brexit Referendum wrong, they read the Trump and Clinton elections wrong and they read the 2004 Indian elections wrong. This year, on the exit poll day, the markets were significantly up; on result day, markets were down. Again, we are up to all-time highs. People tend to swing between greed and fear and end up losing a lot of money — that is not the reason to re-balance.

The other reason for re-balancing could be because of their asset allocation. Let us say, someone’s asset allocation is 60 per cent equity, 40 per cent bonds. Now if equity does very well, the temptation would be to sell equity and buy more bonds. One could do that if that is the appetite. People should follow a disciplined approach and maybe review it once a year. Re-balancing once a year is reasonably ok. In my opinion, typically, people fall into two categories: either people are saving for retirement or people are consuming in retirement. If you are a saver, my recommendation is rather than selling one asset class and buying the other asset class, you can divert your incremental savings to the asset class which is underweighted. For example, say, the allocation is 70:30 between equity and bonds, and you put the year’s savings only in bonds so  that the weightage of bonds starts going up. Each time you switch between asset classes, that is tax-inefficient; you end up paying tax without benefiting from that cash flow.

Similarly, if you are in retirement and you want to re-balance, withdraw from the asset class which is heavier than your target weight rather than trying to sell one and buying the other frequently. Buying–selling creates unnecessary transactions. If it is too lopsided, then sure, one can sell one (asset) and buy the other (asset).

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): Today we are in a slightly tricky situation – we are facing high interest rates and markets also keep going up, not only in India but also, say, in the US. What do you read into this? What are the causes and consequences? How should investors look at this? How do you look at it?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): All Chartered Accountants know that the technically correct formula to value any financial asset is the discounted cash flow of any asset, be it a bond, aircraft lease, equity shares, real estate, etc. This formula helps you decide whether the asset is worth buying or not. One of the factors which affect this discounted cash flow is the discount rate you use. Logically, at higher interest rates, the discounting rate would be higher and at lower rates, the discounting rate is lower. So, when rates go down, the intrinsic value goes up.

The linkage between the federal funds rate, RBI repo rate to bonds has been very clearly established. In the case of government bonds, the cash flow is very certain — you know the exact amount you will get and the exact date on which you will get it. In equity shares, neither is the amount nor is the date certain. So, while interest rates do factor in terms of equity valuations, the linkage is not that very strong. The movement of stock prices is better determined by the growth prospects that people see in cash flows and the business environment. This partly explains the fact you mentioned — when interest rates were going up, we saw stock prices also go up. However, when interest rates come down, stock prices may or may not go up — as the linkage is not that very strong, rather it is a weak linkage.

Today, in terms of the environment, we have factored in a lot of positives that are there in India and globally — so, valuations are looking stretched. In one-off companies and sectors, you find opportunities. But if one looks at the overall market levels, I believe it is time to be cautious in equities.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): Picking information at the right time and analysing it rightly is critical to investing. But like we CAs use the word ‘professional judgment’, how do you stay informed of what action to take? There is way too much information from various sources, such as regulatory changes, market developments, geopolitical risks, etc. How do you sift through all this information to arrive at your investment decision?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Firstly, when you are looking at a company, it helps to look at the market cap and  total profits, rather than other parameters. Let’s assume you have enough money in your bank account to write a cheque and buy the entire company at the current market price. Once you buy it, you are the business owner and now the stock ceases to be listed on the exchange. Would you be happy being a business owner at the current offered price? That kind of thinking really clarifies matters a lot.

I believe most of your readers / listeners are Chartered Accountants. Let’s say you are in practice and some other Chartered Accountant is retiring and offers their professional practice to you for a fee. Would you buy that professional practice at the price offered, basis the same factors you would consider to evaluate a listed business? Chartered Accountants in practice would know what a professional practice is. Similarly, you should be aware of what the business of the listed company is. If you are analysing a telecom company, but you do not know anything about telecom, it is difficult to arrive at a business value. Each analyst and each manager is familiar with a certain number of sectors such that they can arrive at a reasonable judgement; do not stray beyond that, that is my first recommendation; if you do stray, then the chances of making a mistake go up.

You mentioned regulatory changes and other changes too. Typically, the chances of making a mistake in such businesses (where regulations change very frequently) are very high. Jeff Bezos once famously said that he frequently gets asked, “What’s going to change in the next 10 years?” And that he rarely gets asked the question, “What’s not going to change in the next 10 years?” The second question is the more important of the two because one can build a business strategy around the things that are stable in time. In the retail business, customers will always want lower prices, faster delivery and bigger selection. It is impossible to imagine a future 10 years from now when a customer will come up and ask for higher prices, slower deliveries or lesser selection. When one has something that one knows is true, even over the long term, one can afford to put a lot of energy into it.

Similarly, as investors, we need to focus on businesses which will look largely similar 5, 10 or 15 years from now. The basic needs of humans — buying consumer goods, soaps, shampoos, biscuits, basic banking, basic insurance — all these have not changed too much. Whereas if you are in some niche technology space or some biotech space where some regulatory approval could either come or not come, then your entire valuation hinges on that one event happening or not happening; that’s when things become very difficult. Stick to things that you understand and things that are relatively slow-moving. Of course, changes are there everywhere. Even in consumer goods, for example, Gillette which offers shaving products faced competition from a direct-to-consumer brand in the US-based Dollar Shave Club. Be on top of the change; focus on things that are slow moving and then take your time. Opportunities will come your way.

Again, in the late 1990s, all tech companies were overvalued. So, if you bought Infosys or Wipro in the late 1990s, you would have lost money or you would have not broken even for seven to eight years. Ironically, after seven years, if in 2007 you bought these tech companies, you would have done well despite the global financial crisis. So, at what valuation you buy matters, apart from all your business analysis, quality checks and all that and much more. Many times, things are obvious. It’s just that you need patience to wait for the right opportunity to come your way and when it does, you should have the courage to act.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): So, Rajeev, you made a very profound statement that one should focus on things that are not going to change. And one of the things which people expect to continue is the governance structure of the investing company. Broadly speaking, what is your broad governance evaluation mechanism?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I think more than the technical aspects, past behaviour matters. Sometimes people try to use too much of a checklist kind of approach: How many board meetings did this director attend / not attend? How many other boards is this director present on? I agree there is some importance in that, but are these the people running the company? Are they fair to the minority shareholders or not? Do they have a personal interest in the well-being of the company? Let’s say the promoter group has just a 3 per cent to 4 per cent stake in the company. Then they are not going to be so bothered about minority shareholders. They may be interested in building their empire or paying themselves excessive remuneration. So, essentially, are they being fair to the minority shareholders? Do they have the competence to run the business? Are they energetic? All these things matter.

Seen in the photo from left to right: CA Raman Jokhakar, CA Rajeev Thakkar, Dr CA Mayur Nayak and CA Preeti Cherian

Warren Buffett listed three things. Firstly, you want integrity. Without integrity, nothing will work, no matter how good the business is. Secondly, you want competence. Someone may have integrity but does not know how to run the business; then it will not work out. Thirdly, you want energy. You want commitment in terms of time and effort. If someone has integrity and competence but spends all the time on the golf course, then again, it won’t work. So, you need a combination of these three; but largely, you need integrity and competence.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Excellent answer! Moving on, how do you see the role of auditors as one of the lines of defence? There are many auditors who have been involved in fraud across the world. How do you see the role of auditors in this governance structure?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): As investors, we have access to the annual accounts where the auditor puts theirs and the firm’s names behind the assurance that is being given. And that matters a lot. While studying auditing, we were told that we are watchdogs and not bloodhounds. So, if the fraud is too convoluted, there is a limitation on what the auditor can do and cannot do.

The one interesting change in recent times has been in the format of the audit reports. Earlier, you just stated whether these statements were true and fair. Now you have to make additional qualitative disclosures. So, when you read key audit matters and things like that, as an investor, you can decide that this business is too complicated. Then no matter what the published statements say, if there are these significant uncertainties, maybe it’s better to stay away from the company.

Let’s say, one company has a simple standalone balance sheet in India — big promoter stake, long track record, understandable business, not too many issues in terms of inventory valuation, depreciation estimate, impairment, etc., — you can go with the financial statements and invest in it. Now, let’s say, there is another company with 200 subsidiaries in multiple geographies, 20 acquisitions, a huge amount of goodwill lying on the balance sheet and huge paragraphs upon paragraphs of key audit matters. Now in such a case, the reported financials are just these numbers, meaning you can’t nail them down with any precision. Again, if the nature of business is such that it involves a lot of estimates, what is the chance of completing these projects? In the famous case of Enron, the whole structure was so complicated that people could not understand what was going on inside. It’s better to avoid such companies, I think.

When you look at the audit report, irrespective of who the auditor is, the description generally gives you enough information as to what to stay away from. And interestingly, there is a lot of data disclosure these days, apart from whatever is there in the auditor report. There are a lot of data points which are put out by the government and regulatory authorities; there are subscriptions that investors can take and look at. For example, you can do a case search on all the litigations where the company is a party either as a plaintiff or as a respondent, you can look at whether they are filing GST returns on time or not, whether they are paying PF dues on time or not, how many employees do they have, so on so forth; various checks can be done in that manner.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Today, auditors are regarded as conscience-keepers for the stakeholders. Do you believe that auditors have discharged their duties ably or have they failed in some areas? What more can be done by various regulatory authorities like NFRA and ICAI to make the system more robust?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): While I am not part of the audit profession as such, I regard myself as a little bit of both an insider and an outsider. As someone with a Chartered Accountancy qualification but one who is a consumer of the accounts rather than someone who writes an audit opinion, I think we are expecting far too much from auditors. Even the way the financials are reported these days — I am slightly old school in terms of preference — things such as historical cost accounting, the adjustments would be done by the end investor or the users of the financial reports. Nowadays, with this fair value concept, making comparisons across time has become difficult because earlier statements would be under one accounting regime and the later statements are under a different accounting regime. So, in our mind, we must redo the numbers and try and compare again. It is not so much of a challenge in the kind of businesses that we invest in because they are simpler businesses, and we don’t place too much importance on a particular quarter’s result or a particular year’s result — when you look at it over 5 years, 10 years, these things even out. So, it is not so much of a hassle.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Do you use any risk management tools or instruments to hedge against potential losses? Anything from the AI space?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Ask the saying goes, artificial intelligence has not prevented natural stupidity. The market cycles are still what they are. If you look at the US markets, for example, you have these meme stocks where the companies are almost bankrupt but because some people are pumping them up on social media, the stock price keeps going up. And then when it goes up very, very dramatically, the company says, oh, this is a golden opportunity, let’s issue more shares and raise actual cash, and then the stock price collapses, and the capital gets misallocated because the business is inherently bad.

Most of the work we do is old school. AI helps in terms of doing certain activities to speed up things. For example, if you want AI to go through all the conference call transcripts and go to a particular term which was used, let’s say, ‘cloud computing’, then you could do that. You could use AI to scan social media posts for a new car brand that has been launched and do sentiment analysis of the reviews — positive or negative. Those kinds of things could be done. You could use AI to summarise stuff but do not outsource the decision-making to AI. We do use things like derivatives for hedging and so on, but these are firstly not for speculation at all. My advice to the investor, especially the retail investor, is to stay completely away. We are the counterparty to them — whenever the retail investor does something foolish, we benefit from their actions.

A matchbox can be used both to light a fire in the kitchen and to burn down the building. Let me give you a simple example. A biscuit company will want to buy wheat, and a farmer will want to sell it. Now, the farmer may not want to take the price risk since the crop is standing; he may want to lock into a fixed price. On the other hand, the biscuit manufacturer may want to lock in the purchase price. So, they may partly enter a wheat futures contract and de-risk both their operations — this is a case of hedging. Now, there could be a commodity speculator who wants to speculate on the price of wheat. He will pay ₹10 as margin and take a position of 100 or 200 and when the price moves, he either makes a lot of money or loses the entire capital. So, it depends on what a person is using those instruments for.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): Can you walk us through your decision-making process? This is surely the most important work that people count on you for. How do you decide when to buy, and of course, to sell?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Before deciding to buy a particular company or not a few things need to be checked out. First is the promoter quality that we spoke about, the integrity, competence and energy of the promoter, and the manager group. Second are good industry characteristics. Now the same business house may be very successful in running an IT services company and yet may fail very miserably in running an airline company because the businesses are different.

Today, anyone can walk into a bank and make a fixed deposit at 7.5 per cent p.a. If the business is going to generate a return on capital employed of 6 per cent p.a., why would you even invest in such a business? There are certain industries and businesses we rule out; if they do not have a track record of a decent return on capital employed, we simply do not invest in them. Third, we discussed leverage or borrowings. Borrowings increase the riskiness of our business. There are certain exceptions — utilities and banks typically are in the business of borrowing money but otherwise we stay away from leveraged businesses. The business should be understandable — if it’s a biotech company dependent on one approval coming for a particular medicine, I’m not competent to judge that company. It should be a business that we can understand. After all these criteria are met, I want a valuation that is reasonable. This is the decision-making process for a company per se.

We have a team of analysts covering different sectors. They track all the companies under their coverage on a regular basis. Periodically, an opportunity comes, and they pitch it to the fund management team, the investment team. How much to buy depends on the upper limits at the regulation level. We cannot own more than 10 per cent of a company across schemes. So, if the company has an outstanding paid-up capital of 100 shares, we cannot own more than 10 shares in the company across all our schemes. This is the first restriction. Also, as a per cent of our assets, we cannot own more than 10 per cent in a company. The company may be very large, let’s say, TCS, I cannot put 20 per cent of my clients’ money in TCS; I am restricted to 10 per cent. So, this is the second restriction. We also do not want to overextend in a particular sector; so, there are sectoral limits in place.

The weightage also depends on the relative attractiveness of different things. If I have five equally good opportunities, then it would be spread over all five. Of these five, if there are three better opportunities, then the weightage would be slightly higher in those three. Of some of the stocks that we currently own, if we get fresh client money, we would buy more of those companies if they are still attractively valued. If there is redemption, obviously we will sell to pay money to the unit holders.

Another reason to sell is when either the promoter and / or management integrity comes into question. Then the exit is relatively quick. If the business worsens significantly and that too on a permanent basis, then the exit is also very quick. Further, if the valuation keeps going up, we generally trim the position over a period. Then it is not a one-shot exit because there is no precise answer as to when something is overvalued; we would end up reducing the weight over a period.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): These days, when money sort of keeps getting pumped in, with everyone investing in the market through mutual funds, what happens when there is so much inflow?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): We are clear that we will not buy something which is overvalued just because money is coming in. The money will go to money market instruments which, in the current environment, give around 7.5 per cent p.a. Just because inflows are coming, we will not buy just anything.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Investing in US securities – PPFAS MF’s well-acclaimed Flexi Cap Fund has exposure to US equity as well. What has been the experience of your fund to US exposure?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I’ll split the question into two parts. One is only currency and the second is investing abroad, especially in US markets.

One interesting thing about US markets is the opportunity to invest in larger companies — when you are buying into those larger companies, you are participating in the world economy. These companies don’t just operate in the US, they have global operations. Look at Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Meta (earlier called Facebook), these operate globally. In India, when people buy a new cell phone, among the first apps that they download are WhatsApp, YouTube, Google, Amazon, and things like that. So, when you are buying into US companies, you are buying their Asia business, you are buying their European business, their North American business, their South American business — everything comes to you together.

We do not have any view on the US$ as such. We are saying these are businesses on the right side of the business trends that are there — the business trends being the shift from traditional advertising to digital advertising, the shift from on-premises computing to cloud computing, from linear TV to streaming services like Amazon Prime Video or YouTube or Netflix, shift towards AI where again these companies are at the forefront – so these businesses are growing in terms of revenue now.

The US$ could weaken against other currencies, sometimes it could strengthen, which is ok. We are partnering in that business which is global. When we buy into a global business, what this does is that the India-specific ups and downs get muted on the portfolio level. Let’s say, there is a surprise demonetisation in India, there’s uncertainty around GST introduction or there’s border tension with China. All these things get muted in the portfolio — both positive and negative. Like, we had a surprise tax cut, Indian stocks went up, and global stocks obviously did not follow — so, the journey for the investors is smoother to that extent. Also, some opportunities are not available in India. We have a good corporate sector across various industry segments, but some segments are missing. For example, we do not have big EV players. So, if you want a very strong EV player, you must either buy something like a Tesla or BYD globally. If you want device manufacturers, you want to buy Apple or Samsung globally. Look at software and operating systems, we do not have the equivalent of Microsoft kind of companies in India, Google kind of companies in India or innovator pharma companies. Most of our companies are generic companies. A Johnson & Johnson kind of company is not there in India. So, you must look at overseas investing.

I do not have a view on currency; whatever the currency, if the business is valuable, people will pay for that business and the companies will earn a profit. About the central bank’s de-dollarising — clearly, I think the West has overplayed its hand in the Russia–Ukraine war. If a country has balances with you and you say, because I don’t politically agree with you, I’ll freeze or seize your assets, then people will move away. Even people who are not directly involved will say who knows if 5 years, 10 years from now I could be in a similar situation, I don’t want to be taking that risk now. Recently, we have had India bringing back gold to our shores; why keep our gold in foreign countries? Central banks have been buying gold as opposed to US treasury securities. I think that trend could continue. People could create strategic reserves of oil, industrial metals and rare earths, rather than just keep assets in the reserves, in paper money. Then it does not matter what currency you use as a medium of exchange. You could continue to use US$ because it is a temporary thing. If the balance is not too much, you could use $, €, ¥ or whatever.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): How do you see gold as an asset class? Because today we find both equity and gold going up seamlessly, silver is also going up. How do you look at them as an asset class?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Historically, gold has been able to protect purchasing power reasonably well, especially in India, against rupee depreciation or inflation and things like that. But it’s not my favourite asset class. Let’s say, you buy 10 grams of gold. Those 10 grams of gold after 10 years will remain 10 grams of gold. Instead of that, if you buy a business making cars, tractors or manufacturing mobile phones, they could set up new factories, increase turnover and increase profits. It’s productive — putting money in equities or lending money to businesses to generate employment. So as a country, it would be better if we put money in productive assets rather than buying metal, which will go into lockers.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): There are alternative or competitive investment philosophies which state that the word “long-term” is like a cushion because, in the long term, everything anyways goes up. Instead, they propose to see the long-term view but also try and make money with a higher turnover of their holdings by calling it as being more dynamic.

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Firstly, let us distinguish between two things — and I am not passing any moral judgment here — let us distinguish between investing and speculation. Let us say all of us sitting in this room took out a pack of cards and said let’s gamble, right? Can all of us be profitable at the end of the session? No. So if you win, I would have lost money to you. When we add up all the winnings and losses, the total will be zero, right? This is what is called a zero-sum game. In the market, speculation is a zero-sum game minus taxes minus brokerage. It’s a negative sum game; it doesn’t mean everyone will lose money. In fact, some people are very, very successful at this — case in point, Jim Simons, founder of the quant fund, Renaissance Technologies in the West. The fund has earned annual returns of around 60 per cent before fees and has one of the best track records. Overall, it adds nothing to the marketplace — there would be counter parties who would have lost money to that extent.

In investing, if all of us put money and, let’s say, start a restaurant and if that restaurant does well, can all of us make a profit? The answer is yes, because we are partners, and the business is doing well — that is investing — we are in the investing camp. Does it mean that you should sell businesses which are not doing well and buy more of things which are doing well? Periodically, you should eliminate companies that are deteriorating and put money to better use. But this continuous need to try and find the next big theme that will work well goes into the realm of speculation. Some people are successful at that. That is not our style. We are in the investing space where the management quality, the balance sheet quality and understanding the business and values are all that matters. Renaissance Technologies that I spoke about? They did not even know what the companies were doing or what the tickers were doing for them. It was a symbol and price. They would analyse price, volume, data and some other indicators and they would keep buying and selling all the time. They did not care about related party transactions, whether it was a qualified annual report or a clean audit report.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): SEBI has been regulating the mutual fund industry now for almost 30 years. What do you have to tell mutual fund investors about the regulatory protection they have today compared to earlier?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I think with each passing day, investor protection gets stronger, and today, if you ask people working in the field, they sometimes feel, oh, is this necessary? We are already so well-regulated. So, of course, anyone in the industry will keep complaining all the time. But, net-net, everything that is required has been done. We are having this conversation after market hours because, during market hours, there are restrictions on what we can speak about, as while trades are going on, the information should not go out. Everything is audio recorded; there are video cameras in the dealing room recording people’s actions. All the securities are held with the custodian bank, so the fund house does not handle the pay-in / pay-out of the securities. There’s a panel of brokers. There are mutual fund custodians. There are registrar and transfer agent companies who provide services to investors on behalf of mutual fund houses. Portfolio disclosures are very detailed. The expenses that the managers can charge the investors are very tightly regulated and are brought down all the time. It is a phenomenal activity where the interest of the unit holder is kept paramount; the entire activity is overseen by a trustee company where two-thirds of the directors are independent — these are people not associated with the company.

So, a lot of measures have been taken, which is seen in the results. Anyone can just look at the number of investors flocking into mutual funds and the size of the assets. People, in this day of social media, immediately turn against you if the experience has not been good. The experience of the people who have been investing with us for a while has been good, and that strong word-of-mouth is helping — we have now reached roughly 4.60 crore unique investors in mutual funds. Till very recently, it used to be less than 2 crores; so, the numbers are growing and more people are coming in.

The one thing that SEBI cannot do anything about to protect investors is the tendency of the investors to invest by looking at returns from the recent past. One thing I think as an industry we could do better is this practice of launching thematic funds. In the late 1990s, mutual funds launched tech funds. In 2007, they launched real estate and infra funds. These are not great instruments for retail investors. Diversified equity funds are a good product. Diversified equity funds, index funds, fixed-income security funds — these are hybrid funds. These are good categories. In very niche industry-specific funds, typically, the end investor sometimes ends up getting a bad experience, so I think that is something that we could collectively do better by not launching thematic and sectoral funds, but otherwise, it is a very well-regulated product, and people are getting a good experience.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): Compared to markets outside India, in your experience, do you feel there is something that could fall through the cracks as it is not being done and is not yet happening?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I think we are far ahead of other markets. Some of the things we have are not prevalent in other markets; for example, on boarding customers — typically, it is completely digitalised and centralised; once you have done a KYC, you can invest in any of the funds. Partly, the pain point right now is the frequent changes in the way KYC is done. Hopefully, we will resolve this very soon. I do not think too much is left now to be done, but otherwise what happens is someone who has done KYC six or twelve months back gets these SMS notifications saying to do this one more thing, else they will not be able to do XYZ, so that has caused some anxiety, but I think that will get resolved soon.

So, again, just to put things in perspective, globally, it’s not as easy, because here we have Aadhaar, mobile linkage, DigiLocker – all these things are seamless here. So, although there are some pain points, we are still better off than the rest of the world.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): We would like to now ask a few quick questions: if you had to list out three worst investor behaviours, what would they be?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Falling prey to greed and fear, panicking when markets are crashing and just rushing in when your neighbour is making a lot of money — that is one big mistake. The second big mistake is that people invest in fixed-income products and do not allocate enough to equities. Indians, in general, love physical assets like gold or bank fixed deposits and small savings instruments, but not equity. Another is looking at the rear-view mirror or as it is called, a sunk cost fallacy. Say, you have bought something at 100 and it’s fallen to 50, you know it is going to 0, but still, you do not get the courage to exit at 50 because you think it should go up to 200 for you to exit.

Q. (Raman Jokhakar): What are the great habits and routines of investors, meaning what should they cultivate?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I think curiosity is right up there — one must be a constant learning machine. Read all the time, talk to industry people as to what are the drivers of their business, what are the developments happening. Today, the challenge is not access to information; today, the challenge is filtering information. So, how to filter out the noise? How to filter out the useless stuff? Do focused work on what is important.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Which are your all-time top five books or courses on investing that you would recommend to investors? Also, any blogs that you follow particularly?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): My vote goes to some accessible writing where one doesn’t need (to have) too much of a background. I believe Peter Lynch’s books are accessible in that sense — One Up on Wall Street and Beating the Street. Peter Lynch is the famous mutual fund manager of Fidelity Investments in the US, where he has a reasonably long track record.

Warren Buffett’s open letters to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders and the videos which are on CNBC’s website are easily accessible to all — these are very, very interesting. Unfortunately, he hasn’t written a book himself. But there are books written on him, on his investing style, so you could pick up one of those, apart from the letters – Buffett:The Making of an American Capitalist is one such book.

For understanding the qualitative aspects, you could read Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits by Philip Fisher where he looks at buying quality companies for a very long period. Then there are a lot of books on behavioural finance. Our company’s founder, Parag Parikh, has authored two books; look up those. One is Value Investing and Behavioural Finance and the other is Stocks to Riches. You mentioned Morgan Housel. His blog and his books are also interesting.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): One more personal question. How do you relax and unwind?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): So, the organisation has been good in the sense that culturally, we have never subscribed to working long hours or working weekends and things like that. Typically, once we leave the office, we leave work behind in the office. Spending time with the family, listening to music, watching some content on streaming services or reading a book — that is what I like to do.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Any favourite non-investing or non-fiction books you would want to recommend?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar):Deep Work: Rules for Focused Success in a Distracted World is something I would highly recommend. The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People is again a must-read.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): If you were to write a book, what would be the title?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I am not someone who will give something very, very original. In that sense, it would be more on the lived experience part of my journey in the investment process, but it would be something like experiential investing. Charlie Munger was a big fan of vicarious learning. So, instead of making the mistakes yourself, learn from someone else’s mistakes or learn from other people’s experiences.

Q. (Mayur Nayak): Is there any last advice you would like to give to our readers or investors?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): I think people spend far too much time picking individual stocks and individual mutual fund schemes, tracking it all the time, and spend very little time in terms of the basic asset allocation. Whether you bought company A or company B will have less of an impact on your personal finances than how much money you put in equity versus bonds. People will put maybe 5 per cent of their net worth in equities and then expect that 5 per cent to make them billionaires; it doesn’t work that way. Having a meaningful allocation to a diversified portfolio and holding it for the long term is what will create wealth.

Q. (Preeti Cherian): Mr Thakkar, when I look at you, there’s a Zen-like quality around you. So, my question to you is, does anything ruffle you?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Do things upset me? Of course, they do. Things upset any human being. It is not that there is a global financial crisis, but no impact; there is COVID, but no impact. Obviously, there are concerns and there is anxiety. It is not just about markets going up or down. During COVID, it was personal health, being locked up at a place, not even being able to go out for a walk in the initial days — those things ruffled people, I think. One should have a meditation practice, to help oneself calm down. I’ve done vipassana for 10 days and occasionally practise it.

Q. (Preeti Cherian): In your role as CIO, do you exercise a casting vote when it comes to you and your team taking critical decisions?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Our investment team has four individuals, so three individuals and myself. Four of us make the fund management team and, more or less, the decisions we arrive at are on a consensus basis. Typically, if there are concerns which we are not able to address, we do not go ahead with that investment. If there is a clear buy-in from the team, then we go ahead with the investment. I am first among equals in that sense, and there would be a casting vote if there ever arose a need to vote, but we do not work like that.

Q. (Preeti Cherian): Before investing in a company, do you and your team analyse who the independent directors are, on which other boards they sit? Does that carry any weight? Similarly, with auditors — do you look at them — which firm and / or which partner? Does that influence your decision-making?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): One of our team members has created something like a social graph of independent directors and auditors, just like you have a social graph on LinkedIn or Facebook. These directors are associated with this kind of companies, this auditor is associated with these companies. If there is a particular auditor who has also been associated with two or three bad companies, that would be a red flag; similarly for directors. It’s not a very big percentage of how we go about deciding, but it is definitely something we look at, apart from other things.

Q. (Preeti Cherian): Do you get an opportunity to interact with the investee companies?

A. (Rajeev Thakkar): Yeah. So various kinds of interactions happen. Every quarter, there is an analyst call. This is typically on the phone rather than in person. Various brokers have these broker conferences where a lot of companies come over — those are face-to-face meetings. Once in a while, we seek out meetings, go across to the company and meet them. Sometimes, the company management comes to our office, and we meet them. They inaugurate a new plant or R&D facility where they take a group of analysts and investment managers to visit the plant — there are interactions there. When interacting with the company management, we want to make sure that we do not cross the line, we do not ask nor do we get anything which is not in the public domain; but anything that enhances our understanding of the business or increases the knowledge-base of how this sector operates is more than welcome and we seek that out. Typically, this happens after the results are declared, so there is not much to disclose in terms of what is not already known.

Apart from the companies, what our team does is they also interact with other people in the field. So, let’s say we are invested in company A or tracking company A. Company B may be an unlisted company operating in the same space but they would have insights into the strategies of various companies. Sometimes, we  may interact with the channel — where we interact  with the stockists and dealers or we interact with customers. Sometimes, we may interact with suppliers. We could be looking at trade publications or industry exhibitions.

 (Mayur Nayak): This has been an extremely engaging interaction with you, Mr Rajeev Thakkar. I am sure our readers will benefit greatly from your experience. On behalf of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society and my colleagues, I thank you for taking time out of your schedule to talk to us.

(Rajeev Thakkar): Many thanks.

From The President

Dear Members,

  •  More than 17.76 lakh applications were received for 17,471 police constable posts.1
  •  India needs to create an additional 60 to 148 million jobs by 2030.2
  •  India, on average, grew 6.6 per cent a year in the decade starting in 2010, but the employment growth rate was below 2 per cent, which was below its G20 peers.3

The single largest challenge that stands between present-day India and a developed nation is our capacity to create sufficient employment opportunities and, thereby, leverage our demographic dividend. The Indian economy must generate approximately 7.85 million jobs ‘annually’ in the non-agricultural sector until 2030 to accommodate the increasing workforce; currently, we fall short of this target. Empirical evidence suggests that jobless growth can lead to unintended consequences of income inequality, economic stagnation, lower productivity, strain on public finances, unrest, etc.

While the broader issue of ‘oversupply’ is a significant challenge for our nation, within our community and profession, the situation seems to be more balanced or even tipping in the opposite direction. Converse to the national phenomenon:

-The second-most critical challenge facing our profession was considered that of ‘Attracting and Retaining Talent’;4

– We need more than 30 lakh Chartered Accountants by 2047.5

– In 2023–24, the highest number of jobs were created in ‘services’, of which ‘financial services’ is a major contributor. This trend is expected to continue.6


1 Maharashtra police recruitment drive outcome.
2 Gita Gopinath, first deputy managing director of International Monetary Fund
in conversation with 15th Finance Commission chairman N K Singh.
3 Economic Survey – 2024-25
4 BCAS Membership Survey 2024
5 ICAI president at a press conference in New Delhi on 21st February, 2024
6 Study report by Bank of Baroda.

As our profession and organisations expand, we have a genuine opportunity to bridge this dichotomy by creating significant direct and indirect employment, thus remaining true to our purpose of Partners in Nation-building. Globally, the worrisome trend of a declining number of CPAs entering the profession and a fragile student pipeline — alongside over 75 per cent of current CPAs retiring over the next 12 years — creates a unique opportunity for Indian Chartered Accountants to become the key enablers to the business world.

While external factors can offer support, they are not sufficient by themselves to address the challenge of Attracting and Retaining Talent. A vital aspect of fostering growth and excellence in our profession lies in reflecting on our mindset, approach and strategies to attract and, more importantly, retain talent. During the recent BCAS Lecture meeting on Profession @ 2047, Shri Shailesh Haribhakti highlighted the profound effect of small but meaningful adjustments and their overall contribution to our cause. From my observations, a few recurring themes emerge among successful professionals who excel in attracting and retaining talent:

i. Purpose-driven practices: The cultural fabric of purpose-led ethical organisations contrasts sharply with that of short-term, opportunistic entities. Individuals with integrity seek to affiliate with reputable organisations and align with a clear organisational purpose, substantially contributing to team unity. As professional entities, adhering to our core values of ethics, professionalism and knowledge serves as the most effective method for attracting and retaining top-tier talent. Purpose-driven organisations also embody genuine leadership that emanates from the highest levels.

ii. People over profits: While a business aims for ‘maximisation’, a profession strives for ‘satisfaction’. The line between professions and businesses is becoming less clear, and as professionals, an excessive focus on profits is inappropriate. Incidents where health and lives are compromised due to extreme work pressure and toxic environments cause irreparable harm to organisations, their employees and their families. The culture of prioritising ‘profits over people’ requires a complete reversal, placing the well-being of team members at the forefront. The practice of paying 1.3x and demanding 1.5x effort does not support sustainable well-being in the long run. Evaluating our progress on the axis of good > better > best is more meaningful than focusing on being big > bigger > biggest.

iii. Investing in the future: As managers or owners, we also have the responsibility of acting as trustees for the future of our teams. The position of influence we hold should be directed towards genuinely caring for and improving our team’s prospects. Adopting the perspective of your subordinates often leads to a more balanced approach to important issues. Organisations designed for longevity positively affect thousands of lives over time.

iv. Collaborate with scale: The scalability and security of an expanding organisation inherently attract and retain talent. As teams’ ambitions rise, it becomes essential for organisations to grow and provide long-term career opportunities. Scaling also introduces challenges that test and enhance the capabilities of teams, offering them a chance to reach their full potential.

Fostering an environment where we regard our teams with attention, care and respect, rather than merely as ‘resources’, is crucial in tackling the issue of attracting and retaining talent.

Whilst learning events continued throughout the September month, at your Society, four sub-groups have been constituted with specific terms of reference:

i. SA 600 Working Group: The newly released exposure draft on SA 600 by the National Financial Reporting Authority carries significant implications. At BCAS, a working group comprising distinguished accounting professionals has been formed to examine these proposed changes thoroughly and provide meaningful recommendations.

ii. Direct Tax Simplification Working Group: In her Budget speech, the Finance Minister announced plans to undertake a comprehensive simplification of the current Income-tax Act, 1961. As a leading voice in the accounting and tax field, the BCAS has formed a working group with the aims to (i) propose potential simplification strategies, (ii) assess the drafted simplification initiatives once they are available, and (iii) address the educational needs of our members concerning changes brought about by the proposed simplification measures.

iii. Sherpa Steering Group: The BCAS has members spread over 350 cities and towns throughout India. Last year, we launched the Sherpa initiative with the goal of connecting with our community and enhancing engagement. This initiative enables various BCAS projects to extend their reach to different regions, thus magnifying the benefits of the BCAS nationwide. To support the development of this crucial initiative, a dedicated steering group has been established.

iv. IIM-M + BCAS Joint Steering Group: As you know, the BCAS and IIM Mumbai signed a research-focused MoU last month. To advance this initiative, a joint steering committee featuring leading members from both the BCAS and IIM-M has been established. A list of potential research topics has been finalised, and more developments will follow soon.

Separately, the International Tax Committee submitted its representation to the Reserve Bank of India on draft FEM (Export and Import of Goods and Services) Regulations, 2024. The same can be accessed on the Society’s website.

I would like to take this moment to thank our members for their incredible participation in all the BCAS events during the busy September month, as well as for fully consuming the entire stock of BCAS Referencer publications. The dedication and effort from BCAS volunteers in planning, preparing and executing these initiatives are immense, and the enthusiastic response from our community motivates us to continue striving for excellence.

Greetings and best wishes for the upcoming festive seasons.

Thank you.

 

CA Anand Bathiya

President

Work–Life Balance & SA 600

There is a famous quote by Dolly Parton: “Never get so busy making a living that you forget to make a life.”

The age-old debate on work–life balance is back at the centre of discussion, with the deaths of a young chartered accountant and a banker on account of alleged work-related stress.

It is well known that work-related stress is at an all-time high in modern times across every segment of society in India, be it industry, profession, government departments, or even homemakers. One assessing officer confided years ago that after every assessment season, many officers develop a variety of diseases, such as hypertension, diabetes, etc., due to sheer work pressure.

Some professions or occupations are more exposed to pressures and stress, whereas at some places we find toxic work culture due to aggressive work atmosphere.

There are multiple factors leading to toxic or work-related stress. Unrealistic expectations and targets, tight deadlines, intense competition, peer pressure, etc., are some of the factors leading to stress. These factors are man-made and, therefore, can easily be controlled with proper planning and orientation.

Unfortunately, “work from home” has its own set of problems, such as extended working hours, depression, posture problems, loneliness, emotional imbalances and so on.

Whole Life Balance

The problem of balancing “work” and “life” aggravates as we consider them apart and separate from one another. Work is an integral part of our life and therefore, it is not a separate thing. To quote Sadhguru: “There is no such thing as work–life balance. It is all life. The balance has to be within you.”

Unfortunately, our education system teaches us how to make a living but not how to live a life. Systematic training / teaching is required on how to handle pressures and failures in life and live a balanced life.

People who have no work face different kinds of problems, stress and trauma. Work keeps our minds occupied and healthy. Therefore, work, per se, is not bad; it is how we do it that matters. If one has a congenial work atmosphere, with good camaraderie with colleagues, one does not feel the pressures of long hours of work. Here, we also carry the responsibility of making our workplaces healthy, productive and better without too much of pressure. India, being a developing country, needs to put in extra hours of work to catch up with the rest of the world. As Swami Vivekananda said, “There is no substitute for hard work.”

However, when we don’t like our work, situation, people or environment, we feel more stressed. More than physical exertion, mental stress kills a person. If we love our work, then we don’t get stressed even by working for long hours and work itself rejuvenates us. Many of us spend more of our awake time at the office than at our homes, and therefore, everything and anything that happens at the workplace does shape our lives or is part of our lives. We should, therefore, be more careful of how we spend time at our workplaces.

Having said that, we must remember that anything in excess is bad. Therefore, we need to achieve a life balance by a proper mix of official work and personal work.

Proposed revision of Standard of Auditing (SA) 600

Another talk of the profession is about the proposed revision of SA 600 by the National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA). The existing SA 600 on “Using the Work of Another Auditor” essentially deals with guidance on group audits. Its objective is to establish standards in situations where an auditor (referred to herein as the ‘principal auditor’), reporting on the financial information of an entity, uses the work of another auditor (referred to herein as the ‘component auditor’) with respect to the financial information of one or more components included in the financial statements of the entity. “Component” means a division, branch, subsidiary, joint venture, associated enterprise or other entity whose financial information is included in the financial information audited by the principal auditor.

Paragraph 24 of the SA 600 deals with “Division of Responsibility”, whereby it provides that “the principal auditor would not be responsible in respect of the work entrusted to the other auditors, except in circumstances which should have aroused his suspicion about the reliability of the work performed by the other auditors.”

Corresponding to SA 600, the International Standard on Auditing 600 (revised) (ISA 600) addresses issues related to group audits. ISA 600 states that “the group engagement partner remains ultimately responsible, and therefore accountable, for compliance with the requirements of this ISA”.

It may be noted that SA 600 was issued by the ICAI in 1995 and revised in September 2002. The revised version is stated to be generally consistent with the ISA 600 in all material respects but with a significant difference with respect to the degree of responsibility of the Principal Auditor vis-à-vis the Component Auditor. Thus, fundamentally, SA 600 provides for shared responsibility between a principal auditor and component auditors, whereas ISA 600 provides for singular responsibility of the principal auditor for the quality of audit, including the work of component auditors.

NFRA proposed the revision of SA 600 on the lines of ISA 600, primarily with respect to the degree of responsibility and has issued the draft of the proposed SA 600 (Revised) for public consultation and comments by 30th October, 2024. The revisions proposed are to be applied to audits of Public Interest Entities (PIEs)1 except Public Sector Enterprises, Public Sector Banks, Public Sector Insurance Entities and their respective branches.


1 Only those PIEs which fall under Rule 3 of NFRA Rules 2018

As per newspaper reports, the ICAI has raised concerns and requested to put the proposal on hold2. ICAI has a detailed procedure to set or revise any auditing standard, and therefore its opinion does matter. We hope that NFRA will address various concerns raised by the ICAI, and both will work in tandem to improve the quality of audit.


2 The Economic Times, dated 20th September, 2024

The consultation paper on the proposed SA 600 (Revised) by NFRA gives detailed reasoning of the necessity for change and explanations to some of the apprehensions pertaining to the concentration of audits, impact on small and medium accounting and auditing firms, etc. Readers are well advised to go through this paper and give their valuable suggestions to NFRA / ICAI on the proposed revision.

One thing is certain: auditing, per se, has become sophisticated and demanding, and the proposed change will cast a huge responsibility on the Principal Auditor, who needs to be well-equipped to handle such risks. Component auditors can also benefit by adopting best practices and by participating actively from the planning to closing of audits of the entire group.

A day is not far when the Principal Auditor and Component Auditors may require additional qualifications to do audits of large groups, as is prevalent in some countries. ICAI can play a pivotal role in training and upgrading the skills of its members who wish to do audits of large groups / conglomerates.

Well, to sum up on the work–life balance, we need to put more life in our work than work in our life. Take regular breaks and vacations, find out our de-stress buttons and press them often to relax and rejuvenate.

Let the upcoming Deepawali fill your life with brightness and joy.

Best Regards,

 

Dr CA Mayur Nayak

Editor

 

मौनं सर्वार्थसाधनम्

This saying is often used as a proverb. मौनं Mauna means silence, keeping mum. The shloka is from Panchatantra (4.46). The full text is as follows:

आत्मनोमुखदोषेणबध्यन्तेशुकसारिका:!

बकास्तत्र न बध्यन्तेमौनंसर्वार्थसाधनम्!!

Literal meaning

आत्मनोमुखदोषेण: Due to their own fault of ‘talking’

बध्यन्तेशुकसारिका: Parrots and mynas get trapped

बकास्तत्र न बध्यन्ते: Egrets do not get trapped (since they don’t talk like parrots)

मौनंसर्वार्थसाधनम्: By remaining silent, one can achieve everything.

There was a story in Panchatantra of a monkey who wanted to cross a river. One crocodile, using a sweet language, offered to carry him on its back. The monkey trusted the crocodile. Once they reached the middle of the river, the crocodile told the monkey that actually, it intended to eat him once they reach a particular spot. The monkey became frightened but cautious. In between, they passed by a small island where there were tall trees. As soon as they reached the island, the monkey jumped and rescued himself by climbing up a tall tree. The crocodile repented for having disclosed its plans to the monkey.

It is a common experience that people who are intelligent, wise and mature do not talk much. On the other hand, people who lack wisdom and maturity keep on talking incessantly. In that process, they are caught in their own words and people thrust on them many tasks which they are not able to perform. They get entangled and, in a way, trapped.

Actually, this line Maunam Sarvartha Saadhnamis used in another context as well. Those people who are either of scheming nature or shrewd do not talk about their true intentions and plans. It is not necessary that their intentions are bad. Sometimes, they maintain secrecy even with pious intentions and plans, e.g., a country may not talk about its military strength or certain secret research programmes. India carried out the nuclear explosion at Pokhran and did the surgical strike without talking about it.

Even in court proceedings, your trump cards are opened only at an appropriate stage and not in the beginning.

There are people around with negative attitude who may create obstacles in your plans. They will do something which may cause damage or harm to your tasks on hand.

Therefore, it is rightly said मौनं सर्वार्थसाधनम्!!

Society News

fiogf49gjkf0d

International Tax and Finance Conference, 2016 held on 13th August to 17th August 2016 in Sri Lanka

The International Tax and Finance (ITF) Conference, a
popular program of the Society, was organized by The International Taxation
Committee at Bentota & Colombo in Sri Lanka between 13th to 17thAugust,
2016. There were 143 registrations (including spouse and children), from all across
India, Sri Lanka and UAE. The active contribution from learned paper-writers,
speakers, group leaders has yet again proved ITF to be an excellent knowledge
sharing platform which aims for consistent progress of our fellow Chartered Accountants
and industry professionals. Paper writers and speakers played a pivotal role in
bringing out the emerging tax issues in light of the global developments.


L
to R – Mr. Ravi Karunanayake (Hon.Minister of Finance, Sri Lanka), CA
Deepak Shah, CA Chetan Shah (President), CA Gautam Nayak and CA Narayan
Pasari


CA Pinakin Desai(Speaker)

Despite
overnight travel, the delegates participated enthusiastically in the
group discussion on the inbound and outbound tax structuring on the
backdrop of the BEPS. On the 1st day, the interesting group discussion
followed by an outstanding presentation from CA Pinakin Desai. He forced
all to take a deep dive into the ocean of issues The case studies
highlighted the potential issues and implications under the domestic
laws if the recommendations of the OECD were implemented through
domestic legislations.


CA Vijay Dhingra(Speaker)

Day
two was an awakening to the thoughts of “succession planning” wherein
nuances in this untapped field were set forth by CA Vijay Dhingra. The
posers and case studies forced groups to revisit the basic provisions
relating to the determination of residential status of person(s)
resulting into succession related tax issues. The paper-writer
emphasised the importance of succession planning and related tax
consequences for large businesses given the environment where families
are going global and there exist multiple laws on inheritance in various
jurisdictions exist.


CA Padamji Khincha(Speaker)

Moving
on to the world of digitization and e-commerce, CA Padamji Khincha in a
very lucid manner explained equalisation levy in India. The highlights
on the issues covering applicability and non-applicability of the
equalisation levy in conjunction with tax treaties made it interesting. 
Further, an effective panel discussion on various practical issues
arising from effective exchange of information was an excellent show put
up by eminent and renowned speakers within our fraternity – CA T. P.
Ostwal, CA Padamji Khincha and CA Sushil Lakhani.


Mr. Shiluka Goonewardene(Speaker)

In the final session in Colombo, the conference was privileged to have Honourable Minister of Finance, Sri Lanka, Shri Ravi Karunanayake He explained the economy updates of Sri Lanka and was appreciative of India and its progress in a candid manner. The session was followed by presentation on taxation and investment presented by leading professionals from Srilanka Mr Shiluka Goonewardene, and Mr Suresh R. I. Perera. In the concluding session CA T.P. Ostwal   took the participants to the world of intangibles in line with the BEPS action plan. Through various case studies on the Transfer Pricing issues relating to the intangibles in the current time of digital economy, the presentation highlighted the need to unlearn and re-learn the transfer pricing concepts post BEPS.

Mr. Suresh R. I. Perera(Speaker)

CA T.P. Ostwal(Speaker)

The active involvement of the group leaders and the participants at the group discussion along with other proceedings at the Conference has elevated the standard of discussion year after year and this has made this conference popular. The residential nature of the Conference not only built camaraderie amongst fellow professionals but also got personal touch as many participants were accompanied by their spouses and children.
The overwhelming response of the participants, the quality of the discussions backed with eminent speakers and the seamless coordination of the entire event with the help of the coordinators has once again made ITF a grand success.

GST series lecture meetings held on 20th August, 10th September and 17th September, 2016

GST series lecture
meetings were held by Indirect Tax Committee jointly with the Indirect Tax Study
Circle on 20thAugust, 2016, 10th September, 2016 and 17th
September, 2016 at BCAS Conference Hall. A batch of 3 lecture series on GST
model law was organized to discuss the significant provisions of Model GST law
and related literature available in the public domain. Considering the nature
of subject on hand, the maximum enrolment per meeting was restricted to 60
members only.

Each session was led
by two Group Leaders and mentored by two Group Mentors having domain expertise
in various fields of present indirect tax laws like central excise, VAT and
service tax

The contribution by the group leaders especially
in terms of the presentations was highly appreciated. The sessions witnessed
excellent participation amongst members and interactive discussion on the
subject. At times members came forward to discuss the issues by way of dramatic
presentation to other members which made the discussions very interesting.

It was decided to hold one more lecture in the
series on 1st October, 2016 to discuss the provisions of Input Tax
Credit and hold further such sessions once the amended draft is placed in the
public domain.


FEMA
Study Circle Meeting on “Current, Capital Account Transactions and
Liberalized Remittance Scheme (LRS)”held on 26th August 2016

A
FEMA Study Circle Meeting was held on 26th August, 2016 at BCAS
Conference Hall where CA Sudha G. Bhushan led the discussion on the topic of
“Current, Capital Account Transactions and Liberalized Remittance Scheme
(LRS)”. Large number of members participated in this meeting. The Group Leader
deliberated upon factors determining the nature of a transactions as to capital
or current account transactions. Various concepts such as “Balance of Payment”,
“Characterization and Permissibility” of various transactions were discussed at
length. Issues such as:

Whether loan can be given to non-resident
third party under LRS?

Can
payment for ESOP be considered as current account transaction?  

Whether
remittance for minimum investment for obtaining a resident visa or green card
in USA is a permissible current account transaction?

Can
an Individual invest under LRS in a foreign company which is engaged in leasing
of properties?

Can a
grand-mother make remittance outside India for education of her grand-daughter?

Many
such questions were deliberated upon. In all the members got a complete
understanding as to how to determine a transaction under FEMA as a current
account or a capital account transaction and what is permissible under LRS. CA
Sudha G. Bhushan’s experience added value to the participants.

A total of 73 participants
attended the meeting.


Blood Donation Camp held on 27th August 2016

The
purpose of life is not to be happy – but to matter, to be productive, to be
useful, to have it make some difference that you have lived it all.  ~Leo
Rosten


Blood Donation camp at BCAS

The
blood donation drive was one full day event organised by the Membership &
Public Relations Committee of BCAS on Saturday, August 27, 2016 at BCAS
Conference Hall, in collaboration with the Tata Memorial Hospital (TMH), one of
the biggest and renowned hospital in Mumbai for having the sophisticated blood
bank facilities and laboratories. It was a great team effort of 20 to 25
volunteers which included 15 Members from Tata Memorial Hospital and others
from BCAS staff, who actively extended their support for the event and made it
a successful one.

The
drive was extremely well organised and smoothly managed by the volunteers. BCAS
had kept the atmosphere very soothing and lively with smooth instrumental
music.  There was a team of two doctors
and one supervisor from TMH specially to diagnose the donor’s eligibility to
donate blood. he TMH team ensured that each donor was assisted by one volunteer
and that the donor was completely fit and fine after donating blood. .

BCAS got an
overwhelming and encouraging response for this blood donation drive. Awareness
and messages were spread by the BCAS team for this Drive within their family
members and friends.  More than 56 donors
were eligible and could donate blood. The donors consisted more of young
members.  The, BCAS provided all the
donors with a Certificate for donation as a token of appreciation. The donors
will also be given a donor card from TMH, having a validity of two years. 

It was truly an
enriching and enlightening experience for all of us. The experience from this
drive, would always encourage and motivate to participate more in such events
which would be ultimately beneficial for the society at large.


Seminar on Tax Audit held on 27th August, 2016

A full day seminar on
Tax Audit was held by the Taxation Committee of the BCAS at the lndian
Merchants’ Chamber, Churchgate, Mumbai.

President CA. Chetan
Shah gave the opening remarks followed by introductory words from the Chairman
of the Taxation Committee, CA. Ameet Patel.

Various topics were
taken up at the Seminar by the following Speakers:

  • Overview of Tax Audit Provisions, including applicability in
    presumptive cases and calculations of limits, Reporting Requirements,
    Audit Quality and Documentation : CA
    Paresh Clerk
  • Reporting in Form 3CD – Clause by clause analysis by  CA
    Mehul C. Shah and CA. Sanjeev Lalan

·        
E-filing
of Tax Audit Report and other related forms : CA Avinash Rawani


CA Paresh Clerk (Speaker)

CA Paresh Clerk
explained the applicability of Tax Audit in case of business and profession and
provided detailed illustrations in order to explain the applicability of tax
audit in case of presumptive taxation. He provided suggestions with respect to
audit procedures and documentation to be maintained by the auditors. Also, he
highlighted issues which majority of the times go unnoticed by the auditors and
provided practical solutions for the same.


CA Mehul C. Shah (Speaker)

CA Mehul. C. Shah
explained the fundamentals of Tax Audit. He discussed with examples certain
clauses of the Form 3CD. Additionally, he provided a check list covering the
vital aspects of Tax Audit and the information which should be obtained from a
client. He resolved various queries of the participants.

CA Sanjeev Lalan (Speaker)

CA
Sanjeev Lalan discussed in detail the provisions of section 40(a) (ia)
of the Income-tax Act, 1961. He provided clause wise the issues which
should be considered by auditors during Tax Audit.  Suggestions on
various clauses in order to deal with the challenges faced by auditors
while carrying out the tax audit were provided by him.

CA. Avinash Rawani,(Speaker)

CA Avinash Rawani
made the participants aware about the nuances of e-filing of the Tax Audit and
other reports. He explained in detail the stepwise procedure to be followed for
e-filing of the reports. He pointed out several issues faced by auditors while
e-filing and provided tips which would simplify the process.

The content of the
sessions and the speakers’ practical suggestions in response to the numerous
queries raised helped the participants in easing the perplexities of Tax Audit.

The event was
attended by 153 participants.


Seminar on Model GST Law held on 3rd and 9th September, 2016

CA Mandar Telang (Speaker)

CA Sunil Gabhawala (Speaker)

CA Samir Kapadia (Speaker)

BCAS
held a Seminar on Model GST Law at the BCAS Conference Hall on 3rd September..
The speakers included CA. Mandar Telang, CA. Sunil Gabhawalla, CA. Samir
Kapadia, CA. Udayan Choksi, CA. Naresh Sheth, CA. Bharat Shemlani, CA. Janak Vaghani
and CA. Jayraj Sheth


Gita
for Professional in Hindi Publication Release- L to R: CA Govind
Goyal,CA Chetan Shah (President), CA Chetan Dalal (Author), CA Rashmin
Sanghvi,and CA Narayan Pasari

Another,
similar session called GST Seminar Part II having the same topics was
held on 9th September, at Navinbhai Thakkar Hall, Vile Parle, Mumbai. On
this occasion, 1st edition of our publication gita for professionals in
Hindi titled “Gita Vyavsaiyon Ke Liye” was released by the hands of CA
Rashmin Sanghvi. The speakers on this day were CA. Mandar Telang, CA.
Sunil Gabhawalla, CA. Samir Kapadia, CA. Udayan Choksi, CA. Naresh
Sheth, CA. Bharat Shemlani, CA. Janak Vaghani, CA. S .S. Gupta.

CA Udayan Choksi (Speaker)

CA Naresh Sheth (Speaker)

CA Bharat Shemlani (Speaker)

Goods and Service Tax has already received the
President’s assent in September 2016. It will form a major part of our lives
and there is a heated discussion going on around the country and especially
amongst the professionals, who will face a major hurdle in their routine
practice. They would be required to advise clients on the various aspects of
this new law. The topics ranged from concept of new law, Supply and Nature of
Supply, Inter State, Intra State, Payment of Tax, Valuation & Rates of tax,
Input Tax Credit to Compliances like Registrations, Returns & Assessments.
The forecast of the GST Model Law and its after effects were also presented by
Shri Jayraj Sheth and Shri S. S. Gupta at the respective seminars namely 3rd
and 9th September, 2016.

CA Janak Vaghani (Speaker)

CA Jayraj Sheth (Speaker)

CA S. S. Gupta (Speaker)

The
presentations made by the speakers were structured in such a way that that the participants
understood the impact of GST. .

Both
the halls were full of enthusiastic participants who  were quiet satisfied with all the
presentations.

A
total of 105 and 475 participants attended the seminars at BCAS and Vile Parle respectively.


FEMA Study Circle Meeting on “FEMA from Auditor’s Perspective” held on 7th September, 2016

A
FEMA Study Circle Meeting was held on 7th September, 2016 at BCAS
Conference Hall where CA Hardik Mehta led the discussion on the topic of “FEMA
from Auditor’s Perspective” and CA Mayur Nayak chaired the said meeting. The
Group Leader shared from his personal experience what aspects are to be
verified when one audits transactions 
such as investment in equity received under Foreign Direct Investment,
loan borrowed under External Commercial Borrowing regulations, Import / export
of goods and services etc. Issues taken up for discussion amongst others were:

Whether
loans from NRIs are permitted?

Whether
Data Management Company is eligible borrower for ECB under Miscellaneous
sectors where ECB is permitted under automatic route?

Whether
ECB can be utilised to acquire another Indian company?

He
also pointed out what documents one needs to see for these transactions. In all,
the members got an overview of various capital account transactions and
specific audit documentation.  The Group
leader also shared a check-list for verifying various documents related to
these specific transactions which is a handy tool for the auditor.

A
total of 56 participants attended the Study Circle
.


Study
Circle Meeting on “Important practical aspects of Reporting on Internal
Controls on Financial Reporting (ICFR), CARO and Audit Report – For
SME’s ” held on 17th September 2016

The Suburban Study Circle jointly
with
Accounting
and Auditing Study Circle
had organized the study circle meeting on 17th
September, 2016 at Direct-i-plex, Andheri East, Mumbai.

The group leader CA Payal
Punatar ex
plained
the applicability of ICFR reporting as per the requirement of Companies Act,
2013. Group was briefed about the meaning of Process, Risk and need of various
types of controls. She further explained the issues in Implementation of ICFR
framework for Private/ Small/ less complex companies.

The group discussed the various
components of framework such as Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control
activities, Information and communication and monitoring for SME sector.
Further she explained the common constraints faced in implementation / review
of testing and how to meet the compliance requirement. Finally Group discussed
the illustrative Risk Control Matrix (RCM) for Fixed Assets and accounts
payable process.   

The participants were benefited from
the timely guidance for the presentation and experiences shared by the group
leader.

A total of 20 participants attended the meeting.

Society News

fiogf49gjkf0d
Lecture Meeting on Corporate Governance – recent
updates including amendments to Clause 49 of Listing Agreement on 27th
August 2014


L to R : Mr. Somasekhar Sundaresan (Speaker), Mr. Raman Jokhakar, Mr. Nitin Shingala (President), Mr. Jayant Thakur

The
lecture meeting was held at the Walchand Hirachand Hall, IMC. Mr.
Somasekhar Sundaresan, Advocate, addressed the audience on the recent
updates including amendments to Clause 49 of Listing Agreement on
Corporate Governance. More than 250 members benefited from the expert
analysis and knowledge shared by the speaker.

Advanced FEMA Conference on 6th September 2014


L
to R : Mr. Nitin Shingala (President), Mr. Gaurang Gandhi, Mr. Naresh
Ajwani, Mr. Dilip Thakkar, Mr. G. Padmanabhan (Speaker), Mr. Paras
Savla, Mr. C.D Srinivasan (Speaker), Mr. Gautam Nayak, and Mr. Hinesh
Doshi.

The International Taxation Committee of the Society
organised this Conference jointly with The Chamber of Tax Consultants.
The Conference was held at Rangaswar Hall, Y B Chavan Pratisthan. The
objective of the Conference was to offer insight into advanced level
issues on cross border transactions & intricacies involved and to
understand the RBI’s perspective on these developments.

Officials
from RBI, including Mr. G. Padmanabhan, Executive Director and Mr. C.D.
Srinivasan, Chief General Manager along with General Managers, Mr. A.
O. Basheer, Mr. Ajay Vij, Ms. Jayasree Gopalan, Ms. Tuli Roy and Ms.
Rajani Prasad responded to the questions raised by the participants at
the Conference.

The following topics were discussed at the conference:

BCAS
and CTC raised a number of concerns which are causing difficulties
under FEMA. The officials appreciated these concerns and gave an
assurance that they would be addressed. They also expressed their
concerns to the delegates. They advised the participants to look at the
spirit of the law and not just the letter of the law, to avoid lapses
under FEMA.

143 participants attended and benefited from the Conference.

Lecture
Meeting on Auditors Dilemma – Reporting requirements on Internal
Financial Controls as required under the Companies Act, 2013 and Clause
49 of the Listing Agreement on 10th September 2014


Mr. Vishwanath Venkatraman (Speaker)

The
lecture meeting was held at Walchand Hirachand Hall, IMC. Mr.
Vishwanath Venkatramanan, Chartered Accountant addressed the audience on
various aspects of Reporting requirements on Internal Financial
Controls as required under the Companies Act, 2013 and Clause 49 of
Listing agreement and section 134 of the Companies Act 2013. He also
shared his vast experience and perspective on the same. More than 150
members benefited from the expert analysis and knowledge shared by the
speaker.

Monsoon Trek on 13th September 2014


Participants of Monsoon Trek

The
BCAS Youth Group, under the aegis of the Membership and Public
Relations and Human Resources Committee of the Society organised a
Monsoon Trek for Chartered Accountants and their families along the
Jummapatti-Bekere trail near Bhivpuri, Karjat. Attended by 44
participants, the trek saw equal representation from industry and
practice, from the seniors and the youth and from men and women.
Participants enjoyed the easy walk through the lush greenery. They also
got the opportunity to network with different segments of the
profession.

18th International Tax & Finance Conference, 2014


L
to R : Mr. T. N. Manoharan(Speaker), Mr. Deepak Kanabar, Mr. Deepak
Shah, Mr. Nitin Shingala (President), Mr. Gautam Nayak, Mr. Raman
Jokhakar, Mr. Rajesh Shah

The 18th Residential International Tax
& Finance Conference which was organised by the International
Taxation Committee from 14th August 2014 to 17th August 2014 at ITC
Grand Chola, Chennai, received an enthusiastic response from over 190
participants from over 20 cities of India including Hyderabad,
Bangalore, Chennai,

Coimbatore, Delhi, Ahmedabad, Pune, Goa, Secunderabad, Jamnagar, Kolkatta, Mumbai and even Dubai.

The
Conference was inaugurated by Padamshree T. N. Manoharan, Past
President of ICAI who addressed the participants on the Role,
Opportunities and Challenges for the Chartered Accountants. His address
included inspiring anecdotes, analytical insights and subtle humor.


Mr. Pinakin Desai

Papers for Group Discussion:

•
Case studies on International Taxation (including royalty and Capital
Gains) by Shri P. D. Desai who dealt with issues relating to capital
gains on indirect transfers, treaty residence, GAAR, etc.. He also
presented case studies on Liquidation, Distributions and subsequent
disposals, Royalty Taxation, Source Rule, MFN impact, beneficial
ownership and Tax implications of Participation Arrangements.


Mr. T.P. Ostwal (Speaker)

•
Tax Challenges in Digital Economy- OECD Draft (BEPS Action 1) by Shri
T.P. Ostwal, who analysed the emerging developments in information
technology and international taxation regime. He presented business
models in digital economy and discussed opportunity in and tackling of
BEPS in digital technology. Further, he identified the tax challenges
raised by digital economy and the methods dealing with them.

•
Case Studies on structuring Outbound (Investment – Tax & Regulatory
Aspects) by Shri Pranav N. Sayta, who presented intricate case studies
involving issues such as acquisition of overseas entity, tax efficient
structures for such acquisition, Indian Exchange Control Regulations,
Tax Credits, Demergers, etc.


Mr. Yogesh Thar (Speaker)

•
Current Issues in Transfer Pricing (including Domestic Transfer
Pricing) by Shri Yogesh A. Thar, who covered issues relating to
international and domestic transfer pricing in great detail along with
practical examples and solutions covering issues relating to Equity
Infusions Transactions, Business Transfers, Common Cost Allocations,
Real Estate Transactions, Director’s Remuneration, Partner’s
Remuneration, etc.

Papers For Presentation:


Mr. Dilip Sheth (Speaker)

•
Prevention of Money Laundering Act – overview and impact by Shri Dilip
Sheth, who covered issues relating to property, scheduled offences,
transfer, procedural provisions and rules along with important issues
decided by the courts.


Mr. Gautam Doshi (Speaker)

•
Exchange Risk Management (Commercial, Regulatory and Tax aspects) by
Shri Gautam Doshi, who dealt with various types of Forex transactions,
Call and Put options, swaps, hedge, with practical examples.

The
participants gained handsomely from the knowledge and experience shared
by eminent faculties, group discussions and informal interactions. The
audience also appreciated the overall ambience and comfort at the venue.

Society News

fiogf49gjkf0d
Study Circle Meeting on “Benchmarking of Intra Group Services” in transfer pricing on 1st August, 2015 at Direct-I-Plex, Andheri (E)

The Direct Tax Laws Study circle jointly with the Suburban Study Circle had organised a study circle meeting on the Benchmarking of Intra Group Services (including Recent Jurisprudence). The group leader Ms. Riddhi Shah explained in detail, the concerns and issues in respect of the benchmarking of Intra Group services. The group leader also discussed the recent important judgments and issues therein. She covered the following topics while leading the group:

  • Concept
  • Illustrative list of Intra-Group services
  • OECD Guidelines
  • Cost Allocation
  • Other considerations
  • Documentation requirements
  • Audit experience in India

The Chairman, Shri Natwar Thakrar provided his valuable insights on various unresolved issues, controversies and various important notifications/circulars of the Income Tax department. The Chairman elaborated on the concept of shareholder’s activities and duplicative services.

The participants benefited immensely from the interaction and experiences shared by the speaker and the chairman.

Klaus Vogel Study Circle held on 5th August 2015

A meeting of the Group was held on August 5, 2015 to discuss the newly released FAQ on Liberalized Remittance Scheme by RBI. The two Group Leaders were: – CA. Dhishat B. Mehta & CA. Gaurang V. Gandhi. There was interaction amongst the group with regard to most of the FAQs.

Students Study Circle on “Overview of Goods & Services Tax” held on 7th August 2015

The Students Forum of the Society organised a study circle on the topic “Overview of Goods & Service Tax” at the Society’s Office.

The study circle was led by student speaker Shri Sagar Desai under the guidance of the Jt. Secretary of the society and renowned speaker on Indirect Taxation matters, Shri Sunil Gabhawalla.

The motive of organising this study circle was to make the future chartered accountants proactive and aware of the biggest tax reform in the history of Independent India – Goods & Service Tax. The study circle was well attended by 35 students. It was a great learning experience for the student members.

The chairman of the session Shri Sunil Gabhawalla made the session interesting, with his deep knowledge on the subject. The speaker Shri Sagar Desai covered the topic and gave an insight into the proposed tax structure and its benefits to the economy. The roadblocks towards the implementation of Goods & Services Tax were also discussed.

The convenor of the Students Study Circle Shri Viren Doshi encouraged students to participate actively in the activities of the Students Forum and come forward to lead study circles.

Intensive Workshop on “Internal Financial Control” held on 7th and 8th August 2015

In keeping with its title, this was an intensive workshop, covering various components of an Internal Financial Control like Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control Activities, Information and Communications and Monitoring. A workshop well designed keeping in mind the requirements of the Companies Act, 2013 from the perspective of management compliance and Auditors’ certifications
requirements. The Speaker Ms.Preeti Dani shared her knowledge and
experience over a period of 2 full days, in a most lucid manner. Every
topic was well covered and explained to the participants by way of case
studies and examples well designed to understand the complexities of the
subject.

The workshop held at the Palladium Hotel, Mumbai on August 7th and 8th,
2015, was attended by more than 60 participants from various Industries
and Practice arena and from various locations spread across India. The
speaker covered topics like General Computer controls, Entity level
controls, walkthroughs and testing methodology, sampling, Materiality,
Financial Statement Assertions reporting on internal controls, etc. in
detail. The interactions between the participant and speaker were
commendable and considering the positive feedback received, the Society
has organised a similar workshop in Chennai.

19th International Tax & Finance Conference, 2015 held on 14th to 17th August 2015
The
19th Residential International Tax & Finance Conference organised
by the International Taxation Committee from 14th August, 2015 to 17th
August, 2015 at Aamby Valley, received an overwhelming response from
members, with a record enrolment of 262 participants. The delegates were
from over 20 Indian cities as well as from out of India.

The Keynote Address at the Conference was given by Shri Sunandan
Chaudhari, Senior Economist with ICICI Bank, who addressed the
participants on the recent global events (including the Greek crisis and
Chinese slowdown and devaluation) and their impact on the Indian
economy. His address was laced with informative data charts, analytical
insights and insights about future movement of currency. He held the
participants spellbound for more than an hour.

The papers for group discussion were as under:

1. OVERSEAS FUNDS – TA X AND REGULATORY ASPECTS by Shri Bhavin Shah. He dealt with issues relating to taxation of overseas funds and structures for inbound investment by such funds. He also highlighted issues in respect of capital gains on indirect transfers, treaty residence, GAAR, etc. He also provided insights into normal structures of overseas funds.

2. STRUCTURING OF EPC CONTRACTS – TA X & OTHER ISSUES by Shri H. Padamchand Khincha. He highlighted and exhaustively analysed the controversies and issues relating to taxation of various types of EPC contracts, including splitting up of such contracts, treatment of joint ventures, accrual and classification of income from such contracts.

3. EXPATRIATE S – TAX AND REGULATORY ASPECTS by Shri Nikhil Bhatia. He analysed the various issues relating to taxation of expatriates, including determination of residential status, deductibility of social security contributions, and treatment of tax equalisation, and also discussed other provisions affecting expatriates, such as provident fund contribution, etc. This was supplemented by various Case Studies involving issues such as transfers, tax efficient method for such transfers, Indian Exchange Control Regulations, Tax Credits, etc.

4. PLACE OF EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT (POEM) by Shri Pinakin Desai, who analysed the meaning of the newly introduced term in the Indian context. He discussed the international perspective and earlier case laws on control and management, and the various factual aspects which would assist in determination of the POEM.

The group discussions were lively, with active participation of the group members.

The Papers for Presentation were:

BASE EROSION AND PROFIT SHIFTING (BEPS) – RECENT DEVELOPMENTS by Shri T. P. Ostwal, who covered issues relating to recent developments internationally, and at the OECD. He explained the progress on each of the 15 action points under the BEPS initiative, and the expected timelines within which further actions were to be taken.

ISSUES UNDER THE BLACK MONEY (UNDISCLOSED FOREIGN INCOME AND ASSETS) AND IMPOSITION OF TAX ACT, 2015 by Shri Gautam Doshi, who dealt with various issues under this new Act, including issues relating to disclosures under the 3 month window, as well as in respect of valuation under the rules and the FAQs.

The participants benefited immensely from the knowledge and experience shared by the eminent faculty, from the group discussions and from informal interactions. The overall ambience and comfortable stay at the venue was also appreciated by all the participants.

Company Law, Accounting and Auditing Study Circle series on Indian Accounting Standard (IND-AS)

The Company Law, Accounting and Auditing Study Circle announced a series of Study Circle meetings on IND-AS to be held on 20th August, 2015, 7th October, 2015, 15th October, 2015 and 19th October, 2015. After notification of Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules, 2015 comprising of IFRS converged IND-ASs by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, there is a certainty on implementation of IND-AS. The objective of the series is to understand, discuss and deliberate each IND-AS in detail and understand the process of implementation of IND-AS. The series is organised in such a manner that each IND-AS will be dealt with separately.

The first meeting of this series was held on 20th August, 2015 and the discussion was led by CA. Anand Banka. The following topics were covered in this meeting:

(I)    Overview of IND-AS and roadmap to conversion; and

(II)    Presentation of Financial Statements

CA. Anand Banka briefed the members about the background of IND-AS and took the members through the process of formulation of IFRS and IND-AS. He also discussed about the applicability of IND-AS to various companies. In the second part of the session, he explained IND-AS 1 on “Presentation of Financial Statements” in detail. He discussed various issues including initial implementation and conversion of financial statement and preparation of opening Balance Sheet. The members discussed and deliberated on various issues in a lively interactive session. The members appreciated the initiatives taken by BCAS for organising series on IND-AS.

Interactive Presentation for CA Students: “Success in CA Exams” held on 21st August 2015

Human Development and Technology Initiative Committee of our Society jointly with WICASA of The Institute of Chartered Accountants’ of India had organised the second interactive presentation for the benefit of CA students covering the subject: Success in CA exams.

In the welcome address, the President complimented the students sharing many anecdotes of converting challenges into success. The most remarkable and memorable moment of the programme was when young Mahesh Londhe who recently passed his CA Final exam in his first attempt, braving the most challenging economic and social background was felicitated by Shri Narayan Varma and the President of the Society. All those present in the audience including the students and Mahesh’s parents and relatives were deeply moved by his acceptance speech. His message was loud and clear: Dream big, do not allow your dream to die down by challenges in life. Be grateful to all who contribute to achieve our dream and make us worthy human beings.

In the presentation, both the speakers, Shri Atul Bheda and Shri Mayur Nayak discussed at length, important points and issues which would help students while preparing and appearing for the CA Exams.

In the 1st Session, Shri Atul Bheda advised students to study regularly, with confidence, positivity, discipline and consistency. He emphasised on Focusing, the conceptual clarity in each subject, and judicious use of time . His success mantra was “Study the subjects thoroughly and avoid selective way of study”. He advised to refer to the study material, revision test papers, practical manuals published by the ICAI and regular visit of the website: http://www.icai.org to download reference material freely available on it compiled by the Board of Studies of the ICAI. He further said that students must appreciate that the dates of exams are fixed and are well known from the beginning. These exams are conducted with the highest standard of controls, confidentiality and quality in checking of papers. All precautions are taken to avoid any unforeseen situations.

In the second session, Shri Mayur Nayak shared his experiences. He touched upon all important topic of self-improvement. He explained that for success three important elements are Knowledge, Skill and Attitude. i.e. knowledge of the subject. Improving writing and memorising skill. Developing the analytical mind, and keeping

positive attitude even in the most challenging undesirable situation. He presented many motivating stories of illustrious personalities. He emphasised that the key to success is maintaining physical, mental, emotional fitness in all situation. In the end, he conducted a guided meditation.

The Study Circle Meeting on “Service Tax Investigation and Audit” on 22nd August, 2015 at Direct-I-Plex, Andheri (E)

The Indirect Tax Laws Study circle jointly with the Suburban Study Circle had organised a study circle meeting on the Service Tax Investigations and Audit (with special reference to a recent CBEC circular 185/4/2015 ST Dt. 30/06/2015).

The speaker, Shri Gaurav Sarda explained the provisions of the preliminary scrutiny and the detailed manual scrutiny of the Service Tax Returns Form ST-3. He mentioned that the detailed scrutiny will cover the taxability, valuation, reconciliation, classification, Cenvat credit and other similar aspects of the returns.

He also elaborated on the issues to be considered while providing information on the said areas. The criteria for selection, procedure for scrutiny and formats in which the data is to be prepared for submission was also discussed. The speaker also shared his experience of working as a part of the tax department’s audit team.

The Chairman Shri Sunil Gabhawalla provided his valuable insights on the limited scope of the new provisions of manual scrutiny especially in the light of other existing audit and investigation procedures. He advised members to be careful while replying to the notices and avoid going into details which the department can otherwise derive out of its own databases.

47 participants attended the study circle meeting and gained immensely from the details and experiences shared by the speaker and the chairman.

Lecture Meeting on “Food Smart Cities, Leading a Transition to Health, Sustainability and Fairness” held on 28th Aug 2015 at IMC by Speaker Dr. Vandana Shiva.

President Raman Jokhakar welcomed the speaker, Dr. Vandana Shiva who has dedicated over 30 years in protecting the Indian biodiversity from Corporate Biopiracy including the fight to revoke international patents on our Neem, Basmati and Wheat. Dr Shiva is world renowned for her work in dealing with mindless corporate led globalisation that is causing irreversible social, ecological and economic damage. This lecture meeting was under the auspices of Dilip Dalal Oration Fund.

Dr. Shiva commenced her speech with a brief background about how and why around more than 3 lakh farmers committed suicide since 1995. She went ahead to explain that a farmer actually earns only 1/10th of the Minimum Legal Wage in India compared to other vocations. The plight of our Annadattas today as articulated by her was alarming.

This she mentioned was just the beginning of the entire process. We are what we eat and it is this food that is so contaminated with pesticide that it has led to so many diseases. There is an epidemic of diseases related to our lifestyle and food such as diabetes, cancer, hypertension, infertility and heart attacks. India, she added, has emerged as the epicentre of Diabetes. Cancer has seen a 30% increase in the last 5 years with 180 million people affected in India alone.

To eliminate these problems, she took the audience to a solution within our own reach. The feasible way around getting and leading an organic life away from pesticides, benefitting both the annadattas and the consumers of food supplies.

Dr Shiva suggested the concept of ‘eat fresh, eat local’. She mentioned that eating local food and creating a sustainable and healthy FOODSHED for our city meant reducing food miles and toxics in the food chain. Eating local means relating directly to our farmers and helping them shift to an agriculture that allows them to grow biodiverse, safe, healthy food that we all can have access to.

The lecture concluded with the Smart Cities concept which talked about eat fair and eat healthy. This, Dr. Shiva mentions, can be done by eating local food grown in your own garden. This can be started by concepts of smart cities, she mentioned. This can be done by forming a group of citizens and placing bulk orders from organic farms at Navdanya and starting Anna Swaraj Circles. This could lead to profits passing to the one who grows and not to the reseller which is resulting in deaths and deprivation of Indian Farmers.

Towards the end of the session, the enthralled audience raised several questions, asking for practical tips. The talk concluded with a vote of thanks and a round of applause. This talk is available on You Tube channel of the BCAS which can be viewed freely – https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=8UCeGV-19MU

Half-Day Seminar on “Foreign Contribution Regulation Act, 2010” on Friday, 4th September 2015

The FCRA 2010 has done away with the Concept of ‘permanent’ registration, restricting the validity of registration to five years. The validity of registration of NPOs under the previous FCRA is valid upto 30th April 2016, subject to renewal. Such application for renewal is required to be submitted at least six months prior to the date of expiry of the validity period, i.e. before 31st October, 2015.

To understand the nitty-gritty of the FCRA and recent developments, the Corporate & Allied Laws Committee of the Society organised this half – day seminar at the office of BCAS.

Shri Chetan Shah, Vice-President of the Society welcomed the audience. Mr. Kanu S. Chokshi, Chairman of the Corporate & Allied Laws Committee of the Society briefly introduced the subject matter and the Speaker of the Seminar.

The Speaker, Mr. Noshir Dadrawala explained the procedure for registration/ renewal of registration and other compliances under FCRA 2010. He also enlightened the participants about the proposed amendments to the FCRA rules whereby the entire process of registration, renewal, applications, filings etc. is proposed to be online, with no

requirement to send the hard copies of the documents to the Ministry of Home Affairs, Delhi. The Seminar was ended with a question & answer session where the learned and experienced speaker satisfactorily addressed the queries of the participants.

The Seminar received overwhelming response. Out of the 104 participants,69 participants were non-members; and 13 were outstation participants. Presentation of the speaker on the subject was provided to the participants.

The Seminar was coordinated by Ms. Preeti Oza and Shri Manish Sampat.

Intensive Workshop on “Internal Financial Control”– Chennai held on 4th and 5th September 2015

A workshop, as it mentions, was an intensive workshop, covering various components of an Internal Financial Control like Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control Activities, Information and Communications and Monitoring. A workshop well designed keeping in mind the requirements of the New Companies Act, 2013 from the perspective of management compliance and Auditors’ certifications requirements. The program was inaugurated by Padmashri T. N. Manoharan and then Speaker Ms. Preeti Dani shared her knowledge and experience over a period of 2 full days, in the most practical manner. Every topic was well covered and explained to the participants by way of practical case studies and examples well designed to understand the complexities of the Internal Financial control in a simplest way.

The workshop held at the Le Meridian Hotel, Chennai on September 4th and 5th, 2015, was attended by 63 participants from various Industries and Practice arena and from various locations spread across South India. Speaker Ms. Preeti Dani, covered topics like General Computer controls, Entity level controls, walkthroughs and testing methodology, sampling, Materiality, Financial Statement Assertions reporting on internal controls, etc in detail. The interactions between the participant and speaker were commendable and considering the positive feedback received, the future plans for similar workshops in various other cities have already been kicked off.

Lecture Meeting on “Tax & Structuring- The Big Picture” held on 16th September 2015 at IMC by Speaker CA. Ketan Dalal

President Raman Jokhakar introduced Shri Ketan Dalal the speaker for the evening as one having immense knowledge on tax and tax planning aspects. He further added that the discussion will evolve around the speaker’s experiences and thoughts that would stand as a guide for all while advising our clients.

Shri Ketan Dalal started his presentation with his thoughts on addressing the bigger picture which our clients want to see in today’s complex business scenario and increasingly complex tax regulatory scenario. While as tax and legal professionals we all get more and more specialised in our field of expertise and as a fall out, we fail to see the fact that clients are expecting us to understand the business dynamics and expect us to give a holistic advice covering various aspects and not only restrict to tax so that the client can take an informed decision.

It is imperative    for us    professionals to know the regulator’s point of view. Otherwise, there are risks and reputational issues involved. He demonstrated his view with examples of Hero Honda and Maruti’s case. Shri Ketan Dalal mentioned that the client looks at us as a business advisor and not only as a tax advisor. The role of advisors need to undergo a change beyond the technical advice on any issue.

Shri Ketan Dalal concluded his presentation by throwing light on aspects of Transfer Pricing and the complexities involved in Put and Call Options. What the client wants and what the regulators expect from us, both are to be kept in mind while providing the complete picture to the client. Treacherous landscape needs to be recognised while advising on transactions and it’s often better to flag issues at least, even if not within scope. The speaker finally completed his session with an interactive discussion with the audience. The audience asked very practical questions and the speaker very well addressed them.

Finally, Shri Ketan Dalal concluded his session by stating that a holistic view is required in an increasingly specialised world.The session ended with a formal vote of thanks.

Society News

Human Development Study
Circle Meeting on “Interview Demo Pack“ held on 16th August, 2017 at
BCAS.

The meeting organised by
HDTI Committee at BCAS Conference Hall was addressed by Mr. Rahul Majumdar, an
IIT Bombay – IIM Lucknow alumnus and one of the co-founders of “Know Lens”.

He discussed the importance
and relevance of soft skills in the Chartered Accountancy profession and
informed that recent research indicated that 65% of the people are visual
learners. Therefore, today’s learning is more effective by way of visual
knowledge sharing through videos. While there is a lot more rigour in the
management of knowledge, it lacks sufficient focus on skills. To enhance skill
sets, video based learning is more useful, practical and quick to grasp.
Aspiring CAs or article clerks can build their key soft skills to develop their
careers more effectively through video based learning.

The Speaker was of the
opinion that today CAs broadly have their own practices or work in larger
organisations. They have a range of practices including taxation, audit and
even strategic advisory services for some aspects of business. Also,
professionals are exposed to a rapidly changing regulatory framework along with
a fluid client landscape and work culture.

Mr. Rahul also deliberated
upon the case studies on sales interaction and job interviews to make the
participants understand the need to develop soft skills. The meeting was very
interactive and participants benefitted a lot.    

 

“2nd Narayan
Varma Memorial Lecture” held on 18th August, 2017

The
Greatness of one’s life depends not on the number of years lived but rather on
the effect one leaves on the minds of one’s generation.

The 2nd Narayan
Varma Memorial Lecture & Narayan Varma Memorial Awards was organised
jointly by Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, Public Concern for Governance
Trust (PCGT) and Dharma Bharathi Mission(DBM)

The Programme was organised
in the memory of Late Narayan Varma who was closely associated with these
organisations and mentored & nurtured many members of these organisations
with his values, ideology & hard work. It was an occasion to salute and
remember him & also pay tribute to his spirit of giving, professionalism,
commitment towards service to humanity, relentless quest for truth &
justice, wit & wisdom, vision & planning and determination to make a
difference to Society. He always inspired many with his simplicity and humility
by setting an example.


Dr. Shashikala Gurpur

The Memorial Lecture was delivered
by Dr. Shashikala Gurpur, who is a distinguished academician and orator having
presented more than 200 lectures, workshops and seminars across India and
abroad. She has an outstanding career with a wide range of experience in
teaching, research and industry. In her address, she described Late Narayan
Varma’s life and his message to humanity. Dr. Gurpur also mentioned about the
role of giving by a responsible person in the society i.e. to connect with the
people, plunge into the movement for people and utilise resources for the good
of everybody. She described that human life is a gift of goodness without any
expectation and is a spontaneous but satisfying experience in the wonderful
journey of life. She explained that both passion and compassion make a person
innovative to do something new in life. Dr. Gurpur also referred to
intellectual and participative skills and managing conflict to achieve one’s
goal and mission in life. She further emphasised on the responsible citizenship
and patriotic belongingness to India.

In the meeting, three
distinguished persons were awarded for their humanitarian services namely Shri
Pankaj Udhas by DBM, Shri Pradeep Shah by BCAS and Shri Anand Bhandare by PCGT.

The meeting ended with
heart-warming memories and inspiration to work for the Society at large as a
real tribute to Shri Narayan Varma.

FEMA Study Circle Meeting
held on 21st August, 2017 at BCAS Hall

FEMA Study Circle Meeting
was held on the topic of “Analysis of select Compounding Orders passed by RBI”
at BCAS Conference Hall where CA. Harshal Bhuta & CA. Tanvi Vora led the
discussion. The session was chaired by CA. Rajesh P. Shah.

The Group leaders discussed
various Compounding Orders passed by RBI touching upon contraventions relating
to “Restrictions on dealing in Foreign exchange”, “Current Account
Transactions”, “ECB”, “Outbound Investment by Individuals”, “Outbound
Investment by LLP”, “Method of funding overseas direct investment”, etc. The
systematic analysis of these orders helped the participants to understand the
law and gain insights on ‘how to not contravene the same’.

CA. Rajesh P. Shah shared
his experience on various issues and that was a valuable takeaway for the
participants.

The participants gained a
lot and appreciated the views put in by the group leaders and the chairman.

Experts Chat on
Concept & Issues in “Place of Effective Management (POEM)” held on 1st
September 2017 at BCAS    

One thing certain about
life is its manifold uncertainties and the same can be aptly equated with the
newly introduced nascent concept of POEM- ‘Place of Effective Management.’ In
pursuance of the knowledge sharing on this subject, BCAS arranged an expert’s
chat where Mr. Kamlesh Varshney, CIT (International Taxation 2), New Delhi was
hosted by CA. Dinesh Kanabar on 1st September 2017 at BCAS
Conference Hall.  

The session encompassed
multiple aspects ranging from elementary concepts akin to primary intent,
genesis and comparative global practices, to complex conundrums pertaining to
e-presence in board meetings, threshold turnover calculation mechanism, DTAA
& Transfer Pricing implications, GAAR & MAT applicability.

L to R – Mr. Kamlesh Varshney and CA. Dinesh Kanabar

CA. Dinesh Kanabar proposed
poignant posers on wide-ranging matters such as (i) pre-POEM revenue leakage,
(ii) cost-benefit analysis of POEM implementation, (iii) effect on Indian
inbound-outbound investment ratio, (iv) CFC vis-a-vis POEM, (v)
practical existence of overseas business structures for non-tax objectives,
(vi) subjectivity in proceedings and confidentiality concerns in the Income Tax
department, (vii) availability of foreign tax credit, (viii) requirement of
clear-cut guidelines, (ix) FAQs, (x) circulars from Government, etc. Further,
practical impediments, excessive compliances resulting in genuine industry
grievances and necessity to safeguard bonafide entities were duly emphasised.

Several noteworthy points
highlighted in the Chat included – intent of POEM to curb Intentional Tax
Avoidance because profit shifting in tax havens by artificial restructuring,
emphasis on substance over legal form, minimal deep dive on satisfaction of
active business test and supporting documentation required for entities mainly
earning passive income. P/E peculiar issues, adequate documentation for Board
meetings and establishing controlling personnel were also explained.
Thereafter, Mr. Varshney remarked on assurance of confidentiality of disclosed
information pursuant to section 138 of IT Act and endeavour of overall
improvement & reduced litigation in Income Tax Department. He also touched
upon liberalisation and transitional issues.

The  pertinent point pertaining to unaltered
applicability of IT Act provisions specifically applicable to foreign companies
and a foreign company reclassified as resident by POEM drew a fine distinction
between residential status of a company and type of company. Discussions were
also carried out on provisions of draft notification u/s. 115JH of the IT Act
covering eligibility of resident entitled to specific benefits, tax rates for
reclassified foreign companies and implications on other person transacting
with reclassified foreign companies.

The above insightful and
thought-provoking deliberations were followed by Q&A session where queries
were meticulously answered by Mr. Varshney. The participants got highly enthralled
and enriched by the session.

Direct Tax Laws Study
Circle Meeting on “Implications of Ind-AS on MAT” held on 6th
September 2017 at BCAS Hall

The Chairman of the
session, CA. Sanjeev Lalan gave the opening remarks and pointed out some issues
relating to Ind-AS which could face litigation in the long run. The Group
leader, CA. Darshak Shah gave an overview on Ind-AS and its applicability to
companies, NBFCs and Insurance companies.

Thereafter, the group
leader briefly explained the impact of the provisions of MAT under Ind-AS
framework where in order to convert the books of accounts to Ind-AS, the
transition balance sheet has to be prepared from FY 2015-16. The same has been
clarified in the FAQs issued by the Indian Revenue authorities.

CA. Darshak Shah also
touched upon the adjustments under MAT where in case of items accounted under
‘OCI not re-classifiable to P&L’ i.e. revaluation of PPE and Intangible
assets and gains/ losses from investment in equity instruments designed at
FVOCI would be taxed under MAT on disposal only. Also, in case of items
considered as ‘Other Equity’ such as Investments in subsidiaries, JVs and AE
recorded at FMV and cumulative translation, differences of foreign operations
will be taxed under MAT on disposal.

Subsequently, he briefly
explained the provisions in case of certain items that would be offered to tax
equally over the period of 5 years like receivables provided based on expected
credit loss, fair value gains on derivative assets, gains/ loss on fair value
recognition on investments in MFs etc. The team leader then went through
certain case studies to explain various principles impacting the MAT
computation.

The participants got enriched through the
insights provided by the learned Speaker.

Service Tax

I TRIBUNAL

18. M/s. ODC Logistics Pvt. Ltd. vs. CST
2023-TIOL-639-CESTAT-KOL

Date of Order: 23rd June, 2023

Order beyond the scope of SCN is legally unsustainable. The conclusion based on assumptions and conjectures cannot deprive the assessee of the credit.

FACTS

Appellant provided logistics services including transportation of goods. Of the two issues involved in the show cause notice (SCN), the first related to RCM liability under Goods Transport Agency (GTA) service for payments made to suppliers of lorries on hire, based on expenses booked in financial statements as “freight charges”. The appellant contended that the supplier had not issued a consignment note and hence legally, it was not liable to pay service tax. However, the adjudicating authority proceeded by examining the nature of income of the appellant for providing output transportation services and observed that by avoiding issuing consignment notes for rendering output services, it could not avoid service tax liability as the appellant earned freight income and based on the said observation, service tax on GTA service was confirmed. For this conclusion, the appellant’s submission was that besides traveling beyond allegation in the SCN, which is the foundation of the levy and recovery, service tax liability could not be fastened when SCN did not contain allegations for liability on output services and further that service tax on GTA service is payable by the recipient of the service. In the second issue, CENVAT credit availed by the appellant on invoices issued by two specific vendors was disallowed on the ground that the department was unable to trace them at their office address and hence service providers were non-existent. For this, the appellant’s contention was that there was neither any investigation report brought on record nor was there any allegation made in the SCN as to having connivance with the service providers or that the service provider had not deposited by the service tax.

HELD

In the case of the demand under GTA service, the adjudicating authority traveled beyond SCN as the only allegation contained in the SCN was that the appellant did not pay service tax under RCM on expenditure involved on lorry hire charges / freight charges. However, the order conferring liability on the output services is beyond the scope of SCN and hence impermissible in law. Also, the Commissioner has accepted the order that lorry suppliers were not required to issue consignment notes and hence RCM cannot be invoked and hence the demand is set aside. On the issue of disallowance of CENVAT credit, it was observed by Hon. Bench that both SCN and the impugned order are silent on the inquiry report which was not made available at any stage of proceedings. Moreover, there being no allegation of any connivance with the service providers, the Bench was agreeable that denial of credit based on assumptions and conjectures cannot be held legally correct.

Hence the order was unsustainable and hence the appeal was allowed.

19. Alstom Projects India Ltd. vs. CCE
2023-TIOL-629-CESTAT-KOL

Date of Order: 2nd June, 2023

SCN issued after 4 years of information gathered is highly barred by limitation.

FACTS

The impugned order in this case confirmed the duty amount on compensation received on account of the cancellation of the order by West Bengal Power Development Corporation treating the same as additional consideration under Rule 6 of Central Excise Valuation (Determination of Price of Excisable Goods) Rules, 2000 by invoking extended period of limitation. The appellant submitted all material information regarding the non-receipt of two contracts, vide their letter dated 10th May, 2002 and subsequent letter dated 25th March 2003, and that as per the MOU, the appellant received the payment. The show cause notice, however, was issued in October, 2007 to the appellant engaged in the manufacture of boilers and boiler parts. The appellant was awarded two contracts, out of which one was canceled in 1994 on account of a financial crisis at the end of the client wherefore a cancellation order was passed to terminate the unexecuted portion of the contract to mutually agree on the amount of damages for cancellation. On a similar footing, another order of cancellation was issued in 2002 wherein also damages were payable by the contractee to the appellant. Despite the above, a show cause notice was issued as above on the grounds of suppression. The appellant submitted that damages did not attract excise duty and reliance in this regard was placed on various judicial pronouncements inter alia including the latest in the case of Skoda Auto Volkswagen India Private Limited vs. CCE, Aurangabad 2023-TIOL-149-CESTAT-MUM.

HELD

It was found that all the information was available to the department in 2003 itself and since no information was suppressed, the show cause notice issued four years later is not sustainable and is highly barred by limitation and hence merits of the case were not gone into and the appeal was allowed.

20. Maa Kalika Transport Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of CGST & CE
2023-TIOL-625-CESTAT-KOL

Date of Order: 10th July, 2023

The demand of service based on the IT department’s data is not sustainable based on merits as well as a limitation when it is without corroborative evidence. Also, the order was held beyond the scope of SCN.

FACTS

The appellant was issued a show cause notice in December, 2020 demanding a service tax of Rs. 9.50 crore  for the F.Y. 2015–16 based on the data received by the service tax department from the income tax department and which was confirmed by adjudicating authority under the category of cargo handling service by also imposing an equal amount of penalty under section 78(1) of the Act. Hence the appeal. According to the appellant, the bonafide belief is that they provided transportation service for which the service receiver is liable to pay service tax. They transported coal within a distance of 180 km. to 200 km. which was rightly classifiable as transportation of goods (GTA service) and hence service tax is not leviable under cargo handling service. Adjudicating authority was provided with work orders of various parties wherein terms of contract with each party were different. However, essentially the contracts were for the transportation of coal as per the appellant. Further, SCN had not specified any category for proposed demand of service tax.

HELD

In terms of the above facts, the issues before Hon. Tribunal was to examine which of two, viz. cargo handling service or transportation of goods was correct classification and also whether transportation service was bundled with other individual services and hence whether the contract could be vivisected and also whether the demand of tax under “cargo handling service” was beyond the scope of the SCN and whether the demand could be made based on the data received from income tax department without there being any corroborating evidence available with the department, Hence whether suppression was involved at all to demand service tax invoking extended period? Consequently, whether penalties could sustain at all. Based on a perusal of the contracts, it was found that the contracts were composite contracts but primarily for transportation and other services were incidental to it. The contract did not specify separate charges for such ancillary services and hence it could not be vivisected to arrive at a separate value for each service. Also, there was no proposal in the impugned SCN as to the classification of cargo handling service and hence adjudicating authority traveled beyond the scope of the notice which is legally unsustainable. Also as per the appellant, based on the data received from income tax, the department put in no effort to ascertain corroborative evidence and the impugned order contained no finding on this. This view also found support in the case of Larsen & Toubro Ltd. vs. ACST (2023) 2 Centax 327 (Cal.) and in CST vs. Hindustan Cables Ltd, 2022 (382) ELT 188 (Cal.). As for the existence of suppression, it was found that when the department itself was unclear about the classification, no suppression of the facts was involved. For this, reliance was placed on Ugam Chand Bhandari vs. CCE 2004 (167) ELT 491 (SC) and hence extended period was held as not invokable.

Thus, it was held that the appellant provided transportation services which were mutually bundled in the contracts. Further, since SCN did not have a proposal to demand service tax under cargo handling service, the order impugned traveled beyond the scope of the notice. The demand for tax could not be made only on the basis of data furnished by the income tax department without any corroborative evidence. Also when suppression did not exist and hence even on the ground of limitation, the demand would fail and consequently the penalty would not be sustained.

Goods And Services Tax

I. HIGH COURT

51. Dhanya Sreekumari vs. State Tax Officer (IB), State GST Department, Alappuzha
2023 (75) GSTL 404 (Ker.)

Date of order: 27th June, 2023

Cash not forming part of stock-in-trade cannot be seized during the inspection by the department as per section 67 of CGST Act.

FACTS

Petitioner was engaged in the manufacture and sale of Idly/Dosa batter, Parotta, Chappathi, etc. An inspection was conducted by the department in the manufacturing unit and at the residence of the petitioner. Cash amounting to Rs. 32,73,900 was found and seized from the residence of the petitioner. Pay-in-slips for depositing the amount in the bank were also found at the residence of the petitioner. Further, the petitioner made representation before the department for the return of seized cash but no action was taken.

HELD

Cash cannot be seized where it was not forming part of the stock-in-trade of the petitioner. Further, pay-in-slips indicated that cash was intended to be deposited in the bank. Hence, there was no reason to retain it further. It was directed to release the seized cash forthwith. The petition was disposed of in favour of the petitioner.

52. APJ Investments Pvt Ltd vs. Asst. Commr. of CGST, Delhi West
2023 (75) GSTL 451 (Del.)

Date of order: 9th May, 2023

Application for revocation of cancellation of GST registration restored where SCN did not provide reasons for cancellation.

FACTS

Petitioner was issued a SCN for cancellation of registration dated 22nd August, 2022 stating that the petitioner had obtained registration by means of fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts. The petitioner denied the allegations and claimed that it was in the process of winding up its business in Delhi and would voluntarily file an application for cancellation of registration once its import consignments arrived at New Delhi. SCN did not specifically indicate reasons for proposing to cancel the petitioner’s registration. The Proper Officer rejected the response filed by the petitioner and passed an order dated 13th October, 2022, whereby the petitioner’s GST registration was cancelled. Subsequently, the petitioner applied for revocation of cancellation of registration which was rejected and a new SCN dated 11th November, 2022 was issued to which the petitioner did not respond. Further, the petitioner’s application for revocation was rejected by an order dated 28th November, 2022. Thereafter, an appeal filed by the petitioner against the order was rejected on the ground that the petitioner had shifted its premises. Being aggrieved, the petitioner preferred a writ before the Hon’ble Court.

HELD

The Hon’ble High Court held that the SCN issued dated 22nd August, 2022 did not provide necessary particulars for cancellation of registration. It is a well-settled law that SCN must set out reasons for proposing an adverse action in order for the noticee to respond to the same. Undisputedly, in this case, the impugned SCN did not satisfy the said standards. Therefore, it would be appropriate to restore the petitioner’s application for revocation of cancellation of its GST registration. Hence petitioner be granted further opportunity to respond to SCN dated 11th November, 2022 and the opportunity to be heard. Petitioner’s application to be decided afresh.

53. B.C. Power Controls Ltd. vs. Union of India 2023 (75) GSTL 465 (Raj.)

Date of order: 18th April, 2023

Application for refund cannot be withheld on the grounds of pendency of certain other proceedings.

FACTS

Petitioner was engaged in the business of exporting electrical wires and allied products. Petitioner filed a refund claim and considered the shipping bill for application of refund as per section 54 of the CGST Act read with section 16 of the IGST Act and Rule 96 of CGST Rules. Regardless of repeated representations, the respondent did not decide on the claim for the refund as there were allegations against the petitioner that fake invoices were raised for the purpose of claiming the refund. As a result, two SCNs were issued under section 74 of the CGST Act and refund proceedings were kept on hold. According to the respondent, once the pending proceedings are concluded the claim of refund would be decided.

HELD

It was held that the application for a refund once filed needs to be addressed as per the provisions of the law and cannot be kept pending on the grounds of pendency of certain other proceedings. As per revenue’s claim, since this case involved allegations of raising fake invoices and the matter was under investigation, no direction for refund was issued. However, the respondent was directed to decide the petitioner’s refund application.

54. Diya Agencies vs. State Tax Officer [2023] 154 taxmann.com 421 (Kerala)

Date of order: 12th September, 2023

The input tax credit cannot be denied merely on the ground that the concerned invoice does not appear in GSTR-2A. If on examination of the evidence submitted by the assessee, the assessing officer is satisfied that the claim is bonafide and genuine, the assessee should be given input tax credit.

FACTS

The petitioner’s claim for ITC was denied on the ground that as per GSTR-2A in respect of a supply invoice, the taxpayer is only eligible for the input tax amount shown in GSTR-2A.

HELD

The Hon’ble Court held that if the seller dealer (supplier) has not remitted the said amount paid by the petitioner to him, the petitioner cannot be held responsible. The Court relied upon the decision in the case of The State of Karnataka vs. M/s Ecom Gill Coffee Trading Private Limited 2023 (3) TMI 533 SC and held that whether the petitioner has paid the tax amount and whether the transactions between the petitioner and seller dealer are genuine are the matter of facts and evidence. The petitioner has to discharge the burden of proof regarding the remittance of tax to the seller dealer by giving evidence. The Court thus set aside the impugned order holding that merely on the ground that in Form GSTR-2A the said tax is not reflected should not be a sufficient ground to deny the assessee the claim of the input tax credit and remanded the matter with a direction to the concerned revenue authority to allow the petitioner to give evidence to establish genuineness of his claim for input tax credit.

55. AEW Technologies LLP vs.
Assistant Commissioner of Revenue,
Bureau of Investigation
[2023] 154 taxmann.com 265 (Cal.)

Date of order: 29th August, 2023

Where revenue recovered the amount in excess of the statutory pre-deposit required to be made before the first appellate authority and tribunal and that too before the expiry of the period for filing of the appeal, the Court directed the authorities to refund the excess amount.

FACTS

The petitioner challenged the order of the first appellate authority and was also aggrieved by the fact that the department initiated recovery for the amounts which are more than the statutory pre-deposit requirements before the first appellate authority and the second appellate authority; and that such amounts were recovered even before the expiry of the statutory period of time to file the appeal before Tribunal.

HELD

The Hon’ble Court directed the authorities to refund the excess amount of pre-deposit to the petitioner.

56. Vaishnavi Metals vs. Assistant Commissioner (ST) (Madras)
[2023] 154 taxmann.com 331
Date of order: 11th September, 2023

The Court quashed the recovery proceeding pending the disposal of the petitioner’s rectification application by the authorities.

FACTS

The petitioner received an adjudication order along with impugned recovery notices. However, owing to certain errors in the order, the petitioner filed a rectification application against the said order. The department initiated a recovery proceeding against the petitioner.

HELD

The Hon’ble Court quashed the recovery proceeding since the rectification applications were pending and directed the revenue authorities to dispose of the petitioner’s rectification application expeditiously.

57. Zydus Wellness Products Ltd vs. UOI [2023] 154 taxmann.com 261 (SIKKIM)

Date of order: 12th September, 2023

The benefit of the Budgetary Support Scheme for the “remainder period” cannot be given to the new entity when there is a change of ownership. The petitioner’s argument that the exemption should be based on the unit and not on the ownership is not accepted by the Hon’ble Court.

FACTS

The petitioners, Zydus Wellness Products Ltd (Zydus) and Alkem Laboratories Ltd (Alkem) approached the Court seeking a direction to allocate fresh Unique Identity (UID) in the name of new entities and to extend the benefit of the Budgetary Support Scheme (‘Scheme’) to them for the residual period. In the case of Zydus, the partnership firm was converted into a company in February 2019 and in the case of Alkem, a unit belonging to Cachet Pharma was transferred to Alkem as a going concern. The parties had approached the Ministry for obtaining a necessary clarification in this regard and CBIC had opined that as per the guidelines of the Scheme, if any unit undergoes relocation, expansion and change of ownership, it would not be eligible.

HELD

Referring to the definition of ‘person’ under section 22 of the CGST Act, 2017, the Hon’ble Court held that the erstwhile partnership firm of Zydus and the company as also the Cachet Pharma and Alkem are separate and distinct legal entities and required to obtain a separate registration under section 22 of the CGST Act. The Court also observed that the Scheme therefore was a measure of goodwill only to the units that were eligible for drawing benefits under the earlier excise duty exemption/refund schemes but has otherwise no relation to the erstwhile schemes. The Court therefore held that the petitioners who are separate legal entities qua the previous persons who were eligible for the Scheme, could not have filed an application under the said Scheme and were not the eligible units as defined in paragraph 4.1 of the said Scheme. The Court further held that the exemption under Notification No. 20/2007-CE was intended for those who have made investments in the State of Sikkim and not for those who have not made investments. The Court concluded that it was the previous owners who had invested to be eligible for the scheme and not the petitioners and accordingly their petition was dismissed. The petitioner’s argument that the exemption should be based on the unit and not on ownership is not accepted by the Hon’ble Court.

Recent Developments in GST

AMENDMENT IN ACTS

The Goods and Services Tax Council (GST Council) in its 50th and 51st meetings considered representation from various associations on the issues regarding the taxability of Casinos, Horse Racing and Online Gaming and recommended making certain amendments in the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (the Act) to provide clarity regarding taxability of Casinos, Horse Racing and Online Gaming. Accordingly, CGST Amendment Act and IGST Amendment Act, both dated 18th August, 2023 are passed and notified in Gazette.

B. NOTIFICATIONS

1.    Notification No. 39/2023 — Central Tax dated 17th August, 2023

By the above notification, the Amendment is made in Notification No. 2/2017 dated 19th August, 2017 by which some entries are substituted which are regarding territorial jurisdictions.

2.    Notification No. 40/2023 — Central Tax dated  17th August, 2023

The above notification seeks to appoint common adjudicating authority in respect of show cause notices issued to M/s United Spirits Limited.

3.    Notification No. 41, 42, 43 & 44/2023 — Central Tax dated 25th August, 2023

By the above notifications, the extension of time is granted for furnishing of Form GSTR-1, return in Form GSTR 3B (monthly/ quarterly) and GSTR -7 respectively for taxpayers registered in Manipur. The extension is up to 25th August, 2023 for all the above returns.

4.    Notification No.45/2023 — Central Tax dated  6th September, 2023

By the above notification, the CGST Rules are amended. These amendments are in relation to valuation for online gaming including online money gaming and actionable claims in the case of Casinos. For this purpose, Rules 31B & 31C have been inserted.

C. ADVISORY

a)    The information is given by GST: The Advisory is about “Mera Bill Mera Adhikaar Scheme” dated 24th August, 2023.

b)    The GSTN has further informed about introducing “Electronic Credit reversal and Re-claimed statement” dated 31st August, 2023.

D. ADVANCE RULINGS

34. Exemption vis-à-vis Agreement with NSDC
Nxtwave Disruptive Technologies Pvt Ltd (Order No.: A.R. Com/12/2022 dated 27th September, 2022 (TSAAR Order No. 50/2022) (Telangana)

M/s Nxtwave Disruptive Technologies Private Limited has filed this application (name referred to as Nxtwave).

Nxtwave was founded by IIT Bombay, IIT Kharagpur and IIT Hyderabad alumni — Sashank Reddy Gujjula, Anupam Pedarla and Rahul Attuluri. The Nxtwave offers training programs in Industry 4.0 Technologies for college students, graduates, and early professionals.

The Nxtwave aims to empower 150 million college students and recent graduates, between the age groups of 18-24, into highly-skilled professionals to gear up for the 4.0 revolution.

National Skill Development Corporation (“NSDC”), a Section 25 Company under Companies Act, 1956 (corresponding to section 8 of the Companies Act, 2013), was initially set up under the Prime Minister’s National Council on Skill Development with the primary mandate of enhancing and supporting private sector initiatives for Skill Development in India through appropriate Public-Private Partnership (“PPP”) models and striving for significant operational and financial involvement from the private sector. At present, NSDC functions under the aegis of the Ministry of Skill Development & Entrepreneurship (“MSDE”).

NSDC through this Scheme endeavors to create a sustainable and enabling skill training ecosystem by promoting the provision of market-led fee-based Services under the various models like:

(i) self-financed by the candidate,
(ii) financed by the candidate or partner through a loan or under an income sharing arrangements with the partner etc.

Any Eligible Entity having relevant experience in Skill Development can submit a Proposal to become a Partner of NSDC. The Proposal shall be in the prescribed format and shall include details of the services proposed to be offered by the Partner under the Scheme.

Both the Nxtwave and NSDC have entered into an agreement dated 9th June, 2022 to further their objectives, and the Nxtwave has been recognized as a “Training Partner” of the NSDC with effect from 9th June, 2022.

As per the agreement, Nxtwave shall offer its training programs, as detailed in the proposal approved by the NSDC, as amended from time to time with the approval of NSDC.

The scheme extends mutual benefits to all stakeholders, like NSDC, Nxtwave as well as students.

With the above background, following questions were raised before AAR:

“Q1: Whether training programmes offered by the applicant, as approved by NSDC would be construed under the “any other scheme implemented by the NSDC” as required under Serial No. 69 of the Notification and the benefit of GST exemption would be available to the applicant from the date of its agreement with NSDC?

Q2: Whether the training programmes offered in collaboration with other business partners, imparted by business partners of the applicant under a subcontract would be construed under the “any other scheme implemented by the NSDC” as required under Serial No. 69 of the Notification and the benefit of GST exemption would be available to the applicant?

Q3: Exemption of GST is available to the company as a whole as long as its services fulfill the criteria laid down under serial no.69 of the said notification and not limited to Telangana GST?”

Applicant justified its claim of exemption raised in questions, on the ground that Applicant is rendering education and training services under the following models:

CCBP Intensive:
CCBP Intensive enables tech job aspirants (college graduates and early professionals) to get a software job. The details of the program can be referred to on the company website (www.ccbp.in).

CCBP Academy:
CCBP Academy enables college students from engineering & technology colleges to become industry-ready by the time of their graduation and achieve high-paid software jobs.

It was submitted that the above services are covered within the HSN 9992.

It was also submitted that the applicant is an approved training partner of the NSDC and that the project under implementation is already approved by the NSDC and an agreement is executed between parties.

Therefore, a claim was made that the activity is exempt under Entry No. 69 in Notification No. 12/2017 — Central Tax (Rate) issued by the Ministry of Finance dated 28th June, 2017.

The second question was also justified to be exempt as the subcontract is made simply for the furtherance of the objectives of the scheme and is on a principal to principal basis.

Regarding question 3, it was submitted that the exemption of GST shall be available to the company as a whole and not just under the Telangana GST Act.

The ld. AAR made a reference to Entry 69 of Notification No. 12/2017 which provides an exemption to,

“Any services provided by, —
(a) ………….
(b) ………….
(c) ………….
(d) A training partner approved by the National Skill Development Corporation or the Sector Skill Council, in relation to —

(i) The National Skill Development Programme implemented by the National Skill Development Corporation; or

(ii) A vocational skill development course under the National Skill Certification and Monetary Reward Scheme; or

(iii) Any other Scheme implemented by the National Skill Development Corporation.”

The ld. AAR made detailed reference to the object of NSDC and the scheme of exemption granted in Entry 69. The ld. AAR observed that for Entry 69 the service provider has to be a training partner approved by the National Skill Development Corporation or the Sector Skill Council. The applicant has submitted the attested photocopy of the certificate of Partnership which shows that the applicant is the Approved Training Partner of the National Skill Development Corporation (NSDC) from 23rd June, 2022, up to 22nd June, 2023. Therefore, the ld. AAR held that the applicant is presently an Approved Training Partner of NSDC.

The ld. AAR noted further requirements, whether the application is providing any services in relation to any other Scheme implemented by the National Skill Development Corporation. In this context, the ld. AAR found that the applicant is providing courses in relation to the Scheme for market-led fee-based services by the National Skill Development Corporation.

The ld. AAR also found that the applicant has entered into agreement with NSDC dated 23rd June, 2022 which substantiates a partnership with NSDC for executing training under the above scheme for market-led fee-based services under non-funded affiliation.

The ld. AAR also found that the applicant is offering training programs, as detailed in the proposal approved by the NSDC as amended from time to time with the approval of NSDC, mentioned above, like CCBP.

The ld. AAR concluded that the services provided by the applicant are as the training partner approved by the National Skill Development Corporation and are in relation to the Scheme implemented by the National Skill Development Corporation.

Accordingly, the ld. AAR held that the services offered by the applicant fall under Sl. No. 69 (d) (iii) and therefore eligible for exemption under Notification No. 12/2017 for CGST and SGST.

So far as the second question is concerned, the ld. AAR observed that as per Entry 69, the services supplied by the applicant as an approved training partner of NSDC in relation to any other scheme implemented by the NSDC are exempt but not the services received by the applicant from others including a sub-contractor who supplies such services to the applicant, as he is not a training partner approved by the National Skill Development Corporation or the Sector Skill Council. Therefore, the ld. AAR answered question (2) in negative.

Accordingly, the first issue is decided in the favour of the applicant holding the activity as exempt. However, in relation to question (2), the AAR ruled in negative.

In respect of question (3), the learned AAR held that the only services covered by Entry 69 are exempt and not others.

35. Nature of Contract for operation and maintenance of Dam Work
Secure Meter Ltd. (AR No. RAJ/AAR/2022-23 dated 12th October, 2022 (Raj.)

The applicant i.e., M/s Secure Meter Limited, E-Class, Pratap Nagar Industrial Area, Udaipur is engaged in providing compressive water services and currently is in the process of bidding for a tender floated by the PHED, a unit of the Government of Rajasthan for the Operation and Maintenance of the Mansi Wakal Dam Stage-I.

The applicant has explained various aspects of the contract.

The applicant has raised the following questions:

“1.     Whether the activity of operation and maintenance is to be considered as Supply of goods or a Supply of Services under CGST / RGST Act 2017? Accordingly, whether the transaction can be sub-classified as a “Pure Supply of Service” or “Pure Supply of Goods” or “Composite supply of goods and services being a works contract?

2. Whether the applicant is entitled to the benefit of exemption under Entry 3 A of Notification No. 12/2017 — Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017, as amended? If not, what is the applicable rate of tax?”

Based on the written submission made by the applicant and given details, the ld. AAR found that applicant is in the process of bidding for a tender floated by the PHED, a unit of the Government of Rajasthan for the Operation and Maintenance of the Mansi Wakal Dam Stage-I complete system, including mechanical, electrical, instrumentation installation works, switchyards / GSS and maintenance of Dam, pumping machinery, pipe line & tunnel from Mansi Wakal Dam to Nandeshwar filter plant project on ESCO and O&M contract. The terms and scope of the contract combines ESCO Model and O&M contract.

Based on the scope of work as detailed in contract / Tender Document NIT No. 03 / 2021-22, the ld. AAR observed that the ESCO model requires improvement of the whole water supply system involving pump houses, pumping stations, transmission lines, switchyards, and headwork. Re-modelling of pump foundation and extension of pump house, replacement of fittings / fixtures and painting of all permanent structures like pumping station building, Dam, Tunnel etc. are involved in the contract. It was further observed that a single tender shall be floated for Operation and Maintenance of Dam, pumping machinery, pipeline & tunnel on ESCO Cum O&M Contract where the preamble of scope specifies that the contract combines ESCO model and O&M work. It was observed that the activities under the ESCO model and the O&M contract are closely linked.

The ld. AAR referred to the meaning of works contract, Composite Supply and meaning of immovable property. Based on facts that the main intention is to supply maintenance services, the ld. AAR observed that the activity also involves the use of materials. It was also observed that all the components of the pumping system are erected at the prescribed location and permanently attached to the earth and they cannot be dismantled and reassembled, as such dismantling may cause substantial damage to the system and its components. Therefore, the activities to be undertaken by the applicant with respect to Operation and Maintenance are for an immovable property i.e., Mansi Wakal Dam and the given work is works contract, held by the ld. AAR. Accordingly, it was also held that all the conditions of composite supply are satisfied, therefore it is a composite supply of works contract. It was also observed that as per the break-up of material cost under the Operation & Maintenance of Mansi Wakal water project provided by the applicant, the value of supply of goods is 11.50 per cent i.e., below 25 per cent out of the total value of supply and hence, the applicant is eligible for exemption under Entry No. 3A of Notification No. 12 / 2017-CT (R) dated 28th June, 2017.

The ld. AAR gave the ruling as under:
“The activity of O & M of Mansi Wakal Dam Project on ESCO Model and O & M work by the applicant is to be undertaken /being undertaken for a Government Department. In this activity of Composite supply of goods and services, the applicability of GST will be as under:

(a) Composite supply of goods and services where supply of goods is below 25 per cent out of the total value of supply then GST will be @ NIL.

(b) Composite supply of goods and services where the supply of goods is more than 25 per cent of the total value of supply then GST will be @12 per cent (SGST 6 per cent + CGST 6 per cent).”

36. Classification — Satin Rolls, Taffeta Rolls
Mean Light Co. (AR No. KAR/ADRG-43/2022 dated 29th November, 2022 (KAR)

The applicant has raised questions about the “classification of products “Satin Rolls” and “Taffeta Rolls” with sizes between 19 mm to 40 mm.

The brief facts about the products are narrated as under:

“Satin Rolls: Made with 100 per cent polyester, the rolls are available having a width between 10 mm to 810 mm. We mainly deal with sizes between 19 mm to 40 mm. The same will be sold to printers for printing purposes. The ultimate customers of the products are the companies engaged in manufacturing of readymade garments. The products will be ultimately used for the purposes of printing wash care instructions & fabric contents (to capture instructions).

Taffeta Rolls: Made with 100 per cent Nylon and dip quoted sizes available in the market from 10 mm to 810 mm. We mainly deal with sizes between 19 mm to 40 mm. The same will be sold to printers for printing purposes. The ultimate customers of the products are the companies engaged in manufacturing of readymade garments. The products will be ultimately used for the purposes of printing wash care instructions & fabric contents (to capture instructions).”

Applicant further supplied the following information:

“11.1 Taffeta Rolls: The standard manufacturing size of the fabric is 60 inches / 1524 mm wide fabric, made up of polyester yarn. Acrylic coating is made on the fabric for better printing quality and also to protect from raveling or fraying, then will be cut in different sizes and shapes as normal scissor cut.

11.2 Polyester Satin Ribbons: The fabric is made from polyester yarn, standard manufacturing size is 60 inches / 1524 mm wide. Either optical or non-optical coating is made on the fabric for brightening and to remove impurities. Optical brighter coating will give shiny and bright finishing and non-optical dull finishing. It has plain selvedges on both sides of the fabric. Hot blades are used to cut into different shapes and sizes which arrest the fabric from fraying.”

The ld. AAR examined the classification of the impugned products.

The ld. AAR made reference to the Section Notes and Chapter Notes of the relevant Chapters of the Customs Tariff and also the corresponding Harmonised Commodity Description and Coding System Explanatory Notes of the World Customs Organisation (WCO).

The ld. AAR noted that Chapter 5806 of the first schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 covers NARROW WOVEN FABRICS OTHER THAN GOODS OF HEADING 5807; NARROW FABRICS CONSISTING OF WARP WITHOUT WEFT ASSEMBLED BY MEANS OF AN ADHESIVE (BOLDUCS). Read with Notes of Chapter 58, the ld. AAR noted that the impugned products, as per the applicant, are woven fabrics having the width of less than 30 cm; that Taffeta rolls are made up of polyester yarn with acrylic coating to protect from raveling or fraying and also to have better printing quality; It also noted that Satin rolls are made up of polyester yarn, with optical or non-optical coating for brightening and to remove impurities, having plain selvedges on both sides of the fabric; and cut with hot blades to arrest fabric fraying. Therefore, the impugned products qualify to get covered under “Narrow Woven Fabrics”, observed the ld. AAR.

The ld. AAR also referred to Chapter 5807 which covers labels, badges and similar articles of textile materials, in the piece, in strips or cut to shape or size, not embroidered. Referring to Explanatory Notes to tariff heading 5807, the ld. AAR observed that this heading covers (i) Labels of any textile material (including knitted) and (ii) Badges and similar articles of any textile material (including knitted), subject to the following conditions:

a) They must not be embroidered. The inscriptions or motifs on the articles classified here are generally produced by weaving (usually broche work) or by printing.

b) They must be in the piece, in strips (as is usually the case) or in separate limits obtained by cutting to size or shape but must not be otherwise made up.

The ld. AAR found that the impugned products are not embroidered and fulfill the aforesaid conditions. Therefore, the ld. AAR held that the impugned products merit classification under tariff heading 5807 10 20.

37. Exemption vis-à-vis Government Authority
Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board (AR No. AAAR.Com/09/2022 dated
2nd November, 2022 (Telangana)

The Appellant filed this appeal against AAR dated 3rd June, 2022 wherein the Question posed before it was decided as under:

“Question Ruling
1. Is Medical insurance premium taken to provide Health Insurance to the employees, pensioners and their family members, eligible for exemption as mentioned in Entry No. 3 of the Notification No. 12/2017 – Central Tax (Rate), dated
28th June, 2017?
No
2. Is the Vehicle Insurance Policy taken to provide insurance to the vehicles owned by the Board, eligible for exemption as mentioned in Entry No. 3 of the Notification No. 12/2017 – Central Tax (Rate), dated  28th June, 2017? Yes, if the vehicles are directly used to provide services under Schedule XII of the Constitution.

No, if they are used for transportation of employees/board members/other persons with no direct relationship to functions discharged under Article 243W.”

The ld. AAAR referred to the factual position that Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board (The Board) was constituted on 1st November, 1989 under the provisions of Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Act 1989, with the following Functions & Responsibilities in the Hyderabad Metropolitan Area.

•    The Supply of potable water including planning, design, construction, maintenance, operation & management of the water supply system.

•    Sewerage, Sewerage Disposal and sewerage treatment works including planning, design, construction, maintenance, operation & management of all sewerage and sewerage treatment works.

The ld. AAAR also observed that from 1st July, 2017 to 17th November, 2021 as per Sl. No. 3 of Central Tax (Rate) Notification No. 12/207 dated 28th June, 2017 the rate of tax on the supply of the following services is Nil.

“Sl. No. Chapter Section

Heading Group or Service Code

Description of
services
Rate

(per

cent.)

Condition
3 Chapter 99 Pure services (excluding works contract service or other composite supplies

involving the supply of any goods) provided to the Central Government, State

Government or Union territory or local authority or a Governmental authority [or a Government Entity] by way of any activity in relation to any function entrusted to a Panchayat under Article 243G of the Constitution or in relation to any function entrusted to a Municipality under Article 243W of the Constitution.

NIL NIL”

The ld. AAAR concurred that the Appellant is the Government Authority as per the meaning of the same given in section 2(zf).

The ld. AAAR observed that since the Hyderabad Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board is a board set up by an act of state legislature to carry out any function entrusted to a Municipality under Article 243W, it is a ‘Governmental Authority’ as per the above definition.

The Appellant had contended that the following supply of services to them is eligible for exemption under Sl. No. 3 mentioned above:

1) Insurance services provided to the board for insuring their employees and their family members.

2) Insurance services provided to the vehicles of the board.

The ld. AAAR also observed that services are exempted if the following conditions are satisfied.

“1)The services provided should be Pure services (excluding works contract service or other composite supplies involving the supply of any goods).

2) The services provided should be by way of any activity in relation to any function entrusted to a Municipality under Article 243W of the Constitution.

3) After 01-01-2022, the exemption is available only if it is provided to the Central Government, State Government and Local Authority only”.

Based on the above position, the ld. AAAR held that if the services procured by the board are by way of any activity in relation to any function entrusted to a Municipality (like water supply and sewerage), then only the supply is exempt from tax as per condition at Sl. No. 2 above.

The ld. AAAR held that the insurance supplies made to the board for its employees and their family members are not in relation to any function entrusted to the municipality.

The ld. AAAR held that the word ‘in relation to’ will include only functions which are in direct relation to the entry like water supply and sewerage.’

Relevant judicial pronouncements were also referred to.

Therefore, the ld. AAAR held that the insurance services for employees and employees’ family members received by the applicant is not in direct and proximate relation to water supply and sewerage related function entrusted under Article 243W, hence the supply received by the applicant does not fall under Sl. No. 3 of Central tax (rate) Notification No. 12/2017 and are not exempt.

The ld. AAAR also held that the board also receives insurance services for vehicles which are used for transportation of water and sewerage management.  These vehicles are essential for performing the functions as entrusted in 243W of the constitution, the ld. AAAR held that the applicant is eligible for exemption under Entry mentioned above services in relation to all other vehicles which are not used for performing the functions as entrusted in 243W of the constitution shall be taxable, held the ld. AAAR.

Regarding the period from 1st January, 2022, due to changes in Entry 3, by which the Government Authority is omitted from said Entry, the ld. AAAR concurred with AAR that no service will be exempt. In view of the above, the ld. AAAR confirmed the AR.

38. Recovery from employees towards Canteen Facility — Liable to GST
Federal Mogul Goetze India Ltd (AR No. KAR-ADRG-42/2022 dated 29th November, 2022 (KAR)

The applicant, a manufacturer of auto parts, has to maintain the canteen facility as per Factories Act, 1948. The Factories Act provides canteen facilities to all their employees including contractual employees. In the present case, the said canteen is operated by the applicant and all the equipment and items essential for running the canteen such as groceries, utensils, cooking equipment etc., are arranged by the applicant. The applicant entered into a separate contract with a service provider for providing / supplying manpower required to manage the canteen operations. The service provider raises monthly invoices towards the supply of manpower for canteen operations and charges applicable GST.

On the above facts, the applicant has sought an advance ruling in relation to the applicability of GST on the deductions made from the salary of the employees raising the following questions:

‘Whether the subsidized deduction made by the applicant from the employees who are availing food in the factory would be considered as a “supply” by the Applicant under the provisions of Section 7 of the CGST / KGST Act 2017.

a. In case the answer to above is yes, whether GST is applicable on the nominal amount being recovered by the Applicant?

b. Whether Input Tax Credit (“ITC”) of the GST charged by the Service Provider would be eligible for availment to the Applicant?”

The applicant also submitted that with respect to regular employees they deduct Rs.50 from salary and for contract employees Rs.10.

The argument of the applicant was that it is not liable under GST on the above recoveries. The submission was based on three grounds:

(i)    It is not ‘supply’ as per section 7 of the GST Act.

It was contended that there shall be a legal intention of both the parties to the contract to supply and receive the goods or services or both. The absence of such intention would mean that there is no supply within the meaning of the CGST Act.

The further contention was that there was no consideration. The supply should involve quid pro quo — viz., the supply transaction requires something in return, which the person supplying will obtain, which may be in monetary terms / in any other form except in cases of deeming provision as specified in Schedule I. Applicant submitted that in its present case, the transaction is only money transaction and no ‘quid pro quo’ available as the applicant is running a canteen as mandated under the Factories Act, 1948.

The ld. AAR observed that there is the legal intention to provide canteen food and therefore the contention that applicants do not have any legal intention for the provision of a canteen is contrary to the obligation placed on the applicant under the Factories Act, 1948. The ld. AAR also observed that the contractual relationship is evident from the fact that the applicant is charging employees R50 per month from the payroll and union employees and R10 per meal from contract employees. The ld. AAR observed that since the charges are pre-decided and deducted from the salaries, which are also agreed upon by the employees, a contractual relationship is clearly established between the applicant and their employees.

(ii)    Regarding the contention that there is no consideration, the ld. AAR observed that as per the definition of ‘consideration’ in section 2(31) the consideration includes any payment made or to be made, in response to, the supply of goods or services or both. Adequacy of consideration or otherwise is not a factor in deciding whether the activity amounts to supply or not. The ld. AAR held that the fact that a consideration is being charged by the applicant and paid by the employee is sufficient to establish a contractual relationship with reciprocal obligations leading to the supply of service. The ld. AAR rejected the argument of the applicant that there is no quid-pro-quo between them and the employee is factually and legally not sustainable.

(iii)    Regarding the third argument that it is not in the course or furtherance of business, the ld. AAR, after noting the definition of ‘business’ in section 2(17) observed that the applicant is a manufacturer and thus their activity is covered under Section 2(17)(a) of the CGST Act. The ld. AAR further observed that Section 2(17)(b) stipulates that any activity/transaction in connection with sub-clause (a) i.e., Section 2(17)(a), is included in the ‘business’. Since in the instant case, the applicant is running the canteen in connection with the manufacturing activity, the ld. AAR held that providing a canteen facility is incidental to their main activity of manufacture, and therefore covered in the definition of ‘business’ in terms of Section 2(17)(b). The ld. AAR also held that the canteen factory is also in furtherance of business as, if such facility is not provided the quantum of production will get affected as employees will move out for food which will be time consuming.

Regarding the contention of the applicant that the activity is covered by Entry I in Schedule III the ld. AAR held that the said provision is not applicable to the instant case as the issue pertains to the services being provided by the employer to the employees and not vice-versa. As per Entry I of Schedule III, only services by employees to employers are exempted and not services by employers to employees.

In respect of reference to the rulings of various advance ruling authorities and Appellate authorities, the ld. AAR observed that in such cases the canteen facilities were provided by third parties and collection of employees’ share and payments to canteen service providers without profit was held as not amounting to supply by the employer. However, since in the instant case, the applicant themselves are providing the canteen facility, the ld. AAR held that the advance rulings cited before it are not relevant to the facts of the case.

It is also observed that advance rulings are extended to the applicants only and can’t be generalized and applied to all and therefore ld. AAR declined to follow them.

The ld. AAR also referred to the question as to whether GST is applicable on the nominal amount being recovered by the applicant?

The ld. AAR made detailed reference to provisions of valuation like section 15.

In light of the provision of Explanation (a)(iii) to Section 15 of the CGST Act 2017, the ld. AAR observed that employers and employees are related persons. Therefore, it is observed that in the instant case since the supplier of the service i.e., the applicant is the employer and the recipients of the said services are employees, they are related persons.

The ld. AAR also observed that when the supplier and the recipients are related parties and the price is not the sole consideration, Section 15(1) of the Act is not relevant. The ld. AAR observed that Section 15(4) of the Act stipulates that in the cases where the value of the supply of goods or services or both cannot be determined under section 15(1), the same shall be determined in such manner as may be prescribed, is applicable in the present case.

The ld. AAR held that the value should be as per Rule 28 read with Rules 30 or 31.

In respect of eligibility to ITC of GST paid on manpower supply the ld. AAR held that services of applicants are covered in the category of services provided in the canteen and other establishments and merit classification under SAC 996333. It is further observed that the said services attract GST @ 5 per cent, without ITC in terms of Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated
28th June, 2017, as amended. Therefore, the ld AAR held that the applicant is not entitled to ITC of the GST paid on manpower supply servicesthat are used for providing a canteen facility.

39. Recovery towards Canteen Facility — Liable to GST
Tube Investment of India Ltd. (AR No. 12/2022 in Appl. No. 07/2022-23 dated 24th November, 2022 (Uttarakhand)

In this case, the applicant has submitted facts as under:

“(a) That they are a leading engineering company engaged in the manufacture of precision steel tubes and strips, automotive, industrial chains, car door frames and bicycles. And they have a factory in the state of Uttarakhand where more than 500 workmen (both direct and indirect) are employed.

(b) They have entered into an agreement with the contractors to operate a canteen within the factory premises to provide food to their employees.

(c) They recover a nominal amount from the employees on a monthly basis and such recoveries are shown as a deduction in the monthly slip of the employees.

(d) They do not avail Input Tax Credit (ITC) on the expenses incurred on the services provided by the canteen service provider and are absorbing the GST charged by the canteen service provider as a cost in the books of accounts.

(e) They discharge GST @5 per cent on the cost of the canteen service provider’s total taxable value plus 10 per cent notional markup.”
Based on the above, the ruling was sought on the following questions:

“a. Whether the nominal amount of recoveries made by the Applicant from the employees who are provided food in the factory canteen would be considered as a “Supply” by the applicant under the provisions of Section 7 of Central Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017,

b. In case, the answer to the above is “Yes”, — whether GST is applicable on the amount recovered from the employees for the food provided in the factory canteen or on the amount paid by the Applicant to the Canteen Service Provider?

c. Whether input tax credit (ITC) is available to the Applicant and GST charged by the Canteen Service Providers for providing the catering services of the factory where it is obligatory for the Applicant to provide the same to its employees as mandated under the Factories Act, 1948, even if the answer to question (a) is “No”?

d. Whether Input Tax Credit (ITC) can be availed on GST charged by the Canteen service providers, the answer to the question (b) is “Yes”?”

In the course of the hearing, it was further explained that in compliance with the provisions of the Factories Act, 1948, they provide canteen facilities to employees.

It was also explained that they have entered into an agreement with the contractors to operate a canteen within the factory premises to provide food to their employees and the amount raised by the canteen operator is booked as expenses in the P&L account, without taking the benefit of ITC of the GST paid by them.

It was explained that they recover nominal amounts from the employees on a monthly basis and such recoveries are shown as a deduction in the monthly slip of the employees and the recoveries made are credited to the expense account.

The ld. AAR made reference to the CBIC Press release dated 10th July, 2017, wherein the concept of ‘GST on Gifts’ to employees is clarified. However, in this case, since it is not free, as some amount, though nominal, is collected and also canteen is as per requirement of the Factories Act, 1948.

Regarding further contention that it is not in the course or furtherance of business, the ld. AAR observed that establishing a canteen is in the furtherance of the business of the applicant and supply of food to the employees when the same is not part of the agreement is not an allowance as a part of the employment. Thus, the ld. AAR held that the provision of food in the canteen for a nominal cost is a ‘Supply’ for the purposes of GST and it is a service as per relevant Entry in Schedule II to the CGST Act, 2017.

The further contention of the applicant is that the amount, received from the employees, is in the nature of recovery and not consideration as the recovered amount is directly paid to the third-party vendor without any profit element in the hands of the Applicant, also rejected on the ground that the running of a canteen in the factory of the applicant is in the course of furtherance of business. Though the applicant has chosen to run the canteen through a third party vendor, in the factory, the ld. AAR observed that the provision of a canteen facility and bearing certain costs, in running of canteens are mandated on the part of the employer as per the Factories Act and accordingly, such canteens are in furtherance of business.

Considering the definition of ‘consideration’ in section 2(31) the ld. AAR observed that the applicant supplies food to their employees at a nominal cost, and the same is the consideration for such supply made by the applicant on which GST is liable to be paid. The recovery of cost from the salary as deferred payment does not alter the fact of the service provided and the person providing the said supply observed the ld. AAR.

The issue about ITC also ruled in negative in view of the existing section 17(5)(b)(i), even though it was obligatory to provide canteen under other law.

In respect of the AR of other States, AAR also held them not applicable as each AR is based on its own facts.

[Compiler’s Note: Please also refer to Circular No.172 of 2022 dated 6th July, 2022, in which certain clarifications about blockers of ITC under Section 17(5)(b) are given.]

Allied Laws

27. Dheeraj Singh vs. Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority & others AIR 2023 Supreme Court 3110

4th July, 2023

Cross Objection — Cross Objections have the same trapping as a Regular Appeal — Not considered by the High Court — Matter remanded to High Court for fresh adjudication. [O. 41, R. 22, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; S. 14, 17, Land Acquisition Act, 1894].

FACTS

The State of Uttar Pradesh (Respondent) had acquired the land of the Appellants under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and paid compensation for the same. The Ld. District Judge granted further compensation. Aggrieved by the same, the Respondent filed an appeal in the High Court of Allahabad (High Court). Subsequently, the appellants filed a cross objection in the High Court. The Hon’ble High Court confirmed the order of the Ld. District Judge. It was the contention of the Appellants before the Hon’ble Supreme Court that the Cross Objection filed by them (Appellants) was not considered by the Hon’ble High Court.

HELD  

The Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that the Hon’ble High Court failed to consider the Cross Objections filed by the Appellants. The Court further held, relying on Order 41, Rule 22 of the Code for Civil Procedure, 1908, that Cross Objections have all the trappings of a regular appeal. Thus, the matter was remanded to the High Court for fresh adjudication.

28. Manoj Kumar Jain and another vs. UOI AIR 2023 (NOC) 580 (CAL)

9th June, 2023

Look out Circular — Economic Offence — Issuance of Look Out Circular by the bank for non-re-payment of loans — Apprehension that Petitioner would flee the country — Petitioner was not declared a fraudster or economic offender — Constant efforts of settlement of dues — Lookout circular for every borrower incorrect — Lookout Circular quashed. [Art. 226, Constitution of India, O. VI, Rule 17, The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908].

FACTS

The Petitioners were de-boarded from the plane by the Immigration Authority. The Petitioners were informed about the lookout circular issued against them and, thus, the petitioners filed a writ petition challenging the lookout circular. The Petitioner had failed to repay the loan obtained for the expansion of the business. The lookout circular issued by the lender bank was on the apprehension that the petitioner might flee the country and thereby frustrate the whole process of settlement of dues.

HELD     

The Hon’ble Calcutta High Court held that lookout circulars have to be issued in only exceptional cases and cannot be issued at the slightest provocation. The Hon’ble High Court also observed that Petitioner made efforts in the process of settlement of loans by actually paying loans to the other banks in the consortium. Further, the lender bank also had securities of the Petitioner and further realised some of the outstanding by realising the property of the Petitioner. The Hon’ble Court also observed that Petitioner was allowed to travel by the CBI court and there was no complaint with respect to Petitioner not complying with conditions. The court held that Petitioner was not declared a fraud or economic offender and his travel to the UK was for his son’s education. Thus, the lookout circular was quashed.

29. V Narayanasamy vs. Vanchikodi AIR 2023 (NOC) 631 (MAD)
19th April, 2023

Condonation of Delay — Delay of 1,835 days — Negligence of earlier Counsel — Not a sufficient ground — Condonation denied. [S. 5, Limitation Act of 1963].

FACTS

The Petitioner / Plaintiff had filed a suit to declare the title of the property of the Petitioner and a relief of permanent injunction before the lower court. However, the complaint was returned by the Registry for rectifying certain defects and a time of one month was given to the petitioner. The Plaintiff, however, failed to comply with the time period of one month. The lower court dismissed the petition on the ground that no prima facie case was made by the plaintiff and there were no sufficient reasons to condone the delay of the plaintiff. The plaintiff, after a delay of 1,835 days, approached the Madras High Court for the same.

HELD

The Hon’ble Madras High Court held that merely stating that earlier counsel was negligent and did not inform the plaintiff regarding the proceedings of the suit, was not a sufficient reason to condone the delay of 1,835 days. Thus, the Hon’ble High Court upheld the order of the lower court. The Petition was dismissed with no costs.

30. Revanasiddappa & Anr vs. Mallikarjun & Ors Civil Appeal No. 2844 of 2022

1st September, 2023

Hindu Undivided Family — Children born of void or voidable marriage — Have a right in their parent’s share in the Hindu Undivided Family. (Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, S. 16, Hindu Succession Act, 1956, S. 2, S. 6).

FACTS

Section 16(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 provides that even if a marriage is null and void, any child born out of such marriage who would have been legitimate if the marriage had been valid, shall be considered to be a legitimate child. However, Section 16(3) of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955 states such children are entitled to inherit only their parents’ property and will have no right over the other coparcenary shares. On this background, a question of law arose before the three-judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, whether children born out of void or voidable marriage will have a right in their parent’s share in the undivided family property, as Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act 1955 confers legitimacy to children who are born out of invalid marriages.

HELD

The provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 have to be harmonised with the mandate in Section 16(3) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 which indicates that a child who is conferred with legitimacy will not be entitled to rights in or to the property of any person other than the parents. Therefore, the children born of such marriages will be entitled to a right to their parent’s share in the Hindu Undivided Family.

(Editor’s Note: Refer to Laws and Business where this decision and the subject have been discussed).

31. Bhagyanathan Nadar vs. Vishwanathan Nadar and others AIR 2023 (NOC) 568 (KER)

13th April, 2023

Settlement deed — Cancellation unilaterally — No legal effect — Not enforceable by law — A gift deed once executed cannot be revoked. (Specific Relief Act, 1963, S. 34; Transfer of Property Act, 1882, S. 5, S. 123).

FACTS

A settlement deed was executed by the owner of a property in favour of the Original plaintiffs. The deed of settlement did not provide for any power to revoke the settlement. A dispute arose between the parties and the settlement deed was cancelled. The donee / Original Plaintiffs, inter alia, challenged the cancellation deed before the lower court. The lower court, considering all the facts, held in favour of the Original plaintiffs.

On appeal, the first appellate court held in favour of the Original Plaintiffs and dismissed the appeal of the Original Defendants.

On the second appeal

HELD

The Hon’ble Kerala High Court held that the settlement deed was valid and binding. After the acceptance of the gift, if the donor wants to revoke the gift by resorting to Section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the donor will have to institute a suit for the same. A gift can be cancelled only if the gift is the one executed in contemplation of section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and not otherwise. There is no such agreement between the donor and donee to suspend or revoke the gift. It also provides that a gift which parties agree shall be revocable wholly or in part on the mere will of the donor, is void wholly or in part as the case may be. So a gift deed once executed cannot be revoked and even if such contingencies as contemplated under Section 126 of Transfer of Properties Act, 1882 are in existence in the deed, a suit has to be filed for cancellation.

Therefore the settlement deed is valid and the second appeal is dismissed.

सर्वे गुणाः कांचनमाश्रयन्ते !

Friends, in this series, I have been writing on rich thoughts from Sanskrit literature, succinctly put in Subhashitas (shlokas or verses). These are innumerable. I am choosing only those which are popularly used as ‘proverbs’.

The full text of this shloka is: –

यस्यास्ति वित्तम् स नर: कु लीन: |

स पण्डित: स श्रुतवान् गुणज्ञ: |

स एव वक्ता स च दर्शनीय: |

सर्वे गुणाः कांचनमाश्रयन्ते ||

It is taken from Bhartruhari’s Neeti Shatak (नीतिश तक).

This can be interpreted in two ways. In one sense, it says that certain qualities look more graceful when the person possessing these virtues also possesses wealth. However, it is not usually used in this positive sense. The usage is more in a sarcastic sense. That means if a man is rich, all virtues in the world get automatically attributed to him. With money, one is recognised as a meritorious person.

The literal meaning of the shloka is that –

He who has wealth is described as from a high or reputed family (कुलीन). He is a ‘scholar’, a well-read and knowledgeable person, he is reputed and he can recognise talents and merits (पण्डित: श्रुतवान् गुणज्ञ:). He is a brilliant and impressive orator (वक्ता) he alone is ‘handsome’ (दर्शनीय:). In short, he is described as possessing all the virtues, qualities, skills and talents. कांचन (kanchan) means gold. All good qualities are attributed to ‘Gold’!

We come across this situation in many places. It is no doubt true that with money, one can afford many good things. Many comforts and conveniences become affordable to a resourceful person. A rich person can also perform religious things in a better way. In big temples, the ‘special darshan’ of Gods or Idols is available smoothly and quickly by paying higher charges. Higher education, nutritious food, medical treatment — all these become easily available to a rich person. There is nothing inherently wrong with being rich.

The disturbing feature is that by throwing money, nowadays, you can purchase good marks in examinations, get favours in the present judicial system, purchase prizes and awards, manipulate records to show that you are a clean person, etc. You can get a position in the ‘elite class’ merely by your ‘resources’ and not on merit. You can become ‘virtuous’ and a meritorious’. This is markedly visible during elections – be it political elections or that of professionals. By money, one tries to get publicity of qualities which one does not possess; or popularity that one does not deserve.

Today, people with criminal, corrupt or tainted backgrounds can become ‘leaders’, ministers’ or even spiritual leaders on the strength of money!

Against this background, we should be proud of our BCAS, where a member commands respect and reputation only and strictly on the basis of genuine merits. Our endeavour should be to change the disgusting situation in the society. We should spread the message that your virtues, ethics, good qualities, knowledge and talents are the real wealth!

Part B : Some Recent Judgments

I. High Court :

1. CENVAT Credit  :

Non-alcoholic beverage manufacturers of concentrates whether are eligible to avail credit of service tax paid on advertisement, sales promotion, market research and utilise the same against duty liability on the concentrates is the issue involved.

Coca Cola India (P) Ltd. v. CCE, 2009 (22) SIT 130 (Bom.) (HC)

The credit was denied on the ground that advertisements did not relate to concentrates manufactured by the appellant although advertisement expenses formed part of the sale price of the said concentrates manufactured by the appellant. The appellant contended that the advertisement of the brand name with a soft drink had direct relationship with the manufacture of concentrate inasmuch as the demand and consequently, the production of concentrate depended on the consumption of the soft drink and that the advertisement enhanced the market-ability of the concentrate. It was also pleaded by the intervener in the case that service tax like CENVAT was a consumption tax, which had to be borne by the consumer. There was an integral link between the concentrate manufactured by the appellant and the beverage viz. aerated water manufactured by the bottler from it. In this context, the definition of ‘input service’ was analysed in great detail. Further, the Supreme Court’s decision in the case of Bombay Tyres International, 1983 (14) ELT 1896 (SC) was discussed at length. In this case, the Supreme Court held that even though the levy was on the manufacturer, the measure could be with reference to the sale price. Accordingly, it was held that the expense for marketability and selling including advertisement and publicity would form part of the value of goods under assessment. It was also contended by the appellant that revenue never disputed that advertisement of aerated water was an activity related to manufacture and sale of concentrate and that cost of advertisement was relatable to aerated water which formed part of the value of concentrate in the hands of its manufacturer and therefore, it was included in the sale price of concentrate charged by the manufacturer. In this background, the terms ‘means’, includes’, ‘such as’ and ‘business’ used in the definition of ‘input service’ were extensively analysed with reference to several Supreme Court and Larger Bench decisions which inter alia included the following:

Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. CCE, 2003 (158) ELT 552 (SC)

Bharat Co-op. Bank (Mumbai) Ltd. v. Co-op. Bank Employees Union, (2007) 4 SCC 685

Good Year India Ltd. v. Collector of Customs, 1997 I.(95) ELT 450

Doypack Systems (P) Ltd. v. UOI, 1988 (36) ELT (SC).

In summation, what followed from the discussion was that credit was availed on the tax paid on the Input service, which was advertisement and not the contents of the advertisement. Thus, it was observed that it was not necessary that the advertisement must relate to the final product manufactured by the person advertising. So long as the manufacturer can prove that the advertisement services used had an impact on the manufacture of the final product, he could avail the credit of the service tax paid by him. The correlation between the soft drink and the concentrate being direct and proportionate, the advertisement indirectly enhanced the marketability of the concentrate. Once the cost incurred for service was added to the cost assessed, the nexus of the cost of the advertisement service was established with the manufacture of the final product. As such, the expression ‘input service’ was capable of covering indirect use in or in relation to the manufacture of the final product and accordingly, CENVAT credit was available to the manufacturer for payment of duty.

2. Import of service:

Unitech Ltd. v. CST, 2009 (15) STR 385 (Delhi)

The High Court agreed with the issue settled by the Bombay High Court in the case of Indian National Shipowners Association v. UOI, 2009 (13) STR 235 (Bom.) and held that the Revenue could collect tax only upon being invested with due legal authority, an event which occurred only on insertion of S. 66A on 18-4-2006 and as such, the demand confirmed by Tribunal from recipient of taxable service of foreign architect for the period 1-1-2005 till 15-6-2005 was held as done without authority of law and accordingly answered the question of law.

3.Penalty: Power of Commissioner (Appeals) to reduce:

CCE v. Madhuri  Travels, 2009 (15) STR 241 (Bom.)

The short question before the Tribunal was, to examine whether minimum penalty prescribed u/ s.76 could be reduced by Commissioner (Appeals). The Court ruled that considering S. 80 of the Finance Act, 1994 the authority was vested with the power not to impose penalty or reduce the same and matter being covered in the order of the Court in the case of CCE&C Nashik v. D. R. Gade, 2008 (9) STR 348 (Bom.), revenue’s appeal was dismissed.

II. Tribunal:

4.(a) Appeals: Hearing without pre-deposit when divergent views prevail :

SRC Projects P. Ltd. v. CCE, 2009 (15) STR 463 (Tri.-Chennai)

In the instant case, the appellant adjusted excess service tax paid against later liability. The original authority relied on the Single Member Tribunal’s decision of Nelson Org. Mang. P. Ltd. V. CCE, Delhi 2006 (3) STR 503 (Tri.-Del). However, various other decisions including the one in the case of Nima Architect and Valuers V. CCE, 2006 (1) STR 305 (Tri.-Del) decided that excess payment of service tax could be adjusted against later liability of service tax. The Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed the appeal as payment of pre-deposit ordered was not complied with. The Tribunal remanded the matter for fresh decision with a direction that the matter be heard without insisting on pre-deposit in the circumstances when divergent views were held in various Tribunal decisions.

b) Pre-deposit not insisted if tax paid with interest:

    K. Fasteners V. Commissioner of Central Excise, Salem 2009 (15) STR 330 (Tri.-Chennai)
 
The appellant assembled items supplied by its principal. Service tax was demanded under ‘business auxiliary service’ and applicable interest and penalties were levied. The appellant contended the activity as manufacturing yet paid service tax with interest before issuance of Show Cause Notice. The appellant’s appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) was rejected for non-payment of pre-deposit insisted on penalty amount for considering the appeal. While hearing the stay application, appeal itself was taken up by the Tribunal and the matter was remanded to the Commissioner (Appeals) directing that the appeal be heard without pre-deposit as usually when tax is paid with interest, pre-deposit should not be insisted upon.

5. CENVAT Credit :

a) Service tax on construction of compound wall – an input service:

In re: Raymond Zambaiti P. Ltd., 2009 (15) STR 596 (Commr. App)

Appellant availed service tax paid on construction service of compound wall of the factory. CENVAT credit was disallowed on the ground that it was neither used directly for ‘manufacture’ of excisable goods nor for any output service. The appellant contended that the compound w311was part of the factory. Reliance was placed on Apex Court’s decision in the case of South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. V. CCE, 2006 (200) ELT 357 (SC) and according to which ‘precinct’ had to be given broader meaning to include the surrounding area. It was further observed that the definition of ‘input service’ included services used in relation to setting up, modernisation, renovation or repairs of factory and no factory could function without a compound wall to take care of security, environmental protection etc., the construction of compound wall would be input service within the meaning of its inclusive definition and as such, CENVAT credit was considered allowable.

b) Security agency service used for factory admissible:
CCE&C Guntur V. Hindustan Coco-Cola Beverages P. Ltd., 2009 (15) STR 248 (Tri. Bang.)

Services of security agency at the depot and services of pest busters were used in the manufacturing activity of food products for human consumption. The former service used to prevent theft and the latter from contamination were found eligible for CENVAT credit by Commissioner (Appeals) after detailed analysis of ‘input service’ and following precedent of DCM Shriram Consolidated Ltd., 2006 (4) STR 610 (Comrnr. Appl.) Finding no infirmity in the order, plea of department for stay of order was rejected.

c) Substantive benefit not denied on procedural ground:

C&CCE. Vapi  v.  DNH Spinners, 2009 TIOL  1216 CESTAT-AHM

The assessee received invoices from vendors in the name of head office instead of factory. Based on the decisions in the case of Eveready Industries India Ltd., 2007 (219)ELT 333 and Tisco Ltd., 2008 (228) ELT 224, it was held that when the invoices received by head office/registered office were endorsed by the appellant, substantive benefit could not be denied on procedural ground. Incidentally, the appellant being only manufacturing unit, the head office could not be considered as input service distributor and the denial was dismissed.

6. Import  of Service:

a) Limitation: Plea justified when clarity in law is absent:
Ashok Leyland Ltd. v. CCE&ST, LTU Chennai, 2009 (15) STR 289 (Tri. Chennai)

The appellant paid commission to foreign parties during 2004-05 and 2005-06 till October 30, 2005. This was covered as Business Auxiliary Service. However, service was exempt till 9-7-2004 under Notification No. 8/04-ST until it was restricted to services of commission agents relating to agricul-tural produce. The appellant had a bonafide belief as to non-taxability under reverse charge until the introduction of S. 66A on 18-4-2006. Several deci-sions were cited. which inter alia included ‘ Sterlite Industries (India) Ltd. v. CCE, 2008 (11) STR 375), Lohia Strangler v. CCE, 2008 (10) STR 483 (Tri.-Del), Foster Wheeler Energy Ltd. v. CCE, 2007 (7) STR 443. The Tribunal also took a note of the Larger Bench’s decision in the case of Hindustan Zinc Ltd. v. CCE, 2008 (11) STR 338 (Tri.-LB) and distinguished Apex Court’s decision in the case of Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) v. CCE, 2008 (9) STR 3 (SC) cited by the department. The Tribunal found force in the limitation plea as no clarity existed in law at material time as to the issue of applicability of reverse charge provision. It accepted bonafide belief in non-taxability and provided waiver of pre-deposit as part payment was made by the appellant prior to the issuance of Show cause Notice.
 
(b)(i) Import of service (ii) operational assistance for export considered BSS :

Fifth Avenue  v. CST, 2009 (15) STR (Tri.-Chennai)

Service tax was paid by the appellant for the period April 2006 to September 2006 being receiver of operational assistance for execution of export orders to whom payment was made in foreign exchange. Issue involved was two fold: Appellant pleaded to consider the service of operational assistance for export orders as business support service and not business auxiliary service and secondly application of reverse charge was also contended to be applicable only from 18-4-2006 relying on the Bombay High Court’s decision in the case of Indian National Shipowners Association v. UOI, 2009 (13) STR 235 (Bom). Appellant succeeded on merits on both the pleas and therefore, service tax demand for the period prior to 1-5-2005 was set aside.

c. Bathija International v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Salem 2009 (15) STR 249 (Tri. Chennai)

Appellant, an exporter, paid commission to agents abroad. Service tax was demanded under ‘Business Auxiliary Service’ and applicable interest and pen-alties were imposed for the period 12-8-2004 to 27-9-2006. Appellant contended that there being no li-ability prior to introduction of S. 66A on 18-4-2006 and the liability for the subsequent period already having been paid by them, plea was made for remand without further pre-deposit. The matter was remanded without pre-deposit.

7. Refund:    Admissible based  on credit notes:

Professional International Couriers Pvt. Ltd. v. CST, 2009 (15) STR 295 (Tri.-Chennai).

Appellant being co-loader for a courier agency was not required to pay service tax as per Board’s Circular, however inadvertently paid service tax after collecting the same from the principal courier agency and claimed refund. The principal agency was returned the so-collected service tax by way of credit note. The principal agency even reversed the credit taken by them for service tax so paid to the appellant. Relying on the ratio of decision in the case of Shiva Analyticals (I) Ltd. v. CST, 2007 (7) STR 35 (Tri.-Bang.), it was held that in the circumstances when service tax erroneously collected was returned to the customer whether by cheque or by issuing credit note and the fact supported by chartered accountant’s certificate, there being no unjust enrichment,  the refund    was  held  as admissible.

8. Valuation:  Benefit of Notification  No. 12/ 2003 to caterer’s  service:

a. Grand Ashok v. CST, 2009 (15) STR 344 (Tri.-Bang.)

The appellant, an in-flight caterer was called upon to pay service tax on the gross amount of their bill, which included supply of goods and beverages on which VAT was paid. Service tax was paid on handling and transportation. Decision of Imagic Creative P. Ltd. v. CCT, 2008 (9) STR 337 (SC) was discussed at length and relied upon. Apex Court’s decision in case of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. v. UOI, 2006 (2) STR 161 (SC) also was relied upon and it was held that service tax was liable to be paid on outdoor caterer’s service. However on sale of goods, since VAT was paid, service tax could not be levied and the appellant was entitled to benefit under Notification No. 12/2003-ST. Further, appellant being under bonafide belief, longer period of limitation was not invokable.

b. On a similar issue in the case of LSG Sky Chefs (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. CST, 2009 (15) STR 545 (Tri.-Bang.), it was held that sales tax and service tax being mutually exclusive and separate invoices having been issued for supplies of goods, service tax could not be imposed on the portion of the contract on which VAT was paid.

c) Pre-deposit waived: Cost of goods in construction service:

M/s. Sobha Developers Ltd. v. CST, Bangalore 2009 TIOL 1176 CESTAT-Bang.

In case of residential consumption service, the appellant paid service tax on 30% of the contract and VAT was paid on the balance 70% representing value of goods and material. Relying on the same Bench’s final order No. 24/2009 dated 16-1-2009 in case of M/s. LSG Sky Chefs (India) Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and in the case of Wipro GE Medical System Pvt. Ltd., 2008 TIOL 2476 CESTAT-Bang., it was observed that the Board also has issued circular to the effect that the appellant is not liable to pay service tax and the appellant had a strong case of merits based on the fact that where sales tax is paid, service tax would not be demanded and the balance remaining unpaid pre-deposit was waived.

Lecture Meetings

Meeting addressed by Delnaz Mistry, Manager NSDL on Government’s Initiatives on Electronic Credit for Income Tax payments on 26-8-2009 at IMC was well received and appreciated by alL

The Power Point presentation covered all practical issues dealing with TIN, E-payments, Challan Status Enquiry key points for preparation and submission of E-TDS statements,  Quarterly  Statement  Status, Refund  Status, Registration  for view of Form 26AS and benefits  of Form 26 AS.    
        
She brought  out the common errors/inconsistencies and gave practical  hints to overcome  the same and also informed  of new initiatives  planned  which are likely  to be introduced   in near  future.  Members resolved  their  queries  and pointed  out difficulties faced in the question-answer   session.

Vispi Patel, Chartered  Accountant,  addressed  members on Transfer  Pricing Audit  – Documentation and  Benchmarking   in the background   of Recent Assessments/Decisions. He started with  some important  provisions,  and  then  dealt  in detail  with documentation  and Benchmarking  of international transactions   with  associated  enterprises.   He not only covered  important  decisions  on the topic but also dealt with interesting  case study,  so as to have a better  understanding   of the subject, in his inimitable  style,’ which  was  appreciated   by  all those present  in the meeting.        

Accounting & Auditing Committee:

Seminar on Audit of NBFCs on 21-8-2009:

Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) are highly regulated entities and have many statutory /reporting compliances to be adhered to, especially if they are accepting deposits from the public. It is a specialised area of operations and the domain knowledge of the functions, operations, regulations and statutory compliances of NBFCs is necessary for handling matters relating to NBFCs.

NBFCs are fast emerging as an important segment of Indian financial system, performing financial intermediation in a variety of ways, like accepting deposits, making loans and advances, leasing, hire purchase, etc. The working and operations of NBFCs are regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)within the framework of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, and the directions issued by it under the Act.

To make the members and professionals in industry aware about the overall working of the NBFCs, BCAS under its Accounting & Auditing Committee, had organised this full day seminar at Hotel Marine Plaza. It was addressed by four eminent speakers having expert knowledge of the areas covered by each of them. The seminar was well attended by 80 participants and more than half of the participants were from industry, reflecting the importance of the subject.

The seminar was inaugurated by President of BCAS, Ameet Patel who emphasised the need to understand the regulations and compliances for NBFCs properly, so that their audit can be carried out in a meaningful manner.

Later, Chairman of the Accounting & Auditing Committee Himanshu Kishnadwala, touched upon the concept and the importance of topics chosen for the seminar.

The first session was addressed by Archana Mangalagiri, GM, Department of Non-Banking Supervision, RBI. She spoke on the topic of ‘Classification and Regulation for Deposit Acceptance’. Before going into the nitty-gritty of the classification and regulation, she took the participants through the history and build-up of regulatory mechanism over the years, which gave them an in-side view of the purpose of the classification and its regulatory requirements. She also dealt with the supervisory framework undertaken by RBI in the form of on-site inspection, off-site inspection and market intelligence. She further highlighted the importance attached to the role of auditors in the supervisory framework.

The second session was addressed by Jayant Thakur. He dealt with the topic ‘Some Regulatory Aspects for Auditors’. He touched upon the perspectives in NBFCs which are very relevant for the auditors and also shared his knowledge on the working of minimum NOF, what receipts are termed as public deposits, etc.

The third session was addressed by Manish Gujral. He gave a presentation on the topic’ Audit

Procedures and Reporting for NBFCs’. He briefly highlighted the Circulars and Guidelines issued by RBIwhich have to be taken into consideration while preparing financial statements of NBFCs as well as while auditing the same. He very methodically explained the disclosures to be made in the financial statements and also explained the procedures to be performed by the auditors to check the compliances and adequacy of the disclosures.

The last session was addressed by Yogesh Thar. He dealt with the ‘Typical Tax Issues in NBFCs’. He elaborately explained the controversies as to the compliance of Prudential Norms while provisioning of interest and bad debts vis-a-vis the allow ability of those expenses in Income Tax. He also shared his experience on the controversies relating to applica-bility of S. 14A and explanation to S. 73.

Overall, the seminar was a success as the participants got good insight into the important aspects of NBFCs which needs to be complied to have smooth functioning of the NBFCs as well as to carry out a quality audit of NBFCs.

Taxation  Committee:

Seminar on Direct Tax Code:

The Taxation Committee of BCAS had conducted a Special Seminar on Direct Tax Code (DTC) on 28th and 29th August 2009 at Y. B. Chavan Pratishthan, Nariman Point. The seminar received very good response. The total enrolment was 470 participants which included members from the industry and from different parts of the country. The seminar was addressed by prominent speakers namely; Kishor Karia, Pinakin Desai, Gautam Doshi, Rajan Vora, Gautam Nayak, Yogesh Thar and Amrish Shah. The speakers highlighted many of the important aspects of the Direct Tax Code and gave suggestions for making proper representations to the Government on certain contentious and far reaching conse-quences that the DTC may have.

Taxation Committee:

Workshop on ‘How to conduct a Tax Audit’:

The Taxation Committee of BCAS had also conducted a half-day workshop on ‘How to conduct a Tax Audit’ on 4th September 2009 at Wa1chand Hirachand Hall of IMC. The workshop was conducted by CA Himanshu Kishnadwala and CA Anil Sathe, both past presidents of the Society. The speakers covered all the related aspects of tax audit and the participants were immensely benefited with the interactive session. About 270 members benefitted from the workshop. The audience included articled students, tax audit assistants and fresh chartered accountants.

Accounting & Auditing Committee:

Seminar on ‘Implementation of Standard on Quality Control’

A half-day seminar on SQC 1 (Quality Control for Firms that Perform Audits & Related reviews of Historical Financial Information, and Other Assurance & Related Services Engagements) was held on Saturday 5th September 2009 at the premises of the Society. It was attended by 55 participants and addressed by 2 Chartered Accountants in practice, Govind Ahuja and Ramchandran Vasudevan.

The seminar was interactive and covered various nuances of this new Standard on Quality Control which was issued to align quality aspects of Indian Audit practices with the rest of the world. The speakers dealt with important clauses of the standard and in particular covered documentation, monitoring audit assignments, and how a practice can establish quality control mechanism within a medium-sized practice. The participants not only benefitted from the insights of the speakers but received answers to their questions as well.

Miscellaneous

From Published Accounts

1 Disclosures in respect of
derivative losses, corporate debt restructuring, winding up petitions, etc.

WOCKHARDT LIMITED — (15
months ended 31st March 2010)

From Significant Accounting
Policies :

Derivative Financial
Instruments :

The Company uses derivative
financial instruments such as option contracts and interest rate swaps to hedge
its risk associated with foreign currency fluctuations and interest rates.

As per the Institute of
Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) Announcement, accounting for derivative
contracts, other than those covered under AS-11, are marked to market on a
portfolio basis, and the net loss is charged to the income statement. Net gains
are ignored.

From Notes to Accounts :

32. Corporate Debt
Restructuring (CDR) Scheme is effective from April 15, 2009. The outstanding
liabilities of the Company are being restructured under the aegis of Corporate
Debt Restructuring (CDR) Scheme. As required under the Scheme, the Master
Restructuring Agreement (MRA) and other necessary documents have been executed
and effected. The CDR Scheme comprehensively covers the FCCB liabilities and
crystallised derivatives/hedging liabilities.

35. CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
NOT PROVIDED FOR :

(e) Certain
derivative/hedging contracts have been unilaterally cancelled by the banks. The
Company has treated the demand of ‘8,483.22 million (previous year — ‘4,895.24
million) as a contingent liability and has not acknowledged the same as debt,
since the liability cannot be currently ascertained even on a best-effort basis
till the final outcome of the matter.

The Company is of the view
that these are contingent liabilities as these arise from past events and
existence of which will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of
one or more uncertain future events not wholly within control of the Company and
therefore, has not acknowledged these claims against Company as debts.

36. Winding-up petitions are
filed by certain lenders/banks in the Bombay High Court and the Company has
filed affidavit in reply. ICICI Bank, as empowered by CDR and Employee Union
have filed intervention application against the winding-up. The matter is sub-judice
and outcome of which cannot be currently ascertained.

From Auditors’ Report :

5. Without qualifying our
opinion, we draw attention


(a) to Note 32 of the
financial statements, wherein as explained, the Company’s outstanding
liabilities are being restructured under the aegis of Corporate Debt
Restructuring Scheme (CDR) with effect from April 15, 2009 and as required
by the Scheme, the Master Restructuring Agreement (MRA) and other necessary
documents have been executed and are effective.

(b) to Note 36 of the
financial statements, wherein as explained, certain lenders have filed
winding-up petitions against the Company in the Bombay High Court and the
Company has filed affidavit in reply. The matter is sub-judice and outcome
of which cannot be currently ascertained.


The Company’s ability to
continue as a going concern is dependent on the Company being able to
successfully implement the actions proposed in the CDR Scheme and outcome of the
winding-up petitions in favour of the Company.


6. (a) With regard to
outstanding derivative contracts as on March 31, 2010, the premiums
aggregating ‘1,843.79 million are unconfirmed and we are informed that the
relevant documents are being put in place. The consequential effect of
subsequent adjustment/s — if any — on relevant assets and liabilities and
loss for the period is not ascertainable.

(b) In respect of
crystallised derivative losses of ‘11,303.80 million forming part of
‘exceptional items’, we have relied on appropriate written representations.


7. As explained in Note
35(e) to the financial statements, the Company had, on certain derivative
contracts with banks, stopped payment of margins called by the banks. The banks,
based on the Early Termination clause in the agreement, terminated these
contracts and claimed an amount of ‘8,483.22 million, being the loss incurred on
termination of such contracts, which the Company has disputed and not
acknowledged as debt. No provision has been made in the accounts for the above
amount, which has been considered as contingent liability. The consequential
impact upon relevant assets and liabilities and loss for the period is not
ascertainable.

8. In our opinion, and to
the best of our information and according to the explanations given to us,
subject to the matter included in paragraph 6 and 7 above, the effect of which
cannot be currently ascertained, the said accounts give the information required
by the Act in the manner so required and also give a true and fair view in
conformity with the accounting principles generally accepted in India.

From Annexure to Auditor’s
Report :




(vii) In our opinion,
the Company has an internal audit system commensurate with the size and
nature of its business, except that scope needs to be enlarged in respect of
Treasury Operations.

    (ix)(a) In our opinion and according to the information and explanations given to us, considering the loan liabilities being re-structured under the aegis of Corporate Debt Restructuring (CDR) Scheme and Master Restructuring Agreement being signed by lenders, as per the terms of CDR Scheme, there has been no default in repayment of principal and interest to CDR lenders.

    b) With respect to Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds aggregating ‘4,464.02 million which were due for repayment in October 2009, no repayment has been made and as informed, CDR Scheme comprehensively covers FCCB liabilities.

    c) As informed, the Company is in dispute with certain lenders whose liabilities as per books of accounts aggregate ‘1,490.70 million. Further, as stated in Note 35(e), the Company has not acknowledged as debt the demand raised on account of unilateral termination of certain derivative contracts. We are unable to comment in respect of such liabilities whether there has been any default in view of the dispute.

From Directors’ Report?:

With regard to qualification and emphasis of matter contained in the Auditors’ Report, explanations are given below?:

    a) Point 5(a) of Auditor’s Report — Note 32 of Notes to Accounts to the financial statements?:
Corporate Debt Restructuring (CDR) Scheme is effective from April 15, 2009. The Outstanding liabilities of the Company are being restructured under the aegis of Corporate Debt Restructuring Scheme. As required under the Scheme, the Master Restructuring Agreement (MRA) and other necessary documents have been executed and effective. The CDR Scheme comprehensively covers the FCCB liabilities and crystallised derivatives/ hedging liabilities.

    b) Point 5 (b) of Auditor’s Report — Note 36 of Notes to Accounts to the financial statements?:
Winding-up petitions are filed by certain lenders/banks in the Bombay High Court and the Company has filed affidavit in reply. ICICI Bank, as empowered by CDR and Employee Union have filed intervention application against the winding-up. The matters are sub-judice and outcome of which cannot be currently ascertained.

    c) Point 6 of Auditor’s Report?:

The Company has charged the crystallised derivative losses to the Profit & Loss Account and some of the documentation trail is being corelated, for which the Company has formed a task force and necessary actions are being taken.

    d) Point 7 of Auditor’s Report?:
Certain derivatives/hedging contracts have been unilaterally cancelled by banks. The Company has treated the demand of ‘8,483.22 million as a contingent liability and has not acknowledged as debt, since the liability cannot be currently ascertained even on a best-effort basis till the final outcome of the matter. The Company is of the view that these are contingent liabilities as these arise from past events and existence of which will be confirmed only by the occurrence or non-occurrence of one or more uncertain future events not wholly within control of the Company and therefore, has not acknowledged these claims against the Company as debts.

    e) Point (vii) of Annexure to Auditor’s Report?:

The Company has an internal audit system which it believes to be commensurate to the size of its operations. The Company has already commenced the process of further strengthening the internal audit system to enlarge its scope in respect of Treasury Operations. Further, as per the CDR Scheme the Company cannot execute any new derivative transactions (excluding forwards strictly for hedging purposes for a maximum period of 180 days) without prior approval of CDR Empowered Group and accordingly the treasury operations of the Company have been significantly reduced.

Miscellaneous

Creation of business reconstruction reserve to adjust impairment of fixed assets, goodwill on consolidation and other costs

    Hindalco Industries Ltd.

    — (31-3-2009) (standalone)

    From Notes to Accounts :

(a) The Company has formulated a scheme of financial restructuring to deal with various costs associated with its organic and inorganic growth plan. The recent economic downturn particularly in the commodity space is also expected to result in impairment/diminution in value of certain assets/investments. Accordingly, as per a scheme of Arrangement under Sections 391 to 394 of the Companies Act 1956 (‘the Scheme’) between the Company and its equity shareholders approved by the High Court of Judicature of Bombay, a separate reserve account titled as Business Reconstruction Reserve (‘BRR’) has been created by transferring balance standing to the credit of Securities Premium Account of the Company for adjustment of certain expenses as prescribed therein. Accordingly, Rs.8,647.37 crores has been transferred to BRR and following expense incurred during the year have been adjusted against the same as per the Scheme :

(i) Impairment of fixed assets amounting Rs.66.80 crores, net of deferred tax of Rs.34.40 crores (refer Note no. 24 in this schedule).

(ii) Certain costs amounting to Rs.0.18 crores in connection with the Scheme.

(b) Had the Scheme not prescribed aforesaid treatment, the impact would have been as under:

(i) in the Profit and Loss Account

From Auditors’ Report:

6. Without qualifying our opinion, attention is drawn to the following:

b) As per Scheme of Arrangement u/ s.391 to 394 of the Companies Act 1956 approved by the Honourable High Court of Mumbai vide its Order dated 29th June, 2009 the company has been allowed to create Business Reconstruction Reserve by transferring balance standing to the credit of Securities Premium Account for adjusting certain expenses as defined in the scheme. Accordingly, the management of the Company, during the year has identified and adjusted Impairment of Fixed Assets amounting to Rs.66.80 crores (Net of Tax) and certain expenses amounting to Rs.0.18 crores against Business Reconstruction Reserve. This has resulted in the profit before tax and profit after tax for the year being higher by Rs.101.38 crores and Rs.66.98 crores respectively and deferred tax asset being lower by Rs.34.40 crores. Refer Note No. 22 in Schedule 19.

From Directors’ Report:

Scheme of arrangement:

The Company has formulated a scheme of financial restructuring to deal with various costs associated with its organic and inorganic growth plan. The recent economic downturn particularly in the commodity space is also expected to result in impairment/diminution in value of certain assets/investments. The Board of Directors of the Company at its meeting held on 14th February, 2009 had approved said Scheme of Arrangement. Accordingly, as per the Scheme of Arrangement under Sections 391 to 394 of the Companies Act 1956 (‘the Scheme’) between the Company and its equity shareholders approved by the High Court of Judicature of Bombay, a separate reserve account titled as Business Reconstruction Reserve (‘BRR’) has been created by transferring balance standing to the credit of Securities Premium Account of the Company for adjustment of certain expenses as prescribed therein. Accordingly, Rs.8,647 crares has been transferred to BRR and Rs.67 crores in standalone accounts and Rs.4,617 crores in Consolidated accounts have been adjusted against the same as per the Scheme during the year.

HINDALCO INDUSTRIES LTD. – (31-3-2009) (consolidated)

 From Notes to Accounts:

8.(a) The Company has formulated a scheme of financial restructuring to deal with various cost!’ associated with its organic and inorganic growth plan: The recent economic downturn particularly in the commodity space is also expected to result in impairment/ diminution in value of certain assets Zinvestments, Accordingly, as per a scheme of Arrangement under sections 391 to 394 of the Companies Act 1956 (‘the Scheme’) between the Company and its equity shareholders approved by the High Court of judicature of Bombay, a separate reserve account titled as Business Reconstruction Reserve (‘BRR’) has been created by transferring balance standing to the credit of Securities Premium Account of the Company for adjustment of certain expenses as prescribed therein. Accordingly, Rs.8,647.37 crores has been transferred to BRR and following expenses incurred during the year have been adjusted against the same as per the Scheme:

    i) Impairment of goodwill amounting Rs.3,597.30 crores arises on consolidation of Novelis Inc. while preparing consolidated accounts of the Company.

    ii) Impairment of fixed assets amounting Rs.111.30 crores (net of deferred tax of Rs.34.40 crares).

    iii) Interest and Finance Charges amounting Rs.544.47 crores on loan taken by A. V. Minerals (Netherlands) B. V., subsidiary of the Company, for acquisition of Novelis Inc. by the Company.

    iv) Costs amounting to Rs.363.62 crores in connection with exiting business.

    v) Certain costs amounting to Rs.0.18 crores in connection with the Scheme.

b) Had the Scheme not prescribed aforesaid treatment, the impact would have been as under:
    
i) in the Profit and Loss Account


From Auditors’ Report:

5. Without qualifying our opinion, attention is drawn to the following:

c) As per Scheme of Arrangement u/s.391 to 394 of the Companies Act 1956 approved by the Honourable High Court of Mumbai vide its Order dated 29th June, 2009 the company has been allowed to create Business Reconstruction Reserve by transferring balance standing to the credit of Securities Premium Account for adjusting certain expenses as defined in the scheme. Accordingly, the management of the Company, during the year has identified and adjusted Impairment of Goodwill in a subsidiary amounting to Rs. 3,597.30 crores, Impairment of Fixed Assets amounting to Rs. 111.30 crores (Net of Tax) and certain expenses amounting to Rs. 908.27 crores against Business Reconstruction Reserve. This has resulted in loss for the year before tax being understated by Rs. 4,651.27 crores and profit for the year after tax of Rs.485.31 crores of the group would have been converted in a loss for the year of Rs. 4,165.96 crores. Refer Note No. 8 in Schedule 20.

Section B : Miscellaneous

New Page 1

Suggestion of Expert Advisory Committee of ICAI for AS-22 not
followed pending revision of AS-22 by ICAI


Power Finance Corporation Ltd.

— (31-3-2008)

From Notes to Accounts :



20. The Deferred Tax Assets/Liabilities have been created
in terms of the Accounting Standard 22 issued by the Institute of Chartered
Accountants of India (ICAI) since the year it became applicable to the
company, i.e., 2001-02 except on account of ‘Special reserve created
and maintained under Section 36(1)(viii) of the Income Tax Act’ on which the
DTL was created by debiting profit & loss account for 2004-05 and by charging
revenue reserve for 2001-02 to 2003-04. However, PFC has taken up the issue
for total withdrawal of DTL on Special Reserve with the ICAI and with the
Ministry of Corporate Affairs. The Institute in its letter dated 4-4-2007
stated that the Accounting Standard Board examined AS-22, Accounting for Taxes
on Income, in the light of the opinion of the Expert Advisory Committee. It is
further stated that “the Board decided to take up the revision of the standard
on the lines of the corresponding IAS, namely, IAS-12, Income taxes, as a part
of its convergence with IFRS project. It was argued that since IAS-12 is based
on the ‘balance sheet approach’ as against ‘income statement approach’ on
which the existing AS-22 is based, the problem being encountered by the
company may not arise”. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs also endorsed the
letter issued by ICAI to PFC.

In view of this, rectification as suggested by the ICAI
vide their letter dated 31-1-2006 regarding creation of DTL on Special Reserve
created and maintained under Section 36(1)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961
for the period 2001-02 to 2003-04 by charging to P&L Account and crediting the
reserves by Rs.539.39 crores has not been carried out and pending revision of
AS-22, the Company has maintained status quo and continued the practice
of creating the DTL on the Special Reserve created and maintained under
Section 36(1)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

 


From Auditors’ Report :

Attention is drawn to the following Notes in Schedule 18 :

(j) Note No. 20 regarding the suggestion of the Expert
Advisory Committee of the ICAI suggesting the rectification by creating the
Deferred Tax Liability on ‘Special Reserve created and maintained’ under
Section 36(1)(viii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for the period 2001-02 to
2003-04, by charging the Profit & Loss Account (Prior Period Items) and
crediting the Reserves by Rs.539.39 crores, has not been carried out by the
Company pending the decision of the ICAI on the Company’s request for total
withdrawal of provision of AS-22 regarding creation of Deferred Tax Liability
for the Special Reserve Created and Maintained under Section 36(1)(viii) of
the Income-tax Act, 1961. Pending the decision of the ICAI, the Company has
not given effect to the suggestion of the Expert Advisory Committee of the
ICAI.

 


Intangible assets, etc. acquired under a Business Transfer
Agreement adjusted against General Reserve pursuant to High Court Order

Blue Star Ltd. — (31-3-2008)

From Notes to Accounts :



7. The Company has acquired the electrical contracting business of Naseer Electricals Private Ltd. (NEPL) under a business purchase agreement on a slump sale basis for Rs.48,09.77 lakhs (including Rs.5,00.00 lakhs held in Escrow account till the conditions stipulated in the said agreement are fulfilled) with effect from January 24, 2008. After adjusting the value of tangible fixed assets acquired of Rs.1,16.65 lakhs, the balance consideration along with the incidental expenses have been allocated towards various intangible assets and goodwill as valued by an independent valuer as detailed hereunder :
8.    As per the Scheme of Arrangement approved by the shareholders at the Extra-ordinary General Meeting held on March 4,2008 and duly approved by the Hon’ble High Court at Bombay vide its order dated April 11, 2008, the Company has, in accordance with the accounting treatment prescribed therein, adjusted the following amounts against the General Reserve of the Company:

(a)    The intangible assets of Rs.41,18.62 lakhs and Goodwill of Rs.8,32.32Iakhs arising on acquisition of electrical contracting busi-ness of NEPL.

(b)    Loss of Rs.35.10 lakhs on sale of 3,98,000 equity shares of Blue Star Design & Engineering Ltd.


3. Qualification  in Auditors’  Report  on Consolidated  Financial  Statements

NAVIN FLUORINE INTERNATIONAL LTD. – (31-3-2008)

From Auditors’ Report:

5.    Attention is invited to the following in Schedule 17, out of which points i and ii were also the subject matter of our report similarly modified in the previous year:

(i)    Note 3.a, regarding accounts of the joint venture company not having been consolidated which is in contravention of the provisions of AS-27, ‘Financial Reporting of Interests in Joint Ventures’.

(ii)    Note 16, regarding non-accounting of rent/ recovery of expenses of Rs.Nil; aggregate to date as at the year end, Rs.108.83 lacs (previous year, Rs.Nil; aggregate to date as at the previous year end, Rs.108.83 lacs);.

(iii)    Note 12, regarding recognition of deferred tax asset of Rs.285.94 lacs (previous year, Rs.Nil) by the associate in respect of unabsorbed depreciation and carry-forward losses.

We further report that without considering item 5(i) above, the effect of which on the financial statements for the year ended 31st March 2008 and on the corresponding figures in the previous year ended 31st March, 2007, could not be determined, had the observation made by us in item 5(ii) and (iii) been considered, there would have been a loss of Rs.145.53 lacs, as against the reported profit of Rs.56.83 lacs (previous year, a profit of Rs.1,719.09 lacs, as against the reported figure of profit of Rs.1622.47 lacs), reserves and surplus would have been Rs.18,091.65 lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs.18,294.01 lacs (as at 31st March, 2007, Rs.18,450.90 lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs.18,354.28 lacs), investments would have been 1,464.55 lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs.1,750.49 lacs, loans and advances would have been Rs.6,227.21 lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs.6,118.38 lacs (as at 31st March, 2007, Rs.3,124.99lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs. 3,016.16 lacs) and provisions would have been Rs. 842.52 lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs.817.27lacs (as at 31st March, 2007, Rs.880.65 lacs, as against the reported figure of Rs.868.44 lacs).

Subject to the foregoing………….   

From The President

From The President

Dear Esteemed Readers,

Well, by the time you receive this message, the majority of
you folks will be relaxing from post September tax work. We, especially CAs,
need to learn to relax. After a day’s hard work (often putting in more than 10
hours), it is not uncommon to find a CA carrying some work to do at home. The
reason for this state of affairs is that we are unable to work in water-tight
compartments. In my childhood, I had learnt a poem, “Work while you work,
play while you play, it is way to be happy and gay”. Unfortunately, we not only
take work home but also whilst on vacation. As a result, we return home
exhausted despite the vacation. Let us stop being workaholics and start living,
which is all about balancing. In the words of Brian Dyson, CEO of Coca
Enterprises (1959-1994), “Imagine life as a game in which you are juggling five
balls in the air. You name them – work, family, health, friends, and spirit –
and you’re keeping all of these in the air. You will soon understand that work
is a rubber ball. If you drop it, it will bounce back. But the other four balls
– family, health, friends, and spirit are made of glass. If you drop one of
these, they will be irrevocably scuffed, marked, nicked, damaged, or even
shattered. They will never be the same. You must understand that and strive for
balance in your life”.


It reminds me of one of the seven habits of highly effective
people, as discussed by Stephen Covey, i.e. “Begin with the end in mind”. Let us
work toward our goals in different areas of life rather than concentrating on
only one area of life.

Generally, CAs and taxmen are perceived to be practical,
being occupied with so-called boring figure work. They are perceived to be
non-creative, being away from art and culture. Labeling a class of people one
way or the other is not appropriate. Art and culture is a matter of individual
traits and tastes. The Income tax Department is celebrating 150 years of its
existence, to commemorate which, a unique Art Exhibition was organized at the
Prince of Wales Museum in Mumbai during 24-27 Sep. 2010. I had the privilege of
witnessing the creativity of the IT officials. The Art Exhibition displayed
paintings, essays, books and poetry— all the work of taxmen. It was heartwarming
to see the different facets of the taxmen’s collective personality. We were
already aware of the word picture (by delivering well-articulated assessment
orders) by some smart taxmen; this Art Exhibition showed the picture painted.
Our compliments to one and all artistic taxmen and also to the Income tax
Department.

Today, we are living in an era of all-pervading negativity.
Television channels, in their quest to beat each other, are sensationalizing
news and scaring people. For TV Channels, every news is breaking news. Most of
the news is picked up from police files resulting in more of a crime reporting.
Flood or drought, fire or earthquake, any small or big incident is projected as
the beginning of an end of the world i.e. Pralay, in 2012. As it is,
India is struggling with floods in North India, unrest in the Kashmir valley,
attacks by Maoists, terror threats and epidemics such as Malaria, Dengue and
Swine Flu. To add to this, irresponsible TV Channels, and some newspapers are
thoughtlessly adding fuel to the fire. More than natural calamities, this
country suffers from perverted TV serials, which tend to sully our
national/social fabric. The aam junta tries to find solutions to their problems
through TV serials; what is worse is that they (especially teenagers) identify
themselves with the stars of these serials. This is dangerous, as extra marital
affairs, cheating and betraying in families are the corner stones of most of the
prime time TV serials. In the name of reality shows, all unreal things are
projected which is socially detrimental. It is a patent misuse of freedom of
expression. Well, if the power of media is rightly and wisely used, it can make
politicians and bureaucrats accountable and provide good entertainment to tired
souls. The media being the most powerful medium of communication and capable of
influencing the masses, should exercise restraint of the highest order and
discharge its social responsibility.

We must contribute our might to spread positivity. The Right
to Information Act is a powerful weapon in the hands of ordinary citizens to get
justice and instil accountability in public servants.

The much awaited Direct Tax Code (DTC) was introduced in
Parliament on 30th August, 2010 in its new avatar. Critics say it is old
wine in a new bottle. After a lot of hue and cry about the first version, the
second version of the DTC seems to be taking care of many
objections/representations made in the first draft. However, the amendments are
falling short of expectations. Any way, the law is unfolding and the Government
would welcome suggestions. Let us hope that representations from professional
bodies and trade associations are given due consideration before the DTC becomes
the law. Stringent General Anti Avoidance Regulations (GAAR) should not be
introduced without proper checks and balances lest they become a handle to
harass innocent tax payers. Provisions relating to Safe Haven and the likes
should be embedded in GAAR to provide relief to Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises (MSMEs). “Place of effective Management” should be clearly defined
in order to avoid litigation in respect of determination of residential status
of foreign companies. Notwithstanding these irritants, CBDT deserves kudos for
simplification of the tax law (DTC) to be effective from 1st Aril 2012.

Coming back to the BCAS, last month, there was a lull in the
society’s activities as it was busy season. However, a few notable events took
place such as the workshop on “How to Conduct a Tax Audit”, addressed by Messrs
Anil Sathe and Himanshu Kishnadwala, and a Lecture Meeting on Transfer Pricing
by Vispi Patel. Two Webinars were held on the subject of “Introduction to XBRL”
on 11th and 22nd September 2010. The Webinars elicited good participatory
response from local and outstation members as well as those staying overseas.
The Webinars were conducted by Vinod Kashyap. It was the first time such a
Webinar was organised, thanks to the painstaking efforts by the “Infotech and 4i
Committee”. XBRL stands for Extensible Business Reporting Language, which is a
language for electronic communication of business and financial data, which is
revolutionising business reporting around the world. It offers major benefits to
all those who have to create, transmit, use or analyse such information. XBRL
India is facilitated by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI).
Members of XBRL India include various regulators such as RBI, IRDA, SEBI, MCA,
BSE and NSE. CAs can play a role in the implementation of XBRL and this may well
be a new avenue of practice.

Last but not the least, the countdown has begun for the
Commonwealth Games. Let us hope that our athletes bring back to India its lost
glory.

And now that the verdict on the Ayodhya dispute is finally
out, let us pray that people will respect it and maintain communal harmony – the
core essence of India’s cultural heritage.

Tathastu! Amen! So Be
It!


From The President

From the President

Dear BCAJ Lovers,

By the time you get this issue of BCAJ in your hands, the
busy month of September would have been over and you would be a bit relaxed.
The wonderful festival of Diwali would be round the corner. I wish all readers
a peaceful, joyous and memorable festive season.

The views expressed by me regarding today’s students in my
last month’s President’s Page have touched a cord in many readers’ hearts. I
have received calls from several persons including a past president of ICAI
complimenting me on accurately bringing out the plight of students. I am glad
that readers are alive to this serious issue. I hope that more and more people
take a lead in guiding and mentoring the children of today so that we have
better human beings, capable professionals and able leaders tomorrow.

The elections to the regional and central councils of ICAI
have now been announced. The first week of December will see hotly contested
elections. If the past is anything to go by and if reports that are trickling
in are to be believed, the elections this time will see many more candidates
and intense campaigning across the country. Elections in our country – be they
political ones or the ones that take place in professional and other
organisations like ICAI, generally have one feature in common – a lot of
people interested in contesting and very few people interested in voting.
Candidates cry themselves hoarse in inviting, cajoling, imploring voters, to
come out and vote. And voters simply stay at home. This year too, most of us
would have by now been approached by someone or the other, who is planning to
contest the elections. Already, the media of sms, e-mails, facebook, groups,
etc., have started being used by some such persons. Unfortunately, the
enthusiasm shown by the contestants is not shared by the voters. Every
election sees a dismal voter turnout. Not even 50% of professional voters in
the country deem it fit to spend a few minutes to fulfil their moral duty to
go and vote. Why does this happen? First of all, what is it that attracts so
many people to contest the ICAI elections ?

If I don’t have the time and inclination to vote, I have no
moral right to complain about the leaders that get elected. This holds good
for every one of us. We must vote. The recent developments at the ICAI, which
all of us are well aware of, in view of the widely circulated e-mails, are
highly deplorable. When elections are round the corner, it offers all of us a
golden opportunity to set our house in order. Let us all carefully analyse the
credentials of each candidate and then vote for the most competent and
deserving one(s). Hopefully, the ICAI elections would not be fought on caste
and communal lines. Hopefully, the results of elections would not be dependent
on the power of influential candidates backed by large firms or political
parties. Hopefully, ICAI will create a platform for all candidates to appear
before their voters and present their views and thereby allow voters to judge
for themselves whom to vote for and whom not to vote for. Last time, the BCAS
had decided to organise an event titled “Know your Candidates”. However, the
same could not be held on account of the restrictions placed by ICAI on the
candidates appearing in such programmes. This is most unfortunate and I
strongly urge the Central Council to reconsider this particular issue and, if
necessary, to amend its election guidelines to allow candidates to meet their
voters on a common platform. Even during the political elections, we have seen
such programmes being held. It is not enough for ICAI to merely send a
standard booklet giving academic and other achievements of the various
candidates. It is the need of the hour for ICAI to permit the voters to
collectively meet the candidates on a common platform and let the voters judge
the candidates on the basis of personal interaction. In fact, if our leaders’
yoga sessions could be telecast on a TV channel, why not a panel discussion of
the candidates? The future of our profession is dependent on its leaders. If
our leaders are not worthy, our future is hazy.

I urge every member of our Institute who reads the BCAJ to
wake up and take the ensuing elections seriously. Let us rise to the occasion
and vote this time to make a difference. Let us seriously consider the merits
of each candidate and then elect only good, competent and selfless people. Let
us question every person who approaches us for our vote as to why he/she is
contesting the elections. There have always been lurking allegations about
using one’s position in the Council for obtaining empanelment and allotment of
bank and PSU audits or for helping others in doing so. The ICAI must bring out
a clarification on this issue. The ICAI members have every right to question
the ICAI as well as its leaders. After all, that is what democracy is all
about. Several of the sitting and aspiring Council members are my friends. To
all of them as well as to all others, my message is simple and common – prove
your worth and genuineness to me if you want my vote. There is also one
controversial matter that has been at the back of my mind for a long time. I
would like to vote only for the candidate who promises me that he/she would
strive for getting BCAS programmes recognised for CPE credit purposes. This of
course is something which cannot be decided by one or two council members.
However, I have yet to come across any candidate who has actually promised to
make efforts in this behalf. Where there is a will, there is a way. I am
searching for the person with the will. Many BCAS members whom I meet, often
ask me why the BCAS programmes are not recognised for CPE credits even though
they are excellent in terms of quality. My answer to them is to go and ask
this question to the ICAI council members. Maybe, now that elections are round
the corner, it would be a good time to ask this question. This applies with
equal force to programmes organised by other sister organisations which have
been doing fantastic work for their members.

The mystery of the Direct Tax Code is slowly getting known
to all of us. By now, several programmes have been held across the nation on
this subject. One hopes that this Finance Minister reads the Representations
that are made. One also hopes that the large number of mistakes, problems and
anomalies that have been discovered will be rectified when the final version
is unveiled.

The Accounting and Auditing Committee of the BCAS has come
up with an ambitious plan of an IFRS month in December, 2009. We would be
focussing on IFRS during that month. The enthusiastic members of the committee
are excitedly planning for the same. Plans for the annual RRC are also in
progress. You will read more about all these in the days to come.

The BCAS has always excelled in arranging programmes on
technical matters. I would now like the organisation to also help and guide
its members in running their own offices more efficiently and in a better
manner. Practice Management is something that most small and medium sized
firms do not pay much attention to. In the September issue of BCAJ, there is an article on HR. I am hopeful that we will be able to carry more such articles in future on the subject. If smaller firms are serious about facing the challenges from larger firms and global firms, they need to drastically improve their internal systems and processes. BCAS would play the role of a catalyst in this matter, as usual. I invite your feedback on the same.

Have a great festive season.

Sincerely yours,

Ameet Patel
President

From The President

From The President

Dear Professional Colleagues,

When this issue of the Journal reaches you, the deadline for
completion of audits and filing of returns will have just passed. You, along
with your partners, colleagues and staff, must have burnt midnight oil (in some
parts of the country literally) to comply with this deadline. You will have
placed in the hands of your clients, and other stake holders, your reports which
are expected to contain your opinion as to whether the financial statements show
a true & fair view and whether the particulars which you have verified are true
and correct.

The audit process which you follow, and which culminates in
your report is expected to comply with certain assurance standards. The accounts
which are audited have to be compliant with accounting standards. Over the past
few years we have seen, in many forums, protracted debate over the extent of
disclosure required in the accounts. The tenor of discussion often is that if an
opinion need not be expressed according to the letter of the law or if a
disclosure is not required, such an opinion should not be expressed or a
disclosure should not be made.

According to the classical definition of the role of an
auditor, he is required to express his opinion as to whether on the basis of
generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), the financial statements show a
true and fair view. Today these GAAPs have to be read with accounting standards.
In respect of corporate entities the accounts have to comply with the standards
prescribed by the Central Government in consultation with the National Advisory
Committee on Accounting Standards. Non-corporate assessees have to follow most
of the accounting standards prescribed by the Institute of Chartered Accountants
of India. Non-compliance attracts a qualification in the auditor’s report. Some
of these standards are so complex that Chartered Accountants have to debate
interpretation of some of their aspects. In most cases neither the owner/
promoter nor his ill-equipped accountant understands the true import of these
standards. In this scenario, General Purpose Financial Statements at times lose
their purpose of communicating the state of affairs to the reader.

I am conscious of the fact that businesses have become global
and competitive. Measurement and reporting standards have to have an
international acceptance, since the financial statements of entities doing
global business have to be interpreted by users in different countries. However,
the number of entities carrying on such scale of activity is minuscule compared
to the number of entities whose accounts are subjected to audit under one
statute or the other. My only concern is that in the quest for standardisation
and perfection, we should not make presentation of accounts and related
disclosure requirements so complex that the expectation gap between what the
society expects from us and what we deliver becomes so large that we cannot
bridge it.

The accounting standards and reporting requirements mandated
by various statements have the objective of standardising the measurement of
accounting estimates, various disclosures and the manner in which opinions are
expressed by auditors. This is done to make financial statements by various
entities comparable and understood by all users in the same way. However, in
trying to achieve this objective, if both, financial statements and the reports
thereon become lengthy and incomprehensible, it defeats that very objective.
Once this happens, these statements and reports are put away for future
reference but are rarely referred to. It would be interesting to note that the
tax audit report has been with us for twentyfour years. Yet a note from the CAG
dated 31st July 2008 exhorts revenue officials to read this report and in the
same breath asks action to be taken against professionals who have issued
erroneous reports.

Over the years, regulatory authorities, if I may use the
term, ‘outsourced’ responsibility to the auditor. The auditor is required to
comment on or report on aspects which are inherently the domain of the auditee
or the regulatory authorities. With the onus on the auditor being increased
substantially, he may tend to comply with the letter of a regulation rather than
the spirit. He may side-step the regulation, rule or reporting requirement, if
he can do so with some justification and adequate protection. Often more
attention is paid to documentation and working papers, rather than verifying
accounting records to form an opinion. Audit then becomes a compliance ritual
and the soul of audit which is an expression of opinion in regard to the true
and fair view, is lost. It is this opinion that a reader is looking for. The
world accepts that accounts are essentially estimates. The assurance that it
expects from us is that these estimates are made bonafide and in compliance with
the generally accepted accounting principles. If there is something amiss, the
attention of the user must be drawn to that fact. This assurance or if I can use
the term ‘blowing of the whistle’, must be in the simplest form.

I think there is a need to extensively deliberate upon these
issues and find solutions quickly. The International Accounting Standards Board
(IASB) is already in the process of formulating IFRS for SMEs. The only issue is
what constitutes a small and medium enterprise would be materially different in
different countries. If compliance is to be encouraged, India should take the
lead in formulating these simpler standards for SMEs. Stringent measurement and
reporting standards should be restricted to those entities where the users of
those statements and reports can understand them and appreciate their nuances.

If the reports are for different users with different
objectives, distinct formats of both financial statements and reports can be
contemplated. There will be problems in doing this but I am sure they can be
sorted out. For a vast majority of entities, especially non-corporate, the
disclosure requirements should be far simpler as should be the reporting
formats. This will strengthen the faith of the public in our profession which
has been repeatedly shaken in the recent past due to failures of corporate
giants.

All what I have said above actually passed through my mind
during this September. I felt that before we commence audits for the new year it
would be appropriate to leave my thoughts on the subject with you.

This year the advancement of the due date has left us free to enjoy the
festival. I take this opportunity to wish all readers and their families a happy
Diwali and a very prosperous and happy new year !

Anil Sathe

ICAI And Its Members

1. Tax audit provision :

    (i) The threshold limit of total sales/turnover/gross receipts for the purposes of tax audit u/s.44 AB in case of business has been increased from `40 lac to `60 lac from A.Y. 2011-12. In case of the profession, the said limit has been increased from `10 lac to `15 lac.

    (ii) The Direct Tax Code Bill, 2010, proposes to provide in S. 88 that the threshold limit of total sales/turnover/gross receipts for business for tax audit shall be increased from `60 lac to `1 crore. In case of the profession, the said limit is proposed to be increased from `15 lac to `25 lac. The new provision will come into force from F.Y. 2012-13 if the DTC Bill is passed by the Parliament with the above provision.

    (iii) U/s.314(86) of DTC, 2010, the due date for filing the return of income by an assessee, who does not have business income, is proposed to be advanced from the existing 31st July to 30th June. Similarly, the due date for filing the return in cases of companies and other assessees is proposed to be advanced from 30th September to 31st August. Therefore, from 2013 the Tax Audit Report will have to be given by 31st August, 2013.

    (iv) S. 271B provides for levy of penalty for non-compliance with the provisions of S. 44AB at the rate of ½% on total sales, turnover or gross receipts. The maximum penalty has been increased from `1 lac to `1.50 lac from A.Y. 2011-12.

    (v) Proposed S. 232 of the Direct Tax Code Bill, 2010, provides that the minimum penalty shall be `1 lac and the maximum penalty will be `2 lac w.e.f. F.Y. 2012-13 for non-compliance with the provisions of S. 88 to get the tax audit report before the due date.

2. Know your ethics :

The Ethical Standards Board of ICAI has discussed some ethical issues at page 394 of September, 2010, issue of C.A. Journal as under :

(i) Whether a member of the Institute in practice is liable for professional misconduct if he does not follow the direction given by the Council or an appropriate Committee or on behalf of any of them, to the incoming auditors not to accept the appointment as auditors, in the case of unjustified removal of the earlier auditors ?

Ans. : In exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (1) of Part II of the Second Schedule to the CA Act, the Council of ICAI issued General Guidelines, 2008 which specify that a member of the Institute in practice shall follow the direction given by the Council or an appropriate Committee or on behalf of any of them, to him being the incoming auditor(s) not to accept the appointment as auditor(s), in the case of unjustified removal of the earlier auditor(s).

(ii) Can the auditor revise his audit report ?

Ans. : The Council has issued a ‘Guidance Note on Revision of the Audit Report’ in booklet form. The auditor can revise his audit report in the situations and circumstances mentioned therein.

(iii) What is the status of a Chartered Accountant who is a salaried employee of a Chartered Accountant in practice or a firm of such Chartered Accountants ?

Ans. : An associate or a fellow of the Institute who is a salaried employee of a Chartered Accountant in practice or a firm of such Chartered Accountants shall, notwithstanding such employment, be deemed to be in practice for the limited purpose of the training of article assistants. He may hold Certificate of Practice, but he is not entitled to perform attest functions w.e.f. 1-4-2005.

(iv) Can a member in practice be Promoter/Promoter Director of a company ?

Ans. : There is no bar to a member in practice becoming a promoter/signatory to the Memorandum and Articles of Association of any company. For becoming such promoter/signatory, members are not required to obtain specific permission of the Council.

(v) Can such a Promoter/Promoter Director of a company be Director Simplicitor of that company ?

Ans. : There is also no bar for such a Promoter/Signatory becoming Director Simplicitor of that company, irrespective of whether the objects of the company include areas which fall within the scope of the profession of Chartered Accountants. In this case also, specific permission of the Council is not required.

(vi) Can a member in practice be a sleeping partner in a family business concern ?

Ans. : A member in practice can be a sleeping partner in a family business concern, provided he takes specific permission from the Council in terms of Regulation 190A of CA Regulations.

(vii) Can a member who is in part-time/full-time employment apply for Certificate of Practice and perform audit ?

Ans. : He cannot perform the audit although he can apply for Certificate of Practice.

(viii) What should be the size of the signboard for the office ?

 Ans. : With regard to the size of the signboard for his office that a member can put up, it is a matter in which the members should exercise their own discretion and good taste. The size of the signboard should be reasonable. Use of glow signs or lights on large-sized boards as is used by traders or shopkeepers would not be proper. A member can have a name board at the place of his residence with the designation of a Chartered Accountant, provided it is a name plate or name board of an individual member and not of the firm.

3. EAC Opinion: Treatment of liquidated damages payable for delay in commissioning of plant :

    Facts :

A limited company having its registered office in India is a group member of a transnational player in the global gases and engineering industry. The company’s gases division is engaged in the manufacture and sale of industrial, medical and special gases to customers across industries.

The company has entered into one such Long Term Agreement (LTA) dated 31st May, 2006 for supply of industrial gases to a customer by installing an air separation plant (the plant) at the customer’s steel works premises on Build-Own-Operate (BOO) basis. As per one of the clauses of the ‘general conditions’ of the agreement, the company is liable to pay ‘late start liquidated damages’ to the customer if there is a delay in the commencement of gas supply from the plant after the target commencement date due to the company’s fault and the customer is ready to consume gas at its expanded steel-making facility.

As per the agreement, the target commencement date was 31st March, 2008, being the date on which the company estimated that it would be able to start fulfilling its obligation to supply gas from the plant. However, due to delay by the main equipment supplier of the plant and other related problems at site, the company was not ready to commission the plant and commence supplies on the target commencement date and instead, was ready for supply for gases only in November 2008. At this stage, due to the economic downturn, the customer requested to further delay the start-up of the plant which was finally commissioned in February 2009.

The company is now in the process of negotiating a settlement with the customer for the delays in plant commissioning on both its own as well as on the customer’s part. As a result of such negotiation, the company will have to pay ‘late start liquidated damages’ to the customer for the delayed commissioning of the plant due to its inability to have the plant ready for supply of gases on the appointed target commencement date of 31st March, 2008.

    Query:

Based on the facts stated above, the querist has sought the opinion of the Expert Advisory Committee, on the following issue:

“Whether the amount to be paid by the company on account of liquidated damages due to delay in commencement of supply of gases to the customer consequent upon delay in bringing the plant to its working condition on the appointed target commencement date can be capitalised in its books of account as additional cost attributable to the project (capitalised in March 2009) in accordance with the provisions of AS-10 and any other related Accounting Standard or statute, or whether the liquidated damages payable can be treated as deferred revenue expenditure to be amortised over a period of 3 to 5 years after the commencement of commercial production, or whether the company can charge off the amount of liquidated damages as an expense in the profit and loss account?”


    Opinion:

The Committee noted that the basic issue raised in the query relates to the treatment of liquidated damages payable by the company for delay in the commissioning of the plant.

After considering paragraphs 9.1, 20 and 21 of Ac-counting Standard (AS) 10 — Accounting for Fixed Assets, the Committee noted from the facts of the case that the ‘late start liquidated damages’ are payable by the company on account of delay in the commencement of gas supply from the plant on the target commencement date. The Committee is of the view that such expenditure cannot be said to be attributable to bringing the plant to its working condition for its intended use. Such expenditure is not attributable to construction activity. It is also not in the nature of price adjustment on account of which cost of a fixed asset may undergo a change subsequent to its construction. The Committee is of the view that the liquidated damages are of the nature of a penalty resulting from non-fulfilment of the terms of the agreement, in this case, the target date of commencement of gas supply. The amount of liquidated damages is compensation to the customer for loss of revenue on account of non-supply of gas by the company. Accordingly, the Committee is of the view that such expenditure cannot be capitalised and should be expensed by way of charge to the profit and loss account as no future benefit is expected from the same.

    [Refer pages 418 to 420 of C.A Journal of September, 2010]

        4. Important announcements for PE-II and PCC

    Students:

The following important announcement is made by the President, ICAI, in his communication on page 386 of C.A. Journal for September, 2010.

The Council has considered the case of PE-II stu-dents especially in order to mitigate their hardship vis-à -vis their joining the CA course through PCC/IPCC route. PE -II students having joined the course through all streams can now commence articled training in case they have passed any of the groups of PE-II examination instead of earlier requirement of passing both the groups. They will also be eligible to appear in the final examination during the last 12 months of articled training. In addition, such students shall be exempted from undergoing the Orientation Programme, on switching over to IPC course. Further, they shall not be charged any fee for switching over to IPC course, except `1,500 to cover the cost of study material and administrative charges, instead of `4,000 at present.

With a view to bringing overall uniformity, students registered for Professional Competency Course (PCC) shall now be eligible to appear in the final examination during the last six months of the three and a half year period of articled training as against the earlier requirement of appearing in the final examination after completion of articled train-ing. Further, realising the difficulties faced by the students to complete the Information Technology Training (ITT) and Orientation Programme before appearing at the examination, it has now been decided that all students would now be permitted to submit proof of their successful completion of ITT to the Examination Section before the commencement of the article training, instead of earlier requirement of submitting the said proof before appearing in the examination. However, this would not be applicable to the PCC students. However, it has also been observed that many students are withdrawing their registration from ITT centres and they wish to complete the ITT and Orientation Programme before the commencement of the article training. All such students are advised to undergo ITT and Orientation Programme as early as possible, because this would not only help them in solving the questions posed in examinations in the IT paper but also release the pressure on the training centres.

        5. ICAI News:

    (Note: Page Nos. given below are from September, 2010, issue of C.A. Journal)

    (i) ICAI job portal:
The ICAI job portal has been developed to provide a platform for industry to fill their vacancies for Chartered Accountants and Accounting Technicians. The recruiting organisations as well as experienced Chartered Accountants and Accounting Technicians can avail the benefit of this job portal. For this purpose, they can contact the Secretary to CMII by E-Mail placements@icai.org or ssuneja@icai.org (Tel No. 011-30110450/491) (refer page 498).

        ii) ICAI publication:

        a) Accounting Reforms in India — A Bird’s-eye View.

        b) Technical Guide on Internal Audit of Sugar Industry
    (pages 499-500)

        iii) Peer review of audit firms of listed companies:

The Peer Review Board of ICAI is in the process of updating the status of the firms. Accordingly, the Peer Review Board has desired to know the status regarding whether your firm has been peer reviewed in the past or whether the peer review certificate has already been issued to your firm for updation of the latest position regarding the status due to the migration of firms from the Stage II to Stage I and vice-versa. In view of this, it is requested that the latest status of your firm may kindly be sent at email id peerreviewboard@icai.org so as to expedite the peer review of the firms doing the audit of the listed companies which has been mandatory as per the Circular dated April 5, 2010 issued by SEBI. Further, the firms doing the audit of the listed companies who’s peer review process is not initiated by the Board may also send a request for voluntary peer review to the Peer Review Board. (pages 501-502)

        iv) Assurance Reports on Contacts at a Service Organisation:

Auditing and Assurance Standards Board has issued an Exposure Draft of Standard on Assurance Engagements (SAE) 3402 of ‘Assurance Reports on Control at a Service Organisation’ for comments by Members. (Refer pages 507 to 522)

        v) Status of convergence with IFRS:
The latest position of finalisation of Accounting Standards after convergence with IFRS is explained by the President of ICAI in his communication (page 383).

        vi) Training for members for ICAEW membership:

Members of ICAI who desire to become members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants England and Wales have to appear in one paper on Advanced Case Study (4-hour final paper) and undergo training. The ICAI has made arrangements for this training as stated in the President’s Communication. (page 385)

        vii) Disciplinary cases:
It is reported that since February, 2010, onwards the Disciplinary Committee has passed orders u/s. 21D in 60 cases and u/s.21B in 20 cases. Further, 10 old disciplinary cases have also been completed. So far as Board of Discipline is concerned, it has disposed of 34 cases u/s.21A. It is understood that prior to February, 2010, several other similar cases have been decided by the Disciplinary Committee as well as Board of Discipline. (page 385)

    However, the ICAI has not published decisions taken by these two committees under the new provisions and therefore, members of ICAI are not aware as to what are the decisions of these two committees on various provisions of the two Schedules of the CA Act.

ICAI And Its Members

ICAI and Its Members

1. Disciplinary case :


In the case of ICAI and Shri M. D. Loya, reported on Page 461
of C.A. Journal for September, 2008, ICAI received information against the
member. It was alleged that in the audit report given by the member in the case
of a public trust u/s.12A(b) of the Income-tax Act (in Form No. 10B) it was
certified that no income or property of the trust was used or applied during the
previous year for the benefit of persons referred to u/s.13(3) of the Income-tax
Act. It was, however, found that certain fixed deposit receipts of the trust
were pledged by the trustees with a bank and a loan was obtained on security of
these FDRs by a firm in which some of the trustees were partners.

The matter was referred to the Disciplinary Committee of the
Institute which found that the member was guilty of professional misconduct
under clauses (7) and (8) of Part I of Second Schedule to the C.A. Act. The
Council of ICAI accepted this finding and recommended to the Bombay High Court
that the member be reprimanded.

After hearing the matter, the High Court observed that it was
clear that the member did not seriously challenge the lapse on his part in not
calling for all the FDRs for physical verification before signing the audit
report. The High Court has accepted the view of the ICAI Council that the member
be reprimanded for this lapse on his part and accordingly passed the order of
reprimand.

2. Revision of Guidance Note on Tax Audit

u/s.44AB of Income-tax Act :

Clause 17(L) was added to Form 3CD by a Notification No.
208/2006, dated 10-8-2006. This clause deals with ‘Amount of deduction
inadmissible in terms of S. 14A of the Income-tax Act in respect of expenditure
incurred in relation to income which does not form part of the Total Income’.
ICAI had issued a supplementary Guidance Note for Tax Audit u/s.44AB in
September, 2006, explaining the implications of the requirement of clause 17(L)
in Form 3CD. The Government has now amended the Income-tax Rules and inserted
New Rule 8D which lays down the method for determining the amount of expenditure
to be disallowed u/s.14A. ICAI has revised the Guidance Note on Tax Audit
u/s.44AB in the month of August, 2008. The text of this revised Guidance Note is
available on Institute’s website www.icai.org. Operative part of this Guidance
Note (Para 40.6) reads as under :


“40.6 The method prescribed under sub-rule (2) of Rule 8D
is applicable when the Assessing Officer is not satisfied with the correctness
of the claim of expenditure made by the assessee or with the claim made by the
assessee that no expenditure has been incurred. Normally this situation would
arise at the time of assessment i.e., after the tax audit has been
completed and the return has been filed. Therefore, at the time of tax audit
the tax auditor will have to verify the amount of inadmissible expenditure as
determined by the assessee. The method under sub-rule (2) of Rule 8D does not
mandate that the assessee should necessarily compute the disallowance as per
the method prescribed under sub-rule (2). Therefore, the assessee may or may
not adopt the same.”


Further, in para 40.11, it is stated that the Tax Auditor
should verify the amount of inadmissible expenses as worked out by the assessee.
If he is in agreement with the assessee, he should report the amount with
suitable disclosures of material assumptions. If he is not in agreement with the
assessee, he should suitably qualify his report as stated in the above Guidance
Note.

(Refer P. 461 of C.A. Journal for September 2008)

3. Accounting Standard (AS-2) (Revised) — ‘Inventories’ :


Exposure Draft of this revised standard has been published
for comments of members by 15-11-2008. There is no major difference between this
Exposure Draft and the International Accountancy Standard (IAS-2) dealing with
‘Inventories’.

The major difference between the Exposure Draft of revised
AS-2 and the existing AS-2 is as under :

(i) On the lines of IAS 2, the Exposure Draft deals with
the subsequent recognition of cost/carrying amount of inventories as an
expense, whereas the existing AS-2 does not provide the same.

(ii) The Exposure Draft provides explanation with regard to
inventories of service providers, whereas the existing AS-2 does not contain
such an explanation.

(iii) The Exposure Draft does not apply to measurement of
inventories held by commodity broker-traders, who measure their inventories at
fair value less costs to sell. However, this aspect is not there in the
existing AS-2. Accordingly Exposure Draft defines ‘fair value’ and provides an
explanation in respect of distinction between ‘net realisable value’ and ‘fair
value’.

(iv) The Exposure Draft provides detailed guidance in case
of subsequent assessment of net realisable value. It also deals with the
reversal of the write-down of inventories to net realisable value to the
extent of the amount of original write-down, and the recognition and
disclosure thereof in the financial statements. The existing AS-2 does not
deal with such reversal.

(v) The Exposure Draft excludes from its scope only the
measurement of inventories held by producers of agricultural and forest
products, agricultural produce after harvest, and minerals and mineral
products, though it provides guidance on measurement of such inventories.
However, the existing AS-2 excludes from its scope, such types of inventories.

(vi) The existing AS-2 specifically provides that the
formula used in determining the cost of an item of inventory should reflect
the fairest possible approximation to the cost incurred in bringing the items
of inventory to their present location and condition, whereas the Exposure
Draft does not specifically state so and requires the use of consistent cost
formulas for all inventories having a similar nature and use to entity.

(vii) The Exposure Draft requires more disclosures as
compared to the existing AS-2.


4. CPE requirements for members in Industry and senior citizens :


ICAI President has clarified the position on this subject on Page 406 of CA. Journal for September, 2008, as under:

“As you are aware, the unstructured learning activities have been made applicable from January this year and we have already issued.a Continuing Professional Education (CPE)Advisory in this regard. However, I notice that there is some apprehension among certain members in industry and senior citizens about this requirement. I may clarify that for members in industry and senior citizens it is not necessary to attend regular CPE programmes. These regular CPE programmes such as seminars, study circle meetings, etc. are called structured learning activities and are mandatory for members holding certificates of practice, but they are optional for members in industry and senior citizens. Members in industry not holding a certificate of practice and senior citizens could comply with the new CPE requirement by reading articles in journals, books, etc. They could read those articles at their leisure.

You will be glad to know that taking this important initiative forward, it has been decided to grant one hour CPE Credit each for reading some selected article(s) published in the Institute’s journal as part of unstructured learning activities from the September 2008 issue itself.”

5. Exposure Drafts on Auditing Standards:

The following Exposure Drafts are issued for comments by members:

(i) Auditing Accounting Estimates, including Fair Value Accounting Estimates, and Related Dis-closures [Revised Standard on Auditing (SA) 540]

(Refer pages 536-560 of CA. Journal for September 2008)

(ii) Related Parties [Revised Standard on Auditing (SA) 550]

(Refer pages 561-576 of CA. Journal for September 2008)

6.    ICAI News:

(Note: Page Nos. given below are from CA. Journal for September, 2008)

(i)    Internal  Audit  of Accounts  of Stockbrokers:

By letter dated 22-8-2008, SEBI has advised that all Stockbrokers/Clearing members of Stock Exchange should get Internal Audit of their accounts carried out by independent qualified Chartered Accountants. Similarly, the Insurance Regulatory and, Development Authority has also amended its Regulations to provide that every insurance company having Assets under Management (AUM) of not more than Rs.1000 crore shall get Internal Audit conducted on quarterly basis. Insurance companies with AUM of above Rs.1000 crore should appoint a Chartered Accountant firm for Concurrent Audit (Page 406).

(ii) Certificate Course on IFRS and Valuation:

ICAI has decided to conduct (a) a Certificate Course on ‘International Financial Reporting Standards’, and (b) a Certificate Course on ‘Valuation’. Both the courses are to be launched in September/October 2008. (Page 406)

(iii) Rules  of Arbitration:

ICAI has issued the ‘ICAI Rules of Arbitration’ and also decided to start a Certificate Course on Arbitration for our members. Details are hosted on Institute’s website. (Page 407)

(iv) ICAI Toll-free telephones:

Toll-free telephones for getting services from ICAI are now available as under:

(v)  Examination on alternate days:

To reduce stress of our students, it has been decided that from November 2008, Institute examinations will be held on alternate days. Thus November 2008 examinations will be held from 1st to 16th November 2008. (Refer Pages 408 and 532)

(vi) International Conference at Jaipur in November, 2008:

The above conference for members is to be held from 20th to 22nd November, 2008. The details are on Institutes website. (Page 408)

(vii) Recognition for Ph.D Course:

University of Rajasthan has recognised the CA. Course for the purpose of doing Ph.D from that University. (Page 418)

(viii) Peer review:

Some major deficiencies noticed by reviewers while conducting peer review are published on Page 513.

(ix) Director (Discipline) :

ICAI has appointed CA Smt. Vandana Nagpal, Senior Deputy Secretary, as Director (Discipline) to head the Disciplinary Directorate. This Directorate is for making investigations in respect of information and complaint cases against members.
 
(x) New  publication    of ICAI :

Technical Guide on E-Commerce – Consideration for Audit of Financial Statements. (Page 531)

(xi) Obituary:

(a)    CA P. M. Narielvala, former President of our Institute, passed away on 8-8-2008 at Kolkata. He was our President in 1975-76 and a Council Member of ICAI for two terms for 1967-70 and 1973-76. The accountancy profession in India has lost one of its leading lights. We pay our respectful homage and pray that the departed soul may rest in peace. (Page 418)

(b)    CA S. P. Chhajed, Former President of our Institute passed away on 18-9-2008 at Mumbai. He was our President in 1999-2000 and Council Member of ICAI from 1982 to 2001. Shri Chhajed was a very popular figure in Mumbai and other places. Our profession has lost a leading personality. We pay our respectful homage and pray that the departed soul may rest in peace.

To be precise

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

3 To be precise


 

v
“India cannot be held to any emission control target. They (developed
countries) should get off our backs. We are an expanding economy. How can we
levy a cap when millions are living with deprivation ?”

R.
K. Pachauri, Head of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), to
IANS

v
“If you have not been a villain at a certain point in time, you will never be
a hero. And even if you are a hero one day, you may well become a villain the
next”


Carlos Ghosn, CEO, Nissan and Renault, in Newsweek

v
“Technology will not be a differentiator between rich and poor consumers;
personalised experience will be”

C.
K. Prahalad, Professor, Ross School of Business, at the University of
Michigan, in Mint

v
“Being a CEO is like answering a call to bring the organisation to a better
place than where you found it”


Edward J. Ludwig, CEO, Becton, Dickinson and Company, in Harvard Business
Review

v
“I don’t see anybody in Washington or anywhere else saying, look, this energy
crisis is the biggest one we’ve had, let’s really put the best people to work
on figuring out how to reduce the country’s dependence on oil”


Indra Nooyi, Chief Executive Officer, PepsiCo, in Reuters.com

v
“People in India are simple folks, who work hard and save. I believe that the
simpler the product (insurance), the better will be the reception”

P.
Chidambaram, Finance Minister, in Hindustan Times

v
“Over the last several decades, revolutions in communication and technology
have sent jobs wherever there’s Internet connections; that have forced
children in Raleigh and Boston to compete for those jobs with children in
Bangalore and Beijing. We live in a more competitive world, and that is a fact
that cannot be reversed”


Barack Obama, Democrat Party candidate for the US presidential election, in
The Times of India

v
“Once things start slowing down in India, we think that the competition may
give up. We see that as an opportunity”


Martin Sorrell, CEO, WPP Group, in Mint

v
“You have to encourage experimentation. You must hire people who don’t listen
to you. You have to create a sandbox where people can play — and fail, often
and early”


Anand Mahindra, Vice-Chairman & MD, Mahindra & Mahindra, in Harvard Business
Review

(Source :
Business Today, 10-8-2008, 13, 27-7-2008)

Some Recent Judgments

I. Supreme Court :


    1. Penalty :

    Whether levy of penalty can be considered by Court while considering quantification of penalty under a civil appeal ?

    Commissioner of Central Excise, Haldia v. Exide Industries Ltd., 2010 (19) STR 291 (SC)

    The appellants tried to challenge the levy of penalty in the civil appeal filed for its quantification. The Supreme Court rejected the appeal observing that the Tribunal had rejected the appeal for levy of penalty against which the appellants did not appeal. The Court did not express any opinion on merits.

II. High Court :

2. Penalty :

    Whether penalties u/s.76 and u/s.78 can be imposed simultaneously for the same default ?

    Commissioner of C.Ex. Chandigarh v. City Motors, 2010 (19) STR 486 (P&H)

    The Adjudicating Authority levied penalty on the assessee u/s.76 and u/s.78 for the same default. In the first appeal, penalty u/s.78 was reduced and penalty u/s.76 was set aside and this decision was affirmed by the Tribunal. In the Revenue’s appeal to the High Court, it was held that penalty u/s.78 is sufficient to cover the default and two penalties for the same default cannot be imposed.

3. Import of services :

    Can service tax be levied on firms or body corporate under consulting engineer’s services prior to 1st May, 2006 ?

    Commissioner of Service Tax, Bangalore v. Araco Corporation, 2010 (19) STR 169 (Kar.)

    The Department, in appeal, claimed that the respondent providing technical assistance and know-how to an Indian company should be liable to service tax under the category of ‘consulting engineer’s services’ for the period from November, 1998 to December, 2000.

    The assessee contended that S. 65(31) dealt with the definition of ‘consulting engineer’ not the taxability thereof and the term ‘body corporate and any other firm’ in the said S. 65(31) was introduced only w.e.f. 1st May, 2006 and therefore, in the period prior to this date, the category applied only to individuals.

    Secondly, the assessee also claimed that S. 65(31) applied only to an Indian service provider and the foreign service provider is liable to service tax only after the introduction of S. 66A w.e.f. 18th April, 2006.

    According to the Court, reference to S. 65(31) being irrelevant was not acceptable and even on assuming its applicability, it applied only to services of Indian consulting engineers.

    Holding that during the disputed period, the definition did not apply to a firm or body corporates and reverse charge also did not apply prior to 18th April, 2006, the Department’s appeal was dismissed.

    [Author’s Note : The term ‘an engineering firm’ was always there in the definition introduced with effect from 7-7-1997. Therefore, the conclusion is based on misquoted legal provision. However, primarily reverse charge did not apply prior to 18-4-2006 and therefore, it would not impact the decision based on misquoted legal provision.]

4. Liability to pay service tax :

    Whether liable when the services are provided by the principal ?

    Commissioner of Central Excise v. P.C. Paulose, 2010 (19) STR 487 (Ker.)

    By an agreement with Calicut Airport Authority Ltd., a right to collect entrance fees from visitors was provided to the assessee and therefore, the service tax was demanded from them. The demand was confirmed in the first appeal. The Tribunal’s order that the Airport Authority was rendering service and not the respondent was challenged by the Department.

    The High Court held that once licence was given by the Airport Authority to the respondent to permit entry and allow enjoyment of services provided to the visitors, the respondent was a service provider though he was acting only as an agent and liable for service tax.

5. Recovery of dues :

    Can the Department directly recover dues from principal employer u/s.87 ?

    ONGC Ltd. v. Dy. Commissioner of Cus., C. Ex. & S.T., Rajahmundry 2010 (19) STR 164 (AP)

    The Department was of the view that even though no assessment order was passed, manpower supply agencies were liable for assessment and since ONGC made substantial payment to them, notice u/s.87 of the Finance Act, 1994 could be issued on principal employer directing it to remit the payment.

    ONGC Ltd. contended that it was not required to pay service tax in respect of payments made to manpower supply agencies and in absence of any assessment order, the question of directing the principal employer to pay service tax liability did not arise. The High Court observed that the authorities have the responsibility of collecting data and pass an assessment order. Only if there’s a failure or default in payment by the assessee, the Department has the option to call the principal employer in terms of S. 87 of the Finance Act, 1994. Without an assessment order in place, service tax was not crystallised and therefore, S. 87 could not be invoked.

6. Search & seizure :

    Whether Revenue could retain the amount collected during search or seizure in absence of liability being crystallised ?

    Naresh Kumar & Company v. Union of India, 2010 (19) STR 161 (Cal.)

    Search was carried out in the petitioners’ premises and various records and documents were seized. The petitioners claimed that they were compelled to handover cheque of Rs 15 lakh to protect against service tax liability.

    The High Court held that the trial judge did not decide the matter in the right direction and the actual issue was whether the Department could re-tain this amount under the provisions of law. While examining communication with the Department, it could be concluded that the payment was not voluntary and no provisions in the service tax law could justify compulsory payment of service tax in advance. Therefore, no amount could be withheld and the Department was bound to return the same with interest @ 9% per annum.

        7. Storage & warehousing:
    Whether service tax is applicable on compensation received from Government for storage of free-sale sugar?

    Commissioner of C. Ex., Chandigarh v. Nahar Industrial Enterprises Ltd., 2010 (19) STR 166 (P & H)

    A manufacturer of sugar was directed by the Gov-ernment to maintain buffer stock and was also compensated towards storage, interest, insurance charges, etc. by way of subsidy. The Revenue contended that buffer subsidy was taxable under ‘storage and warehousing services’.

    The High Court observed that the respondent stored its own stock in buffer and therefore, there is no service provider and service-recipient relationship emerging as one cannot provide service to his own self. Further, the subsidy was meant as compensation for loss of interest, insurance, etc. and not for rendition of any service. The respondent could not be construed as ‘storage and warehouse keeper’ and Government could not be held as its ‘client’ and accordingly, the appeal was dismissed.

    III. Tribunal:

        8. CENVAT credit:
        i)     Whether CENVAT credit is allowable fully to a service provider having a trading activity in view of Rule 6(3) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004?

    Orion Appliances Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Ahmedabad 2010 (19) STR 205 (Tri.-Ahmd.)

    The appellant engaged in providing repairs and maintenance services and commissioning and installation services was taking full CENVAT credit on advertising, security, courier, telephone and banking services. However, these input services were being used for providing repairs and maintenance services and trading activities. The Department contended that the appellant is liable to pay service tax for excess CENVAT credit availed in respect of trading activities in terms of Rule 6(3) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

    The appellant contested that Rule 6, requiring maintenance of separate books of accounts, applies only to an assessee engaged in providing exempted as well as taxable services and trading activities cannot be considered as exempted services and therefore, Rule 6(3) did not apply to him.

    The Tribunal accepted that trading activity was not a service and therefore, Rule 6(3) did not apply. However, full CENVAT credit could not be availed by the appellant as CENVAT credit of input service requires one to one correlation with output services. Therefore, the appellant had to choose and segregate the quantum of input service attributable to trading activity and exclude the same from availment of CENVAT credit. Since the quantum could not be ascertained in advance, the appellant should calculate such amount once in a quarter or every six months. The matter was remanded for quantifying the amount of reversal, if required, after giving an opportunity to appellant.

        ii) CENVAT credit: Outward transportation up to the place of removal when sale is for destination at customer’s premises:

    L. G. Electronics (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of C. Ex., Noida 2010 (19) STR 340 (Tri.-Del.)

    The appellant availed CENVAT credit of service tax on GTA service in respect of outward transportation of finished goods from factory gate to the customer’s premises or from factory to depots and from depots to customer’s premises. However, the department contended that the outward transportation from place of removal i.e., factory gate or depot to customer’s premises was not covered within the definition of ‘input service’ under Rule 2(l) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

    The appellant contended that in all the cases, the sales to dealers, whether from factory gate or depots, was on FOR basis. Therefore, the goods were transported at the appellant’s risk and sale took place at customer’s premises and the customer’s price included the transportation cost.

    Since the words ‘place of removal’ are not defined in CENVAT Credit Rules, they must be understood as defined by S. 4 of the Central Excise Act where-under the customer’s premises are considered as the place of removal. The credit in respect of GTA services for transportation from factory gate to depots should not be denied as the sales are held to be made from depots. In terms of Circular No. 97/8/07-ST dated 23-8-2007, CENVAT credit of GTA services up to customer’s premises were available to the appellant. Even if duty was paid on MRP-based valuation, credit of GTA services could be taken in terms of Circular No. 137/3/2006-CX-4, dated 2-2-2006.

    The Department contended that in case of payment u/s.4A, Board’s Circular No. 97/8/07 ST, dated 23rd August, 2007 was irrelevant and CENVAT credit could not be availed by the appellant. U/s.37(2)(xvii) of the Central Excise Act, Central Government is entitled to make rules for credit of service tax as well as excise duty. Since there was no nexus between manufacture and input service, outward transportation from the place of removal could not be regarded as ‘input service’. The scope of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 could not travel beyond the scope of provisions of the Central Excise Act.

    The Tribunal in turn observed that the Department’s contention that input duty credit is available only in respect of services used in or in relation to manufacture in terms of S. 37(2) of the Central Excise Act and that “in case of conflict between provisions of the Act and provisions of Rule, provisions of the Act shall prevail” does not hold good for reasons that in Bombay Tyre International Ltd. 1983, the Supreme Court held that it was not acceptable that because the levy of excise was on manufacture, the value of excisable goods must be limited to manufacturing cost and profit only. Referring to the basic principle of value added tax and valuation aspect, since all expenses up to place of removal were included in assessable value, the Tribunal observed that the whole scheme of Central Excise levy is to be kept in mind rather than interpreting Rule 2(l) of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004 and S. 37(2) of Central Excise Act in isolation. The contention of the Department that the duty was paid u/s.4A was found baseless as availability of credit and valuation for payment of duty were found to be two independent issues as explained vide Circular No. 137/3/2006. Since the matter was decided exparte, the case was remanded back to the Commissioner to examine whether the sale was on FOR destination basis and if this was found to be the fact, direction was provided to allow credit up to customer’s place.

        iii) Outdoor catering service used in the factory not an input service

    Commissioner of C.Ex., Chennai v. Sundaram Brake Linings, [2010 (19) STR 172 Tri-Chennai]

    There were 13 appellant manufacturers to the issue involving availment of CENVAT credit on outdoor catering service disallowed holding that they were not used for manufacturing excisable products. Applying decision of GTC Industries 2008 (12) STR 468, the appellate authority allowed the credit.

    The Department contended before the Tribunal citing the case of CCE, Nagpur v. Manikgarh Cement Works, 2010 (18) STR 275 that in order to fall in the definition of input service, the service must be used in or in relation to manufacture directly or indirectly and outdoor catering service had no nexus with the manufacturing activity.

    The appellants relied on the decision of GTC Industries (supra) and contended that it was rightly followed by the first Appellate Authority and since the value of catering service formed a part of cost of production, the same was to be considered as an input service. The Tribunal stated that the Central Government is empowered to frame rules for grant of credit of duty of service tax and held that outdoor catering service cannot be considered as input service and restored the original order deleting however, penalties imposed by the original authority.

        iv) Whether CENVAT credit allowable on invoices in the name of branch, not registered under service tax?

    Manipal Advertising Services Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE, Mangalore 2010 (19) STR 506 (Tri-Bang.)

    The appellant provider of advertisement services was disallowed credit on invoices addressed to branch offices both by original and Appellate Authorities.

    The appellant referred to Rule 4(2) of Service Tax Rules, 1994 which provided that in case of centralised billing or centralised accounting system, in respect of any services, the assessee had the op-tion to register the premises or offices from where centralised billing or central accounting system was located. Accordingly, the appellant got registered its premises on the ground that they had centralised billing or central accounting system. Reliance was placed on the case of Stadmed Pvt. Ltd. 1998 ELT 466 wherein credit of duty was allowed on invoices addressed to branch offices. However, according to the Department, in absence of centralised registration, credit in respect of inputs used at branches was not admissible.

    The Tribunal held that since the appellant discharged service tax liability, the benefit of CENVAT credit could not be denied on the ground that invoices were in the name of branch. The appeal was allowed.

        9. Stay of pre-deposit:

    Whether appellant is engaged in providing business auxiliary services?

    Jetlite (India) Ltd. v. Commissioner of C. Ex., New Delhi 2010 (19) STR 209 (Tri.-Del.)

    The appellant took over M/s. Sahara Airlines Ltd. (SAL) and added the category of ‘business auxiliary services’ in March, 2007 in service tax registration. The Department demanded `128 crore of service tax for the period from July, 2003 to January 2007 under the said category and interest and penalty of the same amount.

    The appellant had entered into an agreement with Sahara India Commercial Corporation Limited (SICCL) in 1995 to promote business of SICCL of housing and real estate projects through printing it on air tickets. Consideration was paid based on per ticket.

    SAL accounted the money received as ‘operational revenue’. However, SICCL recorded the same as ‘project work in progress’ as it was a capital expenditure.

    The Department contended that SAL being already registered with Service Tax authorities ought to have disclosed material facts in the ST-3 return. However, the appellant had taken opinion on 4th August, 2003 in regard to the present activity and therefore, was under a bona fide belief. Therefore, the appellant relisted invoking of extended period of limitation.

    According to the appellant, they merely used logo of SICCL and as per agreement, no brochures or other arrangements to popularise the business was carried out. The difference between promotion of sale of goods and use of brand was explained and the appellant claimed that the entire consideration was only towards display of logo.

    The Tribunal observed that:
    Levy and collection of tax is regulated by law and not by contract. The term ‘service’ has a variety of meanings, but has to be construed depending on the context in which it is used. An activity provided individually or integrally would not make any difference as to its charge. The character of service does not change with permutation or combination of services and the nature of services does not alter if certain clauses of agreement are not fulfilled. No evidence was led to prove that use of logo was not helpful to promote real estate business of SICCL. The information of SICCL’s projects was supplied purposely to air travel passengers.

    There was no case made out to show that undue hardship would be caused to the appellant if no full waiver was granted. Noting Ravi Gupta’s case 2009, wherein it was held that if prima facie it appears that the demand raised would not stand, the assessee should not be compelled to pay full or substantial part of the demand. The appellant was directed by the Tribunal to make pre -deposit of `100 crore within eight weeks of the date of receipt of the order staying the balance demand.

Part B — Some recent judgments

fiogf49gjkf0d
New Page 1

1. High Court :

(i) Service Tax on provision of service and not service provider :

Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. V. Dewanchand Ramsaran,
2008 (11) STR 453 (Bom.)

In this case, the appellant filed appeal against judgment
passed by a single Judge in an arbitration petition. The respondent was
appointed as a handling contractor handling iron & steel for the appellant. In
November 1997, because of creation of reverse charge in case of clearing and
forwarding services, while paying the respondent their handling charge the
appellant deducted 5% Service Tax under the assumption that the respondent was a
clearing and forwarding agent. The deduction was made in spite of objection
raised by the respondent. There being a dispute, the matter was referred to a
sole arbitrator. The arbitrator dismissed the claim and therefore, Dewanchand
Ramsaran filed petition against the award. The Single Judge allowed the petition
and set aside the arbitration award after perusing the agreement between the
parties and finding that the agreement contained no clause or provision fixing
liability of Service Tax on respondent. The payment of tax made by the appellant
to the Government as recipient of service did not imply that it was paid on
behalf of the contractor. The contractor being service provider was not liable
to make payment of Service Tax. The Court considered the arbitration award as
faulty, considering it as opposed to the scheme of Service Tax, which levies tax
on services and not on service provider. The decision in the case of All
India Federation of Tax Practitioners v. UOI,
2007 (7) STR 625 (SC) was
relied upon. The appellant’s appeal was dismissed as dismissal of arbitration
award was upheld.


(ii) Refund :

ICCE Bangalore v. Motorola India P. Ltd., 2008 (11)
STR 555 (Kol).

The assessee in this case paid duty by error in excess of
duty payable and drew attention of authorities who in turn directed to file a
claim of refund. A refund application was subsequently filed by the assessee,
however the same was rejected on the ground of lapse of time and this was also
confirmed by the Appellate Commissioner. On moving the Tribunal, the refund was
allowed. The Court observed that the Tribunal chose to allow the case on the
basis that amount paid by mistake cannot be termed as ‘duty’ and therefore, time
bar did not apply. Since under similar circumstances, the Apex Court in India
Cements Ltd. V. CCE,
1989 (4) ELT 358 had accepted the case of the assessee,
the Court decided not to interfere with the Tribunal’s decision and rejected the
Revenue’s appeal.

2. Tribunal :

(i) Banking and financial services — Machinery given on
lease on monthly user charge basis :

CCE Vadodara I v. M/s. GE India Industries (P) Ltd.,
2008 TIOL 1444 CESTAT-Ahm.

The noticee gave extrusion machinery on lease under an
agreement to a party, which the Revenue held as banking and financial service
and served show-cause notices. The respondent cited the decision in the case of
Thermax Ltd. V. CCE Pune, 2007 (8) STR 487 (Tri. Mum), wherein it was
held that the appellant was not a professional in leasing business, and the
activity was confined to own products and considering ‘interest on loan’ not
forming part of value of taxable service in view of explanation 1 to S. 67 of
the Finance Act, 1994, the demand was held unsustainable. Relevant portion of
the definition of banking and other financial service was analysed and financial
lease covered by the said service as opposed to monthly refutal charge was
discussed. Following the decision in the case of Thermax (supra), the
Revenue’s appeal was rejected.

(ii) Business auxiliary service : Whether
individual/proprietor — a commercial concern ?

(a) Anuradha Jain v. CCE Bhopal, 2008 TIOL 1452 CESTAT-Del.

The appellant pleaded only on the issue that individual or
proprietary concern cannot be treated as commercial concern and Service Tax
applied to only commercial concerns in case of business auxiliary service. The
issue, having been decided in the case of CCE v. R. S. Financial Services,
2008 (9) STR 231, it was no longer ‘res integra’, the service was held as
liable for Service Tax.

(b) CCE Belgaum v. Chadha Auto Agencies, 2008 TIOL
1388 CESTAT-Mad.

The assessee, a dealer in sale and services of two wheelers,
also arranged loan from financial institutions/banks for hire/purchase and thus
promoted/marketed services of banks for which they received commission from such
banks/institutions. The Department proceeded to consider the activity as
business auxiliary service. The Commissioner (Appeals) however held that there
was no evidence to confirm as to whether remuneration was in the nature of rent
or business support service and that assessee provided office space, furniture,
etc. to banks to sell their products and therefore, held it as business support
service, which was challenged by the Revenue. The Bench found that they had
examined similar issue in the case of Silicon Honda v. CCE Bang., 2007
(7) STR 475 (Tri.-Bang). The Bench stated that the assessee did not cause sale
or purchase of services on behalf of another person for a consideration.
Financial institutions paying for occupying table space in the premises of auto
dealer could not be considered business auxiliary service and the Revenue’s
appeal was rejected.

(iii) CENVAT Credit:

(a)    Maersk India Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE Raigad, 2008 TIOL 1477 CESTAT-MUM

The appellant, registered under the category of ‘storage & warehousing’ and ‘maintenance and repairs services’, got a part of its empty containers repaired through its subcontractors. The sub-contractors charged Service Tax on their ‘repair charges’ received from the appellant and in turn, the appellant, against his Service Tax liability on output service of ‘maintenance & repairs’, claimed credit of Service Tax paid on input services of subcontractors. CENVAT credit was denied on the ground that sub-contractors did not have Service Tax liability and that there did not exist an agreement between the appellant and the sub-contractor for providing the latter’s services. The Tribunal found that there existed an agreement between the parties, which even the lower Appellate Authority had taken note of and irrespective of the same, it was ruled that once Service Tax has been paid by the supplier, the same cannot be questioned at the receiver’s end and accordingly, credit cannot be denied. Credit for the period prior to 10-9-2004 (the date on which the CENVAT Credit Rules were prescribed) also was held allowable as the ground was the same and in terms of existence of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002, credit could not be denied.

(b)    Credit: Whether can be utilised for Service Tax payment on GTA service?

M/s. Sri Sarvana Spg. Mills P. Ltd. v. CCE Madurai, 2008 TIOL 1429 CESTAT-Mad.

The short issue involved in the appeal was whether input duty credit can be utilised for payment of Service Tax on GTA services for the period October 2005 to March 2006. Since by an earlier order the appellant was already given a decision in their favour (covered under MMS Steel Ltd. & Others v. CCE Trichy, 2007 TIOL 1317 CESTAT-Mad.) and identical decision was also given in the case of RRD Tex Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE Salem 2007 TIOL 891 CESTAT-Mad., the order of the lower authority was set aside after condoning the delay in filing the appeal.

(c)    Jindal Steel & Power Ltd. v. CCE Raipur, 2008 TIOL 1450 CESTAT-Del.

The appellant, after taking registration as recipient of consulting engineer’s service and on the sum paid to foreign party, paid Service Tax net of abatement for R & D cess paid by them. The foreign party however had transferred merely the technology. Holding that the appellant was not entitled to utilise CENVAT credit for payment of Service Tax on output services, Service Tax was demanded and penalties were imposed. Since output services were provided much later than the year in which Service Tax was paid as receiver of services i.e., deemed service provider, input services were not considered co-relatable with output services. It was held that the date on which the registration for providing output service was sought was not relevant and that Service Tax paid as deemed output service provider was eligible for taking credit of. Further, Service Tax on transfer of technology under ‘consulting engineering service’ was wrongly paid by the appellant at the instance of the department and therefore also credit could not be denied. The Tribunal also stated that there was no time limit prescribed for utilisation of credit and therefore Service Tax paid on deemed output service was available as credit. The decisions cited by the appellant also supported the case of the appellant (Bhushan Power & Steel Ltd. v. CCE, 2008 (10) STR 18 (Tri.-Kol) and CCE Nagpur v. Visaka Industries Ltd., 2007 (8) STR 231 (Tri. Mum). Accordingly, the credit taken and utilised was held regular.

(iv) Management Consultant’s Service: Services to group companies:

M/s.  RPG Enterprises  Ltd. v. CCE Mumbai-IV, 2008 (11) STR 488 (Tri.-Mum).

The appellant received licence fee from various group companies including CEAT Ltd. under agreement with them, They contended as follows:

  • The client-service provider relationship did not exist between the appellant and its group companies.
  • Recovery  of expenses  was not a service.
  • The recovery was only of costs and it operated on no-profit-no-loss basis.
  • Since only cost was shared by all licensees, principle of mutuality was advanced.
  • In-house organisation cannot contextually be considered impartial adviser meeting the criterion of specified category.

The Tribunal stated that being a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 it was a separate legal entity independent of the entities among which its cost incurred was apportioned and it was essential to look at the very nature of the activities undertaken by M/ s. RPG so as to determine its taxability as management consultant as defined in S. 65(37) of the Finance Act, 1994. As per the Tribunal’s observation of company’s memorandum of association, the company’s objectives included developing and providing part of general economic and industrial intelligence, information in diverse areas of taxation, finance, legal, insurance risk management, data processing, information, systems, marketing, drafting, public relations, etc. to develop cadres of managers, provide infrastructure and administrative set-up for promotion, supervision, monitoring, etc. to the licensees. The Tribunal also found and reproduced extracts from income tax assessment order of CEAT Ltd. stating to the effect that RPG issued guidelines for MIS and possessed expertise in strategic planning, corporate finance, etc. In summation, RPG’s activities were held to be providing services with a view to improve the structure of organisations of licensees and therefore charges recovered by them were held to be leviable to Service Tax in the category of management consultancy.

On the plea of principle of mutuality, the Tribunal stated that the relationship between the two independent legal entities was not that of principal-agent and it did not fulfil the conditions enumerated in the decision of Chemsford Club, 200 (37) SCC 214 as the identity of fund contributors and the recipients of the fund was not the same. The amount paid to RPG by CEAT was shown as expense for the receipt of service in the latter’s balance sheet and therefore it was held that no one acted on behalf of the other in the instant case.

The plea of valuing gross amount charged as inclusive of Service Tax also was not accepted on the ground that explanation 2 to S. 67 of the Financial Act, 1994 was added from 10-9-2004 and was not applicable retrospectively for the period under dispute.

The plea for non-applicability of longer period of limitation based on solicitor’s opinion also was not found convincing on the ground that bona fide belief was not blind belief and the intention to suppress the facts existed and thus rejecting the appeal the demand of Service Tax and penalties was confirmed.

(v) Penalty: Bona fide belief held:

Tidewater Shipping Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, 2008 (11) STR 475 (Tri.-Bang).

In four different appeals, the appellant paid entire Service Tax with interest on being pointed out the lapse and much prior to issuance of show-cause notice. The adjudicating authority did not levy penalty considering the discretion u/ s.80. However, the Commissioner reviewed the orders and imposed penalties u/s.76 and u/s.78. Finally, all the cases were held to be under bona fide belief, appeals were allowed with consequential relief.


(vi)  Penalty u/s.78  :

Industrial Security Agency v. CCE All., 2008 (11) STR 347 (Tri. Del).

In this case, circumstances under which penalty is leviable and provisions of S. 78 have been discussed at length. The Tribunal observed that non-submission of return; result and concomitant of non-registration for which penalty is already imposed. Penalty u/s.78 is not imposable simply because the assessee has not filed the Returns. Accordingly, the Tribunal set aside penalty u/ s.78 considering that the facts and circumstances of the case not led by suppression, fraud or even contravention of relevant statutory provisions with an intent to evade Service Tax. Further, according to the Tribunal, if reasonable cause for failure to pay Service Tax is proven, penalty u/s.76 may not be imposed at all. However, the facts of the case were found to be not justifying complete waiver of penalty. Yet, the penalty u/s.76 was reduced.
 

(vii)    Software (Imported) whether goods or service?

Perfect Technologies v. CCE & CS, Siliguri 2008 TIOL 1386 CESTAT-Kol.

The appellants imported software from a foreign company in a digitised form by downloading the same online. The plea was made by the appellant that downloaded software being ‘goods’ was not chargeable to Service Tax. According to the Revenue, it could be treated as online service as it was downloaded online. However, considering the fact that even if it was a service provided online, reverse charge did not apply prior to 18-4-2006 (in terms of S. 66A coming into force) and such view was supported by the decision of Lohia Starlinger v. CCEX Kanpur, 2008 (10) STR 483 (Tri.-Del.) and demand for the subsequent period was not quantified by the Revenue. Further, in the case, there also existed a doubt as to the jurisdiction of the adjudicating Commissioner and therefore it was held fit for waiving pre-deposit.

(viii) Valuation of reimbursements:

Rolex Logistics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Service Tax, Bangalore, 2008 (11) STR 394 (Tri.-Bang) :

The appellants, registered under ‘management consultancy services’ and ‘maintenance and repair services’, filed their returns and paid Service Tax. On search operation, it was found that no Service Tax was paid on reimbursements shown in the balance sheet and hence, differential Service Tax was demanded in the show-cause notice. The appellant pleaded that rent of godown, salary of employees, etc. were not management consultancy services. The Tribunal observed that order of the Commissioner (Appeals) was non-speaking on various case laws relied upon by the appellant. Further, the facts of appellants’ filing of return and checking and scrutinising of records, etc. by the Department could not be prima facie considered ‘suppression’ in the light of various Supreme Court decisions cited by the appellants, waiver of pre-deposit was granted.

FROM THE PRESIDENT

fiogf49gjkf0d
Dear members of BCAS family,

I have been out of practice (pun intended) for many years now since I joined the industry. I had almost forgotten how busy practicing CAs get in a few months in a year. Come September and they become unavailable to friends and family and are completely at the service of their clients. As most of the active core group members, including the office bearers are practicing Chartered Accountants, the activities at BCAS were a wee bit slow.

So a text from my daughter gave me time to reflect on a few things. But first her text; “Papa, can we reschedule our dinner tonight, please? I am so sorry but have to go for dinner with a few friends. Thank you for your understanding!”

The text got me thinking. Yes, I was upset that I couldn’t spend quality time with her, as I had planned. Then why was I not angry? And it struck me… It was the three golden words that she used in her text which set the tone of the text as a very polite request. What if her text read – “Dad, am cancelling dinner. Meeting my best friend for her birthday”?

What am I talking about? What else but the three magic words – Sorry, Please and Thank You! Please–Order someone to do something and they may do it grudgingly, but request that person and you will see him smile. Notice the change in demeanour between ordering an employee to fetch a file and requesting him to get the file. Think about how you felt when you were summoned and how you felt when your presence was requested. What is it about “please” that pleases us and changes the equation between two persons? The fact is that we often take relationships for granted and order people to do things for us instead of requesting them to do us a favour. What is the response from the other person? A wife feels inferior, children are scared and employees are disdainful. A short and simple “Please”, makes the other person feel gracious.
Sorry–They say, “to err is human…” and we do exercise this right. But it takes a lot of courage to accept our mistakes and apologise for them. Saying sorry does not make a person any inferior. In fact, the person is perceived as being honest and is respected. Sorry expresses so many feelings—“I am sorry” – apology, “I am sorry for your loss” – sorrow/sympathy, “I am sorry I said that” – regret, “It’s a sorry situation” – pity. Many of us would have realised the importance of sorry at one point of time or another. For those who have not yet realised its significance, here’s a perspective – Australia, a whole nation, commemorates the mistreatment of a part of its population by having a “National Sorry Day” every year on 26th May, since 1998!

Thank You – Not a day goes by without us taking help from another person, be it family, friends or colleagues and even strangers. Have we ever acknowledged the favours we took? Did we thank the liftman for dropping us at the right floor while we were busy on a call? What about our staff which works round the clock to help us meet deadlines? Do we thank our parents for their fabulous upbringing? Have we thanked our wife for managing the house so efficiently while we are busy at work? Did we remember to thank our husband for supporting our career when husbands in other houses don’t let their wives work? These are small acts of kindness and easy to overlook.

From the time we start our day till we step into our bed for a good night’s sleep, we have taken a number of favours. However, how many times do we thank the other person truly? Why not be free and generous in saying Thank You! Express your gratitude! It does not take away your credit, but definitely makes the other person happy and more willing to help you the next time!

These three simple words can work wonders for people. Genuine use of these words in day-to-day communication with people brings a definite change in the way people respond. Then it doesn’t matter if it is business or personal life.

How do we feel when we are wronged and the other person doesn’t apologise for it? How about not being thanked for a favour? And how about being ordered and not requested to perform a task?

Doesn’t this sound rude?

There is a saying we learnt in school —“Do unto others as you would like others to do unto you”. If I am not polite in my dealings with others, do I have any right to be offended by their rudeness? At the same time, if I am gracious, polite and sensitive, does the other person have any reason to be rude to me?

These three short and simple words sure have a lot of power. They can make a friend out of a foe.

Don’t they add a touch of kindness in this increasingly busy world? In a life which is becoming more and more mechanical, these words help to make relationships human.

These are not just tools for communicating but also for connecting. Many people find ways to express these sentiments in innovative ways. Munnabhai gives his Jaadu ki jhappi. My friend, Lt. Gen. Ata Hasnain has his “10 handshakes-a-day” rule.

I am brought out of my reverie by a knock at my office door by the peon. I ask for a cup of tea and after a split-second, remember to say “please”.

Kudos to the person who invented these three magic words!

Here’s wishing everyone happiness and love.

With Warm Regards

Naushad A. Panjwani

Direct Taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
1. Protocol amending DTAA between India and
Sweden effective from 16th August, 2013 – Notification No. 63/2013 dated
14th August, 2013

2. NEW DRPs constituted – Order No. 2/FT & TR/2013 dated 27-08-2013

The
CBDT has issued this order for Constitution of the Dispute Resolution
Panel in Delhi, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Pune, Kolkata, Bangalore, Hyderabad
and Chennai with effect from 19-08-2013

3. CBDT Instruction
on unmatched TDS challans in Form 26AS–Instruction No. 11/2013 dated
27-08-2013 ( available on www.bcasonline. org)

4. Income-tax
(14th amendment) Rules, 2013– amendment in Rule 37BB and amendment to
Form 15CA and 15CB-Notification No. 67/2013 dated 2nd September, 2013.

In
terms of Notification No. 58/2013 dated 5th August, 2013, Income-tax
(12th amendment) Rules, 2013 were issued to amend Rule 37BB with effect
from 1st October, 2013. Rule 37BB is further amended vide Notification
No. 67/2013 which prescribes the procedure to be followed by a person
responsible for making a payment to a non-resident. Form 15CA i.e., the
form to be filled by the person making remittance and Form 15CB, a
certificate to be issued by the Chartered Accountant are amended.

CBDT
Instruction on procedure for adjustment of refund against
demand—Instruction No. 12/2013 dated 09-09-2013 ( available on
www.bcasonline.org)


Safe Harbour rules notified vide
Income-tax (16th Amendment) Rules, 2013–Notification No. 73/2013 dated
18th September, 2013 Transfer Pricing: Finance Ministry Press Release
Reg Safe Harbour Rules

The Ministry of Finance has issued a
press release stating that the Safe Harbour Rules have been finalized
after considering the comments of various stake holders. The significant
aspect is that in case of transactions in the nature of routine ITES
and ITS activities the earlier ceiling of Rs. 100 crore has been
removed. Transactions upto Rs. 500 crore have been provided safe harbour
margin of 20% and transaction above Rs. 500 crore have been provided
safe harbour margin of 22%. Similarly, the ceiling of Rs. 100 crore
provided for transactions in the nature of corporate guarantee has been
removed. Also, the rules provide for a time bound procedure for
determination of the eligibility of the assessee and the international
transactions. Any rejection of the option exercised by the assessee
shall be by way of a reasoned order passed after hearing the assessee.
The assessee shall have a right to file an objection with the
Commissioner against adverse finding regarding the eligibility. The
Commissioner shall thereafter decide about the validity of the option
exercised by the assessee.

7. Compulsory manual scrutiny
norms for scrutiny during F.Y. 2013-14 have been modified— Instruction
No. 13/2013 dated 20-09-13 ( available on www.bcasonline.org)


8.
Clarification received on 20-09-2013 from the ADIT (Systems), New Delhi
in respect of mandatory requirement of mentioning of Bank Account No.
& IFSC Code in case of Foreign Companies in ITR-6

On
representation, the ADIT (Systems), New Delhi, has clarified vide an
email to the Society that in ITR 6 in case of Foreign Companies not
having a bank account in India, in the space meant for Bank Account No.
put ‘999999999’ i.e. 9 times 9 and in IFSC Code put ‘NNNN0NNNNNN’ [the
fifth digit being ‘Zero’ and NOT alphabet ‘O’], in all cases where there
is no bank account available in India.

9. Board issues instructions regarding non-filers

Instruction No.14/2013
F.No. 225/153/2013/ITA.II
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
Central Board of Direct Taxes

North Block,ITA-II,Division New Delhi the 23rd of September, 2013

To

All Chief-Commissioners of Income-tax All Directors-General of Income-tax

Sir/Madam

Subject: Standard Operating Procedure for cases under Non-filers Monitoring System (‘NMS’)-regarding-

The
existing procedure for monitoring cases of ‘Non-Filers of IT Returns’
as identified by Director General of Income Tax (System) has been
examined by the board. It is felt that at present, cases of Non-Filers
are not being uniformly monitored by the Assessing Officers due to lack
of consistency in approach in dealing with such cases. Therefore, in
order to streamline processing of such cases and to ensure consistency
in monitoring NMS cases by the Assessing officers, the Board, hereby
lays down the following Standard Operating Procedure:

1. The
Assessing Officer should issue letter to the assessee with 15 days of
the case being assigned in NMS, seeking information about the return of
income flagged in NMS. Facility to generate letter has been provided in
the NMS module in i-taxnet.

2. If the letter is delivered, the Assessing Officer to capture the delivery date in the NMS module.

3.
If the letter is not delivered, the Assessing Officer should issue
letter to the alternate address of the assessee available in the Online
Monitoring System or any other address available with the Assessing
Officer through field enquiries or otherwise. All addresses used in IT
Return, AIR, CIB databases have been made available to the Assessing
Officer in the Online Monitoring System to assist the field formations
in identification of current address of the taxpayer.

4. If the
return is received, the assessing officer should capture the details in
AST within 15 days of filing of return, if the assessee informs that
paper return has already been filed which was not captured in AST, the
details of return should be entered in the AST within 15 days of
receiving such information. E-files returns will be automatically pushed
to NMS.

5. If no return is required to be filed in the case, (
non-resident etc.), the Assessing Officer should mark “No return is
required” and mention reason for the same in NMS which needs to be
confirmed by Range head.

6. If the Assessing Officer is not able
to serve the letter and identify the taxpayer, assessing officer should
mark the assessee “Assessee not traceable” in NMS which needs to be
confirmed by Range head.

7. In cases where the assessee has been
identified and no return has been filed within 30 days of the time
given in the letter, the Assessing Officer should consider initiation of
proceedings u/s 142(1)148 in AST.

8. The cases will be
processed every week by the Directorate of Systems and will be marked as
closed in NMS. If one of the following actions are taken for A.Yr.’s
2010-11, 2011-12, and 2012-13:

a) Details of return are available in AST

b) Notice u/s 142(1) or 148 has been issued in AST

c) “ No return is required” is marked by the Assessing Officer and confirmed by Range head.

I
am further directed to state that the above be brought to the notice of
all officers working under your jurisdiction for necessary and strict
compliance.

(Rohit Garg)
Deputy Secretary Government of India

Copy to:
1. Chairperson, CBDT.
2. All Members, CBDT.
3. DIT(PR,PP & OL),Mayur Bhawan,New Delhi.
4. The Comptroller and Auditor-General of India.
5. The DGIT(Vigilance),New Delhi.
6. The Joint Secretary and Legal Advisor, Ministry of Law and Justice, New Delhi
7. All Directors of Income Tax, New Delhi.
8. The DGIT(NADT) Nagpur.
9. ITCC Division of CBDT(3 copies).
10. The DGIT (Systems), New Delhi.
11. NIC, N/o Fin –for uploading on the Department’s website.
12. Data Base Cell-for uploading on irs officers website.

(Rohit Garg)

Deputy Secretary Government of India

From published accounts

fiogf49gjkf0d
Section B:
Gain on sale of Investments in subsidiaries considered in books of account in Consolidated Financial Statements

Adani Enterprises Ltd (CFS) (31-3-2013)

From Notes to Financial Statements

Exceptional Items

(a)
The Company has disposed off its investment in a wholly owned
subsidiary, ‘Adani Infrastructure and Developers Private Limited
(‘AIDPL’) representing the Real Estate Business, to its promoters at a
valuation done by an independent valuer. The Company has accounted a
gain of Rs. 453.63 crore against the disposal of the above said
Investment.

(b) During the financial year 2012-13, during the
year, Adani Ports & Special Economic Zone Limited (APSEZ) a
subsidiary of the Company had initiated and recorded the divestment of
its entire equity holding in Adani Abbot Point Terminal Holdings Pty
Limited (AAPTHPL) and entire Redeemable Preference Shares holding in
Mudra Port Pty Ltd (MPPL) representing Australia Abbot Point operations
to promoter Company, Abbot Point Port Holdings Pte Ltd, Singapore for
consideration of AUD 235.71 million. The Company entered Share Purchase
Agreement (‘SPA’) on 30th March, 2013 to sell its holdings in AAPTHPL
and MPPL. In terms of the SPA the conditionality as regards regulatory
and lenders approvals was obtained except in respect of approval from
one of the lenders who have given specific line of credit to MPPL, which
the APSEZ is following up with lender and is confident of obtaining the
same.

The Company, based on the legal counsel opinion,
concluded that on the date of signing of SPA, AAPTHPL and MPPL cease to
be subsidiaries of the Company w.e.f. 31st March, 2013 and accordingly
not been consolidated as per provisions of Accounting Standard 21
“Consolidated Financial Statements” notified in Companies (Accounting
Standards), Rules, 2006. Adani Ports & Special Economic Zone Limited
(APSEZ) has accounted gain of Rs. 419.57 crore against disposal of
investment.

From Auditors Report
We draw attention to
Note 41(b) to the consolidated financial statements recording sale of
investments in Australia step down subsidiaries, on the basis indicated
in the note, whereby gain of Rs. 419.57 crore have been recognised in
the books. Our opinion is not qualified in respect of this matter.

Reliance placed on judgement of the management on various matters

Lok Housing & Constructions Ltd (31-3-2013) From Notes to Financial Statements Accounting Policies Revenue Recognition

a)
The Company in respect of its construction activity follows substantial
completed contract method of accounting. Under this method profit in
respect of units sold is recognised only when work in respect of the
relevant units is substantially completed which is determined on
technical estimates as certified by management. The auditors have relied
upon such management certificate.

b) Revenue recognition in
respect of transactions for sale of properties/development rights is
done on the date on the date of execution of agreement and the same are
subject to conclusion of formalities such as conveyance and compliance
of applicable legal formalities.

c) Revenue recognition in
respect of constructed premises is on the basis of booking done by the
prospective customers and the same is subject to execution of registered
sale deed under the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act (MOFA) and payment
of consideration.

d) Sales in respect of a particular project are accounted net of cancellation during the same accounting period.

e)
The completion status of a project at the end of each accounting
period, the estimated cost for completion of the construction and
development work relating to the units sold, which are considered for
profit are estimated on the basis of technical evaluation and are so
certified by the management. The auditors have relied upon such
management certificate.

Other Notes (extracts)

a) The
Company is in the process of restructuring and renegotiating its
outstanding unsecured loans. Consequently provision for interest due on
the outstanding unsecured loans has been made on simple interest basis
@18% p.a. Interest is not provided on the original/ last contracted rate
and also no provision for interest is made on the unpaid interest
amount. On account payments made by the Company to its lenders, this
practice results in reduction in the provision.

b) The Company
has entered into debt resettlement with Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd.
However the Company has failed in its re-structured debt obligations to
Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd. At the time of resettlement the Company has
received benefit of interest waiver amounting to Rs. 21.77 lakh which
was credited to Work in Progress account. In the opinion of the Company
the revised liabilities as per the settlement with Ranbaxy Laboratories
Ltd is valid and subsisting, because the Company has not received any
legal notice from the concerned Lender for termination of the
settlement. The liability in respect of Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd., as
reflected in the Books of Accounts of the Company is Rs. 70.77 lakh
(previous year Rs. 60 lakh).

c) In case of disputed/defaulted
loans taken by the Company, provision for interest due on the
outstanding secured loans has been made at the last contractual rate of
interest. No provision is being made for interest on unpaid interest as
also for any penal interest and other charges.

d) The balances
in overdue secured and unsecured loans are subject to confirmation. The
management has been advised that for tactical reasons not to obtain
confirmations from its lenders as the same would impact the ongoing
negotiations of the Company. The Company has also requested the auditors
not to directly write to the lenders to obtain confirmations. The
auditors have relied on the judgement of the management in this regard.

e)
The balances in trade payables, secured and unsecured loans are subject
to confirmation. During the year under review balances in the accounts
of the several trade payables and other current liabilities have been
written off, as in the opinion of the management the same are no longer
payable. The auditors have relied on the judgment of the management in
this regard.

f) The balances in receivables are subject to
confirmation. The management is of the opinion that all the receivables
reflected in the financial statements are fully realisable and that
there is no impairment in them. During the year under review balances in
the accounts of the several receivables have been written off because
in the opinion of the management the same are no longer receivable. The
auditors have relied on the judgement of the management in this regard.

Indirect Taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
10. ST 3-Due date for October to March 13 extended to 10th September, 2013 Order No. 4/2013-ST

Due to difficulties faced by some assesses in uploading the offline utilities, due date for submission of the Form ST-3 for the period from 1st October 2012 to 31st March 2013, has been extended from 31st August, 2013 to 10th September, 2013.

MVAT UPDATE

11.Amendments in Audit Form 704

Notification No VAT/AMD-2013 /1B/Adm-8 dated 23-08-2013

Vide this notification amendments are made in MVAT Audit Form 704.

12.TDS Return to be E-filed

Notification No VAT/AMD-2013/1B/Adm-8 dated 01- 07-2013

Vide this notification, it is provided that return in Form 424 regarding TDS shall be uploaded in electronic form.

13.Norms to qualify as Tribunal Member relaxed

Notification No VAT-1513/CR.96/Taxation-1 dated 07-08-2013

Vide this notification, eligibility requirement for appointment of tribunal member is changed. Now a person who has for a continuous period of not less than two years (earlier three years) held an office, not below the rank of Joint Commissioner of Sales Tax, in the Sales Tax Department of the State Government can be appointed as tribunal member.

14.Administrative Instructions in respect of Assessment/ Audit Plan for the periods 2006-07 to 2010-11

Circular No. 10A OF 2013 dated 28-08-2013

The Commissioner has given administrative instructions in respect of assessment and audit plan for the periods 2006-07 to 2010-11.

Business Etiquette

fiogf49gjkf0d
In the previous articles, we discussed etiquette norms for email phones and business meetings. It might be a good idea now to touch upon how personal grooming, attire and dining etiquette can make a great contribution in your overall success rating. In this concluding series of article on Business Etiquette, we shall discuss those norms in addition to discussing etiquette requirements for conducting a teleconference.

Etiquette for teleconferencing
An important consideration one has to keep in mind while engaging in teleconferencing, (especially with overseas client) is that you are not visible to him. The way you speak and conduct yourself on the phone is the sole criteria of his judgment. While most are familiar with general norms for conducting one on one teleconference, the challenge of engaging on multi-level team teleconference is entirely different. Some of the essential points are given below:

  • Set up an agenda and duration of call in advance.
  • Choose an anchor who will conduct the teleconference and introduce his team members.
  • Start with greeting and small talk not more than a minute.
  • If situation demands long articulation from one side, then keep asking for confirmation from the other side every few minutes. These could be ‘Do you agree?, Is it ok?, Am I coming out clear?, any queries?’ etc.
  • If no answer is forthcoming, then ask the anchor on the other side whether you can continue.
  • Do not interrupt the other side when they are talking. If you must, then interrupt with apology and explain the reason. If the interrupter is person other than the anchor, then he must announce his name and designation. This will remove confusion in the mind of person on the other side as to who has interrupted, why and at what designation level to appropriately respond to the interrupter.
  • If you find difficulty in understanding the accent, request the other side to repeat the sentence and to speak slowly.
  • If the other side has not understood you correctly then use sentences like ‘I think I need to explain more clearly’ or ‘I am afraid I have not been able to communicate it properly’. Never say ‘You are not understanding’ or ‘Your understanding is wrong’.
  • In case of a disagreement on a point, do not stretch it. Say ‘This may need further discussions, let’s park it’ and move on to the next point.
  • Wind up with summary and action plan on both sides.

Personal grooming and attire:
Famous American thinker Emerson once said ‘People begin to evaluate us before any words are ever spoken, who you are speaks so loudly —- I do not hear what you say’. Thus the way you dress and observe personal hygiene will have an impact on your chance to succeed. Some important etiquette tips are given below:

  • Always dress appropriate to occasion. Do not overdress or wear casuals for business meeting. If not sure about the dress code, it is better to stick to semiformal.
  • Ensure that your hair is properly combed and nails are clean and manicured. Shoes should be well polished.
  • The tie should not stretch below the belt. It is a general norm to wear the belt of the same colour as that of the shoes. Socks should be matching the colour of trousers.
  • Do not carry loose sheaf of papers. Carry a folder or a briefcase.
  • Do not make multiple fold of paper and stuff them in the pocket. Pockets should not be bulgy with papers and/or coins.
  • The pen should always be kept in the breast pocket of coat and not in the front pocket of a shirt.


Dining etiquette:
Business lunch and dinner have become indispensable part of modern business. Hospitality is not just a formality but a vehicle to conclude many important business negotiations. Though dining protocols are a subject by themselves and can warrant a separate article, it is essential to know a few basic etiquette norms. They are given below:

  • Always find out the preference of the guest if you are the host.
  • Reach a few minutes early than the given time if you are the host.
  • Please wait to be seated in a fine dining restaurant or a coffee shop of hotel.
  • Belongings should not be kept on the table but on the floor on the right hand.
  • Do not pick up napkin/spoon if it falls down. Politely ask a serving waiter for a new one.
  • Do not blow on hot food to cool it.
  • In the overseas restaurant ask for ‘No Meat’ dishes if you are a vegetarian. In some countries fish food is considered vegetarian.
  • Do not unfold napkin with jerk. When not finished with your meal, please ensure to leave the napkin on the seat if you need to leave your seat for any reason. If you have finished your meal, then please put the napkin on the table. These are silent signals to the waiter.
  • Swab the napkin on your face — Do not wipe with it.
  • Serving is always done from left to right and clearing from right to left. When you find multiple cutlery by your side for different courses, please use the same from the extreme left to right for each course. In such restaurants, water glass for you is on your right side.
  • Please do not use toothpick without covering your mouth with hands.
  • Start discussing business only after ordering is finished. However, you must be aware about protocols of certain countries like Japan where no business discussion is expected to be conducted over meal.
  • Please be discreet about settling the bill. Do not disclose the amount. Be quick to ask the bill as a signal to the serving staff as to who is the host.
  • Always thank the guest for his having graced the invitation and ask him whether he enjoyed the meal.

All the etiquette norms that we have discussed in the series of articles are only indicative. One must remember that the best etiquette is caring for comfort of others around you in a genuine way.

ICAI and its members

fiogf49gjkf0d
1. Code of ethics

The Ethical Standards Board of ICAI has considered some ethical issues which have been published in C.A. Journal for September, 2011, at page 380. Some of these issues are as under:

(i) Issue: If a member has passed any additional course of the ICAI, is he permitted to print such qualification on visiting cards, letter heads and other stationery?

Under Clause (7) of Part I of the First Schedule to the C.A. Act, a member is permitted to print such qualification on the visiting cards, letter heads and other stationery like a degree of a University established by law in India or recognised by the Central Government or a title indicating membership of the ICAI or of any other Institution that has been recognised by the Central Government or may be recognised by the Council.

(ii) Issue: Whether a member in practice can use the designation (District Governor) in his rotary visiting card along with the term ‘Chartered Accountant’?

The member who is in practice cannot use the designation of ‘District Governor’ in his rotary visiting card along with the term ‘Chartered Accountant’.

(iii) Issue: Whether public notice published in the newspaper by a Chartered Accountant individually or jointly with an Advocate in respect of acquirement of land by their client is permitted?

In terms of the Guidelines under Clause (7) of Part I of the First Schedule to the C.A. Act, as appearing in the Code of Ethics, the public notice published in the newspaper in respect of acquirement of land by their client is permissible.

(iv) Issue: Whether it is obligatory for the auditor appointed to conduct a special audit u/s.233A of the Companies Act to communicate with the previous auditor who has conducted the regular audit for the period covered by the special audit?

Council direction under Clause (8) of Part I of the First Schedule to the C.A. Act prescribes that it is not obligatory for the auditor appointed to conduct a special audit u/s.233A of the Companies Act to communicate with the previous auditor who has conducted the regular audit for the period covered by the special audit.

(v) Issue: Whether a Chartered Accountant in practice can accept audit in case the audit fee of the previous auditor remains unpaid?

In case the undisputed audit fees for carrying out the statutory audit under the Companies Act, or various other statues have not been paid, the incoming auditor should not accept the appointment unless such fees are paid. In respect of other dues, the incoming auditor should in appropriate circumstances use his influence in favour of his predecessor to have the dispute as regards the fees settled.

(vi) Issue: Whether a Chartered Accountant firm can accept branch audit of a bank when a partner has taken loan from any other branch of the same bank?

Independence of Auditors can neither be diluted nor any scope be left for dilution in the eye of stakeholders. The term ‘indebtness’ must continue to be in relation to an entity and not in relation to a branch. Thus if a partner has taken loan from any branch of a bank, the firm is not allowed to do the audit of other branch of that bank.

2. Opinion on financial statements when there is substantial interest

The Council has revised the existing guidelines on the above subject w.e.f. 28-6-2011 as under.

“A member of the Institute shall not express his opinion on financial statements of any business or enterprise in which one or more persons who are his ‘Relatives’ within the meaning of Accounting Standard (AS-18) has/have, either by themselves or in conjunction with such member, a substantial interest in the said business or enterprise.

Explanation — For this purpose and for the purpose of compliance of clause (4) of Part I of the Second Schedule of the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, the expression ‘Substantial Interest’ shall have the same meaning as is assigned thereto under Appendix (9) of the Chartered Accountants Regulations 1988.”

It may be noted that para 10.9 of AS-18 defines ‘Relative’ to mean ‘in relation to an individual, means the spouse, son, daughter, brother, sister, father and mother who may be expected to influence or be influenced by that Individual in his/her dealing with the reporting enterprise.’ (Refer pages 488-489 of C.A. Journal for September, 2011).

3. Answer Books of ICAI Examination
In a recent decision of the Supreme Court of India, in a dispute under the Right to Information Act, it is held that ICAI must disclose, if requested by a candidate in its examination, the standard criteria relating to moderation employed by it for the purpose of making revision. The submission of ICAI that it had copy right over question papers and, therefore, this cannot be disclosed even after the tests was rejected by the Court. Further, the submission to the effect that if this criteria is disclosed, the workload on the Institute will increase and it will be difficult to handle this workload in view of the large number of candidates who may demand this information, the Supreme Court has said that “Additional workload is not a defence. If there are practical insurmountable difficulties, it is open to the examining bodies to bring them to the notice of the Government for consideration, so that any changes to the Act can be deliberated upon. Examining bodies like ICAI should change their old mindsets and tune them to the new regime of the disclosure of maximum information. Public authorities should realise that in an era of transparency, previous practices of unwarranted secrecy have no longer a place”.

4. K.Y.C. Norms
The Council has formulated the following Know Your Client Norms (KYC norms) which shall be recommendatory in nature, and apply only in case of attest function by members in practice w.e.f. 13-7-2011.

K.Y.C. Norms

The financial services industry globally is required to obtain information of their clients and comply Know Your Client Norms (KYC norms).

Keeping in mind the highest standards of Chartered Accountancy profession in India, the Council of ICAI thought it necessary to recommend such norms to be observed by the members of the profession who are in practice.

In light of this background, the Council of ICAI approved the following KYC Norms. However, these norms are recommendatory in nature and every Chartered Accountant carrying out attest function is encouraged to follow them.

1. Entity Information
(i) General Information — (a) Name of the Entity, (b) Type of Entity and (c) Business Description

(ii) Corporate Structure — (a) Name of ultimate parent company, (b) Name of parent company and (c) Name of Affiliates

(iii) Regulatory Information — (a) Company PAN No., (b) Company Identification No., (c) Directors’ Identification No., (d) Directors’ Name & Addresses and (e) Name(s) and Addresses of Companies, in which above person is director

2. Other information
a) Entities financial information, (b) Name of the ultimate parent Auditor and (c) Any known violation of any Law/Regulations

5. EAC Opinion

ESOP Accounting on Account of Revision of the Exercise Price

Facts:
A listed manufacturing company had granted stock options to its employees (‘ESOP’) in August, 2007. Total number of options granted originally was 10,000 to be vested over a period of 4 years i.e., 25% each year. Market price of shares of the company on the date of ESOP grant was Rs.2,800 per share and exercise price was Rs.2,000 per share.view of AS-16.

On account of attritions/non-fulfilment of eligibility conditions, the number of options has been reduced to 9,000 in the year 2009. The company has followed intrinsic value method for ESOP accounting as provided by the ‘Guidance Note on Accounting for Employee Share-based Payments’ issued by ICAI.

The company decides to revise the exercise price as Rs.1,800 per share in 2009 on account of reduction in market price of company’s share which was Rs.2,000 per share in that year.

The company has raised the following questions.

(i)    Whether any additional charge is to be taken to the profit and loss account under employee cost on revision of exercise price in 2009. If yes, what will be the amount to be charged as employee cost on revision of the exercise price from 2009 onwards?

(ii)    Whether the extra charge in 2008 will be adjustable in subsequent charge to the profit and loss account in the remaining vesting period, consequent upon reduction in the number of ESOPs eligible for exercise in 2009.

(iii)    What will be the treatment of the amount credited to the ESOP Outstanding Account against original grant, i.e., Rs.800 per share (Rs.2,800 less Rs.2,000) at the time of exercise of options?

Opinion

The Committee has noted that ICAI has issued a ‘Guidance Note on Accounting for Employee Share – based Payments’. It is also noted that SEBI has also issued the “Securities And Exchange Board of India (Employee Stock Option Scheme and Employee Stock Purchase Scheme). The Committee has noted that while accounting for modification of terms of stock option is not addressed in SEBI Guidelines, the same is addressed in ICAI Guidance Note.

After detailed consideration of the above guidance notes, the committee has given the following opinion.

(i)    Incremental cost on account of revision of exercise price is required to be accounted for in respect of outstanding options on the basis of difference between the exercise price measured immediately before and after the revision. As regards the amount to be charged from 2009 onwards as employee cost on account of revision of the exercise price, it should be the sum of the amount chargeable as per original plan plus the relevant portion of the incremental cost to be expensed. The basis of amortisation of the incremental cost should be same as adopted for amortisation of the original cost as per SEBI Guidelines.

(ii)    Extra charge in 2009 will be the net result of accounting for lapses and accounting for incremental cost expensed as explained in paragraph 15 of the opinion.

(iii)    At the time of exercise of the option, amount in ESOP Outstanding Account, to the extent that it is related to the options exercised, should be debited along with the consideration received against them (viz. cash/bank account), while Share Capital and Share Premium account should be credited as explained in para 16 of the opinion.

(Refer pages 416 to 419 of C.A. Journal for September, 2011)

6.    Unique Document Identification (UDIN)
Time and again, various authorities across the country have reposed their faith in chartered accountants as professionals realising the work of their attributes like integrity, excellence and independence. Based on the same, they are relying on various certifications being issued by chartered accountants in practice in the normal course of business. They look upto chartered accountants as reliable source of authentic information and to ensure compliance with various rules, regulations, procedures stipulated under different statues.

However, many instances have been brought to the attention of ICAI wherein financial statements and certificates issued by non -members or members not holding Certificate of Practice have been relied upon by authorities as true statements and certificates. It needs no reiteration that a certificate issued by a practising chartered accountant binds him to its accuracy and subject him to disciplinary proceedings of the Institute, in case a complain in that regard is filed with the Institute by the concerned authorities or any affected party.

To ensure the authenticity of various statements and documents being certified/attested by Chartered Accountants, ICAI has introduced the new concept of Unique Document Identification Number. The said scheme is available at the link http:/www.icai.org/uid

Clarifications on various issues relating to UDIN are given on pages 504 and 505 of C.A. Journal for September, 2011.

7.    CA Profession and Women Empowerment
In the CA students Journal for September, 2011, a write-up on this topic states that CA is one profession which, of late, is witnessing a significant spurt in the number of girls enroling and qualifying in C.A. examination and also figuring prominently in the top 50 Merit List. Some noteworthy information in the write-up is as under.

(i)    Ms. Shirin K. Engineer became the first woman CA 1933. She was followed by Ms. R. Shivabhogam in 1947 and Ms. Nilima Chatterjee in 1954.

(ii)    In November, 1983, Ms. Nandita P. (Shah) Parekh got the honour of becoming the first lady candidate to secure the first rank in C.A. Final Examination. She was followed by Ms. C. V. Sakunthala who secured first rank in May, 1984, Final Examination. Both these girls were awarded special prizes by our Prime Minister late Mrs. Indira Gandhi at a special function organised by the Institute. During the years 1989 to 2011, 14 girl candidates have secured the first rank in Final Examination. In May, 2011 Final Examination all the first three ranks have been secured by girls viz. Ms. Maitreyee Rajaput (Pune), Arti Jain (Bikaner) and Charmy Sheth (Mumbai).

(iii)    The membership of women in C.A. profession in the span of 16 years from 1995 to 2010 has increased from 5.21% in 1995 to 18% in 2010. The women membership increased from 3697 in 1995 to 29491 in 2011. The increase of women in part-time practice was from 541 to 1387, (b) full-time practice 1569 to 9139 and (c) not in practice 1587 to 18965.

ICAI News

fiogf49gjkf0d
(Note : Page Nos. given below are from CA Journal for September, 2012)

 i) Audit of smaller entities: ICAI has prepared a note on the above subject which has been published on pages 453 to 465 of CA Journal for September, 2012. The Standards on Auditing, issued by ICAI, contain objectives, requirements and application and other explanatory material that are designed to support the auditor in obtaining reasonable assurance about the financial statements and express an appropriate opinion. The note prepared by ICAI explains the importance by using SA for Audit of small entities.

ii) Eligibility of paid assistant in CA firm Regulation 43 of Chartered Accountants Regulations has been amended w.e.f 1-8-2012, providing that the period of employment of paid assistant to the same firm of Chartered Accountants for the purpose of engagement of articled assistants 111 (2012) 44-b BCAJ has been increased from the present period of 12 months to 3 years. This notification is available on Institute Website (Page 518).

iii) New branches of students association The following two branches have been opened for Western India Chartered Accountants Students Association w.e.f. 4-7-2012 (Page 518). a) Gandhidham Branch of WICASA b) Solapur Branch of WICASA iv) Announcement for members in practice The following announcement has been published by ICAI (Page 518).

In continuation of the Announcement published in the February, 2011 issue of the C. A. journal at 1174, attention of the members in practice is hereby once again drawn to the resolution of the Council taken in December, 2010 required to be complied with, while responding to tenders or enquiries issued by various users of professional services.

In terms of the said Council decision, a member in practice responding to tenders and accepting professional work based thereon, is required to maintain a cost sheet incorporating therein details of the costs being incurred therein having regard to number of persons involved, hours to be spent, etc.

The said cost sheet is required to be submitted to the Institute, when so directed. Members concerned are required to take note of the above and ensure compliance, in their own interest.

EAC Opinion

fiogf49gjkf0d
Accounting for book value of fixed assets demolished for expansion purpose.

Facts:

A company is an infrastructure company, which is developing, constructing, operating and maintaining an international airport. The company has in its Fixed Assets Register (FAR), various assets, which include buildings and other infrastructure assets used for the airport operations. Depreciation is provided on straight line method (SLM) based on the useful life of the assets in line with the rates prescribed under Schedule XIV to the Companies Act,1956 which are considered as the minimum rates.

The company has stated that after three years of commencement of operations, the company is planning to expand the existing terminal building in order to cater to the increase in passenger traffic movement. Due to this, portion/part of the existing building and other infrastructure assets may have to be demolished. The book value of those assets are of material amounts. Net realisable values arising from disposal of those assets are not material. This demolition is required exclusively for the expansion of the terminal building. Kind of assets demolished includes : (a) part of building, (b) escalators, (c) furniture and fittings and (d) electrical installations.

Query:

On the basis of the above, the company has sought the opinion of Expert Advisory Committee on the treatment of the above value of assets in the books of the company?

Opinion:

The Committee notes that in the company’s case, the fixed assets register is being maintained wherein the details of various assets, viz., buildings, escalators, etc. are being recorded separately and , therefore, the assets which are being demolished can be identified separately. Further, it is understood from the Facts of the Case that the existing assets are being demolished and there is no intention to refurbish such assets. Further, these assets will not be used in future.

The Committee is also of the view that there could be the possibility of a time gap between the time when these assets are retired from their active use and the time when these are demolished/ disposed off. The Committee, considering AS 10

 “Accounting for Fixed Assets”, is of the view that a fixed asset should be eliminated from the financial statements on disposal or when no further benefit is expected from its use and disposal. Further, as per the requirements of AS 10, when an already existing fixed asset is demolished for constructing a new asset, it is the derecognition principles of AS 10, which are to be first applied to the existing asset before recognition of a new asset, irrespective of the purpose for which it has been demolished/ disposed off. Accordingly, the Committee is of the view that on disposal/demolition of the existing fixed assets, the carrying amounts of the portion/items of the fixed assets demolished/disposed off, should be eliminated from the financial statements and the gain or loss on derecognition, i.e., the difference between the net disposal proceeds (if any) and the net book value of such fixed assets, should be recognised in the statement of profit and loss.

As regards capitalisation of book value of the demolished asset to the cost of new asset to be constructed, the Committee is of the view that although demolition/disposal of the existing asset may be necessary for the construction of new asset, the demolished asset is not part of the construction activity and accordingly, can not be said to be directly related to the specific asset or attributable to the construction activity in general. Therefore, the book value of the demolished/disposal of asset should not be capitalised as part of the cost of the new asset.

Code of Ethics

fiogf49gjkf0d
The Ethical Standards Board of ICAI has given answers to some of the ethical issues raised by our members. These are published on pages 416- 418 of C.A. Journal for September, 2012. Some of these issues are as under:

 (i) Issue: In a representation submitted to a company u/s. 225(3) of the Companies Act, 1956, the auditors of the company included the contribution made by the firm in strengthening the control procedures of the company during their association with the company. Is it misconduct? Para (i) under Clause (6) of Part 1 of the First Schedule to the CA Act, provides for scope of such representation, which an Auditor is entitled to make u/s. 225(3) of the Companies Act, 1956. This section permits a retiring auditor to make a representation in writing (not exceeding a reasonable length) to the company. The proposition of the partner to highlight contributions made by the firm in strengthening the control procedures in the representation should not be included in such representation because the representation letter should not be prepared in a manner so as to seek publicity. The Code of Ethics issued by the Institute makes it amply clear that the right to make representation does not mean that an auditor has any prescriptive right or a lien on an audit. The wording of his representation should be such that apart from the opportunity not being abused to secure needless publicity, it does not tantamount directly or indirectly to canvassing or soliciting for his continuance as an auditor. The letter should merely set out in a dignified manner how he has been acting independently and conscientiously through the term of office and may, in addition, indicate if he so chooses his willingness to continue as auditor if re-appointed by the shareholders. The representation proposed by the auditors could not be approved since, it may lead to his being held P. N. Shah H. N. Motiwalla Chartered Accountants icai and its members guilty of professional misconduct under Clause (6) of Part 1 of the First Schedule to the Act.

(ii) Issue:

Can a Chartered Accountant in practice, accept original professional work emanating from the client introduced to him by another member? Para (i) under Clause (6) of Part 1 of the First Schedule to the Act prescribes that a member should not accept the original professional work emanating from a client introduced to him by another member. If any professional work of such client comes to him directly, it should be his duty to ask the client that he should come through the other member dealing generally with his original work.

(iii) Issue:

Whether a Chartered Accountant in practice can give public interviews and also whether he can furnish details about himself or his firm in such interviews? A Chartered accountant in practice can give public interviews. While doing so, due care should be taken to ensure that such interviews or details about the member or his/her firm is not given in a manner highlighting the professional attainments, which may hit clauses (6) & (7) of the First Schedule of the Act.

(iv) Issue:

 Whether a Chartered Accountant in practice can use expression like Income Tax Consultant, Cost Accountant, Company Secretary, Cost Consultant or a Management Consultant? Council direction under Clause (7) of Part 1 of the First Schedule to the Act which prescribes that it is improper for a Chartered Accountant to state on his professional documents that he is an Income tax Consultant, Cost Accountant, Company Secretary, Cost Consultant or a Management Consultant. However, it is permitted to mention his/her degrees.

(v) Issue:

Can a Chartered Accountant in practice give the date of setting up the practice or date of establishment on the letterheads and other professional documents, etc.? Council direction under Clause (7) of Part 1 of the First Schedule to the Act prescribes that the date of setting up of the firm on the letterheads and the professional documents, etc. should not be mentioned. However, in the Website, the year of establishment can be given on a specific “pull” request.