Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

From The President

fiogf49gjkf0d
Dear Members,

By the time this issue reaches your hands, most of you would be feeling relaxed after the hectic days in the end of September. This year Ganesh Chaturthi festival being in the second fortnight of the month, everybody would have faced difficulties and pressure situations. But, surely Lord Vignaharta was there to take care of all the stress. Every year when the deadline approaches, there is a clamour for extension of the date. I would earnestly request each one of you to ask a question to oneself – Do we really need the extension? I am sure the answer would be ‘no extension’, as the scenario would be the same for next month also. The only solution is to educate clients, chalk out systematic schedules, and accept assignments that are within our capacity.

Friends, it’s time to rejoice now and put aside all the stressful & negative experience, and celebrate the positive spiritual vibrations emanating from the coming holy festivals of Navratri & Dussera.

On the Society front, I am happy to share with you that the most eagerly awaited event – our 46th RRC – to be held this year at Bangalore, has received an overwhelming response, and enrolment was closed within a week of it’s announcement. I congratulate our Seminar Committee for the same, and I am sure members enrolled will have a great time. The International Taxation Committee and Taxation Committee of BCAS has forwarded the representation on draft report of the Expert Committee on GAAR, and we do hope that the issues covered in the representation will be considered by the Committee.

I have received various emails and feedback from members suggesting organisation of programmes and events at bigger venues, as they could not attend the programme as enrolment was closed. At the outset, I on behalf of BCAS am thankful to all for attending the programmes in large numbers. We have taken note of the inconvenience faced in the past few months, but my only request to all would be to enrol well in advance and not to wait till the last date. Your early action will help us to take remedial action to the extent possible. At this juncture, I would also urge members to enrol for WEB TV facility offered by BCAS, as then, one can watch the important seminars or lecture meetings posted on the WEB TV. I with all earnestness request all our esteemed readers and members to continue their feedback.

I would like to take this opportunity in this month’s communiqué to delve upon an issue that is on our minds, but has taken a back seat and that is of ‘Being Human’. In a society, where the barometer of happiness is judged through one’s wealth and riches, being ‘human’ is a rare quality.

This issue is aimed at getting us working professionals to take a second out from our busy lives to contribute to the society at large, for what is a professional who has no heart and only a mind? There are endless questions that bother us, but none more pertinent than those that follow:

 Is it right to charge a person who lives below the poverty line for a fatal illnesses like cancer ? Is it right to charge a client more than what he has been serviced for ? In charging fees, should one charge fees commensurate with service or according to the ‘ability to pay’ principle ? The so called ‘realists’ would say ‘yes’ and in their truculent manner, state that it is essential to do so to survive.

The Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 gives an overview of what is ethical and what isn’t, but there is only one guide book which shows us what we should do and what we shouldn’t and that is our conscience. And though we, who are deemed to be the smartest minds in the professional world can manipulate documents and numbers, can we sleep in peace when we know the ‘best practices’ that are being followed aren’t what they should be?

The world has become a place where there is growing interdependence amongst nations, where the previously existing fissiparous tendencies have given way to a cordial environment, where individuals now work without any cultural barriers. In such a global workspace, it is important that we as Indians and especially chartered accountants should set the benchmark. And for me, that would be being human along with being witty. For that would definitely take us places. Here is a real life example:

One of the more heart-warming stories involves a young man, his dying grandmother, and a bowl of clam chowder from Panera Bread. It’s a little story that offers big lessons about service, brands, and the human side of business — a story that underscores why efficiency should never come at the expense of humanity.

Brandon Cook, from Wilton, New Hampshire, was visiting his grandmother in the hospital. Terribly ill with cancer, she complained to her grandson that she desperately wanted a bowl of soup, and that the hospital’s soup was inedible. If only she could get a bowl of her favourite clam chowder from Panera Bread! Trouble was, Panera only sells clam chowder on Friday. So Brandon called the nearby Panera and talked to store manager Suzanne Fortier. Not only did Sue make clam chowder specially for Brandon’s grandmother, she included a box of cookies as a gift from the staff.
It was a small act of kindness that would not normally make headlines. Except that Brandon told the story on his Facebook page, and Brandon’s mother, Gail Cook, retold the story on Panera’s fan page. The rest, as they say, is social-media history. Gail’s post generated 500,000 (and counting) “likes” and more than 22,000 comments on Panera’s Facebook page. Panera, meanwhile, got something that no amount of traditional advertising can buy — a genuine sense of affiliation and appreciation from customers around the world.
Marketing types have latched on to this story as an example of the power of social media and “virtual wordof- mouth” to boost a company’s reputation. But I see the reaction to Sue Fortier’s gesture as an example of something else — the hunger among customers, employees, and all of us to engage with companies on more than just dollars-and-cents terms. In a world that is being reshaped by the relentless advance of technology, what stands out are acts of compassion and connection that remind us what it means to be human.
All of us cannot be philanthropists and open a ‘Being Human’ NGO, for we have our own lives to look into, but we definitely can do something, which would give us a sense of satisfaction which material things will not, and I am sure our auditor i.e. God would want to see a healthy balance sheet.

At BCAS, few of our members actively involve themselves, in activities that are being carried out by BCAS Foundation. One such activity is “Chalo English Sikhaye” , where the volunteers teach English to students of Standard 5th to 8th, studying in vernacular schools. There are a lot of other activities which are carried on by BCAS Foundation with other similar organisations. Any member who is interested, may volunteer and join hands with other fellow colleagues for the good cause.

I wish all the luck to Team India, and let’s hope that they lift the World Twenty-20 Cup.

With Warm Regards,

Yours truly,

Deepak R. Shah

levitra

Lecture Meetings

fiogf49gjkf0d
Subject : Developments in Accounting Standards—In India and Globally

Speaker : Shri Narendra P. Sarda
Day and Date : Wednesday, 4th September, 2013
Venue : K. C. College, Mumbai

Objective of the lecture: To take participants through a journey of the world of accounting developments internationally and in India.

The speaker first dealt broadly with the journey of Accounting Standards formation in India:

Year 1973 – IASC was formed

Year 1977 – ICAI issued the Preface to Accounting Standards.

Year 1977-1993 – 15 Accounting Standards were notified. The pace was slow as India was an insulated economy.

Year 1993-2000 – This was a period of lull, when there were no new AS notified.

Year 2000 – There was a pressure from regulators to keep pace with the international developments in the accounting world, as India had liberalised its policies and there was expectation from the international community to have financial statements prepared at par with international best practices.

Year 2000-2007 – New Accounting Standards formulated included standards on Consolidation, Segment Reporting, Related Parties, etc. There were not only recognition standards, but also standards on disclosures.

Year 2007 – As India was moving fast towards raising resources from foreign countries and there was a flow of foreign companies setting up operations in India, there was a debate as to whether IFRS should be adopted in totality or whether there should be convergence with IFRS. India decided to converge with IFRS.

The speaker highlighted that 95% of countries have decided to converge with IFRS. He also detailed the difference of adoption and convergence with IFRS.

Adoption – Adopt IFRS in totality.

Convergence – Formulate these as such that they are almost on par with IFRS, with some departures considering local business and legal requirements.

Most of the countries in Europe apply IFRS only for Consolidated Financial Statements (CFS), whereas Standalone Financial Statements (SFS) are allowed to be prepared as per local GAAP.

The speaker was of the opinion that India should have done the same; however, India took a decision of applying converged Indian Accounting Standards to CFS as well as SFS.

A set of 35 converged Accounting Standards was prepared and NACAS reviewed the same and these have been put up on MCA’s website. However, the applicability of the same has not yet been announced.

The speaker informed that at present there are three sets of Accounting Standards in India.

• Converged Accounting Standards (IndAS), which are not yet applicable;

• Mandatory Accounting Standards, which are applicable as per the Companies Act, 1956; and

• ICAI-promulgated Accounting Standards, which are applicable to all the other entities.

The speaker then discussed the carve-outs in converged Accounting Standards (IndAS) which are not part of IFRS.

He listed and discussed in detail the carve-outs on the following standards:

• IndAS 21 – The Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates;

• IndAS103 – Business Combinations;

• IndAS 19 – Employee Benefits;

• IndAS 11 – Construction Contracts;

• IndAS101 – First Time Adoption of Indian Accounting Standards;

• IndAS 27 – Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements;

• IndAS 20 – Accounting for Government Grants and Disclosure of Government Assistance;

The speaker also informed the participants about the Revised Schedule VI which is based on IAS 1 and IndAS 1 – Presentation of Financial Statements. As per Revised Schedule VI, Accounting Standards are supreme and if there is any variance between the Revised Schedule VI and Accounting Standards, the Accounting Standards will have to be followed. In view of the same, AS-1 which was based on the Old Schedule VI has been under revision to fall in line with the reporting requirements as prescribed in Revised Schedule VI.

While dealing with the Financial Instruments standards, he brought out an interesting fact that IndAS 39–Financial Instruments–Recognition and Measurement is promulgated but not yet applicable. Similarly AS 30, 31 & 32 dealing with Financial Instruments are also not applicable. Hence at present only AS 13–Accounting for Investments is mandatory and there are no applicable standards for Derivative Contracts. However, on the concept of prudence, ICAI came out with an announcement for accounting and recognising losses on Derivative Contracts though there is no standard made applicable.

The speaker then dealt with the conceptual differences between IFRS and Indian Accounting Standards. He highlighted the main differences as follows:

• IFRS is more focused on Fair Value Accounting;

• Under IFRS, more importance is attached to the balance sheet, whereas in India, importance is to assess the profitability;

• IFRS provides importance to Time Value of Money and hence there is discounting approach;

• IFRS gives more importance to the substance of the transaction than to the form of the same; and

• IFRS is based more on judgments.

He also briefly discussed the draft Tax Accounting Standards (TAS) proposed by the Indian tax authorities. He said that the committee formed to prepare draft TAS, has identified 14 AS where there is a requirement to have separate TAS.

After discussing specifics of the Accounting Standards, the speaker dealt with global developments. He elaborated that earlier there was a competition in drafting Accounting Standards between US GAAP and IASB. However, of late, the approach is that of coordination. There are five specific areas where both the organisations are working on joint projects. The same are as follows:

• Financial Instruments;

• FV Measurement;

• Revenue Recognition;

• Lease Accounting; and

• Insurance Contracts.

He also dealt with the economic crisis of the year 2008, which made all the accounting bodies to accept the fact that there is a need for globally accepted Accounting Standards. There has to be more clarity and guidance for accounting and disclosure of Complex Financial Instruments and Off-Balance Sheet items should be examined thoroughly and to the maximum extent avoided.

Before concluding, he also provided an overview of the developments and progress on various joint projects between FASB and IASB.

The lecture was very well appreciated by the audience and concluded with a well deserved vote of thanks to the speaker.

levitra

ICAI and its members

fiogf49gjkf0d
1. Code of Ethics:

The Ethical Standards Board of ICAI has given answers to some ethical issues raised by our members. These are published on pages 388 to 390 of C. A. Journal for September, 2013. Some of these issues are as under:

Issue:
Can a Chartered Accountant in practice allow any person to practice in his name as a Chartered Accountant?

No, clause (1) of Part-I of the First Schedule to the CA Act prohibits a Chartered Accountant in practice to allow any person to practice in his name as a Chartered Accountant unless such person is also a Chartered Accountant in practice and is in partnership with or employed by him.

Issue:
Can a Chartered Accountant in practice pay to any person any share, commission or brokerage in the fees or profits of his professional business?

No, clause (2) of Part-I of the First Schedule to the CA Act prohibits a Chartered Accountant from paying or allowing any share, commission or brokerage in the fees or profits of his professional business, to any person other than a member of the Institute or a partner or a retired partner or the legal representative of the deceased partner or a member of any other professional body or with such other persons having such qualifications as may be prescribed, for the purpose of rendering such professional services from time to time in or outside India.

Issue:
Can a Chartered Accountant in practice share his fees with the Government in respect of Government Audit?

The Council considered the issue and while noting that the Government is asking auditors to deposit such percentage of their audit fee for recovering the administrative and other expenses incurred in the process, the Council decided that as such there is no bar in the Code of Ethics to accept such assignment wherein a percentage of professional fees is deducted by the Government to meet administrative and other expenditure.

Issue:
Can goodwill of a Chartered Accountant firm be purchased?

Yes. The Council of the Institute considered the issue whether the goodwill of a proprietary firm of a Chartered Accountant can be sold/transferred to another eligible member of the Institute, after the death of the proprietor concerned and came to the view that the same is permissible. Accordingly, the Council passed the Resolution that the sale/transfer of goodwill in the case of a proprietary firm of Chartered Accountants to another eligible member of the Institute, shall be permitted.

Issue:
Can a practicing Chartered Accountant secure any professional business through the services of a person who is not his employee or partner?

No, clause (5) of Part-I of the First Schedule to the C. A. Act prohibits a practicing Chartered Accountant from securing any professional business, either through the services of a person who is not an employee of such Chartered Accountants or who is not his partner.

Issue:
Can a practicing Chartered Accountant solicit clients or professional work by advertisement?

No. Clause (6) of Part-I of the First Schedule to the CA Act prohibits a practicing Chartered Accountant from soliciting clients or professional work either directly or indirectly by circular, advertisement, personal communication or interview or by any other means.

However, there are the following exceptions to it:

(i) A member can respond to tenders or enquiries issued by various users of professional services or organisations from time to time and securing professional work as a consequence.

(ii) A member may advertise changes in partnerships or dissolution of a firm, o r of any change in the address of practice and telephone numbers, the advertisement being limited to a bare statement of facts and consideration given to the appropriateness of the area of distribution of the newspaper or magazine and number of insertions.

(iii) A member is permitted to issue a classified advertisement in the Journal/Newspaper of the Institute intended to give information for sharing professional work on assignment basis or for seeking professional work on p a r t n e r s h i p basis or salaried employment in the field of accounting profession provided it only contains the accountant’s name, address, telephone, fax number and e-mail address.

Issue:
Whether member in practice is permitted to respond to announcement for empanelment for allotment of audit and other professional work and quote fees on enquiries being received?

It has been clarified by the Council under proviso (ii) to clause (6) of part-I of the first schedule of the CA Act that if announcements are made for empanelment by the Government, Corporations, Courts, Cooperative Societies, Banks and other similar institutions, members may respond to such announcements provided the existence of the panel is within their knowledge. The Council has further clarified that the quotations of fees can be sent, if enquiries are received by the members in this regard.

Issue:
Can a member in practice indicate in a book or an article, authored/contributed/published by him, his association with any firm of Chartered Accountants?

No, as per Para (e) under Clause(6) of Part I of First Schedule to the CA Act as appearing in the Code of Ethics, 2009, a member is not permitted to indicate in a book or an article, authored/contributed/ published by him, the association with any firm of Chartered Accountants.

EAC Opinion:

Amortisation of Land Right of Way:

Facts:
A company (hereinafter referred to as ‘the company’) is a Government company within the meaning of section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956. The shares of the company are listed with recognised stock exchanges. The company is engaged in the business of refining of crude oil and marketing of petroleum products. It has two refineries and lube blending/ filling plants. The company also has depots, installation and LPG plants across India, besides having administrative offices at Delhi, Chennai, Kolkata, Mumbai and other major cities.

The company owns pipelines for movement of petroleum products from one location to another for the purpose of stock transfer/sale. These pipelines are underground pipelines having sectionalising valve stations/intermediate pigging stations/ booster pumping stations in between. Products are pumped through these pipelines as and when movement of product is required and at any point of time, the pipeline is filled with the product. For the purpose of laying the pipelines, the company acquires ‘right of way’, i.e., right of use in land (ROU) under which such pipeline is to be laid. The right is acquired under the Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in a Land) Act, 1962, and vests absolutely with the company free from all encumbrances.

Though the ownership of the land under which the pipeline is laid continues with the land owner, the pipeline remains the property of the company. The company also has perpetual and absolute right to enter the land under which pipeline has been laid for the purpose of maintaining, examining, repairing, altering or removing any such pipeline or for doing any other acts necessary for any of the aforesaid purposes or for the utilisation of such pipeline. This enables the company to lay one or more pipelines. The land owner cannot construct any permanent structure or plant any tree having deep roots on this piece of land, though he can raise crops. According to the company, the ROU is an independent fixed asset as this right is absolute and perpetual as per the Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in Land) Act, 1962.

Query
In view of the above, the company has sought the opinion of the EAC on the issues: (i) Whether the current practice of the company not to amortise the land right of way as it is perennial in nature is correct; (ii) In case it is not correct, what should be the useful life to be considered for computing the amortisation in view of the fact that the right of way is perennial in nature?

Opinion
The Committee notes from the facts of the case and the Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in Land) Act, 1962 that the user’s right is restrictive for laying down and maintaining the pipelines and not unlimited for any purpose. Further, after considering AS–26  “Intangible Assets” particularly paragraph 68, the Committee is of the view that the useful life of an intangible asset is always finite, howsoever long and indefinite it may be. AS 26 does not justify non-amortisation; it only requires disclosures where the useful life is considered more than 10 years. It stipulates that the life has to be determined on a prudent and rational basis. The Committee also does not agree with the view of the company that the useful life of land right of way is infinite. In the view of the Committee, the useful life of the land right of way may be determined considering various technical, legal and economic factors, such as, useful life of petroleum reserves from which the petroleum products are being produced and then transported, technological changes in the transportation modes, alternative resources of energy, etc. The Committee is further of the view that as per the Standard, the useful life of the land right of way may be indefinite but it is not finite and, accordingly, the depreciable amount should be allocated on a systematic basis over the best estimate of its useful life. Therefore, the Committee is of the view that the current practice of the company not to amortise the land right of way is not correct. The Committee also wishes to point out that in case useful life of the intangible assets is determined to exceed more than 10 years, the company should provide reasons for such presumption as per the requirements of paragraph 94 of AS 26.

ICAI News:

The result of the Chartered Accountants Intermediate (IPC) Examination was declared on 31st July, 2013. The details of percentage of candidates passed in the said examinations are given below:

New Publications of ICAI

1. Handbook of Auditing Pronouncements 2013 Edition

2.  Revised–Guidance Note on Report under Section 92E of the Income-tax   Act, 1961 (Transfer Pricing)

3.  Trends and patterns in Public Finance: Theoretical and Empirical Aspect.

4.  Technical Guide on Auditing Waste Management.

Ethics and u

fiogf49gjkf0d
Gross negligence – Clause 7 of Part I of Second Schedule (contd.)

Series 5

Shrikrishna (S) –Arey Arjun, I am aware that this is the time of acute pressure of work for you. But why don’t you plan the work properly? Why such last minute rush every year?

Arjuna (A)– Hey Bhagwan! We are continuously into fire-fighting. There is no peaceful time at all! Every month, some deadline or the other. Our time-planning becomes a myth. The tax department also makes us dance to their tune any time.

S – Why? Don’t you have assistants? Why don’t you delegate some of the work?

A – Our trained articles always go on leave for exams exactly when we need them. Clients’ data is never ready when our staff is available.

S – Yours is a seasonal work due to common deadline for all tax-audits. So pressure is bound to be there. But in the Mahabharata War, it was fiercer. Death was constantly hovering around you. Still, you always looked fresh and cheerful.

A – True. But then, in that war, the fighting was only up to sunset. We could relax at nights. But in this war of tax-audits, we are fighting day and night.

S – But now everything is on computers. And there is e-filing. Then what is the problem?

A – This year, we need to upload our tax audit and other reports also. Upto last year, we were comfortable. After the returns were e-filed, we could peacefully complete the reports! Again, they are changing the forms and software every now and then. It is just chaotic!

S – You mean, fighting with a pen is more tiring than fighting with the bow and arrows. But, how do you ensure that the accounts you sign are alright?

A – Everything is Ram Bharose! Who has time to see all those things! Many of the audits we sign just like that! Now take these audits of other CA firms. All the partners of those firms are my good friends. Who has time to check their accounts? And it doesn’t look good also.

S – I remember, one Chartered Accountant signed another CA firm’s accounts in good faith like this. But unfortunately, in their scrutiny assessment, it was noticed that there was a small negative balance of cash on one day!

A – Oh God! Then what happened?

S – The tax officer simply forwarded it to your Institute as a case of negligence! Poor fellow suffered like anything.

A – But the regulation is too much. One friend of mine checked the accounts thoroughly. When that unit became NPA, the bank filed a complaint for negligence. It was revealed that he did not enquire about contingent liability. And there were many such liabilities of contingent nature. Taxation, labour litigations and what not!

S – Last time I told you, there is no end to the forms in which negligence takes place. Now, I am sure, all those company balance sheets you are signing now will carry a date of 31st August or 1st September. And I am also sure that in between, you must have sent e-mails about pending queries. That means you have created evidence of negligence against yourself!

A – No. You had once told me that a senior member of a very reputed firm was held guilty for such back-dating. So I take maximum care.

S – Good, another area of negligence is physical verification of fixed assets and stocks. Do you remember, in the Mahabharata, you used to take inventory of all weaponry—swords, bows, arrows, and also of horses, elephants, food grains and many other things. Are you doing it as an auditor?

A – We had studied all about stock-taking for the exam. In my friend’s enquiry of misconduct, there was no record at all of his ever visiting client’s office, or factory. No one from the auditor’s office ever went for stocks. And many items of machinery were not there. He used to just ‘rely on management’s certificate’.

S – I doubt whether he was obtaining any certificate. You people just mechanically mention in the report that you obtained certificates.

A – I agree. We are very much lax in taking the Management Representation Letter. I have heard stories of all such lapses being treated as misconduct.

S – Are you aware, nowadays, ROC’s inspection has been activated and there are many lapses in audit being reported? ROC is forwarding its observations directly to your Institute. And it is being treated as ‘information’ to initiate disciplinary proceedings.

A – Baap Re! I have heard many of my friends received notices from ROC’s office. They used to think that no one sees the audit reports of private limited companies. But what you say is alarming!

S – Another very important point—you people are under a sweet impression that if two directors sign the balance sheet, it is enough. But read section 215 of the Companies Act. It says what is necessary and important is the Board’s approval.

A – You had told me this once. But our friends sign in good faith, when even directors have not signed. And I know a case where the auditor signed it when only one director signed. Later on, the other director who was his brother, refused to sign the balance sheet. He wanted to take revenge on the CA since the CA had refused to take that director’s daughter as a ‘dummy’ article! So, one should never sign in good faith.

S – Quite strangely, many people argue that there was no mala fide intention. Remember, the Council is not concerned with your intentions but it wants to see whether you discharged the duties diligently. And quite often, those who claim to have clear conscience have a weak memory!

A – You started your philosophy again. Now I make a new year resolution from 1st October that I will prepare for next year’s audits right now!

S – That’s great! But let it not be the usual ‘New Year Resolution”!

Om Shanti !

The above dialogue between Shri Krishna and Arjuna is a continuation of earlier dialogues published in BCA Journals of May 2013 and June 2013. It deals with the terminologies ‘gross negligence’ and ‘lack of due diligence’ used in Clause (7) of Part I of Second Schedule. This is the most important and serious charge of misconduct. Discussion on this clause will continue.

levitra

Company Law

fiogf49gjkf0d
1) Commencement of Companies Act 2013:

The Companies Bill, 2012, received the President’s assent on 29th August 2013 and became the Companies Act, 2013 (new Act). The new Act was published in the Official Gazette on 30th August 2013. The same can be accessed at www.egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/20 13/E_27_2013_425.pdf

Different sections of the new Act will become effective on different dates as may be appointed by the Central Government by notification in the Official Gazette. On 12th September 2013, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) issued a Notification for commencement of 98 sections of the new Act, making them effective from 12th September 2013, the details of which areavailable on the MCA website.

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide Circular 16/2013 Dated 18th September 2013 clarified that with effect from 12-9-2013, the relevant sections of the Companies Act 1956 which correspond to the 98 sections of the Companies Act 2013 brought into effect from 12-09-2013 have ceased to have effect from that date. The Circular can be accessed at www.mac.gov.in/pdf/ General_Circular_16_2013.pdf

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide Circular No. 15 dated 13th September 2013, clarified that:

a) Section 2 (68) the Registrar of Companies may register those Memorandum and Articles of Association received till 11-09-2013 as per the definition clause of the Private Company under the Companies Act 1956 without referring to the definition of Private Company under the “said Act”.
b) Section 102 – Companies which have issued notices of General Meeting on or after 12-09-2013, the statement to be annexed to the Notice shall comply with additional requirements as prescribed in Section 102 of the Companies Act 2013.
c) Section 133 – Till the Standards of Accounting or any addendum thereto are prescribed by the Central Government, the existing Accounting Standards as notified under Companies Act 1956 shall continue to apply.
d) Section 180 – For notices for General Meeting issued prior to 12-09-2013, matters requiring special resolution under section 180 of the Companies Act 2013 as against ordinary resolution required under Companies Act 1956 may be passed in accordance to the requirement of Companies Act 1956.

2) Companies Removal of Difficulties Order 2013

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide its Companies (Removal of Difficulties) Order 2013 dated 20th September 2013, notified for the transfer of all matters, proceedings or cases to the Tribunal constituted under Chapter XXVII of the Companies Act 2013, that the Board or Company Law Administration shall exercise the powers of the Tribunal under sections 24, 58 and 59 of the Act namely – section 24: Power of Securities and Exchange Board to regulate issue and transfer of securities, etc., and sections 58 and 59 pertaining to share capital and debentures: Refusal of registration and appeal against refusal and rectification of register of members respectively. The order can be accessed at

3) Relaxation of Last Date and Additional Fee in Filing E-Form 23C for Appointment of Cost Auditor

Vide general Circular No. 14/2013 dated 3rd September 2013, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs has decide to extend the last date of filing and to relax the additional fess applicable on e-form 23C up to 31st October 2013 i.e., the form can be filed up to 31st October 2013 or within 90 days of the commencement of a company’s financial year to which the appointment relates, whichever is later.

4) Draft Rules under the Companies Act 2013

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has made the draft Rules for 16 chapters under the Companies Act 2013, live for public comments in the 1st phase to be received by 8th October 2013 and those in the 2nd Phase by 19th October 2013. The stakeholders can use the platform at www.ncbfeedback.mca.gov.in/ for providing their suggestions and comments on the draft rules.

levitra

Direct Taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
DTAA between India and Singapore amended — Notification No. 47/2011, dated 1-9-2011.

DTAA between India and Taipei notified — Notification No. 48/2011, dated 2-9-2011.


Procedure for regulating refund of excess amount of TDS deducted and/or paid — Circular No. 6/2011, dated 24-8-2011.

The CBDT vide Circular No. 2/2011, dated 27-4-2011 had notified the procedure to claim excess amount of TDS deducted/paid from the Assessing Officer (TDS) wherein a time limit of two years from the end of the financial year in which such tax was deducted was laid down. This condition is relaxed for the refund claims pertaining to the period up to 31-3-2009 which may now be submitted to the Assessing Officer (TDS) up to 31-12-2012.

Long-Term Infrastructure Bonds notified — Notification No. 50/2011, dated 9-9-2011.

For the purpose of section 80CCF, CBDT has notified conditions to qualify as Long-Term Infrastructure Bonds, namely:

They shall be issued by IFCI, LIC, IDFC, IIFC and NBFC as classified by RBI as Infrastructure Finance Company during financial year 2011- 2012.
The volume of issuance would be limited to 25% of the additional infrastructure investment (as specified) made by the issuer company during financial year 2011-2012.
Tenure of the Bonds would be ten years with a lock-in period of 5 years. Post that the investor would have the option to sell in the secondary market or opt for buyback scheme as mentioned in the offer document at the time of issue by the issuer. Loan, lien, etc. available post lock-in period.

PAN submission during investment is mandatory.

The yields and the end use of the proceeds have been specified.

levitra

FROM THE PRESIDENT

fiogf49gjkf0d
Dear readers,

Glass half empty or half full?

If one were to believe all the reports coming in over the last one month it would be easy to conclude that India was in the midst of a national crisis. Everything that could go wrong was going wrong. Over the last year or so scams were breaking out with a regularity that would put a railway timetable to shame. A nation that was celebrating a World Cup victory in its ‘national’ pastime, cricket had failed to win a single match against England on a miserable tour. The economy which had recovered from the 2008 crisis seemed to be floundering. Inflation was worsening and there seems to be no respite on the horizon.

A discussion in a group of friends set me thinking. Just six months ago I had persuaded the only son of a friend of mine to return to India after having completed his education explaining to him that this was the country of his dreams and not the west. In a recent conversation the young lad asked me whether I still believed what I had told him six months ago.

I think it is really a question of perception as to whether the glass is half empty or half full. The media seems to report only those stories which garner the highest TRP ratings. Corruption has been the buzz word for the last few months. It is undoubtedly true that it is a malaise that has been eating into our national fabric for over six decades and has now reached alarming proportions. However, that does not mean that there are no honest citizens left. Every day one hears stories of individuals who have shown exemplary honesty and courage. These events do not even get a mention, let alone be reported in the media. Every time there is ‘breaking news’ on television it is of an accident, a scam, a robbery or a murder. Has everything good stopped happening in this country? I think the media needs to show far more restraint and balance than it has been showing at present. There are many positive things happening, they need to be not only reported, they need to be highlighted.

While corruption needs to be exposed we also need to tell the world that we have a judicial system where even the high and mighty land up in jail. The system undoubtedly has substantial lacuna, and is painfully slow, but in retrospect it may still be a better system than the instant justice that is being handed out in other parts of the world. Ours is a judicial system where the accused has the fullest opportunity to present his case and not a system where the administrators decide as to who the criminal is and dispense justice.

Undoubtedly the economic growth has slowed down substantially and is a cause for concern, but it is heartening to note that we have an RBI Governor who while listening to what the Government says does not bow to its demands. One may disagree with the actions of the regulator, but the fact that he is independent is indeed satisfying. We may have fallen from grace in our national pastime, that is cricket, but we are possibly on our way to regaining our strength in hockey.

I think in these hard times there needs to be a change in attitude. Society must bring all problems to the fore and focus on solving them, but as it tackles the ills it must also focus on the positive things that happen. I am in entire agreement with what the spokesman of a prominent national party said in a panel discussion on television. When asked as to why representatives insist on disrupting the Parliament rather than focussing on the problems and debating them, he candidly admitted that people who rush into the well of the Lok Sabha get far more publicity than those who make well-researched speeches. If the media is going to reward and report triviality, then that is what we are going to get.

What is true of the attitude of society is equally true of laws and regulations. The law must undoubtedly punish the wrongdoer, mete out severe punishment if the offence so warrants, but must also have provisions to reward compliance. We see newspapers filled with the advertisements of the Income-tax Department calling upon citizens to do their duty and pay tax. While all law-abiding citizens would undoubtedly comply with the law, such compliance must be commended not by way of a ‘sanman’ letter but by way of some action which actually shows that the State cares. While a person is penalised for deducting tax late or not depositing it within time, there is no credit of tax in the deductor’s own case for having deducted tax properly and in time. Collection of revenue is the duty of the State. When it transfers this obligation to its citizen, I believe it is in the fitness of things that if the citizen does a good job he deserves a reward. I am conscious that many of my professional colleagues and even seniors may not agree with this concept, but I believe that this is something that is worth trying.

I am an eternal optimist and I am of the view that we are on the threshold of change. While we must recognise the evils that face us and do our best to eradicate them, it is essential that we encourage those who have achieved something of note. We need to believe that the glass is half full and will get filled up soon, rather than say that it is half empty and it will get drained in future.

I deliberately gave vent to my feeling in my communication for this month, because I felt that in the month of October most of you would have more time on your hands to ponder over what I had said. All of you have been through the grind for the last entire month trying to fulfil your duty towards your clients, the lawmakers and the regulators. It is time to take a break and unwind a little. There can be no better way to unwind than a dance in the approaching Navaratri festival, meeting friends and relatives and enjoying the festival of lights.

I take this opportunity to wish all readers a joyful Navaratri, a happy Dassera, Diwali and a prosperous New Year!

With warm regards,

Pradip K. Thanawala

C A

levitra

Lecture Meetings

Service Tax & VAT on Sale of under Construction Flats

At this lecture meeting held on 22nd August 2012 at the Indian Merchants’ Chamber, Mumbai, Mr. Vikram Nankani, Advocate, addressed the participants on the subject of the meeting. The speaker covered various judicial decisions such as K. Raheja Development Corporation, Assotech Realty Pvt. Ltd., L&T and MCHI among others and explained several vexed and controversial issues. He also dealt with recent Trade Circular 14T dt. 6/8/2012 issued by Sales Tax Department of Maharashtra directing builders to apply for registration by 16/8/2012, file returns by 31/8/2012 along with payment of taxes and interest and brought out the various intricacies of the topic for the benefit of 400 + participants. Mr. Nankani also touched on the new scheme of Service Tax and its approach through negative list. The webcast of the meeting is available on BCAS WebTV.

Negative List based Taxation of Services – Important Issues Mrs. Puloma Dalal, Chartered Accountant, addressed the participants on the issues pertaining to Negative List of Services at this lecture meeting held on 3rd September 2012 at the Indian Merchants’ Chamber. The speaker discussed in detail finer aspects of the new law such as definition of service, declared services, various aspects and interpretation of negative list and bundled services. Nearly 200 participants attended and gained from the knowledge and experience shared by the faculty. The webcast of the meeting is available on BCAS WebTV.

Other programmes

Monsoon Trekking

The Human Resources Committee of the Society organised a one day trek on Saturday, 25th August 2012 from Dodhani Village near Panvel to Sunset Point at Matheran.

The trek was through a thick jungle, with lots of butterflies and birds, and a good view of surrounding hills in the midst of greenery and Panvel reservoir. The view got better as the participants gained height. Considering that climate on that day was unusually hot and humid, the trek turned out to be little above the ‘easy’ grade. Yet the 40 participants did admirably well, enjoyed the nature and successfully completed the trek under guidance from 5 experienced volunteers from Explorers & Adventurers Club. During the return journey, the group lightened the mood and indulged in singing and antakshari amidst stronger camaraderie and bonding.

ASPIRE – Interactive Session for CA Students – Success Mantras for Success in CA exams

The Human Resources Committee of the Society and the Chamber of Tax Consultants jointly organised this seminar on Saturday, 8th September 2012 at Gulmohar Hall of BCAS Society, Mumbai and was presided over by Mr. Deepak Shah, President of BCAS, and Mr. Manoj Shah, President of CTC.

The object of the seminar was to discuss how to overcome various challenges while studying for the professional course of Chartered Accountant and sharing of “Success Mantras” to achieve spectacular success in exams.

The seminar was addressed by Mr. Atul Bheda, Chartered Accountant, and Rank-holders of May 2012 Batch namely Ms. Devshree Ganantra, Mr. Dharan Gandhi, Ms. Isha Changdiwala, Ms. Radhika Subramanian and Mr. Sunny Gosar, who shared their personal experiences of how they prepared for examinations and handled the stress. Past President Mr.Narayan Varma also motivated the students for coming in the profession with good ethics and integrity. The seminar ended with vote of thanks by Mr. Krishna Kumar Jhunjhunwala, Chartered Accountant, to all the faculties for inspiring the students with valuable Success Mantras and invigorating them.

International Tax & Finance Conference 2012

The 16th International Tax and Finance Conference, 2012 was organised by the International Taxation Committee of the Society from 17th August 2012 to 20th August 2012 in very refreshing atmosphere at Holiday Inn Resort, Goa where the following papers were discussed and presented:

Papers for group discussion:

  • Case Studies on International tax (with special reference to amendments in the Finance Act, 2012) ” by Pinakin Desai, Chartered Accountant.
  •  General Anti-avoidance Rules with Case Studies by Pranav Sayta, Chartered Accountant.
  •  Interpretation of Tax Treaties – Important Principles by Gautam Doshi, Chartered Accountant.

Papers for presentation:

  •  Transfer Pricing Regulations – Amendments made in the Finance Act, 2012 with special reference to “Specified Domestic Transactions” by Sanjay Tolia, Chartered Accountant.
  •  Investment Protection Treaty paper written by Rohan Shah, Advocate, and presented by Mr. Tarun Gulati, Advocate.
  • Service-tax on Cross Border Transactions by A. R. Krishnan, Chartered Accountant.

The Conference received excellent response and was attended by 192 participants from various parts of India and overseas including Hyderabad, Bangalore, Chennai, Coimbatore, Delhi, Ahmedabad, Pune, Goa, Secunderabad, Jamnagar, Kolkata, Karnataka and Dubai besides Mumbai.

The participants witnessed a very high quality of deliberations. Seminar on NBFC Regulations (Including Audit & Tax Aspects) Accounting and Auditing Committee of the Society had organised this seminar on 30th August 2012 at the Indian Merchants’ Chamber, Mumbai to equip members and industry professionals with the overall perspective of NBFCs Regulations and the recent updates with respect to RBI directives, legal, accounting and tax aspects. The seminar was attended by over 120 participants with representatives equally from industry and profession.

Mr. Naushad Panjwani, the Vice President, of the Society, inaugurated the seminar and highlighted the importance of the subject of the Seminar. Mr. Himanshu Kishnadwala, Chairman of the Accounting and Auditing Committee, outlined the contents of the seminar and explained the importance of various topics.

Ms. Archana Mangalagiri, General Manager, Reserve Bank of India (RBI), briefed the participants about the recent developments and initiatives taken by RBI in the field of NBFCs and gave RBI’s perspective in respect of various recent developments in the NBFC regulations.

Mr. Anup Shah, Chartered Accountant, discussed in detail various legal aspects applicable to various categories of NBFCs with focus on various recent notifications and circulars.

Mr. Viren Mehta, Chartered Accountant, covered “Audit Procedures and Reporting” and explained role and responsibility of the auditors under NBFC regulations. Mr. Yogesh Thar, Chartered Accountant, dealt with various contentious issues faced by the NBFCs under the direct tax laws.

Workshop on How to Conduct a Tax Audit

The Taxation Committee of the Society organised this workshop on 31st August 2012 at the Indian Merchants’ Chamber, Mumbai where the following faculties, all Chartered Accountants, enlightened the participants on the topics allocated:

Mr. Anil Sathe – Tax aspects
Mr. Himanshu Kishnadwala – Audit aspects
Mr. Raman Jokhakar
Ms. Sonalee Godbole – Clause-wise analysis of Form 3CD

The workshop concluded with an interactive Brain Trust session that provided guidance to over 325 participants on various controversial and catchy issues. The video recording of this workshop is available at BCAS Web TV.

Professional Accountant Course B atch XIV – Convocation

The Human Resources Committee successfully completed Batch XIV of the Professional Accountant and held Convocation on 4th September 2012 at H.R. College, Churchgate to award Certificates of “Professional Accountant” to 33 students. It was a memorable event for these students having put in hard work to learn practical and theoretical aspects of day-to-day accounting and tax compliance. The course was conducted over 23 sessions during April 2012 to July 2012.


The convocation function was graced by the President Mr. Deepak Shah, Past President Mr. Pradeep Thanawala, Convenor of HR Committee Mr. Hemant Gandhi, Vice Principal of HR College Professor Parag Thakkar and Course co-ordinator Ms. Manori Shah.The students acknowledged and appreciated valuable learning from this course that will help them in their career. They also gave valuable feedback to help make this programme more effective.Advanced FEMA Conference

The Conference was inaugurated by the chief Guest Mrs. Rashmi Fouzdar, Chief General Manager, RBI (FED Section). In her keynote address, she expressed her views in regard to various important issues which have arisen on account of current trend and fiscal and monetary policies.


In the first session Mrs. Rashmi Fouzdar and other senior officers from the Foreign Exchange Department of RBI including Mrs. Vanitha Venugopala, General Manager, and Mr. Ajay Vij, Dy. General Manager, answered various important questions raised by the participants.In the second session, Mr. Dilip Thakkar, Chartered Accountant, covered “Practical issues arising from FEMA including on LRS, Immovable properties, etc.”. In the third session, Dr. Pravin P. Shah, Chartered Accountant, dealt with the topic of “Issues on overseas outbound investments”. In the fourth session, Mr. Shabbir Motorwala, Chartered Accountant, covered “Issues on borrowing and lending including ECB, Trade credits, etc.”. In the fifth and last session of the conference, Mr. N.C. Hegde, Chartered Accountant, dealt with “FDI – recent changes and issues” and educated the participants in respect of various issues thereon including issues arising from changes made in the current year in the FDI Policy.The Conference offered deep insight into advance level issues on cross border transactions and enlightened the participants on various intricacies on the said subject.

Cancerous Corruption

fiogf49gjkf0d
From May 2014, this feature is restarted. In June 2014 issue, I recorded one meaning of “Corruption”.

Here under are some definitions of Corruption:

• Transparency.org:

CORRU PTION IS THE ABUSE OF ENTRU STED POWER FOR PRIVATE GAIN. IT HUR TS EVERY ONE WHO DEPENDS ON THE INTEGR ITY OF PEOPLE IN A POSITION OF AUTHORITY. Some More:

• Wrongdoing on the part of an authority or powerful party through means that are illegitimate, immoral, or incompatible with ethical standards. Corruption often results from patronage and is associated with bribery.

• Dishonest behaviour by those in position of power, such as managers or government officials. Corruption can include giving or accepting bribes or inappropriate gifts, double dealing, under-the-table transactions, manipulating election, diverting funds, laundering money and defrauding investors. One example of corruption in the world of finance would be an investment manager who is actually running a ponzi scheme.

World bank writes on Governance & Anti-Corruption:
The World Bank views good governance and anticorruption as important to its poverty alleviation mission. Many governance and anti-corruption initiatives are taking place throughout the World Bank Group. They focus on internal organisational integrity, minimising corruption on World Bank-funded projects, and assisting countries in improving governance and controlling corruption.

Combining participatory action-oriented learning, capacity-building tools, and the power of data, the World Bank Institute (WBI), in collaboration with other units in the World Bank Group, supports countries in improving governance and controlling corruption. We also provide policy and institutional advice and support to countries in their formulation of action programs.

Using a strategic and multidisciplinary approach, we apply action-learning methods to link empirical diagnostic surveys, their practical application, collective action, and prevention. Concrete results on the ground are emphasized in our learning programs and clinics as well as the periodic release of the Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI) and country diagnostics. This integrated approach is supported by operational research and a comprehensive governance databank.

At one of the annual meeting, World Bank officials spoke extensively about corruption. It is an understandable concern: money that the Bank lends to developing countries that ends up in secret bank accounts or finances some contractors’ luxurious lifestyle leaves a country more indebted, not more prosperous.

Corruption Worldwide:
Corruption, fraud and money-laundering cost poor countries a total of $1.0 trillion a year, the anti-poverty organisation ONE said in a study released in this month. The group, founded by U2 rock group singer Bono, said the misuse of funds resulted in $38-64 billion a year in uncollected taxes alone. This in turn cost 3.6 million lives a year that could be saved if the missing money were wisely invested, nongovernment organisation ONE estimated.

Na Khaunga, na khane dunga:
• Bringing up the issue of corruption during the second leg of his daylong tour to Jammu & Kashmir last month, PM Narendra Modi said his mantra was “Na khaunga, na khane dunga (neither will I take bribe, nor will I allow anyone also to take bribe).”

(Compare above with former PM Manmohan Singh: He did not take bribe but allowed many of his ministers to take bribe)

• PM Narendra Modi described corruption as cancer that can destroy India and said people were no longer willing to tolerate it.

Addressing a gathering at a foundation stone laying ceremony for a highway, and amid slogans of Bharat mata ki jai, he asked, “Should strong steps not be taken to remove corruption?” Modi said some had pointed out that he did not speak on August 15.He reminded them that he had said “if somebody had to get any work done one would ask ‘mera kya’ (what’s in it for me). If the work is not done, one would say ‘mujhe kya’ (why do I care). This has spoiled the nation.”

Maharashtra Anti-corruption Bureau ( ACB )
• In a bid to check corruption and embarrass the offenders, the Maharashtra Anti Corruption Bureau (ACB) is planning to launch a page on a popular social networking site where it would upload the pictures of those caught for taking bribes.”In a bid to intensify our action against corrupt and reach out to people, we are planning to use the popular platform of Facebook shortly”, said Director General of Police (ACB) Pravin Dixit. When asked if the court rulings prevented posting pictures of suspects at public places, Dixit said the ACB cases were different. “We have a suspect who is known and arrested after adopting legal procedures. There is no question of identification parade like other crimes. Hence, there is nothing wrong in putting up pictures on the website or elsewhere.” Dixit said.
• The Facebook page, if started, will have the pictures of the accused, besides the details of the bribe amount the accused took, valuables and other documents recovered from him or her during searches at office and home, police said. The ACB which had laid as many as 744 traps so far this year, a 114 per cent jump from the same last year, has been for the past two months publishing pictures of those caught in the act on its own website. During the 744 traps till August 16, it has arrested 1,009 government employees and their associates, who are private individuals. In the same period last year, 348 traps were laid in which 452 were arrested.

Transparency International: Corruption perception Index 2013:

In August issue of BCAJ, some details of Corruption Perceptions Index 2013 were reported. I had missed to report CPI of some more neighbouring countries. Now along with 3 which were reported hereunder are Ranking of India and its neighbouring countries:

It is interesting to note that atleast one neighbouring country, Bhutan ranks at 31, quiet high, and scores 63.

levitra

ICAI and its members

fiogf49gjkf0d
1 ITA Tribunal raises concerns about Professional Standards of ICAI Members:

In a recent order by ITA Tribunal in the case of Shri Vijay V. Meghani vs. DCIT, where there was a delay of 2,984 days in filing appeal against the order of CIT (A) due to misleading advice of a C.A. firm, the Hon’ble Members of the Tribunal have commented about the falling professional standards of ICAI Members. The author of this order being a Senior Chartered Accountant, the contents of this order should be an eye opener for all members of the C.A. profession and need introspection by our members. The relevant portion of the order in Para 9.6 is as under:

“9.6 However, if it is considered for a moment that the above said C.A. firm has really given such advice to the assessee herein and accordingly it has furnished the letter and affidavit, then, in our view, it may be showing signs of deteriorating standards with some of the Chartered Accountants in profession, which needs to be stopped on war footing by the ICAI. We have already noticed that the assessee is having connection with many tax professionals and, in all probabilities, the assessee might have had consultation with any one or more of them on the impugned problem. It is inconceivable that all the Chartered Accountants, whom the assessee might have had consultation or availed services, would have concurred with the view expressed by the above said C.A. firm. If it is presumed for a moment that all the C.A.s have concurred with the said view, then it only shows that the C.A. profession is losing its grip over the Income tax matters, which is another cause of concern for ICAI. The self study model with ‘on-site articled clerk training’ embedded in the Chartered Accountancy course aims to achieve high quality education and training through undergoing practical training, inculcating the habit of thinking, self introspection, application of mind, analytical ability etc. and they enable the C.A. students to have strong grip over the subjects and also to attain expertise in them. The commendable feature of the C.A. course is that, as stated earlier, the C.A. students are trained by the practicing Chartered Accountants during their articled clerk training program. Thus, the methodology adopted by the ICAI enabled the C.A. students to become a thorough professional with versatile knowledge and innovative mind. We notice that, in the recent past, the methodology of self study is given a go-by by some of the C.A. students and they have started depending more and more on the Commercial Coaching Centers, who undertake coaching of various subjects in the class room model. We notice that the ICAI does not appear to have taken steps to contain mushrooming growth of such coaching institutes, which indulge in manufacturing of Chartered Accountants through class room model, which may ultimately have undesirable effect on the quality of Chartered Accountants, since the habit of thinking, introspection, application of mind is replaced by spoon feeding, which kind of teaching discourages independent thinking. There should not be any controversy on the fact that the Chartered Accountants, till date, have occupied pioneer position vis-a-vis their counterparts in other parts of the World. They also contribute a lot to the building, sustenance and growth of our National economy. Any compromise on the quality of Chartered Accountants would not only affect our Country very badly, but is also expected to endanger the pioneer position enjoyed by the C.A. fraternity vis-a-vis their counter parts in other parts of the world. In our view, the ICAI should seriously taken note of these alarming practices emerging in our Country and should take appropriate corrective steps, lest the confidence reposed in C.A.s by the public should get diluted.”

Further, in Para 10 of the order it is observed as under

“Thus, it is seen that the advice claimed to have been given by the C.A. firm has been given without analysing the facts prevailing in the instant case and also without clear understanding of the provisions of the Act and their implications. We have also noticed that a C.A firm could not give such kind of advice, since it cannot forecast the outcome of an appeal filed before the Tribunal.We have already noticed that the CPE programmes have been designed by ICAI with the noble objective of enlightening the Chartered Accountants with current topics, current developments and such programmes are also aimed to continuous updating or refreshing of the knowledge of Chartered Accountants. The advice claimed to have been given by Chartered Accountants, if considered to have been really given, would create doubt about the efficacy of the CPE programmes, since such kind of advices is not expected from a Professional. Further these kind of advices claimed to have been given by a C.A. firm clearly give signals that the CPE programmes might have failed to achieve the desired objectives with some of the Chartered Accountants. It is high time that the ICAI should take note of these practicalities and should take corrective steps in order to maintain/restore the high standards and quality expected from a C.A professional.”

2. Some Ethical Issues

The Ethical Standards Board of ICAI has given answers to some Ethical Issues on pages 316 to 317 of C. A. Journal for September, 2014. Some of these issues are as under:

(i) Issue:

Can goodwill of a Chartered Accountant firm be purchased?

The Council of the Institute considered the issue whether the goodwill of a proprietary firm of a Chartered Accountant can be sold/transferred to another eligible member of the Institute, after the death of the proprietor concerned and came to the view that the same is permissible. Accordingly, the Council passed the Resolution that the sale/transfer of goodwill in the case of a proprietary firm of Chartered Accountants to another eligible member of the Institute, shall be permitted.

(ii) Issue: Can a Chartered Accountant in practice share his fees with the Government in respect of Government Audit?
The Institute came across certain Circulars/Orders issued by the Registrar of various State Co-operative Societies wherein it has been mentioned that certain amount of audit fee is payable to the concerned State Govt. and the auditor has to deposit a percentage of his audit fee in the State Treasury by a prescribed challan within a prescribed time of the receipt of Audit fee.

In view of the above, the Council considered the issue and while noting that the Government is asking auditors to deposit such percentage of their audit fee for recovering the administrative and other expenses incurred in the process, the Council decided that as such there is no bar in the Code of Ethics to accept such assignment wherein a percentage of professional fees is deducted by the Government to meet the administrative and other expenditure.

3. Financial Reporting Review Board (FRRB)

ICAI has published a “Study on Compliance of Financial Requirements.” Some of the observations from this publication are given below for information of Members.

(i) Contingencies and Events occurring after the Balance Sheet Date (AS-4)

From one of the Notes to Accounts given in the Annual Report of a company, it was noted that Advances were given to certain companies which had incurred losses and their net worth had eroded. These Advances were included under the heads of “Sundry Advances” or “Sundry Debtors” on the pretext that the management was confident of recovering these dues. Therefore, no provision was made.

Observation of FRRB (P. 37)

The erosion of net worth of the companies to whom advances were given itself indicated that the amounts due may not be fully recoverable. further, future events should be considered to confirm impairment of the asset rather than expecting its recoverability. If the net worth of the companies had eroded and they were incurring losses, provision should be made unless such companies have already entered into contracts to confirm profitability in future. Non-creation on provision in these cases is contrary to the requirements of AS-4.

(ii)    Provision for Taxation for Earlier years (AS-5)

From the statement of Profit and Loss given in the Annual report of a Company, it was noticed that the provision for taxation  for  earlier  years  was  adjusted  under  the  head “appropriations.”

Observation of FRRB (p42)

Adjustments arising due to prior period items should be included in the determination of net Profit or Loss for the current period instead of showing the same as “appropria- tion” of Profits. Income tax expense relating to prior years cannot be disclosed as appropriation of profits. Hence, the profit of the Company for the year is over stated and the Statement of Profit and Loss cannot be considered to be providing true and fair view of the profit of the busi- ness. accordingly, the company has not complied with the requirements of AS-5.

4.    EAC opinion

Accounting Treatment of Liquidated Damages on Unex- ecuted Portion of Contract.

Facts
A Central public sector enterprise, registered under the Companies act, 1956 was established for manufacturing of weapon systems required for Armed Forces.

The customers of the company recover liquidated damages for delayed delivery of goods, i.e., when goods are delivered after due date. the company makes provision for liquidated damages for the unexecuted portion of contract for the period of delay from due date of delivery till the date of the accounts. the company is following this practice as a prudent policy as liquidated damages amount is quantifiable and is a definite known liability. In most of the cases, the customer extends the due date, however, with levy of full liquidated damages. At the time of payment, the customer recovers the liquidated damages amount and pays the balance amount only.  Then, the company reverses the liquidated damages provision and debits to liquidated damages recovered account (ex- pense account).

Query
from  the  above  background,  the  Company  has  sought the opinion of the expert advisory Committee of the ICAI on the following issues:

(a) Whether the provision for liquidated damages should be made or not in respect of unexecuted portion of the contract for the period of delay from the due date of delivery till date of accounts? (b) Whether such provi- sion for liquidated damages is also required to be made in case the due date falls exactly on the last date of the accounts of the financial year, viz. balance sheet date, i.e., whether one day delay is to be reckoned or not?
(c) Whether the practice is to be spelt out as a ‘major Accounting Policy’ in terms of AS1 or will it be sufficient if a financial note is appended to the statement of profit and loss or even financial note is not required to  be appended?

EAC opinion:
The Committee notes that  in the  case  of the  company, liquidated damages are recovered by the customers for the period of delay between the due date of delivery of goods  and  the  actual  date  of  delivery.   Further,  as  per the Company, there is no clause in the contact to exit from the sales contract(s) entered with the customer, with or without the payment of penalty and the past experience of the company shows that in most cases, although the customers extend the due date of delivery, the liquidated damages are recovered in full. Accordingly, the Committee is of the view that the terms and conditions of the sales contract(s) are binding and legally enforceable by the customers. In the company’s case, although it is stated that the liquidated damages are in the nature of compensatory payment, the Committee is of the view that the liquidated damages are akin to penalty and there is a contractual obligation on the part of the company to pay for liquidated damages as soon as there is a delay in the delivery of goods beyond the due date as per the delivery schedule. Further, this obligation can not be avoided by the company’s future course of actions as it does not have any realistic alternative but to settle the contractual obligation (i.e., making the payment of such liquidated damages).  Thus,  there  exists  a  present  obligation  arising from past event, viz., delay beyond scheduled delivery and settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits. Accordingly, the Committee is of the view that the company should recognise a provision in respect of liquidated damages for the period of delay between the due date of delivery of goods and the expected date of delivery of the said goods and not only for the period of delay till the date of financial statements, in the light of evidence provided by events occurring after the balance sheet date, as per paragraph 36 of AS29.

The Committee is of the view that ‘matching concept’ does not preclude recognition of present obligations as liabilities at the reporting date. the Company should disclose its accounting practice in respect of liquidated damages, considering the materiality of the items and transactions and their impact on the financial statements from the perspective of users financial statements.

[Pl. Refer page nos. 344 to 348 of C. A. Journal – September, 2014]

 
5.    ICAI news

(Note: Page Nos. given below are from C.A. Journal for September, 2014)

(i)    Database of Independent Directors:
Section 150 of the Companies Act, 2013 provides for creation and maintenance of data Bank of independent directors by recognised bodies. iCai has joined with institute of Company Secretaries and Institute of Cost Accountants to operationlise a repository for independent directors. mCa has approved this initiative of ICAI.  The Repository (http://independentdirector.in) will provide opportunity to individuals who are willing to act as independent directors in Companies.  Further, it will be possible for companies which wish to select independent directors to make use of this data Bank. (P.303)

(ii)    Revised    Dates    for    Campus    Placement Programme (P. 432)

It may be noted that the revised dates for campus Placement Programme for October, 2014, are as follows:

S.

no

centre

dates

1

Mumbai & New Delhi

13th to
18th and 20th October, 2014

2

Bangalore, Chennai & Kolkata

14th to
18th and 20th October, 2014

3

Hyderabad

15th to
18th and 20th October, 2014



(iii)    Revised Minimum recommended Fees for Professional Services:

ICAI has revised minimum recommended fees which members can charge for various professional services. The details are given in CA Journal for September, 2014 (P. 424 – 430).

(iv)    Scheme for Enrolment of Overseas Citizens of India:

The Scheme for enrolment of Overseas Citizens of India (OCI) as members of ICAI has been finalised by ICAI. Under this scheme, an oCi holding professional accountancy qualification shall be recognised as a member of ICAI on completion of such examination, training and modules as listed in schedule ‘B’ to C.A. Regulations. Details of the scheme are published on P. 412-415 of C.A. Journal for September, 2014.

(v)    New ICAI Publication

Revised  Guidance  note  on  tax audit  u/s.  44aB  of  the income-tax act, 1961 (2014 edition)

Company Law

fiogf49gjkf0d
1. Amendment to Companies ( Corporate Social Responsibility Policy) Rules

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has notified the following amendment on 12th September, 2014 in the Companies (Corporate Social Responsibility Policy) Rules 2014. In Rule 4, in sub-Rule (6) after the words “but such expenditure” the words and comma “including expenditure on administrative overheads” shall be inserted. Consequently, the clarification (iv) in General Circular No. 21 of 2014 dated 18-06-2014 stands omitted.

2. Clarification regarding Accounting Standard – AS 10 – Capitalisation of Cost

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide General Circular No. 35/2014, dated 27-08-2014, clarified issues with respect to the capitalisation of borrowing costs in Competitive Bid power projects:

1) As per Accounting Standards AS-10 & AS-16 issued by ICAI in consultation with ASB, borrowing and other costs incurred during extended delay in commencement of commercial production after the plant is otherwise ready, should not be capitalised as it does not increase the worth of the fixed assets.

2) As per AS 16, capitalisation of some part of the project which is capable of being used while construction continues for the other units should be capitalised once that part is ready for commercial production

3) it is further clarified that AS-10 & AS-16 are applicable irrespective of whether the power projects are ‘Cost Plus Projects’ or ‘Competitive Bid Projects.’

3. National Advisory Committee

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide circular dated 18th September, 2014 constituted an Advisory Committee to be called the National Advisory Committee on Accounting Standards, consisting of the Mr. Amarjit Chopra, Dr. A. S. Durga Prasad, Shri R. Sridharan and CA K. Raghu and others, to advise the Central Government on the formulation and laying down of accounting policies and accounting standards for adoption by companies or class of companies under the said Act.

The Chairperson and members shall hold office for a period of one year from the date of publication of this notification in the Official Gazette or till the constitution of National Financial Reporting Authority u/s. 132 of the Companies Act, 2013 whichever is earlier. 4. U seful Life Of Asset The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide notification dated 29th August, 2014, substituted the following in Schedule II of Companies Act 2013 – Part A Para 3 (i), substituted;

(i) The useful life of an asset shall not ordinarily be different from the useful life specified in Part C and the residual value of an asset shall not be more than 5% of the original cost.
Provided that where a Company adopts a useful life different from what is specialised in Part C or uses a residual value different from the limit specified above, the financial statements shall disclose the difference and the justification supported by technical advice.’

In Part C under the heading Noted – the para 4 shall be substituted by:

4(a) Useful life specified in Part C of the Schedule is for the whole asset and where cost of a part of the asset is significant to total cost of the asset and useful life of that part is different from the useful life of the remaining asset, useful life of that significant part shall be determined separately.

(b) The requirement under sub-paragraph (a) shall be voluntary in respect of financial year commencing on or after 01-04-2014 and mandatory for financial years commencing after 01-04-2015.

(c) in para 7 (b) for the words ‘shall be recognised,’ the words ‘may be recognised’ are substituted.

levitra

FROM THE PRESIDENT

fiogf49gjkf0d
Dear members, 

In the landmark decision delivered on 25th September 2014 in the matter of the National Tax Tribunals (NTT) Act, 2005, the five judges bench of the Supreme Court declared the NTT Act as unconstitutional mainly on the grounds that the basic structure of the Constitution will stand violated if while enacting the legislation pertaining to transfer of judicial power, the Parliament does not ensure that the newly created court/tribunal, conforms with the salient characteristics and standards, of the court sought to be substituted. And that the constitutional conventions, pertaining to constitutions styled on the Westminster model, will also stand breached, if while enacting the legislation pertaining to transfer of judicial power, conventions and salient characteristics of the court sought to be replaced, are not incorporated in the court/tribunal sought to be created.

In this decision, the Supreme Court also held that allowing Chartered Accountants to appear on behalf of a party before the NTT would be unacceptable in law. The Supreme Court has stated that in their understanding the Chartered Accountants would at best be specialist in understanding and explaining issues pertaining to accounts which fall purely in the realm of facts, whereas the determination at the hands of the NTT is shorn of factual disputes. It observed that the NTT has to decide only ‘substantial question of law’ arising from not only the income tax laws but also a wide range of family, trust, corporate and other laws. This decision draws support from a compilation of 96 different income-tax case laws that involve substantial questions of various laws. The Supreme Court found it difficult to appreciate the propriety of representation, on behalf of a party to an appeal, through a Chartered Accountant and unfortunately bracketed them with the Company Secretaries.

With due respect to the Supreme Court, these observations seem to be misplaced. The Hon’ble Mr. Justice R. V. Easwar, then Judge of Delhi High Court, in an address, has acclaimed the contribution of chartered accountants in shaping of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), and I quote: ‘Several chartered accountants have worked as Members of the Tribunal in its long history of almost 72 years. There were some who became its President…

The Income-tax Act has entrusted a significant role to the chartered accountants. It has reposed immense confidence on them to certify the various claims for deductions…

…With their incisive analysis of the accounting aspect of the case, they have, if I may acknowledge with respect, admirably fulfilled the role expected of them. This is not to say that their judicial insights are any less than the judicial members. Over a period of years they also acquire a grip over the legal aspects of the case and they are second to none in conforming to the judicial norms and discipline in the discharge of their functions.’The expertise of Chartered Accountants has been recognised widely,and they are permitted to appear before not only the direct and indirect tax forums but also under other laws.With international taxation issues gaining prominence and evolution of specialised areas such as transfer pricing, a Chartered Accountant with his vigorous training and resulting expertise brings significant value tothe judicial process pertaining to the revenue matters.It is unfortunate that the highest court has not taken into consideration the pivotal role played by Chartered Accountants in ITAT as well as in their contribution in administration of tax and other laws.

Also, the Supreme Court has not addressed the core issues that plague the judicial redressal system, such as unfathomable delays and multiplicity of proceedings resulting from the existence of multiple appellate levels. The uncertainties and complexities in the judicial redressal system get further compounded by conflicting opinions at various appellate forums having independent jurisdiction across the country.

It is pertinent to note that the idea of the NTT was first mooted in 1955 by the first law commission chaired by Mr. M. C. Setalvad in 1955 and reiterated by the Wanchoo Committee in 1970 and by the C. C. Choksi Committee in 1977. The dilatory, cumbersome reference procedure which caused enormous delay in disposal of tax litigation was the main reason behind them making this recommendation. As an interim measure to the above recommendation, the Choksi Committee suggested, the desirability of constituting Special Tax Benches in High Courts to be comprised of judges with special knowledge of tax law to deal with the large number of pending tax cases.

In this decision, the Supreme Court has once again raised concerns about the growing tribunalisation of justice and rightly so. As per one count, over 100 tribunals have been setup to date by the Central and various State Governments.The Report of the Arrears Committee (1989-90), popularly known as the Malimath Committee Report, stated that the overall picture regarding the tribunalisation of justice in our country is not satisfactory.These concerns remain valid even today.

The NTT and other decisions such as in the matters of 2G and Coalgate also raise concerns about legislative and regulatory capabilities of the legislature and the executive. Commenting on the Companies Act, 2013, Justice A. K. Sikri lamented that this legislation exposes the lack of expertise in legislative draftmaking. He also said that indeterminate laws make the courts struggle to find the intent of legislature where 90 % of the parliamentarians don’t even know when the law comes, what is the law and the same is not even debated.

The BJP in its election manifesto has promised a wide range of measures to ensure justice which is prompt and accessible.It is high time the Government undertakes these comprehensive legal reforms promptly and not restrict itself to cleaning only outdated laws.

Prime Minister Modi launched the ‘Make in India’ initiative to boost our manufacturing sector and aims to improve India’s rank from 135 to 50 in ‘Ease of Business’ ranking. He is sensitising his team and his bureaucracy to not create unnecessary barriers to business and spur positivity and inspire confidence among manufacturers. In this backdrop, it appears that transforming the rigid and mechanical bureaucracy seasoned over decades will be an uphill task. The recent experience with the CBDT where it prolonged extending the due date for filing of the return of income despite a large number of representations until pressurised through various High Courts decisions, is a case in point.

At a recently held Advanced FEMA Conference, organised jointly by the BCAS and the Chamber of Tax Consultants, the Chief Guest Mr. G. Padmanabhan, the Executive Director of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), accepted that the FEMA regulations have become too complex and require a comprehensive review. The Conference provided an opportunity for participants, many from outstation, to raise their difficulties with concerned officials from the RBI directly and expert analysis from the excellent faculty.

The much deserved extension and ensuing season of festivals give us an opportunity to take a break from the routine of multi-tasking and rushing from one deadline to another and instead spend quality time with our loved ones. Let us embrace these celebrations with open hearts and relearn how to enjoy life.

Wishing you all a happy and joyous Deepavali!

With warm regards,

levitra

From The President

fiogf49gjkf0d
Dear Members,

I hope most of you have recovered from the
September pressure. This year was particularly overwhelming, with first
time audits under the Companies Act, 2013, Tax Audit, ITR filing and
Black Money filings all falling at the same time. As usual, the
government did not issue forms in time nor did it relent to extension
requests. The apathy on this topic has become a stable and predictable
feature. In spite of two courts giving directions, the insistence on not
extending the timeline continued. The Revenue Ministry seemed to
disregard the verdict of the Courts as well as request from taxpayers.

The apathy of Revenue Department is such that they would want assessees
to comply, whereas the rules are different for them. Endowed with
administrative privileges and powers, their share of responsibility is
disproportionately low. The way revenue laws are drafted and
administered, appear to be unfavourable for the citizens. The scariest
part of revenue law making today is, that it has become a legitimate way
to unleash excesses on citizens. A tax payer citizen, who is at the
core of this democracy, is now a victim of the very mechanism that is
meant to serve him. If there was the slightest sense of FAIRNESS and
CONSIDERAT ION of the overall situation a taxpayer was placed into, the
department would have suo motu extended the time line. Isn’t it a bit
too much, to ask for fairness and equality, a taxpayer has to go to the
Court. MOF took 4 months to issue new forms for the year that ended in
March 2015, yet it is unwilling to give one more month to tax payer to
carry out their filing. Add to that, the intermittent changes in the
utility even in the last few days. The most bizarre part of the whole
drama was when a press release came from CBDT on 1st October morning,
extending the ‘due date’ by 1 month. I leave to your good sense to
juxtapose all this against the talk about building a STA BLE, PREDICTA
BLE and NON ADVERSARIAL tax regime.

At the BCAS we celebrated the
INTERNAT IONAL RIGHT TO KNOW DAY and 10 years of RT I in India. As we
all know, RT I is the strongest instrument in the hands of our people to
protect, preserve and nurture justice, liberty and equality envisioned
and guaranteed by our founding fathers. Right to know is part of our
fundamental rights. The desire to know and the desire to use that
knowledge are seminal. Since RT I came into force, we have come a long
way asking for information that remained hidden in the secrecy lockers
of the government. Today about 50-80 lacs applications, are made each
year, seeking information. RT I has been a game changer for citizens’
rights and has put a spotlight on the government to move towards the
goal of transparency driven accountability. The struggle today is about
‘information’ – of receiving it for millions whose lives are impacted
whereas not parting with it for few thousands in the seat of power to
keep their chairs. The key note speaker at RT I event Mr. Nikhil Dey,
ended his talk with a very potent quote of Jeremy Cronin – ‘Now we need
to speak truth to power, we now need to make truth powerful, we now need
to make the powerful truthful’.
Each one will have to decide whether he
wants to be in the majority who only wishes for the change or he wants
to be in the minority who will become the change they seek!

Talking of
information, India is marching ahead of the rest of the world in the
area of information technology (IT). The way things are moving, IT could
be the singular redeemer for the destinies of 1.25 billion people. The
MEGATREND S we are seeing will create a tectonic change at a never
imagined pace. Our countrymen, without going through desktops, laptops
or tablets will leapfrog into a different orbit through a little gadget
in their hands. A smart phone, available from Rs. 2500 is at the centre
of this revolution in making. Here are a few samples, taken from a
recent conference, that we need to pay heed to:

Increase in Electronic Clearing – For the first time electronic clearing is on par with paper clearing. The National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI, www.npci.org.in) has created IMPS, an instant clearing product. It was created in 2011 and in 3 years it overtook ‘money order’ (established 1880, and dead now) volumes. IMPS has 1/3 remittance market in India. IMPS will overcome Debit and Credit Card Sales very soon. India has Rs. 800-900 billion remittance market today.

Digital Wallet – Today 900 million Mobile users carry out 3 – 3.5 billion mobile recharges of small values. Digital Wallet has tremendous potential in numerous areas of making transactions through mobiles.

Today DBT (Direct Benefit Transfer) Program of the government for LPG subsidy alone makeup to 3 million transactions a day or 1 billion transaction a year, reaching 120 million customers. This saved Rs. 15000 crore ($2.5 billion) for the government according to the Prime Minister’s Independence Day speech. If this is extended to fertilisers, food, water, etc., it can reach 4 billion transactions and transfer Rs. 300,000 crore ($50 billion).

11 Payment Banks are given licences. This is perhaps the greatest regulatory innovation in recent times. They cannot offer loans but can take money up to Rs. 100,000 and work through mobiles. They will make you do cashless, cheque less, card less transactions.

Today highest E-Commerce transactions are happening in India (and 40% of all transactions are happening through mobile)

The winning formula is 1 billion ADHAAR (900 million already) by 2016 and 1 billion Mobile phones. This magic recipe will result in online authentication, instantaneous bank account opening, instant KYC, and two way credential check (will work as credit card and PIN both). Such two way authentication is nowhere in the world – a single click 2 factor authentication. Most of you will know ADHAAR based e-verification of ITRs this year. Credential checking will be like never before.

The dream of universal banking is closer to reality than ever before. Jan Dhan Yojana has created some 180 million bank accounts in a short time. With 1 billion ADHAAR, 1 billion bank accounts and 1 billion mobile phones the economic landscape of the country will be changed both in size and pace.

Smart Phones will do the work of payment for the payer and for the Merchant it will serve as a receiver of that payment. Unified Payment Interface of NPCI will perhaps make POS Machines, ATM s redundant.

Take for example – PAYTM . It gives you a Person to Merchant payment. PAYTM that began in 2010 is doing more number (volume) of purchase transactions than any bank in India – in ONLY 5 YEARS. But there will be Person to Person wallet also happening soon. Any ‘wallet’ to any ‘wallet’ transaction. This P2P Transaction system will be launched in December 2015 and could reduce cash movement drastically.

Although there will be ATM s and Bank Branches, every person will be an ATM . If a person wanted currency note he could transfer to the persons standing next to him on a local train and in return get a Rs. 100 note from his fellow traveller. Well you could be buying your sabzi with your mobile soon and won’t have to carry your wallet at all!

Digital Locker – This is a mega innovation happening. Check out their website digitallocker.gov.in

In short,
soon all your banking could be on mobile! This explosion of innovation
affecting 1 billion people will be extraordinary for our nation’s financial
services history. The IT super power, making IT work for its citizens. An
unimaginable transformation is waiting to happen for India. Even this tax
filing season you would have seen, how digital prowess worked wonders, through
the e-filing portal. We are entering a new world of digital disruption for a
digital billion. I hope this will change our collective destiny forever, for
good.

Company Law

fiogf49gjkf0d
1. The Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Second Amendment Rules, 2015

The
Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide notification dated 15th
September 2015 amended the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules,
2014. In rule 2, in subrule (1), in clause (c), for sub-clause (viii),
the following is substituted :

“(viii) any amount received from a
person who, at the time of the receipt of the amount, was a director of
the company or a relative of the director of the private company:

Provided
that the director of the company or relative of the director of the
private company, as the case may be, from whom money is received,
furnishes to the company at the time of giving the money, a declaration
in writing to the effect that the amount is not being given out of funds
acquired by him by borrowing or accepting loans or deposits from others
and the company shall disclose the details of money so accepted in the
Board’s report;”.

In rule 3, for the words “paid-up share
capital and free reserves”, wherever they occur, the words “paid-up
share capital, free reserves and securities premium account” shall be
substituted;”

2. Companies (Filing of documents and forms in XBRL ) Rules, 2015

The
Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide notification dated 9th September
2015 issued the Companies (Filing of Documents and Forms in Extensible
Business Reporting Language) Rules, 2015. As per the said rules, all
listed Companies and their Indian subsidiaries or Companies having a
paid up capital of Rs.5 crore or Companies having turnover of Rs. 100
crore and above or Companies which were covered under the Companies
(Filing of Documents and Forms in Extensible Business Reporting
Language) Rules 2011 shall file the financial statements with the
Central Government using the XBRL taxonomy for the financial years
commencing 1st April 2014.

The rules further specify that
companies that are required to file the cost audit report and other
documents with the Central Government shall do so using the XBRL
taxonomy for the financial years commencing 1st April 2014.

3. Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2015

The
Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide notification dated 28th August
2015 issued the Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment
Rules, 2015. As per the amendment, Rule 23 which pertains to special
notice to be given to the Company, the words “not more than five lakh
rupees” is substituted by the words “not less than five lakh rupees”.

The contents of Form MGT-7 for the Annual Return of the Company have been modified.

4. Companies (Accounts) Second Amendment Rules 2015

The
Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide notification dated 4th September
2015 issued the Companies (Accounts) Second Amendment Rules 2015.

Following clauses have been inserted:

Rule 2 ( 1) (da)
‘Indian Accounting Standards “means the Indian Accounting Standards
referred to in rule 3 and Annexure to the Companies (Indian Accounting
Standards) Rules 2015

Rule 4A : Forms and items contained in the Financial Statements :
The financial statements shall be in the form specified in Schedule III
to the Act and comply with Accounting Standards or Indian Accounting
Standards as applicable. Provided that the items contained in the
financial statements shall be prepared in accordance with the
definitions and other requirements specified in the Accounting Standards
or the Indian Accounting Standards as the case may be.

The Ministry has also released the contents of the following forms

AOC – 4 [Earlier Forms 23 AC & 23 ACA] – Form for filing Financial Statements & other documents with the Registrar &

AOC – 4 CFS –
Form for filing Consolidated Financial Statements & other documents
with the Registrar, both to be filed with certification by CA/CS/CMA.

5. Alterations to Schedule III of Companies Act 2013

The
Ministry of Corporate Affairs has vide notification dated 4th September
2015 made the following alterations to Schedule III (General
Instructions for Preparation of Balance Sheet and Statement of Profit
and Loss Account) In Part I Balance sheet under the heading “Equity and
liabilities” for the term trade payables the following shall be
substituted:

Trade payables:

Total outstanding dues of micro enterprises and small enterprises.

Total outstanding dues of creditors other than micro enterprises and small enterprises.

Additional disclosures in Notes in relation to Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises have also been prescribed.

levitra

Indirect Taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
5. Notification No. VAT-1514/CR-69 & 69(1)/Taxation- 1 dated 22-08-2104

Notifies capital goods and parts and components thereof under schedule entry C-107(2A) wef 01-09-2014 and amends the government order Finance Department No. VAT -1507/CR/93/Taxation-1 dated 21-01-2008 wef 01-09-2014.

6. Notification u/s. 42 of the MVAT Act (Retailer Composition Scheme) VAT-1514/CR 58/Taxation dated 21.8.2014 & Trade Circular 17T of 2014 dated 20-09-2014

By this notification new retailer composition scheme introduced in place of old scheme wef 01-10-2014. Now in new retailer composition scheme two options have been provided for payment of composition amount. If dealer opts to pay composition amount on total turnover of sales including tax-free goods then 1% and other option is 1.5% of total turnover of sales of taxable goods. Present dealers who are in composition scheme also have to apply in Form 4A before 31st October, 2014 and opt for the composition scheme otherwise not eligible for new composition scheme and old retailer composition scheme shall expire on 30-09-2014. Trade Circular No. 17T explains eligibility, rate of tax and conditions for composition scheme for retailer.

7. Notification u/s. 31A (2) of the MVAT Act (Tax Collection at source on Minor Minerals) VAT 1514/CR 68/Taxation-1 dated 21-08-2014

Notifies authorities and rate to collect amount from the dealer who has been awarded quarrying lease/permit in respect of minor minerals.

8.Notification under entry 2A of Schedule A appended to MVAT Act.No.VAT 1514/CR-59/Taxation -1 dated 21-08-2014

Notifies spare parts of air crafts for the purpose of Schedule A Entry No. 2A appended to MVAT Act.

9. Trade Circular 16T of 2014 providing E payment facility for Professional Tax, Luxury Tax and Sugarcane Purchase Tax through GRAS dated 17-09-2014

Sales Tax department has decided to accept payments under Professional Tax EC & RC, Luxury Tax and Sugarcane Purchase Tax through Government Receipt Account System (GRAS). Portal https://gras.mahakosh.gov.in/salestax available from 18-09-2014. At present it is optional. Detailed procedure for making payment is explained in the Circular.

levitra

Direct Taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
Due date for filing income tax returns extended from 31 August 2015
to 7 September 2015 – Notification no. F No. 225/154/2015/ITA. II dated 2
September 2015

CBDT has revised the monetary limits for Dossier
Cases requiring periodic review and reporting by various tax
authorities to have focused monitoring and rationalising the work load –
Instruction no. 10/2015 dated 16.9.2015

Additional
clarifications have been issued regarding tax compliance for undisclosed
foreign income and assets under The Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign
Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Rules, 2015 – Circular no. 15
dated 3 September 2015.

Guidance note issued by CBDT dated
31.08.2015 on implementation of reporting requirements for the US law
called “Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act” (FATCA).

Non-applicability of MAT on FIIs/ FPIs for period prior to 1.4.15 – Instruction No. 9/2015 dated 2.9.15 (reproduced alongside)

A
Committee on Direct Tax Matters chaired by Justice A. P. Shah, was
constituted to examine the issue of applicability of Minimum Alternate
Tax (‘MAT ’) on Flis/FPls for the period prior to 01.04.2015. The
Committee has submitted its final report to the Government on
25.08.2015. The Committee has recommended that section 115JB of the
Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘Act’) may be amended to clarify the
inapplicability of the provisions of section 115JB to FlIs/FPls having
no permanent establishment (PE)/place of business in India. The
Government has accepted the said recommendation and it has been decided
to carry out appropriate amendment in the Act so as to prescribe that
MAT provisions will not be applicable to Flls/FPls not having a place of
business/permanent establishment In India, for the period prior to
01.04.2015.

The field authorities are accordingly advised to
take into consideration the above position and keep in abeyance, for the
time-being, the pending assessment proceedings in cases of Flls/FPls
involving the above issue. They are further advised not to pursue the
recovery of outstanding demands, if any, in such cases.

(Rohit Garg)
Deputy Secretary to the Government of India
F. No. 225/237/2015-ITA -II

levitra

From Published Accounts

fiogf49gjkf0d
Section A: Acc ounting for expenditure for assets not owned by the company (enabling assets) by ‘Rate Regulated Entities’

Compiler’s Note
The
EAC of ICAI had in July 2011 opined that expenditure on enabling assets
not owned by the company should be charged off to revenue in the
accounting period in which such expenditure is incurred. ICAI has
subsequently issued ED of AS 10 (revised) wherein the matter was sought
to be addressed. The ICAI has also subsequently issued GN on Rate
Regulated Activities effective from 1st April 2015 with an earlier
adoption permitted.

Given below are instances of accounting
treatment on expenditure incurred by ‘rate regulated entities’ and
earlier adoption of the ICAI GN on Rate Regulated Activities in some
cases.

NTPC Ltd. (31-3-2015)
From Significant Accounting Policies
Fixed Assets

4.
Capital expenditure on assets not owned by the Company relating to
generation of electricity business is reflected as a distinct item in
capital work-inprogress till the period of completion and thereafter in
the tangible assets. However, similar expenditure for community
development is charged off to revenue.

Extract from notes below ‘Tangible Assets’ schedule
h)
The Company has received an opinion from the EAC of the ICAI on
accounting treatment of capital expenditure on assets not owned by the
Company, wherein it was opined that such expenditure are to be charged
to the Statement of Profit and Loss as and when incurred. The Company
has represented that such expenditure being essential for setting up of a
project, the same be accounted in the line with the existing accounting
practice and sought a review.

During the year, ICAI has issued
an exposure draft of AS- 10 ‘Property, Plant & Equipment’ which
would replace the existing AS-10 ‘Accounting for Fixed Assets’. Para 9
of the said exposure draft and explanation thereto provides for
capitalisation of such expenditure alongwith the project cost. The final
AS-10 ‘Property, Plant & Equipment’ is yet to be issued by the
Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA), GOI. Pending receipt of
communication from the ICAI regarding the review of opinion &
notification of the Revised AS-10 by the MCA, the Company continues to
account for the said expenditure as per accounting policy no.E-4.

From Comments of C&AG u/s. 143(6)(b) and management reply thereon

Capital work-in-progress – (Note No.13)

Capital Expenditure on assets not owned by the Company – Rs.76.37 crore
As
per provisions of AS-10 highlighted by the Expert Advisory Committee
(EAC) of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) in their
opinion of May 2010 reiterated in July 2011, the expenditure incurred
on enabling assets not owned by the Company should be charged off to
revenue in the accounting period in which such expenditure is incurred.

The
Company, however, capitalised the expenditure incurred on assets not
owned by the Company. The Company was requested (September 2014) by
Audit, to revise its Accounting Policy in line with the opinion given by
EAC of ICAI, if the decision of EAC on the review application of NTPC
of October 2011 is not received till finalisation of annual accounts of
the Company for 2014- 15. Though the decision of EAC of ICAI in the
matter raised by the Company was not received till finalisation of the
accounts for 2014-15, the Company did not revise its Accounting Policy
on enabling assets not owned by the Company in the current year.

The Company stated that based on their follow up, ICAI issued Exposure Draft of AS-10 which would replace the existing AS-10. The issue is being addressed in the revised AS-10. The reply is to be viewed against the fact that Revised AS-10 has not yet been notified and is likely to have prospective application. Therefore, booking of expenditure on enabling assets not owned by the Company under Tangible Assets and Capital work in progress up to March 2015 has resulted in understatement of “Expenses” by Rs.130.77 crore and overstatement of “Tangible Assets” (Net block) by Rs.54.40 crore as well as “Capital work in progress” by Rs.76.37 crore. Consequently, profit for the year is also overstated by Rs.130.77 crore.

Management Reply
The Company is a Rate Regulated Entity. Accounting of capital expenditure on the assets not owned by the Company was being done by the Company considering the Guidance Note on ‘Treatment of Expenditure during Construction Period’ since long. With the withdrawal of the above guidance note, accounting of such expenditure is being done in line with the provisions of Para 9.1 and 10 of AS 10 on ‘Accounting for Fixed Assets’ which provides that expenditure on assets which is directly attributable to the construction of the power project should be capitalised.

The balances appearing under the head ‘Capital expenditure on assets not owned by the Company’ in Tangible Assets and Capital Work-in-Progress represents expenditure incurred on roads, construction power lines, etc.

Expenditure incurred on these assets is directly attributable to the construction of the power projects without which the construction of projects of the Company would not be possible. In the opinion of the Management, such expenditure is necessary for bringing the asset to the location and condition necessary for it to be capable for operating in the manner intended by the management.

Accordingly, a reference has been made to the Expert Advisory Committee of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India for review of its opinion which is still awaited. Pending disposal of the reference, the company has continued its existing practice of capitalisation of such expenditure which has been followed consistently over the years. This has also been disclosed in Note No.12 (h) of the financial statements.

NHPC Ltd . (31-3-2015)
From Notes to Accounts

10. Construction activities at site of Subansiri Lower Project have been interrupted w.e.f. 16.12.2011 due to protest of anti-dam activists. Technical and administrative work is however continuing. Management is making all out efforts to restart the work at site. In line with the opinion of Expert Advisory Committee (EAC) of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), borrowing cost of Rs. 406.83 crore (up to previous year Rs. 766.90 crore) and administration and other cost of Rs. 115.12 crore (upto previous year Rs. 341.54 crore) have been charged to the Statement of Profit & Loss.

The company has, however, adopted the accounting as per Guidance Note on Rate Regulated Activities issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India which allows recognition of ‘Regulatory Asset’ and corresponding ‘Regulatory Income’ of the right to recover such expense which are not allowed to be capitalised as part of cost of relevant fixed asset in accordance with the Accounting Standards, but are nevertheless permitted by Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC), the regulator, to be recovered from the beneficiaries in future through tariff. (Detailed disclosure as per the ibid Guidance Note is given at para no.23 below of this Note)

23. Disclosure relating to creation of Rate Regulated Assets & recognition of Rate Regulated Income as per the ‘Guidance Note on Accounting for Rate Regulated Activities’ issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) :
The company is engaged in construction & operation of hydroelectric power projects. The price (tariff) to be charged by the company for electricity sold to its customers, is determined by Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) under applicable CERC (terms & conditions of tariff) Regulations. The said price (tariff) is based on allowable costs like interest costs, depreciation, operation &    maintenance including a stipulated return. This form of rate regulation is known as cost-of-service regulations. The basic objective of such regulations is to give the entity the opportunity to recover its costs of providing the goods or service plus a fair return.

For the purpose, the company is required to make an application to CERC based on capital expenditure incurred duly certified by the Auditors or already admitted by CERC or projected to be incurred upto date of commercial operation and additional capital expenditure duly certified by the Auditor or projected to be incurred during tariff year. The tariff determined by CERC is recovered from the customers (beneficiaries) on whom the same is binding.

The above rate regulation does result into creation of right (asset) or an obligation (liability) as envisaged in the accounting framework which is not the case in other industries. The ICAI has issued a Guidance Note on accounting for Rate Regulated Activities, which is applicable to entities that provide goods or services whose prices are subject to cost-of-service regulations and the tariff determined by the regulator is binding on the customers (beneficiaries). As per guidance note, a regulatory asset is recognised when it is probable (a reasonable assurance) that the future economic benefits associated with it will flow to the entity as a result of the actual or expected actions of the regulator under applicable regulatory framework and the amount can be measured reliably.

As explained above, all operating activities of the Company are subject to cost-of-service regulations as it meets the criteria set out in the guidance note hence it is applicable to the Company. Though the Guidance Note is effective from 01.04.2015, the Company has opted to adopt it from the Financial Year 2014-15, since earlier adoption is permitted.

The guidance note also provides that in some cases, a regulator permits an entity to include in the rate base, as part of the cost of self-constructed (tangible) fixed assets or internally generated intangible assets, amounts that would otherwise be recognised as expense in the statement of profit and loss in accordance with Accounting Standards. After the construction is completed, the resulting cost is the basis for depreciation or amortisation and unrecovered investment for rate determination. A regulatory asset is to be recognised by the entity in respect of such costs since the same is recoverable from the customers (beneficiaries) in future through tariffs.

As stated in para 10 above, the borrowing cost of ` 406.83 crore (up to previous year Rs.766.90 crore) and administration and other cost of Rs.115.12 crore (up to previous year Rs.341.54 crore) incurred on ‘Subansiri Lower Project’, wherein the active construction is interrupted since 16.12.2011, have been charged to the Statement of Profit & Loss in compliance of provision of Accounting Standard 10, Accounting for fixed asset & Accounting Standard-16, Borrowing Cost as notified under the Companies Act, 2013. However such expenditure is permitted under CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014 to be recovered through future tariffs.

In pursuance of the above, the company has created regulatory assets and has recognised corresponding regulatory income for the Financial Year 2014-15/ credit to the opening balance of surplus against the amount pertaining to the period 16.12.2011 to 31.03.2014 using transition provision as per the ibid Guidance Note as below:

Regulatory
asset

For the period

For the finan-

Total

created in relation to:

16.12.2011 to

cial year

 

 

31.03.2014

2014-15

 

Borrowing Costs

766.90

406.83

1173.73

 

 

 

 

Administrative & other

341.54

115.12

456.66

Costs

 

 

 

Total

1108.44*

521.95**

1630.39

 

 

 

 

*by corresponding credit to opening balance of Surplus by Rs.876.10 crore (Rs. 1108.44 crore less provision for Income Tax for Rs.232.34 crore) [refer- Note No.3-Reserves and Surplus].

**    by corresponding credit to current year’s profit through “Regulatory Income”. From Auditors’ Report Emphasis of Matters a) ..b) .. c) .. d) .. e) ..

f) Note No. 29 para 23 read with significant accounting policy no. 4 to the Financial Statements regarding earlier adoption (duly permitted) of Guidance Note on Accounting for Rate Regulated Activities issued by The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.

Our opinion is not modified in respect of these matters.

Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd (31-3-2015) From Significant Accounting Policies

Capital Work-in-Progress

Capital work in progress (CWIP) includes all expenditure for acquisition and construction of assets. Such expenditure includes cost of preparing project report, conducting feasibility study, land survey and location study etc. CWIP also includes all direct incidental expenditure during construction (EDC). All common costs are allocated on a rational basis. EDC is allocated on a pro rata basis to the assets capitalised on commencement of commercial operation.

Major Renovation, Modernisation and Upgradation of Units of Stations needing long shut down resulting in increased efficiency of the unit are considered as projects.

All direct expenditure during such major renovation, modernisation & upgradation is considered as ‘CWIP’ and capitalised on its completion.

Any payment in relation to the development schemes/ creation of facilities at projects as per the approval/ directive of Department of Atomic Energy (i.e. regulator for fixation of tariff) and recoverable through tariff is considered as ‘Capital Work in Progress’ and capitalised on completion of the relevant projects.

From Notes to Financial Statements

Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) in consultation with the Tamil Nadu State Government has directed to release funds amounting to Rs.200.00 crore to Tamil Nadu State Authorities (TSAs) towards the approved development schemes for the project affected people of KKNPP. As per the directive of DAE, the said amount released to TSAs is required to be included in the overall project cost of KKNPP 3 & 4 and a sum of Rs.89.34 crore (Rs.45.00 crore in FY 2012-13 and Rs.44.34 crore in FY 2014-15) has been released to TSAs. Further, the said amount released to TSAs is recoverable through tariff on the completion of the said project. The Institute of Chartered Accounts of India in its Guidance note on ‘Accounting for rate regulated activities’ has advised to recognise such nature of payments as regulatory ‘Asset’ as they met the recognition criteria given in the framework. Accordingly, the said amounts released have been accounted under the capital work in progress (Note-12).

Keeping in view the above, a new clause in the significant accounting policies related to Capital Work in Progress (CWIP) has been introduced during the current year ended on 31.03.2015 (Refer Accounting Policy No. G – CWIP). Had this guidance note not been followed , this may result in decrease in CWIP by a sum of Rs.89.34 crore and also decrease in profit before tax by a sum of Rs.89.34 crore.

Ethics and u

fiogf49gjkf0d
Shrikrishna (S) — Arjun, you are looking worried today.

Arjun (A) — Yes. This is September. Virtually a killing month for all CAs.

S — This is every year’s ‘crying’. Why don’t you plan well in advance?.

A — Very easy to say so. But in reality, every month there is some compliance or the other. And consequences of defaults are very harsh. You have to be on your toes constantly.

S — But the tax-audit date has been extended? Isn’t it?

A — T rue; but I am not sure whether the deadlines for filing returns will be extended. Then what is the use? I wonder why the Government does not clarify things well in time.

S — A ll CAs are sailing in the same boat. Granted that it worries you. But you are rather tensed up today. What is the matter?

A — A ctually, nowadays all the returns and other forms are to be submitted on-line. They are to be uploaded.

S — So what?

A — F or this, all the clients are keeping their digital signatures in our custody only.

S — Why?

A — Because all the returns are completed only in the last two days only. And when we are slogging, the clients are enjoying themselves abroad or at hill-stations.

S — Oh, I see. So you take all their tokens of digital signatures in your custody and use them! Is it not?

A — Exactly. And just now, my office informs me that two such signatures are misplaced. Not traceable!

S — O h! It is very risky. But why do you take such a risk? Is there any documentation for keeping it with you? Do you have any written instructions to use them? Otherwise, under the IT Act, it is an offence.

A — I didn’t come across any such provision in Income Tax Act. Is it in DTC?

S — N o Arjun. IT means Information Technology Act, 2000.

A — I have never read it.

S — Actually, using another person’s digital signature in his absence and without his specific consent is a serious offence. It is like a forgery. See section 42 of Information Technology Act. It says that the digital signature can be used only by the subscriber or person authorised by him to affix it.

A — O h, my God! Then what should we do?

S — E very time, you should take a letter from the client that he is handing over the token or the CD of digital signature to you. And there should be a specific instruction authorising you to use it. And when you return it, take his acknowledgement. It may be misused or wrongly used and the blame may come on you.

A — But now what should I do? Their returns are to be filed now. Fortunately, there is no proof that they have handed over to my office.

S — I t is embarrassing. Actually, you should have not only proper documentation but all signs should be kept under lock and key; under the control of a very responsible person.

A — What are the consequences under that Information Technology Act?

S — Penalty is in the form of compensation upto Rs. 25,000 to be paid to the affected person.

A — Baap Re!

S — N ot only that. But it amounts to negligence or lack of due diligence in discharging your duties.

A — I t is a double jeopardy.

S — Y es. And the tension that the misplaced digital signature may be misused is all the more disturbing.

A — I wonder how I will tell those clients that their digital signatures are not traceable! It is a question of my reputation.

S — That’s right. In Bhagavad Geeta also I told you the same thing. Loss of reputation is more harmful than even death. Now it is high time that you focus on systems in your office.

A — It is an eye-opener. Small lapses lead to heavy damage. Usually after our tax audits, we relax, and wake up only next year. But this year, I should change this. I must focus on housekeeping and get better organised. I am convinced that this is a serious professional misconduct and if I were in the client’s position, I would be very much upset.

S — Good. This is a lesson which should change your functioning. All the best to you.

Note: The above dialogue between Shri Krishna and Arjun is based on Clause (7) of Part I of Second Schedule which is reproduced below. This dialogue aims at bringing out those small things that we take for granted. Such small things and lack of documentation can lead to big problems in future. It thus becomes very important to inculcate a habit of documentation not only within us but also amongst our office staff.

Clause (7) of Part I of Second Schedule states that a CA in practice shall be deemed to be guilty of professional misconduct, if he –

“does not exercise due diligence, or is grossly negligent in the conduct of his professional duties”. Be very cautious and see to it that nothing is done in ‘good faith’ without proper documentation/safeguards.

levitra

PART C: Information on & Around

fiogf49gjkf0d
Govt. to challenge SCIC order against CP Rakesh Maria :
The state government has decided to challenge Chief Information Commissioner Ratnakar Gaikwad’s order to institute a judicial probe against Police Commissioner Rakesh Maria for providing misleading information to the widow of a police officer gunned down by Pakistani terrorists in the November, 2008 attacks.

The CIC’s order against Maria had accepted slain officer Ashok Kamte’s wife, Vinita Kamte’s allegations, that there were discrepancies between two copies of call logs of wireless conversation between the control room and Kamte’s van, in which he was shot down by terrorists along with the then Maharashtra ATS chief Hemant Karkare and encounter specialist Vijay Salaskar.

She had charged that there was a delay in sending help to her injured husband and his colleagues and that the call logs were tampered with to hide this. She had also alleged that information about who directed her husband and his colleagues to follow the terrorists into the Cama Hospital lane, where they were ambushed, was denied to her.

RTI activist Anil Galgali said the CIC had exceeded its brief in ordering the judicial inquiry.”Gaikwad has been appointed by the state government to give information and thereby give justice. But he has no powers to order an inquiry. The job of the State Information Commission is to provide information. They have failed in that,” he said.

No plan to strip Saif of Padma Shri:
The home ministry denied any move to strip actor Saif Ali Khan of his Padma Shri award, conferred on him in 2010, in the wake of a Mumbai court framing charges against him for assaulting an NRI businessman at a city hotel.

“The home ministry’s reply to the RTI filed by SC Agarwal to know the status of his own complaint, stating that the matter is under examination, is a routine response to any query that relates to a pending complaint. The home ministry has to call for necessary records from the state government or the court to validate the charges made in the complaint… this takes time and the merits of the complaints are finally decided on the basis to be under examination,” a senior home ministry official said.

Above was in reply to SC Agarwals RTI application to the home ministry

Gifts to PM Manmohan Singh:
From a fancy Bose music system to a glittering Piaget ladies wrist watch, former PM Manmohan Singh took home some 101 unique pieces of gift items that were given to him by heads of states whose countries he visited in his official capacity, an RTI query has revealed. But the government has refused to share details of Singh’s pay and perks, his parting comments or names of countries that gave the presents. Singh is permitted to retain gifts under the Foreign Contribution (Acceptance or Retention of Gifts or Presentations) Regulations, 1978 and its Rules, 2012.

levitra

PART B: RTI Act, 2005

fiogf49gjkf0d
RTI & Political Parties: On 3rd June 2013 full bench of CIC passed a detailed Order (53 pages) holding that 6 political parties:
1) Indian National Congress/ All IndiaCongress Committee (AICC)
2) Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP)
3) Communist Party of India (Marxist) (CPM)
4) Communist Party of India (CPI)
5) Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) and
6) Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP)

are covered as “public authority” under the RTI Act (Covered in my article of July 2013). Last para of the order reads as under:

93. The Presidents, General/Secretaries of these Political Parties are hereby directed to designate CPIOs and the Appellate Authorities as their headquarters in 06 weeks time. The CPIOs so appointed will respond to the RTI applications extracted in this order in 4 weeks time. Besides, the Presidents, General/Secretaries of the above mentioned Political Parties are also directed to comply with the provision of section 4(1) (b) of the RTI Act by the way of making voluntary disclosures on the subjects mentioned in the said clause.

It appears that none of the said 6 parties acted on the above direction.

The Commission had issued notices on 7th February and 25th March, to these parties seeking their detailed comments on the complaint by Agarwal that they had not complied with the orders of the CIC. The notice had been sent to the chiefs of Congress, BJP, BSP and NCP and to the general secretaries of CPI and CPI-M.

In what could spell trouble for Congress president Sonia Gandhi, the Delhi HC in August, 2014 issued direction on a petition accusing her failure to abide by a Central Information Commission directive.

HC directed the CIC to decide in six months a complaint against Gandhi that she hasn’t implemented the transparency panel’s direction making political parties answerable under the RTI Act. The court acted on a petition filed by RTI activist R. K. Jain who had earlier approached the Commission with his complaint against Gandhi saying that party had returned his RTI application without furnishing details that were asked.

Now in the month of September 2014, The Central Information Commission (CIC) has issued showcause notices to BJP President Amit Shah and Congress chief Sonia Gandhi, along with the heads of four other political parties, asking why an inquiry should not be instituted for non-compliance of its order to implement the RTI Act.

levitra

PART A: Decision Of CIC & High Court

fiogf49gjkf0d
In this article, I cover a few decisions of CIC and one of H.C, basically to inform briefly the views of CIC/H.C on the subjects covered.

Section 2(f) – Information:
The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in WP(C) No. 7265/2007 dated 25th September 2009 has observed as follows:

“Information as defined in section 2(f) means details or material available with the public authority. The later portion of section 2(f) expands the definition to include details or material which can be accessed under any other law from others. The two definitions have to be read harmoniously. The term held by or under the control of any public authority in section 2(j) of the RTI Act has to be read in a manner that it effectuates and is in harmony with the definition of the term information in section 2(f) of the RTI Act. It is well settled that an interpretation which renders another provision or part thereof redundant or superfluous should be avoided. Information as defined in section 2 (f) of the RTI Act includes in its ambit, the information relating to any private body which can be accessed by any public authority under any law for the time being in force. Therefore, if a public authority has a right and is entitled to access information from a private body, under any other law, it is information as defined in section 2(f) of the RTI Act.”

[WP (C) No. 7265/2007 dated 25th September 2009]

Section 2(f) – Information:
After hearing both the parties and on perusal of documents, the Commission observes that as deserving as the appellant might be for the post of Social Worker, he cannot ask interrogative questions from a public authority under the Act. The public authority is not bound to answer queries like whether he would be considered for the post since he has crossed the age limit or whether he will be granted any age relaxation and whether his merit will be considered or not. Interrogative queries viz. “How/Why/ When” do not come under the ambit of the RTI Act.

In Dr. Celsa Pinto vs. Goa State Information Commission (W.P.No. 419 of 2007), the High Court of Bombay, in its order dated 03.04.2008, held:

“The definition (of information) cannot include within its fold answers to the question “why” which would be the same thing as asking the reason for a justification for a particular thing. The Public Information Authorities cannot expect to communicate to the citizen the reason why a certain things was done or not done in the sense of a justification because the citizen makes a requisition about information. Justifications are matter within the domain of adjudicating authorities and cannot properly be classified as information.”

[G. Senthil Kumar vs. Dr. Raman, DoH, Directorate of Health & Family Welfare Services, Puducherry – File No. CIC/SS/A/2013/000838-YA: Decided: 28.05.2014]

Section 6(1) &7(1) of the RTI Act:
This matter pertains to an RTI application dated 03-05- 2012 filed by the Appellant, seeking information on twelve points. The CPIO responded on 04-06-2012 and asked the Appellant to deposit photocopying charges, amounting to Rs. 48, to obtain the information running into 24 pages. The CPIO also asked the Appellant to deposit postal charges of Rs. 25.

We note that no further action pending on this RTI application on the part of the Respondents. We also note that the CPIO erred in asking for postal charge of Rs. 25. Accordingly, we direct the CPIO that in case the Appellant deposits the amount of Rs. 48, the information running into 24 pages should be provided to him, within 15 days of deposit of the above amount by him.

[Navneet Singhania vs. CPIO, Oriental Bank of Commerce, Regional Office: Ranjeet Avenue, Amritsar – File No. CIC/VS/A/2012/000711/SH: Decided 05-05-2014]

Section 7(1) of the RTI Act:
The Appellant stated that the FAA had not given him a personal hearing despite his request to that effect. In this context, we advice the FAA that in the interest of natural justice, he should give a personal hearing, in case requested by a person filing an appeal to him on an RTI matter.

The Appellant has drawn our attention to the fact that the CPIO has not been mentioning his name in his replies to RTI applications. In this context, we inform the Respondents the decision of the Commission that the CPIOs and FAAs should mention their name, address, telephone and fax number in all correspondence on RTI matters. The CPIO is directed to ensure compliance with the above decision of the Commission.

[Chayan Ghosh Chowdhury vs. CPIO, Union Bank of India, Lucknow – File No. CIC/VS/A/2013/001508/SH: decided on 23-05-2014]

If readers appreciate this kind of my write ups, I shall continue whenever any landmark decision is not available.

levitra

From published accounts

fiogf49gjkf0d
Section A:
Modified report on account on unconfirmed loans, advances and deposits to related parties, etc. (Part I)

United Spirits Ltd (31-3-2014)


From Notes to Accounts

26. Provision for doubtful receivable, advances and deposits

26(a) Certain parties who had previously given the required undisputed balance confirmations for the year ended 31st March 2013,claimed in their balance confirmations to the Company for the year ended 31st March 2014 that they have advanced certain amounts to certain alleged UB Group entities, and that the dues owed by such parties to the Company will, to the extent of the amounts owing by such alleged UB Group entities to such parties in respect of such advances, be paid/refunded by such parties to the Company only upon receipt of their dues from such alleged UB Group entities. These dues of such parties to the Company are on account of advances by the Company in the earlier years under agreements for enhancing capacity, obtaining exclusivity and lease deposits in relation to Tie-up Manufacturing Units (TMUs); agreements for specific projects; or dues owing to the Company from customers. These dues wereHI duly confirmed by such parties as payable to the Company in such earlier years. However, such parties have now disputed such amounts as mentioned above. Details are as below:

In response to these claims, under the instruction of the Board, a preliminary internal inquiry was initiated by the Management. The results of this inquiry were as follows:

i. One party (which falls under (a) above), who owes certain amounts to the Company, has disputed an amount of Rs. 2,240.7 million (including interest claimed by it as due from an alleged UB Group entity), alleging that it had advanced monies to such alleged UB Group entity based on an understanding that, to the extent of the amounts owed to it from such alleged UB Group entity in respect of such advance, it could withhold from the amounts payable by it to the Company, and such party has said that it would not pay its dues to the Company to the extent of the amounts claimed by it from such alleged UB Group entity as mentioned above, unless it received repayment of the amount advanced by it to such alleged UB Group entity along with interest.

ii. Certain parties (which falls under (a) above), who owes certain amounts to the Company, have disputed an aggregate amount of Rs. 984.5 million (including interest claimed by them as due from alleged UB Group entities), alleging that they had advanced monies to such alleged UB Group entities and that, to the extent of such dues from such alleged UB Group entity as mentioned above, unless it received repayment of the amount advanced by it to such alleged UB Group entity along with interest.

iii. Certain other parties (which fall under [(b) and (c)] above) changed their original stand and acknowledged that their dues from the alleged UB Group entities were based on transactions that were independent of their dealings with the Company. These parties have subsequently provided appropriate confirmations of the relevant balances due from them to the Company. The related balances are Rs. 2,681.8 million.

iv. In addition to the above, there is an additional party, being a TMU, whose allegations are on a similar basis to those of the parties mentioned at (iii) above and who has subsequently provided an appropriate confirmation of the balance due from it to the Company. However, this party’s undertaking has closed down and the related balance of Rs. 648.5 Million (including interest) has been provided in the current year.

v. The claims made in relation to the advances to the parties (including the additional party) mentioned above may indicate that all or some of such amounts may have been improperly advanced from the Company to such parties for, in turn, being advanced to the alleged UB Group entities. The aforesaid, however can only be confirmed by a detailed inquiry which has been authorised by the Board as mentioned below.

vi. The Company is proposing to more fully inquire into the allegations or claims by the parties in detail and does not acknowledge the correctness of the same. In any event, the Management does not believe that the parties referred to above are entitled to withhold payment/ repayment to the Company as claimed by them. The Management further believes that the Company is entitled to recover all the above amounts, including those disputed by certain parties as mentioned in notes (i) and (ii) above, as and when due from these parties. However, the Management has also examined the financial capability of some of these parties, based on which the Management has concluded that the ability of these parties to pay, and consequently the recoverability of, the relevant amounts is doubtful. After considering the above and other considerations and though the above claims were received only when the Company sought balance confirmations from the relevant parties for the year ended 31 March 2014, as a matter of prudence, a provision has been made in the accounts in respect of the dues from these parties (including interest claimed up to the various dates of the balance confirmations from these parties) as detailed below, and as these transactions relate to the period prior to 1 April 2013 they have been reflected as prior period items in the financial statements:

Based on the current knowledge of the Management, the Management believes that the aforesaid provision is adequate and no additional material adjustments are likely to be required in relation to this matter.

As mentioned in Note 26(c), the Board has: (i) directed a detailed and expeditious inquiry into this matter and (ii) authorised the initiation of suitable action and proceedings as considered appropriate by the Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer (MD) for recovering the Company’s dues. Appropriate other action will also be taken commensurate with the outcome of that inquiry.

Pending completion of the inquiry mentioned in note 26(c), the Company is unable to determine whether, on completion of the inquiry, there could be any impact on these financial statements; and these financial statements should be read and construed accordingly.

26(b) Certain pre-existing loans/deposits/advances due to the Company and its wholly-owned subsidiaries from United Breweries (Holdings) Limited (UBHL) which were in existence as on 31st March 2013, had been taken into consideration in the consolidated annual accounts of the Company drawn up as of that date. Pursuant to a previous resolution passed by the board of directors of the Company on 11th October 2012, such dues (together with interest) aggregating to Rs.13,374 million were consolidated into, and recorded as, an unsecured loan by way of an agreement entered into between the Company and UBHL on 3rd July 2013. Further, the amounts owed by UBHL to wholly-owned subsidiaries have been assigned by such subsidiaries to the Company and are recorded as loan from such subsidiaries in the books of the Company. The merger of one of such subsidiaries with the Company is currently under process. The interest rate under the above mentioned loan agreement dated 3rd July 2013 is at 9.5% p.a. to be paid at six months intervals starting at the end of 18 months from the effective date of the loan agreement. The loan has been granted for a period of 8 years and is payable in three annual installments commencing from the end of 6th anniversary of the effective date of the loan agreement.

Certain lenders have filed petitions for winding up against UBHL. UBHL has provided guarantees to lenders and other vendors of Kingfisher Airlines Limited (KFA), a UB Group entity. Most of these guarantees have been invoked and are being challenged in Courts. The Company has also filed its affidavit opposing the aforesaid winding up petitions and the matter is sub-judice.

The management has performed an assessment of the recoverability of the loan and has reviewed valuation reports in relation to UBHL prepared by reputed independent valuers that were commissioned by UBHL, and shared by UBHL with the Company. As a result of  the abovementioned assessment and review by the management, in accordance with the recommendation of the management, the Company, as a matter of prudence, has  not  recognised  interest  income  of  Rs.  963.069 million  and  has  provided  Rs.  3,303.186  million  towards the  principal  outstanding  as  at  31st  march  2014.  the management believes that it should be able to recover, and no further provision is required for the balance amount of rs. 9,956.806 million, though the Company will attempt  to  recover  the  entire  amount  of  rs.14,223.061 million. however, the management will continue to assess the recoverability of the said loan on an ongoing basis.

26(c) the Board has directed a detailed and expeditious inquiry in relation to the matters stated in Notes 26(a), 26(b) and 30(f), the possible existence of any other transaction of a similar nature; the role of individuals involved; and potential non-compliance (if any) with the provisions of the Companies act, 1956 and other regulations applicable to the Company in relation to such transactions. The Board has directed the managing director (“md”) to engage independent advisers and specialists as required for the inquiry. The Board has also authorised the MD to take suitable action and proceedings as considered appropriate by him for recovering the Company’s dues. Appropriate other action will also be taken commensurate with the outcome of that inquiry. On the basis of the knowledge and information of the management, the management believes that no additional material adjustments to the financial statements are likely to be required in relation to the matters mentioned above in this note. However, pending completion of the detailed inquiry mentioned above, the Company is unable to determine the impact on the financial statements (if any), on completion of such detailed inquiry, and these financial results should be read and construed accordingly.

30(f) Subsequent to the balance sheet date, the Company received a letter dated 5th may 2014 from the lawyers  of an entity (alleged Claimant) alleging that it had given loans amounting to rs. 2,000 million to Kfa at an interest rate of 15% p.a. purportedly on the basis of agreements executed  in  december  2011  and  january  2012.  this matter came to the knowledge of the Board for the first time only after the management informed the Board of the letter dated 5th may 2014. the letter alleges that amongst several obligations under these purported agreements, certain investments held by the Company were subject to a lien, and requires the Company, pending the repayment of the said loan, to pledge such investments in favour of the alleged Claimant to secure the aforesaid loans. the Company has responded to this letter received from the lawyers of the alleged Claimant vide its letter dated 3rd june 2014, wherein the Company has disputed the claim and denied having created the alleged security or having executed any document in favour of the alleged Claimant. the  Company  has  reiterated  its  stand  vide  a  follow-up letter dated 28th july 2014 and has asked for copies of purported documents referred to in the letter dated 5th May 2014. Subsequent to the above, the Company has received a letter dated 31st july 2014 from the alleged Claimant stating that in light of certain addendums to the aforesaid purported agreements (which had inadvertently not been informed to their lawyers) the alleged Claimant has no claim or demand of any nature whatsoever against inter alia the Company, including any claim or demand arising out of or connected with the documents / agreements referred to their lawyer’s letter dated 5th May 2014. The Company has replied to the alleged Claimant vide a letter dated 6th august 2014, noting the above mentioned confirmation of there being no claim or demand against the Company, and asking the alleged Claimant  to immediately provide to the Company all the alleged documents referred to in the letter dated 5th may 2014 and the addendum referred to in the letter dated 31st july 2014, and to also confirm the identity and capacity of the signatory to the letter dated 31st july 2014.

Subsequently, in September 2014, the Company obtained scanned copies of the purported agreements (including the purported power of attorney) and various communications between KFA and the alleged Claimant. these   documents   indicate   that   while   the   purported agreements may have sought to create a lien on certain investments of the Company, subsequently, the Alleged Claimant  and  KFA  sought  to  negotiate  the  release  of the purported obligation to create such lien, which was formalised vide a second addendum in September 2012.

The Management has verified from a perusal of the minutes of meetings of the board of directors of the Company that the board of directors of the Company at the relevant time had not approved or ratified any such purported agreement. the management has represented to the Board that till the receipt of scanned copies of the purported agreements in September 2014, the Company had no knowledge of these purported agreements. The management, based on legal advice received, does not expect any liability or obligation to arise on the Company out of these purported agreements.

From auditors’ report (given in italics in the original report) Basis for Qualified Opinion
1.    As stated in Note 26(a) to the financial statements, certain parties who had previously given the required undisputed balance confirmations for the year ended 31st march 2013, alleged during the current year, that they have advanced certain amounts to certain alleged UB Group entities and linked the confirmation of amounts due to the Company to repayment of such amounts to such parties by the alleged uB Group entities. Also, some of these parties stated that the dues to the Company will be paid/refunded only upon receipt of their dues from such alleged UB Group entities. These dues of such parties are on account of advances by the Company in the earlier years under agreements for enhancing capacity, obtaining exclusivity  and  lease  deposits  in  relation  to  tie-up Manufacturing Units; agreements for specific projects; or dues owing to the Company from customers. These claims received in the current year may indicate that all or some of such amounts may have been improperly advanced from the Company to such parties for, in turn, being advanced to the UB Group entities. however, this can only be confirmed after a detailed inquiry. Based on the findings of the preliminary internal inquiry by the management, under the instructions of the Board of Directors; and Management’s assessment of recoverability, an aggregate amount of rs. 6,495.4 million has been provided in the financial statements and has been disclosed as prior period items. Based on its current knowledge, the management believes that the aforesaid provision is adequate and no additional material adjustments to the financial statements are likely to be required in relation to this matter. As stated in paragraph 4 below, the Board of directors have instructed the management to undertake a detailed inquiry into this matter. Pending such inquiry, we are unable to comment on the nature of these transactions; the provision established; or any further impact on the financial statements;

2.    As stated in Note 30(f) to the financial statements, subsequent to the balance sheet date, the Company received a letter dated 5th may 2014 from the lawyers of an entity (alleged Claimant) alleging that the alleged Claimant had advanced loans amounting to rs. 2,000 million to Kingfisher Airlines Limited (hereinafter referred  to  as  “KFA”),  a  UB  Group  entity,  in  an earlier year on the basis of agreements, executed in december 2011 and january 2012, through which the Company was alleged to have created a lien on certain investments in favour of the alleged Claimant as security for the aforesaid loans. The letter alleged that KFA had defaulted in repayment of the foresaid loans as well as interest of Rs. 790 million due thereon and demanded that the Company should pay the aforesaid amounts and pending such repayments, create a valid pledge on the specified investments. The Company responded to the aforesaid letter vide its letters dated  3rd  june  2014  and  28th  july  2014,  wherein the Company denied knowledge of the purported loan transactions and the purported agreements for the creation of security on such investments held by  the  Company. A letter  dated  31st  july  2014  was received from the alleged Claimant wherein they have stated that the notice sent earlier did not take into account an addendum to the loan agreement; and after examining the aforesaid addendum, they have no claim or demand of any nature against the Company. In September 2014, scanned copies of the purported agreements and certain related documents were  obtained  by  the  Company.  These  documents indicate that while the agreements may have sought to create a lien on certain investments of the Company; subsequently, the Alleged Claimant and KFA sought to negotiate the release of the lien, which was formalised vide a second addendum in September 2012.

The  management  has  represented  to  us  that  the Company had no knowledge of these purported agreements; that the Board of directors of the Company have not approved any such purported agreements; and it is not liable under any such purported agreements. We are unable to conclude  on the validity of these agreements; any required compliance with the provisions of the Companies act, 1956; and any consequential impact of the same;

3.    As stated in Note 26(b) to the financial statements, the Company and its subsidiaries had various preexisting loans/advances/deposits due from united Breweries (holdings) limited (hereinafter referred to as “uBhl”). During the current year, pursuant to a previous resolution passed by the Board of directors on 11th october 2012, these dues (together with interest) were consolidated into an unsecured loan aggregating rs. 13,374 million vide an agreement dated 3rd july 2013.

The loan has been granted for a period of 8 years with a moratorium period of 6 years. Certain lenders have filed petitions for winding-up against UBHL. UBHL has provided guarantees to lenders and other vendors of Kingfisher Airlines Limited, which have been invoked and  are  currently  being  challenged  in  courts.  the Company has also filed its affidavit opposing the aforesaid winding up petition and the matter is sub- judice. Based on its assessment of the recoverability of the loan, the Company has made a provision of rs. 3,303 million against the loan outstanding and has not recognised the interest income of Rs. 963 million on the loan. Given the various uncertainties involved with respect to the litigations involving UBHL as aforesaid and the extended period  for  repayment  of  the  loan, we are unable to comment on the level of provision established;

4.    As stated in Note 26(c) to the financial statements, the Board of directors have instructed the management to undertake a detailed inquiry in relation to the matters stated in the paragraphs above; the possible existence of any other transaction of a similar nature; the role of individuals involved; and potential non-compliance (if any) with the provisions of the Companies act, 1956 and other regulations applicable to the Company. The Board has also instructed the management to engage independent advisers and specialists, as  required, for the inquiry. As the inquiry is yet to be carried out, we are unable to comment on any further adjustment that could be identified as a result of the inquiry; its resultant impact on the financial statements; and any potential non-compliances with the provisions of the Companies act, 1956 and other regulations; and

5.    Though the observations in paragraph 1 above relate to claims received in the current year, the underlying transactions were entered into in earlier years. Accordingly, the financial statements of those earlier years and consequently the opening balances may be incorrectly stated to that extent. Further, the detailed inquiry as referred to in paragraph 4 above may result in further adjustments that may have an impact on the opening balances.

Opinion
In our opinion and to the best of our information and according to the explanations given to us, except for the effects of the matter described in the Basis for Qualified Opinion paragraph, the financial statements give the information required by the Act in the manner so required and give a true and fair view in conformity with the accounting principles generally accepted in India. …

From Directors’ Report
BOARD OF DIRECTORS’ RESPONSES TO OBSERVATIONS, QUALIFICATIONS AND ADVERSE REMARKS IN AUDITOR’S REPORT

The Statutory Auditors have qualified their opinion in relation to the matters specified in Notes 26(a), 26(b), 26(c) and 30(f) of the Financial Statement as follows:

1.    Auditor’s observations under Paragraph 1 of the Auditor’s report to the financial statement (“the Statement”): Not reproduced

Director’s Response: Information and explanation on the qualification on paragraph 1 of the audit report is provided in Note 26(a) to the Statement. In particular, as stated in note  26(a),  the  transactions  referred  to in the said note are on account of amounts that were advanced by the Company in the earlier years and were duly confirmed by the relevant parties as payable to the Company in such earlier years, but were disputed by such parties for the first time when the Company sought balance confirmations from them for the year ended 31st march 2014. This was brought to the attention of the Board after 31st march 2014. Accordingly, as mentioned in note 26(a), as a matter of prudence, the amounts mentioned in the note 26(a) have now been provided for. Since the transactions referred to in the said note 26(a) were entered in to prior to 31st March 2013, they have been reflected as prior period items in the financial statements.

Further, as mentioned in Note 26(a), the Board has:
(i)    Directed a detailed and expeditious inquiry into this matter and (ii) authorised the initiation of suitable action and proceedings as considered appropriate by the Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer (MD) for recovering the Company’s dues. Appropriate other action will also be taken commensurate with the outcome of that inquiry.

2.    Auditor’s  observations  under  Paragraph   2   of   the  Auditor’s  report  to  the  financial   statement: not reproduced

Directors’ Response: Information and explanation on the qualification at paragraph 2 of the audit report is provided in Note 30(f) to the Statement. In particular, as stated in note 30(f), the claim is based on documents purportedly executed by the Company in the months of december 2011 and january 2012. however, the claim was received by the Company only after the year  ended  31st  march  2014.  this  matter  was  only thereafter brought to the knowledge of the Board by the management. a letter dated 31st july 2014 was received from the alleged Claimant wherein they have stated that the notice sent earlier did not take into account an addendum to the loan agreement; and after examining the aforesaid addendum, they have no claim or demand of any nature against the Company. Subsequently, in September 2014, the Company obtained scanned copies of the purported agreements (including the purported power of attorney) and various communications between KFA and the alleged Claimant. These documents indicate that while the purported agreements may have sought to create a lien on certain investments of the Company, subsequently, the Alleged Claimant and KFA sought to negotiate the release of the purported obligation to create such lien, which was formalised vide a second addendum in September 2012.

The Management has verified from a perusal of the minutes of meetings of the board of directors of the Company that the board of directors at the relevant time had not approved or ratified any such documents. accordingly, the Company has, in its responses to the alleged Claimant, disputed the alleged  claim  and denied having created the alleged security or having executed any document in favour of the alleged  Claimant.  Further,  the  management,  based on legal advice received, does not expect any liability or obligation to arise on the Company out of these allegations.

3.    Auditor’s observations under Paragraph 3 of the Auditor’s report to the financial statement: Not reproduced

Directors’ Response: Information and  explanation  on the qualification at paragraph 3 of the  audit  report is provided in Note 26(b) to the Statement. In particular, as stated in note 26(b), the management has performed an assessment of the recoverability  of the loan and has reviewed valuation reports in relation to UBHL prepared by reputed independent valuers that were commissioned by UBHL, and shared by UBHL with the Company. As  a  result  of the above mentioned assessment and review by the management, in accordance with the recommendation of the management, the Company, as a matter of prudence, has not recognised interest income of Rs.  963  million  and  has  provided  Rs.  3,303  million towards the principal outstanding as at 31st march 2014.  The  management  believes  that  it  should  be able to recover, and no further provision is required for the balance amount of Rs. 9,957 million, though the Company will attempt to recover the entire amount of Rs.14,223 million. However, the management will continue to assess the recoverability of the said loan on an ongoing basis.

Further,  the  Board  has  directed  the  management  to review the underlying loan agreement(s) and / or other relevant documents (“loan documents”), to inter-alia assess: (i) whether any event of default(s) under the loan documents has occurred on the part of UBHL;
(ii) the legal rights and remedies which the Company has  under  the  loan  documents;  (iii)  whether  the Company should invoke any of the remedies available to it under the loan documents (including recalling of the entire loan); and (iv) whether there is any scope of renegotiating the terms and conditions under the loan documents.

In this regard, the management should expeditiously take all the necessary steps to fully protect the interest of the Company and shareholders.

4.    Auditor’s observations under Paragraph 4 of the Auditor’s report to the financial statement: Not reproduced

Directors’ Response: Information and  explanation  on the qualification at paragraph 4 of the  audit  report is provided in Note 26(c) to the Statement.     In particular, as stated in note 26 (c) above, in addition to commissioning the inquiry, the Board has also authorised the md to take suitable action and proceedings as considered appropriate by him for recovering the Company’s dues. Appropriate other action will also be taken commensurate with the outcome of the inquiry commissioned by the Board. on the basis of the current knowledge and information of the management, the management believes that no additional material adjustments to the financial statements are likely to be required in relation to the matters mentioned above in notes 26(a), 26(b) and 30(f). However, pending completion of the detailed inquiry mentioned above, the Company is unable to determine whether, on completion of such detailed inquiry, there could be any impact on the financial statements.

5.    Auditor’s observations under Paragraph 5 of the Auditor’s report to the financial statement: Not reproduced

Directors’ response: Information and  explanation on the qualification at paragraph 5 of the audit report is provided in Note 26(a) to the Statement. In particular, as stated in note 26 (a), while the claims referred to in note 26(a) were received only when the Company sought balance confirmations from the relevant parties for the year ended 31st march 2014, the transactions referred to in the said note were entered in to prior to 31st march 2013 and therefore, they have been reflected as prior period items in the financial statements. Further, as stated in note 26(a) (iii), the management has stated to the Board that, on the basis of their current knowledge, no additional material adjustments to the financial statements are likely to be required in relation to the matters mentioned in the said Note. As mentioned in Note 26(c) to the financial statement, the Board has commissioned the inquiry referred to in note 26(c). Upon completion of the inquiry, the Board will consider impact on the financial statements, if any.

Compilers’ note
The Auditors’ Report also contains qualifications in the CARO report, which are in turn explained in the Directors’ report. the  same  will  be  reproduced  in  the  next  issue of BCAJ.

Cancerous Corruption

fiogf49gjkf0d
Note on “How IT can reduce corruption” by Mr. Lalit Kanodia to IMC Anti-Corruption Cell Members

Information and Communications Technology (ICT) against corruption

Introduction
Information
and Communication Technologies (ICTs) are increasingly seen by
governments as well as activists and civil society as important tools to
promote transparency and accountability as well as to identify and
reduce corruption. New technologies, in the form of websites, mobile
Phones, applications etc., have been used to facilitate the reporting of
corruption and the access to official information, to monitor the
efficiency and integrity of social services and of a country’s political
life, and to make financial information more transparent. ICTs can also
support campaigning efforts and help mobilise people against
corruption. Over the last decade, governments have launched an
increasing number of e-government initiatives to enhance the efficiency
and transparency of public administration and improve interaction with
citizens.

1. ICTs against corruption: potential and challenges

Potential benefits
There
is a broad consensus that ICTs have the potential to make a significant
contribution in the fight against corruption. By facilitating the flow
of information between government institutions, between government and
citizens, as well as among citizens, new technologies can promote
transparency, accountability and civic participation There are numerous
ways in which ICTs can trigger positive change: by reducing the
asymmetries of information between public officials and citizens;
limiting the discretion of public officials; automatising processes,
cutting out intermediaries, and reducing red tape and bureaucracy. The
Swedish Program for ICT in Developing Regions (Spider) developed a list
of the possible areas in which ICTs can help combat corruption
(Grönlund, 2010):

  • Automation, which can reduce the opportunities for corruption in repetitive operations
  • Transparency, which can help reduce the room for discretion;
  • Detection in operations, to identify anomalies, outliers and underperformance
  • Preventive detection through monitoring of networks and individuals;
  • Awareness raising to empower the public and inform it about its right to resist arbitrary treatment;
  • Reporting, to create complaint channels that can lead to concrete action and help punish violations and close loopholes;
  • Deterrence, by disseminating information about reported cases of corruption;
  • Promoting ethical attitudes through public engagement and online discussions

Impact of ICTs: little evidence but positive signs
Although
new technologies are increasingly seen by governments and
anti-corruption practitioners as a transformational tool and a
game-changer; very limited research has been undertaken to measure the
actual impact of ICTs on corruption at the macro-level. Andersen, in a
study of the impact of e-government measures on the World Bank “Control
of corruption” index, found that the implementation of e-government
solutions often resulted in a considerable reduction of the levels of
corruption: by conservative estimates, moving from the 10th percentile
to the 90th percentile in the e-government implementation implies a
reduction in corruption equivalent to moving from the 10th percentile to
the 23rd percentile in the control of corruption measurement.
Similarly, Shim and Eom studied the correlation between the usage of
ICTs (measured by the UN e-Government readiness index, the UN
e-participation index and the level of internet penetration) and the
level of corruption (measured by Transparency International’s CPI). They
conclude that the country’s position on the e-readiness and
e-participation indices is negatively correlated with the levels of
corruption, meaning that a good positioning on the e-readiness and
e-participation indices goes together with lower levels of perceived
corruption. Both studies argue that the use of ICTs should be combined
with administrative reform but that the order of implementation does not
matter.

A 2013 study by Garcia-Murillo analysing the
correlations between the implementation of e-Government innovations
(measured by the UN e-Government Readiness index and the UN
Telecommunications Infrastructure index) and the level of corruption
(measured by the Worldwide Governance Indicators) comes to similar
conclusions, that the governments’ web presence reduces the perception
of corruption in a country.

Challenges and limitations
In
spite of its potential, the use of ICTs for anticorruption is not a
magic bullet. The realisation of its full E-readiness is the ability to
use ICTs to develop a country’s economy and institutions.
E-participation is the use of ICTs for enabling and strengthening
citizen participation in democratic decision-making processes.
Technological innovations to identify and reduce corruption potential,
depends on political, infrastructural, social and economic factors.
Significant challenges in terms of internet access, confidentiality, and
costs related to the implementation of ICT solutions remain to be
addressed

Political environment
The
prerequisite for the success of ICT solutions is an enabling political
environment that promotes and protects free speech. This conflicts with
the experience of many countries, in which governments have made efforts
to control the development and use of ICTs.

Potential for misuse
ICTs
can be used and misused for social mobilisation. A case study of the
2007/2008 Kenyan presidential election crisis illustrates how digital
technologies can serve as catalyst for predatory behaviours such as
ethnicity-based mob violence (Goldstein J. and Rotich, J.). There is
also a risk of ICTs being misused by undemocratic governments for
control. Such discussions have arisen in Uganda in relation to the
debate about the proposed Interception of Communication Bill, which
sought to authorise security agencies to intercept phone, e-mails and
postal communication for national security reasons. Infrastructural
environments: Worldwide, over a billion people have access to the
internet and can use new information and communication technologies for
development and good governance. However, a vast majority of the world’s
population is still without internet access and thus cut off from these
tools and innovations (Spider, 2010). While mobile phone penetration is
progressing at rapid pace, obstacles remain to universal internet
access. In particular, the lack of backbone links limits the
connectivity between different regions of the world. A series of new
marine and terrestrial cables is currently under construction and it is
expected that it will eventually increase capacity and reduce the cost
of internet access worldwide. The first of these, the SEACOM cable,
eastern Africa’s first modern submarine cable, was completed in 2009
(The Economist, 2009). The lack of reliable access to electricity in
some developing countries can also be an obstacle, making it difficult
and costly for people to charge their phones and other devices,
especially in rural areas. Tech support systems are also usually weak
and hard to reach in developing countries.

Security and confidentiality
There are significant security challenges associated with the use of mobile phones for reporting corruption. If the system is poorly designed or vulnerable, the whistle-blower risks being identified or the message intercepted. In China, for example, the government has allegedly established a SMS monitoring programme to monitor and censor text messages, by setting up SMS surveillance centres around the country (USAID, 2008). According to USAID, plain text messages should not be considered secure, particularly when it is possible that the receiver or sender has been placed under surveillance. Many governments are also putting pressure on operators to register SIM cards to be able to connect a person to the SIM; some countries already require identification for purchasing a SIM card, which may facilitate the identification of the user. The challenge is therefore to secure confidentiality when sensitive information is being communicated.

Operational issues

Operational issues can also be obstacles to the effective use of ICTs. They include usability and the limitations of mobile phones (small screens, short messages, and complicated commands), regulations and legal aspects of mobile applications, costs, payment, revenue sharing, etc. Some services are tied to a specific operator, creating challenges of interoperability between operators and roaming between countries (Hellström, J., 2009).

2.    Examples of technological innovations to identify and reduce corruption

There are multiple ways in which ICTs can contribute to identify and reduce corruption and bribery:
Technologyinnovations can be used by governments to improve the efficiency and transparency of public administration and to better communicate with and provide information to citizens;

  •     It can also be used by citizens and civil society to raise awareness about the issue of corruption, to report abuses, to collect data and to monitor government activities:

  •   The use of ICTs to fight corruption has increasingly served as an avenue to bring the tech community closer to activists and civil society, through the phenomenon of “hackathons”.

   The latest

International Anti-Corruption Conference hosted a hackathon focused on finding innovative ways to fight corruption using new technologies. More concretely, a broad range of initiatives have been successfully implemented in the last decade throughout the world as reflected by the examples below.

  ICTs for reporting

Technology provides effective new channels to report administrative abuses and corruption, and facilitate the lodging of complaints. Reporting can be done via websites, hotlines or phone applications that solicit and aggregate citizens’ experience of corruption.

Reporting bribery and petty corruption

Perhaps the most renowned corruption reporting website is Janaagraha Centre for Citizenship’s ipaidabribe.com. Through this website, citizens can report on the nature, number, pattern, types, location, frequency and values of actual corrupt acts that they experienced. Ipaidabribe.com received almost 22,500 reports between 2010 and 2012, some of which were picked up by the media and resulted in arrests and convictions (IACC, 2012). On the same website, citizens can also report on positive experiences they had with honest officers. The initiative started in India but has now been duplicated in Greece, Kenya, Zimbabwe, and Pakistan. New versions of ipaidabribe. com will soon be launched in Azerbaijan, South Africa, Ukraine and Tunisia. Transparency International has opened over 50 Advocacy and Legal Advice Centres (ALACs) since 2000 to receive citizens’ complaints about corruption and engage in strategic advocacy on people’s behalf. TI Macedonia has launched an online reporting platform called Draw a Red Line which allows individuals that have experienced or witnessed corruption to report their cases via ONE (Mobile Operator) by sending SMS from their mobile phones, sending an email, using a web form, on twitter by using the hashtag #korupcijaMK or by reporting over the phone. The reports are then verified by TI Macedonia staff and forwarded to the appropriate public institution to solicit follow-up. In 2012, Draw a Red Line received about 200 reports, 60 of which were verified. A number of global reporting platforms have also been developed in recent years. BRIBEline is a reporting website available in 21 languages that was initiated by TRACE. BRIBEline collects information, through anonymous complaints, about bribes solicited by certain official or quasi-official bodies – governments, international organizations, security forces, state-owned enterprises, etc. – throughout the world. The information gathered is used to take legal or investigative action and the aggregated data is made available to the public to raise awareness about specific corruption challenges.


Mapping bribery and petty corruption

Bribe Market is a similar initiative developed in Romania that allows citizens to share their experiences of bribery when interacting with public services and the amount of money they had to pay. This initiative was developed in 2012 thanks to the support of the Restart Challenges competition financed by TechSoup Global, the Central and Eastern European Trust for Civil Society, US embassies and Microsoft. Within its first four months of existence Bribe Market received nearly 650 reports of corruption. Reports are mapped to help people identify which service providers are the “cheapest” and the least corrupt (IACC, 2012).

Reporting electoral fraud

Mobile phone reports have also been adapted for citizens election monitoring. In the Philippines for example, during the 2010 presidential elections, the VoteReportPH project encouraged voters to report electoral fraud and irregularities via SMS, email, Twitter and the website, using a collaborative Ushahidi-based platform2. The project has gained much online popularity, attracting around 2,500 unique hits per month (Grönlund, A. et al, 2010). In Uganda, Ugandawatch 2011 is an independent hotline that allows citizens to report problems, fraud and irregularities during the electoral process. The organisations involved then analyse the information and publish reports covering issues such as voter registration issues, money in politics, as well as violence and intimidations (Hellström, J., 2010).


ICTs for monitoring

ICTs are increasingly used to monitor budgets, projects and government activities, as well as to request official information.

Access to information

Alaveteli is a free social email software that is used by citizens to request information from their government. Alaveteli facilitates the correspondence with the relevant authorities and keeps track of all requests and their responses. Alaveteli was funded by the Open Society Institute and the Hivos Foundation and has supported the launch of many FOI websites, such as the EU’s Ask The Eu, Brazil’s Queremos Saber and Kosovo’s Informata Zyrtare.

Budget monitoring

Openspending.org is an Open Knowledge Foundation initiative promoting open knowledge and data, particularly regarding government budgets through a mapping of money flows. The aim of Openspending.org is to help track every government and corporate financial transaction across the world and present it in user-friendly and engaging forms. The project is participative and has been taken up in several countries: Transparency International Slovakia launched Slovakia Openspending in early 2013, presenting budget and expenditure information from more than 20 cities across Slovakia; the World Bank launched Cameroon Budget Inquirer, in collaboration with Opensepending.org, to visualise the national investment budget, to provide a sub-national budget transparency index and to allow people to easily explore the country’s financial data.

Monitoring of political life

ICTs can also serve to monitor a country’s political life, from political party financing to Parliament activities. Argentina’s PoderCiudadano launched the website Dinero y Politica to present data on political party finances. This website has become a point of reference for information regarding political and campaign financing and offers data from national elections dating back to 2007. In France, a group of citizens formed Regards Citoyens to provide official information about the country’s political life (votes and debates at the National Assembly and at the Senate, database of lobbying activities etc.) in a simplified manner. The Czech and Slovak website KohoVolit keeps records of the proposals and positions of electoral candidates before elections and monitors whether candidates and parties’ actions while in power match their campaign programmes and pledges.

Monitoring of social services

In recent years, many social accountability projects have started using ICTs to monitor the delivery of different social services. Transparency International Germany recently launched an online platform to monitor the connections between the business community and German Universities. Hochschulwatch maps the money received by German higher education institution through corporate agreements. A good example of the use of new technologies is the Philippines’ Check My School project. Check My School is a participatory monitoring tool combining ICTs and community monitoring to look into use of public funds by schools. The objective of the project is to help the Department of Education identify resource gaps. ICTs have also been utilised in the health sector. TI Uganda has recently launched a project on “Promoting social accountability in the health sector in northern Uganda”. This project empowers health users to monitor local health centres through the use of the radio, call centre operations, mobile phones and web applications.

Monitoring of the judiciary

ICTs can also help monitor the work of the judiciary. Guatemala is a country where impunity is a serious problem, partly due to the politicisation of the appointment of judges. Guatemala Visible is an online platform, set up and maintained by civil society organisations, that monitors the selection of the Auditor General, the General Prosecutor, the Public Defender, the Ombudsman and other key judiciary officials. Guatemala Visible has so far succeeded in publicising information about candidates to senior judicial positions, compelling the nomination committees to conduct rigorous background checks and scrutinize unqualified candidates (TAI, 2010).

Monitoring of illegal logging

The use of satellite images/cameras to monitor illegal logging is currently being explored within the context of the initiative for Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD). There are major corruptions risks associated with carbon emissions reduction schemes such as REDD. First, REDD takes place in a corruption-prone sector, where corruption is widespread in the form of state looting, elite capture, theft and fraud. In addition, there are specific governance challenges associated with emerging forest development practices and carbon trading schemes, such as inappropriate validation and verification, misappropriation of carbon rights, double counting and fraudulent trade of carbon credits. Satellite Imaging Technology (Remote Sensing) can be used as a tool for monitoring, assessing, reporting and verifying carbon credit and co-benefits. Such technologies are currently widely tested and suggested as a tool for REDD monitoring, assessment and verification (UN-REDD Programme, 2008).

ICTs for data collection

In parallel to online reporting, ICTs can be used to collect and aggregate data to make certain arguments more compelling. Hungary’s K-Monitor has built a database of media reports concerning corruption, searchable by location, political party, sector etc. This initiative had collected, categorised and published over 20,000 reports in 2012. Similarly, although not directly related to corruption, Cambodia’s Human Rights Portal, sithi.org, maps reported cases of journalist assassinations, media harassments, land conflicts and other similar human rights violations. This website aims to provide information on the human rights situations in Cambodia to raise public awareness and improve the understanding of human rights in this specific context.

ICTs for campaigning, social mobilisation and citizen-to government interaction

Citizen mobilisation

ICTs can also be used for citizen mobilisation and awareness raising campaigns. Mobile applications can be designed to reach the majority of mobile subscribers through outreach/publicity campaigns using SMS. Organisation running such initiatives need to build a substantial data base of targeted subscribers with active phone numbers, which can prove challenging. (An example of similar approaches is the campaign run by #InternetNecesario in Mexico, which used a combination of twitter, blogs posts and media outreach to put pressure on Mexican legislators to eliminate a 3% tax on internet access which was passed without civil society consultation (Technology for transparency Network, 2010). ICTs can also be used to mobilise people and raise awareness through art. In Tanzania, Chanjo, a collaborative project between musicians, aims to combat corruption through art, mobile phones and social media. The Chanjo project is structured around concerts and tours throughout the country followed by public discussions and debates about corruption. The music tour organised by the artists through Tanzania is coupled with the free distribution, through mobile phones and internet, of songs about corruption issues. The use of internet and social media allowed the project to reach almost 11,000 people between October and December 2011 (Spider, 2011).

Government-citizen interactions

ICTs can also be used to promote more direct interactions between governments and citizens and empower citizens to influence local governance in their constituency through the use of SMS and the Web. In Kenya, for example, several initiatives enable mobile phone users to pose questions to their local parliamentarians, in order to increase bottom-up communication and citizen-to-government interaction. BungeSMS, a commercial vendor from South Africa, has designed a platform for holding Kenyan Members of Parliament accountable. Citizens can send an SMS to a MP through a designated number which is then routed to the BungeSMS website

E-government initiatives

ICTs are increasingly used by governments all over the world to deliver government information and services to citizens, to enhance the efficiency and transparency of public administration and to better interact with citizens. E-government plays an increasingly important role in the promotion of participatory and inclusive development and democracy, and has grown in parallel to the rising demand for government transparency and accountability (UNPAN, 2012). Numerous e-government initiatives have been successfully implemented in the last decade and those provided below are just a few examples.

E-procurement

E-procurement was one of the first applications of ICTs in government activities. E-procurement is the replacement of paper-based procedures with ICTs throughout the procurement processes. E-procurement can reduce administrative costs, speed up the process, increase transparency, facilitate monitoring, encourage cross-border competition and support the development of a centralised procurement administration. South Korea adopted its Government e-Procurement System (GePS) in 2002, providing integrated bidding information as a one-stop shop for customers and enabling the electronic processing of the entire procurement process. The bidding system and procurement information are available through mobile phones. According to the OECD, South Korea’s e-procurement system has significantly reduced the risks of corruption, through the enhanced transparency made possible by the digitalisation of information, and increased competition (OECD, 2005).

E-taxation

Governments also use ICTs for tax collection and payment, with the objective of making the system more transparent and efficient, and to cut out potential corrupt tax collectors. E-taxation has been implemented in 77 countries throughout the world, which is equivalent to 40% of the United Nations’ member states. An increasing number of developing countries, such as Tunisia, Sao Tome e Principe and Cape Verde, have opted for electronic tax collection to accelerate the tax processing time and ease the process of paying taxes, (UNPAN, 2012).

E-judiciary

ICTs offer considerable potential to improve the way the judiciary operates both nationally (filing, archiving, protection of evidence, reporting, traceability) and internationally (international judicial cooperation, training). E-judiciary has helped make workflows more efficient and court proceedings more transparent (Zinnbauer, 2012). In addition, it informs citizens of their rights and can contribute to simplifying procedures (Velicogna, 2007). India, for example, has implemented a number of ICT-based initiatives in its judiciary, like the e-justice process, to provide better access to justice for Indian citizens. Turkey has launched an SMS judicial information system, offering a legal notification service for citizens and lawyers about any development concerning their cases (UNPAN, 2012).
Electronic identification

New technologies have been used to modernise the process of citizen identification and distribution of social services and benefits. The digitalisation of the procedure to obtain an identity card, E-ID cards and biometric proof of identity captured in electronic authentication mechanisms can have the potential to make the system more accessible, transparent and accountable. Such initiatives can reduce corruption risks in the distribution of social benefits and services, as well as in international aid (Zinnbauer, 2012).

Financial transactions

In 2009, the Afghan National Police began to test paying salaries through mobiles instead of cash, using a text and interactive voice response system. Most policemen assumed that they had been given a significant raise in salaries, while there were simply receiving their full pay for the first time. The new system revealed that in the past at least 10% of payments had been going to ghost policemen and that middlemen in the police hierarchy commonly pocketed a percentage of other policemen’s salaries (Rice, D and Filippelli, G.,2010).The Better Than Cash Alliance, uniting governments, private sector companies as well as the development community, is advocating for organisations to carry out their distribution of benefits, salaries and other payments in electronic form. The Alliance provides research as well as policy and technical assistance on transition to electronic payments.

Part A – Direct taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
1.    Direct Tax Press Release dated 29th August 2016 -The Protocol amending DTAA between India and Mauritius was signed by both countries on 10th May, 2016. The Protocol was entered into force in India on 19th July, 2016 and has been notified in the Official Gazette on 11th August, 2016.

2.    Search and Survey operations and Income Declaration Scheme – Circular No. 32 dated 1st September 2016

Wherever in the course of search under section 132 or survey operation under section 133A of the Act, any document is found as a proof for having already filed a declaration under the Income Declaration Scheme, including acknowledgement issued by the Income-tax Department for having filed a declaration, no enquiry would be made by the Income-tax Department in respect of sources of undisclosed income or investment in movable or immovable property declared in a valid declaration made in accordance with the provisions of the Scheme.

3.    Press Release dated 5th September 2016 – Income Declaration Scheme 2016

– Government issues Clarifications in the form of Sixth Set of Frequently Asked Questions

4.    RBI Circular DBR.No. Leg.BC. 13-09.07.005-2016-17 dated 8 September 2016

– RBI has instructed the banks to accept cash deposits from all the declarants under the Income declaration Scheme irrespective of amount, over the counters, for making payment under the Scheme through challan ITNS-286.

5.    Order F.No.225-195-2016-ITA-II dated 9th September 2016

– Due-date provided under section 139(1) for furnishing return of Income and obtaining Tax Audit Report extended from 30th September, 2016 to 17th October, 2016.

6.    Further Clarifications on the Direct Tax Dispute Resolution Scheme, 2016

– Circular No. 33 dated 12th September 2016 and Instruction no 8 dated 15 September 2016

7.    Circular No. 34 dated 21st September 2016 – where a declaration is made under the Income Declaration Scheme for years, which are not under assessment on an identical issue which is pending in assessment under section 143(3)/147 of the Act , no penalty or prosecution be initiated against such person if he offers to pay the tax and interest, on such issue for the year pending in assessment under section 143(3)/147

8.    Procedure for generation of scrutiny notices under Section 143(2) for limited and full scrutiny under CASS

– Instruction No. 3 dated 16.09.2016

9.    Revised guidelines for engagement of standing counsels and schedule of fees payable  to them
 
– Instruction no. 6 and 7 dated 7 September 2016

10.    Procedure for issue of NOC , voyage return and voyage assessment in case of foreign shipping companies

– Circular No. 30/2016 dated 26th August 2016

Glimpses of Supreme Court Rulings

1.   
Business Income – Set of
accumulated losses of amalgamating company by the amalgamated under section 72A
to be allowed after adjusting the remission of cessation of interest liability
of amalgamating company which are chargeable to tax under section 41(1)

 McDowell and Company Ltd. vs. CIT (2017)
393 ITR 570 (SC)

There was a
company known as M/s. Hindustan Polymers Limited (HPL) which had become a sick
industrial company. Proceedings in respect of the said company were pending
before the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) under Sick
Industrial Companies Act (SICA). At that stage, petitions under sections 391
and 392 of the Companies Act, 1956, were filed in the High Court of Bombay and
Madras for amalgamation of HPL with the Assessee-Appellant, i.e., M/s. McDowell
and Company Limited. Both the High Courts approved the scheme of amalgamation
as a result of which, w.e.f. 01.04.1977, HPL stood amalgamated with the
Assessee/Appellant-company.

HPL owed a lot
of money to banks and financial institutions. In its books of accounts, the
interest which had accrued on the loans given by such financial companies was
shown as the money payable on account of interest to the said banking companies
and was reflected as expenditure on that count. As the interest payable was
treated as expenditure, benefit thereof was taken in the assessment orders
made. The Assessee had approached the Central Government, before moving the
High Court, with the scheme of amalgamation for getting benefits of section 72A
of the Act. This section makes provisions relating to carry forward and set off
accumulated loss and unabsorbed depreciation allowance in certain cases of
amalgamation or demerger etc. Under certain circumstances and on
fulfillment of conditions laid down therein, the company which takes over the
sick company is allowed to set off losses of the amalgamating company as its
own losses. The Central Government had made a declaration to this effect u/s.
72A of the Act granting the benefit of the said provision to the Assessee.

Under the
scheme of amalgamation that was approved by the High Court, after following the
procedure in terms of sections 391 and 392 of the Companies Act, which included
the consent of the secured creditors as well, the banks which had advanced
loans to HPL agreed to waive off the interest which had accrued prior to
01.04.1977. This interest was claimed as expenditure by HPL in its returns. On
the waiver of this interest, it became income in terms of section 41(1) of the
Act. In the return filed by the Assessee for the Assessment Year 1983-1984, the
Assessee claimed set off of the accumulated losses which it had taken over from
HPL by virtue of the provisions contained in section 72A of the Act. This was
allowed. However, later on, it came to the notice of the Assessing Officer that
while allowing the aforesaid benefit to the Assessee, the income which had
accrued u/s. 41 of the Act had not been set off against the accumulated loses.
It so happened that on certain grounds, the assessment was reopened by the
Assessing Officer and while undertaking the exercise of reassessment, the
Assessing Officer also noticed that the aforesaid fact, viz., the income which
had accrued within section 41(1) of the Act as mentioned above, was not set off
while giving benefit of accumulated losses u/s. 72A of the Act to the Assessee.
The Assessing Officer, therefore, treated the aforesaid income at the hands of
the Assessee and adjusted the same from the accumulated losses. The assessment
order was drawn accordingly. This reassessment was challenged by the Assessee
by filing appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), which was
dismissed. However, in further appeal before the ITAT, the Assessee succeeded
inasmuch as the ITAT held that the aforesaid income u/s. 41(1) of the Act was
not at the hands of the Assessee herein but it may be treated as income of the
HPL and since HPL was a different Assessee and a different entity, the Assessee
herein was not liable to pay any taxes on the said income. Feeling aggrieved
thereby, the Revenue sought reference u/s. 256 of the Act and ultimately, the
reference was made on the following questions of law:

“Whether on the
facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in law
in upholding that the over due interest waived by the financial institutions
amounting to Rs. 25.02 lakhs is not assessable in the hands of the Assessee?”

This question
of law was decided in favour of Revenue by the impugned judgment.

The Supreme
Court held that the Assessee was given the benefit of accumulated losses of the
amalgamating company. The effect thereof was that though these losses were
suffered by the amalgamating company they were deemed to be treated as losses
of the Assessee company by virtue of section 72A of the Act. In a case like
this, it cannot be said that the Assessee would be entitled to take advantage
of the accumulated losses but while calculating these accumulated losses at the
hands of amalgamated company, i.e., HPL, the income accrued u/s. 41(1) of the
Act at the hands of HPL would not be accounted for. That had to be necessarily
adjusted in order to see what are the actual accumulated losses, the benefit
whereof is to be extended to the Assessee.

According to
the Supreme Court, this appeal was without any merit and was, accordingly,
dismissed.

Note:
Interestingly, the above case arose as a result of amalgamation which was
effective from 1/4/1977, but the issue came-up in relation to Asst. Year.
1983-84. In the above case, the Apex Court distinguished its earlier judgement
in the case of Saraswati Industrial Syndicate Ltd. [186 ITR 278] on the ground
that in the instant case the assessee had the benefit of carry forward losses
of the sick company [amalgamating company] u/s. 72A and the assessee company
[amalgamated company] had, in fact, availed the benefit of the waiver of
interest [which accrued to the assessee after the sick company had ceased to
exist due to amalgamation] and therefore, the same should be adjusted against
such losses and in that case, the Court dealt with the provisions of section
41(1) per se where section 72A was not the subject matter of the
decision. Therefore, the facts of the two cases are different. The judgment in
the case of Saraswati Industrial Syndicate Ltd. has been analysed in the column
“Closements” in the December, 1990 issue of the BCAJ. It may also be
noted that subsequently, section 41(1) has been substituted by the Finance Act,
1992 [w.e.f. Asst. Year. 1993-94] which effectively nullified the effect of the
ratio of the judgment in the case of Saraswati Industrial Syndicate Ltd.

 2. Exemption – Compensation
received on compulsory acquisition of agricultural land – The acquisition
process is initiated by invoking the provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894
by the State Government is completed with the award and the only thing that
remains thereafter is to pay the compensation as fixed under the award and take
possession of the land in question from the owner and to avoid litigation if
such owner enters into negotiations and settles the final compensation with the
buyer, the character of acquisition would not change from that of compulsory
acquisition to the voluntary sale

 Balakrishnan
vs. UOI and Ors. (2017) 391 ITR 178 (SC)

The Appellant
was the owner of 27.70 acres of land in Sy. No. 18.60 hectares of paddy field
in Block No. 17 of Attippra village in Thiruvananthapuram District comprised in
Sy. No. 293/8. This was agricultural land. The Appellant was using the same to
grow paddy.

The Government
of Kerala sought to acquire the aforesaid property of the Appellant for the
public purpose namely, ‘3rd phase of development of Techno Park’. For this
purpose, Notification u/s. 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘LA Act’) was issued on 01.10.2005. An opportunity was given
to the Appellant to file his objections, if any, u/s. 5A of the LA Act. Record
does not reveal as to whether such objections were filed or not. However
admittedly, thereafter, declaration u/s. 6 of the LA Act was issued on
02.09.2006 wherein the Government had declared that it was decided to acquire
the land for the aforesaid purpose. After this acquisition, the Land
Acquisition Collector (Special Tahsildar), after following the due procedure,
even passed the award on 15.02.2007. As per this award, compensation was fixed
at Rs. 14,36,616/-. The amount of compensation fixed by the Land Acquisition
Collector was not acceptable to the Appellant. At that stage, some negotiations
started between the parties on the amount of compensation and ultimately it was
agreed by the Techno Park, for whom the property in question was acquired, to
pay a sum of Rs. 38,42,489/-. After this amount was agreed upon between the
parties, the Appellant agreed to execute a sale deed of the property in
question in favour of Techno Park. Such sale deed was executed on 08.05.2008
and duly registered with the Sub-Registrar, Kazhakoottam. While disbursing the
aforesaid amount of sale consideration, the Techno Park deducted 10% of the
amount of TDS and it was later refunded to the Appellant herein by the Income
Tax Department on completion of the assessment for the assessment year 2009-10,
taking a view that no capital gain was payable on the aforesaid amount received
by the Appellant as the same was exempted u/s. 10(37) of the Income-tax Act,
1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘ the Act’).

However,
thereafter on 30.05.2012, a notice was issued to the Appellant u/s. 148 of the
Act whereby the Income Tax Department decided to re-open the assessment on the
ground that income which was assessable to income tax escaped assessment during
the year 2009-10. The stand which was taken by the Revenue in this notice was
that the amount of compensation/consideration received by the Appellant against
the aforesaid land was not the result of compulsory acquisition and on the
contrary it was the voluntary sale made by the Appellant to the Techno Park
and, therefore, the provisions of section 10(37) of Act were not applicable.

The Appellant
objected to the re-opening of the said assessment by filing his reply dated
30.11.2012. However, the Joint Commissioner, Income Tax Range-I, Kawadiar,
Thiruvananthapuram, took the view that the case did not come under compulsory
acquisition and directed the Assessing Officer to compute the income
accordingly. This direction dated 11.03.2013 of the Joint Commissioner was
challenged by the Appellant by filing a Civil Writ Petition in the High Court
of Kerala. The learned Single Judge, however, dismissed the said writ petition
vide judgement dated 11.07.2013 relying upon the earlier judgement of the same
High Court in case of Info Park Kerala vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income
Tax
(2008) 4 KLT 782. The writ appeal preferred by the Appellant met
the same fate as it was dismissed affirming the view of the learned
Single Judge.

It is in the
aforesaid backdrop, the following question arose before the Supreme Court for
its consideration.

“Whether, on
the facts and circumstances of the case, the High Court was justified in
denying the claim for exemption u/s. 10(37) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 to the
Appellant?”

The Supreme
Court observed that on the transfer of agricultural land by way of compulsory
acquisition under any law, no capital gain tax is payable. The Supreme Court
noted that the initial view of the Income Tax Department, while refunding the
aforesaid TDS amount to the Appellant, was that the land in question was
compulsorily acquired under the LA Act and, therefore, capital gain tax was not
payable.

According to
the Supreme Court, from the facts mentioned above, it was apparent that the
acquisition process was initiated by invoking the provisions of LA Act by the
State Government. For this purpose, not only Notification u/s. 4 was issued, it
was followed by declaration u/s. 6 and even Award u/s. 9 of the LA Act. With
the award the acquisition under the LA Act was completed. Only thing that
remained thereafter, was to pay the compensation as fixed under the award and
take possession of the land in question from the Appellant. No doubt, in case,
the compensation as fixed by the Land Acquisition Collector was not acceptable
to the Appellant, the LA  Act provides
for making a reference u/s.18 of the Act to the District Judge for determining
the compensation and to decide as to whether the compensation fixed by the Land
Acquisition Collector was proper or not. However, the matter thereafter is only
for quantum of compensation which has nothing to do with the acquisition. The
Supreme Court held that it was clear from the above that insofar as acquisition
was concerned, the Appellant had succumbed to the action taken by the
Government in this behalf. His only objection was to the market value of the
land that was fixed as above. To reiterate his grievance, the Appellant could
have either taken the aforesaid adjudicatory route of seeking reference under
section18 of the LA Act leaving it to the Court to determine the market value.
Instead, the Appellant negotiated with Techno Park and arrived at amicable
settlement by agreeing to receive the compensation in the sum of Rs.
38,42,489/-. For this purpose, after entering into the agreement, the Appellant
agreed to execute the sale deed as well which was a necessary consequence and a
step which the Appellant had to take.

The Supreme
Court reiterated that insofar as acquisition of the land was concerned, the
same was compulsorily acquired as the entire procedure prescribed under the LA
Act was followed. The settlement took place only qua the amount of the
compensation which was to be received by the Appellant for the land which had
been acquired. According to the Supreme Court, had steps not been taken by the
Government under sections 4 and 6 followed by award u/s. 9 of the LA  Act, the Appellant would not have agreed to
divest the land belonging to him to Techno Park. He was compelled to do so
because of the compulsory acquisition and to avoid litigation entered into
negotiations and settled the final compensation. Merely because the
compensation amount is agreed upon would not change the character of acquisition
from that of compulsory acquisition to the voluntary sale. It may be mentioned
that this is now the procedure which is laid down even under the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 as per which the Collector can pass rehabilitation and
resettlement award with the consent of the parties/land owners. Nonetheless,
the character of acquisition remains compulsory.

The Supreme
Court doubted the correctness of the judgment in the case of Info Park
Kerala vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax
(2008) 4 KLT 782.
The Court in the said case took the view that since the title in the property
was passed by the land owners on the strength of sale deeds executed by them,
it was not a compulsory acquisition. The Supreme Court did not subscribe with
the aforesaid view. According to the Supreme Court, it was clear that but for
Notification u/s. 4 and Award u/s. 9 of the LA Act, the Appellant would not
have entered into any negotiations for the compensation of the consideration
which he was to receive for the said land. As far as the acquisition of the
land in question was concerned, there was no consent. The Appellant was put in
such a condition that he knew that his land had been acquired and he could not
have done much against the same. The Appellant, therefore, only wanted to
salvage the situation by receiving as much compensation as possible
commensurate with the market value thereof and in the process avoid the
litigation so that the Appellant is able to receive the compensation well in
time. If for this purpose the Appellant entered into the negotiations, such
negotiations would be confined to the quantum of compensation only and cannot
change or alter the nature of acquisition which would remain compulsory. The
Supreme Court, therefore, overruled the judgment of the Kerala High Court in Info
Park Kerala vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax
(2008) 4 KLT 782.

The Supreme
Court allowed the appeal of the Appellant and quashed the proceedings u/s.148
of the Act.

Note: The above
judgment is very useful in the context of current scenario of emphasis on
infrastructure development by the government and consequent need for land
acquisition with the resultant issue of taxation of capital gain arising on
compulsory acquisition of urban agricultural land, which may arise very often.
In such cases where the assessee receives higher compensation on negotiations
with the concerned party in the process of such acquisition, the benefit of
exemption u/s. 10(37) will be crucial and this judgement will become beneficial
in that context and may also help in reducing the litigation on contesting the
acquisition proceeding under the LA  Act.
Furthermore, in this case, the issue arising out of re-assessment proceedings
initiated in the year 2012 got finally resolved in 2017 [i.e. in a short period
of 5 years] at the level of the Apex Court. This shows clear advantage of
adopting the route of filing Writ Petition challenging such re-assessment
proceedings, especially involving a clear point of law. In normal course, the
matter generally would not have got resolved at that level in a period of less
than two decades.

 3.
Exemption/Deduction – Though
Section 10A, as amended, is a provision for deduction, the stage of deduction
would be while computing the gross total income of the eligible undertaking
under Chapter IV of the Act and not at the stage of computation of the total
income under Chapter VI

 C.I.T. and Ors. vs. Yokogawa India
Ltd. (2017) 391 ITR 274 (SC)

The Supreme
Court formulated the following specific questions arising in the group of cases
before it for consideration.

(i)   Whether
section 10A of the Act is beyond the purview of the computation mechanism of
total income as defined under the Act. Consequently, is the income of a section
10A unit required to be excluded before arriving at the gross total income of
the Assessee?

 (ii)  Whether
the phrase “total income” in section 10A of the Act is akin and pari
materia
with the said expression as appearing in section 2(45) of the Act?

 (iii)  Whether
even after the amendment made with effect from 1.04.2001, section 10A of the
Act continues to remain an exemption section and not a deduction section?

 (iv) Whether
losses of other 10A Units or non 10A Units can be set off against the profits
of 10A Units before deductions u/s.10A are effected?

 (v)  Whether
brought forward business losses and unabsorbed depreciation of 10A Units or non
10A Units can be set off against the profits of another 10A Units of the
Assessee.

The Supreme
Court clarified that the decision of this Court with regard to the provisions
of section 10A of the Act would equally be applicable to cases governed by the
provisions of section 10B in view of the said later provision being pari
materia with section 10A of the Act though governing a different situation.

The Supreme
Court considered the submissions advanced and the provisions of section 10A as
it stood prior to the amendment made by the Finance Act, 2000 with effect from
1.4.2001; the amended section 10A thereafter and also the amendment made by the
Finance Act, 2003 with retrospective effect from 1.4.2001.

The Supreme
Court observed that retention of section 10A in Chapter III of the Act after
the amendment made by the Finance Act, 2000 would be merely suggestive and not
determinative of what is provided by the section as amended, in contrast to
what was provided by the un-amended Section. The true and correct purport and
effect of the amended section would have to be construed from the language used
and not merely from the fact that it had been retained in Chapter III.
According to the Supreme Court, the introduction of the word ‘deduction’ in
section 10A by the amendment, in the absence of any contrary material, and in
view of the scope of the deductions contemplated by section 10A, it had to be
understood that the section embodied a clear enunciation of the legislative
decision to alter its nature from one providing for exemption to one providing
for deductions.

The Supreme
Court held that the difference between the two expressions ‘exemption’ and
‘deduction’, though broadly may appear to be the same i.e. immunity from
taxation, the practical effect of it in the light of the specific provisions
contained in different parts of the Act would be wholly different. The above
implications could not be more obvious than from the cases which had been filed
by assessee having loss making eligible units and/or non-eligible units seeking
the benefit of this section.

The Supreme
Court noted that sub-section 4 of section 10A which provides for pro-rata
exemption, necessarily involving deduction of the profits arising out of
domestic sales, was one instance of deduction provided by the amendment.
Profits of an eligible unit pertaining to domestic sales would have to enter
into the computation under the head “profits and gains from business”
in Chapter IV and denied the benefit of deduction. The provisions of
sub-section 6 of section 10A, as amended by the Finance Act of 2003, granting
the benefit of adjustment of losses and unabsorbed depreciation etc.
commencing from the year 2001-02 on completion of the period of tax holiday
also virtually worked as a deduction which had to be worked out at a future
point of time, namely, after the expiry of period of tax holiday. The absence
of any reference to deduction u/s.10A in Chapter VI of the Act could be
understood by acknowledging that any such reference or mention would have been
a repetition of what has already been provided in section 10A. The provisions
of sections 80HHC and 80HHE of the Act providing for somewhat similar
deductions would be wholly irrelevant and redundant if deductions u/s. 10A were
to be made at the stage of operation of Chapter VI of the Act. The retention of
the said provisions of the Act i.e. section 80HHC and 80HHE, despite the
amendment of section 10A, indicated that some additional benefits to eligible
section 10A units, not contemplated by sections 80HHC and 80HHE, was intended
by the legislature. Such a benefit could only be understood by a legislative
mandate to understand that the stages for working out the deductions u/s. 10A
and 80HHC and 80HHE are substantially different.

The Supreme
Court held that from a reading of the relevant provisions of section 10A it was
more than clear that the deductions contemplated therein were qua the
eligible undertaking of an Assessee standing on its own and without reference
to the other eligible or non-eligible units or undertakings of the Assessee.
The benefit of deduction is given by the Act to the individual undertaking and
resultantly flows to the Assessee. This was also clear from the contemporaneous
Circular No. 794 dated 09.08.2000 which stated in paragraph 15.6 that,

“The export
turnover and the total turnover for the purposes of sections 10A and 10B shall
be of the undertaking located in specified zones or 100% Export Oriented
Undertakings, as the case may be, and this shall not have any material
relationship with the other business of the Assessee outside these zones or
units for the purposes of this provision.”

If the specific
provisions of the Act provide [first proviso to Sections 10A(1); 10A (1A) and
10A (4)] that the unit that is contemplated for grant of benefit of deduction
is the eligible undertaking and that is also how the contemporaneous Circular
of the department (No. 794 dated 09.08.2000) understood the situation, it was
only logical and natural that the stage of deduction of the profits and gains
of the business of an eligible undertaking has to be made independently and,
therefore, immediately after the stage of determination of its profits and
gains. At that stage the aggregate of the incomes under other heads and the
provisions for set off and carry forward contained in sections 70, 72 and 74 of
the Act would be premature for application. The deductions u/s. 10A therefore
would be prior to the commencement of the exercise to be undertaken under
Chapter VI of the Act for arriving at the total income of the Assessee from the
gross total income. The somewhat discordant use of the expression “total
income of the Assessee” in Section 10A could be reconciled by
understanding the expression “total income of the Assessee” in section
10A as ‘total income of the undertaking’.

The Supreme
Court answered the appeals and the questions arising therein, as formulated
above, by holding that though section 10A, as amended, is a provision for
deduction, the stage of deduction would be while computing the gross total
income of the eligible undertaking under Chapter IV of the Act and not at the
stage of computation of the total income under Chapter VI. All the appeals were
disposed of accordingly.

 4.  Assessment – Prima facie
adjustment – Capital or revenue – Even though it is may be a debatable issue
but where the jurisdictional High Court has taken a particular view,
authorities under its jurisdiction are bound by it and it could not be said that the issue was a debatable one in that State

 DCIT vs.
Raghuvir Synthetics Ltd. (2017) 394 ITR 1 (SC)

The
Respondent-Assessee, a public limited company, filed its return for the
assessment year 1994-95, wherein it had claimed revenue expenditure of Rs.
65,47,448 on advertisement and public issue. However, in the return of income,
the company made a claim that if the aforesaid claim could not be considered as
a revenue expenditure then alternatively the said expenditure may be allowed
u/s. 35D of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the
Act”) by way of capitalising in the plant and machinery obtained.

The Assessing
Officer issued an intimation u/s. 143(1)(a) of the Act disallowing a sum of Rs.
58,92,700 out of the preliminary expenditure incurred on public issue. He,
however, allowed one-tenth of the total expenses and raised demand on the
balance amount.

The intimation
was challenged before the first appellate authority which allowed the appeal by
holding that the concept of “prima facie adjustment” u/s.
143(1)(a) of the Act could not be invoked as there could be more than one
opinion on whether public issue expenses were covered by section 35D or section
37 of the Act.

Feeling
aggrieved by the order passed by the first appellate authority, the Revenue
preferred an appeal before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal
upheld the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) and dismissed the
appeal filed by the Revenue.

The Appellant
preferred an appeal u/s. 260A of the Act before the High Court of Gujarat at
Ahmedabad. The Division Bench of the High Court by the impugned order dismissed
the appeal on the ground that a debatable issue cannot be disallowed while
processing return of income u/s. 143(1)(a) of the Act.

The Supreme
Court noted that there was a divergence of opinion between the various High
Courts; one view being that the preliminary expenses incurred on raising a
share capital is revenue expenditure and a contrary view that the said expenses
are capital expenditure and cannot be allowed as revenue expenditure.

The Supreme
Court held that even though it was a debatable issue but as the Gujarat High
Court in the case of Ahmedabad Mfg. and Calico (P.) Ltd. (1986) 162 ITR 800
(Guj) had taken a view that it is capital expenditure which was subsequently
followed by Alembic Glass Industries Ltd. vs. CIT (1993) 202 ITR 214 (Guj)
and the registered office of the Respondent-Assessee being in the State of
Gujarat, the law laid down by the Gujarat High Court was binding. Therefore, so
far as the present case was concerned, it could not be said that the issue was
a debatable one.

According to the Supreme
Court, the order passed by the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), the
Income-tax Appellate Tribunal and also the order of the Gujarat High Court were
not sustainable and were therefore set aside as they had wrongly held that the
issue was debatable and could not be considered in the proceedings u/s. 143(1)
of the Act. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal of the Revenue.

From the President

Dear Members,

We witnessed an
innovative Navratri celebration in Mumbai this year. Enthusiastic dandiya
raas
dancers decked in all their colourful attire were swaying to music
till the early hours in the morning. What’s unique is that they are all wearing
cordless headphones – so now they can celebrate without disturbing anyone! An
ingenious mind and a little technology have saved the day…or rather the
night. This is silent garba beating the noise deadlines !! I hope other
communities may take cue from this and pursue their celebrations without
creating any nuisance or heartburn for others.

Let me also in advance take this opportunity to extend to all of you and
your families my sincere greetings for a truly Happy Diwali and a Prosperous
New Year. May the triumph of light and truth illuminate our lives and the
future of India. And may our festive celebrations overflow with colourful
rangolis, sweet temptations, surprise gifts and a sky ablaze with sparkling
sound proof fireworks of many hues.

Across the
Pacific, there are fireworks between the US and North Korea sparked off by
North Korea’s missile and H-Bomb testing and UN sanctions. Tensions have
escalated with a petulant North Korea Foreign Minister declaring that the US
President had made “their rockets’ visit to the entire US mainland inevitable”
by calling the North Korean leader a “rocket man”. The war of words accompanied
by threats and a show of military strength from both sides have sent stock
exchanges across the world tumbling. The prospect of an all-out nuclear
confrontation looks remote but nevertheless the markets are still on
tenterhooks.

Indian markets
too have been impacted by the geopolitical pressure, but have also taken a
beating for several other reasons. India’s GDP growth rate has slipped to 5.7%
in the June quarter and demonetisation and the GST seems to have been partly
responsible. Both economic measures were very much needed but possibly their
unplanned and hurried implementation has caused the markets toreact sharply.

The proactive
government has already announced a stimulus package to arrest any further
market descent. But it is in a quandary…should it choose to spend and risk
overshooting its fiscal target which it has so carefully maintained. Or should
it reduce expenditure and add to the ferment and pessimism in the market. Both
the avenues have the potential to further unnerve both domestic and foreign
investors.

Against the
dismal economic stagnation, the Indian e-commerce market, which is slated to
touch $100 billion by 2020, is clearly the silver lining. Flagging off the
festival season, the giants in the business Flipkart and Amazon held their big
annual sales. Piggybacking on the buzz generated, several smaller e-commerce
companies too joined the sales bandwagon. The response to the sales has been
phenomenal.

Flipkart claims
that it has doubled sales over the previous year and hopes to touch Rs. 6,000
crore. The high point of their Big Billion Sale is that they sold 1.3 million
smartphones in just 20 hours of the sale. Amazon too scored high saying that it
was their biggest shopping event…the largest in terms of units, sales value,
sellers, customers and pin codes they served. What’s notable is that they
garnered 85% of their new customers from tier 2 & 3 cities. Amazon claims
sales were spectacular with 50% of the 32 categories on offer doubling in value
terms over last year.

What’s
significant is that these e-commerce companies attract a lot of funding which
goes into creation of jobs and infrastructure. E-commerce has disrupted
traditional business models and has turned into a money spinner for all and a
money saver for millions of customers. May their tribe increase!

The journey began
a long time ago…on 18 April 1966, the first protest march against triple
talaq was held. And only in 2017, the Supreme Court has finally decreed it as
unlawful. Post the verdict, activists have now swivelled their attention
towards decriminalising homosexuality and marital rape. Today the focus has
widened considerably and the debate now centres on developing and introducing a
Uniform Civil Code.

Is it possible or
practical to reconcile divergent laws and formulate a common code that is
acceptable to all communities? Those in favour believe a common code will
provide a potential platform to unite India. A stronger argument is being made
that a common code will ensure gender justice and discourage gender bias. But
after a thorough comparative study of personal laws of India’s many
communities, the sheer diversity of laws and the zeal with which they are
adhered to defies any possibility of uniformity.

Those against,
argue that there already exists an optional civil code with several acts that
may be used by those who wish to avoid the religion and custom based laws.
There is also a suggestion, which I like, that instead of trying to force a
common code it would be better to take a few key aspects such as marriage,
adoption, succession and maintenance and progressively work them into a common
code.

Before I conclude
this message, I would like to make this earnest request to all of you to join
me in the BCAS membership drive. The Society needs to increase its membership,
specially the youth. This will help us to generate more revenues, besides the
Society will be taken more seriously when it comes to interaction at all levels
of the Government. After all, numbers do matter. If all of us adopt the
initiative of “Each one brings one”, we can target to double our membership,
which will be a big step forward.

I would like to
end by paying tribute to our Past President Shri Pradeepbhai Shah who left us
this month. As a Trustee of the BCAS Foundation, he was actively involved in charity
and had organised many campaigns for the needy. The drive for cancer afflicted
children at Tata Memorial this year was one of his initiatives. A walking
encyclopaedia of jokes and anecdotes, he helped inspire people and transform
difficult situations with his effervescent optimism. We pray that Shri
Pradeepbhai may reap the abundant rewards he sowed and enjoy eternal rest.

Feel free to
write to me on president@bcasonline.org

With kind regards

CA. Narayan Pasari

President

From Published Accounts

fiogf49gjkf0d

Section A:

Disclosures
regarding Consolidated Financial Statements (CFS) prepared (as per AS 23) for
first time to include results of an Associate

Bajaj
Electricals Ltd (31-3-2016)

From
Notes to CFS

Summary of significant
accounting policies followed by the Company

The consolidated financial statements include
results of the associate of Bajaj Electricals Limited (BEL), consolidated in
accordance with Accounting Standard 23 ‘Accounting for Investment in Associates
in Consolidated Financial Statements’. 
This being the first year Consolidated Financial Statements are drawn
up, the previous year comparative numbers have not been presented and
accordingly no consolidated cash flow statement has been prepared.

Name of
the Company

Country
of incorporation

%
shareholding of

Bajaj
Electricals Limited

Consolidated
as

Starlite Lighting Limited

India

19%

Associate

For the purpose of Section 2(6) of the Companies
Act, 2013, “associate company”, in relation to another company, means a company
in which that other company has a significant influence, but which is not a
subsidiary company of the company having such influence and includes a joint
venture company. Explanation – for the purposes of this clause, “significant
influence” means control of at least twenty per cent of total share capital
and/or the ability to significantly influence the operational and financial
policies of the company but not control them. 
The holding of Bajaj Electricals Limited in Starlite Lighting Limited
(Starlite) is less than 20%. The Starlite Lighting Limited is consolidated as
an Associate by virtue of the formers ability to influence the operational and
financial policies whereby the share of the parent in the associate’s net worth
and profit has been picked up and accounted for under an independent line item
in the “General Reserve”, “Investment” and “Statement of Profit and Loss”.  The excess of cost of Investment in the
associate and the share of net worth of the associate on the day of investing
is reflected as “Goodwill”.

In all other aspects these financial statements
have been prepared in accordance with the other generally accepted accounting
principles in India under the historical cost convention on accrual basis,
except for certain tangible assets which are being carried at revalued amounts.
Pursuant to Section 133 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with Rules 7 of
Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, till the standards of accounting or any
addendum thereto are prescribed by Central Government in consultation and
recommendation of the National Financial Reporting Authority, the existing
Accounting Standards notified under the Companies Act, 1956 shall continue to
apply.  Consequently, these financial statements
have been prepared to comply in all material aspects with the accounting
standards notified under Section 211(3C) of the Companies Act, 1956 [Companies
(Accounting Standards) Rules, 2006, as amended] and other relevant provisions
of the Companies Act, 2013.

All assets and liabilities have been classified as
current or non-current as per the “Company’s normal operating cycle and other
criteria set out in the Schedule III to the Companies Act, 2013.  Based on the nature of products and the time
between the acquisition of assets for processing and their realisation in cash
and cash equivalents, the Company has ascertained its operating cycle as 12
months for the purpose of current or non-current classification of assets and
liabilities.

Notes to these consolidated financial statements
are intended to serve as a means of informative disclosure and a guide to
better understanding of the consolidated position of the companies.  Recognising this purpose, the Ministry of
Corporate Affairs vide its General Circular No. 39/2014 dated 14 October 2014
has clarified that only those note which are relevant to understanding the Consolidated
Financial Statements should be disclosed and not merely repeating the Notes
disclosed in the standalone financial statements to which these consolidated
financial statements are attached to.

Accordingly:

1]  The Company has disclosed only such notes from the
individual financial statements, which fairly present the needed disclosures.

2]  The accounting policies of the parent also broadly
represent the accounting policies of the consolidated entity and hence are best
viewed in its independent financial statements, Note 2.  However the accounting of derivative
instruments on the basis of the principles of hedge accounting specified in
AS-30 followed by the Associate is in contrast to accounting for the same by
parent (BEL) as a fair value to Profit and Loss account, which has been
adjusted to be consistent with the accounting policies followed by the Company
(BEL).  Other accounting policies
followed by the associate consolidated herein have been reviewed and no further
adjustments are considered necessary.

3]  
Note Nos.2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14. 16,
17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35 represent
the numbers and required disclosures of the Parent and accordingly are best
viewed in BEL’s independent financial statements.

GENESYS INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION LTD

(31-3-2016)

From
Notes to CFS

Summary of significant
accounting policies followed by the Company

The
consolidated financial statements include results of the associates of Genesys
International Corporation Limited, consolidated in accordance with Accounting
Standard 23 ‘Accounting for Investment in Associates in Consolidated Financial
Statements’, as below:

Name
of the Entity

Country
of Incorporation

%
of voting right held on March 31, 2016

 

Consolidated
as

           

A.N.Virtual
World Tech Limited

Cyprus

45.01%

Associate

Virtual
World Spatial Technology Private Limited

India

–

Wholly
owned subsidiary of Associate

For
the purpose of Section 2(6) of the Companies Act, 2013, “associate company”, in
relation to another company, means a company in which that other company has a
significant influence, but which is not a subsidiary company of the company
having such influence and includes a joint venture company. Explanation – For
the purposes of this clause, “significant influence” means control of at least
twenty per cent of total share capital and/or the ability to significantly
influence the operational and financial policies of the company but not control
them. The equity holding of Genesys International Corporation Limited in A.N.
Virtual World Tech Limited is 45.01%. The A.N. Virtual World Tech Limited is
consolidated as an Associate by virtue of the formers ability to influence the
operational and financial policies whereby the share of the parent in the
associate’s net worth and profit / loss has been picked up and accounted for
under an independent line item in the “General Reserve”,
“Investment” and “Statement of Profit and Loss”. The excess
of cost of Investment in the associate and the share of net worth of the
associate on the day of investing is reflected as “Goodwill”.

In
all other aspects these financial statements have been prepared in accordance
with the other generally accepted accounting principles in India under the
historical cost convention on accrual basis. Pursuant to Section 133 of the
Companies Act, 2013 read with Rule 7 of Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, till
the standards of accounting or any addendum thereto are prescribed by Central
Government in consultation and recommendation of the National Financial
Reporting Authority, the existing Accounting Standards notified under the
Companies Act, 1956 shall continue to apply. Consequently, these financial
statements have been prepared to comply in all material aspects with the
accounting standards notified under Section 211(3C) of the Companies Act, 1956
[Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2006, as amended] and other relevant
provisions of the Companies Act, 2013.

All
assets and liabilities have been classified as current or non-current as per
the Company’s normal operating cycle and other criteria set out in the Schedule
III to the Companies Act, 2013. Based on the nature of products and the time
between the acquisition of assets for processing and their realisation in cash
and cash equivalents, the Company has ascertained its operating cycle as 12
months for the purpose of current or non-current classification of assets and
liabilities.

Notes
to these consolidated financial statements are intended to serve as a means of
informative disclosure and a guide to better understanding of the consolidated
position of the companies. Recognising this purpose, the Ministry of Corporate
Affairs vide its General Circular No. 39/2014 dated 14 October 2014 has
clarified that only those note which are relevant to understanding the
Consolidated Financial Statements should be disclosed and not merely repeating
the Notes disclosed in the standalone financial statements to which these
consolidated financial statements are attached to.

Accordingly:

1] 
The Company has disclosed only such notes which fairly present the
needed disclosures.

2] The accounting policies of the
parent also broadly represent the accounting policies of the consolidated
entity and hence are best viewed in its independent financial statements, Note
2. However, the useful life of intangible assets for the purpose of its
depreciation is considered as 20 years by the associate, which is in contrast
to the accounting policy of the parent.

3]  Note Nos.
2,3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25,
26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41 represent the
numbers and required disclosures of the Parent and accordingly are best viewed
in Genesys International Corporation Limited independent financial statements.

Part B – Indirect Taxes

fiogf49gjkf0d
MVAT UPDATES

Submission of application under Settlement Act Electronically & FAQs on Settlement of Arrears in Disputes Act, 2016.  
Trade Circular 21T OF 2016 dated 24.8.2016

Commissioner of Sales tax has explained procedure to upload application electronically under the Maharashtra Settlement of Arrears in Dispute Act, 2016 and also updated FAQs  on the said Scheme.

Return filing in new automation processes and changes in procedures
Trade Circular 22T of 2016 dated 24.8.2016

Commissioner has explained new procedure to file MVAT  & CST returns from April-2016 in New Automation System. The process of submission of returns for the period starting from April, 2016 was put on hold because of certain technical problems. However,  dealers were required to pay tax due on or before the due dates prescribed under the provisions of law. For filing monthly and quarterly returns extended due dates are  given in the circular  and the new automation system and procedure to prepare and upload the return are explained. From April, 2016 dealer who is registered under the CST Act and whose turnover under CST Act is NIL requires to file NIL CST return.

Facility through e-Seva Kendra for online submissions
Trade Circular 23T of 2016 Dated 2.9.2016 & 25T of 2016 dated 7.9.2016

Dealers who do not have facility to apply online now can file application of registration through e-Seva Kendras. Other online services for e-filing of Returns, e-Payments and e-CST Declarations will be available from e-Seva Kendras.

Clarification under Settlement of Arrears in Disputes Act, 2016
Trade Circular 24T of 2016 dated 3.9.2016

Commissioner has issued this Clarification and revised instructions regarding various aspects and queries received by department from various associations in respect to availment of benefits under the Settlement of Arrears in Dispute Act, 2016.

Grant of Administrative Relief to Builders and Developers
Trade Circular 26T of 2016 dated 8.9.2016

Commissioner has clarified that Builders/Developers who have complied all the conditions as per the trade circular concerning  registration and  grant of administrative relief for unregistered period except compounding fees paid in time  but paid later are now also be considered for administrative relief.

Amendments to the Maharashtra Settlement of Arrears in Disputes Act, 2016. (Mah. Ordinance No. XXIII of 2016.)
Trade Circular 27T of 2016 dated 21.9.2016

 
Amendment has been made in the Maharashtra Settlement of Arrears in Dispute Act, 2016 by an Ordinance and thereby condition of stay order has been dispensed with.   Similar treatment will be given to payment made after passing the statutory order but before filing of appeal as the treatment given for  part payment made in appeal.

Increase in Rate of Tax in respect of Schedule C, Schedule D-10 (Petrol) and Schedule E goods
Notification VAT. 1516/CR 123/ Taxation-1, dated  16.9.2016

The Government of Maharashtra has issued this Notification to amend Schedules ‘C’, ‘D’ and ‘E’ appended to the MVAT Act, 2002.  W.e.f. 17.9.2016 in Schedule ‘C’ for various entries specified in Notification rate has been increased to 6% from 5.5%   and for Schedule E rate has been increased to 13.5%  from 12.5%. In Schedule ‘D’ in entry 10 any other kind of motor spirit  rate has been increased by Rs.1.5  per litre.

Miscellanea

1. Economy

 1.      
US defence firms want control
over tech in Make-in-India plan

The US- India
Business Council (USIBC) wrote to India’s defence minister last month seeking a
guarantee that US firms would retain control over sensitive technology — even
as joint venture junior partners.

 (Source:
International Business Times dated 19.09.2017)

 2.      
Crypto crash: Bitcoin nosedives
50% in India in just 13days

Bitcoin and newer
rivals like Ethereum and Litecoin have in recent times been fighting a losing
battle against regulators.

 (Source:
International Business Times dated 19.09.2017)

 3.   KitKat Bets on Weird and Wonderful
Flavor’s in Japan – Cough-medicine-flavored KitKat anyone?

It may not be to
everyone’s taste, but this is just one of 300 weird and wonderful flavor’s
flying off the shelves in Japan, which has become the world’s biggest market
for the four-fingered snack. In true Japanese style, human workers are a rare
sight at one Kitkat factory in Kasumiguara, around 100Km east of Tokyo.
Instead, dozens of robots manufacture four million bars a day at breakneck
speed, from mixing the chocolate paste to wrapping them ready for sale. Kitkats
have been around in Britain since 1935 and only arrived in Japan in 1973. But
the Japanese market has a crucial unique selling point – a huge variety of
different flavours. It all started with a strawberry flavoured Kitkat in 2000
and the range expanded quickly – from flavours aimed at local taste buds such
as sake, green tea and wasabi – to more exotic combinations like melon and
mascarpone.

 (Source:
Economic Times dated 07.09.2017)

 4.      
AI system writes next Game of
Thrones novel

Can’t wait to
find out what happens next in the Game of Thrones? A new artificial
intelligence (AI) system has written the first five chapters of the next book
of the popular fantasy series.

The TV show Game
of Thrones, which is based on the George R R Martin book series A Song of Ice
and Fire, has gained widespread popularity worldwide.

The show’s
seventh season recently aired its last episode, and fans will now have to wait
till 2019 to know what happens to their favourite characters next.

Martin is
currently working on the sixth novel of the book series, The Winds of Winter.

 Zach Thoutt, a
software engineer in the US, trained an AI system to predict the events of the
sixth novel using the characters from the fictional Seven Kingdoms of Westeros.

 “I start each chapter by giving it a prime
word, which I always used as a character name, and tell it how many words after
that to generate,” Thoutt said.

 “I wanted to do
chapters for specific characters like in the books, so I always used one of the
character names as the prime word. There is no editing other than supplying the
network that first prime word,” he said.

  (Source: Business Line dated 15.09.2017)

 5. 
Leadership thoughts

 5.      
 Why wisdom can’t be taught?

 “I cannot teach
anyone anything, I can only make them think” – Socrates

In the pursuit of
wisdom, executives may find themselves taking off their masks to become truly
authentic and reflective leaders.

The day after
becoming the CEO of a company facing turbulent times, David had a dream. In it,
while walking on a beach he discovered a bottle. On opening, a genie appeared
offering him a wish in exchange for her freedom. Eschewing riches, fame or a
long life, David opted for the one thing he knew he needed to help him guide
his people in the best way possible. He chose the gift of wisdom.

In today’s
hyperactive digital age, attaining wisdom is a challenge. With tablets and
phones and their various apps constantly vying for our immediate attention, it
is increasingly difficult to find the time and mental space for making
meaningful connections or engaging in the deep conversations, reflection,
emotional awareness, empathy and compassion, necessary in its pursuit.

Indeed, it is an
unfortunate fact for many leaders in David’s position, that while wisdom
requires education, education does not necessarily make people wise. As
Professor Charles Gragg noted in his classic case study “Because Wisdom Can’t
Be Told”, the mere act of listening to wise statements and sound advice doesn’t
necessarily ensure the transfer of wisdom.

What does it mean to be wise?

People often
equate wisdom with intelligence or being knowledgeable; but all too often, it
becomes apparent that being intelligent and being wise are quite different
things. The world is full of brilliant people who intellectualise without
really understanding the essence of things. In contrast, wise people try to
grasp the deeper meaning of what is known and strive to better understand the
limits of their knowledge.

Wisdom implies
more than merely being able to process information in a logical way. Knowledge
becomes wisdom when we have the ability to assimilate and apply this knowledge
to make the right decisions. As the saying goes, ‘knowledge speaks but wisdom
listens’. Wise people are blessed with good judgement. In addition, they possess
the qualities of sincerity and authenticity, the former implying a willingness
to say what you mean, the latter to be what you are.

Wise people are
also humble; their humility deriving from a willingness to recognise the
limitations of their knowledge. They accept that there are things they will
never know. By accepting their ignorance, they are better prepared to bear
their own fallibility. People who are wise know when what they are doing makes
sense, but also when it will not be good enough. Ironically, it is exactly this
kind of self-knowledge that pushes them to do something about it.

Wisdom can be
looked at from both a cognitive and emotional perspective. Cognitively, wise
people have the ability to see the big picture. They are able to put things in
perspective; to rise above their personal viewpoint and observe a situation
from many different angles (thus avoiding simplistic black-and-white thinking).
From an emotional perspective, people acknowledged for their wisdom are
reflective, introspective and tolerant of ambiguity. They know how to manage
negative emotions, and possess both empathy and compassion; qualities that
differentiate them in an interpersonal context.

Ironically, what
makes wisdom more important than success and riches is that it enables us to
live well. Our mental and physical health flourishes when we are congruent with
our beliefs and values. As Mahatma Gandhi once said, “Happiness is when what
you think, what you say, and what you do are in harmony.” Wise people are
attuned to what constitutes a meaningful life. They know how to plan for and
manage such a life. This implies self-concordance, behaving consistently with
their values, a journey that requires self-exploration, self-knowledge and
self-responsibility.

Age doesn’t make us wiser

So, how can we
acquire wisdom and can we expedite its acquisition? Becoming wise is a very
personal quest. It is only through our own experiences, learning how to cope
with the major tragedies and dilemmas embedded within life’s journey, that we
will discover our own capacities and learn how to create wisdom.

Setbacks are
memorable growth experiences contributing to a deeper understanding of the
vicissitudes of life. Overcoming difficult situations contributes to an
increased appreciation of life and the recognition of new possibilities. These
experiences enable us to rise above our own perspectives and see things as they
are.

Unfortunately,
wisdom is not something that automatically comes with the passing of years.
While older people may be more capable than their younger counterparts, many
never put their life experiences to good use. To acquire the required sense of
reflectivity may necessitate the help of others. Educators, coaches,
psychotherapists and mentors can play a significant role, not only by assisting
with the dissemination of knowledge but by helping those searching for wisdom
work through challenging experiences and encouraging them to work on emotional
awareness, emotional self-regulation, relational skills and mindfulness.

Wisdom and authenticity

A learning
community is also a great place to practice open-mindedness. Encouraging
participants to step out of their comfort zone and to deal with people who are
very different from themselves, leads to a deeper understanding and acceptance
of the ambiguous nature of things. If designed in a holistic manner, these
communities are a great exercise in humility, giving participants a better
awareness of their limitations as well as a greater ability to integrate their
knowledge and experiences when dealing with the challenges ahead.

In their pursuit
of wisdom, group members will be encouraged to learn from their mistakes, to
think before acting and, by taking off their masks, to become more authentic in
living their values.

 (Source: Insead Knowledge – The Business School
for the world)

Corporate Law Corner

 1.      
Deccan
Chronicle Holdings Ltd. (DCHL) vs. ROC [2017] 83 taxmann.com 315 (NCLT – Hyd.) Date of Order: 5th July, 2017

Section 297 read
with section 621A of Companies Act, 1956 – Money was advanced to a related
party without any interest without obtaining prior approval of concerned
authority – Even though the amount was returned by such a related party; the
same still violated section 297 – Offence could be compounded subject to
payment of hefty fees.

FACTS

“D Ltd.” a listed company, filed an
application for compounding an offence committed u/s. 297 of Companies Act,
1956 (“the Act”). Section 297 prohibited related party transaction except with
the consent of the Board of Directors and in case the company had a paid up
share capital of not less than Rs. 1 crore, prior approval of Central
Government was required. D Ltd. had transferred Rs. 99 crores to a company ‘F
Ltd.’ towards aircraft maintenance and other fund transfers. ROC issued a notice
demanding an explanation for violation of section 297. D Ltd. submitted that
the transactions with F Ltd. were out of purview of section 297 and also that
owing to some other reasons, F Ltd. was asked to repay all the sums transferred
to it and F Ltd. had duly complied with such request. In view of these facts,
proceedings, if any should be dropped. D Ltd filed an application with NCLT
which was dismissed by it. The Applicants therefore filed an appeal and
Appellate Tribunal directed the NCLT to examine the case in terms of section
621A of the Act which provides for compounding of offences.

Before the Tribunal, D Ltd. urged that the
transactions had been fairly concluded and all amounts remitted to F Ltd. had
been received back. As the offence did not continue, the same qualified for
compounding.  

HELD

The Tribunal observed that although the
amounts advanced to F Ltd. were recovered in full, there was no payment of any
interest by F Ltd. Such advancing of money without payment of interest caused
loss to the shareholders of D Ltd. The Tribunal observed that transparency in
operations is one of the key elements of listed company and appropriate
disclosures of related party transactions are very essential to various
stakeholders and as such, the same is the duty of the Company/Board of
Directors to give true and fair picture of the functioning of the Company to
its shareholders especially any decision having adverse financial impact on the
Company which in turn will have an impact on the shareholders whether directly
or indirectly.

The Tribunal held that D Ltd. was guilty of
violation of section 297 of the Act and directed that offence may be compounded
u/s. 621A upon payment of heavy charges in respect thereof.

2.             Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, In
re

[2017]
84 taxmann.com 175 (All)  Date of Order: 2nd
August, 2017

Sections 21 and
22 of Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 – Chartered Accountant had resigned from
Board of company prior to the opening of its public issue but signed the
prospectus for the same – The Chartered Accountant was held to be guilty of
other misconduct.

 FACTS

Mr. ‘S’ was a member of the Institute of
Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and a director of B Co. S had resigned
from the company before opening of its public issue, but his resignation was
accepted on 09.09.1997 which was after the close of issue. Public issue of BCo
opened on 25.07.1996 and closed on 05.08.1996. Mr. S signed the prospectus of
this public issue on 17.06.1996 which named him as a director of BCo. Mr. S did
not object to the inclusion of his name in the prospectus of BCo.

The disciplinary committee of the ICAI found
him guilty of “other misconduct”. The Council of ICAI considering the said
findings recommended the removal of his name as a member for a period of three
months to the High Court.

Mr. S argued that although he resigned prior
to opening of public issue, his resignation was accepted only on 09.09.1997. He
further submitted that since no public money was received by BCo; there was no
question of misleading investors and inducing them to subscribe to the shares
of the said company.

Counsel appearing for the ICAI urged that
under the Companies Act, 1956, resignation of a director comes into effect the
moment it is tendered. As Mr. S accepted that he in fact resigned from the
company before the opening of the public issue, his name should not have
appeared as a director in the prospectus.

HELD

The High Court observed that the Companies
Act, 1956 did not have any specific provision relating to resignation of
director from the company. Neither of the parties produced the Memorandum Of
Association and Articles Of Association of the company to show anything in this
regard. Accordingly, it was held that common law principle would apply in so
far as resignation of directors was concerned.

The Court having relied on various judgements,
came to a conclusion that resignation of a director of a company was a
unilateral act that came into effect as soon as the resignation was tendered by
the director of the company. The directors were merely agents of the company
and agents were competent to determine the agency at their own end.

As Mr. S had resigned before the opening of
the public issue, his name should not have appeared in the prospectus as a
director of the company which was in fact there. The Court held that such an
act amounted to lending of name to the prospectus and misleading the investors.
It was immaterial whether any investor was actually mislead. The act of
misconduct was nonetheless completed.

The High Court accordingly upheld the
finding of disciplinary committee that held Mr. S guilty of other misconduct
under sections 21 and 22 of the Chartered Accountants Act and accepted the
recommendation of Council on removal of name of Mr. S from the register of
members of Chartered Accountants for a period of three months. 

3.             APC Credit rating (P.) Ltd. vs. ROC

[2017]
84 taxmann.com 75 (NCLT – New Delhi)       Date
of  Order: 19th July, 2017

Section 420 of
Companies Act, 2013 – NCLT does not have an inherent power to review its own
decision – NCLT can only rectify its decision.

FACTS

ACo had violated various provisions of the
Companies Act, 1956 and filed applications with the Tribunal u/s. 441 of the
Companies Act, 2013 for compounding the same. The Tribunal dismissed the
applications vide order dated 26.09.2016 for reasons mentioned therein.
Subsequently, ACo preferred application under Rule 154 of National Company Law
Tribunal Rules, 2016 (“Rules”) for review of the orders in light of certain
decisions which were not considered by the Tribunal. The Tribunal, vide order
dated 28.04.2017, dismissed the applications by holding that review was
different from appeal and it was not possible to replace one order with
another. 

ACo challenged
this order before the Tribunal and also filed an application for condonation of
delay in filing the appeal.

HELD

The Tribunal examined the provisions of
section 420 of Companies Act, 2013 along with Rules 11 and 15. The Tribunal
observed that it has limited power to rectify any mistake apparent from the
record and to amend the order accordingly, but there is no inherent power to
review its own order.

It held that the present case did not fall
within the meaning of ‘mistake apparent on the face of the record’ of appellant
and therefore, there was no occasion for the Tribunal to exercise power
conferred by section 420 (2) of the Act. Further, non-reference to previously
rendered judgement did not constitute an “omission”.

 

As more than 9 months had elapsed from the order
dated 26.09.2016, the Tribunal held that it could not condone the delay in
filing appeal as law capped the power to condone the delay for a maximum of 90
days from the date of order.

Allied Laws

1. Advocate – Professional Misconduct – Advocate cannot file an affidavit in his own name on behalf of his client. [Advocates Act, 1961, Section 30, S ection 35]

Baljeet Singh vs. Pratap Singh and Others. AIR 2017 ALLAHABAD 165

The simple issue before the Hon’ble court was whether the counsel for the appellant before the lower appellate court could have filed the affidavit in support of the present appeal as a family friend?

It was observed that an advocate gets his right to practise in a court only u/s. 30 of the Act. ‘Practise’ in itself means to appear on behalf of his client before a Court or Tribunal in the best interest of his client. Practise, however, certainly does not give liberty to an advocate to identify himself with his client and step into the shoes of his client, so far as the rights of his client are concerned.

It was held by the Hon’ble Court that the said counsel who filed the affidavit is guilty of professional misconduct in identifying himself with his client and filing an affidavit in support of the appeal, but considering that he himself expresses that he had acted under naivety and has submitted an unconditional apology, the matter may not be referred to the Disciplinary Committee of the State Bar Council.

2. Evidence – Admissibility of evidence during the appellate proceedings. [Evidence Act, 1872, Section 65B(4)].

Sonu alias Amar vs. State of Haryana AIR 2017 SUPREME COURT 3441

An objection w.r.t. electronic record being not admissible unless it was accompanied by a certificate was raised in the appellate proceedings.

The only issue is the permissibility of an objection regarding inadmissibility of evidence at the Appeal stage. Admittedly, no objection was taken when the CDRs were adduced in evidence before the Trial Court. It does not appear from the record that any such objection was taken even at the appellate stage before the High Court.

It was observed that objections as to admissibility of documents in evidence may be classified into two classes: (i) an objection that the document which is sought to be proved is itself inadmissible in evidence; and (ii) where the objection does not dispute the admissibility of the document in evidence but is directed towards the mode of proof alleging the same to be irregular or insufficient.

It was held by the Hon’ble Court that it is clear that an objection relating to the mode or method of proof has to be raised at the time of marking of the document as an exhibit and not later. Objections regarding admissibility of documents which are per se inadmissible can be taken even at the appellate stage. Admissibility of a document which is inherently inadmissible is an issue which can be taken up at the appellate stage because it is a fundamental issue. The mode or method of proof is procedural and objections, if not taken at the trial, cannot be permitted at the appellate stage.

3. HUF – Ancestral property – Deemed to be joint – Unless proved otherwise. [Hindu Law]

Adiveppa & Ors. vs. Bhimappa & Anr. CIVIL APPEAL No. 11220 OF 2017 SUPREME COURT (www.itatonline.org)

The disputes were regarding ownership and extent of the shares held by the Appellants (Plaintiffs) in the agricultural lands.

It was alleged that while some properties were ancestral while others were self-acquired and hence the Plaintiffs (Appellants) have 4/9th share in the ancestral properties as members of the family. The Respondents (Defendants) denied the plaintiffs’ claim and averred inter alia that all the suit properties were ancestral properties. It was alleged by the Respondents that during the lifetime of the father of the plaintiff, an oral partition had taken place amongst the family members in relation to the all the suit properties pursuant to which all family members were placed in possession of their respective shares.

It was held by the Hon’ble Court that it is a settled principle of Hindu law that there lies a legal presumption that every Hindu family is joint in food, worship and estate and in the absence of any proof of division, such legal presumption continues to operate in the family. The burden, therefore, lies upon the member who after admitting the existence of jointness in the family properties asserts his claim that some properties out of entire lot of ancestral properties are his self-acquired property. Since the Plaintiffs themselves had based their case by admitting the existence of joint family nucleus and also could not prove with any documentary evidence that the suit properties described were their self-acquired properties, the appeal was dismissed.

4. Search/Survey – Undated cheques for collection of differential duty – Illegal. [Central Excise Act, 1944, Section 12F]

Digipro Import & Export Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors. 2017 (350) E.L.T. 145 (Del.).

Five undated cheques totalling to Rs. 1.25 crore were collected from the Petitioner by the officers of the Anti-Evasion Wing, Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi-I during a Search/Survey conducted under the Central Excise Act, 1944.

The only issue was whether such an act of the department of collecting ‘undated cheques’ constituting the differential duty liability during the process of a visit/search or survey was sustainable.

The Hon’ble Court relying on various decisions held that there was no provision of law or any notification or any circular that permitted the officers who visited the Petitioner’s business premises to collect undated cheques which purportedly constitute the differential duty. It must be realised that the officers of the Anti-Evasion Wing of the Central Excise Department have to function within the four corners of the law. They are bound by not only the Central Excise Act and the Rules made thereunder but all the notifications/circulars/instructions issued from time to time including those issued by the CBEC. There is no scope at all to collect duty and that too without even quantifying the extent of duty evasion.

5. Rectification of mistake apparent – Within 6 months – Date of Order not to be seen. [Central Excise Act, 1944 –Section 35C, Section 37C]

Liladhar T. Khushlani vs. Commissioner of Customs 2017 (351) E.L.T. 36 (Guj.)

The short question, which was posed for consideration was, whether for the purpose of filing the rectification application, period of limitation of six months would commence from the date of the order, which is sought to be rectified or from the date of receipt of the order sought to be reviewed/rectified by the concerned assesse under the Central Excise Act, 1944?

It was held by the Hon’ble court that unless and until a party to the appeal is in a position to go through and study the order it would not be possible, nor can it be envisaged, that a party can claim to be aggrieved by the mistake apparent from the record. Hence, even on this count, the period of limitation has to be read and understood so as to mean from the date of the receipt of the order. In the result, the impugned order passed by the learned CESTAT was quashed and set aside.

From Published Accounts

Accounting for composite scheme of
amalgamation and arrangement as per accounting standards applicable as on the
appointed date and not as per IndAS as applicable for the financial year

Suzlon Energy Ltd. (Year ended 31st March
2017)

 From Notes
to Financial Statements

 Composite scheme of amalgamation and
arrangement

On April 27,
2016, the Board of Directors of the Company had approved a composite scheme
which comprised of merger of its three wholly owned subsidiaries, namely, SE
Blades Limited (‘SEBL’), SE Electricals Limited (‘SEEL’) and Suzlon Wind
International Limited (‘SWIL’) in the Company, with effect from January 1, 2016
(being the appointed date for merger) and demerger of tower business from
wholly owned subsidiary, Suzlon Structures Limited (‘SSL’) (now known as Suzlon
Global Services Limited) (‘Scheme’) from the Company, with effect from April 1,
2016 (being the appointed date for demerger).

This Scheme has been approved by the
Honourable National Company Law Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench on May 31, 2017 and
the Company has incorporated the accounting effects in its books of accounts as
per the accounting treatment prescribed in the Scheme which is in compliance
and accordance with the accounting standards applicable to the Company as of
the appointed date of the Scheme. Accounting standards currently applicable to
the Company are Ind AS. Had the Company applied the accounting treatment in accordance
with Ind AS 103, Business Combination, the following would have been the
accounting treatment:

 a)  The assets and liabilities
of transferor companies would have been taken over at carrying amount in the
books of transferor company and not at fair value;

 b)  Retained earnings appearing
in the books of transferor companies would have been aggregated with the books
of the Company. The total amount of retained earnings would have been Rs.
11,236.30 Crore.

 c)  No new assets / liabilities
would have been recognised and no adjustments would have been made to reflect
fair values of assets or liabilities of the transferor companies. As a result
of acquisition of transferor companies, the Company has recognised Goodwill of
Rs 1,059.80 Crore which shall be amortised over five years in accordance with
the Scheme.

 d)  Financial statements in
respect of prior period would have been restated as if business combination had
occurred from the transition date. The Company has accounted for the business
combination of transferor companies as well as demerged business from the
appointed dates defined in the Scheme.

 e)  Business combinations which
are effected after the balance sheet date but before approval of financial
statements, are not incorporated in the financial statements but only
disclosures required by Ind AS 10 Events after the reporting period are made.
In the current case, the Company has recorded the business combination on the
appointed date defined in the Scheme.

 f)   The Company has not
recognised deferred tax asset or liabilities arising out of assets acquired or
liabilities assumed.

Accounting for
composite scheme of amalgamation and arrangement

On April 27, 2016, the Board of Directors of
the Company had approved a Composite Scheme (‘Scheme’) which comprised of:

 a)  Merger of its three wholly
owned subsidiary companies, namely, SE Blades Limited (‘SEBL’), SE Electricals
Limited (‘SEEL’) and Suzlon Wind International Limited (‘SWIL’) in the Company,
with effect from January 1, 2016 (being the appointed date for merger);

b)  Demerger of tower business
from wholly owned subsidiary, Suzlon Structures Limited (‘SSL’) (renamed as
Suzlon Global Services Limited (‘SGSL”)) from the Company, with effect from
April 1, 2016 (being the appointed date for demerger).

SEBL, SEEL, SWIL are hereinafter referred to
as the ‘transferor companies’ and tower business of SSL is referred to as
‘demerged business’.

Prior to merger, the transferor companies
and tower business of SSL, were engaged in manufacturing components of wind
turbine generators (WTGs). The Scheme defined following accounting treatment
for recording this transaction with transferor companies in the books of the
Company:

 a)  Transfer of all assets and
liabilities appearing in the books of transferor companies to the Company at
their fair values as on the appointed date;

b)  The cost of equity and
preference shares issued by transferor companies and held by the Company, shall
be treated as consideration paid for acquisition of business of transferor
companies;

c)  The Reserves (whether
capital or revenue or on revaluation) of transferor companies should not be
recorded in the financial statements of the Company;

d)  Loans and advances inter-se
between the transferor companies and the Company, if any shall stand cancelled;

e)  Differences in accounting
policy between the transferor companies and the Company will be quantified and
adjusted in the balance in the statement of the profit and loss of the Company;
and

f)   Difference between net
assets value taken over from transferor companies and the cost of investments
defined in (b) above, shall be debited to Goodwill account / credited to
capital reserve account. Goodwill, if any, shall be amortised on a
straight-line basis over period of full five years (i.e. 60 months) and shall
accordingly be amortised proportionately for a part of any financial year, if
so required.

The Scheme defined the following accounting
treatment for recording this transaction with demerged business in the books of
the Company:

a)  Transfer of all assets and
liabilities in the books of demerged business to the Company at their
respective book values, as appearing in the books of SSL immediately preceding
the appointed date

b)  Intercompany balances, if
any between the demerged business and the Company shall stand cancelled

c)  Amount of net assets /
(liabilities) of demerged business transferred to the Company, shall be
recorded as Capital Reserve / Goodwill respectively. This Goodwill / Capital
Reserve shall be independent of Goodwill / Capital Reserve arising on merger of
transferor companies defined above.

This Scheme has been approved by the
Honourable National Company Law Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench on May 31, 2017 and
the Company has incorporated the accounting effects in its books of accounts as
per the accounting treatment prescribed in the Scheme which is in compliance
and accordance with the accounting standards applicable to the Company as of
the appointed date of the Scheme. Accounting standards currently applicable to
the Company are Ind AS.

The details of Fair values of assets and
liabilities taken over from transferor companies and book value of assets and
liabilities taken over from demerged business in accordance with the Scheme are
as follows:

Rs. In crores

 

Sebl

Swil

Seel

Tower
business  Of ssl

Assets

91.60

67.76

134.51

20.38

Property,
plant and equipment

0.67

0.43

0.65

2.71

Trade
receivables

134.93

20.61

188.45

63.89

Inventories

81.68

23.83

102.79

69.57

Other
financial assets

51.31

245.85

7.06

5.04

Other
non-financial assets

1.46

6.02

7.01

2.16

Total
Assets (A)

361.65

364.50

440.47

163.75

Liabilities

Trade payables

209.88

332.28

106.24

51.34

Provisions

7.42

32.61

2.38

2.91

Borrowings

109.01

224.45

215.09

85.22

Deferred tax

–

–

12.61

–

Inter Division Balance

–

–

–

22.14

Other Financial Liabilities

21.85

55.87

24.56

1.84

Other Non-Financial Liabilities

10.02

19.71

4.26

0.30

Total Liabilities (B)

358.18

664.92

365.14

163.75

Net Assets Taken Over C=(A-B)

3.47

(300.42)

75.33

–

Gross Value Of Investment

538.98

203.30

95.90

–

Goodwill Arising on Acquisition

535.51

503.72

20.57

–

Purchase Consideration *refer Note (b) below

 

 

 

 

Equity Share Capital

15.00

10.00

10.00

–

Preference Share Capital

523.98

193.30

85.90

–

Contribution
to amounts reported in year ended March 31, 2017 (before elimination)

Revenue

295.04

2.78

534.70

278.33

Profit
before tax

(66.14)

(128.34)

27.87

1.30

 

None of the trade receivables is credit
impaired and it is expected that the full contractual amounts can be collected.

 

The above mentioned fair valuation is based
on valuations performed by an accredited independent valuer and the valuation
model is in accordance with that recommended by the International Valuation
Standards Committee.

 Notes:

a)  Other financial liabilities
of SSL include an amount of Rs. 22.14 Crore, relating to amount payable by the
tower business to other businesses included in SSL. As this in the nature of
other financial liability, the same has been included in the computation of net
assets of tower business.

b)  The Scheme states that
since the entire share capital of transferor companies being SEBL, SEEL and
SWIL is held by SEL, being wholly owned subsidiaries of SEL, no shares of SEL
shall be allotted in respect of its holding in the transferor companies
pursuant to amalgamation due to operation of law. The value of investment in
the shares of transferor companies held by SEL shall stand cancelled in the
books of SEL, without further act or deed. The cost of acquisition of such
equity and preference shares in the hands of SEL shall be treated as the
consideration for the acquisition of business of transferor companies. As
regards the de-merger of tower manufacturing division of SSL, the Scheme states
that since the entire share capital of demerged company is held by SEL and its
nominees, no shares of SEL shall be allotted in respect of its holding in the
demerged company pursuant to demerger, due to operation of law.

** As a result of the merger, the Company
has recognised adjustment of Rs. 69.15 Crore on account of cancellation of
RCPs, Rs. 111.90 Crore on account of accounting policy alignment including Ind
AS adjustments.

From
Auditors’ Report

Emphasis of Matter

We draw attention to Note 7 of the accompanying
standalone Ind AS financial statements, whereby the Company has recognised
goodwill on amalgamation aggregating to Rs. 1,059.80 Crore and amortised the
same in accordance with the composite scheme of amalgamation and arrangement
approved by the National Company Law Tribunal. This accounting treatment is
different from that prescribed under Indian Accounting Standard (Ind AS) 103 –
Business Combinations in case of common control business combinations as is
more fully described in the aforesaid note. Our opinion is not qualified in respect
of this matter.

From The President

fiogf49gjkf0d
Dear Members,

It was a beautiful Sunday morning with some light drizzle, while enjoying masala chai I was trying to catch up with the news. Alas! My enjoyment disappeared with the immensely distressing news…Eighteen Indian soldiers were martyred by Pakistani infiltrators using grenades and AK 47 rifles. Uri, the picturesque garrison town at the border had plumes of smoke emanating from the site where our Indian soldiers sleeping in tents were killed. The four militants were promptly neutralized in a shoot-out with the Indian army, but the dreams and happiness of eighteen families were irrevocably shattered.

Over the past few decades, Pakistan has been ravaged by its stupidity and short-sightedness. It allowed religious fundamentalism to proliferate unfettered and today it is repeatedly bitten by the monster it nurtured. Its economy is in a downturn; exports are negligible and remittances are contracting drastically. Hardliner Army Chief calls the shots while Prime Minister has been effectively reduced to a puppet. In an attempt to distract its suffering and disgruntled population, it is desperately raking up the Kashmir issue.

Pakistan appears to be spoiling for a fight; from Kargil to Pathankot Air Station and now the army camp in Uri. India has always exercised restraint, but now India has gone on the offensive! Moving quietly but decisively it responded with a campaign of prudent and well-timed initiatives.

First off the block was a stinging rejoinder to Nawaz Sharif’s vitriolic speech at the UN. First Secretary Eenam Gambir minced no words no words as she dubbed Pakistan as the epicenter of terrorism, adding that the effects of its toxic curriculum (imbibed in its extremist madrassas) is felt across the world. She boldly accused Pakistan of channelizing billions of dollars of international aid to training and financing terrorist groups.

International condemnation of the Uri terror attack put Pakistan in a spot. With Nawaz Sharif’s plan in shambles, India pulled out yet another ace as it brought the Indus Water Treaty up for review, with Prime Minister Modi saying “blood and water can’t flow together”. It followed this diversion with External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj lambasting Pakistan at the UN for nurturing and harbouring terrorists responsible for attacks worldwide. She bluntly underlined the fact that “Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India and will always remain so.”

With Pakistan clearly on a back foot, it was time for a master stroke. On a moonless night, two hundred Indian para commandos crossed the Line of Control and destroyed seven terror launch pads. The surgical strikes are believed to have killed at least fifty terrorists and more importantly sent an unequivocal message to Pakistan…that India will not remain complacent any more.

Having gained traction in the diplomatic arena, India needs to be more proactive than reactive. India must continue a concerted and sustained diplomatic campaign to isolate Pakistan. The US, EU and Middle East countries need to be consistently addressed to severely limit aid and trade support to Pakistan in order to force it to give up cross border terrorism.

 “A day will come when people of Pakistan will go against its own government to fight terrorism,”

PM Modi.

Bright Spot? – Modi vs Moody
The silver lining through all the dastardly acts discussed earlier and international economic turbulence is that India’s economy is growing at over 7%. The Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi, speaking at a global summit took pains to reiterate the many achievements of his government. He showcased, increase in FDI, reining inflation, lowest balance of payment deficit and fiscal discipline as achievements, so far, of the Government. Another strong factor of fiscal discipline to be considered is the Debt/GDP (%). India had Debt/GDP in C.Y.2015 of 140 as against the Global Average of 235. This would be more glaringly appreciative when considered against this ratio of some of the Developed Markets(DMs). US – 251, Euro Area – 291, Japan – 481 and UK – 279. This is despite having a growth momentum of more than 7% in GDP.

Jan Dhan Yojana, one of the key initiatives of the government has been hailed as the world’s largest and most successful financial inclusion plan. Two hundred million people have been introduced to the advantages of banking and their accounts today have a balance exceeding a phenomenal $4 billion! It’s relatively new Startup India, Stand-Up India and MUDRA programs are a step in the right direction as they are designed to empower youth, women, SC/ST and OBCs.

In the sphere of good governance, the government has already identified 1,877 old and unnecessary laws. 125 of these have already been repealed, while 758 are in an advanced process of being pulled out of the system. The government’s focus on good governance is highly visible in the passing of the Goods and Services Tax too. Cleared in both houses in the first week of August, the government is now working overtime to ensure its smooth rollout on 1st April 2017.

All these concerted efforts of the government seem to be bearing fruit. Some big global financial institutions have applauded India’s growth rates; and the string of reforms that have been implemented and are already transforming lives.

To take one example, Morgan Stanley Research, in its latest Global Macro Briefing, while dealing with India in Country Highlights has stated that the growth recovery is becoming more broad based, driven by public capex, FDI and consumption. Improved macro-stability conditions should minimize the impact from external uncertainties.

These global financial institutions believe India is “on the cusp of a major growth phase” and “looks to be firing at last”. With the global growth rates inching along, India’s enormous market potential appears to be an oasis for international investors.

The makeover of India is happening due to tone at the Top – Mr. Narendra Modi’s approach of working like a Rock Star for the progress of India. He has been walking on the stage for momentous days of India and playing his heart out. He is delivering the performance of his life. He has instilled a sense of confidence and urgency in his team and also in each and every Indian to deliver the best.

Here I would like to quote Henry David Thoureau, an American Poet –  “I know of no more encouraging fact than the unquestiobale ability of a human being to elevate their life by conscious endeavor.”

However, not all share this gung-ho sentiment. International credit rating giant Moody’s has not been swayed by all the hype and gloss of a media-savvy government. India continues to languish with a ‘Baa3’ rating – the lowest grade of investment rating. India’s pitch for an upgrade has been firmly dashed by a plethora of serious issues; which range from spiraling debt, stagnant revenue, massive NPAs in public sector banks, the slow pace of policy reforms, corruption in some sectors, geopolitical risks and the reluctance of private sector investments.

So is the Indian growth story, economy and prospects all hunky dory? You have heard it from the well informed, Shri “Modi” and got a nutshell analysis from “Moody’s”, the no-nonsense global credit rating agency and now it’s time for you to give India your very own rating!

“In economics there are no miracles, there are only consequences-ruthless and inescapable consequences. Inflation is the invisible tax which has never been passed by Parliament”.

 Nani Palkhivala

After the busy ‘extended’ tax season, this Diwali let us take an opportunity to take a break from the routine of multi-tasking and rushing from one deadline to another and instead spend quality time with our loved ones. Let us embrace these celebrations with open hearts and relearn how to enjoy life.

Wishing you all a happy and joyous Deepavali!

With warm regards,

Chetan Shah

Ethics and You

Arjun (A) — Hey Bhagawan, I always envy you. You are always
enjoying without any worries !

Shrikrishna (S) — Why? What did I do to enjoy?

A —  See, we are slogging here on GST; struggling
to somehow push the returns; and you played ‘Govinda’ dancing on music
with people !

          This year you enjoyed the independence
day by breaking the Dahihandi.

S —  What you are saying is right ! But it is not
that I enjoyed because it was my birthday. It is my very nature to be cheerful.
That is Karmayoga with detachment that I preached through Geeta to you.
Did you forget it?

A — It is very easy to say so; but you don’t
know our plight in complying with the tax laws. It is a nightmare !

S —  I appreciate that. But see my case. I was
born in prison at midnight. If king Kansa had known about my birth, he would
have killed me. Then it was heavily raining. There was a flood in river Yamuna.
In that situation, my father took me across the river and left me at Gokul.

A —  Yes, I am aware.

S —  Further, right in my early childhood, there
were attacks on my life, from cruel demons! I had a hard life.

A —   I know, you had to fight with many Rakshasas
throughout your life.

S —   So enjoyment and cheerfulness is my very
nature – ‘Swabhaava’. It does not depend on external factors. You have
to do your karma religiously.

A —  That is OK. But here the Government has made
it a total mess ! They are pushing the GST when their own machinery is not
geared up.

S —   Arjuna, you have faced many more challenging
situations when you were in exile for 12 years, and when you fought at Kurukshetra
in Mahabharata !

A — That is true; but our Government authorities
are more dangerous and fierceful than those Kauravas. Here, there is
nothing but confusion.

S —  Cool, Arjun. Cool down. Things will be
settled soon. You only put in sincere efforts. Start in time.

A —  But simultaneously, we have to do tax
audits. That deadline is also approaching. There are festivals in between.
Articles are on leave. I wonder how we are going to manage all this !

S —  They will give you enough time. Don’t worry.

A —  Don’t tell me. Nowadays, they have stopped
giving extension !

S —   Never give up hope. Think positive.

A — Actually, I forgot to tell you one incident
of one lady CA. She is a very average practitioner mainly into traditional
work.

S —  What happened to her?

A —  She had two new clients. One wanted some big
amount of loan. By coincidence, the other client claimed to be rendering
financial services; arranging for bank-loans and so on.

S —  Good. So she introduced one to the other.
Right?

A — Yes. And that person asked for advance fees
by cheque as well as cash for expenses. The client who wanted loan insisted
that he would do this only through this CA lady.

S —  Oh ! That’s dangerous.

A — You guessed it right. She collected fees,
issued her receipt; and passed on the amount to the other person through bank.

S —  Even cash ?

A — No. That she delivered physically.

       She sent email to him saying that she
has passed on to him the full amount. He confirmed it by return email; but with
a little vague wording.

S —  That person must have let her down.

A — Absolutely ! He ditched both – the lady as
well as that other client. And both the clients have filed criminal complaints
against each other, dragging the CA also into it.

 S —  So sad !

A — And on the top of it, he also filed a
complaint to our Institute! Poor lady. She just allowed the amount to be routed
through her hands and is now in deep trouble !

S —  That is because she issued a receipt as if
she was going to render the service ! I know, she did it innocently, with
honest intention.

A —  So vulnerable our profession is !

S —  So, again I tell you; Be very cautious. You
will be signing many audit reports this month. Be proactive. Be clear in
communicating. Don’t risk your own image while accommodating a client. Do
proper documentation. Keep all working papers. Don’t have too much good faith
in others. If there are new assignments, write to the previous auditor
immediately. Ensure, by careful verification and in writing that previous
auditors’ audit fees have been really paid – Get proper appointment letter and
engagement letter.

           And………

A —  Oh Lord ! You are telling me the entire Code
of Ethics now perhaps for the 50th time! I know it by heart.

S —  But unfortunately, you don’t follow it and
then succumb to remorse ! It is my duty to tell you, advise you till you get
it. Just as I did it in Geeta.

A —  And Bhagawan, I do put your advice in
action most dutifully !

S — True ! But you must follow it more
skillfully for yoga is skill in action! Do your Karma diligently;
perform your part of duty diligently; and the fruit will follow. That is my
duty !

          Om Shanti.

            The purpose of this
dialogue was to underline the importance of documentation in our work and point
out the vulnerability. Acts done in good faith and to accommodate others may
sometime backfire very badly.

From the President

Dear Members,

As I sit to write this
communication on the 2nd October, the Nation celebrates the birth
anniversaries of two great leaders – Mahatma Gandhi and Lal Bahadur Shastri.  Born in 1869, Mahatma Gandhi steered the
country into independence with his weapons of “truth” and “non-violence”. Born
in 1904, his disciple Lal Bahadur Shastri went on to become the 2nd
Prime Minister of Independent India and made a marked difference in the lives
of citizens with “the White Revolution” and “the Green Revolution”.

 

For such principle-centred
leaders, independence did not mean just transferring colonial era British power
brokering system, favours-driven, bureaucratic, class exploitative structure
and mindset into Indian hands. In fact, Gandhiji had warned that such a
transfer would still be English rule, just without the Englishman. Seven
decades post-independence, as we (as professionals and as citizens) inch closer
towards the Council Elections and the General Elections and cast our votes to
choose the leaders, it is time to take stock and identify leaders whose birth
anniversaries our next generations would be inspired to celebrate.

 

The GST Audit Report was
notified recently. The Society is pleased to note that most of the suggestions
made by it towards simplification of the report and alignment of the same with
the objectives of audit sought by the Act have been accepted. While the Society
is in active dialogue with the Government for certain clarifications and
ironing some gaps in the audit report, it is now time for the professionals to
step up the technical capabilities and live up to the trust placed by the
Government. The Society was invited by the CIT (CPC TDS) to provide inputs about
Phase 2.0 of TRACES Project. This phase will use latest technologies and would
totally transform the TDS Administration in the country and promote the ease of
doing business.

 

For professionals,
September was a very busy month. As members struggled to complete their
obligations and sought extension of due date, the initial reactions were not
very positive resulting in a panic situation. Ultimately, the much-needed
extension was announced. Is the 15-day extension sufficient? Is it fair for the
Government to expect interest in such cases? The social media was abuzz with
various news, views and information in this regard. I would believe that rather
than spending time on such questions, it would be gainful for the members to
concentrate their energies on work, make the most of this extension and
complete the balance work before the extended due date. After completing the
pending work at hand, it may also be a time to strategise the way forward for
better time and work flow management in the coming years.

 

The enrolments for the 52nd
Residential Refresher Course have already gained momentum. This time, the RRC
is at a luxurious venue of ITC Mughal in the historic city of Agra. Packed with
innovative formats, relevant topics and best faculties, this RRC promises to be
an experience of a lifetime. It has a full day devoted to practice management
sessions where members can collectively reflect on the future of the
profession. The detailed announcement is available on the website and I would
urge the members to enrol at the earliest to avail the early bird benefits.

 

Many other interesting
programs have been announced – the long duration study course on GST, full day
panel discussion on burning issues in real estate sector (jointly with IMC),
panel discussion and case studies on GAAR, a specially designed workshop for
senior citizens on using mobile apps. I would request the members to attend
these events and encourage the organisers to innovate and provide you relevant
and best events.

 

During the last quarter,
the Society could release a series of publications on diverse topics and most
of them were sold out within a fortnight. As a matter of convenience, the
Society has a publication imprest scheme whereby books are couriered to members
immediately on their release and the amount is debited to the imprest. Those
who are interested can enrol for the said Scheme.

 

I also take this
opportunity to wish all the members a great festive season ahead. Do take
periodic breaks from your busy schedule and energise yourself with your family and
friends.

 

Warm Regards

 

 

 

CA.
Sunil Gabhawalla

President

 

Society News

22nd “ITF Conference 2018” held from 15th to 18th August at The Narayani Heights, Ahmedabad

 

The International Tax and Finance Conference was conducted from 15th to 18th August at The Narayani Heights, Ahmedabad with a robust attendance of 233 members from around 19 cities across India. The Conference was top lined by experts from respective fields who dealt with their subject matter with in-depth clarity. The 4-day Conference was marked with 6 technical sessions which included 3 group discussion papers, 1 presentation and 2 panel discussions.

 

President CA. Sunil Gabhawalla gave his opening remarks on “Indirect Tax Aspects of Cross Border Structuring” and also explained about BCAS activities and new initiatives.

 

The Conference was inaugurated with a keynote address by Adv. Saurabh Soparkar who dealt in a very succinct manner on “Understanding of codified GAAR in light of, as well as in comparison, to judicial GAAR, in international tax context”.

 

CA. Gautam Doshi spoke on “Business Connection and PE in the context of recent amendments and BEPS”. He dealt with case studies covering various aspects of the recent significant economic presence, principle purpose test, place of effective management and dependent agent. He explained the toughest concepts at a fundamental level and enlightened all in a very concise and enriching manner. The paper provided by him gave justice to all important areas of the topic.

 

CA. Hasnain Shroff explained “Recent Developments in Transfer Pricing”. He discussed recent developments from BEPS, attribution of profits to PE and intangible-related valuation and transactions. The case studies put forward by him brought out many new issues and the concepts yet to be tested were explained thoroughly.

 

CA. Padamchand Khincha deliberated upon “Case Studies on Cross-Border Business Structuring”, Hybrid Instruments and Entities, indirect transfer of shares, BEPS, domestic GAAR and Limitation on Interest Deduction.

 

Dr. Anup Shah’s presentation on “Raising Global Finance (Recent Trends and Indian Regulations including FEMA and other laws)” was well received and he discussed in detail, the tax, FEMA and other regulatory analysis in respect of raising finance from an international perspective.

 

Adv. Vikram Nankani’s presentation on “Interplay of Benami Properties Act, Black Money Act, Fugitive Economic Offenders Bill/Act and PMLA” also provided brief analysis to all participants.

 

The Panel Discussion was chaired by Shri Pramod Kumar, ITAT and Accountant Member with Dr. Vinay Kumar Singh, CA. Pranav Sayta and CA. T. P. Ostwal as panellists. The Panel discussed various case studies on “Interpretation of Tax Treaties against the backdrop of OECD MC 2017, MLI and GAAR”. All the panellists took up case studies which contained the latest and most important concerns including the impact of latest changes introduced as a part of the BEPS Project. It was an enriching experience to hear the stalwarts from both revenue and profession on this new topic.

 

In addition, there were quite a few non-technical but equally enriching personal development programmes such as Strategic Management from IIM-Ahmedabad by Professor Dr. Naman Desai, where delegates had the first-hand experience of strategic management lessons which was followed by the campus tour of IIM-Ahmedabad and a social visit to Swaminarayan Temple along with the water show and also entertainment by Singer Abhijeet Rao and his troupe during the Gala Night.

 

The Conference thus achieved its objective of affording the best of International Tax deliberations and learnings interspersed with useful non-technical sessions.

 

The participants were hugely enlightened from the sessions taken at the Conference.

 

Lecture Meeting on “Proposed GST Return Formats – Whether Simple enough?” held on 21st August 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

BCAS conducted a lecture meeting on a technical topic “Proposed GST Return Formats – Whether Simple enough?” on Tuesday, 21st August 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall. The lecture was delivered by CA. Samir Kapadia who informed the audience regarding the challenges in the present return filing system and significant features of the proposed GST returns format and manner of processing thereof. He also explained to the audience the problems to be overcome for the proposed return filing process to achieve its desired results. The Society has created a dedicated email id:  issues_gstreturns@bcasonline.org on which public at large may consider posting the challenges and issues faced by them during the GST return filing process along with necessary screen shots wherever possible. The Society will communicate such issues to GSTN team at regular intervals and interact with them as an endeavour to assist GSTN Team in designing a hassle-free and efficient return processing platform.

 

The lecture meeting was very interactive and informative and ended with addressing few questions from the audience and vote of thanks to learned speaker.

 

TECHNOLOGY INITIATIVES STUDY CIRCLE 

 

Technology Initiative Study Circle on “Productivity Apps for Workplaces” held on 23rd August, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall 

 

Technology Initiatives Committee conducted a Study Circle Meeting on Productivity Apps for Workplaces on 23rd August, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall which was ably led by CA. Rajesh Pabari who is an HR Consultant by Profession and aspiring management consultant by Passion.

 

In the present scenario, mobile technology plays a key role in oral and written communication within and outside the workplace, to enhance productivity in the organisations. In this context, CA. Rajesh Pabari covered important web based applications (Trello, Evernote, Wunderlist, Mightytext, GoogleDocs, Spreadsheet, Blinkist, edX, Drupe, etc), Desktop applications ( AnyDesk, PDFill, LibreOffice, Calibre, AgentRansack, Flux, XiliSoft, Foxit, Evernote) and important chrome extensions (MyWot, Trello, LastPass, Extensify, Evernote, WebClipper, Nimbus Screenshot, MailTrack, Grammarly, Loom, Mercury Reader, HoverZoom) etc., to make the participants understand the importance of these applications, to achieve the objective of go green and thereby increase efficiency and reduce costs.

 

The session was followed by Q&A session where the Speaker thoroughly addressed all the queries of the participants. The study circle was truly enthralling and the participants appreciated the in-depth insight given by the learned speaker.

 

Narayan Varma Memorial Lecture held jointly with Dharma Bharathi Mission and Public Concern for Governance Trust on 24th August, 2018 

 

The third Narayan Varma Memorial Lecture was delivered by the guest speaker Mr. Vallabh Bhansali on the topic “Rebuilding India” on 24th August 2018 at K. C. College Mumbai. In terms of rotational arrangement agreed for hosting the event, this year the main host was Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society. Dharmabharti Mission (DBM) and Public Concern for Governance Trust (PCGT) were co-hosts.

 

The speaker recalled his memories with late Mr. Narayan Varma and informed that the topic was the most apt from the point of view of the belief system late Narayan Varma practiced. He said the word “rebuilding” connoted bringing about change in things as they stand. Changes are triggered by human beings on what bothers them based on their area of influence. While most ordinary people make attempt to change only things that fall within their area of influence, Mr. Varma – the great leader that he was, would take things that bothered him head on without bothering about his area of influence. He focused on what was needed to be done to redeem the problem believing that area of influence will enlarge. This is the context on which India could rebuild itself, the speaker advocated.

 

Explaining the context, he said that a well-known researcher has found that India had 40-45% share of world GDP for 1800 years as compared to 2.5% now. This is why it needs to rebuild itself. Countries like China and Korea which were far smaller in their share could overtake India because they believed in their vision and planned for it and auctioned it without bothering about other things. In fact, China had one hundred year plan document to pursue their goal to change their fate, overcome challenges that lay ahead. But not deterred by the uncertainties, it just went ahead and made great stride with discipline and persistence.

 

The speaker emphasised that to rebuild India what is needed is a change of our mindset. Shikayat Nahi Shuruat (No complaints, just take the initiative) is the mantra that needs to be practiced. Generally changes in the society are brought about by Government, Corporates, Charities and Individual citizens either singly or in collaboration with each other. Indian mindset is to wait for the government to do everything to bring about a required change.  However, this slows down the change and makes it inefficient. This is what has deprived India of several opportunities despite its tremendous advantages in terms of topography, demographics, largest arable land and vegetation, variety of climate and innovative mindset of its people.

 

Elaborating his argument, the speaker said that he believed transformational change could be brought about to rebuild India only through strong belief backed up by Governance, Value Education and collaboration of its constituent viz. Government, Corporates, Charities and Individuals. Governance meant creating eco system of rules, regulations, code of conduct and design model that can measure and monitor progress. Value education meant inculcating a value system to think beyond oneself and take an inclusive view to contribute towards nation building. He said that ground level progress will be visible only when residents become citizens first and transform themselves into actizens.

 

To explain his arguments, he gave example of his recent projects. He said that in a recent project, to aid drought affected area of Maharashtra, he realised how massive the challenge was. The unanimous opinion was that temporary aid will not be the solution. It needed end to end solution which meant creating an eco-system that can prevent droughts. The target was huge, resources requirements were massive and a bold thinking was must. That is when belief was developed that it could be done with meticulous design model, collaboration of corporates, individuals and government. A detailed proposal was made with comprehensive governance system and it achieved great success by more than expected response from corporates and the government. A proposal that started with just one district as model is now being extended to many affected districts. All this with extraordinary low costs as compared to what just an individual constituent would have spent.

 

Another prerequisite he mentioned was about “Value Education” which is the backbone of progress for any society. Lamenting the legacy of education system, he said that there is hardly any emphasis on the subject of civics that brings civility in the citizens. He said that he was involved with building a value education curriculum that could change the way the young students think to ultimately rebuild India as strong and vibrant country of nationalist citizens. Realising that this could be done only with support of the government, he took it up with the government of Goa and Maharashtra who were more than enthusiastic. After initial pilots, both governments are adopting the project for all the schools run by them in their state. This is the power of collaborative efforts which with right design and belief could do wonders to bring about a change. The take away of the matter is that if one feels strongly for the cause, the ability to make the change happen will follow.

 

Stating that corporate governance in current times was a critical issue, he said that corporates could think of a “Custodian” who could be the focal point for right governance. If there is a strong will to have better governance then it will be followed by needed government regulations and training.

 

Concluding his speech he said that we can certainly rebuild India provided we develop spirit like Narayan Varma to do even a small bit to change the situation that bothers us by being constructive and not critical.

 

The speech was followed by a Q&A session.

 

Next item to follow was the presentation of award by each of the three organisations to the awardees for their selfless contribution to the society. The awardees were:

 

1. Mr. Atul Doshi Awardee -BCAS
2. Mr. Achyuta Samanta Awardee – DBM
3. Mr.Anil Galgali Awardee -PCGT
A short introduction of their work in their respective field was given to the audience by short film and by narration as applicable.

 

A well-deserved vote of thanks was given by Shri Paramjeet Singh, the President of DBM. The meeting was coordinated and compered by CA. Mihir Sheth.

 

ITF STUDY CIRCLE

 

Study Circle Meeting on “Taxation of Profits from Shipping and Air Transport under DTAA” held on 27th August, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

International Taxation Committee organised ITF Study circle on 27th August, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall which was led by CA. Sonia Agrawal, who initially began with an explanation about various operations of Shipping and Aircraft companies within India and outside India. She explained various types of vessels that Indian companies hire from foreign shipping companies and how they function commercially. Similarly, various types of aircrafts which are leased/used by the Indian residents from foreign companies and their operations with regards to cargo/passenger and mobility and use were deliberated in brief. Taxation of profits under presumptive taxation as per Section 44BB and 44 BBA with the difference in taxation and nexus with Section 172 were also explained in detail with examples.

 

The participants resolved their questions and queries with the group leader and further discussion with regards to Article 8 as per the Treaty will be taken up in the forthcoming meeting to be held on 4th October, 2018.The members of the Study Circle discussed their experiences on above mentioned issues and the participants benefitted from the discussion on the subject.

 

Intensive Study Course on “Internal Audit 101: Let’s Start at the Very Beginning” held on 30th and 31st August, 2018 

 

The Accounting and Auditing Committee organised a 2-day Foundation Course on Internal Audit 101 at Orchid Hotel, Mumbai. The course witnessed a full-house, well represented by participants from the profession as also from the industry. The entire course was conceptualised and curated by the newly formed GRC subgroup of the Accounting and Auditing Committee.

 

The course was inaugurated by a welcome address by President CA. Sunil Gabhawalla and opening remarks by Chairman CA. Himanshu Kishnadwala that set the tone for the entire event. The first session, by CA. Jyotin Mehta provided an overview of Internal Audit and the regulatory framework within which it operates. CA. Satish Shenoy unfolded the story by narrating various real life incidents that had the audience rocking with laughter – his unique style provided excellent learning with a big dose of entertainment.

 

CA. Atul Shah meticulously took the participants through the tools and tricks of the trade, by sharing audit techniques deployed at each stage of audit. His tremendous preparation and eye for detail was appreciated by one and all. CA. Nandita Parekh took everyone back to the drawing board on the basics of Risks and Controls – the simplicity of her talk along with a vivid presentation reinforced the core concepts that form the heart of internal audit.

 

The second day commenced with CA. Ashutosh Pednekar, who talked about specific cycle audit. His real life examples and interesting stories captivated the audience. CA. Deepjee Singhal’s session focused on the meeting point of Technology and Internal Audit and covered the entire gamut of areas where use of technology would be a game-changer. His session drove home the point that extensive use of technology tools is no longer a luxury for Internal Audit, it is a necessity for survival.

 

CA. Mario Nazareth, the only guest faculty, held the participants completely spellbound during his 2 hour long presentation on “The Art of telling a Good Story”, a session designed to help participants write and present compelling reports. His presentation, laced with audio visuals, pictures and graphs impressed one and all, and provided a fabulous end to the individual sessions.

 

The 2 day event ended with a panel discussion focussing on “Internal Audit should be at the forefront of an organisation, not a backroom function”. The distinguished panellists were CA. Deepjee Singhal. CA. Satish Shenoy, CA. Mrugesh Shah, CA. Sandip Joshi and CA. Mario Nazareth. The panel discussion, anchored by CA. Nandita Parekh, provided varied views and insights on key issues of internal audit and the rapid fire round brought an interesting finish to this vibrant, energetic 2 day foundation course.

 

The course lived up to its promise of delivering the sessions in a “story-telling” style with anecdotes, real life incidents and practical insights to deliver a unique and interesting experience for the participants who got invaluable insights from the sessions of speakers.

 

Full Day “Seminar on Charitable Trusts – Critical Aspects” Jointly with Chamber of Tax Consultants held on 1st September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall 

 

Corporate and Allied Laws Committee of the Society jointly with the Chamber of Tax Consultants organised a Full Day Seminar on Charitable Trusts on 1st September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall, to discuss the critical aspects and recent developments in this sector.

 

President CA. Sunil Gabhawalla in his opening remarks briefed the participants about the recent development happening in the field of Non-Profit organisation sector. He also highlighted the challenges as well as the opportunities available to the practicing chartered accountants in this sector. President of Chamber of Tax Consultants Mr. Hinesh Doshi also appreciated the initiative taken up by BCAS in organising such event and shared his views on the compliance and other related issues of charitable trusts.

 

The Seminar was inaugurated by Mr. Bharat Vyas – Deputy Charity Commissioner, Maharashtra. He also took the 1st session on Important Procedural Aspects for Trustees and Professionals wherein he shared his views on the recent changes in the Bombay Public Trust Act, FCRA etc., and various other procedural aspects relating to the formation and annual certification relating to the charitable trust.

 

The second session was addressed  by CA. Gautam Shah who enlightened the participants about various Compliances and Issues under the Maharashtra Public Trust Act. He also highlighted about duplication and other practical challenges faced by the practitioners in relation to the charitable trusts.

 

In the third session, CA. Gautam Nayak discussed various issues relating to the Taxation of the Charitable Trusts including the issues arising out of the rejection of the registration of various charitable organisations. He also briefly explained various judicial pronouncements relating to issues e.g. Depreciation on Assets, carry forward of losses etc.

 

During the fourth session, CA. Sanjay Agarwal from Delhi enlightened the participants about various issues relating to the registration and renewal of FCRA license. He also discussed the common issues relating to the separate books of accounts, issues relating to administrative expenses and other important aspects to be considered during the filing of the FCRA returns. He then deliberated on the issues arising after 2016 amendment in the definition of Foreign Source which invited lot of discussion amongst the participants. He also briefly touched upon the issues arising in CSR donations in relation to the receipt of grant vs. service contract.

 

The implication of Goods & Service Tax (GST) on the non-profit organisations has always been an area of debate since July 2017. Fifth session on this topic was taken by Mr. Shailesh Sheth who addressed the participants on various issues relating to the GST in respect of charitable trusts. He also discussed various judicial precedents which can be considered to determine the applicability and other consequential provisions of GST on the charitable organisations.

 

At the end, there was a Panel Discussion under the Moderation of CA. Gautam Shah wherein Mr. Satyanarayan Raju – Addl CIT (Exemptions), CA. Gautam Nayak and Mr. Noshir Dadrawala discussed various issues relating to the charitable trusts. The floor was opened for Q&A session where panellists answered all the queries of the participants.

 

The seminar was very interactive and full of insights into the charitable trusts and the participants were truly enriched with the presentation and the in-depth insights given by all the Speakers. The Seminar received an overwhelming response from the industry as well as practicing chartered accountants in the field of Non-Profit Organisations.

 

STUDENTS STUDY CIRCLE

 

Students Study Circle on “Recent  Amendments in GST Laws” and “New GST Return Filing Procedure” held on 4th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

The Students Forum under the auspices of HRD Committee organised a Students’ Study Circle on the captioned topics on 4th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall.

 

The study circle was led by student group leaders Mr. Jimit Doshi and Mr. Hardik Goyani under the mentorship of CA. Raj Khona. The student co-ordinator Mr. Dhruval Shah introduced the mentor, group leaders and briefly explained the topics. CA. Rajesh Muni, Chairman of the HRD Committee addressed the students and encouraged them to actively participate in the events organised by the Students Forum. Both the group leaders thoroughly covered their respective topics in a very interactive manner. CA. Raj Khona guided the students by explaining implications and rationale behind the recent amendments in a simplified and lucid manner.

 

The group leaders and the mentor also answered various queries raised by the participants. The study circle was an insightful experience for the participating students.

 

INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS STUDY GROUP

 

Meeting on “Trade War to Currency War to Economic War” held on 4th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall 

 

International Economics Study Group held their meeting on 4th September, 2018 to discuss “Trade War to Currency War to Economic War” at BCAS Conference Hall. The Speaker, CA. Rashmin Sanghvi talked on Economic war detailing – how United States of America has been using this tool to harm other Countries. He specifically brought out case of 1992 breakup of USSR into 15 independent republics without firing a single bullet. He brought out various measures USA is taking to adversely affect economy of many nations and highlighted cases of many countries besides USSR. He also highlighted that many countries like Russia, China, Germany & France are raising voices as to why should International Transactions be carried out in Dollar using “SWIFT” even though USA is not a party to such transactions. Sanctions on Iran & Turkey are termed as “Weaponising the Dollar” whereby Dollar is used to harm countries that do not follow US diktats.

 

CA. Harshad Shah highlighted ongoing Trade War that USA unleashed against China and other nations with tariff being raised on many goods and currencies of many countries are getting hurt in the process. There appears to be a greater “Economic War” being playing out between “current Super Power” USA and its “Challenger” China. USA is employing “Trade War” and Dollar is strengthening against most of other currencies and depreciation of Indian Rupee is part of that. Many countries (China, Venezuela, Turkey, Iran, Pakistan etc.) are experiencing economic turmoil & crisis. In case of Iran, the currency has depreciated more than 100% and in case of Turkey, it is over 40%, both of whom are experiencing after effect of Trade War and Economic Sanctions.

 

CA. Milan Sangani suggested that present exercise is more of renegotiating terms of trade in typical style adopted by President Trump. There may not be any Trade War. The tensions will ease once renegotiations are carried out like in the case of USA & Mexico. The meeting was a good takeaway for the participants where the experienced and learned speakers answered their queries as well.

 

Lecture meeting on “GST Audit – A Curtain Raiser” held on 5th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

A lecture meeting on the topic “GST Audit – A curtain raiser” was held on 5th September, 2018 at BCAS conference hall which was addressed by CA. Parind Mehta. In the beginning of the meeting, a book on “Exports and Export Refunds under the GST Law” by CA. Chirag Mehta was released by the hands of the Speaker.

 

During his speech, CA. Parind Mehta discussed the scope of GST audit vis-a-vis recommended draft reports of ICAI and BCAS. He elaborated upon comparatives of both the drafts with positives and negatives. He discussed various reconciliations involved at different stages of GST audit.  He also made the participants aware about challenges in undertaking first GST audit and cautioned them about clarity of role of auditee and auditor and importance of auditee preparedness before undertaking the audit. CA. Parind Mehta responded to the various queries raised by the participants who benefitted a lot from the meeting.

 

FEMA STUDY CIRCLE

 

Study Circle Meeting on “Overview of FEMA” held on 6th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

A FEMA Study Circle Meeting was held on 6th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall where CA. Natwar Thakrar led the discussion on the topic of Overview of FEMA covering Residential Status, Overall Structure, Important Definitions, Notifications and Circulars etc., amongst others. In continuation of earlier meeting on the same subject, the Group Leader deliberated upon residential status by giving examples.

 

He also brought to the notice of the participants that definition of an NRI and Person of Indian Origin have changed and one needs to be careful while advising NRI clients as to who can make investment in India in various assets. He discussed prohibited transactions under section 3 of the Act and shared a compounding order which dealt with violation under section 3.

 

The participants were delighted with the valuable insights on the subject and got their queries on various important definition and changes made in the law resolved.

 

Workshop on “Developments in Audit Reporting, etc., for Audit for 2017-18” held on 6th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

The Accounting & Auditing Committee organised a full day workshop on Developments in Audit Reporting, etc., for Audits for 2017-18 on 6th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall. Vice President CA. Manish Sampat gave the opening remarks. Chairman of Accounting & Auditing Committee CA. Himanshu Kishnadwala then briefed on the need for such workshop & relevance of the topics selected. The following topics were taken up at the workshop by the learned Speakers:

 

Developments & Issues in Accounting Standards CA. Rajesh Mody
Critical FRRB observations on financial statements CA. Abhay Mehta
Audit Reporting Requirements CA. Zubin Billimoria
Developments in Companies Act, 2013 CA. Paresh Clerk

 

CA. Rajesh Mody started the first session highlighting the important issues in revised Accounting Standards. He took various case studies to explain the important aspects of the revised standards and their impact on financial statements. He also dealt with the changes expected in next 2-3 years and how those changes are going to affect the Accounting fraternity dealing with Indian GAAP.

 

CA. Abhay Mehta took the participants briefly through critical observations made by FRRB based on the reviews conducted by the Board and published for the benefit and course correction by the C.A. fraternity, in preparing the financial statements. He also covered critical observations in the areas of Accounting Standards, Auditing Standards & Company Law compliances.

 

CA. Zubin Billimoria spoke on new Audit Reporting Requirements and the changes in reporting requirements which will be applicable for the reporting period ending 31st March, 2019. He particularly covered in detail the “Key Audit Matters” (KAM) which is going to have very wide impact on the way the Audit Report is prepared. He also covered important Audit Reporting Requirements like Emphasis of Matter (EOM) Paragraph, Modified Report, Qualified Report and Disclaimer of Opinion.

 

CA. Paresh Clerk addressed the last session of the workshop dealing with recent changes in Companies Act, 2013. He discussed at length various inconsistencies in the definition under Companies Act, 2013 & Accounting Standards. He also covered many relevant sections of the Companies Act, 2013 which are important for the Auditor for the year 2017-18.

 

The sessions were very interactive and the speakers shared their insights on the subject. The participants benefited immensely with the guidance and practical views on various issues expressed by the faculties.

 

Interactive session with Students for “Success in CA Exams” held on 8th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

The BCAS Students Forum, an initiative of HRD Committee, organised an Interactive session with students for success in CA Exams on 8th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall.  Ms. Labdhi Shah, the student co-ordinator introduced the speakers CA. Mudit Yadav and CA. Nikunj Shah and briefly shared about BCAS and BCAS students forum. CA. Rajesh Muni, Chairman of the HRD Committee addressed the students and encouraged them to actively participate in the events organised by the Students Forum.

 

CA. Mudit Yadav, who himself was a student participating through the activities of Students forum few years back is now a life coach and a motivational speaker. He took the students through his own journey of being student to a Chartered Accountant who cracked CA final exams in first attempt.

 

CA. Nikunj Shah who has a vast experience in teaching in the past, was hands on and completely aware of the challenges faced by students. He provided practical tips and tricks to be implemented in order to qualify as a Chartered Accountant. At the end, CA. Jigar Shah, the in-charge of students’ activities briefed the participants about the forthcoming events and thanked the speakers for sharing their knowledge on the subject.

 

Both the speakers guided students on how to crack CA exams and left the audience spell bound with their invaluable insights.

 

HRD STUDY CIRCLE

 

Study Circle Meeting on “Sound Sleep and Lung Care for Good Health” held on 11th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall

 

Human Resources Development Committee organised a meeting on 11th September, 2018 at BCAS Conference Hall, to discuss the topic “Sound Sleep and Lung care for Good Health” which was presented by Dr. Nimish Shah. The Speaker covered the importance of Sound Sleep and Lung Health. Basic knowledge of sleep, abnormal sleep, insomnia and consequences were discussed. He also spoke on common respiratory ailments, precautions and tests with treatment options for each.

 

Adequate Sleep and lung health are two of the most important elements for a good lifestyle. Sleep deprivation and not maintaining proper lung health leads to many health issues which sometimes turn fatal.

 

The Speaker also answered the queries of the participants who benefitted a lot from the session.

Miscellanea

1. Technology

 

1.      
When will ultrafast internet
5G come to your phone?

 

A surge in mobile-data
demand worldwide has more and more people asking when they will get that speedy
next-generation 5G mobile service. Companies are wondering, too, since 5G has
the potential to revolutionise everything from self-driving cars to robotic
surgery. Mobile providers are racing to patent technologies that will form the
industry standards and build working networks. Yet not all nations are
embracing the push with equal vigor. And concerns about China’s ability to use
5G equipment to spy on other nations may limit its manufacturers’ ability to
profit from the world’s next mobile upgrade.

                      

5G simply stands for
fifth-generation mobile networks or fifth-generation wireless systems. It will
be the successor to 4G, the current top-of-the-line network technology first
introduced commercially in 2009. 5G could end up being 100 times faster than
4G, with speeds that could reach 10 gigabits per second.

 

South Korea showed off the
world’s first commercial use of 5G at the Pyeongchang Winter Olympics in February.
China started trials in more than a dozen major cities this year. In the U.S.,
Verizon Communications Inc., will offer the first 5G internet and TV service in
five cities — Houston, Indianapolis, Los Angeles, and Sacramento, California —
beginning Oct. 1. Verizon will provide the service via portable hot spots
called pucks.

 

These are not standard 5G
gear, though Verizon says it will switch to standardised equipment when it
becomes available. AT&T Inc., says it will be the first with a standards-based
service; later this year it will test 5G devices in Atlanta, Dallas, Waco,
Texas, and two North Carolina cities, Charlotte and Raleigh.

 

5G mobile tests also need
special handsets, transmission hardware and software and a system design that
does not interfere with 4G and 3G networks. And governments need to set aside
mobile spectrum space for 5G. The equipment is being built. China’s Huawei
Technologies Co. Ltd., says it has about 50 contracts with wireless carriers to
test its equipment. Nokia and Ericsson AB each have $3.5 billion contracts with
T-Mobile US Inc. Some telecommunication companies are looking to join forces to
provide more money and reach to develop 5G networks.

 

T-Mobile has promised to
invest $40 billion in a 5G network that will reach 90 percent of the U.S.
population by 2024. But claims are easy to make and trials are easy to pull
off. The real test will be the first field deployment serving large numbers of
customers in a technically challenging urban area. No provider has yet implemented
that kind
of network.

 

(Source
www.financialexpress.com)

 

2.      
Facebook is hiring human
rights policy director to promote peace and prevent conflict.

 

In the recent years,
Facebook has faced severe criticism for its failure to take greater
responsibility for the spread of hate speech and fake news on its platform.
Despite knowing the fall outs of the impact of its platform, the company has
failed to take substantial measures to solve the problem and minimise the
damage. But things are changing and in one of the many measures aimed to
improve the present situation, Facebook has decided to hire a Director of Human
Rights Policy to promote peace and build strong communities. “We are looking
for a Director of Human Rights Policy to coordinate our company-wide effort to
address human rights abuses, including by both state and non-state
actors,” the company wrote in a job listing on its page.

 

The human rights policy
director will hold a critical position at Facebook and will be expected to
perform a number of tasks including- ‘coordinating and advising the company’s
teams working on human rights, conflict prevention, peace-building, and related
projects’; ‘working with Product, Public Policy, Community Operations, and
Security teams to identify and work to disrupt actors that seek to misuse its
platforms and target its users and support those using our platforms to foster
peace-building and enable transitional justice’; ‘working within Facebook’s
Product Policy team to formulate policies that govern user, advertiser, and
developer behavior on its platform’; and ‘representing the company in meetings
with politicians, policymakers, NGOs and civil society groups’ among other
things.

 

In the recent times,
Facebook-owned WhatsApp has been criticised for spreading misinformation which
in turn has led to mob lynchings across the country and death of over a dozen
people. In Myanmar, the social media giant has been accused of ethnic cleansing
of Rohingya Muslims. The company’s role in spreading hate speech against the
Muslim minority in Myanmar had also been cited by the UN investigators.
Meanwhile, in the Philippines, the company stands accused of playing an
important role in the election of President Rodrigo Duterte, who is accused of
covering up at least 12,000 extrajudicial state-sponsored killings since he
assumed the office. The platform has also been used by “keyboard warriors”
in Libya to hunt and kill their enemies.

 

These are some of many incidents
where Facebook’s platform has been used for violence. At a time when Facebook
is struggling to keep its head above the water and prevent its platform from
being misused, the appointment of a human rights policy director shows is one
of the many steps that the company is taking to fix its platform. More
importantly, it represents a serious effort on part of the company in fixing
everything that is wrong with its platform.

 

(Source:
www.indiatoday.in)

 

3.      
Can health services handle
the Apple Watch?

 

When Apple announced two
major new healthcare features this week, it billed them both as terrific
innovations that may well keep us alive. Later this year, Apple Watch will be
able to automatically call emergency services if it detects you have suffered a
fall and are no longer moving. And it will also let you know if you have heart
problems and should perhaps visit your doctor as soon as possible. Other
devices have offered similar functions in the past, albeit in less elegantly
presented gadgets. But with an estimated 50 million Apple Watches out there
already, there are concerns about the pressures it may bring to
already-strained healthcare systems.

 

The result may be even more
calls to emergency services and, according to one of Britain’s leading
surgeons, a new wave of technology-driven hypochondria. “Medical
professionals will also need to be vigilant to the risk of misdiagnosis and
overtreatment that this proliferation of personalised health information could
bring,” said Richard Kerr, chairman of the Royal College of Surgeons’
commission on the future of surgery.

 

(Source:
www.bbc.com)

 

2.  World News

 

4.      
Tax haven link to rainforest
destruction and illegal fishing

 

Some 68% of the investments
tracked in the Amazon came from companies based in countries where no tax is
paid. The analysis shows that of the almost $27bn of foreign capital that was
transferred to key companies involved in beef and soy production in the Amazon
between 2000 and 2011, more than $18bn was transferred from tax haven
jurisdictions. The biggest provider for these activities was the Cayman
Islands. “It is not illegal!” said Victor Galaz, the study’s lead
author, from the Stockholm Resilience Centre. “This is part of the
internal financing of companies, but we need a better assessment of the
environmental consequences of the uses of tax havens both legal and
illegal.” “What we can see in the data, in these sectors there are
subsidiaries placed in tax havens that are providing loans to activities in
Brazil and the Amazon. That you can see.”

 

When it comes to illegal
fishing, around 70% of known vessels are registered in tax havens. Illegal,
unreported and unregulated fishing is also a major blight on the oceans of the
world but according to this paper, the vast majority of the boats involved are or have been flagged under a tax haven
jurisdiction, in particular Belize and Panama.

There is a bit of a double
whammy going on when it comes to illegal fishing as these tax havens are often
what are known as ‘flag of convenience’ states – meaning essentially that the
governments in these countries do not prosecute if the ships on their register
are involved in illegal activities.

 

“The global nature of
fisheries value chains, complex ownership structures and limited governance
capacities of many coastal nations, make the sector susceptible to the use of
tax havens,” says co-author Henrik Österblom, also from the Stockholm
Resilience Centre.

 

While the Paradise Papers
and the Panama Papers exposed how wealthy individuals and companies dodged
personal and corporate taxes, this new study claims to be the first to show
that tax havens have a significant environmental impact as well.

 

(Source:
www.bbc.com)

 

5.      
Amazon chief Jeff Bezos
gives $2bn to help the homeless

 

Jeff Bezos, the founder and
chief executive of Amazon, is well on his way to becoming the richest person in
the world, with a net worth of more than $80 billion. What’s less certain is
what he plans to do with his fortune, and how he could reinvent philanthropy.

 

After
questions from The New York Times about the level of his giving, Mr. Bezos
posted on Twitter a “request for ideas” for philanthropy. “I’m thinking about a
philanthropy strategy that is the opposite of how I mostly spend my time —
working on the long term,” he wrote. “For philanthropy, I find I’m drawn to the
other end of the spectrum: the right now.”

 

Citing a homeless program
in Seattle, Amazon’s hometown, that the company is working with, he said he was
seeking to help people “at the intersection of urgent need and lasting impact,”
adding, “If you have any ideas, just reply to this tweet…”

 

Mr. Bezos, who owns about
17 percent of Amazon, has enjoyed what could be the most rapid personal-wealth
surge in history. As Amazon’s share price has more than tripled since 2015, its
leader has added more than $50 billion to his net worth, bringing his current
total to nearly $83 billion, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index. He
is now less than $7 billion shy of taking the title of the world’s richest
person from Bill Gates, who has held the crown for 18 of the past 23 years.

 

(Source:
nytimes.com)

 

3.  Survey

 

6.      
Indian demi-billionaires to
rise by 70% by 2022

 

The analysis highlights
that in five years time the number of demi-billionaires in Asia will overtake
those in North America for the first time. As the list of wealthy Indians with
over USD 500 million or more in assets grows, the number of demi-billionaires
is poised to grow by 70 per cent by 2022. According to a report by Knight
Frank, India, which had 200 demi-billionaires in 2017, this number is slated to
increase to 340 in 2022. “Prime residential markets in cities such as
Mumbai and Delhi have remained largely stable in the last five years, which
creates a good entry opportunity for buyers. The increase in number of
demi-billionaires clearly underscores the potential for demand and price growth
going forward,” the report said.

 

The analysis highlights
that in five years’ time the number of demi-billionaires in Asia will overtake
those in North America for the first time. Wealth data specialists Wealth-X
predict that there will be almost 3,000 people based in Asia who have more than
USD 500 million in assets by 2022.

 

“Strong global
economic growth, as well as rising asset prices as key drivers behind the
growth in the world’s demi-billionaire population. By 2022, Wealth-X
anticipates that there will be 9,570 demi-billionaires worldwide, up from 6,900
at the end of 2017,” it said.

 

(Source:
Moneycontrol.com)

 

7.      
More Indians plan to take
time off from work and take vacation in 2018

 

A survey conducted by Ipos
showed that a majority of Indians polled (83 per cent) said they will be
spending at least one week away from home on vacation in 2018. This is three
points higher than the previous year. “Companies are encouraging employees to
take a break and return rejuvenated,” said Parijat Chakraborty, executive
director, Ipsos Public Affairs.

Some other markets seeing a
significant increase over 2017 in those planning to go on vacation include
Turkey (74 per cent, up nine points), China (62 per cent, up eight points), and
Sweden (72 per cent, up six points). Some other markets experiencing a similar
upsurge compared to the previous year include Australia (53 per cent, up seven
points), France (66 per cent, up five points), and Saudi Arabia (81 per cent,
up five points).

 

Most Indians plan to use up
their entire entitled vacation days in a year. More Indians plan to use up
their entire quota of leave (72 per cent, up five points), compared to 2017,
the survey said. Those saying no to work emails and messages during vacation
has also seen a significant jump in 2018. More Indians are choosing to unplug
from work emails and messages (54 per cent, up five points), as against 2017.

 

Indians learning to switch
off from work while on vacation is a welcome change. With support from their
teams, it is becoming easier to disconnect as its business as usual,
otherwise,” Chakraborty added.

 

(Source:
www.business-standard.com)

Statistically Speaking

1. Tax return filing before due date:

Source: Live Mint

  1. Stupendous growth in the no. of returns e-filed by persons availing benefit of Presumptive Tax

Source: Twitter @IncomeTaxIndia

  1. Returns e-filed by salaried Individual taxpayers

Source: Twitter @IncomeTaxIndia

  1. The 4G play

Global 4G availability trends

Circle 4G availability score
Singapore 86.6%
Hong Kong 90.4%
Taipei 89.8%
Kuala Lumpur 80.8%
Yangon 82.8%

 

India’s top 5 circles on 4G LTE availability

Circle 4G availability score
Kolkata 90.7%
Punjab 89.8%
Bihar 89.2%
MP 89.1%
Odisha 89.0%

Source: OpenSignal, UK

  1. ITAT Litigation Snapshot for August 2018

Source: Taxsutra

Book Review

Title: Bean Counters – The Triumph of the
Accountants and How They Broke Capitalism

Author: Richard Brooks


A well-researched book that starts with tracing the history of double entry
booking keeping and its growth, need and usefulness to the industry from 1200
AD to its present state. It vividly traces the growth in stature of the “bean
counters” in the US, UK and European countries. A reader will find interesting
history of formation and merger and consolidation of firms leading to the Big 4
firms in its current avatar.

 

Interesting observations on the political
influence across countries of the Big 4 will be both a delight and an eye
opener for any serious reader and observer on the stature and influence of the
Big 4, while the same firms (in spite of rotation) controlling 99% of the
market. The styling of Big 4 in US and UK makes interesting reading which the
author details out in the book.

 

A view pre and post 1980 on the defined role
of Auditors by the author cannot but be missed by the reader where he observes
that “for generations members of these huge influential practices considered
themselves who happened to be in business but beginning 1980 they saw
themselves as businessmen who happened to be in profession.”

 

The author observing that the displaced key
performance indicators of Big4, being revenue growth and improved profit
margins followed by measures of staff and customer satisfaction while exposing
false accounting, fraud, tax evasion and risks to economies’, (everything that
the society might want from accountants) not featuring at all as a performance indicator of the firms, raises a basic question on the
very model that the firms have now become.

 

The observation on devising of legal
structure of the firms for worldwide domination while escaping the
responsibility away from home by the HQ by distancing itself from local
misdeeds elsewhere in the world, while profitably exploiting the name, brand
and commercial networks spills the beans of the operation of the Big 4. For the
few past decades all the firm’s global growth coming from selling more
consultancy services while its talent of turning any change into fee earning
opportunity discloses the growth strategy. In the digital age, cyber security is
the latest major growth engine for the firm’s consultants and now audit fees
worldwide account for 39% while it is 21% in UK making them consultancy firms
with auditing sidelines, rather than the other way around.

 

The author’s observations on the manner in
which the British Accountancy firms converted to LLP by stating it as “a shabby
episode in accountancy history” will not be missed by a reader. When the
Companies Act 1989 allowed accountants to operate as limited liability
companies, the partners were more wedded to the partnership for the tax
advantage that came with being self-employed rather than company directors.

 

The ease of sending money across borders in
the age of financial liberalisation allowed the multinational companies to
break up businesses and park more profitable parts where they would be lightly
taxed and the “bean counters showing them (the companies) how to do it by
exploiting their expertise thereby siphoning billions of euros from hard
pressed economies” shows the bean counters in poor light. It is interesting to
note that the users of such services are leading multinational multibillion
dollar companies, goes to showcase the inter dependency of the multinational
and the Big 4.

 

A list of hundreds of active tax products
under various acronyms by the bean counters makes the author opine that “in
simple truth these were little more than shams.”

The author’s bold statement on the mastered
art of “revolving door” of senior personnel brings closeness that breeds
uniform market oriented view of the public and provides an insight into the
prevalent practice. “So smoothly and frequently the revolving door is spun that
it creates a realistic hope amongst ministers and mandarins that subject to
keeping them happy the Big 4 will present career opportunities to supplement
their pensions.”

 

The 2008 financial crisis proved to the
contrary the assertions of President Bush that “era of false profits are over”
just six years earlier, speaks volumes about the unreformed and unrepentant
approach and influence of the Big 4. The author clearly links a clear nexus
during the period in the US towards lobbying donations to senators and
Congressmen through political action committee by the Big 4 employees hitting
record levels and the reforms being blocked fairly easily.

 

The author has very pertinent and far
reaching suggestions that cover separation of accounting and consultancies,
having strong independent regulations, bring in transparency, suggesting public
auditing of major institutions of the government, ending the “quadropoly” which
brings accountability demands an immediate detailed relook.

 

The book published this year by
AtlanticBooks, UK comes in at the most appropriate time for India when read in
the backdrop of recent Hon. Supreme court judgement of February 2018 and the
vision of the Hon. Prime Minister of India, on Indian Audit firms becoming
world leaders. Any serious reader and well-wisher of audit profession of our
country will find that this book serves a road map towards establishing a new structure
of the audit profession by learning from the mistakes of the West so very well
documented in book.
 

 

Ethics and You

Arjun
(A) — (alone, chanting prayers)

 

Hare Ram Hare Ram Ram Ram Hare Hare

Hare Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare

 

He Bhagwan ! I can’t see
you anywhere. There is a deep darkness all around; and you are also dark
(Krishna) in complexion!

 

Hare Ram Hare Ram Ram Ram Hare Hare

Hare Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare

 

Shreekrishna enters – (smiling at the sight of Arjun)

 

S — Re
Arjun, What’s the matter? Can’t you see me? I am omnipresent. I am there in
your heart.

 

A —
You are right; but I have lost my heart. I have lost everything! I have lost my
senses!

 

S — Cool down, Arjun. I had told you in Geeta that one has to be “sthitapradnya”
– always cool and collected. Never lose your balance. Tell me what happened.

 

A — Nothing is happening!

 

Clients
are not coming in time. Accounts are not ready. Audits are pending. Articled
trainees are on exam leave. So many difficulties! And Government is not
extending the date.

 

S — That’s your annual grumbling. Why don’t you improve your ways
and become pro-active?

 

A — It is very easy to say so. But our profession is essentially
reactive. Government, regulators and clients do something and we are expected
only to react and also act! We can do audits only after the clients’ accounts
are finalised. Government keeps on changing the forms, regulators introduce new
systems; new requirements without understanding practical realities.

S — But now with computerisation everything is digitised.

How is it that the work is
not completed on time.

 

A — Many clients are not tech-savvy. They rely on us. Small
businessmen, senior citizens, charitable organisations, housing societies and
such other people are not used to the `digital environment’.

 

S — So you mean, you alone have to take care of 1000 such small
clients!

 

A — Precisely! And further, in case non-audit assessees the date
was extended from 31st July to 31st August. So, the July
load was carried forward to August 2018. Further GST requirements are keeping
us busy round the year! – It is a big volume.

 

S — Why don’t you represent to the Government?

 

A — We are doing it repeatedly; but it is falling on deaf ears. We
are helpless. Our Institute had made an excellently drafted convincing
representation – and it was rejected on 3 occasions! Actually, there is
something structurally wrong in the present statutory deadlines.

 

S — Relax. You will get extra time.

 

A — But when? On 29th September? – when we have
virtually, somehow pushed the returns!

 

S — That means, somehow or the other you can do it!

 

A — No. Really speaking, it is humanly impossible. And quality
suffers; let alone the stress that affects health.

 

S — But you have to stick to your discipline and ethics. You can’t
afford to compromise on quality. That will defeat the very purpose of audit.

 

A — Yes. Everybody expects that CAs should maintain discipline,
give quick results and at the same time ensure quality! Further we have to
ensure many compliances on day-to-day basis. Hence, we don’t have time for
creative and meaningful work.

 

S — You say there is no room for creativity; but in all scams
Government feels that it was the ingenuity of CAs.

 

A — That’s the pity. Real thieves are different; but everywhere CAs
are blamed. CAs are expected to perform the role of fraud-detectors even in the
normal audit! No one realizes that there is difference between audit and
investigation. I at times wonder why I became a CA!

 

S — Don’t be so nervous. Things will improve.

 

A — I don’t see any chance of that. We are facing humiliation
everywhere. Everybody is taking us for a ride. – Government, regulators,
clients, bankers, staff, even our articled trainees!

 

Everybody is deviating from
ethics.

 

S — That is Kaliyug. But you should never compromise on
ethics. You need to be more firm and assertive.

 

A — I am aware of all this philosophy. Unfortunately though we are
not a part of unethical acts, we are expected to certify the reporting is
correct and `true and fair’.

 

S — It seems, your grievances are unbearable today.

 

A — Yes. We have no choice. By nature, we are not rebellious. But
sometime, our feelings are going to explode. Hell with this compliance
practice! They are thrusting everything on us; and on the top of it, Government
is not even listening to our genuine requests.

 

S — So, what to do now?

 

A — Arey Bhagwan, when I am helpless, I approach you with
this question. And today you are yourself asking me this question? So, you also
don’t have the solution, it seems!

 

S — Go to the Courts.

 

A — Ah! I am skeptical about it. And even if Court intervenes,
Government will not understand the spirit of the verdict. There is no savior
for us.

 

S — Hmmm!

 

A — And in this birth, becoming and practicing as a CA appears to
be a sin! So I don’t know what is going to
happen in next birth.

 

S —  We will see of next
birth. But what are you going to do now?

 

A — Beg to FM, wait, watch and chant bhajan –

 

Hare Ram
Hare Ram Ram Ram Hare Hare

 

Hare
Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare

 

Note: The above dialogue only shows how various stakeholders have taken
our fraternity for granted. It’s high time we put our foot down and unite
together. Though, preaching on Code of Ethics seems old school, this is the
only thing that will help us.


Corporate Law Corner

1. 
Bhagavan Das Dhananjaya Das vs. Union of India [2018] 96 taxmann.com 189
(Madras)

W.P. NOS. 25455 OF 2017 AND 25456, 25729,
26654, 16903, 16970, 16995, 16999, 17151, 17161 of 2018 & Oths.

Date of Order: 3rd August, 2018

 

Section 164(2) of the Companies Act, 2013 –
Disqualification of directors – The provision which came into effect on
01.04.2014 cannot be given a retrospective effect especially when the
disqualification clause did not trigger in the previous regime

 

FACTS

B was a
director of B Co a private limited company incorporated under the Companies
Act, 1956 (“1956 Act”). He was also a director in other company S Co which was
also a private limited company incorporated under the 1956 Act. B Co had no
operations and was lying dormant till the year 2012.

 

In the year
2012, the directors planned to revive the company and there was infusion of
additional share capital as well as introduction of three new members to the
Board of B Co (one of them being Mr. B). The revival plan did not fructify and
B Co continued to remain a dormant company. B Co did not file its annual
returns from financial year 2012-13. The last annual return filed was in
respect of financial year 2011-12.

 

Registrar Of Companies (“ROC”) on 18.03.2017
issued a show cause notice for striking off the name of B Co. There being no
plans to revive the company, B Co issued a no objection letter to the ROC for
striking off. On 08.09.2017 ROC issued a list of directors disqualified u/s.
164(2)(a) of Companies Act, 2013 (“2013 Act”) which included name of B as well.
Accordingly, B would be prohibited from acting as a director in any other
company for a period of 5 years.

 

Aggrieved, B filed a writ petition before
the Hon’ble Madras High Court. B contended that provisions of section 164(2)(a)
came into effect from 01.04.2014. Applicability of the section would commence
in respect of financial years commencing from 01.04.2014 and should not apply
in respect of offences committed prior to that date.

 

HELD

The High Court examined the provisions of
section 274(1)(g) of 1956 Act and section 164 (2)(a) of the 2013 Act. The
former section only disqualified a director from being appointed as a director
in any “public” company for a period of 5 years which was broadened under the
2013 Act to any company. The High Court observed that section 164(2)(a) was
made effective from 1.4.2014, as per section 2(41) of the 2013 Act, the first
financial year for the purpose of section 164 of the 2013 Act would be
31.3.2015 i.e., from 1.4.2014 to 31.3.2015. ROC thus wrongly applied section
164(2)(a) from financial year 01.04.2013.

 

The High Court further held that the
disqualification of directors of a private company could get triggered only on
or after 30.10.2017, hence, the list of disqualified directors published on the
website of the first respondent in September, 2017 had no legal legs to stand
up to the scrutiny of the Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

 

It was observed that General Circular
No.08/14 dated 4.4.2014 also has made it clear that in respect of the financial
year commencing on or after 01.04.2014, the provisions of the new Act shall
apply, the first financial year for the purpose of section 164(2)(a) shall be
1.4.2014 to 31.3.2015 and the second and third financial years would be from
1.4.2015 to 31.3.2016 and from 1.4.2016 to 31.3.2017 respectively.

 

The High Court observed that by virtue of
the first proviso to section 96(1) of the 2013 Act, Annual General Meeting for the
year ending on 31.3.2017 can be held within six months from the closing of
financial year i.e., 30.9.2017, additionally in the light of section 164(2)(a)
referring to “annual return” and “financial statement”, the
time limit to file annual return u/s. 92(4) of 2013 Act is sixty days from
Annual General Meeting or the last date on which Annual General Meeting ought
to have been held, hence, the time limit to file balance sheet u/s. 137(1) of
the 2013 Act is again thirty days from Annual General Meeting. The
disqualification could get triggered off only on or after 30.10.2017 only, if
any company fails to file annual forms for three financial years. Even beyond
that time limit, additional time limit of 270 days was available by virtue of
the then first proviso to Section 403.

 

The High Court observed that ROC although
sent a show cause notice to B Co before striking off its name, it did not give
any such notice to B before disqualifying him as a director.

 

A company can be struck off if that company
has not been carrying on any business for a period of two financial years and
if their directors had not filed the financial statements or annual returns for
any continuous period of three financial years, they shall be, no doubt,
disqualified to be reappointed as a director of that company for a period of
five years from the date on which the said company fails to do so, whereas for
disqualification of the directors u/s. 164(2)(a), there must be a default for
not filing the financial statement or annual return for a continuous period of
three financial years.

 

The ROC should have sent a notice to B
before taking any action, as it affects its right to continue as directors in
other companies which are complying with the provisions of law.

 

The High Court however clarified that the
mischief of removal of the names of the companies by the Registrar of Companies
and the disqualification of the directors in the defaulting company will go
together, as it is inseparable, and the ROC need not give fresh notice to the directors
for their disqualification from the dormant company, if there is a failure to
file the financial statement or annual return for any continuous period of
three financial years as per section 164(2)(a).

 

The High Court thus set aside the order and
allowed the writ petitions filed before it.

 

2. 
Dinesh Kumar Bhasin vs. Batliboi Impex Ltd.[2018] 96 taxmann.com 94
(NCL-AT)

COMPANY APPEAL (AT) (INSOLVENCY) NO. 318 of
2018

Date of Order: 29th June, 2018

 

Section 9 of Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Code, 2016 – NCLT admitted the petition against the corporate debtor which was
filed by the operational creditor for default in payment of certain sum – A
shareholder of the corporate debtor challenged the admission on the ground that
the same was passed without hearing the corporate debtor – The order of the
NCLT was set aside – The dispute was already settled and hence, the same was
not remanded back to NCLT

 

FACTS

B Co filed an application u/s. 9 of the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“the Code”) for initiating corporate
insolvency resolution process against T Co (“Corporate debtor”). National
Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”) admitted the application, passed order of
‘Moratorium’ and pursuant to proceeding, an ‘Interim Resolution Professional’
was appointed.

 

Mr. D, a shareholder of T Co, objected to
the order of the NCLT on the grounds that an opportunity of being heard was not
afforded to B Co. Had B Co been heard, it could have pointed out the grounds
for rejection and in case of non-acceptance, it could have settled the dispute.

 

It was submitted to the NCLAT that T Co and
B Co had arrived at a settlement.

 

HELD

NCLAT held that the order of the NCLT was
passed without giving the corporate debtor an opportunity of being heard.
Accordingly, the same was liable to be set aside.

 

However, as the parties had already come to
a settlement, the same could not be remanded back to NCLT.

 

B Co was further ordered to bear the cost of
resolution professional appointed through the order of NCLT.

 

3. 
[2018] 96 taxmann.com 271 (SC)
State Bank of India vs. V. Ramakrishnan

CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 3595 & 4553 of 2018

Date of Order: 14th August, 2018

 

Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Code, 2016 – Moratorium for limited period mentioned in the Code would not
apply to personal guarantor of a corporate debtor – Amendment to section 14(3)
was clarificatory in nature and accordingly would have a retrospective
application

 

FACTS

V was the Managing Director of corporate
debtor and also its personal guarantor in respect of credit facilities availed
from State Bank of India (“SBI”). The guarantee agreement is dated 22.02.2014.
Owing to non-payment of debt, account of the corporate debtor was classified as
a non-performing asset on 26.07.2015 and proceedings under SARFAESI Act were
initiated.

 

On 20.05.2017 corporate debtor filed a
petition to initiate corporate insolvency resolution process against itself
which was admitted on 19.06.2017 and moratorium was statutorily imposed in
terms of section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“the Code”).

 

V took up a plea that moratorium would apply
to the personal guarantor as well and as a consequence the proceedings against
personal guarantor ought to be stayed. National Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”)
admitted the plea and restrained SBI from moving against V.

 

An appeal filed by SBI against the order of
NCLT before the NCLAT was also dismissed. The reasoning was that since the
personal guarantor can also be proceeded against, and forms part of a
Resolution Plan which is binding on him, he is very much part of the insolvency
process against the corporate debtor, and that, therefore, the moratorium
imposed u/s. 14 should apply to the personal guarantor as well.

 

HELD

Supreme Court examined various provisions of
the Code.


Section 2(e) as substituted by the Amendment Act, 2018 which came into effect
from 23.11.2017 specifically provides that provisions of the Code shall apply
to personal guarantors to corporate debtors. It was observed that Part III of
the Code titled “Insolvency Resolution and Bankruptcy for Individuals and
Partnership Firms” was not yet been brought into force. The repealing
provision, namely section 243, which repeals the Presidency Towns Insolvency
Act, 1909 and the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920, was also not been brought
into force. Section 249, which amends the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and
Financial Institutions Act, 1993, so that the Debt Recovery Tribunals under
that Act can exercise the jurisdiction of the Adjudicating Authority conferred
by the Code, was also not been brought into force.

 

Supreme Court observed that on a plain
reading, moratorium referred to in section 14 can have no manner of application
to personal guarantors of a corporate debtor. It was observed that so far as
personal guarantors were concerned, Part III has not been brought into force,
and neither has section 243, which repeals the Presidency-Towns Insolvency Act,
1909 and the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920. The net result of this was that
so far as individual personal guarantors were concerned, they will continue to
be proceeded against under the aforesaid two Insolvency Acts and not under the
Code. It was further observed that use of the word “bankruptcy” in section
60(2) of the Code would not include SARFAESI proceedings but only to the two
Insolvency Acts referred to above.

 

It was observed that the scheme of section
60(2) and (3) was thus clear – the moment there was a proceeding against the
corporate debtor pending under the Code, any bankruptcy proceeding against the
individual personal guarantor would, if already initiated before the proceeding
against the corporate debtor, be transferred to the NCLT or, if initiated after
such proceedings had been commenced against the corporate debtor, be filed only
in the NCLT. However, NCLT would decide such proceedings only in accordance
with the Presidency-Towns Insolvency Act, 1909 or the Provincial Insolvency
Act, 1920, as the case may be.

 

Section 31 which was relied upon by V, only
stated that once a Resolution Plan, as approved by the Committee of Creditors,
takes effect, it shall be binding on the corporate debtor as well as the
guarantor. Supreme Court observed that this was for the reason that otherwise,
u/s. 133 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, any change made to the debt owed by
the corporate debtor, without the surety’s consent, would relieve the guarantor
from payment. Section 31(1), in fact, makes it clear that the guarantor cannot
escape payment as the Resolution Plan, which has been approved, may well
include provisions as to payments to be made by such guarantor.

 

It was further observed that sections 96 and
101, when contrasted with section 14, would show that section 14 cannot
possibly apply to a personal guarantor. It was open for the Supreme Court to
mark the difference in language between sections 14 and 96 and 101, even though
sections 96 and 101 were not yet been brought into force. This was for the
reason that a law ‘made’ by the Legislature is a law on the statute book even
though it may not have been brought into force.

 

Upon examining the history of the Code and
previous enactments, the Court observed that Parliament, specifically did not
provide for any moratorium along the lines of section 22 of the Sick Industrial
Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 in section 14 of the Code.

 

It was observed that Amendment of 2018,
which makes it clear that section 14(3), is now substituted to read that the
provisions of section 14(1) shall not apply to a surety in a contract of
guarantee for corporate debtor. It was held that object of the Amendment was to
clarify an overbroad interpretation of section 14 and such the same was a
clarificatory amendment which would be retrospective in nature.

 

The order of the NCLT was thus set aside.  

 

Allied Laws

1.       Evidence – Admissibility of electronic
evidence without certification as required under the provision of the
Act–Valid. [Evidence Act, 1872; Section 64B]

 

Shafhi Mohammad vs. The State of Himachal
Pradesh SLP (CRL.) No. 2302 of 2017 dt. 30/1/2018 (SC)

 

An apprehension was expressed on the
question of applicability of conditions u/s. 
65B(4) of the Evidence Act to the effect that if a statement was given
in evidence, a certificate was required in terms of the said provision from a
person occupying a responsible position in relation to operation of the
relevant device or the management of relevant activities.

 

It was argued
that if the electronic evidence was relevant and produced by a person who was
not in custody of the device from which the electronic document was generated,
requirement of such certificate could not be mandatory, since if this is not so
permitted, it will be denial of justice to the person who is in possession of
authentic evidence/witness but on account of manner of proving, such document
is kept out of consideration by the court in absence of the certificate.

 

The Court
clarified the legal position on the subject of the admissibility of the electronic
evidence, especially by a party who is not in possession of device from which
the document is produced. It held that such party cannot be required to produce
certificate u/s. 65B(4) of the Evidence Act. The applicability of requirement
of certificate being procedural can be relaxed by Court wherever interest of
justice so justifies.

 

2.      
Co-Operative Housing Societies
– Voluntary Donation by members of Housing Societies at the time of sale – Even
though voluntary – Can be read as voluntarily with pressure – Illegal.
[Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act]

 

Alankar Sahkari Griha Rachana Sanstha
Maryadit, through Chairman S.K. vs. Atul Mahadev Bhagat and Anr. Writ Petition
No. 4457 of 2014 dt. 31/08/2018 (Bom.)(HC). www.itatonline.org

 

The facts of
the case are that a donation of Rs. 5,00,000/- was made by the respondents to
the Petitioner society. It was alleged by the Respondent that the amount
of  Rs. 5,00,000/- was paid for the
purpose of regularising the transfer of plot to a third party by the respondents.

 

The Petitioner
pointed out that there has been admission on the part of the Respondents with
respect to the amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- being a donation.

 

It was held
that, after the completion of construction of the bungalow, the Respondents
were in need of money and therefore they decided to sell the plot. On the
background of such facts, a person facing financial difficulties will not
donate an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- to the housing Society. Even though in the
present case, the Respondents have given admission that they paid Rs.5,00,000/-
towards donation to the Petitioner-society, it cannot be further read that it
was paid voluntarily without any pressure.

 

Hence, it was
concluded that the amount paid was not donation but money was a transfer fee paid
out of compulsion and it was not a voluntary payment.

 

3.      
Natural Justice – Additional
Evidence – Chance for rebuttal. [CPC, 1908; O.41, R. 27]

 

Akhilesh Singh vs. Lal Babu Singh and Ors.
(2018)4 SCC659

 

A suit seeking
partition of their share in joint family properties was filed by the sons of
the grandfather of the Appellant. The suit was decreed and the Respondents
aggrieved, preferred an appeal. Various applications were filed for accepting
additional evidence. Since, nobody had appeared on behalf of the Appellant, the
High Court proceeded with the hearing of the appeal and relying on additional
evidence set aside the judgment and decree of the Trial Court. Aggrieved by
such order, the present appeal was preferred. It was held by the Court that the
Appellate Court before which any statement in sale deeds was relied ought to
have given an opportunity to lead evidence in rebuttal or to explain the
admission. Opportunity to explain the admission contained in the sale deeds was
necessary to be given to the contesting party. Accordingly, the High Court
order was set aside.

 

4.      
Precedent – Matter pending
before the Supreme Court – No stay granted neither set aside – Law laid down by
the co-ordinate Bench to be followed.

 

Industrial Mineral Co. (IMC) vs. Commissioner
of Custom. 2018 (15) G.S.T.L. 249 (Mad.) (HC)

 

In the present
case, the adjudicating authority had mentioned that the case on hand is similar
to another case, passed by the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate
Tribunal, where the said case has been questioned by the Department, before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and that the issue is yet to reach a finality.

 

The Court was
of the view that when the order passed by the Tribunal has not been stayed or
set aside by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is the bounden duty of the
adjudicating authority to follow the law laid down by the Tribunal. Since a
binding decision has not been followed by the adjudicating authority in this
case, this Court can interfere straightaway without relegating the assessee to
file an appeal. Accordingly, the order
passed by the Tribunal was quashed.

 

Goods And Services Tax (GST)

1.  [2008-TIOL-149-AAR-GST]
Coffee Day Global Ltd dated 21st August, 2018

 

The GST rate applicable to
Restaurant Services classified under heading 996331 is 5% (CGST-2.5% and
SGST-2.5%) without availing input tax credit.

 

Facts

Applicant is in the
business of running restaurants under the name and style of Café Coffee Day
where non-alcoholic beverages and food items are served. Notification
No.46/2017 dated 14.11.2017 provides that restaurants can pay GST @5%
(CGST-2.5% and SGST-2.5%), provided they do not avail input tax credit of the
tax paid on input goods and services. Notification No.11/2017- CTR dated
28.06.2017, at Sl.No.35, provides for levy of GST @18% (CGST-9% & SGST-9%)
on supply of unclassified services and the suppliers are entitled to take input
tax credit in the circumstances where they pay output tax. The question before
the authority is whether Notification No.46/2017-CTR dated 14.11.2017 applies
in circumstances where the applicant does not avail input tax credit; that it
does not prevent a restaurateur from paying tax at 18% (CGST – 9% and SGST –
9%) and availing input tax credit.

           

Held

Services rendered by the
applicant are clearly defined under Service Code (Tariff) 996331 – restaurant
services covered under serial number 7 of the Notification 11/2017-CTR. As the
services provided are covered under a specific heading and the Notification
carves out a specific rate of tax for that heading, the same shall be
applicable. Serial number 35 would qualify for invocation only in respect
of  services that do not find
classification elsewhere, therefore, the applicant is covered by serial number
7 and not 35 (which covers heading 9997). Further right to avail input tax
credit is not an absolute right and conditions and restrictions may be
prescribed for its availment. Thus, Applicant is not entitled to pay the GST @
18% with input tax credit as the services being offered are classified under a
heading attracting GST @ 5%, without input tax credit.

 

2.      
[2018-TIOL-148-AAR-GST]
Emerge Vocational Skills Pvt. Ltd dated 13th August, 2018

 

Education Services in
affiliation with a University is exempted from payment of GST

 

Facts

Applicant is a private
limited company engaged in providing specified educational services in the
field of Hotel Management – advance ruling is sought on the question ‘whether
the services provided in affiliation to specified universities and providing
degree courses to students under related curriculums are exempt from Goods and
Services Tax vide entry no. 66 of the Notification No. 12/ 2017 – Central Tax
dated 28.06.2017.


Held

The Authority noted that
the Applicant has submitted that he proposes to obtain an affiliation with a University in the
State of Karnataka and shall thereafter be engaged in provision of education in
affiliation with the said university in the State of Karnataka. Since the
“Services provided by an educational institution to its students, faculty and
staff” is exempt from tax under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, they
qualify as an educational institution insofar as those courses for which
affiliation has been obtained from the University in the State of Karnataka and
for which University Curriculum is prescribed and the qualifications recognised
by the law for the time being in force is given
after the conduct of examinations by such University. The applicant is exempted
from Goods and Services Tax vide entry no. 66 of the Notification No. 12/ 2017
– Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017.
 

 

 

 

Service Tax

Tribunal

 

1.  [2018-TIOL-2674-CESTAT-MUM] K B Mehta
Construction Pvt. Ltd. vs. CST-Service Tax, Ahmedabad Date of Order: 12th July, 2018

 

When the service is
inclusive of supply of goods in such case, value of goods is exempted by
Notification 12/2003-ST.

 

Facts

Appellant entered into a
consolidated contract involving service and supply of raw material wherein sale
and service value was provided separately. The department contended that the
bifurcation into goods and services is artificial  and thus the total contract value is the
gross value of provision of service liable for service tax.

 

Held

The Tribunal noted that
when the service is inclusive of supply of goods, in such case the exemption in
respect of the value of the goods involved in the provision of services is
exempted by Notification No.12/2003-ST dated 20.06.2003. According to the
Tribunal, the Revenue did not make any effort to verify as to whether despite
making different invoices in respect of services and sale of the goods, the
value of service was suppressed and transferred to the transaction of sale of
the goods. Further, it was observed that they paid VAT in respect of those
invoices where the goods were shown to have been sold. Accordingly, it was held
that if the value shown in the sale invoices was correct towards the sale of
the goods, the same would not be chargeable to service tax in terms of
Notification No. 12/2003-ST dated 20.06.2003. The demand thus was set aside and
the matter was remanded to verify the above observation.

 

2.    
[2018-TIOL-2656-CESTAT-MAD]
International Travel House Ltd vs. Commissioner of Service Tax, Chennai Date of Order: 23rd March, 2018

 

There is no service
provider – service receiver relationship between inter-divisions and both are
one and the same entity. Cost of parking charges collected are in the nature of
reimbursable expenses and are not liable for service tax.

 

Facts

On perusal of ST-3 returns,
it was noticed in audit that assessee had not paid service tax on Parking
charges which their travel desk had collected from customers who were provided
with Rent-a-Cab Services, service charges which they received from their travel
division for booking air tickets for clients staying at the hotel and
Commission received from travel division for booking air tickets on behalf of
service provider. Show Cause Notice was issued proposing demand of service tax
under “Rent a Cab Services” and “Air Travel Agency
Services”. It was argued that the travel division undertakes the booking
of air tickets and raises an invoice charging service tax on basic fare, which
is forwarded to travel desk. The bills raised include the value of
inter-division services along with service tax and service charges. Since
service tax on basic fare is being discharged by travel division of assessee
company under Air Travel Agency Services, the demand on assessee treating these
two divisions as separate entities is incorrect.

             

Held

The Tribunal noted that the
company and its travel division are the same entity and there is no service
provider or service receiver relationship between these divisions. Thus, when
service tax is already discharged by the travel division on the basic fare, the
demand of service tax is without any factual or legal basis and requires to be
set aside. In regard to parking services, it is noted that while providing the
Rent-a-Cab service, the cost of parking charges is also collected. This is in
the nature of reimbursable expenses and therefore cannot be subject to service
tax, as decided in the case of Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats
Pvt. Ltd. [2018-TIOL-76-SC-ST].     

 

3.      
[2018] 96 taxmann.com 2
(Mumbai – CESTAT) Amby Valley City Developer Ltd. vs.
Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune-1
Date of Order: 8th June, 2018

 

The activity of allowing
complementary use of conference hall by hotel, to guests residing therein,
without charging any separate amount therefor cannot be charged on a notional
amount under “convention service”.

 

Facts

The appellant, owner of
hotel, while renting the rooms to various corporate entities, also allows use
of conference hall as complimentary and did not charge any amount separately
for said use of conference hall. The billing of rooms is done on the basis of
single occupancy or double occupancy and specifies that the additional facility
of conference hall, seating arrangements and audio visual will be provided.
Revenue alleged that such use of conference hall is liable to service tax as
provision of “convention services”. Whereas appellant submitted that they are
not separately providing “convention service” as alleged by department and the
conference hall charges are included in room tariff included in total bill i.e.
already loaded in value of taxable services on which service tax liability has
been discharged.

 

Held

The Tribunal noted that
appellant rented rooms and discharged service tax liability wherever
applicable. Further, no separate charges for Convention Center have been
charged and the use has been complementary. Therefore, the Tribunal held that
the demand is computed on notional basis and since the use of convention center
has been complementary, no service tax can be charged. Reliance was placed on
decision in Dukes Retreat Ltd. vs. C.C.Ex., [Final Order No.
M/86948-86949/17/STB, dated 13-4-2017] and Taj View Hotels vs. C.C.Ex. [2014]
47 taxmann.com 198/46 GST 601 (New Delhi – CESTAT)
. Accordingly, the demand
was set aside.

 

4.      
[2018] 96 taxmann.com 390
(Allahabad – CESTAT) Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax,
Noida vs. Fortune Cookie
Date of Order: 26th July, 2018

 

When assessee took
premises of golf course on rent and provided food to members of Golf Course
itself, Tribunal held that such services would be in the nature of “restaurant
services” and not “outdoor catering services”.

 

Facts

Respondent
took premises of Golf Course on rent and paid lumpsum amount to golf course.
From said premises, respondent was providing food to members of Golf Course.
Respondent treated said activity as provision of “restaurant services”, whereas
revenue contended that such activity is taxable as provision of “outdoor
catering service”.

           

Held

The Tribunal noted that the
“outdoor catering service” is to be provided at the premises of the
service recipient i.e. at his own premises or the premises taken on hire by the
service recipient, whereas in the case of “restaurant service”, the
service is to be provided by the service provider in its own premises. The
Tribunal observed that in instant case, the respondent i.e. service provider
renders services from its premises i.e. premises taken on rent from Golf
Course. It was also noted that in Tamil Nadu Kalyana Mandapam Assn. vs.
Union of India [2006] 4 STT 308 (SC)
, the Hon’ble Apex court held that the
service of restaurant and outdoor caterer are distinguishable. Further, the
Tribunal noted that the respondent maintains menu card, fixes prices for every
item and there is no personal interaction with service recipient in restaurant.
Accordingly, it was held that services provided by respondent qualify as
“restaurant services” and not “outdoor catering services” and set aside the
demand.  

 

5.      
[2018] 96 taxmann.com 28
(Bangalore – CESTAT) Hindustan Petrochemical Corporation Ltd. vs. CCE
Date of Order: 8th June, 2018

 

Undertaking certain
activities in relation to maintenance and safety of tank trucks and merely
issuing certificates to the effect that tank trucks are purged as required
under petroleum law cannot be regarded as provision of “technical inspection
and certification services”. 
    

Facts

The appellant is engaged in
the business of refining of crude and marketing of various petroleum products.
They have set up a facility to store the LPG and from there, the stored LPG is
sent to various LPG bottling plants of oil distribution companies through tank
trucks. Whenever LPG tank trucks require any repair or mandatory testing of
safety valves, the tanks are cleaned and completely degassed. For this
activity, the appellant collects cost of water, LPG and the labour charges from
the truck owners. On finding that the repairs to truck tankers had to be
conducted with the advance approval in writing and the repair work should be
conducted as per the code IS 2825/BS 5500, department alleged that the
certificates issued by appellant imply that appellant has certified purging of
truck tankers as required under petroleum law and thus, the activities
undertaken by appellant would be chargeable to service tax under “technical
inspection and certification services”. 

 

Held

Hon’ble Tribunal noted that
the appellants are not basically an agency involved with testing and
certification and the activities performed by them make the truck tanks fit to
be filled with LPG for further transportation. Thus, the Tribunal held that
though appellant performed certain activities in relation to the maintenance
and safety of tank trucks and issued certificates to the effect that the tanks
are purged/degassed, such activities of appellant would be construed only as an
activity related to safety and maintenance of the tank truck. Accordingly, the
Tribunal concluded that since appellant has not fulfilled the conditions so as
to impart the activity of purging and degassing tank trucks as ‘technical
inspection and certification service’, the demand was set aside.

 

6.      
[2018] 96 taxmann.com 323
(New Delhi – CESTAT) Ivanhoe Cambridge Investment Advisory India (P.) Ltd. vs.
Commissioner of Service Tax, Delhi
Date of Order: 27th March, 2018

 

Investment advisory
services provided by Indian service provider to foreign service recipient in
relation to investment opportunities in India, would not be chargeable to
service tax under category of “real estate agency services”.

 

When experts provided by
foreign holding company to Indian subsidiary, had employer-employee relation
with Indian subsidiary, The Tribunal set aside demand under “manpower
recruitment or supply agency services”.  

 

Facts

The appellant renders
non-binding investment advisory service to its holding company located abroad.
Scope of such services includes identification and advise on investment
opportunities to holding company in diverse sectors including real estate
sector, providing financial and economic market intelligence reports, providing
information on investment targets, structuring of investments as well as exit
options etc., and thereby, enables the foreign company to take decisions on
investment opportunities in India. Department alleged that such advisory
services are in the nature of “real estate agency services” and thus, liable to
pay service tax under reverse charge mechanism.

 

Further, the foreign
holding company of appellant provided certain expatriates to appellant who were
experts in the area of investment advisory and they were employed by appellant.
Department alleged that appellant supplied manpower to principal and thus, liable
to service tax under category of “manpower recruitment and supply agency
services”.

 

Held

As regards demand under
category of “real estate advisory services”, the Hon’ble Tribunal noted that in
terms of “Advisory Service Agreement” entered into between appellant and its
holding company, appellant was required to render investment advisory services
in connection with investment opportunities in India and such services were rendered
relating to real estate sector. Also, Tribunal categorically noted that the
scope of the agreement did not cover such advisory services in connection with
any piece of real estate. The Tribunal even observed that various judicial
decisions relied upon by appellant not only support the view canvassed by
appellant but also have held that such activities will be in the nature of
export despite the fact that the contract companies are in India.
Consequently, it was held that services provided by appellant cannot be said to
be covered within the scope of “real estate agency services”. 

 

As
regards demand under “manpower recruitment and supply agency services”, the
Tribunal noted that the terms and conditions under which the expatriates were
placed at the disposal of the appellant are governed by “employment secondment
agreement”. The Tribunal noted that the payment letters issued by appellant to
the expatriates made it clear that such expatriates would be employees of the
appellant during the period of their assignments. Also, the income tax returns
filed by expatriates show appellant as their employer and Income-Tax has also
been paid for the amounts received by the expatriates in India, under the
category of salary. Therefore, the Tribunal held that as the appellant and
expatriates enjoyed employer-employee relationship with appellant, the demand
under “manpower recruitment and supply agency services” would not sustain.

 

7.      
[2018] 96 taxmann.com 549
(New Delhi – CESTAT) Olam Agro India Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise,
Delhi-III
Date of Order: 31st July, 2018

 

The commission paid by
Indian company to its foreign parent company towards corporate guarantee
extended by such parent company in favor of Indian banks, so as to facilitate
provision of bank guarantee by such Indian banks to appellant, is liable to pay
service tax under “business auxiliary services”.

 

Facts

Appellant engaged in
agricultural business was exporting agricultural products. For obtaining loan
from various Indian banks, appellant obtained corporate guarantee from its
foreign parent company in favor of Indian banks. In lieu thereof, the appellant
paid commission amounting to 1 per cent of the value of such corporate
guarantee to their parent company. The Revenue contended this was liable for
service tax under category of “business auxiliary services” under reverse
charge mechanism as services were provided by parent company to appellant in
relation to procurement of service by Appellant. However, appellant contended
that such commission was paid to parent company towards providing guarantee for
obtaining loan by the appellant and not for procurement of any service.
Appellant relied on decision in case of Abdullabhai Abdul Kader vs.
Commissioner 2017 (4) GSTL 38 (Tri Mum.),
wherein it was held that
providing the facility of L/C through their bank to various importers cannot be
charged to service tax under the category of “Business Auxiliary Service” since
it was not in connection with procurement of goods which are inputs for the
clients. It was further submitted that as the parent company did not procure
services from bank for the appellant, there cannot be said to be provision of
business auxiliary services.


Held

Hon’ble Tribunal noted that
a corporate guarantee is used when a corporation agrees to be held responsible
for completing the duties and obligations of debtor to a lender, in case the
debtor fails to comply with the terms of the debtor- lender contract; whereas a
bank guarantee is a promise from a bank that the liability of the debtor will
be met in the event the debtor fails to favour his contractual obligations.
Therefore, the nature of corporate guarantee as well as of bank guarantee is
one and the same i.e. for facilitation of the lending facilities. The Tribunal
observed that in present case the foreign parent company executed corporate
bank guarantee in favor of appellant for facilitation of lending of funds to
the appellant and in turn, received guarantee commission by way of foreign
exchange remittance from appellant. It was found that periodic debit notes were
issued by parent company on appellant towards guarantee commission. This
indicated that the transactions were with regard to lending facilities in
India, it was held that changing name from ‘bank’ to ‘corporate’, it cannot be
said that guarantee commission paid by appellant would not get covered as
“business auxiliary services”. Demand was thus upheld.

GLIMPSES OF SUPREME COURT RULINGS

1.      
The Peerless General Finance
and Investment Company Ltd. vs. CIT (2019) 416 ITR 1 (SC)

 

Capital or revenue receipt – Deposits by
way of subscription pursuant to investment schemes made by subscribers which
have never been forfeited are capital receipts – Nature of receipt cannot be
decided only by the treatment of such subscriptions in the accounts of the
assessee

 

The assessee company had floated various
schemes which required subscribers to deposit certain amounts by way of
subscriptions in its hands and, depending upon the scheme in question, these
subscribed amounts at the end of the scheme were ultimately repaid with
interest. The schemes also contained forfeiture clauses as a result of which
if, midway, a certain amount was forfeited, then the said amount would
immediately become income in the hands of the assessee.

 

For the assessment years 1985-86 and
1986-87, the AO treated these amounts as income inasmuch as under the
accounting system followed by the assessee, these amounts were credited to the
profit and loss account for the years in question as income. The Commissioner
of Income Tax (Appeals) dismissed the appeal from the original assessment
orders and confirmed the same. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, on the other
hand, allowed the appeals by relying upon the judgement of this Court in Peerless
General Finance and Investment Co. Limited and Anr. vs. Reserve Bank of India,
(1992) 2 SCC 343
in which, according to the Appellate Tribunal, the
Supreme Court finally decided the question in the assessee’s own case stating
that such amounts cannot be treated to be income but are in the nature of
capital receipts. This was not only because of the interpretation of an RBI
circular of 1987, but also because, on general principles, such amounts must be
treated to be capital receipts or otherwise they would violate the provisions
of the Companies Act.

 

It further went through the various clauses
contained in the scheme and found that in point of fact no subscription
certificate had, in fact, been forfeited as a result of which it was clear that
there would be no income in the hands of the assessee for these two years. It
also dealt with certificates that were surrendered prior to the stated time and
stated that in such cases whatever would remain as surplus in the hands of the
assessee would be treated as income. It went on to state that there would be no
estoppel in law against the assessee making a claim that these amounts
were in the nature of capital receipts and not income, and also relied upon
certain judgements of the Supreme Court to buttress the proposition that the
Supreme Court had also held that what is the true position in law cannot be
deflected by what the assessee may or may not do in its treatment of the matter
at hand in its accounts. The appeal against the order of the Commissioner of
Income Tax (Appeals) was allowed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal.

 

In the first round, the High Court, by its
judgement dated 9th September, 1999 stated that since no question of
law arose, the reference applications before it were dismissed.

 

The Supreme Court, by an order dated 3rd
December, 2002 set aside the High Court judgement and referred the questions of
law to the High Court.

On remand, the High Court, by the impugned
judgement dated 6th October, 2005, allowed the appeal against the
Appellate Tribunal holding that a perusal of the subscription scheme of the
company showed that since forfeiture of the amounts deposited was possible,
this amount should be treated as income and not as a capital receipt. Further,
it relied heavily upon the fact that the assessee had itself treated such amounts
as income and credited them to its profit and loss account for the years in
question and would, therefore, be estopped by the same. Referring to the
judgement of the Supreme Court in Peerless General Finance and Investment
Co. Limited (Supra)
, it went on to state that since the said judgement
dealt with an RBI circular of 1987, which itself was only prospective, any law
declared as to the effect of clause 12 of that circular would be prospective in
nature and would, therefore, not apply to the assessment years in question.

 

On an appeal by the assessee company, the
Supreme Court observed that the question raised in the appeal was as to whether
receipts of subscriptions in the hands of the assessee company for the previous
years relevant to the assessment years 1985-86 and 1986-87 should be treated as
income and not capital receipts inasmuch as the assessee has in its books of
accounts shown this sum as income.

 

The Supreme Court noted that the
subscriptions were received in the years in question from the public at large
under a collective investment scheme and these subscriptions were never at any
point of time forfeited. It observed that this being the case and surrendered
certificates not being the subject matter of the appeal before it, it was clear
that even on general principles deposits by way of amounts pursuant to these
investment schemes made by subscribers which have never been forfeited could
only be stated to be capital receipts.

 

The Supreme
Court held that while it was true that there was no direct focus of the Court
on whether subscriptions
so
received were capital or revenue in nature, still the Supreme Court had also,
on general principles, held that such subscriptions would be capital receipts
and if they were treated to be income it would violate the Companies Act. It
was, therefore, incorrect to state, as had been stated by the High Court, that
the decision in Peerless General Finance and Investment Co. Limited
(Supra)
must be read as not having laid down any absolute proposition
of law that all receipts of subscription at the hands of the assessee for these
years must be treated as capital receipts.

 

The Supreme Court reiterated that though its
focus was not directly on this, yet, a pronouncement by the Supreme Court, even
if it could not be strictly called the ratio decidendi of the judgement,
would certainly be binding on the High Court. Even otherwise, it was clear that
on general principles also such subscription could not possibly be treated as
income. In cases of this nature it would not be possible to go only by the
treatment of such subscriptions in the hands of accounts of the assessee itself.

 

In the circumstances, the Supreme Court set
aside the judgement of the High Court and restored that of the Income Tax
Appellate Tribunal. The appeal was allowed. 

 

FROM THE PRESIDENT

Dear Members,


On October 2, 2019, the
whole world will celebrate the 150th birth anniversary of the
‘Father of the Nation’ – Mahatma Gandhi. India will mark the event, both
nationally and internationally, by propagating the message of the Mahatma. A
national committee headed by the Prime Minister has been set up for this
purpose. We at BCAS are also making efforts to celebrate this momentous
occasion in a unique way. The October, 2019 issue of the BCAJ carries
special articles and a collage of quotes and thoughts of Gandhiji. We have also
planned an event for members which will include a talk by a senior Gandhian on
the ‘Gandhian’ way of life, some of Gandhiji’s favourite bhajans, a short skit
by members, followed by poetry recitation and exchange of thoughts on
Gandhiji’s principles.

 

There are many lessons from the Gandhian way of
life that we can adopt in our lives. The one Gandhi thought that has made an
everlasting impression on me is: ‘Service which is rendered without joy helps
neither the servant nor the served’. This is very, very true. I try to practice
this in my personal and professional life. In today’s fast and frenzied age, we
are totally immersed in providing service to our clients or the organization
where we work, but the question we need to ask ourselves is, ‘Are we happy with
what we are doing’? If the work that we are doing gives us pleasure and
satisfaction, that is a big motivating factor which keeps us going. It is
rightly said that ‘all other pleasures and possessions pale into nothingness
before service which is rendered in a spirit of joy’. So let us work with this
mindset of joy and enjoyment for ourselves, motivate our staff and students to
enjoy what they are doing and look forward to another day with anticipation;
let us reach our workplace happily every morning rather than out of compulsion,
without energy or enthusiasm.

 

On a different note, on August 26, 2019 the RBI
transferred a record Rs. 1.76 lakh crore of its surplus for F.Y. 2018-19 into
the government’s coffers (more than that of the preceding three years). As per
Section 47 of the RBI Act, 1934, the balance of the RBI remaining after making
all required provisions shall be paid to the Central Government. The current
year’s highest-ever transfer was a result of bumper / higher / exponential
surplus and a one-time exceptional transfer from RBI’s Contingency Fund
amounting to Rs. 52,000 crore. Transfer of surplus funds from Central Banks to
their respective governments has always been a topic of debate and discussion
across the world because every government likes to extract the maximum and the
Central Banks want to retain the surplus to make the balance sheet stronger.
The Dr. Bimal Jalan Committee constituted for this purpose recommended that the
equity reserves be in the range of 6.5% to 5.5% of the balance sheet size (it
was 6.8% prior to this transfer). The recommendations of the Committee were
accepted and reserves in excess of the minimum 5.5% (Rs. 52,000 crore) were
allowed to be transferred, thus leaving no buffer for future contingencies.
Further, the transfer came from a bumper profit triggered by interest income
and gains from foreign exchange transactions. Further, as per the
recommendations of the said Committee, the unrealised gains sitting in the
RBI’s balance sheet have remained untouched.

 

The government has not yet come out clearly about
how and where it intends to use this windfall bonus. Ideally, it should be used
for purposes like recapitalisation of public sector banks, reduce government
borrowing to control the fiscal deficit target, or provide a much-needed
stimulus to a slowing economy, rather than a thoughtless carnival of government
spending. Later, in September, the Finance Minister announced huge direct tax
cuts to boost investments and consumer spending and it appears this revenue
loss will be fully met out of the RBI surplus. Hopefully, this is a one-time
solution and the exception does not become the rule and precedent for future
governments.

 

Before I sign off, 
let me offer my warm wishes to you and your family on the joyous
occasion of Diwali! May this auspicious festival of lights illuminate every
pore of your being by adding sparkling moments of Love, Happiness, Success, Joy
and Good Health.

 

With Best Regards,

 

CA Manish Sampat

President

 

FEMA FOCUS

(i) LIBERALISATION OF THE FDI REGIME

On 28th August,
2019 the Union Cabinet chaired by the Prime Minister approved several proposals
for review of Foreign Direct Investment in the coal mining, contract
manufacturing and single brand retail trade sectors. A press release stated
that the Cabinet had approved major proposals for relaxation of the existing
Foreign Direct Investment Policy (FDI Policy) in these sectors:

 

COAL MINING

Proposal

Permit 100% FDI under
automatic route for sale of coal, for coal mining activities, including
associated processing infrastructure, subject to provisions of the Coal Mines
(Special Provisions) Act, 2015 and the Mines and Minerals (Development and
Regulation) Act, 1957 as amended from time to time, and other relevant acts on
the subject. ‘Associated Processing Infrastructure’ would include coal washery,
crushing, coal handling, and separation (magnetic and non-magnetic).

 

CONTRACT MANUFACTURING

Proposal

The present FDI policy
provides for 100% FDI under automatic route in the manufacturing sector. There
is no specific provision for contract manufacturing in the policy. In order to
provide clarity on contract manufacturing, it has been decided to allow 100% FDI
under automatic route in contract manufacturing in India as well.

 

Foreign
investment in ‘manufacturing’ sector is under automatic route. Manufacturing
activities may be conducted either by the investee entity or through contract
manufacturing in India under a legally tenable contract, whether on
principal-to-principal or principal-to-agent basis.

 

Comments

The law proposes to clarify
that manufacturing need not be done by the FDI entity but can also be done by
any other entity. This proposal will set to rest concerns expressed by some
quarters that contract manufacturing is a trading activity because a company
only sells a product after getting it manufactured.

The contract manufacturer
need not be a group company or working exclusively for an FDI entity. Further,
the arrangement can be on principal-to-principal or principal-to-agent basis.
Thus, the policy includes the typical contract manufacturer as also the toll
manufacturer.

 

A manufacturer is permitted
to sell products manufactured in India through wholesale and / or retail,
including through e-commerce, without government approval.

 

Thus,
this proposal is likely to open up a number of opportunities for retail trading
and promote label products without inviting extant restrictions applicable to
retail trading.

 

SINGLE BRAND RETAIL TRADE (SBRT)

Proposal

As per the existing FDI
policy, 100% FDI is allowed under automatic route for SBRT activity. However,
there are various conditions that need to be fulfilled. The government has
relaxed some of these conditions to attract more FDI for SBRT activities in
India.

 

Local
sourcing norms

The existing FDI policy
provides that in respect of the SBRT entity having more than 51% FDI, the
sourcing of 30% of value of goods purchased must be done from India only. In this
regard, the SBRT entity is permitted to set off its incremental sourcing of
goods (by non-residents undertaking SBRT in India either directly or through
their group companies) from India for global operations against the mandatory
30% local sourcing requirement during the initial five years only. After five
years, the SBRT entity is required to meet the 30% sourcing norms directly
towards its India operations on an annual basis.

 

With regard to the above,
the government has now proposed to relax these conditions as under:

 

Local
sourcing for domestic as well as export sales by SBRT entity:

All the procurements made from India by the SBRT entity for the single brand
shall be counted towards local sourcing, irrespective of whether the goods
procured are sold in India or exported, and the same would apply even beyond
the initial five years.

 

Incremental
sourcing vs. year-on-year sourcing:
As per
the extant policy, only that part of the global sourcing is considered for
abovementioned set-off towards local sourcing requirement which is over and
above the previous year’s value, i.e., only incremental sourcing is considered
for set-off against local sourcing requirements. The government has now decided
the entire (and not the incremental) sourcing from India for global operations
shall be considered towards local sourcing requirement.

 

Direct and indirect sourcing: It has also been decided that the global sourcing would cover sourcing
of goods from India for global operations not only by non-residents undertaking
SBRT in India either directly or through their group companies (resident or
non-resident), but also by an unrelated third party, done at the behest of the
SBRT entity or its group companies under a legally tenable agreement.

 

E-commerce

As per the existing policy,
an SBRT entity must operate through brick-and-mortar stores before starting
retail trading of that brand through e-commerce. However, the government has
now decided to allow retail trading through online trade prior to opening of
brick-and-mortar stores, subject to the condition that the SBRT entity opens
brick-and-mortar stores within two years from the date of start of online
retail.

 

DIGITAL MEDIA

Proposal

The
extant FDI policy provides for 49% FDI under approval route in up-linking of
‘News and Current Affairs’ TV channels. It has been decided to permit 26% FDI
under government route for uploading / streaming of news and current affairs
through digital media on the lines of print media.

 

Comments

(i) This
proposal has given rise to more questions than answers. FDI policy in print
media and broadcasting content service provides for uplinking news and current
affairs TV channels and were defined;

(ii) There
was no clarity in law for FDI in digital media. As per one view, since
uploading / streaming of news and current affairs through digital media is not
covered by sectors or activities listed in Regulation 16 of FEMA 20(R)/2017,
FDI up to 100% was permitted under automatic route;

(iii)
Thus, considering the exponential growth, internet penetration, reducing prices
of smart phones and so on, Indian companies engaged in digital media invited FDI
investments, such as Quint, Dailyhunt, Huffpost, VC Circle, etc. A question
arises on FDI investments made in such companies. Will the law require such
companies to reduce FDI holding?

(iv) In
case of startups engaged in said activities, cap on foreign investment may
hamper future funding as such startups will have to rely on domestic investors
to raise capital;

(v) It is a popular practice for media companies to stream news live on
their apps and websites (e.g., Republic TV, NDTV News, Aaj Tak Live TV, etc.).
Extant FDI policy provides for 49% FDI under approval route in up-linking of
news and current affairs TV channels. Now, the proposal provides 26% limit for
streaming news through digital media. Thus, the issue arises whether differing
FDI threshold will mandate media companies to house digital media in a separate
company and comply with FDI norms. Even if the division is spun off, the
company will be required to give exit to FDI investors which may be a
complicated affair;

(vi)
Further, the proposal brings uploading / streaming of news and current affairs
through digital media under government route. This may result in delays and
mandatory compliance with conditions imposed by ministries concerned;

(vii)
Impact of the above proposal on streaming services offered on social media
platforms such as Facebook and Google is also not clear, or whether foreign
digital news websites that can be accessed in India will continue to be
available or not;

(viii) It
is not clear whether OTT platforms such as Zee5, Hotstar, Voot and others that
have both entertainment and news content would be covered under the 26% or the
49% FDI regime.

 

Since the
policy announcement is yet to be legislated, one expects that the fears
expressed by the media industry will be adequately clarified.

 

(ii) ANALYSIS OF RECENT COMPOUNDING
ORDERS

An analysis of some interesting compounding orders passed by the Reserve
Bank of India in the month of August, 2019 and uploaded on the website1
are given below. The article refers to regulatory provisions as existing at the
time of offence. Changes in regulatory provisions are noted in the comments
section.

_________________________________

1   https://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/Compoundingorders.aspx

 

 

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT (FDI)
COMPOUNDING ORDERS

A.    Dharmpal
Agarwal (for self and on behalf of Vineet Agarwal, Chander Agarwal, Urmila
Agarwal, Priyanka Agarwal & Chandrima Agarwal)

Date of order: 19th July, 2019

Regulation: FEMA 3/2000-RB Foreign Exchange Management (borrowing and
lending in foreign exchange)

 

ISSUE

Availing
of foreign currency loan overseas, for the purpose of purchasing property
abroad

 

FACTS

(a) The
applicant and the others, resident individuals, jointly acquired a residential
property in Singapore at a total cost of SG$ 3,032,320;

(b) SG$
606,464 was met through remittances under LRS; the remaining amount of SG$
2,425,856 (Rs. 6,78,26,933) was paid by availing a loan from OCBC Bank,
Singapore;

(c) During personal hearing it was submitted that instalments for
repayment of loan and payment of interest (EMIs) with respect to the loan were
met out of the proceeds of lease rental received on the lease of the property;

(d) In the
initial years of loan repayment, reduction in principal amount of loan was
small and the interest component made up a large part of the EMI. Therefore,
considering the total amount paid under EMIs on the loan over the years, the
applicant ended up effectively re-paying more than the amount of loan;

(e) The
applicant and the others have sold the property and repaid the loan. The
applicant submitted that he had not made any gains through availing loans
overseas for acquisition of the property abroad.

 

Regulatory provisions

Regulation
3 of Notification No. FEMA 3/2000-RB states that, ‘Save as otherwise provided
in the Act, Rules or Regulations made thereunder, no person resident in India
shall borrow or lend in foreign exchange from or to a person resident in or
outside India’.

 

Contravention

 

Nature of default

Amount involved
(in Rs.)

Time period of default

Availing of foreign currency
loan overseas, for the purpose of purchasing property abroad

Rs. 6,78,26,933

Nine years and six months
approximately

 

Compounding
penalty

Compounding
penalty of Rs. 5,58,702 was levied.

Comments

While
remitting money under LRS for purchase of property is permitted, availing of
foreign currency loan overseas for the purposes was not permitted and was in
contravention of Regulation 3 of FEMA 3(R)/2000-R.

 

Interestingly,
in this case immovable property was leased to earn rental income. In the past,
RBI has taken a view that under LRS route only purchase of immovable property
was permitted and leasing activity was not permitted. However, no such
observations have been made in the instant case. Additionally, it is
interesting to note that under FDI provisions real estate business has been
defined to specifically include earning of rental income from leasing of
property. However, real estate business as defined under ODI regulations does
not include earning of rental income from leasing of property resulting in
dichotomy between real estate business as defined under FDI regulations and the
ODI regulations.

 

B.   Mindtree Limited

Date of
order: 11th July, 2019

Regulation:
FEMA 20/2000-RB Foreign Exchange Management (transfer or issue of security by a
person resident outside India)

 

ISSUE

Delay in reporting the issuance of shares under the Employee Stock
Options Plans (ESOP) beyond the stipulated time period; as also delay in
reporting the issuance of bonus shares beyond the stipulated time period.

 

FACTS

(i) The
applicant is an international information technology consulting and
implementation company that delivers business solutions through global software
development;

(ii) The
applicant company issued shares under ESOP (value – Rs. 1,96,00,000) to foreign
nationals / non-resident Indians (NRIs), but delayed the reporting of the same
beyond the stipulated time period;

(iii)
Besides, the applicant also delayed reporting the issuance of bonus shares
(total value – Rs. 40,12,500) beyond the stipulated time period;

(iv)
During personal hearing it was submitted that the applicant was under inquiry
by the Directorate of Enforcement (DoE) in connection with trade-related
transactions of the company;

(v) RBI,
vide its letter reference No. FED.CO.CEFA/4994/15.20.67/2018-19 dated 21st
February, 2019, had sought a No-Objection Certificate (NOC) from the DoE to
proceed with the compounding process;

(vi) DoE, vide its letter reference No. RBI/SDE/WR/B-223/2019/335
dated 30th April, 2019, conveyed
their no objection to compounding of the abovementioned contraventions.

 

Regulatory Provisions

(a)  Regulation 8(3) of Notification No.
FEMA.20/2000-RB, which dealt with ‘Issue of shares under Employees’ Stock Options
Scheme to persons resident outside India’, as then applicable, says, ‘The
issuing company shall furnish to the Reserve Bank, within thirty days from the
date of issue of shares under the scheme, a report…’;

(b)  Regulation 6B of the above-mentioned Notification
states ‘A company issuing rights shares or bonus shares or warrants in terms of
these regulations shall report to the Reserve Bank in Form FC-GPR as stipulated
in Paragraph 9(1)(B) of Schedule 1 to these Regulations’.

 

Contravention

 

Regulations of FEMA
20/2000-RB

Nature of default

Amount involved
(in rupees)

Time period of default

Regulation 8(3)

Delay in reporting the
issuance of shares under the Employee Stock Options Plans (ESOP)

Rs. 1,96,00,000

7 days

Regulation 6B

Delay in reporting the
issuance of bonus shares

Rs. 40,12,500

8 days

 

 

Compounding penalty

Compounding
penalty of Rs. 24,750 was levied.

 

Comments

(I)   The applicant is required to give an
undertaking at the time of filing compounding application that it is not under
any inquiry / investigation / adjudication by any agency such as Directorate of
Enforcement, CBI, etc., as on the date of the application;

(II)   This condition results in difficulty in
making compounding application by the applicant who is before ED for any other
violation (e.g., non-receipt of export proceeds within permissible time) or
replies to notice issued by ED, but there is no further correspondence from ED.
Issue arises whether existence of on-going ED proceeding shuts the door for
compounding;

(III)  In this order, as also in the case of
Satyanarayan Goel2, RBI has taken a practical view by taking an NOC
from the ED and thereafter compounding the offence. Thus, it is advisable for
an applicant to approach the RBI for compounding by disclosing all pending
proceedings before the ED.

 

OVERSEAS DIRECT INVESTMENT (ODI)
COMPOUNDING ORDERS

C.   Tata Chemicals Limited

Date of
order: 10th July, 2019

Regulation:
FEMA 120/2004-RB – Foreign Exchange Management (transfer or issue of any
foreign security) Regulations, 2004

 

ISSUE

Extending
loan without any equity contribution to overseas Joint Venture (JV), without
prior approval of the Reserve Bank of India.

 

FACTS

(i)   The applicant is engaged in the business of
manufacturing chemicals and fertilizers;

(ii)   The applicant set up an overseas JV, namely,
Grown Energy Zambeze Limitada (GEZ), Mozambique, under overseas direct
investment (ODI) on 22nd April, 2008;

(iii)  The applicant company remitted an amount of
USD 275,000 (Rs. 1,19,15,500) in three tranches between 26th
February and 26th September, 2008 as project advance. No shares were
issued against the remittances sent and these remittances were treated as loans
/ advances by the applicant;

(iv)  In June, 2009, the applicant decided to quit
the project due to uncertainty around allotment of land. The money has now been
brought back to India and the UIN has been closed on 7th May, 2019.

 

Regulatory provisions

Regulation
6(4) of Notification No. FEMA.120/2004-RB, as then applicable, states ‘an
Indian party may extend a loan or a guarantee to or on behalf of the joint
venture / wholly-owned subsidiary abroad, within the permissible financial
commitment, provided that the Indian party has made investment by way of
contribution to the equity capital of the joint venture.’

_________________________

2   CA
No 4910 / 2019

 

Contravention

The applicant has contravened the provisions of Regulation 6(4) of
Notification No. FEMA 120/2004-RB. The amount of contravention is Rs.
1,19,15,500 and the period of contravention is approximately eleven years.

 

Compounding penalty

Compounding penalty of Rs. 1,39,366 was levied.

 

Comments

This order
reflects that conditions prescribed in FEMA 120 of 2004 need to be complied
with strictly. In fact, the amount was disclosed as loans / advances and thus
it resulted in violation of Regulation 6(4) of FEMA 120 of 2004. The provision
does not specify the threshold for investment in equity capital. Thus,
theoretically, a loan based on infusion of nominal equity capital would have
been permissible. Regulation 15(i) obligates an Indian party which has acquired
foreign security to receive a share certificate or other document as evidence
of investment in the foreign entity to the satisfaction of RBI within six
months or such further period as RBI may permit. Flexibility of extended time
limit by RBI is available provided investment is for acquisition of foreign
security. In this case, the amount was stated as loans / advances and, accordingly,
Regulation 15(i) would not apply.
 

CORPORATE LAW CORNER

1.  Shweta
Vishwanath Shirke vs. Committee of Creditors
[2019] 109 taxmann.com 30 (NCLAT) Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) Nos. 601,
612, 527 of 2019
Date of order: 28th August, 2019

 

Sections 12A and 29A of Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – The directors / promoters reached a settlement with the
CoC – More than 90% of voting shares of the CoC approved the withdrawal of
corporate insolvency resolution process – NCLT should have accepted the
application of withdrawal especially when the settlement was being made by
promoters in their individual capacity and not by using the proceeds of crime –
Section 29A would not apply when examining an application u/s 12A

 

FACTS

About 90% of the Committee of Creditors
(CoC) approved the withdrawal of S Co from the Insolvency Resolution Process
and filed an application u/s 12A of the Code. National Company Law Tribunal
(NCLT) rejected the application on the ground that since the promoter was not
eligible to file a resolution plan u/s 29A it could not have filed an
application for withdrawal u/s 12A of the Code.

 

Andhra Bank, which was on the CoC, also
challenged the order of NCLT on the ground that section 29A would not apply to
an application filed u/s 12A which has been approved by more than 90% of the
CoC.

 

The Enforcement Directorate, SEBI and CBI
were also investigating the matter against S Co. The ED submitted that the
assets of S Co were based on the proceeds of crime and, accordingly, they could
not be given to anyone.

 

The matter for examination before the NCLAT
was whether section 29A of the Code would apply to the applicant, if he intends
to withdraw the petition u/s 7 or 9, if the CoC approves a proposal with 90%
voting share in terms of section 12A.

 

HELD

NCLAT examined the provisions of section 29A
of the Code which provides for persons not eligible to be resolution
applicants. It was observed that if any person including the ‘Promoter’ /
‘Director’ was ineligible in terms of any one or more clauses of section 29A,
he / she was not entitled to file any ‘resolution plan’ individually or jointly
or in concert with another. Section 12A, on the other hand, dealt with
withdrawal of the application filed by an ‘applicant’ u/s 7 or section 9 of the
Code, if the CoC with more than 90% voting share approved the proposal.

 

The NCLAT, relying on the observations of
the Supreme Court in the decision of Swiss Ribbons Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of
India (2019 SCC Online SC 73)
held that promoters / shareholders are
entitled to settle the matter in terms of section 12A and in such case, it was
always open to an applicant to withdraw the application under section 9 of the
Code on the basis of which the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process was initiated.
Thus, section 29A would not apply for entertaining / considering an application
u/s 12A as the applicants are not entitled to file an application u/s 29A as
‘resolution applicant’.

 

NCLAT held that since the application u/s 7
was filed by Andhra Bank and the application for withdrawal was approved by
more than 90% of voting shares in CoC, it was not in the purview of NCLT to
reject the application for withdrawal. The order of liquidation passed by the
NCLT was, accordingly, set aside.

 

It was further held that if the ED concludes
that the assets of S Co are based on the proceeds of crime, it could exercise
its powers under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA) and seize
those assets.

 

As the
settlement with creditors was to be paid by the directors / shareholders in
their individual capacity, from the funds held in their accounts and not from
proceeds of crime, the application for withdrawal was approved by NCLAT. It was
further held that the order would not amount to interference with any order
passed by the ED with regard to the assets of S Co. Proceedings under PMLA will
continue against S Co in accordance with the law.

 

It was further directed that the fees of the
liquidator and the resolution professional would be determined and paid by
Andhra Bank on behalf of the CoC and it may adjust the same with the members.

 

2.  State
Bank of India vs. Moser Baer Karamchari Union
[2019] 108 taxmann.com 251 (NCLAT New Delhi) Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 396 of
2019
Date of order: 19th August, 2019

 

Section 36 of
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – All sums due to an employee or a workman
from the provident fund, pension fund and gratuity fund do not fall in the
ambit of the liquidation assets and accordingly cannot be a part of waterfall /
distribution mechanism laid down u/s 53 of the Code

 

FACTS

Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process was
initiated against M Co and an order for liquidation was passed on 20th
September, 2018. Pursuant to the judgement by the National Company Law Tribunal
(NCLT) the workmen stood discharged u/s 33(7) of the Code.

 

The liquidator, vide email dated 5th
December, 2018, denied the payment of the gratuity fund, the provident fund and
the pension fund preferentially and included the same for payments under the
waterfall mechanism provided in section 53 of the Code.

 

In January, 2019 the Moser Baer Karamchari
Union (MBKU) filed a prayer for exclusion of provident fund, pension fund and
gratuity fund from the waterfall mechanism and payment of their dues as they
did not form a part of liquidation estate. NCLT upheld the prayer. SBI, the
secured creditor, filed an appeal to the National Company Law Appellate
Tribunal (NCLAT) against the order passed by the NCLT.

 

SBI submitted that waterfall mechanism
provided under the Code included the contribution to provident fund. Reliance
was also placed on Explanation below section 53 of the Code which suggested
that the ‘workmen’s dues’ shall have the same meaning as assigned to it in
section 326 of the Companies Act, 2013. MBKU highlighted the provision of
section 36 of the Code which defines liquidation assets. It was submitted that
in terms of section 36(4)(a)(iii), liquidation assets specifically excluded all
sums due to any workman or employee from the provident fund, pension fund and
gratuity fund.

 

HELD

NCLAT heard counsel for both sides. The
matter for consideration before NCLAT was whether provident fund, pension fund
and gratuity fund come within the meaning of assets of M Co for distribution
u/s 53 of the Code.

 

NCLAT examined the provisions of sections 36
and 53 of the Code as well as sections 326 and 327 of the Companies Act, 2013.
It was observed that all sums due to any workman or employee from the provident
fund, the pension fund and the gratuity fund shall not be included in the
liquidation estate assets and cannot be used for recovery in the liquidation as
per section 36 of the Code. Further, as the sums mentioned were not a part of
the liquidation estate / liquidation assets, the question of their distribution
in order of priority u/s 53 did not arise at all.

 

Further, while applying section 53 of the
Code, section 326 of the Companies Act, 2013 is relevant for the limited
purpose of understanding ‘workmen’s dues’ which can be more than provident
fund, pension fund and the gratuity fund kept aside and protected u/s
36(4)(iii).

 

It was thus held that the provident fund,
gratuity fund and pension fund do not come within the meaning of ‘liquidation estate’ for the purpose of distribution of assets u/s 53.

 

The NCLAT upheld the order passed by NCLT
and dismissed the appeal.

 

3.  Pioneer
Urban Land & Infrastructure Ltd. vs. Union of India
[2019] 108 taxmann.com 147 (SC) Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 43, 99, 124, 121,
129 of 2019 & Ors.
Date of order: 9th August, 2019

 

Sections 21(6A)(b), 25A and Explanation to
section 5(8)(f) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Amendments made
to the Code which deem the allottees of real estate projects to be ‘financial
creditors’ such that it gives them the right to enforce the Code u/s 7 are
constitutionally valid


FACTS

Amendments were carried out to the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (the Code) pursuant to a report prepared
by the Insolvency Law Committee dated 26th March, 2018 (Insolvency
Committee Report). The amendments so made deemed allottees of real estate
projects to be ‘financial creditors’ so that they may trigger the Code, u/s 7
thereof, against the real estate developer. In addition, being financial
creditors, they were entitled to be represented in the Committee of Creditors
by authorised representatives.

 

The Supreme Court in the case of Chitra
Sharma vs. Union of India (Writ Petition [Civil] No. 744 of 2017)

appointed a representative to protect the interest of home buyers on the
Committee of Creditors. The Insolvency Committee Report suggested that
amendments be made in the Code seeking to clarify, as a matter of law, that
allottees of real estate projects are financial creditors. On 17th
August, 2018, Parliament passed the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Second
Amendment) Act, 2018 (Amendment Act) incorporating the aforesaid amendments as
were provided for by the Amendment Ordinance.

 

The real estate developers filed a petition
challenging the provisions saying it violates two facets of Article 14. One,
that the amendment is discriminatory inasmuch as it treats unequals equally,
and equals unequally, having no intelligible differentia; and two, that there
is no nexus with the objects sought to be achieved by the Code. The amendments
were alleged to be arbitrary, irrational and without determining principle and
in violation of public interest under Article 19(6). Further, there was a
specific legislation on the subject of real estate, namely, Real Estate
(Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA) which provides for adjudication
of disputes between allottees and the developer, together with a large number
of safeguards in favour of the allottee.

 

Reliance was placed on the decision of Swiss
Ribbons vs. Union of India (2019) 4 SCC 17
to drive home the point that
not a single one of several characteristics of financial creditors stated in
that judgement would apply to allottees / home buyers.

 

HELD

The Supreme Court heard the parties and
observed that the Legislature must be given free play in the joints when it
comes to economic legislation. Apart from the presumption of constitutionality
which arises in such cases, the legislative judgement in economic choices must
be given a certain degree of deference by the courts.

 

Further, the Supreme Court observed that
from the introduction of the explanation to section 5(8)(f) of the Code, it was
clear that Parliament was aware of RERA and applied some of its definition
provisions so that they could apply when the Code was to be interpreted. The
fact that RERA is in addition to and not in derogation of the provisions of any
other law for the time being in force, also made it clear that the remedies
under RERA to allottees were intended to be additional and not exclusive
remedies. Further, the Code as amended, is later in point of time than RERA and
must be given precedence over RERA in view of section 88 of RERA. Given the
different spheres within which these two enactments operate, different parallel
remedies are given to allottees – under RERA to see that their flat / apartment
is constructed and delivered to them in time, barring which compensation for
the same and / or refund of amounts paid together with interest at the very
least comes their way. If, however, the allottee wants that the corporate
debtor’s management itself be removed and replaced, so that the corporate
debtor can be rehabilitated, he may prefer a section 7 application under the
Code.

 

As regards unequal treatment afforded, the
Supreme Court observed that home buyers / allottees can be assimilated with
other individual financial creditors like debenture holders and fixed deposit
holders who have advanced certain amounts to the corporate debtor. The Court
gave the example that fixed deposit holders, though financial creditors, would
be like real estate allottees in that they are unsecured creditors. Financial
contracts in the case of these individuals need not involve large sums of money.
Debenture holders and fixed deposit holders, unlike real estate holders, are
involved in seeing that they recover the amounts that are lent and are thus not
directly involved or interested in assessing the viability of the corporate
debtors. Though not having the expertise or information to be in a position to
evaluate the feasibility and viability of resolution plans, such individuals,
by virtue of being financial creditors, have a right to be on the Committee of
Creditors to safeguard their interest. The allottees, being individual
financial creditors like debenture holders and fixed deposit holders and
classified as such, show that they were within the larger class of financial
creditors and there was infraction of Article 14.

 

It was held that home buyers / allottees
give advances to the real estate developer and thereby finance the real estate
project at hand (and) qualified as financial creditors.

 

The Code was observed to be a beneficial
legislation which can be triggered to put the corporate debtor back on its feet
in the interest of unsecured creditors like allottees, who are vitally
interested in the financial health of the corporate debtor, so that a replaced
management may then carry out the real estate project as originally envisaged
and deliver the flat / apartment as soon as possible and / or pay compensation
in the event of late delivery, or non-delivery, or refund amounts advanced
together with interest. It could not be said that amendment to section
5(8) was therefore manifestly arbitrary, i.e., excessive, disproportionate or
without adequate determining principle.

 

The Supreme Court also turned down the
argument of the petitioners that allottees be treated as operational creditors.
It was further held that all persons who have advanced monies to the corporate
debtor, like other financial creditors, be they banks and financial
institutions, or other individuals, should have the right to be on the
Committee of Creditors. Even though allottees were unsecured creditors, but
they did have a vital interest in amounts that were advanced for completion of
the project, maybe to the extent of 100% of the project being funded by them
alone.

 

The Court held that section 5(8) would
subsume within it amounts raised under transactions which are not necessarily
loan transactions, so long as they have the commercial effect of a borrowing.
Amounts raised from allottees under real estate projects would, thus, be
subsumed within section 5(8)(f) of the Code.

 

The Supreme Court thus held that:

(i) The Amendment Act to the Code does
not infringe Articles 14, 19(1)(g) read with Article 19(6), or 300-A of the
Constitution of India.

(ii) The RERA is to be read harmoniously
with the Code, as amended by the Amendment Act. It is only in the event of
conflict that the Code will prevail over the RERA. Remedies that are given to
allottees of flats / apartments are therefore concurrent remedies, such
allottees of flats / apartments being in a position to avail of remedies under
the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, RERA as well as the triggering of the Code.

(iii) Section 5(8)(f) as it originally
appeared in the Code being a residuary provision, always subsumed within it
allottees of flats / apartments. The explanation together with the deeming
fiction added by the Amendment Act is only clarificatory of this position in
law.
 

 

BOOK REVIEW

‘PRINCIPLES’ – by Ray Dalio

 

Ray Dalio, one
of the world’s most successful investors and entrepreneurs, shares the
unconventional principles that he has developed, refined and used over the past
40 years to create unique results in both life and business – and which any
person or organisation can adopt to achieve their goals.

 

In 1975 he
founded an investment firm, Bridgewater Associates. Forty years later,
Bridgewater has made more money for its clients than any other hedge fund in
history and grown into the fifth most important private company in the US,
according to Fortune magazine. Dalio has been named in Time
magazine’s list of the 100 most influential people in the world. Along the way,
he discovered a set of unique principles that have led to Bridgewater’s
exceptionally effective culture, which he describes as ‘an idea meritocracy
that strives to achieve meaningful work and meaningful relationships through
radical transparency.’ It is these principles, and not anything special about
Dalio, that he believes are the reason behind his success.

 

In the book,
Dalio shares what he has learned over the course of his remarkable career. He
argues that life, management, economics and investing can all be systemised
into rules and understood like machines. The book has hundreds of practical
lessons built around his cornerstones of ‘radical truth’ and ‘radical
transparency’; these include the most effective ways for individuals and
organisations to make decisions, approach challenges and build strong teams. He
also describes the innovative tools the firm uses to bring an ‘idea
meritocracy’ to life, such as creating ‘baseball cards’ for all employees that
distil their strengths and weaknesses and employing computerised
decision-making systems to make believability-weighted decisions. While the
book brims with novel ideas for organisations and institutions, Principles
also offers a clear, straightforward approach to decision-making that Dalio
believes anyone can apply, no matter what they’re seeking to achieve.

 

Here, from a
man who has been called both ‘the Steve Jobs of investing’ and ‘the philosopher
king of the financial universe’ (CIO magazine), is a rare opportunity to
gain proven advice unlike anything you’ll find in the conventional business
press. He kicks off by explaining that ‘Good principles are effective ways of
dealing with reality’ and that ‘To learn my own, I spend a lot of time
reflecting.’

 

The book
consists of three parts. In the first, titled ‘Where I’m coming from’, Dalio
looks back at his career and the founding of Bridgewater. ‘Life Principles’ is
the name of the second part and covers Dalio’s approach to life’s challenges
and opportunities. And part three covers Dalio’s ‘Work Principles’.

 

Let me share my
key takeaways from Principles, starting with Dalio’s Life
Principles:

 

Embrace reality
and deal with it
–
Dalio shares an important equation which in his view makes for a successful
life: Dreams + Reality + Determination = A Successful Life. For the
‘reality’ component of this equation to work, Dalio encourages readers to be
radically open-minded and radically transparent.

 

Pain +
Reflection = Progress

– One can see how someone like Dalio has gone through his own share of pain to
get to where he has reached.

 

Using the
5-step process to get what you want out of life
– Start with having clear goals (step 1),
followed by identifying but not tolerating the problems that stand in
the way of your achieving those goals (step 2), then you accurately diagnose
the problems to get at their root causes (step 3), design plans that
will get you around them (step 4) and, finally, do what’s necessary to
push these designs through to results (step 5). Dalio depicts this as a
continuous process and readers can benefit from applying this model to achieve
their goals.

 

Understand
that people are wired very differently
– Dalio stresses the fact that all people are
wired differently and zooms in on the differences between left and
right-brained thinking.

 

Dalio’s Work
Principles
are dominated by the concept of an Idea Meritocracy –
i.e., a system that brings together smart, independent thinkers and has them
productively disagree to come up with the best possible collective thinking and
resolve their disagreements in a believability-weighted way. He successfully
implemented an ‘Idea Meritocracy’ at Bridgewater and shares the components of
such a system in his book:

 

Idea
Meritocracy = Radical Truth + Radical Transparency + Believability – Weighted
Decision-Making

 

Radical
Truth
– Talking openly
about our issues and have paths for working through them.

 

Radical Transparency – Giving everyone the ability to see
everything. Radical transparency reduces harmful office politics and the risks
of bad behaviour because bad behaviour is more likely to take place behind
closed doors than out in the open.

 

Believability – Dalio defines believable people as
‘those who have repeatedly and successfully accomplished the thing in question
– who have a strong track record with at least three successes – and have great
explanations of their approach when probed.’

 

Thoughtful
Disagreement
– The
concept of Believability is closely linked to the art of Thoughtful
Disagreement; the process of having a quality back-and-forth in an open-minded
and assertive way to see things through each other’s eyes.

 

Weighted
Decision-Making
– At
Bridgewater, employees have different believability weightings for
different qualities, like expertise in a particular subject, creativity,
ability to synthesise, etc. Dalio explains that in order to have a true Idea
Meritocracy one needs to understand the merit of each person’s ideas.

 

Prerequisites
for an Idea Meritocracy

– To have an Idea Meritocracy three conditions need to be in place.
Firstly, put your honest thoughts on the table. Secondly, have thoughtful
disagreement. Thirdly, abide by agreed-upon ways of getting past disagreement.

 

Mistakes are
part of the game
–
Dalio has a refreshing outlook on the role and value of mistakes, which he
treats as ‘a natural part of the evolutionary process’. It’s important in this
respect to assess whether people recognise and learn from their mistakes. Dalio
distinguishes between people who make mistakes and who are self-reflective and
open to learning from their mistakes, and those who are unable to embrace their
mistakes and learn from them.

 

Get people
to focus on problems and outcomes
– Assign people the job of perceiving problems, give them time to
investigate and make sure they have independent reporting lines so that they
can convey problems without any fear of recrimination. To perceive problems,
compare how the outcomes are lining up with your goals. Dalio also offers some
valuable tips on how to best diagnose problems.

 

Avoid the
‘Frog in the boiling water’ syndrome
– Apparently, if you throw a frog into a pot of
boiling water it will jump out immediately, but if you put it in water at room
temperature and gradually bring it to a boil, it will stay in the pot until it
dies. If one uses this syndrome as a metaphor for professional life, it
signifies people’s tendency to slowly get used to unacceptable things that would
shock them if they see them with fresh eyes.

 

Don’t just
pay attention to your job
– Instead, pay attention to how your job will be done if you’re no
longer around. Dalio talks about the ‘ninja manager’ as ‘somebody who can sit
back and watch beauty happen, i.e., an orchestrator. If you’re always trying to
hire somebody who’s as good as or better than you at your job, that will both
free you up to go on to other things and build your succession pipeline.’

 

I feel that
Dalio’s principles can provide great direction for all people working in
organisations big or small. His reflections on things such as transparency and
decision-making will be valuable to anyone reading this great book.

 

The book is
aesthetically beautiful in the design and typography, making it a real treat to
read. I really appreciate the biography section of the book that solely focuses
on Ray Dalio’s life and journey towards where he is today. It offers you a
brief insight into what made him the person he is today. Even very humbling experiences,
such as being the only person left in the company that he built and having to
start all over again.

 

In Principles: Life and Work,
Dalio shares the principles that have led to his success. Told with honesty and
enlightening examples, Principles is a fascinating look at how
Dalio has created the largest and most successful hedge fund in the world. You
need only read the first few pages to discover the uniqueness of his approach;
he encourages readers to doubt everything, suggesting that radical open-mindedness
is the best way to learn.

Allied Laws

1.      
Cross objection to be disposed
of independently on merits [Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), Order XLI Rule
22]

Badru (since deceased) through L.R. and
Ors. vs. NTPC Limited and Ors. AIR 2019 Supreme Court 3385

 

The land in question belonged to the
appellants (landowners). The suit land was acquired by the State for the NTPC
for public purpose. A compensation of Rs. 3,87,383 per bigha was awarded
to the appellants for the land. But the appellants felt aggrieved and
approached the Civil Court for determination of the compensation offered by the
Land Acquisition Officer. The Civil Court partly allowed the reference in
favour of the appellants and enhanced the compensation. The State and the NTPC
felt aggrieved by the award and filed appeals before the High Court. The
appellants instead of filing a regular appeal, filed cross objection under
Order 41 Rule 22 of the CPC and sought enhancement in the compensation awarded.
The High Court dismissed the appeals filed by the NTPC / State and, in
consequence, also dismissed the cross objection filed by the appellants. The
effect of the dismissal of the appeals and cross objection was upholding of the
award passed by the Civil Court. The landowners felt aggrieved by the rejection
of their cross objection and filed the present appeals by way of a special
leave before the Supreme Court.

 

It was observed by the Supreme Court that
one remedy was by way of appeal and the other remedy was to file cross
objection. In this case, the landowners took recourse to the second remedy of
filing cross objection. The High Court having dismissed the appeals filed by
the State / NTPC was, therefore, required to examine whether any case was made
out by the landowners in their cross objection for enhancement of compensation.
Order 41 Rule 22(4) of the CPC provides that where, in any case in which any
respondent has under this Rule filed a memorandum of objection, the original
appeal is withdrawn or is dismissed for default, the objection so filed may
nevertheless be heard and determined after such notice to the other parties as
the Court thinks fit. Merely because the High Court dismissed the appeals filed
by the respondents herein, though on merits, yet that by itself would not
result in dismissal of the landowners’ cross objection also.

 

In view of the same, the Supreme Court held
that the cross objection had to be disposed of on its merits notwithstanding
the dismissal of the same by assigning reasons. The case was accordingly
remanded to the High Court for deciding the cross objection filed by the
landowners in accordance with law.

 

2.      
Doctrine of promissory estoppel
– New Package Scheme of Incentives, 1993 – The eligibility for sales-tax
exemption cannot be withdrawn [General Sales Tax (GST), Art. 39(b), 39(c)]

K.M. Refineries and Infraspace Pvt. Ltd.
vs. State of Maharashtra (Bom.) (HC), www.itatonline.org

 

Under the New Package Scheme of Incentives,
1993, monetary and other incentives in the nature of tax subsidy or tax
exemption at the rate prescribed in the scheme and other benefits were given.
As per the eligibility certificate issued by the competent authority, the
certificate was valid for nine years. The Commissioner of Sales Tax prescribed
the effective date but while doing so, curtailed the validity period by about
three years and incentives given in the Incentive Scheme have been
substantially reduced by a new policy prescribing new tax structure of the
State. The assessee challenged the policy on the ground that the new policy
violates the principle of promissory estoppel.

 

Allowing the petition, the Court held that
once a promise has been solemnly given by the State with an intention that it
would be acted upon, and which has been indeed acted upon and liabilities
suffered by the promisee, the State cannot be permitted to backtrack on the
promise and change its position so as to cause loss to the promisee. The
eligibility for sales-tax exemption cannot be withdrawn under GST. (W.P. No.
2209 of 2018, dated 16th July, 2019).

 

3.      
Notional partition – Daughters
entitled to claim a share in the ancestral property after notional partition
between coparceners [Hindu Succession Act, 1956, S. 6]

Gannu Ram and another vs. Dhanmat Bai and
Ors. AIR 2019 Chhattisgarh 148

 

The case was filed by Dhanmat Bai and Deni
Bai, who were the daughters of Ramai before the trial court where it was held
that the daughters were entitled to a share in the property in a case where the
father had expired prior to the amendment in section 6 of the Hindu Succession
Act. The daughters were born before 2005 and hence, the applicability of the
2005 amendment to them was in question. An appeal was preferred against such
order where the question raised was whether the daughter of a pre-deceased karta
/ coparcener is entitled to have equal share in the ancestral property.

 

The court held that the daughters were
entitled to a share in the property but only to the extent of the part of the
shares of their father after a notional partition with the appellant since the
appellant was the coparcener in the Hindu Joint Family property along with the
father of the daughters. For passing an effective decree of partition in favour
of the daughters, the trial court was first required to affect a notional
partition between Ramai and his son (coparcener / appellant) allotting them
half share each in the coparcenary property. Thereafter, a further partition is
required to be affected in respect of the half share of the father which would devolve
equally upon the daughters. The appeal was therefore partly allowed.

 

4.      
Partnership property cannot be
a Hindu Joint Family property [Hindu Law]

Aarshiya Gulati and Ors. vs. Kuldeep Singh
Gulati and Ors. AIT 2019 (NOC) 577 (Del.)

 

While emphasising on the difference between
partnership and a Hindu Joint Family firm, the court referred to Mulla who in
his treatise Hindu Law (21st edition) has pointed out
the following points of difference between a partnership and a Hindu Joint
Family firm: ‘In a joint family business no member of the family can say that
he is the owner of one-half, one-third or one-fourth. The essence of joint
Hindu family property is unity of ownership and community of interest and the
shares of the members are not defined’.

 

The court also referred to the case of Nanchand
Gangaram Shetji vs. Mallappa Mahalingappa Sadalge & Ors.
where it
was held that in a joint Hindu family business, no member of the family can say
that he is the owner of one-half, one-third or one-fourth. The essence of joint
Hindu family property is unity of ownership and community of interest and the
shares of the members are not defined. Similarly, the pattern of the accounts
of a joint Hindu family business maintained by the karta is different
from those of a partnership. In the case of the former the shares of the
individual members in the profits and losses are not worked out, while they
have to be worked out in the case of partnership accounts.

 

In view of the same, the court held that a
partnership property cannot be a Hindu Joint Family property.

 

5.      
Tenancy – Prior consent of
creditor to be taken when tenancy created after mortgage of premises to
creditor – If consent not taken, tenant not entitled to temporary injunction
against dispossession by creditor bank. [Securitisation And Reconstruction Of
Financial Assets And Enforcement Of Security Interest Act, 2002, S. 13]

Chief Manager, Bank of Baroda, Dhanbad
branch vs. Amit and Ors. AIR 2019 Jharkhand 122

 

The brief facts of the case are that the
petitioner bank had sanctioned a loan by keeping the property in question
mortgaged by a collateral security and on having become a non-performing asset,
a notice u/s 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets
and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002, was issued, thereafter
resorting to the provision of S. 13(4) of the Act. The respondent No. 1
(tenant) has entered into an agreement of tenancy prior to mortgaging of the
property by the owner. When a notice u/s 13(4) was served on the owner, the
respondent No. 1 filed a suit pleading therein that he is a monthly tenant and
has been paying rent regularly and on time but without any receipt. The bank
(creditor) appeared and filed show cause, disputed the claim of the respondent
No. 1 by stating that the owner is a director of a private limited company and
has got cash credit facility of Rs. 300 lakhs which was sanctioned and secured
by getting a mortgage of the property; when the loanee became irregular and
despite repeated requests and intimations did not pay the loan amount due to
which the loan amount became an NPA; this forced the petitioner bank (creditor)
to file a suit in the Debt Recovery Tribunal.

 

The tenant also
filed a separate petition for grant of temporary injunction restraining the petitioner
bank (creditor) from taking forceful possession of the tenanted premises.


It was observed by the court that no
borrower shall lease any of the secured assets referred to in the notice
without the prior written consent of the secured creditor and holding therein
that save and except the process of tenancy, there cannot be any eviction of
the tenant.

The court referred to the case of Kalsaria
where the lease has been created after the property had been mortgaged and
therefore, it has been held that before creating tenancy right before the date
of mortgage, consent is required to be taken from the creditors. It is in the
touchstone of this ratio and the definition of mortgage that the case in hand
has been examined by the court.

 

It was held that since it was nowhere on
record that before creating tenancy by virtue of agreement, prior consent of
the creditor has been taken this fact ought to have been appreciated by the
appellate court but having not done so, the appellate court has committed gross
error.

 


Society News

57TH EDITION OF ‘BCAS REFERENCER’ RELEASED

The BCAS Referencer, one of the eagerly-awaited, landmark publications of the Bombay Chartered Accountants Society, entered its 57th year of continuous publication this year – and also the 22nd year of theme-based issues.

The release programme was organised at the M.C. Ghia Hall on 2nd August, 2019 by the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee. Following the lighting of the auspicious lamp, there was a selection of short glimpses of India’s classical dance forms which is the theme of this year’s Referencer.

CA Toral Mehta compered the event and introduced the chief guests of the evening, Mr. Sameer and Ms Arsh Tanna, eminent Bollywood choreographers, and the sponsor, CA Kamal Poddar of Choice Connect.

BCAS President CA Manish Sampat noted in his remarks that the publication, which is recognised as the most dependable knowledge resource and an unparalleled repository of various laws, had been the hallmark of BCAS for the last six decades. He acknowledged all the contributors, specially the youth, and the tremendous efforts put in by the Committee for the release of the Referencer immediately after the Union Budget.

The various Indian classical dance forms – whether Bharat Natyam, Odissi, Kucchipudi, Kathakali, Kathak or Manipuri – were performed by the artists who were actually the members and students of the BCAS. They were led by CA Manori Shah under the choreography of Nita Shah and Vishrut Doshi. Other artists who performed included Chirag Bohra, Jitesh Kakad, Hrudyesh Pankhania, Rishikesh Joshi, Vidisha Shah, Disha Unadkat, Tanvi Parekh, Kinjal Bhuta, Rishita Shah, Richa Agrawal and Vidhi Parekh. The rapt audience appreciated and enjoyed all the dances.

In his address, Committee Chairman CA Narayan Pasari appreciated the efforts of all the contributors, editors, proof-readers, and specially CA Pranay Marfatia who had been instrumental in the publication of the Referencer for several years and for organising the release event. The Referencer was released in the presence of a galaxy of personalities, including the contributors, editors and others and was unveiled by the chief guests.

Chief guest Ms Arsh Tanna said she was amazed by the performances of the artists of the BCAS fraternity and expressed her delight at attending the event which was brilliantly correlated with the theme – Indian classical dance and the contents of the Referencer.

Convener CA Manmohan Sharma proposed a hearty vote of thanks to all present, especially to Choice Connect, the sponsors of the Referencer, Finesse, the printers, the BCAS Events staff and the organising team of the Committee who had put in a lot of hard work.

SUBURBAN STUDY CIRCLE

The Suburban Study Circle organised two meetings on ‘15CB Certification – Who, What, When and How?’, on 16th July and 13th August, 2019, which were addressed by CA Rutvik Sanghvi who made a detailed presentation on the following Rules and Regulations:

(i) Who all are covered under the provisions of section 195?
(ii) What transactions are covered?
(iii) When is the taxation to a non-resident applicable?
(iv) How is it to be applied?

Rutvik explained the nuisances and complexities involved in payments to non-residents in a lucid manner. He explained the importance and requirement of tax residency certificate and taxability of various kinds of payments to non-residents like fees for technical services, royalty, etc. It required two sessions to cover the topic in detail.

The participants benefited from the presentation made by him.

HRD STUDY CIRCLE

The HRD Study Circle met on 13th August, 2019 to discuss ‘Modern Techniques in Physiotherapy.’

The presentation was made by Dr. Rupa Mehta and Dr. Kritika Poddar. Dr. Rupa Mehta and her team run Healthspace clinic at Opera House and have 30 years of experience. They have kept themselves updated with the latest techniques in physiotherapy.

The presentation covered:
(a) Diagnosis and treatment of spine (neck and back), shoulder, elbow, hip, knee and ankle joint pains. (Through her presentation, Dr. Rupa Mehta gave members a detailed explanation for the possible reasons for pain in the joints. She showed simple exercises to address the pain in the initial stages and explained that neglecting it can cause further damage and addressing it early can help avoid surgery);
(b) Bad posture can have a deleterious effect on the body;
(c) It is necessary to improve the core muscles.

The latest techniques used in Healthspace are as follows:
(I) The McKenzie Protocol of exercises
(II) The Mulligan Protocol
(III) Neurodynamic solutions
(IV) Taping
(V) Dry needling
(VI) Core muscle strengthening
(VII) Pilates on the reformer and customised exercise.

Dr. Kritika Poddar highlighted the benefits of pilates. She projected ergonomics with visual inputs and stressed on the need for the right posture. Work life ergonomics and exercises shown by her could be beneficial for all chartered accountants and professionals.

However, the most important point was to spread awareness so that people do not injure themselves and adopt a better lifestyle.

INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS STUDY GROUP

The group held its meeting on 16th August, 2019 to discuss ‘Economic Slowdown and Global Flash Points’. CA Harshad Shah led the discussions and presented his thoughts on the subject.

He said that based on the definition of slowdown and recession, the Indian economy had slowed down and might have entered into a recessionary phase as the GDP had come down from the high of 8.2% in Q1 FY19 to 7.2% in Q2 and in the last quarter dropped to 5.8%. This fulfilled the technical definition of a recession of two consecutive quarters of negative economic growth.

At the macro level, the automobile sector was facing its worst crisis in 20 years with the malaise spreading across much of the industry, both in terms of vehicle type and components as well as geographically in the country’s manufacturing hubs, along with the structural reform of pushing for electric vehicles. The real estate sector had been on a downturn since the demonetisation period, with India’s top 30 cities having 1.28 million unsold housing units as of March, 2019. The health of real estate was a major indicator of the state of the economy. It had links with about 250 ancillary industries – bricks, cement, steel, furniture, electrical products, paints, etc., and affected all of them whether there was a boom or gloom in the sector.

FMCG companies had reported a decline in volume growth due to sluggish rural demand which, in turn, indicated less availability of money in villages. All these factors impacted the unemployment rate which had risen to a 45-year high.

India’s household-sector savings, the biggest source of investment for the economy, had ‘worryingly’ come down to 30.5% (as % to GDP) in 2018 compared to nearly 37% in 2008. Poor savings had been a largely ‘unaddressed’ reason for the country’s continuing slowdown. Retail loans to the sector were growing annually in double digits, pointing to profligate consumption by households with a youthful population (70% of the working-age population being aged between 20 and 40 years) that liked to spend. Many economists widely held that a country’s economic growth should be investment-led rather than being driven by consumption, as had been the case with India.

The NITI Aayog CEO attributed the downshift to a spate of measures (structural reforms) such as GST, RERA and IBC that had led to the current slowdown in the country.

The global economy was bracing for a probable recession in 2020 as nearly half (48%) of CFOs in USA and some prominent economists were also predicting this. One of the indicators, the Yield Curve inversion, had already occurred. An inverted yield curve meant that interest rates had flipped on the US. Treasury with short-term bonds paying more than long-term bonds. This was generally regarded as a warning sign for the economy and the markets.

The global economy was also facing some serious headwinds such as Hard Brexit; US vs. China: From Tariff War to Currency War to Economic War, with USA labelling China as a ‘Currency Manipulator’ for the first time; Argentina’s historic market crash with fears of another default; the Hong Kong protests and probable retaliation by Chinese security forces; and the Iran issue. CA Milan Sanghani and many participants expressed their views on all these issues.

FEMA STUDY CIRCLE

The FEMA Study Circle meeting held on 19th August, 2019 covered the issue of ‘FDI in Trading Sector’.

CA Chintan Shah delved into various facets of the subject, viz., Cash and Carry Wholesale Trading, E-commerce, Single Brand Product Retail Trading, Multi-Brand Product Retail Trading and Duty-Free Shops. The FDI in the above activities was covered from scratch, beginning with sectoral caps applicable to each of them and ending with a healthy discussion on understanding the nuances of their respective definitions, the conditions attached thereto and understanding the manner in which businesses were structured in India. It was indeed a very interesting session given the current business environment in the country in which various multinational companies across the globe were exploring business models to expand their markets here.

4TH NARAYAN VARMA LECTURE

The 4th Narayan Varma Memorial Lecture (and the Narayan Varma Memorial Awards) was organised by the Public Concern for Governance Trust, the Bombay Chartered Accountants Society, the Dharma Bharathi Mission and the Chamber of Tax Consultants at the Indian Merchants Chamber on 23rd August, 2019.

The programme was organised in memory of Narayan Bhai who was closely associated with these organisations, held various posts in them and mentored and nurtured them with his values, ideology and hard work. He left behind an enduring legacy as a great professional, a philanthropist and, above all, a great human being.

The memorial lecture was delivered by Mr. Y.H. Malegam, the well-known CA and a legend in the financial sector who has been honoured with the Padma Shri.

Three distinguished persons from Mumbai were also recognised for their humanitarian service. The DBM NV Memorial Award was given to the Adhyayan Sanstha, the BCAS Narayan Varma Memorial Award went to Mr. Vishwas Gore and the PCGT NV Memorial Award was bestowed on Mr. Shailesh Gandhi.

The programme was very well attended with all top CAs, auditors and people associated with the social sector in attendance. Kudos to all the four other partner organisations for coordinating their efforts to organise the memorable event.

TAXATION COMMITTEE

The Taxation Committee organised a full-day seminar on ‘Tax Audit’ at the BCAS Conference Hall on 23rd
August, 2019.

President Manish Sampat gave the opening remarks. Chairman of the Taxation Committee Ameet Patel gave a brief overview of the seminar and explained the importance of tax audit in the current scenario. He also informed the participants about the onerous responsibility cast on the tax auditor, given that the selection as well as the assessment is now going to be online.

The following topics were taken up by the learned speakers:

Programme Speakers
Audit aspect of Tax Audit – overview of Tax Audit provisions, reporting requirements, audit quality, verification of documents, documentation in light of ICDS, obtaining and relying on management representation, reliance on test checks, etc. CA Himanshu Kishnadwala
Issues arising with tax audit of companies following Ind AS reporting in clauses 13 to 17, clause 19 and clause 24 CA Manish Shah
Reporting in Form 3CD – Certain clauses (namely, clauses 20 to 23, clauses 25 to 27, clauses 30A to 30B and clauses 42 to 44) CA Sonalee Godbole
Reporting in Form 3CD – Certain clauses (namely, clauses 28 to 29B, clause 31, clause 32, clause 34, clause 36 and clause 36A) CA Jagdish Punjabi

Himanshu Kishnadwala set the ball rolling by highlighting various audit aspects that one should keep in mind while conducting a tax audit. He gave his practical insights pertaining to some of the clauses and stressed on the importance of documentation in tax audit.

Next came Manish Shah who described the impact of ICDS through case studies. He also took the audience through various case studies to explain the impact of Ind AS on various clauses in a tax audit report. Apart from the discussion on ICDS and Ind AS, he also dealt with clauses dealing with presumptive taxation.

Sonalee Godbole made a detailed presentation on clauses relating to secondary adjustment, thin capitalisation, GAAR and CBCR. She explained the concepts in a lucid manner with the help of examples and case studies. She also discussed the requirement of reporting the filing in Form 61A and Form 61B.

The last session was addressed by Jagdish Punjabi who covered a large number of clauses, including those related to TDS. He also discussed the impact of section 56(2) on hybrid instruments issued by the company and its reporting requirement in Form 3CD. Apart from this, he explained the applicability of sections 269SS and 269T to loans by book entry and their reporting requirement in Form 3CD.

All the sessions were interactive, with the speakers sharing their insights on their respective subjects. The participants benefited immensely with the guidance and practical views on various issues.

DIRECT TAX LAWS STUDY CIRCLE

The Direct Tax Laws Study Circle meeting on ‘Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS)’ was held on 6th September, 2019 at the BCAS Conference Hall. Group leader CA Darshak Shah gave a brief overview of the applicability of ICDS provisions and the corresponding sections in the Income-tax Act, 1961 (Act). He also explained the general approach to resolve conflicts between the provisions of the Act and ICDS.Thereafter, he discussed in detail the ten ICDS with various examples and relevant case laws. The group leader took questions from the participants with respect to the relevant examples. Besides, he touched upon the possibility of double taxation in case of ICDS – X relating to ‘Provisions, Contingent Assets and Contingent Liabilities’ in a certain scenario.The session concluded with a vote of thanks to the speaker, Darshak Shah.

FELICITATION OF FRESH, YOUNG CAS

Talk on ‘Career Planning & Interview Skills for Fresh CAs’ held on 13th September, 2019 at BCAS Conference Hall

Yet another programme organised by the Seminar, Public Relations and Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee was the felicitation programme for the newly-qualified chartered accountants who had cleared the June, 2019 examination. In fact, within hours of the announcement, the online enrolments crossed the record figure of 300, forcing BCAS to close registrations for this crucial programme.

There was a full house of 160+ participants, including some walk-ins. They were greeted at the registration desk with a copy of the BCA Journal and a membership form.

The evening started with Coordinator CA Preeti Cherian welcoming the participants and giving an overview of the purpose of the event. She was followed by President CA Manish Sampat who took the opportunity to walk down memory lane and recall his early days as a qualified chartered accountant, the sound advice that he had received from his seniors to associate himself with the BCAS, to the present when he had taken over as its President. He described the various initiatives of the Society and particularly dwelt on the 5G Annual Plan.
Chairman CA Narayan Pasari candidly admitted that the Youth or Yuva Shakti was an integral part of the numerous activities organised by the BCAS. He also appealed to the new CAs to become members and play an active role in its various activities. While speaking about the Committee’s initiatives, he talked about the Referencer, the annual RRC and other programmes. He proudly shared that the BCAS was very active on social media and its handle @BCASGlobal had recently crossed the 30K mark.

The speaker for the evening was CA Himani Shah who spoke at length on the various jobs available in the finance industry for chartered accountants. She shared tips on interview skills, including first impressions, what to do before the interview, what to wear, how to prepare, guidelines to answer questions, asking the right questions, etc. She also elaborated on the power of visual communication, business etiquette and communication. That her talk was well received could be judged from the fact that many participants had numerous questions to ask of her in the interactive session that followed.
As part of the felicitation programme, each of the participants was presented a pen with BCAS and the word ‘Achiever’ inscribed on it. The event showcased the vibrancy of the participants, many of whom showed great interest in signing up to be members of the BCAS.
A unique feature of the evening was when one of the participants thanked the speaker for clearing the many doubts that she and her fellow participants harboured. The evening ended with a vote of thanks by Convener CA Mrinal Mehta.

GOODS AND SERVICES TAX (GST)

I. HIGH COURT


1.  [2019] (26)
GSTL 449 (Del.) Comnet Vision (India) Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Trade and
Taxes
Date of order: 28th March,
2019

 

Rule 97A of
CGST Rules, 2017 allows manual filling of forms when the same could not be
filed electronically due to technical difficulties

 

FACTS

The petitioner was aggrieved by the technical difficulties faced while
filing and uploading the GST forms online. Vide Notification No. 48/2018 dated
10th September, 2018 issued by the GST Council, the time limit to
submit the forms online was extended to 31st March, 2019 because of
technical difficulties faced by the concerned entities / individuals.

 

HELD

It was held that the GST Council should enable the petitioner to file
the forms online or, where it is not possible within the time prescribed, i.e.,
31st March, 2019, the Department should entertain the forms manually
as per Rule 97A of CGST Rules, 2017; the writ petition was thus disposed of.

 


2.  [2019] (26) GSTL 334 (Mad.) Ayyan
Firewoks Factory (P) Ltd. vs. Asstt. Commr. (CT)-I (FAC), Sivakasi, Madras High
Court
Date of order: 4th September, 2018

 

Assessing officer
cannot reopen assessment based on opinion of audit party alone


FACTS

The petitioner had paid the tax without any
default. However, the respondent issued show cause notice dated 12th
January, 2010 proposing to levy interest u/s 24(3) of TNGST Act for belated
payment on the basis of the report of the audit party.

 

The grievance of the petitioner was that the opinion of the audit party
cannot constitute information, thus the AO cannot reopen the assessment on the
basis of its report. The petitioner placed reliance on the decision of Punjab
and Haryana High Court in the case of Haryana Co-operative Sugar Mills
Ltd. vs. State of Haryana 107 STC
103, wherein it was
held that ‘the audit note as received by the assessing authority was not
“definite information” as per the meaning of section 31 of the Act.’

 

HELD

The AO has to independently record his view for reopening if he proposes
to do so. Thereafter, the notice has to be issued to the parties regarding such
reopening. Further, after considering their representations / objections, the
order has to be passed. It was regarded as a clear violation of the principles
of natural justice.

 

3. [2019] (26) GSTL 16 (All.) Selvel
Media Services Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of U.P.
Date of order: 6th May, 2019

 

Advertisement
tax cannot be imposed by the municipal authorities after 1st July,
2017 since it was subsumed under the GST Law

 

FACTS

The petition was filed by an advertising company aggrieved by the demand
of advertisement tax imposed by the Nagar Nigam, Kanpur on displaying
advertisements through hoardings. Section 172(2)(h) empowering the municipal
corporation to levy advertisement tax had been deleted by virtue of section 173
of the U.P. Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017. The Constitutional provisions empowering
the State to levy advertisement tax also stood deleted by virtue of the
Constitution (101st Amendment) Act, 2016 with effect from 12th
September, 2016.

 

HELD

The High Court held that there was no power left with the State
legislature to legislate with regards to advertisement tax as the empowering
provisions stood deleted. In light of this, the demand to the extent after 1st
July, 2017
was set aside and the refund of advertisement tax, if any, deposited after 1st
July, 2017 was directed to be refunded.

 


4.  [2019] (TIOL-1975-HC-AP-GST)
Pandurang Stone Crushers vs. Union of India
Date of order: 14th August, 2019

 

Petitioner
allowed to manually rectify the GSTR3B returns for the months of August and December,
2017 and January and February, 2018

 

FACTS

The petitioner sought permission to rectify GSTR3B statements for the
months of August and December, 2017 and January and February, 2018 manually
subject to the outcome of the writ petition, pending disposal of W.P. No.
8662/2019 on the file of the High Court.

 

HELD

The Court noted that the Gujarat High Court in the case of AAP
& Co. [2019] (TIOL-1422-HC-AHM-GST)
has held the press release
dated 18th October, 2018 as illegal to the extent that its para 3
purports to clarify that the last date for availing input tax credit relating
to the invoices issued during the period from July, 2017 to March, 2018 is the
last date for the filing of return in Form GSTR3B. Besides, the Kerala High
Court, [2018] (TIOL-2902-HC-Ker.-GST) had also permitted the
request of transfer of tax liability from the head ‘SGST’ to ‘IGST’
notwithstanding the contention of the Revenue. Prima facie, the Court
held that the case is made out and that as the issues raised in the writ
petition require detailed examination, this is a fit case to grant the interim
order.

 

As such, petitioner is permitted to rectify GSTR3B statements for the
months of August and December, 2017 and January and February, 2018 manually,
subject to the outcome of the writ petition. The Court also directed that if
the petitioner submits rectified statements for the above purpose, the
respondents shall process the same in accordance with the procedure established
by law.

 

II. AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE
RULING (AAR)

 

5.  [2019] (27) GSTL 272 (AAR – GST)
Chowgule Industries Pvt. Ltd., Goa
Date of order: 26th March, 2019

 

Input Tax
Credit on the motor vehicles purchased for demonstration can be availed as ITC on
capital goods and set off against output tax payable under GST

 

FACTS

The appellant was an authorised dealer for sale of motor vehicles and
spares. He purchased vehicles against tax invoice and reflected this in the
books of accounts as capital assets. Those vehicles were used as demonstration
cars for providing trial runs to customers as it was an essential part of
marketing and sales promotion. The vehicles were held for two years or 40,000
km, whichever was earlier, and then sold. The applicable GST was paid on the
selling price.

 

But as per section 17(5) of CGST Act, ITC can only be claimed on motor
vehicles if they were used for taxable supply and for transportation of
passengers or goods or imparting training in driving, flying, navigating such
vehicles or conveniences. The appellant argued that the taxable supply included
further supply of such vehicles and the GST Act did not prescribe the time
limit within which the further supply was to be effected. Hence, section 17(5)
was not applicable in their case. They also argued that since the vehicles were
used in the course of business or furtherance of business, ITC was available as
per section 16(1) of the CGST Act.

 

HELD

It was held that section 17(5) does not prescribe any time limit for
further supply and in the present case the goods were used for business
purposes as capital goods. Therefore, Input Tax Credit on the motor vehicles
purchased for demonstration purpose was allowed. The authority also prescribed
that the credit availed on such capital goods should be subject to reversal as
per section 18(6) at the time of sale.  

Service Tax

I. HIGH COURT



1.  [2019]
(27) GSTL 182 (Cal.) Perfect Technologies vs. CESTAT, Kolkata Date of order: 23rd
April, 2019

 

Mandatory
pre-deposit @ 7.5% of total tax amount demanded on pending appeals as per section
35F of Central Excise Act, 1944. Appellant directed to deposit 50% of 7.5% in
cash and balance 50% as bank guarantee

 

FACTS

The appellant was aggrieved that he had to pre-deposit 7.5% of the
amount at the time of filing the appeal. He had to do so as per section 35F of
the Central Excise Act, 1964. But he felt that the order of pre-depositing 7.5%
was too high and harsh.

 

HELD

The Hon’ble
High Court held that considering the circumstances, relief be given to the
appellant. He was asked to deposit only 50% of the pre-deposit amount in cash
and give a bank guarantee for the balance amount.


2.    [2019] (26) GSTL 462 (Kar.)
Praxair India Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commr. of C.Ex. & ST, LTU, Bangalore
Date of order: 15th April, 2019

 

For sufficient
cause, condonation of delay was allowed on cost

 

FACTS

The appellant submitted that the Tribunal had dismissed the application
seeking condonation of delay. One of the reasons for delay in filing was
misplacement of the order due to shifting of office. However, the application
for condonation was dismissed and the Tribunal rejected the appeal on the
grounds of delay. The appellant 
approached the High Court.

 

HELD

It was held
that the reason of delay being bona fide, the impugned order be set
aside. The appeal was restored on the payment of cost of Rs. 50,000 with the
Registry.

 

II. TRIBUNAL


3.  [2019] (26) GSTL 116 (Tri. –
Ahmd.) Amar Engineering Co. vs. Commissioner of C.Ex. & ST, Vadodara-I
Date of order: 14th June, 2018

 

Refund of duty,
interest and penalty cannot be granted where voluntary payment was made by the
assessee during the course of the audit

 

FACTS

The appellant
had voluntarily made payment towards duty, interest and penalty during the
course of the audit and had requested not to issue show cause notice. The
appellant submitted an undertaking assuring that no refund shall be claimed.
However, the appellant claimed that the said amount was not liable to be paid
and, therefore, the refund claim was filed.

 

HELD

The Tribunal
observed that there was no dispute that voluntary payment was made by the
appellant on the objection raised by the audit party. Further, it was also
observed that an undertaking was filed by the appellant stating that no refund shall be claimed in the future. Thus, there
was no substance in the refund issue raised by the appellant; therefore, the
Tribunal dismissed the appeal.

 


4.  [2019] (26)
GSTL 104 (Tri. – Del.) Theme Exports Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Service Tax,
Delhi
Date of order: 9th April,
2018

 

The amount
charged by the foreign bank while remitting export proceeds from the assessee’s
bank cannot be leviable (subjected) to reverse charge in the hands of the
exporter


FACTS

The appellant
was engaged in export of garments. The appellant realised sale proceeds through
approved banking channels. Certain amount was deducted from the sales proceeds
remitted to the appellant’s bank in India either by the foreign bank or the
intermediary bank involved in the transaction.

 

HELD

The Tribunal, relying on the decision of M/s Dileep Industries
Pvt. Ltd. vs. CCE, Jaipur 2017 (10) TMI 1231-CESTAT, New Delhi
wherein,
relying on the case of Greenply Industries Ltd. vs. CCE, Jaipur it
was held that as the amount deducted by the foreign bank while remitting it to
the Indian banks is in turn charged by the Indian bank from the exporter,
therefore, the appellant was not required to pay tax under reverse charge.
Thus, the appeal was allowed in favour of the appellant.

 

5.  [2019]
TIOL-2496-CESTAT-Hyd.] Asmitha
Microfin Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise and Service Tax Date of order: 17th June, 2019

 

Service tax under RCM set aside on the ground of
revenue neutrality and limitation


FACTS

The assessee is
a public limited company registered as a Non-Banking Finance Company u/s 45 IA
of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934. They entered into a guarantee fee
agreement with a foreign company. As per the agreement, the foreign company
agreed to provide a guarantee to Standard Chartered Bank, London in relation to
the amount borrowed by the assessee from Standard Chartered Bank, Hyderabad.

 

Pursuant to an
audit, a SCN was issued covering the period April, 2009 to March, 2012
demanding service tax along with interest on the guarantee fees paid to the
foreign company covered by the definition of Banking and Other Financial
Services under reverse charge mechanism.

 

HELD

The Tribunal noted that the entire demand is under reverse charge
mechanism and if the appellant had paid the service tax under reverse charge
mechanism, they would have been entitled to CENVAT credit of exactly the same
amount. Therefore, the revenue neutrality in this case is evident. Thus, it was
held that the present demand is hit by limitation and deserves to be set aside
forthwith.

 

MISCELLANEA

I. Economy

 

1.      
Sweeping and slashing to trap
investments

 

Finance Minister
Nirmala Sitharaman’s sweeping reforms slashing corporate tax rates to bring
them at par with most South Asian and Southeast Asian nations are expected to
trap investments headed even to low-tax destinations like Bangladesh and
Vietnam.

 

While markets
saluted the Minister’s sweeping reforms of the corporate tax rates on Friday,
the best is yet to come, according to experts. The tax rates have become
competitive when compared to most other South Asian and even Southeast Asian
investment destinations.

 

A competitive
environment should help India trap some of the capital fleeing China fearing a
worsening of the US-China trade war and imposition of stiffer sanctions on
Beijing. The tariff war touched off by US President Donald Trump has only
worsened with Chinese President Xi Jinping in no mood to relent. India is
eyeing a major share of the capital moving out of China to boost Prime Minister
Narendra Modi’s ‘Make in India’ initiative, say reports.

 

India’s effective
rate of 25.17% compares well against China’s 25%. The new rates will make India
a good bargain when compared to Pakistan’s 31%, Sri Lanka’s 28% and even
Bangladesh’s 25%. Among the Southeast Asian economies, India can easily steal a
march over the Philippines which has a 30% rate and Indonesia and South Korea
who maintain a 25% rate and Malaysia with 24%. Thailand and Vietnam offer 20%,
but India could score in terms of technically skilled labour and better
infrastructure. Only Taiwan and Singapore with 17% still have a clear advantage
over India.

 

The Finance
Ministry, in consultation with the Ministry of Commerce, has been evolving a
strategy to compete with South Asian neighbours like Bangladesh which have
attracted investors because of the cheaper labour and more conducive land
acquisition laws. Indian officials think the country’s reforms will enhance its
ease of doing business rating and make it capable of taking on even Southeast
Asian competitors. Vietnam, which is drawing a lot of investment fleeing
Mainland China, has been on the Indian crosshairs for some time.

 

Government slashed
the corporate tax rate to 22% from 30% for domestic companies – and proposed a
competitive 15% rate for new investment in manufacturing. The cumulative fiscal
boost emanating from the tax law changes would amount to Rs. 1.45 lakh crores, which
sends a strong signal of the government resolve to revive economic growth, a
report on the The Economic Times website said. To be eligible for the
new concessional tax rates, companies need to forego the existing incentives
and exemptions in force. Even those opting for the status quo, the
minimum alternate tax (MAT) shrinks to 15% from 18.5%. Companies will have the
option of the lower tax rate after the expiry of the tax holidays and
concessions that they enjoy now. Once they choose the new tax rate, they can’t
revert to the concessional regime.

 

Prime Minister
Modi, bound for the US to address the historic ‘Howdy Modi!’ event along with
President Trump, termed the step to cut corporate tax rate ‘historic’, saying
it ‘will give a great stimulus to “Make in India”, attract private investment
from across the globe and help create more jobs.’

 

(Source:
International Business Times – By Prathapan Bhaskaran, 21st
September, 2019)

 

2.      
Recruitment may counter the
slowdown gloom

 

India’s
second-largest employer, Coal India Limited (CIL), is offering 9,000 openings;
4,000 people will be recruited to fill up executive posts and the rest will be
technical and non-technical staff.

 

The massive
recruitment drive to fill up about 9,000 openings in the parent company and
subsidiaries amid the gloom of a general economic slowdown and talk of stiff
divestment targets is cheering up the country’s job market, reports say. Of the
vacancies announced, 4,000 will be of executives in the parent company while
the technical hands will be taken in by the company’s eight subsidiaries, said
a report in the Economic Times. CIL sources say this would be the
biggest recruitment drive of the group in a decade.

 

CIL and its subsidiaries employ about 2,80,000 people, second only to
the Indian Railways, including nearly 18,000 at the executive level. CIL is one
of the public sector undertakings (PSU) that Finance Minister Nirmala
Sitharaman has identified for raising Rs. 3.25 lakh crores through divestment
in the next five years of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s second stint in
office. The target for the 2019-20 financial year is an estimated Rs. 1.05 lakh
crores.

 

‘Coal India is
recruiting so many executives in a single year in almost a decade in an effort
to fill up all the vacancies that have been pending for several years. Last
year, we recruited only about 1,200 people,’ the report quotes an unidentified
senior Coal India executive as saying.

 

‘Of the 4,000
executives Coal India plans to recruit, 900 would be through advertisements and
interviews in the junior category, another 400 would be recruited from campuses
and some 100 would be miscellaneous, such as medical officers, etc. We have
already recruited 400 executives most of whom are doctors. Another 75 have been
recruited and would be joining soon. The company will recruit around 2,200
additional executives through competitive examinations.’

 

The company’s coal-producing subsidiaries will recruit 5,000 workers and
technical hands, including about 2,300 who will be recruited as part of a
policy of offering jobs to families whose land was acquired for various
projects. Another 2,350 people will be hired on compassionate grounds as part
of the company’s policy of offering a job to one family member of a deceased
employee. About 400 openings will be of a non-technical nature, the report
said.

 

Set up in 1975, CIL
has been seeing mass retirement of a large number of employees at
superannuation in recent years. The number of employees who have left this way
in the last three years is pegged at more than 12,300. The posts have remained
unfilled because of a general recruitment ban in the government. While not all
posts will be filled up, the group companies need large-scale recruitment over
the next few years to ensure adequate workforce strength, the reports say.

 

(Source:
International Business Times – By Prathapan Bhaskaran, 18th September,
2019)

 

II. 
Finance

 

3.      
Credit fairs aka ‘loan melas’

 

Credit fairs by
public sector banks will bring early festival cheer to consumers as the
corporate tax bonanza will put on steroids PM Modi’s FDI push after ‘Howdy
Modi!’

 

Finance Minister
Nirmala Sitharaman’s big-ticket reforms are focused on a demand boost for the
revival of the domestic economy. For this, the Ministry has set rolling a
series of steps, apart from the headline reform of corporate tax rates that put
the stock market on steroids. The corporate tax reduction that will entail a
revenue loss of Rs. 1.45 lakh crores to the government is expected to help
Prime Minister Narendra Modi make a big splash at the ‘Howdy Modi!’ event after
which he would be meeting top executives of 16 big US corporate houses in his
foreign direct investments (FDI) campaign.

 

The major takeaways
from the series of announcements Sitharaman made were:

 

(i) Credit fairs (loan melas): The public
sector banks (PSBs) will organise fairs for potential borrowers in 400
districts, boosting liquidity and driving demand in the retail sector across
the country. The rural economy survives on retail demand and the increased
liquidity will help drive demand and spending, thus helping the rural revival,
experts believe;

(ii) NBFC role: Sitharaman’s directive to the PSBs
to ensure the participation of NBFCs in the credit fairs will help improve the
liquidity status of the NBFCs. This is particularly important because the
ailing NBFCs have been shown to be behind the economy’s illiquidity, according
to reports;

(iii) Relief for
MSMEs: The injunction on lenders to desist from declaring loans to micro,
medium and small enterprises (MSMEs) as non-performing assets (NPAs) during
this financial year ending on 31st March, 2020, will help reduce
morbidity in a vital segment of the economy, according to experts. With over 60
million units, the MSME segment is second only to the agriculture sector in
employment generation;

(iv)  MSMEs loan restructuring: Banks have been
directed to use the special dispensation that the RBI circular, ‘MSME sector –
Restructuring of Advances’, dated 1st January, 2019, has made
available. ‘We have also requested that at the branch level banks should make
efforts to sit with such stressed asset accounts of MSMEs to get them out of
the situation,’ Sitharaman said. MSMEs that are unable to repay loans within 90
days of the due date will not be stamped with the NPA tag. The facility will be
available to MSMEs whose aggregate exposure, including non-fund-based
facilities, of banks and NBFCs to the borrower does not exceed Rs. 25 crores as
on 1st January, 2019;

(v)        Spreading liquidity: The Reserve Bank of
India (RBI) has said that there is enough liquidity in the economy after its
fifth successive repo rate cuts. Sitharaman says the credit fairs will ensure
that the liquidity reaches the lowest layer of the economy, driving up
consumption;

(vi) All types of
loans: The credit fairs will be organised as public meetings to be monitored by
Minister of State for Finance Anurag Thakur to ensure that the needy get the
loans;

(vii) The reform
announcements ahead of Prime Minister Modi’s meetings in the US will serve to
send a loud message to industrialists across the world to consider India as a
friendly investment destination, especially when the US-China trade wars are
threatening FDI flow to China.

 

(Source:
International Business Times – By Prathapan Bhaskaran, 20th September,
2019)

 

4.      
Just a face to defy the law?

 

PwC India has been fined more than Rs. 230 crores (£ 26.37 m) by the
Indian Enforcement Department for breaches of the Foreign Exchange Management
Act (FEMA).

 

The ‘Big Four’ firm
had been accused of receiving large foreign investments from Netherlands-based
PricewaterhouseCoopers Services BV, which allegedly had been disguised as
‘grants’ to avoid FEMA. The legislation requires foreign investments in
financial services to be approved by the Reserve Bank of India.

 

The Directorate of
Enforcement was brought in by the Indian Supreme Court to investigate PwC’s
affairs following a public interest petition brought by the Centre for Public
Interest Litigation (CPIL), a non-governmental organisation, in 2013.

 

At the time, CPIL
called for a ruling on whether the ‘Big Four’ in general were operating in
India ‘in violation of law in force in a clandestine manner’, whether effective
steps were being taken to enforce the law and, if this was not happening, what
orders were required to ensure proper enforcement. The Indian government later
backed up the original public interest litigation with a second,
similarly-worded petition.

 

PwC was used as an example to illustrate in the petitions how global
firms were exploiting the law to build up their presence in India and gain
access to lucrative audit markets.

 

In February last
year, the Supreme Court ruled that PwC Services BV Netherlands had enabled its
Indian partners to acquire Dalal & Shah, a chartered accountancy firm based
in Mumbai and Kolkata, through a series of interest-free loans to them. This
‘circuitous route’, the judge said, was in violation of the law.

 

The Dutch firm had also shared profits in the form of licence fees and
network charges and made further investments through grants for enhancement of
skills, he said.

 

The judge concluded
that while the court could not involve itself with policy-making, it was
entitled to look at the policy framework to find out whether safeguards for
enforcement of fundamental rights had been maintained. ‘In the present context,
having regard to the statutory framework… it may prima facie appear that
there is violation of statutory provisions and policy framework, effective
enforcement of which has to be ensured’.

 

‘Statutory
regulatory provisions intended to advance the object of law have to be enforced
meaningfully,’ he continued. ‘No vested interest can flout the same by
manifesting compliance only in form. Compliance has to be in substance. The
law-enforcing agencies are expected to see the real situation.’

 

He said that the
large multinational firms’ compliance was in form, not in substance. ‘Having
got registered partnership firms with the Indian partners, the real
beneficiaries of transacting the business of chartered accountancy remain the
companies of the foreign entities. The partnership firms are merely a face to
defy the law.’

 

According to
reports, the Enforcement Department found that PwC had received the equivalent
of Rs. 229 crores in US dollars. The agency said that they were received as
grants and used ‘for various business purposes, including acquisition of other
Indian companies and paying non-compete fee’.

 

(Source:economia.icaew.com/news/september-2019/pwc-india-breached-indian-foreign-exchange-rules)
  

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

Dear Sir,

 

Thanks for continuing to bring interesting,
timely, topical and thought-provoking articles month on month.

 

I write this email regarding the article Banning
the Auditors
published in the August, 2019 issue of BCAJ. The
article covered the topical issue exhaustively and I thank the author for
sharing his valuable views and the intricate legal aspects involved.

 

In Para 1, page 16, he writes,

‘Post-IFRS and Ind AS implementation and
the use of fair values, the “cushion” that was available in
historical cost regime no longer exists. Regulators and other stakeholders need
to accept the fact that these errors in estimates are inherent to the adoption
of fair value accounting.’

 

While I completely agree that there is more
estimation uncertainty involved under Ind AS, is it a valid expectation  to expect regulators/stakeholders to accept
errors in estimates inherent in fair value? If possible, it would be
interesting to understand further the author’s point of view from the legal
defence point, too.

 

Regards,

Vinayak Pai V.

 

 

Glimpses Of Supreme Court Rulings

1.       
1.   Commissioner of Income Tax, Kolkata vs. Calcutta Export Company
(2018) 404 ITR 654 (SC)

 

Business
Expenditure – Disallowance u/s. 40(a)(ia) – The amended provision of section
40(a)(ia) of the Act should be interpreted liberally and equitable and applies
retrospectively from the date when section 40(a)(ia) was inserted i.e., with effect
from the Assessment Year 2005-2006

 

Calcutta Export Company, a
partnership firm, a manufacturer and exporter of casting materials, filed its
return of income for the Assessment Year 2005-06 for Rs. 4,18,17,910/-. The
case was selected for scrutiny and the assessment u/s. 143(3) of the Act was
completed on 28.12.2007. The Assessing Officer, vide order dated 12.10.2009,
disallowed the export commission charges paid by the assessee to Steel Crackers
Pvt. Ltd. amounting to Rs. 40,82,089/- while stating that the tax deducted at
source (TDS) on such commission amount on 07.07.2004, 07.09.2004 and 07.10.2004
ought to have been deposited by the assessee before the end of the previous
year i.e. 31.03.2005 to get the commission amount deducted from the total
income in terms of the provisions of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act as it stood then.
But the same was deposited on 01.08.2005, hence, the assessee could not be
allowed to claim deduction of the commission amount from the total income. The
Assessing Officer revised the total income to Rs. 4,58,99,999/- with the
requirement to pay the additional tax amount of Rs. 23,88,832/- by the
assessee.

 

Being aggrieved by the
order dated 12.10.2009, the assessee preferred an appeal before the
Commissioner of Income tax (Appeals). Learned CIT (Appeals), vide order dated
01.08.2011, allowed the appeal while holding that the commission amount was
eligible for deduction under the said Assessment Year.

 

Being aggrieved, the
Revenue preferred an appeal before the Tribunal, which came to be dismissed on
29.02.2012.

Being aggrieved by the
order dated 29.02.2012, the Revenue preferred an appeal before the High Court.
The High Court, vide judgment and order dated 03.09.2012, dismissed the appeal.

 

Aggrieved by the judgment
and order dated 03.09.2012, the Revenue has preferred this appeal before the
Supreme Court.

 

According to the Supreme
Court, the point that arose for its consideration was as to whether the
amendment made by the Finance Act, 2010 in section 40(a)(ia) of the IT Act is
retrospective in nature to apply to the present facts and circumstances of the
case.

 

If it is so, then the tax
duly paid by the assessee on 01.08.2005 was well in accordance with law and the
assessee is allowed to claim deduction for the tax deducted and paid to the
government, in the previous year in which the tax was deducted.

 

For deciding as to the
retrospective effect of the amendment made by Finance Act, 2010, the Supreme
Court noted the section as it stood before and after the amendment made through
the Finance Act, 2010 and the purpose of such insertion or amendment to the
said provisions. The Supreme Court noted that the purpose of bringing the said
amendment to the existing provision of section had been highlighted in the
memorandum explaining the provision which read as under:

 

“With a view to augment
compliance of TDS provisions, it is proposed to extend the provisions of the
section 40(a)(ia) to payments of interest, commission or brokerage, fee for
professional services or fee for technical services to the residents and
payments to a residential contractor or sub-contractor for carrying out any
work (including supply of labour for carrying out any work), on which tax has
not been deducted or after deduction, has not been paid before the expiry of
the time prescribed under sub-section (1) of section 200 and in accordance with
the provisions of other provisions of Chapter XVII-B”.

 

According to the Supreme
Court, the purpose was very much clear from the above referred explanation by
the memorandum that it came with a purpose to ensure tax compliance. The fact
that the intention of the legislature was not to punish the assessee was
further reflected from a bare reading of the provisions of section 40(a)(ia) of
the Act. It only resulted in shifting of the year in which the expenditure
could be claimed as deduction. In a case where the tax deducted at source was
duly deposited with the government within the prescribed time, the said amount
could be claimed as a deduction from the income in the previous year in which
the TDS was deducted. However, when the amount deducted in the form of TDS was
deposited with the government after the expiry of period allowed for such
deposit then the deductions could be claimed only in the previous year in which
such TDS payment was made to the government.

 

However, it had caused some
genuine and apparent hardship to the assessees especially in respect of tax
deducted at source in the last month of the previous year, the due date for
payment of which as per the time specified in section 200 (1) of Act was only
on 7th of April in the next year. The assessee in such case, thus,
had a period of only seven days to pay the tax deducted at source from the
expenditure incurred in the month of March so as to avoid disallowance of the
said expenditure u/s. 40(a)(ia) of Act.

 

With a view to mitigate
this hardship, section 40(a)(ia) was amended by the Finance Act, 2008.

 

The amendments made by the
Finance Act, 2008 thus provided that no disallowance u/s. 40(a)(ia) of the Act
shall be made in respect of the expenditure incurred in the month of March if
the tax deducted at source on such expenditure had been paid before the due
date of filing of the return. The amendment was given retrospective operation
from the date of 01.04.2005 i.e., from the very date of substitution of the provision.

 

Therefore, the assessees
were, after the said amendment in 2008, classified in two categories namely;
one; those who have deducted that tax during the last month of the previous
year and two; those who have deducted the tax in the remaining eleven months of
the previous year. It was provided that in case of assessees falling under the
first category, no disallowance u/s. 40(a)(ia) of the Act shall be made if the
tax deducted by them during the last month of the previous year has been paid
on or before the last day of filing of return in accordance with the provisions
of section 139(1) of the Act for the said previous year. In case, the assessees
were falling under the second category, no disallowance u/s. 40(a)(ia) of Act
where the tax was deducted before the last month of the previous year and the
same was credited to the government before the expiry of the previous year.
According to the Supreme Court, the net effect was that the assessee could not
claim deduction in the previous year in which the tax was deducted and the
benefit of such deductions could be claimed in the next year only.

 

The
Supreme Court observed that the amendment though had addressed the concerns of
the assessees falling in the first category but with regard to the case falling
in the second category, it was still resulting into unintended consequences and
causing grave and genuine hardships to the assessees who had substantially
complied with the relevant TDS provisions by deducting the tax at source and by
paying the same to the credit of the Government before the due date of filing
of their returns u/s. 139(1) of the Act. The disability to claim deductions on
account of such lately credited sum of TDS in assessment of the previous year
in which it was deducted, was detrimental to the small traders who may not be
in a position to bear the burden of such disallowance in the present Assessment
Year.

 

In order to remedy this
position and to remove hardships which were being caused to the assessees
belonging to such second category, amendments were made in the provisions of
section 40(a) (ia) by the Finance Act, 2010.


Thus, the Finance Act, 2010 further relaxed the rigors of section 40(a)(ia) of
the Act to provide that all TDS made during the previous year can be deposited
with the Government by the due date of filing the return of income. The idea
was to allow additional time to the deductors to deposit the TDS so made.
However, the Memorandum explaining the provisions of the Finance Bill, 2010
expressly mentioned as follows: “This amendment is proposed to take effect
retrospectively from 1st April, 2010 and will, accordingly, apply in
relation to the Assessment Year 2010-11 and subsequent years.”

 

The controversy surrounding
the above amendment was whether the amendment being curative in nature should
be applied retrospectively i.e., from the date of insertion of the provisions
of section 40(a)(ia) or to be applicable from the date of enforcement.

 

The Supreme Court held that
the TDS results in collection of tax and the deductor discharges dual
responsibility of collection of tax and its deposition to the government.
Strict compliance of section 40(a)(ia) may be justified keeping in view the
legislative object and purpose behind the provision but a provision of such
nature, the purpose of which is to ensure tax compliance and not to punish the
tax payer, should not be allowed to be converted into an iron rod provision
which metes out stern punishment and results in malevolent results,
disproportionate to the offending act and aim of the legislation.

 

Legislature can and do
experiment and intervene from time to time when they feel and notice that the
existing provision is causing and creating unintended and excessive hardships
to citizens and subject or have resulted in great inconvenience and
uncomfortable results. Obedience to law is mandatory and has to be enforced but
the magnitude of punishment must not be disproportionate by what is required
and necessary. The consequences and the injury caused, if disproportionate do
and can result in amendments which have the effect of streamlining and
correcting anomalies. As discussed above, the amendments made in 2008 and 2010
were steps in the said direction only. Legislative purpose and the object of
the said amendments were to ensure payment and deposit of TDS with the
Government.


The Supreme Court further held that a proviso which is inserted to remedy
unintended consequences and to make the provision workable, a proviso which
supplies an obvious omission in the section, is required to be read into the
section to give the section a reasonable interpretation and requires to be
treated as retrospective in operation so that a reasonable interpretation can
be given to the section as a whole.

 

The purpose of the
amendment made by the Finance Act, 2010 was to solve the anomalies that the
insertion of section 40(a)(ia) was causing to the bonafide tax payer.
The amendment, even if not given operation retrospectively, may not materially
be of consequence to the Revenue when the tax rates are stable and uniform or
in cases of big assessees having substantial turnover and equally huge expenses
and necessary cushion to absorb the effect. However, marginal and medium
taxpayers, who work at low gross profit rate and when expenditure which becomes
subject matter of an order u/s. 40(a)(ia) is substantial, can suffer severe
adverse consequences if the amendment made in 2010 is not given retrospective
operation i.e., from the date of substitution of the provision. Transferring or
shifting expenses to a subsequent year, in such cases, would not wipe off the
adverse effect and the financial stress. Such could not be the intention of the
legislature. Hence, the amendment made by the Finance Act, 2010 being curative
in nature was required to be given retrospective operation i.e., from the date
of insertion of the said provision.

 

The Supreme Court concluded
that the amended provision of section 40(a)(ia) of the Act should be
interpreted liberally and equitable and applies retrospectively from the date
when section 40(a)(ia) was inserted i.e., with effect from the Assessment Year
2005-2006 so that an assessee should not suffer unintended and deleterious
consequences beyond what the object and purpose of the provision mandates.

 

Since the assessee has
filed its returns on 01.08.2005 i.e., in accordance with the due date under the
provisions of section 139 Act, hence, was allowed to claim the benefit of the
amendment made by Finance Act, 2010 to the provisions of section 40(a)(ia) of
the IT Act.

 

2.       
2.    Commissioner of Income Tax vs. HCL
Technologies Ltd. (2018) 404 ITR 719 (SC)

 

Export of computer
software – Exemption/Deduction – If the deductions on freight,
telecommunication and insurance attributable to the delivery of computer
software u/s. 10A of the Act are allowed only in Export Turnover but not from
the Total Turnover then, it would give rise to illogical result which would
cause grave injustice to the Respondent which could have never been the
intention of the legislature – When the object of the formula is to arrive at
the profit from export business, expenses excluded from export turnover have to
be excluded from total turnover also

 

The Respondent – HCL
Technologies Ltd., a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, was
engaged in the business of development and export of computer softwares and
rendering technical services.

 

The
Respondent had shown gross income from business at Rs. 267,01,76,529/- while
claiming deductions under section 10A of the Act to the tune of Rs.
273,45,39,379/- showing a net loss of Rs. 6,43,62,850/-. The Respondent filed
its return of income for the Assessment Year 2004-05 on 01.11.2004 declaring
the income at Rs. 91,25,68,114/-. Thereafter, on 31.03.2005, a revised return
of income for Rs. 91,16,99,060/- was filed by the Respondent which was selected
for scrutiny u/s. 143 of the Act.

 

The Assessing Officer, vide
order dated 28.12.2006, held that the software development charges, as claimed
by the Respondent, were nothing but in the nature of expenses incurred for
technical services provided outside India. Further, in view of the fact that it
was not purely technical services and some element of software development was
also involved in it and in the absence of such bifurcation, the Assessing
Officer estimated such expense at the rate of 40% and remaining 60% for
providing technical services by the Respondent in foreign exchange to its
offshore clients and assessed the taxable income at Rs. 137,20,34,576/- and
levied penalty to the tune of Rs. 21,81,90,239/-.

 

Being aggrieved, the
Respondent preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals).
Learned CIT (Appeals), vide order dated 09.05.2007, partly allowed the appeal
while estimating 10% as software development charge incurred for technical
services provided outside India as against 60% estimated by the Assessing
Officer.

 

Being aggrieved, the
Respondent as well as the Revenue, preferred cross appeals before the Tribunal.
The Tribunal, vide order dated 23.01.2009, dismissed the appeal filed by the
Revenue while allowing the appeal of the Respondent.

 

Being aggrieved, the
Revenue preferred an appeal before the High Court. The High Court, vide order
dated 15.12.2009, dismissed the appeal of the Revenue.

Hence, Revenue filed
appeals before the Supreme Court.


According to the Supreme Court, the only point for consideration before it was
whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the software development
charges were to be excluded while working out the deduction admissible u/s. 10A
of the Act on the ground that such charges were relatable towards expenses
incurred on providing technical services outside India?

 

The Supreme Court noted
that the Respondent was engaged in the business of software development for its
customers engaged in different activities at software development centres of
the Respondent. However, in the process of such customised software
development, certain activities were required to be carried out at the sight of
customers on site, located outside India for which the employees of the
branches of the Respondent located in the country of the customers were
deployed. Moreover, after delivery of such softwares as per requirement, in
order to make it fully functional and hassle free functioning subsequent to the
delivery of softwares in many cases, there could be requirement of technical
personnel to visit the client on site. The Assessing Officer had not brought any
evidence that the Respondent was engaged in providing simply technical services
independent to software development for the client for which the expenditures
were incurred outside India in foreign currency.

 

The Supreme Court further
noted that the Respondent company had claimed deduction u/s. 10A as per
certificates filed on Form No. 56F. The Respondent, while computing the
deduction, had taken the same figure of export turnover as of total turnover.
The Respondent had cited various judicial cases but all these cases pertained
to deduction u/s. 80HHC.

 

The Supreme Court also
noted that the definition of total turnover had been defined in section 80HHC
and 80HHE of the Act and that the definition of total turnover had not been
defined u/s. 10A of the Act.

 

The Supreme Court held that
the definition of total turnover given u/s. 80HHC and 80HHE could not be
adopted for the purpose of section 10A as the technical meaning of total
turnover, which does not envisage the reduction of any expenses from the total
amount, is to be taken into consideration for computing the deduction u/s. 10A.
When the meaning is clear, there is no necessity of importing the meaning of
total turnover from the other provisions. If a term is defined u/s. 2 of the
Act, then the definition would be applicable to all the provisions wherein the
same term appears. As the term ‘total turnover’ has been defined in the
Explanation to section 80HHC and 80HHE, wherein it has been clearly stated that
“for the purposes of this section only”, it would be applicable only
for the purposes of that sections and not for the purpose of section 10A. If
denominator includes certain amount of certain type which numerator does not
include, the formula would render undesirable results.

 

In the instant case, if the
deductions on freight, telecommunication and insurance attributable to the
delivery of computer software u/s. 10A of the Act are allowed only in Export
Turnover but not from the Total Turnover then, it would give rise to
inadvertent, unlawful, meaningless and illogical result which would cause grave
injustice to the Respondent which could have never been the intention of the
legislature.

 

Even in common parlance,
when the object of the formula is to arrive at the profit from export business,
expenses excluded from export turnover have to be excluded from total turnover
also.

 

On the issue of expenses on
technical services provided outside, one has to follow the same principle of
interpretation as followed in the case of expenses of freight, telecommunication
etc., otherwise the formula of calculation would be futile. Hence, in the same
way, expenses incurred in foreign exchange for providing the technical services
outside should be allowed to excluded from the total turnover.

 

According to the Supreme
Court, the appeal was devoid of merits and thus was dismissed.

 

3.       3.    Mahaveer Kumar Jain vs. Commissioner of
Income-tax (2018) 404 ITR 738 (SC)

 

Income-tax Act not
applicable to Sikkim till 1989 – Prize money earned in Sikkim State Lottery in
1986 – Once the assessee having paid the income tax at source in the State of
Sikkim as per the law applicable at the relevant time in Sikkim, the same
income was not taxable under the Income-tax Act, 1961

 

The Appellant, a resident
of Jaipur, Rajasthan, having income from business and property, won the first
prize of Rs. 20 lakhs in the 287th Bumper Draw of the Sikkim State
Lottery held on 20.02.1986 at Gangtok organised by the Director, State Lottery,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok. Out of Rs. 20 lakhs, the Appellant herein
received Rs. 16,20,912/- through two Demand Drafts for Rs. 8,10,000/- and Rs.
8,10,912/- each, after deduction of Rs. 2 lacs being agent’s/seller’s
commission and Rs. 1,79,088/- being Income Tax under the Sikkim State Income
Tax Rules, 1948.

 

The Appellant herein filed
Income Tax Return for the Assessment Year (AY) 1986-87 disclosing the income
from lottery at Rs. 20 lakhs and deducting the agent/seller commission of Rs. 2
lakhs out of the same. He claimed deduction u/s. 80TT of the Act on Rs.
20,00,000/- i.e. the gross amount of the prize money won in the lottery in
accordance with the provisions of the charging section.

 

On scrutiny, the Assessing
Officer (AO), vide order dated 08.01.1988, allowed the deduction u/s. 80TT of
the Act on Rs. 18 lakhs instead of Rs. 20 lakhs while holding that the
Government of Sikkim, had deducted the tax at source from the lottery amount of
Rs. 18 lakhs as Rs. 2 lakhs have been paid to the agent directly. In other
words, under the relevant provisions of section 80TT of the Act, the deduction
can be claimed only on net income out of lottery and not on the gross income.
The said order was further confirmed by the Commissioner of Income Tax,
(Appeals) vide order dated 31.10.1988.

 

Being aggrieved, the
present Appellant preferred an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
challenging the computation by the Assessing Officer (AO) of the deduction u/s.
80TT of the IT Act. The Appellant Assessee raised an additional ground before
the Tribunal claiming that the authorities below have grossly erred in law in
treating the lottery income of Sikkim Government as income under the Act.

 

Though the Tribunal allowed
the appeal partly vide order dated 26.02.1993 but it dismissed the objections
raised by the Appellant herein as to legality of assessment order and held that
the lottery amount is taxable under the provisions of Act.

 

However, at the instance of
the Appellant Assessee, the Tribunal framed certain questions under Act and
referred the same to the High Court for opinion, considering them the questions
of law fit for reference which are as under:



1.    Whether on the facts and in the circumstance
of the case, the Hon’ble Tribunal was justified in holding that income from
Sikkim State Lottery is taxable under the Income Tax Act, 1961?

 

2.    Whether in the facts and circumstances of the
case the Tribunal was justified in holding that deduction u/s. 80TT is
applicable on the net winning amount received by the Assessee and not on the
gross amount of the winning prize?

 

A Division
Bench of the High Court, vide judgment and order dated 10.09.2004, answered the
questions raised in affirmative.

 

Aggrieved
by the judgment and order dated 10.09.2004, the Appellant-Assessee preferred
appeal by way of special leave before the Supreme Court.

 

According
to the Supreme Court, the issue that arose for its consideration in the present
case was whether income from lottery earned is taxable under the Act especially
when such income was already taxed under the provisions of Sikkim State Income
Tax Rules, 1948. If so, whether the deduction that is to be allowed on such
income u/s. 80TT of the Act is on ‘gross income’ or on the ‘net income’.

 

The
Supreme Court noted that prior to 26.04.1975, Sikkim was not considered to be a
part of India. Any income accruing or arising there from would be treated as
income accruing or arising in any foreign country. However, by the 36th
amendment to the Indian Constitution in 1975, Sikkim became part of the Indian
Union. This, amendment was effected by introducing Article 371F in the
Constitution.

 

According
to the Supreme Court, on a plain reading of this provisions of Article 371F, it
was clear that all laws which were in force prior to April 26, 1975, in the
territories now falling within the State of Sikkim or any part thereof were
intended to continue to be in force until altered or repealed. Therefore, the
law in force prior to the merger, continued to be applicable.

 

The
Income-tax Act was made applicable only by Notification made in 1989 and the
first assessment year would be 1990-91 and by the application of this Act, the
Sikkim State Income Tax Manual, 1948 stood repealed.

 

The
Supreme Court observed that in the present case, it was concerned with the
assessment year 1986-87, and, during this time, the Income-tax Act had not been
made applicable to the territories of Sikkim. The law corresponding to the
Income-tax Act, which immediately was in force in the relevant State was Sikkim
State Income Tax Rules, 1948. Hence, there could be two situations, first is that
the person was a resident of Sikkim during the time period of 1975-1990 and the
income accrued and received by him there only. In such a case, no question of
applicability of the Income-tax Act arises.

 

However,
the problem arises where the income accrues to a person from the State of
Sikkim who was not a resident of Sikkim but of some other part of India. The
question that arises is whether the provisions of the Income-tax Act are
applicable to such income and whether the same could be subjected to tax under
the said Act especially in light of the fact that the income has already been
subjected to tax under the Sikkim State Income Tax Rules, 1948.

 

According
to the Supreme Court, the Appellant, being a resident of Rajasthan, received
the income arising from winning of lotteries from Sikkim during the Assessment
Year in question was liable to be included in the hands of the assessee as
resident of India within the State of Rajasthan where Income-tax Act was in
force notwithstanding that the same had accrued or arisen to him at a place
where the Income-tax Act was not in force even in respect of income accruing to
him without taxable territory. Section 5 of the Income-tax Act casts a very
wide net and all incomes accruing anywhere in the world would be brought within
its ambit.

 

However,
in the present case, that the amount had been earned by the Appellant-Assessee
in the State of Sikkim and the amount of lottery prize was sent by the
Government of Sikkim to Jaipur on the request made by the Appellant. The
result, therefore, was that, while section 5 of the Act would not be
applicable, the existing Sikkim State Income Tax Rules, 1948 would be
applicable, since Sikkim was a part of India for the accounting year,
therefore, on the same income, two types of income-taxes could not be applied.
It was a fundamental Rule of law of taxation that, unless otherwise expressly
provided, income cannot be taxed twice.

 

According
to the Supreme Court, therefore, the only question remained to be decided was
whether in fact there was a specific provision for including the income earned
from the Sikkim lottery ticket prior to 01.04.1990 and after 1975, in the
income-tax return or not. The Supreme Court after going through the relevant
provisions could not find such a provision in the Act wherein a specific
provision has been made by the legislature for including such an income by an
Assessee from lottery ticket. In the absence of any such provision, according
to the Supreme Court, the Assessee in the present case could not be subjected
to double taxation. Furthermore, a taxing Statute should not be interpreted in
such a manner that its effect will be to cast a burden twice over for the
payment of tax on the taxpayer unless the language of the Statute is so
compelling that the court has no alternative than to accept it. In a case of
reasonable doubt, the construction most beneficial to the taxpayer is to be
adopted. So, it was clear enough that the income in the present case was
taxable only under one law. By virtue of Clause (k) to Article 371F of the
Constitution which starts with a non-obstante clause, it would be clear that
only the Sikkim Regulations on Income-tax would be applicable in the present
case. Therefore, the income could not be brought to tax any further by applying
the rates of the Income-tax Act.

 

In view of the aforementioned
discussions, the Supreme Court held that once the assessee had paid the income
tax at source in the State of Sikkim as per the law applicable at the relevant
time in Sikkim, the same income was not taxable under the Income-tax Act, 1961.
Having decided so, the other issue whether the income that is to be allowed deduction
u/s. 80TT of the IT Act is on ‘Net Income’ or ‘Gross Income’, became academic.

From Published Accounts

Accounting and disclosure regarding application of Ind AS by
companies in the Non-Banking Financial Sector (NBFC) for the quarter ended 30
th
June 2018

 

Compilers’
Note:
As per
the transition notification of Ministry of Company Affairs (MCA), Ind AS became
applicable to Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) with effect from 1st
April 2018 with a transition date of 1st April 2017. Given below are the disclosures in unaudited results
of Quarter ended 30th June 2018 by few NBFCs.

 

Bajaj Finance Ltd

1.   The company has adopted Indian Accounting
Standards (‘IndAS’) notified u/s. 133 of the Companies Act, 2013 (“the Act”)
read with the Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules, 2015, from 1st April, 2018 and the effective
date of such transition is 1st
April, 2017. Such transition has been carried out from the erstwhile Accounting
Standards notified under the Act, read with relevant rules issued thereunder
and guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of India (‘RBI’) (collectively
referred to as “The Previous GAAP”). Accordingly, the impact of transition has
been recorded in the opening reserves as at 1st April, 2017 and the corresponding figures presented
in these results have been restated/ reclassified.

 

There is a
possibility that these financial results for the current and previous periods
may require adjustments due to changes in financial reporting requirements
arising from new standards, modifications to the existing standards, guidelines
issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and RBI or changes in the use of
one or more options exemptions from full retrospective application of certain
IndAS permitted under IndAS-101.

 

2.   As required by paragraph 32 of IndAS 101, net
profit reconciliation between the figures reported under previous GAAP and
IndAS is as follows:

(Rs.in Crore)

Particulars

Quarter Ended

Year ended

31.03.2018 (reviewed)

30.06.2017 (reviewed)

31.03.2018 (reviewed)

Net profit after tax as reported under Previous GAAP

720.95

602.04

2646.7

Adjustments increasing/ (decreasing) net
profit after tax as reported under previous GAAP:

 

 

 

Adoption of EIR* for amortisation of income and expenses-
financial assets at amortised cost

13.51

(122.11)

(118.03)

Adoption of EIR for amortisation of expenses- financial
liabilities at amortised cost

(1.91)

3.37

6.6

Expected Credit Loss

20.4

(8.4)

(0.92)

Fair Valuation of Stock options as per IndAS 102

(12.26)

(8.75)

(45.01)

Actuarial Loss on employee defined benefit plan recognised in
‘Other comprehensive income’ as per IndAS 19

5.23

–

5.23

Fair valuation of Financial Assets at Fair value through
profit
and loss

(3.14)

(9.75)

(10.06)

Net Profit after tax as per IndAS

Other comprehensive income, net of tax

742.78


(7.59)

456.4


3.03

2484.51


(17.62)

Total Comprehensive Income

735.19

459.43

2466.89

 

 

*EIR = Effective
Interest Rate

 

Mahindra & Mahindra Financial Services
Ltd

1.   The financial results of the company have
been prepared in accordance with Indian Accounting Standards (‘IndAS’) notified
under the Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules, 2015 as amended by the
Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules, 2016.

 

The Company has
adopted IndAS from 1st
April, 2018 with effective transition date of 1st April, 2017 and accordingly, these financial results
together with the results for the comparative reporting period have been
prepared in accordance with the recognition and measurement principles as laid down
in IndAS 34- Interim Financial Reporting, prescribed u/s. 133 of the Companies
Act, 2013 (‘the Act’) read with relevant rules issued thereunder and the other
accounting principles generally accepted in India.

 

The transition to
IndAS has been carried out from the erstwhile Accounting Standards notified
under the Act, read with Rule 7 of Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014 (as
Amended) guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of India (‘the RBI’) and other generally accepted accounting principles in
India (collectively referred to as ‘the Previous GAAP’).

 

Accordingly, the
impact of transition has been recorded in the opening reserves as at 1st April, 2017 and the
corresponding adjustments pertaining to comparative previous period/ quarter as
presented in these financial results have been restated/ reclassified in order
to conform to current period presentation.

 

The financial
results have been drawn up on the basis of IndAS that are applicable to the
Company as at 30th June 2018 based on the Press Release issues by
the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (“MCA”) on 18th January, 2016. Any
application guidance/ clarifications/ directions issued by RBI or other
regulators are implemented as and when they are issued/ applicable.

 

2.     As required by Para 32 of IndAS 101, the profit reconciliation between the figures previously reported under Previous
GAAP and restated as per IndAS is as follows:

(Rs.in Lakhs)

 

Quarter ended 30th June 2017

Profit after tax as reported under Previous GAAP

4738.5

Adjustments resulting in increase/
(decrease) in profit after tax as reported under Previous GAAP

 

(7257.72)

29573.51

981.24


194.63


55.24

(8149.11)

i) Impact on recognition of fixed assets and financial
liabilities at amortised cost by application of effective interest rate
method

ii) Impact on application of Expected Credit Loss method for
loan loss provisions

iii) Impact on reconciliation of securitised loan portfolio
(derecognised in Previous GAAP)

iv) Reclassification of Actuarial Loss to Other Comprehensive
Income

v) Others

vi) Tax Impact on above adjustments

Profit after tax as reported under IndAS

20136.37

(127.27)

Other Comprehensive Income/ (Loss) (Net of Tax)

Total Comprehensive Income (After Tax) as reported under
IndAS

20009.10

 

 

Housing Development
Finance Corporation Ltd

1.     The corporation has adopted Indian
Accounting Standards (‘IndAS’) notified u/s. 133 of the Companies Act, 2013
(“the Act”) read with the Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules, 2015,
from 1st April,
2018 and the effective date of such transition is 1st April, 2017. Such transition
has been carried out from the erstwhile Accounting Standards notified under the
Act, read with relevant rules issued thereunder and guidelines issued by the
National Housing Bank (‘NHB’) (collectively referred to as “The Previous
GAAP”). Accordingly, the impact of transition has been recorded in the opening
reserves as at 1st
April, 2017. The corresponding figures presented in these results have been
prepared on the basis of the previously published results under previous GAAP
for the relevant periods, duly restated to IndAS. These IndAS adjustments have
been reviewed by the Statutory Auditors.

 

These financial
results have been drawn up on the basis of IndAS Accounting Standards that are
applicable to the corporation as at 30th June, 2018 based on MCA
Notification G.S.R. 111 (E) and G.S.R. 365 (E) dated 16th February, 2015 and 30th March, 2016 respectively.
Any application guidance/ clarifications/ directions issued by NHB or other regulators
are adopted/ implemented as and when they are issued/ applicable.

 

2.     As required by Paragraph 32 of IndAS 101,
net profit reconciliation between the figures reported, net of tax, under
previous GAAP and IndAS is give below:

 

(Rs.in Crore)

 

Quarter ended 30th June 2017

Profit after tax as per Previous GAAP

1552.42

 

 

Adjustment
on account of effective interest rate/ forex valuation/ net interest on
credit impaired loans

(106.31)

Adjustment
on account of expected credit loss

(50.55)

Adjustment
due to fair valuation of employee stock options

(95.16)

Fair
value change in investments

17.49

Reversal
of Deferred tax Liability on 36(1)(viii) for the quarter

105.21

Other
Adjustments

1.37

 

 

Profit after tax as per IndAS

1424.47

Other
Comprehensive Income (Net of Tax)

(14.56)

Total Comprehensive Income (Net of Tax) as per IndAS

1409.91

 

 

LIC Housing Finance Ltd

1.     The company has adopted Indian Accounting
Standards (‘IndAS’) notified u/s. 133 of the Companies Act, 2013 (“the Act”) read
with the Companies (Indian Accounting Standards) Rules, 2015, from 1st
April, 2018 and the effective date of such transition is 1st April,
2017. Such transition has been carried out from the erstwhile Accounting
Standards notified under the Act, read with relevant rules issued thereunder
and guidelines issued by the National Housing Bank (‘NHB’) (collectively
referred to as “The Previous GAAP”). Accordingly, the impact of transition has
been recorded in the opening reserves as at 1st April, 2017. The
figures for the corresponding period presented in these results have been
prepared on the basis of the published results under previous GAAP for the
relevant periods, duly restated to IndAS. These IndAS adjustments have been
reviewed by the Statutory Auditors.

These financial
results have been drawn up on the basis of IndAS that are applicable to the
company based on MCA Notification G.S.R. 111 (E) and G.S.R. 365 (E) dated 16th
February, 2015 and 30th March, 2016 respectively. Any
guidance/ clarifications/ directions issued by NHB or other regulators are
adopted/ implemented as and when they are issued/ applicable.

 

2.     As required by Paragraph 32 of IndAS 101,
net profit reconciliation between the figures reported, net of tax, under
previous GAAP and IndAS is give below:

 

(Rs.in Crore)

 

Quarter ended 30th June 2017

Net Profit after tax as per Previous
GAAP

470.06

 

 

Adjustment on account of effective
interest rate for financial assets and liabilities recognised at amortised
cost / net interest on credit impaired loans

23.14

Adjustment on account of expected credit
loss

(65.07)

Reversal of Deferred tax Liability on 36(1)(viii)
for the quarter

51.37

Other Adjustments

0.15

 

 

Net Profit after tax as per IndAS

479.65

Other Comprehensive Income (Net of Tax)

(0.47)

Total Comprehensive Income (Net of Tax)
as per IndAS

479.18

 

 

TATA Investment Corporation Ltd

1.     The company has adopted Indian Accounting
Standards (‘IndAS’) as notified under of the Companies Act, 2013 (“the Act”),
from 1st April, 2018 with the effective date of such transition
being 1st April, 2017. Such transition had been carried out from the
erstwhile Accounting Standards as notified (referred to as ‘the Previous
GAAP’). Accordingly, the impact of transition has been recorded in the opening
reserves as at 1st April, 2017 and the corresponding figures
presented in these results have been restated/ reclassified.

 

2.     As required by Paragraph 32 of IndAS 101,
net profit reconciliation between Indian GAAP and IndAS for the quarter ended
30-06-2017 is as follows:

       (Rs.in Crore)

Particulars

Quarter ended 30th June 2017

Unaudited

Net Profit as per Indian GAAP

45.3

IndAS Adjustments

 

 Gain on equity
instruments classified as fair valued through Other Comprehensive Income
(OCI)

(36.97)

Changes in fair value of mutual funds/ venture capital funds

2.25

Taxes impacts (Current Tax and Deferred Tax)

7.41

Decrease in Interest Income by using Effective Interest rate

(0.01)

Total Effect of Transition to IndAS

(27.32)

 

 

Net Profit after tax as per IndAS (transfer to retained
earnings)

17.98

 

 

Other Comprehensive Income (OCI) as per IndAS

 

(a) Items that will not be reclassified
to Profit and Loss account:

 

Changes in Fair valuation of equity instruments

291.58

Tax Impacts on above

(62.23)

(b) Items that will be reclassified to
Profit and Loss account:

 

Changes in Fair value of Bonds/ Debentures

5.2

Tax Impacts on above

(1.11)

 

 

Total Other Comprehensive Income

233.44

 

 

Total Comprehensive Income as per IndAS

251.42

 

 

Max Financial Services Ltd

1.     The financial results of the company have
been prepared in accordance with Indian Accounting Standards (‘IndAS’) notified
under section 133 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with relevant rules issues
thereunder (‘IndAS’). Beginning 1st April, 2018, the company has for
the first time adopted IndAS with the transition date of 1st  April, 2017. These financial results
(including the period presented in accordance with IndAS-101 First time
adoption of the Indian Accounting Standards) have been prepared in accordance
with the recognition and measurement principles in IndAS 34- Interim Financial
Reporting, prescribed u/s. 133 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with relevant
rules issued thereunder and other accounting principles generally accepted in
India.

 

There is a
possibility that these financial results for the current and previous period
may require adjustments due to changes in financial reporting requirements
arising from new standards, modifications to the existing standards, guidelines
issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs or changes in the use of one or
more optional exemptions from full retrospective application of certain IndAS
provisions permitted under IndAS 101 which may arise upon finalisation of the
financial statements as at and for the year ending 31st March, 2019
prepared
under IndAS.

 

2.     Reconciliation of net profit between Indian
GAAP as previously reported and Total Comprehensive Income as per IndAS is as
follows:

 

(Rs. in Crores)

Sr. No.

Nature of Adjustments

Corresponding 3 months ended 30.06.2017

 

Net Profit after tax as per erstwhile Indian GAAP (prior GAAP)

66.58

a)

Effect of Fair value of Investments in Mutual Funds

0.64

b)

Effect of measuring financial instruments at amortised cost*

–

c)

Effect of recognising Employee Stock Options and phantom
stock options cost at fair value

(1.75)

d)

Effect of recognising actuarial (gain)/ loss on Employee
defined benefit liability under Other Comprehensive Income

0.01

e)

Effect of fair value of financial instruments carried at fair
value through Profit or loss (FVTPL)

1.71

 

Net Profit after tax as per IndAS (A)

67.19

 

Other Comprehensive Income/ (loss) (B)

(0.01)

 

Total Comprehensive Income as per IndAS (A+B)

67.18

 

 

*Amount is Rs. 0.29 lakhs.   

 

MISCELLANEA

I. Economy

1. India’s plan for public-private partnerships and
investments in railways set to transform the sector

 

The Indian Railways is in for a massive
makeover, rather a complete transformation. ‘India needs world-class railways
and it needs to be better than the airports,’ Amitabh Kant, CEO of the Niti
Aayog, said during a press conference at National Media Centre, while giving a
peep into the upcoming public-private partnerships in passenger train
operations. Joining him was the CEO of the Railway Board, Vinod Kumar Yadav.

 

‘This creates a win-win situation for Indian
Railways as well as investors, by tapping into the potential of huge unmet
demand in the passenger business. The private sector investment we are looking
at is about Rs. 30,000 crores,’ Kant said.

 

A peep into the Railways 2.0

The infrastructure of Indian Railways will
meet private entities operating modern technology. This means quality trains,
advanced technology, better service and a much better experience.

 

‘We are looking at 109 origin-destination
pairs, divided into 12 clusters requiring 151 trains… Our objective is also
50 railway stations.’

 

Kant further explained that efforts are
underway for transparent competitive bidding and some new, attractive routes
based on huge unmet demand will be put out to run premium passenger services.
In sync with the modernisation vibe, the newly-developed railway hubs will be
called Railopolis.

 

Public-private participation, it’s
happened before

Any inclusive discussion on privatisation
has often turned into apprehensions to do with the government’s redundancy. For
those looking at the flipside of the private investment, Kant puts a lot of
apprehensions to rest with the simple precedence of banks.

 

‘It is like when private banks were set up
in India. So many private players came in the banking sector. But that did not
lead SBI to shut. Private investment will bring in newer technologies. It will
create competition in the railway sector. The competition will increase
efficiency and reduce fares in the long run,’ he clarified to both in-house and
web-based participants during the conference.

 

Nominal hike in fares, experience
overhaul

The request for a quotation has already been
floated and the due date for applications is 7th October, 2020.
Addressing queries on the user charge proposed to be levied for the
redevelopment of railway stations, he assured that it will be a nominal amount.

 

‘It will be an affordable amount but it is
important to levy if we are looking at world-class facilities comparable to
airport infrastructure.’

 

The logistics, in a nutshell

The project will have a two-stage bidding
process; the first stage will comprise RFQ for pre-qualification based on
financial capacity, at least 50% of the estimated project cost. There will be
twelve clusters available for investment, namely, Chandigarh, Chennai,
Bengaluru, Delhi 1 and 2, Howrah, Mumbai 1 and 2, Jaipur, Patna, Secunderabad
and Prayagraj.

 

(Source: International Business Times –
By Manpriya Khurana – 18th September, 2020)


 

2. RBI stands battle-ready to take whatever steps
needed for Covid-hit Indian economy: Governor Shaktikanta Das

 

Reserve Bank of
India (RBI) Governor Shaktikanta Das, while addressing the members of the India
Inc. body FICCI, said that the country’s economic recovery is not fully
entrenched and will be gradual as the impact of the coronavirus pandemic has
still not subsided.

 

‘Recovery is not
yet fully entrenched. In some sectors, the optics noticed in June and July
appear to have levelled off. By all indications, the recovery is likely to be
gradual as efforts towards reopening of the economy are confronted with rising
infections.’

 

The Governor’s
remarks come at a time when the country’s economy is going through a period of
crisis. He also said that some high-frequency indicators including agricultural
activity, Purchasing Managers Index for manufacturing, certain private
estimates for unemployment point to ‘some stabilisation’ of economic activity
in the second quarter of the current fiscal year.

 

‘Contractions in
many other sectors (are) simultaneously easing,’ he said.

 

‘Global economy
is estimated to have suffered the sharpest contraction in living memory in
April-June, 2020 on a seasonally adjusted quarter-on-quarter basis. World
merchandised trade estimated to have registered a steep year-on-year decline of
over 18% in the second quarter of the 2020 calendar year,’ the RBI Governor
added.

 

(Source:
International Business Times – By Meghna Sen – 16th September, 2020)

 

II. Science & Health

 

3. World leaders
drew 2020 deadline to save earth; set 20 goals, achieved none in 10 years

 

One million
species are at the risk of extinction as nature degrades and new opportunities
emerge for the spread of viruses like this year’s coronavirus.

 

Ten years; 196
world leaders; business as usual approach. And a bad report card. In 2010,
leaders from 196 countries gathered in Japan and agreed on a long list of goals
to save the only inhabitable planet known to mankind, Earth. They set a 2020
deadline to save nature and meet the 20 targets – but not a single target has
been met.

 

According to the
UN’s Global Biodiversity Outlook Report, the fifth report published in the
matter, the world has failed to achieve even a single goal from the list of
Aichi Biodiversity Targets. Aichi Targets are to biodiversity what the Paris
Convention is to climate change. These targets were established under the UN
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and are the best bet of nations for
biodiversity conservation.

 

First the sad
news, then the scary news

As per the UN
report, one million species are at risk of extinction. ‘Pollution, including
from excess nutrients, pesticides, plastics and other waste, continues to be a
major driver of biodiversity loss. Plastic pollution is accumulating in the
oceans, with severe impacts on marine ecosystems,’ the report states.

 

It must also be
noted, the report further warns, ‘The number of extinctions of birds and
mammals would likely have been at least two to four times higher without
conservation actions in the past decade.’

 

So small steps,
though not nearly enough, still truly count.

 

Twenty
targets, only six achieved… partially

Let’s start with
the less bad news. Each nation was supposed to meet each of the 20 targets. The
six targets that have been partially met in the past decade are to do with –
preventing invasive species, conservation of protected areas, sharing benefits
from genetic resources, biodiversity strategies and improvement and
dissemination of knowledge, the science base and technologies relating to
biodiversity.

 

On average, the
participating countries reported that more than a third of national targets are
on track to be met, 50% of them were seeing slower progress, 11% showed no
progress and 1% were in fact moving in the wrong direction.

 

Money spent
vs. money needed

The 212-page
report also zeroes things down to funding. The half-hearted approach and the
significance governments attach to the environment and climate crises reflect
in the funding. Governments at a global level spend $78 to $91 billion annually
towards the conservation and promotion of biodiversity. That is significantly
less than the hundreds of billions of dollars needed to give the cause the
momentum it needs.

 

The faint
silver lining

As per the
report, the recent rate of deforestation is lower than that of the previous
decade, but only by about one-third, but deforestation may be accelerating
again in some areas. Programmes to eradicate invasive alien species, especially
invasive mammals on islands, have benefited native species. However, the report
cuts short the celebration, ‘These successes represent only a small proportion
of all occurrences of invasive species.’

 

Now what?

‘This flagship
report underlines that humanity stands at a crossroads with regard to the
legacy we wish to leave to future generations,’ said CBD Executive Secretary
Elizabeth Maruma Mrema.

 

The statement
further reads, ‘As nature degrades, new opportunities emerge for the spread to
humans and animals of devastating diseases like this year’s coronavirus. The
window of time available is short, but the pandemic has also demonstrated that
transformative changes are possible when they must be made.’

 

If the pandemic
doesn’t make humanity imbibe the lessons, nothing else really will.

 

(Source:
International Business Times – By Manpriya Khurana – 17th September,
2020)

 


SOCIETY NEWS

WEBINAR ON
‘CLOUD SOLUTION’

 

The Technology Committee of the BCAS
organised a webinar on ‘Cloud Solution by Google and Microsoft’ on Saturday, 25th
July, 2020.

 

Mr. Juned
Kasmani
, a Google Sales
‘Certified Professional’ having an experience of more than ten years in the
cloud industry and in Google Cloud, gave an overview of G-Suite and compared it
with MS Office 365 relevant to the professionals. He also gave a glimpse of the
management interface and administrative control of G-Suite.

 

Mr. Kasmani also
shared a demo on the productivity apps for creating and collaborating documents
on the Cloud and showcased the various corporate communication tools available
to practitioners.

 

He was joined by Mr. Punit Thakkar,
CEO of Shivaami Solutions, who answered all the questions posed by the
participants and also ran a live demo of the G-Suite and MS Office
applications.

 

The session was interactive and the speakers
concentrated on:

1.  Introduction and comparison of G-Suite and
Office 365,

2.  Business email and shared calendaring
services,

3.  Corporate communication tools,

4.  Productivity apps for creating and
collaborating,

5.  Google Drive vs. One Drive based on online
storage, with shared space for collaboration along with security features,

6.  Comparisons based on offering and price
points,

7.  Solutions by third party service providers.

 

The participants gained insights into
G-Suite and MS Office 365 applications and learned new ways of working more effectively
in an evolving and changing professional services and regulatory environment.

 

SOFTWARE
FOR GST

 

The Suburban Study Circle along with the
Technology Initiatives Committee conducted an online meeting styled ‘Excel –
GST ki Jugalbandi’
on 5th September. The meeting was led by Sandeep
Modi
.

 

The speaker demonstrated many Excel Tips and
Tricks for effective preparation and compilation of data for filing GST
returns. The following issues were discussed:

 

(i)    Look Up Magic,

(ii)   How to handle frequent
updating of client data in
       Excel,

(iii)  Date format issues,

(iv)  Tricks / Automating GSTR1,

(v)   GSTR2 & Purchase Reconciliation,

(vi)  Shortcuts in filing GSTR3B,

(vii) GST Liability Calculation Sheet.

 

Sandeep Modi
also shared Excel templates with the participants for future reference and use.
The personal working experiences in Excel for filing GST returns, issues faced
and their solutions will be of immense help to the participants.

 

There were more than 140 participants on
Zoom and 300 on YouTube who attended and imbibed the knowledge that was shared.
The speaker answered all the questions raised by the participants in the
session.

 

 

Let us learn to appreciate there
will be times when the trees will be bare, and look forward to the time when we
may pick the fruit

— 
Anton Chekhov

STATISTICALLY SPEAKING

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ETHICS AND U

Shrikrishna: Parth, you are
looking in a cheerful mood today! Quite unusual.

 

Arjun: Why?

 

Shrikrishna: Normally, in September
you are always stressed, depressed and nervous. This is the time you are always
busy longing for extension of the tax deadline.

 

Arjun:
You’re right! But this year, for tax returns the date is already extended. Now,
the company’s AGM dates have also got extended. So, relaxing.

 

Shrikrishna: And what about staff?
Articles?

 

Arjun: That is always a problem. But due to Covid
everybody is pretending to be working from home. Normally, we are quite used to
articles remaining at home on exam leave. But this year even the exam schedule
is a big question mark.

 

Shrikrishna: I think the May exam is
already cancelled.

 

Arjun: We wonder how to cope with this situation.

 

Shrikrishna: Actually, this is a good
opportunity to improve upon the quality of audit.

 

Arjun: How? We are somehow managing the ‘virtual’
audit on scanned documents.

 

Shrikrishna: That’s OK. But today you
are having some peaceful time to do things which are necessary but you can’t do
due to fire-fighting.

 

Arjun: Like what?

 

Shrikrishna: Real updating of
knowledge, not merely CPE hours.

 

Arjun: What do you mean?

 

Shrikrishna: See, in your audit text
book you studied many things. How far are you implementing them? All these new
standards of accounting are nothing but an elaboration and refinement of those
basic principles.

 

Arjun: Give me some examples.

 

Shrikrishna: You are supposed to have
a permanent audit file of each client. Do you have it? Have you ever read the
basic formation documents like Memorandum of Articles of companies,
constitution and bylaws of societies, Trust Deeds…?

 

Arjun: I am not sure whether we really have these
basic documents on our record. They might have been taken perhaps decades ago.

 

Shrikrishna: Have you ever seriously
looked into the secretarial records of companies – like minutes, notices,
attendance records?

 

Arjun: Ah! That we never see.

 

Shrikrishna: Fixed assets register?

 

Arjun: For that we just put a standard remark.
Maintained, but not updated! God alone knows whether that really exists.

 

Shrikrishna: And third party evidence?
There is a specific SA on that. Writing to banks and debtors, creditors,
lenders for confirmation of balances?

 

Arjun: We have never done it. But I agree, we
should make a beginning somewhere. But without staff how can we do it?

 

Shrikrishna: Technology! Prepare a
standard letter and insist on the clients to send them. Everything is possible.
What you lack is will power.

 

Arjun: What you say is right. These things were
never done before and clients find it difficult to digest such things now. We
were lax in this respect.

 

Shrikrishna: But it is necessary for
your own benefit. If you contravene the Council’s guidelines, it is misconduct.

 

Arjun: I don’t know why the Council is putting so
much burden on us!

 

Shrikrishna: It is for your own
safety. Users of financial statements audited by you are not happy about the
quality. You are losing credibility. The Council does not want that to happen.

 

Arjun: The future of our profession is really
gloomy. There are very few new entrants, regulation is increasing so much that
it is unbearable. It is not remunerative as no one understands the value of our
services.

 

Shrikrishna: You’re right. But what
else can you do? So whatever you are doing, try to do it properly,
systematically.

 

Arjun: Due to Corona, the economy is already
depressed. We are all in very low spirits. So, better not get further
frightened by a discussion on disciplinary cases. Actually, I feel the Council
should declare an amnesty scheme for all misconduct that has occurred so far.

 

Shrikrishna: You have already gone
away from ethics, that is why your future is gloomy. But make good use of this
time for creative thinking, knowledge upgradation… That will at least help
you in future after Corona goes away. Otherwise, you will repent that you lost
the opportunity to get better organised. Such a time may never come again. Be
positive! Be brave.

 

Arjun: I agree.

 

Shrikrishna: So wake up. Think of what
best you can do to perform better in the post-Covid scenario.

 

Arjun: Yes, my Lord! I will walk on the path shown
by you. Thank you, Lord.

 

Om Shanti!

 

(This dialogue is based on the general attitude required to face the
present Covid scenario and take things in a positive manner so as to follow
ethics better.)

REGULATORY REFERENCER

DIRECT TAX

Banks are
advised to immediately refund the charges collected, if any, on or after 1st
January, 2020 on transactions carried out using the electronic modes prescribed
u/s 269SU of the IT Act and not to impose charges on any future transactions
carried out through the said prescribed modes. [Circular No. 16/2020 dated
30th August, 2020.]

 

COMPANY LAW

I.
COMPANIES ACT, 2013

(I)   Amendments made in Corporate Social
Responsibility Rules
– The MCA has issued the
Companies (Corporate Social Responsibility Policy) Amendment Rules, 2020 in
order to amend the Companies (Corporate Social Responsibility Policy) Rules,
2014. Following this Notification, any company engaged in research and
development activity of a new vaccine, drugs and medical devices in their
normal course of business, may undertake research and development activity of
new vaccine, drugs and medical devices related to Covid-19 for the financial
years 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23 subject to the conditions mentioned in the
said Notification. [Notification dated 24th August, 2020.]

 

(II)  MCA dispenses with the requirement to annex
extract of Annual Return in Form MGT-9 in Board’s Report if web link for Annual
Return is disclosed in the Board’s Report
– The MCA
has clarified an amendment in section 92 which now requires companies to place
a copy of the Annual Return on its website and the web-link of the same to be
provided in the Board’s Report. In such cases, companies are not required to
attach Form MGT-9 (Extract of Annual Return) in the Board’s Report. [Notification
dated 28th August, 2020.]

 

(III) MCA amends definition of deposits with respect
to convertible notes issued by Startups
– In order
to bring the definition of deposit in line with the revised definition of
Startup by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade, the MCA
has notified revision to the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 2014.
Now, convertible notes issued by Startups which are convertible into equity
shares or repayable within a period not exceeding ten years
(as against the
original tenure of ‘five years’) from the date of issue, shall not be
considered as deposits. Further, the maximum limit in respect of deposits to
be accepted from members shall not apply to a private company which is a
Startup for ten years
(as against the original tenure of ‘five years’) from
the date of its incorporation. [Notification dated 7th September,
2020.]

 

(IV) MCA
extends due date of filing of Cost Audit Report till 30th November,
2020
– In view of the
extraordinary disruption caused due to the pandemic, it has been decided that
if cost audit report for the financial year 2019-20 is submitted by 30th
November, 2020
, then the same would not be viewed as violation of Rule 6(5)
of the Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules, 2014. Consequently, the cost
audit report for the financial year ended on 31st March, 2020 shall
be filed in e-form CRA-4 within 30 days from the date of receipt of the copy of
the cost audit report by the company. However, in case a company has availed
extension of time for holding Annual General Meeting, then e-form CRA-4 may be
filed within the timeline provided under the proviso to rule 6(6) of the
Companies (Cost Records and Audit) Rules, 2014. [General Circular No.
29/2020 dated 10th September, 2020.]

 

(V)  Lok Sabha passes Companies (Amendment) Bill,
2020 on 19th September, 2020
– The Lok
Sabha has passed the Companies (Amendment) Bill, 2020 to decriminalise several
non-compoundable offences as also to promote ease of doing business. The Bill
will permit direct listing of securities of Indian companies in overseas stock
exchanges without listing them on domestic stock exchanges. The Bill also
stipulates that specified classes of unlisted companies will have to prepare
and file their periodic financial results. The said Bill was introduced in the
Lok Sabha in March this year.

 

II. SEBI

 

(VI) SEBI notifies cut-off date for re-lodgement of
transfer deeds to 31st March, 2021
– As
per SEBI’s Circular No. 12/2019 dated 27th March, 2019 the Board had
clarified that transfer of securities held in physical mode lodged before the
deadline (1st April, 2019) but rejected and returned due to
deficiency in the documents, may be re-lodged with requisite documents. SEBI
has now fixed the cut-off date for such re-lodgement as 31st March,
2021 and shares that are re-lodged for transfer shall be issued only in
DEMAT mode
. [Circular SEBI/HO/MIRSD/RTAMB/CIR/P/2020/166 dated 7th
September, 2020.]

 

(VII) SEBI extends time to share information towards
Automation of Continual Disclosures under Regulation 7(2) of SEBI (Prohibition
of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015 to 30th September, 2020
– SEBI has extended the deadline for submission of required
information as prescribed vide its circular dated 9th
September, 2020 with the designated depository by the listed companies to 30th
September, 2020 (as against the previous deadline of 18th September,
2020).

 

ACCOUNTS AND AUDIT

(A) Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting
under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS)
– The
revised Ind AS Framework, corresponding to IASB’s Conceptual Framework 2018,
is applicable for Standard-setting activity from accounting periods beginning
from 1st April, 2020 and for the preparers of financial statements
from a future date. [ICAI Announcement dated 28th August, 2020.]

 

(B) Revised Long Form Audit Report (LFAR) – The formats of LFAR for (i) Statutory central auditors, (ii)
Branch auditors, and (iii) Large / irregular / critical accounts for Branch
Auditors have been revised and are required to be put into operation for the
period covering F.Y. 2020-21 and onwards. [RBI Notification No.
RBI/2020-21/33 dated 5th September, 2020.]

 

FEMA

The
Government had announced a hike in the limit for investment in the Defence
Sector
from 49% to 74% in May, 2020. The DPIIT has now issued a press
release for the same. The changes are:

 

(a) An industry under the Defence Sector requiring
Industrial and Arms Act Licences can now receive FDI under automatic route up
to 74%, increased from the earlier limit of 49%. However, this relief is
available only to companies seeking new industrial licenses.

(b) FDI beyond 74% can be received under Government
Route, and as at present, where it is likely to result in access to modern
technology or for other reasons to be recorded.

(c) Companies not seeking industrial licence, or
those that have already obtained Government approval, will require Government
approval for raising their FDI beyond 49%. Further, such companies will now
also need to mandatorily submit declaration with the Ministry of Defence (MoD)
in case of change in equity or shareholding pattern or for transfer of stake to
a new foreign investor.

(d) Government has now reserved the right to review
any foreign investment in the Defence Sector as also subject foreign
investments to scrutiny on grounds of national security.

(e) Other conditions related to security clearance
and self-sufficiency remain applicable as at present.

 

It should be noted that these changes will become
effective only from the date that necessary amendments are made in the FEMA
(NDI) Rules, which have not yet taken place. [Press Note 4 of 2020 dated 17th
September, 2020.]

 

ICAI MATERIAL

 

1.  New Compendium of Indian Accounting Standards
(Ind AS) as on 1st April, 2020
–
Compendium containing updated Ind AS’s applicable for the accounting period
beginning 1st April, 2020. [25th August, 2020.]

 

2.  Handbook on Potential for ‘NEO Import
Substituting Industrialisation in India’ – ISI (Covid-19)
– Research publication providing guidance in respect of potential
for import substitution industries in India. [3rd September,
2020.]

 

3.  Relief Measures Introduced
in Insolvency Resolution Process in the Country due to outbreak of Covid-19
Pandemic
– Booklet enumerating judicial, legislative and economic measures
initiated on account of the pandemic. [8th September, 2020.]

 

Problems are not stop signs, they are
guidelines

— 
Robert H. Schuller

CORPORATE LAW CORNER

1. P. Parameswaram vs. Union of India  [2020] 118 taxmann.com 113 (Delhi) Date of order: 23rd July, 2020

 

Section 164 read with section 167 of the
Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 11 of the Companies Act (Appointment and
Qualification of Director) Rules, 2014 – Disqualifications for appointment of
Director. Director had defaulted in filing annual returns for three consecutive
years. Another company, in which also he was a Director, had been struck off by
the Registrar of Companies on account of its defaults in filing requisite
returns. Thus, the Director was disqualified as a Director and his DIN was
de-activated. Since he had not filed necessary Form with Registrar of Companies
at the material time, his prayer of not treating him as disqualified Director
was rejected. However, since he had been disqualified as a Director, he could
not access the website of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs to file returns or
forms as a Director of any other company and further, since his DIN was not
de-activated in terms of Rule 11 of Appointment and Qualification of Director
Rules, the ROC was directed to activate his DIN

 

FACTS

PP was appointed as an Independent Director
of KHF Limited (KHF) but had resigned on 22nd May, 2016. He was not
only a Director in KHF Limited but also in another company, SLD Company Private
Limited (SLD). The name of SLD had also been struck off from the Register of
Companies as it had defaulted in filing annual returns as required under the
Companies Act, 2013. In view of the defaults committed by KHF and SLD, PP was
disqualified as a Director in terms of sections 164(2) and 167(1) of the
Companies Act, 2013.

 

HELD

The limited
questions that were to be considered by the Court were whether the decision of
the ROC in disqualifying PP was illegal? And whether the other decision of the
ROC to deactivate his DIN was sustainable?

 

The Court held
as under: There is no dispute that KHF had defaulted in filing its annual
returns for three consecutive years. Similarly, SLD had also been struck off
from the Register of Companies on account of its defaults in filing the
requisite returns under the Companies Act, 2013.

 

PP claimed
that he had resigned from the Board of Directors of KHF with effect from 26th
May, 2016. However, he had not filed the necessary form with the Registrar of
Companies at the material time.

 

The question
whether a Director would be disqualified to act as a Director by virtue of
provisions of sections 164(2)(a) and 167(1)(a) of the Companies
Act is covered by the decision of the Delhi High Court in Mukut Pathak
& Ors. vs. Union of India and Ors. [W.P. (C) 9088/2018 decided on 4th
November, 2019].

 

Insofar as the
prayer that his DIN be directed to be activated is concerned, the said issue is
also covered by the decision of the Delhi High Court in Mukut Pathak
& Ors.
(Supra).
It is not disputed that the DIN of PP
had been deactivated only on account of his being disqualified to act as a
Director. As held in Mukut Pathak’s case, the said action is not sustainable.
The DIN could be deactivated in terms of Rule 11 of the Companies Act
(Appointment and Qualification of Director) Rules, 2014. But admittedly, the
DIN of PP has not been deactivated in terms of the said Rules.

 

In view of the
above, the prayer that the ROC be restrained from treating PP as a disqualified
Director was rejected. However, the ROC was directed to activate PP’s DIN.

 

PP had further
prayed that he be permitted to access the website of the Ministry of Corporate
Affairs, Government of India, but it cannot be acceded to. PP has been
disqualified as a Director; therefore, he cannot access the said website to
file returns or forms as a Director of KHF or any other company.

ALLIED LAWS

1. Home-buyer –
Cannot invoke IBC – Recovery of RERA award [Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code,
2016, S. 3(10), S. 5(7) S. 7, S. 65; Real Estate (Regulation and Development)
Act, 2016, S. 40]

 

Sh. Sushil Ansal vs. Ashok Tripathi &
Ors.
Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 452 of
2020 (NCLAT) Date of order: 14th August, 2020

Bench:
Bansi Lal Bhat J. (Acting Chairperson), Anant Bijay Singh J. and Dr. Ashok
Kumar Mishra

 

FACTS

The respondents are two house allottees who
booked flats with the appellant (Ansal Builders). As per the agreements, the
appellant had undertaken to complete the project within a period of two years
from the initiation of construction in 2015. However, on account of not
fulfilling the terms as per the agreement, the respondents approached the Uttar
Pradesh RERA where they were awarded a decree of Rs. 73 lakhs. Further, RERA
also issued recovery certificates against the builders. The respondent
allottees sought recourse under IBC for the recovery of their dues.

 

HELD

The three-member Bench held that as per
section 7 of the IBC as amended by the 2020 Amending Act, to make an
application under IBC it requires a minimum of 100 buyers or 10% of all
home-buyers, whichever is lower.

 

Further, the respondents have not approached
the Adjudicating Authority in the capacity of ‘allottees of a real estate
project’, therefore they cannot be brought within the meaning of ‘financial
creditors’. They can only be construed to be decree-holders on account of
non-payment of principal amount along with penalty as decreed by UP RERA.
Therefore, a decree-holder, though covered by the definition of ‘creditor’ u/s
3(10) of IBC, does fall within the definition of a ‘financial creditor’ across
the ambit of section 5(7) of the IBC and should have taken steps for filing an
execution case in the Civil Court.

 

2. Co-operative
Societies – Part of Constitutional Scheme – Unnecessary interference to be
avoided [Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1961, S. 77, S. 80, S. 152;
Constitution of India]

 

Rambujarat
Ramraj Chaurasia vs. State of Maharashtra
WP-ASDB-LD-VC 220 of 2020 (Bom) (HC) Date of order: 2nd September,
2020
Bench: Ujjal Bhuyan J. and Abhay Ahuja J.

 

FACTS

The petitioner is the Chairman of Vidhisha
Shantiniketan CHS Ltd. and the petition has been filed challenging the order of the Dy. Registrar, Thane (Respondent No. 2) directing a bank to
not allow the petitioner to operate the Society’s bank account and to allow another member, as assigned by the
Respondent No. 2, to operate the same.

 

The Society had imposed a penalty on one Mr.
Ramesh Mankar. Aggrieved by the penalty, he had approached the Respondent No. 2
who had given certain directions to the petitioner, failing which the
Respondent No. 2 would appoint an Administrator. Pursuant thereto, and on
account of inaction, Respondent No. 2 dissolved the Managing Committee of the
Society and appointed an Administrator.

 

The Society appealed before the Divisional
Joint Registrar, Co-operatives, Respondent No. 3, who quashed and set aside the
order of the Respondent No. 2 on 20th May, 2020. However, Respondent
No. 2, via a communication dated 14th July, 2020 directed the bank
to allow the Administrator, as appointed by him, to operate the accounts.

 

HELD

The Court held that the Society shall be
jointly managed under the Chairmanship of the petitioner and the Respondent No.
6 Administrator only for day-to-day affairs till the disposal of the appeal
before the Respondent No. 3. Further, that co-operative societies are now part
of the Constitutional scheme as co-operative societies have been inserted in
the Constitution of India as Part IX B by way of the Constitution (97th
Amendment) Act, 2011 w.e.f. 15th February, 2012. Therefore,
co-operative societies should have the necessary space and autonomy to function
and develop to their full potential. Interference in the affairs of
co-operative societies should be avoided unless there is serious statutory
breach or compelling necessity.

 

3. Unpaid
instalment – As per agreement – Not an operational debt [Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016, S. 5(21), S. 9]

 

Brand Realty Services Ltd. vs. Sir John
Bakeries India Pvt. Ltd.
(IB) 1677(ND) of 2019 (NCLT) (Del.) Date of order: 22nd July, 2020 Bench: Mr. K.K. Vohra and Mr. Abni Sinha

 

FACTS

Sir John Bakeries India Pvt. Ltd. (the
corporate debtor) approached Brand Realty Services Ltd. (the operational
creditor) for investment and consultancy services vide an agreement in
November, 2014. The agreement was further ratified in 2018. As per the new
agreement, the corporate debtor agreed to pay the outstanding sum of Rs. 33
lakhs via post-dated cheques. However, the corporate debtor then requested the
operational creditor to hold on and not deposit the cheques and that the
payment would be met via RTGS. However, that never happened either.

 

A legal notice and a demand notice were
issued under the IBC. The corporate debtor denied any liability in the absence
of any document and said that there exists a dispute between the parties with
respect to the debt.

 

HELD

In order to trigger section 9 of the IBC,
i.e., application for initiation of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process by
the operational creditor, an operational creditor is required to establish a
default for non-payment of operational debt as defined in section 5(21) of the
IBC. The application u/s 9 of the IBC was filed for the breach of the terms and
conditions of the settlement agreement between the parties and not against the
invoices raised in terms of the original agreement between them. Therefore, a
default on an instalment of the settlement agreement doesn’t come within the
purview of operational debtors.

 

The application was dismissed.

 

4. Dishonour of
cheque – Not offence against society – Can be compounded – Sentence reduced
[Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, S. 138; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, S.
147, S. 386, S. 401]

 

Rakesh Kumar vs. Jasbir Singh and another Crl. Rev. No. 3004 of 2019 (P&H)(HC) Date of order: 11th August, 2020 Bench: Sudhir Mittal J.

 

FACTS

The revision petitioner is the accused. He
issued a cheque dated 22nd April, 2006 to the complainant-respondent
No. 1, which was dishonoured. Vide a judgment dated 8th July,
2016, the petitioner was convicted and sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for two years. He was also directed to pay compensation equal to
the cheque amount along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date
of the cheque till the date of the judgment. An appeal against the judgment of
conviction was dismissed, leading to the present revision petition.

 

HELD

Sentencing is
primarily a matter of discretion as there are no statutory provisions governing
the same. Even guidelines have not been laid down to assist the courts in this
matter. Further, provisions inserted in the Negotiable Instruments Act are for
inculcating greater faith in banking transactions as the same needed more teeth
so that cases involving dishonour of cheques are reduced. Therefore, deterrence
and restoration are the principles to be kept in mind for sentencing. At the
same time, the Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the offence u/s 138 of
the Act is quasi criminal in nature. Section 147 of the Act makes the
offence compoundable notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973. It is not an offence against society and an accused can escape
punishment by settling with the complainant. It was further held that the
cheque amount is only Rs. 4 lakhs, and the award of maximum sentence is
arbitrary. On the facts of the case, the sentence is reduced to one year and
six months.

 

5.
Disqualification of Director – Companies Fresh Start Scheme, 2020 –
Disqualification to be set aside [Companies Act, 2013, S. 164(2)(a)]

 

Sandeep Agarwal & Ors. vs. UOI &
Anr.
WP No. 5490 of 2020 (Delhi) (HC) Date of order: 2nd September,
2020
Bench: Prathiba M. Singh J.

 

FACTS

The petition has been filed by the
petitioners, Mr. Sandeep Agarwal and Ms Kokila Agarwal, both of whom are
directors in two companies, namely, Koksun Papers Private Limited and Kushal
Power Projects Private Limited. The name of Kushal Power was struck off from
the Register of Companies on 30th June, 2017 due to non-filing of
financial statements and annual returns. The petitioners, being directors of
Kushal Power, were also disqualified with effect from 1st November,
2016 for a period of five years till 31st October, 2021 u/s
164(2)(a) of the Companies Act, 2013. Pursuant to the disqualification, their
Director Identification Numbers (DIN) and Digital Signature Certificates (DSC)
have also been cancelled. In view thereof, they are unable to carry on the
business and file returns, etc. in the active company Koksun Papers. By the
present petition, the disqualification is challenged and quashing is sought of
the impugned list of disqualified directors.

 

HELD

Companies
Fresh Start Scheme (CFSS) is a new scheme which has been notified on 30th
March, 2020. This Scheme was not invoked before the learned Division Bench. The
Scheme is obviously launched by the Government in order to give a reprieve to
such companies who have defaulted in filing documents; they have been allowed
to file the requisite documents and to regularise their operations, so as to
not face disqualification. The Scheme also envisages non-imposition of penalty
or any other charges for belated filing of documents.

 

This Scheme
provides an opportunity for active companies who may have defaulted in filing
of documents, to put their affairs in order. It thus provides the directors of
such companies a fresh cause of action to also challenge their disqualification
qua the active companies.

 

In view of the
fact that in the present case the petitioners are directors of an active
company Koksun Papers in respect of which certain documents are to be filed and
the said company is entitled to avail of the Scheme, the suspension of the DINs
would not only affect the petitioners qua the company, whose name has
been struck off, but also qua the company which is active.

 

Further,
considering the Covid-19 pandemic, the MCA has launched the Fresh Start
Scheme-2020, which ought to be given full effect. It is not uncommon to see
directors of one company being directors in another company. Under such
circumstances, to disqualify directors permanently and not allow them to avail
their DINs and DSCs could render the Scheme itself nugatory; therefore, the disqualification of the petitioners as directors is set aside.
The DINs and DSCs of the petitioners are directed to be reactivated within a
period of three working days.

GOODS AND SERVICEs TAX (GST)

I.          HIGH
COURT

 

1. [2020 (9) TMI 42 (Madhya Pradesh)] Smt. Kanishka Matta vs. UOI Date of order: 26th
August, 2020

 

Sections 2(17), 2(31), 2(75) and 67(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 – Money can
also be seized by investigating agency / Department during search and seizure

 

FACTS

A search operation was carried out at the business and residential
premises of the petitioner and cash amounting to Rs. 66,43,130 was seized. The
petitioner filed a writ petition on the ground that the Department does not
have power under law to effect seizure of ‘money’ as it cannot be treated as
‘documents, books or things’ and, therefore, such action is violative of
Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner requested a
direction for release of the seized cash.

 

HELD

The Hon’ble High Court held that the law has to be seen as a whole and
the definition clauses are the keys to unlock the intent and purpose of the
various sections and expressions used therein, where the said provisions are
put to implementation. A conjoint reading of various relevant definitions and
provisions, i.e., sections 2(17), 2(31), 2(75) and 67(2) of the CGST Act,
showed that money can also be seized. The word ‘things’ as stated in section
67(2) of the CGST Act shall be given wide meaning. As per Black’s Law
Dictionary
(10th edition) any subject matter of ownership within
the spear of proprietary or valuable right would come under the definition of
‘thing’. A statute is to be given an interpretation which suppresses the
mischief and advances the remedy. Though the ‘confession statement’ of the
husband of the petitioner was retracted at a later stage, no relief could be
granted at this stage. It was held that the cash was rightly seized from the
husband of the petitioner and until the completion of investigation and
adjudication, the question of releasing the amount would not arise.

 

2. [2020 (39) G.S.T.L. 129 (Kol.)]
Subhas & Company vs. Commissioner of CGST and CX, 5585 (W) of 2020 Date of
order: 24th June, 2020

 

Section 140, Rule 117 of the CGST Act, 2017, section 137 of the
Limitation Act, 1983 – Three-year period would be the maximum period for
availing transitional credit which could not be availed due to technical
glitches faced while filling TRAN Form

 

FACTS

The applicant filed a writ petition for violation of principles of
natural justice as it was unable to claim transitional credits under GST due to
technical glitches faced while filling the necessary forms. The writ petition
was filed for reopening TRAN-2 or for accepting manual TRAN-2 for claiming
transitional credits and setting it off against GST liability without interest
.

 

HELD

The High Court, on the basis of the facts and
circumstances of the case and after considering section 140 of the CGST Act
read with Rule 117 of the CGST Rules, held that the transition from the pre-GST
regime to the GST regime had not been smooth and many assessees had faced
hardships. Various cases with similar facts were decided by the Court holding
that inability to submit forms within the time limit prescribed to claim
transitional credit due to technical issues cannot result in forfeiture of
rights. However, the Court took a view that credit cannot be allowed in
perpetuity and thus, considering the Limitation Act as the guiding principle, a
maximum period of three years was allowed for availing transitional credit. The
Court directed the GST portal to be reopened for the petitioner to fill the
necessary forms or allow filing the forms manually to transfer credit to the
GST regime by 30th June, 2020.

 

II. NATIONAL ANTI-PROFITEERING
AUTHORITY

 

3. [2020] 119 taxmann.com 79 (NAA)] Ratish Nair vs. Man Reality Ltd. Date of order: 24th August,
2020 (National Anti-Profiteering Authority)

 

The penalty provisions u/s 171(3A) of the CGST Act introduced by section
112 of the Finance Act, 2019 which were made effective from 1st
January, 2020 are prospective in nature and cannot be made applicable for a
prior period

 

FACTS

In the present case, the applicant No. 2 (the Director-General
Anti-Profiteering), had submitted that he had conducted an investigation on the
complaint of the applicant No. 1 and found that the respondent (Man Reality
Ltd.) had not passed on the benefit of Input Tax Credit (ITC), as per the
provisions of section 171(1) of the CGST Act, 2017 in respect of the flat
purchased by the applicant No. 1 in the ‘One Park Avenue’ project of the
respondent. Vide his above report, the DGAP had also submitted that the
respondent had denied the benefit of ITC to applicant No.1 and other buyers
pertaining to the period from July, 2017 to September, 2018 and had thus indulged
in profiteering and violation of the provisions of section 171(1) of the CGST
Act.

 

Accordingly, a notice was
issued to show cause as to why penalty u/s 171(3A) should not be imposed. The
respondent in his submission stated that the provisions of section 171(3A) were
introduced vide section 112 of the Finance Act, 2019 and the same were
made effective prospectively with effect from 1st January, 2020.
Since the case of the respondent pertained to the period prior to the effective
implementation of the penalty provision, the same would not be applicable.

 

HELD

It was noted that the respondent has not passed on the benefit of ITC to
his buyers from 1st July, 2017 to 30th September, 2018
and hence he has violated the provisions of section 171(1) of the CGST Act,
2017. However, it is also noted that the Central Government vide
Notification No. 1/2020-Central Tax dated 1st January, 2020 has
implemented the provisions of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2019 from 1st
January, 2020 vide which sub-section 171(3A) was added in section 171 of
the CGST Act, 2017 and penalty was proposed to be imposed in the case of
violation of section 171(1) of the CGST Act, 2017. It was, therefore, held that
since no penalty provisions were in existence during the period from 1st
July, 2017 to 30th September, 2018 when the respondent had violated
the provisions of section 171(1), the penalty prescribed u/s 171(3A) cannot be
imposed on the respondent retrospectively.

 

Note: A similar
decision is rendered in the case of Diwakar Bansal vs. Horizon Projects
Private Limited, National Anti-Profiteering Authority, 2020, 119, 18(NAA).

 

 

 

III. AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE
RULING

 

1. George Jacob, Re: [2020] 119 taxmann.com 10 (AAR,
Kerala)] Date of order: 20th May, 2020

 

The annual lease charges collected for leasing of land including water
bodies used for fish farming are exempted as services relating to the rearing
of all life forms of animals under Serial No. 54 of the Exemption Notification

 

FACTS

The short question in the application was whether lease rent charged by
the municipality for land, i.e., water channel used for fish farming, falls
within the meaning of ‘services relating to the rearing of all life forms of
animals’ and is eligible for exemption as per Serial. No. 54 of Notification
No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017.

 

HELD

As per Serial No. 54 of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate)
dated 28th June, 2017, under Heading 9986 services relating to the
rearing of all life forms of animals by way of renting or leasing of vacant
land with or without a structure incidental to its use are exempted from GST.
The term ‘rearing’ means to bring up and care for until fully grown. They take
care of the fish / crab from the point that they are eggs until they are fully
grown up by providing them with feed and also taking care of them in all
possible ways. The next condition is that the rearing should be of animals.
They are rearing fish and crab and there is no dispute that fish and crab are
animals. The next condition is that the land should be provided on rent or
lease. It is clear from the allotment letter and agreement that the wetland is
taken on an annual lease.

 

‘Renting in relation to immovable property’ means allowing, permitting,
or granting access, entry, occupation, use or any such facility, wholly or
partly, in immovable property, with or without the transfer of possession or
control of the said immovable property and includes letting, leasing, licensing
or other similar arrangements in respect of the immovable property. As per Black’s
Law Dictionary
, ‘Land’ includes not only the soil or earth, but also things
of a permanent nature affixed thereto or found therein, whether by nature, such
as water, trees, grass, herbage, other natural or perennial products, growing
crops or trees; minerals under the surface; or by the hand of man, such as
buildings, fixtures, fences, bridges as well as works constructed for use of
water, such as dikes, canals, etc. It is, therefore, clear that all the conditions
stipulated in Serial. No. 54 of the Notification No. 12/2017- Central Tax
(Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 are satisfied and hence the rent paid
to the Gram Panchayat is exempt from GST.

 

5. [(2020) (39) GSTL 430 (AAR, Madhya Pradesh)] Atal Bihari Vajpayee Institute of Good Governance &
Policy Analysis Date of order: 2nd March, 2020

 

Articles 243G and 243W of the Constitution of India, Notification No.
12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 – GST not
applicable on services provided to Government, Governmental Authority or
Government Entity for doing research work and study, which help them make
policies or understand their impact

 

FACTS

The applicant, an institute established as a society, is a part of the
Department of Public Service Management, Government of M.P. It acts as a
knowledge resource hub for promotion of good governance. It conducts impact
evaluation, research works and studies for various government departments on good
governance and policy analysis. This study helps such departments to review and
improve the policies for utmost benefit of the target beneficiaries. The
applicant applied for an advance ruling regarding taxability and applicability
of exemption notification on the amounts recovered from government departments
for doing research work.

 

HELD

The Authority held that in order to avail exemption [Sr. No. 3 of
Notification No. 12/2017-CGST (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017], three
conditions need to be satisfied. The activity should be pure service (excluding
works contract or composite supply), the service should be provided to
Government, Governmental Authority or Government Entity, and such activity
should be in relation to any function entrusted under Article 243G or 243W of
the Constitution of India. As all such conditions were satisfied here, the
Authority ruled that GST shall not be levied on the amount recovered by the
applicant from other government departments.

 

Further, the applicant
being a co-operative society regulated by the Government of M.P., falls within
the definition of ‘Government Entity’ but not ‘Government’ or ‘Local
Authority’. Thus, such service provided by the applicant to other government
departments would not qualify for exemption vide Entry 8 of the
exemption Notification (Supra). It was further specifically held that
the ruling would be applicable prospectively and, therefore, the applicant
cannot claim refund of GST which might have been paid before obtaining this
ruling.

 

6. [(2020) 39 G.S.T.L. 310 (AAR, Andhra Pradesh)] Master Minds AAR No. 08/AP/GST/2020 Date of order: 5th
March, 2020

 

Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June,
2017 – Exemption under said Notification will be available only to educational
institutions imparting education as a part of curriculum prescribed for
obtaining a qualification prescribed by law

 

FACTS

The applicant was providing coaching / training services to students as
per the syllabus prescribed by the ICAI or ICWAI. The applicant questioned if
it is covered under exemption from GST as an educational institute. It
contended that there were no legal requirements for the institute to be
recognised or authorised and the only condition was that the education imparted
should be a part of the curriculum for obtaining a qualification recognised by
any law.

 

HELD

In the instant case, the applicant was providing coaching / training
services in respect of CA and CWA courses. The Authority held that the
applicant was not accredited or affiliated to or recognised or authorised by
statutory bodies. Exemption is available to services when provided by these
statutory bodies through their authorised regional councils or branches for
which course completion certificates are issued. Moreover, coaching or training
in the applicant’s coaching centre was not mandatory compliance for aspirants
for their study and obtaining a certificate from the statutory bodies. Therefore,
the services provided by the applicant were not a service by way of education
as a part of curriculum which was prescribed for obtaining a qualification
prescribed by law. Accordingly, it was ruled that the exemption available to
educational institutes will not be available to the applicant as its activities
are not covered under the definition of ‘education institution’. For the same
reason, exemption would not be available on supply of food and accommodation
services by the applicant to its students

 

7. [2020-TIOL-257-AAR-GST (AAR, Karnataka)] M/s Gnanaganga Gruha Nirmana Sahakara Sangha Niyamitha
Date of order: 18th February, 2020

 

Collection of contributions from members annually or once in ten years
is a service liable to GST. Water charges collected are exempt from the
liability of GST

 

FACTS

The applicant is a housing society engaged in the development and sale
of sites for its members. The question before the Authority is whether
maintaining the facilities at the layout with the funds collected from the
members is a service liable for GST? Does the collection of water charges
attract GST? Further, whether lump sum amount collected as endowment fund to be
used for maintenance activities is liable for GST?

 

HELD

The Authority held that contributions collected from members either
annually or once in ten years towards sourcing of goods or services from a
third person for common use of its members must be divided by the recipients of
such services in the society, and if the said amount per member does not exceed
Rs. 7,500 in that tax period, such amount is exempted from tax as per Entry No.
77(c) of 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate); but if the amount exceeds Rs.7,500, then
the entire amount is taxable. Further, it was held that water charges collected
are exempt under Notification 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate) – Entry 99. With
respect to the endowment fund it was noted that the same is collected when the
members are selling their sites and that being in the nature of service, is
liable to GST.

 

8. [2020-TIOL-251-AAR-GST (AAR, Gujarat)] Oswal Industries Ltd. Date of order: 9th
July, 2020

 

Wellness facilities like naturopathy, ayurveda, yoga, etc. provided at
naturopathy centres which necessarily require accommodation to be provided to
customers, is a taxable supply, the principal supply being accommodation
services

 

FACTS

The applicant has stated that it has one of the largest Naturopathy
Centres in India and offers physical, psychological and spiritual ‘health
overhaul’ with the help of the power of nature. It also provides different
types of wellness facilities such as naturopathy, ayurveda, yoga and
meditation, physiotherapy and special therapy. Its contention is that the
classification of services provided by it is human health and social care services
and hence exempted in view of Serial No. 74 of 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate).

 

HELD

The Authority noted that the packages offered by the applicant, as
evident from their website, indicates that the therapy offered by them is
strictly on a residential basis and this is also evident from the fact that the
consideration is solely dependent on the type of room opted for by the
customer. In all the packages, three types of rooms are offered either on a
single-occupancy basis or a double-occupancy basis. The rates of the rooms per
night have been specified and these form the major part of the consideration
towards the selected package. The entire package consists of the above three
components of accommodation, food and therapy and the packages would not be possible
without any one of the three components. Thus, the packages offered are
naturally bundled and would be aptly covered under the definition of Composite
Supply.

 

Further, the principal supply would be the accommodation services since
the therapy can in no way be administered without accommodation. In fact, there
is no option available for the customer to avail the wellness package without
opting for the accommodation. Therefore, in the instant case, the composite
supply of services would be treated as a supply of accommodation service
taxable under GST.

 

9. [2020-TIOL-245-AAR-GST (AAR, Maharashtra)] M/s Tata Motors Ltd. Date of order: 25th
August, 2020

 

Nominal amount recovered from employees towards transport facility is
not a supply liable to GST as the same emanates from an employer-employee
relation. Further, input tax credit is allowable to the extent of the cost
borne by the company

 

FACTS

The applicant has engaged service providers
to provide transportation facility to its employees, in non-air conditioned
buses having seating capacity of more than 13 persons. A nominal amount is
collected from the employees for usage of the bus facility. The question before
the Authority is whether ITC is available on the GST charged by the service
provider on hiring of bus / motor vehicle having seating capacity of more than
13 persons? The next question is whether the amount collected from the
employees is a supply liable to GST and whether ITC is allowable proportionate
to the extent of the cost borne by the company?

 

HELD

The Authority noted that section 17(5)(b)(i) of the CGST Act, 2017  has been amended with effect from 1st February,
2019 to block ITC on leasing, renting or hiring of motor vehicles having
approved seating capacity of not more than 13 persons. Thus, where the vehicle
capacity is more than 13 persons, such ITC is allowable. With respect to the
amount collected from the employees, it is noted that the applicant is not
providing transportation facility to its employees; in fact, they are receiving
such services. The transaction between the applicant and its employees is due
to ‘Employer-Employee’ and is not a supply under the GST Act. Thus, such
amounts recovered are not liable to GST. Further, as for the last question, it
is held that ITC will be available to the extent of the cost borne by the
company.

 

 

 

 

Service Tax

I. HIGH COURT

 

1. [2020]
119 Taxmann.com 174 (SC)
  L.R. Brothers Indo
Flora Ltd. vs. CCE
  Date of order: 1st
September, 2020

 

The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
amendment to Notification No. 126/94-Cus dated 3rd June, 1994 by
Amending Notification No. 56/01-Cus dated 18th May, 2001 is
prospective in nature, as an essential requirement for application of
legislation retrospectively is to show that the previous legislation had any
omission or ambiguity or it was intended to explain an earlier act; in the
absence of the above ingredients, legislation cannot be regarded as having
retrospective effect

 

FACTS

The appellant is a 100% Export-Oriented Unit
required to export all articles produced by it. As a consequence, it is
exempted from payment of customs duty on the imported inputs used for the
production of the exported articles, vide Notification No. 126/94-Cus
dated 3rd June, 1994. Under the said Notification, exemption on levy
of customs duty had been extended even to the inputs used in the production of
articles sold in the domestic market in accordance with the Export-Import
Policy and subject to other conditions specified by the Development
Commissioner. In the case of non-excisable goods, the customs duty was payable
on the inputs used for production, manufacturing or packaging of such articles
at a rate equivalent to the rate of customs duty that would have been leviable
on the final articles.

 

The said
Notification was amended by Notification No. 56/01-Cus dated 18th
May, 2001 after which the customs duty on inputs was charged at the rate
equivalent to the duty leviable on such inputs and not on the final articles. The
EXIM Policy 1997-2002 provided that a 100% Export-Oriented Unit in the
floriculture sector was permitted to sell 50% of its produce domestically,
subject to achieving a positive net foreign exchange earning of 20% and upon
approval of the Development Commissioner. The appellant, without obtaining the
approval of the Development Commissioner and without maintaining the requisite
net foreign exchange earning, made sales domestically. Notably, they
subsequently sought ex-post facto approval from the Development
Commissioner. However, in the meanwhile a show cause notice was issued for levy
of customs duty on the domestic sales made in contravention of the EXIM Policy.
The duty was confirmed as per the pre-amended Notification which was
operational during the period under consideration.

 

HELD

 

As regards the first ground, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that on a combined reading of the Notification with the
conditions laid down in the EXIM Policy, it is clear that the fulfilment of the
said conditions is a condition precedent to becoming eligible to make domestic
sales. The domestic sales pertaining to excisable goods made in conformity with
the conditions of the EXIM Policy are exigible to excise duty, but once there
is a contravention of the conditions of the Policy, irrespective of the goods
produced being excisable or non-excisable, the benefit under the exemption
Notification is unavailable. In such a situation, the very goods would become
liable to the imposition of customs duty as if being imported goods. The Court
further held that the demand made in the show cause notice ‘treating’ cut
flowers that were grown on Indian soil as deemed to have been imported was only
for the purpose of quantification of the customs duty on the imported inputs
and not the imposition of customs duty on the domestically grown cut flowers as
such.

 

The Supreme Court held that the language
employed in the amendment Notification does not offer any guidance on whether
the amendments as made were to apply prospectively or retrospectively. It is a
settled proposition of law that all laws are deemed to apply prospectively
unless either expressly specified to apply retrospectively or intended to have
been done so by the Legislature. The latter would be a case of necessary
implication and it cannot be inferred lightly. Referring to Circular No.
31/2001-Cus dated 24th May, 2001, the Court held that upon a bare
reading of the circular, it can be noted that it discusses the mechanism in
force before the amendment, the reason for bringing in the change and the
changes brought in. The circular does not mention that the earlier methodology
in force was deficient or devoid of clarity in any manner. It rather says that
the same was being disadvantageous to the export units as compared to the other
units due to the difference in charging rates in the respective circulars. Upon
considering that, the amendment has been brought in to establish parity with
the excise notifications and to vindicate the disadvantage that the earlier
regime was causing to export-oriented units.

 

Merely because an anomaly has been
addressed, it cannot be passed off as an error having been rectified. Unless
shown otherwise, it has to be seen as a conscious change in the dispensation,
particularly concerning fiscal matters. To call the amendment Notification
clarificatory or curative in nature it would require that there had been an
error / mistake / omission in the previous Notification which is merely sought
to be explained. As regards the Notifications, in this case, referring to the proviso
in the charging section of the Central Excise Act, the Court concluded that the
exemption Notification was not an error that crept in but was intentionally
introduced by the Government to determine the charging rate and hence it cannot
be said to be clarificatory in nature.

 

II. HIGH COURT

           

2. [2020 (39) G.S.T.L. 388 (Guj.)] Hitech Projects vs.
UOI Date of order: 6th
July, 2020

 

Section 125 of Sabka Vishwas (Legacy
Dispute Resolution) Scheme – Fair opportunity to be provided to the petitioner
if unable to attend the personal hearing owing to the lockdown on account of
the Covid-19 pandemic

 

FACTS

The petitioner applied for the Sabka
Vishwas
(Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme with respect to two pending
appeals. However, the applications were held to be not maintainable as the case
involved confiscation of goods and imposition of redemption fine. A personal
hearing for the same was scheduled during the period of lockdown when the
offices of the petitioner and the Department were closed. On failure of the
petitioner to appear for the matter, SVLDRS-3 was issued by the Department
directing it to pay the disputed amount. The petition was filed requesting a
fresh hearing and to set aside the SVLDRS-3.

 

HELD

Without going into the merits of the case
whether benefit of the SVLDR Scheme would be available to the petitioner, the
High Court held that an opportunity should be given to the petitioner to put
forward its case before the Department in person. Besides, though the payment
under the Scheme was to be made by 30th June, 2020, the Department
was directed to accept the payment considering the fact that the litigation was
pending before the Court.

 

 III. TRIBUNAL

 

3. [2020-TIOL-1403-CESTAT-Kol.] M/s Acclaris Business
Solutions Pvt. Ltd. vs. Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise Date of order: 10th
September, 2020

 

When the services are 100% exported, refund
is eligible of the entire CENVAT credit irrespective of whether export payment
is received or not received

 

FACTS

A 100% exporter of services, the appellant
claimed refund of accumulated CENVAT Credit under Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. Both the authorities below denied the refund of a
certain amount while applying the formula prescribed for maximum permissible
refund of the credit amount. In the said formula, the authorities included the
value of export invoices for which payment is not received in the relevant
period while considering the value of ‘total turnover’ and granted
the refund proportionately to the extent of payment received.

 

 

HELD

The Tribunal noted that refund is allowed of
the ‘net CENVAT credit’ availed. The intention of the formula of refund claim
of export value in the numerator and total turnover in the denominator is to
restrict the refund only to export services and not for domestic services.
Thus, when there is no domestic service, in both numerator and denominator the
amount of export turnover has to be considered. There is no reason to consider
the aggregate of the value of export turnover payment of which has been
received and that for which payment has not been received, since it is not
required in the prescribed formula. It was further noted that if the contention
of Revenue is accepted, then the assessee will never be allowed refund of the
‘CENVAT credit amount availed in the relevant period’ inasmuch as the refund in
the subsequent period would be allowed by considering the ‘net CENVAT credit’
availed in that period. That is neither the intention of the law nor prescribed
in the formula above and therefore the refund is fully admissible.

 

 

4. [2020-TIOL-1401-CESTAT-Kol.] Commissioner of
Service Tax vs. M/s Naresh Kumar and Company Date of order: 6th
February, 2020

 

The activity of liaising and supervision,
not involving physical handling of goods, is not covered by clearing and
forwarding agent services

 

FACTS

The assessee is rendering various services
like liaison and follow-up on behalf of consumers between collieries and the
railways, supervision, monitoring, witnessing the loading of specified size and
grade of coal and shortage en route, ensuring optimum quantity of supply,
ensuring proper weighment, coordinating receipt of necessary documents and
submitting the same to consumers and organising sampling and analysis of coal.
It is the case of Revenue that these activities amount to rendering ‘clearing
and forwarding services’. But as per the assessee, these activities do not
amount to rendering ‘clearing and forwarding services’ as they do not
physically handle or receive or store the goods, but only do liaising,
supervision and coordination.

 

HELD

The Tribunal,
relying on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Coal Handlers
Pvt. Ltd.
vs. Commissioner of Central Excise [2015-TIOL-121-CESTAT-Mum.]
where the Apex Court has categorically held that the activity of liaising and
supervision will not be considered as clearing and forwarding since there is no
physical activity involved, set aside the demand.

 

5. [2020-TIOL-1377-CESTAT-Mum.] M/s Aban Offshore
Ltd. vs. Commissioner of GST and Central Excise
Date of order: 28th July, 2020

 

Short-term accommodation, rent-a-cab
service and outdoor catering service are allowable as CENVAT credit post-1st
April, 2011

 

FACTS

The appellant was engaged in providing
various services including mining service, utilised CENVAT credit on the input
services used for providing such output services. The input services used
included short-term hotel accommodation, rent-a-cab, outdoor catering and
housekeeping services. A show cause notice was issued disallowing the said credit
availed post-1st April, 2011. The assessee contended that the crew
is deployed to the offshore location from various geographical locations;
further, there are several permissions and approvals required before the work
is commenced. Therefore, the crew requires to be accommodated during the
relevant time. With respect to the rent-a-cab service, it was stated that the
same is required for their naval officers and surveyors to travel to the rig.
And outdoor catering services were used for the personnel working on the rig. Thus, the services used being wholly for business
purposes, the credit should be allowable.

 

 

HELD

The Tribunal noted that the service of
accommodation was necessarily required to be provided till the time the
necessary approvals and permissions were received. Therefore, such service not
being for personal consumption, the credit is allowable. As for the rent-a-cab
service, it was submitted that the exclusion merely restricts credit on
vehicles which qualify as capital goods. From the recipient’s point of view, a motor vehicle can never be
capital goods and he would never be eligible for credit if a narrow
interpretation is given. Thus, credit is allowable on rent-a-cab service. With
respect to the outdoor catering, it is held that access to proper food is the
most basic requirement for any person to carry out a task. If the appellant’s
personnel fall ill on account of stale / spoilt food, the operation being
carried out by the appellant would be adversely impacted and, consequently, the
output service. Thus, the service being in relation to output service, the
credit is allowable.

 

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN GST

NOTIFICATIONS

(i) Aadhaar Card
Authentication for Registration Notification No. 62/2020-Central Tax dated 20th
August, 2020

By this Notification, Rule 8
of the CGST Rules has been amended. It provides for authentication of Aadhaar
Card for Registration under GST. Different situations are carved out regarding
authentication. The substance of the amendment is that if Aadhaar is
authenticated then there will not be physical verification, and if it is not
authenticated, then there may be physical verification of the place of
business.

 

(ii) Levy of Interest
Notification No. 63/2020-Central Tax dated 25th August, 2020

Section 50 of the CGST Act,
regarding levy of interest, was amended by section 100 of the Finance (No. 2)
Act, 2019. By the said amendment, the Legislature wants to provide that the
interest for delayed return should be levied on cash component. When the
amendment was made, the operation of the said amendment was kept pending, to be
made applicable by way of Notification. The aforesaid Notification is issued to
make the above amendment operative from 1st September, 2020.
Representations were made that the operation of the amendment should be made
effective from 1st July, 2017. The CBIC has issued a press note
dated 26th August, 2020 stating that though the amendment is not
made effective retrospectively due to technical reasons, for practical purposes
it will be operative for past period also.

 

(iii) Extension of Filing date
for Form GSTR 4 Notification No. 64/2020-Central Tax dated 31st
August, 2020

By this Notification, the due
date for filing Form GSTR4 (Annual Return by Composition Dealer) for the year
2019-2020 is extended to 31st October, 2020.

 

(iv) Extension of compliance
date u/s 171 Notification No. 65/2020-Central Tax dated 1st September,
2020

This Notification seeks to
amend Notification No. 35/2020-Central Tax dated 3rd April, 2020 to
extend the date of compliance u/s 171 (relating to anti-profiteering) which
falls during the period from ‘20.03.2020 to 29.11.2020’ till 30th November,
2020.

 

ADVANCE
RULINGS

1. Lease of residential
property vis-a-vis commercial use

M/s Lakshmi Tulasi Quality
Fuels (AAR No. 12/AP/GST/2020 dated 5th May, 2020; A.P.)

The applicant in Andhra
Pradesh has filed for an Advance Ruling (AR) in the following background:

 

The applicant has a building
in Telangana with 73 rooms. The rooms have all amenities like exhaust fans,
geysers, lights and fittings, curtain rods and sanitary fittings, etc. The said
building is given on lease basis to a lessee with a monthly rent of Rs.
7,20,000.

 

Its contention is that it is
meant for residential purposes. Though the lease may be on a long-term basis,
it is being rented out as a residential property and it should be exempt under
Entry 13 of the Exemption Notification dated 28th June, 2017. The
said Entry is reproduced below:

 

‘Sl. No. 13 of Exemption Notification, i.e.,
Notification No. 9/2017 dated 28th June, 2017:’

 

Sl.
No.

 

Chapter,
Section, Heading, Group of Service Code (Tariff)

Description
of Services

Rate
(Per cent)

Condition

13

Heading 9963 or Heading 9972

Services by way of renting
of residential dwelling for use as residence

NIL

NIL

 

The Learned AAR referred to
various clauses in the lease agreement and observed the following facts:

 

(a)        The lessee is entitled to engage third-party service
providers, including food, catering, hospitality, security, cleanliness, event
organisation, transportation, management and supervision of the total property
as deemed necessary by the lessee for the purpose.

(b)        The lessee shall have the right to deploy branding strategies
on the property.

(c)        The lessee has the right to sub-lease the aforesaid property
during the lease term to any third party with prior intimation to the applicant
for the purpose of long stay accommodation. For this, the applicant presented a
sample sub-lease agreement as Exhibit-3.

(d)       Exhibit-3 presented by the applicant was examined by the AAR.
It is a ‘Residents Enrolment Form’ but not a sub-lease agreement as claimed by
the applicant. Apart from the residents’ personal details, information like
food preference, optional service price, etc., is being collected through the
enrolment form. With regard to the ‘Rules and Regulations’ attached to the
‘Residents Enrolment Form’, apart from others there are conditions like ‘Rents
will be calculated according to your rent ledger’, ‘Premium dishes will be
limit’, etc.

 

Based on the above facts, the
AAR observed that the building appears to be meant for commercial use, i.e.,
with the purpose of running a lodge. There is provision of food and hospitality
services. Observing the above, the AAR held that the exemption under Entry 13
of the Exemption Notification is not eligible and it will be taxable at 18%
IGST.

 

2. Interstate / Intra-state
supply

High Tech Refrigeration &
Air Conditioning Industries

(Advance Ruling No. GOA/GAAR/5
of 2019-20/530 dated 26th February, 2020; Goa)

The applicant has raised
several questions before the AAR for its ruling. The questions are as under:

 

(i)         Fixing of air conditioner and VRV system in Goa for a client
(recipient) registered outside Goa but not registered in Goa. Whether IGST or
SGST and CGST rate applicable and whether billing B to C or B to B?

(ii)        Supplying of air conditioner to client (recipient) registered
outside Goa but not registered in Goa consisting of air conditioner (28%),
copper pipe, drain pipe, electric cable, etc. (18%) and fixing rate (18%).
These items can be supplied / billed separately under GST.

(iii)       Supplying of air conditioner (28%) for residential house in
Goa consisting of required additional items, i.e., copper pipe, drain pipe,
electric cable, etc. (18%) and fixing rate (18%). Is billing them separately
allowed?

(iv)       Can installation of air conditioner (28%) be done by sister
concern or third party to client based in Goa or outside Goa @ 18% GST for
fixing?

(v)        Can composite dealer raise service bill for fixing of air
conditioner and also what GST rate would be applicable?

(vi)       Stabiliser may or may not be sold with the air conditioner.
What is the rate of GST applicable on stabiliser (18%) when it is attached /
supplied with air conditioner (28%)?

(vii)      What is the rate of GST on centralised air conditioning system?
The rate for works contract GST on a split air conditioning system fixed in a
room? And the rate of GST on movable air conditioning system? Client registered
in Goa or client registered outside Goa?

 

The AAR made reference to
section 97(2) of the CGST Act and held that except the first question, the
others are not maintainable before it.

 

Question No. 1 was regarding
levy of IGST or CGST / SGST. In respect of this issue, the AAR observed that
the applicant is supplying to a third party situated in Goa on behalf of his
recipient situated in another state and who is not registered in Goa.

 

He observed as under in
respect of the above aspects:

 

‘For classification of any
supply as interstate supply or intra-state supply, two ingredients are relied
upon; these are, the location of the supplier and the place of supply. In the
instant case, as stated by the applicant, the location of the supplier is Goa
and the place of supply will be outside Goa as per section 10(1)(b) of the IGST
Act since goods are supplied on behalf of a registered person outside Goa to a
place in Goa.’

 

The AAR then passed an order
stating that the aforesaid supply should be held as an interstate supply.

 

3. Classification – LED (Stem)
(Long bulb) with fittings

INVENTAA LED Lights Private
Limited (order No. 21/AAR/2020 dated 24th April, 2020; Tamil Nadu)

The issue before the AAR was
about classification of the above item, that is, LED (Stem) (Long bulb) with
fittings, under GST.

 

The applicant gave relevant
information about its activities and the product. About the product the
information given was as under:

 

‘The applicant is engaged in
the design, manufacture and supply of LED lights of various applications in a
wide range of sizes and voltage with fixtures and fittings where the fixtures
and fittings are made of plastics, aluminium, steel, or a combination thereof.
The applicant has stated that they have developed an LED Stem (Long bulb) which
has a 360-degree light output and at the same time saves power up to 60% in
comparison to the CFL bulb, whereas the conventional LED bulb delivers only
180-degree light output. It can be fitted into a B22 or E27 holder. About 70%
of the raw materials are manufactured indigenously and 30% imported from China,
while the manufacturing is done in-house. The applicant named the product as
LED Stem (Long bulb) and has applied for the patent of the technology involving
manufacturing of LED Stem (Long bulb) which has the feature of 360-degree light
output’.

 

The contention of the
applicant was that the item is covered by HSN 9405 of the Customs Tariff and
liable to tax at 12%. The AAR observed that the other competing Entry under
Customs Tariff is 8539. Both the tariff entries are reproduced in the AR.

 

The jurisdictional authority
concerned consented that the classification merits inclusion under HSN 9405.

 

The AAR also made reference to
the rules of classification under the Customs Tariff. He then concluded as
under:

 

‘From the above, it is evident
that Chapter 94 falls under section XX which covers “Miscellaneous Manufactured
Articles”. Lamps and light fittings can be any source and made of any material.
Further, those lamps and light fittings covered under Chapter 85 are not
covered under this heading by the specific exclusion in the Chapter Notes.
Further, lamps for exterior lighting are covered under CTH 9405. In the instant
case, the product is an LED lamp fixture with LED light integrated into it
which can function independently as garden lights. Therefore, they are
classifiable under CTH 94054090 as “others electric lamps and light fitting”.’

 

Accordingly, the AAR held that
the item is covered by the Entry at Serial No. 226 in Schedule II of the
Notification No. 01/2017 CT-(Rate) dated 28th June, 2017, liable to
GST at 12%.

 

4. Co-operative housing
society and levy of GST

Apsara Co-operative Housing
Society Limited (No. GST-ARA-21/2019-20/B-34 Mumbai,
dated 17th March, 2020; Maharashtra)

The applicant is a residential co-operative housing
society. It wanted to know whether the activities carried out by it for its
members qualify as ‘supply’ under the definition of section 7 of the CGST Act,
2017. Another issue raised was that if the activities of the applicant are
treated as supply under the CGST Act, 2017 then whether the applicant has
correctly discharged GST as per the illustrative copy of the invoice generated by
the applicant.

 

The applicant provided the
bye-laws of the society. As per these, the society is required to do certain
functions like obtain conveyance from the builder, manage, maintain and
administer the property of the society. There were further functions also, like
raising funds for achieving the objects of the society and recreation
activities and to do all things necessary or expedient for the achievement of
the objects of the society.

 

To achieve the above objects,
the applicant raises funds by collecting contributions from the members,
including towards property taxes, common electricity charges, water charges,
repair and maintenance, other such expenses and sinking fund, etc. It was the
contention of the applicant that there was no other activity.

 

The applicant stressed upon
the phrase used in section 7(1) that to constitute a supply under the GST Act,
the activity should be in the furtherance or course of business. The applicant
submitted that so far as the activities of the society are concerned, they are
not in the nature of business and therefore there is no supply as per the CGST
Act, 2017. The further contention of the applicant was that the society
functions on the principle of mutuality and there are no separate entities such
as supplier and recipient to constitute supply.

 

The jurisdictional officer
objected to the above contentions, relying on the fact that there is
consideration against giving services.

 

Based on the above contentions and facts, the AAR
examined the provisions of the CGST Act. He observed that the concept of supply
under the CGST Act is wide and that the definition of person in section
2(84)(i) of the CGST Act specifically includes a co-operative society
registered under any law relating to co-operative societies. Therefore, the
society and members are two distinct persons. The charges collected from
members were held to be consideration towards provision of services.

 

In respect of the contention about
‘business’, the AAR referred to clause (e) in the definition of ‘business’ in
section 2(17) which specifically provides that provision by club, associations,
society or any such body for subscription or any other consideration of the
facilities or benefits to its members is ‘business’. Therefore, it is observed
that there is business in the activities of the society. The applicant has
cited various rulings in respect of the principle of mutuality. However, the
AAR distinguished the same on the ground that the present case is under the GST
Act and hence such rulings are not related to the issue.

 

Finally, the Learned AAR held that the
society is liable to GST. He declined to give a ruling about the quantum of tax
on the ground that such a question is not covered within the scope of section
97(2) of the CGST Act.

 

ROLE OF A STATUTORY AUDITOR VIS-À-VIS GST

INTRODUCTION

In the last article we dealt with the
interplay between the process of statutory audit and the GST domain from the perspective
of planning the entire audit and understanding the processes applied from the
perspective of GST. In this article, we shall cover aspects related to review
from the perspective of financial statements and the various checks and
assertions which would be required during the audit process.

 

REVENUE
UNDER STATEMENT OF PROFIT & LOSS

Revenue is generally earned when a company
makes outward supply of goods or services, or both, and recovers the
consideration from its customers. However, it’s not necessary that the entire
consideration is accounted for as revenue in the books. In some cases, the
amounts recovered from customers are accounted in credit / liability ledgers,
especially in cases where there is recovery of expenses. The auditor should
therefore ensure that all such expenses are identified and that wherever there
are credit entries on account of outward supply, the corresponding tax is being
discharged.

 

Once the
auditor obtains assurance that all invoices are accounted in the calculation of
the revenue from operations, the first thing that needs to be checked is
whether or not the tax rate charged on the invoice is correct. For this, the
auditor needs to identify different kinds of transactions, i.e., outward
supplies made by the company and for each class of transactions determine if
there are different rates applied / any exemptions claimed and wherever there
are such variations, identify the reasons for the same. Similarly, wherever
there are conflicts in tax rates, especially in the case of goods due to
classification, the auditor should review the basis for the classification used
by the company to arrive at his conclusion.

 

It is not only the tax rate but the
determination of location of supplier in case of a multi-locational entity,
place of supply mentioned in the invoice, time of supply, value of supply,
etc., which also become important. For example, in a particular contract the
client has issued an order to a certain branch which executes and delivers the
entire contract. However, while raising the invoice, inadvertently the company
bills the client from a different branch. This may result in a challenge since
there is a possibility that the branch which has executed and delivered the
contract might face a demand in future from the tax authorities to pay tax on
the supplies made (although the same might have been paid at another branch).
In other words, the synchronisation between delivery location and contracting
location is one aspect which the auditor should check, especially in case of
service contracts.

 

Similarly, whether or not the time of supply
provisions are complied with also needs to be reviewed. In case of goods, the
auditor should check if invoices have been issued in all cases before the
outward movement of goods takes place. This is because for goods the time of
supply takes place before or at the time of the supply of goods. However, it
gets trickier in the case of services since the invoice can be issued even
after completion of service. The auditor should check cases where revenue has
been recognised under the accrual concept, but invoicing is yet to be done. In
such cases, the auditors should obtain reasonable assurance that the service
provision is incomplete. If it is determined that the service provision has
been completed but invoicing is not done for some reasons, there may be a
non-compliance with the time of supply provisions which might trigger a
contingent interest liability.

 

The next point that the auditor should
review is the value of supply for the purpose of GST. Whether the value on
which GST has been charged is as determinable u/s 15 of the CGST Act, 2017 or
not? In case of contracts, if there are instances of some materials being
supplied by the recipient, the auditor should also analyse if the value of such
material is includible in the value of supply. The auditor might want to
consider the applicability of a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of CST
vs. Bhayana Builders Private Limited [2018 (10) GSTL 118 (SC)].

Similarly, if the company is claiming non-inclusion of certain amounts on
account of reimbursement, the auditor should also check whether or not the
condition for pure agents prescribed u/r 33 of the CGST Rules, 2017 are
satisfied. Similarly, in case of related party transactions, the auditor should
check whether the same are at arm’s length or not.

 

DEEMED
SUPPLIES

Entry 3 of Schedule I of the CGST Act, 2017
deems supply of goods or services between distinct persons / related persons as
supply even if made without a consideration. Further, once a supply is made to
a related person, section 15 kicks in which requires valuation as per the
prescribed method under the CGST Rules, 2017 (Rules 28-32).

 

The controversy, however, revolves around
the first part of the entry, i.e., supply of goods or services between distinct
persons. This entry has resulted in a lot of confusion and caused
interpretation issues, especially from the service perspective on multiple
fronts, such as what constitutes supply between distinct persons, on what value
is it to be applied, what time of supply provisions apply, etc. The confusion
has further increased in view of the AAAR in the case of Columbia Asia
Hospitals Private Limited [2019 (20) GSTL 763 (AAAR-GST)].

 

The primary checkpoints while dealing with
supplies under Entry 3 of Schedule I are:

(i)  Identifying supplies getting covered under
Entry 3,

(ii) Ensuring compliance with valuation provisions,

(iii) Ensuring that such supplies are properly
accounted in the books of accounts, i.e., outward supply reported by one branch
should be reported as input tax credit in the corresponding branch and there is
no loss of the input tax credit.

 

It may be important to note that there are
serious legal interpretation issues relating to branch transfer of services. In
such scenarios it may be in order for the auditor to ensure that the company
has adopted a suitable policy in due consultation with legal experts and that
the policy is actually implemented.

 

BARTER
TRANSACTIONS

Let us try to understand the concept of
barter in the context of a real estate project where the company has entered
into an area-sharing Joint Development Agreement with the landowner. In such a
transaction, what usually happens is that the company gets the right to
construct on the land while the landowner, instead of getting monetary
consideration, is allotted certain constructed area in the new building which
he can self-use or sell. The company is liable to pay GST on the constructed
area to be allotted to the landowner. However, there is no consideration for
this which is determined by a prescribed method and there is no record of such
consideration in the books of the company. In such a case, though there is no
revenue received by the company, it ends up paying GST on a value which is
disclosed as an outward supply. This results in a gap between the books of
accounts and the GST returns.

 

In such a scenario, the auditor should look
into the applicability of Accounting Standards relating to revenue recognition
and accrual – whether the company is required to accrue the expenditure for the
supply made by the landowner or recognise revenue for constructed area allotted
to the landowner. It is imperative to note that there is no exchange of
monetary consideration and even the value adopted for the transaction under
different statutes may not be the same. While analysing this point, apart from
GST the auditor should also consider the probable implications under Income Tax
since if the transaction is treated as sale and purchase of constructed area /
land, respectively, there might be probable TDS implications.

 

EXPENDITURE
UNDER STATEMENT OF PROFIT & LOSS

GST works on the concept of value-added
taxation, i.e., a company ideally pays tax only on the value addition by it in
the transaction chain. This is achieved by the concept of input tax credit
(ITC), which is at the heart of GST and accrues to a company when it incurs an
expenditure, whether revenue or capital in nature. But the important point that
one needs to note is that this credit is not always available and the same is
subject to conditions. There are various facets to be noted when taking ITC
which can be as under:

 

1. Input tax credit can be claimed only
if goods or services are received for use in the course or furtherance of
business

One of the primary conditions for claiming
ITC is that the goods or services received by a company should be used in the
course or furtherance of business. What constitutes ‘business’ has been defined
under GST. However, this condition has created quite a controversy. For
example, CSR expenses, which certain classes of companies are mandatorily
required to incur under the Companies Act, 2013 are not treated as expenses
incurred for the purpose of business / profession u/s 37 of the Income Tax Act,
1961. It would therefore be important to evaluate this controversy, especially
during the pandemic times where various companies have incurred more CSR
expenditure than what they are mandatorily required to incur under the Companies
Act, 2013.

 

2. Conditions for claiming input tax
credit should be satisfied

Apart from the primary condition that the
goods or services should be used in the course or furtherance of business,
section 16(2) also lists other conditions which are required to be satisfied
for claiming input tax credit:

 

* The company should be in possession of
a prescribed document issued by the supplier

A condition procedural in nature, there must
be reasonable assurance that the company should be in possession of documents
based on which it is claiming ITC. One of the primary aspects to be checked is
whether the documents based on which the credit has been claimed contains the
standard list of disclosures mandated under the CGST Rules, 2017 and has the
other disclosures as well or not. It should further be checked if the company
claims credit based on the supporting invoice or even when it books provisional
expenses.

 

* The goods or service should have been
received

This is an important condition the
satisfaction of which would be the key to supplement the claim of ITC. The
condition relating to receipt of goods would be easily satisfied owing to the
tangible characteristic of goods. However, the receipt of goods should be
correlated with corresponding documents evidencing the same, such as E-way
bill, lorry receipts, etc.

 

However, in the context of service,
demonstration of receipt of service would be crucial. This can be done by
relying on documentary evidence, including agreements, work certifications,
etc. For example, in the case of construction services received, a surveyor’s
certificate certifying the extent of work based on which the invoice has been
issued can be a proof for receipt of service. Even an internal certification by
an authorised person can be the basis for demonstration of receipt of service.
A similar method should be followed for other services as well.

 

One important aspect to be noted by the
auditor is to deal with a situation where the tax authorities allege
non-receipt of goods or services. There are various cases where the tax
authorities allege that certain transactions of inward supplies are fictitious
and that the ITC claimed by the company is not eligible. There can be instances
where the company might have contested the allegation, though the credit might
have been reversed under protest due to coercion from tax authorities.

 

The auditor should carefully analyse this
level of transaction since it points at probable fraud, mismanagement and
misstatement of financial statements and requires specific disclosure in the
auditor’s report, including the statement on internal financial controls. The
decision on this would be critical, especially in cases where the dispute is
not concluded, i.e., the company continues to litigate the allegations. While
many such instances have been reported in the judiciary, the auditor should
take a call based on the facts of the specific case since in each case the
facts may be different.

 

* The supplier should have paid the tax
and the recipient should have filed the return u/s 39

This would be a check which should be maintained
in the monthly return filing process. The company should ensure that the
supplier should have filed not only his GSTR1, but also his GSTR3B.

 

* The payment to supplier should have
been made within 180 days from the date of invoice

This condition has already been discussed in
the earlier part of this article [refer discussion on 2nd proviso
to section 16(2) r.w. Rule 37].

 

* The ITC should be taken within the
prescribed time limit, i.e., before the due date of filing return for the month
of September of the succeeding financial year

An important aspect, this is one more
condition which should be a part of the monthly return filing process of each
company. From the auditor’s perspective, the auditor should also check if all
the returns are filed on time and in case of delay, whether there is any impact
on eligibility to claim input tax credit and what position the company has
taken on this?

 

One specific issue which needs to be noted
is that the tax authorities have been challenging the claim of ITC in cases
where returns for a tax period are filed after the due date for filing the
return of September of the succeeding financial year. The tax authorities have
challenged the eligibility to claim ITC u/s 16(4). The auditors should review
if there are such instances and should also analyse the legal position taken by
the company.

 

3. Application of section 17

Section 17 deals with two aspects, one being
apportionment of ITC and the second being blocked credits. The first part,
i.e., apportionment of ITC, comes into the picture when inward supplies are
used for making outward supplies which are used for making taxable supplies as
well as exempt supplies. In such cases, compliance with provisions of Rules 42
and 43 (already discussed in the earlier part of this article) should be
analysed. The auditor should specifically check if the compliance is done on a
monthly basis, whether the true-up as mandated u/r 42 and 43 is done within the
prescribed time limit and, lastly, the accounting for the apportionment u/r 42
and 43 – whether the amount of reversals / re-credit is booked to specific
expense or a general expense? The auditor should also analyse the method of
reporting the true-up effect of Rules 42 and 43 in the subsequent financial
year – whether as prior period expense or regular expense?

 

The above would be more relevant in case of
timing difference in booking of expenses used for making exempt supplies. Let
us take an example of a supplier engaged in making exempt supplies who had
contracted to receive certain expenses during a F.Y. Based on the contract, the
auditors had advised the company to accrue the said expense in its books in one
F.Y. The issue that would remain is whether the auditor should recommend
provision of only the basic expense or expense including GST, considering the
fact that in the subsequent period when the expense will actually be booked,
the corresponding GST will not be allowable for ITC and, therefore, the issue
of whether the GST component may be treated as prior period expense arises.

 

The second part, i.e., blocked credits, is
trickier. There has been a lot of controversy on this subject, be it inputs or
capital goods. While reviewing the ITC claim from the viewpoint of eligibility,
the auditor should specifically check on the following key aspects:

 

(a)
Determining what is covered u/s 17(5)(c) and 17(5)(d) relating to receipt of
goods or services for construction of immovable property other than plant and
machinery, subject to the condition that the cost is capitalised in the books
of accounts

The key issue which the auditor needs to
look at is the applicability of the decision of the Orissa High Court in the
case of Safari Retreats Private Limited vs. CC of GST [2019 (25) GSTL 341
(Ori.)]
which held that the provision of section 17(5)(d) was ultra
vires
the provisions of the object of the Act and held that ITC should be
allowed on receipt of goods or services used in the construction of an
immovable property which is used for providing an output service.

 

Another aspect which needs to be looked at
is the distinction between depreciation and amortisation. Depreciation
generally applies to expenses capitalised whereas amortisation applies in cases
where expenses are incurred upfront, but their recognition is spread over
years. The former applies in cases involving ownership, while the latter
applies in cases where no ownership exists, for example, in the case of leased
premises, costs incurred under BOT projects, etc.

 

(b)
Determining what constitutes personal consumption for disallowance u/s 17(5)(g)

This provision states that credit of goods
or services used for personal consumption would not be eligible. But the
question remains, what constitutes ‘use for personal consumption’, especially
in case of companies where all personnel working for the company are either
employees / consultants? Therefore, the question of personal consumption should
not have arisen. While analysing this provision, the auditor should also check
whether there is alignment with the position taken under the ITA, 1961 which
requires reporting of personal expenses in Form 3CD.

 

(c) Determining the scope of section 17(5)(h) –
where goods are lost, stolen, destroyed, written off or disposed of by way of
gift or free samples

The issue of
when eligibility of ITC is to be checked is a settled position in view of the
decision of the Tribunal in the case of Spenta International Limited vs.
CCE, Thane [2007 (216) ELT 133 (Tri – LB)]
where the court held that
credit eligibility should be checked at the time of receipt of goods. The
applicability of this decision to GST is important to be reviewed, since there
is no other provision under the statute which deals with this aspect under GST.

 

Similarly, what constitutes gift is also
important. A business undertakes sales promotion activity by virtue of which
the company would give ‘freebies’ to its customers. While no specific
consideration is received for such freebies, a business would not give any
freebies if the cost is not recovered from customers indirectly. A reference to
CBIC Circular 92/11/2019 – GST dated 7th March, 2019 would be
important while dealing with eligibility to claim ITC.

 

ROLE OF
GSTR2A IN AUDIT PROCESS

Apart from the above, there is one other
factor which should also be looked at in the context of ITC, which is the role
of GSTR2A. GSTR2A is the document which is made available on the GST portal
based on the details uploaded by a supplier and help the company in matching
the compliances of its vendors. There are different factors which need to be
looked at here:

(A) Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules, 2017
provide that for any tax period the ITC claim should not be more than 110% of
the amount appearing in GSTR2A. The auditor should not only check whether this
provision is complied with or not, but also the accounting treatment in case
there is a need to defer the credit in view of Rule 36(4).

(B) The auditor should also review the net
amount of ITC which remains unmatched and analyse the implication it might have
on such credit claims in future.

 

LIABILITIES
UNDER BALANCE SHEET

The GST collected by the company gets
credited to the GST payable account, which gets covered under the head
‘Liabilities’ in the Balance Sheet. The auditor should obtain a reasonable
assurance that the liabilities on account of GST reported in the Balance Sheet
give a true and fair view and is specifically required to give a report of this
in the CARO statement as to:

 

(I) Whether the company has been regular
in depositing undisputed statutory dues as applicable with the appropriate authorities?

The answer to the first question can be
obtained by collating a compliance table under GST which would assist the
auditor in determining whether the company has been regular in depositing
statutory dues with the authorities concerned. One might also need to determine
whether mere filing of return in time would be the correct basis to arrive at a
conclusion, or whether the auditor needs to check if all the information has
been correctly mentioned in the returns, or there is a delay. For example, supplies
made in April may be reported in the returns of June. Therefore, while in
totality all the applicable statutory dues would have been paid, but whether
this can be treated as ‘regular deposition of undisputed statutory dues’ or not
would depend on the professional judgement of the auditor.

 

(II) Whether any undisputed statutory
dues are pending for a period of more than six months as on the balance sheet
date?

This is an important part of the audit
process as it requires the auditor to check the workings of the client on a
monthly basis to ensure that all the monthly liabilities are paid in time.
Generally, the best way to look at this would be by comparing the liability as
on the balance sheet date with the liability as per the returns for the last tax
period ending on the balance sheet date. If both the figures reconcile, this
would mean that there are no statutory dues pending for a period of more than
six months as on the balance sheet date. However, in case there is a mismatch,
the auditor would be required to check and identify the month in which there is
a mismatch in liability as per the books vs. liability as reported in the
returns, and determine if the same is pending for a period of more than six
months which would require reporting in CARO. Of course, the auditor will need
to ensure whether the outstanding dues are disputed or undisputed and only if
they are undisputed would such dues be required to be reported. On the basis of
this reporting, even the tax auditor might need to look at the impact on his
reporting for section 43B compliances in Form 3CD.

 

Apart from the liability to pay tax under
forward charge, i.e., on supplies made by a company, the next area to be
discussed is the accounting and discharge of reverse charge liability. While dealing
with RCM liability, there are various aspects which an auditor should look
into, such as method of accounting of reverse charge considering the varied
time of supply provisions, claim of corresponding ITC, reconciliation (expense vis-à-vis
returns), etc. Let us look into each of these aspects.

 

(III) Accounting & discharge of RCM
liability

In case of reverse charge, the point of
taxation generally depends on two factors, namely, date of payment to the
supplier, or 60 days from the date of invoice, whichever is earlier. This would
mean that under legal parlance the accounting of invoice, which also earmarks
the date of acknowledgement of liability towards the supplier and the due date
at which the applicable GST is required to be paid, are not linked to each
other, which is in contrast to the position when compared with outward
supplies.

 

The general practice followed by companies
is that as and when they account for an invoice on which tax is liable to be
paid under reverse charge, they also book the corresponding liability and
credit (if eligible) or expense out the tax amount and, in a majority of the
cases, it is observed that the tax is also paid based on the same for the sake
of convenience on various aspects, the most important being the ease of
reconciliation of liability. However, there are instances wherein companies,
although they account the liability as well as the corresponding credit on
accrual basis, may discharge the same and claim credit under GST only when the
liability becomes due. In such instances, there will always be a mismatch in
the liability as per the books vs. the liability reported in the GST returns,
which would need reconciliation as the same would be the basis for reporting
under CARO as well as 3CD.

 

Furthermore, while dealing with related
party transactions, the auditor should also ensure that in case of provisions
made for expenditure payable to foreign associated enterprises, the liability
should have been discharged on accrual basis, i.e., the general rule does not
apply to such transactions. The auditor should check on whether any provision
for payments to be made to foreign associated enterprises are open for a period
of more than six months on the balance sheet date and, if yes, whether the
applicable GST is discharged therein or not, as the same might necessitate
reporting under CARO.

 

(IV) Impact of credit notes &
reconciliation issues

Generally, it is observed that a company
recognises its reverse charge liability when it accounts for an expense wherein
reverse charge is applicable. At that point of time, it might also be claiming
corresponding credits as and when available.

 

However, there are cases wherein once the
above is done, against the said invoice, the recipient receives a credit note,
meaning there is a reversal of the expense / the amount of expense. For such
cases, the logical practice to be followed would be that when such credit notes
are booked, corresponding tax liabilities as well as credits claimed, if any,
should be reduced. This would be more important in cases where credits are not
available and the tax paid under reverse charge is expensed out as this would
help in reducing the expense of the company. This will also ensure proper
reconciliation of expenses as per books vs. returns filed.

 

However, in cases where credits are
available, the general practice is that the tax effect of the credit notes is
ignored since this would be a cash neutral exercise as the tax paid upfront was
not a cost. However, this might need an adjustment when preparing the
reconciliation of expenses as per books vs. returns filed. Further, under
CENVAT regime this practice was also questioned by the Department which had in
a particular case sought reversal of credit without appreciating the fact that
the assessee had not reversed corresponding tax liability under reverse charge
emanating from a credit note. This demand was set aside by the Tribunal in the
case of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited vs. Commissioner of
Central Tax, Visakhapatnam [2019-VIL-295-CESTAT-HYD].

 

COMPLIANCE
OF 2ND PROVISO TO SECTION 16(2) OF CGST ACT, 2017 R.W. RULE 37 OF
CGST RULES, 2017

One more area to look into is the trade
payables which are outstanding for more than 180 days. The second proviso
to section 16(2) provides that in case where payment to the supplier is not
made within a period of 180 days, corresponding ITC should be added to the
output tax liability of the company to the extent that there is a failure to
pay to such vendor. Since this is an amount which is liable to be added to the
output tax liability, as a prudent exercise an auditor should undertake the
verification of whether or not the company has complied with these provisions.
However, while dealing with this, the auditor needs to consider two important
points, namely:

 

i) Input Tax Credit under GST should have
been claimed against the invoices which are outstanding

ii) There should have been a failure to pay
to the supplier. What constitutes ‘failure to pay’ has been a subject matter of
litigation and one should refer to the decision in the case under CENVAT
regime; the Tribunal in Commissioner vs. Hindustan Zinc Limited [2014
(34) STR 440 (Tri.–Del.)]
held that where the amounts are not paid due
to contractual terms and the entire tax amount is paid to the vendor /
supplier, the need to reverse Rule 4(7) should not apply. While reviewing this
compliance, the auditor should also analyse whether the position taken by the
company is in line with this decision and accordingly determine if there is a
need for reporting under CARO for undisputed dues outstanding for more than six
months or not.

 

ASSETS
UNDER BALANCE SHEET

* GST & tangible / intangible assets

Under GST, all inward supplies of goods are
classified into either inputs or capital assets. What constitute capital assets
are those inward supplies of goods which are capitalised in the books of
accounts. However, if any input services are capitalised, the same do not
constitute capital goods for the purpose of GST but are treated as input
services.

 

When looking at tangible / intangible
assets, traditionally known as ‘fixed assets’ under GST, there are various points
which need consideration. The key point to be looked into is the operation of
the provisions of section 17(5) of the CGST Act, 2017 which lists certain
inward supplies where ITC would not be available, also known as blocked
credits. Some of the items in this category include purchase of modes of
transportation of persons, or construction of immovable property, goods used
for personal consumption, etc. The auditor should primarily review whether
there are any specific instances wherein credits have been claimed though the
same are restricted u/s 17(5).

 

Apart from the above, the auditor should
also ensure that in cases where any capital goods, on which ITC was claimed,
are being sold, the provisions of section 18(6) of the CGST Act, 2017 r.w. Rule
44 of the CGST Rules, 2017 have been complied with. The same provide that in
supply of capital goods, the amount of tax payable would be the higher of the
amount payable on value of supply of such capital goods, or the un-depreciated
ITC to be calculated vis-à-vis the method prescribed u/r 44 of CGST
Rules, 2017.

 

Similarly, the auditor should also look into
whether or not the company has complied with the provisions of Rule 43. This is
important since the amount determined u/r 43 is to be added to the output tax
liability and, therefore, if there is non-compliance, reporting under CARO
might be triggered. Further, to the extent credit is liable to be reversed u/r
43, the auditor should also check whether the amounts liable to be reversed u/r
43 are capitalised or expensed out and the correctness of the said accounting
treatment.

 

Apart from the above, in case of
multi-locational companies having presence in multiple states, the auditor
should also check whether the movement of goods is properly documented and the
applicable compliances under GST in view of Entry 3 of Schedule I of the CGST
Act, 2017 are undertaken or not? This is an important aspect since there would
be a liability to pay tax at the branch sending the fixed assets and
eligibility to claim credit at the receiving branch. In case of non-compliance,
the company might end up with a situation where a subsequent identification of
non-compliance might result in liability at the sending branch with no
corresponding ITC at the receiving branch, thus resulting in incremental cost
on account of the non-compliance.

 

* GST balances

GST balances comprise of two parts, one
being ITC balance and the second being the balance on account of payment of
tax. ITC balance is one of the most important parts of GST as it represents the
outcome of the entire process of claim of ITC undertaken by the company. The
first and foremost check to be undertaken by the auditor is whether or not the
ITC balances appearing in the books of accounts are matching with the balance
in the electronic credit ledgers available on the portal as on the balance sheet date. In an ideal scenario, the balance appearing in the
books of accounts should reconcile in all respects with the balance appearing
in the electronic credit ledger. However, there are instances where the amounts
do not reconcile, primarily in the following cases:

 

(a)  All adjustments to ITC which are reported in
GSTR3B are not accounted for in the books of accounts. For example, even if a
company complies with the second proviso to section 16(2) requiring
reversal of ITC in case of non-payment to suppliers, a separate entry is not
passed in the books of accounts. Similarly, there are instances wherein there
is a delay in accounting of Rule 42 / 43 adjustments.

(b)  Amount of refund claim filed online is reduced
from the balance in the electronic credit ledger. However, in the books,
instead of transferring it to refund receivable account, it continues to remain
in ITC account and, as and when amounts are received, reduced directly from the
ITC account.

(c)  Input tax credit accounted for in the books
but not claimed in GSTR3B due to operation of Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules,
2017 which requires that in any tax period the amount of ITC cannot be more
than 110% of the amounts appearing in GSTR2A.

(d)  Offset entries for March, 2020 are passed in
April, 2020 in the books of accounts but portal balance for comparison is taken
as per electronic credit ledger after filing of returns of March, 2020, thus
resulting in a timing gap.

 

While the above reasons may not represent
any non-compliances / material misstatement on the part of the company, an
auditor may consider suggesting a change in practice which will ensure
appropriate reconciliation of accounts which will, in turn, help the company
not only in the future audit process but also during the assessment proceedings
wherein it would be easier to explain to the tax authorities.

 

Another issue with respect to balance in ITC
ledgers is with respect to accumulation of amounts in the ledger for multiple
reasons, such as company is engaged in making zero-rated supplies without
payment of tax and therefore eligible to claim refund, where there is inverted
rate structure, in case of startups where the revenue during the initial years
is low while corresponding expenditure is high, or, simply put, loss-making
companies. With respect to this, it is observed that on various occasions where
the refund is stuck for many years, the auditors require the company to
determine the scope of recoupment of the balances and make a provision for
write-off of balance to the extent there is no certainty of recoupment.
However, while doing so the auditors should keep the following aspects in mind:

 

1.  In case of accumulation due to zero-rated
supplies / inverted rate of structure, one of the key points to be eligible to
claim refund is that the incidence of tax should not be passed on to another
person. Once the balance is written off, this principle kicks in and recouping
the balance by way of refund might become a challenge for the company.

2.  In case of accumulation due to loss, the
company can explore the option of claiming the refund by relying on the
decision in the case of Union of India vs. Slovak India Trading Co.
Private Limited [2008 (10) STR 101 (Kar.)]
or by entering into a scheme
of merger / business transfer arrangement whereby either the entire company or
the loss-making division can be transferred along with all assets and
liabilities, including balance in electronic credit ledger, thus encashing the
said balances. Furthermore, one should also note that writing off balance in
view of uncertainty of utilisation in future might actually be in conflict with
the basic fundamentals of the audit, that the financials are prepared on a
going concern basis since there is a reasonable certainty of profitability in
the future.

 

The second part when dealing with GST
balance is the balance of tax paid in the cash ledger. Generally, it is seen
that any payment of tax is directly accounted in the liability ledgers. It is,
however, always prudent that a separate account (for each tax type) be created
in the books where all payments are booked and, as and when the liability is
discharged in the returns filed, corresponding entries be passed in the books
of accounts. This is for the important reason that mere payment of amount into
cash ledger does not amount to payment of tax itself. It takes place either
when the return is filed or by making a declaration in Form DRC-03. In fact,
even if there is sufficient balance in the cash ledger, the interest is liable
to be paid from the due date till the date of return / DRC-03 which actually
marks the payment of tax under GST as this results in reduction in balance in
the electronic cash ledger. This aspect should be kept in mind, especially when
dealing with reporting under Form 3CD.

 

DISCLOSURE
OF BALANCES IN BALANCE SHEET

There are two sets of GST GLs which a
taxpayer should generally maintain. One set of GST GLs to deal with GST
payable, which may be either on outward supplies or inward supplies where
reverse charge mechanism applies and is accounted as liability when the company
books revenue / expenses which attract RCM in its books; and second set of GST
GLs which deal with ITC, which gets accounted as assets when they book an
expense where the vendor has charged ITC and book it as receivable in their
balance sheet.

 

The following points are relevant for
discussion:

(A) Manner of reporting GST GLs – whether
the liability GLs will be clubbed under the head ‘Liabilities’ and credit GLs
will be clubbed under the head ‘Assets’ or only net balance to be disclosed,
either under the head ‘liabilities’ or ‘credits’ as the case may be? This is an
important aspect since in GST while the liability becomes due once the outward
supply is made, irrespective of whether the liability has been actually booked in
the books of accounts, ITC is claimed only when the same is reported in GSTR3B.
There can be scenarios where though a credit is booked in the books of
accounts, the same may not have been reported in GSTR3B and therefore not
claimed by the company. Similarly, there might be credit balances which may not
be immediately available to the company [deferred credits in view of the second
proviso to section 16(2), rule 36(4), etc.]

 

In such a case, would it be correct for the
company to show such net balance in GST GLs, or should it report separately,
liability GLs under the liability head and credit GLs under the assets head?
Separate reporting under the head ’liabilities’ and ‘assets’ rather than net
reporting seems to be a more correct approach.

 

(B) Once an auditor takes a view that the
balances have to be reported separately, it would imply that the balance for
March or the last tax period of the financial year to be reported is to be
disclosed before the offset entry. This would entail reporting of a higher
amount as liability u/s 43B in the Form 3CD. However, no major ramifications
are expected since the liability would have been discharged in April and
therefore entail no disallowances under Income Tax.

 

CONCLUSION

It is often said that tax and accounting are
strangers. However, they invariably overlap since both of them are based on
underlying transactions. Since the scope of the auditor also includes ensuring
correct compliance with various laws including tax laws, in cases where the
treatments under the two domains are different, statutory auditors may be
required to do a balancing act and suitably customise their audit processes to ensure that the
auditors have reasonable confidence in the true and fair nature of the
financial statements.



A man can be himself only so
long as he is alone, and if he does not love solitude,
he will not love freedom, for it is only when he is alone that he is really
free

— 
Arthur Schopenhauer

 

 

Patience is not simply the
ability to wait – it’s how we behave while we’re waiting

 — 
Joyce Meyer

 

 

What sunshine is to flowers,
smiles are to humanity. These are but trifles, to be sure; but scattered along
life’s pathway, the good they do is inconceivable

 — 
Joseph Addison

FROM PUBLISHED ACCOUNTS

ILLUSTRATION OF
QUALIFIED OPINION FOR A BANK

 

YES BANK LTD.
(STANDALONE) (YEAR ENDED 31ST MARCH, 2020)

 

From
Auditors’ Report

Basis of Qualified opinion

We draw attention to Note 18.3 of the
Standalone Financial Statements, which indicates that during the year ended 31st
March 2020, the Bank has breached the regulatory requirements of the Reserve
Bank of India (RBI) regarding maintaining the minimum Common Equity Tier
(CET)-1 and Tier-1 capital ratios which indicates the position of capital
adequacy of a bank. The breach is primarily on account of the increase in the
provision for advances during the year ended 31st March, 2020 as the
Bank has decided, on a prudent basis, to enhance its Provision Coverage Ratio
on its Non-Performing Asset (NPA) loans over and above minimum RBI loan level
provisioning. Further, the write-back of the Additional Tier (AT)-1 bonds on 14th
March, 2020 also resulted in the breach of Tier-1 capital ratio as at 31st
March, 2020. The CET-1 ratio and the Tier-1 capital ratios for the Bank
as at 31st March, 2020 stood at 6.3% and 6.5 % as compared to the
minimum requirements of 7.375% and 8.875%, respectively. This implies that the
Bank will have to take effective steps to augment its capital base in the year
2020-21. Further, in view of the RBI norms relating to the breach of the
aforesaid ratios, there is uncertainty around RBI’s potential action for such a
breach. We are unable to comment on the consequential impact of the above
regulatory breach on these Standalone Financial Statements.

 

We draw attention to Note 18.6.69 to the
Standalone Financial Statements which discloses that the Bank became aware in
September, 2018 through communications from stock exchanges of an anonymous
whistle-blower complaint alleging irregularities in the Bank’s operations,
potential conflicts of interests in relation to the former MD and CEO and
allegations of incorrect NPA classification. The Bank conducted an internal
inquiry of these allegations, which resulted in a report that was reviewed by
the Board of Directors in November, 2018. Based on further inputs and
deliberations in December, 2018, the Audit Committee of the Bank engaged an
external firm to independently examine the matter. During the year ended 31st
March, 2020, the Bank identified certain further matters which arose from other
independent investigations initiated by the lead banker of a lenders’
consortium on the companies allegedly favoured by the former MD & CEO. In March,
2020, the Enforcement Directorate has launched an investigation into some
aspects of dealings and transactions by the former MD & CEO on the basis of
draft forensic reports from external agencies which further pointed to conflict
of interest between the former MD & CEO and certain companies and arrested
him. In view of the fact that these inquiries and investigations are still
on-going, we are unable to comment on the consequential impact of the above
matter on these Standalone Financial Statements.

 

We conducted our audit in accordance with
the Standards on Auditing (SAs) specified u/s 143(10) of the Act. Our
responsibilities under those SAs are further described in the Auditor’s
Responsibilities for the Audit of the Standalone Financial Statements section
of our report. We are independent of the Bank in accordance with the Code of
Ethics issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India together with
the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit of the Standalone
Financial Statements under the provisions of the Act and the Rules thereunder,
and we have fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with
these requirements and the Code of Ethics. We believe that the audit evidence
we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our
qualified opinion on the Standalone Financial Statements.

 

MATERIAL
UNCERTAINTY RELATED TO GOING CONCERN

We draw attention to Note 18.3 of the
Standalone Financial Statements which indicates that the Bank has incurred a
loss of Rs. 16,418 crores for the year ended 31st March, 2020.
Particularly during the last six months, there has also been a significant
decline in the Bank’s deposit base, an increase in their NPA ratios resulting
in breach of loan covenants on its foreign currency debt and credit rating
downgrades, resulting in partial prepayment of foreign currency debt linked to
external credit rating. The Bank has also breached minimum Statutory Liquidity
Ratio (SLR) and Liquidity Coverage Ratio requirements of RBI during the year
and has provided an amount of Rs. 334 crores for the expected penalty on the
SLR breach. The Bank has also breached the RBI-mandated CET-1 ratio and Tier-1
capital ratio which stood at 6.3%.and 6.5% as compared to the minimum
requirements of 7.375% and 8.875%, respectively. This requires the Bank to take
effective steps to augment its capital base in the year 2020-21. The breach of
the CET-1 and Tier-1 requirements was also impacted by the decision of the Bank
to enhance its Provision Coverage Ratio, on a prudent basis, on its NPA loans
over and above the RBI’s minimum loan provisioning norms. Further, on 5th
March, 2020, the Central Government, based on the RBI’s application, imposed a
moratorium u/s 45 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 for a period of 30 days effective 5th
March, 2020. The RBI, in consultation with the Central Government and in
exercise of the powers u/s 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act 1949, superseded
the Board of Directors of the Bank on 5th March, 2020. The above
indicators of financial stress and actions taken by the RBI resulted in a
significant withdrawal of deposits.

 

On 13th March, 2020, the
Government of India notified the Yes Bank Limited Reconstruction Scheme 2020
(the Scheme) [notified by the Central Government in exercise of the powers
conferred by sub-section (4) and sub-section (7) of section 45 of the Banking
Regulation Act, 1949]. Under this Scheme the authorised share capital of the
Bank was increased to Rs. 6,200 crores. The Bank has received capital from
investors amounting to Rs. 10,000 crores on 14th March, 2020. The
State Bank of India (SBI) and other banks and financial institutions invested
in the Bank at a price of Rs. 10 per equity share of the Bank (Rs. 2 face value
with a Rs. 8 premium). SBI is required to hold up to 49% with a minimum holding
of 26% by SBI in the Bank (which is subject to a three-year lock-in). Other
investors are subject to a three-year lock-in for 75% of the investments they
make in the Bank under this Scheme. Existing investors (other than investors
holding less than 100 shares) in the Bank are also subject to a lock-in for 75%
of their holding as per this Scheme. A new Board of Directors, CEO and MD and
Non-Executive Chairman have also been appointed pursuant to the Scheme. In
addition, the moratorium imposed on the Bank on 5th March, 2020 was
vacated on 18th March, 2020 as per the Scheme.

 

RBI has also granted short-term funding to
the Bank for a period of 90 days. The Bank has submitted a proposal seeking
extension (of this) for a period of one year. The draft reconstruction
scheme proposed on 6th March, 2020 had also envisaged that the Bank
would be able to write back Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) securities amounting to
Rs. 8,695 crores to equity. However, the final Scheme issued by the Government
of India on 13th March, 2020 does not contain any reference to the
write-back of the AT-1 securities.

 

Based on the legal advice on the contractual
terms of the AT-1 bonds, the Bank has fully written back AT-1 bonds aggregating
to Rs. 8,415 crores on 14th March, 2020. This action by the Bank has
been legally challenged through a writ petition in the Hon’ble Bombay High
Court.

 

In line with the RBI’s Covid-19 Regulatory
Package dated 27th March, 2020 and 17th April, 2020, the
Bank has granted a moratorium of three months on the payment of all instalments
and / or interest, as applicable, falling due between 1st March,
2020 and 31st May, 2020 to all eligible borrowers classified as
Standard, even if overdue, as on 29th February, 2020.

 

In the opinion of the Bank, based on the
financial projections prepared by the Bank and approved by the Board for the
next three years, the capital infusion, lines of liquidity provided by RBI and
the reconstruction Scheme, the Bank will be able to realise its assets
(including its deferred tax asset) and discharge its liabilities in its normal
course of business and hence the financial statements have been prepared on a
going concern basis. The said assumption of going concern is inter alia
dependent on the Bank’s ability to achieve improvements in liquidity, asset
quality and solvency ratios and mitigate the impact of Covid-19 and thus a
material uncertainty exists that may cast a significant doubt on the Bank’s
ability to continue as a going concern. However, as stated above, as per the
management and the Board, there are mitigating factors to such uncertainties
including the amount of capital funds that have been raised in March, 2020, the
nature and financial resources of new investors who have infused funds in the
Bank, the new Board of Directors, CEO and MD and part-time Chairman appointed
as per the Scheme and the extent of regulatory support provided to the Bank by
the RBI.

 

Our conclusion on the Standalone Financial
Statements is not modified in respect of this matter.

 

Emphasis
of matter

We draw attention to Note 18.6.51 of the
Standalone Financial Statements, which states that the Bank has a total
deferred tax asset of Rs. 8,281 crores as at 31st March, 2020. As
per the requirements of AS 22 – Income Taxes, based on the financial
projections prepared by the Bank and approved by the Board of Directors, the
Bank has assessed that there is reasonable certainty that sufficient future
taxable income will be available against which such deferred tax assets can be
realised. The Bank expects to have a taxable profit for the future years. Our
conclusion is not modified in respect of this matter.

 

We draw attention to Note 18.4 of the
Standalone Financial Statements which states that the Bank had made an
additional provision of Rs. 15,422 crores for the period ended 31st
December, 2019 on a prudent evaluation of the status of NPAs based on
discussions with the regulator over and above the RBI norms relating to the
minimum provision to be made by banks on their loans and advances. The
additional provision is judgemental based on the quality and status of specific
loans identified by the Bank as at 31st March, 2020. We believe that
this judgement exercised by the Bank is appropriate. Our conclusion is not
modified in respect of this matter.

 

From
Notes to Financial Statements

18.3 Assessment of Going Concern

In the aftermath of the IL&FS crisis in
September, 2018, the financial sector had been heavily constrained from a
liquidity stand-point. Also, rising defaults in the power and infra sectors in
the second half of 2019 have taken a toll on the stressed book of various banks
and NBFCs. In this macro environment, given its low capital covers, the Bank
has been adversely impacted on account of elevated slippages in its corporate
book, especially in the power and infra sectors. The Bank reported a marginal
profit for the quarter ended 30th June, 2019 and reported loss in
the quarter ended 30th September, 2019. For the quarter ended 31st
December, 2019, as a consequence of increase in NPAs, additional recording
slippages post-period end and increase in PCR, the reported loss was Rs.
185,604 million. The Bank had also breached the RBI-mandated Common Equity
(CET-1) ratio which stood at 0.62% at 31st December, 2019 as
compared to the requirement of 7.375%. The delay in capital raising triggered
the downgrade of the Bank’s rating by rating agencies.

 

In addition, the deposit outflow in early
October on account of a combination of events such as invocation of promoter’s
pledged shares / IT glitches for Yes Bank (and others) / problems arising from
financial distress in Punjab and Maharashtra Co-operative Bank led to a
continuing breach in Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR) starting October, 2019 and
continues till date. The Bank’s deposit base has seen a reduction from Rs.
2,094,973 million as at 30th September, 2019 to Rs. 1,657,554
million as at 31st December, 2019. The deposit position as at 31st
March, 2020 is Rs. 1,053,639 million and has reduced further to Rs. 1,027,179
million as at 2nd May, 2020. The Bank had also prepaid ~ USD 1.18
billion (Rs. 85,000 million) by 29th February, 2020. On 5th
March, 2020, the Central Government, based on the RBI’s application, imposed a
moratorium u/s 45 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 for a period of 30 days
effective 5th March, 2020 which was lifted on 18th March, 2020.
Further, the RBI, in consultation with the Central Government and in exercise
of the powers u/s 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, superseded the
Board of Directors of the Bank on 5th March, 2020. As per the
moratorium, a restriction was imposed on the withdrawal by depositors of
amounts up to Rs. 50,000 and the Bank also could not grant or renew loans or
make any investments.

 

On 13th March, 2020, the
Government of India notified the ‘Yes Bank Ltd. Reconstruction Scheme, 2020’
(Scheme). As per the Scheme, authorised capital has been increased from Rs.
11,000 million to Rs. 62,000 million. The State Bank of India (SBI) and other
investors invested in 10,000 million shares at a price of Rs. 10 per equity
share of the Bank (Rs. 2 face value with a Rs. 8 premium). The Bank has
received capital amounting to Rs. 100,000 million as of 14th March,
2020 from a consortium of Banks and Financial Institutions led by State Bank of
India. SBI is required to hold up to 49% with a minimum holding of 26% by SBI
in the Bank (which is subject to a three-year lock-in). Other investors are
subject to a three-year lock-in for 75% of the investments they make in the
Bank under this Scheme. Existing investors (other than investors holding less
than 100 shares) in Yes Bank are also subject to a lock-in for 75% of their
holding as per this Scheme.

 

A new Board of Directors, MD and CEO and
Non-Executive Chairman have also been appointed under the Scheme. The Bank has
since obtained a Board approval to raise additional equity of up to Rs. 150,000
million. As a consequence of the reconstitution the Bank was deemed to be
unviable. Consequently, write-back of certain Basel III additional Tier-1 Bonds
(AT-1 Bonds) issued by the Bank had been triggered.

 

Hence, such AT-1 Bonds amounting to Rs.
84,150 million have been fully written down permanently. The Trustees, on
behalf of the holders of AT-1 Bonds, have filed a writ petition seeking to
challenge the decision of the Bank to write down AT-1 bonds. The Bank, based on
the legal opinion of its external independent legal counsel, is of the view
that the merits of the Bank’s decision to write back the AT-1 bonds is in
accordance with the contractual terms for issuance of AT-1 Bonds. The Bank had
also been granted a short-term special liquidity facility for 90 days (ending
on 16th June, 2020) from the RBI. The Bank has written to RBI for an
extension of the same for a year. The Bank also raised CDs of Rs. 72,000
million as at 31st March, 2020. As a consequence of the above
factors, the Bank’s loss post-tax and AT-1 write-back (exceptional income) is
Rs. 164,180 million. The Bank’s CET-1 ratio is 6.3% (regulatory requirement
with CCB of 7.375%) and Tier-1 capital ratio is 6.5% (regulatory requirement of
8.875%) as at 31st March, 2020. The Bank has substantially enhanced
its PCR and strengthened its Balance Sheet. However, RBI’s current framework on
‘Prompt Corrective Action’ (PCA) considers regulatory breaches in CET as a
potential trigger. The Bank remains in constant communication with RBI on the
various parameters and ratios and RBI has not imposed any fine on the Bank for
the regulatory breaches.

 

The Bank’s deposit base has seen a reduction
from Rs. 2,276,102 million as at 31st March, 2019 to Rs. 1,053,639
million as at 31st March, 2020 (position as at 2nd May,
2020: Rs. 1,027,179 million). Consequently, the Bank’s quarterly average
‘Liquidity Coverage Ratio’ (LCR) has fallen from 74% for the quarter ended 31st
December, 2019 to 40% for the quarter ended 31st March, 2020
(regulatory limit 100%); position as at 2nd May, 2020 (was) 34.8%
(regulatory limit 80%). The Bank also has a deferred tax asset of Rs. 82,810
million as at 31st March, 2020. Though the Bank has made a loss of
Rs. 164,180 million for the year ended 31st March, 2020, the Bank
has a taxable profit for the year ended 31st March, 2020.

 

In the month of March, 2020, the SARS-CoV-2
virus responsible for Covid-19 continued to spread across the globe and India,
which has contributed to a significant decline and volatility in global and
Indian financial markets and a significant decrease in global and local
economic outlook and activities. On 11th March, 2020, the Covid-19
outbreak was declared a global pandemic by the WHO. On 24th March,
2020, the Indian Government announced a strict 21-day lockdown which was
further extended across the country to contain the spread of the virus. The
extent to which the Covid-19 pandemic will impact the Bank’s future results
will depend on related developments, which remain highly uncertain. While
further reduction in deposits lost post-moratorium may cast material
uncertainty, particularly in the current Covid scenario, the Bank under the
leadership of new management and Reconstituted Board is confident that it can
tide over the current issues successfully.

 

This belief is reinforced by the pedigree of
new investors of the Bank (led by State Bank of India and other Financial
Institutions). Further, the Bank’s management and Board of Directors have made
an assessment of its ability to continue as a going concern based on the
projected financial statements for the next three years and are satisfied that
the proposed capital infusion and the Bank’s strong customer base and branch
network will enable the Bank to continue its business for the foreseeable
future, so as to be able to realise its assets and discharge its liabilities in
its normal course of business. As such, the financial statements continue to be
prepared on a going concern basis.

 

18.4 Use of estimates

The preparation of financial statements
requires the management to make estimates and assumptions that are considered
while reporting amounts of assets and liabilities (including contingent
liabilities) as of the date of the financial statements and income and expenses
during the reporting period. Management believes that the estimates used in the
preparation of the financial statements are prudent and reasonable. Future
results could differ from these estimates. Any revision to accounting estimates
is recognised prospectively in current and future periods.

 

18.6.69 Disclosure on Complaints

The Bank became aware in September, 2018
through communications from stock exchanges of anonymous whistle-blower
complaints alleging irregularities in the Bank’s operations, potential conflict
of interest of the founder and former MD & CEO and allegations of incorrect
NPA classification. The Bank conducted an internal inquiry of these
allegations, which was carried out by management and supervised by the Board of
Directors. The inquiry resulted in a report that was reviewed by the Board in
November, 2018. Based on further inputs and deliberations in December, 2018 the
Audit Committee of the Bank engaged an external firm to independently examine
the matter. In April, 2019 the Bank had received the phase 1 report from the external
firm and based on further review / deliberations had directed a phase 2
investigation from the said firm. Further, during the quarter ended 31st
December, 2019, the Bank received forensic reports on certain borrower groups
commissioned by other consortium bankers, which gave more information regarding
the above-mentioned allegations.

 

The Bank at the direction of its Nomination
and Remuneration Committee (NRC) obtained an independent legal opinion with
respect to these matters. In February, 2020 the Bank has received the final
phase 2 report from the said external firm. Meanwhile, in March, 2020, the
Enforcement Directorate has launched an investigation into some aspects of
transactions of the founder and former MD & CEO and alleged links with certain
borrower groups. The ED is investigating allegations of money-laundering, fraud
and nexus between the founder and former MD & CEO and certain loan
transactions. The Bank is in the process of evaluating all of the above reports
and concluding if any of the findings have a material impact on financial
statements / processes and require further investigation. The Bank has taken
this report to the newly-constituted Audit Committee and Board and will
progress further action on the basis of the guidance and recommendations.

 

During the year ended 31st March,
2020, the Bank had received various whistle-blower complaints against the
Bank’s management, former MD & CEO and certain members of the Board of
Directors prior to being superseded by the RBI. The NRC, on the basis of
investigations conducted by the management has, post its review, concluded that
they have no material impact on financial statements.

 

In January, 2020, the then Chairman of the
Audit Committee of the Bank highlighted certain concerns around corporate
governance and other operational matters at the Bank. The then Board decided to
get this investigated by an independent external firm. A preliminary report has
been received by the Board. While most of the allegations are unsubstantiated,
the Board has requested the external firm for detailed recommendations
highlighting areas where corporate governance can be further strengthened.

 

From
Directors’ Report

Qualification, reservation, adverse
remark or disclaimer given by the Auditors in their Report

The Report given by the Statutory Auditors
on the Financial Statements of the Bank for the financial year ended on 31st
March, 2020 forms part of this Annual Report. The auditors of the Bank have
qualified their report to the extent and as mentioned in the Auditors’ Report.
The qualification in Auditors’ Report and Director’s response to such
qualifications are as under:

 

1. Details of Audit Qualification:

The Bank has breached CET-1 ratio and the
Tier-1 capital ratio as at 31st March, 2020. CET-1 ratio stood at
6.3%.and Tier-1 ratio stood at 6.5 % as compared to the minimum requirements of
7.375% and 8.875%, respectively.

 

Response:

The Bank’s Capital Adequacy Ratio as at 31st
March, 2020 was lower than the minimum regulatory requirement primarily due to
lower than envisaged capital raise in F.Y. 2019-20 and higher NPA provision.
The Bank had decided, on a prudent basis, to enhance its Provision Coverage
Ratio on its NPA loans over and above the RBI loan level provisioning
requirements. With the proposed capital infusion in F.Y. 2020-21, internal
accretion of capital, expected recoveries of NPA and with selective
disbursement of loans to preserve RWA, the Bank expects CET ratio to be
comfortably above the minimum regulatory requirement.

 

2. Details of Audit Qualification:

The Bank became aware in September, 2018
through communication from stock exchanges of an anonymous whistle-blower
complaint alleging irregularities in the Bank’s operations, potential conflicts
of interests in relation to the former MD & CEO and allegations of
incorrect NPA classification. The Bank conducted an internal inquiry of these
allegations, which resulted in a report that was reviewed by the Board of
Directors in November, 2018. Based on further inputs and deliberations in
December, 2018, the Audit Committee of the Bank engaged an external firm to
independently examine the matter. During the year ended 31st March,
2020, the Bank identified certain further matters which arose from other
independent investigations initiated by the lead banker of a lenders’
consortium on the companies allegedly favoured by the former MD & CEO. In
March, 2020, the Enforcement Directorate has launched an investigation into
some  aspects of dealings and
transactions by the former MD & CEO on the basis of draft forensic reports
from external agencies which further pointed out to conflict of interest
between the former MD & CEO and certain companies and arrested him. In view
of the fact that these inquiries and investigations are still on-going, we are
unable to comment on the consequential impact of the above matter on these
Standalone Financial Statements.

 

Response:

The Bank conducted an internal inquiry of
these allegations, which was carried out by management and supervised by the
Board of Directors. The inquiry resulted in a report that was reviewed by the
Board in November, 2018. Based on further inputs and deliberations in December,
2018, the Audit Committee of the Bank engaged an external firm to independently
examine the matter. In April, 2019, the Bank had received the phase 1 report
from the external firm and based on further review / deliberations had directed
a phase 2 investigation from the said firm. Further, during the quarter ended
31st December, 2019, the Bank received forensic reports on certain
borrower groups commissioned by other consortium bankers, which gave more
information regarding the above-mentioned allegations. The Bank at the
direction of its Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC) obtained an
independent legal opinion with respect to these matters. In February, 2020 the
Bank has received the final phase 2 report from the said external firm.
Meanwhile, in March, 2020 the Enforcement Directorate has launched an
investigation into some aspects of transactions of the founder and former MD
& CEO and alleged links with certain borrower groups. The ED is
investigating allegations of money-laundering, fraud and nexus between the
founder and former MD & CEO and certain loan transactions. The Bank is in
the process of evaluating all of the above reports and concluding if any of the
findings have a material impact on financial statements / processes and require
further investigation. The Bank has taken this report to the newly-constituted
Audit Committee and Board and will progress further action on the basis of the
guidance and recommendations.

 

During the year ended 31st March,
2020, the Bank had received various whistle-blower complaints against the
Bank’s management, former MD & CEO and certain members of the Board of
Directors prior to being superseded by RBI. The NRC, on the basis of
investigations conducted by the management has, post its review, concluded that
they have no material impact on financial statements.

 

In January, 2020 the then Chairman of the
Audit Committee of the Bank highlighted certain concerns around corporate governance and other operational matters at the Bank. The then
Board decided to get this investigated by an independent external firm. A
preliminary report has been received by the Board. While most of the
allegations are unsubstantiated, the Board has requested the external firm for
detailed recommendations highlighting areas where corporate governance can be
further strengthened.

 

Also, no offence of fraud was reported by
the Auditors of the Bank.

GLIMPSES OF SUPREME COURT RULINGS

1. Director of Income Tax-II
(International Taxation), New Delhi and Ors. vs. Samsung Heavy Industries Co.
Ltd.
Civil Appeal No.
12183 of 2016 Date of order: 22nd July, 2020

 

DTAA between India and Republic of Korea – Permanent Establishment –
Taxability of income attributable to a ‘permanent establishment’ set up in a
fixed place in India – Profits earned by the Korean GE on supplies of
fabricated platforms could not be made attributable to its Indian PE as the
installation PE came into existence only after the transaction stood
materialised – No taxability could arise in a case where the sales are directly
billed to the Indian customer and the price at which billing is done for the
supplies does not include any element for services rendered by the PE – When it
comes to ‘fixed place’ permanent establishments under double taxation avoidance
treaties, the condition precedent for applicability of Article 5(1) of the double
taxation treaty and the ascertainment of a ‘permanent establishment’ is that it
should be an establishment ‘through which the business of an enterprise’ is
wholly or partly carried on – The maintenance of a fixed place of business
which is of a preparatory or auxiliary character in the trade or business of
the enterprise would not be considered to be a permanent establishment under
Article 5 – It is only so much of the profits of the enterprise that may be
taxed in the other state as is attributable to that permanent establishment –
The onus is on the Department to first show that the project office in India is
a permanent establishment

 

The Oil and Natural
Gas Corporation (ONGC) on 28th February, 2006 awarded a ‘turnkey’
contract to a consortium comprising of the respondent / assessee, Samsung Heavy Industries
Co. Ltd. (a company incorporated in South Korea), and Larsen & Toubro
Limited, being a contract for carrying out the ‘work’ inter alia, of
surveys, design, engineering, procurement, fabrication, installation and
modification at existing facilities and start-up and commissioning of entire
facilities covered under the ‘Vasai East Development Project’ (Project).

 

On 24th
May, 2006 the assessee set up a Project Office in Mumbai which, as per the
assessee, was to act as ‘a communication channel’ between the assessee and ONGC
in respect of the project. Pre-engineering, survey, engineering, procurement
and fabrication activities which took place abroad, all took place in the year
2006. Commencing from November, 2007, these platforms were then brought outside
Mumbai to be installed at the Vasai East Development Project. The project was
to be completed by 26th July, 2009.

 

With regard to A.Y.
2007-2008 the assessee filed a return of income on 21st August, 2007
showing Nil profit, as a loss of Rs. 23.5 lakhs had allegedly been incurred in
relation to the activities carried out by it in India.

 

On 29th
August, 2008, a show cause notice was issued to the assessee by the Income-tax
Authorities requiring it to show cause as to why the return of income had been
filed only at Nil; the assessee replied to it in detail on 2nd
February, 2009.

 

But dissatisfied
with the reply, a draft assessment order was passed on 31st
December, 2009 (Draft Order) by the Assistant Director of Income
Tax-International Transactions at Dehradun (Assessing Officer). This draft
order went into the terms of the agreement in great detail and concluded that
the project in question was a single indivisible ‘turnkey’ project, whereby ONGC
was to take over a project that was to be completed only in India. As a result,
profits arising from the successful commissioning of the project would also
arise only in India. Having so held, the draft order then went on to attribute
25% of the revenues allegedly earned outside India (which totalled Rs.
113,43,78,960) as being the income of the assessee exigible to tax, which came
to Rs. 28,35,94,740.

 

The Dispute
Resolution Panel, by its order dated 30th September, 2010, after
considering objections to the draft order by the assessee, confirmed the
finding contained in the said order that the agreement was a ‘turnkey’ project
which could not be split up, as a result of which the entire profit earned from
the project would be earned within India. Basing itself on data obtained from
the database ‘Capital Line’, the Panel picked up four similar projects executed
by companies outside India and found the average profit margin to be 24.7%,
which, according to the Panel, would therefore justify the figure of 25%
arrived at in the draft order. The Panel having dismissed the assessee’s
objections, the draft order was made final by the A.O. on 25th
October, 2010.

 

The assessee then
filed an appeal against the assessment order before the Income Tax Appellate
Tribunal (ITAT).

 

The ITAT confirmed
the decisions of the A.O. and the DRP that the contract was indivisible. It
then went on to deal with the argument on behalf of the assessee that the
Project Office was only an auxiliary office and did not involve itself in any
core activity of business, as the accounts that were produced would show that
there was no expenditure which related to execution of the project. The ITAT
held that the arguments put forward in this respect were only by inference such
as the accounts were maintained by the assessee in India but the maintenance of
accounts was in the hands of the assessee and the mere mode of maintaining the
accounts alone could not determine the character of the PE as the role of the
PE would only be relevant to determine what kind of activities it had to carry
on. Having held thus, the ITAT found that there was a lack of material to
ascertain as to the extent to which the activities of the business were carried
on by the assessee through the Mumbai project office; and therefore it was
considered just and proper to set aside the attribution of 25% of gross revenue
earned outside India – which was attributed as income earned from the Mumbai
project office – the matter being sent back to the A.O. to ascertain profits
attributable to the Mumbai project office after examining the necessary facts.

 

An appeal from the
ITAT was filed in the High Court in Uttarakhand by the assessee. While
admitting the appeal, the High Court framed five substantial questions of law
as follows:

 

(i)   Whether, on the facts and in the
circumstances of the case, the Tribunal erred in law in holding that the
appellant had a fixed place ‘Permanent Establishment’ (PE) in India under
Article 5(1)/(2) of the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement between India and
Korea (the Treaty), in the form of a project office in Mumbai?

 

(ii) Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the
case and in law, the finding of the Tribunal that the project office was opened
for coordination and execution of the VED project and all activities to be
carried out in relation to the said project were routed through the project
office only, is perverse inasmuch as the same is based on selective and / or
incomplete reference to the material on record, irrelevant considerations and
incorrect appreciation of the role of the project office?

 

(iii) Without prejudice, whether, on the facts and
the circumstances of the case and in law, the Tribunal erred in not holding that even if the appellant had a fixed place PE in India, no
income on account of offshore activities, i.e., the operations carried out
outside India (viz., designing, engineering, material procurement, fabrication,
transportation activities) was attributable to the said PE, instead, in setting
the issue to the file of the A.O.?

 

(iv) Without prejudice, whether, on the facts and
circumstances of the case and in law, the Tribunal erred in not holding that
even if the appellant had fixed place PE in India, no income could be brought
to tax in India since the appellant had incurred overall losses in respect of
the VED project?

 

(v)  Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the
case, the contract was divisible / distinguishable pertaining to the activities
associated with designing, fabrication and installation of platforms and, if so,
whether the activities pertaining to designing and fabrication took place in
any part of India?

 

By the impugned
judgment dated 27th December, 2013, the High Court found that the
order of the A.O. had been confirmed by the ITAT and concerned itself only with
the following question:

 

‘Can it be said
that the agreement permitted the India Taxing Authority to arbitrarily fix a
part of the revenue to the permanent establishment of the appellant in India?’

 

The High Court held
that the question as to whether the project office opened in Mumbai cannot be
said to be a ‘permanent establishment’ within the meaning of Article 5 of the
DTAA would be of no consequence. The High Court then held that there was no finding
that 25% of the gross revenue of the assessee outside India was attributable to
the business carried out by the project office of the assessee. According to
the Court, neither the A.O. nor the ITAT made any effort to bring on record any
evidence to justify this figure. That being the position, the appeal of the
assessee was allowed.

 

According to the
Supreme Court, the question as to the taxability of income attributable to a
‘permanent establishment’ set up in a fixed place in India, arising from the ‘Agreement
for avoidance of double taxation of income and the prevention of fiscal
evasion’ with the Republic of Korea (DTAA) had been raised by the Department in
the present appeal.

 

The Supreme Court
noted the relevant provisions of the DTAA and some of its own judgments which
had dealt with similar double taxation avoidance treaty provisions, namely, (i)
DIT vs. Morgan Stanley & Co. Inc. (2006) 284 ITR 260 (SC),
and
(ii) CIT vs. Hyundai Heavy Industries Co. Ltd. (2007) 291 ITR 482 (SC).

 

Applying the tests
laid down in the aforesaid judgments to the facts of the present case, the
Supreme Court held that profits earned by the Korean GE on supplies of
fabricated platforms could not be made attributable to its Indian PE as the
installation PE came into existence only after the transaction stood
materialised. It emerged only after the fabricated platform was delivered in
Korea to the agents of ONGC. Therefore, the profits on such supplies of
fabricated platforms could not be said to be attributable to the PE.

 

According to the
Supreme Court there was one more reason for coming to the aforesaid conclusion.
In terms of Paragraph (1) of Article 7, the profits to be taxed in the source
country were not the real profits but hypothetical profits which the PE would have
earned if it was wholly independent of the GE. Therefore, even if it was
assumed that the supplies were necessary for the purposes of installation
(activity of the PE in India) and even if it was assumed that the supplies were
an integral part, still no part of the profits on such supplies could be
attributed to the independent PE unless it was established by the Department
that the supplies were not at arm’s length price. No such taxability could
arise in the present case as the sales were directly billed to the Indian
customer (ONGC) and also as there was no allegation made by the Department that
the price at which billing was done for the supplies included any element for
services rendered by the PE.

 

The Supreme Court
therefore concluded that the profits that accrued to the Korean GE for the
Korean operations were not taxable in India.

 

The Court referred
to its decisions in Ishikawajma-Harima Heavy Industries Ltd. vs. Director
of Income Tax, Mumbai (2007) 3 SCC 481,
and E-Funds IT Solution
Inc. (2017) 399 ITR 34 (SC),
where a similar double taxation treaty
agreement entered into between Japan and India and India and the USA were
considered. The Court observed that a reading of the aforesaid judgments made
it clear that when it comes to ‘fixed place’ permanent establishments under
double taxation avoidance treaties, the condition precedent for applicability
of Article 5(1) of the double taxation treaty and the ascertainment of a
‘permanent establishment’ is that it should be an establishment ‘through which
the business of an enterprise’ is wholly or partly carried on. Further, the
profits of the foreign enterprise are taxable only where the said enterprise
carries on its core business through a permanent establishment. Besides, the
maintenance of a fixed place of business which is of a preparatory or auxiliary
character in the trade or business of the enterprise would not be considered to
be a permanent establishment under Article 5. Further, it is only so much of
the profits of the enterprise that may be taxed in the other State as is
attributable to that permanent establishment.

 

The Supreme Court
referred to the application submitted by the assessee to the RBI dated 24th
April, 2006, the Board Resolution dated 3rd April, 2006 and the RBI
approval dated 24th May, 2006 and observed that a reading of the
Board Resolution would show that the project office was established to
coordinate and execute ‘delivery documents in connection with construction of
offshore platform modification of existing facilities for ONGC’. Unfortunately,
the ITAT relied upon only the first paragraph of the Board Resolution and then
jumped to the conclusion that the Mumbai office was for coordination and
execution of the project itself. The finding, therefore, that the Mumbai office
was not a mere liaison office but was involved in the core activity of
execution of the project itself was therefore clearly perverse. Equally, when
it was pointed out that the accounts of the Mumbai office showed that no
expenditure relating to the execution of the contract was incurred, the ITAT
rejected the argument stating that as the accounts are in the hands of the
assessee and the mere mode of maintaining accounts alone cannot determine the
character of permanent establishment. This was another perverse finding which
is set aside.

 

Equally, the
finding that the onus is on the assessee and not on the Tax Authorities to
first show that the project office at Mumbai is a permanent establishment was
also incorrect. The Supreme Court further observed that though it was pointed
out to the ITAT that there were only two persons working in the Mumbai office,
neither of whom was qualified to perform any core activity of the assessee, the
ITAT chose to ignore the same. That being the case, it was clear that no
permanent establishment had been set up within the meaning of Article 5(1) of
the DTAA as the Mumbai project office could not be said to be a fixed place of
business through which the core business of the assessee was wholly or partly
carried on. The Mumbai project office, on the facts of the present case, would
fall within Article 5(4)(e) of the DTAA, inasmuch as the office was solely an
auxiliary office meant to act as a liaison office between the assessee and
ONGC.

 

The appeal against
the impugned High Court judgment was therefore dismissed by the Supreme Court.

 

2. Shiv Raj Gupta vs. Commissioner of Income Tax,
Delhi-IV
Civil Appeal No.
12044 of 2016 Date of order: 22nd
July, 2020

 

Appeal u/s 260-A – Substantial questions of
law – It is only the substantial question of law that is framed that can be
answered and no other – If some other question is to be answered, the Court
must first give notice of the same to both sides, hear them, pronounce a reasoned
order and thereafter frame another substantial question of law, which it may
then answer

 

Reasonableness of the amount paid –
Commercial expediency has to be adjudged from the point of view of the assessee
and that the Income-tax Department cannot enter into the thicket of
reasonableness of amounts paid by the assessee

 

Non-compete fees – Payment under an
agreement not to compete (negative covenant agreement) was a capital receipt
not exigible to tax till A.Y. 2003-2004 – It was only vide the Finance
Act, 2002 with effect from 1st April, 2003 that the said capital
receipt was now made taxable [see section 28(v-a)]

 

A Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) dated 13th April, 1994 was made between the
appellant Mr. Shiv Raj Gupta, who was the Chairman and Managing Director of M/s
Central Distillery and Breweries Ltd. (CDBL), which had a unit in Meerut
manufacturing beer and Indian-Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) and three group
companies of M/s Shaw Wallace Company Group (SWC group). The appellant, his
wife, son, daughter-in-law and two daughters were the registered holders of
1,86,109 equity shares of Rs. 10 each constituting 57.29% of the paid-up equity
share capital of CDBL listed on the Bombay and Delhi Stock Exchanges.

 

The MoU referred to
a direction of the Supreme Court which was made by an order dated 11th
March, 1994 that made it clear that the company’s manufacturing activity at the
Meerut plant was suspended until a secondary effluent treatment plant is
installed and made operative by the company. This led to the sale of this
controlling block of shares, which was sold at the price of Rs. 30 per share
(when the listed market price of the share was only Rs. 3 per share). It was
stated in the said MoU that the entire sale consideration of Rs. 55,83,270 had
since been paid by the SWC group to Mr. Gupta as a result of which he has
irrevocably handed over physical possession, management and control of the said
brewery and distillery of CDBL to a representative of the SWC group on 10th
February, 1994.

 

By a Deed of
Covenant dated 13th April, 1994, Mr. Gupta gave a restrictive
covenant to and in favour of the SWC group for not carrying on directly or
indirectly any manufacturing or marketing activities whatsoever relating to
IMFL or beer for a period of ten years from the date of the agreement for the
consideration of a non-competition fee to be paid to him by SWC.

 

But the A.O. held,
by an order dated 31st March, 1998, that despite the fact that the
appellant owned a concern, namely, M/s Maltings Ltd., which also manufactured
IMFL, being a loss-making concern, no real competition could be envisaged
between a giant, namely, the SWC group and this loss-making dwarf, as a result of
which the huge amount paid under the Deed of Covenant could not be said to be
an amount paid in respect of a restrictive covenant as to non-competition. It
was further held that the son of the appellant was not paid any such
non-compete fee or amount despite the fact that he also resigned from his
position as Joint Managing Director. It was also held that this was a lump sum
payment with no reason as to why such a huge amount of Rs. 6.6 crores was being
paid. It was also found that there was no penalty clause to enforce the
performance of obligations under the aforesaid Deed of Covenant, as a result of
which, applying the judgment in McDowell & Co. Ltd. vs. CTO (1985) 3
SCC 230,
the Deed of Covenant was held to be a colourable device to
evade tax payable u/s 28(ii)(a) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. As a result
thereof, this amount was then brought to tax under the aforesaid provision.

 

An appeal to the
Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) was dismissed. When it came before the
Appellate Tribunal, the Learned Accountant Member (A.M.) differed with the
learned Judicial Member (J.M.). The A.M. held that the two deeds would have to
be read separately and that Revenue cannot challenge the business perception of
the assessee. Further, it was held that there was no colourable device involved
and that, as a result, the non-compete fee payable under the Deed of Covenant
was not taxable u/s 28(ii)(a) or any other provision of the Act. The J.M., on
the other hand, substantially agreed with the A.O., as a result of which he
decided in favour of the Revenue.

 

A reference was
then made to a third member, who was also a Judicial Member. This Member
emphasised the fact that a share worth Rs. 3 was sold for Rs. 30 under the MoU
as a result of transfer of control of the CDBL. It cannot be said that these
shares have been undervalued, neither can it be said that there was any
collusion or other sham transaction, as a result of which the amount of Rs. 6.6
crores has escaped income tax. He pointed out that by a letter dated 2nd
April, 1994, a ‘penalty clause’ was provided for, in that, out of the amount
received by the assessee, a sum of Rs. 3 crores was to be deposited with the
SWC group for two years under a public deposit scheme, it being made clear that
in case there is any breach of the terms of the MoU resulting in loss, the
amount of such loss will be deducted from this deposit. The result, therefore,
was that the appeal stood allowed by a majority of 2:1 in the Appellate
Tribunal.

 

The Revenue
preferred an appeal u/s 260-A to the High Court. In its grounds of appeal, the
Revenue framed the substantial questions of law that arose in the matter as
follows:

A)  Whether the ITAT has correctly interpreted the
provisions of section 28(ii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961?

B)  Whether the ITAT was correct in holding that
the receipt of Rs. 6.6 crores by the respondent / assessee as non-compete fee
was a capital receipt u/s 28(iv) of the Act and not a revenue receipt as
envisaged in section 28(ii)?

C)  Whether the ITAT failed to distinguish between
the nature of capital and the nature of benefit in the commercial sense in
respect of the amount of Rs. 6.6 crores received in view of the restrictive
Deed of Covenant dated 13th April, 1994?

D)  Whether the Judicial Member of the ITAT was
correct in recording his difference of opinion that the receipt of Rs. 6.6
crores by the respondent / assessee was actually a colourable exercise to evade
tax and the same was held to be taxable u/s 28(ii)?

 

By the impugned
judgment of the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court dated 22nd
December, 2014, the Division Bench framed the following substantial question of
law:

 

‘Whether, on the
facts and in the circumstances of the case, the amount of Rs. 6.6 crores
received by the assessee from SWC is on account of handing over management and
control of CDBL (which were earlier under the management and control of the
assessee) to SWC as terminal benefit and is taxable u/s 28(ii) or the same is
exempt as capital receipt being non-competition fee by executing Deed of
Covenant?’

 

After going through
the MoU and the Deed of Covenant, both dated 13th April, 1994, and
extensively referring to the order of the A.O. dated 31st March,
1998, the High Court agreed with the A.O. and the first J.M. of the Appellate
Tribunal, stating that the Deed of Covenant could not be read as a separate
document and was not in its real avatar a non-compete fee at all. However, in
its ultimate conclusion, disagreeing with the A.O. and the minority judgment of
the Tribunal, the High Court went on to state that the said sum of Rs. 6.6
crores could not be brought to tax u/s 28(ii)(a), but would have to be treated
as a taxable capital gain in the hands of the appellant, being part of the full
value of the sale consideration paid for transfer of shares.

 

On an appeal by the
appellant, the Supreme Court observed that the bone of contention was whether
the said Deed of Covenant could be said to contain a restrictive covenant as a
result of which payment was made to the appellant, or whether it was in fact
part of a sham transaction which, in the guise of being a separate Deed of
Covenant, was really in the nature of payment received by the appellant as
compensation for terminating his management of CDBL, in which case it would be
taxable u/s 28(ii)(a) of the Act.

 

The learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellant inter alia raised as a preliminary
submission the fact that u/s 260-A it is only the substantial question of law
that is framed that can be answered and no other. If some other question is to
be answered, the Court must first give notice of the same to both sides, hear
them, pronounce a reasoned order and thereafter frame another substantial
question of law, which it may then answer. This procedure had not been followed
in the present case as it was clear that the substantial question of law framed
did not contain within it the question as to whether the assessee could be
taxed outside the provisions of section 28(ii)(a). The entire judgment was,
therefore, vitiated and must be set aside on this ground alone.

 

After hearing both
the sides, the Supreme Court was of the view that the appeal had to succeed
first on the preliminary ground raised by the counsel for the appellant.

 

The Supreme Court
after noting the provisions of Section 260A observed that the said provision,
being modelled on a similar provision that is contained in section 100 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, makes it clear that the High Court’s jurisdiction
depends upon a substantial question of law being involved in the appeal before
it. First and foremost, it shall formulate that question and on the question so
formulated, the High Court may then pronounce judgment, either by answering the
question in the affirmative or negative or by stating that the case at hand
does not involve any such question. If the High Court wishes to hear the appeal
on any other substantial question of law not formulated by it, it may, for
reasons to be recorded, formulate and hear such questions if it is satisfied
that the case involves such question [Section 260-A(4)]. Under sub-section (6),
the High Court may also determine any issue which, though raised, has not been
determined by the Appellate Tribunal or has been wrongly determined by the
Appellate Tribunal by reason of a decision on a substantial question of law
raised.

 

The Court referred
to its judgments in Kshitish Chandra Purkait vs. Santosh Kumar Purkait
(1997) 5 SCC 438, Dnyanoba Bhaurao Shemade vs. Maroti Bhaurao Marnor (1999) 2
SCC 471
(see paragraph 10) and Biswanath Ghosh vs. Gobinda Ghosh
(2014) 11 SCC 605
(paragraph 16) in the context of the provisions of
section 100 of the Code and, noting its provisions, observed that the
substantial question of law that was raised by the High Court did not contain
any question as to whether the non-compete fee could be taxed under any
provision other than section 28(ii)(a). Without giving an opportunity to the
parties followed by reasons for framing any other substantial question of law
as to the taxability of such amount as a capital receipt in the hands of the
assessee, the High Court answered the substantial question of law treating Rs.
6.60 crores as consideration paid for sale of shares, rather than a payment u/s
28(ii)(a) of the Act.

    

According to the
Supreme Court, without any recorded reasons and without framing any substantial
question of law on whether the said amount could be taxed under any other
provision of the Act, the High Court had gone ahead and held that the amount of
Rs. 6.6 crores received by the assessee was part of the full value of sale
consideration paid for the transfer of shares – and not for handing over
management and control of CDBL, and was consequently not taxable u/s 28(ii)(a).
Nor was it exempt as a capital receipt being non-compete fee, as it was taxable
as a capital gain in the hands of the respondent-assessee as part of the full
value of sale consideration paid for transfer of shares. The Court held that
this finding was contrary to the provisions of section 260-A(4), requiring the
judgment to be set aside on this score.

 

The Supreme Court
thereafter also dealt with the merits of the findings given by the High Court.
In paragraph 22, the High Court had found as under:

 

‘22. …No doubt,
market price of each share was only Rs. 3 per share and the purchase price
under the MOU was Rs. 30, but the total consideration received was merely about
Rs. 56 lakhs. What was allegedly paid as non-compete fee was ten times more,
i.e., Rs. 6.60 crores. The figure per se does not appear to be a
realistic payment made on account of non-compete fee, de hors and
without reference to sale of shares, loss of management and control of CDBL.
The assessee had attributed an astronomical sum as payment toward non-compete
fee, unconnected with the sale of shares and hence not taxable. Noticeably, the
price received for sale of shares it is accepted was taxable as capital gain.
The contention that quoted price of each share was mere Rs. 3 only, viz., price
as declared of Rs. 30 is fallacious and off-beam. The argument of the assessee
suffers from a basic and fundamental flaw which is conspicuous and evident.’

 

The Supreme Court
held that the aforesaid finding was contrary to the settled law. A catena of
judgments has held that commercial expediency has to be adjudged from the point
of view of the assessee and that the Income-tax Department cannot enter into the
thicket of reasonableness of amounts paid by the assessee. The Court referred
to its judgments in CIT vs. Walchand & Co. (1967) 3 SCR 214, J.K.
Woollen Manufacturers vs. CIT (1969) 1 SCR 525, CIT vs. Panipat Woollen &
General Mills Co. Ltd. (1976) 2 SCC 5, Shahzada Nand & Sons vs. CIT (1977)
3 SCC 432,
and S.A. Builders Ltd. vs. CIT (2007) 1 SCC 781.

 

It affirmed the
view taken by the Delhi High Court in CIT vs. Dalmia Cement (B) Ltd.
(2002) 254 ITR 377 (Del)]
that once it is established that there was
nexus between the expenditure and the purpose of the business (which need not
necessarily be the business of the assessee itself), the Revenue cannot
justifiably claim to put itself in the armchair of the businessman or in the
position of the Board of Directors and assume the role of deciding how much is
reasonable expenditure having regard to the circumstances of the case. No
businessman can be compelled to maximise his profit. The Income Tax Authorities
must put themselves in the shoes of the assessee and see how a prudent
businessman would act. They must not look at the matter from their own
viewpoint but that of a prudent businessman. As already stated above, we have
to see the transfer of the borrowed funds to a sister concern from the point of
view of commercial expediency and not from the point of view whether the amount
was advanced for earning profits.

    

The Court noted
that the same principle had also been cited with approval by its judgment in Hero
Cycles (P) Ltd. vs. CIT (2015) 16 SCC 359.

 

According to the
Supreme Court, the High Court’s next finding in paragraph 56 was based on the
judgment in Vodafone International Holdings B.V. vs. Union of India (UOI)
and Ors.,
which was as follows:

 

‘56. In view of the
aforesaid discussion and our findings on the true and real nature of the
transaction camouflaged as “non-compete fee”, we have no hesitation and
reservation that the respondent-assessee had indulged in abusive tax
avoidance.’

 

To this, the
Supreme Court reiterated that the majority judgment of the Appellate Tribunal
had correctly found that:

 

(i)  A share of the face value of Rs. 10 and market
value of Rs. 3 was sold for Rs. 30 as a result of control premium having to be
paid.

 

(ii) It is important to note that each member of the
family was paid for his / her shares in the company, the lion’s share being
paid to the assessee’s son and wife as they held the most number of shares
within the said family.

 

(iii) The non-compete fee of Rs. 6.6 crores was paid
only to the assessee. This was for the reason stated in the Deed of Covenant,
namely, that Mr. Shiv Raj Gupta had acquired considerable knowledge, skill,
expertise and specialisation in the liquor business. There is no doubt that on
facts he has been Chairman and Managing Director of CDBL for a period of about
35 years; that he also owned a concern, namely, M/s Maltings Ltd., which
manufactured and sold IMFL and beer and that he was the President of the
All-India Distilleries Association and the H.P. Distilleries Association.

 

(iv) It is further recorded in the judgment of the
A.M. that the amount of Rs. 6.6 crores was arrived at as a result of
negotiations between the SWC group and the appellant.

 

(v) That the restrictive covenant for a period of
ten years resulted in the payment of Rs. 66 lakhs per year so that the
appellant ‘…will not start or engage himself, directly or indirectly, or
provide any service, assistance or support of any nature, whatsoever, to or in
relation to the manufacturing, dealing and supplying or marketing of IMFL and /
or beer.’ Given the personal expertise of the assessee, the perception of the
SWC group was that he could either start a rival business or engage himself in
a rival business, which would include manufacturing and marketing of IMFL and
beer at which he was an old hand, having experience of 35 years.

 

(vi) As was correctly held by the
second J.M., it was also clear that the withholding of Rs. 3 crores out of Rs.
6.6 crores for a period of two years by way of a public deposit with the SWC
group for the purpose of deduction of any loss on account of any breach of the
MoU, was akin to a penalty clause, making it clear thereby that there was no
colourable device involved in having two separate agreements for two entirely
separate and distinct purposes.

 

According to the Supreme
Court, the reasons given by the A.O. and the minority judgment of the Appellate
Tribunal were all reasons which transgressed the lines drawn by the judgments
cited, which state that the Revenue has no business to second-guess commercial
or business expediency of what parties at arm’s length decide for each other.
For example, stating that there was no rationale behind the payment of Rs. 6.6
crores and that the assessee was not a probable or perceptible threat or
competitor to the SWC group, was the perception of the A.O., which could not
take the place of business reality from the point of view of the assessee. The
fact that M/s Maltings Ltd. had incurred a loss in the previous year was again
neither here nor there. It may in future be a direct threat to the SWC group
and may turn around and make profits in future years.

 

Besides, M/s
Maltings Ltd. was only one concern of the assessee – it was the assessee’s
expertise in this field on all counts that was the threat perception of the SWC
group which cannot be second-guessed by the Revenue. Equally, the fact that
there was no penalty clause for violation of the Deed of Covenant had been
found to be incorrect given the letter dated 2nd April, 1994. The
fact that the respondent-assessee in his letter dated 26th March,
1998 in reply to the show cause notice had stated that the SWC group had gained
substantial commercial advantage by the purchase of shares in CDBL as the
turnover increased from Rs. 9.79 crores in the accounting period ending 31st
March, 1991 to Rs. 45.17 crores in the accounting period ending 31st March,
1997, was again neither here nor there. As a matter of fact, the SWC group, due
to its own advertisement and marketing efforts, may well have reached this
figure after a period of six years (the date 30th September, 1995
was wrongly recorded by the High Court in paragraph 19 – the correct date as per the letter dated 26th
March, 1998 was 31st March, 1991).

    

Lastly, the Supreme
Court referred to its judgment in Guffic Chem (P) Ltd. vs. CIT (2011) 4
SCC 254
wherein it was held that a payment under an agreement not to
compete (negative covenant agreement) was a capital receipt not exigible to tax
till A.Y. 2003-2004. It was only vide the Finance Act, 2002 with effect from 1st
April, 2003 that the said capital receipt was made taxable [see section
28(v-a)]. The Finance Act, 2002 itself indicated that during the relevant
assessment year compensation received by the assessee under non-competition
agreement was a capital receipt, not taxable under the 1961 Act. It became
taxable only with effect from 1st April, 2003.

 

The Supreme Court,
following its aforesaid decision, therefore allowed the appeal and set aside
the impugned judgment of the High Court.

FROM THE PRESIDENT

My Dear Members,

As I
sit to write this, the India Meteorological Department (IMD) has announced that
the city recorded 3,680 mm of rain, the second-highest total since 1958 (3,760
mm)! The downpour in the penultimate week of September was the heaviest spell
this season, causing severe disruption of life.

 

This
coincided with a ‘stormy’ monsoon session of Parliament which also set a new
mark of productivity. In one of the shortest sessions in history due to
Covid-19, Parliament approved 25 bills in ten days, although it was ‘stormy’
because of protests by opposition parties. Parliament clocked 167% productivity
in the session – the highest in its history! Among the key bills passed were
the Labour Code Bills, the Foreign Contribution (Regulation)
Amendment Bill, 2020 (FCRA)
, and The Banking Regulation (Amendment)
Bill.

 

The
three Labour Code Bills are crucial second-generation reforms to improve the
ease of doing business and make the Indian labour market competitive to realise
the ‘Make in India’ dream. The Bills are designed to protect the interests of
the workers and ensure compliance. Its success will need to be assessed in the
context of the Indian economy’s recovery from the impact of the current
pandemic.

 

As
for the FCRA Bill, 2020, NGOs are a vital and important element of civil
society. Many of them implement and monitor the Government’s welfare policies,
operating at the grassroots level where the official apparatus is often
non-existent. No doubt the NGOs need to be transparent about their finances,
sources of funding, etc. The provisions such as details of spends on
administration, restricting inter-NGO money transfers and funding to be routed
through a specified bank branch suggest too much micro-managing and would affect
the social objective which is the biggest requirement of the hour.

 

Coming
to co-operative banks, so far they have been under the dual control of
co-operative societies as well as the RBI. Now, to protect the interests of
depositors, the Lok Sabha passed an amendment to the Banking Regulation Act to
bring co-operative banks under the supervision of the RBI. The Bill seeks to
strengthen co-operative banks by increasing their professionalism, enabling
access to capital, improving governance and ensuring sound banking. The RBI
will also be able undertake a scheme of amalgamation or reconstruction of a
co-operative bank without placing it under moratorium. This would go a long way
in bringing much needed stability of the co-operatives under single window monitoring.

 

The BCAS
has made various representations individually and also jointly with other
sister organisations to address difficulties faced in compliances and for
extension of due dates. The same are reported elsewhere in this Journal.
Normally, we favour adhering to the original time lines of the compliances and
generally abstain from representations for extension of due dates. But the
current situation is an extraordinary one and the BCAS realised the
difficulties faced by small and medium-sized practitioners in adapting to the
requirements. We expect a favourable response from the Government. However, may
I appeal to the members to complete the compliances to the extent possible,
without waiting for any extensions.

 

In
September, our Taxation Committee released its first publication on ‘Income
Tax Settlement Commission – A Practical Guide’.
It is an excellent law and
practice guide on a specialised subject with FAQs. Similarly, the Corporate and
Commercial Laws Committee released its twin handbook publications on ‘All
about Startups and all about MSMEs’
together with their E-versions. The
publications will be of tremendous use for professionals and also for the
business units in that category for practical aspects with FAQs. I am thankful
to all the authors and contributors. Both the publications are available for
sale with the BCAS.

 

October
is the month of Navaratri. I wish all of you a Happy Navaratri and good wishes
for Dussehra.

Best Regards,

 

 

Suhas
Paranjpe

President

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

Referring to the Editorial in the BCAJ Journal of September, 2021, reader Chinmaya has sent the following mail:

Great article, Raman (WHY INDIA SHOULDN’T JUST AIM TO BE A $5 T ECONOMY) about why Indians succeed more outside of India… agree on everything you have outlined. ‘Hatred for business’ is something we really need to talk about and celebrate ‘good businesses’ as role models, including assessing their impact on the people and on society. Is it possible to do a good job, earn a fair wage and advance and can it be that simple…? Yes, it can.

How many managers and members of the C-suite are really good ‘leaders’? I do feel leadership training and leading with a human element allows for a good environment for all hardworking and talented individuals to succeed, especially Indians, who benefit from great mentorship and fair opportunity in addition to professional qualifications and hard work, the latter two of which we do have in India, too, but the first two are not always there!

I will be very proud when we can bridge this ‘small’ gap… Then we will soar!!!

– Chinmaya Thakore, Canada

SOCIETY NEWS

BOOK REVIEW

HARSH REALITIES – THE MAKING OF MARICO

Authors: Harsh Mariwala and Ram Charan

Reviewed by Raman Jokhakar, Chartered Accountant

The unique cover of the book strikes you when you first hold it in your hands. It’s a transparent plastic jacket where part of the title is printed on the plastic jacket and part on the hardbound cover. ‘Transparency. Always. The very basis of my life. My work’ writes Mr. Mariwala on the second cover. And that is what the book is really about. The wordplay of the title – mixing maker with Marico – makes the book more enticing for the reader.

I was delighted to one day receive an email from Mr. Harsh Mariwala (HM) mentioning about the release of his book and requesting my address to send it. He had graced the BCAS Annual Day celebrations as the Guest Speaker on 6th July, 2016 when my term as the President of the Society was coming to a close. In his email he described (t)his book as: ‘It encapsulates my journey, the challenges I faced, the risks I took and learnings from not only my successes but, more importantly, my failures. It is meant for entrepreneurs, business leaders, professionals & students who will relate to the Marico story, and the learnings therein.’ I was delighted to request him to sign and send the book, to make it a collectable although I would have loved to buy it and have the author sign it in person if it were not for the Covid times.

The book is divided into 21 chapters and has more than 200 pages. It tells the tale of ‘what determines success’, ‘scaling up’, ‘about failing’, ‘creating right to win on a perpetual basis’ and not only building a business but ‘impetus to give back to the society. To make a difference.’ In other words, almost everything one would dream of going through in one’s lifetime.

The book is co-authored by his coach Ram Charan, who summarises, analyses, unpacks, distils the wisdom at the end of the chapters.

Like most businesses around the world, Marico had roots in a large joint family business that was cohesive and bonded. Although HM was amongst the eight boys of his generation and eldest grandson of the senior-most Mariwala, he and other cousins felt difficulties in realising their business aspirations within the model created by the previous generations. They sat down and decided to carve out the family business of Bombay Oil Mills into subsidiaries where they could find space for their vision and aspirations. A great process to amicably split yet stay tied, and chart one’s own course…

We all know that some Marico brands are household names in India for a few generations now. Those who grew up in the 1990s know of the strong buzz Marico advertisements created, through shock, attention-gripping commercials.

Although I cannot write about everything nor summarise all chapters, I have tried to share the juice from important themes and key learnings. An important chapter that grabbed my attention was about hunting for talent. How to be a gravitational power that would attract the best, make the organisation that would survive him. HM shares how a Chief HR Officer was his first acquisition target. The chapter chronicles hiring people who knew much more than he did. He notes that this strategy paid off when Marico’s turnover grew from Rs. 80 crores to Rs. 648 crores in ten years from 1990 to 2000, giving a CAGR of 24%.

The chapter on Shared Vision and Unique Culture covers setting the tone across the organisation. HM was particularly influenced by reading stories of successful companies and biographies of well-regarded business leaders. The lessons from those stories he MARinated with his own thoughts and crafted the core beliefs of the company which eventually took shape as 3Ps – People, Products and Profits. It is fascinating that ideas of Dharma from Bharatiya ethos moved through these ideas. I remember having visited HM’s office and seeing Sanskrit verses etched on the walls of the passageway leading to his office. The author shares in detail the principles and practices of Marico and how it went on to spot the gaps between values and practices to ensure that its people walked the talk. A 5E model of continuous improvement was set up to sustain and enhance culture, which consists of Educate, Engage, Enable, Evaluate, and Evolve. In short, culture is taken as a competitive advantage and a force that drives decisions, actions and behaviour on a perpetual basis.

The middle section of the book walks you through the brass tacks of transformation, challenges… and growth. Inspiring stories one would love to read: of building brands like Parachute (the most copied) and Saffola; of agony of family separation, and Organising for Growth and Scaling (Marico’s Rs. 236-crore market cap in 1996 multiplied 190 times by 2020). The episode of Hindustan Lever (HL) wanting to take over Marico is full of movie material where Dadiseth threatened to turn Marico into history if HM didn’t sell out. This was the time when Coca Cola had bought Thums Up. But how nimbleness and strategy worked for Marico is to be read from the book (and not here) when post the war for market, Parachute came out stronger against the giant HL, gaining 4% additional market share to 52%, Marico gaining better strategic health and reputation. An important lesson that must be pointed out is about having a coach in Prof. Ram Charan at various stages. The ideas of building a brand extension in Saffola and making it suit Indian taste buds make some obvious yet innovative stories where western breakfast brands have not clicked. The overseas expansion theme has several anecdotes where Marico captures 82% market share in Bangladesh, and where the Unilever director wants to put their soaps in shops that sold Parachute although Unilever were in Dhaka since the 1800s.

The chapter on managing the capital markets is particularly ingenious. About splitting the Kaya business out, to having cartoons along with newspaper reports and keeping cheeky humour alongside reporting on performance. HM’s approach to using Board and governance as a competitive advantage where he would pre-empt practices before they were mandated by law. HM selected competencies and then selected Board members who fit the bill.

Imagine a company that reached a value of Rs. 25,000 crores in 25 years and its scrip outperforming the FMCG index had to plan for the most contentious challenge – the future leadership where the founder had to give up the ‘cocaine’. A chapter deals with how the founder had to find people who had foresight, competencies, were steeped in organisational culture and purpose and who would enhance profitability, respect and growth. A tall order! HM did step back while handing over the hot seat to a non-family professional to assume that responsibility. This, in the words of the author, was the toughest call he had to make. The last two of three chapters take one through purpose beyond profit and personal social responsibility. Of numerous initiatives and investments. The final chapter lists out Milestones and Maxims that I would like you to read in the book. A rich list coming straight out of rich, wide and deep experience.

After reading the book, which is an easy read, one feels like having gone through a live life story of a man, his endeavours and a business. As HM writes in the end about his perpetual quest to do more, BE more and make a difference. The takeaways from the book are countless like the shades in a rainbow, and enlighten every reader, no matter which station of life she is at. By the time you reach the end of the book, you will get a feeling of your mind opening a bit more, just like a parachute which works only when open!

REGULATORY REFERENCER

DIRECT TAX

1. Extension of due dates for filing various forms CBDT has extended the time limit for filing applications for registration of trusts u/s 10(23C)/11/80G, electronic filing of Form No. 15CC, Equalization Levy Statement in Form No. 1, Form No. 15CC, uploading of declaration received in Form No. 15G/15H, Form No. 10BBB, Form 3CEAC, Form 3CEAD, Form 3CEAE and Form II SWF due to difficulties faced by the assessees in electronic filing of Forms and non-availability of the utility for e-filing of Forms. [Circular 16 of 2021 dated 29th August, 2021.]

2. CBDT under Direct Tax Vivad se Vishwas Act, 2020 extended the last date of payment of the amount (without any additional amount) to 30th September, 2021. [Notification No. 94 of 2021 dated 31st August, 2021.]

3. Insertion of Rule 9D – Income-tax (25th Amendment) Rules, 2021 The Finance Act, 2021 amended section 10(11) and section 10(12) to provide that exemption shall not be available for the interest income accrued during the previous year on the recognised and statutory provident fund account of the person to the extent it relates to the contribution made by the employee in excess of Rs. 2,50,000 / Rs. 5,00,000 in the previous year.

The CBDT has inserted Rule 9D to calculate the taxable amount of interest relating to the contribution made to a statutory or a recognised provident fund in excess of the threshold limit. [Notification No. 95 of 2021 dated 31st August, 2021.]

4. Insertion of Rule 26D and Form No. 12BBA – Income-tax (26th Amendment) Rules, 2021 – A senior citizen proposing to claim benefit of section 194P shall furnish a declaration in Form No. 12BBA in paper form to the specified bank. On furnishing the declaration, the specified bank will compute the total income of such senior citizen after considering the deduction allowable under Chapter VI-A and rebate allowable u/s 87A. The specified bank will deduct income-tax on the total income so computed at the rates in force. The specified bank shall properly maintain the declaration and the evidence furnished by the senior citizen and shall make available the same to the PCCIT or CCIT as and when required. [Notification No. 99 of 2021 dated 2nd September, 2021.]

5. Insertion of Rule 14C – Income-tax (27th Amendment) Rules, 2021 To ease the process of authentication of electronic records under the Faceless Assessment Regime, CBDT has provided that the persons who are mandatorily required to authenticate electronic records by digital signature shall be deemed to have authenticated the electronic records when they submit the record through their registered account in the Income-tax Department’s portal. [Notification No. 101 of 2021 dated 6th September, 2021.]

6. Extension of due dates for filing Income tax returns and various audit reports for A.Y. 2021-22 The due date of filing return of income, Tax Audit Report, Transfer Pricing Audit Report and filing revised / belated return for A.Y. 2021-22 was extended vide Circular No. 9/2021 dated 20th May, 2021, which is now further extended. [Circular 17 of 2021 dated 9th September, 2021.]

COMPANY LAW

I. COMPANIES ACT, 2013

1. MCA amends norms relating to creation and maintenance of databank of Independent Directors (IDs) MCA has notified the Companies (Creation and Maintenance of databank of Independent Directors) Second Amendment Rules, 2021. A new Rule 6 has been inserted requiring the Institute to submit an annual report on the capacity-building of IDs within 60 days from the end of every financial year to every individual whose name is included in the databank and also to every company in which such individual is appointed as an ID in prescribed format. [Notification No. S.O. 3406(E), dated 19th August, 2021.]

2. MCA issues FAQs on various issues concerning Corporate Social Responsibility The FAQs have been broadly classified into topics such as (a) Applicability of CSR, (b) CSR Framework, (c) CSR Expenditure, (d) CSR Activities, (e) CSR Implementation, (f) Ongoing Project, (g) Treatment of Unspent CSR Amount, (h) CSR Enforcement, (i) Impact Assessment, and (j) CSR Reporting & Disclosure. [General Circular No. 14 /2021, dated 25th August, 2021.]

II. SEBI

3. SEBI revises format for disclosure of shareholding pattern of promoters and promoter group entities In the interest of transparency for investors, SEBI has revised the format for disclosure of shareholding pattern. Consequently, all listed entities shall henceforth provide shareholding, segregated into promoter(s) and promoter group. At present, the shareholdings of promoter(s) and promoter group entities are collectively disclosed showing shareholding pattern of the promoter and promoter group. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/CFD/CMD/CIR/P/2021/616, dated 13th August, 2021.]

4. SEBI asks depositories to create, host, and maintain a system using ‘Distributed Ledger Technology’ In order to strengthen the process of security creation, monitoring of security created, monitoring of asset cover and covenants of the non-convertible securities, SEBI has asked depositories to create, host, and maintain a system using the distributed ledger technology. The new system shall come into effect from 1st April, 2022. However, testing of the system shall start from 1st January, 2022. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/MIRSD/MIRSD_CRADT/CIR/P/2021/618, dated 13th August, 2021.]

5. SEBI notifies single regulations on Share-Based Employee Benefits and Sweat Equity The market regulator, SEBI, has merged SEBI (Issue of Sweat Equity) Regulations, 2002 and SEBI (Share-Based Employee Benefits) Regulations, 2014 into a single regulation called SEBI (Share-Based Employee Benefits and Sweat Equity) Regulations, 2021. The new Regulation has provided flexibility in switching the administration of their schemes from the trust route to the direct route and vice versa. [Notification No. SEBI/LAD-NRO/GN/2021/40, dated 13th August, 2021.]

6. SEBI specifies additional penalty for repeated delivery default In order to put in place a sufficient deterrent mechanism to handle instances of repeated delivery defaults, SEBI has stated that in the case of a ‘Repeated Default’ by a seller or a buyer, an extra penalty of 3% of the total value of the delivery default will be imposed. Here, the term ‘Repeated Default’ shall be defined as an event wherein a default on delivery obligations takes place three times or more during a six-month period on a rolling basis. The penalty levied on ‘Repeated Default’ shall be transferred to the Settlement Guarantee Fund (SGF) of the Clearing Corporation. However, the Circular shall be effective after one month from the date of its issuance. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/CDMRD/DRMP/CIR/P/2021/619, dated 17th August, 2021.]

7. SEBI requires depositories to use distributed ledger technology to monitor security creation SEBI has asked depositories to use blockchain technology to record and monitor security creation as well as covenants of non-convertible securities. Distributed ledger technology has the potential to provide a more resilient system than traditional centralised databases. It offers better protection against different types of cyberattacks. The move is aimed at strengthening the process of security creation and monitoring of security created, asset cover and covenants of non-convertible securities. [Press Release No. 26/2021 dated 25th August, 2021.]

8. AMCs must disclose ‘risk-o-meter’ of scheme while disclosing its performance In order to enhance the quality of disclosure w.r.t. risk and performance, SEBI has asked AMCs to disclose the ‘risk-o-meter’ of the scheme wherever the performance of the scheme is disclosed and the ‘risk-o-meter’ of the scheme and benchmark wherever the performance of the scheme vis-a-vis that of the benchmark is disclosed. The provisions of this Circular shall be applicable with effect from 1st October, 2021. However, AMCs may choose to adopt the provisions of this Circular before the effective date. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/IMD/IMD-II DOF3/P/CIR/2021/621, dated 31st August, 2021.]

9. SEBI asks investors to link PAN with Aadhaar before 30th September, 2021 SEBI has asked investors to link their PAN with Aadhaar by 30th September, 2021 for continual and smooth transactions in the securities market. As per CBDT Notification GSR 112(E) dated 13th February, 2020, the PAN of a person allotted as on 1st July, 2017 shall become inoperative if it is not linked with Aadhaar by 30th September, 2021 or any other date specified by CBDT. SEBI has also asked market intermediaries to ensure compliance of the said Notification. [Press Release 27/2021, dated 3rd September, 2021.]

FEMA

(i) Amendment in rate of interest on advance payment under export regulations Where an exporter receives advance payment with interest from a buyer / third party named in the export declaration made by the exporter, outside India, the exporter shall be under an obligation to ensure that the rate of interest payable on the advance payment does not exceed London Inter-Bank Offered Rate (LIBOR) + 100 basis points. This rate has now been amended to include any other applicable benchmark as may be directed by the RBI. No direction has yet been provided by the RBI in this matter. [Notification F. No. FEMA 23(R)/(5)/2021-RB, dated 8th September, 2021.]

MISCELLANEA

I. World News

1 US-Australia submarine deal: What are the risks?

The US decision to sell nuclear-powered submarines to Australia has put at risk longstanding but fragile global pacts to prevent the proliferation of dangerous nuclear technologies, according to experts.

The deal killed a previous French agreement to sell non-nuclear subs to Australia and radically bolsters Canberra’s ability to project military power across the Asia-Pacific region.

But will it encourage other countries to freely sell their nuclear technology, potentially expanding the number of countries who can build nuclear weapons?

Australia had originally sought conventional diesel-powered French submarines, which are more easily detected and must rise to the surface every few days to recharge their batteries.

Nuclear-powered submarines can spend weeks on end beneath the surface, travelling long distances undetected, only limited by stocks of food and water for the crew, generally a maximum of three months.

The submarines used by the US Navy, and also the British, who are part of the deal with Australia, use highly-enriched uranium, or HEU, enriched to a level of 93%. At that level the submarines can run for 30 years without new fuel.

But that is also the same level of uranium concentration necessary for a powerful nuclear weapon.

One of the key worries about nuclear proliferation is that weapons-grade HEU cold fall into the hands of a rogue state or terror group, said Alan Kuperman, coordinator of the Nuclear Proliferation Prevention Project at University of Texas at Austin.

‘The most likely path to such a bomb would be for an adversary to divert or steal one of the two required nuclear explosives, plutonium or highly-enriched uranium, from a non-weapons purpose like reactor fuel,’ Kuperman wrote on the Breaking Defense news site.

US Navy ships ‘use about 100 nuclear bombs’ worth of HEU each year, more than all of the world’s other reactors combined,’ he said.

Only six countries – the United States, Britain, France, China, India and Russia – have nuclear-powered submarines. Countries have been cautious about allowing the spread of the technology and the fuel.

For James Acton of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, the US sale to Australia is a disturbing precedent.

He noted that under the 1970 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, countries that do not have nuclear weapons are not prohibited from acquiring nuclear-powered submarines and, if they wanted, could remove the nuclear material from the watercraft.

‘This is a huge loophole,’ Acton wrote on Twitter.

‘I’m not particularly concerned that Australia will acquire nuclear weapons. I am concerned that other states will use this precedent to exploit a serious potential loophole in the global non-proliferation regime,’ he said.

Daryl Kimball of the Arms Control Association said the US sale ‘compromises’ Washington’s own non-proliferation principles.

’It has a corrosive effect on the rules-based international order,’ he told AFP.

White House spokeswoman Jen Psaki insisted that the United States is still committed to non-proliferation, calling the sale to Australia ‘an exceptional case, not a precedent-setting case.’

But experts call it risky.

The US-Australia deal ‘could well open a Pandora’s Box of proliferation,’ said Tariq Rauf, the former head of verification at the International Atomic Energy Agency, which helps enforce nuclear agreements.

He said it could encourage non-nuclear weapons countries like Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Saudi Arabia or South Korea to buy nuclear submarines that could give them weapons-grade fuel.

Hans Kristensen of the Federation of American Scientists worries there could be a snowball effect of proliferation.

After the US-Australia deal, he told AFP, ‘Russia could potentially increase supply of such technology to India, China could potentially provide naval reactor technology to Pakistan or others, and Brazil might see an easier way forward on its troubled domestic submarine reactor project.’

Experts say a somewhat safer alternative could be for Australia to obtain nuclear submarines that use low-enriched uranium (LEU).

LEU is enriched to a level of less than 20% uranium, a grade used in nuclear power plants.

In submarines, it has to be replaced every ten years, in a dangerous and difficult process.

That has not deterred the use of the technology by navies in France and China. The US Navy has been pressured to shift to LEU, but has yet to do so.

(Source: International Business Times – By Sylvie Lanteaume – 21st September, 2021)

II. Economy

2 OECD marginally lowers India’s F.Y.22 growth projection to 9.7%

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has marginally lowered India’s growth projection for the on-going fiscal year to 9.7%, a reduction of 20 basis points (bps), and to 7.9% for the next financial year, down 30 bps from its May forecast, citing pandemic risks.

The inter-governmental economic organisation with 38 member nations had slashed India’s F.Y.22 growth forecast to 9.9% in May from 12.6% estimated in March, as the second Covid-19 wave impacted recovery.

‘The risk of lasting costs from the pandemic also persists. The output shortfall from the pre-pandemic path at the end of 2022 in the median G20 emerging-market economy is projected to be twice that in the median G20 advanced economy, and particularly high in India and Indonesia,’ OECD said in a report.

It pointed out that high-frequency indicators had rebounded. ‘High-frequency activity indicators, such as the Google location-based measures of retail and recreation mobility, suggest global activity continued to strengthen in recent months, helped by improvements in Europe and a marked rebound in both India and Latin America,’ it said.

The OECD projected a strong global growth of 5.7% this year and 4.5% in 2022, slightly changed from its outlook in May of 5.8% and 4.4%, respectively, on the back of continuing vaccine roll-out and a gradual resumption of economic activity, besides decisive actions by governments and central banks at the height of the crisis.

Vaccination key to recovery
The OECD report cautioned that to maintain recovery stronger international efforts were needed to provide low-income countries with the resources to vaccinate their populations, both for their own and global benefit. ‘Ensuring that the recovery is sustained and widespread requires action on a number of fronts – from effective vaccination programmes across all countries to concerted public investment strategies to build for the future,’ said OECD secretary-general Mathias Cormann.

(Source: Economic Times Bureau – 22nd September, 2021)

III. Industry

3 Will 2021 be the second-best year in a decade for Indian car market? Yes, IF it survives chip shortage

It’s always the darkest before the day dawns.

India’s carmakers, despite niggling chip shortages, are proving this year that there’s much more than a grain of truth in that age-old saying.

Last year was a washout and car sales slumped to levels not seen in a decade. But 2021 has been stellar by all yardsticks so far: The passenger vehicle market has already posted its second highest sales in a decade through August in 2021.

And that isn’t all: This calendar year may turn out to be the second best in a decade!

With sustained demand and expectations of improving chip supplies, Jato Dynamics expects the Indian passenger vehicle market to end 2021 with volumes of 3.34 million units – the second highest in a decade and just about 50,000 lower than the peak.

Sales charts would have gleamed even more had Covid two not come in the way.

Global forecasting firm IHS Markit expects India to overtake Germany as the fourth largest light vehicle maker in the world in 2021.

So far this calendar year, volumes have climbed over 70% to 2.13 million units, which is the highest growth rate in a decade. Vehicle makers produced 58% more than last year, against the highest in absolute terms at 2.29 million units.

The low base of last year, the need for personal mobility and the spike in demand for SUVs have led to a swift rebound.

Vehicle makers have posted sales of over three lakh units per month this calendar year, and despite the second wave of Covid-19, the revival has been so quick that dealer inventory has been among the lowest. For some, inventory is only for days as against weeks.

Ravi Bhatia, president of JATO Dynamics India, told ET that sales this year are running close to the best in a decade and the market is expected to close at 3.34 million units.

The Indian middle class pool of 121 million households with an income of Rs. 75,000 to Rs. 150,000 clearly wants to get back to work and they need personal mobility, which is clearly reflected in the numbers.

Year

Volumes

2012

27,70,730

2013

25,71,683

2014

25,95,185

2015

28,03,088

2016

29,93,492

2017

32,26,175

2018

33,91,094

2019

29,72,786

2020

24,47,697

2021
(estimate)

33,45,752

*Source: Jato Dynamics India

‘If vaccinations proceed and we have no severe third wave, then it could be close to one of the best. What stands out is the resilience of demand. Also, dealers have done this with lower inventory, lower incentives and higher prices,’ added Bhatia.

One of the factors hurting output recently has been the disruption in manufacturing in Malaysia due to rising Covid cases. However, the situation is gradually improving and that may help the Indian market secure better supplies than in the recent months. Vehicle makers on their part have adapted to the chip shortage with special trims.

Bhatia says Malaysia has 13% of the world’s automotive testing and packaging capacity and that the testing and packaging capacity is almost back up, boosting supplies in the coming months.

Experts believe that if not for chip shortages, the market could have crossed its peak. Over a dozen models have a waiting period of more than eight weeks. The industry still faces pending bookings of more than four lakh units and the numbers are swelling, with several more high-profile launches – of Mahindra XUV 700, Tata Punch, MG Astor and Citroen C3, for instance – coming up.

China

23.14 million

US

8.96 million

Japan

7.45 million

India LVP

3.9 million

Germany LVP

3.43 million

*Source: IHS Markit

Gaurav Vangaal, associate director at IHS Markit, says strong demand, low semi-conductor content, better product mix and proactive management have cushioned the impact of chip shortage.

‘We project India to surpass Germany in 2021 to become the fourth largest manufacturing base for Light Vehicle Production. However, Germany might regain its position once the supply scenario improves. Demand is indeed very strong; however, the recent disruption in the supply scenario is a cause of concern and it is likely to continue. How vehicle makers manage this disruption will determine the final numbers,’ Vangaal added.

(Source: ET Bureau – By Ketan Thakkar & Ashutosh R. Shyam – 22nd September, 2021)

CORPORATE LAW CORNER

1 Achintya Kumar Barua alias Manju Baruah & Ors. vs. Ranjit Barthakur & Ors. Company Appeal (AT) No. 17 of 2018 National Company Law Appellate Tribunal [2018] 143 CLA 233 Date of order: 8th February, 2018

Section 173(2) which gives right to the Directors to participate in the Board meetings through video conferencing / other audio-visual means (VC/OAVM), is mandatory and companies need to provide the facilities as per section 173(2) of the Companies Act, 2013 subject to fulfilling the requirements of Rule 3 of the Companies (Meetings of Board and its Powers) Rules, 2014

FACTS
The petition was filed by Mr. R.B. and Others before the NCLT seeking the facility of attending Board meetings through video conferencing u/s 173(2) of the Companies Act, 2013.

The matter had earlier come up before the Company Law Board (‘CLB’) and, being aggrieved by certain observations, the same was carried to the High Court of Guwahati. The High Court found that the appeal did not raise any question of law and sent the matter back to the the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Guwahati Bench which allowed the application and directed that the facility should be made available u/s 173(2).

An appeal was filed before the National Company Law Appellant Tribunal (‘NCLAT’) against the order passed by the NCLT, Guwahati Bench where it was submitted that when the Director participates in the meetings through video-conferencing, it would not be possible to ensure that nobody else is present at the place from which the Director would be participating.

It was averred that the Secretarial Standards on Meetings of the Board of Directors have also considered this aspect and have prescribed that such option under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rules should be resorted to only when the facilities are provided by the company to its Directors.

It was further submitted that sub-section (2) of section 173 of the Act was not a mandatory provision and it was not compulsory for the company to provide such facility. The counsel during the course of the hearing submitted that the responsibility had been put on the Chairperson to ensure that no person other than the Director concerned was attending or having access to the proceedings of the meeting through video-conferencing mode or other audio-visual means. It was also stated that when a Director resorts to availing the facility of video conferencing, it would not be possible for the Chairperson to ensure that the Director was alone while participating from wherever the video call was made as the Chairperson would have no means to know as to who else was sitting in the room or place concerned.

HELD
The NCLAT held that section 173 of the Companies Act, 2013, as well as the Rules referred to, were introduced under the 2013 Act and, following these provisions, it would be in the interest of the companies as well as the directors. It would not be appropriate to shut out these provisions on mere apprehensions.

The word ‘may’ which has been used in sub-section (2) of section 173 only gives an option to the Director to choose whether he would be participating in person or through video-conferencing or other audio-visual means. This word ‘may’ does not give an option to the company to deny this right given to the Directors for participation through video-conferencing or other audio-visual means if they desire to do so. In this regard, the provisions of Rule 3 are material.

The NCLAT further referred to the order of NCLT, Guwahati Bench and noted that it had taken note of the fact that the company had all the necessary infrastructure available and had no reason not to provide the facility. Hence, NCLT had come to the conclusion that the provisions of section 173(2) of the Companies Act, 2013 are mandatory and the companies cannot be permitted to make any deviations therefrom.

An important observation made by the NCLAT was that the rules require that the company shall comply with the procedure prescribed for convening and conducting the Board meetings through video-conferencing or other audio-visual means. The Chairperson and Company Secretary, if any, have to take due and reasonable care as specified in Rule 3(2). The argument of the counsel for the appellant is that sub-Rule (2)(e) puts the burden on the Chairperson to ensure that no person other than the Director concerned is attending and this would not be possible for the Chairperson to ensure in video-conferencing.

NCLAT did not find force in the submission as the Rules, read as a whole, were a complete scheme. Sub-clause (4)(d) of Rule 3 also puts responsibility on the participating Director. The Chairperson was required to ensure compliance of sub-clause (e) or clause (2), and the Director would need to satisfy the Chairperson that sub-clause (d) of Clause 4 was being complied with.

The NCLAT noted that counsel for the appellants tried to rely on the Secretarial Standard on Meetings of the Board of Directors, that such participation could be done ‘if the company provides such facility’. NCLAT observed that such guidelines cannot override the provisions under the Rules. The mandate of section 173(2) read with the Rules mentioned above cannot be avoided by the companies.

The NCLT thus directed the company to provide the facilities as per section 173(2) of the Companies Act, 2013 subject to fulfilling the requirements of Rule 3(3)(e) of the Rules.

Thus, NCLAT did not find any reason to interfere with the NCLT order and observed that the order was progressive and in the right direction and therefore the admission of the appeal was denied.

2 CGI Information Systems and Management Consultants Private Limited Compounding Application CP No.: 55/2017 National Company Law Tribunal, Bengaluru Bench Source: NCLT Official Website Date of order: 27th April, 2018

If the company did not have adequate surplus in the profit and loss account but had declared interim dividend based on the belief that it indeed did have adequate profits and surplus in its profit and loss account, a compounding application on suo motu basis can be entertained even though the company had contravened the provisions of section 123(3) of the Companies Act, 2013

FACTS
The compounding application was filed by M/s CISMCPL (‘the company’) u/s 441 of the Companies Act, 2013 before the NCLT, Bengaluru Bench with a prayer for compounding of the violation committed under the provisions of section 123(3) of the Companies Act, 2013.

The submissions of the company were as follows:

The company, based on its estimates and belief that it had adequate profits and surplus in its profit and loss account, had declared an interim dividend of Rs. 96,14,14,080 pursuant to the Resolution of the Board of Directors dated 25th September, 2014 and accordingly paid the same to the eligible shareholders.

However, at the time of declaration of interim dividend the company had not finalised any method of accounting and believed that the method of accounting would not result in any deficit in the profits or in the surplus in the profit and loss account.

However, later on the company adopted the Pooling of Interest Method for accounting its amalgamation.

While declaring dividend, it had inadvertently not considered the fact that by adopting the pooling of interest method of accounting, there would be a deficit in the surplus in the profit and loss account, as a result of which the company had contravened the provisions of section 123(3) of the Companies Act, 2013.

Hence, the company and its Directors suo motu filed the application for admitting violation and had prayed for compounding.

HELD
NCLT held that the company had violated the provisions of section 123(3) of the Companies Act, 2013 and shall be punishable u/s 450 of the said Act. The company and every officer of the company who was in default, or such other person, shall be punishable with fine which may extend to Rs. 10,000, and where the contravention was a continuing one, with a further fine which may extend to Rs. 1,000 for every day after the first day during which the contravention continued.

Therefore, the compounding fee of Rs. 94,200 on the company and Rs. 94,200 on each of the Directors was levied considering the delay of 932 days.

ALLIED LAWS

1 Ramesh and Others vs. Laxmi Bai AIR 2021, Madhya Pradesh 56 Date of order: 1st March, 2021 Bench: Vivek Rusia J

Condonation of delay – Appeal cannot be decided without deciding on the application for condonation of delay in favour of the appellant [Civil Procedure Code, 1908, Ord. 41, R. 3A; Limitation Act, 1963, S. 5]

FACTS
The plaintiffs had filed a civil suit for declaration of title and partition of joint family property. By the judgment dated 24th January, 2009 it was held that they were entitled to partition through the Court. Defendant No. 1 was restrained from getting a mutation in his name. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree, the Defendants filed an appeal in the year 2013 along with an application for condonation of delay u/s 5 of the Limitation Act.

On 24th February, 2019, it came to the notice of the Additional District Judge that the application u/s 5 of the Limitation Act had not been decided so far. Both the parties agreed to first argue on the aforesaid application. The arguments were heard and kept for order on 27th April, 2019. By an order dated 27th April, 2019, the Additional District Judge decided that the application u/s 5 of the Limitation Act would be decided along with the first appeal on merit.

The plaintiffs filed a petition challenging this order of 27th April, 2019 on the ground that the Additional District Judge had committed an error of law while keeping the application u/s 5 for consideration along with the appeal while finally hearing the appeal on merit.

HELD
The Court referred to the decision in the case of State of M.P. vs. Pradeep Kumar 2000 (7) SCC 372. In that the Supreme Court held that the object of enacting Rule 3-A of Order 41 of the Civil Procedure Code seems to be two-fold. The first is to inform the appellant himself that appeal is time-barred and it would not be entertained unless it is accompanied by an application explaining the delay. The second is to communicate to the respondent a message that it may not be necessary for him to get ready to meet the grounds taken up in the memorandum of appeal because the Court has to deal with the application for condonation of delay as a condition precedent.

The Court also referred to the decision in S.V. Matha Prasad vs. Lalchand Meghraj and Others (2007) 14 SCC 772 wherein the Supreme Court had held that the Division Bench of the High Court had not only condoned the delay but took a decision on the merit as well and such exercise was not justified as the only issue before the Division Bench was the question of limitation; accordingly, the judgment of the High Court was set aside to the extent that it went on to the merits of the controversy but maintained it insofar as it dealt with the question of limitation.

In view of the above, the Court held that the Additional District Judge was required to decide first the application u/s 5 of the Limitation Act and if it condoned the delay then there would not be any impediment to deciding the appeal on merit. Further, the Court held that although there is no specific bar which restrains the appellate Court from hearing and deciding the appeal along with the application for condonation of delay, the provisions put a bar on the appellate Court on deciding the appeal unless the application for condonation of delay is decided in favour of the appellant. The petition was allowed.

2 Amola Saikia and Others vs. Pankajit Narayan Konwar AIR 2021, Gauhati 50 Date of order: 23rd January, 2021 Bench: Anchintya Malla Bujor Barua J

Intestate succession – Property of Hindu female – Grant of succession certificate to husband held to be proper [Indian Succession Act, 1925, S. 372; Hindu Succession Act, 1956, S. 15]

FACTS
The respondent-husband filed an application u/s 372 of the Indian Succession Act for grant of succession certificate. The respondent had succeeded in the said application vide order dated 10th June, 2015.The appellants, viz., the mother, sisters and brother of the deceased, challenged the said order of 10th June, 2015.

HELD
As per section 15(1) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 it is clearly provided that the property of a female Hindu dying intestate shall devolve firstly upon the sons and daughters and the husband. Thereafter, it would devolve upon the mother and father and then upon the heirs of the father, and finally upon the heirs of the mother. Hence, the grant of succession certificate was in accordance with law.

The appeals were dismissed.

3 Sozin Flora Pharma LLP vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and another AIR 2021, Himachal Pradesh 44 Date of order: 7th January, 2021 Bench: Tarlok Singh Chauhan J and Jyotsna Rewal Dua J

Stamp Duty – Conversion of partnership firm to limited liability partnership – No stamp duty or registration fee [Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, S. 58(1), 58(4)(b); Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act, 1974, S. 118]

FACTS
The petitioner was registered as a partnership firm on 14th December, 2005 in the office of the Deputy Registrar of Firms. With the intention of availing of the benefits of the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, the petitioner firm converted itself from ‘Firm’ to ‘Limited Liability Partnership’ (LLP). The conversion was as per section 55 of the LLP Act.

The petitioner applied to the Deputy Commissioner for changing its name in the revenue record from ‘M/s Sozin Flora Pharma’ to ‘M/s Sozin Flora Pharma LLP’. The permission to change the name in the revenue record was granted on the condition that stamp duty and registration fee shall be chargeable. The petitioner submitted a representation to the respondent on 25th June, 2019 against the imposition which was rejected on 23rd August, 2019. Hence the writ petition.

HELD
Upon conversion of a registered partnership firm to an LLP under the provisions of the Limited Liability Partnership Act, all movable and immovable properties of the erstwhile registered partnership firm automatically vest in the converted LLP by operation of section 58(4)(b) of the Limited Liability Partnership Act.

The transfer of assets of the firm to the LLP is by operation of law. Being a statutory transfer, no separate conveyance / instrument is required to be executed for transfer of assets.

Since there is no instrument of transfer of assets of the erstwhile partnership firm to the limited liability partnership, the question of payment of stamp duty and registration charges does not arise as these are chargeable only on the instruments indicated in section 3 of the Indian Stamp Act and section 17 of the Indian Registration Act.

The partnership firm’s legal entity after conversion to limited liability partnership does not change. Only the identity of the firm as a legal entity changes. Such a conversion or change in the name does not amount to a change in the constitution of the partnership firm.

Therefore, stamp duty and registration fee cannot be levied upon conversion of a partnership firm to an LLP.

4 Kiran Gupta vs. State Bank of India and another AIR 2021, Gauhati 50 Date of order: 2nd November, 2020 Bench: Hima Kohli J and Subramonium Prasad J

Recovery of dues – Pendency of IRP proceeding against principal borrower – Bank can proceed against guarantor under SARFAESI Act [SARFAESI Act, 2002, S. 13; Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, S. 14, S. 31; Contract Act, 1872, S. 128]

FACTS
The short question that arises for consideration in this writ petition is whether a bank / financial institution can institute or continue with proceedings against a guarantor under the SARFAESI Act when proceedings under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) have been initiated against the principal borrower and the same are pending adjudication.

HELD
The view expressed by the Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India vs. V. Ramakrishan and Another, (2018) 17 SCC 394 amply demonstrates that neither section 14 nor section 31 of the IBC place any fetters on banks / financial institutions from initiation and continuation of the proceedings against the guarantor for recovering their dues. That being the position, the plea taken by the counsel for the petitioner that all proceedings against the petitioner, who is only a guarantor, ought to be stayed under the SARFAESI Act during the continuation of the Insolvency Resolution process qua the principal borrower, is rejected as meritless. The petitioner cannot escape her liability qua the respondent / bank in such a manner. The liability of the principal borrower and the guarantor remain co-extensive and the respondent / bank is well entitled to initiate proceedings against the petitioner under the SARFAESI Act during the continuation of the Insolvency Resolution process against the principal borrower. The petition is dismissed.

Editor’s Note: The Supreme Court in the case of Lalit Kumar Jain vs. Union of India [2021] 167 SCL 1 had held that a personal guarantor is also liable under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.

GOODS AND SERVICES TAX (GST)

I. SUPREME COURT
    
1 Union of India vs. Vishnu Aroma Pouching (P) Ltd. [2021 (129) taxmann.com 17 (SC)] Date of order: 29th June, 2021

The Supreme Court dismissed the SLP as barred by limitation and passed strictures on the Department regarding its lethargy and delay in filing the SLP without any cogent or plausible ground for condonation of delay, calling it a ‘certificate case’ and also imposed a cost of Rs. 25,000 for wastage of judicial time

FACTS

The Supreme Court dismissed the SLP belatedly filed by the Revenue against the order of the Gujarat High Court in the case of Vishnu Aroma Pouching (P) Ltd. vs. Union of India [2021] 129 taxmann.com 16 (Guj). In the said case, the petitioner paid GST liability for August, 2017 on 19th September, 2017 (i.e., before the due date). However, due to portal limitations, it could not file the return for August, 2017 before the due date. Further, when the return was filed on 21st September, 2017, due to technical glitches all the amounts appeared as ‘Nil’ in the said return. After a long-drawn follow-up with the Department, the petitioner was permitted to file Form GSTR3B for September, 2019 with taxes payable for August, 2017 and the same was accepted by the system. The Gujarat High Court had held that the petitioner had duly discharged the tax liability of August, 2017 within the period prescribed; however, it was only on account of technical glitches in the system that the tax amount had not been credited to the Government account, hence the petitioner would not be liable to pay any interest on the tax amount for the period from 21st September, 2017 to October, 2019.

HELD


While dismissing the SLP as barred by limitation, the Court passed strictures regarding the lethargy on the part of the Revenue Department for the delay in filing the SLP and called this case as a ‘certificate case’ filed only with the object to obtain a quietus from the Supreme Court, to complete a mere formality and to save the skin of the officers who may be at default in following the due process, or may have done it deliberately, noting that the petitioner has approached this Court without any cogent or plausible ground for condonation of delay. Referring to the decisions in the cases of State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Bheru Lal [SLP (c) Diary No. 9217 of 2020, dated 15th October, 2020]; and State of Odisha vs. Sunanda Mahakuda [SLP (c) Diary No. 22605 of 2020, dated 11th January, 2021], the Court stated that the leeway that was given to Government / public authorities on account of innate inefficiencies was the result of certain orders of this Court which came at a time when technology had not advanced and thus, greater indulgence was shown. This position is no more prevalent and the current legal position has been elucidated by the judgment of this Court in Office of Chief Post Master-General vs. Living Media India Ltd. [2012] 20 taxmann.com 347. The Supreme Court thus imposed costs on the petitioner(s) of Rs. 25,000 for wastage of judicial time.

2 Union of India & others vs. VKC Footsteps India Pvt. Ltd. [2021-TIOL-237-SC-GST] Date of order: 13th September, 2021

In case of Inverted Duty Structure, refund is allowed only of inputs and not with respect to input services

FACTS
Section 54(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 allows refund of unutilised input tax credit involving zero-rated supplies made without payment of tax and credit accumulated on account of the rate of tax on inputs being higher than the rate of tax on output supplies. Writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution were instituted before the High Courts of Gujarat and Madras. It was submitted that refund on account of inverted duty structure should be allowed on both input as well as input services. Restricting the credit only to inputs would be unconstitutional as it would lead to discrimination between input and input services. The Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court held that ‘Explanation (a) to Rule 89(5) which denies the refund of “unutilised input tax” paid on “input services” as part of “input tax credit” accumulated on account of inverted duty structure is ultra vires the provision of Section 54(3) of the CGST Act, 2017’. The High Court therefore allowed the refund. However, the Madras High Court gave a contrary decision in the matter. The Union of India has filed the present appeal against the decision of the Gujarat High Court.

HELD
The Court noted that section 54(3) allows refund of inputs, which by no parameters can also include input services. The Court noted that with the clear language which has been adopted by the Parliament while enacting the provisions of section 54(3), the acceptance of the submission will involve a judicial re-writing of the provision which is impermissible in law. Reading the expression ‘input’ to cover input goods and input services would lead to recognising an entitlement to refund, beyond what was contemplated by Parliament. The Court stated that proviso to section 54(3) is not a condition of eligibility but a restriction provided in the law. It was also noted that a discriminatory provision under tax legislation is not invalid per se, input goods and input services are not treated as one and the same, and they are distinct species under the GST law. Therefore, the submission that goods and services must necessarily be treated at par cannot be accepted. Thus, refund is allowed only in case of inputs in case of inverted duty structure. Therefore, the Court affirmed the decision of the Madras High Court and allowed the appeal of the Revenue filed against the Gujarat High Court.

II. HIGH COURT

3 Deem Distributors (P) Ltd. vs. UOI [2021 (129) taxmann.com 134 (Tel)] Date of order: 3rd August, 2021

The provisions of the GST law do not confer any advisory jurisdiction on the respondents to issue any ‘advises’ to the taxpayers to pay tax before ascertainment of the liability as required by section 74(9) and no demands in the form of letters asking the taxpayer to pay GST along with interest and penalty can be issued or raised when the investigation is still in progress

FACTS
The petitioner is a partnership firm registered under the GST Act. They availed Input Tax Credit (ITC) based on invoices issued by certain suppliers / firms. The Department requested them to reverse the said credit on the ground that the said credit has been availed fraudulently without receiving any material as the suppliers / firms are fictitious and are issuing fake invoices with intent to pass on the ITC. Summonses were also issued in the name of the Directors of the petitioner firm; however, the investigation was not complete and the show cause notice u/s 74 was issued. The petitioner deposited certain amounts merely to avoid coercion and buy peace, but challenged the said letters before the Court on the ground that liability cannot be determined by the respondents before conducting inquiry when even the investigation is incomplete and that any advice or demand can at best be a provisional one; and the petitioner cannot be compelled coercively to pay  the amounts.

HELD
Referring to the provisions of section 74 and the affidavit in reply filed by the Department, the Court held that a conclusion that the petitioner had availed ITC and raised invoices by certain fictitious suppliers without actual receipt of goods, appears to have been drawn based on an incomplete investigation. It further held that section 74(5) gives a choice to the assessee to make any payment if he so chooses, but it does not confer any power on the respondents to make a demand as if there has been a determination of the liability of the assessee and demand tax along with interest and penalty. Hence, before ascertainment of the liability, as required by section 74(9), the Department could not have issued the letters advising the petitioner to reverse the input tax allegedly availed. The Court accordingly held that no advisory jurisdiction is conferred on the respondents to issue any ‘advises’ of the nature issued to the petitioner and no demands can be issued or raised when the investigation is still in progress. The Department cannot be allowed to put the cart before the horse and collect any tax, interest or penalty before they determine it in an inquiry. Any such action is wholly arbitrary and without jurisdiction. The Court thus directed the Department to refund the amount already deposited along with interest and proceed with their inquiry strictly in accordance with the provisions of law.

4 R.M. Dairy Products LLP vs. State of UP [2021 (129) taxmann.com 37 (All)] Date of order: 15th July, 2021

Rule 86A is not a recovery provision but only a provision to secure the interest of Revenue. It only provides, in certain situations and upon certain conditions being fulfilled, the specified amount that may be held back and be not allowed to be utilised (i.e., debited to the electronic credit ledger) by the assessee towards discharge of its liabilities on the outward tax or towards refund. Hence, if as on the date of passing the order there is no balance in the electronic credit ledger, the order would be read to create a lien up to the monetary limit mentioned in the said order in respect of future credits availed and credited in the electronic credit ledger

FACTS
The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the order passed by the Department under Rule 86A(1)(a)(i) [i.e., not allowing debit in the electronic credit ledger of the amount equivalent to the credit of input tax that has been allegedly availed on the strength of tax invoices or debit notes issued by the registered person who has been found to be non-existent or not to be conducting any business] of the State / Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 raising the objections that the Department has no jurisdiction or authority to block any ITC over and above any amount that may have been actually available on the date of the order. The Department has to record a positive ‘reason to believe’ that credit of input tax had been fraudulently availed or the petitioner was wholly ineligible to avail the same. The adjudication proceedings in respect of the very same matter are underway in accordance with section 74 and till those proceedings are concluded, no amount would become recoverable from the petitioner u/s 78.

HELD
Referring to various provisions of the Act, the Court noted that the recovery provisions are contained in section 79 and the enabling Rules fall under Chapter XVIII being Rules 142 to 161. On the other hand, Rule 86A falls under Chapter IX of the Rules regarding payment of tax. It further held that the ambit and purpose of Rule 86A are inherently different and independent of the recovery provisions. Referring to Rule 86A, the Court held that it does not contemplate any recovery of tax due from an assessee. It only provides, in certain situations and upon certain conditions being fulfilled, the specified amount that may be held back and be not allowed to be utilised by the assessee towards discharge of its liabilities on the outward tax or towards refund. It creates a lien without actual recovery being made or attempted. The Court further clarified that Rule 86A does not allow the Revenue to reverse or appropriate any part of the credit existing in the electronic credit ledger or to adjust that credit against any outstanding demand or likely demand. It is at most a provision to secure the interest of Revenue, to be exercised in the presence of the relevant ‘reasons to believe’, as recorded and in respect of the amount equivalent to credit fraudulently taken which has to be kept unutilised. To that effect, the Legislature has chosen the words ‘not allow debit’ which is different from the word ‘appropriate’. The adjustment or appropriation may arise only upon an adjudication order attaining finality or after the lapse of three months from the date of it being passed if there is no stay granted in appeal, etc., that, too, as a consequence of the recovery provisions but not under Rule 86A of the Rules.

The Court further held that the words ‘input tax available’ used in the first part of sub-rule (1) of Rule 86A cannot be read as actual input tax available on the date of the order passed under that Rule. It would always relate back in time when the assessee allegedly availed ITC either fraudulently or which he was not eligible to avail. It does not refer to and therefore does not relate to the ITC available on the date of Rule 86A being invoked. The word ‘has been’ used in Rule 86A (1) leaves no manner of doubt in that regard. The Court also explained that the ‘ineligibility’ of the credit as mentioned in the said Rule is only for the reasons mentioned in the said Rule. The Court noted that the correctness or otherwise or the sufficiency of the ‘reason to believe’ was not the subject matter of dispute before it and the ‘reason to believe’ is based on material with the competent authority indicating the non-existence of the selling dealer which is a valid reason to invoke the said Rule.

5 Satyam Shivam Papers Pvt. Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Service Tax, Hyderabad [2021 (50) GSTL 459] Date of order: 2nd June, 2021

Section 129 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 – Mere expiry of E-way bill cannot lead to a presumption of intention to evade tax and invoke penalty

FACTS
The petitioner had made an intra-state supply and generated an E-way bill on 4th January, 2020. The transporter started for the delivery by an auto-trolley at 4.33 pm on the same day. On the way, there was a traffic jam on account of a political rally due to which the auto trolley could not move. This continued till 8.30 p.m. by which time the shop of the buyer was closed. Therefore, the driver took the auto trolley to his residence and planned to complete the delivery on the next working day. The next day being a Sunday, the goods were intended to be delivered on 6th January, 2020. On the way to delivery, the Respondent No. 2 (i.e., Deputy State Tax Officer, Bowenpally-II, Circle, Begumpet Division) detained the goods and a Notice for Detention in Form GST MOV-07 was issued alleging that the validity of the E-way bill had expired and proposing to impose tax and penalty.

The detained goods were unloaded at the premise of a relative of Respondent No. 2 without tendering any acknowledgement receipt for the same. The petitioner made various representations against the action of Respondent No. 2; however, all of them were ignored, stating that it was a clear case of evasion of tax. Therefore, to get the goods released, the petitioner made a payment of Rs. 69,000 towards tax and penalty on 20th January, 2020. Further, the Respondent No. 2 passed an order dated 22nd January, 2020 in Form GST MOV-09, which was signed by the Respondent No. 1 (i.e., Assistant Commissioner [ST], Osmanganj, Circle, Charminar Division, Hyderabad). It was stated in the order that the petitioner admitted the liability and it had no objection to pay the proposed tax and penalty. Aggrieved by the said order of 22nd January, 2020, the petitioner preferred the present petition.

HELD
The High Court held that there had been a blatant abuse of power by unloading the goods at a relative’s premise and by issuing an order that was signed by the Respondent No. 1. Also, no material was placed on record by the Respondent No. 2 to conclude that there was evasion of tax by the petitioner. Mere expiry of time limit mentioned on the E-way bill cannot lead to a presumption of intention to evade tax. Therefore, the order dated 22nd January, 2020 was set aside and the Respondents were directed to refund the amount of Rs. 69,000 to the petitioner along with interest @ 6% p.a. from 20th January, 2020 till the date of repayment. The Respondent No. 2 was also directed to pay a cost of Rs. 10,000 to the petitioner.

6 Anuj Mahesh Gupta vs. Asstt. Commissioner of Sales Tax, Mumbai [2021 (50) GSTL 180 (Bom)] Date of order: 12th July, 2021

Section 167(2)(a)(ii) of Code of Criminal Procedure – Assessee can be granted bail on expiry of 60 days from detention even in case of cognisable and non-bailable offences

FACTS
The petitioner is sole proprietor of M/s Savvy Fabrics and partner in M/s Shubhmangal Textile Industries LLP. It was alleged that he was actively involved in receiving tax invoices or bills without any actual supplies of goods or services or both and claiming ineligible ITC on such invoices. Thus, he had committed cognisable and non-bailable offences u/s 132(1)(b)(c) of the MGST Act by receiving fake invoices of more than Rs. 277 crores and taking ITC of at least Rs. 31 crores. As per clause (i) of section 132 of the CGST Act, in cases where the amount of tax evaded or the amount of ITC wrongly availed of or utilised or the amount of refund wrongly taken exceeds Rs. 500 lakhs, then the punishment would be imprisonment for a term which may extend to five years and with fine. As per section 167 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 where investigation could not be completed within 24 hours, the accused can be detained up to a maximum period of 60 days where the investigation relates to an offence other than those which are punishable with death, imprisonment of life or imprisonment of at least ten years and on expiry of such 60 days, the accused shall be released on bail. The petitioner was arrested on 15th January, 2021 and had completed 54 days in custody; therefore, the present petition was filed to examine the prayer for bail made by the petitioner.

HELD
The High Court applied section 167(2)(a)(ii) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and held that the petitioner should be released on bail subject to certain conditions, viz., he should furnish case surety of Rs. 5 lakhs and within two weeks of release he should furnish solvent surety of like amount, the petitioner should co-operate in the investigation, he shall not tamper with any evidence or try to intimidate any witness, and the petitioner shall deposit his passport with the authorities.

7 Kerala Communicators Cable Ltd. vs. Addl. Dir.-General DGGI, Kochi [2021 (50) GSTL 116 (Ker)] Date of order: 24th March, 2021

Section 83 of the CGST Act, 2017 – Stay was granted to furnish the bank guarantee during pendency of writ petition filed to challenge the validity of the provisional attachment of bank accounts

FACTS
A search and inspection u/s 67 of the CGST Act was conducted at the premises of the petitioner. Based on this and to protect the interest of Revenue, the respondent had passed orders to provisionally attach the bank accounts of the petitioner. The petitioner had objected to such provisional attachment of its bank accounts and preferred a writ petition. During the pendency of the said petition, the provisional attachment order was modified and the petitioner was directed to furnish a security in the form of bank guarantee equivalent to Rs. 30 crores along with a bond. Pursuant to this direction, the petitioner furnished the bank guarantee and bond under protest reserving the right to challenge the modified order. Thus, being aggrieved by the modified provisional attachment order imposing additional condition to furnish bank guarantee and bond, the present writ petition was filed.

HELD
The High Court observed that the respondent had not disclosed reasonable apprehension that necessitated the issuance of the provisional attachment order. Also, the bank guarantee of about Rs. 30 crores would certainly block a huge amount from the business of the petitioner. Therefore, the High Court granted a stay on the direction that required the petitioner to furnish the bank guarantee till the disposal of the writ petition and directed the petitioner to execute an undertaking that it shall not sell, alienate or deal with any of its fixed assets, plant, property and equipment shown in the balance sheet dated 31st March, 2020.

8 Dhirendra Singh vs. Commissioner of CGST, Commissionerate [2021 (50) GSTL 176 (Guj)] Date of order: 4th March, 2021

Input tax credit wrongly availed in respect of goods allegedly never received by assessee – Department directed to proceed further in accordance with law – Section 70 of CGST Act, 2017

FACTS
The petitioners are the Directors of M/s Manpasand Beverages Limited (‘MBL’). They were issued multiple summonses and instructed to produce all the documentary evidence essential to verify their GST liability. However, the Directors were unable to produce the requisite documents and the final GST liability could not be arrived at. Hence, the Department was of the view that MBL had contravened the provisions of section 16 of the CGST Act inasmuch as they knowingly availed ITC and used the same in payment of GST liability. This constitutes an offence under sections 132(1)(b), 132(1)(c) and 132(1)(l) of the CGST Act and they are liable for punishment of imprisonment up to five years in terms of section 132(5) of the CGST Act. Therefore, the present writ petition was filed to evade arrest by challenging the validity of the summonses issued u/s 70 of the CGST Act.

HELD
The High Court held that there was no good or legal ground to challenge the validity of the summonses issued u/s 70 of the CGST Act. As such, the writ application becomes infructuous and the Court was not inclined to extend any further protection to the petitioners. Further, if the petitioners apprehended that they would be arrested any time, it was open for them to take recourse to the steps available to them in accordance with the law to avoid arrest.
    
III. AUTHORITY OF ADVANCE RULING

9 Eastern Coalfields Ltd., Kolkata [2021-TIOL-221-AAR-GST] Date of order: 9th August, 2021

Since the supplier has paid tax belatedly, the assessee is denied input tax credit

FACTS
The question is whether the applicant is entitled for ITC already claimed by him on the invoices raised by one of the vendors pertaining to January, February and March, 2020 for which the supplier has actually paid the tax charged in respect of such supply to the Government in the month of November, 2020 while filing the GSTR3B in November, 2020. And whether the applicant has to reverse the said ITC already availed by him where the vendor has actually paid the tax, though belatedly.

HELD
The Authority noted that section 16 of the GST law prescribes conditions and restrictions towards entitlement of ITC. Sub-section (c) allows ITC provided the tax charged in respect of such supply has been actually paid to the Government, either in cash or through utilisation of ITC admissible in respect of the said supply. However, it is evident that while the applicant has availed ITC in the months of January, February and March, 2020, respectively, the supplier has declared such outward supplies in his respective Form GSTR1 in the month of November, 2020 and has also paid the taxes on such supply upon furnishing of return in Form GSTR3B in the month of November, 2020. The Authority also noted that Form GSTR2B has been made effective from 1st January, 2021 but at the same time the applicant cannot deny that the provisions of sub-rule (4) of Rule 36 were already in force during the period when the applicant availed of the ITC. The applicant is therefore not entitled for ITC claimed by him pertaining to the months January, February and March, 2020 for which the supplier has furnished Form GSTR1 and Form GSTR3B in the month of November, 2020 and the applicant is, therefore, required to reverse the said ITC.

Note: The Authority in the present case has denied the entire credit even though the tax is paid by the supplier. Denial of entire credit does not appear to be justified; at the most, interest could be demanded for availment of credit prior to payment by the supplier.

IV. APPELLATE AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULING

10 M/s Pioneer Bakers, Odisha [2021-TIOL-29-AAAR-GST] Date of order: 27th July, 2021

Restaurant is a place where food items are prepared and served to customers. A mere outlet where ready-to-eat items are sold across the counter cannot be considered as a restaurant

FACTS
The applicant is operating under the Brand name of ‘Go-Cool’ since the year 1997. They have established it as a brand in the field of bakery items, especially cakes. Their principal business is producing and selling of bakery products, viz., cakes, artisan cakes, pastries, pizza, patties, sandwiches, self-manufactured ice-creams, handmade chocolates, cookies, beverages, etc. They also offer a number of customisation options to customers with respect to the above products. The outlets are equipped with all the facilities to dine such as tables and chairs, air conditioner, drinking water, stylish lights for providing a nice ambience which provide an overall good experience to the customers.

The question before the Authority, whether supply of food items prepared at the premises of the applicant and supplied to the customers from the counter (with the facility to consume the same in the air-conditioned premises itself) is covered under restaurant services was answered in the affirmative. Aggrieved by the order, this appeal was filed.

HELD
The Authority noted that the meaning of restaurant is provided in the Cambridge Dictionary as a place where meals are prepared and served to the customer. The serving of the items to the customers for consuming the food in the premises is done for very few customers. Therefore, the establishment cannot be considered as a restaurant. It was stated that, in the instant case, it is a bakery outlet where ready-to-eat items are sold and a mere facility is provided to eat them in the shop itself. The applicant only prepares birthday cakes as per orders for take-out service and does not prepare birthday cakes immediately on the customer’s order. For those who want to consume it within the premises, they merely supply the readily available cakes. They do not serve food on the customer’s table and in most cases the items are sold only across the counter. Therefore, the applicant should not be considered as providing Restaurant Services.

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN GST

NOTIFICATIONS
Changes in Rules: Notification No. 32/2021-Central Tax dated 29th August, 2021
By the above Notification, the following changes have been effected in the CGST Rules, 2017:

(i) In case of companies a facility to upload returns, etc., by EVC was valid up to 31st August, 2021. With this Notification, the said facility is extended till 31st October, 2021. The facility will not be available from 1st November, 2021.
(ii) As per rule 138E of the CGST Rules, 2017 there are restrictions on furnishing of information in Part A of Form GST-EWB-01, if there is failure to file returns for two consecutive tax periods. However, in view of the pandemic, the above restriction was made non-applicable if the failure to file return was for the period February, 2020 to August, 2020 and the relaxation was operative up to 15th October, 2020. Now, by inserting a 5th proviso in the above rule, the said restriction is relaxed for the period from 1st May, 2021 to 18th August, 2021 in case where the return in Form GSTR3B or Form GSTR1 or GST-CMP-08 has not been filed for the period March, 2021 to May, 2021.
(iii) Certain changes have been made in Form GST-ASMT-14 (i.e., notice for assessment u/s 63). The notice now provides a reference number of the order cancelling registration. This will be useful for ready reference. The second change in the above form is to remove duplication of contents. And the third change is to incorporate the address of the issuing authority. This is also a good change so that the noticee can easily locate the officer.

Extension of amnesty regarding late fees: Notification No. 33/2021-Central Tax dated 29th August, 2021
By the earlier Notification dated 1st June, 2021 (details of which are given in the BCAJ issue of July, 2021) the Government has given relaxation in late fees for delayed filing of returns. The time limit for availing the above relaxation was up to 31st August, 2021. By the above Notification, the said time limit is extended up to 30th November, 2021.

Extension for filing revocation application: Notification No. 34/2021-Central Tax dated 29th August, 2021
Upon cancellation of registration, the affected person is allowed to file revocation application whereby he can apply for revocation of cancellation of registration. Such application is required to be filed within 30 days of cancellation of the registration order. By the above Notification, relaxation is given that if such cancellation is under section 29(2)(b) or (c) and if the time limit for filing revocation application falls between 1st March, 2020 and 31st August, 2021 then, such person can file revocation application till 30th September, 2021.

Under section 29(2)(b) the registration can be cancelled if there is failure to file returns by the composition person for three consecutive tax periods.

Under section 29(2)(c) the registration can be cancelled if there is failure to file returns by any registered person for a continuous period of six months.

The benefit of relaxation is given in the above cases only.

CIRCULARS

Clarification regarding extension of limitation for filing revocation application: Circular No. 158/14/2021-GST dated 6th September, 2021
The Government has given relaxation in filing revocation application as per Notification No. 34/2021-Central Tax dated 29th August, 2021, mentioned above. In respect of the above relaxation, the CBIC has issued the above Circular in which various clarifications covering various situations are given. The intention is that the affected person should get an opportunity to get his grievance of cancellation redressed by way of a revocation application.

Clarification on doubts related to scope of ‘Intermediary’ services: Circular No. 159/15/2021-GST dated 20th September, 2021

The Government has clarified the scope of Intermediary Services through the above Circular, issued after the GST Council meeting held on 17th September, 2021.

Clarification on certain issues: Circular No. 160/16/2021-GST dated 20th September, 2021
The above Circular has been issued to clarify certain issues in respect of
1. Time limit for availment of ITC in respect of Debit Notes to be considered with reference to the date of issuance of Debit Note, w.e.f. 1st January, 2021 [section 16(4)].
2. No necessity of carrying physical copy of Tax Invoice during journey in case where invoice has been generated in prescribed mode of e-invoice. [Rule 48(4).] Production of QR code, with embedded IRN, would suffice.
3. Applicability of restrictions imposed u/s 54(3) of the CGST Act for availment of refund of accumulated ITC, in case of export of certain goods.

Clarification relating to Export of Services: Circular No. 161/17/2021-GST dated 20th September, 2021
An important aspect related to Export of Services has been clarified through the above Circular. After a detailed analysis of legal provisions, the Circular concludes that ‘a company incorporated in India and a body corporate incorporated by or under the laws of a country outside India, which is also referred to as foreign company under Companies Act, are separate persons under the CGST Act, and thus are separate legal entities. Accordingly, these two separate persons would not be considered as “merely establishments of a distinct person in accordance with Explanation 1 in section 8”.’

Therefore, supply of services by a subsidiary / sister concern / group concern, etc., of a foreign company, which is incorporated in India under the Companies Act, 2013, may qualify for being considered as export of services, as it would not be treated as supply between merely establishments of distinct persons under Explanation 1 of section 8 of the IGST Act, 2017. Similarly, the supply from a company incorporated in India to its related establishments outside India, which are incorporated under the laws outside India, would not be treated as supply to merely establishments of distinct person under Explanation 1 of section 8 of the IGST Act, 2017. Such supplies, therefore, would qualify as ‘export of services’, subject to fulfilment of other conditions as provided under sub-section (6) of section 2 of the IGST Act.

ADVANCE RULINGS
(1) ITC – Eligibility for Solar Plant
M/s KLF Nirmal Industries Pvt. Ltd. (Order No. 19/ARA/2021 dated 18th June, 2021) (Tamil Nadu)

The facts are that the applicant is in the business of edible oil and has an extracting plant in the State of Tamil Nadu. For operating the plant, the applicant has got a solar plant installed in its factory. The supplier has considered the supply / installation of the solar plant as works contract.

It is positively confirmed that the electricity generated is only used for its captive consumption in the plant and nothing is given to outside agencies. To substantiate this fact, they have produced the memo issued by the Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd., wherein it is stated as under:

‘(13) At present, as per the Hon’ble TNERC’s Grid Connectivity and Intra-State Open Access Regulations, 2014, parallel operation charges (Rs. 15,000 per month per MW or part thereof as per TNERC Order No. 5 of 2019 dated 29th March, 2019) as fixed by the TNERC have to be paid by the generator. This charge is applicable as the generator is availing parallel operation with the grid for captive use of solar power without availing open access and it is subject to revision based on the TNERC order issued from time to time.’

The applicant also submitted that the solar plant is capitalised in their books in the category of ‘Plant and Machinery’ and also that no depreciation is claimed on the GST component.

Based on the above facts, the applicant has posed the following questions:

‘1. Whether the company is eligible to take input tax credit as inputs / capital goods or input services of the items listed in Appendix-A.
2. Whether the company is eligible to take input tax credit for inputs and services for running the solar plant.’

The AAR referred to the statutory provisions of sections 16 and 17 of the CGST Act and observed the requisites for getting ITC. He noted that the applicant fulfils the conditions of section 16 as it has tax invoice, it is for business, the goods are received, the tax charged is paid and the return is filed. There is no dispute about compliance of the above conditions.

Reference was also made to the provision of blocked credit in section 17(5)(c). The said section is also reproduced in the AR as under:

‘(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) of section 16 and sub-section (1) of section 18, input tax credit shall not be available in respect of the following, namely,
(c) works contract services when supplied for construction of an immovable property (other than plant and machinery) except where it is an input service for further supply of works contract service;
(d) goods or services or both received by a taxable person for construction of an immovable property (other than plant or machinery) on his own account including when such goods or services or both are used in the course or furtherance of business.
Explanation – For the purposes of this Chapter and Chapter VI, the expression “plant and machinery” means apparatus, equipment and machinery fixed to earth by foundation or structural support that are used for making outward supply of goods or services or both and includes such foundation and structural supports but excludes
(i) land, building or any other civil structures;
(ii) telecommunication towers; and
(iii) pipelines laid outside the factory premises.’

The AAR observed that the said section will not affect the case of the applicant because although the solar plant is a works contract and it is an immovable property, but still it is in the excluded category being ‘plant and machinery’.

There were other purchases in the block of plant and machinery. However, since it was not substantiated further, the AAR did not give any further ruling on the same.

Based on the above facts, the AAR held that the applicant is eligible to take ITC on the solar plant.

(2) Exemption – Registration
M/s Sachdeva College Ltd. (Advance Ruling No. HR/HAAR/2020-21/16 dated 23rd June, 2021) (Haryana AAR)

The applicant is a limited company incorporated under the Companies Act. It provides training to selected candidates sponsored by the Directorate of Welfare of Scheduled Caste and Backward Classes Department, Haryana (referred to as Directorate of Welfare).

There is an agreement with the Directorate of Welfare and the whole expenditure is borne by the Government.

Based on the above facts, the following questions were put before the AAR:

‘2. The questions framed in advance ruling application are:
2.1 To determine the liability to pay GST / IGST tax on training to students at the behest of the Directorate of Welfare of Scheduled Caste and Backward Classes Department, Haryana by the applicant under a training programme for which the total expenditure is borne by the State Government of Haryana which implements three types of schemes, i.e., State Scheme, Sharing basis, Centrally-sponsored Scheme, especially in view of Entry No. 72 of the Haryana Government Excise & Taxation Department Notification No. 47/ST-2 dated 30th June, 2017, and whether this Entry grants exemption of GST on the training of students by the petitioner?
2.2 Whether the applicant is liable to be registered under the State of Haryana under HGST / CGST in view of the facts and circumstances of the present case?’

The applicant is claiming exemption for fees received from the Directorate of Welfare. The Excise and Taxation Commissioner, Haryana has clarified that no GST is payable on schemes related to training as per Entry No. 72 of the Haryana Department vide Notification dated 30th June, 2017.

The AAR referred to the exemption entry in the Haryana SGST and CGST as under:

‘E. Following services have been exempted by Notification No. 47-ST-2 (HGST) Entry No. 72 of HGST; 09/2017 (IGST) Entry No. 75 of IGST; and 12/2017 (CGST) Entry No. 69 of CGST:

47-ST-2 (HGST) Entry No. 72 of HGST:
“Services provided to the Central Government, State Government, Union Territory Administration under any training programme for which total expenditure is borne by the Central Government, State Government, Union Territory Administration.”

09/2017 (IGST) Entry No. 75 of IGST:
“Services provided to the Central Government, State Government, Union Territory Administration under any training programme for which total expenditure is borne by the Central Government, State Government, Union Territory Administration.”

12/2017 (CGST) Entry No. 69 of CGST:
“Services provided to the Central Government, State Government, Union Territory Administration under any training programme for which total expenditure is borne by the Central Government, State Government, Union Territory Administration”.’

The meaning of ‘coaching’ as given in the Cambridge Dictionary was referred to, which defines coaching as under:
‘the job or activity of providing training for people or helping to prepare them for something.’

The AAR relied upon the clarification given by the Excise Commissioner to the Directorate of Welfare in which, with reference to the above Entry No. 72 in Notification No. 47/HGST dated 30th June, 2017, it is clarified that no tax is payable, the transaction being exempt under the above entry.

Accordingly, the AAR opined that no tax is payable on the above transactions.

Regarding the liability for registration, the AAR observed as under:

‘Further, section 23 of the Act provides that any person engaged exclusively in the business of supplying goods and services or both that are not liable to tax or fully exempt from tax under this Act or under the Integrated Goods and Service Tax Act… So the applicant is not liable for registration till he supplies goods and services or both that are not liable to tax or fully exempt from tax under the GST Acts.’

Thus, the AR decided in favour of the applicant.

(3) Exempt supply vis-à-vis local authorities
M/s CMS Engineering Concern (Advance Ruling No. 05/WBAAR/2021-22 dated 30th July, 2021) (WB AAR)

The applicant, M/s CMS Engineering Concern, is engaged in the operation of water pumps and safeguarding pumping machinery at various pump-houses in different districts of West Bengal for supply of drinking water to the public and hospitals upon receipt of a work order from the Directorate of Public Health Engineering, Government of West Bengal (hereinafter referred to as the PHE Directorate).

The applicant is of the opinion that he provides services to local authority, i.e., Panchayat and Municipality, whose powers and duties are described in Article 243G and Article 243W of the Constitution of India. The services are described in the Eleventh and Twelfth Schedule of the Constitution attached to Article 243G (Panchayat) and Article 243W (Municipality). Both of the said Schedules contain ‘Drinking water’ and ‘Water supply for domestic, industrial and commercial purposes’.

Therefore, according to the applicant, the services provided by him are pure services which do not involve any supply of goods. Further, such services are provided to a local authority by way of activity in relation to the function entrusted to the Panchayat under Article 243G or in relation to the function entrusted to the Municipality under Article 243W and therefore the services are exempt from taxation vide entry at serial number 3 of the Notification No. 1136 F.T. dated 28th June, 2017 of the WB SGST [corresponding Central Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 under CGST], as amended from time to time.

Based on the aforesaid nature of supply, the applicant has sought advance ruling on the question as to whether or not the services provided by him are exempt from GST.

The applicant referred to the advance ruling pronounced by the West Bengal AAR in the matter of Mahendra Roy (Case No. 35 of 2019-2019-VIL-288-AAR) where the applicant is stated to be providing conservancy / solid waste management service to the Conservancy Department of the Howrah Municipal Corporation. In this case, the AAR has held that the supply is exempt from the payment of GST under Sl. No. 3 of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017, as amended from time to time.

The Revenue objected that the services rendered by the applicant for supervision of electrical installation and operating and guarding of pumping machinery are supply of services in the form of works contract or job work. These supplies in no way are sovereign services of the Government. Therefore, it was submitted that the stated services could not be considered as services falling under the purview of Articles 243G and 243W of the Constitution.

The AAR referred to the Entry involved and reproduced the same as under:

Entry serial No. 3 of the Notification No. 1136 F.T. dated 28th June, 2017:

Sl.
No.

Chapter, Section, Heading, Group or Service Code
(Tariff)

Description
of Services

Rate
(per cent)

 

Condition

3

Chapter 99

Pure Services (excluding works

NIL

NIL

 

 

(continued)

contract service or other composite supplies involving supply of
any goods) provided to the Central Government, State Government or Union
Territory or Local Authority or a Governmental authority by way of any
activity in relation to any function entrusted to a Panchayat under Article
243G of the Constitution or in relation to any function entrusted to a
Municipality under article 243W of the Constitution

 

 

    

Based on the above entry, the issues to be decided were:
(i) whether the instant supply of services can be treated as pure services;
(ii) whether the applicant provides services to the Central Government, State Government or Union Territory or Local Authority or a Governmental authority; and
(iii) whether the said services are in relation to any function entrusted to a Panchayat under Article 243G or to a Municipality under Article 243W of the Constitution of India.

The AAR observed that pure services will mean supply of services which do not involve any supply of goods.

Although minute details of the work involved were not available, the AAR assumed that if it does not involve goods, it will not be works contract, as works contract takes place when goods are involved. Since there is no activity of treatment or process of goods, it cannot be job work also, observed the AAR.

The AAR also referred to the functions entrusted to the Panchayat and Municipality under Articles 243G / 243W by reproducing the Articles.

He found that the functions entrusted to a Panchayat or to a Municipality as listed in the Eleventh and / or Twelfth Schedule include the functions like drinking water or water supply for domestic, industrial and commercial purposes.

In view of the above, the AAR held that the services as provided by the applicant for operation of water-pump and safeguarding pumping machinery at various pump-houses in different districts for supply of drinking water is a matter listed in the Eleventh and / or Twelfth Schedule in relation to functions entrusted to a Panchayat under Article 243G and / or to a Municipality under Article 243W of the Constitution and accordingly held the supply as exempt.

(4) Maintainability of Advance Ruling application
M/s Sree Krishna Rice Mill (Advance Ruling No. 04/WBAAR/2021-22 dated 30th July, 2021) (WB AAR)

The applicant, Sree Krishna Rice Mill, has entered into agreements with State Government agencies for custom milling of paddy, i.e., production of rice on job work. In the execution of custom milling, the applicant has to collect / procure paddy from paddy storage centres (commonly known as Mandis) and thereafter transport it to its milling site. After milling of rice from the said procured paddy, the applicant delivers such milled rice from its milling site to the various delivery centres.

According to the applicant, milling charges and usage charges for packing of rice is a taxable supply on which tax is levied @ 5% (CGST @ 2.5% and SGST @ 2.5%). However, on the issue of the services of transportation of paddy / rice, the applicant is of the opinion that the transportation charges in relation to paddy / rice are exempt from payment of tax under Entry serial No. 21 of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017, being services provided by a goods transport agency by way of transport in a goods carriage of agricultural produce. The applicant further expressed his view that labour charges on procurement of paddy are not liable to tax under the GST Act.

Based on the aforesaid nature of supply, the applicant raised the following issues before the AAR:
(i) Whether transportation of raw paddy from the point of purchase to the rice mill is taxable or not;
(ii) Whether the reimbursement of Mandi labour charges is taxable or not.

The AAR discussed details of the above issues at great  length. However, he noted that at present investigation proceedings are pending related to custom milling of paddy. He referred to the 1st proviso to sub-section (2) of section 98 of the CGST Act which says that the AAR shall not admit an application where the question raised is already pending or decided in any proceedings in the case of an applicant under any of the provisions of this Act.

Although in the application uploaded on 31st March, 2021 a declaration is made that the questions raised in the application are not pending nor decided in any proceeding, the correct fact is that the applicant has been served with a notice dated 16th March, 2021 in connection with proceedings under the provisions of the GST Act and the questions raised in the instant application are related to the said proceedings.

Under the circumstances, the AAR denied any ruling on the application and disposed of it accordingly.

FROM PUBLISHED ACCOUNTS

Compiler’s Note:
In the financial sector, virtual currencies are the topic of discussion. Several companies across the world have embraced this new development and started accepting or investing in virtual currencies. Given below are illustrative disclosures in the financial statements of three companies in the US which have accepted virtual currencies as a mode of settlement of their trade transactions or are investing in the same.

MICROSTRATEGY INCORPORATED

Organisation
MicroStrategy pursues two corporate strategies in the operation of its business. One strategy is to grow our enterprise analytics software business and the other is to acquire and hold Bitcoin.

Digital assets
During the second half of 2020, the Company purchased an aggregate of $1.125 billion in digital assets, comprised solely of Bitcoin. The Company accounts for its digital assets as indefinite-lived intangible assets in accordance with Accounting Standards Codification (‘ASC’) 350, Intangibles-Goodwill and Other. The Company has ownership of and control over its Bitcoin and uses third-party custodial services at multiple locations that are geographically dispersed to store its Bitcoin. The Company’s digital assets are initially recorded at cost. Subsequently, they are measured at cost, net of any impairment losses incurred since acquisition.

The Company determines the fair value of its Bitcoin on a non-recurring basis in accordance with ASC 820, Fair Value Measurement, based on quoted (unadjusted) prices on the active exchange that the Company has determined is its principal market for Bitcoin (Level I inputs). The Company performs an analysis each quarter to identify whether events or changes in circumstances, principally decreases in the quoted (unadjusted) prices on the active exchange, indicate that it is more likely than not that any of the assets are impaired. In determining if an impairment has occurred, the Company considers the lowest price of one Bitcoin quoted on the active exchange at any time since acquiring the specific Bitcoin held by the Company. If the carrying value of a Bitcoin exceeds that lowest price, an impairment loss has occurred with respect to that Bitcoin in the amount equal to the difference between its carrying value and such lowest price.

Impairment losses are recognised as ‘Digital asset impairment losses’ in the Company’s Consolidated Statements of Operations in the period in which the impairment is identified. The impaired digital assets are written down to their fair value at the time of impairment and this new cost basis will not be adjusted upward for any subsequent increase in fair value. Gains (if any) are not recorded until realised upon sale, at which point they would be presented net of any impairment losses in the Company’s Consolidated Statements of Operations. In determining the gain to be recognised upon sale, the Company calculates the difference between the sales price and carrying value of the specific Bitcoins sold immediately prior to sale.

See Note 5, Digital Assets, to the Consolidated Financial Statements for further information regarding the Company’s purchases of digital assets.

Note 5: Digital Assets
During the year ended 31st December, 2020, the Company purchased approximately 70,469 Bitcoins for $1.125 billion in cash, including cash from the net proceeds related to the liquidation of short-term investments and the issuance of its convertible senior notes. During the year ended 31st December, 2020, the Company incurred $70.7 million of impairment losses on its Bitcoin. As of 31st December, 2020, the carrying value of the Company’s Bitcoin was $1.054 billion, which reflects cumulative impairments of $70.7 million. The carrying value represents the lowest fair value of the Bitcoins at any time since their acquisition. The Company did not sell any of its Bitcoins during the year ended 31st December, 2020.

SQUARE, INC.


Bitcoin Revenue
The Company offers its Cash App customers the ability to purchase Bitcoin, a cryptocurrency denominated asset, from the Company. The Company satisfies its performance obligation and records revenue when Bitcoin is transferred to the customer’s account. The Company purchases Bitcoin from private broker dealers or from Cash App customers and applies a small margin before selling it to its customers. The sale amounts received from customers are recorded as revenue on a gross basis and the associated Bitcoin cost as cost of revenues, as the Company is the principal in the Bitcoin sale transaction. The Company has concluded it is the principal because it controls the Bitcoin before delivery to the customers, it is primarily responsible for the delivery of the Bitcoin to the customers, it is exposed to risks arising from fluctuations of the market price of Bitcoin before delivery to the customers, and has discretion in setting prices charged to customers.

Investments in Bitcoin
Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency that is considered to be an indefinite lived intangible asset because Bitcoin lacks physical form and there is no limit to its useful life. Accordingly, Bitcoin is not subject to amortisation but is tested for impairment continuously to assess if it is more likely than not that it is impaired. The Company has concluded Bitcoin is traded in an active market where there are observable prices, a decline in the quoted price below cost is generally viewed as an impairment indicator, in which case the fair value is determined to assess whether an impairment loss should be recorded. If the fair value of Bitcoin decreases below the carrying value during the assessed period an impairment charge is recognised at that time. After an impairment loss is recognised, the adjusted carrying amount of Bitcoin becomes its new accounting basis. A subsequent reversal of a previously recognised impairment loss is prohibited until the sale of the asset. In the fourth quarter of 2020, the Company acquired $50 million of Bitcoin that it expects to hold as an investment for the foreseeable future. There was no impairment loss recorded on Bitcoin for the year ended 31st December, 2020.

Cost of revenue
Transaction-based costs
Transaction-based costs consist primarily of interchange and assessment fees, processing fees and bank settlement fees paid to third-party payment processors and financial institutions.

Subscription and services-based costs
Subscription and services-based costs consist primarily of caviar-related costs, which included processing fees, payments to third-party couriers for deliveries and the cost of equipment provided to sellers. Caviar-related costs for catered meals also included food costs and personnel costs. Subscriptions and services-based costs also included costs associated with Cash Card and Instant Deposit. The caviar business was sold in the fourth quarter of 2019.

Hardware costs
Hardware costs consist of all product costs associated with contactless and chip readers, chip card readers, Square Stand, Square Register, Square Terminal and third-party peripherals. Product costs consist of third-party manufacturing costs.

Bitcoin costs
Bitcoin cost of revenue comprises of the amounts the Company pays to purchase Bitcoin, which will fluctuate in line with the price of Bitcoin in the market.

Other costs
Other costs such as employee costs, rent and occupancy charges are generally not allocated to cost of revenue and are reflected in operating expenses.

TESLA, INC.
Investments
In January, 2021, we updated our investment policy to provide us with more flexibility to further diversify and maximise returns on our cash that is not required to maintain adequate operating liquidity. As part of the policy, we may invest a portion of such cash in certain specified alternative reserve assets. Thereafter, we invested an aggregate $1.50 billion in Bitcoin under this policy. Moreover, we expect to begin accepting Bitcoin as a form of payment for our products in the near future, subject to applicable laws and initially on a limited basis, which we may or may not liquidate upon receipt.

We will account for digital assets as indefinite-lived intangible assets in accordance with ASC 350, Intangibles-Goodwill and Other. The digital assets are initially recorded at cost and are subsequently re-measured on the consolidated balance sheet at cost, net of any impairment losses incurred since acquisition. We will perform an analysis each quarter to identify impairment. If the carrying value of the digital asset exceeds the fair value based on the lowest price quoted in the active exchanges during the period, we will recognise an impairment loss equal to the difference in the consolidated statement of operations.

The cost basis of the digital assets will not be adjusted upward for any subsequent increases in their quoted prices on the active exchanges. Gains (if any) will.

GLIMPSES OF SUPREME COURT RULINGS

1 South Indian Bank Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Income Tax [Appeal No. 9606 of 2011]

Civil Appeal No. 9606 of 2011; Civil Appeal No. 5610 of 2021 [Arising out of SLP (C) No. 32761 of 2018; Civil Appeal Nos. 9609, 9610, 9611, 9615, 9608, 9612, 9614, 9613, 9607 of 2011; and 3367 and 2963 of 2012

Date of order: 9th September, 2021

Disallowance of expenditure – Section 14A – Expenditure incurred in relation to incomes which are not includible in total income – Proportionate disallowance of interest is not warranted u/s 14A for investments made in tax-free bonds / securities (held as stock-in-trade) which yield tax-free dividend and interest to assessee banks in those situations where interest-free own funds available with the assessee exceeded their investments

1. The question of law that arose before the Supreme Court was on the interpretation of section 14A which reads as follows:

‘Whether proportionate disallowance of interest paid by the banks is called for under section 14A of Income-tax Act for investments made in tax-free bonds / securities which yield tax-free dividend and interest to assessee banks when the assessee had sufficient interest-free own funds which were more than the investments made?’

1.1 For convenience, the Supreme Court adverted to the facts from the Civil Appeal No. 9606 of 2011 (South Indian Bank Ltd. vs. CIT, Trichur) to decide the appeal.

The assessees were scheduled banks and in the course of their banking business they also engaged in the business of investments in bonds, securities and shares which earned them interests from such securities and bonds, as also dividend income on investments in shares of companies, and from units of UTI, etc., which were tax-free.

1.2 None of the assessee banks amongst the appellants maintained separate accounts for the investments made in bonds, securities and shares wherefrom the tax-free income is earned so that disallowances could be limited to the actual expenditure incurred by the assessee.

1.3 In the absence of separate accounts for investments which earned tax-free income, the A.O. made proportionate disallowance of interest attributable to the funds invested to earn tax-free income. The A.O. worked out proportionate disallowance by referring to the average cost of deposit for the relevant year. The CIT(A) had concurred with the A.O.’s view.
    
1.4 The ITAT in the assessee’s appeal against the CIT(A), considered the absence of separate identifiable funds utilised by the assessee for making investments in tax-free bonds and shares but found that the assessee bank was having indivisible business and considering their nature of business, the investments made in tax-free bonds and in shares would therefore be in the nature of stock-in-trade. The ITAT then noticed that the assessee bank was having surplus funds and reserves from which investments could be made. Accordingly, it accepted the assessee’s case that investments were not made out of interest- or cost-bearing funds alone. In consequence, it was held by the ITAT that disallowance u/s 14A was not warranted in the absence of the clear identity of the funds.

The decision of the ITAT was reversed by the Kerala High Court on acceptance of the contentions advanced by the Revenue in its appeal.

2. The appellants argued before the Supreme Court that the investments made in bonds and shares should be considered to have been made out of interest-free funds which were substantially more than the investment made and therefore the interest paid by the assessee on its deposits and other borrowings should not be considered to be expenditure incurred in relation to tax-free income on bonds and shares; and as a corollary, there should be no disallowance u/s 14A. On the other hand, the counsel for Revenue referred to the reasoning of the CIT(A) and of the High Court to project its case. The contention on behalf of the assessee was rejected by the CIT(A) as also by the High Court primarily on the ground that the assessee had not kept its interest-free funds in a separate account and as such had purchased the bonds / shares from a mixed account.

3. The Supreme Court noted that section 14A was introduced by the Finance Act, 2001 with retrospective effect from 1st April, 1962. The new section was inserted in the aftermath of the judgment of this Court in the case of Rajasthan State Warehousing Corporation vs. CIT [(2000) 242 ITR 450 (SC)]. The said section provided for disallowance of expenditure incurred by the assessee in relation to income which does not form part of its total income. As such, if the assessee incurs any expenditure for earning tax-free income such as interest paid for funds borrowed, for investment in any business which earns tax-free income, the assessee is disentitled to deduction of such interest or other expenditure. Although the provision was introduced retrospectively from 1st April, 1962, the retrospective effect was neutralised by a proviso introduced later by the Finance Act, 2002 with effect from 11th May, 2001 whereunder reassessment, rectification of assessment was prohibited for any assessment year up to the assessment year 2000-01 when the proviso was introduced, without making any disallowance u/s 14A. The earlier assessments were therefore permitted to attain finality. As such, the disallowance u/s 14A was intended to cover pending assessments and for the assessment years commencing from 2001-02.

3.1 The Supreme Court noted that in the present batch of appeals before it, it was concerned with disallowances made u/s 14A for the A.Ys. commencing from 2001-02 onwards or for pending assessments.

4. The Supreme Court noted several decisions wherein it was held that in a situation where the assessee has mixed funds (made up partly of interest-free funds and partly of interest-bearing funds) and payment is made out of such mixed fund, the investment must be considered to have been made out of the interest-free fund.

4.1 In Pr. CIT vs. Bombay Dyeing and Mfg. Co. Ltd. (ITA No. 1225 of 2015), the question whether the Tribunal was justified in deleting the disallowance u/s 80M on the presumption that when the funds available to the assessee were both interest-free and loans, the investments made would be out of the interest-free funds available with the assessee, provided the interest-free funds were sufficient to meet the investments, was answered in favour of the assessee. The resultant SLP of the Revenue challenging the Bombay High Court judgment was dismissed both on merit and on delay by this Court.

4.2 In Commissioner of Income Tax (Large Taxpayer Unit) vs. Reliance Industries Ltd. [(2019) 410 ITR 466 (SC)], a Division Bench of the Supreme Court held that where there is a finding of fact that interest-free funds available to assessee were sufficient to meet its investment, it will be presumed that investments were made from such interest-free funds.

4.3 In HDFC Bank Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax [(2016) 383 ITR 529 (Bom)], the assessee was a scheduled bank and the issue therein pertained to disallowance u/s 14A. In this case, the Bombay High Court, even while remanding the case back to the Tribunal for adjudicating afresh, observed (relying on its own previous judgment in the same assessee’s case for a different assessment year) that if the assessee possesses sufficient interest-free funds as against investment in tax-free securities, then there is a presumption that investment which has been made in tax-free securities has come out of interest-free funds available with the assessee. In such a situation, section 14A would not be applicable. Similar views were expressed by other High Courts in CIT vs. Suzlon Energy Ltd. [(2013) 354 ITR 630 (Guj)], CIT vs. Microlabs Ltd. [(2016) 383 ITR 490 (Karn)] and CIT vs. Max India Ltd. [(2016) 388 ITR 81 (P&H)].

4.4 On reading of these judgments, the Supreme Court was of the opinion that the High Courts had correctly interpreted the scope of section 14A in their decisions favouring the assessees.

4.4.1 According to the Supreme Court, applying the same logic, the disallowance would be legally impermissible for the investment made by the assessees in bonds / shares using interest-free funds u/s 14A. In other words, if investments in securities are made out of common funds and the assessee has available non-interest-bearing funds larger than the investments made in tax-free securities, then in such cases disallowance u/s 14A cannot be made.

4.4.2 The Supreme Court said that the decisions in S.A. Builders vs. CIT (2007) 1 SCC 781, where this Court ruled on the issue of disallowance in relation to funds lent to a sister concern out of mixed funds and which was pending consideration before the larger bench of this Court in SLP (C) No. 14729 of 2012 titled as Addl. CIT vs. Tulip Star Hotels Ltd., were distinguishable as the factual scenario was different and therefore the issue pending before the larger Bench had no bearing on the present matters. In that case, loans were extended to a sister concern, while here the assessee banks had invested in bonds / securities.

4.4.3 According to the Supreme Court, the High Court herein had endorsed the proportionate disallowance made by the A.O. u/s 14A to the extent of investments made in tax-free bonds / securities, primarily because a separate account was not maintained by the assessee. The Supreme Court in this context observed that there was no corresponding legal obligation upon the assessee to maintain separate accounts for different types of funds held by it. In the absence of any statutory provision which compels the assessee to maintain separate accounts for different types of funds, the Revenue’s contention could not be sustained.

5. The Supreme Court then adverted to Maxopp Investment Ltd. vs. CIT [(2018) 402 ITR 640 (SC)] which also dealt with the issue of disallowance u/s 14A in cases where investments were held as stock-in-trade and referred to some of its following observations:

(i) The purpose behind section 14A in not permitting deduction of the expenditure incurred in relation to income, which does not form part of total income, is to ensure that the assessee does not get double benefit. Once a particular income itself is not to be included in the total income and is exempted from tax, there is no reasonable basis for giving benefit of deduction of the expenditure incurred in earning such an income.

(ii) As per section 14A(1), deduction of that expenditure is not to be allowed which has been incurred by the assessee ‘in relation to income which does not form part of the total income under this Act’. Axiomatically, it is that expenditure alone which has been incurred in relation to the income which is includible in the total income that has to be disallowed. If an expenditure incurred has no causal connection with the exempted income, then such expenditure would obviously be treated as not related to the income that is exempted from tax and such expenditure would be allowed as business expenditure. To put it differently, such expenditure would then be considered as incurred in respect of other income which is to be treated as part of the total income.

(iii) It is to be kept in mind that in those cases where shares are held as stock-in-trade, it becomes a business activity of the assessee to deal in those shares as a business proposition. Whether dividend is earned or not becomes immaterial. In fact, it would be a quirk of fate that when the investee company declared dividend, those shares are held by the assessee, though the assessee has to ultimately trade those shares by selling them to earn profits. The situation here is, therefore, different from the case like Maxopp Investment Ltd. [Maxopp Investment Ltd. vs. CIT (2012) 347 ITR 272 (Del)] where the assessee would continue to hold those shares as it wants to retain control over the investee company. In that case, whenever dividend is declared by the investee company, that would necessarily be earned by the assessee and the assessee alone. Therefore, even at the time of investing into those shares, the assessee knows that it may generate dividend income as well, and as and when such dividend income is generated, that would be earned by the assessee. In contrast, where the shares are held as stock-in-trade, this may not necessarily be the situation. The main purpose is to liquidate those shares whenever the share price goes up in order to earn profits.

(iv) It will be in those cases where the assessee in his return has himself apportioned but the A.O. is not accepting the said apportionment. In that eventuality, it will have to record its satisfaction to this effect.

6. The Supreme Court thereafter referred to another important judgment dealing with section 14A disallowance, viz., Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Co. Ltd. vs. DCIT [(2017) 394 ITR 449(SC)]. Here, the assessee had access to adequate interest-free funds to make investments and the issue pertained to disallowance of expenditure incurred to earn dividend income, which was not forming part of the total income of the assessee. It was observed that for disallowance of expenditure incurred in earning an income it is a condition precedent that such income should not be includible in the total income of the assessee. The Supreme Court accordingly concluded that for attracting provisions of section 14A, the proof of fact regarding such expenditure being incurred for earning exempt income is necessary.

7. The Supreme Court proceeded further to examine yet another aspect of the matter. It noted that the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) had issued Circular No. 18 of 2015 dated 2nd November, 2015 which had analysed and explained that all shares and securities held by a bank which are not bought to maintain Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) are its stock-in-trade and not investments, and income arising out of those is attributable to the business of banking. This Circular came to be issued in the aftermath of CIT vs. Nawanshahar Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. [(2007) 160 Taxman 48 (SC)], wherein the Supreme Court had held that investments made by a banking concern is part of its banking business. Hence, the income earned through such investments would fall under the head Profits & Gains of business. The Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Pr. CIT vs. State Bank of Patiala [(2017) 393 ITR 476 (P&H)] while adverting to the CBDT Circular, concluded (correctly, according to the Supreme Court) that shares and securities held by a bank are stock-in-trade and all income received on such shares and securities must be considered to be business income. That is why section 14A would not be attracted to such income.

7.1 Reverting back to the situation, the Supreme Court observed that the Revenue in the present case was not contending that the assessee banks had held the securities for maintaining the SLR as mentioned in the Circular. In view of this position, when there was no finding that the investments of the assessee were of the related category, tax implication would not arise against the appellants from the said Circular.
    
8. The Supreme Court concluded that the proportionate disallowance of interest was not warranted u/s 14A for investments made in tax-free bonds / securities which yielded tax-free dividend and interest to the assessee banks in those situations where interest-free own funds available with the assessee exceeded their investments. The Supreme Court agreed with the view taken by the ITAT favouring the assessees.

8.1 The Supreme Court clarified that the above conclusion was arrived at because a nexus had not been established between expenditure disallowed and earning of exempt income. The respondents had failed to refer to any statutory provision which obligated the assessee to maintain separate accounts which might justify proportionate disallowance.

9. Finally, referring to the general expectations from tax policies / systems, the Supreme Court quoted the following words of Adam Smith in his seminal work, The Wealth of Nations:

‘The tax which each individual is bound to pay ought to be certain and not arbitrary. The time of payment, the manner of payment, the quantity to be paid ought all to be clear and plain to the contributor and to every other person.’

9.1 In the above context, the Supreme Court observed as under:

‘Echoing what was said by the 18th century economist, it needs to be observed here that in taxation regime, there is no room for presumption and nothing can be taken to be implied. The tax an individual or a corporate is required to pay is a matter of planning for a taxpayer and the Government should endeavour to keep it convenient and simple to achieve maximisation of compliance. Just as the Government does not wish for avoidance of tax, equally it is the responsibility of the regime to design a tax system for which a subject can budget and plan. If proper balance is achieved between these, unnecessary litigation can be avoided without compromising on generation of revenue.’

10. In view of the foregoing discussion, the Supreme Court answered the issue framed in these appeals against the Revenue and in favour of the assessees. The appeals by the assessees were accordingly allowed with no order on costs.

Notes:
(i) The judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Maxopp Investments Ltd. (the Maxopps case) considered in the above case [referred to in para 5 above] was analysed in the BCAJ in the column Closements in the months of January and February, 2018.
    
(i-a) After the judgment in the Maxopps case, a debate had started as to whether in case of securities held as stock-in-trade yielding exempt income, section 14A should apply or, in view of a specific para in the Maxopps case [reproduced in our above Closements at para 7.1.1], section 14A should not apply. This para is also largely referred in the above case at para 5(iii). Post Maxopps case, the trend in the decisions largely relied on the said para to take a view that in such cases section 14A should not be invoked for making proportionate disallowance of the interest, etc. The issue generally in these cases was the interpretation / implications of the said para in such cases. The said para is now considered as the key observation in the above case [i.e., the South Indian Bank Ltd. case] in adjudicating the issue of expenditure on securities held as stock-in-trade. This issue now gets finally settled with the above judgment in the South Indian Bank Ltd. case. Of course, in case of direct expenses incurred for exempt income, different consideration may apply.
    
(ii) In the above case, a common question has been decided in a set of appeals involving a few banks. The Kerala High Court had decided this issue against the assessee and the Apex Court considered the South Indian Bank Ltd. case [unreported] as a lead case and considered the facts of that case to decide the common issue. As such, the facts of the case are taken as available in the judgment of the Apex Court. Some of the other cases in appeal are also unreported. It seems that the above cases related to A.Y. 2001-02 up to A.Y. 2007-08 and in these cases the provisions of section 14A(2) [read with Rule 8D] and section 14A(3) [introduced and becoming effectively applicable from A.Y. 2008-09] were effectively not applicable either because of the prior assessment years involved or due to non-recording of a requisite satisfaction as envisaged in section 14A(2).
    
(ii-a) In the above case, a common question [referred to in para 1 above] considered by the Apex Court was whether proportionate disallowance of interest paid by the banks is permissible u/s 14A for investments made in securities (held as stock-in-trade) yielding exempt dividend / interest income where the assessees had sufficient interest-free own funds available which were more than such investments.
    
(ii-b) In the appeals before the Apex Court, it was an admitted fact that the assessees did not maintain separate accounts for interest-free own funds and other funds [mixed funds] for making such investments and the investments were made from the mixed funds. However, in all cases the interest-free funds available with the assessee were more than such investments. In such cases, the real issue was whether a presumption can be made that such investments under such circumstances are to be considered as made out of own interest-free funds available with the assessee (Presumption Theory). A majority of the High Courts had decided the issue in favour of the assessees by accepting the Presumption Theory. However, the Kerala High Court was of a different view and hence the above cases came up before the Apex Court in the cases of certain banks.

(iii) The issue of applicability of Presumption Theory in such cases was largely settled in the context of the provisions of 36(i)(iii) [Ref: Reliance Industries Ltd. (410 ITR 466) and Hero Cycles Pvt. Ltd. (379 ITR 347-SC)]. However, in the context of section 14A this was considered, more so by the Revenue, as pending for final view. This may be due to the fact that in the Reliance Industries case before the Apex Court, the issue relating to section 14A disallowance was not raised, although it was decided by the High Court. In the context of section 36(i)(iii), it is also worth noting that now in the above case, the Apex Court has approved the view taken by the Bombay High Court in the case of the HDFC Bank Ltd. case [referred to in para 4.3 above]. In this case, the Bombay High Court followed its earlier decision in the case of the same assessee [(2014) 366 ITR 505 (Bom)] wherein the High Court had applied its earlier decision in the case of Reliance Utilities and Power Ltd. [(2009) 313 ITR 340 (Bom)] in which the Presumption Theory was applied in the context of disallowance u/s 36(1)(iii). As such, the judgment of the Bombay High Court in the Reliance Utilities case should be also treated as impliedly approved on this Theory in the above case.

(iii-a) In view of the above judgment, now the applicability of Presumption Theory in such cases in favour of the assessees gets settled in the context of disallowance u/s 14A. The Court has specifically held that in the absence of any statutory provisions requiring the assessee to maintain separate accounts for different types of funds, this Presumption Theory is applicable. Effectively, the Court has accepted the assessee’s proposition that in respect of payment made out of the mixed fund, it is the assessee who has such right of appropriation and also the right to assert from what part of the fund a
particular investment is made, and it may not be permissible for the Revenue to make an estimation of a proportionate figure.

(iv) In the above case, the Apex Court was dealing with a specific issue referred to in para 1 above [and mentioned in above Note (ii-a)] and the Court has responded favourably to decide that disallowance of interest u/s 14A under such circumstances is unwarranted. The Court has also approved the interpretation of section 14A in the decisions of various High Courts taking similar view [as mentioned in paras 4.3 and 4.4 above] and disagreed with the view taken by the Kerala High Court on this issue. In the process, the Court has also made certain observations in the judgment. It is worth noting that it is settled principle of law that the judgment of the Court should be read as a whole and observations made therein should be considered in the light of the questions before the Court. The decision is binding authority only for what it actually decides and not from what may come to flow from some observations made therein [Ref: Sun Engineering Works (P) Ltd. (198 ITR 297 – SC); CIT vs. Sudhir J. Mulji (214 ITR 154 – Bombay High Court), etc.].

(v) In the above case, after concluding the question before the Court, the Court has also made certain significant general observations [referred to in paras 9 and 9.1 above] with regard to the tax system in the country and pointed out that it is the responsibility of the regime to design a system for which a subject can budget and plan to avoid unnecessary litigation. Even earlier, the Apex Court has made significant observations in such context in other cases (e.g., CIT vs. Arvind Narottam 173 ITR 479.) We only hope that one day the authority [which has the power to take remedial action] will appreciate such a desire coming from the highest court of the land and make the life of genuine taxpayers easy in this context. At the same time, to achieve this goal genuine efforts are also required by all other shareholders without which the common goal of certainty and substantial reduction in litigation does not seem to be feasible. Let us hope that this will happen in the near future with the joint efforts of all stakeholders.
    
(vi) Currently, the earlier available exemption in respect of long-term capital gain on transfer of shares as well as dividend income is done away with and major litigation for disallowance u/s 14A was due to these exemptions. In this scenario, the efficacy and impact of section 14A is substantially reduced and as such the above judgment would be of more use only in pending litigation for earlier years except for the entities like banks which continue to make such investments in tax-free securities yielding exempt interest income [and hold them as stock-in-trade] for certain reasons. As such, the practical utility of the above judgment will now be limited for the general taxpayers. Therefore, the instant euphoria created in some quarters on the implications of the judgment appears to be misplaced. In fact, this is the reason why it was thought fit by us to cover this judgment in this column instead of with a detailed analysis [like in the Maxopps case] in the column Closements.

Service Tax

I. TRIBUNAL

1 Neyveli Lignite Corporation Ltd. vs. CCE&ST [2021-128 taxmann.com-405-CESTAT-Chen] Date of order: 26th July, 2021

Liquidated damages recovered from the contractor cannot be said to be a consideration for agreeing to tolerate the act of the contractor of not completing the task within time schedule so as to attract the provisions of section 66E(e) of the Finance Act, 1994

FACTS
The issue before the Tribunal relates to the demand of service tax on liquidated damages recovered by the appellant for acts of default such as delayed or deficient supplies by various suppliers. The period involved in all the appeals is after 1st July, 2012 and the case set out by the Department is that the appellant had agreed to tolerate breach of timelines stipulated in the contract against the amount imposed as liquidated damages as consideration u/s 66E(e) of the Finance Act, 1994.

HELD
The Tribunal relied upon the decisions in the cases of South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. vs. CCE&ST [2021] 124 taxmann.com 174 (New Delhi-CESTAT) and M.P. Poorva Kshetra Vidyut Vitaran Co. Ltd. vs. Pr. Commissioner CGST & CE [2021] 126 taxmann.com 182 (New Delhi – CESTAT) and held that it is not possible to sustain the view taken by the Commissioner that since the contractor did not complete the task within the time schedule, the appellant agreed to tolerate the same for a consideration in the form of liquidated damages, which would be subjected to service tax u/s 66E(e) of the Finance Act. The appeal was accordingly allowed.

Note: A similar view is also taken by the Chennai Tribunal in the case of Steel Authority of India Ltd. vs. CCE [2021] 128 taxmann.com 400 (Chennai-CESTAT), order dated 26th July, 2021.

2 M/s Seaport Lines India Pvt. Ltd. vs. CGST&CE [2021-TIOL-574-CESTAT-Mad] Date of order: 7th September, 2021

A freight forwarder, when acting as a principal, will not be liable to pay service tax when the destination of the goods is from a place in India to a place outside India when there is a mark-up between the freight received and freight paid

FACTS
During verification of records of the assessee, it was noticed that they hire containers from different liners like Maersk and Hapag Lloyd and ‘sell’ these to their customers; that while arranging containers for shippers, the assessee collected ocean freight and local charges like terminal handling charges and documentation charges; and they also availed CENVAT credit on such charges and paid service tax on the invoice amount raised on customers. It was noticed that the assessee collected ocean freight charges higher than the actual amounts charged by shipping lines / steamer agents; however, they did not include the ocean freight charges collected in taxable value for the purpose of payment of Service Tax under business support services.

HELD
The Tribunal, relying on the decision in the case of M/s Marinetrans India Pvt. Ltd. [2020] (33) GSTL 241 (Tri-Hyd) held that buying and selling space on ships does not amount to rendering a service and any profit or income earned through such transactions is not liable to service tax. The demand was accordingly set aside.

3 M/s. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd vs. CCE&ST [2021-TIOL-551-CESTAT-Kol] Date of order: 25th August, 2021

A joint reading of section 67 of the Finance Act and Rule 3 of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006 clarifies that service tax is chargeable on the value of the service provided. Any other expenses incurred and reimbursed is not includible in the value for charge of service tax

FACTS
The appellant is a PSU and a 100% subsidiary company of Coal India Limited engaged in the business of mining and selling of coal. They receive security services under a Memorandum of Understanding from the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) and were discharging service tax under reverse charge. For the purpose of valuation, the amount paid to CISF towards cost of deployment, cost of arms and ammunition and cost of clothing items (uniforms), etc., was considered. In addition to the above, they were also providing facilities to CISF for free residential accommodation, free medical services to the CISF personnel at its premises, free vehicles / cabs to CISF personnel and reimbursement of expenditure on petty imprest expenses, medicines and telephones on actual submission of bills / invoices. The appellant has not included the value of the above facilities for payment of service tax on reverse charge basis.

HELD
The Tribunal, relying on the case of Central Industrial Security Force 2019-TIOL-3277-CESTAT-All where it has been held that expenses incurred towards medical services, vehicles, expenditure on dog squad, stationery expenses, telephone charges, expenditure incurred by service recipient for accommodation provided to CISF, are not includible as the same cannot be considered as consideration for providing security services.

FROM THE PRESIDENT

Dear BCAS Family,
The month of October commences with the 2nd day being celebrated as ‘Gandhi Jayanti’ in honour of the birth anniversary of the Father of the Nation, Mahatma Gandhiji. This year it will be his 152nd birth anniversary. He preached two major principles to be followed in life, viz., Ahimsa (non-violence) and Swaraj (freedom). To correlate these principles with our professional life, we have to be conscious of the fact that merely by not involving in physical violence and by taking our own decisions during professional commitments, do not mean that we are following the path of Ahimsa and Swaraj, respectively.

The true spirit of Ahimsa is to be aware during our professional journey of not being part of any deeds which are intended to hurt the well-being of some other person or the State. Similarly, Swaraj is attained by a professional when he advises or takes decisions without the fear of its consequences and in a thoroughly independent manner. To be on the path of these principles one has to make them the standpoints of one’s life and, more importantly, to stand by these standpoints.

For a professional who follows the path of these principles, I am reminded of the quote of my GURU Mahatria Ra:

Your work ethic is a true reflection of your character.
Hold yourself to the highest standards possible.

An eminent person and one of the most respected professionals, Padma Shri CA T.N. Manoharan, Past President of the ICAI, had once stated in an interview that he was transformed the most by reading My Experiments with Truth by Mahatma Gandhi.

Now I turn to the developments on the professional and economic fronts. Let me first discuss the good tidings of the strong rebound during the July-September quarter projected by Standard & Poors (S&P) based on the high frequency indicators after a steep contraction in activities in the previous quarter. It has retained GDP growth at 9.5% for the current fiscal. The capital markets are also exuding confidence in the future earnings of the listed corporates, by taking the Sensex past 60,000 and the Nifty almost touching 18,000. India as a preferred destination for foreign investments is also gathering steam and there is a continuous flow of FDI into the country.

On the professional front, there is the Consultation Paper released by the National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA) on Statutory Audit and Auditing Standards for Micro, Small and Medium Companies (MSMCs). It has sought the views of all the stakeholders on four issues relating to the auditing areas of MSMCs. Two of the issues I feel may need deliberations, viz., (i) exempting MSMCs meeting certain criteria and thresholds from statutory audit under the Companies Act, 2013, and (ii) the approach for estimating standard cost of audit computed by NFRA.

With due respect to the regulatory body NFRA, it is really disturbing of them to make sweeping remarks in the Consultation Paper while dealing with issues related to audit of MSMCs, such as ‘The inference that is inescapable is that such audit is (sic) being carried out is perhaps only a sham.’ And ‘In any event it is clear that such audit as is being carried out cannot boast of any quality at all.’ I feel such statements, even though in a Consultative Paper, should be avoided by the regulator since it depicts the profession of Chartered Accountancy and its foremost quality as auditors in bad light.

The regulator has also inferred that there may be lack of adequate accounting professionals with the companies which are not filing Annual Financial Statements (AFS) and MGT-7. Only 52.48% of the total number of active companies has filed its AFS and MGT-7 for the F.Y. 2018-19 as on June, 2021. Here I would like to state that another reason may be the inefficiency / unwillingness of the promoters and management of such companies for not complying with the regulatory requirements. To cast the entire onus and responsibility on the professionals without further research into the reasons for such non-compliances would be totally unjust.

Further, I feel the estimation of standard costs to carry out an audit as tabulated by NFRA will also require a lot of inputs from professionals who are into conducting audits. The efficiency of conducting audits has increased substantially with the assistance of the various audit softwares available and adopted by the auditing firms. I urge all the professionals to come forward and share their views on the Consultation Paper. BCAS will shortly send an email to collect comments from members. Further, we will deliberate within a group of professionals and give appropriate response as sought.

BCAS through its philanthropic arm the BCAS Foundation and the HRD Committee, has for several decades been undertaking a ‘Tree Plantation and Eye Camp’ in the remote tribal areas of Dharampur, Gujarat. This year, on 25th and 26th September, an enthusiastic group of 25 volunteers visited Pindval and with the assistance of the Sarvodaya Parivar Trust carried out tree plantation. There was a visit to an NGO ARCH, which is engaged in mother and child care services for the tribals at Nagaria, Dharampur. On the next day, the volunteers visited Sant Ranchhoddas Eye Hospital which along with the Dhanvantari Trust conducts cataract operations for the tribals and needy people at Vansda, Gujarat. The BCAS Foundation donated reasonable amounts to all the three NGOs.

The zeal and dedication of the persons involved at all the three NGOs was to be seen to be believed. Their experiments with social work would seem simple, but the circumstances and conditions under which they carry out the activities make the work exemplary. I can say that if you create anything which is simple but powerful, it will have value in this world. For the efforts of such mortals who have sacrificed the comforts for the larger goal of serving deprived human kind, I would end with a quote from my GURU Mahatria Ra:

The bullet that had left the gun cannot return to the gun. It has to hit the target.
A venture begun should be a venture accomplished.
Whether something is a stepping stone or a stumbling block depends on how you use it.
Go on. Go on. Do not halt. Do not stagnate. Endeavour continuously.
Don’t stop. Rest not. Go on. Keep going on.

Best Regards,
 

Abhay Mehta
President

Society News

LECTURE MEETING ON SPIRITUALITY IN PROFESSIONAL LIFE
On 12th July 2022, BCAS organised a hybrid lecture meeting on “Spirituality in Professional Life (for inner peace, self-sufficiency & abundance)” by Swami Swatmananda.

Key takeaways

What is Spirituality?
•    Not a way to look at certain things. It is a certain way to look at all things.
•    It is a Vision and not just Actions.

What kind of Vision is required to attain spirituality?
•    Vision of holistic growth and transformation through the mind and life management.

What is Success?
“Success is a tribute that life pays to excellence.” – Swami Chinmayanand

The formula for success is S-S = S+S. Here, S-S stands for Success without stress, and S+S stands for Skill and Strength.

To explain to the audience: How to invoke strength and spiritual knowledge, Swamiji used the Acronym “HIGHER”

[H]igh vision requires high inspiration.

•    A person who has a high vision and goal is likely to be highly inspired.
•    A perfect alignment of the three elements (body, mind & intellect) gives Result + Happiness. Their non-alignment results in emptiness.

[I]n-line with Swadharma and [I]n-line with Dharma: Helps us with inner Strength, Goodwill, and peace & harmony.

•    Swadharma
o    Inner peace and inner satisfaction should be prioritized.
o    Do what you love, love what you do.

•    Dharma
o    Dharma refers to Duty, Righteousness, Value, and Ethics.
o    Aspects of Dharma include Integrity, Honesty, and Prompt Execution.
o    Success should be dharmic and not with Adharma.

 [G]reater Fortitude

•    Higher the Goal, the greater will be the obstacles. Never lose hope and faith. Never give up.
•    Swamiji also explained the connection between yagna and teamwork.

o    Both yagna and team have the purpose of coming together for a greater cause and co-operative endeavour; contributing their best and its results benefit everyone.

o    Neither dependence nor independence but inter-dependence.
[H]igher Team

o    Swamiji explained the importance of results achieved with the consistent team work.

o    He asked the audience, What is family? Like wise, at work place also results are achieved through quality team work.

Working in silos would not yield any result.

[E]xcellence and [E]xpertise

Excellence + Expertise = Effectiveness

•    Where Excellence comes from Awareness and Expertise comes from Knowledge.
•    Effectiveness is the result of the application of Awareness and Knowledge.
•    Excellence comes from paying full attention to your work (3 hours of multitasking = 1 hour of focus).

 [R]esult

•    “Karma kiye jaa fal ki chinta mat kar” – Do best, leave rest.

Swamiji also discussed the importance of ‘mental health’ and explained how to conserve mental energy. The best way to live life is to have no regrets of the past and no anxiety about the future. Methods to keep up the mental strength: deep breathing, solving logical puzzles, counting backwards (like 50 to 1), do not ask ‘why’ ask ‘how’ and meditate.

Swamiji answered all the questions raised by the participants present physically as well as raised on the chat and Q&A box.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open-to-all to attend and participate. Missed the Lecture Meeting, but still interested in viewing the entire meeting video?

Visit the below link OR scan the below QR code with your phone camera:

Link : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FF9Qz9i9OzI


 

SEMINAR ON TAX AUDIT REPORTING

With numerous changes and nuances relating to Tax Audit, the Taxation Committee of the society organised a seminar on Intricate Issues relating to Tax Audit Reporting on 19th August, 2022, in hybrid mode. The seminar comprised of three sessions and was conducted in-person at BCAS office and simultaneous through the BCAS online hybrid learning platform.

CA Paresh Clerk explained the importance of documentation, various audit techniques and quality control while carrying out a tax audit. He also touched upon the various clauses of Form 3CD and explained the applicability of Form 3CA-3CB. He also replied to various queries raised by online and offline participants.

In the second session, CA Rutvik Sanghvi addressed the issue of reporting of Foreign Income and claiming foreign tax credits and filing various other important forms. He explained the reporting mechanism along with applicable rules in a very lucid manner. He shared his practical insights on a few issues faced by the participants.

In the last session, CA Vallabh Gokhale touched upon all the important clauses in the Form 3CD, including two new clauses relating to GAAR and GST applicable from F.Y. 2021-22. He explained both the new clauses in detail with various examples and gave his views on the likely issues which most of the assesses would face while filling up the said clauses.


BLOOD DONATION CAMP & DISCOUNTED HEALTH CAMP
As part of the Azadi ka Amrit Mahotsav celebrations, the BCAS Foundation, along with the SPR&MD Committee, organised a ‘Blood Donation Camp & Discounted Health Check-up Camp’ on 20th August 2022, at the Brahmakumaris’ GHRC BSES M G Hospital.

In the past, all such camps have been held at the BCAS office, and this was the first out-of-the-office venture specially targeted towards the Society members located in the western suburbs. The medical team at the hospital was ably led by Dr. Madhura Patkar, Medical Administrator. The hospital also made available attractive Discounted Check-Up Plans, and the opportunity to meet and seek medical advice from a wide range of consultants at an extremely nominal price, to the members, their families, and friends.

The spiritual culture that is deeply ingrained in the DNA of the hospital made the interaction a truly memorable experience.

WORKSHOP ON PROCESS AUTOMATION UNDER GST

The Indirect Taxation Committee of BCAS organised a half-day Workshop on Process Automation under GST on 10th September 2022, at Jolly Bhavan. The speakers were CA Jigar Doshi and CA Yash Goenka.

The workshop was directed at how to reduce the time involved in preparing GST Returns and other related compliances using Robotic Process Automation (RPA), a business process automation technology based on metaphorical software robots (bots) or on artificial intelligence.

Both the speakers took the participants through the entire process of preparing Macros and preparing a BoT by giving a live demo. They explained how the RPA tools allow data to be handled in and between multiple applications, for instance, receiving an email containing an invoice, extracting the data, and then typing that into a bookkeeping system. Their presentation covered Enterprise Modernization, developing a Macro, benefits of RPA solutions and using the same in resolving the problem statements in GST, live designing and development of a BOT together with preparation of Business Requirement Document (BRD) and User Requirement Specification (URS) including preparing a Flowchart enabling decision making in RPA.

Considering requests from members, the recording of the same will be put on Course Play for the benefit of those who could not attend. They can subscribe for the same and watch it at their convenience.

The workshop was very well received, and the participants requested a more detailed workshop on the same topic. Considering the same, the Committee has organized on similar workshop on the same with hands-on practical training on 19th November 2022.


FELICITATION OF YOUNG CAs OF MAY 2022 EXAMINATION
A special event was organised for the freshly qualified Chartered Accountants of the May 2022 final examination on 10th September 2022, at the BCAS Hall under the aegis of the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee.

The evening started with Convenor, CA Preeti Cherian, welcoming all the participants by acknowledging the fantastic performance of Mumbai finalists, and the presence of 14 rank holders in the house (including AIR 1 and AIR 4). This was followed by the address of the President, CA Mihir Sheth, who took the opportunity to reminisce about his days as a young Chartered Accountant, the sound advice he had received to associate with BCAS, and the benefits he had reaped from that. He briefed the audience on the various initiatives of the Society and invited them to be part of this vibrant organisation. Vice President, CA Chirag Doshi, addressed the audience and encouraged them to try new avenues and identify themselves with a mentor who would be able to guide them.

In his address, the Chairman of the SPR&MD Committee, CA Narayan Pasari, praised the Youth or Yuva Shakti, which forms an integral part of the numerous activities organised by the BCAS. He also appealed to the new CAs to become members and play an active role. While speaking about the Committee’s initiatives, he dwelled on the BCAS Referencer, Annual RRC, Mentor-Mentee Program, etc. He shared that the Season 2 announcement for the Mentor-Mentee Program (scheduled for Nov/ Dec 2022) would soon be rolled out and invited the participants to register at the earliest given the minimum available seats.

This was followed by the Fireside Chat with the three eminent speakers. CA Jayant Gokhale shared his three principles – (1) Understand and analyse the problem; (2) Be confident – do not fear failure and seek guidance from the right mentors; (3) Have empathy and understanding for your client. He advised the young hopefuls to allow themselves a year or two to explore and try out different things so that they could identify what is it that they would like to do. He suggested that they prepare a list of priorities and follow their passion.

CA Anand Bathiya shared his insights on critical choices between practice vs. employment, boutique vs. big firms, specialization vs. versatility and related quandary. Talking on secondary courses post-qualification, he emphasised on developing skillsets surrounding emerging technologies to build a tech edge. He also spoke on nuances of setting up a new practice and methodical approach towards practice management that can be followed.

CA Mudit Yadav gave the audience a refreshing perspective on the word ‘confusion’ – he reminded the audience that confusion is a privilege they enjoy because they have the resources, power and freedom (having passed one of the toughest exams in the world). Look at the first job as an experiment. If someone is working with a corporate and is wondering whether the practice is their calling, they may consider offering their weekends to a CA firm on a pro bono basis for six months to see for themselves.

This was then followed by the felicitation ceremony, with the 14 rankers being felicitated first and AIR 1, Meet Shah, and AIR 4, Akshat Jain, sharing their thoughts, followed by cake cutting by them. The rest of the achievers were also felicitated. The event showcased the vibrancy of the participants, many of whom showed great interest in signing up to be members of the BCAS.

The session is highly recommended for young professionals. Incase you missed it, but still interested in viewing the entire session video?

Visit the below link OR scan the below QR code with your phone camera:

Link : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdubHfRWygw

 

IESG MEETING – FREAKONOMICS

The International Economics Study Group of BCAS held a meeting on Freakonomics on 14th September 2022. Freakonomics is a ground-breaking collaboration between Levitt and an award-winning author and journalist, Stephen J. Dubner.

Through forceful storytelling and wry insight, Freakonomics shows that economics is, at root, how people get what they want or need, especially when other people want or need the same thing. Freakonomics challenges how we think all over again, exploring the hidden side of everything. There are 3 main themes: (1) Incentives, the issue of how we react to rewards and punishments, (2) Information asymmetry, and what consequences arise from various gaps of knowledge and how we try to compensate for those, and (3) Causation vs. correlation and how we often try to explain things the wrong way.

CA Naushad Panjwani, Past President of BCAS, shared his thoughts on incidents such as playschools, parenting, real estate agents and elections. Authors have attempted to apply established principles of microeconomics to common phenomenon and from the additional spectrum of Philosophy and Spirituality. He also shared his thoughts with real life examples about how incentives work with doctors, lawyers, accountants, mechanics, real estate agents and correlation with crimes. He took to the participants through the partitions of India and Pakistan, Korea, Israel and Palestine, all of which had a correlation to economics. The last 1,000 years witnessed control through conquer, colonization, compete, and cartels, the future could be conflicts and collaboration.

Miscellanea

I. ECONOMY – US MARKETS

20 Banks head into a perfect storm – A repeat of the 2008-09 Crisis?

After enjoying a couple of years of tailwinds, U.S. banks are heading into a perfect storm, fueled by a collapse in mortgage originations and an inverted yield as interest rates rise. And it will squeeze both bank revenues and earnings.

A Collapse in Mortgage Originations

Mortgage originations are a big business for traditional banks. They allow them to collect origination fees, discount points, closing costs and loan service fees, which boost their top and bottom lines.

But mortgage originations are susceptible to interest rate fluctuations. They rise as interest rates fall and drop as interest rates rise. For instance, in 2020, when the 30-year mortgage rate declined to a record low of 2.80%, mortgage originations soared from $601 billion to $1.36 trillion. But mortgage originations have recently collapsed to $677 billion, as mortgage rates climbed to 6.43%. And the worst may have yet to come as new and existing home sales are plunging, and homeowners see no reason to refinance loans at higher mortgage rates.

Then there’s the inverting of the yield curve, which makes matters worse.

Inverted Yield Curve

A rising interest environment is usually good for banks, provided that long-term interest rates rise faster than short-term interest rates, resulting in a normal yield curve. That’s mainly the case in a growing economy and benefits banks in two ways. One, it boosts loan demand, bringing to the cash register the usual mortgage fees associated with new mortgage originations and servicing. And two, it allows banks to collect a positive “spread.” That’s the difference between the short-term rates they pay depositors and the long-term rates they charge mortgage borrowers or collect from investing these deposits in Treasury bonds with long maturity — a measure of bank profitability.

But a rising interest rate environment can be bad for banks if long-term interest rates rise at a slower pace than the short-term rates, resulting in an inverted yield curve, as has been the case in the U.S. in recent months. Last week, for instance, the 30-year U.S. Treasury bond traded with a yield of 3.60%, well below the 4.20% of the two-year bond.

An inverted yield curve is usually a sign of an impending recession and hurts banks by lowering the demand for loans and turning the interest rate spread negative.

Dean Kaplan, president of The Kaplan Group, a commercial collection agency, thinks that this combination of collapsing mortgages and an inverted yield curve push banks into a perfect storm. “With inflation caused by events beyond anyone’s control (Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and persistent supply chain issues related to the pandemic), central banks are compelled to raise interest rates and cut back on liquidity efforts,” he told International Business Times in an email. “Financial institutions already see reduced mortgage demand due to higher rates, and many have changed requirements for extending new credit. But, with all the volatility, once credit contraction gets started, it can be a downward spiral that is difficult to stop.”

Shmuel Shayowitz, president and chief lending officer at Approved Funding, is seeing some similarities between now and 2008. “From a consumer end, they probably won’t bear the brunt of what they saw in 2008,” he told IBT. “Instead, banks face a perfect storm of liquidity constraints, business slowdown, and a weak economic outlook.”

[Source: International Business Times – By Panos Mourdoukoutas, Ph.D. – 26th September, 2022.]

21 What the end of free money means for investing in financial assets?

The era of free money is over. Money has a “price again,” a positive interest rate that borrowers must pay to lenders. And that brings back the old game on Wall Street when investors purchased financial assets based on fundamentals rather than on a narrative.

For years, central bankers printed money like there was no tomorrow, driving short-term and long-term interest rates near zero. That’s thanks to the “disappearance of inflation,” which allowed them to focus on pursuing maximum employment rather than price stability.

While easy money has helped central bankers to get close to the elusive goal of maximum employment, it had a “side effect,” most pronounced during the COVID pandemic. It fueled a speculative frenzy on Wall Street, which distorted capital allocation, according to Patrick Wells, Portfolio manager & CFA at Pinnacle Associates.

“One hallmark of the COVID bull market was indiscriminate buying across the riskiest companies with unproven business models,” he told International Business Times.

Bryan Shipley, CFA, CAIA, Co-CEO, Chief Investment Officer, Managing Principal, and Senior Investment Advisor, agrees. He thinks that low borrowing costs have made it possible for investors to expect double-digit returns on speculative assets like commodities, real estate, and cryptocurrencies.

“As a result, they had to rush to put their money into work for fear of missing out on that growth,” he told IBT.

In the last year, the economic situation has changed. Inflation has appeared again, reaching a 40-year high in some countries. And that has forced central banks to end the era of easy money by hiking interest rates. For instance, in the last six months, the Federal Reserve has raised interest rates several times, bringing the Federal Funds rate to 3.25%, up from 0.25% a year ago.

In addition, the Fed has begun to unload its Treasury Bonds and Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS), pushing Treasury bond yields and mortgage rates higher. For instance, the 10year Treasury bond yielding 0.55% in 2020 is now paying 3.60%. Likewise, the 30 year mortgage rate, which in 2020 stood at 2.90%, is now over 6%.

Rising interest rates have made money costly again, bringing back the old game on Wall Street. As a result, investors now have to pay attention to the economic fundamentals of different assets, like the companies’ business model behind equity shares, their revenues, earnings, free cash flow, and leverage rates.

“A rising tide lifts all boats, even those that aren’t very seaworthy,” Robert R. Johnson, Ph.D., CFA, CAIA, Professor of Finance, Heider College of Business, Creighton University, told IBT. “The end of free money means that investors are becoming more discerning and demand that potential investments have a sustainable business model and are cash flow positive or have a path to being so.”

Johnson further thinks that under the free money regime, many assets were trading on a narrative rather than on fundamentals, as investors had no viable alternatives in money market funds and bonds, which paid tiny yields. But the situation is changing with bond and money market yields rising for the first time in years. Moreover, speculative assets lead the correction in financial markets, as seen in the significant declines in cryptocurrency markets and small tech shares in NASDAQ.

[Source: International Business Times – By Panos Mourdoukoutas, Ph.D. – 24th September, 2022.]


II. SPORTS

22 FIFA to introduce SAOT technology at Qatar World Cup to help referees

FIFA announced on 1 July 2022 that semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) will be used at the 2022 World Cup in Qatar to enable referees to make faster, more accurate offside decisions at the world’s biggest football gala.

“At the FIFA World Cup in 2018, FIFA took the brave step to use Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology. Semi-automated offside technology is an evolution of the VAR systems that have been implemented across the world,” the world football governing body president Gianni Infantino noted, saying that SAOT will provide the very best for the teams, players and fans who will be heading to Qatar in November this year.

According to the FIFA statement, the SAOT system uses 12 dedicated tracking cameras mounted underneath the roof of the stadium to track the ball and up to 29 data points of each individual player, 50 times per second, calculating their exact position on the pitch, while the sensor positioned in centre of the tournament’s official match ball “Al Rihla” sends data 500 times per second, allowing a very precise detection of the kick point.

The data collected by cameras and the ball sensor will be processed by artificial intelligence within a few seconds to check the offside situation. Once an offside position is detected, the SAOT system will provide an automated offside alert to the video match officials team, reports Xinhua.

After the decision has been confirmed by the VAR and the referee on the pitch, the SAOT will then generate a 3D animation to be displayed on the giant screens in the stadium and on TV, which gives the best possible perspectives for an offside situation.

FIFA Director of Football Technology & Innovation Johannes Holzmuller said that the new technology has been successfully trialed at numerous test events including the FIFA Arab Cup 2021 and the FIFA Club World Cup 2021.

“During the tests, the average VAR offside check time has reduced from 70 seconds to 25 seconds, and the 3D animation could improve a better communications with fans,” he revealed in the online press conference.

“VAR has already had a very positive impact on football and we can see that the number of major mistakes has already been dramatically reduced. We expect that semi-automated offside technology can take us a step further. We will have a very valuable support tool to help referees and assistant referees make the best and most correct decision on the field of play,” Pierluigi Collina, chairman of the FIFA Referees Committee, said of the technology.

Collina pointed out that the SAOT is still limited and noted that “the referees and the assistant referees are still responsible for the decision on the field of play,” Collina added.

[Source: International Business Times – By IANS – 2nd July, 2022.]


Regulatory Referencer

DIRECT TAX

1.    Income-tax (26th Amendment) Rules, 2022:
Rule 40G inserted and Form 29D prescribed for filing refund claim u/s 239A of the tax deducted and paid to the credit of Central Government u/s 195. [Notification No. 98/ 2022 dated 17th August, 2022.]

2.    Applicability of Section 206C (1G):  Provisions of section 206C(1G), pertaining to tax collection at source at five per cent of the tour program package, shall not apply to a person (being a buyer) who is a non-resident in India as per section 6 of the Act and who does not have a Permanent Establishment in India. [Notification No. 99/ 2022 dated 17th August, 2022.]

3.    Income-tax (27th Amendment) Rules, 2022:
The due date to furnish Form 67 for claiming a foreign tax credit, was on or before the due date for furnishing the original return. The due date is now extended to ‘on or before the end of the assessment year, relevant to the previous year in which the foreign income has been taxed in India and the return for such assessment year has been furnished within the time specified u/s 139(1) or 139(4)’. In the case of an updated return, the time limit to file Form 67 is before filing the return. [Notification No. 100/ 2022 dated 18th August, 2022.]

4.    Additional Guidelines for removal of difficulties under sub-section (2) of section 194R:
The Finance Act 2022 inserted a new section 194R w.e.f. 1st July, 2022. The said section requires a person responsible for providing any benefit or perquisite to a resident to deduct tax at source at 10% of the value or aggregate of the value of such benefit or perquisite. The CBDT had issued guidelines for deduction of tax under the said section vide Circular No. 12/2022 dated 16th June, 2022 and has now issued additional guidelines to provide clarification on issues which will help to remove difficulties in implementation of section 194R. [Circular No. 18/2022 dated 13th September, 2022.]

COMPANY LAW

I. COMPANIES ACT

1.    Incorporation Rules amended: MCA has notified the Companies (Incorporation) Third Amendment Rules, 2022. A new rule 25B has been inserted prescribing the manner of physical verification of a Company’s registered office. Under this rule, the physical verification of a Company’s registered office shall be conducted by ROC in the presence of two independent witnesses of the locality where the Company’s registered office is situated. Further, if required, ROC can also seek the assistance of the local Police for such verification. [Notification No. G.S.R. 643(E) dated 18th August, 2022.]

2.    Forms STK-1, STK-5, and STK-5A amended:
MCA has amended Form STK-1, Form STK-5, and Form STK-5A.  Now, ROC can issue notice for removal of the name of a Company if it finds that it is not carrying any business or operation from the registered office as revealed during the physical verification of its registered office carried out u/s 12(9). Accordingly, Form STK-5 and Form STK 5A (i.e., Public Notice by ROC) have also been changed. [Notification No. G.S.R. 658(E), dated 24th August, 2022.]

3.    E forms DPT-3 and DPT-4 revised seeking enhanced disclosures on acceptance of deposits: The Government has modified the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 2014. As per the amended rules, the auditor must submit a declaration regarding deposits with E-form DPT-3. Further, the formats of DPT-3 and DPT-4 have been revised. The enhanced disclosures are to be made in the revised forms. [Notification dated 24th August, 2022.]

4.    Revised forms for Director’s KYC notified:
The government has substituted existing DIR-3 KYC and DIR-3-KYC web forms with new DIR-3 KYC and DIR-3-KYC web forms to align the same with MCA’s new portal. A new entry has been inserted in the form capturing the ‘jurisdictional police station’ in the address details of directors. [Notification No. GSR 662(E), dated 29th August, 2022.]


II. SEBI

5.    Conditions for investment in overseas investee companies by AIF/VCFs: SEBI has specified various conditions for investment in overseas investee companies by Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) and Venture Capital Funds (VCFs). The AIFs/VCFs shall file an application to SEBI for allocation of overseas investment limit in the format as specified. The requirement of the overseas investee company to have an Indian connection has been omitted. AIFs/VCFs shall furnish the sale/divestment details to SEBI within 3 working days of the disinvestment. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/AFD-1/POD/CIR/P/2022/108, dated 17th August, 2022.]

6.    In case of death of Karta of HUF, his name will be replaced by new Karta in the Beneficial Owner account:
SEBI has modified the norms w.r.t opening of Demat account in case of HUF. As per the amended norms in case of death of HUF’s Karta, the name of the deceased Karta in the Beneficial Owner (BO) account shall be replaced by the new Karta of the HUF who shall be the eldest coparcener in the HUF or a coparcener who is appointed as Karta by an agreement entered between all the coparceners of the HUF. Earlier, the new Karta was appointed by HUF’s members who shall be the senior most member of the family. [Circular No. SEBI/HO/MRD/MRD-POD-2/P/CIR/2022/114, dated 26th August, 2022.]

FEMA

1.    Restrictions on LRS Funds brought in: The Liberalised Remittance Scheme allows for the remitter to retain and reinvest the income earned on the investments made through the LRS funds. The RBI has amended Master Direction – Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS) stating that the received, realised, unspent or unused foreign exchange unless reinvested, shall be repatriated and surrendered to an authorised person within 180 days from the date of such receipt, realisation,  purchase or acquisition or date of return to India, as the case may be. RBI has stated that this amendment has been brought in to bring the provisions in accordance with Regulation 7 of ‘Realisation, repatriation and surrender of foreign exchange’ Regulations, 2015 [Notification No. FEMA 9(R)/2015-RB]. It should be noted that the amendment has been directly made in the Master Direction without any notification or circular being issued on the same. This amendment is apart from the changes made on 22nd August, 2022 as a consequence of notification of the new Overseas Investment Rules. [Amendment made on 24th August, 2022 in para 16 of Master Direction – Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS) [FED Master Direction No. 7/2015-16]]

2.    ‘Alert List’ of entities not authorised to deal in forex:
RBI has time and again warned the public not to trade in forex transactions on unauthorised electronic trading platforms (ETPs) or remit money for the same. As queries were being received for specific ETPs, RBI has decided to place an ‘Alert List’ on its website of entities which are neither authorised to deal in forex nor authorised to operate ETPs for forex transactions. RBI has mentioned that the Alert List is not exhaustive; and covers entities and ETPs known to RBI at the time of issuing this Press Release. An entity not appearing in the Alert List should not be assumed to be authorised by the RBI. The authorisation status of any person / ETP can be ascertained from the list of authorised persons and authorised ETPs, which are already made available in the RBI website. RBI has reiterated that residents undertaking forex transactions for purposes other than those permitted under the FEMA or on unauthorised ETPs shall be violating FEMA. [Press Release 2022-23/835, dated 7th September, 2022.]

ICAI ANNOUNCEMENTS

1. External confirmations through third-party vendors: In view of concerns regarding some banks using the services of third-party vendors to provide confirmations on their behalf to auditors that lead to the risk that such information may not be authentic and complete, the ICAI has advised auditors to seek direct confirmation from concerned banks. [7th September, 2022.]

2. Mandatory evaluation of audit quality maturity of firms using AQMM Rev v1.0:
Effective 1st April, 2023, firms auditing a listed entity, or a bank other than a co-operative bank (except multi-state co-operative banks), or an insurance company are mandatorily required to undertake an evaluation of their audit quality maturity using the Audit Quality Maturity Model Revised Version 1.0 (AQMM Rev v1.0). Firms conducting only branch audits are excluded from this mandate. [13th September, 2022.]

Corporate Law Corner Part A : Company Law

10 Onn Chits Private Ltd.
Roc/2021/Onn Chits/Penalty Order/6324-6327
Office of the Registrar of Companies, NCT of Delhi & Haryana
Adjudication order
Date of order: 2nd November, 2021

Order for Penalty u/s 454 for violation of section 12(1) r.w.s. 12(4) of the Companies Act, 2013

FACTS

M/s OCPL has its registered address at Faridabad, Haryana.

RoC had received a letter from the Registrar of Chit Fund, New Delhi (RCF) dated 10th June, 2020 as a complaint received from Sajneev Hinanandani against M/s OCPL stating that M/s OCPL was not maintaining its registered office. The Complaint Cell referred the matter to Adjudication Cell for initiation of action u/s 12 of the Companies Act, 2013, against M/s OCPL and its officers in default, which attracted the violation of section 12(1) and the provision of section 12(8) of the Companies Act, 2013.

Thereafter, RCF issued a Show Cause Notice u/s 12(8) dated 10th December, 2020 to M/s OCPL and its officers in default. No reply was received from M/s OCPL or its representative against the SCN issued by RCF on 10th December, 2020. Notice of Inquiry was sent vide notice dated 31st August, 2021 fixing date of hearing on 20th September, 2021 before the Adjudicating Officer.

An e-mail was received on 20th September, 2021 from FCA  Anurag Kapoor requesting for grant of some time. An e-mail was sent to M/s OCPL wherein the date of hearing was fixed on 29th September, 2021 by the Adjudicating Officer.

On 29th September, 2021, Navneet Bhutan (Mr. NB), authorized representative, appeared before the Adjudicating Officer and period of default was fixed i.e., from 24th July, 2019 to 4th September, 2019, and was directed to bring the relevant
documents on next date of hearing i.e., on 13th October, 2021.

Extracts of sections 12(1), 12(4) And 12(8)
Section 12(1) –
A company shall, on and from the fifteenth day of its incorporation and at all times thereafter, have a registered office capable of receiving and acknowledging all communications and notice as may be addressed to it.

Section 12(4) – Notice of every change of the situation of the registered office, verified in the manner prescribed, after the date of incorporation of the company, shall be given to the Registrar within fifteen days of the change, who shall record the same.

Section 12(8) – If any default is made in complying with the requirements of this section, the company and every officer who is in default shall be liable to a penalty of one thousand rupees for every day during which the default continues but not exceeding one lakh rupees.

Factors to be taken into account by the Adjudicating Officer

While adjudging quantum of penalty u/s 12(8) of the Act, the Adjudicating Officer shall have due regard to the following factors, namely:

a.    The amount of disproportionate gain or unfair advantage, wherever quantifiable, made as a result of default.

b.    The amount of loss caused to an investor or group of investors as a result of the default.

c. The repetitive nature of default.

With regard to the above factors to be considered while determining the quantum of penalty, it was noted that the disproportionate gain or unfair advantage made by M/s OCPL and its officers in default or loss caused to the investor as a result of the delay on the part of M/s OCPL and its officers in default to redress the investor grievance were not available on record. Further, it was difficult to quantify the unfair advantage made by M/s OCPL and its officers in default or the loss caused to the investors in a default of this nature.

HELD

Having considered the facts and circumstances of the case and after taking into account the factors and as per documents submitted by Mr. NB, penalty amount of Rs. 43,000 each on M/s OCPL and its officers in default was imposed by the Adjudicating Officer, and thus a total penalty of Rs. 1,39,000 was levied for the period of default from 24th July, 2019 to 4th September, 2019 (default of non-maintenance of registered office admitted before the Adjudicating Officer on date of hearing).

Allied Laws

30 Anurag Padmesh Gupta vs. Bank of India
AIR 2022 Bombay 3751
Date of order: 7th June, 2022
Bench: A.S. Chandurkarand & Amit Borkar JJ.

Fundamental Rights – Powers to Debt Recovery Tribunal – No power to restrain individual from travelling abroad [Art. 19, 21, Constitution of India; S. 19, 22, 25, Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993]

FACTS

The petition raised an important issue regarding the interpretation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India as to whether the expression “personal liberty” occurring in the said Article includes the right to travel abroad. Second important question that arose was whether the order passed by the Debt Recovery Tribunal refusing to grant permission to travel abroad results in the infringement of Article 21 of the Constitution of India?

HELD

If the right to travel is a part of the personal liberty of a person, he cannot be deprived of his right except according to the procedure established by law. The right to travel abroad is a right distinct and separate from the right of freedom of movement in a foreign country. The right to travel abroad by its necessary implications means the right to leave the home country and visit a foreign country. The right to travel abroad has been spelt out from the expression “personal liberty” in Article 21 of the Constitution.

Further held, the Tribunal, while exercising the powers of a Civil Court adjudicating money suit, is limited to the extent of passing interim order by way of injunction or stay which are expressly conferred on it. The Tribunal can travel beyond the powers conferred by the Code of Civil Procedure with a view to observe the principle of natural justice. In our view, Section 22 of the Act confers the procedural right to regulate proceedings before it. In the absence of a specific provision conferred on the Debt Recovery Tribunal by statute, the Debt Recovery Tribunal does not have power to restrain a citizen from travelling abroad, particularly when the said right has been recognized as a facet of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

Petition is allowed.

31 Ayan Kumar Das and another vs. UOI & others
AIR 2022 Gauhati 120
Date of order: 6th April, 2022
Bench: Devashis Baruah JJ.

Appointment of Guardian – Mother of the Petitioner in comatose state – Petitioner appointed as a guardian to deal with the properties of his mother. [Art. 226, Constitution of India]

FACTS

The question that arose for consideration was as to whether in law and on facts the petitioner could be appointed as the guardian of the mother who is in ‘persistent vegetative state’ and ‘coma’ for managing her properties so as to meet medical expenses.

HELD

Article 226 of the Constitution empowers this Court to pass suitable orders on an application being filed to appoint a guardian or a next friend to an incompetent person like the petitioners’ mother who is in persistent vegetative state. In absence of any appropriate legislation, the High Court in exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, can issue guidelines as temporary measures till the field is taken over by a proper legislation for appointment of guardian to a person lying in a comatose state or a vegetative state. Accordingly, on the basis of the materials on record, the Court was of the view that the reliefs sought for by the petitioners were reasonable and may be granted considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case. However, to ensure that the order of this Court is followed in letter and spirit and there is no breach thereof, it is also essential that there should be some kind of monitoring of the functioning of the guardian though for a limited duration to ensure that guardianship is being used for the benefit of the person who is in a vegetative state and such monitoring be carried out through the forum of the Assam State Legal Services Authority constituted under the Legal Services Authority Act, 1987.    

Petition was allowed.    
 

32 State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Sita Ram Sharma
AIR 2022 Himachal Pradesh 120
Date of order: 30th March, 2022
Bench: Mohammad Rafiq CJ & Ajay Mohan Goel & Sandeep Sharma JJ.

Constitutional Rights – Right to property – Unless land is voluntarily surrendered – the landowner is entitled to compensation [Art. 300A, Constitution of India]
 
FACTS

The matter has been referred to a larger bench on account of conflict of opinion between judgements. The question before the larger bench is whether a person(s) whose land(s) has been utilised for construction of road under ‘PMGSY’ is entitled to compensation?
    
HELD
Even after the right of property enshrined under Article 19(I)(f) was deleted by the 44th amendment to the Constitution, Article 300A still retains the right to property as the constitutional as well as legal right, and mandates that no person can be deprived of his property except by authority in law. The action of the State in dispossessing a citizen of his private property, without following the due process of law, would be violative of Article 300A of the Constitution of India, as also negate his human right. Thus, the right to property has  been acknowledged, not only constitutional as well as statutory, but also human right, to be construed in the realm of individual rights, such as right to health, livelihood, shelter, employment etc. in a Welfare State. The State Authorities cannot dispossess any citizen of his property except in accordance with the procedure established by law, that too by due process of law and by acquiring land and paying adequate compensation.

33 Sudipta Banerjee vs. L.S. Davar and Company and others
AIR 2022 Calcutta 261
Date of order: 5th April, 2022
Bench: Soumen Sen and Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, JJ.

No specific legislation – Trade secret – Factors for determining whether information is confidential. [O. 39 R. 1, Civil Procedure Code, 1908]

FACTS

Dr. Sudipta Banerjee and Dr. Indira Banerjee are well qualified patent professionals. They were working in L.S. Davar and Company, a reputed Intellectual property firm since 1st June, 1994 and 1st September, 1994 respectively until their resignations in June 2020. Arpita Ghosh was working as an office assistant of L.S. Davar & Company since 2010 until she resigned on 22nd January, 2021. All of them joined another firm by the name of P.S. Davar and Company, after their resignations were accepted by their erstwhile employer.

On the allegation that the appellants are divulging the confidential information and trade secrets acquired during their course of employment in L.S. Davar and Company, in clear breach of the confidentiality agreement, L.S. Davar and Company filed a suit.

In the suit the plaintiff filed an application for injunction in which the ad interim order of injunction was passed and subsequently extended from time to time.

HELD

There is no specific legislation in India to protect trade secrets and confidential information. Nevertheless, Indian Courts have upheld trade secret protection on basis of principles of equity, and at times, upon a common law action of breach of confidence, which in effect amounts to a breach of contractual obligation. The remedies available to the owner of trade secrets is to obtain an injunction preventing the licensee from disclosing the trade secret, return of all confidential and proprietary information, and compensation for any losses suffered due to disclosure of such trade secrets.

In India, a person can be contractually bound not to disclose any information that is revealed to him/her in confidence. The Indian courts have upheld a restrictive clause in a technology transfer agreement, which imposes negative covenants on the licensee to not disclose or use the information received under the agreement for any purpose other than that agreed to in the said agreement.

The court, while assessing an ad interim order of injunction is required to assess if the plaintiff was able to make out a prima facie case and thereafter consider the other two factors namely; balance of convenience and irreparable loss that might result in the event the ex parte ad interim order of injunction not being passed. In fact, an ad interim order of injunction should be of limited duration, which the learned Trial Court granted; however, we find that extension of the said ad interim order was made mechanically and could be prejudicial to the appellant. The non-compete clause in the instant case may be prejudicial to the appellants, but no order has been passed restraining them from carrying on their profession.

The plaintiff as a professional body may not have any trade secrets per se, but the persons who were/are in the employment of the plaintiff would certainly be privy to privileged information, and any sharing of such information and communication would not only be unethical but also a breach of the confidentiality clause resulting in serious prejudice and harm to the clients of the plaintiff firm. It may also expose the plaintiff firm to civil and criminal consequences. The nature of the complaints, on which the plaintiff relies, is to be assessed at the final disposal of the injunction application. However, at this stage, it cannot be said that the trial court has overstepped its limit or did not follow the accepted guidelines in passing the ad interim order of injunction. However,  there is a possibility of the ad interim order being misconstrued as it appears to be widely worded to cover issues beyond the scope of the confidentiality and non-compete clauses, and not intended by the impugned order. Accordingly, the ad interim order is modified by restraining the appellants from disclosing, divulging or sharing confidential information gathered during the course of their employment in any manner whatsoever till the disposal of the injunction application on merits.

The order of injunction passed by the trial court is modified and clarified to the aforesaid extent.

Goods and Services Tax

I HIGH COURT

38 India Yamaha Motor Private Limited vs. A. C. Chennai & Others
(2022) 142 taxmann.com 369 (Madras)
Date of order: 29th August, 2022

Whether sufficient balance in Electronic Cash Ledger (ECR) and/or Electronic Credit Ledger (ECrR) is good enough to not attract interest u/s 50 when return filing is delayed. Held: No interest is payable

FACTS

The single issue involved in the writ petition relates to attracting interest u/s 50 of the CGST Act when petitioner had filed GSTR-3B for July to October, 2017 belatedly mainly on account of an inadvertent error committed in GSTR-3B of July, 2017 and a grievance petition filed seeking modifications of the return for July, 2017 was not addressed soon by the authorities, and until the outcome of the grievance petition, proper ascertainment of tax liability for subsequent months was hard to be computed and hence they were filed after delay. However, there was sufficient credit in both ECR as well as ECrR and hence there was no loss caused to the Revenue, as per the plea of the petitioner while challenging the order of the Adjudicating Authority wherein interest for belated remittance of GST was called upon. The petitioner also argued that the basis on which the proviso to section 50 was made retrospectively applicable should be adopted because by virtue of the same, interest is not payable on input tax credit available and it would be attracted only on the delayed cash payment.

HELD

The Hon. High Court replied that while payment in cash denotes the actual availability of cash to the credit of the assessee, deposit standing to the credit of the an assessee / petitioner does not, under all circumstances, imply that the balance lying in electronic cash or credit ledger is within the reach of the department. When the returns are actually not filed by the petitioner, and hence a debit is not effected to the ECR or ECrR to the extent of the tax payable, credit cannot be equated with cash remittances.

39 Raghav Metals vs. State of Haryana
2022 (63) GSTL 300 (P&H)
Date of order: 14th March, 2022

Proceedings u/s 129 of CGST Act, 2017 cannot be initiated merely due to negligible difference between quantity of goods stated in e-way bill and actual quantity of goods

FACTS

The petitioner was engaged in the business of copper wires and copper scraps. He sold copper scraps to a dealer in Rajasthan for Rs. 83,69,594. While in transit, the goods were intercepted by GST authorities at Manesar on 27th November, 2021 and sought e-way bill as well as invoice. The said documents were produced. However, the vehicle was stationed and Form GST MOV-02 was issued. The petitioner submitted a reply on 3rd December, 2021. On the same date, an Order of Detention was passed in Form GST MOV-06 stating that there was mismatch of 90.7 kgs between actual quantity of goods vis-a-vis that stated in invoice and e-way bill. Thereafter, a notice in Form GST MOV-07 was issued to petitioner alleging intent to evade tax due to short payment of tax of Rs. 11,000. Being aggrieved by such order of detention and subsequent issue of notice, the petitioner filed a writ petition before Hon’ble High Court.

HELD

The High Court relied upon the decision of M/s. Shiv Enterprises vs. State of Punjab and Others 2022 (58) GSTL 385 (P&H), whereby it was stated that the intent to evade a tax must have direct nexus with activity of trader. He cannot be blamed for avoidance of tax merely because of negligence on part of person not immediately linked to his activity. Also, where difference in quantity stated in e-way bill and actual quantity was less than 1 per cent, by any stretch of imagination it cannot be regarded as intent to evade tax and entail proceedings u/s 129 of CGST Act, 2017. Accordingly, the writ petition was allowed in favour of petitioner.
40 Sri Desikanathar Textiles Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India
2022 (62) G.S.T.L. 449 (Mad.)
Date of order: 24th February, 2022

Transitional Credit cannot be denied merely because of a technical mistake while filing Form TRAN-1
 
FACTS

The petitioner was a manufacturer of grey woven fabric. He filed TRAN 1 in accordance with Section 140 of TNGST Act, 2017 and furnished the details in part 7(d) instead of part 7(c) of Tran-1. Due to this error, credit could not be transitioned to the petitioner’s electronic credit ledger. Petitioner sent various representations but did not get any favourable response and subsequently filed a manual return dated 18th June, 2020 and requested the respondents to transition the credit manually. However, the petitioner’s request was rejected as it was filed beyond the period of limitation. Being aggrieved by such rejection of credit, the petitioner preferred a writ petition before this Hon’ble High Court.

HELD

It was held to allow transition of credit which could not be transitioned due to wrong declaration in form Tran-1. The Court also directed the concerned jurisdictional officer to examine the records and arrive at an independent conclusion about the petitioner’s entitlement to the said credit. Pursuant to such conclusion, if credit was available, the petitioner shall be allowed to either file a revised Tran-1 or directly by making credit entry in electronic credit ledger.

41 Golden Cashew Products Pvt Ltd vs. Commercial Tax Officer, Puducherry
2022 (63) GSTL 26 (Mad)
Date of order: 3rd February, 2022

Transitional credit cannot be denied merely because petitioner failed to include amount of eligible CENVAT credit at the time limit of filing Form TRAN-1

FACTS

The petitioner was required to file the Tran-1 on GST Portal on or before 27th December, 2017. However, the petitioner had not filed TRAN–1 on time. Instead, he sent a representation dated 15th March, 2019 to the Commercial Tax Officer stating that there was a technical error and resubmitted TRAN-1 as per notification No.48/2018 – Central Tax to claim ITC of Rs. 28,29,208. On verifying the GST portal, the respondent could not find the return filed by the petitioner and asked him to resubmit the letter along with an evidence of filed TRAN-1. The petitioner submitted the letter on 29th March, 2019 enclosing the screenshots of TRAN-1 which displayed that TRAN-1 was not filed. Respondent ordered that filing of TRAN-1 was not available after the due date. Therefore, the petitioner was not entitled to the transition of credit. Being aggrieved by such an order rejecting transitional credit, the petitioner filed a writ petition before this Hon’ble High Court.

HELD

The Hon’ble High Court held that unutilized ITC on capital goods, service tax or inputs which has been availed validly under Central Excise Act, 1944, Finance Act, 1994 and VAT Act, 2006 cannot be denied. It was further held that merely because GST portal did not permit to rectify mistake in TRAN 1, the petitioner cannot be deprived of its indefeasible right of credit. The High Court directed the respondent to examine the validity of the petitioner’s unutilized amount existing in CENVAT account, and VAT returns and the amount shall be either refunded or allowed to be transitioned irrespective of the fact that petitioner may have failed to file Tran-1 in time. Accordingly, the petition was disposed of in favour of petitioner.

42 Rajdhani Security Force Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India
2022 (63) GSTL 299 (M.P.)
Date of order: 25th April, 2022

Unexplained delay in filing appeal is not condonable

FACTS

The petitioner was a registered company engaged in providing security services. However, on account of non-filling return, GST registration of the petitioner was cancelled on 19th June, 2019. Hence, the petitioner preferred an appeal against the order cancelling registration on 30th January, 2021. The same was dismissed by the respondent as it was filed after unexplained delay of one and half years. Being aggrieved by the same, the petitioner preferred a writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court.

HELD

It was held that the appeal preferred by petitioner was filed almost after one and half years from the order of cancellation of registration without providing any sufficient cause for such delay. Accordingly, it was held that an order passed by respondent dismissing the appeal was proper.

43 Uni Well Exim vs. State of Gujarat
2022 (63) GSTL 289 (Guj.)
Date of order: 31st March, 2022

Refund of ITC cannot be denied by way of an order travelling beyond the show cause notice

FACTS

The petitioner was engaged in the business of tobacco trading. The Department had issued a show cause notice proposing to reject refund application merely on one ground that certain necessary documents were not furnished by petitioner. The petitioner replied to the notice and furnished the requisite documents. However, respondent passed an order rejecting the refund application filed by the petitioner mentioning that transactions carried out by the petitioner were doubtful. Being aggrieved by such rejection, the petitioner is before this Hon’ble High Court.

HELD

It was held that the refund of ITC could not be denied by an order travelling beyond show cause notice. Moreover, if the authority had any further doubt in respect of certain transactions it could have easily given an opportunity to the petitioner before passing the refund rejection order. Accordingly, the order was quashed and the matter was remanded back for fresh adjudication.

44 TVL.G.K. Digital Printing vs. Assistant Commissioner (Circle), Tiruppur
2022 (63) GSTL 34 (Mad.)
Date of order: 1st April, 2022

Even if appeal against cancellation of GST registration is dismissed, still registration is liable to be restored

FACTS

The respondent issued a show cause notice dated 1st October, 2019 for seeking a response as to why the petitioner had not filed returns for a continuous period of six months. The petitioner failed to respond to above mentioned notice and as a result, GST registration was cancelled vide order dated 16th October, 2019. The petitioner preferred an appeal against the cancellation order, which was also dismissed on the ground of time bar. Hence, the petitioner filed a writ before Hon’ble High Court.

HELD

It was held that the petitioner’s case was squarely considered by this Court in Tvl. Suguna Cutpiece Center vs. Appellate Deputy Commissioner [2022 (61) GSTL 515 (Mad.)] wherein it was held that no useful purpose would be served if the registration is not revived. It will hamper the GST collection. Also, there are enough provisions under the GST law to prevent abuse by petitioners for non-payment of tax or filing of returns. Accordingly, relief was granted to the petitioner subject to fulfilment of certain conditions.

Recent Developments in GST

I. INSTRUCTIONS

1. Instruction No.2/2022-23 (GST Investigation) dated 17th August, 2022

By above instruction, guidelines are given for the arrest and bail in relation to offences punishable under CGST Act, 2017.

2. Instruction No.3/2022-23 (GST Investigation) dated 17th August, 2022

By above instruction, guidelines on issuance of summons u/s 70 of CGST Act are given.

3. Instruction No.4/2022-23 (GST Investigation) dated 1st September, 2022

By above instruction, guidelines for launching of prosecution under CGST Act are given.
 
II.    CIRCULAR

1.  Filing/revising of TRAN-1/TRAN- 2 – Circular No.180/12/2022-GST dated 9th September, 2022

In above circular guidelines for filing / revising TRAN-1/ TRAN-2 in terms of order dated 22nd July, 2022 and 2nd September, 2022 of Hon. Supreme Court in the case of Union of India vs. Filco Trade Centre Pvt Ltd are given.

III. ADVANCE RULINGS

21 Rameshwar Havelia with Trade Name
M/s Doon Valley Logistics (A.R. 07/2022-23 in App.No.03/2022-23 dated 18th July, 2022)(Uttarakhand)

ITC on Building – Question not decided

The issue involved before the ld. AAR, Uttarakhand was about eligibility to ITC on inward supply used for construction of building. The applicant submitted that there is construction of building for use as warehouse which will be leased to earn rentals.

Since the inward supply is for earning rentals liable to output GST, the argument before the ld. AAR was that it complies with all conditions as per section 16(1) and the ITC do not get blocked as per section 17(5)(c)/(d).

The judgment of Orissa High Court in case of Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd. vs. Chief Commissioner of CGST, Bhubaneshwar in WP(C) No.20463 of 2018 (2019-VIL-223-ORI) was cited in support of above argument.

The ld. AAR noted the facts and relevant sections and referred to section 17(5)(c)/(d) which blocks credit in relation to the construction of immovable property, even if it is in course of business. Though the applicant has  made argument about double tax, intention of law, equality, the ld. AAR observed that the eligibility to ITC is subject to restrictions/conditions as stated in section 16(1) itself.

In case of Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd, though the issue is decided in favour of the concerned petitioner, the Hon. Supreme Court has admitted appeal and hence the issue is sub-judice. Considering above pendency, the ld. AAR refrained from answering the question and thus disposed of application without any ruling.
 

22 Tutor Comp Infotech India Pvt. Ltd.
[A.R. No. KER/143/2021 dated 27th July, 2022]

Classification – Exemption as Educational Institution

The applicant has requested an advance ruling on the following:

“Whether the (i) transaction between applicant and individual student on a one-to-one basis; and (ii) providing education up to Higher Secondary School; falls under:

Sl. No. 66(a) of Notification No.12/2017 – Central Tax (Rate).”

The applicant submits that they are offering education services to students through its own online platform. The applicant provides services in the following categories:

a. Educational services to individual students.

b. Educational services to institutions and the students.

c. Educational services to the Government.

The applicant submitted the process of registration and the nature of services rendered by them. The main submission was that there is ascertainment of particular requirements of student, planning of lessons as per requirements in individual case and timings as per mutual suitability. The fees were charged describing ‘tuition fees’.

The claim was that they fall in entry at Sl. No. 66(a) of Notification No.12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017. It was also contended that they also fall in definition of ‘Educational Institution’ given in clause (y) in para 2 of said notification.

Further arguments were made on merits of case including meaning of ‘education’ and ‘institution’ as per dictionary and judgments.

Based on the same, the applicant submitted that “education”, means, (a) systematic instruction, schooling or training given to the young persons in preparation for the work of life; (b) bringing up; the process of developing and training the powers and capabilities of human beings; (c) is not merely the instruction received at school or college but the whole course of training – moral, intellectual and physical. It was also submitted that it is sometimes used as synonymous with ‘learning”. It was also contended that judgments make it clear that schooling is not the only method of providing education, and any kind of systematic training constitutes “education” and accordingly any training or instruction given to the young for their preparation constitutes education.

The ld. AAR examined above contentions on behalf of applicant. The entry at Sl. No. 66(a) of the Notification No.12/2017-CT (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 was reproduced as under:-

Sl. No.

Chapter, Section, Heading, Group or Service code

Description of Services

Rate (per cent)

Condition

66

Heading
9992

 

Services
provided

(a)
by an educational institution to its students, faculty and staff;…”

Nil

Nil

The classification of educational service under Heading 9992 in Notification No.11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 was also considered.

The reference also made to term ‘educational institution’ as defined in clause (y) of Para 2 of Notification No.12/2017 CT(Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 which is as follows:

classification of educational service under Heading 9992 (in Notification No.11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017) was also considered.

The reference also made to term ‘educational institution’ as defined in clause (y) of Para 2 of Notification No.12/2017 CT(Rate) dated 28th June, 2017 which is as follows:

“educational institution” means an institution providing services by way of-

i.    pre-school education and education up to higher secondary school or equivalent;

ii.    education as a part of a curriculum for obtaining a qualification recognized by any law for the time being in force;

iii.    education as a part of an approved vocational education course.”

The ld. AAR held that the entry exempts educational institutions from pre-school to higher secondary school or an educational institution which is equivalent to a ‘school’. It observed that, the applicant is not a formal school, but an institution providing special training / coaching to students enrolled in formal schools for education up to higher secondary or equivalent. Accordingly, the ld. AAR observed that even though the activity of training and coaching undertaken by the applicant can be claimed to be education services in layman’s understanding, those activities do not qualify to be classified under any of the Groups; 99921- Preprimary education services; 99922 – Primary education services or 99923 – Secondary education services as core educational services are provided by schools up to higher secondary or equivalent. The ld. AAR held that the services provided by the applicant are appropriately classifiable under Heading 9992 – Group – 99929 – SAC – 999293 as commercial training and coaching services. It is observed that the service of applicant also does not lead to any qualification recognised by any law. Accordingly, the applicant does not fall under the scope of educational institution as defined in sub-clause (i) of clause (y) of Para 2 of Notification No. 12/2017 CT (rate) dated 28th June, 2017.

The ld. AAR gave the following ruling:

“Question: Whether the (i) transaction between applicant and individual student on a one to one basis; and (ii) providing education up to Higher Secondary School; falls under Sl.No.66(a) of Notification No.12/2017 – Central Tax (Rate).

Ruling: The applicant is not an educational institution as defined in clause (y) of Para 2 of Notification No. 12/2017 CT (Rate) dated 28.06.2017. Therefore, the services provided by the applicant are not exempt under Sl. No. 66 of the said notification.”
 

23 Ess Ess Kay Engineering Company Pvt. Ltd.
(AAR/GST/PB/016 dated 16th August, 2022)

Classification – Roof Mounted AC package for fitment in LHB/LGB.

The applicant is a manufacturer of air conditioners for fitting in railway coaches. Following question was posed for ruling:

“The applicant has sought advance ruling on the classification of roof mounted Air-conditioning unit especially for use in railway coaches (manufactured as per railway design) i.e. whether they are classifiable under HSN- 8415 1090- IGST @ 28% or under HSN 8607 99 – IGST @ 18% as parts of Railway Coaches/ Locomotives?”

In hearing, the applicant made following submission:

“The applicant is inter-alia engaged in manufacture of “Roof Mounted Air-conditioning unit for Passenger Coaches of Railway as per RDSO specification and drawing” (in short impugned goods). The impugned goods are exclusively for use in railway coaches, it has no marketability except use in railways coaches. It is an integral / essential part of Air-conditioned railway coaches and accordingly classifiable under HSN 8607 99 of Customs Tariff Act as made applicable to GST vide Notification No. 1/2017 CT ® dated 28.06.2017.”

Various other judgments / rulings were cited. On behalf of Revenue, there was no objection to classification suggested by applicant. Revenue brought to notice of ld. AAR, the AR in case of Prag Polymers dated 14th February, 2020 – 2021-VIL-174-AAR by Authority for Advance Ruling-Uttar Pradesh and Hon. Supreme Court judgment in case of Westinghouse Saxby Farmer Ltd. vs. Commr. of Central Excise Calcutta -2021-VIL-33-SC-CE.

The ld. AAR analysed the subject with reference to Tariff under Customs Act. After elaborate reference, the ld. AAR observed that the Air Conditioners are covered in Chapter 8415 and classification of same cannot get altered on account of supply to Railway. Accordingly, the ruling is given classifying the product under Chapter 8415 rejecting contention of classification under Chapter 8607.

24 Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Ltd.
(AAR No. 04/AP/GST/2022
dated 21st March, 2022)

Composite Supply – Administration of COVID Vaccines

The facts are that the applicant, M/s Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences Limited is a Public Limited Company and a multi-specialty hospital, rendering healthcare services and claiming exemption on the said service vide notification No. 12/2017 Central Tax Rate. The company has been permitted to administer COVID-19 vaccine and the process of administering it has been narrated to be critical administration. The health care staff is well trained for safe and effective vaccination. Elaborate process and the personnel involved in process are narrated in AR.

The actual vaccination involved pre-vaccine consultation, actual vaccination and post vaccination observation as well as follows up as may be necessary. The applicant approached this Authority with following questions:

“1.    Whether administering of COVID-19 vaccination by hospitals is Supply of Good or Supply of Service?

2.    Whether administering of COVID-19 vaccine by clinical establishments (Hospitals) qualify as “Health care services” as per Notification No. 12/2017 Central Tax Rate dated 28th June, 2017?

3.    Whether administering of COVID-19 vaccination by clinical establishment is exempt under GST Act?”

Applicant was submitting that it is healthcare services covered by Sl. No. 74 of Notification No.12/2017 (CT) (Rate) dated 28th June, 2017. The meaning of ‘health care services’ given in above notification No. 12/2017 was also referred to.

The meaning of ‘authorized medical practitioner’ as given in Notification No.12/2017 was also placed for meaningful determination of the question.

The applicant referred to the definition of ‘composite supply’ given in section 2(30) of CGST Act, which reads as under:

“composite supply” means a supply made by a taxable person to a recipient consisting of two or more taxable supplies of goods or services or both, or any combination thereof, which are naturally bundled and supplied in conjunction with each other in the ordinary course of business, one of which is a principal supply;”

It was submitted that the vaccine vial is not available in pharmacy / hospital, and the beneficiaries are not at liberty to get vaccinated by themselves or by other than medical practitioner. The various stages of vaccination bifurcated as under:

“Sl. No.

Step

Components  involved

Good or Service

1.

Documentation
and records maintenance

Service
involved in verifying the documentation, processing and maintaining

Service

2.

Pre-consultation

Consultation
service by medical professional

Service

3.

Disinfecting
the skin by using Alcohol and cotton by a medical professional

Cotton,
alcohol and services by medical professional

Both

4.

Injecting
the vaccination to the person

Usage
of Syringe, composition of drug and services by medical professional

Both

5.

Consultation
including medical Advice

Post
vaccination observation and consultation by medical professional

Service”

Based on above it was argued that the activity of vaccination is composite supply where health care service is principal supply and hence exempt.

The ld. AAR went to examine first as to whether the administering of COVID-19 vaccine by hospitals is supply of goods or services or both.

The ld. AAR observed that, two activities are involved in this transaction, ‘sale of vaccine’ under ‘supply of goods’ and ‘administering of vaccine’ under ‘supply of service,’ and when it comes to administering of the vaccine by hospitals, it involves a combination of two supplies, which are naturally bundled, i.e., ‘supply of vaccine’ and the ‘service component’ by way of administering the same. Therefore, it is composite supply.

It is further observed that both the supplies are intrinsically connected with each other, and viewed as a single package by the recipient, where he purchases the vaccine and gets it administered subsequently. The ld. AAR decided, which of the above two, is the principal supply. It observed that generally, the primary requirement of the recipient would be the receipt of the vaccine, basing on his choice i.e., Covishield or Covaxin. Thus, the ld. AAR held that the supply of goods constitutes the major supply. It is further held that the proper administration of the vaccine by a technically qualified personnel as prescribed by the guidelines of the government becomes the ancillary supply, which involves ‘service charge’. With above analysis, the ld. AAR held that the taxability of the total transaction in the instant case is based on the tax rate of the principal supply i.e., sale of vaccines which is at 5 per cent. It is also held that it is not healthcare service but sale of goods.

 

25 Sri Sairam Gopalkrishna Bhat
(AAAR No. KAR-AAAR/05/2022
dated 25th August, 2022)

Appeal to AAAR – Condonation of delay in Filing appeal

Appellant received Advance Ruling order No. KAR/ADRG/03/2022 dated 21st January, 2022 passed by AAR. Appeal filed to AAAR. The appeal was delayed by 65 days. The delay was sought to be condoned based on Supreme Court order in Suo Motu Writ (Civil) No.3/2020 dated 10th January, 2022 where in limitations are extended due to Covid lockdown. The date wise chart of events is as under:

“Actions
relating to the impugned advance ruling

Dates as per Section 100 of the
CGST Act of Situation 1

Dates computed as per Supreme Court
order dt.10.1.2022 Situation 2

Remarks

Date
of issue of AAR order

21.1.2022

21.1.2022

–

Date
of receipt of AAR order by the Appellant

19.2.2022

19.2.2022

 

Date
of limitation for filing an appeal

21.3.2022

30.3.2022

Period
between 20.2.2022 to 28.2.2022 is excluded as per SC order”

Further
period of 30 days condonable by AAAR

20.4.2022

29.4.2022

 

Date
of filing appeal

26.5.2022

26.5.2022

 

No
of days delay after condonable period

36

27

 

The ld. AAAR reproduced the operative part of above order of Supreme Court as under:

“5. Taking into consideration the arguments advanced by learned counsel and the impact of the surge of the virus on public health and adversities faced by litigants in the prevailing conditions, we deem it appropriate to dispose of the M. A No 21 of 2022 with the following directions:

I. The order dated 23.03.2020 is restored and in continuation of the subsequent orders dated 08.03.2021, 27.04.2021 and 23.09.2021, it is directed that the period from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022 shall stand excluded for the purposes of limitation as may be prescribed under any general or special laws in respect of all judicial or quasi-judicial proceedings.

II. Consequently, the balance period of limitation remaining as on 03.10.2021, if any, shall become available with effect from 01.03.2022.

III. In cases where the limitation would have expired during the period between 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022, notwithstanding the actual balance period of limitation remaining, all persons shall have a limitation period of 90 days from 01.03.2022. In the event the actual balance period of limitation remaining, with effect from 01.03.2022 is greater than 90 days, the longer period shall apply.

IV. It is further clarified that the period from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022 shall also stand excluded in computing the periods prescribed under Section 23(4) and 29A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and provisos (b) and (c) of Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and any other laws, which prescribe period(s) of limitation for instituting proceedings, outer limits (within which the court or tribunal can condone delay) and termination of proceedings.”

The appellant was relying on Para 5(III). The ld. AAAR did not agree with above submission observing that the limitation in present case expired after 28th February, 2022 and not prior to 28th February, 2022.

The ld. AAAR also examined the position from different angle as under:

“15. There is another reason why the directions at Para 5(III) extending the limitation period to 90 days from 28-02-2022 will not apply to this case. No doubt the Hon’ble Supreme Court has passed the orders on extending the period of limitation by exercising its power under Article 142 of the Constitution. However, it is a settled principle of jurisprudence that even while exercising that power, the Supreme Court cannot render the statutory provision otiose. The limitation period of 30 days as laid down in Section 100(2) of the CGST Act will continue to prevail with the exception that the 30 days period will be computed from 01-03-2022 as per the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s directions at Para 5(I) and not from 19-02-2022 which is the date of communication of the impugned order. Therefore, the appeal filed on 26-05-2022 is beyond the period of limitation prescribed under Section 100(2) of the CGST Act.”

The ld. AAAR also held that it is bound by 30 days’ time limit for condonation and no power to condone any delay beyond 30 days.

It is held that section 5 of Limitation Act is not applicable to appeals to be filed u/s 100(2). The appeal was rejected on ground of limitation.

Financial Reporting Dossier

A. KEY RECENT UPDATES

1. PCAOB COMPLETES 20 YEARS

On 30th July, 2022, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) completed 20 years of existence. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) of 2002 established the PCAOB, a non-profit corporation, to oversee the audits of US public companies, protect investors, and further the public interest in the preparation of informative, accurate, and independent audit reports. The PCAOB also oversees the audits of brokers and dealers, including compliance reports filed under federal securities laws. Since its creation, the PCAOB has:

•    Registered over 3,800 audit firms,

•    Completed more than 4,300 firm inspections in 55 countries – reviewing more than 15,000 audits of public companies and over 1,000 broker-dealer engagements,

•    Issued more than 330 settled orders, and

•    Sanctioned more than 230 firms and 270 individuals.

2. FASB – PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS TO ACCOUNTING FOR INVESTMENTS IN TAX CREDIT STRUCTURES

On 22nd August, 2022, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued an Exposure Draft (ED) of Accounting Standards Update, Accounting for Investments in Tax Credit Structures Using the Proportional Amortization Method. The ED proposes amendments to US GAAP Topic 323, Investments – Equity Method and Joint Ventures. The proposed amendments would permit reporting entities to elect to account tax equity investments, regardless of the program from which the income tax credits are received, using the proportional amortization method if specified conditions are met.

In 2014, the FASB issued ASU No. 2014-01 that introduced an option allowing entities to elect to apply the proportional amortization method to account for investments made primarily to receive income tax credits and other income tax benefits. The guidance limited the proportional amortization method to investments in low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC) structures. Under the proportional amortization method, an entity amortizes the initial cost of the investment in proportion to the income tax credits, and other income tax benefits received and recognizes the net amortization and income tax credits and other income tax benefits in the income statement as a component of income tax expense/(benefit). Investments in other tax credit structures are typically accounted for using the equity or cost method, resulting in investment gains and losses and tax credits being presented gross on the income statement in their respective line items. [https://www.fasb.org/page/getarticle?uid=fasb_Media_Advisory_08-22-22]

3. SEC – PAY VERSUS PERFORMANCE RULES

On 25th August, 2022, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted amendments to its rules requiring registrant companies to disclose information reflecting the relationship between executive compensation paid and the registrant’s financial performance (Pay vs Performance Rules). The rules implement a requirement mandated by the Dodd-Frank Act and require registrant companies to provide a table disclosing specified executive compensation and financial performance measures of the five recent fiscal years. A company must report its total shareholder return (TSR), the TSR of companies in its peer group, its net income and a chosen financial performance measure. Using the information presented in the table, registrants will be required, inter alia, to describe the relationships between the executive compensation paid and each of the performance measures, as well as the relationship between the registrant’s TSR and the TSR of its selected peer group. [https://www.sec.gov/rules/final/2022/34-95607.pdf]

4. PCAOB – AGREEMENT SIGNED WITH CHINESE AUTHORITIES, TAKING FIRST STEP TOWARD COMPLETE ACCESS FOR PCAOB TO SELECT, INSPECT AND INVESTIGATE IN CHINA

On 26th August, 2022, the PCAOB signed a Statement of Protocol with the China Securities Regulatory Commission and the Ministry of Finance of the People’s Republic of China (PRC). This was the first step taken towards opening the access for the PCAOB to inspect and investigate registered public accounting firms headquartered in mainland China and Hong Kong, consistent with the US law.  In 2020, the US Congress passed the Holding Foreign Companies Accountable Act (HFCAA). Under this Act, beginning with 2021, after three consecutive years of PCAOB determinations that positions taken by authorities in PRC obstructed the board’s ability to inspect and investigate registered public accounting firms in mainland China and Hong Kong completely, the companies audited by those firms would be subject to a trading prohibition on US markets. In 2021, the PCAOB made determinations that the positions taken by PRC authorities prevented the PCAOB from inspecting and investigating in mainland China and Hong Kong completely. The PCAOB is now required to reassess its determinations by the end of 2022. [https://pcaobus.org/news-events/news-releases/news-release-detail/fact-sheet-china-agreement]

5. IASB – PROPOSALS TO UPDATE IFRS FOR SMEs ACCOUNTING STANDARD

On 8th September, 2022, the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) published proposals to update the IFRS for SMEs Accounting Standard. The Exposure Draft, Third Edition of the IFRS for SMEs Accounting Standard, aims to update the IFRS for SMEs literature to align it with: The Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting; the simplified requirements based on IFRS 13, Fair Value Measurement and IFRS 15, Revenue from Contracts with Customers; and updating new requirements in IFRS 3, Business Combinations, IFRS 9, Financial Instruments, IFRS 10, Consolidated Financial Statements and IFRS 11, Joint Arrangements. The proposed updates include other improvements made to full IFRS Accounting Standards since the publishing of the previous (second) edition of IFRS for SMEs Accounting Standard in 2015. [https://www.ifrs.org/content/dam/ifrs/project/2019-comprehensive-review-of-the-ifrs-for-smes-standard/exposure-draft-2022/snapshot-ed-ifrsforsmes-sept2022.pdf]


INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING MATERIAL

UK FRC – Thematic Review, Judgements and Estimates: Update. [26th July, 2022.]

IAASB – First-Time Implementation Guide for ISA 315 (Revised 2019),
Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement. [27th July, 2022.]

IAASB – New FAQs for Reporting Going Concern Matters in the Auditor’s Report. [1st August, 2022.]

FASB – 2022 FASB Investor Outreach Report. [4th August, 2022.]

UK FRC –
Snapshots of Current Practice in Auditor Reporting. [16th August, 2022.]

UK FRC – Thematic Review, Earnings per Share (IAS 33). [8th September, 2022.]


B. EVOLUTION AND ANALYSIS OF ACCOUNTING CONCEPTS – INDEFINITE-LIFE INTANGIBLE ASSETS

SETTING THE CONTEXT

An intangible asset is an identifiable non-monetary asset without physical substance. The Day 2 (subsequent) measurement of indefinite-life intangible assets under prominent GAAPs has seen interesting developments over the years, which are discussed herein.

THE POSITION UNDER PROMINENT GAAPS

US GAAP
Historical Developments

The Accounting Principles Board (APB) of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) issued Accounting Research Bulletin (ARB) No. 43 in 1959. Chapter 5, Intangible Assets of ARB No. 43, classified intangible assets as ‘Type a’ and ‘Type b’.

‘Type a’ intangible assets included those whose term of existence was limited by law, regulation, or agreement, or by their nature – for example, patents, copyrights, leases, licenses, franchises for a fixed term, etc.

‘Type b’ intangible assets included those with no such limited term of existence and as to which there was, at the time of acquisition, no indication of limited life – for example, trade names, secret processes, subscription lists, perpetual franchises, etc.

‘Type a’ intangible assets were required to be amortized to the income statement over the period benefitted. As regards ‘Type b’ intangible assets, the guidance stated that when it becomes reasonably evident that the term of existence of a ‘Type b’ intangible assets has become limited and that it has, therefore, become a ‘Type a’ intangible asset, then its cost should be amortized by systematic charges in the income statement over the estimated remaining period of usefulness.

This accounting practice was criticised since alternative methods of accounting for costs were acceptable. Some companies amortized intangible assets over a short arbitrary period to reduce the amount of the asset as rapidly as practicable, while others retained it until evidence showed a loss of value, and then recorded a material reduction in a single accounting period.

Such criticisms led the APB to issue APB Opinion No. 17, Intangible Assets, in 1970. APB Opinion No. 17 required goodwill and other intangible assets to be amortized by systematic charges over the period expected to be benefitted by those assets, not to exceed 40 years. The Board opined (in para 22) that accounting for the cost of a long-lived asset after acquisition normally depends on its estimated life. The cost of assets with perpetual existence, such as land, is carried forward as an asset without amortization, and the cost of assets with finite lives is amortized by systematic charges to the income statement. Goodwill and similar intangible assets do not clearly fit either classification; their lives are neither infinite nor specifically limited but are indeterminate. Thus, although the principles underlying the then practice conformed to accounting principles for similar types of assets, their applications had led to alternative treatments. Amortizing the cost of goodwill and similar intangible assets on arbitrary bases in the absence of evidence of limited lives or decreased values resulted in recognising expenses and decreases of assets prematurely, but delayed amortization of the cost until a loss was evident and thereby recognised the decreases after the fact. The Board felt that a practical solution would be to set a minimum and maximum amortization period. Allocating the cost of goodwill or other intangible assets with an indeterminate life over time is necessary because the value almost inevitably becomes zero at some future date. Since the date at which the value becomes zero is indeterminate, the end of the useful life must necessarily be set arbitrarily at some point or within some range of time for accounting purposes.

APB Opinion No. 17 presumed that goodwill and all other intangible assets were wasting assets (i.e., finite lived assets), and thus the amounts assigned to them should be amortized in determining net income. It also mandated an arbitrary ceiling of 40 years for that amortization. The FASB noted that having the same maximum amortization periods for intangible assets as for goodwill might discourage entities from recognizing more intangible assets apart from goodwill in mergers and acquisitions. Not independently recognizing those intangible assets when they exist and can be reliably measured adversely affects the relevance and representational faithfulness of the financial statements.

In 2001, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued the Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 142, Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, which superseded APB Opinion No. 17. SFAS No. 142 did not presume such goodwill and intangible assets to be wasting assets. Instead, it mandated that the goodwill and intangible assets with indefinite useful lives should not be amortized but should be tested annually for impairment. Intangible assets that have finite useful lives would continue to be amortized over their useful lives but without the constraint of an arbitrary ceiling.

Current Position

Extant US GAAP ASC 350, Intangibles – Goodwill and Others carries forward the guidance of SFAS No. 142. The relevant extracts from the standard are: “The accounting for a recognized intangible asset is based on its useful life to the reporting entity. An intangible asset with a finite useful life shall be amortized; an intangible asset with an indefinite useful life shall not be amortized.” [ASC 350-30-35-1.]

IFRS
Historical Developments

IAS 38, Intangible Assets, issued in 1998, assumed that the useful lives of intangible assets were always finite. The standard also prescribed a presumptive maximum useful life of 20 years. The presumption was rebuttable, though.

The IASB amended IAS 38 in 2004, whereby the rebuttable presumption of useful life of 20 years was withdrawn, and the concept of indefinite life intangible assets (not subject to amortisation but annual impairment testing) introduced.

In developing the revised standard, the IASB observed that the useful life of an intangible asset is related to its expected cash inflows. For example, some intangible assets are based on legal rights conveyed in perpetuity rather than for finite terms. As such, these assets may have cash flows associated with them that may be expected to continue for many years or indefinitely. The Board concluded that if the cash flows are expected to continue for a finite period, the useful life of the asset is limited to that finite period. However, if the cash flows are expected to continue indefinitely, the useful life is indefinite.

To be representationally faithful, the amortisation period for an intangible asset generally should reflect that useful life and, by extension, the cash flow streams associated with the asset. The Board concluded that it is possible for management to have the intention and the ability to maintain an intangible asset in such a way that there is no foreseeable limit on the period over which that particular asset is expected to generate net cash inflows for the entity [38.BC 61.]. Accordingly, IAS 38 (Revised) required an intangible asset to be regarded as having an indefinite useful life when, based on an analysis of all the relevant factors, there is no foreseeable limit to the period over which the asset is expected to generate net cash inflows for the reporting entity.

Current Position

Under extant IFRS (IAS 38, Intangible Assets), the subsequent measurement of an intangible asset is based on its useful life. An entity must assess whether an intangible asset’s useful life is finite or indefinite.

The depreciable amount of an intangible asset with a finite useful life shall be allocated on a systematic basis over its useful life. [38.97.]

An intangible asset with an indefinite useful life shall not be amortised. [38.107.] It may be noted that an intangible asset is regarded as having an indefinite useful life when there is no foreseeable limit to the period over which the asset is expected to generate net cash inflows for the entity. ‘Indefinite’ does not mean ‘infinite’. An entity must test an indefinite useful life intangible asset for impairment annually. [38.108.]

An entity should also disclose for an intangible asset assessed as having an indefinite useful life, the carrying amount of that asset and the reasons supporting the assessment of indefinite useful life. While giving these reasons, the entity should describe the factors that played a significant role in determining that the asset has an indefinite useful life.

Ind AS
Current Position

Ind AS 38, Intangible Assets is in line with IFRS (IAS 38, Intangible Assets) in the accounting topic of Day 2 (subsequent) measurement of indefinite life intangible assets.

AS
Current Position

Paragraph 62 of AS 26, Intangible Assets (IGAAP), which deals with measurement after initial recognition, requires intangible assets to be carried at cost less accumulated amortisation and accumulated impairment losses. The depreciable amount of an intangible asset should be allocated on a systematic basis over the management’s best estimate of its useful life. However, there is a rebuttable presumption that the useful life of an intangible asset will not exceed 10 years. However, if there is persuasive evidence that the useful life will be a specific period longer than 10 years, the presumption stands rebutted, and the reporting entity is required to amortise the intangible asset over the best estimate of its useful life and subject it to impairment testing annually. In such circumstances, the entity must also disclose why the presumption is rebutted and the factors that played a significant role in determining such useful life.

THE LITTLE GAAPS
US FRF for SMEs

Chapter 13, Intangible Assets of the AICPA’s US Financial Reporting Framework for Small and Medium-Sized Entities (FRF for SMEs), a self-contained framework not based on US GAAP, considers all intangible assets to have a finite useful life. The standard states that when the precise length of an intangible asset’s useful life is not known, the intangible asset is amortized over the best estimate of its useful life [13.55.].

IFRS for SMEs

Prior to the 2015 ‘Comprehensive Review’ of IFRS for SMEs by the IASB (effective 1st January, 2017), if an entity could not reliably estimate the useful life of an intangible asset, it was presumed to have a default 10-year life.  

Extant International Financial Reporting Standard for Small and Medium-sized Entities (IFRS for SMEs), Section 18, Intangible Assets Other than Goodwill considers all intangible assets to have a finite useful life. The requirement also states that if the management cannot reliably establish the useful life of an intangible asset, then it shall determine the life based on the best estimate, which should not exceed ten years.

C. GLOBAL ANNUAL REPORT EXTRACTS – REMUNERATION POLICY FOR EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS

BACKGROUND

The UK Large and Medium-sized Companies and Groups (Accounts and Reports) (Amendment) Regulations 2013, mandates disclosures of ‘Directors Remuneration Report’ by quoted companies.

Relevant extracts from Schedule 8 of the Regulation (Quoted Companies: Directors Remuneration Report) are provided below.

PART 4
DIRECTORS’ REMUNERATION POLICY

24.—(1) The information required to be included in the directors’ remuneration report by the provisions of this Part must be set out in a separate part of the report and constitutes the directors’ remuneration policy of the company.

25.—(1) The directors’ remuneration report must contain in tabular form a description of each of the components of the remuneration package for the directors of the company which are comprised in the directors’ remuneration policy of the company.

26. In respect of each of the components described in the table there must be set out the following information—

(a)    how that component supports the short and long-term strategic objectives of the company (or, where the company is a parent company, the group);

(b)    an explanation of how that component of the remuneration package operates;

(c)    the maximum that may be paid in respect of that component (which may be expressed in monetary terms, or otherwise);

(d)     where applicable, a description of the framework used to assess performance including—

(i)    a description of any performance measures which apply and, where more than one performance measure applies, an indication of the weighting of the performance measure or group of performance measures;

(ii)    details of any performance period; and

(iii)    the amount (which may be expressed in monetary terms or otherwise) that may be paid in respect of —

(aa)    the minimum level of performance that results in any payment under the policy, and

(bb)    any further levels of performance set in accordance with the policy;

(e)    an explanation as to whether there are any provisions for the recovery of sums paid or the withholding of the payment of any sum.


EXTRACTS FROM ANNUAL REPORTS

Flutter Entertainment Plc, (Listed on LSE, FTSE 100 index constituent); Y.E. 31st December, 2021 Revenue – £ 6.04 billion.

Directors Remuneration Report – Remuneration Policy

Remuneration Policy table

The table below sets out our Remuneration Policy for Executive Directors. It has been represented in full and unchanged from 2020:

Element

Purpose and link to strategy

Operation and performance measures

Maximum opportunity

Salary

To attract and retain high-calibre
talent in the labour market in which the Executive Director is employed.

Generally reviewed annually but may
be reviewed at other times of the year in exceptional circumstances.

 

Salaries (inclusive of any Director
fees) are set with reference to individual skills, experience,
responsibilities, Company performance and performance in role.

 

Independent benchmarking is
conducted on a periodic basis against companies of a similar size and
complexity, and those operating in the same or similar sectors, although this
information is used only as part of a broader review.

Increases (as a percentage of
salary) will generally be in line with salary inflation and consistent with
those offered to the wider workforce.

 

Higher increases may be appropriate
in certain circumstances including, but not limited to:

 

· where an individual changes role;

 

· where there is a material change
in the responsibilities or scope of the role;

 

· where an individual is appointed
on a below market salary with the expectation that this salary will increase
with experience and performance;

 

· where there is a need for
retention;

 

· where salaries, in the opinion of
the Committee, have fallen materially below the relevant market rates; and

 

· where the size of the Group
increases in a material way.

 

The Committee will review salaries
if the proposed combination with The Stars Group completes. This may lead to
increases awarded at rates higher than the wider workforce level, given that
it would represent a significant change in the scale and complexity of the
business and therefore the roles of the Executive Directors.

Benefits

To provide market competitive, cost
effective benefits.

Employment-related benefits may
include (but are not limited to) private medical insurance, life assurance,
income protection, relocation, travel and accommodation assistance related to
fulfilment of duties, tax equalisation and/or other related expenses as
required. Where expenses are necessary for the ordinary conduct of business,
the Company may meet the cost of tax on benefits.

The value of benefits may vary from
year-to-year in line with variances in third-party supplier costs which are
outside of the Company’s control, business requirements and other changes
made to wider workforce benefits.

Pension

To provide retirement benefits that
are appropriately competitive within the relevant labour market.

Paid as a defined contribution
and/or cash supplement.

Contribution of up to 15% of salary

(or an equivalent cash payment in
lieu) for current Executive Directors. These will reduce to the UK and
Ireland wider workforce level from the start of 2023. For any new Executive
Directors appointed during the term of this Policy, contributions will be set
in line with the wider workforce level upon recruitment.

Annual bonus and DSIP

To incentivise and reward the
successful delivery of annual performance targets. The DSIP also provides a
link to long-term value creation.

The Committee reviews the annual
bonus prior to the start of each financial year to ensure that the
opportunity, performance measures, targets and weightings are appropriate and
in line with the business strategy at the time.

Threshold performance will result in
an annual bonus pay-out of 25% of the maximum opportunity.

 

For target performance, the annual
bonus earned is two-thirds of the maximum opportunity.

Annual bonus and DSIP

 

Performance is determined by the
Committee on an annual basis by reference to Group financial or strategic
measures, or personal objectives, although the financial element will always
account for at least 50% of the bonus in any year. The DSIP will be subject
to a financial underpin; for 2020 this will be a revenue underpin but a
different measure may be used in future years.

 

Half of any annual bonus is paid in
cash, with the remaining half deferred into shares under the DSIP. Any
deferred element is released 50% after three years and 50% after four years
from the date of grant.

 

Malus and
clawback provisions apply to the annual bonus and DSIP both prior to vesting
and for a period of two years post-vesting. Dividends (or equivalent) accrue
and are paid on DSIP awards that vest.

Maximum annual opportunity of 285%
of total salary for the CEO and 265% of salary for other Executive Directors.

LTIP

To attract, retain and incentivise
Executive Directors to deliver the Group’s long-term strategy while providing
strong alignment with shareholder interests.

Annual grant of shares or nil-cost
options, vesting after a minimum of three years, subject to the achievement
of performance conditions.

 

The Committee reviews the
performance measures, targets and weightings prior to the start of each cycle
to ensure that they are appropriate. The measures and respective weightings
may vary year-on-year to reflect strategic priorities, but at least 75% will
always be based on financial measures (which can include TSR).

 

Following vesting, awards are
subject to a holding period of up to two years, such that the overall
timeframe of the LTIP will be no less than five years. Directors may sell
sufficient shares to satisfy the tax liability on exercise but must retain
the net number of shares until the end of this two-year period.

 

Malus and clawback provisions apply
to the LTIP, which allow the Company to reduce or claw back awards during the
holding period. Dividends (or equivalent) accrue and are paid on LTIP awards
that vest.

The normal maximum opportunity is
180% of salary for the CEO and 150% of salary for other Executive Directors.
Threshold performance will result in no more than 25% vesting.

SAYE

To facilitate share ownership and
provide further alignment with shareholders.

The Company operates Save As You
Earn share plans for all employees (in the UK this is an HMRC-approved and in
Ireland this is an Irish Revenue-approved plan); the Executive Directors may
participate in the plan on the same basis as other employees.

 

Participants are invited to save up
to the monthly limit over a three-year period and use these savings to buy
shares in the Company at up to the maximum discount allowable in the relevant
jurisdiction.

Maximum opportunity is in line with
HMRC and Irish Revenue limits (currently £500 and €500 per month for UK and
Irish employees respectively).

 

Maximum opportunity for employees in
other countries is the equivalent of €500 per month.

Shareholding guidelines

To create alignment between the
interests of Executive Directors and shareholders.

Executive Directors must build up
and maintain a holding of shares in the Company equivalent to a minimum of
300% of salary for the CEO and 200% of salary for other Executive Directors.
Executive Directors must retain half of post-tax vested awards until the
guidelines are met. Shareholding guidelines may be met through both
beneficially owned shares and vested but unexercised options on a notional
net of tax basis. Executives are required to hold the lower of their respective
shareholding guideline and the actual shareholding immediately prior to
departure for two years post-departure.

n/a

D. FROM THE PAST – “ACCOUNTING IN THE PAST HAS NOT TOLD THE WHOLE TRUTH”

Extracts from a speech by Russell G. Golden (then FASB Chairman) at the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Geneva held in 2015:

“Accounting standards must be established in an arena free of bias and free of even the hint of political or business interference. If investors and other stakeholders ever sensed that standards were being set behind the scenes, or to benefit a particular industry or group, they would lose faith in financial reporting and, by extension, the capital markets.

While our process is designed to circumvent politics, outside forces sometimes come into play. One example centered on stock options.

In 1993, FASB issued a proposal that would have required companies to expense the value of their stock options. This did not go over well with some companies, especially with tech industry startup companies that used stock options to compensate employees. In a nutshell, expensing stock options would make profits appear smaller.

Also opposing it were all eight of the major accounting firms. Four of the five commissioners at the SEC spoke out publicly against us. SEC Chairman Arthur Levitt also said he could not support the proposal. In fact, one of the only people who spoke out in our favour was Warren Buffett.

Congress got involved. In the end, we tempered the rule so that companies could either report the cost of options in a footnote, with no effect on earnings, or book them as an expense.

Fast forward to 2001. A series of accounting scandals—including Enron—forced Congress to get serious about reforming corporate practices. The stock options proposal finally made it into GAAP—shortly after Congress enacted the Sarbanes–Oxley Act of 2002. By the way, Sarbanes-Oxley is formally known as “Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection Act.”

Years later, Arthur Levitt publicly admitted that his failure to support the FASB on stock options was the single worst decision that he made during his tenure as chair of the SEC.

Standards that provide an objective view of a company’s financial position enable investors and other users to make the best-informed decisions possible about the allocation of their capital, and second, allows our capital markets to operate as efficiently as they can.

We currently are working to solve some accounting problems where accounting in the past has not told the whole truth.”

Glimpses of Supreme Court Rulings

11 National Petroleum Construction Company vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 2 (2), International Taxation, New Delhi & Ors. (2022) 446 ITR 382(SC)

Deduction of tax at source – Payment to non-resident – Issue of a certificate u/s 197(1) of the IT Act–Scope of enquiry and investigation in proceedings for grant of Certificate u/s 197 of the IT Act – Difference of opinion amongst the judges of Division Bench – Reference made to a larger Bench

The Appellant, National Petroleum Construction Company, was a company incorporated under the laws of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and was a tax resident of that country. The Appellant was, inter alia, engaged in the fabrication of petroleum platforms,pipelines and other equipment, installation of petroleum platforms, submarine pipelines, onshore and offshore oil facilities and coating of pipelines.

Pursuant to different tender notices issued by the ONGC from time to time, the Appellant submitted tenders, inter alia, for installation of petroleum platforms and submarine pipelines. The tenders submitted by the Appellant were accepted, and contracts executed by and between the Appellant and ONGC. The first contract executed was between the Appellant and ONGC in the F.Y. 1996-97, corresponding to the A.Y. 1997-98.

On 28th August 2005, the Appellant was awarded a contract termed as Contract No. MR/OW/MM/NHBS4WPP for the Well Platform Project-II, hereinafter referred to as ‘LEWPP Contract’, pursuant to a global tender floated by the ONGC in July 2005. This was the third contract between the Appellant and ONGC. Later on 23rd November 2006, the Appellant entered into another contract termed as Contract No. MR/OW/MM/C-Series/03/2006, hereinafter referred to as ‘C-Series Contract’, for C-Series Project.

The scope of work as described in the “General Conditions of Contract” for LEWPP Contract and C-Series Contract included, “surveys (pre-engineering, pre-construction/pre-installation and post-installation), design, engineering, procurement, fabrication, anticorrosion and weight coating (in case of rigid pipeline), load-out, tie-down/sea fastening, tow-out/sail-out, transportation, installation, hook-up, installation of submarine pipelines, installation and hook-up of submarine cables, modifications on existing facilities, testing, pre-commissioning, commissioning of entire facilities as described in the bidding document.”

The contracts referred to above included various activities. Whilst the activities related to survey, installation and commissioning were done entirely in India, the platforms were designed, engineered and fabricated overseas – in Abu Dhabi.

The Appellant had been filing its Income Tax Returns from the A.Y. 1997-98. Its income had been computed on a presumptive basis by taxing the gross receipts related to the activities in India, less verifiable expenses at the rate of 10 per cent and the receipts pertaining to activities out of India at the rate of 1 per cent. The provisions of the Agreement for Avoidance of Double Taxation, hereinafter referred to as the “AADT”, between India and the UAE were applicable in determining the taxable income of the Appellant under the IT Act.

The Appellant adopted the said basis for computing its assessable income and filed its returns for the A.Y. 1999-2000 onwards. Accordingly, the returns filed by the Appellant for the A.Ys. 2004-05, 2005-06 and 2006-07 were processed u/s 143(1) of the IT Act. However, the returns filed by the Appellant for A.Ys. 2007-08 and 2008-09, were not accepted by the Assessing Officer, hereinafter referred to as the ‘AO’.

The AO passed a Draft Assessment Order dated 31st December 2009 for the A.Y. 2007-08 holding that the Appellant had a Fixed Place Permanent Establishment in India in the form of a Project Office in Mumbai. The AO further held that Arcadia Shipping Ltd. (ASL), an agent of the Appellant had a Permanent Establishment in India, which constituted a Dependent Agent Permanent Establishment, hereinafter referred to as “DAPE”, of the Appellant.

With regards to the Appellant’s contention that the fabricated material was sold to ONGC outside India, the AO found that the contract was a turnkey and a composite one. It was not divisible as claimed by the Appellant. Accordingly, the AO held that the entire contractual receipts, including the payments for activities performed outside India, were taxable in India. The consideration received by the Appellant for design and engineering was held to be Fees for Technical Services, hereinafter referred to as the ‘FTS’. Since the Appellant had not maintained separate books on the contract, the AO estimated the Appellant’s profit at 25 per cent of the consideration received from ONGC.

The Appellant did not accept the Draft Assessment Order and filed its objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel, hereinafter referred to as the “DRP”. The DRP held that Article 5 of the AADT provided an inclusive definition of ‘Permanent Establishment’ (PE) and that the Appellant’s Project Office constituted a PE of the Appellant in India. The DRP concurred with the AO that ASL was a DAPE of the Assessee.

The DRP observed that the pre-engineering or pre- design survey, claimed to be done by a sub-contractor employed by the Appellant, was an integral part of the contract and the time spent by the subcontractor would also constitute the time spent by the Appellant in India, in computing residence in India for over nine months during the Assessment Year, in terms of the AADT.

The DRP rejected the contention that the contract was a divisible contract and the income of the Appellant for the activities done outside India was not taxable under the IT Act.

The Appellant filed an appeal against the order of the assessment passed by the AO before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal hereinafter referred to as the “ITAT”. The ITAT concurred with the AO and rejected the Appellant’s contention that it did not have a PE in India. The ITAT also concurred with the AO that the establishment of ASL in India was a DAPE of the Appellant.

The ITAT, however, accepted the Appellant’s contention that the contract could be segregated into offshore and onshore activities, and the Appellant’s income for the activities carried on out of India could not be attributed to its PE in India.

The ITAT rejected the Appellant’s contention that the tax payable should be computed as per the formula adopted in the preceding years, i.e. 10 per cent of the receipts attributable to activities in India, less expenses in India and 1 per cent of the receipts attributable to activities carried on overseas.

By a judgment and order dated 29th January 2016, in the appeal being ITA No. 143 of 2013, filed by the Appellant and other related appeals filed by the Revenue, the Division Bench of the High Court of Delhi concurred with the view of the ITAT that consideration for activities carried on overseas could not be attributed to the Appellant’s PE in India. The Court observed that it was not disputed that invoices raised by the Appellant specifically indicated whether the work was done outside India or in India. Thus, even though the contracts might be turnkey contracts, the value of the work done outside India was segregable.

Two contracts were concluded by and between the Appellant and ONGC, one dated 30th September 2016, hereinafter referred to as LEWPP Contract, and the other dated 7th February 2018, hereinafter referred to as the R-series Contract. The Appellant received payments for work done under the said two contracts in F.Y. 2019-20 corresponding to the A.Y. 2020-21.

By a judgment and order dated 9th May 2017 in Writ Petition (C) No. 2117 of 2017, the High Court of Delhi set aside a Certificate dated 31st January 2017 issued by the Respondent No. 1 u/s 197 of the IT Act, requiring deduction of TDS at the rate of 4 per cent on all payments made by the ONGC to the Appellant for activities out of India and within the country in respect of the contract dated 30th September 2016. The R-series Contract was executed after the judgment of the High Court dated 9th May 2017, referred to above. The High Court had no occasion to consider the R-series contract.

On or about 8th May 2019, the Appellant applied for a certificate u/s 197 of the IT Act for deduction of nil tax on payments received from ONGC for activities carried on outside India, in the F.Y. 2019-20 in relation to the aforesaid contracts.

The Respondent, Income Tax Authorities raised queries on its portal, to which the Appellant responded by a letter dated 21st May 2019 addressed to the Respondent No. 1. On further query from the Income Tax Department, the Appellant filed a reply on 13th June 2019 pointing out that no income from activities outside India could be brought to tax in India. The Appellant also submitted a table showing the similarities between the contracts forming the subject-matter of the decision of the High Court and the contracts in the year under consideration, that is, the F.Y. 2019-20.

By the said letter dated 13th June 2019, the Appellant pointed out that for over two and half months since the start of the F.Y. 2019-20, no certificates had been issued to the Appellant u/s 197 of the IT Act as a result of which the Appellant was suffering undue hardship as its cash flow was being hampered. The Appellant, therefore, requested the Respondent No. 1 to issue certificate at the earliest. On 17th June 2019, the Appellant submitted activity-wise key dates for each platform under the R-Series and LEWPP Contracts to the Respondent No. 1.

By letter dated 22nd June 2019, addressed to the Respondent No. 1, the Appellant answered further queries. However, in view of the financial crunch faced by the Appellant, the Appellant requested:

“The Applicant humbly submits that since it is facing financial hardship as the first quarter of F.Y. 2019-20 has come to an end and it is yet to have the lower withholding tax certificate, the Applicant (without prejudice to its legal position), is willing to offer a concession to have the certificate at the tax rate of 4% plus applicable surcharge and cess for the entire contractual revenues, which is in line with the recently concluded assessment proceedings for A.Y. 2016-17 in Applicant’s own case, where your goodself concluded that the entire contractual revenues were chargeable to tax u/s 44BB of the Act at an effective tax rate of 4% plus applicable surcharge and cess. In light of the above, it is our humble request to your goodself to kindly issue the certificate at your earliest convenience.”

The Appellant had contended that a certificate of nil TDS, for payments received in respect of activities outside India, should have been issued to the Appellant, in deference to decisions rendered by various appellate authorities from the A.Ys. 2007-08 to 2015-16, opining that income in respect of activities out of India was not taxable in India and as also the judgments of the Delhi High Court referred to above.

In the A.Y. 2018-19, the Respondent had followed the same approach as in the A.Y. 2017-18 and issued a certificate dated 10th April 2018 u/s 197 of the Act for nil TDS in respect of payments for activities outside India. This direction was in respect of both LEWPP Contract as well as R-Series Contract.

However, in departure from the position taken in the previous years, the Respondent No. 1 issued a certificate dated 26th June 2019 u/s 197(1) of the IT Act for the F.Y. 2019-2020 corresponding to the A.Y. 2020-2021 directing ONGC to deduct TDS at the rate of 4 per cent on receipts in respect of activities both outside and inside India.

The Appellant filed a Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India being Writ Petition (C) No. 8527 of 2019, inter alia, challenging the said certificate dated 26th June 2019. The Writ Petition was dismissed by the High Court.

Both the judges of the Supreme Court wrote independent judgements differing form each other.

According to Hon’ble Ms. Justice Indira Banerjee, the High Court rightly held that the question of whether the Appellant had PE, could not possibly be undertaken in an enquiry for issuance of a certificate u/s 197 of the IT Act, having regard to the time-frame permissible in law for deciding an application, more so, when regular assessment had been completed in respect of the immediate preceding year and the Appellant was found to be taxable under the IT Act at 10 per cent of the contractual receipts. The Assessing Authority in that year had found that the Appellant had PE in India in the concerned Assessment Year and that the appeal of the Appellant was possibly pending disposal.

According to the leaned judge, whether the Appellant had PE or not, during the Assessment Year in question, was a disputed factual issue, which had to be determined on the basis of the scope, extent, nature and duration of activities in India. Whether project activity in India continued for a period of more than nine months, for taxability in India in terms of the AADT, was a question of fact, that had to be determined separately for each Assessment Year.

Further, it was noted that by its letter dated 22nd June 2019, referred to above, the Appellant had made a request to the Revenue for issuance of a certificate u/s 197(1) of the IT Act permitting deduction of TDS at the rate of 4 per cent plus applicable surcharge and cess, for all contractual receipts, in line with assessment proceedings for the A.Y. 2016-2017 without prejudice to its legal position, since the Appellant had been facing financial hardship and urgently required funds. On 26th June 2019, the Respondent No. 1 issued the impugned Certificate directing ONGC to deduct TDS at the rate of 4 per cent for all sums receivable in respect of activities both outside and inside India. According to the learned judge, the impugned certificate being as per the request of the Appellant, it was not open to the Appellant to make a volte-face and challenge the impugned certificate.

It was further noted that in the final assessment for one or two preceding Assessment Years, it was found that the Appellant did have PE in India and appeals were pending. Furthermore, in course of hearing, Counsel for the Revenue had handed a Draft Assessment Order, issued in respect of the Assessment Year in question, that is, 2020-21, holding that the Appellant had PE in India and was liable to tax in India under the IT Act. According to the learned judge, in any event, tax deducted at source was adjustable against the tax, if any, ultimately assessed as payable by the Assessee and any excess tax deducted was refundable with interest. Hence, interference was not warranted at this stage.

It was however clarified that any observation made by the Court or by the High Court would not influence the final assessment which has to be made in accordance with the law considering all relevant facts and circumstances or any appeal therefrom. In the event, it was found that the Appellant was not liable to tax and would be entitled to refund of TDS with interest.

After going through the judgment and the opinion formed by Justice Ms. Indira Banerjee, Hon’ble Shri Justice J.K. Maheshwari, respectfully disagreed to the conclusions as drawn therein for the following reasons.

According to the learned judge, on reading of the relevant provision and the rules, it was clear that for issuance of a certificate u/s 197 of the IT Act, an application should be made to Assessing Officer under Sub-rule (1) of Rule 28. The Assessing Officer after recording satisfaction that existing and estimated tax liability justifies the deduction of tax at lower rate or no deduction of tax as the case may be shall issue a certificate. While exercising the power to issue a certificate, the Assessing Officer is required to follow the procedure as per Sub-rule (2). He shall consider the existing and estimated tax payable on estimated income of the previous year; tax payable on the assessed or returned income of the last four years from previous year; existing liability under the IT Act; advance tax payment i.e. tax deducted and collected at source for the assessment year relevant to the previous year till the date of making application under sub-rule (1) of Rule 28. Thus, for the purpose of issuance of certificate under Chapter XVII of Section 197 of the IT Act, the procedure for determination has been prescribed to the Assessing Officer on which satisfaction may be recorded by him.

The learned judge, after considering the provisions for assessment of income concluded that, the issuance of the certificate u/s 197(1) is based on the existing and estimated tax liability after recording satisfaction by Assessing Officer following the procedure so prescribed, in rules. However, the procedure for assessment as specified in Chapter XIV of the IT Act is different.

The learned judge noted that the High Court in the impugned order relied upon the proceedings of the Revenue Department, which had been referred in para 10 of the judgment. As per the proceedings referred, the department had acknowledged the High Court order dated 29th January 2016 and said that for A.Y.s 2007-2008 to 2010-2011 there was no PE in India, but the department filed the appeal C.A. No. 8761/2016 which was pending before the Supreme Court. In para 10(7), the High Court further referred the decision of Delhi High dated 9th May, 2017 passed in W.P.(C) No. 2117/2017 and CM No. 9268/2017. The said judgment was solely on the issue of issuance of the certificate u/s 197 relating to the F.Y. 2016-2017. As per the ratio of the said judgment, it was clear that the certificate issued by the Respondent No. 1 regarding deductions of the TDS at the rate of 4 per cent on the entire payment made by the ONGC was set aside. Following the said decision, the department issued the certificate for F.Y. 2016-2017 at the rate of 4 per cent excluding surcharge and cess for inside India revenue and at the rate of 0% for outside India revenue. Further for F.Ys. 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 certificates were issued following the said decision of Delhi High Court for both type of contracts i.e. LEWPP and R-Series. Thereafter, it was recorded that assessments for A.Ys. 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 were completed with a finding that activities of the Appellant were covered u/s 44BB of the IT Act. It was further recorded that the assessment for A.Y. 2017-2018 was selected under CASS which was still pending. Thereafter, noting was made that it was difficult to bifurcate the revenue generated by onshore and offshore activities. However, the rate of deduction proposed was at the rate of 4 per cent. The relevant excerpt of note sheets further reflected that the demand of existing liability was Rs. 35.88 crores for the year 2015-16 and 2016-17 but later it was reduced to Rs. 2.67 crores out of which Rs. 2.63 crores pertained to A.Y. 2017-18 which was still under scrutiny for assessment, thus there appeared to be no existing demand.

According to the learned judge, the said note sheets of the Revenue did not reflect that Clause (i), (ii), (iii) and (iv) of Rule 28AA(2) of Rules regarding estimated and assessed liability of last four previous years; existing liability and advance tax payment i.e. deducted and collected at source till the date of submitting application had been considered for determination, and that the Assessing Officer had applied its mind prior to issuance of desired certificate.

The learned judge was of the opinion that the Delhi High Court made unreasonable attempt to distinguish previous order dated 9th May, 2017 relying on the note sheets of the revenue and tried to distinct LEWPP and R-Series contracts. According to the learned judge, on admitting the certificates at 0% tax deductions for both LEWPP and R-Series contracts for the preceding financial years, the High Court was not justified to make distinction between two types of contracts. In fact the Court ought to have seen the satisfaction recorded by the Assessing Officer after determination of the issues specified in Rule 28AA(2). The Appellant had reiterated that the terms of LEWPP contract and R-Series contract were identical while department without disputing the said facts relied upon the orders of assessment passed in previous years without bringing on record the fact of estimated liability. According to the learned judge, distinction drawn, accepting the contention of the revenue by the High Court ignoring admission of issuing certificate for both types of contracts was completely misplaced. In fact, the certificate u/s 197(1) was issued during a financial year, and on closing of the said financial year, the assessment of which would be made after submission of the return of income and documents with respect to the income from the contract of that particular year. The department may enquire about establishment of PE and income attributable to that PE in assessment proceeding but while dealing the issue of issuance of certificate u/s 197(1) relying upon said issues by the High Court is not justified. During the course of the hearing, the counsel for the Appellant handed over two orders dated 8th September, 2021 passed by Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) for A.Ys. 2016-2017 and 2017-2018 allowing the appeals filed by the Appellant challenging the assessment order for respective assessment year. While allowing the appeal, Commissioner of Income Tax held that the Appellant did not have PE during relevant financial year and, accordingly, the PE contract receipts were not taxable in India.

Further, the record of the case indicated that for the F.Y. 2017-18 two certificates each dated 8th June, 2017 were issued for zero TDS for the A.Y. 2018-19. Similarly, for the F.Y. 2018-19 (A.Y. 2019-20) two certificates dated 10th April, 2018 and 8th May, 2019 were issued for zero TDS. Therefore, after the order of the High Court dated 9th May, 2017, it ought to have been of relevant consideration to Assessing Officer to record satisfaction, which had not been considered by the High Court. The reply of the Appellant dated 22nd June, 2019 had been referred in the impugned order stating that the Appellant reserved its right subject to legal objections and requested for issuance of certificate at the rate of 4 per cent plus applicable surcharges and cess because of financial hardship. The said letter should not have influenced the wisdom of the Court, where the prescribed procedure under Rule 28AA had not been followed by the Assessing Officer.

According to the learned judge, since there was no change in circumstances and the situation of the Appellant in the F.Ys. 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 (A.Ys. 2018-19 and 2019-20) respectively and at the F.Y. 2019-20 in question (A.Y. 2020-21), were the same, the principle of consistency ought to be followed while considering the application u/s 197 of the IT Act.

The learned judge held that the order passed by the High Court was without considering the perspective and scope of issuance of the certificate for deduction of tax at lower rate or no deduction at tax and also without following the prescribed procedure. The High Court had wrongly distinguished the previous judgment dated 9th May, 2017 on the premises which was not tenable, and relied upon undertaking dated 22nd June, 2019 of Appellant submitted perforce.

In view of the difference of opinion between the judges, the Registry was directed to place the matter before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India so that an appropriate Bench could be constituted to hear the case.

From The President

Dear BCAS Family,

When you get this message you would have been heaving a sigh of relief from the battle against the timeline for filing the income tax returns and the tax audit reports. Much needs to be talked about and put forward to the concerned authorities on the procedural issues that we all faced but at the start of this auspicious season of festivals, let us focus on some positives.

“It’s not India’s decade. I actually think it’s India’s century…” Let these words of Bob Sternfels, CEO, McKinsey & Co. reverberate in our minds, hearts and being, and inspire us! I was absolutely enthused when I read it, and I think all Indians should align and work towards building India, the great nation that we are. Bob ardently believes that India is where economic history is going to be written. India, he said is the future talent factory of the world. By 2047, India would have 20 per cent of the world’s working population. Manufacturing would also move to the next level with critical supply chains being reimagined. Digitisation is another pillar; he believes that will play a pivotal role in India’s economy.

While the major economies of the world are staring at stagnant growth, spiralling inflation and looming recession, India is surging ahead. For the first quarter of the F.Y. 2022-23, India’s GDP growth rate was a phenomenal 13.5 per cent – that’s 2.8 times higher than the average GDP growth for the 20 largest economies. To accelerate the pace of development and enable India to keep striding confidently ahead, the government has regularly introduced a spectrum of focussed growth boosters. Make in India, Start-up India, Digital India, the Smart City Mission and the Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation…are just some of the government’s flagship initiatives to strengthen the nation’s economy.

India is certainly on a good wicket!

The government’s concerted efforts to attract investments both from local and global sources are already paying rich dividends. With more than 100 unicorns valued at US$ 332.7 billion, India has the third-largest unicorn base in the world. India recognises almost 80 start-ups each day, that’s the highest per date rate in the world. This achievement is the result of the government’s foresight and diligence in implementing ‘Ease of Doing Business’ measures. Tax incentives, intellectual property rights and regulatory reforms are some of the key focus areas that have enabled corporate entities to take root and flourish. CMIE data on investments in new projects by the private sector for June 2022 has escalated 117 per cent over the pre-Covid level.

Financial services are another benchmark that clearly defines the growth trajectory of the economy. It has notched a 9.2 per cent increase in credit growth – with disbursal in F.Y. 2023 close to Rs. 6 trillion. Interestingly, MSME, which employs many people and retail loans have been the main drivers of this growth. Another key indicator of a vibrant economy is the growing momentum of cashless payments. The drive to encourage digital payments was initiated to curtail black money and corruption. This endeavour got a further impetus during the pandemic, which pushed many more to adopt digital transaction for personal safety. Unified Payment Interface registered a record 657 crore transactions in August, amounting to Rs. 10.7 lakh crore – reflecting the choice of a digitally empowered generation.

Manufacturing has been picking up momentum…in May 2022, the Index of Industrial Production (IIP) stood at 137.7 driven by mining, manufacturing and electricity sectors. This is fairly commendable when one factors in the devastating impact of the Ukraine war which severely disrupted global supply chains and sent commodity and energy prices steeply upwards.

Spiralling Tax Collections

With the decimating of the pandemic, India’s economy has not merely revived but demonstrated impressive growth. Further ramping up India’s economic surge are the concerted efforts and visionary policies of the proactive government. Business processes have been simplified and clearances streamlined, to encourage investment across all sectors. Technology has been effectively leveraged, to plug tax leakages. And the results have been quite astounding…

The gross collection of Direct Taxes for the F.Y. 2022-23 stands at Rs. 8,36,225 crore compared to Rs. 6,42,287 crore in the preceding financial year, registering a growth of 30 per cent. Advance Tax too has shot up, with collections for the F.Y. 2022-23 at Rs. 2,95,308 crore as on 17th September, 2022 resulting in a growth of 17 per cent.
.
Also remarkable is the huge increase in the speed of processing of income tax returns, with almost 93 per cent of the duly verified ITRs having been processed. Refunds amounting to Rs. 1,35,556 crore have been issued in the F.Y. 2022-23, an increase of over 83 per cent over the previous year.

GST collections have ascended 28 per cent year-on-year to touch Rs. 1.44 lakh crore in August. This is the sixth consecutive month in which GST collections have stayed above the Rs. 1.4 lakh crore mark. The stepped-up collection is a mirror of confidence in the government and the use of technology to nudge many more into contributing to nation-building.

Does this mean all is well in India and this is a story about India shining? Have we reached a point where we do not need to ponder over the areas where we need to better our record both as society and elected government? No way! In my humble opinion in our haste to seizing economic opportunities, we are overlooking social ills and disparities. No government can function effectively without the active contribution by its subjects. Are we participating in the initiatives of disseminating education to underprivileged of almost 50 crore people? Are we helping in any way people to get water and other basic necessities? Our record as citizens is far from encouraging on these issues. Hence, consequential inequality is increasing alarmingly and needs to be addressed urgently.

At the government level there seems to be a perception that for every aberration noticed in the economy, a tightened hold of bureaucracy and further compliances would cure the malaise and resolve the issue. This has resulted in an uncanny situation where on one hand “Ease of Doing Business” is getting priority in government policy; while on the other hand the increasing bureaucratic compliances is becoming an antithesis to the idea. Let us hope that we as nation will overcome these hurdles.

Let me have the pleasure to give you all a little update on some important developments and events.

ICAI announced Audit Quality Maturity Model (AQMM) will become mandatory for certain audit firms to self-assess their audit quality maturity from next financial year. This indeed is a welcome step. At BCAS we had some very interesting events organized. Seminar on Charitable Trusts, Workshop on Process Automation under GST, Felicitation of newly qualified CAs, and Workshop on IA were truly appreciated by the participants. A Workshop on DSC Management is being organized on the 8th October by the Technology Committee. There are many more interesting events being planned in the coming months. May I request you to keep tab on the announcements?

And before I sign off, let me wish You and Your Families a very Happy Navratri and Diwali. Let the light of knowledge kindle our lives with unending bliss and happiness.

Representation Made

1. BCAS has submitted, “Representation to the Charity Commissioner”, regarding extension of time-limit for audit submission of audited accounts and related documents in the Office of Charity Commissioner for FY 2022-23

To read the Representation – Scan here

2. BCAS has submitted, “Representation to the Finance Minister of India”, regarding Notification No. 7/2023 dated February 21, 2023, in respect of filing Form 10B & 10BB, deferring the applicability by one year.

To read the Representation – Scan here

SOCIETY NEWS

‘GST ISSUES RELATING TO INTERMEDIARY’

The Indirect Tax Study Circle of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society arranged its inaugural meeting on ‘GST Issues relating to Intermediary’ on 7th July which was addressed by Group Leader CA Yash Dhadda and Mentored by CA Udayan Chokshi.

CA Yash Dhadda made a detailed presentation on the law and issues relating to Intermediary Services under GST. The presentation broadly covered the following:

(1) Taxability under the erstwhile Service Tax regime;
(2) Definition and Place of Supply provisions under GST;
(3) Current outcome of writ petitions;
(4) Discussion on case studies covering various scenarios.

All the above issues were discussed at length. Mentor CA Udayan Chokshi explained the complexities involved in various scenarios and shared his views on the same. Important case studies and advance rulings were also discussed.

More than 150 participants benefited from the presentation shared by the duo of CA Yash and CA Udayan.

GST INTERPLAY – CUSTOMS, FTP & SEZ

The BCAS Indirect Tax Study Circle arranged a two-day meeting on ‘GST Interplay – Customs, FTP & SEZ’ on 31st July, and 10th August, 2021. It was addressed by Group Leader CA Rishabh Singhvi and Mentored by CA Prashant Deshpande.

CA Rishabh Singhvi made a detailed presentation on the concepts and parameters for differences and similarities between the various indirect tax laws, viz., Customs, GST, FTP and SEZ. Several case studies were drafted by the Group Leader and discussed at length by the participants. The following important issues were discussed:

(i)  Merchant Trade,
(ii) EOU Unit Implications,
(iii) SEZ Unit Implications,
(iv) MOOWR Implications,
(v) Dual Incidence Implications,
(vi) Rule 96(10) issues, and
(vii) FTA Benefits.

Mentor CA Prashant Deshpande guided the group discussion at various stages and shared his expert views on the multiple tax issues involved. Important case studies and advance rulings were also taken up.

CA Jayesh Gogri had mentored and guided the Group Leader in drafting the presentation and the case studies.

The active participation of more than 80 members helped them to benefit from the group discussion.

DEPARTMENTAL AUDIT & ADJUDICATION PROCEDURES

The Indirect Tax Study Circle’s meeting on ‘Case Studies on Department Audit and Adjudication Procedures and Practical Issues’, which was held on 7th August, was addressed by Group Leader CA Keval Shah with CA Rajiv Luthia as Mentor.

Group leader CA Keval Shah had drafted detailed case studies for discussion which covered the following aspects in regard to Department Audit and Adjudication:

(a) Whether the scope of Departmental GST Audit can cover the period under Service Tax;
(b) Partial submission of data within time limit u/s 65(4) of the CGST Act, 2017;
(c) Interest on ineligible input credit availed but not utilised;
(d) Eligibility of ITC claimed in GSTR3B but not reflected in GSTR2A;
(e) GST on purchases from unregistered dealers;
(f) Payment of tax and interest demanded by audit team through utilisation of ITC; and
(g) Eligibility of ITC on delayed payment of GST under the RCM.

Mentor CA Rajiv Luthia guided the group discussion and shared his expert views on the multiple tax issues involved. Important case studies and advance rulings were also discussed. More than 60 participants benefited from the presentation.

SILVER JUBILEE ITF CONFERENCE

 

The Silver Jubilee International Tax and Finance (ITF) Conference, 2021 was conducted online from 12th to 16th August with a record attendance of 474 members from around 36 locations all over India. The total number of participants, including faculties and special invitees, crossed the 500-mark.

In keeping with the tradition of past ITF Conferences, this year’s Conference, too, was designed to include various contemporary and practically relevant topics for the international tax practitioner.

Eminent personalities and experts graced the Conference and shared their invaluable thoughts and experiences on their respective areas of expertise. The five-day Conference was marked by 13 technical sessions, including three group discussion papers, five presentations, three panel discussions (spread over four sessions) and one fire-side chat.

There were a total of 32 members on the faculty, including speakers and session chairmen, 29 group leaders and 19 contributors for case studies and the background material. It clocked over 35 hours of solid study during the Conference.

Facilitating Group Discussions: This year’s ITF had three papers for group discussion written by CA Pinakin Desai, CA Padamchand Khincha and CA Yogesh Thar. The participants were split into six, each group ably led by 29 group leaders (across the three papers) who helped generate in-depth discussion of the case studies from the papers. The paper writers could undertake a virtual tour of each group to follow the discussions by the participants.

Day 1: 12th August

President CA Abhay Mehta gave his opening remarks and explained the BCAS’s activities and its new initiatives. Chairman of the International Taxation Committee Dr. CA Mayur B. Nayak welcomed the participants and made the introductory remarks.

The Conference was inaugurated by the Past Chairman of the International Taxation Committee and the Chairman of the very first ITF Conference, CA Dilip J. Thakkar, with a welcome address. The President of the ICAI, CA Nihar Jambusaria, also addressed the participants. This being the Silver Jubilee Conference, CA Rashmin Sanghvi, Founding Member of the ITF study group, also spoke.

The Keynote Address was delivered by Padma Vibhushan N.R. Narayana Murthy on a very interesting and relevant topic – ‘The role of culture in improving governance in a company’. He laid stress on three key values, namely, ethics, transparency and honesty, for building a sound organisational culture and governance in a company.

As readers would be aware, investment and business activities have substantially increased in the Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (GIFT City) and various regulatory amendments have been made to enhance the lure of GIFT City – India’s first International Financial Services Centre (IFSC). On the first day of the Conference, Advocate Siddharth Shah dealt with ‘GIFT City IFSC – Regulatory and Tax Aspects of Investments and Transactions’ in great detail and explained various complex nuances to the participants. CA Vispi Patel chaired the session and also provided his insights on the subject.

Day 2 – 13th August

The day began with a group discussion on the paper written by CA Pinakin Desai on ‘Controversial Issues Arising from Tax Treaty Interpretation’.

CA Gautam Doshi spoke on ‘Structuring of Family Trusts – FEMA & Other Regulatory Aspects’. He covered various aspects of the subject in great detail, including conceptual explanations, legal and practical points for consideration, provisions of income-tax, FEMA, SEBI and even CRS regulations. Past President CA Dilip J. Thakkar chaired the session and also provided insights on the issues involved.

CA Pinakin Desai, dealing with his paper ‘Controversial Issues Arising from Tax Treaty Interpretation’, for over two and a half hours, highlighted in a detailed but succinct manner various issues such as possibility of access to tax treaty in light of general anti-avoidance rules (GAAR); principal purpose test (PPT) driven by MLI; simplified limitation of benefits provision (SLOB) driven by MLI; and certain select issues of treaty interpretation. Interestingly, CA Pinakin Desai was also a speaker and the Chairman of the International Taxation Committee at the 1st ITF Conference held in 1997 at the Manas Resorts, Igatpuri, Maharashtra. Past President CA Kishor Karia chaired the session and also gave his views on the subject.

The last session of the day was the panel discussion on ‘Experience and Developments in Transfer Pricing’. The panel consisted of CA Vijay Iyer, Dr. CA Hasnain Shroff and CA Kunj Vaidya and was chaired and Moderated by CA T.P. Ostwal.

The panel shared its thoughts and gave insights on specific issues in transfer pricing through case studies. The case studies covered practical issues which would be of relevance in today’s scenario, such as the Covid-19 impact on TP arrangements, APAs for service entities and profit attribution to PE, section 56(2)(X) and TP valuation, impact of secondary adjustment provisions, Covid-19 impact on the manufacturing sector and so on.

Day 3: 14th August

The proceedings started with a group discussion on the paper written by CA Padamchand Khincha on ‘Recent Developments in Taxation of Digital Economy in India’.

Dr. CA Anup Shah spoke on ‘Startups – Tax, FEMA & Regulatory Aspects’ covering various relevant issues such as registration and certification, funding options, exit options and new-age structures, SPACs, Externalisation of Investments and so on. Past President CA Chetan Shah chaired the session and set the ball rolling with his opening remarks.

CA Rashmin Sanghvi, speaking on ‘Future of International Tax Practice and Global Economy’, gave his perspective on the current status of the Indian regulatory system and international tax practice in India. He then described the background of the global events impacting international tax, especially the digital tax war, and provided guidance to professionals on the future of international tax practice. Past President CA Raman Jokhakar chaired the session and offered his perspectives on the topic.

Prior to the fireside chat and panel discussion on taxation of digitised economy, Advocate Mukesh Butani spoke succinctly on Pillar 1 and Pillar 2 of the OECD proposal in the context of taxation of the digitised economy.

In the fireside chat (recorded earlier) on ‘Global Developments in Taxation of Digitised Economy’ with Advocate Mukesh Butani, Mr. Pascal Saint-Amans, Director, Centre for Tax Policy and Administration, OECD, shared his thoughts and gave participants an insight into the potential future of taxation of the digitised economy and what one can expect in the near future. The chat was widely covered by the media in India as well as abroad.

Subsequently, there was a panel discussion on ‘Global Developments in Taxation of Digitised Economy’. The panel consisted of Mr. Carlos Protto, Director of International Tax Relations, Ministry of Economy, Argentina; Mr. Rajat Bansal, a senior IRS official and CCIT; and CA Radhakishan Rawal. It was chaired and Moderated by Advocate Mukesh Butani. The panel covered some of the nuances of the 2-Pillar approach agreed upon by the Inclusive Framework and also gave its views on the future of unilateral measures and Article 12B of the UN Model.

CA Padamchand Khincha, with his paper on ‘Recent Developments in Taxation of Digital Economy in India’, highlighted the various developments in India on the subject, including Significant Economic Presence (SEP), Equalisation Levy (EL), TDS provisions u/s 194-O and taxation of software in light of the recent Supreme Court judgment. Past President CA Rajan Vora chaired the session and gave his valuable inputs on the subject.

Day 4: 15th August

The day began with a group discussion on the paper written by CA Yogesh Thar on ‘Emerging issues in Cross-Border Personal Taxation’.

The first part of the panel discussion on ‘International Taxation – Recent and Emerging Issues and Developments in Law, MCs and Jurisprudence’, was held on Day 4. The panel consisted of Mr. Kamlesh Varshney, IRS and Joint Secretary (TPL) – Finance Ministry, Senior Advocate Ajay Vohra and CA Padamchand Khincha and was chaired and Moderated by CA Pranav Sayta. It was a unique and technically-rich discussion, as the panellists discussed issues from different perspectives.

The issues discussed covered a range of topics of relevance in today’s world – issues related to tax residence of individuals, the applicability of anti-abuse provisions, i.e., GAAR and PPT, availing benefit under the MFN Clause, withholding tax aspects in Multilateral Instrument (MLI), digital currency (classification of income and related issues), Covid-19-related taxation of foreign companies in India, and the term ‘Liable to tax’ and interpretation of Article 3(2).

The frank and thorough exchange of views among the panellists, ably supplemented by the Chairman’s probing queries, made the discussion very interesting and elaborate and provided a lot of food for thought to the participants. The panel discussion was based on case studies prepared by BCAS contributors who also presented their case studies to the participants.

CA Yogesh Thar, while dealing with his paper on ‘Emerging issues in Cross-Border Personal Taxation’, raised interesting points arising from recent developments in personal taxation due to amendments in section 6 relating to residence in India, and Covid-related issues in personal taxation. Past President CA Gautam Nayak chaired the session and also gave his inputs.

The day ended with a special programme, ‘Reminiscences of ITF Journey’ wherein the role of all past Chairmen, coordinators, speakers and contributors of the previous ITF Conferences was recognised, their experiences were relived and their efforts applauded – thus creating an emotional walk down memory lane for all participants. The programme was anchored by Dr. CA Mayur B. Nayak and CA Mayur B. Desai. It was well attended by past contributors and they shared memories of every Conference. CA Jagat Mehta prepared the presentation with details of past Conferences with photographs.

Day 5: 16th August

The second part of the panel discussion on ‘International Taxation – Recent and Emerging Issues and Developments in Law, MCs and Jurisprudence’ (already explained above) was held on Day 5. The frank and thorough exchange of views continued between the panellists, Mr. Kamlesh Varshney, IRS and Joint Secretary (TPL) – Finance Ministry, Senior Advocate Ajay Vohra and CA Padamchand Khincha, ably supplemented by Chairman CA Pranav Sayta’s probing queries.

CA S. Krishnan spoke on ‘Foreign Tax Credit – Practical Aspects and Experience with Case Studies’ covering various issues related to the topic and shared his rich, practical experience. CA Dinesh Kanabar chaired the session and also provided his insights.

Concluding remarks

While the personal touch and the camaraderie amongst participants during past physical Conferences were definitely missed, the participants were hugely enthused by the various sessions. This was the second consecutive ITF Conference held online, wherein delegates participated from their respective places – but thanks to the seamless connectivity, it was one of the most engaging and successful Conferences.

The Silver Jubilee ITF was held under the guidance of the Chairman of the International Taxation Committee Dr. CA Mayur Nayak. CA Abbas Jaorawala as the Chief Conference Director, ably assisted by CA Mahesh Nayak as Joint Conference Director, minutely supervised all the sessions personally and devoted a tremendous amount of time and effort to make it the resounding success that it turned out to be.

Other members of the core team were CA Ganesh Rajgopalan, CA Rutvik Sanghvi, CA Siddharth Banwat, CA Anil Doshi, CA Jagat Mehta, CA Natwar Thakrar, CA Tarunkumar Singhal and CA Rajesh P. Shah. Several others also made laudable contributions of time and effort to make the Conference a landmark event for the BCAS. It ended on a high note and received encouraging response and feedback from the participants.

Proceedings of the Conference can be viewed on YouTube at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWR2h3f0frg and also via the following QR Code:

 

 ‘LOCAL AND GLOBAL INVESTING’

The BCAS organised a lecture meeting by Mr. Kushal Thaker on ‘Evaluation of Stocks – New Economy vs. Old Economy – Local and Global Investing’ on 18th August.

It was planned with the aim of empowering professionals in understanding evaluation techniques and equipping them with the requisite knowledge as they set out on the road to becoming efficient business advisers.

President CA Abhay Mehta welcomed the participants and offered his remarks on the subject. CA Mihir Sheth introduced the speaker, Mr. Kushal Thaker, who is an astute trader and investor in commodities, equities and currency also known as ‘Specunomist’.

 

 

The speaker explained the concepts relating to various asset classes and their analysis.

Key issues and learnings of the meeting
1. New Economy vs. Old Economy
(a) New Economy: IT sector has experienced quantum leap from .com in 2000 to an apps-based life and now moving to Artificial Intelligence,
(b) Old Economy: Cement to Metal to Mining,
(c) Now, old economy is helping new economy companies by providing raw material and other products that act as inputs for new economy stocks,
(d) To analyse Electric Vehicle Companies, it is important to study the trend of commodities like copper, lithium and nickel. This can be extended to companies undertaking mining of these commodities.

2. Local and Global Investing
(e) Look at stocks beyond the Indian border. It’s likely that India may not have companies listed in that space,
(f) For example, global copper and lithium mining. There are no lithium mining companies listed in India. To take advantage of the upward trend in lithium, investing in global lithium mining would be beneficial.
(g) Never think in terms of defensive stocks. That comes only in a bear market. A bear market scenario in India is unlikely over the next decade.

3. Crude Oil
(h) As crude prices go up, investors usually look to buy oil-producing and oil marketing companies. It will be much better to have globally diversified companies in this space, as Indian companies are either government-controlled or in the small caps space.

4. E-commerce
(i) The pandemic acted as a tailwind for e-commerce. But then there were no e-commerce companies listed in India. Now we have Zomato. So, investing in global e-commerce is profitable as these companies have given mammoth returns during the last one year.

5. Key drivers of growth for the next decade
(j) High tech, new economy, old economy stocks – all supplemented new economy stocks,
(k) Hence one cannot see any bear cycle. Of course, corrections are likely, but only of approximately 10% to 20%, but not a bear market,
(l) A bull market is always going on somewhere in world. So it is not necessary stick to the Indian market,
(m) Be bullish on commodities – gold, silver, steel, rare earth or base metals, natural gas.

6. Beginners into International equity
(n) Internationally, ETF on FAANG returns is lower than the return generated by individual stocks,
(o) Direct investment through brokerage houses – Interactive brokers or Kotak Securities

7. Cryptocurrency
(p) Crypto is an asset class by itself. Each crypto has a role to play. Top 15 cryptos are worth reading against 800 cryptos being available for trading,
(q) SWIFT code is a messaging service between international banks and Indian banks for transfer of forex. SWIFT cannot move fast. But crypto is direct transfer of funds and very fast, too. Crypto-backed services are Ripple and Stellar,
(r) Some cryptos are moving into gaming and bond markets,
(s) India has 11 Crypto platforms and each has its own Crypto (currency). If there are more miners (of Cryptocurrencies), then volatility is going to be very high.

8. IPOs
(t) New IPOs in fintech and logistics companies are good,
(u) Investors should not hesitate from investing in high-growth loss-making companies as long as they don’t foresee any competition coming up in that space,
(v) Also, look into how management is planning for future growth. Many of these new e-commerce and fintech companies have global presence,
(w) If the company has good potential of going into Artificial Intelligence or becoming a Tech Company, supporting fast-growing companies can be considered as good potential investments.

The speaker, Mr. Kushal Thaker, also addressed the queries raised by the participants and shared his thoughts on evaluation techniques for stocks and commodities.

The meeting concluded with a vote of thanks proposed by CA Anand Bathiya to Mr. Kushal Thaker, who addressed the participants from his office in Chicago, USA.

The proceedings of the meeting are available on YouTube at:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDBOMkHCN2E and also on the following QR Code:

 

‘MUMBAI’S COVID PANDEMIC MANAGEMENT MODEL’

The BCAS, along with the Dharma Bharti Mission and the Public Concern for Governance Trust, organised a lecture meeting in memory of the Late Shri Narayan Varma on ‘Mumbai’s Covid Pandemic Management Model’ on 24th August. It was addressed by Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal, IAS and Commissioner of the BMC. It was held through virtual mode on Zoom platform with live-streaming on YouTube.

 

Ms. Farheen Peshimam started the proceedings and shared a video containing fond memories of the late Shri Narayan Varma with the three associations. She also read a message from the Late Shri Narayan Varma’s Family.

Mr. Paramjeet Singh, President of the Dharma Bharti Mission, delivered the welcome address. He also welcomed the keynote speaker and the three awardees. He gave an insight into the various initiatives taken and the contributions made by the Late Shri Narayan Varma during his lifetime and the impact he made on society and the three organisations at large. Ms Farheen Peshimam then formally introduced Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal.

Mr. Chahal started by describing the scenario under which he had taken charge of the BMC on 8th May, 2020. Since then, innumerable initiatives had been taken by him and the BMC during the pandemic; he summarised these as follows:

• Systems were created to fight the long war against Covid-19. The model that was created had 27 sub-models to fight the pandemic;
• The model was implemented by dividing Mumbai into 24 war rooms with a real-time dashboard of the Covid-19 cases;
• The approach was a combination of proactive and offensive steps to contain the pandemic at the very start;
• Containment zones were created to chase the virus;
• Sanitization drives were conducted to break the chain of the virus and prevent the multiplication of cases;
• Appointing community leaders in slum areas so as to achieve better coordination;
• Increase spending by BMC on the medical infrastructure and addition of 800 ambulances to fight the virus;
• Distribution of free PPE kits to doctors and medical practitioners;
• A Covid dashboard was created with public and private hospitals and all the reports were managed by a BMC-appointed team of doctors;

• Hospital beds were allotted on the basis of social equality, thereby avoiding a chaotic or panic situation of patients running from one hospital to another;
• Creation of seven Jumbo centres in various parts of the city which were converted into full-fledged greenfield hospitals in record time under the mentorship of top doctors;
• Private hospitals helped by agreeing to cap the rates of beds and other medical facilities which made this a successful public-private partnership;
• Pre-emptive stocking of life-saving medicines at the onset of the second wave proved to be crucial to successfully manage and control the second wave;
• Various campaigns run by BMC to fight Covid-19, like ‘My family, My responsibility’ and ‘No Mask No entry’ to create awareness among the people;
• Initiatives taken to avoid any major mishaps during the oxygen crisis in the second Covid-19 wave and the cyclone faced by Mumbai in the month of May, 2021.

Mr. Chahal shared that the speed of vaccination was quite steady and if this continued, then Mumbai would be spared any major third wave that was likely to hit in October-November, 2021. He lauded the contribution of various NGOs in distribution of food packets and other initiatives. He also responded to the questions from the participants before concluding his session.

To summarise Mr. Chahal’s address, he made some important statements:

1. Let us not be demoralised,
2. We have been chosen by God and given this opportunity to serve humanity,
3. Systems will fight the pandemic and not the individuals, and
4. We have to chase the virus in an offensive manner.

Following this excellent talk, the three Narayan Varma Memorial Awards were announced.

1. The first awardee was Advocate Maharshi Dave, Founder of Sparsh Trust. This Trust was initially founded to help stray dogs in the city, but its principles led them to expand their efforts towards helping both animals and humans.

Giving a brief talk, Mr. Dave emphasised that the foundation believed in the concept of service and empathy. It believed that the more one gave, the more one got. ‘The platform provided by this event is very important for the Trust as it helps in spreading the word about the services that we can provide to many more in need,’ he added.

2. The next awardee was Shri Ravi Singh, Founder of Khalsa Aid International. This is a UK-based humanitarian relief charity that provides aid to people affected by various natural as well as man-made disasters. Even in this pandemic, it was at the forefront and donated planeloads of oxygen cylinders and oxygen concentrators to all parts of India and the world.

3. The third and final awardee was Mr. Ranga Rao, who retired as Assistant Director in the Intelligence Bureau in January, 2010 after 39 years of service. The Late Shri Narayan Varma had encouraged Mr. Rao to learn how to use RTI. Soon, Mr. Rao had started filing RTI applications to address the grievances brought to his attention by poor citizens. The success rates of these applications encouraged his group to start a programme which focused on spreading awareness about the use of RTI to help resolve several issues. Since 2013, Mr. Rao has taught more than 2,000 students all over India the use of the RTI Act to fight corruption.

The meeting ended with a vote of thanks to Mr. Iqbal Singh Chahal proposed by BCAS President CA Abhay Mehta, who officially concluded the meeting.

The lecture is available on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IgaLf8rqvZs and via QR Code

 

‘GDP & ECONOMIC ANALYSIS – PERSPECTIVE AND IMPORTANCE FOR CAS’

A lecture meeting was organised by the BCAS on ‘GDP & Economic Analysis – Perspective and Importance for CAs’. It was delivered by CA Raj Mullick on 25th August.

 

.

The lecture was designed with the aim of empowering professionals in understanding and interpreting economic data and economic indicators, to broaden the horizon for advising and enabling professionals in taking a more holistic view about the way businesses are carried out, and their overall impact on the country at large.

President CA Abhay Mehta welcomed the participants and shared his views on the topic under discussion. CA Chirag Doshi introduced the speaker.

The speaker, CA Raj Mullick, made a detailed presentation on the concepts relating to Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and its analysis. The presentation broadly covered the following:

1. Economy during the pandemic,
2. Micro- and macro-economics,
3. Economy’s income and expenditure,
4. What is GDP?
5. GDP components – (Consumption, Investment, Government spending, Net exports),
6. Real vs. nominal GDP,
7. GDP indicators,
8. Limitation of GDP as a measure of a nation’s well-being,
9. International differences in GDP and quality of life,
10. Saving and investment in national income accounts,
11. Impact of pandemic on the GDP,
12. GDP – Current India @ 2021,
13. GST indicators,
14. Role of Chartered Accountants.

CA Raj Mullick made extensive use of charts, circular flow diagrams and graphics to explain the concept of GDP and so on. He also conducted a quick check of the understanding of the participants by posing practical case studies and eliciting responses on the impact of various situations on the GDP.

The participants took active part by sharing their views on the questions and case studies posed by the speaker. More than 100 persons benefited from the presentation shared by him.

CA Mrinal Mehta proposed the vote of thanks.

The lecture is available on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bVuE73LaEk and also via QR code:

AMENDMENTS IN INCOME-TAX ACT, 1961

The Students’ Forum, under the auspices of the BCAS HRD Committee, organised a training session for CA Article Students on ‘Changes in Income-tax Forms and Corresponding Amendments in the Income-tax Act, 1961 for Individuals and HUFs’ on 30th August.

The Study Circle was led by CA Utsav Shah and CA Viren Doshi who are experts on the subject. CA Khubi Shah, the coordinator, introduced the speakers and spoke about the various activities and events conducted by the BCAS Students’ Forum. He encouraged students to actively participate in the events organised by the Forum.
The speakers covered the return-filing process right from the beginning and described in detail the filing of returns on the newly-launched portal using the new utilities introduced. They discussed in detail the section-wise and clause-wise changes and corresponding changes in the return format.

CA Utsav and CA Viren also covered the detailed process and utility walkthrough and guided the students on filing various sections of the form and precautions to be taken to avoid validation error, defective return and demand u/s 143(1). A return-filing checklist was also provided for the benefit of the students.

The session ended with CA Dnyanesh Patade, coordinator, proposing the vote of thanks both to the speakers and to the participants. Around 100 students participated in the interactive session and their feedback was very positive.

The entire session can be viewed on the BCAS YouTube channel at ‘Training Session for CA Article Students – YouTube’ and also via the following QR Code:

 

TREE PLANTATION & EYE CAMP PROJECT 2021

After a gap of one year because of the Covid-19 pandemic, it was time to continue with the decade-old legacy of contributing to the upliftment of tribals and needy persons. The current pandemic has taught us the importance of oxygen, immunity and healthcare.

The HRD Committee under the aegis of the BCAS Foundation organised a two-day visit to Dharampur and Vansda on 25th and 26th September with the objective of caring for nature by planting trees, to provide primary healthcare and quality education to the tribal population, and to help in reaching out to the hitherto neglected people and provide them with timely treatment of cataracts. Thanks to the generosity of our esteemed donors, the BCAS contributed Rs. 7,00,000 for these noble causes.

In view of the current scenario of Covid, a small group of 21 volunteers, representing BCAS on behalf of the donors, got together for the symbolic tree plantation and attended the eye camp. It also visited three NGOs active in the remote villages.

(1) Sarvodaya Parivar Trust (SPT). The group reached Pindval-Dharampur to visit the SPT centre. The trust implements the vision of Acharya Vinoba Bhave of unconditional service to tribals. It works in the fields of environment, education and water conservation and follows a holistic approach for poverty alleviation based on Gandhian principles. The BCAS group interacted with the trustees and volunteers. It also met the children studying at the centre, interacted with them and distributed sweets. The group, along with a team of local farmers, conducted symbolic tree plantation in the fields. It planted mango and bamboo saplings. The BCAS Foundation contributed Rs. 3 lakhs for the plantation of 10,000 trees. Sujataben told them about the activities being conducted by the trust in 35 nearby villages and the challenges faced by them in doing the same. She also explained the outcome of the activities which impacted the life of thousands of residents of the hilly region.

(2) ARCH – Action Research in Community Health, Nagaria. ARCH was founded by the Late Dr. Daxaben Patel to provide basic preventive, curative and maternal-child health services. The Managing Trustees are Mr. Rashmibhai and  Mr. Sudarshan Iyengar, former Vice-Chancellor of Gujarat Vidyapeeth and a leading scholar on Gandhian studies. They and their young and passionate associates took the BCAS team through various innovative teaching techniques for students and their skill development programme, as also the new water-saving techniques used in the plantation. ARCH also conducts mobile health camps in inaccessible villages. The BCAS contributed Rs. 1,50,000 for the triple purposes of tree plantation, skill development and children’s education.

(3) Dhanvantari Trust – Sant Ranchhoddas Eye Hospital Vansda. This body runs an eye hospital which provides free cataract operations and other kinds of eye care for the indigent people. Ghanshyambhai and other trustees described the contribution of the founder trustee, the Late Dr. Kanubhai, in pioneering a 100-bed hospital and that has conducted over 60,000 eye operations with the support of doctors and volunteers who identify patients and arrange for their treatment at Vansda. He explained how ignorance about eye problems because of extreme poverty, misconceptions and so on, result in blindness among the poor. The trustees also talked about the future plans of bettering the facilities, services and upgrading the equipment. The BCAS Foundation contributed Rs. 2,50,000 for the eye camp which performed 250 cataract operations.

 

 

It was a touching experience to see the devotion and selfless service by volunteers for upliftment of the tribal society. All the participants and Trustees expressed their thanks to BCAS for organising the visit to the project sites.

Society News

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS

1. Full Day Workshop – “Use of Technology in GST Compliance” held on 9th September, 2023, at BCAS Hall.

The Indirect Taxation Committee jointly with Technology Initiative Committee organised a full day workshop on the use of technology in GST compliance through a demonstration of various automation tools. Automation and use of software in compliance processes can help professionals increase the efficiency of their team and improve compliance.

The 1st session was addressed by CA Jigar Doshi and CA Yash Goenka on strategies for evaluation and selection of automation software and practical challenges in implementation. They explained the checkpoints and important considerations while selecting ERP and ASP / GSP Software.

This was followed by a Panel Discussion on Issues, challenges and areas for automation in GSTR1, GSTR 3B and ITC Reconciliation by use of ASP / GSP Software. The Panel was composed of Darshan Shah and CA Punit Mehta from Tally, CA Aneree Shah from ClearTax and CA Vaishali Dedhia and the panel was moderated by CA Mandar Telang.

The 3rd session was addressed by CA Nachiket Pendharkar who explained the use of VBA and Macros in Excel for preparation of data for GST returns and reconciliation.

CA Rajiv Narayanan explained and demonstrated the use of Robotic Process Automation and Artificial Intelligence tools like Python, Alteryx, Chat GPT and Gamma.app in the 4th and the final session. He emphasised on the increase in efficiency and accuracy of the team by use of RPA and AI.

The event was attended by more than 50 participants and they benefited from the deliberations of the speakers.

2. Half Day Seminar on “Revised Format of Audit Report for Charitable Institutions”, held on 2nd September, 2023, at IMC, Churchgate.

A half-day seminar on Revised Format of Audit Report containing a session explaining the changes made in Form 10B and 10BB applicable for A.Y. 2023–14 followed by a Panel Discussion was organised by the Taxation Committee in a hybrid mode.

CA Sonalee Godbole explained Form 10B clause-wise with a break-up of the details being called by the auditor. She explained the care to be taken while reporting the information and the risks associated with incorrect or incomplete reporting and how the auditor is responsible for the entire reporting to the Income-tax Department.

At the time of the panel discussion — clause-wise questions and answers were undertaken by CA Anil Sathe and CA Gautam Nayak. They cited the decisions of the courts and tribunals which helped the participants to understand the coverage of the revised forms.

The seminar ended with a Q&A session with the participants. The seminar was attended by over 425 participants physically and online.

Representation dated 11th September, 2023, requesting the deferment of the applicability of the revised form 10B / 10 BB (Audit report for Charitable Trusts) by one year.

Based on the various aspects discussed in the said seminar, the Society, with the help of Taxation Committee, also made a representation to the Hon’ble Finance Minister on 11th September, 2023, expressing concerns over complex coverage of the forms vis-a-vis machinery and resources available with the assessees (viz. charitable / non-profit organisations) to compile the details and information called for in the said forms. The Society therefore requested the deferment of the revised forms for a period of one year and continuance of the old forms for the time being.

To read the Representation, Scan the QR code on the following page:

[Editor’s Note: Vide Circular No. 16/2023, dated 18th September, 2023 the CBDT has extended the due date for furnishing Audit Reports in form 10B/Form10BB for the A.Y. 2023–24 from 30th September, 2023, to 31st October, 2023]

3. “Forensic Accounting and Investigation Standards (FAIS)” event held on Friday, 1st September, 2023, at Hotel Parle International.

The ICAI has recently issued revised Forensic Accounting and Investigation Standards (FAIS). These standards have now become mandatory for all the engagements conducted on or after 1st July, 2023. Internal Audit Committee organised this seminar to enlighten the participants about the framework governing these revised standards, the basic concepts covered in the standards, legal framework and report writing. The seminar received a good response, particularly from young participants who want to foray into the field of forensic audits.

The seminar was divided into four sessions followed by a panel discussion. The faculty for the sessions were part of the Expert committee of ICAI which was involved in the standard-setting process and hence they had good insights on the topic. CA Satish Shenoy, in his key-note address, spoke about the need for FAIS, governing framework and professional opportunities for CAs. CA Nikunj Shah, in the first technical session discussed various concepts across FAIS. This was followed by discussion about its relevance and recognition and the extent of reliance on the work of the professionals in legal world which was taken by CA Uday Kulkarni. Lastly, CA Chetan Dalal shared his practical experiences, recent cases and discussed a few tips about the report writing. The seminar ended with a panel discussion between all the three technical session experts and interaction with the participants in Q&A form which was guided by CA Ashutosh Pednekar. All speakers were very lucid and they made the sessions very interesting and engaging with lots of examples.

Link for downloading the standards:  https://resource.cdn.icai.org/75009daab030723.pdf

4. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle on “Key changes under TCS provisions” on 1st September, 2023, in Online Mode.

The study circle meeting was led by CA Chaitee Londhe wherein the participants discussed the following points:

• Amended Provisions of Section 206C(1G) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and her analysis of the same.

• Overview of the Amendments introduced to the TCS provisions by the Finance Act, 2023.

• Subsequent changes were introduced to the TCS provisions by way of Circular No. 10/2023.

• Amended Provisions of Section 206CC and 206CCA of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

• Amendments introduced in the Liberalised Remittance Scheme of RBI.

• Clarifications issued by the CBDT with respect to the amended TCS provisions.

The speaker delivered a comprehensive analysis and insightful perspective on the amended TCS provisions, offering invaluable clarity by dissecting the CBDT’s issued clarifications.

5. Panel Discussion on “Investing in India’s AmritKaal: Equities and beyond” held on Friday, 25th August, 2023, in Online Mode.

In a dynamic financial landscape, the event “Amrit Kaal” organised by the Managing Committee shed light on the shifting paradigms of investment. The speakers Mr Kushal Thaker, Mr Aditya Sood, and CA Vikas Khemani meticulously navigated through the evolving asset classes, emphasising how Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs), Commodities, Portfolio Management Services (PMS), and even Sovereign Gold Bonds are carving distinctive realms within the investment spectrum. These unconventional avenues, once ancillary, are now emerging as robust investment classes, offering diversification and new avenues for wealth creation.

A pivotal theme of the event was the transformation in India’s macroeconomic landscape. The speakers illuminated how India’s economic trajectory has witnessed notable shifts over recent years, reshaping the investment narrative. Insights were shared on the changing dynamics of growth, inflation, fiscal policies, and global positioning, offering attendees a comprehensive view of the macroeconomic trends shaping investment decisions.

Of paramount significance was the discourse around equity investments. The event unpacked how equity, as an enduring asset class, is extending its allure to new entrants in the market. With insightful discussions on long-term strategies, risk management, and the role of technology, attendees gained a profound understanding of the opportunities and challenges that equity investments present, not only for seasoned investors but also for those embarking on their investment journey.

Throughout the event, the resonating message was the need for adaptability. The financial landscape is no longer static; it’s a dynamic ecosystem where traditional norms are being redefined. The event encapsulated the essence of embracing change, whether by exploring diverse asset classes, decoding macroeconomic shifts, or embracing equity investments as a transformative force.

The panel discussion was guided by CA Abhay Mehta who moderated the session.

Link for watching the session: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xs5frO6kdo

QR Code:

6. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle meeting on “Reassessment under the Income-tax Act — Law and Practice” held on Thursday, 24th August, 2023, via Zoom.

Dharan Gandhi took up Part 2 of the meeting on the topic of Reassessment under the Income-tax Act — Law and Practice, wherein he discussed the following concepts and issues relating to the assessment procedures:

• Section 150 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 relating to cases where assessment is in pursuance of an order on appeal.

• Section 151 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 relating to Sanctions for issue of notices by the specified authority for the purposes of Section 148 and Section 148A.

• Procedure for reassessment under the new provisions in Search and Non-Search Cases, and Search Cases of a third-party including steps, approval and time period relating to the same.

• Relevant Case Laws on Section 148 and 148A of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

• Analysis and views of various courts on notices issued at different points in time.

The speaker conducted a thorough examination of the recently established reassessment provisions, clearing not only their intricacies but also delving into the diverse perspectives presented by various courts in response to the raised issues during the reassessment proceedings. The session concluded with a vote of thanks.

7. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle meeting on Issues with respect to “Deductions under Capital Gains” held on Friday, 18th August, 2023, in Online Mode.

The study circle meeting was led by CA Shashank Mehta in which the participants discussed various issues w.r.t. allowability of deductions under capital gains, with the help of Case Studies. The following concepts were covered:
• Cost of Acquisition with respect to section 55 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (Act).

• Eligible exemption as per section 54F read with section 50C of the Act.

• Cost of acquisition in case of House Property where the entire amount of Interest is not allowed as a deduction u/s 24(b) of the Act.

• Eligible Indexation as per section 48 of the Act.

• The criteria to be fulfilled for claiming exemption as per section 54, section 54EC, section 54F of the Act.

• Deduction under section 54 in case investment in new house property is not purchased in the name of the Assessee.

The group leader provided a comprehensive breakdown of capital gains deductions, citing case studies and case laws to illustrate allowable deductions and exemptions shedding light on important concepts.

8. BCAS’s Social Cause Visit to Umargaon: “Nurturing Education and Nature” on 5th and 6th August, 2023.

As one of the initiatives of the Managing Committee, in a remarkable display of community spirit, BCAS & BCAS Foundation orchestrated a two-day event that combined the power of education and environmental stewardship. A group of 27 dedicated volunteers participated in the social cause visit at Umargaon.

The event kicked off with a Social Cause visit to schools helped by the BCAS Foundation in collaboration with the Rushabh Foundation which took on the admirable responsibility of providing education infrastructure in 25 schools, through the introduction of Digital Classrooms. These schools overcame the challenge of teacher shortages and ignited a newfound enthusiasm for learning. Witnessing the astonishing results achieved in just six months was nothing short of awe-inspiring. BCAS has assured its support to ensure quality education for all. The team played indoor and outdoor games, fostering an atmosphere of joy and inclusivity.

As planned, the team visited Bhaskar Save’s Natural Farm, “Kalpavruksha”. Revered as the ‘Father of Natural Farming’ in India, Bhaskar Save and his successors illuminated the principles of Natural Abundance. Exploring the dichotomy between Natural and Organic Farming, the team learned how the farmer aligns with the fundamental principle of cooperation inherent in nature itself. The five critical concerns of farming — Tillage, Fertility Inputs, Weeding, Irrigation, and Crop Protection — were elegantly addressed through nature’s intricate balance. Bhaskar Save’s conviction that “Non-violence is only possible through natural farming” resonated deeply, a testament to the harmony that can be achieved through sustainable practices.

 

On the subsequent day, the group ventured to the proposed land of the MaBap Foundation. The four pillars of the foundation are PrakrutikChikitsa (Natural Healing), SanskrutikVikas (Cultural Development), Vedic Abhyas (Vedic Practices), and AdhyatmikUnnati (Spiritual Progress), through which the foundation embodies holistic growth. The significance of PanchTatva (Five Elements)

in every facet of existence was highlighted, setting the tone for a symbolic tree-planting ceremony. Excitement and enthusiasm rippled through the group as they planted Ashopalav, Neem, Mango, Jamun, and Saru trees, marking a significant stride towards BCAS’s 75th year.

The group treasured enriching memories and returned with an enlightening experience of profound learning, gratitude, and an unshakable belief in the power of concerted efforts to create a better world.

9. A Panel Discussion on “Disclosure of Foreign Assets and Incomes” held on 26th July, 2023, in Online Mode.

The Taxation Committee organised a Panel Discussion on Disclosures of Foreign Incomes and Assets in a virtual mode. The Panel consisted of CA RutvikSanghavi, CA KartikBadiani, and CA Mahesh Nayak who co-authored the book on “Disclosures of Foreign Assets and Incomes” published by BCAS.

CA Hardik Mehta moderated the session addressing various questions to each of the panelists bringing out comprehensive responses from each Panelist.

CA Rutvik Sanghavi explained the importance and objective and the rationale behind the enactment. He also stressed on the principles one needs to keep in mind while reporting the same. He also explained the importance of the documentation for reporting the foreign assets and income. He also briefly touched upon reporting of gifts, ESOPs, etc. The issue of mismatches was also explained and how to mitigate the same with proper documentation.

CA Kartik Badiani answered questions with respect to reporting in the foreign asset schedules including the impact of change in residential status, reporting by minors, reporting of joint holding of house properties, investments in Gift City etc. He also took the case study of ESOPs and its reporting issues.

CA Mahesh Nayak took the participants through the case study of overseas brokerage accounts and how to report the same. He also explained as to which cases will be covered in subparts A1 to A4 and others in B of the FA Schedule.

All three panelists touched upon various other issues involving the FA schedule and what each subpart intends to cover. They even explained the issue regarding the easy availability of foreign exchange rates for reporting., the issue of calendar year vs. financial year etc. The panel discussion was very well received and appreciated the insights shared by all three panelists.

Link to access the space session:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dXoApEdvwnw

QR Code:

10. A Twitter Space Session on “Filing ITR for A.Y. 2023–24” held on 4th July, 2023, in Online Mode.

This Twitter Space Session on filing ITR for A.Y. 2023–24 was organised by the Technology Initiative Committee, with an objective of sharing the crucial precautions and best practices for filing ITR that professionals need to observe.

In a candid discussion that was moderated by the chairman of the committee, CA Ameet Patel, the speakers, CA Nitin Shinghala, CA Sanjeev Lalan, and CA Rajni Shah, shared insights on the dos and don’ts for tax professionals to ensure a hassle-free tax filing experience.

The session was open to all and got an encouraging response as several non-members, including representatives from the media attended the same.

Miscellanea

I. WORLD NEWS — ECONOMY

1. Two Fed Officials Suggest That Interest Rates Will Rise Again

In their first comments since the Federal Reserve Bank decided to keep the US key interest rate unchanged this week, officials from the bank signaled that the hiking cycle hasn’t ended.

Fed Governor Michelle Bowman and Boston Fed President Susan Collins both warned in separate events that inflation is still a threat.

“Inflation is still too high, and I expect it will likely be appropriate for the Committee to raise rates further and hold them at a restrictive level for some time to return inflation to our 2 per cent goal in a timely way,” Bowman said in a speech at an event of the Independent
Community Bankers of Colorado in Vail. “I see a continued risk that energy prices could rise further and reverse some of the progress we have seen on inflation in recent months.”

Bowman said that, according to economic projections assessed by the FOMC, inflation will stay above the Fed’s 2 per cent “at least until the end of 2025.”

The Fed’s Federal Open Market Committee voted on Wednesday to maintain the benchmark rate in the range of 5.25 per cent to 5.50 per cent, the highest level in 22 years. Both Bowman and Collins said they supported the decision.

Projections in the Fed’s dot plot, which accompanied the announcement, showed the likelihood of one more hike this year and two cuts in 2024, or two fewer than indicated in June’s update.

“I expect rates may have to stay higher, and for longer, than previous projections had suggested, and further tightening is certainly not off the table,” Collins said at the annual convention of the Maine Bankers Association. “There are some promising signs that inflation is moderating and the economy rebalancing. But progress has not been linear and is not evenly distributed across sectors.”

Annual U.S. inflation accelerated to 3.7 per cent in August from 3.2 per cent in July, pressured mainly by gas prices. The Fed has two more monetary policy meetings in 1st November, and 13th December, 2023.

(Source: International Business Times — By Helder Marinho — 22nd September, 2023)

2. SPORTS

1. India Fires First World Record of Asian Games as Japanese Teen Dazzle

India claimed the first world record of the Hangzhou Asian Games on Monday as hosts China snapped up more gold medals and 15-year-old skateboarder Hinano Kusaki triumphed for Japan.

The Indian trio of DivyanshPanwar, RudrankkshPatil and AishwaryTomar blew away the field with a new world-best 1,893.7 points to win the men’s 10m air rifle team event on day two of the multi-sports extravaganza.

They beat the previous mark of 1,893.3 set by China last month in Baku.

In doing so they won India’s first gold of a Games where the hosts have swept 28 of the 44 titles decided so far.

“In the 10m event they are both perfect athletes,” Tomar said of his teammates. “Playing with them is huge, it’s really good.”

Another shooting world record fell to China’s Sheng Lihao in the men’s 10m air rifle with his 253.3 points surpassing teammate Yu Haonan’s 252.8 from Rio four years ago.
“I had good luck in the final. I did quite well today, I was basically smooth,” said Sheng.

Like India, Macau clinched its first gold in Hangzhou, with wushu athlete Li Yi winning the Changquan title to become the first woman in history from the Chinese territory to earn an Asian Games gold.

“I’m really proud. This one completes the process so I feel really fortunate,” said the 31-year-old.

“This, maybe, brings my 20 years as an athlete to a perfect end.”

In other early action on day two, Kusaki dazzled in skateboarding to easily win the women’s park final at Qiantang Roller Sports Centre.

“I am very happy with how everything went,” said the teenager.

After winning all seven gold medals in the swimming pool on the opening day, China is primed to dominate again on Monday night, spearheaded by breaststroke world champion Qin Haiyang.

The Chinese star caused a major upset at the world championships in Fukuoka in July when he won the 100m gold in 57.69 ahead of a stacked field and in the absence of British great Adam Peaty.

He went on to complete an unprecedented clean sweep of the breaststroke titles, an achievement he is aiming to match at his home Asiad as he builds towards next year’s Paris Olympics.

Qin, the second-fastest ever over 100m after Peaty, was in a class of his own in the heats, touching in 58.35 to better the previous Games best set by Japan’s Yasuhiro Koseki in 2018.

South Korea’s Choi Dong-yeol came in second — a gaping 1.55 seconds behind Qin.

Hong Kong’s Siobhan Haughey could prevent another Chinese clean sweep when she lines up in the women’s 200m freestyle final.

(Source: International Business Times — By Martin Parry — 25th September, 2023)

3. BUSINESS

1. India fourth in number of startups with $50million + funding: Study

India ranks fourth in the world in the number of scaleups, or startups that have received more than $50 million of disclosed VC investment. Ahead of India are the US, China, and the UK, the first edition of Startup Genome’s Scaleup Report said.

However, it’s ahead of the UK in the total VC investment that has gone into these scaleups, and in the cumulative tech value investment of the scaleups. India, the report says, has recorded 429 scaleups, with a VC investment of $127 billion and a total value of tech investment of $446 billion.

The report is a research into scaleup success factors, building on the question of what behaviours, resources, and characteristics of startups differentiate those that within four to eight years scaled to $50 million and higher valuations from those startups that didn’t.

Startup Genome, an innovation policy advisory and research firm, surveyed startups in over 80 cities across more than 40 countries and looked at 60 plus metrics.

The report said India has startups with 50 per cent or more of their customers coming from outside of their continent and having the highest scaleup rate. This can partly be attributed to startups that tailor their products and services to truly global markets — not just beyond their country, but beyond their continent — dramatically increasing their potential customer base.

Startups based in large countries (US excluded) scale at a higher rate when they focus on their domestic market. In those countries, the size of the domestic market is so large that it may be worth delaying or forgoing global markets. This is certainly clear in India, where B2C startups can achieve unicorn status and billion-dollar exits without going out of the country. Startups with a local connectedness index score of 6 or above achieve a scaleup of 5.1 per cent compared to 3.8 per cent for those with a score of 2 to 4 — a 34 per cent boost. The local connectedness index measures the size, density, and quality of a startup’s local network. Early-stage startups with a higher local connectedness index see their revenue grow twice as fast as those with a lower local connectedness index.

Scaleup success rate clearly increases with global connectedness, and startups that develop a high level of global connectedness have a 3.2 times higher chance of scaling than those with a low level. Ecosystems that are more connected to top global ecosystems (such as Silicon Valley, NYC and London) see their startups go global at a much higher rate on average (66 per cent correlations between those very distinct variables)

Founders looking to improve their chances of scaling should ensure that they offer stock options for all employees, have more than five global connections to top ecosystems, and have at least three advisers for their startup.

(Source: Times of India – By ShilpaPhadnis – 25th September, 2023)

Regulatory Referencer

I. COMPANIES ACT, 2013

1. One-time relaxation for filing of Forms–3, Form–4 and Form–11 under the LLP Act without any additional fee: MCA has granted one-time relaxation in additional fees for LLPs that are/were unable to file Forms 3, 4 and 11 within due dates. Filing of Forms 3 and 4 without additional fees shall be applicable for event dates from 1st January, 2021 and onwards. The filing of Form 11 without additional fee shall be applicable for F.Y. 2021-22 onwards. Further, these forms shall be available for filing from 1st September, 2023 onwards till 30th November, 2023. [General Circular No. 8/2023, dated 23rd August, 2023]

2. MCA extends the tenure of the Company Law Committee by another one year till 16th September, 2024: The Ministry of Corporate Affairs vide an order dated 18th September, 2019 had constituted the Company Law Committee to examine and recommend various provisions and issues pertaining to the implementation of the Companies Act, 2013 and the LLP Act, 2008. The tenure of the said Company Law Committee was set to expire on 16th September, 2023 which is now extended till 16th September, 2024. [Order No. 2/1/2018-CL-V, dated 13th September, 2023]

II. SEBI

3. Voluntary delisting norms for non-convertible debt securities and non-convertible redeemable preference shares: SEBI (LODR) (3rd Amendment) Regulations, 2023 are notified. As per the amended norms, a new chapter —VI A has been added which prescribes the framework for voluntary delisting of non-convertible debt securities/ non-convertible redeemable preference shares. It shall not be applicable on certain listed entities like a listed entity that has outstanding listed non-convertible debt securities or non-convertible redeemable preference shares issued by way of a public issue etc. [Notification No. SEBI/LAD-NRO/GN/2023/149, dated 23rd August, 2023]

4. Additional disclosures for certain Foreign Portfolio Investors: SEBI has mandated the criteria for submission of additional disclosures by foreign portfolio investors under FPIs norms. As per the criteria, details of all entities holding any ownership, economic interest, or exercising control in the FPIs need to be provided by certain FPIs. These are FPIs that hold more than 50 per cent of their Indian equity Assets Under Management (AUM) in a single Indian corporate group and FPIs that individually, or along with others hold more than R25,000 crore of equity AUM in the Indian markets. [Circular No. SEBI/ HO/ AFD/ AFD — POD — 2/CIR/ P/2023/148, dated 24th August, 2023]

5. Framework for unitholders of REITs and InvITs allowing them to exercise their board nomination rights: SEBI has released a framework for eligible unit holders of Real Investment Trusts (REITs) and Infrastructure Investment Trusts (InvITs) allowing them to exercise their board nomination rights. As per the framework, the manager of a REIT / InvIT must review whether the eligible unit holders who have exercised their board nomination right, continue to hold the required number of units of REIT / InvIT and make a report on the same. The circular shall be effective immediately. [Circular No: SEBI/HO/DDHS-POD-2/P/CIR/2023/153 & 154, dated 11th September, 2023]

DIRECT TAX: SPOTLIGHT

1. Guidelines under Section 10(10D) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 — Circular No. 15/2023, dated 16th August, 2023:

Finance Act, 2023 made amendments to Section 10(10D). These amendments significantly impact the income-tax exemption eligibility for sums received under life insurance policies.

The circular contains comprehensive guidelines, designed to determine the taxability of consideration received under eligible life insurance policies with the help of a series of detailed scenarios and examples.

2. Extension of timelines for filing Form 10B/10BB and Form ITR 7 for Assessment Year 2023-24 — Circular No. 16/2023, dated 18th September, 2023:

The CBDT has extended the due date for furnishing Audit reports in Form 10B/Form 10BB for A.Y. 2023–24 from 30th September, 2023 to 31st October, 2023.

Consequently, the due date for filing the Return of Income in Form ITR-7 for the A.Y. 2023–24 has also been extended from 31st October, 2023 to 30th November, 2023.

3. Insertion of Rule 11UACA Computation of income chargeable to tax under section 56(2)(xiii)- Income-tax (Sixteenth Amendment) Rules, 2023 – Notification No. 61/ 2023, dated 16th August, 2023:

The Rule provides computation of income chargeable to tax under Section 56(2)(xiii), where any person receives at any time during any previous year any sum under a life insurance policy.

4. Amendment to Rule 26 Rate of Exchange for the purpose of deduction of tax at source on income payable in foreign – Income-tax (Seventeenth Amendment) Rules, 2023 – Notification No. 64/ 2023, dated 17th August 2023.

5. Amendment to Rule 3(1) computation of perquisite value of rent-free accommodation provided by employer — Income-tax (Eighteenth Amendment) Rules, 2023 —Notification No. 65/ 2023, dated 18th August, 2023.

6. Insertion of Rule 134 and Form 71- Application under section 155(20) regarding credit of tax deduction at source – Income-tax (Twentieth Amendment) Rules, 2023 — Notification No. 73/2023, dated 30th August, 2023:

Where any income has been included in the return of income furnished by an assessee for any assessment year and tax on such income has been deducted at source in a subsequent financial year, the assessee can apply to the Assessing Officer in Form 71 to obtain credit of TDS.

FEMA AND IFSCA REGULATIONS

1. RBI allows residents to make study-related remittances in IFSCs under LRS:

Presently, remittances to IFSCs under LRS can be made only for making investments in securities. Resident individuals can now remit payment of fees to foreign universities or foreign institutions in IFSCs for pursuing courses mentioned in the Notification No. S.O. 2374(E), dated 23rd May, 2022 under the purpose ‘studies abroad’ as mentioned in Schedule III of Foreign Exchange Management (Current Account Transactions) Rules, 2000. [A.P. (DIR SERIES) Circular No. 6, dated 22nd June, 2023]

2.Discontinuation of MIFOR as a ‘Significant Benchmark’:

RBI has announced that after 30th June, 2023, the Mumbai Interbank Forward Outright Rate (MIFOR) shall cease to be recognised as a ‘significant benchmark’. This decision comes as a result of the cessation of the US Dollar LIBOR. The updated list of significant benchmarks shall come into effect from 1st July, 2023. [Circular No. FMRD.FMSD. 03/03.07.25/2023-24, dated 23rd June, 2023]

3. International Credit Card usage brought under LRS:

On 16th May, the Government omitted Rule 7 of Current Account Transaction Rules resulting in transactions made through the use of ICCs by residents abroad to be covered under LRS. The purpose was to bring transactions made through ICCs under the TCS net. This change was covered in the previous journal. However, after hue and cry, the Government has backtracked and reinstated the rule, w.e.f. 16th May. In effect, the use of ICCs abroad is again outside the LRS limit and the status quo is maintained. However, further changes can be expected by 1st October 2023, the date till when TCS on LRS has been deferred to. [Notification No. G.S.R. 472(E) [F. NO. 1/5/2023-EM], dated 30th June, 2023]

4. IFSCA introduces the definition of ‘distributor’:

IFSCA has introduced the definition of ‘distributor’ in IFSCA (Capital Market Intermediaries) Regulations, 2021 and made related amendments in other regulations. [Notification No. IFSCA/2023-24/GN/REG040, dated 3rd July, 2023]

5. Central Government prescribes the procedure for import, export, procurement and supply of ships by an IFSC Unit:

The Government has amended the SEZ Rules by inserting a new Rule 29B to set the procedures for import or export or procurement from or supply to the Domestic Tariff Area of ships by a Unit in the International Financial Services Centre. [Notification No. G.S.R. 481(E) [F. NO. K-43013(13)/2/2022-SEZ], dated 4th July, 2023]

6. RBI issues report of the IDG on Internationalization of INR:

An Inter-Departmental Group (IDG) of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) was formed to examine the internationalization of INR. The objective of the IDG was to review the extant position of INR as an international currency and to frame a road map for the internationalization of INR. The IDG has submitted its report containing its final set of recommendations. The recommendations of the report will be examined by RBI for implementation. [Press Release 2023-2024/539, dated 5th July, 2023]

7. IFSCA allows IFSC Banking Companies to set up banking units in IFSC in addition to IFSC banking Units:

IFSCA has amended its Banking Regulations to allow IFSC Banking Companies to set up banking units in IFSC in addition to IFSC banking Units. The amendment allows the establishment of a banking unit in an IFSC as either an IFSC Banking Unit (IBU) or an IFSC Banking Company (IBC). Earlier, this option was not available. The key amendments include the introduction of the terms “IFSC Banking Unit” and “IFSC Banking Company”, along with the criteria for granting a license or permission to set up an IFSC banking company have been prescribed. [Notification No. IFSCA/2023-24/GN/REG041, dated 6th July, 2023]

Letters to the Editor

To
The Editor,
BCAS,
Mumbai

Respected Sir,

This has reference to the latest articles by Dr. Anup P. Shah in the September Edition of BCAJ.

The article written by Mr. Anup Shah is of great importance as most of the clients of a practicing chartered accountant have borrowed funds for personal / business purposes. The Indian System of borrowing from banks and financial institutions invariably seek collateral securities and backed by guarantee from one or more guarantors. Often such guarantors are not aware of their responsibilities and future contingent liabilities.

The author has provided detailed analysis of provisions under Indian Contract Act as also other contemporary laws such as IBC laws, etc. The evolution of legal case laws and up to date situation of applicable laws to a guarantor have been brought out succinctly and comprehensively. The utility value of such articles of day to day advisory services to clients has been enormous and highly useful. Many of articles written by the author Dr. Anup P. Shah have been highly useful for day to day practice for CAs and tax practicing professionals.

We thank Mr. Anup Shah for taking time out of his very busy schedule and rendering yeoman’s service to the profession on a regular basis for last several years by way of comprehensive articles under the heading “Law and Business”.

CA Mukesh Shah

Dear BCAJ Team,

I write to express my profound appreciation for the enlightening two-part interview featuring Senior Advocate Shri Arvind Datar. His valuable insights derived from a 40-year-long professional journey shed light on a multitude of aspects:

• The early struggles and eventual triumphs in his career trajectory provide a glimpse into the challenging yet rewarding path of the legal profession.

• The delicate balance between his writing experiences and demanding work life offers a perspective that aspiring professionals can learn from.

• From gleaning wisdom from seasoned seniors to imparting guidance and motivation to the younger generation, Shri Datar’s advice and reflections present a roadmap for budding legal minds.

• His candid and bold views, along with suggested improvements to legal provisions, shed light on the need for fairness within the legal system and the hardships faced by the citizens and taxpayers of our nation.
This piece stands as one of the boldest contributions within BCAJ, and I hope it resonates with the right audience, conveying a powerful message.

A significant portion of the credit for this enriching experience goes to the thoughtfully crafted and practical questions posed by the three astute interviewers. Shri Datar reciprocated with equal thoughtfulness, delivering a unique experience for BCAJ readers.

I vividly recall Shri Datar’s impactful address during the release of the Festschrift “Essays and Reminiscences” in honour of N.A. Palkhivala at NCPA, Mumbai, in January 2020. He shared the painstaking efforts and unwavering commitment of his team in curating old records and documents to bring forth the book, even at the expense of their professional practice.

This interview represents a rare and invaluable opportunity, and all involved made the best of it for the benefit of all.

Kudos and three cheers to everyone involved!

Thank you.

CA Suhas Paranjpe