Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

A. P. (DIR Series) Circular No. 20 dated 29th August, 2012

fiogf49gjkf0d
Non-resident guarantee for non-fund based facilities entered between two resident entities.

 Presently, a non-resident can issue a guarantee to a resident lender as security for funds lent to a resident borrower. RBI has granted general permission to resident borrower to make payment to the non-resident guarantor who has met the liability under the guarantee.

This circular grants general permission to a nonresident to issue a guarantee to a resident provider of non-fund based facilities, such as Letters of Credit/ Guarantees/Letter of Undertaking/Letter of Comfort, etc., to a resident borrower. General permission has also been granted to a resident borrower to make payment to the non-resident guarantor who has met the liability under the guarantee.

Further, annexed to this circular is a format introduced by RBI for reporting, on a quarterly basis, the issue and invocation of such guarantees. This format has to reach the Chief General Manager, Foreign Exchange Department, ECB Division, Reserve Bank of India, Central Office Building, 11th floor, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001, not later than 10th day of the following month.

levitra

Wealth Tax: Exemption: Section 40(3)(vi) of Finance Act, 1983: A. Ys. 1988-89 to 1992-93: Assessee in leasing business: Property given on lease is asset used in business: Property falls within specified assets u/s. 40(3)(vi): Exemption available.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. Donatus Victoria Estates and Hotel P. Ltd.; 346 ITR 114 (Mad.)]

Assessee was carrying on the business of leasing. The assessee had let a hotel building and the lessee used it as a hotel. In the A. Ys. 1988-89 to 1992-93, the assessee claimed exemption from wealth tax in respect of the property u/s. 40(3)(vi) of the Finance Act, 1983 as an asset used in the assessee’s business. The Assessing Officer rejected the claim. The Tribunal allowed the assessee’s claim.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Madras High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i) One of the conditions to be satisfied by the assessee u/s. 40(3) was that, the asset must be used in the assessee’s business. The assets let out were used in the leasing business. Not all the assets used in the business were exempt from the purview of the wealth tax. Once the asset let out came within the specified clause as contemplated u/s. 40(3)(vi) of the Finance Act, 1983, the assessee was entitled to exemption.

 ii) One of the objects of the assessee was leasing and another object was running a hotel in the property. Accordingly, the assessee had leased out the property as a hotel and the lessee also used the property as a hotel. Therefore, the assets came within the specified assets as contemplated u/s. 40(3)(vi) of the Finance Act, 1983. The assessee was entitled to exemption.”

levitra

Transfer pricing: Arm’s length price: A. Y. 2002-03: Merely because the assessee had paid the royalty even in respect of the products sold by it to the clients, who had not paid for the same, it would make no difference to the determination of the ALP of the transaction: Once it is accepted that the ALP of the royalty is justified, there can be no reduction in the value thereof on account of the assessee’s customers failing to pay the assessee for the product purchased by them from the assessee<

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. CA Computer Associates India (P) Ltd.; 252 CTR 164 (Bom.)]

For the A. Y. 2002-03, the assessee had filed the return of income, declaring a loss of about Rs. 14.5 crore. Assessee had claimed the ALP of royalty at the contractual value of Rs. 7.43 crore. The Assessing Officer computed the ALP of royalty at Rs. 5.85 crore on the ground that the assessee had paid royalty even in respect of the products sold by it to the clients who had not paid for the products purchased by them. This resulted in the reduction of the loss of about Rs. 1.50 crore. The Tribunal allowed the assessee’s appeal and held that merely because the assessee had paid the royalty even in respect of the products sold by it to the clients, who had not paid for the same, it would make no difference to the determination of the ALP of the transaction.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Bombay High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i) The Tribunal rightly came to the conclusion that merely because the assessee had paid the royalty even in respect of the products sold by it to the clients, who had not paid for the same, it would make no difference to the determination of the ALP of the transaction. Section 92C provides the basis for determining the ALP in relation to international transactions. It does not either expressly or impliedly consider failure of the assesee’s customers to pay for the products sold to them by the assessee to be relevant factor in determining the ALP.

 ii) Indeed, in the absence of any statutory provision or the transactions being colourable bad debts on account of purchasers refusing to pay for the goods purchased by them from the assessee can never be a relevant factor, while determining the ALP of the transaction between the assessee and its principal.

iii) Once it is accepted that the ALP of the royalty is justified, there can be no reduction in the value thereof on account of the assessee’s customers failing to pay the assessee for the products purchased by them from the assessee.

iv) The question is therefore, answered in the affirmative in favour of the assessee. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.”

levitra

Search and seizure: Abatement of assessment proceedings: Section 153A: A. Y. 2002- 03: Assessment or reassessment proceedings pending at the time of search abate: Appeal from assessment pending before Tribunal would not abate.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. Smt. Shaila Agarwal; 346 ITR 130 (All.)]

When the assessee’s appeal for the A. Y. 2002-03 was pending before the Tribunal, search proceedings were initiated against the assessee. The Tribunal passed the order as under:

 “i) The present appeal arises out of the assessment made prior to the date of search. The intention of the Legislature is to make a combined assessment of all the income disclosed or assessed in regular assessment and discovered in search. We accordingly restore the assessment to the file of the Assessing Officer to consider these additions in the assessment u/s. 153A as well. However, in an event where search is declared illegal by any court or the assessment u/s. 153A is held invalid, then this appeal in relation to regular assessment will revive at the instance of the Department, if an application is moved to the Tribunal in this behalf.

 ii) Accordingly, the appeal of the assessee was allowed, but for statistical purposes and subject to the observations made above.”

On appeal by the Revenue, the Allahabad High Court reversed the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i) We are of the opinion that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal erred in abating the regular assessment proceedings, which had become final, and restoring them as a consequence of search u/s. 132, and notice u/s. 153A of the Act to the file of the Assessing Officer.

ii) The appeal is allowed. The order of the Tribunal is set aside. The Tribunal will decide the appeal on the merits in accordance with law.”

levitra

Reassessment: Notice u/s. 148 to be issued for each year separately: AO issuing combined notice for all four years: Reassessment not valid.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[Mohd. Ayub Vs. ITO; 346 ITR 30(All.)]

For the A. Ys. 1994-95 to 1997-98, the Assessing Officer issued a combined notice u/s. 148 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and passed reassessment orders. The Tribunal upheld the validity of the notice and the reassessment order.

On appeal by the assessee, the Allahabad High Court reversed the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

 “i) Each assessment year is an independent unit of assessment and the provisions of the Act applied separately. Even where there had been escapement of income, the Assessing Officer was obliged to issue a separate notice for each assessment year.

ii) He had not issued a separate notice u/s. 148 of the Act and instead had issued a composite notice which did not meet the requirement of section 148 of the Act. Thus the entire reassessment proceedings were wholly without jurisdiction.”

levitra

Microsoft Office 2013 – Part II

About this write-up

MS Office is a popular application software and enjoys wide usage across the world. Recently, Microsoft released the Customer Preview of the latest version of its Office suite i.e. Microsoft Office 2013 (a. k.a Office 15). This write up briefly discusses some of the new features likely to be introduced in the new software, product enhancements to existing features, some pros and cons associated there with.

Background

This write up is the second part of the article on MS Office 2013. The first part dealt with some of the new features that are expected to be a part of MS Office 2013. Some of the features described in the article were:

  • Cloud integration
  • Touch and stylus based interface
  • The new “Metro” look
  • Convenience of editing PDF documents in MS Word 2013
  • Support for Open document format (“ODF”) 1.2
  • Social media-related integration

In this part, we will look at some of the enhancements, new features which are expected to be a part of MS Office 2013. While there are many features that one could write about, given below is a short summary of the changes / new features that you may find useful:

MS Word:

Right from the first moment you start Word, you will notice the crisp new interface. The basic interface has been changed (“Metrified”). The ribbon feature has been changed (Microsoft has made it more flatter) to appear more spacious. One of the reasons for this is that, when the MS Word is used on a smart phone, the look and feel and the user experience while switching from desktop to tablet / smart phone would appear seamless.

Besides the above, cleaning up the main inter-face has the effect of giving more space and allows the user to focus on the document itself rather than the tools (which are supposed to help and not hinder). To be candid, when I migrated from Office 2003 to Office 2007, the one convenience that I appreciated the most, was that the interface allowed me to work on the document / spreadsheet. All the tools that I would need, were neatly organised on the ribbon. Whenever the need arose, they were only 2 or 3 clicks away or (most of the time) just a right click away. I haven’t had the chance to use the MS Word 2013, but I have a feeling that the experience is going to be even better.

The Read Mode feature is yet another feature to look forward to. This feature is particularly aimed at tablet users. As the name suggests, this feature is for reading. When you switch to the Read Mode, the interface is literally reduced to a bare minimum, thus allowing the document to reflow and to fit in to the screen. One can say its almost like the full screen mode. The interface provides “thumb friendly” buttons on either side of the screen for easy navigation. Some users may be in for some disappointment, because this mode allows the reader to read only one document at a time. Duh ….. you wanted to read ….right!!!!, what else do you want???.

The track changes feature too has been improved for better user experience. The user interface in Word 2013 uses a simpler mark-up look, which appears to be less overwhelming (for many) and intimidating (for some) than the earlier red (strikethroughs) and blue (bold/ underline) mark ups. The new Markup view provides final version of the document with indicators in the margin to indicate the sentences which may have been edited. Whenever you are ready to focus on the changes, just click on the indicator line and it will expand into a thread. Users may find this feature particularly useful while collaborating with others.

One of the conveniences that have been discontinued in MS Office 2013 is the option to add spelling in auto correct by right clicking. This feature was introduced way back in MS Office 97 (I think) and was an instant hit. This feature was very useful for correct typos – – the types you make while typing any document for instance you type “o fthe” instead of “of the”. Earlier, all the user needed to do was to right click and instead of just correcting this one instance—add to the auto correct and save the effort for all similar typos. MS Office 2013 will no longer offer this convenience… but don’t despair, you can still go to the Auto Correct menu and add the same. The only difficulty will be finding it.

EXCEL:

Once again, the basic interface has been metrified i.e. looks and feels very crisp. The look and feel is common between all the other applications of MS Office 2013.

If you thought that MS Excel was an outstanding product, the latest version Excel is even better. Microsoft has added some awesome tools, Quick Analysis tool is one them. In the earlier version, if you selected a range of cells with numbers, nothing happened. In MS Office 2013 – Excel, if you select a range of cells with numbers, a QUICK ANALYSIS tool pops up next to the selected range and gives you a variety of options like—Conditional formatting, charts showing most of the information, formulae, tables formats and in cell sparklines (introduced in Office 2010). However, go around any of the options and you will see it either in the data or in one of the pop up charts. The suggestions are intuitive and change according to the data highlighted. While the overall number of options remain the same, the interface would suggest some of the options (such as why a particular chart or a pivot table may be more suitable) which you may find useful.

The next in line is the Chart advisor. An early prototype was featured on the Office Labs, which has now been fully integrated along with other analytical tools in excel. One can say its a plain vanilla version of professional business analytic tools. With the Chart Advisor, the likelihood of you getting the right chart or pivot table in the first attempt itself is far higher…….which many may agree……… translates to tremendous savings in time. Guess that’s one up for artificial intelligence.

The previous avatar of MS Office ie Office 2010 brought in several features which kinda added “jazz” to Excel. The current version ie Office 2013 has focussed more on functionality rather than “jazz”. But that does not mean that there is no “jazz” added in MS Office 2013. As a matter of fact, the error function (ie the indicator which highlight errors or inconsistencies) has been spruced up quite a bit. For instance: if you move between cell or add or delete some figures that lead to a change in some other result or formula, you are likely to see subtle animations to draw your attention to what changes have happened. So what’s new eh!!!!! Well, for starters, if the change is in the area (ie the displayed area / sheet) then the animation is …. let’s just say …..less animated and if its in a different sheet or so …. the animation is …..a bit more animated. If you click the cell, there will be onscreen prompts to lead you to whatever it is that Excel intends to draw your attention to. This makes it much harder to change or delete information that changes your results without noticing that it makes a difference.……sounds exciting, doesn’t it?

Even the error messages are more useful. For instance: suppose you drag a cell across the worksheet when what was really meant to do was to click somewhere else — the older version would give you a fairly “cryptic” warning ….. but this will not be a problem in MS Office 2013— now Excel gives you a warning in far more simple / descriptive manner, suggesting what’s wrong. Add to this, now there is a whole new add-in to look for errors and inconsistencies between worksheets.

Time slicer & the Quick analysis tools are some other tools to look forward to. The time slicer tool helps you to dig further into your data. For instance: it organises data by date, so you can filter down to a specific period or jump through figures month by month to see the differences. The Quick Analysis is like a shortcut of sorts for making sense of your data as it is or one may say that it is a way to preview different visuals i.e. you’ll see various format-ting options, and as you hover over them you’ll see the document change accordingly, giving you a glimpse of what you’ll see if you end up selecting that option. This is quite similar to the formatting and fonts option available since the Office 2007 days.

In MS Office 97, Microsoft introduced the auto fill feature. It’s one of the features that I have come to appreciate over a period of time. It is an excellent tool to use when filling up data in tables. The Flash Fill apparently is a step up. Flash Fill is a feature that recognizes your data patterns to the point where it should be able to predict what belongs in the remaining blank cells and fill them in for you. For example, if you were to make a time sheet spreadsheet detailing on which client time was spent and by which employee, Excel would eventually pick up on the fact of every employee who has worked on the client / specific project and fill up the data for you. For instance: every Saturday is booked for internal filing etc– in theory, you just have to enter some of that data and then go to the Data tab, where you press the Flash Fill button to make it fill in the rest. A bit of caution here …. Feedbacks available indicate that the Flash Fill is not able to interpret / pick on trends in “all” data.

There are several other features to write about but may be in future… once I lay my hands on the official version. Well that’s all for this month… wish you a Happy Diwali in advance.

Disclaimer: The discussion regarding the features and enhancements contained in this write up are based on the various feedbacks/ reviews available on the internet and various magazines, blogs, etc. The purpose of this write up is only to share the knowledge and not to malign any person or product.

Income from house property: Section 22: A. Y. 2004-05: Where service agreement is dependent upon rent agreement, service charges have to be included as a part of its rental income.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. J. K. Investors (Bom) Ltd.; 25 Taxman.com 12 (Bom.)]

In the A. Y. 2004-05, the assessee received rent and service charges in respect of a property owned by it. It claimed both rent income and service charges as ‘Income from house property’. The Assessing Officer accepted the rent income as ‘Income from house property’. So far as service charges were concerned, he held that these service charges were for ancillary services and, therefore, assessable under the head ‘Income from other sources’ and not as ‘Income from house property’. The CIT(A) allowed the claim of the assessee. The Tribunal held that the assessee was providing no services/facilities to the occupants of its property. The services, if any, were being provided by the society. Mere splitting of rent was not decisive and each case had to be examined on its own facts to determine whether the service charges were part of the rent. Therefore, the service charges could not be taxed under the head ‘Income from other sources’, but had to be taxed along with rent income as ‘Income from house property’. Further, the service charges received by the assessee were considered by the Assessing Officer to determine the net maintainable rent and fair market value of the property under the provisions of the Wealth-tax Act. It, therefore, upheld the order of the CIT(A).

 On appeal by the Revenue, the Bombay High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i) There are concurrent findings of fact by the Commissioner (Appeals) as well as the Tribunal that no services are being provided by the assessee to the occupants of its property and that the service charges have to be included as a part of its rental income.

 ii) The test to determine whether the service agreement is different from the rent agreement would be whether the service agreement could stand independently of the rent agreement. In the instant case, the service agreement is dependent upon the rent agreement, as in the absence of the rent agreement there could be no service agreement.

iii) It may also be pointed out that according to the assessee, the services being provided under the service agreement are in respect of staircase of the building, lift, common entrance, main road leading to the building through the compound, drainage facilities, open space in/ around the building, air condition facility, etc. These are services which are not separately provided, but go along with the occupation of the property. iv) Therefore, the amounts received as service charges are to be considered as a part of the rent received and subjected to tax under the head ‘Income from house property’.”

levitra

Fees for technical services: DTAA between India and Netherlands art. 12 r/w. ss. 9 and 90: Indian company prospecting for minerals: Agreement with Netherlands company for conducting geophysical survey and providing data and maps to Indian company: Ownership of data and maps vesting with Indian company: Amount paid by Indian company not assessable in India.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. De Beers India Minerals P. Ltd.; 346 ITR 467 (Kar.)]

The assesses were private companies engaged in the business of prospecting and mining for diamonds and other minerals. For the purpose of carrying out geophysical survey, the assessee entered into an agreement with a Netherlands company Fugro. For the technical services rendered by them, the assessee paid a consideration. The Assessing Officer treated the consideration as falling within the definition of fees for technical services under article 12 of the DTAA between India and Netherlands r.w.s. 90 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Alternatively, he also held that the payment in question was for development and transfer of a technical plan or technical design. He, therefore, held that the assessee had failed to deduct tax on the payments made to Fugro and treated the assessee in default. He levied tax u/s. 201(1) and interest u/s. 201(1A) of the Act. The Tribunal allowed the assessee’s appeal and held that Fugro had not developed or transferred any technical plan or design to the assessee so as to attract article 12(5)(b) of the DTAA and that the amount was not assessable in India.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Karnataka High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

 “i) In terms of the contract entered into with Fugro, Fugro had given the data, photographs and maps, but had not made available technical expertise, skill or knowledge in respect of such collection or processing of data to the assessee, which the assessee could apply independently and without assistance and undertake such survey independently. The technical services provided by Fugro would not enable the assessee to undertake any survey either in the very same area Fugro conducted the survey or in any other area. They did not get any enduring benefit from the survey. In view of the matter, though Furgo rendered technical services as defined under Explanation 2 to section 9(1)(vii), it did not satisfy the requirement of technical services as contained in the DTAA. Therefore, the liability to tax was not attracted.

ii) By way of technical services, Fugro delivered to the assessee the data and information after such operations. The data was certainly made use of by the assessee. Not only the data and information was furnished in the digital form, it was also provided to the assessee in the form of maps and photographs. These maps and photographs which were made available to the assessee could not be construed as technology made available. Fugro had not devised any technical plan or technical design. Therefore, the question of Fugro transferring any technical plan or technical design did not arise in the facts of the case.

 iii) Therefore, the cases did not fall in the second part of clause 15 dealing with development and transfer of plans and designs. Thus, the amount was not taxable in India.”

levitra

Deduction u/s. 80-IA(4) : A. Ys. 2003-04 to 2005-06: Infrastructure facility: Meaning of inland port: Inland container depots are inland ports: Assessee entitled to deduction:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[Container Corporation of India Vs. Asst. CIT; 346 ITR 140 (Del.)]

The assessee, a public sector undertaking, was engaged in the business of handling and transportation of containerised cargo. The activity of the assessee was carried out mainly on its inland container depots, Central freight stations and port container terminals which were spread all over the country. The assessee had a total of 45 inland container depots. For the A. Ys. 2003-04 to 2005-06, the Assessing Officer disallowed the assessee’s claim for deduction u/s. 80-IA(4). The Tribunal upheld the disallowance.

On appeal by the assessee, the Delhi High Court reversed the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

 “i) Out of the total 45 inland container depots operated by the assessee, except two, all others were notified by the Central Board of Direct Taxes for the purposes of section 80-IA(12)(ca). Having regard to the provisions of the Customs Act, the Communication issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs as well as the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, the object of including “inland port” as an infrastructure facility and also that customs clearance also takes place in the inland container depot, the assessee’s claim that the inland container depots were inland ports under Explanation (d) to section 80-IA(4) required to be upheld.

ii) The appeals are allowed.”

levitra

Business expenditure: Capital or revenue: Section 37: A. Y. 2001-02: Assessee manufacturing telecommunication and power cables: Software is not a part of profit-making apparatus of the assessee: Software expenditure is revenue expenditure:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. Raychem Rpg Ltd.; 346 ITR 138 (Bom.)]

The assessee is in the business of manufacturing telecommunication and power cables. For the A. Y. 2001-02, the assessee claimed deduction of the software expenditure as revenue expenditure. The Assessing Officer disallowed the claim, holding it to be capital expenditure. The Tribunal allowed the assessee’s claim. On appeal by the Revenue, the Bombay High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i) The Tribunal in the assessee’s own case for the preceding year had allowed the software expenditure as revenue expenditure, finding that software did not form part of the profit making apparatus of the assessee. The appeal filed by the Revenue for that year has been dismissed for want of removal of office objections and thus the order passed by the Tribunal for that year has attained finality.

 ii) Further, it held that the business of the assessee was that of manufacturing telecommunication and power cable accessories and trading in oil tracing system and other products. The software was an enterprise resource planning package and, hence, it facilitated the assessee’s trading operations or enabled the management to conduct the assessee’s business more efficiently or more profitably but it was not in the nature of profit making apparatus. Therefore, the expenditure is to be allowed.”

levitra

Appeal to CIT(A)/Tribunal: Power: A. Y. 2004- 05: CIT(A)/Tribunal have power to admit/ allow additional ground/claim not made in the return:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT Vs. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders (P) Ltd.; 252 CTR 151 (Bom.)]

For the A. Y. 2004-05, in the return of income, the assessee had claimed deduction of Rs. 20,00,000/- in respect of payment of SEBI fees taking into account the provisions of section 43B of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Subsequently, the assessee found that the amount actually paid and allowable u/s. 43B was Rs. 40,00,000/-. As the time for filing revised return was over, the assessee made the claim for deduction of Rs. 40,00,000/- by a letter, in the course of assessment proceedings and also filed the relevant evidence.

The Assessing Officer disallowed the claim, relying on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Goetz (India) Ltd. Vs. CIT; 284 ITR 323 (SC). CIT(A) allowed the assessee’s claim and the same was upheld by the Tribunal. On appeal by the Revenue, the Bombay High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under: “In an appeal before the CIT(A) and Tribunal, an assessee is entitled to raise additional grounds not merely in terms of legal submissions, but also additional claims not made in the return filed by it.”

levitra

Housing project: Deduction u/s. 80IB(10): A. Y. 2006-07: Ceiling on commercial area inserted w.e.f. 01/04/2005 in section 80-IB(10(d) does not apply to projects approved before that date:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[Manan Corporation Vs. ACIT (Guj); ITA No. 1053 of 2011 dated 03/09/2012:]

The assessee’s housing project commenced prior to 01/04/2005, when section 80-IB(10) of the Incometax Act, 1961 did not impose any ceiling on the commercial area that could be embedded in the project. For the A. Y. 2006-07, the Assessing Officer denied deduction u/s. 80-IB(10) relying on the ceiling prescribed in section 80-IB(10) as amended by the Finance (N0.2) Act, 2004 w.e.f. 01/04/2005. The Tribunal upheld the decision of the Assessing Officer.

On appeal by the assessee, the Gujarat High Court reversed the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

 “i) The judgment of the Bombay High Court in Brahma Associates 333 ITR 280 (Bom) holding that w.e.f. 01/04/2005, deduction u/s. 80-IB(1)) would be governed by the restriction on the commercial area imposed by clause (d) does not mean that even projects approved prior to 01/04/2005 would be governed by the said restriction.

ii) Neither the assessee nor the local authority responsible to approve the construction projects are expected to contemplate future amendment in the statute and approve and/or carry out constructions maintaining the ratio of residential housing and commercial construction as provided by the amended Act.

iii) The entire object of section 80-IB(10) is to facilitate the construction of residential housing project and if at the stage of approving the project, there was no such restriction in the Act, the restriction subsequently imposed has to be necessarily construed on the prospective basis
and as applying to the projects approved after that date.”

levitra

Whether penalty is discretionary or automatic? – Held, discretionary – What is reasonable cause? – Held, bonafide dispute whether tax is payable or not is a reasonable cause for waiver u/s. 80 – Penalties to be interpreted strictly – penalty cannot be imposed u/s. 76 and 78 simultaneously etc. – Further, if the penalty is levied within the range prescribed, the Revisional authority could not enhance it.

fiogf49gjkf0d
2. 2012 (27) STR 225 (Kar) CST – Bangalore v. Motor World
    
Whether penalty is discretionary or automatic? – Held, discretionary – What is reasonable cause?
–    Held, bonafide dispute whether tax is payable or not is a reasonable cause for waiver u/s. 80
–    Penalties to be interpreted strictly – penalty cannot be imposed u/s. 76 and 78 simultaneously etc. – Further, if the penalty is levied within the range prescribed, the Revisional authority could not enhance it.

Facts:

It was a batch of cases on an identical issue wherein Respondents had paid penalties levied by adjudicating authorities, inspite of having proved that there was a reasonable cause for non payment/ short payment of taxes. The Commissioner exercising powers under the then section 84, revised the orders of lower authorities to enhance the penalties.

Held:

 The imposition of penalty is not automatic. Not only the ingredients of the penal sections should exist but also there should be absence of reasonable cause for the failure to comply with the law. The adjudicating authority has the discretion to levy penalty within the limits prescribed under the law. Penalty sections to be construed strictly and if there are two views possible, the one which is favourable to the assessee should be preferred. If the penalty levied is not less than the minimum limit prescribed, the revisional authority has no power to enhance the same on the ground that it is less. If the adjudicating authority exercising powers conferred u/s. 80 has held that there was a reasonable cause for non levy of penalty, revisional authority can’t take a contrary stand and levy penalty. No penalty can be imposed u/s. 76 as well as section 78 for the same offence.

levitra

Wrong availment of CENVAT Credit – Assessee not paid tax on roaming charges received from other operators but availing CENVAT Credit on output services in excess of prescribed limit of 35% – Availment of CENVAT Credit on exempted services not disclosed – Deliberate suppression and not mere omission – Held – Extended period applicable – Penalty levied u/s. 76 and 78 held valid.

fiogf49gjkf0d
1. 2012 (53) VST 139 (Raj) – Vodafone Digilink Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Jaipur-II

Wrong availment of CENVAT Credit – Assessee not paid tax on roaming charges received from other operators but availing CENVAT Credit on output services in excess of prescribed limit of 35% – Availment of CENVAT Credit on exempted services not disclosed – Deliberate suppression and not mere omission – Held – Extended period applicable – Penalty levied u/s. 76 and 78 held valid.


Facts:

The appellant was engaged in the business of providing cellular telephone service. Apart from charges received from its own subscribers, it also received roaming charges from other operators towards roaming facility provided by the appellant to the subscribers of the latter. The appellant did not pay any tax on the amount so received towards roaming charges and utilised the entire service tax credit availed of on various input services for payment of service tax without any restriction of 35% as required under Rule 3(5) of the Service Tax Credit Rules, 2002 and nowhere disclosed the said excess amount so utilised.

Held:

The appellant wilfully suppressed the facts of availment of input credit in respect of exempted services in excess of the prescribed limit of 35%. When the limit is prescribed, facts ought to have been mentioned clearly. When exempted service was availed of in excess of the prescribed limit, it was incumbent upon the appellant to disclose it. Thus, the case being covered under the proviso to s/s (1) of section 73 of the Act, the case is not one of mere omission to give correct information but was devised deliberately to evade tax liability. Not finding any involvement of substantial question of law, the Court dismissed the appeal.

levitra

IS IT FAIR TO ISSUE CERTIFICATES U/S. 197 WITH UNNECESSARY CONDITIONS?

fiogf49gjkf0d
Introduction

There are many non-resident Indians having long term capital assets, particularly residential house properties in India. After the sale of such assets, many of them further propose to reinvest requisite amounts either in house property or in eligible bonds to avail benefits of section 54/54EC/54F of the Income tax Act, 1961 (‘the Act’) . Since it is a transaction with a nonresident, the issue of withholding tax arises. Ideally, since the assessee seller is going to reinvest in eligible assets u/s 54/54EC/54F, no tax should arise. However, the buyer (being the payer of the sale consideration) would be under an obligation to deduct tax for payment being made to a non resident in terms of section 195 of the Act.

In such cases, most of the non-residents opt to apply under section 197 for NIL/lower deduction certificates. An affidavit that requisite amounts would be invested in eligible assets u/s 54/54EC/54F is also submitted alongwith other documents (like sale deed, proof of being a non-resident, computation of capital gains etc.). On the basis of the same, it can be fairly decided that the buyer need not deduct any tax or deduct tax at lower rate. It has been observed that it is a normal practice within the Department to issue such certificate but with a direction to the buyer to issue a cheque of requisite amount directly in favour of REC/NHAI Bonds or Capital Gains Account Scheme (‘CGAS’).

The unfairness:

 The facility of obtaining NIL/lower deduction certificates in case of non-residents is to make matters easier for them and not to subject them to unnecessary conditions. Such directions frustrate the very purpose of applying for NIL withholding certificate. C.N.Vaze Chartered Accountant is it fair? The fact that the assessee is submitting an affidavit should be sufficient proof that he wishes to comply with the necessary provisions.

Further, where it is proposed to reinvest in house property, the direction of issuing cheques directly in favour of CGAS account is not fair as the assessee has got time upto due date of filing return of income and may like to deposit his funds in fixed deposit for the time being, to reap the benefit of higher interest rates. In an extreme illustration, sale may be effected in the month of April so that the seller has an option of making investment within six months (for section 54EC of the Act) and upto 30th September of the following year (for CGAS Scheme) as the case may be. This option is unduly curtailed by such conditions.

In many of the cases, it may really put the assessee (i.e. the non-resident seller) and the buyer in a dilemma where part payment is to be made by the bank (being housing loan obtained by the buyer) directly to the seller and part payment is made by the buyer himself. Further, it may also give rise to serious practical problems if the payment is deferred/ made in instalments. At the most, the assessee may be directed to submit the proof of such investment before the due date of filing return. Needless to state that since all documentary evidences are on record, the tax department always has power and access to catch hold of the concerned persons, if they commit any default.

Conclusion:

Such direct instruction to the buyer to issue a cheque of requisite amount directly in favour of REC/NHAI Bonds or CGAS Account would be encroaching upon assessee’s right to plan his investments. This also brings us to the question as to whether the assessing officer has the power to issue such directions to the payer.

levitra

Transfer of property – Deed of dissolution of partnership – Receipt of assets of firm on dissolution would not construe transfer – Conveyance: Section 2(10) Stamp Act 1899:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[Balbir Singh vs. State of U.P. and Ors. AIR 2012 Allahabad 113]

A partnership firm in the name and style of M/s Guru Govind Singh Rice Mills was constituted on 25.3.1975 consisting of petitioner and six others partners. The said partnership stood dissolved on 29.10.1984. A fresh partnership deed was executed by the petitioner with one of his ex-partners and three other partners of the dissolved firm in the name and style of M/s UP National & General Rice Mills.

One of the partners died, as a consequence of which the firm was dissolved. In this behalf, a deed of dissolution was executed between the petitioner and four partners and legal heirs of the deceased person. Two partners received a sum of Rs.1.80 and Rs.1 lakh respectively towards their share in the capital of the dissolved firm. The other two partners namely Balbir Singh and Rajesh Kumar received their shares in the shape of assets i.e. land, building, plant, machinery. After dissolution of the firm, petitioners and other partners, Rajesh Kumar entered into a fresh partnership in the name and style of the earlier dissolved firm namely UP National & General Rice Mills, which is in existence.

Report of the Deputy Registrar (Stamp) suggested that there was shortage of levy of stamp of 84,990/- and shortage in the registration fee amounting to Rs. 14,660/-. Notice was issued by Addl. Collector. A detailed reply was filed by the petitioner indicating that there was no transfer of movable or immovable property while effecting the dissolution of the firm. It was purely a share received by the petitioner upon the dissolution of the partnership and as such did not constitute ‘Conveyance’ as defined u/s 2(10) of the Indian Stamp Act. The plea of the petitioner was rejected by the Addl. Commissioner, Stamp. The appeal was also dismissed.

On further appeal, the High Court observed that in order to attract provision of explanation to section 2(10) of Stamp Act, an essential feature is that a person who is transferring his right in the property, should have a definite and assigned share in the property before its transfer to other partners. There is no assigned or definite share of the partners in the movable or immovable assets and assigning of shares on dissolution is done on the basis of the shares which the partners hold in the firm. By no stretch of imagination, does it fall within the explanation of section 2(10) of the Stamp Act.

Receipt of the assets of the firm on dissolution would not be construed as conveyance as contemplated u/s 2(10) of the Stamp Act, as the error in construing the same as conveyance/transfer is based upon the premise of treating the status of member of the partnership firm with that of a person holding joint property with definite shares. The finding that on account of dissolution of firm the assets which are distributed by the partners amongst themselves or in favour of some person who has retired from the partnership would constitute the transfer as defined in the Transfer of Property Act, is wrong.

Where the immovable properties had been allotted in the deed of dissolution to the releasees and therefore, the consequential deed of release was only based on the dissolution and in such circumstances, the document could never be treated as a conveyance. The immovable properties had been allotted in the deed of dissolution to the partners. The deed of release was only a sort of acknowledgement of the title of the partners to the immovable properties which was conferred on them by the deed of dissolution. It could not, by any stretch of imagination, be treated as a conveyance of the properties, because the releasors had no right to the properties at the time of the release. In that view, the document could not be treated as a conveyance and stamp duty cannot be demanded on that basis.

levitra

Refund of port services cannot be denied on the ground that the service provider was not authorised by port – It should be allowed provided service tax was paid to the service provider by the recipient. Refund of Goods Transport Agency (GTA) services should be allowed based on the debit notes issued by the service provider vide Rule 4A of the Service Tax R ules, 1994 and R ule 9(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

fiogf49gjkf0d
9. 2012 (27) STR 158 (Tri.-Ahmd.) Gujarat Tea Processors & Packers Ltd. v. C. C. E., Ahmedabad-II

Refund of port services cannot be denied on the ground that the service provider was not authorised by port – It should be allowed provided service tax was paid to the service provider by the recipient.

Refund of Goods Transport Agency (GTA) services should be allowed based on the debit notes issued by the service provider vide Rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 and Rule 9(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.


Facts:

The appellant claimed refund of CENVAT Credit on port services and GTA services on exporting finished goods. The refund claim for port services was rejected on the ground that the service provider was not the authorised person of the port. The refund claim for GTA services was rejected on the ground that the CENVAT Credit was claimed on the basis of debit note and the original copies of debit note/invoice were not signed and as such, the appellant could not produce sufficient documentary proof to the satisfaction of the lower authorities.

Held:

The issue with respect to port services has already been decided in favour of the assessee by the Ahmedabad Tribunal in the following cases:

  • Dishman Pharma & Chemicals Ltd. 2011 (21) STR 246
  •  Ramdev Food Products Pvt. Ltd. 2010 (19) STR 833

With respect to refund of GTA services, the Tribunal observed that proviso to Rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994 specifically allowed any document containing requisite details from a GTA service provider. Further, Rule 9(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules provided that the Adjudicating Authority could accept any document containing details as specified in the said Rule and the appellant provided a detailed statement showing the details of value of services, service tax payable and paid etc. and the same could be considered to be valid in the absence of the ledger. The self certified copies of documents cannot be a reason to reject the refund claim and the same is a curable defect and the matter was remanded to the original adjudicating authority.

levitra

Export of services-Phrase “used outside India” needs to be interpreted to mean that the benefit of the services should accrue outside India vide CBEC Circular no. 111/5/2009-ST dated 24.2.2009. Export of services-Merely not showing the commission separately in profit and loss account cannot be a ground to reject the claim of the assessee that the services are exported especially when other documentary evidences proving provision of services to foreign client and receipt of amount in foreign cur<

fiogf49gjkf0d
    8. 2012 (27) STR 155 (Tri.-Ahmd.) Manish Agarwal vs. Comm. Of Service Tax, Ahmedabad
    
Export of services-Phrase “used outside India” needs to be interpreted to mean that the benefit of the services should accrue outside India vide CBEC Circular no. 111/5/2009-ST dated 24.2.2009.

Export of services-Merely not showing the commission separately in profit and loss account cannot be a ground to reject the claim of the assessee that the services are exported especially when other documentary evidences proving provision of services to foreign client and receipt of amount in foreign currency were in place and not rebutted by the department.


Facts:

The department demanded service tax on differential amount as shown in service tax returns and profit and loss account. The appellant contended that the said amount pertained to export of services and there was no mandatory requirement to show export of services in service tax returns during the relevant period, therefore, the same was not reflected in the service tax returns. Further, the appellant mainly contended that commission was received from foreign clients in foreign currency and the documentary evidences in this respect, was provided to the department. However, the same was not challenged by the department. Further, service tax was demanded without showing any working. Also, non-mention of the foreign commission separately in the profit and loss account was not a valid ground for demand of service tax. The demand was however confirmed as there was no bifurcation of domestic and export commission.

Held:

The ground taken by the Commissioner (Appeals) that the commission was not shown separately in the profit and loss account, cannot be a valid ground to reject the services in view of documentary evidences proving that the commission was received from foreign clients in foreign currency. Further, the appellant had paid service tax on domestic commission which was submitted to the Commissioner (Appeals), therefore, there were no contradictory stands taken by the appellant. Vide Circular no. 111/5/2009-ST dated 24.2.2009, the foreign commission was not liable to service tax since the phrase “used outside India” was required to be interpreted to mean that the benefit of the service should accrue outside India including cases where all the activities pertaining to provision of service were performed in India. 7

levitra

Doctrine of unjust enrichment whether applies to refund of pre-deposit when the burden is not passed on to the customers.

fiogf49gjkf0d
7. 2012 (27) STR 140 (Tri.-Kolkata) Comm. Of C. Ex., Kolkata-VII v. G. D. Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd.

Doctrine of unjust enrichment whether applies to refund of pre-deposit when the burden is not passed on to the customers.


Facts:

The respondent made a pre-deposit u/s. 35F of the Central Excise Act, 1944. In view of favourable decision from the Commissioner (Appeals), the respondent filed refund claim for pre-deposit. The lower adjudicating authority and the Commissioner (Appeals) granted the refund. Therefore, the department filed the present appeal and contended that Mumbai Tribunal in case of Poona Rolling Mills vs. CCE, Pune – I 2009 (240) ELT 85 held that the doctrine of unjust enrichment is applicable in case of pre-deposits as well, and the said doctrine was not examined in the said case. However, the respondent argued that the said doctrine did not apply to the present case in view of non-passing of the burden of such pre-deposit to any other person.

 Held:

Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 dealing with doctrine of unjust enrichment is applicable to duties and not to pre-deposits. Since the burden of pre-deposit was passed on to others in the case of Poona Rolling Mills (Supra), the said case is distinguished from the present case. The doctrine of unjust enrichment does not apply to refund of pre-deposit when the same is not passed on to others.

levitra

2012-TIOL-1145-CESTAT-MUM – Royal Western India Turf Club Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Mumbai Royal Western Turf Club Ltd. charged fee from bookies, royalty income from other racing clubs for live telecast of races and royalty from caterers for providing infrastructural facility inside the club – None of the activities taxable under respective categories of “Intellectual Property Rights Services”, “Broadcasting Services” and “Business Support Services” – Total confusion in the minds of

fiogf49gjkf0d
6. 2012-TIOL-1145-CESTAT-MUM – Royal Western India Turf Club Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Mumbai

Royal Western Turf Club Ltd. charged fee from bookies, royalty income from other racing clubs for live telecast of races and royalty from caterers for providing infrastructural facility inside the club – None of the activities taxable under respective categories of “Intellectual Property Rights Services”, “Broadcasting Services” and “Business Support Services” – Total confusion in the minds of adjudicating authorities as to the nature of the tax and the measure of the tax – Impugned orders demanding Rs.6 crore set aside – Appeals allowed with consequential relief.


Facts:

The appellant, engaged in the activity of conducting horse racing, provided stalls to bookies during the race and they accept bets from the public in the premises of the appellant for which the appellant charged fixed and variable fees. They also conducted live telecast of races at other racing clubs in India for which they received royalty income viz. fixed and variable. They also received royalty from caterers who have been permitted to use the infrastructural facilities and operate within the premises of the club.

Four different SCN’s covering the period between 2002 and 2009 were issued classifying the above activities under different categories and the same activity under different categories in different SCNs.

The appellant relied on the case of Madras Race Club vs. CST [2009 (14) STR 646 (T)] and the CBEC Circulars viz. no.334/4/2006-TRU dated 28.02.2006 and no. 109/3/2009-ST dated 23.02.2009 to conclude that the receipts received from bookies were not taxable under the category of Business Support Services and relied on the judgement of the Hon. Bombay High Court in C.K.P. Mandal vs. CCE [2006 (3) STR 183 (Bom)] to conclude that receipts received from caterers also were not taxable under the category of Business Support Services.

For demand under the category of Intellectual Property Rights Services, relying on CBEC Circular No. 80/10/2004-ST dated 17.09.2004 stated that neither the SCN nor the O-I-O stated under which intellectual property would the said activity fall viz. patents, copyrights, trademarks or designs. For demand under “Broadcasting Services”, it was contended that the appellant had been charged under the said category by M/s Essel Shyam Communications for providing technical support for the telecast and hence, they cannot be treated as the provider as well as the receiver of the service at the same time and further stated that the activity of telecasting was brought under the tax net from 01.07.2010 vide clause 65(105)(zzzzr) – permitting commercial use or exploitation of any event.

Held:

After perusing the impugned orders, the Hon. Tribunal held that the orders clearly evidenced lack of clarity and understanding on the part of the department. The same activity viz. telecast of horse race, was classified under “Broadcasting Services” during one period and under “Intellectual Property Rights” during another period. Also, the consideration in respect of telecast of horse races and in respect of bookmakers have been classified under two different categories for the same period based on different modes of payment.

Intellectual Property Rights Service

Neither the SCN nor the impugned orders gave a clear proposal or finding as to what is the intellectual property right involved as clarified by the CBEC Circular dated 17.09.2004 and hence the demand was set aside. Broadcasting Services It was held that the said activity was undertaken by M/s. Essel Shyam Communications who appropriately discharged its liability and that the activity of the appellant was covered under the category of permitting commercial use or exploitation of any event w.e.f. 01-07-2010

 Business Support Services

As regards the activity to make available space to the caterers and bookmakers, it was held that it was nothing but hiring/leasing of immovable property as defined under 65(105)(zzzz) and not taxable as Business Support Service. It relied upon the definition of Business Support Service as defined under 65(104c) and the CBEC circular No.334/4/2006-TRU dated 28-02-2006. Since no merit was found, the entire demand under all the categories was set aside with consequential relief.

levitra

Bombay Flying Club registered as charitable institution – Offered training courses in Aircraft Maintenance Engineering, Pilot training & overhauling work of aircrafts – Appellant’s courses not considered of Vocational Training for notification 24/2004-ST – AAR ruling applied in view of identical facts and questions of law – Activity of pilot training taxable under “Commercial Coaching or Training Services” – activity of overhauling of aircrafts taxable under “Management, Maintenance & Repair Se<

fiogf49gjkf0d
5. 2012-TIOL-841-CESTAT-MUM – The Bombay Flying Club v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Mumbai –II

Bombay Flying Club registered as charitable institution – Offered training courses in Aircraft Maintenance Engineering, Pilot training & over-hauling work of aircrafts – Appellant’s courses not considered of Vocational Training for notification 24/2004-ST – AAR ruling applied in view of identical facts and questions of law – Activity of pilot training taxable under “Commercial Coaching or Training Services” – activity of overhauling of air-crafts taxable under “Management, Maintenance & Repair Services” – Pre-deposit ordered of 1.5 crores ordered.


Facts:

The appellant, engaged in providing training in Aircraft Maintenance Engineering, also undertook maintenance and repair of aircrafts owned by its members. The department contended that the above services were taxable as “Commercial Coaching or Training Services” and “Management, Maintenance and Repair Services”. Accordingly, four show cause notices were issued demanding an amount of Rs.2.56 crore. The appellant stated that it was under a bonafide belief that the activities undertaken by them were statutory functions and being a charitable organisation, there was no commercial aspect to its activities and consequently, they never recovered any service tax. It also contended that the demand for service tax under the category of “Management Maintenance or Repair” for the overhauling of aircrafts of its members was bad in law as the said service was not provided under a contract or agreement. The memorandum of the appellant company wherein they have undertaken to provide the said service to its members is not a contract or agreement. The department on its part relied on the CBEC circular, clarifying that the said activity was liable for service tax under the purview of “Commercial Training or Coaching” service and that exemption under Notification No.24/2004-ST was not available to such training programmes. The department also put their reliance on the AAR ruling in the case of CAE Flight Training (India) Ltd.2010 (18) STR 785 (AAR) which held that the activity undertaken was liable for service tax as “commercial training or coaching”.

Held:

Commercial Coaching or Training services: Referring to sections 65(26) and 65(27) of the Finance Act, 1994 relating to definitions of commercial training or coaching, the Tribunal held that the appellant was not covered under the exclusion clause. It also held that the appellant was not eligible for any duty exemption in terms of Notification No.24/2004–ST dated 10.09.2004 and Notification No.03/2010–ST dated 27.02.2010 (after amendment). Due weightage was placed on the CBE&C circular no.137/132/2010–ST dated 11th May, 2011 and on the AAR ruling. Thus, the activity of pilot training was considered as taxable. Management, Maintenance & Repair Services: Referring to the definition u/s. 65(64), the Tribunal stated that the statute does not stipulate any separate contract or agreement, written or otherwise, with the service recipient so as to bring the activity under the tax net. The fact that the activity was stated in the memorandum in the objects clause showed that there was understanding with the members. Thus, the activity of overhauling of aircrafts was also held as taxable. Bonafide belief was considered and Rs.1.71 crore being within normal period, pre-deposit of Rs.1.5 crore was ordered.

levitra

Depreciation – Goodwill is an intangible asset under Explanation 3(b) of section 32(1) of the Act and is entitled to depreciation under that section.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT v. Smifs Securities Ltd. (Civil Appeal No.5961 of 2012 dated 22-8-2012)]

Entries in books of accounts – the manner in which the assessee maintains its accounts is not conclusive for deciding the nature of expenditure.

The following three questions of laws were raised before the Supreme Court:

1. Whether Stock Exchange Membership Cards are assets eligible for depreciation u/s. 32 of the Income Tax Act, 1961? Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, deletion of Rs.53,84,766/- has been made correctly?

2. Whether goodwill is an asset within the meaning of section 32 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and whether depreciation on ‘goodwill’ is allowable under the said section?

3. The third question raised was regarding cancellation of disallowance of an amount of Rs.83,02,976/- as a bad debt.

 The Supreme Court held that the first question was covered by the decision in the case of Techno Shares and Stocks Ltd. [(2010) 327 ITR 323 (SC) ], in favour of the assessee. With regard to the second question, the Supreme Court noted that the facts were as under: In accordance with Scheme of Amalgamation of YSN Shares & Securities (P) Ltd. with Smifs Securities Ltd. (duly sanctioned by Hon’ble High Courts of Bombay and Calcutta) with retrospective effect from 1st April, 1998, assets and liabilities of YSN Shares & Securities (P) Ltd, were transferred to and vest in the company. In the process, goodwill had arisen in the books of the company.

The excess consideration paid by the assessee over the value of net assets acquired of YSN Shares and Securities Private Limited [Amalgamating Company] was considered as goodwill arising on amalgamation. It was claimed that the extra consideration was paid towards the reputation which the Amalgamating Company was enjoying in order to retain its existing clientele.

The Assessing Officer held that goodwill was not an asset falling under Explanation 3 to section 32(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [‘Act’ for short]. The Supreme Court after adverting to the provisions of Explanation 3 to section 32(1) of the Act held that ‘Goodwill’ was an intangible asset under Explanation 3(b) to section 32(1) of the Act. The Supreme Court observed that in the present case, the Assessing Officer, as a matter of fact, had come to the conclusion that no amount was actually paid on account of goodwill. This was a factual finding.

The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) had come to the conclusion that the authorized representatives had filed copies of the Orders of the High Court ordering amalgamation of the above two Companies; that the assets and liabilities of M/s. YSN Shares and Securities Private Limited were transferred to the assessee for a consideration; that the difference between the cost of an asset and the amount paid constituted goodwill and that the assessee-Company in the process of amalgamation had acquired a capital right in the form of goodwill because of which the market worth of the assessee- Company stood increased. This finding had also been upheld by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. According to the Supreme Court, there was no reason to interfere with the factual finding. The Supreme Court further observed that against the decision of ITAT, the Revenue had preferred an appeal to the High Court in which it had raised only the question as to whether goodwill is an asset u/s. 32 of the Act. In the circumstances, before the High Court, the Revenue had not filed an appeal on the finding of fact referred to hereinabove. So far as the third question is concerned, the Supreme Court noted that the argument on behalf of the revenue was that, since the Tax Audit Report indicated that the amounts have been incurred on capital account, the assessee was not entitled to deduction of bad debt.

 The Supreme Court observed that both the CIT(A) as well as the ITAT had concluded that the assessee had satisfied the provisions of section 36(1)(vii) of the Act. They held that bad debt claimed by the assessee was incurred in the normal course of business and, therefore, the assessee was entitled to deduction u/s. 36(1)(vii). The Supreme Court held that it is well settled now by a catena of decisions that the manner in which the assessee maintains its accounts is not conclusive for deciding the nature of expenditure.

The Supreme Court held that in the present case, the concerned finding of facts recorded by the authorities below indicated that the assessee was entitled to deduction in the course of business u/s. 36(1)(vii) of the Act.

levitra

Interest – Whether interest is payable by the Revenue to the assessee if the aggregate of installments of Advance tax/TDS paid exceed the assessed tax is a question of law – Correctness of the judgement in Sandvik Asia Ltd. v. CIT doubted.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT v. Gujarat Flouro Chemicals SLP (Civil) No.11406/2008 dated 23-8-2012]

The question that was before the Supreme Court was – whether interest is payable by the Revenue to the assessee, if the aggregate of installments of Advance Tax/TDS paid exceeds the assessed tax? The Supreme Court observed that advance tax is leviable in the very year in which income accrues or arises. It is normally paid in three installments. A similar situation arises in the case of TDS. It is Tax Deductible at source which is also called as ‘withholding tax’ u/s. 195 of the Act. Broadly, both Advance Tax as well as TDS are based on estimation of income by the assessee.

Before the Supreme Court, the assessee relied upon the decision in Sandvik Asia Ltd. v. CIT (2006)280 ITR 643(SC). The Supreme Court noted that it was a case relating to payment of advance tax. The main issue which arose for determination in Sandvik Asia was; whether the assessee was entitled to be compensated by the Revenue for delay in paying to it the amounts admittedly due. The Supreme Court observed that the argument in Sandvik Asia on behalf of the assessee was that, it was entitled to compensation by way of interest for the delay in payments of the amounts lawfully due to it which were wrongly withheld for a long period of seventeen years and that the Division Bench of the Supreme Court vide Para 23 had held that in view of the express provisions of the Act, the assessee was entitled to compensation by way of interest for the delay in payment of the amounts lawfully due to the assessee, which were withheld wrongly by the Revenue.

The Supreme Court, with due respect to the decision in Sandvik Asia, was of the view that section 214 of the Act does not provide for payment of compensation by revenue to the assessee in whose favour a refund order has been passed. According to the Supreme Court, in Sandvik Asia, interest was ordered on the basis of equity and also on the basis of Article 265 of the Constitution.

The Supreme Court however, expressed serious doubts about the correctness of the judgment in Sandvik Asia. According to the Supreme Court, its judgment in Modi Industries Ltd. v. CIT [1995 (6) SCC 396] has correctly held that advance tax or TDS loses its identity as soon as it is adjusted against the liability created by the Assessment order and becomes tax paid pursuant to the Assessment order. The Supreme Court questioned that – if advance tax or TDS loses its identity and becomes tax paid on the passing of the assessment order then, is the assessee not entitled to interest under the relevant provisions of the Act? The Supreme Court referred to the provisions of sections 195(1), 195A, 214, 219, 237, and 244, which stood at the relevant time and were of the view that Sandvik Asia has not been correctly decided. The Supreme Court directed the Registry to place the matter before the Hon’ble Chief Justice on the administrative side for appropriate orders.

levitra

Reassessment – An assessment cannot be reopened on the basis of change of opinion.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[ACIT v. ICICI Securities Primary Dealership Ltd.(Civil Appeal No.5960 of 2012 dated 22-8-2012)]

The petitioner, a limited company, was engaged in the business of carrying on various non-banking financial activities. An assessment order for the assessment year 1999-2000 was passed u/s. 143(3) on 28-3-2002 determining total income at Rs.27.72 crore. A notice u/s. 148 was issued on 27-3-2006 (after expiry of four years from the end of the assessment year) for reopening assessment. In the reasons recorded for reopening the assessment, it was stated that from the accounts it was noted that petitioner had a incurred a loss in trading in share. After discussing the various entries appearing in the opening and closing stocks and purchases and sales of those stocks it was concluded that there was a loss of Rs.19.86 crore and that loss was a speculative one and not allowable as deduction.

Accordingly, it was alleged that income to the extent of Rs.19.86 crore had escaped assessment. On a writ petition filed by the petitioner before the Bombay High Court, it was held that there was nothing new which had come to the notice of the revenue. Under the proviso to section 147, it was not possible to reopen the assessment on merely a relook of the accounts. The High Court quashed the notice dated 27-3-2006 (W.P.No.1919 of 2006 dated 28-2-2006). Being aggrieved, the revenue approached the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court observed that the assessee had disclosed full details in the return in the matter of its dealing in stocks and shares. The Supreme Court noted that according to the assessee, the loss was a business loss, whereas according to the revenue, the loss incurred was a speculative loss. The Supreme Court was of the opinion that reopening of the assessment was clearly based on a change of opinion and in the circumstances, reopening of the assessment was not maintainable.

levitra

Interest – Before any amount paid is construed to be interest, it has to be established that the same is payable in respect of debt incurred – Discounting charges paid for getting the export bill discounted is not interest within the ambit of section 2(28A) – SLP dismissed.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT v. Cargil Global Trading I.P. Ltd. (SLP (CC) No.19572 of 2011 dated 10-5-2012]

In the assessment year 2004-05, the respondentassessee filed the income tax return declaring the income at 1.14 crore. During the assessment proceedings, the Assessing Office (AO) noticed that the assessee had paid a sum of Rs.3.97 crore to its associate concern, M/s. Cargil Financial Services Asia Pvt. Ltd. (CFSA), Singapore on account of discounting charges for getting the export sale bill discounted. The AO was of the view that the discounting charges were nothing but the interest within the ambit of section 2(28A) of the Income Tax Act (for brevity ‘the Act’). Since the assessee had not deducted tax at source u/s. 195 of the Act, he invoked the provisions of section 40(a)(i) of the Act, and disallowed the sum of Rs.3.97 crore claimed by the assessee u/s. 37(1) of the Act.

CIT(A) deleted the addition holding that the discount paid by the assessee to CFSA cannot be held to be interest and therefore, provisions of section 40(a)(i) of the Act would not apply. Accordingly, he allowed the expenditure of Rs.3.97 crore as claimed by the assessee.

The Revenue did not accept the aforesaid decision of the CIT(A) and therefore, challenged the same by filing the appeal before the Tribunal, which was unsuccessful as the Tribunal affirmed the order of the CIT(A). The Tribunal observed that discounting charges were not in the nature of interest paid by the assessee, rather the assessee had received net amount of bill of exchange accepted by the purchaser after deducting amount of discount. Since CFSA was having no permanent establishment in India, it was not liable to tax in respect of such amount earned by it and therefore, the assessee was not under an obligation to deduct tax at source u/s. 195 of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the said discounting charges could not be disallowed by the AO by invoking section 40(a)(i) of the Act.

On an appeal by the Revenue, the Delhi High Court [ITXA No.331 of 2011 dated 17-2-2011] observed that before any amount paid is construed as interest, it has to be established that the same is payable in respect of any money borrowed or debt incurred. According to the High Court, on the facts appearing on record, the Tribunal had rightly held that the discounting charges paid were not in respect of any debt incurred or money borrowed. Instead, the assessee had merely discounted the sale consideration received on sale of goods.

The High Court held that no substantial question of law arose, as the matter was already settled by the dicta of the Supreme Court in Vijay Ship Breaking Corporation v. CIT [(2008) 219 CTR 639 (sc)] as well as clarification of CBDT in Circular No. 674 dated 22-3-1993 itself.

The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition filed by the revenue against the aforesaid order of the Delhi High Court.

levitra

A. P. (DIR Series) Circular No. 19 dated 28th August, 2012

fiogf49gjkf0d

Issue of Indian Depository Receipts (IDRs)

 – Limited two way fungibilty. Presently, automatic fungibility of IDR is not permitted. This circular, subject to compliance with SEBI (Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2009, permits a limited two way fungibility for IDR. It imposes an overall ceiling of INRNaN billion on raising of capital by foreign companies by issuance of IDR. It also states that re-issuance of IDR would be allowed only to the extent of IDR that have been redeemed/converted into underlying shares and sold.

levitra

Convergence to Ind AS 16 – Property, Plant & Equipment

fiogf49gjkf0d
Introduction

India has principally agreed to converge to IFRS by implementing Revised Schedule VI, being the first constructive step in the journey. Let us appreciate the requirements of accounting for fixed assets, in specific under Ind AS (ie IFRS), in the light of the existing governing principles under Indian GAAP.

Ind AS 16, corresponding to International Accounting Standard (IAS), 16 governs the accounting, measurement and reporting for fixed assets. This means that it also governs the accounting for depreciation. Presently, two standards namely, AS 6 – Depreciation Accounting and AS 10 – Accounting for Fixed Assets govern the subject.

Following are the major points of differences between the two GAAPs that have wider industry impact:

a. Component approach for accounting of fixed assets

b. Depreciation provision

c. Revaluation of fixed assets

This article brings out the major differentiating characteristics under Indian GAAP including relevant governing provisions under the Statute and Ind AS, for accounting of fixed assets on above points. We later discuss the industry impact analysis and way forward.

Existing Governing Literature in India on Fixed Assets

AS 10 – Accounting for Fixed Assets

This standard governs the treatment of capital expenditure related to acquisition and construction of fixed assets. It introduces broad categories of assets as observed in many entities. These include land, buildings, plant and machinery, vehicles, furniture and fittings, goodwill, patents, trademarks and designs. The standard requires management to apply judgment to use the aggregation rule for individually insignificant items.

It encourages an improved accounting for an item of fixed asset, where the total expenditure thereon is allocated to its component parts, provided they are in practice separable, and estimate is made of the useful lives of these components. For example, rather than treat an aircraft and its engines as one unit, it may be better to treat the engines as a separate unit if it is likely that their useful life is shorter than that of the aircraft as a whole.

However, the entry in fixed asset register is made at a class of asset. For example, aircraft is capitalised as a single asset. This is because Schedule XIV prescribes a common rate for aeroplanes, aero engines, simulators, visual system and quick engine change equipment at 16.2% (WDV) and 5.6% (SLM). In such a case, often, if the engine is replaced before it is fully depreciated, the balance WDV is charged off to Profit and Loss Account and the new engine is capitalised for being depreciated till the maximum life of its parent asset. This approach may lead to deferment of charge till the year of replacement. Indian Companies Act, 1956 Schedule XIV plays a critical role in accounting for fixed assets under Indian GAAP, in recording of assets and depreciating it over its useful life.

Recording of assets: There are about 20 different rates of depreciation under Schedule XIV under single shift usage, which drive the allocation of cost of assets. The broad categories or class of assets include Land, Building, Plant & Machinery, Furniture & Fitting and Ships. Plant & Machinery is further subdivided into various sub-asset classes considering business specific allocations.

 Consider ‘mines and quarries’ being one of the groups under ‘Plant & Machinery’ that attracts 13.91% rate of depreciation. It includes Surface and underground machinery, Head gears, Shafts, Tramways, etc. and all being depreciated at the same rate. In practical terms, all of them may have a different useful life. Companies (Auditor’s Report) Order (2003) (CARO) requires every company to maintain proper records showing full particulars, including quantitative details and situation of fixed assets under para 4.1(a). Companies maintain minimum quantitative records for fixed assets that can be physically verified on an overall basis, in order to comply with CARO.

Depreciation: Section 205(2) of the Companies Act, 1956 (Act) provides that a company can declare or pay dividend only out of its profits. The profits for this purpose are to be arrived at after providing for depreciation as per section 350. If dividend is to be declared out of the profits of any earlier year or years, it is necessary that such profits should be arrived at after providing for depreciation for the respective years.

Section 350 of the Act requires a company to provide depreciation at the rates specified in Schedule XIV of the Act for arriving at net profit of the company for the purposes of section 205(2) and section 349 of the Act. There is no direct reference to useful life in the Act, but has indirect reference to it by prescribing depreciation rates for all types of assets for depreciation under the said Schedule. The rates prescribed under Schedule XIV are minimum rates (Circular No. 2/89, dated March 7, 1989 issued by Department of Company affairs).These are applicable for all the companies.

Thus, entities cannot depreciate the assets at a lower rate even if the technically established useful life of the asset is more than that derived from the rates specified under Schedule XIV, if they are governed by Companies Act. (In case of electricity companies, it is the Electricity Act that governs the minimum depreciation rates). There is also no provision of revisiting the rates at every year end.

AS 6 Depreciation Accounting

Para 5 of AS 6 requires assessment of depreciation based on historical or substituted historical cost, estimated useful life and residual value. U/s. 350 read with Circular. No. 2/89 as mentioned above, companies cannot estimate a useful life longer than that prescribed under Schedule XIV.

Companies exercise their judgement of useful life in the light of technical, commercial, accounting and legal requirements. It may periodically review the estimate and if it is considered that the original estimate of useful life of an asset requires any revision, the unamortised depreciable amount of the asset is charged to revenue over the revised remaining useful life.

Companies can use a shorter useful life based on parameters stated above and disclose the fact by way of a note. However, there is no requirement to review residual value at periodic intervals. AS 6 prescribes two methods of depreciation, namely, Straight line method (SLM) and Written down value method (WDV). The method of depreciation is applied consistently to provide comparability of the results of the operations of the enterprise from period to period. A change from one method of providing depreciation to another is considered as a change in policy and is made only if the adoption of the new method is required by statute or for compliance with an accounting standard or for more appropriate presentation of financial statements. Change in accounting policy requires retrospective recomputation of depreciation as per the new policy i.e. new method of depreciation and adjustment in the accounts in the year of such change. Thus, the depreciation charge in subsequent years is not impacted with the change adjustment.

Ind AS 16: Property, plant and equipment (i.e. IAS 16)

Ind AS brings in a more stringent requirement to maintain component details of fixed assets, in terms of its Component Approach. Hence, it may increase the line items in fixed asset register and work of physical verification for each identifiable component.

The Standard does not prescribe the unit of measure for recognition. However, judgement is required in applying the recognition criteria to an entity’s specific circumstances. It may be appropriate to aggregate individually insignificant items, such as moulds, tools and dies, and to apply the criteria to the aggregate value. We will discuss the component approach is a separate section below.

Under AS 16, major overhauling expenses are capitalised with the asset line item and are depreciated till the next scheduled maintenance date unlike AS 10 that requires such costs to be expensed as incurred, unless it increases the future benefits from the existing asset beyond its previously assessed standard of performance and is included in the gross book value.

Elements of cost also include an initial estimate of the costs of dismantling and removing the item and restoring the site on which it is located, the obligation for which an entity incurs either when the item is acquired or as a consequence of having used the item during a particular period for purposes other than to produce inventories during that period. The value of such provisions is done based on discounted cash flow approach and depreciated over the useful life of the asset. Any change in estimate on account of principal amount would get adjusted in the cost of asset and any change on account of discount rate would be accounted in finance cost.

The major driving factor for component approach comes from the requirement to depreciate the asset over its own useful life. Though the useful life approach exists under Indian GAAP, the Companies Act has been considered more prominent since it forms part of the Statute.

As a convergence step towards IFRS, Revised Schedule VI has been helpful in addressing the conflict between erstwhile hierarchy of application between Schedule VI and Accounting Standards, by giving an upper hand to Accounting Stan-dards. Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has so far notified Ind ASs, for which implementation date is still to be notified. One may look forward for similar clarification or convergence of Schedule XIV and/or of section 350 of the Act, with Ind AS 16 useful life approach, so that entities can in true spirit converge to Ind AS 16.

It is practically observed that steel plants of SAIL and Tata Steel are more than 30 to 40 years old. These plants require a regular maintenance and can continue longer. Similarly, many refineries in Europe and US are more than 30 years old as against the derived depreciation rates under Schedule XIV that work out to 18-20 years on SLM basis.

As a point of reference, British Petroleum Plc depreciates its refinery and petroleum assets over a period of upto 30 years. Corus Plc depreciates its steel making facilities upto 25 years under IFRS and Arcelor Mittal Plc has attributed upto 30 years of useful life for its plant & machinery. Both of them have a life more than what is prescribed under the Indian GAAP.

As a reverse impact, items where the useful life under Schedule XIV is likely to be more that its actual useable life, may include electrical machinery, X-ray and electrothera-peutic apparatus and its accessories, medical, diagnostic equipments, namely, cat-scan, ultrasound machines, ECG moni-tors, etc. that have 20% rate under WDV method and 7.07% under SLM for depreciation. This works out to around 13 years keeping 5% residual value. The actual life of these electronic equipments could be less considering the technology advances and consequential obsolescence.

Assuming Ind AS 16 will get an upper hand in terms of accounting of Fixed assets, it may be expected that the entities could benefit from lower provision for depreciation based on more realistic estimate of useful life of the assets such as power plants, refineries, smelters, etc.

Another point of difference comes from para 51 and para 61 of Ind AS 16, which provide that the residual value, useful life of an asset as well as the depreciation method shall be reviewed at least at each financial year-end. Such changes are to be accounted for as a change in an accounting estimate in accordance with Ind AS 8 Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors. Ind AS 8 requires such changes in estimates to be accounted prospectively.

Point to note that change in method and rates of depreciation are a change in estimate with prospective application under Ind AS 16 whereas, under AS 6 it is a change in policy that needs retrospective application.

Ind AS 16 is self contained, in the sense that it also prescribes the depreciation guidelines on fixed assets unlike the current environment where it is governed by AS 10, AS 6, Schedule XIV and Guidance notes. One may note that, exposure draft of AS 10 (Revised) issued by ICAI before notifying Ind ASs, was also in line with Ind AS 16, and included component approach and provided for calculating depreciation based on estimated useful life.

Component approach

Is component approach of assets required?

Yes, when it is significant. Ind AS 16 does not prescribe a unit measure. However, it requires that each part of an item of property, plant and equipment which has a probability of future economic benefits associated with the item will flow to the entity and the cost of the item can be measured reliably and is significant in relation to the cost of the item shall be depreciated separately. Implicitly, component approach is required under para 43 of Ind AS 16 which requires each significant part of the total asset to be depreciated separately.

How to determine components?

The determination of whether an item is significant requires a careful assessment of the facts and circumstances.

These assessments would include, at a minimum:

i.    comparison of the cost allocated to the component to the total cost of the property, plant and equipment; and

ii.    effect on depreciation expense between component approach and clubbing approach.

Following factors may broadly assist in arriving at component identification:

  •     Shut down or major repairs and maintenance.

Shutdown costs are made of replacement of an item and labour cost. Thus, items that require replacement on a regular basis can be identified as separate components. For example, a furnace may require relining after a specified number of hours of use, or aircraft interiors such as seats and galleys may require replacement several times during the life of the airframe.

  •    Useful life estimates of major components at the acquisition date. Example; it may be appropriate to depreciate separately the airframe and engines of an aircraft.

  •    Technical knowhow and obsolescence may be considered in case of information technology (IT) and electronic equipment. With respect to IT, hardware has a different useful life as compared to software.

Revaluation model

Under Ind AS 16, there are two models of accounting fixed assets, namely ‘Historical Cost’ model and ‘Revaluation’ model.

Under AS 10, revaluation of fixed assets is considered as substitution for historical costs and depreciation is calculated accordingly. However, under Ind AS, it is a separate model of accounting. Once an entity chooses ‘Revaluation model’, it will be considered as its accounting policy to an entire class of property, plant and equipment. Revaluation is required to be made with sufficient regularity to ensure that the carrying amount does not differ materially from that which would be determined using fair value at the balance sheet date.

The base fundamental of Ind AS 16 and AS 10 remain the same, i.e. revaluation does not affect the Income Statement, and valuation difference is recognised in reserves, unless the revaluation adjustment decreases the value of asset below its original cost. In such a situation, it would result in a change in profit and loss account which is indirectly an impairment of asset.

However, there is a difference in amortisation impact when it comes to Ind AS 16. The depreciation is calculated on the fair value of the asset and is amortised over the useful life by debiting profit & loss account without taking any credit from the revaluation reserve. It is pertinent to note that, under the present Indian GAAP, the entities plough back the reserves in income statement to the extent of additional depreciation and balance if any, at the time of disposal in line with paragraph 11 of the Guidance note as stated below; and thus the debit in profit & loss account is reduced to that extent.

“The Revaluation Reserve is not available for payment of dividends. This view is also supported by the Companies (Declaration of Dividend out of Reserves) Rules, 1975. Similarly, accumulated losses or arrears of depreciation should not be set off against Revaluation Reserve. However, the revaluation reserve can be utilised for adjustment of the additional depreciation on the increased amount due to revaluation from year to year or on the retirement of the relevant fixed assets.”(Paragraph 11 from Guidance note on treatment of reserve created on revaluation of fixed assets, issued 1982)

This guidance note will not be applicable once Ind AS is implemented and thus the depreciation charge will increase for the entities that follow Revaluation approach. Additionally, the existing unutilised reserve will get transferred directly to retained earnings instead of being routed through the profit and loss account.

Note: Under Ind AS 12, deferred tax is calculated on all temporary differences. The revaluation adjustment will be considered as a temporary difference and hence the amount that will flow to equity will be net of deferred tax.

Industry Impact Analysis – Ind AS 16 Property Plant & Equipment:

Industry will be impacted due to Component Approach in Ind AS 16. Since the Schedule XIV rates are not split into various parts of heavy duty machinery, companies will have to go through a detailed exercise of breaking down its fixed asset line item into various components and assess each item’s independent useful life.

Mining and Construction

Assets in Mining and Construction industry include heavy duty trucks, vehicles, dozers, excavators, loaders & unloaders, tunnelling machinery, etc. These heavy duty machineries are made up of various assembled parts which are high in value and also have a different useful life as compared to the other parts such as chassis, rollers, body, electrical systems, etc. These items will have to be broken in to their components.

Entities will also have to estimate mine restoration liabilities and capitalise with the initial cost of the mine.

Excerpts from Mining major, Xstrata Plc’s Annual Report 2011:

“Where parts of an asset have different useful lives, depreciation is calculated on each separate part. Each asset or part’s estimated useful life has due regard to both its own physical life limitations and the present assessment of economically recoverable reserves of the mine property at which the item is located, and to possible future variations in those assessments. Plant & equipment have useful lives from 4-30 years.”

“Provision is made for close down, restoration and environmental rehabilitation costs.. ….At the time of establishing the provision, a corresponding asset is capitalised, where it gives rise to a future benefit, and depreciated over future production from the operations to which it relates”.

Commodity manufacturing Industry – Crude, Ore, Power

These industries include oil and ore refineries, smelters that are used to melt the ore, and power plants among others. These plants carry huge investments with complex designs and take years to build. They are made of various facilities that can be identified as first level components such as Water treatment, Gas tapping, Conveyors, Turbines, Rooters, Shafts, Grids, Tankages, Ovens, Casters, Moulds, Furnaces, Rolling mills, etc.. More often one component that is left out in the analysis is the Pipelines, which have material value and dif-ferent useful life.

Second level components will need a detailed analysis of each identified first level component with their individually assessed useful lives. Each unit will need separate line items for identification.

Entities will need to estimate its asset retirement obligations at the time of initial capitalisation.

A Nuclear Power Plant will have to estimate its related decommissioning liabilities and capitalise with power plants.

Another impact will be on account of capital repairs that are incurred during shut down, cell realignment, etc. This will be capitalised under fixed assets and amortised till the next overhauling date.

By virtue of assessment of useful life, entities get a chance to increase the useful life for depreciating the assets to its true useful lives.

Shipping

Main parts of a ship include hull and engine. Further, hull is made up of deck, chassis, propeller, funnel, stern and super structure. A modern ship includes a fair component of electronic and automatic control systems. Entities will have to carry out a detailed exercise and use its judgement for capitalising each component.

Dry dock expenses in shipping industry which carried out periodically will need capitalisation and amortisation.

Similar to the commodity industry, entities will get a chance to increase the useful life for depreciating the assets to its true useful lives. International peers such as B+H Ocean Carrier Plc have estimated useful life of 30 years for its vessels from the date of construction and capital improvements are amortised over a period of five years.
 
Major differences between AS and Ind AS on Accounting of Fixed Assets:


Hotel Industry

A restaurant maintains a minimum stock of silverware and dishes. Some entities treat cutlery, crockery, linen, etc, as stores and spares and group them under inventory. Any increase or decrease is accounted as consumption in profit and loss ac-count. Moreover, Schedule XIV does not lay down any rate for depreciating such items and hence companies in India adopt inventory and consumption approach to account these items.

For a restaurant, cutlery is similar to a plant, without which it cannot operate. Under Ind AS 6, these items fall into the definition of tangible assets and hence need to be capitalised as such and depreciated based on its useful life. Considering the nature of these assets, the estimation of their useful life may involve a significant amount of judgment. The management should consider factors such as physical wear and tear, commercial obsolescence, asset management policy of an entity that may involve replacement of such assets after a specified period, etc for such assessment. John Keels Hotels Plc, depreciates its Cutlery, Crockery, Glassware & Linen in a period of three years, as per its 2010 annual report.

Way forward:

(i)    It is advisable to start updating the fixed as-set records in SAP or any other ERP with major component details. This can be done by opening various sub group codes for the master asset.

(ii)    Any new capitalisation should be based on component approach assessing specific use-ful life of each component and then applying the aggregate rule.

(iii)    Expect changes or clarifications for section 350 or Schedule XIV or both to avoid conflict with depreciation principles under Ind AS 16.

(iv)    Assessment of useful life and residual value will have to be done by the management on a regular basis.

(v)    Estimate dismantling, decommissioning, restoration liabilities valued at discounted cash flow basis at the beginning and continue to reassess on a regular basis.

(vi)    Entities following revaluation approach for accounting fixed assets, will be impacted more, as Ind AS 16 does not allow an entity to plough back the reserve in profit and loss account to match the additional depreciation on revaluation. Ind AS 16 will come with first time exemptions under Ind AS 101 and hence entities may decide an appropriate policy when they adopt Ind AS, for the first time.

Right to Information – Public authority – Co-operative societies registered under Kerala Co-op Societies Act are public authority: Right to Information Act, section 2(4):

fiogf49gjkf0d
[Mullour Rural Co-operative Society Ltd, Trivandrum vs. State of Kerala & Ors. AIR 2012 Kerala 124]

The issue arose for consideration as to whether a co-operative society registered under the Kerala Co-op Societies Act was a `public authority’ u/s. 2(h) of RTI Act. It is fundamental that every member of the society, every depositor and every one interested in the affairs of the society, are entitled to get all information relating to the society, which is possible only if RTI Act is implemented against co-operative societies. However, it may be noticed that sufficient safeguard is made in section 8 of the RTI Act which prohibits furnishing of certain items of information on which statutory immunity is provided thereunder, for obvious reasons. Subject to the exceptions contained in that section, any other information relating to a co-operative society should be made available to the public on application, is what is contemplated under the RTI Act.

 The attitude of the managing committee of a society to refuse to furnish information relating to the Society itself, should be a matter of serious concern by the Joint Registrar, because people tend to cover up only wrong things and not things which are properly done. The Court observed that the completion of statutory audit of societies is delayed by four to five years and most of the managing committees escape from being caught for mismanagement only because of delay in auditing, detection of irregularities and delay in initiation of proceedings thereafter. The court was of the view that atleast vigilant members and the public, by obtaining information through RTI Act, will be able to detect and prevent mismanagement in time. Therefore, the RTI Act will certainly help as a protection against mismanagement of the societies by the managing committee and by society employees.

Therefore, it was held that Co-operative Societies registered under the KCS Act are “public authorities” within the meaning of section 2(h) of the RTI Act. The applicability of the RTI Act to Co- operative Societies was upheld. Therefore, even if society by itself does not answer the description of “public authority”, the statutory authorities under the KCS Act being public authorities within the meaning of clause (c) of section 2(h), are bound to furnish information after accessing the same from the co-operative society concerned.

levitra

Right to Information – Public Interest – Disclosure of information regarding Vigilance matter – Section 8(1)(e); 8(1)(g) and 8(1)(j) of RTI Act

fiogf49gjkf0d
[UPSC vs. R.K. Jain (2012) (282) ELT 161 Del]

The respondent by an application filed u/s. 6 of the Act, sought the Information from the petitioner (UPSC) namely, inspection of the records, documents, note sheets, reports, office memorandum, part files and files relating to the proposed disciplinary action and/or imposition of penalty against Shri G.S. Narang, IRS, Central Excise and Customs Officer of 1974 Batch and also inspection of records, files, etc., relating to the decision of the UPSC thereof.

The Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the petitioner, however, declined to provide the same on the ground that the information sought pertained to the disciplinary case of Shri G. S. Narang, which was of personal nature, disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest. It further stated that the disclosure of the same may infringe upon the privacy of the individual and that it may not be in the larger interest. The petitioner, therefore, claimed exemption from disclosing the information u/s. 8(1)(j) of the Act.

The Appellate Authority dismissed the Appeal on the same ground that the information sought was exempted from disclosure u/s. 8(1)(j) of the Act. The Respondent preferred an appeal before the CIC. The CIC set aside the decision of the First Appellate Authority and held that opinions/advices tendered/given by the officers (public officials) can be sought for under the Act, provided the same have not been tendered in confidence/secrecy and in trust to the authority concerned, i.e. to say, in a fiduciary relationship. Since the petitioner has not been able to set up the same in the present case, as aforesaid, the claim of exemption u/s. 8(1) (e) stands rejected.

The court observed that a bare perusal of section 8(1)(g) of the Act, makes it clear that the exemption would come into operation only if the disclosure of information would endanger the life or physical safety of any person or would identify the source of the information or assistance given in confidence for law enforcement or security purposes. The opinion/advice, which constitutes the information in the present case, cannot be said to have been given “in confidence for law enforcement or security purposes”, as aforesaid. Therefore, that part of the clause would be inapplicable and irrelevant in the present case. So far as the petitioner’s submission, that the disclosure of Information would endanger the life and safety of the officers who tendered their opinion/advices, is concerned, as aforesaid, in the facts of the present case, may be addressed – by resorting to section 10 of the Act. The exemption u/s. 8(1)(g) of the Act, therefore, as claimed by the Petitioner, would be no ground for disallowing the disclosure of the information (sought by the Respondent) in the facts of the present case.

The other information sought related to the note sheets and final opinion rendered by the UPSC regarding imposition of penalty/punishment on the charged offer. Such information, as is evident from a plain reading, relates to noting and opinion post investigation i.e., after the investigation is complete. Disclosure of such information cannot, by any means whatsoever be held to “impede the process of investigation” which could be raised only when an investigation is ongoing. As such, the exemption u/s. 8(1)(h) of the Act also cannot be raised by the petitioner in the present case.

levitra

Registration of Marriage – Personal appearance of parties to marriage not necessary for presenting application – All marriage solemnised within state should be compulsorily be registered irrespective of religion of parties: Kerala Registration of Marriage (common) R ules, 2008:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[Najma Sirajudden Musliyar vs. Registrar General of Marriages/Deputy Director of Panchayath & Anr AIR 2012 Kerala 115]

The Petitioner was aggrieved by the non acceptance of an application submitted before the second respondent for registration of her marriage, under the provisions of Kerala Registration of Marriage (Common) Rules, 2008. According to her, she married a person of Indian origin, who subsequently acquired citizenship of United Arab Emirates (UAE). The marriage was solemnised as per religious rites and customs and it is registered at ‘Kottol Mahallu Juma Masjid’. The Secretary of the Juma Masjid had issued Marriage Certificate about conduct of the marriage as per religious rites. The Complaint of the petitioner was that 2nd respondent had not received the application for registration submitted stating reasons that, both the spouses should appear in person for submitting such application and that a marriage in which a foreign national is one of the parties cannot be registered under the said Rules.

The Hon’ble Court held that there was no need for personal appearance of the parties to the marriage, for presenting the application for registration. The court further relied on the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Seema v. Aswani Kumar (2006 (1) KLT 791 (SC)) in which a direction was issued to all state Governments to formulate Rules for compulsory registration of marriages, irrespective of religion of the parties. The Rule 6 indicates that all marriage solemnised within the state should compulsorily be registered, irrespective of religion of the parties. Nowhere in the Rules, it can be noticed of any insistence about the nationality of the parties contracting the marriage. On consideration of the relevant personal law (Mohammedan Law), no prohibition can be pointed out with respect to a foreign national marrying an Indian lady, if both of them are professing the religion of Islam. Hence, the objection raised by the 2nd respondent for registration of marriage was unsustainable.

levitra

Guarantor liability – Co-extensive with that of debtor – Financial institution – Not to act as property dealers: Contract Act 1872, sec. 128:

fiogf49gjkf0d
[ Ram Kishun & Ors vs. State of UP and Ors AIR 2012 SC 2288.]

One Ganga Prasad had taken an agricultural loan to the tune of Rs.8,425/- from the Union Bank of India on 20.3.1982 and Chuni Lal, father of the Appellant stood guarantor. Ganga Prasad, debtor died in 1985 and Chuni Lal died in 1986. Ganga Prasad could not pay the loan during his life time. Therefore, the bank initiated the proceedings for recovery and ultimately sent the matter to the District Collector, Banda, for realisation of the loan amount as an arrear of land revenue.

In order to make the recovery, land belonging to said Ganga Prasad was put to auction and it could fetch only a sum of Rs. 6,000/-. In order to recover the balance amount, the proceedings were initiated against the Appellants as their father had stood guarantor. The Appellants raised objections that instead of putting their property to auction, the loan amount be recovered from legal heirs of Ganga Prasad as he had left movable/immovable properties and livestocks and other assets to meet the recovery of the bank loan. Their objections were not accepted and the land of the Appellants was put to auction. Respondent No. 4 purchased the said land for Rs.25,000/-. The sale was confirmed and sale certificate was issued by the Collector in favour of Respondent No. 4 and he was put in possession. Aggrieved, the Appellants approached the Board of Revenue, U.P. by filing Revision. However, the same was dismissed. The High Court upheld the said revisional order of the Commissioner.

The Court, on further appeal, observed that there can be no dispute to the settled legal proposition of law that in view of the provisions of section 128 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the liability of the guarantor/surety is co-extensive with that of the debtor. Therefore, the creditor has a Dr. K. Shivaram Ajay R. Singh Advocates Allied laws right to obtain a decree against the surety and the principal debtor. The surety has no right to restrain execution of the decree against him until the creditor has exhausted his remedy against the principal debtor, for the reason that it is the business of the surety/guarantor to see whether the principal debtor has paid or not. The surety does not have a right to dictate terms to the creditor as to how he should make the recovery and pursue his remedies against the principal debtor at his instance. Section 146 of the Contract Act provides that co-sureties are liable to contribute equally. Thus, in case there are more than one surety/guarantor, they have to share the liability equally unless the agreement of contract provides otherwise.

A person cannot be deprived of his property except in accordance with the provisions of statute. (Vide: Lachhman Dass vs. Jagat Ram and Ors.: (2007) 10 SCC 448; and Narmada Bachao Andolan v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Anr. AIR 2011 SC 1589). Thus, the condition precedent for taking away someone’s property or disposing of the secured assets, is that the authority must ensure compliance of the statutory provisions.

 Therefore, it becomes a legal obligation on the part of the authority that the property be sold in such a manner that it may fetch the best price. Thus essential ingredients of such sale remain a correct valuation report and fixing the reserve price.

levitra

Understanding the business before understanding the audit

fiogf49gjkf0d
Introduction:

One of the objectives of an audit is to identify and assess the risk of material misstatement within the financial statements, together with an assessment of the internal control environment within which an entity operates, to provide a basis for designing and implementing audit procedures to respond to the assessed risks of material misstatement. One of the best ways to identify and assess the risk of material misstatements to the financial statements is through understanding the entity and its environment, which is nothing but having an understanding of the business of the entity which is ultimately to be audited.

Obtaining an understanding of the entity’s business helps to undertake an effective and efficient audit, by tailoring audit procedures to suit the individual facts and circumstances of each client and to undertake the audit procedures and evaluate the audit findings in an informed manner. Knowledge of the entity’s business also helps to develop and maintain a positive professional relationship with the client. Accordingly, business relevance is becoming a key consideration in an audit. In view of the hectic pace at which changes are taking place, auditees have less time and they would prefer to listen to auditors who can demonstrate that they have business knowledge which would make them more credible and relevant. Accordingly, auditing is now a skill which cannot be applied in a business vacuum. Understanding the entity is an iterative and continuous process from the pre-engagement stage to the reporting stage.

The purpose of this article is to identify the professional responsibilities of auditors in dealing with various aspects of the entity’s business environment, which need to be considered by the auditor and evaluating their impact during an audit of the financial statements, duly supplemented by various practical scenarios.

Relevant Auditing Pronouncements:

The following Standards of Auditing (SAs) deal with various aspects of understanding of the entity and its environment during an audit of the financial statements: l SA-315 on Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatements Through Understanding the Entity l SA-250 on Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements l SA-402 on Audit Considerations Relating to an Entity Using a Service Organisation l SA-550 on Related Parties Professional Responsibilities of Auditors: Various professional responsibilities of auditors under each of the above SAs, to the extent they deal with various aspects of understanding of the entity and its environment in an audit of financial statements, are briefly discussed below. SA-315 on Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatements Through Understanding the Entity: SA-315 is the primary standard which deals with the various aspects of understanding an entity and its environment, keeping in mind the following two objectives:

  •  Identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatements within the financial statements.
  •  Understanding the Entity and its Internal Control environment.

Risk Assessment Procedures: The auditor should obtain an understanding of the entity’s strategies and related business risks that may result in material misstatement of the financial statements. Business risk is primarily concerned with external factors that could affect the entity, which may result in material misstatement within the financial statements. It arises as a result of significant conditions, events, circumstances or actions that could adversely affect the entity’s ability to achieve its objectives and strategies. Risk assessment can be undertaken by a combination of one or more of the following procedures:

  •  Inquiries with the Management, operating personnel, those charged with governance, legal counsel etc. which could provide an insight into the industry developments, new products and services, extent of IT support, nature and extent of ongoing litigation and claims etc. Based on the results of the inquiries, the auditor is able to assess the impact of the following possible risks, which could have an impact on the financial statements:

1. Nature and extent of management override of controls especially in small and promoter driven entities. In such cases, the auditor should specifically inquire as to whether the transactions are undertaken on an arms length basis.

2. The risk of technological obsolescence of certain products which may necessitate provisioning for items lying in inventory.

3. The controls over the preparation and generation of financial information and reporting.

  •  Analytical review of financial and non-financial information to identify any unusual trends or characteristics which will help in identifying risks of material misstatements, especially in relation to fraud. This will help the auditor in identifying any aspects which he is not aware of. Based on the results of the analytical review, the auditor is able to assess the impact of the following possible risks, which could have an impact on the financial statements.
  • Observation and inspection to enable gathering of evidence concerning assertions made by the management and others through one or more of the following procedures:

1. Observation of the entity’s activities and operations which would give an insight into the revenue streams, materials used etc.

2. Inspection of various documents like Minutes of meetings, MIS reports, Procedural Manuals etc. which would give an insight into future trends, investments, acquisitions, financial reporting mechanisms etc.

3. Performing walk through tests (i.e observing evidence of controls which are documented in the procedure manuals for a sample of transactions of each type) on various controls which would help identify any procedural inadequacies vis-a-vis the documented controls in the key business cycles like purchasing, revenue, payroll, fixed assets etc. which could result in possible risks and material misstatements.

  • Discussion amongst the engagement team members especially for recurring engagements. This enables the experienced team members to share their insights and learning with the junior and new staff members. Considering the global diversification of many entities, discussion is an effective way of communicating with the engagement teams located in different countries/jurisdictions.
  • Understanding the Entity and its Internal Control Environment: The auditor must understand the entity, the environment in which it operates and its internal control structure, so as to enable him to undertake an effective and efficient audit. This involves an understanding of the following aspects:
  •  External factors
  • Nature of the entity 
  • Internal Controls

External Factors:

There are various external factors as indicated below which the auditor needs to evaluate to ascertain the impact thereof during the course of the audit:

  •  Industry and Economic Developments – These include a consideration of the following aspects: 

1. Seasonality or cyclicality of the products or services which would help in applying appropriate analytical procedures.

2. Technological advances or obsolescence
of the entity’s products or service offerings, which could have an impact on the demand and also whether any provision for impairment or obsolescence is warranted.

3. Economic conditions like interest rates, exchange rates etc. which could impact the ability to raise and service borrowings.

  •     Specific Operational Issues – A large part of gaining an understanding of an entity and its environment, involves looking at the specific factors attached to the entity. The following are certain specific factors which an auditor should consider, when gaining an understanding of the entity and the environment in which it operates:
1.    The entity’s business operations which encompass various matters such as revenue streams, nature of products and services, geographic dispersion, key customers and suppliers, legal and regulatory issues, research and development activities and initiatives etc.

2.    Investments and investment activities including any planned or recently executed acquisitions, investments in various securities
and special purpose entities.

3.    Financing and financing activities including those pertaining to subsidiaries and associated entities, consolidated and non consolidated structures, debt matters and use of derivatives and hedging instruments and structures.

4.    Financial reporting issues such as the use of industry specific accounting policies (e.g. financial services, software, media and entertainment etc.), revenue recognition practices (e.g. fertilisers, telecom etc.), fair value accounting (e.g. investments, brand acquisitions etc.) and other complex transactions which could give rise to “substance over form” issues.

Nature of the Entity:

It is of prime importance for an auditor to gain a thorough understanding of the nature and structure of the entity, its owners and other parties who purport to control the entity in substance. This is particularly important for identification of any related party transactions in accordance with the applicable financial reporting and regulatory framework. In case of complex entities operating in various jurisdictions, this can be a complicated and long winding process.

The understanding of the ownership and control structure is particularly important and relevant for new entities, whose audit is accepted for the first time and must be performed prior to acceptance of the audit as part of the KYC procedures, which the ICAI has recently recommended vide its announcement dated 4th August, 2011. In terms of the said announcement, for all attest engagements, the Council has recommended that certain details be obtained by every member before accepting any attest function. Though the above guidelines are recommendatory, it is in the best interest of the auditor to adhere to them.

Internal Controls:
This is the single most important factor which determines the course of the audit, since it helps to identify factors that affect the risk of material misstatements within the financial statements. An ineffective internal control environment is more likely to give rise to material misstatements. However, a robust internal control environment is not a fool proof guarantee of success but merely an enabler to reduce the risk of material misstatements.

Internal controls represent processes designed and implemented by the management, those charged with the governance and other personnel to provide reasonable assurance about the achievement of the entity’s objectives and to address the business risks identified by the management. The nature and complexity of the internal controls is directly proportional to the size of the entity.

For the purposes of determining which internal controls are relevant to the audit, the following five components as laid down in the COSO framework, are useful to ascertain the different aspects of an entity’s internal controls:

  •     The Control Environment
  •     The Entity’s Risk Assessment Process

  •     The Information System, including Related Busi-ness Processes relevant for Financial Reporting and Communication

  •     Control Activities

  •     Monitoring of Controls


The Control Environment:

An entity’s Control Environment is a crucial aspect. More than any tangible factors, it represents the intangibles which define an entity and its culture, values and ethics which the management and employees imbibe through a code of conduct or other similar means. The quality of the entity’s human resources plays a vital role in ensuring the effectiveness of the control environment. The following are some of the matters which an auditor needs to consider, whilst evaluating the adequacy of the control environment and the degree and extent of reliance which he needs to place thereon to determine the nature, timing and extent of further audit procedures:

  •     Board and Committee Structure – The nature and composition of the Board and its various committees and the degree and extent of their involvement is the single most important factor that determines the effectiveness of the control environment. There is no better substitute than the “tone at the top” which determines the success or failure of the control environment. This can be determined based on a review of the minutes and the information which is furnished to the Board as part of the agenda.

  •     Organisation Structure- A simple structure may work for smaller entities, whereas for larger and more complex entities, it is important to ascertain the authority and responsibility matrix and the lines of reporting.

  •     HR Policies – Human resources play a vital role in the entity’s control environment. This can be evidenced by the selection of appropriately trained individuals for various roles and having appropriate KYC procedures prior to their selection, coupled with appropriate training and continued professional development activities.

Entity’s Risk Assessment Process:
The entity should have risk assessment processes in place to deal with the various business risks relevant to the preparation of the financial statements, which would encompass estimating the level of such risks as well as identifying the likelihood of their occurrence. The following are examples of certain factors which need to be considered by the auditor, to ascertain the impact of changes in circumstances due to which either new risks could arise or the existing risks could change:

  •     Changes in the regulatory and operating environment can result in changes in competitive pressures leading to significantly different risks. A recent example is the power sector, which is impacted by the availability of coal both domestically and internationally.

  •     Significant and rapid expansion of operations can strain controls and increase the risks of breakdowns in internal control.

Information System, including Related Business Processes, Relevant for Financial Reporting and Communication:

In today’s age, most entities deal with reporting and communication of financial issues through the use of IT. It is imperative for an auditor to obtain an understanding of the various general and application controls for various business cycles, to enable him to ensure that all assertions for the generation of financial statements can be tested to enable him to issue an opinion thereon:

  •     Identifying and recording all valid transactions.

  •     Obtaining sufficient details of all transactions on a timely basis to enable proper classification thereof.

  •     Measuring the value of transactions in a manner that permits recording thereof at the proper value.

  •     Determining the time period in which the transactions occurred, to permit the recording thereof in the proper accounting period.

The controls for capturing of data especially the master data is of prime importance, to determine the quality of the system generated reports and information, which not only affects the management’s ability to take appropriate decisions, but also enables preparation of reliable financial reports.

Control Activities:

An auditor must obtain a sufficient understanding of the control activities of the various business cycles, to assess the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level and to design further audit procedures in response to the levels of assessed risks. Control activities encompass a combination of one or more of the following procedures, which the auditor needs to review as deemed appropriate:

  •    Authorisation procedures
  •     Performance reviews
  •     Information processing
  •     Physical controls
  •    Segregation of duties


Monitoring of Controls:

This is an all encompassing activity which covers each of the above components and is primarily performed by the management. It represents the major type of activities that the management uses to monitor internal controls over financial reporting, including those related to control activities relevant to an audit and how corrective actions are initiated. The Audit Committee and Internal Audit are the key facilitators in this process. There are various external and regulatory agencies which also monitor specific aspects of the controls relevant to them like tax authorities, RBI inspectors, factory inspectors etc. One of the most common methods of monitoring controls, is the preparation of the bank reconciliation statement on a monthly or more frequent basis and its regular review and followup.

Other Standards:

The requirements of other SA’s which deal with the audit considerations pertaining to the understanding of the entity and its environment are summarised below:

  •    SA-250 casts a responsibility on the auditor to obtain an understanding of the various laws and regulations impacting the entity which is a key element of the environment in which the entity operates. The SA broadly envisages the following two situations:

1.    Laws and regulations which have a direct effect on the financial statements and issuance of audit reports and other certificates in respect of the reporting entity.

2.    Laws and regulations which do not have a direct effect on the financial statements of the reporting entity, but compliance with which may have a fundamental effect on the operating aspects of the business, non-compliance with which may result in material penalties being levied by the concerned regulatory authorities.

  •     SA-402 casts a responsibility on the auditor to understand the nature of services provided to a user entity by a service organisation which is defined as a third party organisation or a segment thereof that provides services to user entities that are part of those entities’ information systems relevant to financial reporting since such service organisations are nothing but an extension of the environment in which the entity operates in accordance with the provisions of SA-315. The most common examples of service organisations are payroll processing agencies, registrars and transfer agents, custodians, accounting and tax compliance service entities etc. The following are some of the matters which the auditor needs to consider relating to the service organisation:

1.    The nature of services provided.

2.    The contractual terms.

3.    The extent to which the internal controls of the entity interact with those of the service organisation.

4.    Information available on the relevant internal controls of the service organisation.

5.    Types of transactions processed.

The aforesaid information can be obtained in either of the following ways:

1.    Visiting the service organisation.

2.    Obtaining an independent auditors report on the design, implementation and operating effectiveness of the internal controls of the service organisation, commonly referred to a Type 1 and Type 2 reports.

3.    Using another auditor to perform procedures to obtain an understanding of relevant controls at the service organisation.

  •     SA-550 casts a responsibility on the auditor to ensure that the management has correctly identified the related party transactions and made sufficient disclosures thereof in the financial statements, which is part of the broader framework of understanding the entity and its environment in terms of SA-315. The following are examples of procedures to identify related parties:

1.    Review of the declarations from directors in Form 24AA under the Companies Act, 1956.

2.    Review of the minutes of board meetings.

3.    Reviewing the audited accounts of known related parties to identify any step-down relationships.

4.    Review of bank confirmation for existence of guarantees given to related parties.

Illustrative Scenarios On Understanding Certain Aspects of Business/Environment in which an Entity Operates:

An attempt here is made to give an illustrative understanding in respect of certain aspects of the business/environment in which an entity is operating which could have an impact on financial reporting.

Business Model/Supply Chain:

An understanding of the business model is the primary driver of the revenue streams and cash flows of an entity. It covers the entire supply chain right from the co-ordination with the suppliers for sourcing of raw materials, the production to be undertaken in line with the demand from the customers, the extent of inventory to be maintained, the various stocking points and the distribution chain. It is imperative to gain an appropriate understanding of the business model and assess its utility in the light of the changes in the business dynamics and competitive environment in which the entity is operating. This would help to assess whether the entity would be able to sustain its existence on a going concern basis, which is one of the fundamental assumptions for the preparation of the financial statements. Understanding the business model/ supply chain gives the auditor an insight into the following matters, amongst others:

  •     The extent, level and type of inventory to be maintained and its valuation methodology.

  •     The nature and type of customers and accordingly the extent of provisioning for any non recoveries.

  •     The normal margin and cost structure.


Brand/Intellectual Property:

An understanding of the brands/intellectual properties owned/acquired by the entity is imperative to gain an understanding of the sustainability of the business model of the enterprise vis-a-vis the competition. This would help the auditor to assess the value at which it is to be recognised and whether any impairment needs to be considered.

Insurance Coverage

The nature and extent of the risk coverage is an important indicator of the risk management and risk philosophy of the entity. It also helps to assess the extent of loss, both qualitative and quantitative, in times of damages or other stresses that the business might have to undergo. It is imperative that the auditor is able to assess the adequacy of the nature and extent of insurance coverage, to enable the entity to sustain its existence on a going concern basis.

Properties:

The policy of the entity with regard to the type and nature of properties to be acquired needs to be understood, keeping in mind the business model and the cash flows of the entity. This would consequentially determine special accounting requirements, especially with respect to lease transactions and other similar matters.

Conclusion:

Understanding the business environment during the audit is a continuous activity which an auditor needs to undertake for an effective and efficient audit. To conclude, effective auditing requires not just good technical skills, but also a willingness to venture outside the box to gain a better understanding of the entity.

Reference Material:

  •     Indian Auditing Standards
  •     Wiley’s Interpretation and Application of International Standards on Auditing by Steven Collings
  •     Various Research Reports on Audit Process available for general public.

Notifications w.r.t. Schedule C:

fiogf49gjkf0d
No. 1512/C.R.91 (1)/Taxation-1, dated 17-8-2012 No. 1512/C.R.91 (2)/Taxation-1, dated 17-8-2012 No. 1512/C.R.91 (3)/Taxation-1, dated 17-8-2012 No. 1512/C.R.91 (4)/Taxation-1, dated 17-8-2012

First Notification exempts sale of furnishing fabrics notified under schedule entry C-101 when sold other than last point of sale within the state. Second Notification adds; furnishing fabrics notified under Schedule Entry C-101, in exclusions from sales turnover under composition scheme for retailers in the notification issued on 1-06-2005 Vat 1505/C.R.105/ Taction-1 for Composition Scheme. Third Notification specifies varieties of furnishing fabrics under Schedule Entry No.C-101 (a). Fourth Notification amends list of varieties of sugar, tobacco textiles and textile articles by Schedule Entry C-101 issued in Notification 1505/C.R. 120/Taxtion 1, Dated 1-6-2005. All the notifications are effective from 1-9-2012.

levitra

Tax on vocational education/training courses

fiogf49gjkf0d
Circular No. 164/15/2012-ST dated August 28, 2012

CBEC- TRU has issued this Circular clarifying certain issues in relation to levy of service tax on certain vocational education/training/skill development courses (VEC). Accordingly, VEC offered by the Central Government or State Government or local authority themselves ,is covered in the Negative List under Section 66D and hence, service tax is not leviable. When the VEC is offered by an institution, as an independent entity in the form of society or any other similar body, service tax treatment is determinable by the application of either sub-clause (ii) or (iii) of clause (l) of section 66D. Services provided by way of education as a part of a curriculum for obtaining a qualification recognised by any law for the time being in force, are not chargeable to service tax. Services provided by way of education as a part of an approved vocational education course are not chargeable to service tax.

levitra

Central sales Tax- State Government–Power to Grant Exemption total/partial – U/s. 8(5) – Not Affected Even After Amendment From 11.5.2002-To Grant Exemption From Payment of Tax – On sales Not Supported by Form C/D – Section 8(5) of The Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.

fiogf49gjkf0d

2. M/S. Prism Cement Limited and Another v.
State of Maharashtra and Others , Writ Petition No. 6475 of 2009 decided
on 30.8.2012 by The Bombay High Court.


Central sales Tax- State
Government–Power to Grant Exemption total/partial – U/s. 8(5) – Not
Affected Even After Amendment From 11.5.2002-To Grant Exemption From
Payment of Tax – On sales Not Supported by Form C/D – Section 8(5) of
The Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.

Facts

The
dealer filed a writ petition against three trade circulars issued by the
Commissioner of Sales Tax, dated 27.5.2002, 20.7.2002 and 8.2.2007 and
also notices issued by the commissioner for revising the assessment
before the Bombay High Court. By the above mentioned circulars, the
Commissioner had informed that u/s. 8(5) of the CST Act, amended by
Finance Act, 2002 from 11.5.2002, State Government is empowered to grant
exemption only in respect of inter-State sales to the registered
dealers or to the Government covered by section 8(1) of the Act, unless
such sales are supported by declaration in form C or D respectively, as
provided in section 8(4) of the act. It was further informed that as a
result of the above amendment, any notification issued u/s. 8(5) of the
act prior to 11.5.2002, which is contrary to the amended section 8(5)
shall be amended accordingly. In other words according to Commissioner,
unless C or D forms are produced, benefit of exemption or concessional
rate of tax, under any notification issued prior to 11.5.2002, cannot be
granted in respect of any inter-state sales effected after 11.5.2002.

Based
on the above, the department initiated proceedings against the dealer
to recover tax on inter- state sales not supported by either form C or
D, which was claimed by the dealer as exempt from payment of tax under
notification issued by the State prior to 11.5.2002.The dealer filed
writ petition before the Bombay High Court challenging the
abovementioned three trade circulars issued by the Commissioner of sales
tax and other notices issued by the assessing authority.

The
question to be considered by the High Court was, whether section 8(5) of
the act as amended by the Finance Act, 2002 restricts the powers of
State Government to grant exemption either wholly or partially only in
respect of sales of goods to registered dealer/Government subject to
furnishing declaration in form C or D as the case may be?

If the
answer is yes, then whether amended section 8(5) affects the vested
right of the eligible unit to claim the exemption from payment of tax
under package scheme of incentives 1993, so far it relates to
inter-State sales of goods to dealers other than registered
dealers/Government?

Held

The High Court rejected
the self-destructive argument of the department that section 8(5) of the
Act after the amendment, restricts the power of State Government to
grant total/partial exemption in respect of inter-State sales covered by
section 8(1) only. Even after the amendment to section 8(5) of the act,
the power of state Government to grant total/partial exemption in
respect of inter-state sales covered by section 8(2) of the act is not
affected. Since the High Court decided first question in favour of the
dealer, second question was not answered by the High Court.
Accordingly, the High Court allowed the writ petition and quashed and
set aside the impugned trade circulars issued by the Commissioner of
sales tax and other notices issued by the Department.

levitra

Valuer services are not consulting engineer services and therefore, not leviable to service tax

fiogf49gjkf0d
11. 2012 (27) STR 113 (Guj.) Institution of Valuers v. Union of India

Valuer services are not consulting engineer services and therefore, not leviable to service tax


Facts:

The petitioner received a clarification from the Commissioner of Central Excise on 27.03.1998 which stated that valuers of immovable property (other than agricultural lands, plantations, forests, mines and quarries) and valuers of plant and machinery are consulting engineer services leviable to service tax. The petitioner’s contentions were as under: Valuation broadly means assessing worth of any tangible or intangible assets. Following principles are applied for the purpose of valuation:

  •  Supply and demand
  •  Competition
  •  Substitution
  •  Assessment of circumstances having a direct or indirect nexus on the degree of utility and productivity of an asset
  •  Assessment of market forces
  •  Relative purchasing power of money
  •  Technological advancement or changes etc.

There is no legislation to regulate the profession of valuation. However, under Wealth Tax Act, 1957, the valuation can be carried out by a person registered with the Central Government u/s. 34AB of the said Act read with Rule 8A of the Wealth Tax Rules, 1957. One such person is defined to be a graduate in civil engineering and therefore, the respondent levied service tax on valuer services. However, valuation is not recognised as a discipline of engineering and the services can be provided by a number of professionals. The very fact that persons having other qualifications can also render valuer services is sufficient to conclude that valuation is not a discipline of engineering. Valuation requires knowledge of law, economics, accountancy, town planning, environmental science etc. Graduate in any stream is eligible for admission to the said course. Valuation is not a discipline of engineering and therefore, the services cannot be leviable to service tax under “consulting engineer services” even if the services are rendered by an engineer. The services are not in the nature of advice, consultancy or technical assistance in common parlance and therefore, when valuer services are provided by a consulting engineer, it is an unreasonable restriction on the fundamental right of the petitioner to carry on their profession and therefore, the levy is unconstitutional.

According to the respondent, provisions of Rule 8A of the Wealth Tax Rules, 1957 suggests that a graduate in civil engineering could become a registered valuer and the services provided by a valuer of immovable property or plant and machinery is a highly technical job. Further, prospectus of a university states that the course is imparted by the faculty of engineering and technology. The course content is mostly in the field of engineering. Reliance is placed on the judgment in case of V. Shanmughavel vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai – II 2001 (131) ELT 14 (Mad) wherein it was observed that vide Wealth Tax Laws, the person should hold a degree of engineering and should be a high standard engineer. Further, the services are in the nature of advise, consultancy or technical assistance and therefore, are liable to service tax as “consulting engineer’s services”. Therefore, when an engineer becomes a registered valuer of immovable property or plant and machinery, he is rendering consulting engineer’s services.

Held:

Vide Rules 8A of the Wealth Tax Rules, 1957, the qualifications prescribed for each category of valuers are different. The provisions with respect to valuation of immovable property and plant and machinery, allow an engineer to be a registered valuer. However, being an engineer is not a condition precedent for being eligible to be a registered valuer. The syllabus of valuer contains general subjects and subjects pertaining to engineering are limited. Valuation services rendered by a person, not being an engineer, is not consulting engineer’s services. Further, valuation services rendered by an engineer is also not leviable to service tax under “consulting engineer’s services” since there is no advise, consultancy or technical assistance involved in the said activity and it is not in relation to any discipline of engineering. Services rendered by the petitioner as valuer is not leviable to service tax as “consulting engineer’s services”.

levitra

Appointed date as approved by High Courts has to be considered the date of amalgamation and therefore, the services provided by the respondent in subsequent period should be considered to be services to self-service tax paid thereon, therefore, is eligible for refund.

fiogf49gjkf0d
10. 2012 (27) STR 145 (Tri.-Del.) Commissioner of Service Tax, Delhi-I vs. ITC Hotels Ltd.

Appointed date as approved by High Courts has to be considered the date of amalgamation and therefore, the services provided by the respondent in subsequent period should be considered to be services to self-service tax paid thereon, therefore, is eligible for refund.


Facts:

The respondent and M/s. Ansal Hotels Ltd. were subsidiary of M/s. ITC Ltd. However, both these subsidiaries were amalgamated into the holding Company. The Hon. Delhi and Kolkata High Courts sanctioned the scheme in September 2004 w.e.f. 01.04.2004. Therefore, the respondent filed a refund claim for service tax paid for services rendered by them to the holding company during the period from April 2004 to September 2004, considering the services provided to self in view of the orders of High Courts. The original adjudicating rejected the refund claim considering the effective date as the date on which all the orders, sanctions, approvals, consents, conditions, matters or filings were obtained/ filed. The respondent had filed application with the Registrar of Companies on 23.03.2005, therefore, effective date of amalgamation was considered to be 23.03.2005. The Commissioner (Appeals) observed that: The date provided in the scheme of amalgamation was to be considered to be the effective date as held by the Hon. Apex Court in case of M/s. Marshall Sons & Co. (India) Ltd. vs. Income Tax Officers 1997 (223) ITR 0809 SC and all the entities to be considered as one entity w.e.f. 01.04.2004 and consequently, services provided between the entities should be considered as services to self, not leviable to service tax relying upon following decisions:

  •  Precot Mills Ltd. vs. C. C. E., Tirupati 2006 TIOL 818 CESTAT-Bang.
  •  Kwality Zipper Ltd. vs. C. C. E., Kanpur 2002 (145) ELT 296 (Tri.-Del)

 The matter was remanded back to the original adjudicating authority to verify service tax involved in the matter and that the burden of the same was not passed on to others. The department on the other hand contended that as per the scheme of amalgamation, the employees of the transferor company were transferred to the transferee company w.e.f. 23.03.2005. Therefore, the separate identity of the service provider and service receiver remained intact till 23.03.2005 and the scheme further specified that any transactions or proceedings already concluded on or before the effective date should not be affected by the scheme of amalgamation. As per the decision in case of M/s. Wallace Flour Mills Co. Ltd. vs. Collector of Central Excise 1989 (44) ELT 598 (SC), the excise duty had to be determined at the rate prevalent on the date of removal, therefore, the taxable event being provision of service, contrary order cannot be passed by the Commissioner (Appeals).

Held:

In case of M/s. Marshall Sons & Co. (India) Ltd. (Supra), the Hon. Apex Court had held that the date of amalgamation as presented in the scheme, has to be considered to be the transfer date and not the date of the order sanctioning the scheme. The law declared by the Hon. Supreme Court was binding on all the Courts as per Article 141 of the Constitution of India and therefore, the ratio laid down in the Income Tax Act can be made applicable to Service Tax Laws in view of peculiar facts of the case. The Hon. Tribunal’s decision in case of Technocraft Industries (I) Ltd. (Supra) supported the respondent’s case that effective date needed to be preferred over the approval date. Wallace Flour Mills (Supra), was not applicable as it did not deal with the effective date of amalgamation and, accordingly, department’s appeal was rejected.

levitra

Hiring of manned cranes to ONGC – Cranes at disposal of ONGC and per day hire charges paid – Service tax paid thereon – Services of staff and maintenance incidental to hiring – ONGC alone entitled to exclusive use of cranes – Transfer of right to use goods – Assam Value Added Tax, 2003.

fiogf49gjkf0d
4. 2012 53 VST 401 (Gauhati) – Brahmaputra Valley Construction and Suppliers v. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. and Others

Hiring of manned cranes to ONGC – Cranes at disposal of ONGC and per day hire charges paid – Service tax paid thereon – Services of staff and maintenance incidental to hiring – ONGC alone entitled to exclusive use of cranes – Transfer of right to use goods – Assam Value Added Tax, 2003.


Facts:

ONGC entered into contracts with dealers to provide manned cranes according to technical specifications with the necessary accessories with valid permits, insurance, for performing the duties as advised by ONGC, at the appointed time and place. The agreement showed that the activity was in respect of hiring of cranes. The work was to be executed by ONGC itself. The cranes were at the disposal of ONGC and per day hire charges were paid, except maintenance days. The services of staff operating them and maintenance were incidental to hiring of the cranes. The appellant’s case was that it owned cranes and in pursuant to notice inviting tenders, they entered into the contract. The cranes were at ONGC’s disposal without transfer of possession and custody thereof. All operating costs were to be borne by the appellant and thus there was no transfer of ownership of the cranes, nor of the right to use to ONGC and they paid service tax considering this as taxable service. The Revenue contended that the relevant clauses of the agreement such as the availability of cranes on a particular day or time (including maintenance off days), its operational time, arrangements of fuel lubricants etc. remained a sole discretion of ONGC, indicating dominion and control of ONGC during the entire period of operation.

Held:

For all the practical purposes, it was evident that the use of the cranes was transferred to ONGC for the period of contract and the assessee had no right to use the same. Such a right having been transferred to ONGC for consideration. The mere fact that the responsibility of the maintenance and use was vested with the assessee, does not deviate from the nature of transaction being transfer of right to use. The taxability u/s. 65(105)(zzzzj) under the Finance Act, 1994 – supply of tangible goods services would have been applicable if the right to possession and control remained with the service provider, which is not the case here. The judgement of the Hon. Supreme Court in BSNL vs. Union of India [2006] 3 VST 95 (SC) was relied upon.

levitra

Penalty – u/s. 271(1)(c) – Penalty cannot be imposed on the additions made under the normal provisions of the Act when the income is assessed u/s. 115JB –SLP dismissed.

fiogf49gjkf0d
[CIT v. Nalwa Sons Investment Ltd. (SLP (Civil) No.18564 of 2011 dated 04-05-2012]

For the assessment year 2001-02 the respondent- assessee had filed return declaring loss at Rs.43.47 crore. Thereafter, the revised return exhibiting the income at Rs.3,86,82,128/- was filed under the provisions of section 115JB. The assessment order was framed by the Assessing Officer u/s. 143(3) at a loss of Rs.36.95 crore as per normal provisions and at book profits at Rs.4,01,63,180/- u/s. 115 JB of the Act. While doing so, various additions were made by the Assessing Officer including the following:-

a. In so far the claim of depreciation was concerned, the Assessing Officer disallowed the depreciation to the extent of Rs.32,51,906/-.

b. The addition towards the provident fund of Rs.3,030/- treating the same as income, was also made on the ground that this contribution was made belatedly by the assessee.

c. The Assessing Officer also disallowed deduction u/s. 80HHC of the Act on the ground that the assessee had not adjusted the loss incurred on manufactured and traded goods exported out of India against incentives and had claimed deduction u/s. 80HHC of the Act on 90% of the incentives.

These additions were upheld by the CIT(A).

While drawing the assessment order, the Assessing Officer also directed that penalty proceedings be initiated against the assessee by issuing a show cause notice u/s. 271(1)(c) of the Act. The show cause notice was thus given to the respondent-assessee, who submitted its reply thereto. However, the Assessing Officer was not convinced with the reply and thus, passed the order dated 28th September, 2007 imposing a penalty of Rs.90,97,415/- in respect of the aforesaid three additions, holding that the assessee had furnished inaccurate particulars of the income which fell within the purview of the section 271(1)(c) of the Act and Explanation 1 thereto.

The assessee preferred an appeal, which was allowed by the CIT (A), who set aside the penalty order. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal affirmed the order of the CIT(A) maintaining that no penalty could have been imposed upon the assessee under the given circumstances.

On further appeal by the revenue, the Delhi High Court [ITXA No.1420 of 2009 dated 26/8/2010] observed that the judgment of the Supreme Court in Gold Coin’s has clarified that even if there are losses in a particular year, penalty can be imposed as even in that situation there can be a tax evasion. As per section 271(1)(c), the penalty can be imposed when any person has concealed the particulars of his income or furnished incorrect particulars of the income. Once this condition is satisfied, quantum of penalty is to be levied as per clause (3) of section 271(1) (c), which stipulates that the penalty shall not exceed three times “the amount of tax sought to be evaded”. The expression “the amount of tax sought to be evaded” is clarified and explained in Explanation 4 thereto, as per which it has to have the effect of reducing the loss declared in the return or converting that loss into income.

The question, however according to the High Court, in the present case, was as to whether furnishing of such wrong particulars had any effect on the amount of tax sought to be evaded. The High Court held that under the scheme of the Act, the total income of the assessee is first computed under the normal provisions of the Act and tax payable on such total income is compared with the prescribed percentage of the ‘book profits’ computed u/s. 115JB of the Act. The higher of the two amounts is regarded as total income and tax is payable with reference to such total income. If the tax payable under the normal provisions is higher, such amount is the total income of the assessee, otherwise, ‘book profits’ are deemed as the total income of the appellant in terms of section 115JB of the Act.

In the present case, the income computed as per the normal procedure was less than the income determined by legal fiction, namely ‘book profits’ u/s. 115JB of the Act. On the basis of normal provision, the income was assessed in the negative i.e. at a loss of Rs.36,95,21,018. On the other hand, assessment u/s. 115 JB of the Act resulted in calculation of profit at Rs.4,01,63,180.

The income of the assessee was thus assessed u/s. 115 JB and not under the normal provisions.

According to the High Court, judgment in the case of Gold Coin (supra), did not deal with such a situation. What was held by the Supreme Court in that case was that, even if in the income tax return filed by the assessee losses are shown, penalty could still be imposed in a case where on setting off the concealed income against any loss incurred by the assessee under other head of income or brought forward from earlier years, the total income was reduced to a figure lower than the concealed income or even a minus figure. The Supreme Court was of the opinion that the tax sought to be evaded would mean the tax chargeable, not as if it were the total income. Once this rationale to Explanation 4 given by the Supreme Court is applied in the present case, it would be difficult to sustain the penalty proceedings. Reason was simple. No doubt, there was concealment but that had its repercussions only when the assessment was done under the normal procedure. The assessment as per the normal procedure was, however, not acted upon. On the contrary, it was the deemed income assessed u/s. 115 JB of the Act which had become the basis of assessment as it was the higher of the two. Tax was thus paid on the income assessed u/s. 115 JB of the Act. Hence, when the computation was made u/s. 115 JB of the Act, the aforesaid concealment had no role to play and was totally irrelevant. Therefore, the concealment did not lead to tax evasion at all.

The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition filed by the revenue against the aforesaid order of the Delhi High Court. CIT v. Nalwa Sons Investment Ltd.

levitra

“Used for the purposes of business or profession” for depreciation u/s 32

fiogf49gjkf0d
The controversy sought to be discussed herein fails to die down and one finds that the same continues to be relevant more so in view of the conflicting judicial views.

The general scheme of the Act is, that income is to be charged regardless of the exhaustion or diminution in the value of capital. To this principle of taxation, an exception is afforded by section 32, wherein an allowance is provided in respect of depreciation on the value of certain capital assets in computing the profits and gains of business or profession u/s. 28 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘the Act’).

The relevant part of section 32 of the Act is reproduced below for ease in understanding and ready reference in context of controversy to be discussed:

“32(1) In respect of depreciation of –

 (i) Buildings, machinery, plant or furniture, being tangible assets;

(ii) Know-how, patents, copyrights…. or any other business or commercial rights of similar nature, being intangible assets, acquired on or after the 1st day of April, 1988, owned, wholly or partly, by the assessee and used for the purpose of the business or profession, the following deductions shall be allowed……”

Section 32 while conferring the benefit on the assessee, lays down two conditions to be satisfied by an assessee .These two conditions are, firstly, that the asset must be owned by the assessee and, secondly, the asset must be used for the purpose of business or profession of the assessee.

Pradip Kapasi Gautam Nayak Ankit Virendra Sudha Shah Chartered Accountants Controversies Therefore, ownership and usage of the asset by the assessee for the purpose of the business and profession are the pre-requisites for grant of depreciation u/s. 32 of the Act.

The controversy revolves around the determination of the event in point of time when the asset under consideration can be said to be ‘used’ for the purpose of business or profession. Conflicting decisions of the Courts are available on the subject wherein Delhi, Rajasthan, Punjab and Haryana, Madras, Calcutta and Gauhati High Courts have supported the view that an asset which is owned and is kept ready for use should be eligible for grant of depreciation even where the same is actually not used during the year [hereinafter referred to as “passive user of asset”] while the Bombay, Karnataka and Gujarat High Courts have held that not only the asset should be owned by the assessee, but the same should be actually used during the year [hereinafter referred to as “actual user of asset”].

Oswal Agro Mills case

Recently, the Delhi High Court in the case of CIT v. Oswal Agro Mills Ltd. and Anr (supra) (‘the company’) had an occasion to deal with the aforesaid issue under consideration, wherein a question arose for grant of depreciation in respect of assets in the unit of the assessee company at Bhopal, which remained closed throughout the year. The AO denied the claim for depreciation in respect of assets of Bhopal unit of the assessee company on the ground that it was closed throughout the year, which was upheld by the CIT(A) on appeal by the assessee. The Delhi Tribunal, however, reversed the findings of the lower authorities, after considering the submissions of the assessee and held as under:

  • The Bhopal unit remained dormant and could not function due to various reasons and the Revenue could not bring on record that this unit was finally closed or sold out in succeeding years;
  •  That revenue could not controvert that this unit did not form part of the block of assets;
  • If any of the part of the block of assets was not used during the year, but remaining part of the block of assets was in continuous use, then assessee was entitled for the depreciation on the entire block of assets; and
  • If the assessee’s unit was temporarily closed for a year or so and its commercial activities were in lull for that period, then assessee could not be deprived from its claim of depreciation unless and until, it was proved that the assessee had closed its business forever and had no intention of reviving the same.

On further appeal by the Revenue before the Delhi High Court, the Court after referring to the conflicting judgements of other High Courts as referred to above, opined in principle that the passive user of the asset was also recognised as user for the purpose of expression ‘asset used for the purpose of business or profession.’ After relying on its own decisions on the subject, the Court held that even when an asset was not used for certain reason in the concerned assessment year but was kept ready for use, in such a case, assessee should not be denied the claim for depreciation.

For the sake of completeness, as to the facts, in the aforesaid case on facts, the assessee failed to prove that the assets were ready for use, since the assets under consideration were not used for number of years. Even then, the assessee was allowed depreciation on the impugned assets by applying the ‘block of assets’ concept which was brought by the Legislature in section 2(11) of the Act w.e.f. 1st April 1988 vide Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 1986 where the grant of depreciation, additions and deletion of assets are considered qua the block of assets and not qua the individual assets. In other words, the High Court held that since the impugned assets had lost their individual identities under the block of asset concept, and therefore, it was not possible to disallow depreciation qua the individual assets of Bhopal unit, once such assets entered the block of assets. Further, the Court also observed that the Revenue would not be put to any loss by adopting such method and allowing depreciation, since whenever the assets at Bhopal unit were sold, it would result in short term capital gain, which would be exigible to tax.

The High Court accordingly agreed that the depreciation was allowed where the asset was ready for use, but allowed the claim of the company for grant of depreciation based on ‘block of assets’ concept as referred to above.

Dineshkumar Gulabchand Agrawal’s case

 In a short judgement by the Bombay High Court in the case of Dineshkumar Gulabchand Agrawal (‘the assessee’) v. CIT and Anr (supra) with limited facts on record, the Court held that the word ‘used’ in s. 32 denoted actually used and not merely ready to use. The assessee submitted before the Court that, since the vehicle was ready to use for the purpose of business even though not actually used, should be allowed claim of depreciation placing reliance on the earlier Bombay High Court decision in the case of Whittle Anderson Ltd. vs CIT (79 ITR 613). The Bombay High Court distinguished the decision of Whittle Anderson Ltd (supra) on the ground that in the said case, the Court was concerned with the interpretation of the terms ‘use’ or ‘used’ and further referred to an amendment in section 32 of the Act, post the decision of Whittle Anderson Ltd. Inserted for clarifying that the expression ‘used’ meant actually used for the purpose of the business and accordingly upheld the decision of the Mumbai Tribunal in disallowing the claim of depreciation on vehicles kept ready for use.

In a further development, the assessee’s Special Leave Petition (‘SLP’) before the Apex Court reported in 266 ITR (St.) 106 was also dismissed by the Supreme court with the following observations:

“Dismissed
The Bombay High Court in view of the amendment to section 32 held that the expression “used” meant actually used for the purpose of business and upheld the Tribunal’s order that the assessee was not entitled to claim benefit of depreciation on assets not actually used though kept ready to use. [ITA No. 2 of 2001, dt. 9 Jan 2003]”

Before we provide our observations as regard to controversy under consideration, it would be necessary to discuss the relevance of SLP being dismissed and/or rejected and its implications on the order under appeal in the context of doctrine of merger and precedence. The Supreme Court in the case of Kunhayammed & Ors. Vs State of Kerala & Anr. (245 ITR 360) while considering the jurisdiction of High Court to entertain a review petition once a SLP before SC is dismissed, observed as under:

  •     Where an appeal or revision is provided against an order passed by a Court, Tribunal or any other authority before superior forum and such superior forum modifies, reverses or affirms the decision put in issue before it, the decision by the subordinate forum merges in the decision by the superior forum and it is the latter which subsists, remains operative and is capable of enforcement in the eye of law;

  •     The jurisdiction conferred by Article 136 of the Constitution of India is divisible into two stages. First stage is upto the disposal of prayer for special leave to file an appeal. The second stage commences if and when the leave is granted and SLP is converted into an appeal;

  •    Doctrine of merger is not a doctrine of universal or unlimited application. It will depend on the nature of jurisdiction exercised by the superior forum and the content or subject-matter of challenge laid or capable of being laid shall be determinative of the applicability of merger. The superior jurisdiction should be capable of reversing, modifying or af-firming the order put in issue before it;

  •     Under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, the Supreme Court may reverse, modify or af-firm the judgement, decree or order appealed against, while exercising its appellate jurisdiction and not while exercising the discretionary jurisdiction disposing of petition for special leave to appeal. The doctrine for merger can, therefore, be applied to former and not to the latter;

  •    An order refusing special leave to appeal may be a non-speaking order or a speaking one. In either case, it does not attract doctrine of merger. An order refusing special leave to appeal does not stand substituted in place of the order under challenge. All that it means that the Court was not inclined to exercise its discretion so as to allow the appeal being filed;

  •     If the order refusing leave to appeal is a speaking order ie gives reasons for refusing the grant of leave, then the order has two implications:

–    Firstly, the statement of law contained in the order is a declaration of law by Supreme Court within the meaning of Article 141 of Constitution of India; and

–    Secondly, other than the declaration of law, whatever is stated in the order is a declaration of law by the Supreme Court which would bind the parties thereto and also the Court, Tribunal or authority in any proceedings sub-sequent thereto by way of judicial discipline, the Supreme Court being the apex court of the country;

–    But this does not amount to saying that the order of Court, Tribunal or authority below has stood merged in the order of Supreme Court rejecting SLP or that the order of the Supreme Court is the only order binding as res judicata in subsequent proceedings between the parties.

In light of above relevant findings of the Supreme Court, it may be concluded that even though SLP to Dineshkumar Gulabchand Agrawal case was dismissed, irrespective whether being speaking or non-speaking order, it would not be binding as res judicata and/or binding on other parties or serve as doctrine of merger to subsequent proceedings between the parties thereto.

Observations
Upon perusing the provisions of section 32 of the Act and the legislative history thereof, one finds that the word “used” was in the statute from its inception and there has been no change brought in the said section except by the second proviso to section 32 inserted vide Finance (No. 2) Act, 1991 and further substituted by the Income-tax (Amendment) Act, 1998 to its present form, which reads as under:

“Provided further that where an asset referred to in clause (i) or clause (ii) or clause (iia), as the case may be, is acquired by the assessee during the previous year and is put to use for the purpose of business or profession for a period of less than one hundred-eighty days in that previous year, the deduction under this sub-section in respect of such asset shall be restricted to fifty percent of the amount calculated at the percentage prescribed for an asset under clause ……………”

In Dineshkumar Gulabchand Agrawal’s case (supra), the Bombay High Court found that subsequent to the earlier law as laid down in Whittle Anderson Ltd v. CIT(supra), there has been an amendment to section 32 of the Act in context of the word “used” and so earlier decision as relied upon by the assessee had no application. The Bombay High Court as well as the Supreme Court, while ruling, did not provide any reference to the amendment carried out in the expression “used”. It is also not possible for a reader to fathom the above referred amendment out from a plain reading of the said decision.

It may not be incorrect to hold, in the circumstances, that an erroneous presumption was made by the court which error formed the basis of the decision. It may also be correct to presume that neither this error was pointed out to the court by the assessee nor was it pointed out to the apex court. In the alternative, though not expressly referred to by the court, one may gather that the Bombay High Court was probably referring to the expression “put to use” that is referred to in the second proviso to section 32 of the Act. According to the second proviso to section 32 of the Act, if the assets acquired during the previous year are put to use for less than 180 days, then depreciation is restricted to 50% of the depreciation as otherwise available for the whole year.

Surely, the stipulation in the proviso could not have the effect of curtailing the scope of the main provision, unless specifically provided for. Again, had that been the intention, the main provision could have been amended simultaneously, more so where the controversy was fairly known to all concerned. It may be inappropriate to restrict the scope of the term ‘used’ found in the main provision by gathering the meaning thereof from the proviso, which again has been introduced for the limited purpose of restricting the quantum of depreciation and not for the disallowance thereof. Accordingly, even in the context of the proviso, it is not possible to hold that the eligibility of depreciation under the main provision of section 32 is based on actual user of the asset. The courts have consistently upheld the claim of the assessee on being satisfied with readiness of the asset for its use. This view has been unanimously upheld by all the courts including the Bombay high court for the period prior to the amendment and does not require any change on account of the proviso.

The said proviso otherwise is found to be relevant only for the first year of claim of depreciation and has been found to be inapplicable once the identity of the asset is merged with that of the block of assets. Once in the block, it is not possible to seggregate an asset for disallowance, nor it is possible to determine the written down value of an individual asset that is believed to have not been used for the year.

The Act has used several terms surrounding the user. For example; used, wholly used, put to use and partly used. It has also used the term ‘actually’ wherever required, for example in section 43B where actual payment is desired. All these clearly show that the Act would have provided for in clear terms, that the asset should have been actually used, if the intention was to restrict the depreciation to such user only. In the absence of the condition to ‘actually’ use the asset, it is apt that a wider meaning is given to the term ‘used’ as was given by the Bombay high court in the case of CIT v. Vishwanath Bhaskar Sathe, 5 ITR 621.

The expression “put to use” in a general sense may otherwise also mean and include an asset that is ready for use. In many cases, an asset is not actually used during the year, but is kept ready for use. For example, standby plant and machinery, step-ins, spare parts, etc. Further, in many cases like strike, lock out, flood, fire,etc., the assets cannot be actually used, even if desired. In these cases, though the assets are not actually used during the previous year, even then depreciation is not denied considering the intention to use such assets. It is, therefore ,appropriate to hold that the user of asset should signify all such cases where an asset is kept ready for use for the purpose of business or profession.

This view also finds support from the the Circular No. 621 of 1991 (supra), which attempts to match the claim of the depreciation with the income offered for taxation. Once the assessee has derived income from business to which the said asset belongs, the claim for depreciation should not unreasonably be withheld.

The intention of the legislature cannot be gathered from the proviso introduced at a much later date with the limited effect of reducing the quantum of the claim of depreciation and not for denying the same altogether.

An asset is depreciated for several factors and user is just one of them. Therefore, to deny the claim for depreciation simply for non user is otherwise not very appealing. The position at the most can be held to be debatable and where it is debatable, the view beneficial to the assessee should be adopted especially in interpreting the incentive provisions, like, depreciation.

The Supreme Court in the case of Kunhayammed & Ors. Vs State of Kerala & Anr. (245 ITR 360) while considering the jurisdiction of High Court in cases where a SLP on the same issue is dismissed by the Supreme court, observed as under:

  •     Where an appeal or revision is provided against an order passed by a Court, Tribunal or any other authority before superior forum and such superior forum modifies, reverses or affirms the decision put in issue before it, the decision by the subordinate forum merges in the decision by the superior forum and it is the latter which subsists, remains operative and is capable of enforcement in the eye of law;

  •     The jurisdiction conferred by Article 136 of the Constitution of India is divisible into two stages. First stage is upto the disposal of prayer for special leave to file an appeal. The second stage commences if and when the leave is granted and SLP is converted into an appeal;

  •     Doctrine of merger is not a doctrine of universal or unlimited application. It will depend on the nature of jurisdiction exercised by the superior forum and the content or subject-matter of challenge laid or capable of being laid, shall be determinative of the applicability of merger. The superior jurisdiction should be capable of reversing, modifying or affirming the order put in issue before it;   

  •     Under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, the Supreme Court may reverse, modify or af-firm the judgement, decree or order appealed against while exercising its appellate jurisdiction and not while exercising the discretionary jurisdiction disposing of petition for special leave to appeal. The doctrine for merger can, therefore, be applied to former and not to the latter;

  •     An order refusing special leave to appeal may be a non-speaking order or a speaking one. In either case, it does not attract doctrine of merger. An order refusing special leave to appeal does not stand substituted in place of the order under challenge. All that it means is, that the Court was not inclined to exercise its discretion so as to allow the appeal being filed;

  •     If the order refusing leave to appeal is a speaking order ie gives reasons for refusing the grant of leave, then the order has two implications:

–    Firstly, the statement of law contained in the order is a declaration of law by Supreme Court within the meaning of Article 141 of Constitution of India; and
–    Secondly, other than the declaration of law, whatever is stated in the order is a declaration of law by the Supreme
Court which would bind the parties thereto and also the Court, Tribunal or authority in any proceedings subsequent thereto by way of judicial discipline, the Supreme Court being the apex court of the country;
–    But this does not amount to saying that the order of Court, Tribunal or authority below has stood merged in the order of Supreme Court rejecting SLP or that the order of the Supreme Court is the only order binding as res judicata in subsequent proceedings between the parties.

Once an asset entered in to the block of assets, in view of the findings of the Delhi High Court in Oswal Agro Mills Ltd’s case (supra), the “user” shall be relevant only in the year of entry of asset into the block, because once it enters the block, it is neither possible nor necessary to consider whether each asset in the block has been used during the subsequent years.

REMEMBERING MAHATMA GANDHI

fiogf49gjkf0d
Generations to come, it may well be, will scarce believe that such a man as this one ever in flesh and blood walked upon this Earth. —Albert Einstein on Gandhiji’s
70th Birthday Every year, we remember Gandhiji for a day on 2nd October and then forget him for the rest of the year. We should never forget him even for a single day, but we rarely remember him. We know very little about one of the greatest persons whom we call “The Father of Nation”. It is time we know more about his work and his life. It is difficult for the present generation, which is leaderless, to understand how this frail man had the strength to shake the mighty British Empire, how he won our freedom with weapons of Love, Truth, and Nonviolence. It is difficult to envisage his tremendous influence over millions of our people, across the length and breadth of the country. He exercised influence without any authority.

“My life is my message” said Gandhiji.

In the days of our freedom struggle, thousands were arrested. A few of them asked for pardon and got out from jails. There were rumours about terrible tortures being inflicted on our freedom fighters. I had heard a rumour about Dr. Usha Mehta who was caught operating a secret radio station. Dr. Usha Mehta addressed our BCA Society Members, when she talked about this incident. “My mother was a follower of Mahatma Gandhi and was not very highly educated, approached the prison warden, and arranged to send a food parcel to me. In between chapattis, a note was smuggled giving a clear message. “Usha, it is rumoured that you are going to seek pardon of the British Govt. and get released. If ever you do so, never come back to our house again!” – This was the spirit instilled in millions of Indians by Gandhiji. I, Pradeep, have seen many people, who were ordinary persons like you and me who became heroes. They were prepared to sacrifice everything and did sacrifice everything for our country.

Gandhiji’s ability to touch the hearts of people did not end with Gandhiji’s demise. Recently we have the case of Laxman Gole, a young person who had 19 criminal cases pending against him. He changed completely by merely reading Gandhiji’s writings while in jail. He came up clean before the judges and confessed to his crimes. He dedicated himself to spreading Mahatma’s message amongst his fellow prisoners while in jail and later to the outside world. I do not know of any other person who after more than 50 years after his passing away – could influence and change the hearts of men – and change a Walia Robber to a Saint Valmiki.

 Some of us know of his work in India, but very little is known about his work in South Africa. Our knowledge is limited to the incident when he was thrown out of the train at Maritzburg Station. Little do we realise that that was the first event, in a struggle which went on for over 10 years! In fact, it was 13 years later, that this resulted into a mass nonviolence resistance against “The Black Act”. We all believe that he gave a legal practice which was quite small and insignificant. I was stunned to read this very recently that he had 30 juniors working under him and the practice in current rupee value was over 1.5 crores annually.

What should we do to remember Mahatma Gandhi? We must remember what Gandhiji said and act accordingly.

levitra

Accounting for fair value hedge s and hedge s of net in vestment in foreign operations

fiogf49gjkf0d
In our previous
article, we discussed the need for hedge accounting by companies as well
as the basic principles of hedge accounting and criteria required to
qualify for hedge accounting. We gave an example of a cash flow hedge of
a highly probable forecast purchase transaction and illustrated the
impact of hedge accounting on a companies’ profit or loss account
through the term of the hedging instrument. In this article, we shall
elucidate the accounting using fair value hedges and the hedge of a net
investment in a foreign operation and illustrate the accounting
treatment through examples.

Fair value hedges:

A fair value hedge is a
hedge of changes in the fair value of a recognised asset or liability,
an unrecognised firm commitment, or an identified portion of such an
asset, liability or firm commitment, that is attributable to a
particular risk and could affect profit or loss. The following are
examples of fair value hedges: a hedge of interest rate risk associated
with a fixed rate interest-bearing asset or liability (e.g. converting a
fixed rate instrument to a floating rate instrument using an interest
rate swap); a hedge of a firm commitment to purchase an asset or to
incur a liability; or a hedge of interest rate risk on a portfolio basis
(a portfolio fair value hedge).

Accounting for a fair value hedge:

  • l
    Hedging instruments that are derivatives – Fair value changes are
    recognised in the profit or loss account.
  •  Hedging instruments that are
    non derivatives – Foreign currency components of their carrying amounts
    measured in accordance with Ind-AS 21 are recognised in the profit or
    loss account.
  •  Hedged item otherwise measured at amortised cost (Eg.
    fixed rate borrowing) or through other comprehensive income (Eg.
    available for sale financial asset) – Adjustment to the carrying amount
    of the hedged item related to the hedged risk are recognised in the
    profit or loss account.
  • The categorisation of the fair value hedge
    adjustment as either a monetary or a non-monetary item, under Ind-AS 21,
    should be consistent with the categorisation of the hedged item under
    Ind-AS 21.
  •  In a fair value hedge, any ineffectiveness automatically is
    reported in profit or loss through the accounting process, unlike in a
    cash flow hedge, in which the ineffectiveness has to be calculated and
    recognised separately.

 If the fair value hedge is fully effective, the
gain or loss on the hedging instrument would fully offset the gain or
loss on the hedged item attributable to the risk being hedged.
Accordingly, there would be no net impact to the profit or loss account.

The qualifying criteria for hedge accounting remain the same across
types of hedges, i.e. cash flow hedges, fair value hedges or net
investment in foreign operation.

Let us look into fair value hedges in
more detail by way of the following example.

Example 1: Fair Value
Hedges

RV International Limited (RVIL) is a manufacturer with an Indian
Rupees (Rs.) functional currency with trade transactions with several
countries. The company has the maximum number of trade transactions with
companies in the United States of America. RVIL’s reporting dates are
30th September and 31st March.

On 15th July 20X1, RVIL enters into a
contract to sell its manufactured units to a company in the United
States. As per the contract, RVIL is committed to deliver 1,000 units at
a price of INRNaN per unit on 30th June 20X2. The contract contains
several specifications of the units to be delivered and also contains a
penalty clause that states that if RVIL fails to adhere to its time and
quality commitment, as per the specifications of the contracts, it shall
be liable to a penalty of INRNaN million. The invoice is payable on
31st August 20X2. RVIL expects that is shall incur costs of Rs. 67.5
million in manufacturing and packing the units. All such costs are
denominated in its functional currency, Rs.

On the date that RVIL enters
into the contract of sale, its management decides to hedge the
resulting foreign currency risk and enters into a forward contract to
sell INRNaN million against Rs. The terms of the sale transactions and
of the forward contract are as shown in Table 1 and Table 2

RVIL
accordingly adopts a risk management strategy to hedge its firm
commitment denominated in $ as a fair value hedge. The management of the
company designates the spot component of the forward contract as a
hedge of the change in the fair value of the contracted firm commitment
attributable to movements in spot rates. All critical terms of the
hedged item and hedging instruments match, on the date of inception –
15th July 20X1. The hedge is determined to be 100% effective on a
prospective basis considering that all the critical terms match. The
fair value of the forward contract (hedging instrument) is Nil as on the
date of inception. Fair value is calculated as the difference between
the discounted fair value of the forward contract at the forward rate on
inception (18,000,000 * 45.9420 * discount factor at 10.6500% = Rs.
749,959,475) with the discounted fair value of the forward contract on
testing date (18,000,000 *45.9420 * discount factor at 10.6500% = Rs.
749,959,475). On 30th September the fair value shall be Rs. 37,707,866
[(18,000,000 * discount factor at 10.8600 * (48.2040 – 45.9420)]. Hedge
accounting principles also require retrospective effectiveness testing
at each date which is determined to be 100% in this example for each
testing date.

In this example, the designated hedged risk is the spot
component i.e. hedge effectiveness is measured on the basis of changes
in spot component of the forward rates. The change in the fair value of
the derivative attributable to the forward points is excluded from the
hedge relationship. This forward points component does not therefore
give rise to any ineffectiveness. It is recognised in profit or loss as
‘other operating income and expense’. Alternatively, the forward points
can be recognised as ‘interest income and expense’.

Also important to
note is that in a fair value hedge, the full fair value of the hedging
instrument is recognised in the profit and loss account. Hence,
ineffectiveness is not measured separately. The journal entries for the
transaction are as shown in Table 3.

Hence the revenue is recognised, at
a net amount of Rs. 810,000,000, which is equivalent to the value at
the hedged rate i.e. the spot rate on the date of inception (18,000,000 *
45.000).

Net Investment in a Foreign Operation: Ind-AS 39 does
not override the principles of Ind- AS 21, but it does provide the hedge
accounting model for hedging an entity’s foreign exchange exposure
arising from net investments in foreign operations.

A net investment
hedge is a hedge of the foreign currency exposure, arising from a net
investment in a foreign operation, using a derivative and/or a
non-derivative monetary item as the hedging instrument.

The hedged risk is the foreign currency exposure arising from a net investment in a foreign operation when the net assets of that foreign operation are included in the financial statements. The application of hedge accounting for a net investment in foreign operation is relevant only for the consolidated financial statements of a group of companies.

Accounting for net investment hedges:

  •     If the hedging instrument in a net investment hedge is a derivative, then it is measured at fair value. The effective portion of the change in fair value of the hedging instrument is computed by reference to the functional currency of the parent entity against whose functional currency the hedged risk is measured.

  •     This effective portion is recognised in other comprehensive income and presented within equity in the foreign currency translation reserve. The ineffective portion of the gain or loss on the hedging instrument is immediately recognised in profit or loss.

  •     If the hedging instrument is a non-derivative, e.g. a foreign currency borrowing, then the effective portion of the foreign exchange gain or loss, arising on translation of the hedging instrument into the functional currency of the hedging entity, is recognised in Foreign Currency Translation Reserve.

  •     The effective portion is computed by reference to the functional currency of the parent entity, against whose functional currency the hedged risk is measured. Effectiveness is usually achieved if currency matches and notional amount of invest-ment is unlikely to go below notional amount of derivative, for e.g., due to losses incurred.

Hence, cumulative amounts are recognised in the other comprehensive income – changes on foreign currency translation of the foreign operation and effective portion of the gains or loss on the hedging instrument.

When a net investment in a foreign operation is disposed of, the cumulative amounts recognised previously in other comprehensive income, are re-classified to profit or loss. However, it is necessary for an entity to keep track of the amount recognised in other comprehensive income separately in respect of each foreign operation, in order to identify the amounts to be reclassified to profit or loss on disposal or partial disposal.


Let us look into net investment in foreign operations hedges in more detail by way of the following example.

Example 2: Hedges of net investment in a foreign operation


Company P is an Indian company with an Rs. functional currency. It has a subsidiary in the US, Company S, whose functional currency is $. The net investment of Company P in Company S is $ 10 million. The reporting dates of Company P for its consolidated financial statements are 30th September and 31st March. The group’s presentation currency is Rs.

On 1st April 20×1, Company P takes a two-year $ 10 million floating rate (Six month LIBOR) loan. Interest payment dates are 30th September and 31st March of the respective years. The loan matures on 31st March 20X3. It is assumed that no transaction costs are incurred relating to the loan issuance.

The management of Company P has decided to hedge its net investment in Company S by designating the $ denominated loan, in order to reduce the volatility in its consolidated balance sheet on account of foreign currency translation of its net investment in Company S. The net investment of Company P is not expected to fall below $ 10 million as company S is a profitable entity and has a profit forecast for future years as approved by the board of directors of Company P. However, on 30th September 20X2, the net investment of Company P in Company S decreases to $ 9.8 million on account of unexpected losses incurred by Company S.

As per hedge effectiveness testing, the hedge is 100% effective upto the time when losses are incurred by Company S which leads to a certain amount of ineffectiveness. Relevant details of the exchange and interest rates are as shown in Table 4 and Table 5 on page 90.

The journal entries for the transaction are as under:

At each period, following the process of consolidation of a foreign subsidiary’s net assets, Company P records a Foreign Currency Translation Reserve (FCTR) which is presented in Column C above. Journal entries relating to the loan are given in Table 6:



Section B: I. Scheme of amalgamation accounted as per Purchase Method Nagarjuna Fertilizers and Chemicals Ltd (31-3-2012)

fiogf49gjkf0d
From Notes to Financial Statements

1. CORPORATE OVERVIEW

a. Nagarjuna Fertilizers and Chemicals Limited (Erstwhile NFCL) has during the year undertaken restructuring of its businesses. Accordingly, a Composite Scheme of Arrangement and Amalgamation (“Scheme”) was prepared, which was duly consented by the shareholders at the Court Convened Meeting held on 15th April, 2011 and also received the approval of jurisdictional High Courts of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad and Bombay at Mumbai. The restructuring envisaged de-merger of the Oil business undertaking to a separate company, Nagarjuna Oil Refinery Limited (“NORL”). The scheme also provide for merger of residual business of Erstwhile NFCL into its wholly owned subsidiary viz., Kakinada Fertilizers Limited (“KFL”) along with the business operation of iKisan Limited (iKisan). The entire scheme is made effective from 30th July, 2011 but operative from 1st April, 2011, being the Appointed Date.

b. Pursuant to the Scheme:

 i. Oil Business Undertaking of erstwhile NFCL was demerged into NORL and residual NFCL and iKisan are merged in to KFL.

 ii. The Effective Date of the Scheme is 30th July, 2011 but shall be operative from the Appointed Date i.e. 1st April, 2011. The Record Date of determining shareholders eligible to receive shares of KFL and NORL was fixed as 1st September, 2011.

iii. Equity Shares were allotted to the shareholders of erstwhile NFCL and iKisan on 1st October, 2011 and the account of the respective of shares, the existing pre-arrangement issued capital of Rs. 5 lakh stood cancelled.

iv. The name of KFL stands changed to Nagarjuna Fertilizers and Chemicals Limited w.e.f. 19th August, 2011

 c. The Financial Statement for the year have been drawn-up incorporating necessary adjustments as envisaged in the Scheme and in compliance with purchase method of accounting under AS 14 (Accounting for Amalgamations). In accordance with the Scheme:

i. the assets and liabilities of residual business of erstwhile NFCL and iKisan have been recorded in the books of KFL at Fair Values as on 1st April, 2011

ii. the fair values were determined by the Board of Directors based on the report obtained from a reputed firm of valuers.

iii. the difference between the fair value of equity shares and face value of equity shares is considered as Securities Premium.

iv. the difference between the value of net assets transferred to KFL over the fair value of Equity shares, and Preference shares allotted is credited to Capital Reserve Account. shareholders were credited in electronic mode or share certificates issued, as the case may be. Consequent to the allotment

v. on and from effective date, the Authorised shares capital of NFCL stands increased to Rs.
801,00,00,000/- comprising of 621,00,00,000 equity shares of Rs. 1/- each and 2,00,00,000 preference shares of Rs. 90/- each.

vi. 59,80,65,003 equity shares of Rs. 1/- each aggregating to Rs. 59,80,65,003/- have been allotted to the shareholders of erstwhile NFCL and iKisan on 1st October, 2011 without payment being received in cash.

d. Amalgamation expenses incurred Rs. 500.16 lakh have been adjusted to capital reserve.

e. The Bombay Stock Exchange vide letter dated 14th December, 2011 approved the application of the company for listing of the equity shares and the National Stock Exchange vide letter dated 13th January, 2012 accorded in-principle approval for listing of the equity shares subject to relaxation by Securities and Exchange Board of India from the fulfilment of requirement under Rule 19(2)(b) of Securities Contracts (Regulation) Rules, 1957.

levitra

Use of PC in Bed & Sleep Disruption

fiogf49gjkf0d
In today’s gadget-obsessed world, sleep experts often say that for a better night’s rest, people should click the “off” buttons on their gadgets before tucking in for the night. Gizmos stimulate brain activity, they say, disrupting your ability to drift off to sleep. Increasingly, researchers are finding that artificial light from some devices at night may tinker with brain chemicals that promote sleep.

Researchers at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute showed that exposure to light from computer tablets significantly lowered levels of the hormone melatonin, which regulates our internal clocks and plays a role in the sleep cycle. In the study, published in the journal Applied Ergonomics, the researchers had volunteers read, play games and watch movies on an iPad, iPad 2 or PC tablet for various amounts of time while measuring the amount of light their eyes received.

They found that two hours of exposure to a bright tablet screen at night reduced melatonin levels by about 22%.

levitra

CENVAT Credit – Refund of service tax paid on input services – Export of software – Non taxable at the relevant point in time – Exporter entitled to refund of such unutilised CENVAT Credit on furnishing requisite documents – Registration is not a pre-requisite to claim CENVAT Credit in absence of any such statutory provisions.

fiogf49gjkf0d
3. 2012 (27) STR 134 (Kar) mPortal India Wireless Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. CST, Bangalore
    
CENVAT Credit – Refund of service tax paid on input services – Export of software – Non taxable at the relevant point in time – Exporter entitled to refund of such unutilised CENVAT Credit on furnishing requisite documents – Registration is not a pre-requisite to claim CENVAT Credit in absence of any such statutory provisions.

Facts:

The petitioner was an STPI unit engaged in development and export of software and a 100% export oriented unit. The Assistant Commissioner rejected the refund claim in absence of registration certificate and requisite documents as well as the reason of time bar and the order was upheld by the Commissioner. The Tribunal observed that the petitioner was entitled to the refund of CENVAT credit with respect to input services even when export of softwares was not liable to service tax and that limitation u/s. 11B of the Central Excise Act did not apply in this case. However, it upheld that the CENVAT Credit could be claimed only when the assessee was registered.

Held:

Bar of limitation was not the ground for rejection of refund claim of accumulated unutilised CENVAT Credit by an export of services. Further, there is no express provision providing restriction on availment of CENVAT Credit in case of unregistered assessees and therefore, it was held that registration is not a pre-requisite for claiming CENVAT Credit. The matter was remanded for verification of invoice/s/bill/s/challan/s, service tax payment etc.

levitra

OUR MOTTO FOR LIVING OTHERS

fiogf49gjkf0d
OUR MOTTO FOR LIVING
OTHERS

Lord, help me live from day to day
In such a self-forgetful way,
That even when I kneel to pray,
My prayer shall be for “Others”,

Help me in all the work I do
To ever be sincere and true,
And know, that all I do for you
Must needs be done for “Others”
And when my work on earth is done
And my new work in Heavens begun
May I forget the crown I’ve won,
While thinking still of “Others”
“Others, “ Lord, yes, “Others!”
Let this my motto be,
Help me to live for others
That I may live for Thee

P.C.
Your Guru desires that the above message may reach
all tax practitioners of Maharashtra. Please therefore pass on
the above message to your known Tax Practitioners.

From your Guru

On Teacher’s day 5th September 2012
levitra

Editor

fiogf49gjkf0d
Editor,

Re: Make Section 206AA inapplicable to Non Residents

After 8 years of inaction/ drift, a number of mega scams and countless reported incidents of corruption at high echelons of Indian polity, the Government has now woken up and has initiated steps to stimulate economic growth, encourage FDI and remove misapprehensions from minds of foreign investors caused by the policy paralysis and various retrospective amendments by the Finance Act, 2012.

At the ground level, one provision which greatly inconveniences and irks Non-Residents is Section 206AA inserted with effect from 01-04-2010, requiring every person to obtain and furnish his PAN Number to the payers or otherwise, be ready to suffer TDS @ 20% irrespective of the actual rate of TDS applicable to the transaction either under the Tax Treaty or under various provisions of Incometax Act applicable to Non Residents. One fails to understand the rationale of making this provision applicable to Non-Residents.

 The Non-Residents, particularly those who do not have frequent transactions with India, are very hesitant to obtain PAN. Further, the procedure for obtaining PAN is very cumbersome and time consuming. In most transactions, the Non-Resident wants payment net of tax and, therefore, the burden of paying the tax @ 20% falls on the Indian Resident and it works out to 25% due to the application of Grossing up provision u/s 195A.

The Government has all the Information online about the Non-Resident payees, as the payer has to upload full details about all remittances in Form 15CA before making any remittance overseas. If the resident payer makes any mistake in deducting TDS from any remittance to a Non-Resident, the payment is liable to be disallowed u/s 40(a)(i) besides other consequences by way of recovery of tax short deducted, interest and penalty.

How many advanced countries have such harsh provisions? The FM should consider consequences for Indian MNCs and others, if India’s trading partners were to introduce provisions similar to Section 206AA in their Tax Laws.

If the Finance Minister really wants to create a business / investor / tax payer friendly environment in India, he should make Section 206AA inapplicable to Non-Residents. Such an action would remove a massive irritant and also reduce the cost of doing business with Non Residents.

Yours sincerely,

Tarun Singhal.

levitra

India Inc braces for stricter bribery laws

fiogf49gjkf0d
India Inc is gearing up to face more stringent and specific anti-bribery laws with the government planning to amend the Indian Penal Code (IPC) to cover bribes given domestically by the private sector.

Once this comes into force, the employee concerned and also the company’s management could face imprisonment of upto seven years. It is likely that the proposed IPC amendment would be broad based and, in addition to bribes given to public officials, will also cover bribes within the private sector (such as company A, a supplier, bribing an official in company B to bag huge orders).

levitra

Nine of ten, unemployable – No movement yet on quality control in higher education

fiogf49gjkf0d
The state of professional higher education in India is abysmal. Consider engineering. All told, there are 1.5 million engineering seats in the country. Almost a third of these are unfilled, so about a million engineers are produced every year. Yet, barely 10 per cent of them are readily employable. About a quarter don’t know enough English to make sense of the curriculum. The tab for this monumental inefficiency is picked up by the companies that draw from this pool. Every year, they end up spending thousands of crores of rupees to retrain the fresh graduates and make them job-worthy. The situation is no better in business schools. Unlike engineering colleges, the rot has not been measured here. But it can’t be vastly different. People are, naturally, disillusioned: the number of students who appear in the entrance examinations for business schools has fallen steadily for three years. There are as many as 300,000 seats on offer; about one-third of this capacity is vacant. As a result, close to a hundred business schools have shut down in the last couple of years. More are bound to follow.

 All engineering colleges and stand-alone business schools are regulated by the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE). Business schools under universities are regulated by the University Grants Commission (UGC). The AICTE has thus far focused exclusively on fattening the supply pipe of engineers and MBAs. The logic is that India’s higher-education enrolment ratio is very low compared to other emerging countries; to improve that, the AICTE has been liberal with approvals. This strategy is turning counterproductive. The AICTE should now focus on the quality of education imparted.

Employers complain that the output of engineers and MBAs is poor because the teaching faculty is weak. Engineering colleges and business schools, in turn, say that’s because the salaries are regulated by the AICTE, which keeps them from hiring good teachers. While the norms for engineering colleges are fairly stringent (not less than 2.5 acres of land, at least one acre of land for every 300 students, working capital of at least Rs 1 crore and a studentteacher ratio of not more than 15), those for business schools are lax: 20,000 square feet of built-up area, seven faculty members, 20 computers, 2,000 books in the library and subscription to 30 journals. The lack of entry barriers has caused the glut and the consequent fall in quality. These are issues that the AICTE needs to address urgently.

The crucial reform this sector needs is more effective legislation. Legislative initiatives like the Higher Education and Research Bill, 2011, which seeks to replace the AICTE and the UGC with a commission responsible for ensuring quality, and the National Accreditation Regulatory Authority for Higher Educational Institutions Bill, 2010, which will make it mandatory for all institutes of higher education to be accredited by an independent agency, have not made much headway. Unfortunately, in another craven surrender to its allies, the government reportedly withdrew the latter Bill – two years after its introduction – on Tuesday, because the Trinamool Congress had objections. Surely these objections were not new? If so, why has the human resource development ministry waited for so long to review the Bill? Such lack of seriousness in reform will only worsen the sector’s crisis.

levitra

Readying quacks

fiogf49gjkf0d
Sometimes, the Indian state demonstrates a naive belief in numbers that obscures the real issues. Take healthcare; by the government’s own reckoning, the country’s doctor-patient ratio should be around 1:1,000. Currently, it is 1:2,000. That’s the kind of problem the government thinks it understands.

Health minister Ghulam Nabi Azad informed the Rajya Sabha about the steps taken to counter this situation. Among other things, the government has relaxed norms for establishing new medical colleges in terms of faculty, land and other infrastructure. It has also relaxed the student/teacher ratio in postgraduate classes and raised the intake capacity at the undergraduate level from 150 to 250. The result will be more doctors, but given the dilution on various counts, it could very well mean poor-quality ones. This is inadequate medicine for an already sick healthcare system.

levitra

Supreme Court on Sahara Matter – A Milestone Decision

fiogf49gjkf0d
It is a historic decision on several grounds – of the companies being asked to refund huge sums of money, of a pursuit by SEBI till the logical end despite numerous hurdles including inter-regulator conflicts, of certain important rulings on the point of law by the Supreme Court which involved, perhaps on facts, removal of several creases in various laws. It is worth knowing the entire sequence of facts, the issues involved and the orders passed. This article cannot obviously do justice to the 263 page Supreme Court order, but an attempt to highlight important issues has been made.

The matter, of course, is far more complex than being a linear sequence of orders and appeals. It had several detours to Allahabad and other courts but, in essence, it is sufficient to consider this series of orders only. The decision covers many important areas – powers of SEBI, what constitutes an issue to the public, the sanctity in law of Guidelines of SEBI and so on. Concerns have been expressed about the dubious role that the Registrar of Companies performed. The Supreme Court also appears to have endorsed the possibility of criminal action against the Saharas (the two Sahara group companies against whom the orders were passed). These and other issues may need separate analysis as to its scope and implications. Further, the progress of implementation of the order of the Supreme Court in terms of payment of refund monies into the designated bank, identification of the OFCDs holders, etc. will have to be seen. There are reports that the Saharas may pursue further litigation and hence, this matter may develop even further.

The essential facts – as stated in the decisions – are summarised in a simplified manner below. However, one preliminary thought comes to mind. The facts are quite glaring and extreme. The Saharas offered their Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures (“OFCDs”) to crores of people, hiring lakhs of agents through thousands of branches and raised tens of thousands of crores of rupees. And then they claimed, clearly on technical grounds, that there was no issue of securities to the public that would result in need for compliance of SEBI Regulations and other laws for disclosure, investor protection, etc. Further, they refused to provide information to SEBI and adopted delaying tactics. In the face of such facts, one even wonders whether the decision – which rejects every contention of the Saharas and even removes several creases and gaps in law in the process – could be interpreted to some extent as restricted to the facts of the case.

The Saharas, as the Supreme Court records, sought to raise funds through OFCDs. They filed/circulated an information memorandum/ Red Herring Prospectus with the Registrar of Companies, but no documents with SEBI. It took a view that issue of shares to a group of people – described in an extremely broad manner – did not amount to an issue to the public requiring compliance with the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, the SEBI Act and Regulations, etc. that dealt with public issues. The Saharas, however, appointed about 10,00,000 agents, opened 2900 branches and offered the OFCDs to crores of people, and issued the OFCDs to some 66 lakh people (it appears that the actual figures may be even higher).

Contrast this with the maximum limit of 49 offerees permitted u/s 67(3) of the Companies Act, 1956, beyond which the offer would become a public offer. When the Sahara Group filed an offer document through a merchant banker for a public issue of shares of another group company, SEBI, having come to know through this offer document of the earlier issues of OFCDs, made preliminary inquiries with the merchant banker. The merchant banker essentially replied, relying on legal opinions, that the earlier issues of OFCDs were in compliance of law but did not provide more details. When SEBI pursued the matter further with the Saharas, they insisted that SEBI had no jurisdiction and that they had complied with the law and would respond only to the Registrar of Companies. In what was seen to be further delaying tactic, they claimed that the issue as to whether they are liable to provide information to SEBI was pending determination before the Law Ministry and SEBI should wait till the matter was resolved. This resulted in gathering of information by SEBI from ROC documents and passing of certain orders by SEBI, petitions before the High Court, etc. and finally, the Order by SEBI which, alongwith the Order on appeal by SAT was upheld by the Supreme Court. Several issues were raised before the Supreme Court. The ruling of the Supreme Court and its implications would need a far more detailed analysis and at this stage, some of the important issues and rulings are highlighted below. Was the offer of OFCDs by the Saharas a “private placement” or an issue to the public? It was noted that the offer was made to “friends, associates, group companies, workers/ employees and other individuals associated/affiliated or connected in any manner with Sahara India Group of Companies”. These persons in reality turned out to be nearly 3 crore in number. When finally the details of the allottees were provided, the Supreme Court was dissatisfied with the details and noted that just the first page of the data was enough to cast doubts on the genuineness of the persons. An allottee was named merely “Kalavati” and the person introducing her was named “Haridwar”. No details were provided on how the allottees formed part of the group described above. The Court held that in view of the first proviso to section 67(3), offer to more than 49 persons would be deemed to be an offer to the public. The fact that the offer was clearly made to more than 49 persons attracted this provision. Apart from the offer to more than 49, another preceding condition, that the offer should have been made as a matter of domestic concern between the persons making and receiving the offer, was also not satisfied in view of the extremely broad description of the offerees. Further, since the OFCDs were transferable, yet another preceding condition – that the offer should not be calculated to be received by persons other than the offerees – was also not satisfied. Thus, the offer was clearly an offer to the public u/s. 67(3) of the Companies Act, 1956.

Whether the OFCDs which admittedly were “hybrids”, were securities and hence amenable to jurisdiction of SEBI? The Saharas contrasted the definition of securities under the SEBI Act/SCRA and the Companies Act, 1956 to submit that the term securities under the SEBI Act/SCRA did not cover hybrids while that under the Companies Act, 1956, covered it. Reliance was placed on the definition under the Companies Act, 1956, which reads:- “2(45AA) “securities” means securities as defined in clause (h) of section 2 of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (42 of 1956), and includes hybrids;” (emphasis supplied). Thus, it was argued by Saharas that since hybrids were specifically included as an addition, it showed that the basic definition of securities under SCRA could not have included hybrids. Thus, in short, the OFCDs, being hybrids, were governed only by the Companies Act, 1956, and SEBI – which derives jurisdiction under the SEBI Act/SCRA, could not govern issue of securities.

The Supreme Court first held that since u/s 55A, SEBI had powers to administer various specified provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, in matters of issue of securities and since securities specifically included hybrids, SEBI did have jurisdiction to that extent.

Then, the Supreme Court examined the definition of hybrid under the Companies Act, 1956, and noted that it covered any security that had the character of more than one type of security including their derivatives. The definition under SCRA defines securities inclusively and not exhaustively. Since, by definition, a hybrid is a “security”, it is covered by definition of “securities” under SCRA. Further, securities under SCRA included “other marketable securities of a like nature” and thus hybrids would once again be covered. It was particularly noted that the OFCDs were transferable, i.e., “marketable” as understood in this context.

Thus, hybrids were held to be securities under SCRA too and hence, SEBI was held to have jurisdiction over them.

It is submitted that this does not fully explain why the definition under the Companies Act, 1956, specifically included hybrids.

Whether the listing of OFCDs on stock exchanges was optional or mandatory?

The Saharas argued that u/s. 60B, there was a clear demarcation of listed and unlisted companies and unlisted companies were required to file the RHP only with the Registrar of Companies. The Saharas were neither listed nor intended to be listed. SEBI countered that section 73 clearly requires that a company seeking to offer securities to the public has to apply for listing to the stock exchanges.

The Supreme Court read section 60B and section 73 harmoniously and held that it was concluded by it earlier that the offer was indeed an offer to the public. In view of this, there was no option left in the manner of applying for listing. Listing was an inevitable consequence of such an offer and thus not optional but mandatory. Requirement of listing automatically brings in the jurisdiction of the SEBI, as it transforms a “public company” into a “listed public company” and thus covered by section 60B too.

Whether Section 55A gave powers to SEBI to administer specific provisions on unlisted companies that did not intend to get their securities listed?

Section 55A gives powers to SEBI to administer certain provisions in case of listed companies and unlisted companies that intended to get their securities listed on the recognised stock exchanges. The Saharas were neither listed nor, they claimed, they intended to get listed. This was even clearly specified in various documents.

The Supreme Court held that the intention could not be grasped and determined out of context of the actions of the Saharas. The Saharas did make an issue to the public. Such a public issue necessarily resulted in their being mandatorily required to get such securities listed. Thus, there is a deemed intention, since they could not carry out acts which require listing and then claim that they do not intend to list their securities.

Even otherwise, the Supreme Court held, section 11 of the SEBI Act was wide enough to give powers to SEBI to protect the interest of investors in securities and to regulate the securities markets by such measures as it thinks fit. This is wide enough to give powers to SEBI under the present facts. Later provisions of the Act do state that SEBI has certain powers over “other persons associated with the securities markets” and public companies, which intend to get their securities listed on the recognised stock exchanges. Even if these are taken to be restrictions for those sections and purposes, they do not apply to the former provisions. Thus, SEBI has adequate powers to govern the unlisted Saharas.

Furthermore, section 11A is even more specific in matters of issue of prospectus, etc. Sections 11B/11C reinforce this conclusion that SEBI has powers to govern listed and unlisted companies. Being a stand alone statute, the SEBI Act cannot be limited even by the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956.

Thus, SEBI had the jurisdiction to regulate and administer the unlisted Saharas.

Whether the SEBI DIP Guidelines had statutory force or were mere “departmental instructions”?

The Supreme Court held that the DIP Guidelines did have “statutory force” and that the OFCDs were issued in contravention of the DIP Guidelines as also of the SEBI ICDR Regulations that succeeded them.

Whether there was a pre-planned attempt by the Saharas to bypass the regulatory and administrative authority of SEBI in respect of issue of OFCDs?

It was pointed out by SEBI that the Saharas had modified the explicit format of declaration required to be given in the prescribed format. The prescribed format required the companies issuing a prospectus to state, inter alia, that the guidelines of SEBI have been complied with and no statement is made contrary to the provisions of the SEBI Act or rules made thereunder or guidelines issued thereunder. The Saharas omitted these declarations. There was further attempt to misguide by stating that the offer was by way of private placement when the invitation was extended to approximately three crore persons. The Supreme Court said that it cer-tainly seemed so that there was a pre-planned intention to bypass the regulatory and administrative authority of SEBI.

The manner of issuing the information memorandum/RHP showed that the procedure adopted was “obviously topsy-turvy and contrary to the recognised norms in company affairs”. All this made, the Supreme Court said, the entire approach of the Saharas “calculated and crafty”.

Their repeated refusals to share information and their non-cooperation, the unrealistic and possibly fictitious information provided and other similar factors made the Supreme Court to also state that the whole affair was “doubtful, dubious and questionable”.

Accordingly, the Supreme Court upheld the proceedings initiated by SEBI and the Orders of SEBI and SAT. It upheld the Order of SAT for refund of the amounts collected by issue of OFCDs alongwith interest @ 15% per annum. A mechanism was laid down to ensure this including deposit of the amounts with a nationalised bank, appointment of a retired Judge of the Supreme Court to oversee the process and several other directions for safeguarding various interests.

PART A : JUDGMENT OF THE SUPREME COURT

fiogf49gjkf0d
RTI operation being annihilated: On 13th September, 2012, the Supreme Court of India (SC) delivered a judgment which, though a landmark on the subject of RTI, has nearly stopped the operation of RTI at various Commissions. It is a judgment running into 107 para. First, nearly 50 pages analyse the RTI Act. Some of the paragraphs/ sentences therein are:

  •  The value of any freedom is determined by the extent to which the citizens are able to enjoy such freedom. Ours is a constitutional democracy and it is axiomatic that citizens have the right to know about the affairs of the Government which, having been elected by them, seeks to formulate some policies of governance aimed at their welfare. However, like any other freedom, this freedom also has limitations. It is a settled proposition that the Right to Freedom of Speech and Expression enshrined under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India (for short ‘the Constitution’) encompasses the right to impart and receive information. The Right to Information has been stated to be one of the important facets of proper governance. With the passage of time, this concept has not only developed in the field of law, but also has attained new dimensions in its application. The legal principle of ‘A man’s house is his castle. The midnight knock by the police bully breaking into the peace of citizen’s home is outrageous in law’, stated by Edward Coke has been explained by Justice Douglas as follows: “The free State offers what a police state denies- the privacy of the home, the dignity and peace of mind of the individual. That precious right to be left alone is violated once the police enter our conversations.”
  •  The foundation of the power of judicial review, as explained by a nine-judge’s Bench in the case of Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association & Ors vs Union of India [(1993) 4 SCC 441], is the theory that the Constitution which is the fundamental law of the land, is the ‘will’ of the ‘people’, while a statute is only the creation of the elected representatives of the people; when, therefore, the ‘will’ of the legislature as declared in the statute, stands in opposition to that of the people as declared in the Constitution – the ‘will’ of the people must prevail. It is the Constitution which is Supreme in India and not the Parliament.
  •  Certain principles have often been reiterated by this Court, while dealing with the constitutionality of a provision or a statute. Even in the case of Atam Prakash v. State of Haryana & Ors. [(1986) 2 SCC 249] the Court stated that whether it is the Constitution that is expounded or the constitutional validity of the constitution as a statute that is considered, a cardinal rule is to look to the preamble of the guiding light and to the Directive Principles of State Policy as the Book of Interpretation. The Constitution being sui generis, these are the factors of distant vision that help in the determination of the constitutional issues.
  •  The freedom of speech is the lifeblood of democracy. It is a safely valve. ? Justice V R Krishna Iyer in his book “Freedom of Information” expressed the view: “The right to information is a right incidental to the constitutionally guaranteed right to freedom of speech and expression. The international movement to include it in the legal system gained prominence in 1946 with General Assembly of the United Nations declaring freedom of information to be a fundamental human right and a touchstone for all other liberties. Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights says:

“Everyone has the right to freedom of information and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.” It may be a coincidence that Article 19 of the Indian Constitution also provides every citizen the right to freedom of speech and expression. However, the word ‘information’ is conspicuously absent. But, as the highest Court has explicated, the right of information is integral to freedom of expression. The Court then dealt with scheme of the Act of 2005 (comparative Analysis of Act of 2002 and Act of 2005) To restrict the length of the Article, though very interesting, the same is not being reported here.

 The Court then dealt with the writ matter of validity of the provisions under the RTI Act pertaining to appointment of the Central Information Commissioners (section 12) and of the State Information Commissioners (section 15).

“In order to examine the constitutionality of these provisions, let us state the parameters which would finally help the Court in determining such questions”.

The Court stated:

“The Courts would preferably put into service the principle of ‘reading down’ or ensure the attainment of the object of the Act. These are the principles which clearly emerge from the consistent view taken by this Court in its various pronouncements.”

Four issues framed by the supreme court in para 44 were as under:

  •  To examine the constitutionality of sections 12 and 15 of the RTI Act, the Supreme Court framed the following issues, viz.,

 a. Whether the law under challenge lacks legislative competence?

 b. Whether it violates any Article of Part III of the Constitution, particularly Article 14?

 c. Whether the prescribed criteria and classification resulting therefrom is discriminatory, arbitrary and has no nexus to the object of the Act? and

d. Whether a legislative exercise of power which is not in consonance with the constitutional guarantees and does not provide adequate guidance makes the law just, fair and reasonable?

  • The Supreme Court then dwelt upon determination of the nature of Tribunals, Commissions and their functions in India and referred to the scenario prevalent in some other jurisdictions of the world.
  •  The Supreme Court after analysing the scheme of the RTI Act discussed at length, the kind of duties and responsibilities that the Central Information Commissioner and the State Information Commissioners and other Information Commissioners are expected to perform, and the multifarious functions that the Information Commission is expected to discharge in its functioning, and observed as under:-

“Besides separation of powers, the independence of judiciary is of fundamental constitutional value in the structure of our Constitution. Impartiality, independence, fairness and reasonableness in judicial decision making are the hallmarks of the Judiciary. If ‘Impartiality’ is the soul of Judiciary, `Independence’ is the life blood of Judiciary. Without independence, impartiality cannot thrive, as this Court stated in the case of Union of India v. R. Gandhi, President, Madras Bar Association {(2010) 11 SCC 17}”

“The above detailed analysis leads to an ad libitum conclusion that under the provisions and scheme of the Act of 2005, the persons eligible for appointment should be of public eminence, with knowledge and experience in the specified fields and should preferably have a judicial background. They should possess judicial acumen and experience to fairly and effectively deal with the intricate questions of law that would come up for determination before the Commission, in its day-to-day working. The Commission satisfies abecedarians of a judicial tribunal which has the trappings of a court. It will serve the ends of justice better, if the Information Commission was manned by persons of legal expertise and with adequate experience in the field of adjudication. We may further clarify that such judicial members could work individually or in Benches of two, one being a judicial member while the other being a qualified person from the specified fields to be called an expert member. Thus, in order to satisfy the test of constitutionality, we will have to read into section 12(5) of the Act that the expression ‘knowledge and experience’ includes basic degree in that field and experience gained thereafter and secondly that legally qualified, trained and experienced persons would better administer justice to the people, particularly when they are expected to undertake an adjudicatory process which involves critical legal questions and niceties of law. Such appreciation and application of legal principles is a sine qua non to the determinative functioning of the Commission as it can tilt the balance of justice either way. Malcolm Gladwell said, “the key to good decision making is not knowledge. It is understanding. We are swimming in the former. We are lacking in the latter”. The requirement of a judicial mind for manning the judicial tribunal is a well accepted discipline in all the major international jurisdictions with hardly any exceptions. Even if the intention is to not only appoint people with judicial background and expertise, then the most suitable and practical resolution would be that a ‘judicial member’ and an ‘expert member’ from other specified fields should constitute a Bench and perform the functions in accordance with the provisions of the Act of 2005. Such an approach would further the mandate of the statute by resolving the legal issues as well as other serious issues like an inbuilt conflict between the Right to Privacy and Right to Information while applying the balancing principle and other incidental controversies. We would clarify that participation by qualified persons from other specified fields would be a positive contribution in attainment of the proper administration of justice as well as the object of the Act of 2005. Such an approach would help to withstand the challenge to the constitutionality of section 12(5)”

“As a natural sequel to the above, the question that comes up for consideration is as to what procedure should be adopted to make appointments to this august body. Section 12(3) states about the High-powered Committee, which has to recommend the names for appointment to the post of Chief Information Commissioner and Information Commissioners to the President. However, this section, and any other provision for that matter, is entirely silent as to what procedure for appointment should be followed by this High Powered Committee. Once we have held that it is a judicial tribunal having the essential trappings of a court, then it must, as an irresistible corollary, follow that the appointments to this august body are made in consultation with the judiciary. In the event, the Government is of the opinion and desires to appoint not only judicial members but also experts from other fields to the Commission in terms of section 12(5) of the Act of 2005, then it may do so, however, subject to the riders stated in this judgment. To ensure judicial independence, effective adjudicatory process and public confidence in the administration of justice by the Commission, it would be necessary that the Commission is required to work in Benches. The Bench should consist of one judicial member and the other member from the specified fields in terms of section 12(5) of the Act of 2005. It will be incumbent and in conformity with the scheme of the Act that the appointments to the post of judicial member are made ‘in consultation’ with the Chief Justice of India in case of Chief Information Commissioner and members of the Central Information Commission and the Chief Justices of the High Courts of the respective States, in case of the State Chief Information Commissioner and State Information Commissioners of that State Commission. In the case of appointment of members to the respective Commissions from other specified fields, the DoPT in the Centre and the concerned Ministry in the States should prepare a panel, after due publicity, empanelling the names proposed at least three times the number of vacancies existing in the Commission. Such panel should be prepared on a rational basis, and should inevitably form part of the records. The names so empanelled, with the relevant record, should be placed before the said High Powered Committee. In furtherance to the recommendations of the High Powered Committee, appointments to the Central and State Information Commissions should be made by the competent authority. Empanelment by the DoPT and other competent authority has to be carried on the basis of a rational criteria, which should be duly reflected by recording of appropriate reasons. The advertisement issued by such agency should not be restricted to any particular class of persons stated u/s. 12(5), but must cover persons from all fields. Complete information, material and comparative data of the empanelled persons should be made available to the High Powered Committee. Needless to mention that the High Powered Committee itself has to adopt a fair and transparent process for consideration of the empanelled persons for its final recommendation.

This approach is in no way innovative but is merely derivative of the mandate and procedure stated by this Court in the case of L. Chandra Kumar (supra) wherein the Court dealt with similar issues with regard to constitution of the Central Administrative Tribunal. All concerned are expected to keep in mind that the Institution is more important than an individual. Thus, all must do what is expected to be done in the interest of the institution and enhancing the public confidence. A three Judge Bench of this Court in the case of Centre for PIL and Anr. v. Union of India & Anr. [(2011) 4 SCC 1] had also adopted a similar approach and with respect we reiterate the same.

Giving effect to the above scheme would not only further the cause of the Act but would attain greater efficiency, and accuracy in the decision-making process, which in turn would serve the larger public purpose. It shall also ensure greater and more effective access to information, which would result in making the invocation of right to information more objective and meaningful.

For the elaborate discussion and reasons afore-recorded, we pass the following order and directions:

1.    The writ petition is partly allowed.

2.    The provisions of sections 12(5) and 15(5) of the Act of 2005 are held to be constitutionally valid, but with the rider that, to give it a meaningful and purposive interpretation, it is necessary for the Court to ‘read into’ these provisions some aspects without which these provisions are bound to offend the doctrine of equality. Thus, we hold and declare that the expression ‘knowledge and experience’ appearing in these provisions would mean and include a basic degree in the respective field and the experience gained thereafter. Further, without any peradventure and veritably, we state that appointments of legally qualified, judicially trained and experienced persons would certainly manifest in more effective serving of the ends of justice as well as ensuring better administration of justice by the Commission. It would render the adjudicatory process which involves critical legal questions and nuances of law, more adherent to justice and shall enhance the public confidence in the working of the Commission. This is the obvious interpretation of the language of these provisions and, in fact, is the essence thereof.

3.    As opposed to declaring the provisions of section 12(6) and 15(6) unconstitutional, we would prefer to read these provisions as having effect ‘post-appointment’. In other words, cessation/termination of holding of office of profit, pursuing any profession or carrying any business is a condition precedent to the appointment of a person as Chief Information Commissioner or Information Commissioner at the Centre or State levels.

4.    There is an absolute necessity for the legislature to reword or amend the provisions of section 12(5), 12(6) and 15(5), 15(6) of the Act. We observe and hope that these provisions would be amended at the earliest by the legislature to avoid any ambiguity or impracticability and to make it in consonance with the constitutional mandates.

5.    We also direct that the Central Government and/ or the competent authority shall frame all practice and procedure related rules to make working of the Information Commissions effective and in consonance with the basic rule of law. Such rules should be framed with particular reference to section 27 and 28 of the Act within a period of six months from today.

6.    We are of the considered view that it is an unquestionable proposition of law that the Commission is a ‘judicial tribunal’ performing functions of ‘judicial’ as well as ‘quasijudicial’ nature and having the trappings of a Court. It is an important cog and is part of the court attached system of administration of justice, unlike a ministerial tribunal, which is more influenced and controlled and performs functions akin to the machinery of administration.

7.    It will be just, fair and proper that the first appellate authority (i.e. the senior officers to be nominated in terms of section 5 of the Act of 2005) preferably should be the persons possessing a degree in law or having adequate knowledge and experience in the field of law.

8.    The Information Commissions at the respective levels shall henceforth work in Benches of two members each. One of them being a ‘judicial member’, while the other an ‘expert member’. The judicial member should be a person possessing a degree in law, having a judicially trained mind and experience in performing judicial functions. A law officer or a lawyer may also be eligible, provided he is a person who has practiced law at least for a period of twenty years as on the date of the advertisement. Such lawyer should also have experience in social work. We are of the considered view that the competent authority should prefer a person who is or has been a Judge of the High Court for appointment as Information Commissioners. Chief Information Commissioner at the Centre or State level shall only be a person who is or has been a Chief Justice of the High Court or a Judge of the Supreme Court of India.

9.    The appointment of the judicial members to any of these posts shall be made ‘in consultation’ with the Chief Justice of India and Chief Justices of the High Courts of the respective States, as the case may be.

10.    The appointment of the Information Commissioners at both levels should be made from amongst the persons empanelled by the DoPT in the case of Centre and the concerned Ministry in the case of a State. The panel has to be prepared upon due advertisement and on a rational basis as afore-recorded.

11.    The panel so prepared by the DoPT or the concerned Ministry ought to be placed before the High-powered Committee in terms of section 12(3), for final recommendation to the President of India. Needless to repeat that the High Powered Committee at the Centre and the State levels is expected to adopt a fair and transparent method of recommending the names for appointment to the competent authority.

12.    The selection process should be commenced at least three months prior to the occurrence of vacancy.

13.    This judgment shall have effect only prospectively.

14.    Under the scheme of the Act of 2005, it is clear that the orders of the Commissions are subject to judicial review before the High Court and then before the Supreme Court of India. In terms of Article 141 of the Constitution, the judgments of the Supreme Court are law of the land and are binding on all courts and tribunals. Thus, it is abundantly clear that the Information Commission is bound by the law of precedence, i.e., judgments of the High Court and the Supreme Court of India. In order to maintain judicial discipline and consistency in the functioning of the Commission, we direct that the Commission shall give appropriate attention to the doctrine of precedence and shall not overlook the judgments of the courts dealing with the subject and principles applicable, in a given case. It is not only the higher court’s judgments that are binding precedents for the Information Commission, but even those of the larger Benches of the Commission should be given due acceptance and enforcement by the smaller Benches of the Commission. The rule of precedence is equally applicable to intra appeals or references in the hierarchy of the Commission.

The writ petition is partly allowed with the above directions, however, without any order as to costs. [writ & petition (CIVIL) No. 210 of 2012 in the matter of Namit Sharma vs Union of India decided on 13.09.2012. The judgment was dictated by Swatanter Kumar and the other judge was A. K. Patnaik.]

Repayment of Deposits

fiogf49gjkf0d
Introduction

One of the most important and easy sources of raising funds for companies and non-banking financial companies has been public deposits. As per statistics from the RBI, as on March 2010, the aggregate public deposits of the NBFC sector were Rs. 17,247 crore. Add to this the amount raised by companies as public deposits u/s. 58A of the Companies Act, 1956, deposits being accepted by unincorporated entities, and you would have an amount which would be mind boggling. However, since it is very easy to raise these deposits, a very large number of cases of defaults and frauds are also associated with public deposits. Various Central and State Legislations have been enacted to curb the default in repayment of deposits. Some of these Legislations appear to be entrenching each other’s territories and hence, have invited close scrutiny from the Supreme Court and various High Courts. The Supreme Court’s decision in the case of Sahara India Real Estate Corp. v SEBI, C.A. No. 9813 of 2011, Order Dated 31st August, 2012, is an example of Courts taking the matter of investor repayment very seriously. Although that case was not in relation to public deposits, it does show us the importance the Courts place on these matters. Let us look at some of the important and controversial issues connected with repayment of deposits which the Courts have had an occasion to consider.

Laws Governing Raising of Deposits by Companies

 Deposits generally mean any deposit of money with a company, subject to exclusions mentioned expressly. What does and does not constitute a deposit can be a subject matter of discussion by itself. However, it would suffice to say that the scope of the term is very large. Deposits can be raised by two types of companies:

(a) Non-banking Financial Companies; and

(b) Companies other than NBFCs

Anup P. Shah Chartered Accountant laws and Business The raising of deposits by NBFCs is governed by Chapter III B of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 (“the RBI Act”). Pursuant to this Act, the RBI has notified the Non-Banking Financial Companies Acceptance of Public Deposits (Reserve Bank) Directions, 1998; Residuary Non-Banking Companies (Reserve Bank) Directions, 1987 and the Miscellaneous Non-Banking Companies (Reserve Bank) Directions, 1977.

 In the case of Companies which are not NBFCs (also known as NBNFCs), the raising of public deposits is governed by s/s. 58A to 58AAA of the Companies Act,1956 read with the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 1975. These Laws lay down the meaning of the term deposit as well as various conditions subject to which public deposits can be raised by companies or NBFCs.

Repayment of Deposits by NBFCs S/s.

 45Q and 45QQA of the RBI Act provide that every deposit accepted by a NBFC shall be repaid in accordance with the terms and conditions of the deposit. In case the NBFC fails to so repay the deposit, then the Company Law Board is empowered, either suo moto or an application, to order repayment or reschedule the terms and conditions of repayment. The provisions of these sections override all other laws. In case the NBFC fails to comply with the CLB’s Order, then the RBI can launch prosecution in respect of the same. Any person in default is liable to be punished with imprisonment for a term of up to three years and a fine of at least Rs. 50 for every day of noncompliance.

In the case of Piyush Rastogi v Moulik Finance and Resorts Ltd., 88 SCL 104 (All), it was held that RBI had power, jurisdiction and authority to file a criminal complaint against default/contravention made in respect of deposits’ repayment by the company and its directors and, therefore, submission of petitioner that initiation of criminal proceedings was illegal and without any jurisdiction was wholly erroneous. In the case of RBI v Integrated Finance Co. Ltd., 145 Comp. Cases 87 (Mad), the Court held that the repayment of a deposit contemplated under the RBI Act was repayment in cash and not in kind. It further held that the jurisdiction of the CLB to order repayment could not be usurped by any other Court. The CLB has held that there are no fetters on the powers of CLB under the RBI Act and in a particular case, the CLB may order repayment of deposits in modification of the parameters fixed by the RBI – B. Bharathi v Rockland Leasing Ltd., 95 Comp. Cases 471 (CLB).

Repayment by Other Companies

If a company, other than an NBFC, accepts deposits in violation of the Companies (Acceptance of Deposits) Rules, 1975 made u/s. 58A of the Companies Act, 1956, then the same shall be repaid within 30 days. The CLB may, u/s. 58A(9) order the repayment or rescheduling of the repayment of the deposits by companies other than NBFCs. Failure to comply with the CLB’s order may result in an imprisonment of three years and a fine of at least Rs. 500 for every day of non-compliance. Further, in case of defaults in repayment of deposits of small depositors (deposit of Rs. 20,000 or less in a financial year), the company is required to intimate the CLB. The validity of section 58A has been upheld by the Supreme Court in the case of Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co Ltd v UOI, (1983) 4 SCC 166.

Deposits by Individuals, Firms, AOP
s

The RBI Act prohibits any individual, firm, AOP, etc., from accepting deposits if that person’s business is that of financing/non-banking financial activities/ receiving deposits/any lending, etc. However, loans raised from certain relatives, partner’s capital, etc., are allowed. The penalty for violation of this provision is punishable with imprisonment for a term of upto two years and/or with a fine higher than Rs. 2,000 or upto twice the deposit received by that person.

The validity of these provisions has been upheld in Kanta Mehta v UOI, 62 Comp. Cases 769 (Delhi) which was affirmed by the Supreme Court in T. Velayudhan Achari v UOI, (1993) 2 SCC 582. The Supreme Court has also held that the provisions of this section are applicable to money-lenders, being individuals/firms, registered under State Moneylending Acts, e.g., the Bombay Money-lending Act, 1946 and the State Laws cannot override the RBI Act – Kerala Small Financiers’ Association v UOI, 116 Comp. Cases 641 (SC). Very recently, the RBI has clamped down on certain sole proprietary firms of the promoters of some large NBFCs, which were raising deposits in violation of this provision.

Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (in Financial Establishments) Act, 1999 (MPID Act)

 In addition to the above two Central Acts, various States, such as, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Bihar, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, etc., have enacted Depositor Protection Acts. One such Act is the MPID Act of 1999 applicable in the State of Maharashtra. MPID is an Act to protect the interest of depositors of Financial Establishments and applies to “deposits” raised by a Financial Establishment. Section 014 of this Act provides that this Act overrides all other laws. Section 2(c) of the MPID Act defines the expression “deposit” to include any receipt of money or acceptance of any valuable commodity by any Financial Establishment to be returned after a specified period or otherwise, either in cash or in kind or in the form of a specified service with or without any benefit in the form of interest, bonus, profit or in any other form. Thus, the definition of the term is much wider than the definition found under the Companies Act or the RBI Act. The definition expressly excludes the following:

(i) Amounts raised by way of share capital, debenture, bond, other instruments in accordance with SEBI Regulations. Thus, the public issue of securities is excluded.

(ii) Partners’ capital in a firm.

(iii) Amounts received from a bank.

(iv)    Any amount received from specified Public Financial Institutions.

(v)    Amounts received in the ordinary course of business by way of, –
(a)    security deposit,
(b)    dealership deposit,
(c)    earnest money,
(d)    advance against order for goods or services;

(vi)    Any amount received from an individual or a firm or an association of individuals not being a body corporate, registered under any enactment relating to money lending which is for the time being in force in the State. Thus, money received from a money-lender registered under the Bombay Money-lending Act, 1946 is not a deposit.

(vii)    Any amount received by way of subscriptions in respect of a Chit.

A    “Financial Establishment” is defined to mean any person accepting deposit under any scheme or arrangement or in any other manner. It does not include a Government company or a bank. The term is very wide and covers within its purview, individuals, firms, NBFCs, companies, etc., which receive deposits.

Section 3 of the MPID Act provides that if any Financial Establishment fraudulently defaults in repayment of a deposit on maturity, then every person, including the promoter, partner, director, any other person, employee, etc., responsible for the management or conducting the business/affairs of the Financial Establishment shall be punished. The penalty is a term of upto six years and fine of upto Rs. 1 lakh. In addition, the Financial Establishment shall be liable for a fine of up to Rs. 1 lakh. The provisions of the MPID Act do not overrule the Criminal Procedure Code and all provisions of arrest, bail, etc., provided in the Code would have to be followed – Uday Mohanlal Acharya v State, (2001) 5 SCC 453.

Section 4 provides an additional recourse to the aggrieved depositor. If the State Government is satisfied that there is a default, it may order attachment of the Financial Establishment’s properties. Only property belonging to the defaulter can be attached. Property taken onleave and licence by the defaulter is not his property and cannot be attached – Chimanlal Modi v State, 2004 (2) Bom. CR. (Cri) 866.

Validity of State Depositor Protection Acts

The validity of the MPID and other similar State Depositor Protection Acts have been the subject matter of great debate. The moot point has been that, when there are Central Statutes in the form of the Companies Act and the RBI Act, how can a State Statute legislate on the very same issue? A Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Vijay C Puljal v State, 128 Comp. Cases 196 (Bom) (FB), had an occasion to consider this issue in detail. Striking down the validity of the MPID Act as being ultra vires, the Bombay High Court held as follows:

(i)    The constitutional validity of s. 58A of the Companies Act, 1956 has been upheld by the Supreme Court. It has also held that the Parliament has legislative competence to enact Sections 58A, 58AA and 58AAA of the Companies Act, 1956.

(ii)    The validity of the provisions of the RBI Act and the legislative competence of Parliament to enact Chapter III-C of this Act were upheld by the Supreme Court.

(iv)    The legislation enacted by the MPID Act directly conflicted with the provisions contained in the Central Legislation. The MPID Act has created an offence in respect of the same subject matter by providing different punishments;

(v)    The law enacted by the MPID Act is, in pith and substance, referable to legislative heads contained in the Central Acts. Hence, the State Legislature has enacted a law which it was not competent to enact.

However, the Supreme Court in the case of K.K. Baskaran v State, (2011) 3 SCC 793 has overruled the aforesaid Bombay High Court decision. Although this was a case in relation to the Tamil Nadu Depositors Act, the Supreme Court expressly overruled the decision in the case of Vijay Puljal. The Madras High Court had upheld the validity of the TN Act, and the case before the Supreme Court was in challenge to this Order. The Apex Court took a socialistic view of the situation and upheld all Depositor Protection Acts. Some excerpts from its judgment are as follows:

“18. Learned counsel for the appellant relied on the Full Bench decision of the Bombay High Court in Vijay C. Punjal’s case (supra) in support of his contention that the Tamil Nadu Act, like the Maharasthra Act, was unconstitutional being beyond the legislative competence of the State Legislature. We do not agree.

19.    We have carefully perused the judgment of the Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in Vijay’s case (supra) and we respectfully disagree with the view taken by the Bombay High Court.

……………..

22.    We are of the opinion that the impugned Tamil Nadu Act enacted by the State Legislature is not in pith and substance referable to the legislative heads contained in List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution though there may be some overlapping. In our opinion, in pith and substance the said Act comes under the entries in List II (the State List) of the Seventh Schedule.

23.    It often happens that a legislation overlaps both Lists I as well as List II of the Seventh Schedule. In such circumstances, the doctrine of pith and substance is applied. We are of the opinion that in pith and substance the impugned State Act is referable to Entries 1, 30 and 31 of List II of the Seventh Schedule and not Entries 43, 44 and 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule.

24.    It is well-settled that incidental trenching in exercise of ancillary powers into a forbidden legislative territory is permissible.

…………

38.    The Court should interpret the constitutional provisions against the social setting of the country and not in the abstract. The Court must take into consideration the economic realities and aspirations of the people and must further the social interest which is the purpose of legislation.

…………….

39.    We fail to see how there is any violation of Article 14, 19(1)(g) or 21 of the Constitution. The Act is a salutary measure to remedy a great social evil. A systematic conspiracy was effected by certain fraudulent financial establishments which not only committed fraud on the depositor, but also siphoned off or diverted the depositor’s funds mala fide.

……………..

44.    We are of the opinion that there is no merit in this petition. The impugned Tamil Nadu Act is constitutionally valid. In fact, it is a salutary mea-sure which was long overdue to deal with these scamsters who have been thriving like locusts in the country.”

Directors’ Duty

Directors of a company/entity accepting public deposits should be extra cautious, because the consequences are quite stringent in nature. In case of any doubt over whether the company is in violation of any Central/State Deposit Law, they should immediately obtain expert advice. Courts, generally, have a sympathetic attitude towards depositors and hence, deposit acceptors should be wary of any non-compliance on their part. The old adage of “better safe than sorry” would work best and hence, they should consider setting a system of checks and balances in place beforehand.

Courts and arbitrators may take their time, but grumbling is prohibited

fiogf49gjkf0d
Litigants and society in general have become inured to long delays in courts. Decades-old cases no longer shock anyone. Like climate change, the deceleration of the wheels of justice is hardly discernible to the naked eye.

The Supreme Court stated that 37 years of prosecution is not sufficient in itself to conclude that the accused people have been deprived of their fundamental right to speedy trial.

If this is so in criminal cases, the record of civil courts is worse. Property and partition suits take a lifetime of visiting the courts. In a judgment delivered by the Delhi High Court last week, delays in arbitration was the main argument for quashing the award (Oil India Ltd vs Essar Oil Ltd).

The Supreme Court has dealt with this problem in one of the leading cases, ONGC vs Saw Pipes Ltd (2003). It stated that “it is for the parties to take appropriate action of selecting proper arbitrator(s) who could dispose of the matter within reasonable time fixed by them. It is for them to indicate the time-limit for disposal of the arbitral proceedings. It is for them to decide whether they should continue with the arbitrator (s) who cannot dispose of the matter within reasonable time.”

Long delays keep important issues out of sight and out of mind. For instance, some urgent questions in arbitration law have been referred to a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in the 2002 Bhatia International case, but the court has shown no haste to resolve them. Instead, it gave precedence to the problem of incorrect legal reporting mooted by an offended foreign telecom major, and spent two months over it.

There are several economic issues crying for early court decision for decades. These gross cases render the rubric of speedy trial mere rhetoric. Who remembers the appeal lying in the Delhi High Court about the attempted murder of a former Chief Justice of India? It was there for nearly four decades. The trial in the 1993 Bombay blast cases is trundling along in the special court, with no end in sight. All these will climb up the judicial ladder in due time. But remember, no grumbling, and inordinate delay will not be heard as a ground to close the dog-eared files.

levitra

2014 (35) STR 564 (Tri. – Chennai) Shriram RPC Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Service Tax, Chennai

fiogf49gjkf0d
Is penalty leviable when service tax along with interest is paid before issuance of Show Cause Notice? Held, No.

Facts:
On being pointed out by departmental auditor, service tax along with interest was paid. However, Show Cause Notice was issued imposing penalties. Since tax along with interest was paid before issuance of Show Cause Notice, the appellant claimed entitlement of benefit of 73(3) of the Finance Act, 1994 and also requested for benefits of section 80. Relying on the decision in case of CCE & STC, Bangalore vs. First Flight Couriers 2007 (8) S.T.R. 225 (Kar.), the revenue denied benefit of section 73(3) considering the case as one of suppression.

Held:
Section 73(3) of Finance Act, 1994 was issued with an intention to encourage immediate realisation of short payment and avoid unnecessary litigations. Karnataka High Court in case of ADECCO Flexione Work Force Solutions Ltd. 2012 (26) STR 3 (kar.), had held that unless there is any active suppression, section 73(3) should be applicable considering First Flight Couriers (supra) on a different footing and not finding even bonafide error or doubt regarding legal provisions, the penalty was set aside.

levitra

2014 (35) STR 397 (Tri.-Del.) Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. vs. Comm. of C.Ex., & ST, Allahabad

fiogf49gjkf0d
Whether denial of CENVAT Credit on the ground that invoice did not contain service tax registration number of service provider is valid? Held, No

Facts:
CENVAT credit was denied on the ground that service tax registration number of service provider was not mentioned on the invoice. Adjudicating authority though observed the fact of deposit of tax by service provider in the ST-3 returns denied CENVAT Credit.

Held:
In view of production of ST-3 returns, the defect in the invoice had become a rectifiable defect and accordingly, Tribunal allowed CENVAT Credit.

levitra

2014 (35) STR 529 (Tri. – Ahmd.) Patel Air Freight vs. Commr. Of C.Ex. & Service Tax, Vadodara

fiogf49gjkf0d
In case of invoices paid after availing discounts, is CENVAT Credit available in full or proportionately? Held in view of facts, full credit would be available.

Facts:
The appellants had availed full CENVAT Credit on discounted invoices. The Revenue contended that CENVAT credit should be allowed proportionally. The appellants relied on Circular No. 877/15/2008-CX, dated 17th November, 2008 and Circular No. 122/3/2010- ST, dated 30th April, 2010 which clarified that CENVAT Credit will be available for such amount which has been paid as Excise Duty/Service tax whether at full value or proportionate value.

Held:
There was no evidence brought to prove that reduced service tax was paid. Also, CENVAT credit was availed of amount paid as service tax, full credit was held as available in view of the above refered circulars.

levitra

[2014] 48 taxmann.com 232 (Gujarat) – Cema Electric Lighting Products India (P.) Ltd. vs. Commissioner of Central Excise

fiogf49gjkf0d
Whether assesse is entitled to the CENVAT Credit in respect of catering services received when consideration is recovered from the beneficiaries/assessee’s own employees? Held, No

Facts:
The appellant, a manufacturer availed CENVAT Credit of entire payment made to the canteen contractor even though the amount is recovered from its employees/ beneficiaries of canteen service. The demand was confirmed under Rule 14 of the CCR in respect of the amount recovered. Both Appellate authorities confirmed the demand.

Held:
The appellant is not entitled for CENVAT Credit if the amount is recovered from the beneficiaries/its own employees while running the canteen. Further, it was held that concurrent finding of facts by both the authorities below, that full details were not furnished and entire amount was recovered, justifies the invocation of extended period of limitation

levitra

S. 43 (5) — Loss suffered in F&O transactions could not be considered as speculation loss.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B — Unreported Decisions


(Full texts of the following Tribunal decisions are available
at the Society’s office on written request. For members desiring that the
Society mails a copy to them, Rs.30 per decision will be charged for
photocopying and postage.)


6 R. B. K. Securities Ltd.
v. ITO


ITAT ‘B’ Bench Mumbai

Before G. C. Gupta (JM) and

A. L. Gehlot (AM)

ITA No. 2465/Mum./2006

A.Y. 2003-04. Decided on : 21-7-2008

Counsel for assessee/revenue : Prakash K. Jotwani/ Niraj
Bansal

S. 43(5) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 — Speculation loss —
Whether the loss suffered in F&O transactions could be considered as speculation
loss — Held, No.

Per G. C. Gupta :

Issue :

Whether the losses suffered in F&O transactions could be
considered as speculation loss.

Held :

Relying on the Mumbai Tribunal decision in the case of SSKI
Investors Services Pvt. Ltd., it was held that dealings in derivatives was a
separate kind of transaction which did not involve any purchase & sale of shares
and therefore loss on account of derivative trading cannot be treated as
speculative loss. Further, the Tribunal also referred to the Bangalore Tribunal
decision in the case of C. Bharath Kumar, where the constructive or implied
delivery was held to be as good as actual delivery. Based on the same, the
Tribunal held that the loss claimed by the assessee on F&O transaction was a
business loss and not speculation loss as contended by the Revenue.

Cases referred to :



1. DCIT v. SSKI Investors Services Pvt. Ltd., (2008)
113 TTJ (Mumbai) 511,

2. C. Bharath Kumar v. DCIT, (2005) 4 SOT 593 (Bang.)

levitra

S. 12A(a) — Once CIT is satisfied about objects of the trust and genuineness of activities, he is required to grant registration w.e.f. date of creation

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B — Unreported Decisions


(Full texts of the following Tribunal decisions are available
at the Society’s office on written request. For members desiring that the
Society mails a copy to them, Rs.30 per decision will be charged for
photocopying and postage.)




5 The Indus Entrepreneur
v. The CIT-II


ITAT ‘B’ Bench, Jaipur

Before I. C. Sudhir (JM) and

B. P. Jain (AM)

ITA No. 32/JP/2008

A.Y. : 2003-04. Decided on : 20-6-2008

Counsel for assessee/revenue : Mahendra Gargieya/

J. L. Basumatari

Assessee society was registered under Rajasthan Societies
Registration Act on 1-9-2005 — Assessee applied to CIT for registration
u/s.12A(a) of Income-tax Act, 1961 — CIT vide his order dated 7-11-2007 granted
registration w.e.f. 1-4-2007 — Whether once CIT is satisfied about objects of
the trust and genuineness of activities, he is required to grant registration
w.e.f. 1-9-2005 — Held, Yes.

Per B. P. Jain :

Facts :

The assessee is a Society registered under Rajasthan
Societies Registration Act on 1-9-2005. The assessee applied for registration on
10-4-2007 before the CIT. The CIT granted registration u/s.12A(a) of the Act
vide its order dated 7-11-2007 w.e.f. 1-4-2007. The assessee made application to
make the said registration effective from 1-9-2005.

Held :

At the outset, the Tribunal noted that the CIT has committed
an error by observing that the application has been made on 10-4-2007, whereas
the same was made on 2-8-2006. A reminder letter dated 10-4-2007 was made to the
CIT, which was wrongly taken as the date of application. Having noted this
error, the Tribunal held as under :

As per the Act, the assessee is required to make the
application in Form 10A before 1-1-1973 or before the expiry of the period of
one year from the date of creation of the trust. In the instant case, the Trust
was created on 1-9-2005 and the assessee has submitted the application on
2-8-2006, which is in time. The CIT is required to grant registration w.e.f.
1-9-2005, if he is satisfied about the objects of the trust and genuineness of
the activities. In the present case, the learned CIT is satisfied about the
objects and genuineness of the activities of the trust and so he has granted
registration, though from a wrong date on a wrong interpretation of the facts of
the case.

The learned CIT is required to pass an order for granting or
refusing the registration u/s.12AA(1)(b) of the Act before 6 months from the end
of the month in which the application is received. The language of the provision
makes it mandatory for the learned CIT either to grant or refuse the
registration within the stipulated period, failing which the assessee is
entitled to assume that its application has been accepted and the registration
granted.

Accordingly, the learned CIT was directed to grant
registration w.e.f. 1-9-2005.


Editor’s note : S. 12AA has been amended w.e.f. 1-6-2007,
whereby the exemption is now available from the financial year in which the
application is made.

levitra

When the assessee converted his immovable property into stock-in-trade and entered into development agreement, the said transaction cannot be said to be a sale of immovable property.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 2

 part A: reported decisions

 

6 (2010) 42 DTR (Chennai
ITAT) 127

R. Gopinath (HUF) v. ACIT

A.Ys. : 2004-05 & 2005-06.
Dated : 24-7-2009

 

When the assessee converted
his immovable property into stock-in-trade and entered into development
agreement, the said transaction cannot be said to be a sale of immovable
property.

Facts :

The assessee converted his
land from capital asset to stock-in-trade and thereafter entered into a
development agreement dated 1-9-2003 along with a supplementary development
agreement dated 23-12-2003 with a developer, whereby the assessee provided his
land measuring 44,090 sq.ft. to the developer and in return the developer was to
give the assessee a built-up area of 25,285 sq.ft.

The assessee offered capital
gains accrued on conversion of land to stock-in-trade proportionate to the
built-up area sold in different years.

The Assessing Officer was of
the view that the long-term capital gain on transfer of land was assessable in
the year in which the assessee handed over the possession of the land to the
developer itself, pursuant to the agreement.

Held :

S. 53A of the Transfer of
Property Act does not provide the conditions for transfer, but it provides
protection to the transferee of any immovable property by a written contract.

S. 53A of the Transfer of
Property Act is borrowed only with respect to the transfer of capital asset as
provided u/s.2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and the same is not applicable in
other cases which do not fall u/s.2(47).

The sale/transfer of
stock-in-trade cannot be equated with transfer of capital asset u/s.2(47). The
decisions relied upon by the learned Departmental representative as well as the
lower authorities are with respect to the transfer of capital asset u/s.2(47)
and not in respect to stock-in-trade.

The assessee handed over the
possession of the property for construction of residential apartments by the
developer. The assessee did not receive any consideration for handing over the
possession of the property to the developer, but to get the built-up area of
25,130 sq.ft.

In the absence of the
transfer of the title of the property and any consideration at the time of
development agreement, the handing over of the possession was merely a temporary
measure for carrying out the construction work by the developer and the
exclusive possession of the property in legal sense remains with the assessee.

The nature of the transaction between the
parties by way of development agreement cannot be said to be a sale of immovable
property which is stock-in-trade.

levitra

Income-tax Act, 1961 — S. 45 — The gain arising on transfer of FSI/TDR is chargeable to tax under the head ‘capital gain’ and not under the head ‘Other Sources’ — However, as there is no cost of acquisition of the asset transferred, there will be no liabi

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 2

 part A: reported decisions


5 (2010) TIOL 512 ITAT-Mum.

ITO v. Shri Ram Kumar
Malhotra

ITA No. 4843/Mum./2009

A.Y. : 2006-07. Dated :
14-5-2010

Income-tax Act, 1961 — S. 45
— The gain arising on transfer of FSI/TDR is chargeable to tax under the head
‘capital gain’ and not under the head ‘Other Sources’ — However, as there is no
cost of acquisition of the asset transferred, there will be no liability to
capital gains.

Facts :

The assessee, in the year
1977, acquired the property under the registered lease and became co-owner of
the property and was holding 5t shares of the society. The assessee entered into
a development agreement with M/s. P. R. Investsment for the development of the
said property (bungalow) to construct 7-storied building as per approved plans.
The assessee retained proportionate FSI in the said plot for his own residential
accommodation to be constructed by the developer for a consideration of
Rs.21,00,000. The balance FSI was to be utilised by the developer for
construction of the building. The developer was authorised to use the TDR as per
applicable law. Thus, the assessee gave development rights to the developer for
construction of the property. The assessee regarded income arising from transfer
of development rights to be chargeable to tax as capital gains.

The Assessing Officer taxed
the proceeds as Income from other sources on the ground that the assessee had
not extinguished his right, title and interest in the property in any manner and
continued to hold leasehold rights in the property jointly with Shri Anil Kumar
Malhotra. The arrangement under the development agreement, according to the AO,
was to enable the developer to bring in marketable TDR on the plot and construct
and develop the same and sell the constructed area to outside people of his
choice who will have no right, title and interest in the plot of land.

Aggrieved, the assessee
preferred an appeal to the CIT(A) who directed the AO to tax the gain arising on
transfer of FSI/TDR as capital gain and to make necessary calculation of sale
consideration and cost of acquisition and/or improvement and also allow
exemption u/s.54 and u/s.54EC to the extent of investments made, after due
verification.

Aggrieved, the Revenue
preferred an appeal to the Tribunal.

Held :

The Tribunal following the
ratio of the decisions of the Tribunal in the case of New Shailaja Co-operative
Housing Society Ltd. v. ITO, (2009 TIOL 58 ITAT-Mum.), ITO v. Lotia Court Co-op.
Hsg. Soc. Ltd., (2008 TIOL 404 ITAT-Mum.), Jethalal D. Mehta v. Dy. CIT, (2 SOT
422) (Mum.) and Maheshwar Prakash 2 CHS v. ITO, 20 DTR 269 (Mum.) held that the
CIT(A) was right in holding that the gain arising on transfer of FSI/TDR is
chargeable to tax under the head ‘capital gain’ and not under the head ‘other
sources’. However, as there is no cost of acquisition of the asset transferred,
there will be no liability to capital gains.

 

levitra

Income-tax Act, 1961 — S. 32 — Router and switches when used along with a computer and when their functions are integrated with a ‘computer’ would be included in the block of ‘computer’ entitled to depreciation at the rate of 60%.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 2

 part A: reported decisions

 

4 (2010) TIOL 473 ITAT-SB-Mum.

DCIT v. Datacraft India Ltd.

ITA No. 7462 & 754
/Mum./2007

A.Ys. : 2003-04 and 2002-03.
Dated : 9-7-2010

 

Income-tax Act, 1961 — S. 32
— Router and switches when used along with a computer and when their functions
are integrated with a ‘computer’ would be included in the block of ‘computer’
entitled to depreciation at the rate of 60%.

Facts :

The assessee-company was
engaged in data communication, design, development, purchase and sale of
networking products, etc. The assessee claimed depreciation amounting to
Rs.3,27,67,150 at the rate of 60% under the head ‘Computers’. The assessee had
included routers and switches in the block of computers. The Assessing Officer
(AO) held that routers and switches were entitled to depreciation at the general
rate of 25% as applicable to plant and not as claimed by the assessee at 60%.

Aggrieved, the assessee
preferred an appeal to the CIT(A) who held that the routers and switches fall
under the block of ‘computers’. He allowed the assessee’s appeal.

Aggrieved the Revenue
preferred an appeal to the Tribunal. The President referred the following
question to the Special Bench (SB) for its consideration :

“Whether routers and
switches can be classified as computer entitled to depreciation at 60% or have
to be classified as general plant and machine entitled to depreciation only at
25%.”

Held :

The SB noted that the term
‘computers’ is not defined in the Act. Even the General Clauses Act does not
define the term ‘computers’. The term ‘computer systems’ has been defined in S.
36(1)(xi) but considering the fact that the object of S. 36(1)(xi) is quite
distinct from that of S. 32 the SB was of the opinion that the definition of the
term ‘computer system’ given in the Explanation to S. 36(1)(xi) cannot be
applied as such (for giving meaning to ‘computer’) in the context of S. 32.
Considering the scheme of the Information Technology Act, 2000 and also the
objects of the said Act, the SB noted that the rationale behind the Information
Technology Act, 2000 is quite distinct from that of the Income-tax Act and since
both these acts are not pari materia the definition of ‘computer’ as given in
the Information Technology Act, 2000 cannot be applied in the context of S. 32
of the Act. Considering the general parlance meaning of the term ‘computer’ and
also that of ‘routers’ and ‘switches’ the SB held that router and switches can
be classified as computer hardware when they are used along with a computer and
when their functions are integrated with a ‘computer’. It held that when a
device is used as part of the computer in its functions, then it would be termed
as a computer to be included in the block of ‘computer’ entitled to depreciation
at the rate of 60%.

The appeal filed by the
Revenue was dismissed.

 

levitra

Income-tax Act, 1961 — Principle of mutuality — Principle of mutuality is applicable to the assessee even though it is an incorporated company —Interest earned by the mutual association from banks, bonds, etc. on surplus funds is not liable to tax.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 2

 part A: reported decisions


 

3 (2010) TIOL 481 ITAT-Mum.

ITO v. Hill Properties Ltd.

ITA No. 6223/Mum./2009 and

ITA No. 6249/Mum./2009

A.Y. : 2005-06. Dated :
16-7-2010

Income-tax Act, 1961 —
Principle of mutuality — Principle of mutuality is applicable to the assessee
even though it is an incorporated company —Interest earned by the mutual
association
from banks, bonds, etc. on surplus funds is not liable to tax.

Facts :

The assessee-company
constructed a building, flats in which were allotted to shareholders. The
assessee in its return of income claimed the amounts collected towards share
transfer fees : Rs.62,20,000; nominee occupancy charges and repairs :
Rs.3,00,000; security deposits (non-refundable) : Rs.5,85,000 and interest and
dividend: Rs.11,95,577 to be not chargeable to tax on the ground of mutuality.
The assessee received nominee occupancy charges in respect of flats which were
given on rent by the members. Non-refundable security deposits were received by
the assessee from shareholders who carried out repairs to their flats. The
Assessing Officer (AO) in an order passed u/s.147 of the Act taxed all these
amounts on the ground that the principle of mutuality applies only to
co-operative bodies and as regards transfer fees he held that since the transfer
fees were received from incoming members, in view of the ratio of the Special
Bench decision of the ITAT in the case of Walkeshwar Triveni CHS Ltd. the same
are taxable. Aggrieved the assessee preferred an appeal to the CIT(A).

The CIT(A) held that the
principle of mutuality applies. He held that the share transfer fees, nominee
occupancy charges and security deposits (non-refundable) to be not chargeable to
tax. He, however, held that interest and dividend is chargeable to tax since in
case of interest and dividend contributors to the common fund are non-members of
the
assessee-company, who are not entitled to participate in the surplus.

Aggrieved the assessee and
the Department preferred an appeal to the Tribunal.

Held :

The Tribunal noted that in
earlier years, in the as-sessee’s own case, the Tribunal has accepted that the
principle of mutuality is applicable even in the case of an assessee being a
company. The Tribunal following the orders of the Tribunal in the as-sessee’s
own case and the ruling of the Supreme Court in the case of Bankipur Club Ltd.
(226 ITR 97) (SC) confirmed the decision of the CIT(A) that principle of
mutuality is applicable to the assessee even though it is an incorporated
company.

The Tribunal following the
judgment of the Bombay High Court in the case of Sind Co-operative Housing
Society Ltd., held the share transfer fees to be not chargeable to tax because
of the principle of mutuality.

The Tribunal having noted
that non-refundable security deposits were received by the assessee from its
members who wanted to carry out some repairs in their flats and the identity of
the contributors and the participants in the surplus was preserved, held the
same to be not chargeable to tax.

Non-occupancy charges were
held to be not liable to tax by following the decision of the Bombay High Court
in the case of Mittal Court Premises Co-operative Society Ltd. (2009 TIOL 548 HC
Mum.-IT).

Interest earned from banks
on surplus funds was held to be not liable to tax by following the order of the
Tribunal in the assessee’s own case for A.Y. 2004-05 and also the order of the
Tribunal in the case of Bombay Gymkhana Ltd. (ITA No. 7624/Mum./2007 dated
20-4-2009).

The appeal filed by the
assessee was allowed and the appeal of the Department was dismissed.

 

levitra

S. 254(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 — Principle of consistency qua judicial forums is not unexceptionable; if the subsequent Bench finds it difficult to follow the earlier view due to any convincing reason, the earlier view cannot be thrust upon it; whe

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 2

 2 (2010) 129 TTJ 521 (Mum.)
(SB)


The Maharashtra State Coop.
Bank Ltd.
v.

ACIT

A.Y. : 2000-01. Dated :
22-1-2010

(a) S. 254(1) of the
Income-tax Act, 1961 — Principle of consistency qua judicial forums is not
unexceptionable; if the subsequent Bench finds it difficult to follow the
earlier view due to any convincing reason, the earlier view cannot be thrust
upon it; when a matter is referred to the Larger Bench, the appeal needs to be
decided on merits rather than following the earlier view taken by the Tribunal
in assessee’s own case.

(b) S. 80P(2)(a)(i) of the
Income-tax Act, 1961 — Interest u/s.244A received by assessee, a co-operative
bank, on refund of income-tax paid by it in relation to the banking business
carried on by it is covered within the expression ‘profits and gains of
business’ occurring in S. 80P(2)(a) and the assessee is entitled to deduction
u/s.80P(2)(a)(i).

S. 254(1) :

The principle of consistency
qua the judicial forums is not unexceptionable. It is true that ordinarily the
order passed by the earlier Bench on the same point should be respected and
followed. But if the subsequent Bench finds it difficult to follow the earlier
view due to any convincing reason, such as change in the factual or legal
position or non-raising or non-consideration of an important argument by the
earlier Bench having bearing on the issue, then the earlier view cannot be
thrust upon it. So when a matter is referred to the Larger Bench, the view
earlier taken by the Division Bench ceases to be binding on the Special Bench
though it retains the persuasive value. In view of the above-discussed legal
position, the action of the Division Bench in referring the matter for
consideration by a Special Bench is perfectly in order since it found itself
unable to agree with the earlier view taken by another Division Bench of the
Tribunal in the assessee’s own case. Therefore, there is no infirmity in the
action of the Division Bench in making reference for the constitution of the
Special Bench when it found it difficult to accept the earlier view taken in the
assessee’s own case. Under these circumstances the exception to the application
of principle of consistency gets attracted and the appeal needs to be decided on
merits rather than following the earlier view taken by the Tribunal in its own
case.

The Tribunal relied on the
decisions in the following cases :

(a) Union of India &
Anr. v. Paras Laminates (P) Ltd.,
(1990) 87 CTR (SC) 180/(1990) 49 ELT 322
(SC)

(b) Dy. CIT v. Reliance
Industries Ltd.,
(2004) 82 TTJ (Mumbai) (SB) 765/(2004) 88 ITD 273
(Mumbai) (SB)

S. 80P(2)(a)(i) :

The Assessing Officer,
during the reassessment proceedings, opined that the interest received by the
assessee on income tax refund was on account of non-banking activity. The CIT(A)
also accepted the Assessing Officer’s order.

The Special Bench, relying
on the decisions in the following cases, ruled in favour of the assessee :

(a) ITO (ITA No.
4252/Mumbai/2000) and Punjab State Co-op. Bank v. Dy. CIT, (2000) 113
Taxman 128 (CHD) (Mag.)

(b) Cambay Electric
Supply Industrial Co. Ltd. v. CIT, 1978
CTR (SC) 50/(1978) 113 ITR 84 (SC)

The Special Bench noted as
under :

(1) The assessee was
carrying on banking business over the years and tax was collected by the
Revenue in relation to such banking business. Thus, there is a nexus between
the payment of income-tax, its refund and interest on such refund with the
business of banking. But for the carrying on of the banking business, the
assessee would not have paid the income-tax which was refunded to it. Since
income-tax was paid in relation to the banking business, the interest on
income-tax refund will be considered as ‘gain’ (not ‘profit’) of banking
business covered within the expression ‘profits and gains’ of banking
business. Therefore, interest on refund of income-tax would be covered within
the expression ‘profits and gains of business’, notwithstanding the
fact that it falls under the head ‘income from other sources’.

(2) The direct nexus of
interest on income-tax refund is with the payment of income-tax but when the
relation between income-tax and the income on which it was paid is traced, it
comes to light that the same was for the business of banking. Thus, there
exists a commercial and casual connection between the interest on income-tax
refund and the banking business.

(3) Therefore, the
assessee is entitled to deduction u/s.80P(2)(a)(i) on the amount of interest
received u/s.244A on the refund of tax.

 

levitra

Penalty proceedings being separate and independent, the assessee can show that finding recorded in the quantum proceedings is not reliable and sufficient to impose penalty.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 2

 part A: reported decisions


1 (2010) 125 ITD 313 (Ahd.)
(TM)

Dhirajlal Maganlal Shah v.
ITO

A.Y. : 2001-02. Dated :
25-9-2009

 

Penalty proceedings being
separate and independent, the assessee can show that finding recorded in the
quantum proceedings is not reliable and sufficient to impose penalty.

Facts :

During the scrutiny
assessment the Assessing Officer found that the assessee had paid a sum of
Rs.4,68,305 to some SJT as transport charges. The Assessing Officer held that
the payment was not a genuine one and disallowed the same. On appeal, the CIT(A)
confirmed the disallowance and so did the Tribunal. The Assessing Officer
initiated the penalty proceedings.

In reply to the show-cause
notice, the assessee contended that he had produced all the evidences, including
copies of account payee cheques, in respect of the impugned payment. He further
contended that the Assessing Officer was not able to appreciate the facts of the
case and merely levied penalty only on the basis that the bills produced were
unsigned. On appeal, the CIT(A) confirmed the levy of penalty.

On further appeal to the
Tribunal, the Members differed. The Accountant Member held that there was no
evidence that the payment was made through account payee cheque. He further
observed that the findings of the ITAT in quantum appeal that the assessee has
not discharged the onus has become final. Further, relying on the decision of
Dharmendra Textiles 306 ITR 227 (SC) and other decisions, he upheld the levy of
penalty.

The Judicial Member on the
other hand, observed that the assessee had furnished all the evidences and
details. The bank statement also confirmed the payment made to SJT. He concluded
that the explanations offered by the assessee was not false.

On matter being referred to
the third Member, the following was observed and held :

Held :

It is a settled law that
finding recorded in assessment proceedings is not conclusive, although it is
entitled to great weight. The penalty proceedings being separate and independent
proceedings, the assessee can always show that the finding recorded in the
quantum proceedings is not reliable and sufficient to impose penalty. The
assessee had produced all the evidences along with the bank statements. The
payment was made through account payee cheque. In this background there is no
justification to term the explanation of the assessee as false and levy penalty.

 

levitra

S. 80IB(10) — Land purchased in 1996 — Revised plan approved, commencement certificate issued, and use of land for non-agricultural purposes permitted after 1-10-1998 — Whether AO justified in denying deduction u/s.80IB(10) on ground that commencement of

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B — Unreported Decisions


(Full texts of the following Tribunal decisions are available
at the Society’s office on written request. For members desiring that the
Society mails a copy to them, Rs.30 per decision will be charged for
photocopying and postage.)


1 ITO, 14(3)(3) v.


Shri Vimalchand M. Dhoka

ITAT ‘A’ Bench, Mumbai

Before K. C. Singhal (JM) and V. K. Gupta (AM)

ITA No. 5520/Mum./2005

A.Y. : 2002-03. Decided on : 19-5-2008

Counsel for revenue/assessee : Sanjay Agarwal/

Vimal Punmiya


S. 80IB(10) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 — In respect of
Lonavala Project of the assessee for which deduction was claimed u/s.80IB(10),
land was purchased in 1996 — Wall was constructed — WIP of this project on
31-3-1998 was stated to be Rs.10,17,615 — Original plan expired after validity
period of one year — Revised plan was approved and commencement certificate
issued on 30-9-2000 — User of land for non-agricultural purposes was permitted
on 28-6-2001 — Whether AO justified in denying deduction u/s.80IB(10) on the
ground that the condition u/s.80IB(10)(a)
viz. commencement of the
construction after 1-10-1998 was not satisfied — Held, No.


Per V. K. Gupta :

Facts :

The assessee was engaged in the business of textiles and
construction. In A.Y. 2002-03, in respect of construction business, the assessee
claimed deduction u/s.80IB(10) at Rs.62,21,131 in respect of his projects at
Virar and Lonavala. In respect of Lonavala project, land was purchased in 1996
for Rs.5.50 lakhs and work-in-progress as on 31-3-1998 was shown at
Rs.10,17,615. The AO disallowed the claim for deduction u/s.80IB(10) of
Rs.3,32,369 in respect of Lonavala project, on the ground that the project had
commenced prior to 1st October 1998, since land for Lonavala project was
purchased in 1996 and as on 31st March 1998, certain expenses were shown as
work-in-progress and also a wall was constructed. According to the AO, the
project did not satisfy the condition stated in S. 80IB(10)(a). Before the CIT(A)
the assessee contended that :

(a) no construction work actually took place before 1st
October 1998;

(b) the wall was constructed merely to prevent the entry of
trespassers;

(c) the plan, originally submitted, expired after the
validity period of one year, hence revised plan was submitted, which was
approved by the concerned statutory authorities and, thereafter construction
work started after 1-10-1998;

(d) the land was an agricultural land and conversion of
land use was permitted only on 28-6-2001;

(e) the expenses shown in the balance sheet were of
administrative nature and not of construction activity. The CIT(A) found force
in the arguments of the assessee that the expenses incurred on architect fees,
landscape and elevation on filling the plot are the expenses which were
necessary for submitting the plan for the project and that incurring of these
expenses cannot be taken as commencement of the project. The fact that
permission for conversion of land from agricultural use to non-agricultural
use was issued on 28-6-2001 and also the commencement certificates were issued
by the relevant authority only on 30-9-2000 also weighed with the CIT(A). The
CIT(A) also stated that before getting the order for conversion and
commencement certificate, the construction activity cannot be started. He,
therefore, agreed with the assessee and directed the AO to grant deduction to
the assessee as claimed by it. The Revenue preferred an appeal to the
Tribunal.


Held :

The expenses incurred for change of land use and other
administrative/other land development expenses incurred prior to statutory
approvals, which approvals have been received after 1st October 1998 cannot
result into commencement of the project before 1st October 1998. The Tribunal
observed that the CIT(A) has examined the issue in detail and found itself to be
in agreement with the findings of the learned CIT(A), hence the Tribunal
confirmed the order passed by CIT(A). Accordingly, appeal filed by the Revenue
was dismissed.

levitra

S. 14A – Where surplus earned is more than the investment made, no disallowance u/s.14A could be made

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B — Unreported Decisions


(Full texts of the following Tribunal decisions are available
at the Society’s office on written request. For members desiring that the
Society mails a copy to them, Rs.30 per decision will be charged for
photocopying and postage.)



4 Faze Three Exports Ltd. v. Addl. CIT


ITAT ‘I’ Bench, Mumbai

Before J. Sudhakar Reddy (AM) and V. D. Rao (JM)

ITA Nos. 7701 and 4677/Mum./2004 and 2005

A.Ys. : 2001-02 and 2002-03. Decided on : 28-7-2008

Counsel for assessee/revenue : Jitendra Jain/Bharat Bhushan

S. 14A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 — Disallowance of expenses
in relation to exempt income — Assessee, an exporter, had made investments in
shares of different companies, including group companies — Assessee able to show
earnings more than the amount of investment made — Whether Assessing Officer
justified in disallowing interest — Held, No.

Per J. Sudhakar Reddy :

Facts :

The assessee was in the business of exports of goods. As the
assessee had investments in equity shares, in addition to Rs.4.52 crore invested
in preference shares of a group company in the year under appeal, the Assessing
Officer disallowed part of the interest cost u/s.14A of the of the Act.

On appeal the CIT(A) held that interest paid on term loan,
discounting charges and other bank charges as well as interest on vehicles’ loan
cannot be disallowed, as the same can be held to have been utilised for specific
purposes. However, with reference to interest paid on packing credit, the CIT(A)
was of the view that the same could be subjected to S. 14A, and he accordingly,
restricted the disallowance to Rs.4.57 lacs.

Before the Tribunal the Revenue justified the orders of the
authorities below and contended that certain interest expenditure could
definitely be attributable to the investments made by the assessee. It further
relied on the Delhi High Court decision in the case of Motor General Finance
Ltd.

Held :

According to the Tribunal, the CIT(A) had erroneously
concluded that the packing credit was available for all the activities of the
assessee and that since the assessee was having only one bank account, it should
be presumed that the investment had also gone out of packing credit loan and the
same was required to be apportioned. The Tribunal noted that as per the terms of
the packing credit facility, the fund is released only against export orders.
According to the Tribunal, the presumption of the CIT(A) that the assessee would
have violated the stipulation laid down by the bank was unwarranted, especially
when there was no evidence in that regard. Further, it was noted that the
assessee was able to demonstrate that its earning during each of the years was
much more than the investment made in the particular year. It had own fund of
Rs.48.44 crore as against the borrowed fund of Rs.6.3 crore, while the
investment in equity was Rs.4.52 crore. Based on the above and also relying on
the Supreme Court decision in the case of Munjal Sales Corpn., the Tribunal
allowed the appeal of the assessee.

Cases referred to :



1. Munjal Sales Corpn. v. CIT, 298 ITR 298 (SC)

2. CIT v. Motor General Finance Ltd., 254 ITR 449
(Del.)



levitra

S. 43B – Interest on Custom duty not covered in S. 43B

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B — Unreported Decisions


(Full texts of the following Tribunal decisions are available
at the Society’s office on written request. For members desiring that the
Society mails a copy to them, Rs.30 per decision will be charged for
photocopying and postage.)



3 Royal Cushion Vinyl Products Ltd. v. ACIT


ITAT ‘F’ Bench, Mumbai

Before Sushma Chowla (JM) and

Abraham P. George (AM)

ITA No. 2824/M/2006

A.Y. 2002-03. Decided on : 31-7-2008

Counsel for assessee/revenue : Mayur Shah/

K. M. Varma

S. 43B of Income-tax Act, 1961 — Interest on Customs duty —
Whether such interest falls within the ambit of provisions of S. 43B — Held, No.

Per Abraham P. George :

Facts :

The assessee was a manufacturer of PVC flooring, leather
cloth, etc. It had imported certain raw materials under advance licence without
the payment of customs duty. This exemption was granted with the condition that
the assessee would export required value of goods. However, for its failure to
export goods, the assessee was made to pay the customs duty of Rs.9.52 crore,
which was waived on goods imported, along with the interest of Rs.3.78 crore. In
its tax audit report, the assessee had shown Rs.13.20 crore as disallowable
u/s.43B. However, in its return of income filed, the assessee had disallowed the
sum of Rs.9.52 crore only i.e., the amount equal to the custom duty. The
interest of Rs.3.78 crore was claimed as not covered u/s.43B. The Assessing
Officer as well as the CIT(A) held that the interest was disallowable u/s.43B.

Held :

The Tribunal referred to the Calcutta High Court decision in
the case of Hindustan Motors Ltd., where it was held that interest payable under
the Customs Act, 1962 was not part and parcel of customs duty payable and hence,
such interest did not attract S. 43B of the Act. According to it, the same High
Court followed the said decision in Orient Beverages Ltd., where it was held
that interest payable on outstanding municipal taxes could not be disallowed
u/s. 43B. Further, it also referred to the Apex Court decision in the case of
Harshad Mehta, where it was held that penalty or interest could not be
considered as tax. In view of the same, and the fact that there were no
decisions of the jurisdictional High Court, though there were decisions which
were against the assessee but of a different High Court, the Tribunal allowed
the appeal and deleted the disallowance of Rs.3.78 crore.

Cases referred to :



1. Hindustan Motors Ltd. v. CIT, 218 ITR 450 (Cal.)

2. CIT v. Orient Beverages Ltd., 247 ITR 230 (Cal.)

3. Harshad Mehta v. Custodian and Others, 231 ITR
871 (SC)



levitra

Whether CIT(A) was justified in refusing to admit additional evidence — Held, No

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B — Unreported Decisions


(Full texts of the following Tribunal decisions are available
at the Society’s office on written request. For members desiring that the
Society mails a copy to them, Rs.30 per decision will be charged for
photocopying and postage.)



2 Anmol Colours India (P) Ltd.
v. ITO


ITAT ‘A’ Bench, Jaipur

Before I. C. Sudhir (JM) and

B. P. Jain (AM)

ITA No. 379/JP/2008

A.Y. : 2002-03. Decided on : 20-6-2008

Counsel for assessee/revenue :

Mahendra Gargieya/P. C. Sharma

Assessing Officer issued notice u/s.143(2) of the Income-tax
Act, 1961 and gave the assessee various opportunities to produce documents in
support of the return filed — None appeared for the assessee — AO proceeded to
make an ex-parte assessment u/s.144 by treating addition to unsecured loans and
share application money during the year as unexplained u/s.68 of the Act —
Before CIT(A), assessee contended that it had given all documents/evidences to
its counsel who failed to appear before the AO — Assessee should not be made to
suffer for no lapse on his part — Assessee filed application under Rule 46A
along with documents/ evidences for admission thereof as additional evidence —
CIT(A) refused to admit additional evidence — Whether CIT(A) was justified in
refusing to admit additional evidence — Held, No.

Per B. P. Jain :

Facts :

The assessee was served notice u/s.143(2) of the Act on
29-10-2003. Thereafter, the assessee was given various opportunities and show
cause for producing the documents in support of the return filed. No one
appeared and the AO proceeded to make an ex-parte assessment u/s.144 of
the Act. The AO treated the addition to the unsecured loans and share
application money during the year as unexplained u/s.68 of the Act and added the
same to the income of the assessee. The AO further denied the claim of the
business loss of Rs.1,77,365 and treated the business income as Nil. Before the
CIT(A), the assessee contended that all the documents/evidences were given to
the counsel of the assessee and that the assessee was totally dependent upon his
counsel for representing the matter before the AO, but he did not care to attend
the proceedings. It was submitted that the assessee should not be made to suffer
for the serious lapse on the part of his counsel. The assessee stated that upon
receipt of the assessment order it came to know for the first time about the
additions made by the AO. The affidavit in this regard was filed before CIT(A).
The assessee contended that the circumstances were beyond the control of the
assessee and therefore, assessee was prevented by sufficient cause from
producing the documents/evidence before the AO. The assessee filed an
application under Rule 46A and produced the necessary evidences, before the
CIT(A), which were, in the opinion of the assessee, required for disposal of the
case. The CIT(A), upon receipt of the application along with documents/evidences
sent the said application along with documents/evidences to the AO. In response
thereto, the AO wrote a letter to the CIT(A) stating that assessee had not
appeared and had not produced any evidence despite various opportunities and now
on the basis of evidence filed before the CIT(A), the said loans and share
application money are verifiable from the books of the assessee. Upon receipt of
the letter from the AO, the CIT(A) held that none of the conditions specified
under Rule 46A are fulfilled and therefore he refused to admit the additional
evidence and confirmed the action of the AO. The assessee preferred an appeal to
the Tribunal.

Held :

The explanation of the assessee appears to be bona fide
and the assessee was prevented by sufficient cause from producing the evidence
which it was called upon to produce before the AO. Therefore, the CIT(A) was not
justified in not admitting the additional evidence under Rule 46A of the
Income-tax Rules, 1962.

When the application under Rule 46A along with documents was
sent to the AO and the AO in his letter to the CIT(A) stated that on the basis
of evidence filed before the CIT(A), the said loans and share application money
are verifiable from the books of the assessee, then the CIT(A) within his power
under sub-rule 4 of Rule 46A could direct the AO to examine the
documents/evidences filed by the assessee to dispose of the appeal.

The powers of the first Appellate Authority are very wide and
co-terminus with those of the AO and what AO can do, he can do and what AO fails
to do, that also he can do [refer Kanpur Coal Syndicate, 53 ITR 225 (SC)]. S.
251 and S. 252 of the Act have also been worded keeping the same spirit, as also
Rule 46A.

S. 250(4) empowers the CIT(A) to make further inquiries on
its own or to direct the AO to make further inquiry and to report to him.

The embargo put on his power under Rule 46A(1) and (2) has
also been loosened by sub-rule 4 which empowers the CIT(A) to direct the
production of any document/examination of witness, to enable him to dispose of
the appeal. Thus, the legislative intent is quite clear and the CIT(A) should
not jump straightway to reject, if the appellant files some evidence before him
under the provisions of Rule 46A(1).

The powers of the CIT(A) as submitted above are also to be
interpreted in the context of the amended law, wherein he is no more empowered
to restore back any matter which was earlier u/s.251(1)(a), necessitating a
compulsory admission of the evidence before him in the interest of justice.

Since all the evidences have to be examined by the AO,
therefore, in the interest of justice, the matter is restored back to the file
of the AO who will examine the evidences filed by the assessee before the CIT(A)
and decide the issue de novo, but by providing adequate opportunity of
being heard to the as-sessee. The assessee may submit further documents or
evidences as required in support of his claim before the AO. The AO is directed
to act accordingly.


levitra

Ex debito justitiae

fiogf49gjkf0d

The Word

The expression ‘ex debito justitiae’ literally stands
for doing justice. In legal usage, it speaks of a remedy which enables one to
get justice when principles of equity and justice are violated in any order of
the Court. The principle embodied in the maxim is that a Court of plenary
jurisdiction should have powers to correct its own judgments and order of
subordinate Courts, regardless of any specific power conferred on it, for the
purpose of preventing abuse of process and grave palpable errors.


2. A judgment pronounced by a Court is generally final until
disturbed by a Court of competent jurisdiction. However, if for any reason — a
glaring omission or a patent mistake — there is some manifest illegality or want
of jurisdiction in the order, the Courts are empowered to remedy the abuse of
process by reviewing its decisions on petition or suo motu ‘ex debito
justitiae’
, as no suitor should suffer for the wrong of the Court.

3. Drawing distinction between remedies available for regular
and irregular orders, the Privy Council in Isaacs v. Robertson, (1984) 3
AER 140 observed that “if an order is regular it can be set aside by an
Appellate Court; if the order is irregular, it can be set aside by the Court
that made it on application being made to that Court either under the rules of
that Court dealing expressly with setting aside orders for irregularity or,
‘ex debito justitiae’
, if the circumstances warranted, namely, violation of
the rules of natural justice or fundamental rights.

4. Cases of frank failure of natural justice are obvious
cases where relief is granted as of right. The principle finds acceptance in S.
151 of the Code of Civil Procedure which reads :

“151. Nothing in this code shall be deemed to limit or
otherwise affect the inherent power of the Court to make such orders as may be
necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the
Court.”


5. In criminal cases, the maxim was recognised in spirit by
S. 561A of the 1898 Code which finds expression in S. 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973. The Section reads :

“482. Nothing in this Code shall be deemed to limit or
affect the inherent powers of the High Court to make such orders as may be
necessary to give effect to any order under this Code, or to prevent abuse of
the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice.”


6. The Apex Court relied heavily on the maxim in A. R.
Antulay v. R. S. Nayak & Anr.,
[1988 AIR 1513 (SC)] where the appellant, the
then Chief Minister of Maharashtra who resigned in deference to a High Court
judgment, but continued as MLA, was charged before the Special Judge u/s.161 and
u/s. 165 IPC for taking gratification in respect of official act. After several
proceedings in lower and the High Court, the Supreme Court, in appeal before it,
set aside the order of the Special Judge discharging the accused and, as the
proceedings had dragged too long, withdrew the case from the Special Judge
suo motu
and assigned it to a sitting Judge of the High Court. As the order
of the Supreme Court was in disregard of the provisions of the Criminal Law
Amendment Act, 1952, under which such offences could be tried by Special Judge
only, the same was challenged before the High Court and then, in appeal, before
the Supreme Court. Admitting the wrong, the Court repelled the argument that as
the Superior Court is deemed to have general jurisdiction, the law presumes that
the Court acted within jurisdiction. The Court observed that ‘the impugned
direction were in deprival of the constitutional rights, contrary to the express
provisions of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 1952, in violation of the
principles of natural justice, and without precedent in the background of the
Act of 1952. The directions definitely deprived the appellant of certain rights
of appeal and revision and his rights under the Constitution. The Court further
observed “having regard to the enormity of the consequences of the error to the
appellant and by reason of the fact that the directions were given suo motu,
there is nothing which detracts the power of the Court to review its judgment
‘ex debito justitiae’
, in case injustice has been caused.

7. The maxim can operate even against the express bar on
review, if circumstances so require. In Madhu Limaye v. State of Maharashtra,
1978 AIR, SC 47, the appellant was prosecuted u/s.500 IPC for making defamatory
statement against the then Law Minister Shri A. R. Antulay. The same was
challenged on the ground that the statement made was in personal capacity. The
challenge having been rejected by the Sessions Judge, revision petition was
filed before the High Court, which was held not maintainable on the ground of
specific bar in relation to interlocutory orders in S. 397(2) of the Cr. P.C.
Holding that the High Court has inherent power to be exercised ‘ex debito
justitiae’
to do the real and substantial justice for the administration of
which alone Courts exist, the Supreme Court observed that “The instant case
wherein the order impugned rejected the application challenging the jurisdiction
of the Court to proceed with the trial, undoubtedly fell for exercise of the
power of the High Court in accordance with S. 482, even assuming, although not
accepting that invoking the revisional power of the High Court is
impermissible.” Similar issue was involved in V. C. Shukla v. State, 1980
AIR 962 SC where the jurisdiction to issue directions by the Judge of Special
Court for charges to be framed against the appellant were challenged. The High
Court held the revision petition not maintainable on the ground of the order
being interlocutory. Not agreeing with the High Court, the Supreme Court held
that “apart from the revisional power, the High Court under the code of 1898
possessed an inherent power to pass order ‘ex debito justitiae’ in order
to prevent abuse of the process of the Court.”

8.    The power of review or revision ‘ex debito justi-tiae’ is exercisable only by Courts exercising original, appellate or revisional jurisdiction. The High Court’s power to grant stay of demand in reference proceedings u/s.256 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 came for consideration before the Supreme Court in CIT Delhi v. Bansidhar and Sons, [157 ITR 665 (SC)]. The assessee sought injunction and stay of demand relying upon the inherent jurisdiction u/ s. 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which was granted by the High Court on condition of furnishing of adequate security. Upholding the Revenue’s challenge, the Supreme Court ruled that the power to act I ex debito justitiae’ related to matters of procedure and not substantive rights of the parties. In answering questions or disposing of references either u/ s.66 of the 1922 Act or S. 256 of 1961 Act, the High Courts do not exercise any jurisdiction conferred upon them by the C.P.C. or the Charters or by the Act establishing respective High Courts. It is a special jurisdiction of a limited nature conferred by the Income-tax Act for limited purpose of”obtaming the High Court’s opinion on questions of law. Rendering advice has nothing to do with recovery of tax or granting stay. Therefore, the concept of granting stay In a reference’ ex debito justitiae’ does not arise. That concept might arise in case of the Appellate Authority exercising its power to grant stay where there is no express provision.

9.    With the deletion of S. 256 and insertion of S. 260A and S. 260B conferring Appellate jurisdiction on High Courts, the aforesaid observations no longer remain relevant.

10.    Even though it is neither advisable nor possible to enumerate all the grounds on which the petition ‘ex debito justitiae’ is maintainable, the Courts have been acting only in cases of grave justice and breach of principle of natural injustice where consequences are grave for the aggrieved. In Shivnath Prasad v. State of W.B. and Others, [2006] INSC 62, the High Court’s order refusing to intervene in proceedings launched u/s.120B, u/s.406, u/s.417 and u/s.420 of IPC against R S Lodha in connection with the allegedly forged will of Late Smt. Priyamvada Birla was challenged. An argument was made that since the complaint was frivolous, vexatious, oppressive and malicious, the High Court should have exercised its powers u/ s.482 of Cr. P. C, because such powers are required to be exercised ‘ex debito justitiae’ or for the ends of justice. After going in detail into the facts of the case and scope of the inherent power enshrined in S. 482, the Apex Court declined to inter-fere and the appeal was dismissed.

Processing of returns for A.Y. 2007-08 and steps to clear the backlog. Instruction No. 12/2008, F.No.225/106/2008-ITA-II dated 5-9-2008 (reproduced).

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

2 Processing of returns for A.Y. 2007-08 and
steps to clear the backlog. Instruction No. 12/2008, F.No.225/106/2008-ITA-II
dated 5-9-2008 (reproduced).

Kindly refer to the above.

 


2. A review of CAP-II statements for June and July 2008 shows
a large pendency of returns for A.Y. 2007-08 in almost all CCIT Regions. The
Board had earlier kept a target of 4-6 months for processing of returns. The
criteria for matching claims for granting TDS certificates were relaxed in June
2006, in order to expedite the processing of pending returns and necessary
instruction in this regard was issued vide Instruction No. 6/2008, dated 18th
June, 2008. However, the number of returns processed has not shown any
significant improvement. A large number of electronic returns for A.Y. 2007-08
as also refund returns are still pending for processing. The Board is concerned
about the slow pace of progress in this regard. In order to speed up the
processing of pending returns for A.Y. 2007-08, it has been decided to adopt the
following strategy :

(1) All pending returns for A.Y. 2007-08 involving refund
claims (including electronic returns with refund claims) must be processed on
priority basis by 30th September, 2008. Where any scrutiny assessment is
pending in these cases, refund should be issued only after completion of the
scrutiny assessment.

(2) For processing electronic returns involving refund
claims, TDS data supplied by DGIT (Systems) on CDs along with AST instructions
68 may be utilised.

(3) Refund returns involving inter-RCC migration of PAN may
be processed on TMS.

(4) Since data of electronic returns is already on the
system, once this is acquired into the RCC data base, it will become part of
the selection process under CASS. Therefore, electronic returns for A.Y.
2007-08 not involving refund claims can be taken up for processing after 30th
September. However, it has to be ensured that all such returns are acquired
and incorporated into RCC data base before the next round of CASS is run.

(5) Returns in forms ITR-4 and 5 filed in paper made by
business assessees and not covered by S. 44AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961
should be taken up for processing on AST at the stations on network on
priority basis at the earliest before the next round of selection through
CASS.

(6) Salary returns for A.Y. 2007-08 in which there is no
refund or demand and the TDS claim is below Rs.5 lakh, may be given the last
priority for processing.

 


This may be brought to the notice of all concerned for strict
compliance. Any difficulties arising in processing of returns on AST may be
brought to the notice of DGIT (Systems) and, wherever necessary, to the Board.

levitra

Scrutiny of FBT returns — Instruction No. 11/2008, F.No.225/44/2008-ITA-II, dated 5-9-2008 (reproduced)

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Scrutiny of FBT returns — Instruction No.
11/2008, F.No.225/44/2008-ITA-II, dated 5-9-2008 (reproduced)


Kindly refer to the above.

 

2. I am directed to state that all the corporate cases
selected for scrutiny as per the guidelines contained in the Action Plan
document 2008-09, which have returned income of Rs.5 crore or more and where
provisions of Fringe Benefit Tax (FBT) apply, assessment order shall also be
passed u/s.115WE of the Income-tax Act, 1961 after scrutiny of all such cases.

 

This may be brought to the notice of all concerned.

levitra

Miscellaneous

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part D : Miscellaneous


5 The Employees’ Provident Fund
Organisation has launched a facility for online verification of status of the
claim under the EPF. The facility can be availed at http://epfindia.nic.in/indiaepf%5Cloginnew.aspx
the user needs to select his State, the EPF office, Establishment Code,
Extension code, if any and then enter the employee number to ascertain the claim
status.

levitra

The Cost Inflation Index has been notified for the financial year 2008-09 as 582 — Notification No. 86/2008 [f. no. 142/8/2008-tpl], dated 13-8-2008.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

4 The Cost Inflation Index has been notified
for the financial year 2008-09 as 582 — Notification No. 86/2008 [f. no.
142/8/2008-tpl], dated 13-8-2008.

levitra

Income earned in foreign countries to be included in the total income of the Resident in India — Notification No. 90/2008 and 91/2008, dated 28-8-2008.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

3 Income earned in foreign countries to be
included in the total income of the Resident in India — Notification No. 90/2008
and 91/2008, dated 28-8-2008.


The CBDT has notified that when the income earned by a
Resident Indian outside India, is taxed outside India as per the provisions of
Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements, such foreign income needs to be included
in the total income of the Resident in their return of income in India. Also,
relief would be granted as per the elimination of double taxation avoidance
provisions provided in the respective Agreements applicable to the assessee.
This provision equally applies to Indian associations as specified in S. 90A of
the Act also.

levitra

Classification of New Services notified through Finance Act, 2010 under Export of Services Rules, 2005 — Circular No. 129/11/2010-ST, dated 21-9-2010

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Part B : INDIRECT TAXES


SERVICE TAX UPDATE

15 Classification of New
Services notified through Finance Act, 2010 under Export of Services Rules, 2005
— Circular No. 129/11/2010-ST, dated 21-9-2010.

To resolve the doubts raised
by the service tax payers regarding classification of new services introduced by
the Finance Act, 2010, the CBEC has clarified that all the new services shall
fall in category 3(iii) of the Export of Services Rules, 2005 and Taxation of
Services (Provided from Outside India and Received in India) Rules, 2006
popularly known as Import Rules, 2006. Consequently for services to be
classified as an eligible export, the same must be provided to a service
recipient located outside India and for services to be classified as import of
service the same must be provided from outside India to a service recipient
located in India.

levitra

Delhi HC pulls up IT Dept. for filing appeal where issue of law is well-settled

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

17 Delhi HC pulls up IT Dept. for filing appeal
where issue of law is well-settled


Income-tax Department has come under sharp criticism from the
Delhi High Court for filing appeal against Tax Tribunal decisions in which issue
of law is well-settled.

A Bench comprising Chief Justice Dipak Misra and Justice
Manmohan said that the judicial capital is extremely limited and should not be
wasted in needless litigations.

“In our view, appeals should not be filed in matters where
either no question of law arises or the issue of law is a settled one. We give
this direction because the ‘judicial capital’ in terms of manpower and resources
is extremely limited,” the Court said. The Court’s direction came on a petition
filed by the Revenue Department challenging an order of Tax Tribunal ITAT.

The Court, which was inclined to impose cost on the
Department, refrained by warning it to be careful in future before filing appeal
against ITAT.

 

(Source : Internet – www.forum4finance.com dated
10-8-2010)



“Only economic prosperity can produce progress. Prosperity arises out of
innovation and enterprise, from the technological ingenuity and the skills
that are housed in the great companies. Prosperity needs to move seamlessly
across the world so that no country is left behind. This means the corporate
CEO and the ambassador are locked in partnership.”


— PEPSICO Chairperson & CEO, Indra Nooyi addressing Indian Ambassadors in New
Delhi.

(Source :
The Economic Times, dated 14-9-2010)

levitra

CAG slams tax authorities’ weakness for appeals

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

16 CAG slams tax authorities’ weakness for appeals


The Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG)
has come down heavily on the Tax Department for fostering “a perception that it
has a tendency to opt for appeals even when it is on a weak wicket” and this “appealititis
is more detrimental when applied on small taxpayers constituting a large chunk
of appellants.” In a first-of-its-kind holistic study of appeals, the CAG report
on the Appeal Process, tabled in the Parliament on Friday, minced no words when
it said point-blank that the proliferation of appeals decisions were prompted by
counsels of Income-tax Appellate Tribunal. They could also be fuelled by the
Assessing Officers (AOs) deciding to play safe “rather than judge a case on its
merits and save the system of the strain that weak cases place on it.”

Stating that the dimensions of disputes in
income-tax remain ‘staggering,’ the report said the aggregate amount locked up
in appeal at various levels is `2.2 lakh crore, which could almost wipe off the
revenue deficit of the Union Government in 2008-09. It said that for the span
2006-09, the audit analysed data and 48% of the demands raised by AOs remain
uncollected with disputes accounting for 45% of the uncollected demands, and 22%
of the demands raised in assessments at disputes by taxpayers. Even as the
implementation of Appellate orders is placed low in the AOs priorities,
inadequate attention on correctness in implementation of Appellate orders led to
mistakes amounting to `1,456 crore in 385 cases, it said, adding that 97% of
these mistakes led to under-assessment of tax benefitting the taxpayer which
“raises doubts on the integrity of the process.”

The audit also highlighted the constraints under
which it had undertaken this study in the absence of a centralised database on
appeals at the State level which hampered the selection of the audit samples.
“Poor maintenance of records across the assessment and judicial wings of the
Department is an area of concern,” it said, adding that the Department produced
only 49% of the records it requisitioned for audit and it was as low as 5% in
the case of Delhi office. Despite a steady reduction in the number of appeals
referred to the Commissioners of Income-tax (CsIT), the inventory of appeals
with CsIT was building up because of low disposal of appeals which was one-third
of the targeted level, it said. At the current levels of disposal, the CsIT
(Appeals) would take 2.4 years to clear the inventory. The average time taken
for disposal of a case is 14 months, which is substantially longer than the
global norms. It further said low-end appeals (with demand less than Rs.1 crore),
constituted 66% of the total appeals. Hence, CAG suggests hiving off of small
taxpayers’ disputes and such segregation would promote greater focus on the ‘big
ticket’ appeals with rationalisation of workload of the CsIT (A). Stating that
the assessment process is evidently unable to satisfy the small taxpayer, the
category which is least equipped to bear the cost of litigation, the CAG said
that this must be viewed alongside the fact that the success rate of the
Department at various levels of appeals is “low and appeals go decidedly in
favour of the taxpayers.” Even as there are some provisions in the Act such as
imposition of penalty that lead to disputes, it said deviations from prescribed
procedures by AOs have also contributed to rows. It also excoriated the tendency
to escalate the disputes to higher levels and “instances of inaction in such
cases where a second appeal would have safeguarded revenue.” There is lack of
consistency while considering a case for second appeal with divergent actions
weakening the Departmental stand in appeals. “The absence of independent
evaluation of decisions for escalation creates unchecked avenues for arbitrary
exercise of discretionary powers by the AOs,” it said, and added that there is a
need to remove ambiguities in the provisions of the Act to reduce the use of
discretion by the AOs. It said the penal provisions of the Act calls for a
relook, since “the deterrent edge to these provisions is being blunted due to
inability to sustain the penalty orders in appeals.”

(Source : The Hindu Business Line, dated 13-8-2010)

levitra

Oxford English Dictionary — Online dictionary spells doom for printed version

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

15 Oxford English Dictionary — Online dictionary
spells doom for printed version


It’s been in print for over a century, but in
future the Oxford English Dictionary — the authoritative guide to the English
language — may only be available to peruse online. Publisher Oxford University
Press said that burgeoning demand for the dictionary’s online version has far
outpaced demand for the printed versions. By the time the lexicographers behind
the dictionary finished revising and updating the latest edition — a gargantuan
task that will take many more years — publishers are doubtful there will still
be a market for the printed form.

The online Oxford English Dictionary now gets 2
million hits a month from subscribers. The current printed edition — a hefty
20-volume, £ 750 set published in 1989 — has sold about 30,000 sets in total.

The first instalment of the Oxford English
Dictionary was published in 1884, and it kept growing for decades until the
complete text went out in 1928. It was the first comprehensive English
dictionary since Samuel Johnson’s ‘A Dictionary of the English Language’
published in 1755, and has evolved to become the accepted authority on the
meaning and history of words.

(Source : The Times of India, dated 30-8-2010)

levitra

App for docs : iPhone app to replace the stethoscope ?

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

14 App for docs : iPhone app to replace the
stethoscope ?


The iPhone could soon replace the doctors’ best
friend, the traditional stethoscope, thanks to a free application created by a
University College London researcher.

Peter Bentley invented the ‘iStethoscope’
application which monitors heartbeat through sensors in the iPhone as just a bit
of fun. And, more than three million doctors across the world are signing up for
the free application.

(Source : The Hindu, dated 1-9-2010)

levitra

IT Dept. worried with 50% TDS data mismatch cases

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

13 IT Dept. worried with 50% TDS data mismatch
cases


Tax deducted at source (TDS) has become a
problematic issue with the Income-tax Department, as in more than 50% TDS refund
cases, it is facing an uphill task in matching the data provided in the
assessee’s income-tax returns with the TDS deductor’s information available with
the NSDL.

And the mismatch is resulting in the assessee
running from pillar to post to get back the refund due to him from the
Department.

“It’s a pan-India problem; the Government wants the
system to be fully computerised so that things are streamlined,” said Jamshedpur
Commissariat DCIT (TDS) S. M. S. Tauheed recently.

 

(Source : The Financial Express, dated
10-8-2010)

levitra

Govt. to change role of accounting standards body

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

12 Govt. to change role of accounting standards body


The Government plans to redefine the functions of
the National Advisory Committee on Accounting Standards (NACAS) to convert it
into an independent regulatory entity to monitor the quality of audit undertaken
across the corporate sector in the country.

The proposal, made by the Corporate Affairs
Ministry to the Parliamentary Committee on Finance that looked into the
Companies Bill, 2009, says the revamped NACAS should be allowed to oversee and
monitor the performance of standard-setting bodies for the accountancy and audit
professions.

Autonomous institutions such as the Institute of
Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and the Institute of Company Secretaries
of India, under the administrative control of the Corporate Affairs Ministry,
are the standard-setting bodies for accountancy and audit professions.

The Ministry response came after the Parliamentary
Committee, which submitted its report last week, expressed concerns over the
global economic crisis and the failure of big companies and suggested the
formation of an independent regulator to recommend standards for corporate
financial reporting, corporate audit and the quality of service of professionals
associated with ensuring compliance with such standards. It also wanted this
body to oversee, monitor and supervise the bodies involved in setting such
standards.

(Source : Internet www.taxguru.in, dated
10-9-2010)

levitra

House Panel calls for harmonisation of Provisions of Companies Bill with International Financial Reporting norms

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

11 House Panel calls for harmonisation of
Provisions of Companies Bill with International Financial Reporting norms


 

The Standing Committee
of the Parliament, which thoroughly examined The Companies Bill, 2009, has
observed that there are several matters included in the Bill, which need
modification with a view to harmonising them with the International Financial
Reporting Standards (IFRS). The Committee has, therefore, desired that all such
matters requiring harmonisation with IFRS should be considered and appropriate
amendments may be made in the relevant proposals contained in the Bill. The
Standing Committee on Finance (SCF) presented its Twenty-First Report, which
pertains to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, to the Parliament recently.

The Committee’s
examination of the subject and the replies of the Ministry received thereon
reveal that the following provisions/clauses of the Bill require modification
for achieving convergence with IFRS :



2(1)(b) :
(Definition of the term ‘accounting standard’)

 

46(2) : Utilisation of securities premium
account

 

49(1) : -do-

 

59(3) : Reduction of share capital

 

110(2) : Prescription of depreciation rates

 

117(1)

and

 

117(4) : Financial statements to comply with
accounting standards

 

201 :
Schemes of mergers and


amalgamations.




(Source : www.taxindiaonline.com, dated
8-9-2010)

 

levitra

CVC Report — A plan to curb corruption

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

10 CVC Report — A plan to curb corruption


It’s a truism that corruption is pervasive in
India. An equally troubling aspect is that our leaders, administrators and civil
society are aware of the problem. And in spite of a plethora of laws to control
the problem, it only continues to grow.

Now the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) has
issued a national anti-corruption strategy that it hopes will make a difference.
There is much to be said in favour of the report : It high-lights the issue very
well and makes a series of thoughtful solutions. But that is just about what CVC
can do. The levers that can ameliorate the problem lie elsewhere.

The matter is clearly highlighted in section III
of the report where CVC talks about the strategy to address political and
administrative corruption. The problem of funding electoral and other
expenditures of political parties is highlighted clearly. Insensitivity of civil
servants and their remoteness from citizens at large is also discussed.

The CVC’s solution to these problems is threefold.
One, strengthening political will to confront corruption; two, building ethical
competence in public officials; and finally, strengthening administrative
reforms. This is like putting the cart before the horse. If political will did
exist, then the matter would have been sorted out a long time ago.

By putting a large part of the onus on
strengthening of political will, CVC has taken the problem in a different,
psychological, direction. That is a different and intractable issue.

The solutions are fine on paper, as is the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The reality is very different and altogether
nasty.

(Source : The Mint, dated 30-8-2010)

(Can legal and administrative measures alone
eliminate corruption ?)

levitra

National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme — A joke worth Rs.1

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

9 National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme — A
joke worth Rs.1


 

Here’s the cruel underbelly of modern India :
Villagers in Rajasthan’s Tonk district are paid `1 per day for work under the
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS), and a State
Minister justifies it as consistent with the work done.

 

The political apathy and corruption that cause such
incidents are well known. But at issue are MGNREGS’ structural weaknesses which
make rooting corruption out a tough task. Why was the work not supervised for
quantity and quality ? Perhaps because, as a recent report suggests, village
leaders in the state discourage third-party supervision of MGNREGS.

Supervision is also required at higher levels — not
even the smallest amount of work justifies a wage of `1 per day. The problem is
little political will exists to undertake the high cost of monitoring
corruption. The results are conflicting responsibilities and interests for the
administration, and a cruel joke for the poor.

(Source : Quick Edit in The Mint Newspaper,
dated
30-8-2010)

[Is the cost incurred by our nation on our
non-performing MPs and MLAs and other political representatives justified ?]

 

levitra

SC — Damages for road deaths without deciding on guilty

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

8 SC — Damages for road deaths without deciding on
guilty


In two judgments last
week, the Supreme Court (SC) ruled that in road accidents, insurance companies
should pay compensation under the ‘no-fault liability’ clause in the Motor
Vehicles Act, irrespective of the circumstances of the deaths. In one appeal,
Indra Devi v. Bagada Ram,
the death was invited by the negligence of the
deceased driver himself. The Rajasthan HC asked the recipients of the
compensation to return the amount with interest to New India Assurance Co. as
the claimants were not entitled to the amount. The SC set aside the High Court
order and asserted the ‘no-fault liability’ u/s.140 of the Act did not depend
upon the conduct of the driver or the victim. In the second case, Eshwarappa
v. CS Gurushanthappa,
the drunk driver and his four friends died while
rashly driving to a temple without informing the car-owner. The Accidents
Tribunal denied any compensation. However, the SC ruled even in such cases,
‘no-fault liability’ cannot be avoided.

(Source : The
Business Standard, dated 23-8-2010)

levitra

Eight gifts that do not cost a penny !

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

7 Eight gifts that do not cost a penny !


1. The gift of
listening :

But you must REALLY
listen.

No interrupting, no
daydreaming,

No planning your
response.

Just listening.

2. The gift of
affection :

Be generous with
appropriate hugs,

Kisses, pats on the
back, and handholds.

Let these small
actions demonstrate the

Love you have for
family and friends.

3. The gift of
laughter :

Clip cartoons.

Share articles and
funny stories.

Your gift will say,
“I love to laugh with you.”

4. The gift of a
written note :

It can be a simple

“Thanks for the
help” note or a full sonnet.

A brief, handwritten
note may be remembered

For a lifetime, and
may even change a life.

5. The gift of a
compliment :

A simple and
sincere,

“You look great in
red,”

“You did a super
job,”

Or “That was a
wonderful meal”

Can make someone’s
day.

6. The gift of a
favour :

Every day, go out of
your way

To do something
kind.

7. The gift of
solitude :

There are times when
we want nothing better

Than to be left
alone.

Be sensitive to
those times and give

The gift of solitude
to others.

8. The gift of a
cheerful disposition :

The easiest way to
feel good is

To extend a kind
word to someone.

Really, it’s not
that hard to say,

“Hello” or “Thank
You”.

(Source :
Internet)

levitra

With Rs.75K crore stuck in disputes, Tax Department proposes e-solutions

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

5 With Rs.75K crore stuck in disputes, Tax
Department proposes e-solutions


 

The Income-tax Department has proposed a national
e-management system for quick disposal of tax disputes, with more than `75,000
crore, an amount close to a fifth of the Government’s annual direct tax
collections, locked in litigations.

The new system will allow the Tax Department to
make optimum use of its workforce, reduce painful wait for the disposal of tax
appeals and free up resources quickly.

The system would track the entire life cycle of
appeals to ensure expeditious settlement through a more equitable distribution.

More than 1.78 lakh appeals were pending with the
Commissioner Appeals (Income-tax), the first level of litigation, as on February
1, 2010, with amounts locked-up running into several thousands of crores.

(Source : The Economic Times, dated 30-8-2010)

(In our view, the real issues are lack of knowledge
and expertise, productivity and integrity in the Appellate machinery and
non-adherence to the decisions of the Higher Courts leading to repetitive
appeals.)

levitra

An obituary of Common Sense printed in the London Times

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

6 An obituary of Common Sense printed in the London
Times


 

Today we mourn the passing of a beloved old friend,
Common Sense, who has been with us for many years. No one knows for sure how old
he was, since his birth records were long ago lost in bureaucratic red tape. He
will be remembered as having cultivated such valuable lessons as :



  •   Knowing when to
    come during the rain;


  •   Why the early bird
    gets the worm;


  •   Life isn’t always
    fair; and


  •   Maybe it was my
    fault.


Common Sense lived by
simple, sound financial policies (don’t spend more than you can earn) and
reliable strategies (adults, not children, are in charge).

His health began to
deteriorate rapidly when well-intentioned but overbearing regulations were set
in place. Reports of a 6-year-old boy charged with sexual harassment for kissing
a classmate; teens suspended from school for using mouthwash after lunch; and a
teacher fired for reprimanding an unruly student, only worsened his condition.

Common Sense lost
ground when parents attacked teachers for doing the job that they themselves had
failed to do in disciplining their unruly children.

It declined even
further when schools were required to get parental consent to administer sun
lotion or an aspirin to a student; but could not inform parents when a student
became pregnant and wanted to have an abortion.

Common Sense lost the
will to live as the churches became businesses; and criminals received better
treatment than their victims.
Common Sense took a beating when you couldn’t defend yourself from a burglar in
your own home and the burglar could sue you for assault.
Common Sense finally gave up the will to live, after a woman failed to realise
that a steaming cup of coffee was hot. She spilled a little in her lap, and was
promptly awarded a huge settlement.

Common Sense was
preceded in death, by his parents, Truth and Trust, by his wife, Discretion, by
his daughter, Responsibility, and by his son, Reason.

He is survived by his
4 stepbrothers :

I Know My Rights

I Want It Now

Someone Else Is To
Blame

I’m A Victim

Not many attended his
funeral because so few realised he was gone. If you still remember him, pass
this on. If not, join the majority and do nothing.

(Source :
Internet)

levitra

I-T ex-official moves SC to make declaration of foreign bank A/cs mandatory while filing returns

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

4 I-T ex-official moves SC to make declaration of
foreign bank A/cs mandatory while filing returns



The Supreme Court has admitted a petition, filed by
a retired Chief Commissioner of Income-tax, which suggests that a legislation be
made to make it mandatory for taxpayers to declare offshore bank accounts while
filing annual returns. The premise behind the suggestion is to enable the
Government to take effective measures to seize wealth parked in Swiss and other
offshore bank accounts by Indian residents.

The petitioner is KVM Pai, retired Chief
Commissioner of Income tax, Mumbai and the suggestion it contains is in
consonance with the recent legislation passed in the US making it compulsory for
US residents to declare their offshore bank accounts, even if such declarations
do not yield any tax revenue. Mr. Pai also pitches for the setting up of an
intelligence unit under the auspices of the Income-tax administration to help
detect those who have illegal deposits in offshore banks and corroborate the
data with the information furnished in their tax returns.

Quoting a 1980 study carried out by International
Monetary Fund (IMF), Mr. Pai pointed out that Indians hold the largest share of
deposits in Swiss banks. Referring to other studies quoted in the petition, he
points out that there are deposits worth $ 11.6 trillion in tax havens. One such
reference relates to Raymond Baker’s ‘Capitalism’s Achilles Heel’ which holds
that half the world’s slush money lying in tax havens belongs to Indians. Mr.
Baker has recently estimated the annual capital flight to tax havens at $1
trillion per year.

Mr. Pai also states in his petition that the
governments of France and the US have been successful in securing the release of
huge unreported funds from Swiss banks belonging to US residents but the Indian
Government did not make any such serious effort except for scheduling meetings
with Swiss authorities.

Recently, due to pressure from the US and the UK,
the Swiss government agreed to disclose the names of account holders, but only
if the respective governments formally ask for it. It is understood that the
Swiss government has agreed to provide France the details of 3,000 French
customers who have deposits worth $ 4.3 billion in Swiss accounts and the US
government with details of 4,450 customers having $ 18 billion in deposits.

(Source : The Economic Times, dated 30-8-2010)

 

levitra

Return of double-dip fears — Jackson Hole conference shows US still not out of the hole

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

3 Return of double-dip fears — Jackson Hole
conference shows US still not out of the hole



We have come a long way from the ‘Great Panic of
2008’, but there’s a long road ahead to robust growth, confident consumer
spending and lower unemployment. That was the essence of US Federal Reserve
Chairman Ben Bernanke’s speech at this year’s Jackson Hole conference last week.
It was a rather subdued Mr. Bernanke who sought to reassure his audience, by all
accounts. Confessing candidly that “central bankers alone cannot solve the
world’s problems”, Mr. Bernanke exuded guarded
optimism about the sustainability of the ongoing recovery in the US economy. He
conceded that the recovery “appears somewhat less vigorous than we expected”,
and did not rule out the possibility of deflationary tendencies reasserting
themselves. The thrust of Mr. Bernanke’s statement, which his critics have
attacked as “Nero fiddling while Rome is burning”, was to suggest that the good
news from the US economy was not good enough. Based on the latest national
income growth data for the US, released last week, US authorities have revised
downward the annual estimated rate of growth from the more optimistic initial
number of 2.4% to a significantly lower 1.6% in the quarter ending June 2010.
Export growth is near zero, unemployment levels are high and consumer spending
is still weak. “The prospect of high unemployment for a long period of time,”
said Mr. Bernanke, “remains a central concern of policy.”


Mr. Bernanke’s prognosis suggests that the spectre
of double-dip recession continues to haunt US policy-makers. It is now clear
that the economic slowdown the US faces is more structural than cyclical. This
means there are limits to monetary policy, a fact that Mr. Bernanke openly
confessed even as he assured his audience that the US Federal Open Market
Committee (FOMC) would be open to using all the weapons in its monetary policy
arsenal to stimulate growth, prevent deflation and ensure price stability.
Ending his speech, Mr. Bernanke said, rather chillingly, “Although what I have
just described is, I believe, the most plausible outcome, macroeconomic
projections are inherently uncertain, and the economy remains vulnerable to
unexpected developments.” That is more than a sobering thought. Are Mr. Bernanke
and his Jackson Hole companions being more cautious than necessary or more
optimistic than warranted ? Perhaps the Jackson Hole audience was trying to make
up for past hubris or is afflicted by the paranoia of failed magicians. The
problem for the US is that while monetary policy is unlikely to make much of a
difference, there isn’t much room for fiscal policy either, though the Barack
Obama administration has done more than most developed country governments to
use fiscal policy to stimulate demand. The US needs a boost of confidence in
itself and an investment in its capabilities.

(Source : The Business Standard, dated
30-8-2010)

levitra

Tax evasion at the top

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

2 Tax evasion at the top


The Government gave out some interesting numbers.
The Revenue Secretary told a news conference that nearly 96% of the 32.5 million
who pay income-tax reported a taxable income of under `5 lakh; and only 2.2% (i.e.,
715,000 people) reported taxable income of over `8 lakh. Why is this
interesting ? Because when you match these with the income numbers put out by
the National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER), on the basis of its
household surveys, some numbers make sense while others don’t. For instance,
NCAER projected for 2009-10 that some 32.3 million households would have annual
incomes of over `2 lakh — which is a reasonably good fit with the total number
of people paying income-tax (the threshold being taxable income of Rs.1.6 lakh).

When you look at the high-income category, however,
the numbers diverge hugely. NCAER says that in 2009-10, there should have been
3.8 million families with annual income of over Rs.10 lakh, a figure that is
more than five times the 715,000 people who report income over `8 lakh (on the
plausible assumption that taxable income of `8 lakh is broadly compatible with
total income of Rs.10 lakh, because of the various tax exemptions available).
Admittedly, some households have more than one income earner, so it could be a
case of clubbing the incomes of husband and wife. Still, it would appear that,
while there is probably not much tax evasion by the middle class, those in the
upper class continue to be predominantly tax evaders.

The good news is that the extent of evasion may be
coming down — sharply. Back in 2004-05, only 122,000 people reported taxable
income of over Rs.10 lakh, whereas nearly six times that number now report
taxable incomes of over Rs.8 lakh. While incomes have been rising rapidly at the
top of the pyramid, few would have expected that India’s highest earners would
multiply so rapidly over five years. In other words, tax compliance has improved
dramatically — but even then, the scope for much greater compliance exists.

That conclusion would be contested by Surjit Bhalla,
who has argued that the rich are the most tax compliant group in the country
(with only 50% practising evasion !). He has used National Sample Survey data to
contend that there were 250,000 people with incomes over Rs.10 lakh in 2004-05
(when there were only 122,000 people reporting that amount of tax income), and
that the population of high-income earners would have gone up to 360,000 in
2006-07. On that kind of track, the number by 2009-10 should have been about
620,000. But since we have 715,000 reporting taxable income of `8 lakh and more,
it looks like 100% tax compliance by the high-rollers —which strains credulity.

Still, if compliance is improving, thank the spread
of tax deduction at source, and the cross-matching of computerised data with
regard to credit card spends, mutual fund investments and the like. But if one
were to assume that three-box cars are bought by only those in this income
bracket, there is another data point worth looking at — because 350,000
three-box cars were sold in the country last year. On the assumption that most
people buy a new car after five years, this figure too suggests many more
high-income people than exist in the tax records.

The point of focussing on this group is that 60% of
all income-tax revenue (or Rs.72,000 crore) comes from these 715,000 people ! If
the number coming into this category were to double, income-tax collections
would go through the roof.





(Source :
The Business Standard, dated 4-9-2010

— Weekend
Ruminations by T. N. Ninan)




levitra

Centre moves SC on levy of service tax on rental income

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

Miscellanea

Raman Jokhakar
Tarunkumar Singhal
Chartered Accountants

15 Centre moves SC on levy of service tax on
rental income

 

The Centre today sought the Supreme Court’s intervention in
deciding the constitutional validity of the Finance Act, 2007 that empowers the
Government to impose service tax on rental income from commercial properties.

A Bench headed by Justice B. N. Agrawal while seeking reply
from Retailers’ Association of India, Confederation of Real Estate Developers’
Associations of India and Multiplex Association of India
on the transfer petition filed by the Centre also stayed proceedings before
various High Courts.

The Centre through the Department of Revenue has sought
transfer of petitions pending before the High Courts of Bombay, Madras, Kolkata,
Punjab and Haryana and Kerala on the ground that there was a likelihood of
conflicting decisions.

According to the petition, retailers, real estate developers
and multiplex owners had filed writ petitions before various High Courts
challenging levy of service tax on leasing, letting, renting or any other
similar arrangement in respect of immovable property for use in furtherance of
business or commerce.

It further said that they had challenged the constitutional
validity of the Finance Act, 2007 on the ground that it was beyond the
legislative competence of the Union and thus Parliament cannot levy
such a tax.

(Source : Internet, 19-8-2008 —

Also widely reported in print media)


levitra

SC asks tax authorities to seek technical help

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

1 SC asks tax
authorities to seek technical help


The Supreme Court has asked the Central Board of
Direct Taxes (CBDT) and other tax authorities to get help of technical experts
while deciding income-tax liability of cellular service providers.

The order came after a batch of appeals by
income-tax authorities against the ruling of the Tribunal favouring Bharti
Cellular Ltd. and other service providers. The question was whether manual
intervention was involved in the technical operations by which cellular service
providers were given the facility by BSNL/MTNL for interconnection.

A related question was whether TDS was to be
deducted by service providers when they paid interconnect charges/access/port
charges to BSNL.

“The problem which arises in these cases is that
there is no expert evidence from the side of the Department to show how human
intervention takes place, particularly, during the process when calls take
place,” the order passed by a Bench headed by Chief Justice S. H. Kapadia said.
“We are only highlighting these facts to emphasise that these types of matters
cannot be decided without any technical assistance available on record.”

The Supreme Court underlined “with the emergence of
our country as one of the BRIC countries and with the technological advancement,
matters like the present one will keep on recurring and hence, the time has come
when the Department should examine technical experts so that the matters could
be disposed of expeditiously and further it would enable the Appellate forums,
including this Court, to decide legal issues based on factual foundation.”

(Source : The Business Standard, dated
23-8-2010)

levitra

Cyber News

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

14 Cyber News

Design flaws in bank sites

A
majority of websites suffer from design-related flaws which could make their
customers vulnerable to cyber-theft, according to a recent study by Atul Prakash,
an Indian-American professor at the University of Michigan and his doctoral
students, Laura Falk and Kevin Borders. The team surveyed web-sites of 214
financial institutions and found that three-fourths of them had at least one
design flaw. Significantly, these were not flaws that could be fixed with a
patch, but stemmed from the very flow and layout of the sites, the researchers
revealed “Our focus was on users who try to be careful, but unfortunately some
bank sites make it hard for customers to make the right security decisions when
doing online banking,” Prakash said. Such flaws leave cracks in security that
hackers could exploit to gain access to private information and accounts, the
study noted.

 

  Studying abroad

A
California-based education information provider recently launched
www.studyplaces.com, targeted primarily at Indian students who form a chunk of
overseas universities in many parts of the world. The portal disseminates
information, connects and guides students to over 2,00,000 courses from 10,000
colleges worldwide including universities in India, the US, UK, Europe,
Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, Canada and West Asia. It utilises the
expertise of professionals, many of them alumni of Stanford, IIMS, IITS and
Wharton, to offer guidance to students looking for higher study options. “The
portal is an attempt to help students make the right career choice based on
credible information and professional counseling,” says founder Amitabh Nagpal.
It offers platform for career counselling and college planning and helps
students find, compare, evaluate and select the right course and institution. In
addition, it provides free online counselling and free practice tests for AIFEE,
GMAT, IIT-JEE, TOEFL, etc. The site has a team of 20 counselors, each
specialising in one or more educational domains, which use tools such as
psychometric tests to ascertain students’ aptitude and interests. The students
can also access information on fee structures, expenses involved, life on
campus, and application procedures.

 

  Saving time

The
Wall Street’s www. ExecutiveLibrary.com is an amazing site for those interested
in accessing information for research and other uses. Since early 1990s, the
world has been using the Net to research finance, stocks, economic trends,
demographics, and industry information. And the problem has been not a lack of
information but a surfeit of data, with fewer and fewer sources providing useful
information. To address this, the portal has created a public directory that
lists only the most relevant business sites. Currently, the portal has links to
1,500 useful sites where users can read news, research companies, get answers to
legal questions, hunt for jobs, look up medical information, download software,
and find other information. In addition to a content-heavy homepage, which lists
hundreds of news and reference sources, users can avail the research link which
provides access to the government, financial market research, statistics,
economy, business and law, marketing and advertising information. In that sense,
it’s a great time-saver for those who use the Net for professional and credible
information on a regular basis.

(Source
: Business India, 21-9-2008)

levitra

Delhi High Court convicted Senior

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

13 Delhi High Court convicted
Senior

Advocates

The Delhi High Court convicted senior advocates R.
K. Anand and I. U. Khan in the BMW expose case for obstructing administration of
justice. “They are senior advocates and they did not tender either conditional
or unconditional apology for their conduct in the BMW case,” a Division Bench of
Justices Manmohan Sarin and Madan B. Lokur said, in their 112-page verdict in
the contempt case relating to the expose.


Recommending that they be stripped of their
designation of senior advocate, the Court asked them not to appear in the Delhi
High Court and its subordinate Courts for the next four months as punishment.


The Bench also imposed a fine of Rs.2,000 on each
of them and rapped them for their ‘irresponsible’ behaviour, saying “we are not
dealing with young lawyers. Both are seasoned lawyers and such conduct was not
expected of them.

(Source : Internet, 21-8-2008

— Also widely reported in print media)

levitra

Foreign cos must report exempted income to I-T.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

12 Foreign cos must report exempted income to I-T.


Taxmen will now be able to keep a closer tab on
income exempt under foreign tax treaties. The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT)
has said that any income arising in India, but exempt from the country’s tax
laws, because of a double tax avoidance treaty, must be first reported to the
Tax Department before availing the exemption.

Even if the income is taxable outside India, the
assessee must include it in the total income chargeable to tax in India, the
board has said in a recent notification. “Relief will be granted in accordance
with the method for elimination or avoidance of double taxation provided in such
agreement,” the Notification added.

With a large number of foreign companies operating
in India, the Department has found that there are many cases where either they
are not reporting their exempt income or underreporting it.

While the assessee can avail the same foreign tax
credit even now, the Tax Department will get a much better understanding of his
earnings, a Finance Ministry official explained.

The Department’s missive, however, only relates to
earnings of resident companies and individuals. Tax experts are of the view that
with increased movement of workers and the cross-border nexus between companies,
the Notification will help the Department get a better understanding of the
income of such assessees.

“It looks like the Department’s intention is to get
a complete picture of a person’s global earnings regardless of the benefits
under the tax treaties,” Amitabh Singh, partner Ernst and Young said. The
clarification is the latest in the CBDT’s efforts to plug loopholes in the
country’s international tax laws given that a large number of MNCs have set up
shops in India through back offices and subsidiaries and are availing benefits
under tax treaties.

(Source : Internet, 8-9-2008)

levitra

Plastic containers may be deadly for your brain.

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

11 Plastic containers may be
deadly for your brain.


Plastic containers may be deadly for your brain.
Canadian researchers have found that Bisphenol A (BPA), the chemical used in
making plastic containers, might be responsible for impairing many brain
functions such as learning and remembering.

They also fear that it could be a factor behind
Alzheimer’s, schizophrenia and depression.

BPA is globally used in making plastic water
bottles, baby food bottles, food containers and dental prostheses.

In their study, the researchers at the University
of Guelph found that BPA might be leaking into the solid or liquid foods kept in
the plastic containers.

When these foods and liquids are consumed, they
said, the chemical might be getting into the human system, disrupting
communication between brain neurons which is vital in understanding and
remembering.

(Source : The Times of India, 5-9-2008)

 

levitra

MNCs seek detectives’ help to check IPR violations

fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

10 MNCs seek detectives’ help to
check IPR violations


In order to provide brand protection and curb
duplication of products, IT, pharma, electronics, telecom and electrical goods
manufacturing giants are approaching private detectives to safeguard them
against Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) violation.


Detective agencies have also been approached by
national and international industry associations to extend help for safeguarding
their products.


According to an ongoing study commissioned by the
Ministry of Human Resource Development, the estimated losses due to piracy in
motion pictures is 7.3%, sound recordings and musical compositions 24.5%, books
21%, and the highest is in the software domain, reaching 292.8%.

While recent trend of piracy has badly affected
Indian film and musical industry, we are doing our best to bring this fake
business to end.

To recommend improvements in the working of the
Intellectual Property (IP) regime in India in terms of IT enabling and
networking of operations and enhancing human resource capabilities, the
Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industries (Ficci) and Department
of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP), Ministry of Commerce and Industry,
have also joined hands to set up a working group.

DIPP has taken note of Ficci’s recommendations and
it has been decided to digitise all the patents granted till date and open it up
for online public access.

Showing concern over the trend, the patent office
has started e-filing of patent and trademark applications through its website
http://www.patentoffice.nic.in.

The term ‘Intellectual Property’ reflects the idea
that its subject matter is the product of the mind or the intellect. These could
be in the form of patents, trademarks, geographical indications, industrial
designs, layout-designs (topographies) of integrated circuits, plant variety
protection and copyright.

According to the data released by the industries
body, the filing of patent applications has increased from 4,824 in the year
1999-2000 to 28,882 applications in the year 2006-07. The grant of patents has
shot up from 1,881 in 1999-2000 to 7,359 in 2006-07.

“Although companies and administration are doing
their best to stop it, we feel that a separate wing from the government to
tackle this crime would help us and the firms,” an expert said.

(Source : Business Standard, 25-8-2008)

 

levitra