Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!
January 2026
Accountancy and Audit
  • From Published Accounts

    From Published Accounts

    By Himanshu Kishnadwala, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 11 mins
  • IND AS/IGAAP - Interpretation & Practical Application

    Selling a Business… But What about the Goodwill?

    By Dolphy D’souza | Geetanshu Bansal, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 8 mins
Articles
  • Article

    Assessment and Appeals under the Income Tax Act, 2025

    By Anil Sathe, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 14 mins

    DPDP Law, Cyber Security and Chartered Accountants

    By Apoorva Bookseller, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 11 mins

    Income-Tax Act, 2025: TDS & TCS Provisions

    By Nilesh Kapadia | Dhruva Kapadia, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 14 mins

    India’s New Labour Codes

    By Peeyush Sharma, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 17 mins

    Understanding Scope 2 Emissions And Why They Matter

    By NVS Pawan Kumar, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 18 mins
Corporate And Other Laws
  • Allied Laws

    Allied Laws

    By Dr. K. Shivaram, Senior Advocate, Rahul K. Hakani | Shashi Bekal, Advocates
    Reading Time 9 mins
  • Corporate Law Corner

    Company Law

    By Pramod Prabhudesai, Chartered Accountant | Kaushik M. Jhaveri, Company Secretary
    Reading Time 9 mins
  • Laws And Business

    Transmission Of Securities

    By Dr Anup P. Shah, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 15 mins
  • Securities Laws

    Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs): Decoding the Structure, Purpose, and Investment Merits

    By Bhavesh Vora | Khushbu Shah, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 10 mins
Direct Taxes
  • Controversies

    Registration under Section 12A in Cases of an Object for Application outside India

    By Pradip Kapasi | Gautam Nayak | Bhadresh Doshi, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 20 mins
  • Glimpses Of Supreme Court Rulings

    Glimpses of Supreme Court Rulings

    By Kishor Karia, Chartered Accountant | Atul Jasani, Advocate
    Reading Time 15 mins
  • In the High Courts: Part A-Reported Decisions

    Appeal to High Court u/s. 260A — Additional question of law raised for first time in High Court — Jurisdiction of High Court — General principles — Assessee-company merged with another and ceased to exist — Assessment in name of non-existing entity(Merged company) — Question whether assessment order passed on non-existing entity is void — Question involving jurisdictional issue not raised before Tribunal — Whether merits consideration — Held by High Court that the additionally proposed question of law involved in these appeals is involving jurisdictional issue and hence included.

    By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
    Reading Time 5 mins

    Charitable trust — Exemption u/s. 11 — Exception u/s. 13 — Salary paid to chairperson treated as payment to person prohibited u/s. 13(3) — AO held the payment is excessive and disallowed 30 per cent of the salary u/s. 40A(2)(a) — CIT(A) deleted addition finding salary reasonable — Tribunal dismissed the appeal filed by Department after examining qualification and experience of chairperson — Held, reasonable remuneration for services rendered did not constitute benefit u/s. 13(1)(c) — Assessee entitled to exemption u/s. 11.

    By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
    Reading Time 4 mins

    Offences and prosecution — Compounding of offences — Delay — Compounding application was rejected solely on the ground of delay of 36 months from date of filing complaint — Held, limitation period stipulated in CBDT guidelines — Guidelines treated as binding statutes without exercising discretion — Where Act provided no limitation period, rigid time-line through guidelines is impermissible — Held, mechanical rejection of application without considering facts and circumstances is improper — Order set aside and matter remanded for reconsideration exercising proper discretion.

    By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Revision u/s. 264 — Revision of intimation issued u/s. 143(1) accepting the returned income — Revision application filed pursuant to decision of Jurisdictional Tribunal in S. K. Ventures — — Rejection of application by CIT — Decision of Jurisdictional Tribunal not acceptable to the Department — High Court held — CIT bound to follow Jurisdictional Tribunal — Merely because order is challenged in appeal before the High Court cannot be the ground to not follow.

    By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
    Reading Time 5 mins

    Search and seizure — Assessment of any other person — Satisfaction note — Time of recording satisfaction note — Permissible stages — If not recorded immediately after completion of searched person’s assessment —Proceedings are invalid — Delay of 22 months in recording satisfaction note — Contrary to Circular No. 24/2015 — Notice issued u/s. 153C quashed and set-aside.

    By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
    Reading Time 4 mins
  • In The High Courts: Part B-Unreported Decisions

    Document Identification Number – mandate of Circular 19/2019 dated 14.08.2019 sets out the requirement of all communications from the department to bear a DIN. Section 154(7) – Rectification – Not permissible after the expiry of four years from the end of the Financial Year in which the order sought to be amended/rectified was passed.

    By Ajay R. Singh, Advocate
    Reading Time 20 mins
  • Tribunal News: Part A-Domestic Taxation

    Assessee is liable to deduct tax at source under section 194-IC even though the agreement has been entered into with a person who is not owner of land but has leasehold rights therein.

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Penalty under section 270A is not leviable merely because assessee has declared income under a head different from which the Assessing Officer assessed it.

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Minimum Guarantee Fee paid to various hotels / guest houses for not meeting contractual obligations for unsold rooms and loss from sold rooms is not rent as per section 194-I of the Act.

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 4 mins

    Assessment order passed u/s 143(3) by ACIT is valid despite notice u/s 143(2) having been issued by ITO and ACIT since the territorial jurisdiction of the ITO and the ACIT/DCIT working in the same Range is common and within the common jurisdiction, the cases are assigned to the ITO and to the ACIT/DCIT on the basis of the monetary limit.

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 6 mins

    Where milk procurement from farmers was not a standalone profit-oriented business, but an incidental and inseparable activity directly connected to the charitable object of the assessee-society of providing fair and remunerative prices to small and marginal farmers and thereby protecting them from exploitation by middlemen, the activities of the assessee fell within “relief of poor” under section 2(15) and exemption under section 11 could not be denied to it on the ground that it was carrying on commercial activity.

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Where the amount received by the assessee from milk supplying societies was not a voluntary contribution but a compulsory levy linked to the quantity of milk fat supplied, it could not be regarded as a corpus donation exempt under section 11(1)(d).

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Merely because the assessee jointly owned another property as on the date of transfer of the asset, his claim for deduction under section 54F could not be rejected.

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 2 mins

    Section 271(1)(c) read with section 54F – Penalty – Wrong claim of exemption – Bona fide explanation due to builder’s default

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Section 143(2) read with section 120 – Assessment framed by non-jurisdictional Assessing Officer

    By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
    Reading Time 2 mins
  • Tribunal News: Part B: International Tax Decisions

    Articles 8 and 11 of India-Ireland DTAA – Consideration received towards lease of aircraft is taxable as operating lease in terms of Article 8 of India-Ireland DTAA and not as interest in terms of Article 11; therefore, right to tax such income is vested only with Resident State.

    By Geeta Jani | Dhishat B Mehta | K. Prasanna, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 3 mins

    Article 5 of India-Japan DTAA – Seconded employee who worked under the supervision and control of the Indian entity could not constitute fixed place permanent establishment of the Foreign Company

    By Geeta Jani | Dhishat B Mehta | K. Prasanna, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 2 mins
Editorial
  • Editorial

    CA Firm Of 2030

    By CA Sunil Gabhawalla, Editor
    Reading Time 4 mins
From The President
  • From The President

    From The President

    By CA Zubin F. Billimoria, President
    Reading Time 5 mins
Indirect Taxes
  • Decoding GST

    Place of Supply of Goods In Case Of Ex-Works Transactions

    By Sunil Gabhawalla | Rishabh Singhvi | Parth Shah, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 12 mins
  • Recent Decisions: Part A: Goods and Services Tax

    Goods And Services Tax

    By Puloma Dalal | Jayesh Gogri | Mandar Telang, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 19 mins
  • Recent Developments In GST

    Recent Developments in GST

    By G. G. Goyal, Chartered Accountant | C. B. Thakar, Advocate
    Reading Time 17 mins
Namaskaar
  • Namaskaar

    इष्टम् धर्मेण योजयेत् !

    By C. N. Vaze, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 3 mins
News And Views
  • ICAI And Its Members

    ICAI and Its Members

    By Paras Savla, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 12 mins
  • Light Elements

    Revelation

    By C. N. Vaze, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 3 mins
  • Miscellanea

    Miscellanea

    By Jhankhana Thakkar | Chirag Chauhan, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 4 mins
  • Regulatory Referencer

    Regulatory Referencer

    By Rutvik Sanghvi | Sonalee Godbole, Chartered Accountants
    Reading Time 3 mins
  • Society News

    Learning Events at BCAS

    By Mandar Telang | Mrinal Mehta, Hon. Jt. Secretaries
    Reading Time 23 mins
  • Tech Mantra

    Tech Mantra

    By Yazdi Tantra, Chartered Accountant
    Reading Time 4 mins

From Published Accounts

From Published Accounts

By Himanshu Kishnadwala, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 11 mins

IND AS/IGAAP - Interpretation & Practical Application

Selling a Business… But What about the Goodwill?

By Dolphy D’souza | Geetanshu Bansal, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 8 mins

Article

Assessment and Appeals under the Income Tax Act, 2025

By Anil Sathe, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 14 mins

DPDP Law, Cyber Security and Chartered Accountants

By Apoorva Bookseller, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 11 mins

Income-Tax Act, 2025: TDS & TCS Provisions

By Nilesh Kapadia | Dhruva Kapadia, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 14 mins

India’s New Labour Codes

By Peeyush Sharma, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 17 mins

Understanding Scope 2 Emissions And Why They Matter

By NVS Pawan Kumar, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 18 mins

Allied Laws

Allied Laws

By Dr. K. Shivaram, Senior Advocate, Rahul K. Hakani | Shashi Bekal, Advocates
Reading Time 9 mins

Corporate Law Corner

Company Law

By Pramod Prabhudesai, Chartered Accountant | Kaushik M. Jhaveri, Company Secretary
Reading Time 9 mins

Laws And Business

Transmission Of Securities

By Dr Anup P. Shah, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 15 mins

Securities Laws

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs): Decoding the Structure, Purpose, and Investment Merits

By Bhavesh Vora | Khushbu Shah, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 10 mins

Controversies

Registration under Section 12A in Cases of an Object for Application outside India

By Pradip Kapasi | Gautam Nayak | Bhadresh Doshi, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 20 mins

Glimpses Of Supreme Court Rulings

Glimpses of Supreme Court Rulings

By Kishor Karia, Chartered Accountant | Atul Jasani, Advocate
Reading Time 15 mins

In the High Courts: Part A-Reported Decisions

Appeal to High Court u/s. 260A — Additional question of law raised for first time in High Court — Jurisdiction of High Court — General principles — Assessee-company merged with another and ceased to exist — Assessment in name of non-existing entity(Merged company) — Question whether assessment order passed on non-existing entity is void — Question involving jurisdictional issue not raised before Tribunal — Whether merits consideration — Held by High Court that the additionally proposed question of law involved in these appeals is involving jurisdictional issue and hence included.

By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
Reading Time 5 mins

Charitable trust — Exemption u/s. 11 — Exception u/s. 13 — Salary paid to chairperson treated as payment to person prohibited u/s. 13(3) — AO held the payment is excessive and disallowed 30 per cent of the salary u/s. 40A(2)(a) — CIT(A) deleted addition finding salary reasonable — Tribunal dismissed the appeal filed by Department after examining qualification and experience of chairperson — Held, reasonable remuneration for services rendered did not constitute benefit u/s. 13(1)(c) — Assessee entitled to exemption u/s. 11.

By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
Reading Time 4 mins

Offences and prosecution — Compounding of offences — Delay — Compounding application was rejected solely on the ground of delay of 36 months from date of filing complaint — Held, limitation period stipulated in CBDT guidelines — Guidelines treated as binding statutes without exercising discretion — Where Act provided no limitation period, rigid time-line through guidelines is impermissible — Held, mechanical rejection of application without considering facts and circumstances is improper — Order set aside and matter remanded for reconsideration exercising proper discretion.

By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
Reading Time 3 mins

Revision u/s. 264 — Revision of intimation issued u/s. 143(1) accepting the returned income — Revision application filed pursuant to decision of Jurisdictional Tribunal in S. K. Ventures — — Rejection of application by CIT — Decision of Jurisdictional Tribunal not acceptable to the Department — High Court held — CIT bound to follow Jurisdictional Tribunal — Merely because order is challenged in appeal before the High Court cannot be the ground to not follow.

By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
Reading Time 5 mins

Search and seizure — Assessment of any other person — Satisfaction note — Time of recording satisfaction note — Permissible stages — If not recorded immediately after completion of searched person’s assessment —Proceedings are invalid — Delay of 22 months in recording satisfaction note — Contrary to Circular No. 24/2015 — Notice issued u/s. 153C quashed and set-aside.

By Keshav Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
Reading Time 4 mins

In The High Courts: Part B-Unreported Decisions

Document Identification Number – mandate of Circular 19/2019 dated 14.08.2019 sets out the requirement of all communications from the department to bear a DIN. Section 154(7) – Rectification – Not permissible after the expiry of four years from the end of the Financial Year in which the order sought to be amended/rectified was passed.

By Ajay R. Singh, Advocate
Reading Time 20 mins

Tribunal News: Part A-Domestic Taxation

Assessee is liable to deduct tax at source under section 194-IC even though the agreement has been entered into with a person who is not owner of land but has leasehold rights therein.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 3 mins

Penalty under section 270A is not leviable merely because assessee has declared income under a head different from which the Assessing Officer assessed it.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 3 mins

Minimum Guarantee Fee paid to various hotels / guest houses for not meeting contractual obligations for unsold rooms and loss from sold rooms is not rent as per section 194-I of the Act.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 4 mins

Assessment order passed u/s 143(3) by ACIT is valid despite notice u/s 143(2) having been issued by ITO and ACIT since the territorial jurisdiction of the ITO and the ACIT/DCIT working in the same Range is common and within the common jurisdiction, the cases are assigned to the ITO and to the ACIT/DCIT on the basis of the monetary limit.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 6 mins

Where milk procurement from farmers was not a standalone profit-oriented business, but an incidental and inseparable activity directly connected to the charitable object of the assessee-society of providing fair and remunerative prices to small and marginal farmers and thereby protecting them from exploitation by middlemen, the activities of the assessee fell within “relief of poor” under section 2(15) and exemption under section 11 could not be denied to it on the ground that it was carrying on commercial activity.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 3 mins

Where the amount received by the assessee from milk supplying societies was not a voluntary contribution but a compulsory levy linked to the quantity of milk fat supplied, it could not be regarded as a corpus donation exempt under section 11(1)(d).

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 3 mins

Merely because the assessee jointly owned another property as on the date of transfer of the asset, his claim for deduction under section 54F could not be rejected.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 2 mins

Section 271(1)(c) read with section 54F – Penalty – Wrong claim of exemption – Bona fide explanation due to builder’s default

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 3 mins

Section 143(2) read with section 120 – Assessment framed by non-jurisdictional Assessing Officer

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant Devendra Jain & Aditya Bhatt, Advocates
Reading Time 2 mins

Tribunal News: Part B: International Tax Decisions

Articles 8 and 11 of India-Ireland DTAA – Consideration received towards lease of aircraft is taxable as operating lease in terms of Article 8 of India-Ireland DTAA and not as interest in terms of Article 11; therefore, right to tax such income is vested only with Resident State.

By Geeta Jani | Dhishat B Mehta | K. Prasanna, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 3 mins

Article 5 of India-Japan DTAA – Seconded employee who worked under the supervision and control of the Indian entity could not constitute fixed place permanent establishment of the Foreign Company

By Geeta Jani | Dhishat B Mehta | K. Prasanna, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 2 mins

Editorial

CA Firm Of 2030

By CA Sunil Gabhawalla, Editor
Reading Time 4 mins

From The President

From The President

By CA Zubin F. Billimoria, President
Reading Time 5 mins

Decoding GST

Place of Supply of Goods In Case Of Ex-Works Transactions

By Sunil Gabhawalla | Rishabh Singhvi | Parth Shah, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 12 mins

Recent Decisions: Part A: Goods and Services Tax

Goods And Services Tax

By Puloma Dalal | Jayesh Gogri | Mandar Telang, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 19 mins

Recent Developments In GST

Recent Developments in GST

By G. G. Goyal, Chartered Accountant | C. B. Thakar, Advocate
Reading Time 17 mins

Namaskaar

इष्टम् धर्मेण योजयेत् !

By C. N. Vaze, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 3 mins

ICAI And Its Members

ICAI and Its Members

By Paras Savla, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 12 mins

Light Elements

Revelation

By C. N. Vaze, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 3 mins

Miscellanea

Miscellanea

By Jhankhana Thakkar | Chirag Chauhan, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 4 mins

Regulatory Referencer

Regulatory Referencer

By Rutvik Sanghvi | Sonalee Godbole, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 3 mins

Society News

Learning Events at BCAS

By Mandar Telang | Mrinal Mehta, Hon. Jt. Secretaries
Reading Time 23 mins

Tech Mantra

Tech Mantra

By Yazdi Tantra, Chartered Accountant
Reading Time 4 mins