Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

Learning Events At BCAS

I. BCAS HOSTS DISTINGUISHED INTERACTION WITH ICAI LEADERSHIP

On Thursday, 12th March 2026, a close interaction was organised at the BCAS Office, Jolly Bhavan, featuring CA Prasanna Kumar D, President ICAI, and CA Mangesh Pandurang Kinare, Vice President ICAI. The dignitaries were warmly felicitated by CA Zubin Billimoria, President BCAS, and CA Kinjal Shah, Vice President BCAS, in the presence of select BCAS past presidents, office bearers, Western Region Central Council Members, WIRC ICAI office bearers and elected members, and BCAS Core Group members.

The session, moderated by CA Zubin Billimoria, facilitated a structured, time-bound discussion on key professional issues, including:

  • Representation before the Charity Commissioner
  • Policy sustainability for professional growth
  • Freedom to operate and regulatory minimisation
  • Clarity in networking guidelines
  • Updates on Delhi High Court litigation concerning CAs’ representation rights before Tribunals
  • Profession vs industry dynamics
  • Top three opportunities and challenges facing the profession
  • Future of audit, ethics, and stakeholder expectations
  • Capacity building in audit, technology, and AI
  • CA employability and syllabus dynamism

CA Prasanna Kumar D and CA Mangesh Pandurang Kinare responded thoughtfully to members’ queries, sharing ICAI’s strategic vision and forthcoming developments. The interaction concluded with collaborative ideas for strengthening BCAS-ICAI coordination to advance the chartered accountancy profession.

BCAS-Hosts-Interaction-with-distinguished-ICAI-Leadership BCAS-Hosts-Interaction-with-distinguished-ICAI-Leadership BCAS-Hosts-Interaction-with-distinguished-ICAI-Leadership BCAS-Hosts-Interaction-with-distinguished-ICAI-Leadership

II. Learning Events At BCAS

1. Sakhi Circle – International Women’s Day held on 14th March 2026@ BCAS.

Speakers: Panelists – Hetal Kotak, Nisha Gala

Moderator – Kinjal Bhuta

The Women’s Day Celebration hosted by BCAS featured an engaging panel discussion on Ambition without Apology.

The event opened with an insightful panel discussion that highlighted how careers move through varied phases—from moments of doubt to moments where one’s voice is valued. The panel emphasised themes of continuous learning, authenticity, and staying relevant in a dynamic work environment.

A rapid-fire segment added energy to the discussion, drawing spontaneous and practical insights from the panelists. The evening concluded with a networking activity where participants introduced themselves using two adjectives, prompting self-reflection and encouraging authentic engagement within the group.

The session also reinforced that in person interactions create meaningful value, especially for women professionals, as shared experiences often help them draw strength from one another. Participants agreed that opportunities to connect, converse and collaborate play a vital role in personal and professional growth.

Sakhi-Circle-International-Womens-Day Sakhi-Circle-International-Womens-Day

2. Seminar on Attachment and Seizure Provisions under Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 held on Friday, 27th February 2026 @ Hybrid

This event was jointly organised by Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, along with the Commercial & Allied Law Committee of The Chamber of Tax Consultants at the BCAS Auditorium, Churchgate and was conducted as a hybrid event, with participants attending both physically and virtually.

The details of the program was as follows:

Topic Session Summary Faculty
Opening Remarks by CA Kinjal Shah, Vice President BCAS and CA Jayant Gokhale  President CTC
Session I : Keynote Address on the Framework of Search & Seizure under Section 17 of followed by an Interactive Discussion on Defense Strategies and Compliance Informative session which explained the scope of powers vested in the enforcement authorities, the statutory requirement of “reason to believe,” and the procedural safeguards that must be followed during the conduct of such actions. The address also touched on important judicial interpretations that shape the application of the provision. The session provided participants with valuable insights into both the investigative powers under the law and the practical approaches for handling such proceedings. Hon’ble Justice Ms. Aarti Sathe, Judge, Hon’ble Bombay High Court

 

Adv. Sunny Punamiya

CA Shardul Shah

 

Moderator: CA Apurva Shah

 

Session II: Keynote Address on the Framework of Attachment under Sections 5 & 8 of PMLA followed by an Interactive Discussion on the Attachment Procedure Enlightening lecture which explained the concept of provisional attachment, the conditions required for invoking such powers, and the procedure followed by the Enforcement Directorate before and after passing an attachment order. The address also highlighted the role of the Adjudicating Authority under Section 8 in confirming or setting aside the attachment after providing an opportunity of hearing. The session provided an overview of the practical aspects, legal safeguards, and key considerations for professionals dealing with such proceedings, enabling participants to gain a clearer understanding of the statutory process and its implications. Hon’ble Justice Shri. Advaith Sethna, Judge, Hon’ble Bombay High Court

 

Adv. Sunny Punamiya

Adv. Bernardo Reis

 

Moderator: CA Kinjal Shah

 

 

The Seminar provided a comprehensive perspective on the framework of search and seizure and attachment proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, and featured two insightful and interactive sessions that simplified the legal and procedural complexities surrounding these provisions.

The program had 10 physical attendees and 108 virtual attendees. 34 of the participants who attended this seminar were from outside Mumbai.

This informative seminar was coordinated by Shardul Shah, with the help of convenors Raj Khona and Khubi Shah Sanghvi, and Team CTC.

Seminar-on-Attachment-and-Seizure-Provisions-under-Prevention-of-Money-Laundering-Act-2002 Seminar-on-Attachment-and-Seizure-Provisions-under-Prevention-of-Money-Laundering-Act-2002

3. FEMA Study Circle -“Downstream Investment” held on 27th February 2026@ Virtual

The FEMA Study Circle organised a meeting to deliberate on the Downstream Investment provisions as provided under the FEM (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019. The session was chaired by CA Hardik Mehta and led by CA Swetha Prasad.

The discussion covered key aspects as provided below:

  • Definition of downstream investment & indirect foreign investment
  • Aspects to keep in mind before making downstream investments
  • Computation of indirect foreign investment
  • Procedural compliance in relation to downstream investments
  • Pricing & reporting guidelines for downstream investments
  • Relaxations/clarifications issued in relation to downstream investments

The group leader also took the participants through various scenarios for the identification of FOCC, computing foreign ownership, etc. There were good discussions about the issuance of stock options and non-equity instruments by the FOCC and how it would trigger downstream investment provisions. There were deliberations on investment holding entities making downstream investments, considering the recent relaxation by the RBI for NBFCs. The meeting concluded with participants sharing practical learnings on downstream investments.

4. 23rd Residential Leadership Retreat held on Friday, 27th February 2026 and Saturday, 28th February 2026 @ Rambhau Mhalgi – Bhayander

The 23rd Residential Leadership Retreat was conducted over two days on the theme Krishna Niti for Life Excellence, at Rambhau Mhalgi Prabodhini.

Dr. Girish Jakhotiya

Dr. Girish Jakhotiya, a renowed author and economist, drew structured lessons from the life journey of Lord Krishna, linking key milestones – from Gokul and Mathura to Dwarka and Kurukshetra – with principles of strategic thinking, leadership and self-transformation.

 Dr. Jakhotiya distinguished excellence from perfection and explained “Life Excellence” through four pillars: economic prosperity, intellectual supremacy, social equality, and cultural bliss. Through case studies and illustrations from Krishna’s life, he encouraged participants to examine strategy, risk versus uncertainty, leadership styles, branding, ethical flexibility and institution building.

The Leadership retreat received an encouraging response from members across practice and industry. Around 50 participants from 8+ cities and towns across India enrolled for this residential program. Participants appreciated the clarity of explanations and the practical insights shared by the faculty.

5. BCAS Women’s Study Circle — SAKHI CIRCLE on Voice to Influence – Build Yourself as a Professional Speaker held on Saturday, 21st February 2026@ Virtual.

Speaker: Ms. Kalpana Thakur

The Women’s Study Circle organized an engaging session titled “Voice to Influence – Build Yourself as a Professional Speaker.” The session focused on how individuals can develop their speaking abilities by strengthening three core elements: Action, Belief and Visibility. Participants were encouraged to take proactive steps toward improving their communication skills and not wait for perfection before beginning their journey. The importance of building strong internal beliefs—particularly the confidence to express ideas and share knowledge—was highlighted as the foundation of impactful speaking.

The faculty emphasized the power of visualizing one’s future self and breaking long-term aspirations into smaller, consistent practice-based goals. Practical guidance was provided on preparing content, practicing delivery, presenting effectively, and developing one’s personal brand through clarity and consistency. The session also covered techniques for narrowing down areas of expertise and leveraging digital platforms to enhance visibility and influence. Attendees found the insights valuable for strengthening their professional presence and building themselves as confident speakers.

Motivational Highlight:The rest of my life is going to the best of my life!!

6. ITF Study Circle meeting on the ruling of “Binny Bansal” held on Tuesday, 17th February 2026@ Virtual.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organized an online meeting to discuss the Tribunal ruling in the case of Binny Bansal and its implications.

The session began with brief opening remarks by the Chairman of the session, CA Rashmin Sanghvi. Thereafter, the Group Leader, CA Nithin Surana, explained the case in detail, covering the facts of the case, the arguments of the taxpayer and the tax authorities, and the ruling given by the Tribunal, along with key inputs from the Chairman.

After presenting the case, the Group Leader shared his analysis of the ruling and discussed the legal issues arising from it. The participants actively shared their views on the implications of the ruling.

The Chairman and the Group Leader also shared their perspectives on the possible way forward and the likely outcomes if the matter is taken to higher appellate levels. The discussion was comprehensive and covered the important aspects of the ruling.

7. FEMA Study Circle – “Guarantees under FEMA” held on 13th February 2026@ Virtual.

The FEMA study circle organised a meeting on the revised Guarantee regulations issued by the RBI. The session was chaired by CA Vijay Gupta and led by CA Jigar Mehta.

  • The discussion covered the following aspects:
  • Concept and classification of Guarantees under FEMA
  • Important Definitions
  • Exemptions from Guarantee Regulations
  • Permissions under the Regulations
  • Guarantee as per ODI regulations
  • Reporting requirements
  • Case studies for discussion

The meeting provided insight into the new regulations for the issuance and receipt of inward as well as outward guarantees.

8. Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Study Circle – NBFCs: Key Regulatory Developments And Emerging Areas held on Thursday, 12th February 2026 @ Virtual.

Speaker: Mr. Kunal Mehta

The Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws (FCAL) Study Circle organised a virtual session on the Zoom platform to discuss the intricate regulatory framework governing Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs). The meeting, attended by 52 participants, focused on providing practical insights into the rapidly evolving regulatory landscape and recent developments initiated by the RBI. Key discussion points included identifying major compliance challenges faced by NBFCs in the current dynamic environment. The speaker highlighted best practices for maintaining audit readiness and ensuring robust adherence to statutory requirements. Participants explored the essential concepts of the NBFC framework to better navigate evolving legal standards. The session emphasised the importance of staying updated with shifting regulatory expectations to mitigate operational risks. Attendees engaged in a dialogue regarding the practical application of these regulations within their respective professional capacities. The event concluded with a comprehensive overview of how firms can maintain a proactive stance toward future regulatory shifts.

9. Report on Conclave on Union Budget 2026 & Deliberation on New Income Tax

Association of Corporate Advisers & Executives (ACAE), jointly with Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS), successfully organized a full-day programme on Conclave on Union Budget 2026 and Deliberation on the New Income Tax Law on 7th February, 2026 at Williams Court, 40, Shakespeare Sarani Road, 4th Floor, Kolkata – 700017, bringing together eminent professionals and experts to deliberate on key fiscal and legislative developments impacting the nation.

The Inaugural Session commenced with the ceremonial Lighting of the Lamp by CA. Jai Prakash Agarwal, Chairman of ICAI Dubai Chapter, CA. Kinjal M. Shah, Vice President of BCAS, CA. Niraj Kumar Harodia, President of ACAE, other esteemed dignitaries and ACAE Office Bearers symbolizing the pursuit of knowledge and wisdom.

This was followed by a warm and insightful Welcome Address by CA. Niraj Kumar Harodia who highlighted the significance of the Conclave, shared his reflections on his interactions with the esteemed speakers, spoke about the rich legacy and evolution of ACAE as one of the oldest professional associations in Kolkata and welcomed everyone to the Conclave.

The distinguished Guests of Honour, CA. Kinjal M. Shah, Vice President of BCAS, initiated the deliberations with an analytical perspective on Shaping Responsible, Respected and Future Ready Professionals for Decades.

CA. Jai Prakash Agarwal, Chairman of ICAI Dubai Chapter, further enriched the discussion with his practical insights on Emerging Professional Opportunities in the Middle East.

The first technical session was delivered by eminent Guest Speaker, CA. Pradip N. Kapasi, Past President of BCAS, Mumbai, on an in-depth comparative analysis on the Major Changes between the Income Tax Act, 1961 vis a vis Income Tax Act, 2025, clearly outlining structural reforms, simplification measures, and compliance implications.

CA. Padamchand Khincha, Partner at H C Khincha & Co., Chartered Acountants, Bengaluru, in the second technical session elaborated on the Major Amendments proposed through the Income Tax Bill, 2026, explaining the legislative intent, interpretational aspects, and the anticipated impact on tax administration.

Mr. Sameer Narang, Head at Economics Research Group, ICICI Bank, Mumbai, concluded the speaker sessions with a macro-economic perspective on the Impact of Budget on Indian Economy, addressing fiscal discipline, growth projections, capital expenditure focus, and the overall economic outlook.

The Conclave witnessed enthusiastic participation from over 100 delegates, including members, professionals, and representatives from various industries. The sessions were highly interactive, marked by meaningful discussions and thought-provoking queries, making the programme both informative and intellectually stimulating.

The joint initiative with the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society reinforced the spirit of professional collaboration and knowledge sharing, ensuring that members remain well-equipped to navigate the evolving taxation landscape.

The programme concluded with a formal Vote of Thanks, expressing sincere gratitude to the esteemed speakers, dignitaries, and participants for contributing to the grand success of the Conclave.

Report on Conclave on Union Budget 2026 & Deliberation on New Income Tax

10. ITF Study Circle meeting on “Discussion on Supreme Court Ruling in the case of Tiger Global” held on 27th January 2026@ Virtual.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organised an online meeting to discuss the implications of the Supreme Court’s ruling in the case of Tiger Global.

Group Leaders CA Ramesh Khaitan and CA Jimit Devani

The session opened with remarks from the group leaders on their initial thoughts on the Supreme Court ruling, covering the facts of the case, the contentions raised, and the Court’s ruling. Then the group leaders discussed the critical implications of the ruling. Some of the issues discussed included whether a Tax Residence Certificate is sufficient to claim benefits under a tax treaty, the application of the substance-over-form principle, etc. The group leaders discussed the likely next course of action for Tiger Global. The participants also shared divergent views on the implications of the Supreme Court ruling. The participants expressed apprehensions about the wider application of the principles in this ruling and its unintended consequences.

The discussion covered several key issues that will impact similar cases in the future. The session closed with concluding remarks by the Group Leaders.

11. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on Practical Issues under GST in Healthcare Industry held on Thursday, 22nd January 2026 @ Virtual

Group Leader: CA. Shefali Bang

Mentor: CA Parag Mehta

The group leader first presented the Law pertaining to the healthcare industry under GST, followed by five case studies covering the various aspects of Issues in the healthcare industry under GST.

The presentation covered the following aspects of the Healthcare Industry for a detailed discussion:

  • Whether treatment for Substance Use Disorder through OPD consultation, counselling, and supervised medicine dispensing qualifies as an exempt healthcare service under GST, or whether it may be treated as a taxable supply of medicines.

  • Whether doctor consultation and medicines supplied to outpatients by the hospital pharmacy should be treated as separate taxable supplies or a composite supply of healthcare services, and the related ITC reversal mechanism.
  • GST implications in a revenue-sharing arrangement between a diagnostic laboratory and a sample collection centre, focusing on the taxability of sample collection services and diagnostic testing services.
  • Whether health check-up packages marketed by a company through empanelled hospitals and diagnostic centres qualify for GST exemption as healthcare services, particularly when sold to healthy individuals or corporate employees.
  • Whether naturopathy therapies, along with residential accommodation provided by a wellness retreat, constitute a composite exempt healthcare service or whether accommodation should be taxed separately.
  • The reversal of Input Tax Credit (ITC) when certain life-saving drugs become GST-exempt, particularly regarding raw materials, semi-finished goods, finished goods, and capital goods held in stock
  • Around 100 participants from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader and the mentor.

III. REPRESENTATION

1. Representation to SEBI on Research Analyst Regulations

BCAS has submitted a representation on 24th February 2026 to SEBI highlighting practical issues faced during registration under the Research Analyst (RA) Regulations, 2014. The representation is based on feedback from professionals and applicants.

Key concerns include the absence of a clear framework for transition from individual to corporate entities, leading to disruption and duplication of processes. BCAS has also pointed out delays in processing applications after delegation to BSE.

Further, the Society has raised issues regarding restrictive interpretation of rules, especially relating to the “other employment” of Principal Officers, and lack of clarity on certain operational aspects.

BCAS has requested SEBI to provide necessary clarifications and streamline the process to reduce difficulties faced by applicants while ensuring investor protection.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/SEBI-RA-Representation.pdf

IV. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

  • BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Blood Donation & Platelet Donation Awareness Drive held on Friday 13th February 2026 @ BCAS.

On Friday, 13th February 2026, the BCAS Foundation, jointly with the Seminar, Membership & Public Relations Committee of BCAS, held the annual “Blood Donation Drive”, enlisting the support of Tata Memorial Hospital (TMH).

Blood Donation

Doctors and technicians from TMH screened 63 potential donors using a detailed questionnaire they completed. 54 units of blood were collected from eligible donors, including the former president, the Hon. Joint Secretary, the Convenors of the SMPR committee, and BCAS members and staff.

To raise awareness and dispel myths about platelet donation, a “Platelet Donation Awareness Drive” was also held, with donors providing a blood sample for a platelet donation eligibility check.

In recognition of their invaluable contribution, each blood donor was presented with a “Life Saver” medal. NSS volunteers from H R College of Commerce & Economics and Dharma Bharathi Mission canvassed around the area to spread awareness of the drive and encourage interested parties to come and get their eligibility confirmed for donating blood to the noble cause.

2. Public Lecture Meeting on Direct Tax Provisions of Finance Bill, 2026 held on Saturday, 7th February 2026 @ Yogi Sabhagruh Auditorium, Dadar East.

The public lecture on Direct Tax Provisions under the Finance Bill 2026 was delivered by noted tax expert CA Shri Pinakin Desai before a packed audience at Yogi Sabhagruha, Dadar. The session assumed particular significance as this is the first Budget where amendments operate simultaneously in two legislations — the Income-tax Act, 1961 and the new Income-tax Act, 2025, which is set to come into force from 1 April 2026.

Public Lecture Meeting

Shri Desai described the Budget as largely calibrated and balanced, but cautioned that certain policy-level concerns emerging from the transition to the 2025 Act merit closer professional examination. He observed that while the Joint Parliamentary Committee largely confined itself to administrative aspects, some substantive policy shifts embedded in the new legislation may require representation and deeper deliberation at professional forums.

Certain deliberations from his session are covered here in brief:

1. Broad framework:

Unlike prior years, there were virtually no changes to slab rates. The focus was on structural rationalisation:

  • Calibration of Securities Transaction Tax (STT) to moderate speculative activity.
  • Rationalisation of TDS/TCS rates.
  • Reduction of TCS on overseas tour packages from 20% to 2%.

2. Corporate and Structural Reforms

MAT Regime:

From 1 April 2026, companies continuing under MAT may lose MAT credit going forward, effectively nudging domestic companies towards the concessional regime. Foreign companies, lacking this option, appear disproportionately affected.

ICDS and Ind AS Integration:

A proposal to merge ICDS with Ind AS has been introduced. Concerns remain regarding compatibility with IFRS-based accounting standards.

Transfer Pricing and Safe Harbour:

Safe harbour margins for IT-enabled services have been consolidated at 15% with an enhanced turnover threshold of ₹2,000 crore. Correlative relief is now provided to foreign companies where APAs lead to secondary adjustments.

Data Centres and GCCs:

Foreign companies procuring specified data centre services in India are granted tax protection up to 2047, reducing litigation around income attribution.

3. Computation and Compliance Amendments

Dividend and Interest:

No deduction of interest expenditure will be allowed against dividend or mutual fund income under “Income from Other Sources,” raising concerns on taxation of gross income principles.

Employees’ PF Contribution:

A relief measure now allows deduction if employees’ contribution is deposited before the due date of filing the return under section 139(1), even if delayed under the PF Act.

Buyback Taxation:

Buyback proceeds will be taxed under capital gains from 1 April 2026 instead of as dividend income. Promoter-category shareholders face higher specified tax rates, raising interpretational issues.

Unexplained Income:

Voluntary disclosure in the return attracts tax at 30%. If detected in an assessment, immunity from penalty requires payment of tax plus 120% additional tax.

4. Litigation and Procedural Changes

Decriminalisation:

Several prosecution provisions have been removed or diluted, with reduced imprisonment terms and enhanced monetary thresholds — a significant compliance reform.

Retrospective Amendments:

Four retrospective amendments, including one dating back to 2007 relating to DRP timelines, were introduced — a development viewed with concern.

Mandatory Fees:

Certain penalties are proposed to be converted into mandatory fees, removing discretion and the opportunity of hearing.

Combined Assessment and Penalty Orders:

Assessment and penalty may now be passed through a combined order. While the recovery of the penalty may remain stayed on appeal, concerns were expressed about potential bias and increased litigation exposure.

5. Other Notable Clarifications

Sovereign Gold Bonds:

Exemption on redemption will apply only to primary subscribers holding bonds till maturity, though coverage is extended to all bond series prospectively.

Compulsory Acquisition:

Exemption relating to acquisition under the land acquisition law is now incorporated into the Income-tax Act, though limited to individuals and HUFs, creating possible interpretational issues for companies.

In conclusion, Shri Desai remarked that although the Budget may outwardly appear minimalist, it contains several nuanced structural changes with long-term implications for corporate taxation, transfer pricing, litigation strategy, and compliance architecture.

The meeting witnessed an enthusiastic response, with over 400 participants attending in person and more than 11,491 viewers online and still counting.

The lecture meeting can be viewed on the BCAS YouTube channel at the designated QR code.

Public Lecture

3. 26th Course on Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements held from Monday 15th December 2025 to Thursday 29th January 2026@ Virtual.

Following the highly successful and well-received Silver Jubilee edition of the Course on Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement, which featured a revised format, this edition returned to the traditional format of live sessions covering all topics. The course broadly included the following:

• 28 sessions on various international tax topics and covered almost all the key articles of the DTAAs.

• An overview of FEMA / MLI / GAAR, Transfer Pricing/ key provisions under the Income-tax Act/ TDS on payments to non-residents/ Dispute resolution under MAP, APA, etc.

• A Brain Trust session with distinguished panelists, and key current issues were debated, with panelists sharing divergent perspectives.

The sessions were relevant for beginners and intermediate levels of knowledge in international tax, with emphasis on case studies and sharing of practical insights.

More than 150 participants from more than 30 cities attended the course.

Scan to watch online at BCAS Academy

26th DTAA

4. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting – “Analysis of Section 56(2) (x) of the Act with Practical Scenarios” held on Wednesday, 28th January 2026@ Virtual.

Section 56(2)(x) is a significant anti-abuse provision that aims to tax receipts of money or specified property without, or for inadequate consideration. The session highlighted key tax provisions, legal principles, and practical considerations involved in interpreting and applying the provision, particularly in the context of varied practical transactions.

Speaker: CA Chaitee Londhe

  • The session provided an overview of Section 56(2) (x) as a residuary charging provision and explained the conditions governing its applicability.
  • The expanded scope of the provision covering all categories of persons and specified properties was discussed.
  • Judicial principles laid down by courts on the classification of income under appropriate heads were briefly highlighted.
  • Practical implications of receipt of money or property without or for inadequate consideration were examined.
  • Key scenarios involving compensation and indemnity receipts, distress-driven transactions, and waiver of loans were analysed.
  • The taxability of issue and receipt of shares, including valuation-related aspects, was deliberated with reference to case law.
  • The interplay between Section 56(2) (x) and Section 68 was discussed to highlight practical assessment issues.
  • Certain complex and evolving scenarios, including transactions involving relatives and digital assets, were briefly touched upon.

The session was highly interactive, with active participation from the members. The speaker presented the complex provisions of Section 56(2) (x) in a structured and practical manner, enabling participants to gain clarity on its application across varied scenarios.

5. Lecture Meeting on Decision of Supreme Court in Tiger Global and it’s ramifications held on Friday, 23rd January 2026 @ Virtual

The lecture meeting, arranged to discuss the Supreme Court (SC) ruling in the case of Tiger Global pronounced on 15 January 2026, received wide interest from across India, given the ramifications of the decision. The chairman of the Session, Shri R. S. Syal laid down the context of the decision. The moderator CA Mahesh Nayak took the participants through the decision before opening the floor for brainstorming. Other Panelists, CA Rajan Vora and Adv. Rajesh Simhan addressed barrage of questions arising from the SC ruling in the Tiger Global. The Chairman, Adv. R. S. Syal also provided his thoughts on each of the questions raised to the panelists.

The discussion was focused on how one reads some of the observations of the Supreme Court as well as practically, how the decision impacts taxpayers, as well as Chartered Accountants who certify the taxability on foreign remittances. Some of the questions posed to the panel were:

  • Whether the decision of the Supreme Court is only prima facie or is it a final ruling on the taxability?

  • Can Judicial Anti-Avoidance provisions apply when GAAR rules are already in force?
  • What is the difference between an investment and an arrangement, and what is grandfathered under the GAAR rules? Various other practical nuances (such as reopening of past matters / pending matters) were discussed.
  • The Lecture meeting was attended by around 745 participants

The lecture meeting can be viewed on the BCAS YouTube channel at the designated QR code.

Lecture Meeting on Decision of Supreme Court in Tiger Global and it's ramifications

6. Lecture Meeting on Ancient Roots, Global Routes: Reimagining Global Leadership for the Indian CA held on Wednesday, 21st January 2026 @ Mathuradas Vasanji Hall, Grant Road, Mumbai

Seminar, Membership & Public Relations (SMPR) Committee organized a Lecture Meeting was held “Ancient Roots, Global Routes: Reimagining Global Leadership for the Indian CA” – by CA Shourya Doval on 21st January 2026. CA Shourya Doval, in his address, stated that India is emerging as a major economic power, now ranked fourth globally. “There can be no global peace and no global order without India,” he said. The session focused on how Chartered Accountants must navigate a rapidly evolving international economic and financial landscape while remaining anchored to core principles. The discussions centred on ethical leadership and value-based decision-making as essential foundations for developing future leaders in the global economy.

Lecture Meeting on Ancient Roots Global

During the session, he was asked an insightful question: Coming from a proud Indian Military family, what inspired him to pursue Chartered Accountancy? His response reflected both depth and foresight. He explained that until 1990, global leadership was defined by military power, but the world thereafter began to be shaped by economic strength. His father had told him that future global influence would rest with nations built on strong economic foundations — a perspective that deeply resonated with him and ultimately inspired his decision to become a Chartered Accountant, contributing to the economic engine that drives nations forward.

The event concluded with interactions and networking among participants, underscoring BCAS’s focus on professional development and leadership preparedness within the Chartered Accountancy fraternity.

The lecture meeting was positioned alongside a guided tour specially conducted for BCAS members of the Jyot Foundation Exhibition “Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam Ki Oar 4: The 12 Principles That Can Shape a New World Order,” designed to provide attendees with an expanded cultural and philosophical understanding of the Global Leadership dialogue.

7. Members’ Awareness Drive on Practice Management held on Saturday, 15th November 2025 to Saturday, 17th January 2026 @ Virtual.

The Seminar, Membership and Public Relations Committee of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) organised the “Members’ Awareness Drive on Practice Management – Reimagining Practice: Awareness, Opportunities & Excellence – Empowering Every Member – One Area at a Time”. It was a 10-session virtual series held every Saturday from 15th November 2025 to 17th January 2026, with the objective of strengthening BCAS members’ practice management capabilities. In acknowledgement of the unwavering support displayed by the members to the flagship event of BCAS, all registered participants of the (then) upcoming 59th Members’ Residential Refresher Course were offered an opportunity to attend the series gratis.

The series focused on equipping practitioners to manage and grow their firms beyond technical competence, covering people management, technology adoption, profitability, collaboration, and future-readiness.

Session Highlights

  1. CA Mrinal Mehta addressed practical challenges and common errors in GST Annual Returns and reconciliations, offering actionable compliance insights
  2. CA Samit Saraf shared effective tools and techniques to strengthen internal audit processes and enhance audit value.
  3. CA Vivek Shah provided a practical roadmap for setting up a CA firm in Dubai, covering opportunities, challenges, costs, and market considerations
  4. CA Anand Banka discussed key nuances and practical complexities under IND AS with real-life application perspectives.
  5. CA Lokesh Nathani emphasised the power of networking in professional growth and building long-term practice sustainability.
  6. CA Nikunj Shah demonstrated how Artificial Intelligence can be harnessed to improve efficiency and competitiveness in CA practice.
  7. CA Mangesh Kinare shared practical insights on financial reporting for SMEs, drawing valuable learnings from disciplinary matters.
  8. CA Milin Mehta elaborated on strategic collaborations and firm mergers as growth drivers for small and mid-sized practices
  9. CA Sushrut Chitale guided members on building a future-ready firm through structured processes, technology, and strategic vision.
  10.  CA Chirag Mehta explained practical aspects of E-Invoicing and automation solutions tailored for small practitioners.

The sessions witnessed enthusiastic participation from the practising members, fostering meaningful discussions and the exchange of practical experiences.

8. BCAS NXT – Learning & Development Bootcamp – Overview of the New Income Tax Act, 2025 held on Friday, 16th January 2026 @ Virtual

The Human Resource Development Committee organised a BCAS NXT Learning & Development Bootcamp on “Overview of the New Income Tax Act, 2025” on Friday, 16th January 2026, from 5.00 pm to 7.00 pm.

The session was led by Ms Shravani Erram, a CA Final student, who delivered a detailed presentation covering an overview of the Income Tax Act, 2025, explaining the rationale behind the introduction of the new Act and the key structural and drafting changes. She highlighted important concepts such as the distinction between tax year and financial year, along with major comparative changes in heads of income, TDS, and TCS provisions. CA Aditya Pradhan, the mentor for the session, provided valuable insights and guidance throughout, offering expert interventions as needed.

The bootcamp was held in person at ASDT & CO and was also streamed online, with active participation from students across India.

More than 150+ students benefited from this session.

Scan to watch online on YouTube.

BCAS NXT - Learning & Development Bootcamp - Overview of the New Income Tax Act

9. GST Compliances & Returns – A Practical Walkthrough: BCAS Initiative for Students held on Tuesday, 13th January 2026 @ N M College.

The session on GST Compliances & Returns – A Practical Walkthrough was organised for third-year B.Com students, with 46 students participating. The objective of the programme was to provide students with a practical understanding of GST compliance and the return filing framework, bridging the gap between academic concepts and real-life application.

GST Compliances & Return

The session conducted by CA Mansi V. Nagda focused on the GST return mechanism and process flow, explaining the compliance cycle from reporting of transactions to filing of returns. A structured explanation of GST utility forms was undertaken, covering GSTR-1, GSTR-2A, and GSTR-3B, with key terminologies, functional flow, inter-linkages, and commonly encountered compliance issues.

Emphasis was laid on understanding outward and inward supply reporting, reconciliation aspects, summary return filing, and the importance of accuracy and timeliness in GST compliance. The session adopted an interactive approach, enabling students to clarify conceptual and procedural aspects of GST returns.

10. Lecture Meeting on The World in 2026 and Beyond held on Friday, 12th December 2025 @ BCAS (Hybrid)

The joint lecture meeting of the Bombay Chartered Accountants Society and the Chamber of Tax Consultants featured Mr Sundeep Waslekar, Founder of Strategic Foresight Group and an internationally recognised expert on geopolitics and future studies. The session examined the evolving global order in 2026 and beyond, focusing on geopolitical tensions, artificial intelligence, economic uncertainty and strategic realignments.

The speaker framed the present period as a transitional and potentially turbulent phase in world history, where the existing global order is weakening while a new framework has yet to stabilise.

Key Global Themes

– Western Political and Economic Strain- Persistent geopolitical conflicts, particularly the prolonged Ukraine war, combined with economic stress and political polarisation, could create instability in parts of the West. Such shifts may alter global power balances and open strategic space for emerging economies.

– The AI Arms Race – The competition between the United States and China has moved beyond consumer AI applications to AI-driven scientific discovery. Advanced systems capable of generating new insights in biology, chemistry and physics could redefine global technological leadership. Risks discussed included AI-enabled cyber warfare, biological threats and even autonomous military escalation, underscoring the need for ethical and strategic safeguards.

– Competing Models of World Order- If large-scale conflict is avoided, the next phase may involve a philosophical contest over models of global governance and power concentration. Current geopolitical manoeuvres were analysed in this broader context.

IMPLICATIONS FOR INDIA

India’s balanced geopolitical stance was described as strategically prudent. However, the speaker cautioned that India must invest more deeply in foundational scientific research and advanced AI systems, rather than limiting itself to application-level innovation. Space technology and next-generation computing were identified as important opportunity areas.

While moderate global growth remains possible, geopolitical shocks and rapid AI investments could significantly influence economic trajectories. The Gulf region’s rise as an AI and data infrastructure hub was noted, though accompanied by regional vulnerabilities.

The session concluded with a balanced perspective — acknowledging serious global risks while emphasising that the majority of nations and people seek stability and prosperity. The coming years will determine whether cooperative global leadership can prevail over destabilising forces.

The lecture witnessed active participation from members across regions, reflecting the profession’s growing engagement with global developments that increasingly influence economic and professional landscapes.

The lecture meeting can be viewed on the BCAS YouTube channel at the designated QR code.

II. BCAS INITIATIVES

  •  BCAS Signs MOU with SIMSREE

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) has signed an MOU with Sydenham Institute of Management Studies, Research and Entrepreneurship Education (SIMSREE) to establish a framework for cooperation in the areas of capacity building, training & skill development between the two Insititutions.

The MOU between BCAS & SIMREE is to facilitate and conduct the following activities as mutually agreed upon:

  1. Workshops & Seminars
  2. Curriculum Development
  3. Invitation to select Programs & use of each other’s premises
  4. Research & Advocacy

The MOU Signing Ceremony was conducted in the presence of President CA Zubin Billimoria, Vice President CA Kinjal Shah, Joint Secretary CA Mandar Telang, SMPR Committee Chairman CA Uday Sathaye & Past President CA Pradip Thanawala.

III. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

  •  BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on Application of Excel in Professional Practice held on Friday, 16th January 2026 @ SHBA & Co LLP.

  •  Suburban Study Circle organised a hands-on technical session on “Application of Excel in Professional Practice” on Friday, 16th January 2026 and lead by CA Yashesh Jakhelia & CA Vivek Gupta.
  •  The session focused on Excel 365 dynamic array functionalities with specific applications in GST reconciliation and data analysis.
  •  Key Excel functions such as XLOOKUP, FILTER, UNIQUE, SORT and GROUPBY were demonstrated through live, practice-oriented illustrations.
  •  Participants were guided on practical structuring of data for reconciliation, validation and reporting requirements.
  •  The session emphasised improving efficiency, accuracy and turnaround time in professional assignments using Excel tools.
  •  The program was conducted as an interactive, laptop-based workshop enabling participants to practice alongside demonstrations.
  • Members actively participated and appreciated the practical relevance of the session for day-to-day professional work.
  •  The session witnessed participation from members as well as a few CA trainees, who benefited from the practical orientation of the program.

2. BCAS Cricket Tournament 2026 (2nd Edition) held on Sunday, 11th January 2026 @ Gallant Sports Club (TurfStation – Juhu).

BCAS Cricket Tournament 2026

  •  The Second Edition of the BCAS Turf Cricket Tournament was successfully conducted on 11th January 2026 at TurfStation, JVPD, Andheri (West), featuring 12 Men’s Teams and 2 Women’s Teams. The event showcased competitive cricket in a vibrant atmosphere of sportsmanship and camaraderie, with the participation of 140 players.
  •  The tournament was exclusively open to Chartered Accountants and witnessed an enthusiastic response with overwhelming registrations.
  •  In the Men’s category, the tournament followed a four-group league format (three teams per group), culminating in Quarterfinals (8 teams), Semi-Finals (4 teams), and the Final, ensuring a structured and competitive progression.
  •  The event witnessed participation from both returning firms from the previous edition and first-time participating firms, reflecting the growing acceptance of the tournament as a platform for professional engagement and networking.
  •  The matches were marked by notable individual performances, engaging live commentary, and enthusiastic spectator support, contributing to an energetic and engaging sporting environment.
  •  After a series of closely contested matches, Fiscal Fireballs emerged as the Men’s Champions, while NPV Chak De Girls secured the Women’s Title, following several thrilling encounters throughout the day.
  •  The tournament successfully reinforced its objective of informal networking and community engagement among CA firms, and left a strong impression on participants, setting a solid foundation for future editions of the event.3. Women’s Study Circle meeting – SAKHI CIRCLE! held on Friday, 9th January 2026 @ Virtual.

The Women’s Study Circle organised a session on “The Power of First & Lasting Impressions – Your Soft Skills Advantage,” focusing on the role of communication and presence in professional interactions. In this session, CA Renu Shah, highlighted how first impressions influence engagement, credibility, and long-term perception. It was explained that impressions are often formed through subtle behavioural cues such as posture, tone, pace of speaking, and clarity of thought, rather than credentials alone.

Common communication behaviours that can dilute impact—such as over-explaining, excessive fillers, lack of eye contact, and digital distractions—were discussed through practical examples. The session introduced structured communication frameworks, including WHY–WHAT–HOW and Present–Past–Future, to help professionals articulate their thoughts with clarity and confidence.

Participants were also introduced to the “Remember Me” formula, emphasising posture, structured thinking, power words, and the effective use of pauses. Practical power phrases for professionals were shared to enhance clarity and impact in everyday interactions. The session reinforced that conscious communication and small behavioural shifts can significantly strengthen professional presence and leave lasting impressions.

4. AI and Technology ki Pathshala: A Technology Orientation Program for CA Students” held on Saturday, 20th December 2025 and Sunday, 21st December 2025@ Virtual.

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organised a two-day technology orientation program titled “AI and Technology Ki Pathshala” for CA students.

Day 1 commenced with an inspiring keynote address by CA Rahul Bajaj on understanding technology and its impact on the CA profession. This was followed by an insightful session by CA Rahul Dharne, who demonstrated the practical use of AI tools such as GPTs and automation to simplify work and draft professional reports more efficiently, and also shared AI techniques for exam preparation.

The Day 1 program concluded with a session by CA Shyam Agrawal, who demonstrated tools for enhancing productivity using MS Office 365, Zoho, and Google applications.

Day 2 began with a session by CA Rahul Gabhawala, who explained how advanced Excel formulas and macros can automate tax reconciliations and improve accuracy in professional work. This was followed by a session by CA Chinmay Pathak, who introduced participants to the basics of vibe coding, website development, tools for sending multiple emails to clients, and techniques for identifying plagiarism.

Overall, the students gained a practical understanding of how technology can be effectively used in both professional and academic work. More than 100 students from across India benefited from this two-day technology orientation program.

Scan to watch online at BCAS Academy

5. DIRECT TAX RETREAT 1.0 held on Thursday 18th December 2025 to Sunday 21st December 2025 @ Taj Vivanta, Dwarka, New Delhi

The Direct Tax Committee of BCAS successfully organised Direct Tax Retreat 1.0 from 18th to 21st December 2025 at Taj Vivanta, Dwarka, New Delhi. Envisioned as a residential retreat rather than a routine conference, the program was designed to create a space where learning could happen through discussion, debate, reflection and shared experience. Over four days, tax professionals from across the country came together for meaningful engagement on contemporary direct tax issues in an environment that encouraged participation and open dialogue.

The Retreat began with an inspiring Inaugural Session by Mr Raman Chopra, Former Joint Secretary (Tax Policy), who addressed the gathering on “Where Policy Meets Practice: Creating an Efficient Tax Eco-System for the Next Decade.” Drawing from his extensive experience in policy-making, he shared valuable insights into how tax laws are conceptualised, the intent behind legislative changes, and the practical challenges faced during implementation. His address helped participants better understand the broader policy framework within which tax professionals operate and set a thoughtful tone for the technical discussions that followed.

Direct Tax 1

The first technical session on Day 1 featured a Panel Discussion on “Reconstitution of Firms – Sections 45(4) and 9B: Contrasting Perspectives.” CA Bhadresh Doshi and Adv. Dharan Gandhi presented differing viewpoints on interpretation, recent judicial developments and practical structuring concerns, while CA Pinakin Desai ably chaired the session. The discussion was intense, lively and informative, offering practical takeaways for professionals dealing with partnership restructurings and related tax implications.

Day 2 commenced with Group Discussions on Assorted Case Studies, a format that encouraged delegates to actively engage with complex factual situations and share their practical experiences. The group discussion model allowed participants to appreciate multiple viewpoints and sharpen their analytical approach through peer learning.

A standout feature of Direct Tax Retreat 1.0 was the guided visit to the New Parliament of India. For many delegates, this was a deeply enriching and memorable experience. Walking through the corridors of the institution where tax laws are debated and enacted offered a unique perspective on the legislative process. The visit helped connect the technical discussions in the conference hall with the constitutional and institutional framework of taxation, reminding participants of the larger system within which tax laws evolve.

The day concluded with Replies by the Paper Writer, CA Yogesh Thar, who addressed the key issues raised during the group discussions. His responses provided clarity on practical concerns and helped participants consolidate their learning from the day.

On Day 3, the Retreat continued with Group Discussions on Deeming Fictions and Valuation Changes, topics that often present significant challenges in practice. This was followed by a presentation by CA Rahul Bajaj on “Tax & Tech – The New Frontier,” which highlighted the increasing role of technology in tax administration, compliance, and advisory work. The session offered valuable insights into how professionals must adapt to a rapidly changing digital environment.

The afternoon featured concise and focused Tax Capsules, covering Tax Insurance by CA Upamanyu Manjrekar and Rewarding Employees Local & Global by CA Mahesh Nayak. These short sessions delivered high-impact learning and were well appreciated for their practical relevance. The day’s technical sessions concluded with Replies by the Paper Writer, CA Pradip Kapasi, on “Navigating Deeming Fictions & Vexatious Valuations,” where he addressed key interpretational and litigation-related concerns.

Adding a refreshing balance to the intensive technical sessions, the Saturday evening Bingo game provided delegates an opportunity to unwind and interact informally. The specially curated game created an atmosphere of camaraderie and laughter, strengthening connections among participants and reinforcing the idea that learning is most effective when combined with meaningful human interaction.

The final day of the Retreat featured a much-anticipated Brain Trust Session and Open Mic, with Senior Advocate Shri S. Ganesh and Shri G. S. Pannu, Former President of the ITAT. The session allowed delegates to ask questions, benefiting from insights drawn from decades of experience at both the Bar and the Bench. The candid and practical nature of the discussion made this session particularly engaging and valuable.

The Retreat concluded with a Valedictory Session, during which appreciation was expressed to all those who contributed to the success of the program, including the speakers, paper writers, group leaders, mentors, organisers, hospitality team and the BCAS team whose collective efforts ensured a seamless and enriching experience for all participants.

Overall, Direct Tax Retreat 1.0 was widely appreciated for its depth of content, interactive formats and emphasis on participative learning. By successfully combining rigorous technical discussions with institutional exposure, informal interaction, and community building, the Retreat set a new benchmark in professional tax education and laid a strong foundation for future editions.

Direct Tax 2Direct Tax 3

6. Webinar on Mastering Compliance with India’s DPDP Act, 2023 held on Monday, 15th December 2025 @ Virtual.

In this session, Mr Shrikrishna Dikshit provided a practical overview of the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023 and the intent behind its key provisions. It covered the implications of the draft rules and how organisations should interpret them for operational compliance. The roles and responsibilities of Data Fiduciaries and Data Processors were explained with emphasis on accountability and governance. Key aspects such as consent management, cross-border data transfers, and grievance redressal mechanisms were discussed.

The session also highlighted risks arising from third-party vendors and the importance of managing vendor ecosystems effectively. Sector-specific insights were shared for BFSI, healthcare, e-commerce, and manufacturing sectors. Overall, the session enabled participants to understand compliance expectations and practical steps for strengthening data protection frameworks under the DPDP Act.

Scan to watch online at BCAS Academy

Webinar on Mastering Compliance with India’s DPDP Act

7. Webinar on BHARAT CONNECT FOR BUSINESS (BCB) held on Saturday, 13th December 2025 @ Virtual

The Technology Initiatives Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society successfully hosted a webinar on “Bharat Connect for Business (BCB)” on 13 December 2025, which witnessed enthusiastic participation from members across age groups and practice profiles.

The webinar focused on the evolving landscape of connected accounting for MSMEs, highlighting how Bharat Connect for Business aims to seamlessly integrate invoices, payments, and reconciliations across accounting platforms. The session provided valuable insights into how automation and interoperability between systems can significantly enhance efficiency, accuracy, and turnaround time for businesses and their advisors.

Eminent speakers Mr Rupesh Thakkar (Tally Solutions), Mr Vignesh RV (Zoho), and Mr Vipul Arun (NPCI Bharat BillPay Limited) shared practical perspectives on the concept, functionalities, and real-world impact of BCB. A key highlight of the webinar was a live demonstration of transaction flow between Zoho and Tally, which was particularly well appreciated by the participants for its practical relevance.

The session concluded with an engaging Q&A, reflecting keen interest among members in adopting connected and automated solutions in their professional practice. Overall, the webinar was well-received and reinforced BCAS’s continued commitment to keeping its members abreast of emerging technological developments impacting the profession.

Scan to watch online at BCAS Academy

Webinar on BHARAT CONNECT FOR BUSINESS (BCB)

II. REPRESENTATIONS

1. Representation on Section 12A Registration Renewal Requirements

BCAS submitted a representation on January 7, 2026, to the Revenue Secretary, Chairman of CBDT, and the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (Exemptions), highlighting issues faced by public charitable trusts in the renewal of registration under Section 12A. The Society opposed the insistence on an express irrevocable clause in trust deeds for Form 10AB, citing judicial precedents and state trust laws which establish irrevocability in law even without such clauses. BCAS requested the issuance of suitable clarifications to avoid unnecessary amendments to trust deeds.

QR Code:

Representation on Section 12A Registration Renewal Requirements

2. Representation on GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C Filing Challenges

BCAS submitted a representation on December 29, 2025, to the Hon’ble Finance Minister, CBIC Chairperson, and GST Council Secretariat seeking extension of the due date for filing Forms GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C for FY 2024-25. The Society highlighted difficulties arising from enhanced ITC reporting requirements, revised GSTR-9 auto-population, delayed availability of audited financials due to extended tax audit timelines, and overlap with adjudication deadlines under the CGST Act. BCAS requested suitable relaxation to enable accurate compliance.

QR Code:

Representation on GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C Filing Challenges

Readers can read the full representation by scanning the QR code or visiting our website www.bcasonline.org

III. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

  •  BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

Learning Events at BCAS

1. CA Pariksha Pe Charcha held on Saturday, 6th December 2025@ Virtual.

Speakers: CA K S Ranjani, CA Heramb Maheshwari, CA Utsav Shah, CA Nidhish Naik, CA Naman Gupta, CA Ansh Bhorawat & CA Anjali Shukla

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organised “CA Pariksha Pe Charcha”, an interactive learning session designed to guide CA students in their exam preparation journey. The program commenced with an inspiring keynote by CA K S Ranjani, who spoke on resilience, overcoming setbacks, and developing a success-oriented mindset. This was followed by an insightful session by CA Heramb Maheshwari (AIR 1 – November 2024), who shared his exam preparation journey, practical exam strategies and clarified ICAI evaluation myths.

A dynamic panel discussion featuring top rankers from the September 2025 CA Final exam brought real-life perspectives on study routines, discipline, answer writing, and balancing mental well-being. Students from across the country participated enthusiastically, making the session highly engaging and impactful.

Overall, the program provided a blend of motivation, actionable techniques, and relatable experiences, helping students approach their CA journey with clarity, confidence, and a structured plan.

Scan to watch on Youtube

CA Pariksha Pe Charcha

2. Webinar on New Labour Codes: Legal Framework, Financial Impact & Practical Implementation held on Friday, 5th December 2025@ Virtual.

The Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised a webinar on “New Labour Codes: Legal Framework, Financial Impact & Practical Implementation” on Friday, 5th December 2025.

The Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised a webinar on “New Labour Codes: Legal Framework, Financial Impact & Practical Implementation” on Friday, 5th December 2025.

The programme was conducted in two segments. Adv. Sundeep Puri covered the legal and conceptual aspects of the Codes, explaining the structure, intent and major changes introduced. CA Alok Agarwal and CA Bhavin Rajput discussed the financial, compliance and implementation-related implications, highlighting areas requiring organisational preparedness, policy review and systems alignment.

The webinar received an encouraging response from members across practice and industry. 316 participants enrolled for this webinar from 50+ cities and towns across India. Participants appreciated the clarity of explanations and the practical insights shared by the speakers.

Scan to watch online at BCAS Academy

Webinar on New Labour Codes

3. AARAMBH – Making Articleship Count held on Thursday, 04 December, 2025 @ HR College of Commerce & Economics, Churchgate, Mumbai

AARAMBH

Every meaningful journey begins with a purposeful start. Aarambh, meaning a new beginning, represents BCAS’s commitment to guiding CA students at one of the most defining stages of their professional journey – the commencement of articleship.

Through the Aarambh – Making Articleship Count Initiative, BCAS fulfils its professional social responsibility by engaging directly with students and sharing practical insights, real-life experiences, and guidance from young Chartered Accountants who have recently walked the same path. The sessions are designed to bridge the gap between academic learning and professional realities, enabling students to approach articleship with clarity, confidence, and a long-term perspective.

The first session under this initiative was held at H.R. College of Commerce & Economics, Churchgate, Mumbai, on Thursday, 4th December 2025. The programme was made possible through the wholehearted support and cooperation of Principal Mrs. Pooja Ramchandani and Director – Placement, Dr. Navin Punjabi.

The programme witnessed enthusiastic student participation, driven by an engaging panel discussion and vibrant interaction. The presence and encouragement of the team BCAS – President CA Zubin Billimoria, Hon. Joint Secretary CA Mrinal Mehta, Managing Committee member CA Anand Kothari, and the panelists from Core Group CA Mahesh Nayak, CA Aditya Pradhan and CA Vatsal Paun, further reinforced the Society’s collective commitment to nurturing the future torch-bearers of the profession.

BCAS remains steadfast in its mission to mentor, inspire, and support the next generation of Chartered Accountants, contributing meaningfully to the profession and to the nation at large.

4. FALCON – Making Articleship Count held on Wednesday 03rd December, 2025 at N M College of Commerce & Economics, Vile Parle, Mumbai

FALCON

The falcon bird symbolises vision, power and victory. With this initiative, BCAS offers young CA aspirants an opportunity to interact and learn from young Core Group members – those who have walked the path before them. The panellists dwell on the topics of Articleship, Post Qualification, Professional Association & Networking, and Leadership. To ensure that the aspirants feel both comfortable and confident to engage with the panellists, the initiative has BCAS meet them on their home turf – be it college, or coaching class or even CA firm.

The first session under this initiative was held at N M College of Commerce & Economics on Wednesday, 3rd December 2025. Principal Dr Parag Ajgaonkar and Vice Principal CA Dr Savita A Desai of the college personally welcomed the visiting team from BCAS comprising the President, CA Zubin Billimoria, Managing Committee member, CA Preeti Cherian and the three panellists – Managing Committee members, CA Samit Saraf and CA Sneh Bhuta and Core Group member, CA Vedant Gada. The session was ably supported by the Association of Accountancy Committee of N M College. The audience, comprising degree college students who are set to embark on this wondrous journey, found the discussion both informative and helpful.

From the BCAS perspective, engaging with the students as they commit themselves to a demanding, yet extremely satisfying career choice is imperative – these students are the face of tomorrow of the profession.

In the words of the American author, Mercedes Lackey, “The hatched chick cannot go back to the shell, the falcon who has found the sky does not willingly sit the nest.”

5. CATHON (Marathon) – Run for Fitness, Fun and Purpose held on Sunday, 30th November 2025 @ Iconic Bandra Fort, Mumbai.

CATHON

India’s Second Edition of CA-Thon 2025 – A Run for Fitness, Fun & Purpose was organized on Sunday, 30th November 2025 near Bandra Fort, Mumbai under the aegis of the Seminar, Membership & Public Relations (SMPR) Committee.

The event attracted 2,000+ participants – Chartered Accountants and non-Chartered Accountants alike – between the age group of 8 to 70 years – drawn from all walks of life, from different corners of the country. An added feature this year was the participation of select CA firms that enlisted their team members for the run.

The annual event helped increase the visibility of Brand BCAS, cement relationships within the community, promote health and fitness among participants drawn from all walks of life and contribute to a righteous cause (part of the proceeds went to donating professional sewing machines to women from marginalized communities, to help them become entrepreneurs in their own right). BCAS Foundation also joined hands in supporting these women through this donation.

Through this annual run, the CA-Thon hopes to encourage runners to incorporate physical activity as part of their daily routine, thereby leading to an agile and healthy life, which is one of the cornerstones of financial well-being.

6. Webinar on Tax Law in Transition- Impact on Landmark Rulings After Introduction of New Income Tax Act 2025 and Recent decisions covering the Real Estate sector held on Saturday, 29th November 2025 @ Virtual.

The Direct Tax Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organized a Webinar on Tax Law in Transition – Impact on Landmark Rulings after New Era of Reform and Recent Decisions covering the Real Estate Sector.

The session focused on how the real estate sector continues to face complex tax challenges, especially due to frequent litigation, changing business models, and evolving regulatory rules. Participants were taken through key judicial developments and how these decisions affect day-to-day tax positions in the industry.

CA Harsh Kothari spoke on the impact of the New Income Tax Act on landmark decisions under the old Act. He explained how the restructured law attempts to simplify provisions but also creates new interpretational considerations. His session focused on how earlier judicial principles may continue, where they may no longer apply and what tax professionals should keep in mind while interpreting the new Act. The webinar offered clear and practical insights for professionals in a period where both the law and its interpretation are going through a significant transition.

CA Anil Sathe presented a clear and insightful overview of recent and significant rulings impacting the real estate industry. He explained how courts have interpreted issues such as development agreements, joint development models, withholding implications, timing of income recognition, and capital gains triggers. His session helped participants understand how these rulings guide practical tax positions and compliance for developers, landowners, and investors.

Scan to watch online at BCAS Academy

Webinar on Tax Law in Transition

7. Women’s Study Circle meeting — SAKHI CIRCLE! held on Friday, 28th November 2025@ Virtual.

The inaugural session of the Women’s Study Circle was an inspiring and interactive experience. The theme, ‘Celebrate Your Uniqueness’, encouraged participants to embrace individuality and make conscious choices about their personal and professional lives.

CA Nandita Parekh opened the session with a powerful quote from Michelle Obama:

“Each of us carries a bit of inner brightness, something entirely unique and individual. A flame that’s worth protecting. When we recognise our own light, we become empowered to use it.”

Through two engaging stories—one about Michelle Obama’s journey and another about a monkey— CA Nandita Parekh illustrated the importance of self-worth and clarity in decision-making. She posed thought-provoking questions:

– What do you truly want?

– What are you holding on to, and what can you let go?

– Are you trying to fit in or do you truly belong?

The discussion highlighted how women’s paths are diverse and often non-linear.

The session emphasized that success is not about fitting into a mould but about defining your own balance between career, family, hobbies, and aspirations.

Key Takeaways:

– Embrace individuality and celebrate your uniqueness.

– Define priorities and make conscious choices.

– Build support systems and networks for growth.

Motivational Highlight:

“Celebrate who you are today, while creating space for who you want to become.”

8. Lecture Meeting on Boosting Business and Professional Productivity through AI held on Wednesday, 26th November 2025 @ Virtual.

A public lecture meeting was conducted by the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society virtually on zoom platform on 26th November 2025.

The speaker CA Umesh Sharma explained how Artificial Intelligence can significantly enhance professional and business productivity, particularly for chartered accountants. The speaker highlighted several core technologies, including machine learning, natural language processing, and generative AI, emphasizing their roles in fraud detection, financial advisory, and process automation. He outlined a strategic framework for AI implementation, moving from individual skill-building to sector-wide integration while maintaining essential human judgment and ethical standards. Practical advice was provided for firms of all sizes to address operational challenges, such as managing document chaos and improving client relations through digital dashboards. Ultimately, the speaker encouraged professionals to view AI as a powerful assistant rather than a threat, urging proactive learning and technical adaptation to stay competitive in a changing financial landscape.

The lecture was well-attended, with over 260 participants joining online.

Scan to watch online on Youtube

Lecture Meeting on Boosting Business and Professional Productivity

9. FEMA Study Circle Meeting on How to Study FEMA held on 25th November 2025 @ Virtual

The FEMA Study Circle held a meeting on the topic “How to study FEMA” which dealt with the core fundamentals of gaining expertise in FEMA.

The session was chaired by CA Naresh Ajwani and led by group leader, CA Vivek Vithlani.

The chairman provided a deep insight into the unique aspects of the exchange control law, which makes this topic worthy of being taken for beginners.

The group leader explained the approach which is required to study and gain expertise in any law in general. Along with the approach, he shared the chronology of steps which he has developed over the years to understand any law. Further, the group leader showed how the generic approach and step-wise chronology can be applied to FEMA in particular and the nuances pertaining to the same. Light was also thrown on different legal documents issued by the Central Government and the RBI to show a 360-degree view of FEMA.

The meeting was concluded by summarising the milestones of gaining expertise in any law.

10. Power Summit 2025 held on 21st & 22nd November 2025 @ Lemon Tree Premier – Pune.

Power Summit

Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organised a two-day residential program “The Power Summit 2025” on 21 & 22 November 2025 at Hotel Lemon Tree Premier, Pune. This was the 10th season of the Power Summit with the first one being held in 2011.

The theme for the Power Summit was Growth, Governance & Generational Transition – Shaping The Firms of 2030. The Power Summit hosted about 95 participants coming from cities across the country. There were certain participants who had been part of all the previous ninePower Summits as well as participants attending for the first time. This diversity added to the charm of the Summit.

The presentation and panel discussions over the two days were creative, intriguing, and interwoven in a manner that left all participants with valuable insights and a renewed determination to progress along their growth trajectory.

A brief snapshot of the presentation and panel discussions is as follows:

Topic Speaker / Panellist
& Moderator
Key Learnings for Participants
Grow In Continuum: Succession Planning Strategies

for Proprietorship & Small Firms

CA Jayraj Sheth Participants learnt from Jayraj’s presentation about key areas such as exploring when to begin succession planning, grooming successors and client transition strategies.
Partnership Deeds – Beyond the Fine Print,

ICAI – Latest Updates.

 

Speaker: CA Vishal Doshi | Moderator: CA Ameet Patel Candid discussion with Vishal gave insights into how ICAI, at institution level, is perceiving and looking at mergers, multi-disciplinary partnerships etc. Also, Vishal shared updates on the latest progress happening at ICAI level on these topics.
Fireside Chat: Women in Leadership: The Evolving Role

of Women Professional

 

Speaker: CA Priti Savla | Moderator: CA Nandita Parekh The chat highlighted the various initiatives taken by ICAI for empowering Women Professionals. Also, the personal journey of Priti, motivated and inspired all the participants.
Mergers and Expansion –

Why some work, why many fail

 

Panellists: CA Manish Sampat, CA Naman Shrimal  | Moderator: CA Vaibhav Manek The power packed discussion with the panellists left the participants with lots of food for thought on various merger models, geographic / vertical expansion, profit-sharing agreements, reasons for things not working out and practical suggestions on how to navigate these challenges.
Practice Excellence- Preparing For Growth/ Merger Panellists: CA Paresh Shaparia, CA Subhash Saraf | Moderator: CA Ameet Patel The practical experience shared by both the panellists gave interesting insights to all participants on how to get oneself or one’s own firm ready for Growth and Merger. Key takeaways being around areas of practice reviews, policy documentation, MIS systems etc.
Professional Firms @ 2030

What will it take?

 

Panellists: CA Nilesh Vikamsey, CA Naman Shrimal | Moderator: CA Vaibhav Manek The panellists shared multiple perspectives on what would be the key drivers for a successful CA Firm in 2030. Also, they shared interesting suggestions on future-proofing professional firms in the next decade.
Legal Insights on the Professional Service Firms – How to Navigate the Regulatory Landscape and Prepare for Risks and Liabilities Panellists: Mr. Shreyas Jayasimha, Ms. Radhika Iyer | Moderator: Vaibhav Manek It was an interesting panel discussion to provide a flavour to all the participants on the kind of legal risks that a professional is carrying in today’s time and practical suggestions on ways to navigate them. There was also discussion on how different professionals can collaborate to create a win-win situation for everyone.
Walk & Talk: Challenges of Firm Growth CA Nilesh Vikamsey, CA Ameet Patel, CA Nandita Parekh This was the concluding session in which the discussions focused on real-world barriers in expansion and how peers have navigated them. Interesting Q&As and discussions were done with the participants as well.

The Summit successfully generated substantial interest among the participants, thereby motivating them to strategically plan for their growth. The participants expressed their profound gratitude to the organising team for their exceptional work and the provision of a high-quality program. All participants shared their testimonials and gratitude via WhatsApp groups and social media platforms.

11. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on Succession Planning from a Direct Tax Perspective held on 20th November, 2025@ Virtual.

Succession planning plays a vital role in ensuring smooth intergenerational transfer of wealth and preventing disputes. The session highlighted key tax provisions, legal mechanisms, and practical considerations in designing an effective succession structure.

The following major areas were discussed during the session:

  1.  Succession Modes – Wills, trusts, nominations, and family arrangements are the primary structuring options, each carrying different tax outcomes.
  2.  Legal Representative Liability – Responsibility of Legal heirs with respect to tax liabilities of the deceased, including interest and penalty till the date of death.
  3. Taxation of Executors [S. 168] – Separate assessment of the executor on the income of the estate until its complete distribution.
  4. Nominee vs. Legal Heirs – The difference between the two was highlighted with an example of a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Shakti Yezdani, wherein it was held that a nominee merely facilitates transmission and does not override the rights of legal heirs.
  5. Will-based transfers – Tax Neutrality – transfers under a Will are not regarded as a “transfer” under Section 47(iii), and inheritance is specifically exempt under Section 56(2)(x). Thus, passing assets through a Will is a tax-efficient mechanism.
  6. Family Arrangements – Not a Transfer – The session clarified that a genuine family settlement based on antecedent rights is not treated as a transfer for capital gains. It simply realigns existing rights in property to preserve peace and prevent litigation within the family.
  7. Situations wherein Family Settlements become taxable – The session clarified that If parties lack pre-existing rights—as in P.P. Mahatme (Bom HC)—payments received may be treated as taxable capital gains. Antecedent rights are therefore key to determining tax neutrality.
  8. Specific vs. Discretionary Trusts – The speaker clarified that certain trusts have identifiable beneficiaries with defined shares, while discretionary trusts allow trustees to decide distributions. Discretionary trusts are generally taxed at the maximum marginal rate unless specific exceptions apply.

Conclusion: The session was highly interactive, with participants actively engaging and gaining practical clarity on the tax and legal aspects of succession planning. The discussions helped simplify complex concepts and gave attendees a clear understanding of how to apply the right tools in real-life situations. Overall, the audience left with valuable insights to plan succession more confidently and effectively.

12. Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs of the September 2025 Batch held on Monday, 17th November, 2025@ Sydenham College

Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs Nov

The Seminar, Membership and Public Relations (SMPR) Committee hosted a felicitation ceremony on 17th November 2025 in the auditorium of the Sydenham College of Commerce & Economics, Churchgate, to honour the newly qualified Chartered Accountants from the September 2025 batch. Out of the 450 registrations, over 325 enthusiastic newly qualified CAs participated in the event. The guest and mentor for the event was CA (Adv.) Kinjal Bhuta, Treasurer of BCAS. In her address, she reminisced about her early days, the support she received from her clientele and elders in the profession, and how her association with BCAS has helped in shaping her career and growth as a professional. She shared six life lessons with the audience and invited them to come within the BCAS fold and partake of the bouquet on offer.

AIR 16, Nidhish Naik, AIR 28 Ansh Bhorawat, AIR 34 Naman Gupta and AIR 46 Anjali Shukla were then felicitated. A celebratory cake was cut post which all the other newly passed CAs were felicitated. The ceremony served as a warm welcome of the newly qualified CAs into the wider professional fraternity.

Scan to watch online on Youtube

Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs

13. ITF Study Circle meeting – Black Money Act – Penalty for Non-Disclosure of Foreign Assets: Key Rulings held on 14th November, 2025@ Virtual.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organized a meeting (online) on 14 November 2025 to discuss key rulings with respect to penalty for non-disclosure of foreign assets under the Black Money Act:

Chairman of the session – CA Sushil Lakhani

Group Leader CA Kush Vatsaraj

  •  The session opened with the initial remarks from the chairman on the topic.
  • Post that, the group leader discussed the rationale of the Black Money Act and the basic provisions to set the context for the group.
  • Next the group leader discussed a number of rulings with respect to levy of penalty under the Black Money Act, including rulings under other laws but applicable to penalty under the Black Money Act.
  • The group leader discussed a recent Special Bench ruling with respect to the penalty being discretionary in greater detail
  • The participants debated various nuances with respect to the levy of penalty under the Black Money Act, especially with respect to some divergent views adopted by appellate authorities.
  • The group leader took the group through a number of scenarios with respect to the levy of penalty under the Black Money Act and shared his insights on the same. The chairman of the session also shared his insights.
  • The session closed with the floor being opened up for Q & A. Participants raised a number of questions and the same were answered by the group leader and the chairman of the session. Other participants also shared their practical experiences.

14. BCAS NXT – Learning & Development Bootcamp – A Deep Dive into GST Annual Return (GSTR-9) and Reconciliation Statement (GSTR -9C) held on 14th November, 2025@ Virtual.

The Human Resource Development Committee organized a BCAS NXT Learning & Development Bootcamp on “A Deep Dive into GST Annual Return (GSTR-9) and Reconciliation Statement (GSTR-9C)” on Friday, 14th November 2025, from 4:00 PM to 6:00 PM.
The session was led by Ms Riya Bhavesh Shah, a CA Final student, who delivered a detailed presentation covering each table in the GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C forms, the correct placement of data, and the importance of accurate and timely filing. The session also highlighted the consequences of late filing, recent procedural changes, and updates in reporting requirements. CA Ashwin Chotalia, the mentor for the session, provided valuable insights and guidance throughout, offering expert interventions as needed.

The bootcamp was held in person at Gokhale &  Sathe Chartered Accountants and was also streamed online, with active participation from students across India.

 

More than 250 students benefited from this session.

Scan to watch online on Youtube

BCAS NXT - Learning & Development Bootcamp

15. Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Study Circle – Financial Wellness for Professionals held on Thursday, 13th November 2025 @ Virtual

The session on “Financial Wellness for Professionals” by Mr Tarun Birani focused on helping high-earning professionals move from income dependence to true wealth independence through structure and discipline. Using interactive polls and case studies, he highlighted how lifestyle inflation, safety bias and scattered assets often keep professionals financially vulnerable despite strong incomes.

Tarun introduced a clear Wealth Allocation Framework, classifying assets into safety, stability and aspirational buckets, and showed how goal-based cash flows, risk assessment and stress testing can convert affluence into resilient, long-term wealth. He emphasised the power of disciplined equity allocation, behaviour management and periodic rebalancing over market prediction or product selection.

Through real-life client stories, he demonstrated the dangers of concentration in business / profession and real estate, lack of liquidity buffers and poor succession planning, and contrasted this with the benefits of structured family wealth architectures and family offices.

The session concluded with practical action points for professionals to document their finances, separate business and personal wealth, and work with fiduciary, conflict-free advisors to achieve financial wellness with peace of mind.

16. Half-Day Panel Discussions on Transfer Pricing Benchmarking and Compliances held on Friday, 10th October 2025 @ Virtual

The Society successfully conducted its Half-Day Panel Discussions on Transfer Pricing Benchmarking and Compliances via an online platform on Friday, 10th October, 2025 from 2:00 pm to 6:30 pm.

Based on participants’ feedback and consultation with seniors in the Committee, this year BCAS has come up with unique concept of sharing the recordings of the transfer pricing workshop undertaken in October 2023 along with recordings of panel discussions conducted in October 2024 to the participants as pre-reading for the workshop followed by two live panel discussions to take forward the learnings by discussing the intricate and practical issues on transfer pricing making the same more interactive. Details of these two live panel discussions:

Session Topic Panel Members/ Faculties
1 Panel Discussion on Indian TP Compliance – Beyond Documentation, Towards Value Creation Moderator – CA Anjul Mota Panelists- CA Namrata Dedhia, CA Naman Shrimal and CA Stuti Trivedi
2 Panel Discussion on Burning Issues in Indian TP – From Litigation to Strategic Risk Management Chairman cum Moderator – CA Vispi Patel  Panelists- CA Bhavesh Dedhia, CA Suchint Majmudar and CA Vijay Iyer

Participants were also provided an option to share the queries or issues to the panellists by way of Google form before the respective panel discussion which the panellists addressed during the panel discussion. Eminent tax professionals of the country were the panelists as well as moderator for such panel discussions.

Both the live sessions including the recorded sessions covered all the concepts of Transfer Pricing under the Income Tax Act, 1961 and the other relevant provisions.

More than 54 Participants from 15 states spread over 30 cities attended these live panel discussions which was well-received and appreciated by the participants.

Scan to watch online on BCAS Academy

Half-Day Panel Discussions on Transfer Pricing Benchmarking and Compliances

II. REPRESENTATIONS

1. BCAS Seeks Extension for GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C Due to Increased Compliance Complexity

On 11 December 2025, BCAS submitted a representation to the Hon’ble Finance Minister, highlighting challenges in filing GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C for FY 2024-25. Recent notifications have withdrawn long-standing relaxations, increasing compliance complexity. Key concerns include detailed ITC reporting (Table 7), new import reconciliation requirements (Table 8H1), changes in auto-population (Table 8A shifting from GSTR-2A to GSTR-2B), and technical glitches on the GST portal causing mismatches.

For GSTR-9C, withdrawal of turnover reconciliation relaxations and mandatory cross-year ITC reporting have made preparation more onerous. Tight timelines due to dependence on audited financial statements further exacerbate the challenge.

BCAS has requested a three-month extensionfor filing to allow professionals sufficient time to adapt, ensure data accuracy, and avoid inadvertent errors.

Readers can read the full representation by scanning the QR code or visiting our website www.bcasonline.org

QR Code:

BCAS Seeks Extension for GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C

III. BCAS OUTREACH

• BCAS Delegation Meets Chief Executive, Indian Banks’ Association

BCAS Delegation Meets Mr Atul Kumar

A delegation of BCAS – Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, led by CA Zubin Billimoria, President, and CA Kinjal Shah, Vice President, met Mr. Atul Kumar Goel, Chief Executive of the Indian Banks’ Association(IBA).

The delegation briefed Mr. Goel on the key initiatives and activities of BCAS and discussed potential areas of future cooperation between BCAS and IBA.

Mr. Daljit Dogra, Board Member of IBA and Managing Director of Zoroastrian Cooperative Bank, was also present and facilitated the interaction.

BCAS looks forward to a long-term and mutually beneficial professional association with the Indian Banks’ Association.

• Meeting of Office Bearers with Mr. Sudhir Hirdekar, ACP Crime Branch, Mumbai Police

IV. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

  •  BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

News and Views

Learning Events at BCAS

1. 8th Long Duration Course on Goods and Services Tax held on 18th August 2025 to 17th November 2025 @ Virtual

The 8th Long Duration Course on GST- 2025, organised by the BCAS, was successfully conducted in a fully Virtual (Online mode) from 18th August, 2025 to 17th November, 2025. The programme was scheduled every Monday and was thoughtfully covered theoretical as well as practical aspects of GST, enabling the participants to gain a comprehensive understanding of the subject.

The course covered 24 pre-recorded training videos, each ranging from 90-120 minutes, along with 9 live interactive sessions. Each session was delivered by the proficient faculty having immense expertise in the field of indirect taxation. The course started with the levy under CGST & SGST, scope of supply & related definitions and covered various concepts such as ISD vs. Cross charge, E-way bills, Registration, Valuation Principles, refunds under GST, POS Services – Domestic & International, Appellate procedure, returns, Annual returns & reconciliation, etc.

The pre-recorded videos provided participants with the opportunity to learn at their own pace, grasp technical concepts in depth, and come prepared with queries for the live sessions. This significantly enhanced engagement during the sessions, allowing participants to highlight practical issues and discuss them with nearly 24 distinguished GST experts, who enriched the learning through their insights.

During the live sessions, the moderators effectively coordinated the flow of discussions, addressed questions raised by participants, and facilitated meaningful deliberations on the assigned topics. This interactive format encouraged collaborative learning and ensured that participants gained clarity on complex provisions of GST law.

The course received an overwhelming response, with 178 participants enrolling from various cities across the country. The consistently positive feedback shared by attendees at the conclusion of the programme serves as a strong motivation for us to continue designing and delivering more such knowledge-enhancing courses in the future.

BCAS Academy link: – https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/8th-long-duration-course-on-goods-and-services-tax/

QR code:

8th Long Duration Course on Goods and Services Tax

2. The Family Offices Masterclass 2025 held on 15th November, 2025@ BCAS – Hybrid.

Family Office.

The Family Offices Masterclass 2025 explored the evolving structures, governance models, and regulatory considerations relevant to family offices in India and overseas. The masterclass witnessed strong participation with around 75 attendees present physically and over 235 participants joining virtually. The keynote address by CA (Dr.) Anup Shah emphasized the importance of long-term planning and cross-border readiness for wealth-owning families. CA Toral Shah explained foundational structuring options, including trusts, LLPs, companies, and governance elements for both single and multi-family offices. Adv. Poorvi Chothani discussed key global jurisdictions—UAE, Singapore, UK, US, and Portugal—highlighting regulatory nuances and practical considerations.

In the session on succession and estate planning, CA Falguni Shah covered wills, settlements, conflict management and case law insights relevant to business families. An interactive segment with Dr Srinath Sridharan provided perspectives on founder-successor dynamics and behavioural aspects illustrated through real-life experiences. Adv. Bijal Ajinkya addressed drafting and governance pitfalls with a focus on trust deeds, shareholder agreements, and fiduciary responsibilities.

Further, CA Mehul Bheda delivered an overview of domestic tax and regulatory issues relating to GAAR, POEM, AIFs and compliance challenges. The concluding session by CA Rutvik Sanghvi focused on cross-border tax and regulatory matters, including FEMA, DTAA application, NRI heirs, foreign trusts and global inheritance tax trends. The full-day masterclass concluded with an informal networking interaction.

3. Kung Fu Panda: Lessons on Life & Leadership held on Saturday, 8th November 2025 @ BCAS

Kung Fu Panda

The HRD Committee organised a unique and engaging session that brought together both CA members and CA students, creating a shared learning platform rooted in storytelling, reflection, and community interaction.

 

The event began with a movie screening of Kung Fu Panda, setting the stage for an open and thought-provoking discussion. Post the screening, participants reflected on powerful themes from Po’s journey—from overcoming self-doubt to discovering purpose—and how these ideas inspire us to embrace challenges as catalysts for growth.

The discussion encouraged attendees to interpret scenes through their own lens, drawing parallels to real-life challenges and personal evolution. Many participants shared their experiences and insights, making the discussion diverse and deeply relatable.

The session highlighted the power of self-belief, mentorship, resilience, and authenticity, seamlessly blending entertainment with impactful learning. It reaffirmed that some of the most meaningful lessons can emerge from the most unexpected narratives.

4. Full Day Workshop on Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) held on Saturday 01st November 2025 @ Hybrid.

Full Day Workshop on GST.

1. 125 participants from across 20 cities in India had registered for the workshop, with 37 participants enrolling for the physical event and the remaining participants enrolling virtually.

2. The first session covered the “Overview of the GSTAT framework”, including –

(a) Constitution of the GSTAT; Principal Bench; State Benches; Single and Division Benches.

(b) Distinguishing features between GSTAT, CESTAT and VAT / Sales Tax Tribunal.

3. The second session covered the “Significant and substantive aspects of GSTAT”, including appealable orders, timelines for filing appeals, the substantial changes proposed in the GSTAT Rules and their proposed functionality compared to the existing procedures in CESTAT, the inconsistencies between the provisions contained in the Act & Rules, etc..

4. The third session was on the technical subject of “Art of Drafting Pleadings”, where the speaker explained in detail the various fields in the appeal Form APL-05 and what information must be submitted therein, how the statement of facts and grounds of appeal must be drafted, care to be taken while preparing the appeal file, etc.

5. The fourth session covered the “Art of Advocacy” where the speaker explained the practical aspects of appearing before the Tribunal/ Courts, emphasizing how to conduct in court, realizing when to speak and when not to speak, the dual responsibility of the professionals, maintaining the decorum of the Court, operating ethically, etc..

The full-day workshop was completely interactive, with the faculty answering the queries raised by the participants.

BCAS Academy Link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/workshop-on-goods-and-services-tax-appellate-tribunal-gstat-law-procedure-and-practice/

QR code:

Full Day Workshop on Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT)

5. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle on “GST Annual Return Critical Amendments and Compliance Insight” held on Tuesday, 28th October 2025 @ Virtual

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society had organized the following Study Circle Meeting under Indirect Taxes on 28th October 2025:

Group Leader: CA. Aman Haria, Mumbai

Mentor: CA. Rajat Talati, Mumbai

The group leader first presented the various changes made to the GST Annual Return relating to F.Y. 2024-25, followed by seven case studies covering the various aspects of reporting in the Annual Return and its implications.

The presentation covered the following aspects of the GST Annual Return for a detailed discussion:

  •  Changes made to GST Annual Return (GSTR-9) vide CGST (Third Amendment) Rules, 2025 w.e.f. 17.09.2025, including the FAQs released by GSTN.
  •  Implication on reporting in case of errors relating to the nature of supply (inter-State vs. intra-State), category of recipient (B2B vs. B2C), and non-disclosure of RCM liability made in the monthly GST returns
  •  Nuances and issues in reporting ITC in cases where taxpayers have reported ITC in their monthly returns by following Circular No. 170/02/2022-GST, dated 06.07.2022, vs. taxpayers who have not followed the said circular.
  •  Effect of amendment to invoices by suppliers on the values reported in Table 8 of GSTR-9.
  •  Effect of reporting ‘additional ITC reversal’ in Annual Return, which is found during finalisation of accounts.
  •  Implications of mandatory details required to be reported in GSTR-9 of F.Y. 2024-25, which may not be readily available to the taxpayer.
  •  Difference between reporting details of Table 8C and Table 13 of GSTR-9.
  •  Challenges in reporting details in Table 12 of GSTR-9C owing to changes made in GSTR-9.

Around 112 participants from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader and the mentor.

6. Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Study Circle – Critical Issues Related to FCRA Laws for NPO held on Friday, 24th October 2025 @ Virtual.

On 24th October 2025, a virtual Study Circle meeting on “Critical Issues related to FCRA Laws for NPOs” was conducted with CA Khubi Shah Sanghvi as the speaker. She commenced the session by explaining the inception, scope and key definitions under the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA), particularly the meaning of “foreign contribution” and “foreign source”. The discussion then moved to important periodic and event-based FCRA compliance and the relevant prescribed forms. The learned speaker provided valuable insights into critical aspects of registration, renewal, suspension, cancellation and surrender of FCRA registration, along with major reasons for rejection of applications. An in-depth analysis of the amendments made in 2020, 2024 and 2025 was shared, followed by a useful overview of the FATF Charter for Associations and expectations under the Charter for Chartered Accountants. Recent circulars, public notices and notifications were also highlighted, with the speaker addressing several practical compliance issues faced by NPOs. The session was highly informative and well-received by all attendees, with a total of 38 participants benefiting from the knowledge-sharing.

7. ITF Study Circle Meeting on “Nuances in Residential Status for Individuals – Income Tax Perspective” held on 14th October, 2025@ Virtual.

Chairman of the session – CA Mayur Nayak and Group Leaders: CA Nithin Surana and CA K Prasanna

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organized a meeting (virtual mode) on 14 October 2025 to discuss the nuances in the Residential Status of Individuals from an Income Tax Perspective.

  •  The session opened with introductory remarks from the chairman on his initial views on the determination of residential status.
  •  As a precursor to the decision of DCIT vs. M Mahadevan [2025] 175 taxmann.com 383 (Chennai ITAT), the group leaders began with a quick look at the core principles for determining residential status as per Section 6 of the Income-tax Act 2025 (ITA 2025).
  •  The group leaders discussed the facts of the case, the contentions of the taxpayers and the tax authorities and the ruling by the Chennai ITAT in the case of. Mahadevan (supra).
  •  Further, the nuances about the concept of deemed residency & ‘liable to tax’ as per section 6(7) of ITA 2025 read with Article 4 of the OECD MTC.
  •  Deliberation was done on various connecting factors relevant to determining residential status as per OECD MTC.
  •  The chairman highlighted key points during crucial moments of the discussion and subsequently opened the floor for deliberation on the topic of ‘Split Residency’.
  •  Several participants shared their perspectives on the various implications of the ruling, and a range of divergent views emerged on multiple issues. The session was attended by a number of senior members of the fraternity. The discussion was lively and enriching for the participants.

The session closed with the concluding remarks made by the chairman.

8. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle – Issues in Exports and Refunds Under GST held on Tuesday, 07th October 2025 @ Virtual

Group Leader: CA. Deepak Kothari
Mentor: CA. Jignesh Kansara

The group leader first presented the Law pertaining to Exports and Refunds under GST, followed by seven case studies covering the various aspects of Issues in Exports and Refunds under GST.

The presentation covered the following aspects of Refunds and Exports for a detailed discussion:

  •  Implications for delayed receipt of Foreign Exchange and its implications under GST under Rule 96 of the CGST Act 2017.
  •  Implication of the Commercial Invoice amount being higher than the value declared in the Shipping Bill owing to freight charges and its implication on the refund under GST.
  •  Interpretation of Intermediary and its implications under claiming refunds under GST, and discussion about erroneous refund and powers of the department in relation to the same.

Around 92 participants from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader and the mentor. Due to paucity of time, only three case studies were completed; hence, BCAS is planning a Second Session for the same.

9. Professional Accountant Course held on Saturday, 19th July 2025 to Sunday 5th October 2025 @ Guru Nanak College

Professional Accountant Course

The Professional Accountant Course, jointly conducted by the Human Resource Development Committee, DBM India, and Guru Nanak College, concluded with its certification ceremony on 10th October 2025.

The programme was spread across 20 sessions over the weekends, held at Guru Nanak College, aimed to bridge the gap between academic learning and professional application for undergraduate students aspiring to build careers in finance, taxation and accounting. The course sought to provide classroom learning with industry practices, building the competence required for emerging professionals. The sessions covered an overview of diverse topics across various domains, including Direct Tax, Auditing, GST, Corporate and Allied Laws, Accounting & MIS and Technology Applications for Accounting and Management Reporting, thoughtfully curated to provide a holistic understanding of accounting and finance.

Each session was designed to promote conceptual clarity through practical examples and interactive learning. The knowledge was delivered through engaging sessions conducted by eminent professionals. BCAS served as the Knowledge Partner, with members from various Committees across BCAS and other professionals volunteering their time and expertise to deliver high-quality sessions and mentor the participants. The programme received an enthusiastic response with 59 students from the college participating in these sessions.

A key highlight of the initiative is the Internship Assistance Programme, supported by BCAS, under which eligible students are being connected with CA firms and industry networks for internship placements. This initiative provides participants with an opportunity to experience hands-on learning and apply classroom concepts in real-world scenarios.

The Professional Accountant Course marks another milestone in BCAS’s ongoing efforts to strengthen student connect and build a bridge between academia and the profession, empowering students through learning, mentorship, and collaboration to become future-ready professionals.

10. Panel Discussion Webinar on implications of OBBBA on Indian NRIs and Indian companies investing in the USA held on Monday, 11th August 2025 @ Virtual

OBBBA 1

Moderator: CA Paresh Shah

Panellists: CPA Vinay Navani & CA Prathamesh Hegishte

The panel gave their insights on the recently enacted One Big Beautiful Bill Act, 2025, in the US. The discussion focused on the implications of the new law on the Indian entities wishing to invest in the US and US residents wishing to invest in India. Queries raised to the panellists were practical and relevant for people having business relationships with the USA. The panel also responded to other US tax-related queries of the participants.

More than 200 participants attended the panel discussion.

All the participants well received the program.

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D78cb9xGd2o&t

QR code:

OBBBA

II. REPRESENTATIONS

The Bombay Chartered Accountants Society (BCAS) submitted feedback on the Draft ECB Regulations to the RBI on 24th October, 2025. Key points:

  •  Eligible Borrower: Clarification sought on FDI-linked restrictions and statutory registration requirements.
  •  Lender Due Diligence: Recommended standardised procedures for non-compliant jurisdictions.
  •  Operational Clarity: Guidance requested on borrowing limits, pricing norms, and ALP applicability.
  •  Existing ECBs: Proposed enabling provisions for revised interest rates or reduced MAMP.
  •  Reporting & Monitoring: Clarification sought on ECB utilisation and parking procedures.

This submission underscores BCAS’s commitment to practical and member-friendly regulatory reforms.

QR Code:

REPRESENTATIONS

Readers can read the full representation by scanning the QR code or visiting our website www.bcasonline.org

III. BCAS INITIATIVES

1. “Are You Aware?” PODCAST Series.

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society continues its commitment to spreading knowledge and strengthening public understanding of complex international taxation matters. Through the “Are You Aware?” podcast series, the BCAS International Taxation Committee has been creating accessible, high-quality content on important cross-border tax and regulatory issues.

The latest podcast on the topic of Consequences of Non-Disclosure of Foreign Assets by CA Rutvik Sanghvi, CA Kartik Badiani, and CA Mahesh Nayak was released in the month of Oct 2025.

This episode dives deep into the legal, compliance, and procedural aspects of foreign asset disclosure, highlighting the implications of non-reporting under Indian tax law.

The other episodes in the series cover a wide spectrum of relevant topics, including:

  •  Global Taxation – Five decades of change & the road ahead by CA Hitesh Gajaria, in conversation with CA Pinakin Desai.
  •  Are You Aware? How to claim Foreign Tax Credit in India? by CA Divya Jokhakar, in conversation with CA Nilesh Kapadia.
  •  Are You Aware? Of Exposure to Foreign Companies under Indian Income-tax Act? by CA Divya Jokhakar, in conversation with CA Sushil Lakhani.
  •  FERA to FEMA & Beyond: Evolution of India’s Forex Laws – A conversation with CA Shri Dilip J Thakkar and CA Rutvik Sanghvi.

These initiatives reflect BCAS’s broader mission to contribute to society by promoting informed decision-making, voluntary compliance, and continuous professional development. The Society remains dedicated to offering resources that bring clarity to complex laws and empower stakeholders at all levels. To explore all episodes under the “Are You Aware?” podcast series, kindly scan the QR code below.

PODCAST

2. BCAS Library Now Open for Book Lending!

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society is pleased to reopen its Library Lending Service, welcoming members and students to rediscover the joy of reading. With a thoughtfully curated collection—from technical resources to enriching general reads—the library offers a space to learn, reflect, and grow.

Library Access at a Glance:

  •  Who Can Borrow? BCAS members and students
  •  Deposit: A one-time refundable ₹500
  •  Borrowing Allowance: One book per month
  •  Easy Returns: Drop-off at the BCAS office

We encourage members and students to explore the book list, understand the borrowing guidelines, and enrol to enjoy the benefits of this valuable resource.

Explore the Book List: https://lin-k.ai/BCAS-Library-List-2025x

QR code:

BOOK list

Library Enrollment Form & SOP: https://lin-k.ai/BCAS-Library-Enrollment-Form

QR code:

L Enrollment

IV. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

• BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

News

Learning Events at BCAS

1. FEMA Study Circle – Draft Borrowing and Lending Regulations Issued by RBI held on 17th October, 2025@ Virtual

The FEMA Study Circle organized a meeting on 17th October 2025 to deliberate on the Draft Borrowing and Lending Regulations issued by the RBI. The session was chaired by CA Natwar Thakrar and led by CA Smeet Naren Madlani.

The discussion covered several key aspects:

  • Clarification on Eligibility Nexus
  • Scope of the Term ‘Eligible Borrower’
  • Use of ECB Proceeds for Acquisitions
  • Ambiguity in Regulation 3A(f)(iii)
  • Lenders from FATF/IOSCO Non-Compliant Jurisdictions
  • Borrowing Limit – Period of Maintenance
  • Currency of Borrowing
  • Arm’s Length Pricing of Borrowings
  • Credit of ECB Proceeds to FCY Accounts
  • Applicability of Revised Parameters to Existing ECBs
  • Reporting Requirements under Form ECB-2.

The session provided valuable insights into the evolving FEMA framework and its implications for cross-border borrowing and lending transactions.

2. India IPO Conclave held on Thursday, 9th October 2025 @ Ginger by Taj, Mumbai Airport

The India IPO Conclave 2025, organised by the Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS), was held on 9th October 2025 at Ginger by Taj, Mumbai Airport, in collaboration with NISM, with the Bombay Industries Association (BIA) as the Industry Partner. The theme of the Conclave was “Readiness, Challenges & Opportunities.” The event was spearheaded by Co-Chairman CA Anand Bathiya and led by Convenor CA Rimple Dedhia, supported by CA Sahil Parikh and CA Simran Vishwakarma, under the able stewardship of Chairman CA Naushad Panjwani.

The Conclave witnessed participation from around 150 professionals, with 30% of attendees joining from cities beyond Mumbai and nearly half being non-members, reflecting a diverse and pan-India engagement.

The event commenced with an inaugural session, followed by an address from Mr Jeevan Sonaparote, Executive Director, SEBI, who highlighted the critical role of auditors as gatekeepers in the capital-market ecosystem and SEBI’s reliance on them as first-level regulators. Mr Rajeev Thakkar, Chief Investment Officer, PPFAS, delivered the keynote address on the “Current State of Indian Primary Capital Markets.”

Throughout the day, sessions delved into various facets of India’s IPO landscape, including legal and regulatory preparedness, promoter mindset, investor expectations, and the roles of auditors and merchant bankers in the listing process. Esteemed speakers and moderators included Adv. Janak Bathiya, Adv. Yash Ashar, CA Bhavik Shah, Dr Rachana Baid, Dr Jinesh Panchali, and CA Sahil Parikh, while panellists Mr Arvind Agrawal, Mr Jigar Shah, Dr Lalit Kanodia, Mr Deven Choksey, Mr Nimish Shah, Mr Umesh Agarwal, Mr. Pinak Bhattacharyya, Mr V. Prashant Rao, and Mr Vivek Vaishnav shared their valuable insights and perspectives.

Key takeaways included actionable insights on IPO readiness and compliance, encompassing legal, audit, and regulatory perspectives, as well as real-world lessons from promoters, investors, and industry leaders on successful listing strategies, market timing, and investor expectations.

The Conclave successfully provided a comprehensive platform for knowledge-sharing, discussion, and networking.

BCAS Academy link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/india-ipo-conclave-2025/

3. Daughters’ Rights in Succession Laws held on Thursday, 25th September 2025 @ BCAS (Hybrid)

On International Daughters’ Day, the Finance Corporate and Allied Laws Committee of BCAS organized a special session on “Daughters’ Rights in Succession Laws”, led by renowned family law expert Adv. Mrunalini Deshmukh. The session aimed to raise awareness about the legal rights of daughters in inheritance and succession, a topic of growing relevance in India’s evolving socio-legal landscape.

Adv. Deshmukh covered key legal provisions, landmark Supreme Court rulings, and the impact of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, highlighting the equal rights of daughters in ancestral property. The talk also touched on practical challenges and societal attitudes that often hinder the implementation of these rights.

The hybrid event drew strong engagement from both in-person and virtual attendees from across the country, making it a truly inclusive and enlightening experience.

BCAS Academy link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/daughters-rights-in-succession-laws/

4. ITF Study Circle Meeting on “Future of MLI Post Mumbai Tribunal Ruling in Sky High” held on 23rd September, 2025@ Virtual.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organized a meeting on 23 September 2025 to discuss the future of the Multilateral Instrument post the Mumbai Tribunal’s ruling in the case of Sky High.

Chairman of the session – CA Ganesh Rajagopalan

Group Leaders CA Abhitan Mehta and CA Nemin Shah

  • The session opened with remarks from the chairman on his initial views of the Mumbai Tribunal ruling.
  • Post that, the group leaders began with a quick look at the basic concepts of BEPS and MLI and various steps taken by the Government.
  • Next, the group leaders discussed the facts of the case, the contentions of the taxpayers and the tax authorities and the ruling by the Mumbai Tribunal.
  • Then the group leaders discussed the nuances and implications of the ruling. The chairman of the session also added key points at critical points in the discussion. The chairman opened the floor for discussion on the key implications of the ruling.
  • Many participants shared their views on a number of implications of the ruling, and divergent views were expressed on a lot of issues. The discussion was lively and enriching for the participants. The session was attended by a number of senior members, and the participants benefited from their expert views on the ruling.

The session closed with concluding remarks by the chairman.

5. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Applicability of Valuation Provisions under Income Tax Act” held on 18th September2025@ Virtual.

Speaker: Mr. Raghav Bajaj

The speaker began by emphasizing the critical role of valuation in ensuring fair taxation and its relevance across advisory, restructuring, and litigation contexts. He then examined key valuation provisions of the Act, illustrating them with practical examples and interpretative insights.

The following major areas were discussed during the session:

1. Section 9(1)(i): Indirect transfer provisions and their valuation implications in cross-border transactions.

2. Section 17(2)(vi): Determination of perquisite value in the case of ESOPs, including nuances in valuation methodology.
3. Section 28(via): Tax treatment on conversion of inventory into capital assets and its valuation considerations.

4. Sections 9B and 45(4): Capital gains taxation arising on dissolution or reconstitution of firms and valuation of distributed assets.

5. Section 50B: Valuation in slump sale transactions and computation of capital gains in scenarios involving negative net worth.

6. Sections 50C and 50CA: Valuation disputes in the transfer of immovable property and unquoted shares vis-à-vis stamp duty and fair market values.

7. Section 56(2)(x): Determination of fair market value for receipt of property and shares, particularly in related-party or group transactions.

8. Sections with no explicit FMV mechanism: Practical issues in adopting alternative valuation methodologies and dealing with the absence of prescribed rules.

Overall, the discussion offered valuable insights into the interplay between valuation and taxation, equipping participants with practical knowledge to navigate evolving tax and regulatory landscapes effectively.

6. One-Day Seminar on NBFCs – Challenges, Opportunities and the Road Ahead held on Friday, 12th September 2025 @ Babubhai Chinai Hall IMC.

To dive deep into governance, RBI compliance, digital disruptions, fintech innovations and sustainable financing, the BCAS organized a full-day seminar on NBFCs.

The NBFC Seminar has become a regular feature on the BCAS calendar, providing members with an important platform to stay abreast of evolving trends in the financial services sector. With Ind AS stabilising in the industry, economic growth gaining momentum, technological disruptions reshaping business models, and RBI guidelines constantly evolving, this year’s seminar proved to be both a refresher on established principles and a window into emerging opportunities.

The seminar opened with remarks from CA. Zubin Billimoria, President of BCAS, and CA. Abhay Mehta, Chairman of the Accounting and Auditing Committee. Both highlighted the significance of knowledge-sharing and the society’s role in equipping members for the future of the profession.

The technical sessions covered a wide spectrum of contemporary issues and were delivered by an eminent panel of speakers:

NBFC Universe & RBI Compliance – CA. Bhavesh Vora offered an insightful overview of the role of NBFCs in India’s growth trajectory, touching on regulatory developments and key market undercurrents. He highlighted how NBFCs complement the banking system and bridge the last-mile credit gap in the economy.

From Legacy to Digital: FinTech Disruptions – CA. Keshav Loyalka explained how AI and technology are reshaping the credit landscape, enabling new business models and driving economic expansion. He emphasised how fintech players are transforming customer experience and risk assessment frameworks.

Sustainable Financing by NBFCs – Ms Namita Vikas presented thought-provoking insights on the emerging field of climate finance, illustrating its transformative impact with practical examples, including initiatives supporting salt farmers in Gujarat. She stressed that sustainability is not just a social responsibility but also a strategic business imperative.

Auditing Digital Lenders & FinTech NBFCs – CA. Murtuza Vajihi addressed the challenges faced by auditors in a rapidly digitising environment, emphasising the need to be well-versed both technically and technologically. He pointed out that audit approaches must evolve to deal with data-driven business models and high transaction volumes.

Enterprise Risk Management in Fintech & LSPs – Dr Gautam Sanyal introduced important concepts such as risk culture, risk appetite, control frameworks, and risk-based governance, enriching his session with real-life case studies. He underlined that proactive risk management is central to building resilience and investor confidence.

Ind AS vs. Ind Guess? Decoding ECL, Fair Value & Audit Judgment – CA. Manan Lakhani shared practical insights into the complexities of Ind AS, with a special focus on Expected Credit Loss, fair value assessments, and the role of professional judgment in audits. He also explained common pitfalls observed in practice and how auditors can exercise balanced judgment.

BCAS Academy link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/seminar-on-nbfcs-challenges-opportunities-and-the-road-ahead/

7. FEMA Study Circle meeting on “Residence of Individuals under FEMA – Issues and implications out of recent SAFEMA Tribunal decision” held on 4th September 2025@, Virtual.

The FEMA Study Circle held a meeting on the recent SAFEMA Tribunal decision pronounced in the case of Pradeep Mishra vs. Special Director, ED, which dealt with the interpretation of the definition of “person resident in India” as defined under Section 2(v) of FEMA.

The session was chaired by Chairman, CA Rashmin Sanghvi and led by group leader, CA Bhavya Gandhi.

The chairman provided a deep insight into the history and background of the definition provided under Section 2(v) of FEMA, the two possible interpretations that can be made and their associated complexities.

The group leader explained the significance of determining the residential status under FEMA while dealing with foreign exchange transactions and assessing FEMA implications thereon. Practical examples were discussed to demonstrate the challenges associated with adopting a literal interpretation of the definition instead of a purposive interpretation. Light was also thrown on different RBI Regulations/Master Directions or Government press releases, which indicate how the residency definition should be interpreted.

Elaborate discussions were held on the implications of the interpretation adopted by the SAFEMA Tribunal in pronouncing the decision. The group members also participated by asking queries, giving their views and experiences on the matter.

The meeting was concluded by summarising what are the best practices while dealing with controversial provisions of FEMA.

II. REPRESENTATIONS

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) has made two important representations to the GST authorities during the period under review, highlighting practical difficulties faced by professionals and taxpayers.

1. Representation for Extension of Due Date for Filing GSTR-3B for September 2025

On 8th October 2025, BCAS has requested an extension of the statutory due date for furnishing Form GSTR-3B and discharging tax liability for the month/quarter ending September 2025. The request was made considering that the original due date coincides with a weekend and major festival days across several regions, which could lead to operational and logistical constraints for taxpayers and professionals. The Society has urged the authorities to grant a reasonable extension to ensure smooth compliance and avoid hardship.

2. Representation for Dedicated Login and Dashboard Facility for Authorised Representatives on the GSTAT e-Filing Portal

On 29th September 2025, BCAS has requested the introduction of a dedicated login and dashboard facility for Authorised Representatives (ARs) on the GSTAT e-Filing Portal. Currently, the portal allows access primarily to appellants and respondents, creating challenges for ARs who manage multiple cases. A separate login for ARs would facilitate efficient case tracking, hearing management, and document access. The Society has emphasized that such functionality, similar to that available in other judicial forums like the ITAT and NCLT, would enhance overall efficiency and ensure better compliance management.

Through these initiatives, BCAS continues to promote a more efficient, practical, and taxpayer-friendly GST administration.

Readers can read the full representation by scanning the QR code or visiting our website www.bcasonline.org

III. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

Learning Events At BCAS

1. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Section 74 Notices Under GST: Demands, Defenses & Dilemmas” held on Tuesday, 16th September, 2025 @ Virtual.

Group leader CA. Ganesh Prabhu Balakumar prepared five case studies covering various aspects of Section 74 of the CGST Act.

The presentation covered the following aspects with the background of the applicability of section 74 for detailed discussion:

  1. Issues relating to the classification of drones, procedural aspects of inspection proceedings u/s section 67 of the CGST Act, and whether misclassification may lead to suppression.
  2. Aspects relating to RCM on import of services, implications of treatment of transactions in the books of accounts and allegations of suppression.
  3. Whether every mismatch or lapse, classification differences, return reconciliations, delayed RCM, and ITC mismatches amount to fraud, wilful misstatement and suppression u/s 74, or should they be treated as clerical and interpretational errors u/s 73.

Around 102 participants from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader and the mentor.

2. Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws (FCAL) Study Circle –  AGM Related Compliances (W.R.T. Private Companies) including Recent Amendments in Directors’ Report & Annual Filings held on Tuesday, 2nd September 2025 @ Virtual.

The Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Study Circle of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) organised a virtual session on 02nd September 2025 on the topic “AGM-related compliances (w.r.t. Private Companies) including recent amendments in Directors’ Report and annual filings.” The session focused on providing participants with a comprehensive understanding of the statutory provisions and practical considerations surrounding annual general meetings for private companies.

During the session, the speaker explained the latest regulatory updates and their implications on corporate governance and statutory filings. The discussion covered recent amendments impacting Directors’ Reports and annual filings, key timelines, and documentation requirements under the Companies Act. Various practical issues faced by companies were addressed, including common mistakes in annual filings and strategies to ensure timely and accurate compliance.

The session was highly interactive and was well-received by the attendees. A total of 65 participants benefited from the detailed discussion and gained clarity on evolving compliance requirements and best practices to manage statutory obligations efficiently.

3. Family Offices Summit 2025 held on 30th August 2025@ The Rooftop & Malabar Trident, Nariman point.

The Family Offices Summit 2025, organised by the Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Committee of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, held on 30th August 2025 at Trident, Nariman Point, Mumbai, was a landmark summit that brought together leading voices from family businesses, investment management, and advisory practices. The day-long summit featured keynote addresses, thought-provoking panels, and engaging conversations that explored the evolving role of family offices in India and in the global arena.

Setting the Context – The Rise of Family Offices

The summit began with a keynote address by Mr Rishabh Mariwala, who eloquently captured the rise of family offices in India. He spoke about why family offices matter now more than ever, emphasising their role in professionalising wealth management, preserving legacies, and empowering the next generation to carry forward values and vision alongside wealth.

The international perspective on structuring family offices in Asia, the Hong Kong Perspective featured insights from Mr Jason Fong, who delivered a short video message, and Ms Joanne Zheng, who gave a presentation. Together, they highlighted Hong Kong’s evolving ecosystem for family offices and noted that Indian families are increasingly exploring global jurisdictions for wealth structuring. This shift underscores Hong Kong’s appeal as a hub for family offices, thanks to its favourable tax policies, strategic location, and professional services.

Ancient Wisdom for Modern Day Family Businesses

National award-winning author Dr Radhakrishnan Pillai delivered an invigorating talk on ancient wisdom for modern family businesses. Drawing from the Arthashastra and Chanakya’s principles, he connected timeless governance and leadership insights with today’s family business challenges. His address reminded participants that while structures and strategies evolve, the essence of values, vision, and governance remains constant.

Session 1: Family Offices in India – Emerging Trends & Realities

The first panel brought together diverse voices across two parallel discussions. Panel 1A, moderated by Mr Avik Ashar featured Ms Anupa Tanna Shah, Mr Rubin Chheda, Mr. Sachin Tagra  and Mr. Samir Shah. The discussion revolved around the growing sophistication of family offices, professional management, and the balance between preserving legacy and seeking growth through new asset classes.

Panel 1B, moderated by Mr Devashish Khanna, hosted Mr Amit Jain, Mr Rahul Khanna, and Mr Subeer Monga. This discussion focused on the realities of structuring, the need for governance frameworks, and the importance of aligning investment philosophy with family objectives. Together, both panels highlighted the vibrancy and evolving maturity of family offices in India.

Session 2: Smart Structuring – Tax-Optimized Wealth Transfer & Succession

Post lunch, the focus shifted to succession and tax-efficient structuring. Moderated by Mr Rutvik Sanghvi, the panel featured Dr Anup Shah, Mr Parthiv Kamdar, and Mr Tanmay Patnaik. The session explored practical approaches to wealth transfer, succession planning tools, and the nuances of tax implications across jurisdictions. The discussion underscored that succession is not merely a legal exercise but a delicate balance of family dynamics, governance, and foresight.

Fireside Chat – Global Playgrounds: Jurisdiction Shopping for Indian Wealth

One of the highlights of the summit was the engaging fireside chat between Mr Dinesh Kanabar and Mr Anand Bathiya. Their candid conversation on jurisdiction shopping unpacked the rationale behind families considering global structures for wealth, covering regulatory considerations, global opportunities, and challenges. The discussion was both practical and visionary, offering participants a clear sense of the opportunities available in an increasingly interconnected world.

Session 3: Family Offices as Strategic Partners in Alternative Funds

The third thematic session focused on family offices as active partners in alternative investment platforms. Moderated by Ms Kinnari Gandhi, the panel included Mr Aditya Jha, Mr Anurag Agrawal, Mr Manish Chhabra, and Mr Nirav Shah. The dialogue highlighted how family offices are now playing a strategic role in shaping investment ecosystems, co-creating ventures, and deploying patient capital to nurture long-term opportunities.

Session 4: Real-Life Case Studies in Succession Planning

The final session was a powerful exploration of succession in action, moderated by Mr. Amit Goenka. Esteemed panellists Mr Aashish Somaiyaa, Mr Ravi Sheth, Mr Shishir Srivastava, and Mr Vivek Rajaraman shared real-life experiences from different sectors. The dwiscussion illuminated both the challenges and best practices in ensuring smooth transitions, underscoring the importance of trust, governance, and preparation in sustaining legacies.

Concluding Note

The day’s deliberations made it abundantly clear that family offices are not merely financial structures but institutions of continuity, vision, and stewardship. The Family Offices Summit, 2025, was attended by 76 participants, 40 were BCAS members, and the remaining 36 were non-members. Further, 19 participants attended from 12 cities outside the Mumbai Metropolitan Region.

This informative Summit was competently coordinated by Kinnari Gandhi with the help of convenors Khubi Shah Sanghvi and Rimple Dedhia and the guidance of Kanubhai, Naushadbhai and Anandbhai.

Family Offices Summit

4. Webinar on Mastering Charitable Trust Compliances held on Friday, 29th August 2025 @ Virtual

The BCAS webinar on “Mastering Charitable Trust Compliances” was successfully conducted on Friday, 29th August 2025, over the Zoom platform. The session was led by CA Gunja Thakrar and CA Ujwal Thakrar, and attracted wide participation from across the country, with over 145 attendees joining in. The audience comprised a diverse mix of professionals, trustees, and compliance officers, with attendees from more than 40 cities, including Mumbai, Bengaluru, Ahmedabad, Chennai, Delhi, Jaipur, Coimbatore, and even remote locations like Tuensang and Bhimavaram.

The webinar was structured around key compliance areas for charitable and religious trusts under the Income-tax Act. CA Gunja Thakrar led the first half of the session, beginning with an explanation of the Audit Report in Form 10B / 10BB, focusing on the interpretation of the 49 clauses, key compliance expectations, and documentation frameworks. This was followed by an overview of ITR-7, highlighting its key schedules and the accurate reporting of total income. She also covered the nuances of Forms 9 and 10, with emphasis on their applicability and disclosure requirements.

In the second half, CA Ujwal Thakrar delved into the increasingly important area of renewal and re-registration under Sections 12AB and 80G. He offered practical guidance on assessing organizational readiness, fulfilling financial compliance prerequisites, and navigating critical timelines. His session also included tips on managing documentation workflows, engaging with regulatory authorities, and monitoring post-registration conditions — all essential for effective compliance in today’s regulatory environment.

The session concluded with an engaging Q&A round, where attendees raised practical concerns from their daily practice. With participants spanning ages from below 30 to above 60, and nearly 45% of them from outside Mumbai, the webinar served as a robust learning platform. The comprehensive structure and clarity of presentation made it especially valuable to professionals managing trust compliance, reinforcing BCAS’s role in continuous learning and capacity building within the profession.

BCAS Academy Link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/webinar-on-mastering-charitable-trust-compliances/

5. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Use Of Technology in GST- Part 2” held on Friday, 29th August 2025 @ Virtual

The Bombay Chartered Accountant Society had organized the following Study Circle Meeting under Indirect Taxes on 29th August 2025.

Group leader CA Rahul Gabhawala prepared a step-by-step demonstration of the prompt use of technology in GST.

The Presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  1. Use of Chat-GPT to create codes in order to carry out Login at the GST Portal.
  2. Use of Selenium Wrapper to teach test automation at the GST Portal.
  3. Use of Selenium Wrappers to make test automation more efficient, reliable, and user-friendly.
  4. Use of Codes in automating certain functions at the GST Portal.

Around 80 participants from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader.

This was Part 2 of the session; Part 1 was held on 25th July 2025, and the write-up was published in the September 2025 issue of BCAJ.

5. DigiSetu – The Tech Bridge for Senior Professionals held on 7th, 14th, 21st, & 28th August 2025  @ Virtual

Speakers:

  • Ms Mahima Bhalotia, Mumbai
  • Mr Rohit Khiste, Nashik
  • CA Tanmay Bhavar, Nashik
  • CA Anup Tabe, Pune

SUMMARY:

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society hosted a four-part online series, DigiSetu – The Tech Bridge for Senior Professionals, in August 2025 through its Technology Initiatives Committee. Designed to blend technology with simplicity, the initiative empowered senior Chartered Accountants to stay updated in a fast-changing digital world — without jargon or complexity.

The journey began with DigiRakshak – Smartphone Safety Secrets, equipping participants with tools to block spam, manage app permissions, and secure payment apps. DigiSavdhaan – Cyber Safety 101 spotlighted online threats and safe digital habits. DigiSahayak – Gadgets & Apps Every Senior Professional Should Know opened a world of productivity apps and smart gadgets, while the finale, DigiBadlaav – AI Basics for Senior Professionals, demystified AI through practical uses of ChatGPT, automation, and ethical insights.

Short, crisp, and highly practical, DigiSetu proved that technology need not overwhelm senior professionals. Instead, it can serve as a bridge to confidence, efficiency, and ease in daily practice.

BCAS Academy Link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/digisetu-the-tech-bridge-for-senior-professionals/

6. Full Day Workshop on GST Appellate Tribunal held on Friday, 22nd August 2025 @ BCAS (Hybrid)

Session Topic Faculty
Session I Pre-preparation for Tribunal CA. Adv. Ishaan Patkar
Session II Understanding the Law and Procedure CA. Adv. Vinay Jain
Session III Drafting & Filing of GSTAT Appeals CA. Vinod Awtani

(1) 123 participants from across 45 cities in India had registered for the workshop, with 32 participants enrolling physically, all the way travelling from Panaji, Satara, Nashik, Navi Mumbai and Vadodara, apart from Mumbai

(2) The first session covered the pre-preparation aspects for the upcoming GSTAT and had a detailed discussion on

– Modes of discharging pre-deposits, acceptance of taxes already paid due to compulsion from the department, discussion on case laws relating to the legal validity of such issues in the erstwhile legacy IDT laws or GST laws for the previous level. Discussions also covered the amendments of 2025 for pre-deposits on penalty orders and their implications

– Understanding the distribution of appeals filed with the Principal Bench and State Bench, and how to segregate the place of supply matters

– Understanding the bandwidth of the professionals to manage the appeals across various benches if virtual hearings are not made available

– Action points for matters remanded back from the high courts

(3) The second session covered understanding the law and procedure pertaining to GSTAT

– A comprehensive discussion amongst the participants on the legal provisions, section 109 to section 113, and CGST Rule 110 to Rule 113A was covered

– Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 2025, being notified and covering detailed procedural aspects, were discussed threadbare.

– GSTAT Forms, which are other than the appeal forms, were also covered to complete the procedural aspects.

(4) The last session covered the practical aspects

– Drafting and Filing of GSTAT Appeals

– Paper Book Compilation

– Drafting of Statement of Facts and Grounds of Appeals and prayers

– Curing the defects, communication with Registry

– Condonation of Delay, Miscellaneous Applications, Additional Evidence, Corrections

– This session covered the finer points and care to be taken during the entire process of drafting. The Do’s and Don’ts

(5) The full-day workshop was completely interactive throughout the 3 sessions, with the queries of the participants attending both physically as well as virtually were discussed by the group and answered by the faculty.

Full Day Workshop on GST Appellate Tribunal

BCAS Academy Link: https://academy.bcasonline.org/courses/workshop-on-gst-appellate-tribunal/

7. ITF Study Circle Meeting on the Discussion on Demystifying SC’s Decision in Hyatt International held on 20th August 2025@ BCAS Hybrid.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organized a meeting (hybrid mode) on 20th August 2025 to discuss the implications of the Supreme Court’s ruling in the case of Hyatt International.

Chairman of the session – Mr Prashant Maharishi

Group Leaders CA Rohit Jethani and CA Sangeeta Jain

  • The session opened with remarks from the chairman on his initial views of the Supreme Court ruling.
  • Post that, the group leaders began by discussing the concept of Permanent Establishment.
  • Next, the group leaders discussed the facts of the case, the contentions of the taxpayers and the tax authorities and the ruling by the Supreme Court.
  • Then the group leaders discussed the implications of the ruling. The chairman of the session also added key points at critical points in the discussion.
  • Many participants shared their views on the ruling and their practical experiences in dealing with similar situations.
  • The group leaders also presented certain key points from meticulously undertaken research on various aspects of the ruling.

The session closed with concluding remarks by the chairman.

8. Webinar on Filing of Income Tax Returns for AY 2025-26 held on Tuesday, 12th August 2025 @ Virtual

The webinar on “Filing of Income Tax Returns for AY 2025-26 (ITR 1 to 6)” was successfully conducted on Tuesday, 12th August 2025, via Zoom, and witnessed an overwhelming response with 500+ participants. The session was jointly addressed by CA Divya Jokhakar and CA Khyati Vasani, both of whom are eminent professionals with deep domain expertise in direct tax compliance.

The speakers provided a detailed walkthrough of the changes introduced in ITR Forms 1 to 6 for AY 2025-26, including recent disclosure enhancements and practical nuances of reporting under the updated forms. Special emphasis was placed on understanding the granular reporting requirements in light of CBDT’s clarification that the filing due date was extended specifically to accommodate the extensive changes. The session highlighted how even small inaccuracies in ITR filings could lead to serious implications in terms of tax and interest liabilities.

The webinar concluded with an engaging Q&A session where participants actively raised their queries on tricky reporting areas, which were addressed with clarity by the speakers. The event reinforced the critical role of tax professionals in the evolving compliance landscape and was aimed at enhancing the readiness of members and their teams to ensure accurate and timely filing of income tax returns.

YouTube: – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fNkRsvnRhzI&t

9. Tree Plantation Drive 2025 held on 02nd and 03rd August 2025@ Vada, Palghar District.

On 2nd and 3rd August 2025, 24 BCAS members along with 6 BCAS staff, participated in a school visit and tree plantation drive organized by the BCAS Foundation. The visit began on the morning of 2nd August at Lakhani School, where the team proudly inaugurated a new Digital Classroom supported by the Foundation. Members interacted with students and teachers to understand their expectations and aspirations around digital learning.

Later that evening, the group visited MM School, where the BCAS Foundation had earlier implemented a Digital Classroom, along with a Library and Science Lab. Members had the opportunity to evaluate the positive impact of these initiatives, observing encouraging outcomes such as increased student engagement, heightened interest in learning, and a noticeable reduction in dropout rates. Witnessing the transformative power of technology and infrastructure in shaping young minds was both humbling and inspiring.

On 3rd August, participants visited Koseri Village in Casa District for a tree plantation drive. The villagers welcomed the BCAS team with a vibrant tribal dance, and school students offered a heartfelt prayer before the plantation began. Together, members, staff, and villagers planted 6,000 saplings across six villages, contributing to long-term environmental sustainability and rejuvenation of green cover in the region.

The visit also included an immersive experience at Keshav Srushti, where members explored the Oxygen Park and learned about the organization’s remarkable Gramya Vikas initiatives aimed at uplifting underprivileged rural and tribal communities. Keshav Srushti’s holistic efforts in education, skill development, and building self-reliant ecosystems left a deep impression on everyone. Planting saplings amidst such an inspiring environment of service and sustainability made the experience even more meaningful.
Walking through the Oxygen Park, breathing in the freshness, and witnessing how thoughtfully nature and development coexist offered members a rare pause from their fast-paced urban lives.  The two-day visit concluded with a renewed sense of gratitude and pride in being associated with BCAS Foundation, reaffirming the collective commitment to education, environmental care, and community upliftment.

Tree Plantation

II. REPRESENTATIONS

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) has submitted three key representations to the Government:

1. Charitable Trust Compliance Extensions: On 4th September 2025, BCAS requested extensions and clarifications for charitable and religious trusts, highlighting practical and procedural difficulties. Key requests include:

  • Extending the due date for renewal of registration under section 12AB (Form 10AB) from 30th September 2025 to 31st December 2025.
  • Addressing the punitive tax on accreted income under Section 115TD due to procedural hurdles.
  • Seeking a single renewal form for Section 12AB and Section 80G approvals.
  • Requesting a lenient approach to rejections based on technical grounds.
  • Extending the due date for Form 10B/10BB beyond 30 September 2025 due to the late release of the ITR-7 utility (late August 2025).
  • Clarifying the filing timelines for Form 9A/Form 10

Linkhttps://bcasonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BCAS-representation-letter-to-CBDT-Form-10A-12A1aci-and-renewal-of-12AB-extension.pdf

 

2. Income Tax Due Date Extensions for AY 2025–26: On 1st September 2025, BCAS requested extensions for Income Tax Return and Audit Report due dates for Assessment Year 2025–26, especially for audit cases. This request is due to the delayed release of ITR forms and utilities (some as late as August 2025), technical portal issues, overlapping deadlines, reduced working days, and increased compliance burdens. BCAS proposed extending deadlines for:

  • Tax Audit Reports (including Firms, Companies, Trusts) to 30th November 2025.
  • ITR Filing for audit cases to 31stDecember 2025.
  • Transfer Pricing Reports (Form 3CEB) to 31st January 2026

Link : https://bcasonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BCAS-Representation-for-extension-of-due-dates.pdf

3. GST Reforms: On 30th August 2025, BCAS proposed “next generational” reforms for Goods and Services Tax (GST). These suggestions focus on structural improvements, rate rationalisation, and ‘Ease of Living’ for taxpayers. Key areas include simplifying registration processes, clarifying grounds for registration cancellation, improving input tax credit (ITC) rules, streamlining invoicing and return systems, and enhancing refund mechanisms.

Link : https://bcasonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BCAS-Representation-GST-August-2025.pdf

Readers can read the full representation by scanning the QR code or visit our website www.bcasonline.org

III. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

Learning Events at BCAS

1. BCAS Townhall Meeting, Jaipur

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) successfully conducted a vibrant Townhall meeting on 16th August, 2025, at Jai Club, Jaipur, strategically scheduled alongside the 29th International Tax & Finance (ITF) Conference.

BCAS Townhall Meeting, Jaipur

This initiative represents a cornerstone of BCAS’s national reach-out project, strengthening professional relationships through dedicated representatives termed ‘Sherpas’ across India. These Sherpas serve as vital bridges between BCAS and local CA communities, facilitating professional development programs while maintaining the Society’s ethical standards.

The session focused on the ‘New Income Tax Bill, 2025’, masterfully presented by CA Gautam Nayak, Past President of BCAS. His comprehensive presentation addressed fundamental changes in the Bill and their implications across various taxpayer categories. The interactive Q&A session transformed theoretical discussions into practical solutions, addressing real-world challenges faced by tax professionals.

The event was meticulously coordinated by Jaipur Sherpa, CA Naman Shrimal. Approximately 30 Chartered Accountants participated enthusiastically, with a significant majority being non-members, extending BCAS’s reach beyond its immediate membership base.

Media professionals are actively engaged, seeking expert opinions on proposed changes, resulting in comprehensive coverage across local and national media platforms – both print and digital.

An enriching dialogue session, led by Past President CA Gautam Nayak and Vice-President CA Kinjal Shah, provided profound insights into BCAS’s vision and ongoing activities. CA Naman Shrimal shared his inspiring journey, describing how BCAS shaped his professional trajectory, encouraging participants to actively engage with the Society.

The evening culminated with a delightful networking session over High Tea, fostering meaningful connections and professional camaraderie among participants.

This Townhall meeting exemplifies BCAS’s unwavering commitment to professional excellence, knowledge dissemination, and community building across the Indian Chartered Accountancy landscape.

2. Webinar on Navigating the Tax and Regulatory Landscape for Private Equity Transactions in India held on Friday, 8th August 2025, @ Virtual.

The Taxation Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised a webinar on “Navigating the Tax and Regulatory Landscape for Private Equity Transactions in India”.

The session began with an overview of the growing complexity in tax and regulatory rules for private equity (PE) transactions in India. With increasing scrutiny by tax authorities, changes in global tax treaties, and new regulations affecting fund flows and exits, the Speaker educated the participants about the latest developments and practical solutions for smooth deal execution.

The speaker gave an overview of private equity fund structures, including the role of fund managers, pooling vehicles, SPVs, and offshore jurisdictions. The speaker explained how different jurisdictions are used for structuring and highlighted major PE funds currently active in India.

The Speaker also focused on transaction structuring and tax matters, such as pre-acquisition planning, tax implications under Indian law and DTAAs, and recent court rulings on capital gains. Key clauses in transaction agreements and the use of tax insurance to reduce deal risks were also discussed.

The webinar offered useful insights and practical guidance for handling PE transactions in a compliant and effective manner.

Speaker: CA Prem Jain.

3. Lecture Meeting on Recent Developments in Related Party Transactions Disclosures held on 6th August 2025 @ Virtual.

Lecture Meeting on Recent Developments in Related Party Transactions Disclosures

A public lecture meeting was conducted by the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society virtually on the Zoom platform on 6th August 2025.

The speaker, CS Anoop Deshpande, mentioned that the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), vide its circular dated 26th June 2025, has introduced revised industry standards specifying the minimum information to be provided to the Audit Committee and shareholders for the approval of Related Party Transactions (RPTs).

These revised standards, effective from 1st September 2025, will supersede the earlier circulars dated 14th February 2025 and 1st March 2025.

The speaker covered the following matters:

  1.  Overview of Related Party Transactions
  2.  Key features of New ISF Note
  3.  Applicability and Exemptions from Reporting
  4.  Categorisation for Disclosure in Part A, B & C.
  5.  Key Issues on various RPT Transactions

The session provided valuable insights into the updated RPT framework, which replaces earlier guidelines and introduces enhanced disclosure standards for listed companies. Participants gained clarity on the regulatory background, key changes, compliance steps, and practical implications—including the need to revisit approval processes and information templates to align with SEBI’s new expectations.

The lecture was well-attended, with over 190 participants joining online.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open-to-all to attend and participate. Missed the Lecture Meeting, but still interested in viewing the entire meeting video?

Visit the below link or scan the QR Code with your phone scanner app:

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBBSsyqY748

QR Code:

Lecture Meeting on Recent Developments in Related Party Transactions Disclosures 1

4. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Finalisation & Review of Accounts from GST Perspective” held on Tuesday, 5th August 2025 @ Hybrid.

The Bombay Chartered Accountant Society had organised the following Study Circle Meeting under Indirect Taxes on 5th August 2025.

Group leader CA Nitin Bhuta prepared a PowerPoint presentation on the Finalisation of Accounts, keeping in mind the GST Implications.

The material covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  1.  Nature of Business Transfer Agreements, their GST Implications and their treatment in the books of accounts.
  2.  Aspects of Revenue Recognition and GST implications on Revenue Recognition done in the books of accounts.
  3.  GST Implications on Remuneration to Partners and the correct treatment in the books of accounts.
  4.  GST implications on the assesse when an Income tax Raid is conducted on the assessee and its treatment in the books of accounts of the assesse.
  5.  Implications of GST on the Cross Charge Valuation
  6.  Implications of GST on the Employee Stock Options Plan and its treatment in the books of accounts

Around 80 participants virtually and 10 participants physically from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader.

5. Finance, Corporate & Allied Law Study Circle – Recent Regulatory Changes Reshaping the AIF Landscape held on Friday, 1st August 2025 @ Virtual

The session provided a comprehensive overview of the evolving regulatory framework governing Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) in India. The speakers discussed the lifecycle of AIFs, recent SEBI circulars, and the phased dematerialisation of AIF units and assets.

They also dealt with key reforms such as standardisation of valuation norms, introduction of dissolution period for illiquid assets, changes in borrowing limits, and enhanced due diligence for investors and investee companies.

The session also addressed pro-rata and pari-passu rights, reforms in angel fund structures, and the operationalisation of co-investment opportunities through regulated AIF structures. Insights were shared on SEBI’s push for greater transparency, investor protection, and systemic oversight through PPM audits, custodian requirements, and cybersecurity compliance.

The lecture was timely and well-received by participants for its clarity and coverage of both technical and practical aspects.

Speaker: CA Eshank Shah, jointly with CA Sivasangari Chinnappa

6. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Use of Technology in GST,” held on Friday, 25th July, 2025, @ Virtual

Group leader CA Rahul Gabhawala prepared a step-by-step demonstration of the prompt use of technology in GST.

The material covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  1.  Use of Chat-GPT to create code in order to carry out Login at the GST Portal.
  2.  Use of Selenium Wrapper to teach test automation at the GST Portal.
  3.  Use of Selenium Wrappers to make test automation more efficient, reliable, and user-friendly.
  4.  Use of Codes in automating certain functions at the GST Portal.

Around 200 participants from all over India benefited while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader. Considering the response of the participants and the time required for a detailed demonstration, it is proposed to have Part 2 of the meeting in
August 2025.

7. Suburban Study Circle – Interactive Case Studies on Tax Audit held on Friday 25th July 2025 @ S H B A & CO LLP (formerly Bathiya & Associates LLP)

The Suburban Study Circle of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) hosted a power-packed and interactive session on “Tax Audit – Interactive Case Studies & Recent Amendments” on 25th July 2025. The session was conducted by two distinguished professionals, CA Sonakshi Jhunjhunwala and CA Bandish Hemani, both brought deep technical insight and remarkable clarity to the discussion.

Key Highlights of the Session

  •  Recent Amendments to Form 3CD (Applicable from A.Y. 2025-26)

The session began with a structured overview of the recent CBDT Notification No. GSR 207(E) dated 28.03.2025, which introduced significant changes to Form 3CD. Notable changes include:

New clause 36B – Buyback receipts disclosure under section 2(22)(f)

Revised Clause 22 – Extensive reporting of MSME payments under section 43B(h)

Amendment in Clause 21(a) – Reporting of disallowable expenditures under newly notified laws such as SEBI, Competition Act, etc.

Each clause was dissected with comparisons of old vs new provisions, implications, and reporting challenges.

  •  Deep Dive into ICDS – III (Construction Contracts) & VI (Foreign Exchange)

Through practical case studies, the speakers navigated the interplay between ICDS, the Act (Sections 43A and 43AA), and accounting standards (AS/IndAS). The complexities of tax vs accounting treatments were clarified with logical reporting approaches under Clauses 13(e), 13(f), and 21(a).

  • MSME Disclosure – Clause 22 Revamp

One of the session’s most relevant segments was around new reporting obligations regarding payments to MSMEs. Case studies illustrated the implications of delay in payments, interest disallowance, and classification issues. Practical tips were shared on Udyam verification and Clause 26(A) linkages.

  •  Case Study Method – Interactive & Practical

The hallmark of the session was its interactive format—participants were encouraged to debate views and test their understanding through curated scenarios:

  • Tax Audit applicability in cases of 44AD/Presumptive tax opt-out
  • Multiple businesses – whether the audit applies to each or the combined turnover
  • Reporting under section 40A(2)(b) – confusion between P&L expenses and payments
  • Controversial issues under section 43B – conversion of interest into loans or debentures

Rapid Fire Round & Compliance Nuggets: The session concluded with a rapid-fire round on common but tricky reporting items in the Tax Audit Report.

Conclusion

The Suburban Study Circle expresses its sincere gratitude to CA Bandish Hemani and CA Sonakshi Jhunjhunwala for delivering a high-calibre, practice-oriented, and thoroughly engaging session. Their lucid style and insightful commentary turned a technical subject into a deeply enriching experience for all attendees.

8. Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs of the May 2025 Batch event held on Friday, 18th July, 2025@IMC.

The Seminar, Membership and Public Relations (SMPR) Committee hosted a felicitation ceremony on 18th July 2025 at Walchand Hirachand Hall, IMC Building, Churchgate, to honour the newly qualified Chartered Accountants from the May 2025 examination. The felicitation event received an overwhelming response of more than 550 registrations. Out of said registrations, over 460 enthusiastic new qualified CAs participated in the event. The guest and mentor for the event was CA Mandar Telang, Hon. Secretary. In a heartfelt session, he walked the audience through his early days as a young CA and how his involvement with BCAS helped him discover opportunities, build lasting connections, and develop a deeper understanding of the profession beyond books. Through personal anecdotes, he encouraged the newly qualified CAs to actively engage with BCAS and its many initiatives. AIR 33, Ms. Bhawana Gayari was then felicitated, and she addressed the audience. In her address, she made a mention of how she had achieved this remarkable feat without seeking the help of coaching classes – a statement which drew a thunderous applause from the audience. SMPR Committee member, CA Vatsal Paun, also addressed the audience. He recounted the fact that in August 2024, he was felicitated by BCAS in a similar event and mentioned how being a part of BCAS has helped in his professional development. A celebratory cake was cut, and then all the successful newly passed CAs were felicitated. The felicitation ceremony served as a warm welcome of the newly passed CAs into the wider professional fraternity.

Youtube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tL-8C_iW8Jk&t

QR Code:

. Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs

Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs May

9. Lecture Meeting on Preparation & Audit of Financial Statements for FY 2024-2025 on 16th July 2025 @ BCAS Hybrid.

A public lecture meeting conducted by CA Himanshu Kishnadwala at the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society and also streamed virtually, provided an extensive overview of the preparation and audit of financial statements for the fiscal year 2024-2025. The session commenced with a discussion on the relevant regulatory bodies and applicable laws, including recent amendments to the Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) and the Companies Act, 2013, as well as updates to auditing standards and guidelines issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and other authorities.

Lecture Meeting on Preparation & Audit of Financial Statements for FY 2024-2025

The speaker elaborated on the applicability of accounting standards to both corporate and non-corporate entities, including MSMEs, highlighting specific standards such as Ind AS 117, Ind AS 116, Ind AS 21, and various relaxations and guidance notes relevant for MSME financial statements. The audit segment focused on audit methodology, encompassing audit planning, execution, and reporting, emphasising a risk-based audit approach. Detailed insights were provided on Standards on Auditing (SAs) 800, 805, and 810, covering their objectives, applicability, and disclosure requirements.

Key topics included the audit of related party transactions and disclosure mandates under SEBI LODR 2015, the Companies Act 2023, and other applicable standards. The responsibilities of principal auditors, in light of findings by the National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA), were discussed alongside critical considerations for component auditors, such as independence, fraud risk, internal controls, and risks of material misstatement.

The speaker addressed common challenges faced by auditors, changes in audit reporting requirements, and strategies to ensure compliance with auditing standards, including ethical considerations and fraud detection measures. Additional topics covered included frequent errors, taxation impacts on financial statements, and statutory disclosure requirements, providing participants with a comprehensive understanding of the subject matter.

The program underscored the importance of applying professional judgment alongside technical expertise to manage audit risks and promote transparency in financial reporting. It also offered practical guidance for efficient audit planning and execution tailored to the 2024-2025 financial year.

The lecture was well-attended, with over 700 participants joining both online and in person.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open-to-all to attend and participate. Missed the Lecture Meeting, but still interested in viewing the entire meeting video?

Visit the below link or scan the QR Code with your phone scanner app:

YouTube Link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e__ylNR9jWw

QR Code:

Lecture Meeting on Preparation & Audit of Financial Statements for FY 2024-20251

10. Direct Tax Laws study Circle – Case Studies in Transactions of Immovable Property held on Wednesday, 2nd July 2025 @ BCAS -Hybrid.

Jagdish T Punjabi took up the above-mentioned topic, wherein cases relating to tax implications on immovable property transactions were discussed:

  1.  The cases covered capital gains computation under Sections 45, 50C, and 112 when the sale consideration differs from the stamp duty value, especially in intra-family transfers.
  2.  Redevelopment agreements and joint development models were examined – highlighting taxability of rent reimbursement, hardship compensation, and bonus area under Sections 56(2)(x) and 194IC.
  3.  Case studies highlighted disputes on valuation, treatment of stock-in-trade conversion, and capital gains deferment under Section 45(5A) in development agreements.
  4.  One of the case studies also highlighted the impact of amendments to Sections 54 and 54F, restricting exemption to r 10 crore, especially in the context of investment via Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS).
  5.  Discussion included interpretation challenges around DVO references, valuation differences, and the role of indexed cost in determining gains.
  6.  The implications of new LTCG rates (12.5%) for sales post-23.07.2024, timing of capital gain recognition, and AO actions under reassessment proceedings (Sec. 148A) were explored.
  7.  Specific scenarios involving the conversion of inherited property into business assets, advance tax computation, and treatment of unsold flats received under DA were evaluated.
  8.  The session concluded with a comprehensive legal analysis, giving participants clear takeaways for client advisory and compliance in light of evolving jurisprudence and legislative updates.

11. Special Premiere Screening of WELL DONE CA SAHAB!! Held on Friday, 27th June 2025 @ Cinepolis, Fun Republic, Andheri West.

The HRD Committee of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) successfully hosted an exclusive paid preview of the film Well Done CA Sahab! on 27th June 2025 – the day of its national release. The event was held in Mumbai and witnessed an overwhelming participation of around 250 members, including Chartered Accountants, students, and their families.

Well done CA saheb

Well Done CA Sahab! is a unique cinematic initiative created by seven Chartered Accountants from Ahmedabad and has been selected as an official entry to the Dadasaheb Phalke Film Festival. The film beautifully captures the journey, challenges, and resilience of the CA profession.

Attendees were treated to a special interactive session with the star cast and makers of the film after the screening. The event provided not just entertainment but also inspiration and pride in the profession, especially for young members and students who could see their aspirations reflected on screen.
The committee received extremely positive feedback, with many appreciating the blend of learning, motivation, and cultural engagement the event offered. The initiative was a creative step toward community building and celebrating the CA identity beyond professional boundaries.

II. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

  •  BCAS has been featured in several news and media platforms, showing our active involvement, professional contributions, and commitment to the field. This reflects the growing recognition of BCAS in the public and professional space.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

Learning Events At BCAS

1. 77th Founding Day Conclave:

– Lecture Meeting by Shri Tuhin Kanta Pandey, Chairperson SEBI on “Corporate Governance, in letter and spirit – role and responsibilities of professionals” and

– Fireside chat with Shri Nithin Kamath, Founder & CEO at Zerodha on “Navigating Tomorrow: How CAs can lead Financial Innovation and Sustainability” held on 5th July, 2025 at Garware Club, Churchgate.

The 77th Founding Day of the Society was marked by a significant, one of its kind conclave, featuring a talk by, SEBI Chairperson – Shri Tuhin Kanta Pandey, and a Fireside chat with Shri Nithin Kamath.

Lecture Meeting

This session featured a lecture by Shri. Tuhin Kanta Pandey, Chairperson of SEBI, on the critical role of corporate governance and the responsibilities of professionals, particularly Chartered Accountants.

Key takeaways:

1. SEBI’s Mandate and CA’s Dual Role: SEBI has a dual responsibility of developing and regulating the securities market. Chartered Accountants also play a dual role, acting as both business enablers (CFOs, Consultants) and a “first line of defense” (Auditors, Independent Directors).

2. Uncompromising Ethics and Values: He stressed that ethics and a strong value system are of uncompromising importance for CAs’, regardless of their specific role. He reinforced Azim Premji’s saying: “for a professional, grey is black,” meaning that ambiguous situations should be treated with the same clarity as wrong actions to ensure strong corporate governance.

3. Corporate Governance as an Imperative: Corporate governance is not optional but an “imperative” that builds trust with stakeholders and ensures investor confidence, board independence, and effective oversight.

4. Chartered Accountants as Financial Custodians: Chartered Accountants are deemed “financial custodians of corporate India” and “stewards of trust”. Their role extends beyond financial reporting to ensuring accuracy, integrity, robust internal controls, transparency in related party transactions, and ethical conduct. They serve as a bridge between management, auditors, and regulators, upholding fairness and accountability. A crucial point he made is that CAs must ensure corporate governance is “not reduced to a checklist”.

5. Evolution of Governance Framework: India’s corporate governance framework has continuously evolved, with significant milestones including Clause 49 (2000), the Company’s Act 2013, and SEBI LODR Regulations 2015. SEBI adopts a hybrid approach, combining rule-based and principle-based elements, to encourage going beyond mere compliance and embracing the spirit of good governance.

6. Transparency and Information Symmetry: SEBI mandates a robust disclosure framework, including periodic financial and governance reports and event-based disclosures, to ensure timely and reliable information for all stakeholders and prevent information asymmetry.

7. Enforcement and Regulatory Reforms: SEBI undertakes stringent enforcement actions against misconduct, including debarring entities, imposing penalties, and directing the return of siphoned funds. Recent reforms include quantitative thresholds for materiality of events and mandating shareholder approval every five years for special rights or director continuation, aiming to enhance transparency and accountability.

8. Ease of Doing Business Initiatives: SEBI has introduced measures such as a single filing system, simplified RPT standards, flexibility in Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR), extended disclosure windows for board meeting outcomes, and the option to not publish detailed financial results in newspapers. These measures aim to simplify compliance, enhance transparency, and encourage technology adoption, while also being mindful of the burden of excessive compliance.

9. Collaborative Ecosystem: The strength of capital markets lies in “partnership and shared purpose” among all participants. Teamwork, technology, transparency, professional ethics, trust, and a shared vision are key pillars for progress.

10. Investor Service and Digitisation: Indian capital markets are considered among the most advanced globally, with a significant increase in unique investors (from under 50 million in 2019 to 130 million, targeting 400 million). He praised tech startups like Zerodha for their role in reaching investors across the country.

11. Investor Protection Initiatives: SEBI is working on initiatives like “@VALID” (a UPI subsystem for authorised bank accounts) and a SEBI Check app to prevent fraud. They also plan massive campaigns on cyber fraud and responsible investing, and advocate for differentiated regulation based on investor risk appetite.

12. BRSR Reporting Assurance: He emphasised the need for trustworthy standards and credible third-party assessments as the reporting moves from self-certification.

13. Debt Capital Markets: While equity markets have developed significantly, he noted the substantial growth in the corporate bond market. He highlighted the unique EBP platform for electronic bidding in corporate bonds and initiatives to improve retail access through online bond platforms and brokers. Challenges remain in secondary market liquidity and investor understanding of bonds as “yield to maturity” products. Investor awareness initiatives, such as NISM webinars, are underway.

14. Final Message: Corporate governance should be implemented “not only in letter but also in spirit” to achieve its true objective and purpose.

Fireside Chat

The Fireside Chat featured Shri Nithin Kamath, Founder & CEO at Zerodha interviewed by CA Vaibhav Manek. The discussion focused on Zerodha’s journey, financial innovation, and investor trends, with insights into how Chartered Accountants (CAs) can lead in these areas.

Key takeaways from Shri Nithin Kamath:

1. Zerodha’s Inception and Growth: Nithin Kamath started trading in the late 1990s, experienced significant losses in 2001, worked in a call centre, and later became a sub-broker and Reliance Money franchisee before starting Zerodha in 2009. He highlighted that the genesis of Zerodha was transparency, which allowed customers to know all upfront charges, a previously unheard-of practice.

2. Unforeseen Scale and Organic Growth: Kamath never envisioned Zerodha reaching its current scale of 17 million customers, with his initial best-case scenario being 100,000 customers. He emphasised that Zerodha achieved this scale without spending on advertising, proving that building a good product with the customer at its centre naturally attracts users.

3. Emphasis on Market Cycles and Grounding: He attributes much of Zerodha’s success to being in the “right place, right time” during India’s growth period, highlighting the importance of the market cycle over just business skills for an entrepreneur. He also noted that wealth has not materially changed his lifestyle, helping him stay grounded.

4. Future Opportunities in Broking: Kamath believes it would be difficult to build another Zerodha today due to the unique timing of its growth (e.g., online onboarding coinciding with events like COVID-19). He sees the main opportunity in India as building an advisory-first broker, as many new investors lack guidance on what to do.

5. Transformational Shift in Investor Trends: He predicts that India, being a generation behind the US, will see investors mature over time. With the rise of AI tools like Chat GPT, he foresees a major transformational shift where brokers might become mere “pipes” to exchanges, and customers will build custom apps for trading.

6. Role of Chartered Accountants: Kamath greatly values the role of CAs, citing Zerodha’s CAs (Bharat and Om) as instrumental in building the business without “legacy debt” by ensuring transparency and ethical operations. He believes CAs can nudge business owners towards holistic decisions, especially regarding sustainability and ESG, beyond just “checkbox” compliance.

7. Investment Perspective: He sees accounting firms as “investable” due to their steady and sustainable revenue and high customer retention. When evaluating investment opportunities, he primarily looks for founders with core competency and experience in the industry, rather than just an idea. He also prioritises investing in contrarian market cycles like health and climate.

8. Leadership and Growth Philosophy: Kamath defines his leadership by prioritising the long-term over the short-term, such as analysing business numbers over a three-year moving average rather than quarterly. He believes this gives Zerodha an advantage over competitors forced to focus on short-term results.

9. Mistakes for Start-up Founders: He advises founders to avoid overselling to investors, as it creates false expectations for the team. He advocates for effective team building by treating employees as more than just “resources,” implementing policies like no work chats after 6 pm and encouraging hobby projects. He stresses that people motivated solely by money tend to leave for money. He also criticises the “excessive consumerism” of constant growth targets, suggesting that true happiness comes from chasing metrics beyond mere revenue.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open-to-all to attend and participate. Missed the Lecture Meeting, but still interested in viewing the entire meeting video?

Visit the below link or scan the QR Code with your phone scanner app:

YouTube Link:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIK12-f19nw&t 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff5-CAnK4TM

2. One Day Seminar on “Ind AS 117 – Insurance Contracts – A Curtain Raiser” held on Friday, 4th July 2025 @IMC.

The landscape of insurance accounting is undergoing a paradigm shift in India with the introduction of Ind AS 117 – Insurance Contracts, aligning more closely with the international standard IFRS 17.

As India moves toward adopting this landmark standard, it is essential for all professionals in the insurance sector, auditors of insurance companies, actuaries and all those associated with the insurance industry, to gain a solid understanding of its principles, implementation issues, and practical implications.

In this direction (to act as curtain raiser), Accounting & Auditing Committee of BCAS organised one day seminar on the said topic in hybrid mode (physical as well as online) at Babubhai Chinai Hall, 2nd Floor, IMC Building, Churchgate, Mumbai.

This seminar was designed to introduce and equip professionals with a basic understanding of Ind AS 117 and help them navigate its complexities with confidence.

The Seminar was inaugurated with the opening remarks from the Vice-President of BCAS, CA Zubin Billimoria, followed by the Chairman of the Accounting and Auditing Committee –CA. Abhay Mehta, both of them underlining the importance of knowledge sharing and role of the BCAS in conducting such programs for the benefit of members and the profession at large.

The seminar commenced with an Inaugural Address by CA. M P Vijay Kumar setting the tone for the following sessions, narrating the journey and emphasizing the importance of readiness and adaptation to the new standard.

This was followed by an insightful session on “Introduction to Ind AS 117 and Transitional Issues“, which provided a foundational overview along with transition challenges, strategies and practical insights by CA Ashutosh Pednekar.

Thereafter, specialised sessions on the “Accounting Impact on Life Insurance Sector” and “General Insurance Sector” were taken by Mr. Dinesh Pant and CA Samir Shah, respectively, offering deep technical perspectives on how Ind AS 117 reshapes financial reporting in these domains.

The session on the “Impact of Ind AS 117 on Other Ind AS Standards”, by Mr. Jitendra Jain, highlighted convergence and divergence areas, especially with Ind AS 109 and Ind AS 115.

The Seminar concluded with a critical session by Mr. Rajesh Dalmia on the “Interplay of Actuarial Aspects vis-à-vis Ind AS 117“, focusing on the alignment between actuarial valuations and accounting treatment, bringing together finance and actuarial domains.

The seminar proved to be a highly informative platform for professionals navigating the implementation challenges of Ind AS 117.

The Seminar provided an excellent opportunity to gain valuable knowledge and practical insights on the topics covered. The Seminar attended by 45 participants (including 36 virtual participants) was well received, and the overall feedback from the participants was very encouraging.

3. Finance Corporate & Allied Law Study Circle – Overview of Due diligence with focus on Financial due diligence held on Monday, 23rd June 2025 @ Virtual

  • The session focused on the structure, scope, and strategic importance of due diligence in modern transactions, particularly financial due diligence (FDD). 55 participants attended the session.
  • CA Sahil Parikh outlined the phases of a typical DD assignment, from planning to reporting and finalisation.
    Key distinctions between audit and due diligence were discussed, with real-life case examples highlighting revenue overstatement, related party risks, and valuation adjustments.
  • The speaker shared insights from engagements involving private equity, IPOs, and distressed assets, demonstrating how DD findings impact deal structure and pricing.
  • Buyer vs Seller perspectives were explained, along with red flag negotiation strategies.
  • The session covered FDD checklists, normalisation of EBITDA, tax and legal DD overlaps, and the role of secretarial compliance.
  • Emerging trends such as AI-based review tools, digital data rooms were also touched upon.
  • The talk concluded with a strong emphasis on ethical rigour, independence, and value creation through diligent and balanced reporting.
  • The session was well received and drew appreciation for its practical orientation and structured delivery.

4. Redevelopment 360: From Concept to Completion held on Saturday, 21st June 2025 @ Hybrid

This event was organized by the Finance, Corporate, and Allied Laws Committee on Saturday, 21st June, 2025, at BCAS Hall. Initially planned as an in-person attendance event, the seminar was converted into a hybrid format in response to the overwhelming interest and demand, allowing participants to attend virtually as well.

The details of the Seminar are as follows:

Topic Session Summary Faculty
Keynote Address on The Rise and Need of Redevelopment

Shri Romell delivered an insightful keynote address, emphasizing the urgent necessity of redevelopment in a land-constrained city like Mumbai. He articulated the advantages of cluster redevelopment over other models and positioning redevelopment as both a civic necessity and a social responsibility. His address set a compelling tone for the sessions that followed.

Shri Domnic Romell

President, Maharashtra
Chamber of Housing Industry

 

 Session 1:

Understanding Redevelopment Process and Regulatory Framework

 

This session provided a comprehensive overview of the redevelopment landscape—covering various types of redevelopments, notable DCPR schemes, and their comparative analysis. Mr. Nayan Dedhia also touched on self-redevelopment initiatives.

 Mr. Nayan Dedhia

Director, Toughcons Nirman Pvt. Ltd

 

 Session 2: Role and Importance of PMC in Redevelopment

CA Aditya Bansal outlined the critical role of Project Management Consultants in ensuring smooth execution at every stage of a redevelopment project. He illustrated how PMC involvement mitigates risks and enhances project efficiency.

 CA Aditya Bansal,

Associate Director,
Knight Frank

 Session 3: The Redevelopment Checklist

Dr. Harshul Savla emphasized the importance of having a well-structured redevelopment checklist. He stated that the checklist should, inter alia, comprise the key points of a plot, the due diligence checklist, significant points of redevelopment, buffet of FSIs, importance of ‘Know your Developer’, and certain RERA compliances of a redevelopment project.

 Dr. Adv. Harshul Savla

Managing Partner, Suvidha Lifespaces

 

 Session 4: GST Implications in Redevelopment

CA Raj Khona dealt with GST implications with respect to developer-led redevelopment as well as self-redevelopment of societies. In case of developer-led redevelopment, GST on rehab flats, resale by landowners before OC, various payments to the society and its members, additional area purchased along with liability to pay GST were considered. He also dealt with the GST implications in respect of self-redevelopment funded by the members’ contribution. He presented the possible divergent views.

 CA Raj Khona

Founder, Aarkay Advisors

 

 Session 5: Income Tax and Stamp Duty Implications in Redevelopment

The fireside chat dealt with the income tax implications on various aspects of redevelopment of cooperative societies, including TDS on and from AY 2024-25, such as development rights, availing permanent alternative accommodation with or without additional area, garage, Jodi flats, temporary alternative accommodation compensation, hardship compensation, sinking fund, in in-kind benefits. Stamp duty implications and the potential role of seeking Advance Rulings were also discussed.

 CA Pradip Kapasi in fireside chat with CA Jhankhana Thakkar:
 Session 6: Legal Drafting in Redevelopment Projects

Adv. Sajit Suvarna and Adv. Mitali Naik dealt with drafting essentials in Development Agreement, Power of Attorney, Intimation of Disapproval. They emphasized careful and diligent drafting of critical clauses relating to granting of development rights, displacement allowance, security, building enough safeguards to have a balanced document.

 Adv. Sajit Suvarna

Senior Partner, DSK Legal

 Adv. Mitali Naik, Partner, DSK Legal

 

 Panel Discussion on Redevelopment Realities – Successes, Pitfalls & Lessons Learned

This engaging panel brought together perspectives from both society representatives and developers. Panelists shared success stories and critical lessons from their redevelopment journeys. They discussed key factors contributing to success, such as selection of developer, structuring the deal, challenges during execution phase, and surprise – pleasant or otherwise – experienced during the possession of the new residential premises. Each panelist shared their Success Mantras – The Do’s, Don’ts, and Ratnas.

 Panelists:


CA Ketan Mehta

(Society Office Bearer)

 

• Mr. Ayaz Kazi

(Society Office Bearer)

 

• CA Anish Shah

Director, Amal Group (Developer)

 Moderator:

CA Chetan Shah

Past President – BCAS

The Seminar was appreciated for its concept to completion. Each session offered in-depth insights, with experts sharing valuable experiences. The seminar concluded with participants gaining an overall (360º) understanding of Redevelopment of societies, especially in Mumbai. The Chairman of BCAS – FCAL committee suggested that Monograph/s may be published on the questions raised during the seminar. Out of the total 194 participants, 126 were BCAS members, and the remaining 68 were non-members. Further, 44 participants attended from 21 cities outside the Mumbai Metropolitan Region.

II. OTHER EVENTS AND NEWS

1. BCAS Office Bearers, Chairpersons, Co-Chairpersons & Convenors Meeting held on Saturday, 12th July 2025@ BCAS Hall.

A meeting of the Office Bearers, Chairpersons, Co-Chairpersons, and Convenors of the various BCAS Committees for the year 2025–26 was held on 12th July 2025 at the BCAS Hall.

President CA Zubin Billimoria welcomed all members and shared the vision for the year ahead, aligning the initiatives with the BCAS Five-Year Plan. He presented ten key strategic projects that the Office Bearers have outlined for the year.

Convenors of the respective committees also shared their proposed annual plans and activity schedules for 2025–26. The updated Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) were discussed, emphasising the roles and responsibilities of Chairpersons and Convenors. Discussions also focused on best practices for event planning, communication, and outreach.

The BCAS Office Manager and Department Heads were introduced to the members, along with an overview of their functions. An open townhall session saw active participation and meaningful suggestions from members, which were duly noted for implementation.

2. Meeting of Newly Inducted Core Group Members (2023–24 to 2025–26) held on Saturday, 12th July 2025 @ BCAS Hall.

The second half of the day saw a dedicated session for newly inducted Core Group members during the last years from 2023–24 to 2025–26. The meeting provided an opportunity for the new members to introduce themselves and engage with the Office Bearers and fellow Core Group members.

President CA Zubin Billimoria elaborated on the key strategic initiatives under the BCAS Five-Year Plan and reiterated the importance of collaborative leadership. The structural framework of BCAS departments was presented, and the Heads of Departments were formally introduced.

The roles, expectations, and responsibilities of Core Group members were discussed in context of the updated SOPs. The interactive townhall that followed allowed members to offer suggestions and share insights, which were warmly received and noted for action by the leadership team.

3. BCAS Academy: A New Era of Digital Learning and Networking @ Mumbai.

Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society proudly unveiled the BCAS Academy portal, at the 76th Annual General Meeting of the society held on 5th July 2025 at Garware Club House, Mumbai. The BCAS Academy is a robust digital learning and networking hub designed to empower members through knowledge, collaboration, and innovation.

Key Features:

i. Groups – Members can now connect through dedicated groups based on areas of interest or professional focus, enabling peer learning and closer networking within the community.

ii. Forums – The platform hosts interactive forums where users can post queries, share insights, and engage in meaningful discussions on emerging topics and technical issues.

iii. Self-paced e-Learning with BCAS Certificate – A growing library of structured online courses allows members to learn at their own pace and earn BCAS-certified credentials upon completion.

iv. Custom ChatGPT – An AI-powered assistant tailored for the CA profession provides instant guidance, answers, and learning support, enhancing the user’s experience and understanding.

v. BCAS Journal Flip Book Version – Members can now access the Bombay Chartered Accountants Journal in a convenient, interactive flip book format, enhancing readability and portability.

vi. Recorded Videos – Access to a rich repository of recordings from past webinars, lectures, and conferences ensures that knowledge is never missed and always within reach.

vii. Event Registration – The portal offers seamless registration for upcoming BCAS events, making it easier for members to stay updated and involved.

viii. Order Publication Online – Users can conveniently browse and order BCAS publications through the portal, with a streamlined interface for selection and checkout.

The BCAS Academy marks a significant leap forward in the Society’s digital journey, aligning with its mission to foster continuous learning and professional excellence among Chartered Accountants.

The BCAS Academy is now accessible to all members of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society. Access the BCAS Academy: https://academy.bcasonline.org/

4. White Paper: Enhancing the Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) Ecosystem in India@ Mumbai

A White Paper prepared by Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) jointly with National Institute of Securities Markets (NISM) on “Enhancing the Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) Ecosystem in India” was presented to Shri Tuhin Kanta Pandey, Chairperson, Securities & Exchange Board of India (SEBI) at the 77th Founding Day Conclave held on 5th July 2025 at Garware Club House, Mumbai.

Previously, on the sidelines of the Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) Conclave 2025, which was held on 17th and 18th January, 2025, at Hotel Ginger Mumbai Airport, a Closed-Door Roundtable Discussion was held on the Challenges and Gaps in the AIF Ecosystem.

The discussion was attended by Shri Rajesh Gujjar, Chief General Manager at SEBI, officials from BCAS and NISM, top leadership from 15 AIFs, and legal experts. The session was moderated by Adv. Siddharth Shah. The insights and suggestions provided by the panelists were documented in the form of a White Paper.

The white paper serves as a foundation for policy advocacy and industry transformation, capturing the key recommendations and insights from the discussion held during the roundtable discussion. The recommendations outlined in the paper serve as a strategic roadmap for improving governance, expanding investor access and streamlining compliance in the AIF sector.

The White Paper is now accessible to all BCAS members and is expected to serve as a valuable resource for professionals engaged in investment advisory, fund structuring, tax planning, and regulatory compliance.

Access the White Paper here:

https://bcasonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/White-Paper-on-Alternative-Investment-Fund.pdf

5. BCAS Foundation Receives Yoga Sangam Patra from the Ministry of Ayush

We are delighted to share that the BCAS Foundation has been awarded the prestigious Yoga Sangam Patra by the Ministry of Ayush, Government of India, in recognition of our active participation in celebrating International Yoga Day on 21.06.2025.

The Yoga Sangam event organized by BCAS Foundation was held at Prestige Hotel, Andheri, in alignment with the national celebrations led by the Hon’ble Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi from Visakhapatnam. The event brought together members and well-wishers in a shared commitment to promote health, wellness, and inner harmony through the timeless practice of yoga.

We extend our heartfelt thanks to all the enthusiastic participants who contributed to making this initiative a meaningful and memorable one.

This recognition is a proud moment for the BCAS community and a reflection of our ongoing efforts to promote holistic well-being alongside professional excellence.

6. 15,000 & Growing!

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) is proud to share a significant digital milestone — our LinkedIn community has crossed 15,000 followers!

We extend our heartfelt thanks to each member of our growing network for your support, engagement, and trust. Your continued participation strengthens our mission to share credible, relevant, and insightful knowledge with the professional community.

If you haven’t joined us yet, we invite you to become part of an active network of finance professionals, Chartered Accountants, and thought leaders who look to BCAS for:

  • Expert sessions and event updates
  • Thought leadership in taxation, audit, technology, and policy
  • Key regulatory insights and member-driven initiatives
  • Let’s continue to learn, lead, and grow — together.

Follow us on LinkedIn for more meaningful content and updates.

Link: https://www.linkedin.com/company/bombay-chartered-accountants-society/?viewAsMember=true

III. BCAS IN NEWS & MEDIA

BCAS was quoted in 48 news and media platforms during July 2025. This coverage reflects our thought leadership and commitment to the profession. For details

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

AI Won’t Replace You… But the CA Who Uses It Better Might

The future of finance is here — and those who adapt will lead.

In a thought-provoking episode of the popular podcast Paisa Vaisa, BCAS President Anand Bathiya joins host Anupam Gupta to discuss the transformative role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the finance and accounting profession.

From automation and analytics to ethics and upskilling, the discussion sheds light on how AI is reshaping the Chartered Accountant’s role — and why adopting these technologies is no longer optional.

Whether you’re a Chartered Accountant, a finance student, or simply curious about the intersection of money and machines, this episode offers timely insights on how to stay relevant, resilient, and future ready.

Watch the full episode here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6TbBDLbv1g

Learning Events at BCAS

1. 19th Residential Study Course on GST @ Kolkata

The Indirect Tax Committee organised its 19th Residential Study Course at The Westin, Rajarhat, Kolkata, between 12th – 15thJune 2025, exclusively on Goods & Service Tax. More than 310 delegates attended the program from over 60 towns and cities in India.

The Study Course started with Shree Ganesh Vandana and the lighting of lamp. Later, it was inaugurated by Shri Shrawan Kumar, Chief Commissioner of Central GST & Central Excise, Kolkata Zone, who spoke on the 8 years of GST and the way forward. Shri Ranjit Kumar Agarwal, immediate Past President of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, was the guest of honour. Chairman CA Govind Goyal welcomed all the participants, and Past Chairman CA Deepak Shah spoke about various activities of BCAS.

The first technical session on day 1 was a presentation paper by CA. Mandar Telang on the topic – “Addressing the deficiencies in Returns, Forms & Portal through effective documentation & strategic preventive steps”. The session takeaways primarily covered the facts that inadvertent mistakes are not akin to fraud, and for proper facts, justice is received even though it might be delayed. Committee member CA. Vikram Mehta chaired the session.

On day 2, the participants deliberated on the case studies in the group discussion format on the Panel Discussion paper on the topic “Real Estate Transactions”. The participants were divided into seven groups, each group led by 2 group leaders. As an innovative approach, the role of group leaders in each group was divided into “pro-revenue and pro-taxpayer” so that the participants get an understanding of the likely stand that can be taken by the department also. This format of GD was appreciated by the delegates.

After the GD session, the delegates gathered for the 2nd technical session by Adv. (CA) Ankit Kanodia. It was a presentation session on the topic of “Penalties under GST”. Committee Member CA. Jayesh Gogri chaired the session.

The 3rd technical session was the replies to the Panel Discussion paper on the topic “Real Estate Transactions”. The panel comprised of CA. A R Krishnan, as Moderator, CA. Sunil Gabhawalla & CA. A. Jatin Christopher as panelists. CA. Sunil Gabhawalla’s replies were from the taxpayer’s perspective, while CA. A. Jatin Christopher’s replies were from the Department’s perspective. Past President CA. Govind Goyal chaired the session.

On day 3, the participants deliberated on various case studies involved in the Group Discussion paper on the topic “Assorted Issues in GST”. This was followed by the 4th technical session – “T-20 capsules”. This is the continuous 4th year wherein selected delegates are invited to submit a detailed research paper on the assigned topic and further make a 20 minutes brief presentation on the technical topic at the RSC, thus providing them a forum to express their views on technical topics in just 20 minutes, i.e. in T20 Format. Committee Member CA. Prashant Deshpande chaired the session.

The sightseeing arrangements were made for the delegates, and they were delighted to visit the Victoria Memorial, Belur Math and Dakshineshwar Kali Temple. The delegates enjoyed the outing.

On the concluding day, i.e., day 4, the 5th technical session was the replies on the Group Discussion Paper by CA. S S Gupta. The session was chaired by the Vice President, CA. Zubin Billimoria.

The RSC concluded with acknowledgements and thanks to all those who had worked towards making the event a success, especially the Paper Writers, Group Leaders, Mentors, Panelists, Article contributors to the paper book and others who had worked tirelessly to deliver a seamless experience. Last but not least, thanks were expressed to the participants, without whom the sessions would not have been so interactive. Overall, it was an enriching experience and was appreciated by all the participants. This 4-day Residential Study Course at Kolkata (the city of joy) concluded with sincere appreciation for the tremendous efforts put in by the conveners CA Dushyant Bhatt, CA Gaurav Save and CA Parth Shah.

2. BCAS Town Hall Meeting @ Kolkata

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) successfully conducted a Town Hall Meeting in Kolkata on 14th June 2025, on the sideline of the 19th Residential Study Course on GST. Organised with the support of CA Sanjay Poddar, CA Arup Das Gupta, and CA Abhishek Agarwal, the event brought together members for an open dialogue on professional development, Society initiatives, and future opportunities in the region.

The meeting featured key inputs from BCAS leadership:

  •  CA Zubin Billimoria, Hon. Vice President, provided an overview of the Society’s structure, committee ecosystem, and the contributions of its 250+ core group members.
  •  CA Mandar Telang, Hon. Treasurer, outlined recent initiatives, stressed the importance of local study circles, and expressed BCAS’s enthusiasm for future events in Kolkata, supported by active member involvement with the help of other sister organisations and local representatives.
  •  CA Gaurav Save offered insights into the efforts behind the GST RRC and shared how online Indirect Tax Study Circles have broadened access to national subject matter experts.

The event also featured active participation from attending members, who shared their expectations and ideas. Office bearers engaged constructively, addressed the queries raised and assured members of continued support in tailoring future programs to local needs.

Esteemed professionals, including CA Sushil Kumar Goyal, Past Central Council Member, ICAI, graced the occasion, making it a memorable and impactful exchange of ideas.

This Town Hall reaffirmed BCAS’s focus on regional inclusivity and its resolve to co-create meaningful platforms for professional excellence.

3. Webinar on Opportunities for CAs in Oman held on Tuesday, 10th June 2025@ Virtual

The webinar organised by the Seminar, Membership & Public Relations Committee enhanced the audience’s understanding of the opportunities present in Oman concerning practice, employment, and business. Around 200 participants registered for the event – drawn from across the country and mainly holding senior positions.

India and Oman are on the verge of signing a Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA), which is expected to create new prospects in accounting, taxation, and transfer pricing for Chartered Accountants.

The Guest of Honour, Ms. Juhaina Al Balushi from the Ministry of Commerce, Industry, and Investment Promotion, addressed the participants regarding the investment climate in Oman and the tax incentives available for newly established businesses.

Dr. Yousuf Hamed Al Balushi, a respected thought leader and former employee of the Central Bank of Oman, provided valuable insights into the mining, renewable energy, and financial services sectors.

CA Jay Duseja discussed the employment opportunities in Oman, along with the practical considerations for relocating to the country. Additionally, CA Abhishek Vaishya outlined the necessary steps to establish an auditing or consultancy firm in Oman.

The webinar concluded with a Q&A session with participants sharing their questions and seeking clarifications.

Youtube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jlt6aUSQxig

QR Code:

4. International Economics Study Group – In the context of the Trade war, what are the Strengths, Weaknesses & Threats to China, and what are the opportunities for India vis-a-vis China held on Monday, 9th June 2025 @ Virtual

The meeting was led by CA Harshad Shah & CA Vijay Maniar and presented the following:

Strength of China: World’s 2nd Largest Economy, Manufacturing Powerhouse, Large Domestic Market, Largest Foreign Reserves, Infrastructure Development, Technological & Innovation, Major Trading Partner to Many Large Economies, Over-Reliance on Many Sectors, Products, & Critical Minerals in many countries, Large, Competent Labor Pool with Unmatched Productivity, World’s Largest Military etc.

China’s Weaknesses: Authoritarian & Police State, Systemic Issues in Governance, Corruption, Chinese Demographic Disaster, Rising Unemployment in Youths, Real Estate Market Collapse, Very High Debt Levels, Export Dependency, Overcapacity, Untested Military (5+ Decades) etc.

Opportunities for India: Manufacturing & Supply Chain Diversification, Export Growth to the U.S. Market, Attracting Foreign Investment, Aviation and Aerospace Opportunities, etc.

Threats to China: Shutdown of Industries reliant on the US Market, Unemployment from Industrial Shutdowns, Disruption of Supply Chains, Infrastructure Overexpansion, Risk of Recession, Risk of Technological Decoupling & Containment, Currency, Financial & Stock Market Volatility, Stress on China’s Fragile Banking System, Potential for Protests and Civil Unrest etc.

5. Four-Day Study Course on Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) held on 30th to 31st May 2025 & 6th to 7th June 2025 @ Virtual (except the last day in Hybrid Mode at BCAS)

Four Day Study Course on Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA) – on Day 4, it was planned as FEMA Focus – Advanced Perspectives on Foreign Exchange Laws

The first three days of the course were online and Day 4 was in hybrid mode. Many participants (including some from outside Mumbai) were present at the BCAS office and appreciated the personal interaction with speakers and networking opportunities with peers. The course was attended by nearly 300 participants.

This course covered the basic concepts of FEMA. The objective was to simplify extremely complex provisions for the participants. The course was comprehensive, and all key aspects of FEMA were covered. The speakers shared their vast experience with the participants and covered concepts as well as their practical applications. The examples and insight into real-life scenarios deeply enriched the participants.

After 3 days of covering basics, the last day focused on advanced level discussions and participants who were interested only in that day’s proceedings enrolled separately for the seminar “FEMA Focus – Advanced Perspectives on Foreign Exchange Laws”.

Day 4 began with an address by Dr. Aditya Gaiha, Chief General Manager, Foreign Exchange Department, Reserve Bank of India – who shared the regulator’s perspective and shed light on certain developments that are likely to take place over the next few months. It is worthwhile to note that he spoke at a professional forum after a long time and his session was greatly appreciated by the participants.

Other sessions on Day 4 covered advanced concepts and practical insights on succession in cross-border scenarios and cross-border restructuring.

The final session was a panel discussion with esteemed members of the profession. Interesting case studies were discussed during the panel discussion, and panelists shared divergent views on various issues.

Overall, the course was very enriching for the participants in terms of conceptual understanding as well as practical insights on FEMA.

6. Direct & Indirect Tax – Concept & Intricacies of Joint Development Agreements held on Friday, 6th June 2025@ Hyderabad.

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) organised an engaged its first Sherpa Event in Hyderabad on 6th June 2025 at the G. P. Birla Auditorium. The Sherpa Initiative is BCAS’s national reach-out project aimed at deepening relationships with members and the wider community by appointing dedicated BCAS representatives (‘Sherpas’) in various towns and cities across India. These Sherpas act as a vital bridge between BCAS and local Chartered Accountant communities, helping plan and execute high-quality professional development programs while upholding the society’s strong ethical standards.

The session focused on the ‘Concept and Intricacies in Direct & Indirect Tax related to Joint Development Agreements’, featuring insightful presentations by CA Jagdish Punjabi (Direct Tax) and CA Mandar Telang (Indirect Tax). A highlight of the session was an interactive Q&A round lasting over an hour, addressing practical issues and real-world challenges faced by professionals.

The event was efficiently organised by Hyderabad’s SherpaCA Siddharth Mantri, whose efforts ensured smooth conduct and meaningful interaction. It saw an overwhelming response with 125+ Chartered Accountants in attendance, including 60+ non-members, reflecting BCAS’s growing reach and relevance. Additionally, an open dialogue led by Past President CA Narayan Pasari and CA Kinjal Bhuta provided participants with a deeper understanding of BCAS’s vision, the Sherpa Initiative, and the society’s ongoing activities and opportunities for members and aspiring professionals alike.

The evening concluded with a lively networking meet and dinner, fostering connections and camaraderie among the participants.

7. Supply Chain – A Gold-mine for Internal Auditors held on Friday, 6th June 2025@ Vile Parle.

The Internal Audit Committee hosted a full-day seminar, “Supply Chain – A Gold Mine for Internal Auditors,” on 6th June 2025, at the Ginger Hotel in Vile Parle. This event brought together over 60 participants eager to learn from distinguished supply chain experts from both industry and consulting practice.

Esteemed speakers included Mr Amit Kumar Baveja, Mr Vineet Jajodia, Mr Venkatadri Ranganathan, Mr Pankaj Raut, Mr Kaushal Mehta, Mr Chetan Thakkar, and Mr Govind Purohit. They generously shared their wealth of experience and insights with an engaged audience.
The seminar delved into the complexities of the supply chain, emphasising how internal auditors can play a pivotal role in helping organisations manage risks and disruptions. Key topics explored during the sessions included:

  •  The dynamics of supply chains amid the rise of AI, automation, sustainability initiatives, and the current geopolitical landscape.
  •  Technologies employed by companies to mitigate supply chain disruptions.
  •  Fraud detection and prevention in supply chain audits.
  •  The digital transformation of supply chains, sustainability, and ESG reporting, particularly within the B2C sector.
  •  Practical case studies on supplier risk management.

This seminar provided valuable knowledge and strategies for internal auditors, helping them enhance their contributions to the ever-evolving field of supply chain management.

9. Lecture Meeting on Recent Judicial Pronouncements under GST held on Wednesday, 21st May 2025 @ Virtual.

BCAS hosted a virtual lecture meeting on recent jurisprudence in GST, which was delivered by Senior Advocate Mr Vikram Nankani. The session covered over ten significant court rulings, with Mr. Nankani providing clear and insightful explanations that helped demystify complex legal concepts.

Attendees greatly appreciated the depth of his knowledge and the structured manner in which he presented the evolving legal landscape under GST. His perspectives offered valuable guidance for professionals in the field.

The session concluded with a formal vote of thanks, expressing gratitude for Mr. Nankani’s time and contribution. More than 300 Participants acknowledged the enriching nature of the lecture with a round of virtual applause.

Youtube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QF4ZFe70lGc

QR Code:

9. Direct Tax Home Refresher Course – 6 held from 17th May 2025 to 31st May 2025 @ Virtual.

Taxation Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, in collaboration with the Association of Chartered Accountants, Chennai, Chartered Accountants Association, Ahmedabad, CA Association of Jalandhar, The Chartered Accountants Study Circle, Chennai, Hyderabad Chartered Accountants Society, Karnataka State Chartered Accountants’ Association and Lucknow Chartered Accountants’ Society, Maharashtra Tax Practitioners Association, Pune, Chartered Accountants Association, Surat and All India Federation of Tax Practitioners (West Zone), organized its flagship online course known as Direct Tax Home Refresher Course – 6.

The course again this year got a good response from the participants and more than 480 total registrations were received for the course. There were 14 sessions, where 14 speakers from different
cities across India covered 14 important topics on direct tax.

Session 1 CA Narendra Jain delved into an overview of Section 536 of the New Income Tax Bill and its impact on the scope and charge of income. He covered the issues which can emerge during this transition from the current Income Tax Act to the New Income Tax bill.

Session 2 was taken by CA T G Suresh, where he gave a detailed presentation on Capital Gains including recent amendments and issues emerging out of that.

Session 3 was on the subject of Transfer Pricing, where CA Vijay Iyer discussed the recent developments and jurisprudence in Transfer Pricing. He also shared his insights on the APA Program and the benefits of the Safe Harbour Rule.

Session 4 was GAAR, TRC and PE, wherein CA Amrish Shah delved deep into the concepts and even explained the recent jurisprudence on all three topics.

Session 5 was on GIFT City and its framework, where CA Jaiman Patel gave a bird’s eye view of the entire framework and explained the regulations of the same under various Laws.

Session 6 was addressed by CA Pradip Kapasi on the topic of the Interplay of Benami and Income tax and other Economic Laws w.s.r.t.s 68 to 69D, SAAR and GAAR provisions. He beautifully explained the critical points that one needs to be aware of while dealing with the relevant provisions of those Acts.

Session 7 was on the subject of Related Party Definitions under various Laws vis-à-vis the Income Tax Act. CA Dr. Anup Shah dealt with the topic holistically and explained the interplay and the differences between those definitions.

Session 8 was addressed by Mr Purshottam, ITO CPC TDS Ghaziabad, wherein he explained the entire TDS/TCS Framework and the recent changes made under the same.

Session 9 was on the topic of Foreign Assets and Overseas Income and its reporting under the Income Tax Act, which was taken up by CA Rutvik Sanghvi in detail. His presentation covered each and every aspect, including the implications under the Black Money Act and various case studies on the same.

Session 10 was on the new age topic of AI and in Legal, Tax and Ethical Issues, which was beautifully explained by Huzefa Tavawalla and Ipsita Agarwalla.

Session 11 was taken up by CA E Chaitanya on the topic of ITR Forms for AY 2025-26 wherein he explained the forms and the changes made this year. He also explained the precautions to be taken while filing tax returns.

Session 12 was on Tax Audit changes for FY 24-25, addressed by CA K Gururaj Acharya wherein he explained the process of tax audit and the Forms and the points one has to be mindful of while conducting a Tax Audit.

Session 13 was addressed by Sr. Advocate Tushar Hemani on the subject of Appeal before CIT(A) & ITAT – Practical Tips – covering the Importance of cross-objections / Additional grounds/etiquette/drafting grounds, etc., which was very detailed and practical. He also addressed some of the common issues which practitioners need to be aware of.

In the last session, 14, CA Ishraq Contractor dealt with features and the recent changes of the Faceless Assessments. He also discussed the challenges faced by the department and assesses possible resolutions for the same.

The course was overall well-received by the participants.

10. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on 360 Degree of TDS held on Friday, 16th May 2025 @ S H B A & CO LLP.

The Suburban Study Circle hosted an insightful session on “360 Degree of TDS” led by CA Ravi Soni.

CA Ravi Soni delivered a practical and comprehensive presentation covering the entire spectrum of TDS—from foundational provisions to the latest amendments introduced by the Finance Act 2024. His expertise and clarity helped demystify common issues related to TRACES, default rectification, and complex sections such as 194Q, 206AB, and the newly introduced 194T (TDS on payments to partners).

Key Takeaways

Concept and Purpose: TDS as a mechanism to ensure regular tax collection and expand the tax base.

Amendments Covered: Several threshold increases and per-transaction applicability across Sections 194, 194A, 194C, 194H, 194M, etc.

Compliance Challenges: Common defaults, interest implications, and correction processes were explained with real-time illustrations.

TRACES Utility: A walkthrough of functionalities like downloading Form 16/16A, correction statements, and justification reports.

Latest Changes: New section introductions and amendments effective from October 2024 and April 2025 were discussed in detail.

The session concluded with an engaging Q&A, where participants discussed practical challenges in monthly filings, reporting, and reconciliations. The speaker also shared compliance checklists and tools to simplify TDS obligations for deductors and firms alike.

11. ITF Study Circle Meeting on Provisions of the New Income Tax Bill 2025 related to International Tax – Part 2 held on Thursday, 15thMay 2025 @ Virtual.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organised a meeting (online mode) on 15 May 2025 to discuss the provisions of the Income Tax Bill 2025 related to International Tax. The agenda covered corresponding provisions of Section 44B to 44DA and 92 to 92F of the Income-tax Act, 1961

  •  CA Siddharth Parekh covered Sections 92 to 92F (the transfer pricing provisions). At the outset, he shared insights on the Income Tax Bill 2025 and various rules for interpretation.
  •  He then discussed the subtle differences between the language in the current provisions and the provisions in the Income Tax Bill 2025.
  •  There was a lively discussion on the potential implications of these subtle differences, and divergent views were expressed.
  •  The group agreed that there will be uncertainty for the initial years when the Income Tax Bill 2025 is implemented.
  •  Adv Gunjan Kakkad took the group through the provisions of Section 44B to 44DA and the corresponding provisions of the Income Tax Bill 2025.
  •  He pointed out that there weren’t many differences between the language of the existing provisions
    and the corresponding provisions of the Income Tax Bill 2025.
  •  He further pointed out that the provisions in the Income Tax Bill 2025 were more structured with easy to understand tables as compared with the current provisions and took the group through the new provisions.

II. BCAS QUOTED IN NEWS & MEDIA

BCAS was quoted in 18 news and media platforms between May 2025 and June 2025. This coverage reflect our thought leadership and commitment to the profession. For details

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

Learning Events at BCAS

1. “Blood Donation & Platelet Donation Awareness Drive” on 16th May, 2025

On Friday, 16th May, 2025, the BCAS Foundation, jointly with the Seminar, Membership & Public Relations Committee of BCAS, held the annual “Blood Donation Drive”, enlisting the support of Tata Memorial Hospital (TMH).

Doctors and technicians from TMH screened 74 potential donors through the detailed questionnaire filled in by them. Contrary to popular belief, patients diagnosed with cholesterol, thyroid, blood pressure issues could also donate blood, provided they met certain criteria. 54 units of blood were collected from eligible donors, which included the President, Chairman of the SMPR committee, BCAS members and staff.

To create awareness and dispel the myths about platelet donation, a “Platelet Donation Awareness Drive” was also held with donors giving blood sample for the platelet donation eligibility check.

For their invaluable contribution, each blood donor was presented a “Life Saver” medal, the BCAS Calendar and a BCAS publication from the Book Mela which was held on the same day

2. International Economics Study Group – Operation Sindoor, Ceasefire or Surrender? What Comes After the Silence & Beyond the Battlefield: The Economic Repercussions of India’s Stand-off held on Monday, 12th May, 2025 @ Virtual

In the meeting, CA Harshad Shah and CA Vijay Maniar presented the following points. Operation Sindoor, named to honour women widowed in the Pahalgam terror attack, marked a paradigm shift in India’s military strategy by challenging Pakistan’s assumption that nuclear threats deter conventional responses. Its objectives included disrupting terrorist infrastructure, preventing future attacks, and establishing a deterrence doctrine equating terrorism with conventional aggression. In 88 hours, India neutralised 9 terror infrastructures and 11 Pakistani airbases with precision strikes using BrahMos, HAMMER, and SCALP missiles while dismantling Pakistan’s air defences. The Indian Integrated Defense System (S-400, Akash platforms, anti-aircraft guns, fighter jets and electronic warfare system) successfully intercepted missile and drone attacks, showcasing cutting-edge technology. Strikes on strategic sites like Kirana Hills and Nur Khan Airbase crippled Pakistan’s nuclear command centres. Operation Sindoor delivered a psychological and tactical blow, signalling zero tolerance for terrorism and elevating India’s defence capabilities. Pakistan’s halt to hostilities under U.S. pressure highlighted its vulnerability. Key outcomes included bolstering India’s resilience, leveraging non-kinetic tools like Indus Waters Treaty suspension, and redefining counter-terrorism norms globally.

3. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “GST on Societies, Trusts, Charitable Institutions, etc.” held on Monday, 5th May, 2025 @ Virtual

Group leader, CA Mohit Gupta prepared and presented various case studies on GST on Societies, Trusts, Charitable Institutions, etc.

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  1.  Concept of Clubs, Society, Members, Trust, etc.
  2.  Supplies by Resident Welfare Association (RWA), Different charges collected by RWA, Clubs.
  3.  Activities undertaken by Trusts, CSR Donation received by Trusts.
  4.  Taxability of different charges paid to RWA and Clubs.

Around 75 participants from all over India benefitted while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader & group mentor.

4. Lecture Meeting on Fund Raising Opportunities through GIFT IFSC

Group leader CA. Nihar Dharod, prepared case studies covering various contentious issues around refunds under GST in consultation with Group Mentor Adv Keval Shah, Mumbai.

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) hosted a lecture meeting detailing fundraising opportunities through GIFT IFSC (Gujarat International Finance Tec-City International Financial Services Centre) on 30th April, 2025. Speakers from the IFSCA, India International Exchange (India INX), and a legal firm discussed the regulatory framework, tax benefits, and strategic advantages for Indian and foreign companies seeking capital.

Arjun Prasad (GM, IFSCA) delivered a Keynote address and explained that the IFSCA acts as the unified regulator for GIFT City’s SEZ, streamlining regulations. He highlighted that GIFT City SEZ is treated as foreign jurisdiction under FEMA, enabling unrestricted capital flows and treating flows to domestic India as foreign investments. GIFT City has experienced substantial growth, with a significant increase in entities, banking assets, funds, and exchange turnover, aiming to compete with global financial hubs.

Riddhi Vora (Head of Listing, India INX) discussed India INX’s role as the first international exchange in GIFT IFSC, aiming to establish Gift City as a global price setter. Recent regulatory changes now permit direct equity listings for Indian companies on IFSC exchanges without mandatory prior domestic listing, facilitating capital raising from both resident and non-resident investors. IFSC listing regulations are designed to be less stringent than domestic ones, with lower minimum public shareholding requirements and flexible issue periods. India INX also promotes Green/ESG bond listings.

Ketki Gor Mehta shared that the IFSC within GIFT City’s SEZ functions as India’s offshore platform and transactions occur in freely convertible foreign currencies. While subject to Indian laws, IFSC entities enjoy specific tax exemptions and fiscal benefits. Beyond equity and debt, the IFSC supports ECBs and a growing fund management market, with advantages in specialized sectors like aircraft and ship leasing.

Vishal Yaduvanshi discussed recent regulatory changes that have created a robust framework for various entities to raise funds on IFSC exchanges through diverse instruments, including equity, debt, REITs, and InvITs. A key attraction is that FATF-compliant foreign companies can undertake fundraising without redomiciling to India. Generating liquidity is crucial for IFSC exchanges to attract more listings and investors.

Speakers responded satisfactorily to the queries raised by the participants. More than 200 participants attended the Lecture Meeting.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yh3VNNfEvs

QR Code:

5. ITF Study Circle Meeting on “Provisions of the New Income Tax Bill 2025 related to International Tax – Part 1” held on Tuesday, 29th April, 2025 @Zoom

Group Leaders – CA Nemin Shah and CA Hansh Gangar

Decode the New Income Tax Bill, 2025 – International Tax Focus

Corresponding provisions of sections 6, 7 and 115A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 in the Income Tax Bill, 2025- Group Leader CA Nemin Shah

During the session, CA Nemin Shah started the discussion with general changes in the New Income Tax Bill, 2025 (ITB), such as changing the previous year and assessment year to tax year and replacement of provisos and explanations with sub-sections. The Group Leader discussed that broadly, except for the section numbering, there was no change in the language of the corresponding clauses to sections 6, 7 and 115A of the Income-tax Act, 1961(Act). The corresponding clauses in the ITB are sections 6, 7 and section 207. The Group Leader pointed out that in Explanation 1(a) of section 6 of the Act, the language ‘for the purpose of employment been changed to ‘for employment outside India ‘ in the corresponding clause in ITB clause 6(3)(b). The group discussed that this would result in a narrowing of the language. Another thought was whether it was just an attempt to simplify the language or something else. Further, the Group Leader went on to point out that the redundant sections in the Act were removed in the Bill.

Corresponding provisions of sections 9, 9A, 90 to 91of the Income-tax Act, 1961 in the Income Tax Bill, 2025 – Group Leader CA Hansh Gangar

CA Hansh Gangar started with the macro analysis of the changes in sections 9, 9A, 90 to 91. He pointed out that the provisions of business connection and Indirect Transfer were pushed behind in clause 9 of the ITB. Section 9A of the Act is now merged with clause 9 of ITB under clause 9(12). Further, eligibility conditions relating to business connections were listed in Schedule I. In the ITB, the term “for the purpose of” has been removed has been removed from many provisions. Further, provisions which are either redundant or have a sunset clause have also been removed. Provisions with single para with long explanations are now broken down into pointers. In the detailed comparative analysis, the Group Leader pointed out the changes in language, such as section 9(1)(ii) of the Act relating to Salaries has a language ‘…if it is earned in India’. This language has been removed from the ITB. He pointed out that in section 9(1)(vi)(b) of the Act relating to royalty, the restriction imposed by the term “any right, property or information used or services utilized” has been removed in the corresponding section 6(a)(ii) of ITB thereby widening the scope of royalty payments made for business outside India. The Group Leader also pointed out a typographical error in clause 6(a)(iii)(B) wherein the word ‘outside’ has been used. Further, in the definition of ‘royalty’ given in clause 6(b) of the ITB after the term ‘transfer’, the term ‘grant’ has also been inserted under ITB.

6. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on Income-Tax Provision Applicable for FY 2025-26 held on Saturday, 26th April, 2025 @Zoom

CA Avinash Rawani discussed important provisions of the Income Tax Act applicable for FY 2025-26:

i. New Tax Regime (Section 115BAC): Tax slabs have been revised, and the standard deduction under this regime has been increased from ₹50,000 to ₹75,000, effective 01.04.2025.

ii. Capital Gains Tax: Short-term capital gains (STCG) under Section 111A will be taxed at 20% (earlier 15%), and long-term capital gains (LTCG) under Section 112A will be taxed at 12.5% (earlier 10%) with indexation benefits withdrawn for post-23.07.2024 transactions.

iii. Business Income (Section 28): Rental income from residential properties held as stock-in-trade will now be taxed under “Income from House Property,” even if let out as part of the business.

iv. Start-up Incentives (Section 80-IAC): The eligibility period for start-ups to claim a 100% deduction of profits for three consecutive years has been extended to those incorporated before 01.04.2030.

v. Presumptive Taxation (Section 44BBC): Introduced for non-resident cruise ship operators, taxing 20% of gross receipts from passenger carriage.

vi. TDS and TCS Amendments: Numerous threshold limits have been increased across sections like 194A (interest) and 194 (dividends); new sections such as 194T introduced TDS on payments to partners in firms/LLPs.
vii. Form 3CD Reporting: Updated with new clauses to include presumptive income reporting, expenditure related to legal contraventions, MSME dues, and buy-back of shares compliance.

viii. Updated Return Filing (Section 139(8A)): Time limits extended up to 48 months post-A.Y. end, with corresponding increases in additional tax liability.

ix. Charitable Trusts: Registration validity for small trusts (income ≤ ₹5 Cr) was extended from 5 to 10 years, and procedural amendments were made for mergers and application errors.

x. Miscellaneous: Sunset clauses for IFSC tax concessions were extended to 31.03.2030, and numerous procedural and compliance changes (e.g., in reassessment, penalty provisions) were introduced.

The presentation was well received and appreciated by the participants.

7. Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Study Circle – Overview of recent regulatory changes in Company Law & SEBI Listing Regulations and certain important ROC Adjudication Orders held on Thursday, 24th April, 2025 @ Virtual

The Study Circle session on 24th April, 2025, led by CS Gaurav Pingle, focused on recent changes in Company Law and, SEBI LODR Regulations and ROC / RD adjudication orders.

Key highlights on Company Law updates covered MCA’s launch of the e-Adjudication platform and CPC, CPACE to also undertake LLP strike-off, and facilitating changes in mobile/email of a DIN holder through DIR-3 KYC, ease of merger of a foreign holding company with its Indian WOS, extension of timelines for compulsory demat, LEAP rules for facilitating listing in IFSC, etc.

SEBI updates inter alia covered rumour verification, new norms for the appointment of secretarial auditors (brought in line with those applicable to statutory auditors), RPT exemptions, and changes in the procedure of reclassification of promoters.

The learned speaker deliberated on some Important ROC/ RD adjudication orders (relevant from CA’s perspective) on CSR lapses, delays in the appointment of internal auditors, private placement, etc.

The session was quite informative, giving an overview of the practical implications of the reforms as well as responding to all the queries raised by the participants.

8. FEMA Study Circle Meeting “Decoding FEMA Draft Regulations and Directions on Foreign Trade” held on Tuesday, 22nd April, 2025 @Zoom.

Group Leader : CA Naziya Sayyed

  •  Overview of Draft Regulations under FEMA:

• Examination of the key objectives behind the draft regulations and directions issued by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999, focusing on modernisation, simplification, and alignment with current global trade practices.

  •  Revised Framework for Import and Export Transactions:

• Discussion on the proposed changes in compliance procedures for cross-border trade, including timelines for realisation and repatriation of export proceeds and settlement of import payments.

  •  Liberalisation vs. Control Mechanisms:

• Analysis of how the draft balances ease of doing business with necessary foreign exchange controls to safeguard India’s external sector stability.

  •  Impact on Advance Payments and Deferred Payment Terms:

• Clarification of norms regarding advance remittances for imports and extended credit terms for exports, including risk mitigation measures suggested in the draft.

  •  Directions on Third-Party Payments in Trade:

• Interpretation of the provisions regulating third-party payments in export/import transactions and their alignment with global banking practices.

  •  Trade Credit Regulations:

• Review of updated norms for suppliers’ credit and buyers’ credit, including ceilings, maturity periods, and all-in-cost benchmarks.

  •  Treatment of Merchanting Trade Transactions (MTT):

• Discussion on streamlined procedures and compliance requirements for merchanting trade, ensuring transparency and monitoring of such transactions under FEMA.

  •  Penal Provisions and Non-Compliance Consequences:

• Overview of the enforcement mechanisms, penalties for contraventions, and the role of Authorized Dealers (AD Banks) in ensuring adherence to the directions.

  •  Alignment with WTO and International Trade Norms:

• Evaluation of how the draft regulations harmonise India’s foreign exchange laws with international trade agreements and obligations.

  •  Stakeholder Implications and Compliance Challenges:

• Identification of practical challenges for exporters, importers, banks, and consultants in adapting to the new regulatory environment and recommendations for ensuring a smooth transition once these drafts are finalised.

9. Full Day Seminar on “TDS and TCS Provisions – a 360° Perspective” held on Thursday, 17th April, 2025 @ IMC.

Taxation Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, in collaboration with the Indian Merchant Chamber of Commerce and Industry and the Chamber of Tax Consultants, organised a full-day seminar on “TDS and TCS Provisions – a 360° Perspective”.

The seminar commenced with a welcome address by office bearers of the organising institutions, followed by a keynote address by Shri Raj Tandon, Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax (Mumbai), who emphasised the government’s evolving approach toward compliance and streamlining of tax deduction and collection mechanisms.

Session 1 delved into critical issues under domestic TDS and TCS provisions, particularly Sections 194R, 194Q, 194D, 194J, and TCS on goods. The discussion focused on interpretational ambiguities, industry challenges, and compliance strategies. The session was moderated by CA Vikas Aggarwal, with panel insights from Ms. Vidhi Killa and CA Bhaumik Goda.

Session 2 dealt with enforcement-related aspects such as penalties, prosecutions, and compounding procedures under the TDS/TCS regime. It was chaired by Shri G.M. Doss, CCIT (TDS), Mumbai, who also delivered a keynote on departmental expectations and recent trends. The session was moderated by CA Mahendra Sanghvi and featured expert inputs from CA Rahul Verma and CA Jagdish Punjabi.

Session 3 addressed issues under Section 195 – TDS on payments to non-residents, including complexities involving Significant Economic Presence (SEP) and the Multilateral Instrument (MLI). The session began with a keynote by Smt. Malathi Sridharan, Principal CCIT (International Taxation & Transfer Pricing), West Zone, and was moderated by CA Sushil Lakhani, with panel contributions from Mr Vinod Tanwani (Pr. CIT, Mumbai), CA Sunil Choudhary and CA Ganesh Rajgopalan.

Session 4 focused on procedural and system-level issues, including TDS return filing errors, refund mismatches, credit issues, and lower deduction certificates. The discussion was moderated by CA Ameet Patel and featured participation from senior tax officers, including Mr Mudit Nagpal (CIT-TDS, Mumbai), Mr Sanjeev Kashyap (CIT-TDS), a representative from DGIT (Systems)/CPC, and CA Prayag Kinariwala.

The seminar concluded with closing remarks by Mr. Rajan Vora, Chairman Direct Taxation Committee, IMC. The event was highly appreciated for its expert-led, solution-oriented discussions and its 360° coverage of TDS and TCS provisions, offering valuable insights for both corporates and tax professionals.

10. CAMBA 2025 held on 11th – 13th April, 2025 @ Atlas SkillTech University, Mumbai.

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS recently wrapped up an enriching and impactful event in collaboration with Atlas Skilltech University, Mumbai – CAMBA 2025. CAMBA 2025 was a 3-day course thoughtfully curated to cater to the evolving needs of Chartered Accountants across different stages of their careers.

This year, three specialised batches were conducted to maximize relevance and learning outcomes: below 35, below 35 (advanced) and above 35. Each batch featured content tailored to the specific professional journeys and aspirations of the participants, making CAMBA 2025 more focused and effective than ever before.

The program saw enthusiastic participation from 90+ Chartered Accountants representing almost 20 cities across India, bringing together a vibrant and diverse group of professionals.

A standout element of the course was the Speed Mentoring session, which allowed participants to engage directly with experienced leaders from the profession. This interactive session was particularly well-received and widely appreciated for its practical value and engaging format.

CAMBA 2025 was more than a course—it was a catalyst for transformation. The sessions inspired attendees to think strategically, act like leaders, and embrace the mindset of a visionary problem solver.

Programs like CAMBA continue to reflect the Society’s unwavering commitment to empowering its members with the tools, insights, and confidence they need to thrive in an ever-evolving professional landscape.

11. ESG Essentials seminar held on Friday 4th April, 2025 @ Hotel Ginger

  •  The seminar on ESG Essentials addressed the growing importance of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) frameworks in shaping sustainable business practices and responsible corporate governance.
  •  The introductory session established the urgency of integrating sustainability into business, emphasising the need for present actions to preserve resources for future generations and highlighting the pivotal role of professionals, especially Chartered Accountants, in ESG reporting and assurance.
  •  The first technical session explained the ESG framework, recent global developments, and the significance of compliance, providing participants with practical insights on implementing ESG standards and building a sustainable foundation for organisations.
  •  The session on green financing explored how climate change is influencing investment strategies, the role of public and private funding in supporting green infrastructure, and the current gaps and opportunities in green finance for India’s transition to a green economy.
  •  Panel 1 provided an in-depth look at the SEBI-mandated BRSR (Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting) framework, discussing the nine guiding principles, the adoption of emerging technologies beyond AI and blockchain for ESG reporting, and the need for materiality and comparability in disclosures.
  •  The panel also discussed India’s standing in ESG relative to global benchmarks, the broadening of assurance providers for ESG reports, and strategies for capacity-building within the profession, including the potential for India-specific ESG standards.
  •  Panelists examined emissions management, especially the complexities of Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions, and shared insights on how energy companies are transitioning from thermal to renewable energy, supported by innovative technologies and policy incentives.
  •  Panel 2 addressed governance and transparency challenges, including the integration of ESG at the board level, embedding ESG into budgeting and resource allocation, and the importance of stakeholder engagement to ensure meaningful and credible ESG reporting.
  •  The risks of greenwashing were discussed, with practical indicators for identifying superficial ESG claims and strategies for enhancing the reliability and value of ESG disclosures, including the proactive role of internal audit.
  •  The seminar concluded with a discussion on ESG leadership models, debating the merits of dedicated sustainability roles versus integrated responsibilities and highlighting the need for clear accountability, robust governance, and ongoing professional development to advance ESG maturity.

Speakers: Gandharv Tongia, Himanshu Kishnadwala, Om Prakash Chandak, Priti Savla, Prabhu Narayan Singh, Rakesh Agarwal, Sarita Bahl, Mitika Bajpai, Vijayalakshmi Suresh.

12. One Day Conference on “Practical Issues under FEMA” jointly with CTC held on Saturday, 22nd February, 2025 @IMC.

The International Taxation Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, in collaboration with the Chamber of Tax Consultants, organised a full-day Conference on Practical issues under FEMA.

The seminar commenced with a welcome address by office bearers of the organising institutions, followed by a keynote address by Shri Prashant Kumar Dayal, General Manager, RBI. The keynote address was followed by a panel discussion session where General Managers and Deputy General Managers from RBI provided their detailed replies to various queries which were circulated to them and the participants before the conference. The responses of RBI managers, the depth and explanation of the answers and the forthcoming nature of the RBI managers to discuss the practical issues faced by the Professionals and AD banks were well appreciated by the participants.

The post-lunch session was taken up with CA Rutvik Sanghvi delved into certain very important recent developments on capital and current account transactions in FEMA. Dr. CA Mayur Nayak ably chaired the session.

The last session of the day was a Panel Discussion, which featured Shri. Himanshu Mohanty (Ex-General Manager, RBI), Mr Suhas Bendre – ex-AD Banker and CA Shabbir Motorwala as panellists and the discussion was ably chaired and moderated by CA Paresh P. Shah. The panel discussion involved discussion on case studies on practical issues such as cross-border share swap transactions, cross-border mergers, recent foreign investment clarifications and issues on certain specific transactions from an AD banker’s perspective.

The seminar concluded with closing remarks by office bearers of BCAS and CTC. The event was highly appreciated for its expert-led, solution-oriented discussions and practical insights due to the presence of the RBI managers.

II. BCAS QUOTED IN NEWS & MEDIA

BCAS was quoted in 6 news and media platforms during April 2025 and May 2025. These coverage reflect our thought leadership and commitment to the profession. For details

Youtube Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Issues in the Hospitality Sector” held on Monday 14th April 2025 @ Virtual.

The 1st meeting of the Indirect tax study circle for 2025-26 was held on 14th April, 2025 and attended by 90 participants. The Group Leader CA. Ronak Gandhi, prepared case studies covering the following contentious issues in GST pertaining to the hospitality sector:

a) Issues in determining the GST Rate for hotel accommodation services & restaurant services based on the room rate and the impact of additional services, such as extra beds, on such classification.
b) Eligibility of ITC on capital goods used for restaurants and already put to use, if the hotel decides to opt in as specified premises.
c) Classification conundrum (sale vs. services) for bakery and other ready to eat items supplied by eating joints, not operating as a traditional restaurant.
d) Taxability of packaged food items, water bottles & other beverages sold by Quick Service Restaurants
e) Tax implications of combo deals involving supply of food with alcohol for a lumpsum consideration
f) Valuation issues for goods supplied below the cost by a restaurant
g) Valuation issues for goods supplied to franchise-owned outlets vs company-owned outlets

A detailed deliberation was held on the case studies, and the members appreciated the efforts put in by the group leader & group mentor CA. Yash Parmar, Mumbai.

2. International Economics Study Group — Trump’s Tantrums: Shaping & Shaking Contemporary Geopolitics & Geo-Economics held on Tuesday 8th April, 2025 @ Virtual.

In the meeting, CA Harshad Shah presented key global geopolitical & economic developments, prompting a lively exchange among the Group. The discussion addressed the ongoing tariff war and Trump’s territorial expansion agenda. Emerging trends such as de-dollarization, higher Bond yields, information warfare, and supply chain conflicts were explored alongside the escalating U.S.-China rivalry. Members argued that tariffs alone cannot fix the trade deficit, as they simply shift consumer spending rather than solve core problems. The Group highlighted negative outcomes of such policies, including higher consumer prices, reduced exports, and disruptions to global trade, all of which could weaken U.S. competitiveness and its financial leadership. With U.S.-China trade declining, India was seen as well-positioned to gain from new export opportunities. The meeting concluded with concerns about the risk of a U.S. recession or worse amid these turbulent dynamics.

3. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on “Issue In GST Refund” held on Thursday, 27th March, 2025 @ Virtual

Group leader CA. Nihar Dharod, prepared case studies covering various contentious issues around refunds under GST in consultation with Group Mentor AdvKeval Shah, Mumbai.

The material covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

1. Implication of section 16 (5) on refund rejection orders that are not challenged
2. Is the claim for refund of tax paid on SEZ supplies subject to limitation?
3. Refund claims arising due to negative tax liability on account of credit notes
4. Interest on refunds delayed due to litigation.
5. Refund of tax paid on contracts cancelled after the time limit prescribed u/s 34.
6. Whether retention clauses in export contracts result in non-compliance with realization provisions?
7. Implications of amendments relating to rules 89 (4A), 89 (4B) and 96 (10).

Around 50 participants from all over India benefitted while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader & group mentor.

4. International Women’s Day 2025 “EMPOWERED WOMEN = EMPOWERED LIVES” held on Monday, 24th March 2025 @ BCAS

The Women’s Day event for 2025 was held on 24th March 2025 at the BCAS Hall at Jolly Bhavan. The SMPR Committee and the HRD Committee jointly conducted the event. The theme for the event was Empowerment, and to celebrate this theme, three ladies who are themselves empowered in various capacities, addressed the gathering.

CA Shradhha Joshi Barde, who is an entrepreneur in the field of sustainable and slow fashion, shared her journey from numbers to fashion. She explained the concept of slow fashion and also elaborated on mindful consumption which can have a great ecological impact.

When we talk of empowerment, there are various enablers to this aspect, the key ones being a healthy mind and a healthy body. Ms Neha Pandit Tembe, who is a qualified nutritionist very well elaborated on the various aspects of health from the point of view of nutrition. She included the concepts of a healthy plate, healthy inventory shopping as also reading food labels, which was very insightful. Ms Prajakta Gupte conducted an interactive session where she made the audience do some exercises which they could do at their workplaces and avoid aches and pains. She also conducted breathing exercises and meditation.

The event was well received by the audience, whose feedback made it clear that they had great takeaways from the session.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LOH4XqgM2mw

QR Code:

5. BCAS Nxt Learning and Development Bootcamp on Bank Branch Audit from Article’s Perspective held on Saturday, 22nd March, 2025 @ Virtual

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organized a BCAS NXT Learning & Development Bootcamp on “Bank Branch Audit from Article student’s perspective” on Saturday, 22nd March, 2025. The session was led by Mr Atharva Joshi & Ms Sanskruti Nalegaonkar, CA Final students, who delivered a comprehensive presentation on the planning & preparation for bank branch audit. The presentation covered a wide range of topics, including Key concepts & Essential Terms, LFAR & compliance reporting, Core audit areas and Audit finalization & closure. They also shared practical experiences to help beginner article students navigate the complexities of Bank Branch Audits.

CA Rishikesh Joshi, the mentor for the session, provided valuable insights and guidance throughout, offering expert interventions as needed. The boot camp was held in person at the office of Kirtane&Pandit LLP, Chartered Accountants and streamed online, with active participation from students across India.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/ watch?v=Wdh075aF1O8

QR Code:

6. XIIIth Residential Study Course on IND AS held from Thursday 20th March, 2025 to Saturday 22nd March, 2025@ The Rhythm Lonavala.

BCAS has always been a pioneer in equipping its members in particular and other stakeholders at large, with the knowledge of Ind AS. BCAS had started the subject specific Residential Study Course (RSC) for achieving the stated objective.

The Accounting & Auditing Committee organised its XIIIthInd AS Residential Study Course to address the practical challenges in IND AS and also share the experiences of experts in dealing with and addressing such challenges. This year, the format of the RSC included 3 papers for Group Discussion (GD) covering a very wide range of interesting issues, 2 papers for presentation, followed by the Panel discussion by eminent panellists. The RSC was held for 2 nights and 3 days from 20th March 2025 to 22nd March, 2025 at Rhythm Hotel, Lonavala.

The main objective of the RSC was to provide a platform to the Members in Industry and Practice to come together and get the opportunity to get deep insights into the practical challenges which they face while implementing the complex standards. The individual sessions were designed to give practical and case study-based insights to the participants on various topics.

RSC Programme Schedule included the following topics and speakers:

The RSC was inaugurated with the opening remarks from the President of BCAS, CA Anand Bathiya, followed by the Chairman of the Accounting and Auditing Committee – CA. Abhay Mehta, both of them underline the importance of knowledge sharing and the role of the BCAS in conducting such a Residential Study Course. To make the RSC interesting and engaging, domain expert speakers with relevant experience were invited to give participants practical insights and wholesome experiences.

The course started with the presentation session of CA Himanshu Kishnadwala, where he updated the participants on various NFRA orders, practical examples and issues and Learnings from the same. He also highlighted the NFRA Educational series which would be relevant for the Audit Committee to discuss the issues in Audit with the Auditors.

The first Group Discussion on Ind AS 116 on Lease &Ind AS 103 on Business Combination under common control was followed by the Session of the paper writer – CA Alok Garg who dealt with both the IND AS and critical case studies covering detailed concepts of both the standards besides sharing his practical experience of the industry with the participants.

The second Group Discussion on Ind AS 115 on Revenue from Contracts with Customers was followed by the Session of the paper writer – CA Archana Bhutani, covering the issues in Revenue Recognition and also covering concepts and issues in E-Commerce and Fintech platforms. The paper writer also made the presentation on Updates on Important Amendments in Ind AS Applicable to the March 2025 closure and also highlighted amendments in relevant IFRS.

The third Group Discussion on Case Studies on Intricacies in Financial Instruments (Ind AS 32 &Ind AS 109) was followed by the Session of the paper writer – CA R. Venkat Subramani, covering the issues in ECL and Hedge Accounting.

The Panel Discussion on Connectivity between Financial Statements and Sustainability was moderated by the Chairman of the Committee – CA Abhay Mehta, covering the relevant Issues and Questions for the eminent Panelists CA Himanshu Kishnadwala who shared his experience as a Member in Practice on the professional opportunities available to the members in the areas of ESG and CA Raj Mullick as Member in Industry sharing his experience and challenges in implementing ESG and sharing his views on Carbon Credits.
.
The RSC provided excellent opportunity to gain valuable knowledge and practical insights on the topics covered and gave the chance to interact with the speakers and participants through informal chats. 70 participants from across India attended the course, and was well received, and the overall feedback from the participants was very encouraging.

7. Finance, Corporate and Allied Law Study Circle Meeting on “How to read and analyse Annual Report” held on Friday, 7th March 2025 @ Virtual.

The session was intended to highlight the need for a paradigm shift from financial literacy to financial intelligence, i.e. not only to be able to read the annual report but to attempt to understand and analyse the same and connect the dots to unlock the secrets of the annual report.

CA Pankaj Tiwari’s approach from concept to case studies made the session very enriching.

He took the participants through the regulatory framework contents of the annual report, including critical areas, identification of red-flags, key points for investors, ICAI’s AI tools for analysis, important aspects in analysis, and recent developments in India and globally in financial reporting. He emphasised to connect the dots between financial as well as equally important non-financial information.

He was joined by CA Meet Gandhi for certain case studies.

To summarise, the learned speaker, through his vast knowledge and experience, enlighted the participants about the intelligent analysis of the annual report.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLxs8_S_BoA

QR Code:

8. आDaan-Daan– BCAS Mentoring Circle – Season 4

The fourth season of ‘आDaan-Daan – BCAS Mentoring Circle’, an initiative of the Seminar, Membership and Public Relations Committee of BCAS, unfolded between January and March 2025, with 19 mentors and 20 mentees coming together for one-on-one online sessions.

This year, the program welcomed participants without any age restrictions, acknowledging the evolving nature of mentorship, including a few reverse mentoring requests received in the previous season.

Open to both members and non-members, the series continued its aim of fostering meaningful professional conversations.

Rather than a fixed format, mentees set the direction—sharing their background, aspirations, and challenges in advance—giving mentors the opportunity to prepare and personalise the interaction.

The strength of the series lay in its simplicity: guided conversations that encouraged reflection, direction, and clarity. Care was taken to pair each mentee with a mentor whose experience aligned with their goals.

Feedback from both sides pointed to the value of a safe space for exchange, where curiosity met experience. Mentors appreciated the platform to contribute meaningfully, while mentees walked away with new insights and confidence.

The Committee thanks all participants and looks forward to building on this growing community of shared learning.

9. Online Panel Discussion on Recent Developments in Taxation of Charitable Trusts held on Thursday, 20th February, 2025 @ Zoom

The webinar on the recent developments in the taxation of charitable trusts got more than 100 plus registrations.

Dr. Manoj Fogla discussed the background and implications of the two landmark Supreme Court decisions (New Noble Education Society and Ahmedabad Urban Development Society) that unsettled many settled legal positions regarding charitable trusts. He explained how charitable trusts traditionally generate income and the challenges posed by recent amendments and court rulings on the taxability of various types of income, including incidental business activities. He also provided insights into the spirit of the law concerning the application of income by trustees and the evolving interpretation under section 11 of the Income Tax Act.

CS Suresh Kumar Kejriwal took the lead in explaining the amendments proposed in the Finance Bill and the Income Tax Bill 2025, focusing on key concepts such as “substantial contributor,” “specified persons,” and the new rules affecting the exemption and business income of charitable trusts. He elaborated on how these amendments impact the compliance and tax planning for trusts, especially in light of the unsettled legal landscape after the Supreme Court decisions.

Mr Gautam Nayak moderated the session, introduced the panellists, and contextualized the discussion by highlighting the significance of the topic for the nonprofit sector. He emphasized the role of IMC and BCA in supporting professionals and organizations through knowledge dissemination and advocacy on taxation issues affecting charitable trusts.

This structured presentation helped clarify the complex and evolving tax framework for charitable trusts in India, addressing recent Supreme Court rulings, legislative amendments in 2023 and 2024, and the implications of the newly introduced Direct Tax Bill. The experts provided practical guidance on compliance challenges and strategic considerations for charitable trusts under the current tax regime.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l00dA2jYgf0

QR Code:

10. Webinar on New Income Tax Bill, 2025 held on Tuesday 18th February, 2025 @ Zoom

The webinar on the new Income Tax Bill 2025 featured esteemed Chartered Accountants discussing the bill’s implications, structure, and expected impact. It got more than 600 plus registrations.

CA GautamNayak addressed some of the important points as enumerated below:

  •  Outlined the bill’s structural changes: reduction in sections (from 819 to 536), chapters (from 47 to 23), and word count (from about 512,000 to 260,000), with schedules increased from 11 to 16.
  •  Highlighted the removal of complex provisos and explanations, replaced by clearer subsections and clauses, and elimination of confusing alphanumeric section numbers.
  • Warned that frequent amendments may continue to complicate the law over time, potentially undermining the simplification effort.
  •  Noted the government’s provision of FAQs and a navigator tool to help users transition from the old to the new law.
  •  Stressed that the bill has been referred to a parliamentary Select Committee for further review, and its ultimate impact will depend on future amendments and implementation.

Some of the key points addressed by CA Bhadresh Doshi:

Budget Speech Expectations: Despite the Finance Minister’s indication that the new Income Tax Bill would carry forward the “spirit of Naya” (newness), similar to the changes in the Indian Penal Code, there were no significant decriminalization or dilution of penal provisions for offences like TDS/TCS defaults.

Commendable Effort with Side Effects: CA Doshi acknowledged the commendable effort of 150 officers who spent approximately 60,000 man-hours simplifying the six-decade-old law but pointed out potential “side effects” resulting in new complications.

Missing Punctuation and Language Issues: He highlighted instances where simplification led to issues due to changes in language.

Inconsistencies in Referring to Old Provisions: He pointed out inconsistencies in how the new bill refers to the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the Indian Income Tax Act, 1922, across different sections.

Income from Salaries: CA Doshi noted no changes in provisions related to income from salaries, except for government employees, where the entertainment allowance deduction under Section 16 has been omitted in the new bill (Section 19).

Income from House Property: CA Doshi discussed several changes in provisions related to income from house property:

Intentional vs. Unintended Changes: CA Doshi clarified that it is unclear whether the identified changes were intentional or unintended errors, and only time will reveal their true nature.

In summary, CA Doshi’s key points revolved around unintended complications arising from the simplification process, inconsistencies in referencing older laws, and specific changes in provisions related to house property and salaries. He emphasized the need for careful interpretation and potential rectifications in the future.

The webinar was very well received by the participants.

II. OTHER EVENTS

1. Session On Eye Health Care for the BCAS Staff held on Tuesday 8th April, 2025 @ BCAS

The Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) organised a session on eye health care on 8th April, 2025. The session was conducted by Dr. Viram Agrawal, a renowned expert in eye care. It was held at BCAS premises from 5:30 p.m. onwards. The session aimed to educate staff members on maintaining good eye health and preventing eye-related problems.

Dr Agrawal shared practical tips on reducing eye strain, such as blinking regularly and palming. Staff members learned about best practices for protecting their eyes from potential hazards.

Staff members actively participated in the session, asking questions and engaging in discussions. Dr. Agrawal’s expertise and guidance were highly appreciated by the attendees. Staff members left with practical knowledge and awareness about maintaining good eye health.

The eye health care session reflects BCAS’s commitment to prioritizing staff well-being and promoting holistic growth and development. By organizing such initiatives, BCAS demonstrates its concern for staff’s overall health and well-being.

2. Session on Yoga for the BCAS Staff held on Monday 17th February, 2025 @ BCAS

As part of our ongoing staff development program, the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS), CA Raman Jokhakar, Past President of the BCAS, conducted an informal session on Yoga and how it is beneficial for the staff working in BCAS, on 17 February 2025, at Churchgate Chambers from 5:30 p.m. onwards.

He informed about the yoga techniques and breathing exercises to reduce stress and improve productivity. He also highlighted the benefits of yoga for overall health. He suggested to invite a yoga expert who can show the yoga techniques to the staff. The session was informative, engaging, and well-received, boosting staff morale and productivity. BCAS continues to prioritise staff well-being and development, reflecting its commitment to holistic growth.

CA Raman Jokhakar also suggested a future session on eye health care with Dr Viram Agrawal, further demonstrating BCAS’s dedication to staff’s overall health and well-being. The session was a success, and the feedback was positive.

III. BCAS QUOTED IN NEWS & MEDIA

BCAS has been quoted in 113 esteemed news and media platforms, reflecting our thought leadership and commitment to the profession. For details

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Navigating the New Income Tax Bill, TDS, Deductions & Critical Provisions” on Thursday, 13th March, 2025 and at C/o SHBA & Co. LLP, Andheri (E), Mumbai.

Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Navigating the New Income Tax Bill, TDS, Deductions & Critical Provisions”, was led by CA Upamanyu Manjrekar & CA SnehalMayacharya, where they delved into critical amendments in the Income Tax framework, with a focus on TDS, deductions, and key provisions. The discussion highlighted changes in terminology, procedural updates, and practical implications for businesses and professionals.

Key changes discussed included:

  • Modifications in Income Tax Bill Wording – Minor yet impactful changes in phraseology, altering interpretation and compliance requirements.
  • TDS Revisions – Updates on applicability, rates, and compliance, including sector-specific changes.
  • Procedural & Compliance Changes – New filing requirements, reporting obligations, and penalty structures.
  • Impact on Business & Professionals – Discussion on how the amendments affect different taxpayer categories.
  • Group Interpretation & Case Studies – Open discussion on ambiguous provisions and their practical implementation.
  • Retrospective vs. Prospective Amendments – Debate on whether certain provisions apply retrospectively or prospectively.
  • Practical Challenges & Solutions – Addressing common compliance difficulties and suggested best practices.
    The session was highly interactive, with participants engaging in insightful discussions and real-world case studies. CA Upamanyu Manjrekar & CA SnehalMayacharya provided clear explanations, ensuring attendees left with a well-rounded understanding of the amendments and their implications.

2.  HRD Study Circle on The Secret Formula of Successful ENTREPRENEURS on Tuesday, 11th March, 2025 @ Virtual.

The Human Resources Development Committee Organised a Talk on Topic “The Secret Formula of Successful ENTREPRENEURS” on 11th March, 2025.
Faculty Mr. Walter Vieira

The takeaways from the workshop are briefly given below:

  1.  Comparing entrepreneur with a turtle he quoted James Byrant Conant who said – “Behold the turtle. He makes progress only when he sticks his neck out.”All cannot be entrepreneurs. Those who stick their neck out — take risk, have perseverance, conviction in their idea and believe in themselves could become excellent entrepreneurs
  2.  Entrepreneurship is a process of creating something new and needs deep study of business environment backed up by Fundable business plan.
  3.  There is a certain degree ofaptitude and attitude that is needed to do business and move further as Entrepreneur

They are

a) Creativity and flexibility
b) Resilience
c) Humility to accept success and failure
d) Perseverance
e) Spirit of adventure
f) People skills with a back-up technical knowledge in the subject

There were 167 participants who attended the meeting and good number of them asked questions which were well answered by the faculty.

3. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on Tuesday, 25th February, 2025, @ Virtual

The Group Leader & the Group Mentor introduced the participants to the topic and dealt with the relevant provisions & clarifications before proceeding to the case studies covering the following contentious & practical issues on the topic:

  1. Can an application be filed u/s 128A filed when there is a demand for only interest & penalty?
  2. Distinction between self-assessed liability and whether section 128A can be invoked if an Order is passed confirming demand for such self-assessed liability?
  3. Practical challenges in adjusting liability when payment is made in GSTR-3B / pre-deposit while filing an appeal / third party recovery against DRC-13.
  4. In case of appeal Order, section 128A application to be filed against the appeal Order or adjudication order?
  5. Is section 128A option available if the Appeal Authority remands the matter?
  6. Can application for rectification of order for demand confirmed for multiple points, including section 16 (4) be filed?
  7. Can the rectification order for demand confirmed u/s 16 (4) go beyond the scope of the original notice?
  8. Availability of refund of pre-deposit paid in case of successful appeal order for demand u/s 16 (4)

The meeting was attended by 50 members. The participants appreciated the efforts of the Group Leader and Group Mentors.

4. Tarang 2K25 – The 17th Jal ErachDastur CA Students’ Annual Day on Saturday, 22nd February, 2025 @ M M Pupils Own School — Khar.

The completion of the November 2024 CA exams commenced the preparations for the grand Tarang 2k25. The stage was set for the awe-inspiring event to happen, and it was when the Students’ Team and members of the Human Resource Development Committee (HRD) met to re-write the success story of the marvellous legacy of the past 16 years.

The 17th year of Jal ErachDastur CA Students’ Annual Day under the brand of ‘Tarang’ had to be engaging, enthralling, and magnificent. With this mission in mind, the Students’ Team started upon the journey for delightful Tarang 2k25 under the requisite guidance of CA MihirSheth, CA DnyaneshPatade, CA Jigar Shah, and CA Utsav Shah. MsPrachi Shah and Mr Paras Doshi were appointed as the student coordinators.

Tarang, when described, is an ecstatic annual CA students’ celebration mainly intended to provide a platform for CA students to unleash their talent and creativity in areas of public speaking, writing skills, performing arts, business, technical, and innovative skills. Additionally, the event also intends to act as an insight and potential gateway into the real world outside academic books by providing access and tutelage by skilled and experienced leaders in the form of participation in various fields with a view to building interpersonal and team-building skills with an opportunity to fraternize and network with hundreds of like-minded students.

The event was organized under the auspices of the HRD Committee of BCAS. All meetings were held in offline and online format. The event was supported by a total of 30 volunteers. Tarang 2k25 completely changed the dull and monotonous perception regarding CA students when they were witnessed as event managers, anchors, talented dancers, and photographers too!

As intended, it was truly an event ‘Of CA Students, By CA Students and For CA students.’

Tarang 2k25, to our surprise, saw a huge enrollment of around 350 students despite the pending due dates. There were an overall 165 participants in Tarang 2k25, along with the highest number of participants in the ‘Treasure Hunt’ too. The event became very popular, and we received huge enrollments along with amazing ideas that were pitched to the judges, which were worth the watch.

Also for the very first time Mock Stock exchange was organised specially for CA students where around 75 students participated.

The 17th Jal ErachDastur CA Students’ Annual Day – ‘Tarang 2K25’ elimination rounds were held at the BCAS Hall on the 15th and 16th of February 2025, To keep the fun going and the crowd engaged, the students’ team had organized various online games and networking sessions, This provided a unique opportunity for all the participants to build a productive and constructive network along with a lot of fun too.

The Grand Finale of Tarang 2k25 was held at MM Pupils School, Khar on the 22-2-25 from 3 pm onwards. We were delighted to have Bank of Baroda as the sole sponsor for the prizes of the winners of the various games and quizzes held offline. Arrangements for various exciting games were made to engage and build excitement among the audience before the event’s commencement.

The grand finale commenced at 3 pm with the lighting of the divine lamp by the HRD Committee with the Ganesh Vandana and Saraswati Vandana being played in the background to seek blessings and express gratitude to Lord Ganesh and Maa Saraswati.

The winners of the competition representing their firms were announced as follows:

Invest, Conquer, Compete (Mock Stock Exchange) – Winning Team – Dikshant Pandiyan, Jainil Sheth and Priyansh Jindal

Reel Making Competition ‘Shutter Stories’ – Sushil Khubchandani

Photography Competition ‘The Capture Challenge ’ – Anjali Vaishya

Antakshari Competition – ‘Suronke Maharathi’
Winning Team – NikunjPatel ,Harshita Dave and Rahul Jaiswar

Debate Competition – ‘The Battle Of Perspectives’ Winning Team – Sanjog Shah, Jainam Doshi, Vedant Agarwal and Madhur Bhartiya

Best Debater – Vedant Agarwal

The Rotating Trophy went to – Vedant Agarwal (SRBC and Co)

Talk Tastic – Winner – Piyush Gupta

2nd – Neha Agnihotri

3rd – Sejal Bagda

The Rotating Trophy went to – Piyush Gupta (DBS Bank)

Essay Writing Competition – ‘Pen- Power- Play’ 1st Prize Winner – Dhairya Thakkar

2nd Prize Winner – Neha Agnihotri

3rd Prize Winner – JesikaSahaya

The Rotating Trophy went to – Dhairya Thakkar (JHS Associates)

Talent Show ‘CA’s Got Talent’ Best Performer – Music Category – YashLadha

Best Performer – Instruments Category – Mithil Category

Best Performer – Dancing Category – The JDians

Best Performer – Other Performing Arts Category – Param Savijani and Rishit Raithatha

Pirates Plunder (Treasure Hunt) winners – Rushi Ghuge, Siddharth Gada and Yash Khalse

Hearty Congratulations to all the winners and their firms.

The euphoric evening was superbly anchored by the Master of Ceremony with their unmatched energy and mind-boggling acts to keep the audience engaged throughout the event.

With the 17th edition reaching new milestones and the scale increasing, all eyes are now set on what the anticipated 18th edition would have to offer. One thing is clear, the sky will not be the limit for the goals set to be achieved.

II. BCAS Quoted in News & Media

BCAS has been quoted in various esteemed news and media platforms, reflecting our thought leadership and commitment to the profession. For details

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Finance, Corporate & Allied Law Study Circle – REIT n InvIT as Investment avenues held on Thursday, 13th February, 2025 @ Zoom.

CA Harry Parikh explained the concepts of REIT and InvIT, their features, structural overview, eligibility criteria, investment conditions, etc. He highlighted that REIT or InvIT are investment products and not a tax-saving product. He dealt with the decision-making criteria for investing in REIT or InvIT vis-a-vis traditional investment with the help of examples of REITs. He also enlightened on the key differences between Equity vs. Mutual Fund vs. REIT vs. InvIT, and tax implications thereof. He also shared his insights on factors to be considered for investing in REIT.

More than 70 participants enriched out of the masterly analysis of REIT, InvIT as investment avenues.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxO-5VpL-xk

2. Public Lecture Meeting on “Union Budget 25 — Indirect Tax Proposals” held on Wednesday, 12th February 2025 @ Zoom.

The lecture meeting on the Union Budget 2025 and its Indirect Tax Proposals, held on 12th February 2025, featured CA Sunil Gabhawalla discussing various amendments in the Finance Bill 2025. He focused primarily on GST provisions while briefly touching upon customs, excise, and service tax amendments.

He began by explaining the concept of ‘input service distributor,’ detailing its position in the pre-GST regime, GST regime until 31st March 2025, and the post-2025 scenario. He highlighted differences in the definition of ‘Input Service Distributor’ (ISD) between the existing and proposed regimes, emphasising the potential for varied interpretations and possible litigations. Using the draft circular issued by the CBIC and other relevant jurisprudence, he illustrated cases falling under the ISD and Cross Charge Mechanisms.

He also examined the impact of retrospective amendments in the GST law, referencing the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s decision in the Safari Retreat’s case and highlighting open issues post-amendment. Further, he discussed issues arising from the amendment that incorporates additional conditions for self-adjustment of taxes based on credit notes. He provided guidance on addressing these issues, especially in light of the mandatory Invoice Management System (IMS) introduced by GSTIN in October 2024. He cited practical examples to highlight various aspects taxpayers should consider when dealing with the IMS mechanism. Additionally, he explained how the proposed track and trace mechanism would complement E-way Bill provisions. The meeting emphasised the government’s intent to gather maximum data and use artificial intelligence to curb tax evasion, leading to increased compliance and affecting the ease of doing business.

Finally, he covered miscellaneous amendments related to ‘local authorities,’ ‘vouchers,’ amendments in Schedule III concerning supplies by SEZ / FTWZ units, and the rationalisation of pre-deposits required under appellate proceedings in disputed orders imposing penalties.

The lecture was attended by approximately 325 participants online.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open to all to attend and participate. The readers can view the lecture meeting at the below-mentioned link:

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yAzBv4CAHNw

3. Public Lecture Meeting on Direct Tax Provisions of Finance Bill, 2025 held on Thursday 6th February, 2025 @ Yogi Sabhagruh Auditorium Dadar East

The public lecture on Direct Tax Provisions under the Finance Bill 2025 was a comprehensive discussion led by noted tax expert CA Shri Pinakin Desai. The session emphasised the significant changes in income tax slab rates and corresponding rebate provisions, which were perceived positively. The lecture highlighted that this year’s budget prioritises stimulating consumption over infrastructure investment, marking a substantial increase in tax-free slab rates compared to previous years. Notably, there was a significant shift anticipated as taxpayers may transition from the old tax regime to the new one, leading to increased discretionary spending and ultimately contributing to GDP growth.

Shri Pinakin Desai provided insights into several key provisions of the Finance Bill, 2025 analysing changes to tax rates, corporate taxation, TDS rationalisation, and the taxation of charitable trusts. The lecture also discussed new provisions concerning Tax Collection at Source (TCS) and implications for companies undergoing amalgamations. Shri Pinakinbhai’s thorough analysis offered clarity on how these changes would affect various stakeholders and emphasised the need for careful navigation of the new tax landscape.

KEY INSIGHTS

  • Increased Tax-Free Income Thresholds: The new regime allows individuals to earn up to ₹12.75 lakhs without incurring tax, significantly benefiting middle-income taxpayers. This change is expected to uplift the overall spending capacity of households, resulting in higher consumption rates and positively influencing economic growth.
  • Charitable Trust Registration Validity: The extension of the registration period for small charitable trusts from five to ten years represents a significant reduction in administrative burdens for these entities, encouraging more charitable initiatives and financial stability among smaller trusts.
  • Tax Deductions for Rent Payments: The amendment reducing the threshold for tax withholding on rent from ₹2.4 lakhs annually to ₹50,000 monthly for companies is a notable change.
  • Implications of Changes in applicability of Rebate: The decision to disallow rebates for special rate incomes under capital gains could reduce tax relief for many taxpayers, necessitating careful consideration of investment strategies to optimise tax liabilities.
  • Restrictions on Loss Migration: The amendment aims to curb the indefinite extension of loss carry-forwards through repeated amalgamations, ensuring a fair and consistent tax treatment. Previously, amalgamated companies could extend the carry-forward period indefinitely, effectively resetting the 8-year limit with each new amalgamation. The amendment aims to prevent this perpetual “evergreening” of losses. Shri Pinakinbhai explained the impact of this amendment through various illustrations.
  • Non-Resident Tax Incentives: The concessional tax rates for foreign entities providing technology and services to specified manufacturing industries reflect India’s strategy to foster foreign investment in critical sectors such as electronics, enhancing competitive advantages and technological development. A new presumptive taxation scheme introduced for non-residents providing services or technology to Indian companies engaged in the manufacture of electronic goods. Shri Pinakinbhai also highlighted possibility of a drafting error in the proposed legislation, mistakenly suggesting that both payment and receipt of 100 rupees result in a taxable consideration of 200 rupees which should be corrected to align with sections 44B and 44BB, of the Income-tax Act.
  • Extension of time limit for passing Penalty Orders: The time limit for completing penalty orders related to assessment has been changed from 6 months from the month of receiving the order from the tribunal to 6 months from the end of the quarter of receiving the order.
  • Transfer Pricing Assessment: Instead of annual assessments, a block of 3 years for determining the Arm’s Length Price (ALP) is introduced. Once the methodology is settled in the first year, it remains binding for the next two years. Taxpayers can opt for this block assessment, either during or after the Transfer Pricing (TP) assessment. He also mentioned that the effectiveness of these new measures shall depend upon the rules to be prescribed in this regard.
  • Updated Return Filing: The provision now allows updated returns to be filed up to the end of the third or fourth year, with additional taxes of 60 per cent and 70 per cent, respectively. This provision aims to promote compliance by offering a structured approach for taxpayers to rectify errors or omissions, albeit with significant additional tax implications for later filings.

In summary, the lecture delivered by Shri Pinakin Desai provided a detailed analysis of the Finance Bill 2025, shedding light on various changes that will impact individual taxpayers, businesses, and charitable organisations alike. The meeting was attended in person by 450 plus participants and encouraging response of over 26,000+ viewers online.

The readers can view the lecture meeting at the below-mentioned link:

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ncVT3ejAtPA

4. Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs of the November 2024 Batch held on Friday, 31st January, 2025 @ IMC.

Milestone 2.0 — Felicitation of newly qualified CAs of the November 2024 batch.

A felicitation event for the newly qualified chartered accountants of the November 2024 batch was held on 31st January, 2025, at the Walchand Hirachand Hall of the Indian Merchant Chambers building at Churchgate by the SMPR Committee. The event was highly successful and close to 400 candidates attended the event. The theme for the event was Milestone 2.0, and the guest and mentor for the event was Past President CA Naushad Panjwani. He guided the participants by taking them through the Japanese concept of Ikigai and drawing parallels to their phase in life where they should aim to find their Ikigai, which would lead them to success and happiness. The participants diligently listened and also provided their perspectives on the matter. Rankers were felicitated first, and they addressed the audience subsequently and shared their experience throughout the journey of becoming a CA. A celebratory cake was cut and then all the successful newly passed CAs were felicitated. The excitement on everyone’s faces was visible, and that is testimony to the success of the event.

5. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting held on Friday, 31st January, 2025 @ Zoom.

Group leaders CA G. Sujatha & CA Archana Jain prepared and presented various case studies on Government Supplies and explained the concepts of Central Government, Government Authority, State Government, etc.

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

1. Concept of Supplies by Central Government, State Government, Local Authority.

2. Supplies liable to tax or part of sovereign function.

3. Taxability of charges paid to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs at the time of registration & subsequently do both enjoy the exemption.

4. Detailed discussion on mining rights and other rights associated with land and fees paid for getting rights.

Around 60 participants from all over India benefitted by taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader & group mentor.

6. ITF Study Circle Meeting held on Thursday, 30th January, 2025 @ Zoom.

Group Leaders – CA Nemin Shah and CA Dipika Agarwal

Guidance for Application of Principal Purpose Test under India’s treaties vide CBDT Circular 1/2025 dated 21st January, 2025 (Circular) — Group Leader CA Nemin Shah.

During the session, CA Nemin Shah discussed the context relating to the Principal Purpose Test (PPT). For this, he extensively discussed the basics of MLI and PPT. Another perspective which was discussed was whether PPT was for general anti-avoidance or a specific anti-avoidance. The Group Leader went on to discuss the key points of the Circular, such as the application of PPT is based on an objective assessment of the relevant facts and circumstances, its applicability in cases where the PPT has been incorporated through bilateral negotiations or through MLI, the scope of grandfathering provisions under the treaties which will remain outside the purview of PPT. He went on to discuss the various issues that could arise, such as its applicability to the India-Mauritius tax treaty, which MLI does not cover.

SC Lowy P.I. (Lux) S.A.R.L, Luxembourg v. ACIT [2024] 170 taxmann.com 475 (Del-Tribunal) – Group Leader CA Dipika Agarwal

CA Dipika explained the facts and the arguments of the assessee and revenue. She discussed the Tribunal’s findings. One of the key focus points of the discussion was that it appeared from the Tribunal’s order that PPT was not invoked at the assessment level, but discussed only at the Appellate level. Further,
there was no discussion in the Tribunal’s order for choosing Luxembourg over the Cayman Islands for making investments. The group discussed the implications of the same. The Group Leader went on to discuss the Tribunal’s findings in relation to Tax Residencey Certificate (TRC) and Limitation of Benefits (LOB). With respect to the PPT clause, the assessee’s incorporation in Luxembourg was not for the principal purpose of obtaining tax treaty benefits, as it had substantial investments, which it continues to hold.

7. 22nd Residential Leadership Retreat — Living in Harmony held on Friday, 24th January, 2025 and Saturday, 25th January, 2025 @ Rambhau Mhalgi Prabodhini Keshav Srushti Bhayander (West)

The 22nd Leadership Retreat was held on the theme of `Living in Harmony’ under the guidance and training of Mr M. K. Ramanujam and Mr R Gurumurthy. 27 participants including 6 couples attended, of which, more than 15 participants were attending the Leadership Retreat for the first time.

The key learnings are summarised as follows:

  • Harmony is unity in diversity which brings joy, peace, happiness, satisfaction and fulfilment.
  • One has to focus from zoom in to zoom out. i.e. look at the wider picture from a broad perspective for a higher purpose over a long span and come out of small and micro views. Zooming out is like a compass of values to find the right meaning in life.

To identify challenges, zoom in and use an emotional filter to zoom out.

  • P R E M A: The acronym represented Positive Emotions, Relationship, Engagement.
  • (Karma Yoga), Meaningful Life and Achievement – selfless service for a noble cause. This could be the guiding light.
  • Listen vis-a-vis Silent. Listen with empathy and compassion. Words “Silent” and “Listen” are complementing. So, engage in listening to be silent within and establish connect outside.
  • R A S (Reticular Access Syndrome) explains that whatever one focuses on, expands in the mind. We see the world as we are. So, one can use this to reinforce the attention to important things in life.
  • Nature operates on contrast. Sattva, Rajas and Tamas are like an interplay of darkness and light. The contrast of bright and dark, light and dark, day and night, white and black, happiness and sadness, joy and gloom. Contrast is natural. Negative things help us to appreciate the value of positives. Pain is a warning signal to pause. Self-acceptance guides us to Harmony. Therefore, one can transform from fear to faith, anger to care and work to relax.
  • Practice Harmony by observing without being judgemental.
  • Understand the basic needs, physical, social, spiritual, personal, interpersonal. The needs are distinct from wants. Needs are expressed through feelings. Listen to the feelings. One can understand that anger moves us away, whereas Love and compassion bring us closer to Harmony. Human pursuit (Purushartha) is for Kama, Artha, Dharma & Moksha. The purpose of human life is Moksha, for which doing Kama or pursuing Artha should be based on Dharma, respecting the highest universal values and principles.
  • Like a peel on the surface of a juicy fruit, the outer layer may have an unpleasant taste, but with faith and conviction, one can have the taste of juice and nectar within.
  • Bring inner transformation by working from Gratitude with Empathy & compassion.

In the penultimate session, discussion was on the film Peaceful Warrior and the inspiring message coming out from the film’s dialogues.

In the concluding session, the participants shared the key points of learning from the camp.

8. Fireside Chat on “Return of Trump – What does it mean for America, India and the World” held on Monday, 27th January, 2025 @ BCAS

Speaker: Shri Natwar Gandhi

Moderator: Shri Rashmin Sanghvi

Widespread fear about various executive orders signed by Mr Trump is misplaced as most of them have been challenged and will have to pass the test of constitutional validity.

America has a strong democracy and deep-rooted institutions. No president can make fundamental changes at his will. Even with a majority in Congress and Senate, constitutional changes are not going to be possible in his four-year term.

One can expect him to use tariffs as a negotiating tool to gain trade favours. However, in the long term, it will hurt the US as well as the country on which high tariff is levied because it will lead to higher costs and consumer resistance. That will not augur well for the USA.

The USA will continue to be a dominant world power as long as the majority of trade uses USD as currency for settlement.

Tall claims about taking over some territories should be discounted as election rhetoric.

The US economy, despite popular perception, is doing well, with average household income (even in the most backward area) still much above par with the rest of the world. With the new administration, one can expect business-friendly policies and a return to manufacturing.

It will be difficult to reduce bureaucracy as all policies require ground-level staff to implement. The USA, with its large size and federal structure, will make such reduction only ornamental.

A large deficit close to USD 35 trillion will not curtail any growth initiatives as the world still uses America as its investment and wealth destination.

Despite threats, it will neither be possible nor practicable to deport almost 10 million illegal immigrants out of the US due to procedural and logistic challenges. By rough estimate, the cost and time of that purge will be 1 trillion USD and will take more than 10 years for the current number.

White supremacy lobby will continue to flourish, and borders will see very strong protection to prevent illegal immigrants from entering the USA. Despite that America is likely to become a Hispanic state with so many migrants from Latin America.

Skilled labour will be there to stay as the big business will not be able to operate without them. Hence, despite all the shouting about work visas, they will stay.

9. Webinar on Recent Important Decisions under Income Tax held on Friday, 24th January, 2025 @ Virtual

The Taxation Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised a Webinar on Recent Important Decisions under Income Tax.

Adv. Devendra Jain delivered an in-depth presentation on reassessment proceedings. He explained the evolving judicial perspective on reassessment, especially in light of recent amendments and rulings by the Supreme Court and the High Courts. His session provided clarity on the crucial points to be considered while representing matters on reassessment cases.

Adv. Ajay Singh began the session by providing a detailed analysis of key judicial decisions that have significant implications for the interpretation and application of Income tax laws. He highlighted the judgments relating to capital gains, gift tax under section 56(2)(x), reduction of share capital, Condonation of delay in filing forms, interest on IT refund, penalty provisions and share transactions, focusing on their impact on taxpayers and professionals alike. He emphasised the importance of understanding these rulings to develop better compliance and advisory strategies.

The session provided participants with a comprehensive understanding of recent developments in Income tax law and practical insights to navigate legal complexities.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlL13OSdCOw

10. 25th Silver Jubilee Course on Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements held from Monday, 2nd December, 2024, to Tuesday, 21st January, 2025 @ Zoom.

The Society successfully conducted its 25th Silver Jubilee Study Course on ‘Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement’ via an online platform spanning from 2nd December, 2024 to 21st January, 2025.

Based on participants’ feedback and consultation with seniors in the Committee, for this 25th Silver Jubilee Course on Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements, BCAS has come up with a unique concept of sharing the recordings of the 24th DTAA Course undertaken in December 2023 as an option to the participants followed by multiple panel discussions. One introductory session on “Overview of International Taxation & DTAAs” and ten panel discussion sessions were planned to take forward the learnings by discussing the intricate and practical issues on the topics of International Taxation, making the course more interactive. Participants were also provided an option to share the queries or issues to the panellists by way of Google form before the respective panel discussion. Eminent tax professionals of the country were the panellists as well as moderators for the series of panel discussions.

All sessions of the course, including last year’s recorded sessions, covered all articles of DTAA, an overview of FEMA / BEPS / MLI / GAAR, Transfer Pricing, Source Rules under the Income Tax Act, 1961, TDS under section 195, Substance v/s Form, and other relevant provisions. The course included complex topics such as Taxation of Specific Structures (e.g., Partnership, Triangular Cases, AOP, etc.) and Selection of Structures.

More than 200 Participants from 15 states spread over 30 cities attended the course which was well-received and appreciated by the participants.

11. Revolutionising CA Practice with Generative AI: Practical Use Cases for Efficiency and Growth held on Thursday, 9th January, 2025 @ Virtual

CA Rahul Bajaj recently led an insightful 2-hour webinar, “Revolutionising CA Practice with Generative AI: Practical Use Cases for Efficiency and Growth,” showcasing how AI can transform Chartered Accountancy practice. The session delved into real-life applications of Generative AI, highlighting its potential to enhance productivity, streamline operations, and improve client servicing. Participants learned how AI can be used to draft professional emails, generate legal documents, automate data entry in Tally, and prepare financial forecasts, all while saving time and reducing errors.

Key takeaways included using AI to create checklists, templates, and peer review documentation like Engagement and Appointment Letters. AI also supports the generation of client training materials, social media content, and even notices, helping firms stay engaged with clients while improving efficiency. By automating repetitive tasks such as bank statement analysis, CAs can focus more on strategic activities, boosting overall productivity.

The session concluded with CA Rahul Bajaj emphasising the importance of integrating AI into CA practices for long-term growth. With tools that enhance accuracy and decision-making, AI is positioning itself as a game-changer, enabling Chartered Accountants to provide higher-value services and streamline their operations for greater success in an increasingly digital world.

The excellent response that the webinar got in terms of enrolment from across various cities of India and from persons of various age groups, as well as the feedback received at the end of the webinar, is testimony to the growing importance and popularity of AI in the CA fraternity.

12. BCAS Turf Cricket Tournament 2025 held on Sunday, 5th January, 2025 @ Andheri Sports Complex, Azad Nagar, Andheri West

The BCAS Turf Cricket Tournament 2025 held on 5th January 2025 at Andheri Sports Complex, was a resounding success, hosting 12 men’s and 2 women’s teams in a thrilling display of sportsmanship and camaraderie.

The tournament was exclusively for CA Members, Students, and BCAS Staff was well received with overwhelming participation.

The format in Men’s category was of four groups of three teams each, which formed the league stages followed by knockout rounds of Quarter-finals (8 teams), Semi-finals (4 teams) and the Finals. The 12 Men’s teams that competed in the Tournament were Bansi Jain Warriors, Bathiya Bravehearts, BYA Titans, CNK Super Strikers, G&S Gladiators, Kirtane & Pandit Maestros, KNAV Smashers, MAS Mavericks, MCS Super Kings, MGB Yoddhas, NPV Challengers and TeaMPC whereas the 2 Women’s teams were NPV Thunderbirds and BCAS Queens.

The tournament was filled with exciting matches, impressive individual performances, fun-filled live commentary and enthusiastic support from the spectators. The 8 teams that qualified for the Men’s quarterfinals were MAS Mavericks, Kirtane & Pandit Maestros, CNK Super Strikers, MGB Yoddhas, G&S Gladiators, NPV Challengers, KNAV Smashers and Bathiya Bravehearts. The Semi Finals were then played between the 4 teams viz. Kirtane & Pandit Maestros vs. NPV Challengers and CNK Super Strikers vs Bathiya Bravehearts.

The day culminated in a nail-biting Men’s final between Bathiya Bravehearts vs Kirtane & Pandit Maestros, with the former emerging victorious whereas BCAS Queens emerged as winners in the Women’s category.

The tournament left a lasting impression on all participants and thus setting the stage for future editions of this exciting event.

13. BCAS Nxt Learning and Development Bootcamp on Idea to IPO: A Beginner’s Guide held on Saturday, 4th January, 2025 in hybrid mode

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organised a BCAS NXT Learning & Development Bootcamp on “Idea to IPO: A Beginner’s Guide” on Saturday, 4th January, 2025. The session was led by Mr Aditya Rathod, a CA Final student, who delivered a comprehensive presentation on the fundamentals and key regulations governing IPO in India. His presentation covered a wide range of topics, including essential definitions, various IPO methods, and an overview of the IPO process and its approach. He also shared practical experiences to help beginner article students navigate the complexities of the IPO Listing Process.

CA Rimple Dedhia, the mentor for the session, provided valuable insights and guidance throughout, offering expert interventions as needed. The boot camp was held in person at the Mehta Chokshi & Shah LLP office and streamed online, with active participation from students across India.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WYuPDeOJus&t

14. Series of Sessions on Standards on Auditing and Key Learnings from NFRA Orders held on Friday, 13th December, 2024 to Friday, 3rd January, 2025 @ Zoom

BCAS has always been a pioneer in equipping its members, in particular and other stakeholders at large with the knowledge in the arena of Accounting Standards, Ind AS and Standards on Auditing. The challenge of the auditor is to address the risks posed while providing assurance services within the regulatory framework of ICAI and NFRA. Compliance with Auditing Standards is of utmost importance while carrying out audits.

Considering these challenges that the auditor has to address while performing duties, the Accounting & Auditing Committee organised a well-designed series of virtual sessions covering Auditing standards and Key Learnings from NFRA orders, which should be kept in focus while executing audit assignments along with practical guidance. The Sessions were held on Fridays for 2 hours each, totalling 8 hours.

The main objective of designing this series of sessions was to delve deeply into the subjects affecting the audit fraternity and to provide a platform for the Members in Practice to come together and get the opportunity to have deep insights into the practical challenges which crop up while implementing the complicated standards.

Course Segments: 4 sessions of 2 hours each

Session Topic Speaker
Learnings from recent NFRA Orders Ms Vidhi Sood Secretary, NFRA
Audit Documentation (SA 230) CA Amit Majmudar
SA 600 – Using the work of another auditor (along with the NFRA Circular dated October 03, 2024, regarding responsibilities of the Principal Auditor and Other Auditors in Group Audits CA Pankaj Tiwari
Planning risk assessment and related matters (SA 300, 315, 320 & 330) CA Murtuza Vajihi

The sessions were designed to give practical and case study-based insights to the participants on various topics.

The course was inaugurated with the opening remarks from the Chairman of the Accounting and Auditing Committee CA Abhay Mehta and the President of BCAS, CA Anand Bathiya, both underline the importance of knowledge sharing and the role of the BCAS in conducting such programs. To make the course effective, faculties with specialised knowledge and relevant experience were engaged to give participants practical insights and wholesome experiences.

The course started with the session of Ms Vidhi Sood Secretary, NFRA, where she updated the participants on various NFRA orders, practical examples and issues and learnings from the same.

The session of Audit Documentation SA 230 by CA Amit Majmudar broadly covered the areas pertaining to the Assembly of Audit Files, Key Audit Workpapers and guidance on ICAI Audit Documentation

The Session on SA 600 — Using the work of another auditor by CA Pankaj Tiwari mainly covered existing SA 600 & procedures adopted by the Auditor, various lapses highlighted by NFRA in the audit of CFS, Key elements of Circular issued by NFRA & potential challenges in implementation of the Circular.

The session on Planning Risk Assessment and Related Matters by CA Murtuza Vajihi broadly covered the scope, objective, and documentation of the standard along with practical examples of the standards and also reference to NFRA and QRB learnings on these standards.

The above sessions generated a lot of interactions between the participants and the respective faculties. The course commenced on 13th December, 2024, and ended on 3rd January, 2025. 111 participants attended the Course, and was well received with the overall feedback from the participants was very encouraging.

REPRESENTATIONS AND SOCIAL MEDIA

1. NFRA Representation: Addressing Duplication in Fraud Reporting for Statutory Auditors

BCAS has submitted a representation to the National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA) regarding the fraud reporting requirements for statutory auditors of regulated entities. The representation highlights the need to eliminate the duplication of reporting to various authorities, aiming to streamline the process and simplify the regulatory framework for entities such as banks, insurance companies, and NBFCs. By reducing redundant reporting, the proposal seeks to create a more efficient and effective regulatory environment.

Readers can read the entire representation by link: https://bit.ly/NFRA-Representation

2. Union Budget 2025: 8th Consecutive Budget by FM Nirmala Sitharaman — BCAS’s Pre-Budget Memorandum Available Online.

As Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman presents her 8th consecutive Union Budget, BCAS continues its proactive role in representing the views of its members and the wider community. We are pleased to announce that BCAS has submitted the Pre-Budget Memorandum for the Finance Act 2025-26 to the Union Minister of Finance and the Ministry of Finance, Government of India.

Readers can read the entire representation by link: https://bit.ly/Pre-Budget-Memorandum-2025-26

3. BCAS Reimagine Conference: Exclusive Videos Now on YouTube, with Thousands of Views!

BCAS hosted the ReImagine Conference, a three-day event in January 2024 that explored progressive topics crucial to the professional landscape. With an overwhelming response, the discussions held the potential to shape the future trajectory of our profession.

In line with BCAS’s mission of knowledge dissemination for professional development, the event videos are now available on YouTube, completely free of charge. Featuring a wide range of topics presented by industry experts and professional stalwarts, these videos offer valuable insights for professionals at all levels.

Playlist Titles:

1. Reimagine India – Keynote Address by Padma Bhushan Shri Kumar Mangalam Birla

2. Digital Infrastructure – A Game Changer

3. Reimagine the new age professional firms

4. CFO Round Table – Technology, Innovation and Sustainability

5. Use of AI / Tech-Data as Evidence in Tax Cases – Direct Tax and Indirect Tax

6. Reimagine India’s Capital Market Landscape

7. Changing Corporate Landscape – Professional opportunities

8. The Victorious – A Model for Leadership

9. New Age Wars – Future of the World – Role of Professional

10. One World – One tax – VasudhaivaKutumbakam

11. Ride the Capital Market – Take the Bull by its Horns

12. The Future of Audit Profession

13. One Giant Leap – Start-ups – Importance of Professionals in Start up Journey

14. Interchanging Roles – Practice to CFO, CFO to Practice, CA to Nation Building

15. Reimagine – Closing Ceremony & Vote of Thanks

YouTube link: https://bit.ly/Reimagine-Conference

4. BCAS YouTube Channel Hits 1 Million Views

The BCAS YouTube channel has reached a significant milestone, surpassing 1 million views. Over the years, it has evolved into a valuable resource, offering a wealth of professional content and knowledge. With an expanding collection of open-for-all sessions, the channel continues to serve as a hub for valuable learning. Members who have not yet subscribed are encouraged to do so and stay updated with the latest content.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3cxrmOi8hRA31LxBEXGpUQ

5. Interactive meeting of managing Committee Members with Dr Harish Mehta and Mr Rajiv Vaishnav

Dr Harish Mehta and Mr Rajiv Vaishnav were invited to interact and share their experience of building and successfully running the NPO with the BCAS Managing Committee members on 8th January, 2025.

Dr Harish Mehta is a founder member and former Chairman of NASSCOM and Rajiv Vaishnav is former President of NASSCOM. They shared experience in building brands, nurturing teams, and growing organizations. During the interaction, Dr. Harish Mehta and Mr. Rajiv Vaishnav appreciated the work done by BCAS and emphasised the importance of valuing volunteers, building trust, and promoting unity, especially during challenging times. They also advised that before making representations to government authorities, it’s essential to gather collective opinions from members.

Dr Mehta autographed copies of his book, “Maverick Effect: The Inside Story of India’s IT Revolution”, for the committee members.

BCAS IN NEWS

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

Society News

1. Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) Conclave 2025 was held on 17th and 18th January, 2025 at Hotel Ginger Mumbai Airport.

This event was organized by the Finance, Corporate, and Allied Laws Committee jointly with the National Institute for Securities Market (NISM) on Friday and Saturday, 17th and 18th January, 2025, at the Hotel Ginger Mumbai Airport. Kotak Alternate Assets Manager Limited supported the event as Knowledge Partners.

The details of the program were as follows:

Keynote Address on India’s Regulatory Framework and the Role of AIFs in Capital Markets-Shri Manoj Kumar, Executive Director, SEBI, delivered the keynote address, highlighting the critical role of AIFs in driving innovation and economic growth. He discussed recent regulatory developments, SEBI’s focus on transparency and investor protection, and the need for adopting best practices in the evolving AIF landscape.

Day 1: Foundation & Regulatory Landscape

Session 1: Introduction to AIFs- CA DhavalVakharia S V N D & Associates, Chartered Accountants: provided an overview of AIFs, explaining their structure, types, and regulatory framework. He highlighted the key differences between AIFs and traditional investment vehicles, emphasizing their appeal to high-net-worth individuals and institutions.

Session 2: Legal and Regulatory Framework of AIFs- Adv. Leelavathi Naidu IC Universal Legal: outlined the legal and regulatory framework governing AIFs, focusing on SEBI’s regulations. She addressed challenges in compliance and the importance of investor protection within this sector.

Session 3: Structuring an AIF-CA Subramaniam Krishnan Ernst & Young LLP: discussed the key considerations in structuring AIFs, including entity types, tax optimization, and governance. He emphasized how proper structuring ensures compliance and attracts investors.

Session 4: Investment Strategies for AIFs – Equity, Debt, and Hybrid Models – CA ShitalGharge Senior Vice President, Kotal Alternate Asset Manager Limited: CA ShitalGharge explored various investment strategies for AIFs, including equity, debt, and hybrid models. She discussed how each strategy aligns with investor objectives and market conditions, offering diverse risk-return profiles.

Session 5: Role of Trustees in AIFs – Ensuring Governance and Compliance- CA Naushad Panjwani Chairman, Mandarus Partners and Board Member – ITI Trusteeship: discussed the vital role of trustees in ensuring governance and regulatory compliance within AIFs. He emphasized the importance of trustee oversight to protect investor interests and ensure transparency.

Panel Discussion 1: Key Challenges for Aspiring AIF Promoters Panelist 1: Mr. Abhishek PrasadManaging Partner, Cornerstone Venture Partners, Panelist 2: Mr Gopal Modi Limited Partner in various funds, Panelist 3: Ms Aparna Thyagarajan Chief General Manager, SEBI Panelist 4 MrSachinTagra Managing Partner, JSW Ventures & Moderator Prof. K S Ranjani Asst. Professor, Indian Institute of Management. Mumbai: This panel addressed challenges faced by AIF promoters, including fundraising, regulatory hurdles, and market competition. Panellists shared practical strategies to overcome these obstacles and succeed in the AIF sector.

Session 6: Technology and Innovation in AIFs- Mr. Neeraj Sharma, Executive Vice President – Technology, 360 One Asset Management Limited, discussed the role of technology in AIF operations, focusing on AI, blockchain, and digital platforms. He highlighted how technology improves efficiency, transparency, and investor engagement in AIFs.

Day 2: Advanced Techniques & operational Aspects

Session 7: GIFT City Showcase: India’s Emerging Global Financial Hub for AIFs – Mr. Sandip Shah Head – IFSC Department, GIFT City: presented GIFT City as a global financial hub, outlining its advantages for AIFs, including tax incentives, infrastructure, and favourable regulations. He discussed how GIFT City can help India attract international AIF investments.

Session 8: Comparative Global Destinations for AIFs: Opportunities and Strategies- Adv. Siddharth Shah Khaitan& Co: Adv. Siddharth Shah compared global AIF destinations, discussing regulatory advantages and challenges in jurisdictions like Singapore, Luxembourg, and the Cayman Islands. He offered strategies for selecting the best jurisdiction for AIFs.

Session 9: Fundraising, Investor Relations, Risk Management, and Compliance in AIF – CA Shreyas Trivedi Partner & CFO, Cornerstone Venture Partners: focused on fundraising, managing investor relations, and ensuring compliance in AIFs. He shared strategies to build investor trust, address risks, and navigate regulatory complexities effectively.

Session 10: Valuation, Reporting, and Transparency – Mr. Ravishu Shah, Managing Director at RBSA Advisors, emphasized the importance of accurate valuation, transparent reporting, and maintaining high standards of financial integrity in AIFs. He discussed methodologies and best practices for ensuring investor confidence.

Panel Discussion 2: Success Journeys of AIF Funded Companies – Panelist 1: MrUmair Mohammed, Chief Executive Officer, Nitro Commerce, Panelist 2: Mr Sandeep Ghule Co-Founder and Chief Product Officer, Credilio Financial Technologies Private Limited & Panelist 3: Mr. Manish Chhabra Chairman of Hygienic Research Institute Private Limited, Moderator: Mr. PranayVakil Chairman of Praron Consultancy (India) Pvt. Ltd.:Panellists shared the success stories of companies funded by AIFs, highlighting the role of AIF capital in their growth. They discussed key factors contributing to success, such as market positioning, innovation, and strategic partnerships.

The 2-day AIF Conclave brought together industry leaders, professionals, service providers, regulators and experts to discuss the latest trends and challenges in the Alternative Investment Funds sector. With insightful sessions, enriching discussions, and valuable networking opportunities, participants explored innovative strategies and solutions to navigate the evolving landscape. The conclave concluded on a high note, reinforcing the importance of collaboration and knowledge-sharing in shaping the future of AIFs. Participants attended the program. Out of the total 146 participants, 88 were BCAS members, and the remaining 58 were non-members. Further, 47 of the participants who attended this seminar were from outside of Mumbai.

On the sidelines of the AIF conclave, a Closed-Door Roundtable Discussion was held on the Challenges and Gaps in the AIF Ecosystem. The discussion was attended by Shri Rajesh Gujjar, Chief General Manager at SEBI, officials from BCAS and NISM, top leadership from 15 AIFs, and legal experts. The session was moderated by Adv. Siddharth Shah. The insights and suggestions provided by the panellists were documented and will be presented to the regulators in the form of a White Paper.

2. Lecture Meeting on Navigating the Insolvency & Restructuring Landscape

The Lecture meeting on “Navigating the Insolvency & Restructuring Landscape” was held virtually on Wednesday 15th January, 2025. More than 150 participants attended the webinar.

The Keynote address was delivered by Mr. M.S. Sahoo, Former Chairperson – IBBI.

The key takeaways of the session are:

  •  The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) aims to resolve stress by reviving viable companies and facilitating the exit of unviable ones. The IBC uses both resolution plans and liquidation as means to achieve stress resolution.
  •  The IBC overrides pre-insolvency rights and prioritizes stakeholder claims via a hierarchical order. It is designed to prevent a value-reducing run on company assets.
  •  The code rebalances the rights of stakeholders, allowing creditors to decide the fate of debt-laden companies, as they are considered to possess the necessary commercial wisdom.
  •  IBC is not a recovery mechanism. The code’s performance should be assessed based on its effectiveness in resolving stress, not just the recovery rate. It is realizing 65% of the value of the assets, which is the organizational capital.
  •  The IBC promotes entrepreneurship by providing a framework for stress resolution, but it currently only applies to corporate entities, leaving proprietorships, partnerships, and individuals without access.

Key takeaways from – Role of Chartered Accountants under IBC by CA Dhinal Shah

  •  Chartered Accountants (CAs) can play a critical role as resolution professionals (RPs), acting as a link between the corporate debtor, creditors, and potential buyers. This role requires them to act as a de facto CEO.
  •  The role of an RP is demanding and requires a broad range of skills, including soft skills, business acumen, and a solution-oriented approach. RPs need to maintain the company as a going concern.
  •  CAs can contribute in various supportive roles, such as verification of claims, preparing and updating accounts, and ensuring regulatory compliance.
  •  CAs can also play a crucial role in investment banking activities, assisting with the preparation of information memorandums and identifying potential buyers.
  •  It is critical to maintain integrity, ethics, and transparency while performing any role under the IBC and avoid any conflict of interest.

The field of insolvency and restructuring continues to evolve with significant developments, challenges, and opportunities for professionals. The webinar helped the participants to gain insights from the experts and enhance their understanding of this critical domain.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open to all to attend and participate. The readers can view the lecture meeting at the below-mentioned link/code:

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJ2fWjg6UBI

QR Code:

3. Succession & Estate Planning – Advanced Tax and Legal Aspects held on Saturday, 4th January, 2025 @ IMC, Churchgate.

This event was organized by the Finance, Corporate, and Allied Laws Committee on Saturday, 04th January, 2025 at the IMC Hall, Churchgate.

The details of the program were as follows:

Key Strategies for Wealth Transfer – CA Ketan Dalal: Informative session on wealth transfer that guided the participants through the subtle intricacies of gifting, bequests, and the delicate dance of tax efficiency.

Legal Framework of Wills & Probate:Drafting and Contesting Wills – Adv. Bijal Ajinkya: The enlightening lecture demystified the art of wills and probate. It helped equip the participants with the tools to draft wills that stand the test of time and mitigate disputes before they arise.

Trusts in Estate Planning: Structuring, Taxation and Legal Framework – CA Suresh Surana: Descriptive discussion which unravelled the magic of trusts—structures that combine the elegance of legal precision with the power of asset protection. This session redefined the way you approach succession planning.

Cross-Border Estate Planning: Navigating International Tax and Legal Complexities – Adv. Nishith Desai: A contemporary talk by this global thought leader, his expertise helped bridge the chasm between jurisdictions; this session highlighted the myriad of different laws affecting different countries and their complex laws.

Panel Discussion: Key Challenges and Future Trends – Panellist: CA DrAnup Shah & CA ParthivKamdar and Moderator: CA SnehBhuta: An interactive exchange by the power-packed panel, artfully moderated with precise questions that delved into the future of succession planning, giving us a lens into the emerging challenges and trends that will shape the profession in the years to come.

The Seminar brought forward a holistic perspective on Succession and estate planning laws, it included a series of interactive sessions which simplified this complex topic.
The program had 190 physical attendees. Out of the total 190 participants, 121 were BCAS members, and the remaining 69 were non-members. Further, 48 of the participants who attended this seminar were from out of Mumbai.

4. India’s First Edition of CA-Thon 2024 – Run For A Cause on 22nd December 2024 in South Mumbai – by Seminar, Membership & Public Relations (SMPR) Committee.

India’s First Edition of CA-Thon 2024 – Run for Cause was organized on Sunday, 22nd December 2024, in South Mumbai (the area around Azad Maidan) under the aegis of the Seminar, Membership &Public Relations (SMPR) Committee.

The event attracted 1,600+ participants – Chartered Accountants and non-Chartered Accountants alike – between the age group of 7 to 70 years – drawn from all walks of life, from different corners of the country.

The event helped increase the visibility of Brand BCAS at a pan-India level, deepen relationships within the community at large, promote health and fitness among participants drawn from all walks of life and contribute to a righteous cause(part of the proceeds went donating sewing machines to women from marginalized communities, to help supplement their livelihood and become financially independent). BCAS Foundation also joined hands in supporting these women through this donation.

The CA-Thon proved to be a fitting finale to an eventful year – one which had started with the grand three-day mega event in January 2024.

5. Workshop on Mastering the Art of Negotiation held on Saturday, 21st December, 2024 @ BCAS.

The Speaker for the Workshop Mr. Jagdeep Kapoor, is a leading Brand Strategic Marketing Consultant with an impressive list of clients- national and foreign. He defines negotiation as the means by which people deal with their differences. In the Workshop, he discussed various ways that would help professionals like Chartered Accountants to be good negotiators.

The starting point to negotiate effectively is overcoming the fear of losing clients, for which one should choose expertise, be sure of oneself, and be decisive, disciplined and proactive.

Further, it is important to assess the core style of negotiation that one has, like – is one naturally inclined to fight or take flight or filled with fright in negotiation scenarios. Whatever the style, one has to keep in mind that the basic objective of negotiation is to continue the business and professional relationship seamlessly.

There are barriers to negotiation which should be broken like lack of trust, poor communication, over-confidence, irrational expectations and ego-driven escalations of the offer.

Mr. Kapoor shared a 9E Strategy Module, which covers nine qualities to be possessed for negotiating effectively which are- Exclusive, Excellent, Effective, Engaging, Efficient, Economical, Expertise, Extraordinary and Evolving. Each of these was explained in detail with examples from his own experiences.

Lastly, the Speaker also shared ways of handling objections from the clients by normalizing them and giving appropriate responses.

The program had 42 physical attendees.

6. ITF Study Circle Meeting held on Thursday, 12th December, 2024 @ Zoom.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organized a meeting (online mode) on 12th December, 2024 to discuss the issues faced by Fiscally Transparent Entities in claiming the benefit of tax treaties.

The Group Leader commenced the discussion with the meaning and type of Fiscally Transparent Entities in various jurisdictions and the core issue involved in claiming tax treaty benefits.

The Group further discussed the recent ruling of the Delhi Tribunal in the case of General Motors and other significant rulings with respect to the availability of the tax treaty benefits to Fiscally Transparent entities and India’s position on the above issue was also discussed.

The discussion ended with members expressing their views on various controversies arising out of the core issue of the availability of tax treaty benefits to Fiscally Transparent Entities.

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Webinar on Transforming Tax Practice with AI: A Practical Approach for Professionals on Automating Compliance, Litigations and Drafting held on Thursday, 19th December, 2024 @ Virtual

The Technology Initiatives Committee of BCAS conducted this webinar and it was aimed at enlightening the participants on how to improve a CA Firm’s tax practice management techniques through the use of technology. It was a highly informative session that attracted participants from more than 65 different cities. Led by the speaker CA Vijay Srinivas Kothapalli, the webinar focused on how artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionising the tax profession and practice. The session highlighted the growing role of AI in automating various aspects of tax compliance, litigation processes, and document drafting, offering practical strategies for professionals to leverage these advancements. As tax regulations become increasingly complex, the integration of AI into routine tasks is emerging as a game changer for efficiency and accuracy.

A significant portion of the webinar covered the automation of Income Tax (IT) and Goods and Services Tax (GST) notices using AI. This technology allows tax professionals to quickly generate responses, manage compliance deadlines, and process notices with greater precision. Additionally, AI-powered tools for Income Tax Return pre-scrutiny were discussed, which can help identify potential issues before submission, reducing errors and enhancing the quality of tax filings. The session also delved into documentation demonstrating how AI streamlines the preparation and filing process while ensuring adherence to legal requirements. Managing compliance calendars with AI tools was another key area covered, allowing professionals to stay on top of critical dates and avoid penalties.

Overall, the webinar provided tax professionals with practical insights on how to harness AI to streamline their work, reduce manual errors, and stay competitive in an increasingly digital landscape and received active participation from more than 330 participants.

2. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Navigating GST Reforms: Updates and Opportunities under the Amnesty Scheme on Thursday, 5th December, 2024 at C/o Bathiya& Associates LLP, Andheri

The meeting brought together tax professionals and GST enthusiasts to deliberate on the recent GST reforms, including key changes introduced as part of the Amnesty Scheme and was led by Group Leader CA Akshay Sharma and chaired by CA Janak Vaghani.

The speaker provided detailed insights into recent GST Council recommendations, including procedural simplifications, rate revisions, and compliance relief measures under the Amnesty Scheme. The session Chairman provided valuable guidance and support to the session leader, offering relevant examples to enhance the discussion on the topic.

KEY AREAS COVERED INCLUDED:

  1.  Analysis of GST Reforms — A comprehensive overview of the latest changes and their practical implications for businesses.
  2.  Opportunities under the Amnesty Scheme — Strategies to leverage this scheme for pending returns, late fee waivers, and compliance restoration.
  3.  Challenges in Implementation — A discussion on resolving ambiguities and preparing for future reforms.

The meeting was well received and participants actively engaged in the Q&A session, seeking clarity on various provisions and discussing sector-specific challenges.

3. Lecture Meeting on Deciphering The Current State of Indian Capital Markets held on Wednesday, 4th December, 2024@ Virtual.

The Bombay Chartered Accountant Society (BCS) organised a lecture meeting on 4th December, 2024, marking the conclusion of its 75th anniversary celebrations. The session, titled “Deciphering the Current State of Indian Capital Markets,” was presented by Mr. Nilesh Shah, Group President and Managing Director of Kotak Mahindra Asset Management Company.

During the insightful discussion, Mr. Shah delved into significant trends shaping global and Indian capital markets. He highlighted challenges such as rising debt levels in major economies, uneven economic growth within India, and the critical role of domestic investors in sustaining market resilience amidst Foreign Portfolio Investor (FPI) movements.

KEY TAKEAWAYS INCLUDED:

  •  Global Dynamics: The economic leverage seen in global powerhouses like the US and China, underscoring their implications for interest rates and global trade.
  •  Indian Economy: Despite its robust growth trajectory, India faces challenges of uneven development and employment generation. Mr. Shah pointed out structural reforms and sectoral opportunities necessary for sustaining long-term growth.
  • Market Analysis: He offered an optimistic view on corporate earnings and advised moderation in return expectations for equity markets due to high valuations. He also shared insights into sectoral opportunities, emphasising private banking and telecom, while cautioning about sectors like capital goods and infrastructure.

The session concluded with a lively Q&A, where participants engaged on topics like asset allocation, sectoral outlooks, and strategies for navigating the current investment landscape. Mr. Shah’s data-driven insights, combined with his ability to weave economic trends with relatable analogies, made the session highly impactful.
The meeting was well appreciated by 200 plus participants.

YouTube Link:

QR Code:

4. The Non-Profit Organization (NPO) Conclave 2.0, 2024 held on Friday, 29th November, 2024 at the Mayor’s Hall, All India Institute of Local Self Government, Andheri West

This event was organised by Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Committee along with Internal Audit Committee of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society.

The details of the program are as follows:

  •  The sessions focused on balancing regulatory compliance with continued growth and uninterrupted charitable work. Key takeaways included actionable steps to stay compliant with evolving regulations, safeguard resources, and ensure financial transparency in the NPO sector.

The program was well received and attended by 70+ participants

5. 7th Long Duration Course on Goods and Services Tax held on 16th August, 2024 to 29th November, 2024 @ Virtual

The 7th Long Duration Course on GST- 2024 was conducted by BCAS Virtually (Online mode) and was spread across 10 live sessions designed on a panel discussion format covering theoretical as well as practical aspects of GST.

The course covered 27 pre-recorded training videos of 90-120 minutes duration each conducted by the proficient faculty having immense expertise in the field of indirect taxation. The pre-recorded videos were made available in advance to the participants. Listening to pre-recorded videos helped the participants to have an interactive session by highlighting various issues in GST before the faculties. The live session covered the queries posted by the participants as well as drafted by the moderators. The presence of multiple faculties at the same time enabled sharing of thoughts and detailed deliberations. The course covered various concepts such as supply, valuation, ITC, place of supply, returns, registration, refunds and litigations etc.

The course received a very good response having 200 + participants enrolled from across the nation. The participants appreciated the program structure, course content and its’ execution.

6. Indirect Tax Law Study Circle — Blocked Credits under GST — clause (c) & (d) of section 17 (5) of CGST Act, 2017 held on Monday, 25th November, 2024 @ Virtual

Group leader, CA Yash Shah prepared case studies covering various contentious issues around clauses (c) & (d) of Section 17(5) of the CGST Act, 2017, especially in light of the recent decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Safari Retreats Private Limited. The discussion was ably supported by insights from mentor-
CA Naresh Sheth

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  1.  Availability of ITC on goods & services used for construction of hotels, cold storage facilities, theatres (single screen / multi-screen), auditorium, recreation parks, etc.
  2.  Availability of ITC on transfer fee paid to industrial corporations and lease owner in case of assignment of lease when the lease hold land is used for construction of a Mall / manufacturing facility for own use.
  3.  Availability of ITC on goods and services used for construction of a R&D department.
  4.  Interplay between section clause (c) & (d) of section 17 (5) and availability of ITC to the extent used for construction of premises to be leased out.
  5.  Is vivisecting a contract an option to seek exclusion from the scope of clauses (c) & (d)?

Around 75 participants from all over India benefitted and took an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader & group mentor.

7. Full Day Workshop on Recent Developments in GST held on Saturday, 23rd November, 2024 @ BCAS.

The workshop was organized to cover various judicial & legislative developments in the field of GST.

CA Sunil Gabhawalla covered the legislative amendments and took the participants through the proposed amnesty u/s 128A, amendments relating to section 16 (5) of the CGST Act, 2017 and RCM related amendments from the perspective of time of supply.

CA DivyeshLapsiwalla covered the procedural amendments, such as the introduction of Invoice Management System, TDS on Metal Scrap, etc.

As the due date for filing of annual returns for FY 2023-24 is approaching, CA Chirag Mehta took the participants through the various issues revolving around the filing of annual returns and specific care to be taken in the same.

A panel comprising of CA S S Gupta & CA A R Krishnan moderated by CA Mandar Telang covered recent decisions (Safari Retreats, Mineral Area Development Authority, Creative Infocity, L&T IHI Construction, etc.) under the GST Law.

The participants appreciated the content of the workshop. The workshop was conducted in a hybrid mode with 50 participants attending physically and around 100+ participants attending virtually across India.

8. Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Study Circle meeting on “All About Fast track merger” held on 18th November, 2024@ Virtual.

Group Leader CA Ankit Davda gave an overall perspective of Fast Track Merger (including demerger).

He covered the applicable provisions under the Companies Act 2013 with the help of case studies. The learned speaker highlighted key elements of a Scheme of Arrangements, key provisions and procedures, broad timelines and critical points for consideration in respect of fast track merger. He touched upon other aspect which have an effect on such mergers in areas of Income tax, GST, Stamp duty, Transfer premium, Other charges and Change of control.

He satisfactorily responded to all the queries of the participants. In limited time, he dealt with all the aspects of Fast Track Merger in a lucid manner. The program was attended by 85+ participants.

YouTube Link:

QR code:

9. International Economics Study Group – Impact Analysis of Trump’s victory on Geo-economics & Geopolitics held on Monday, 18th November, 2024 @ BCAS

The Participants deliberated following points:

A. Geopolitics:

  •  Ukraine-Russia Conflict: Trump’s victory could result in a shift in the U.S. stance towards Ukraine.
  • Middle East Tensions: Trump may take a more aggressive approach against Iran and its proxies (Hamas, Hezbollah & Houthi).
  • Heightened tensions with China are expected.
  • Russia and NATO Expansion: Trump’s policies could challenge NATO’s expansion in Eastern Europe.
  • India and Neighbouring Challenges: India’s relationship with the U.S. could be impacted favorably over troubled neighbours like China, Pakistan and Bangladesh.

B. Geo-economics:

  • Trade War with China: The likelihood of a second trade war under Trump could result in higher tariffs on Chinese goods, worsening trade relations, and impacting global supply chains.
  • Immigration Restrictions: With a focus on reducing illegal immigration, there may be tighter border controls, potentially affecting labour markets and demographic dynamics in the U.S.
  • Tax Cuts and Healthcare: Trump’s tax policies may reduce taxes, but with concerns about rising deficits and the challenge of controlling government spending.
  • Economic Impact on India: Economic fallout from tariffs, restrictions on immigration, and shifts in U.S. economic policies could create uncertainties for India’s export-driven economy.

All the Participants, Co-Convener CA Harshad Shah put up their points for discussions.

BCAS in News – BCAS as one of the stakeholders have been quoted in various news for its views, the below is link of the news articles where the Society was quoted. Also, our various other events and alliances are released in press too. Our readers can view these articles through this QR code. and You can then just provide list of articles.

Link: https://bcasonline.org/bcas-in-news/

QR Code:

Learning Events at BCAS

1. AI and Technology ki Pathshala: A Technology Orientation Program for Article Students, held on Thursday, 7th November, 2024 and Friday, 8th November, 2024 @ virtually.

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organised this interesting program to provide article students with a robust foundation in artificial intelligence (AI) and emerging technologies, empowering them to stay ahead in the dynamic professional landscape. The program commenced with an interactive session led by CA Nirav Bhanushali, who demonstrated the effective use of productivity applications within MS Office 365 and Google Workspace. His live demonstration showcased practical tips and tricks to enhance efficiency in managing tasks, documents, and collaboration. CA Narasimhan Elangovan delved into the exciting possibilities of leveraging AI tools like ChatGPT. He illustrated how these tools can be employed to simplify articleship tasks, enhance learning, and prepare more effectively for exams.

On the second day, CA Abhay Gadiya introduced participants to cutting-edge tools such as Power Query and Power BI. His session emphasised how these technologies can be harnessed to process and analyse large datasets, generate meaningful insights, and present data visually, enabling informed decision-making. CA Nikunj Shah, who offered a deep dive into Microsoft Excel, equipping participants with advanced techniques to streamline and enhance their workflow. The program drew enthusiastic participation from over 55 article students, who appreciated the interactive and hands-on approach of these sessions.

2. FEMA Study Circle Meeting on Amendments in NDI Rules and Compounding under FEMA, held on Friday, 25th October, 2024 @ Virtual

During the session, Group Leader — CA Deepender Kumar extensively discussed amendments on the subject. He emphasised the expanded scope of non-debt instruments under FEMA, clarifying that NDI includes investments not classified as debt, such as equity, capital contributions, and other equity-characteristic securities. The amendments outlined specific instruments that qualify as equity, such as shares, convertible securities, and share warrants, which help investors precisely understand which instruments are eligible for foreign investment. He highlighted that these clarifications provide clear guidelines for investors and regulators alike, reducing ambiguity in foreign investment transactions.

The focus of the meeting was on sectoral changes and investment caps. Certain sensitive sectors like insurance, defence, and media now have revised foreign investment limits, aligning with India’s strategic economic objectives. These sector-specific adjustments include transitions from the automatic to the approval route, which mandates prior government or RBI approval for foreign investment in certain areas. This change underscores the need for entities to be vigilant in understanding sectoral thresholds and compliance requirements. He noted that businesses must carefully interpret these sector-specific regulations to ensure they remain compliant, especially in sectors where government intervention has increased. The meeting was well received by 40+ participants attending the discussion.

3. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on ‘Framework of Adjudication, recent ROC/RD orders and important amendments under the Companies Act, 2013, held on Thursday, 24th October, 2024 held at C/o Bathiya & Associates LLP, Andheri (E).

Group Leader CS Raj Kapadia explored the framework of adjudication, recent orders by the Registrar of Companies (ROC) and Regional Directors (RD), and key amendments under the Companies Act, 2013. He covered Sections 15 and 16 of the MSMED Act, 2006, highlighting critical compliance requirements for payments to MSME suppliers and the importance of Form MSME 1.
The key discussions were:

  • Payments to MSME suppliers must be made within the agreed due date, not exceeding 45 days.
  • Failure to pay on time incurs compound interest at three times the bank rate, calculated monthly.
  • Interest accrual starts the day after the due date.
  • Recent amendments focus on decriminalising certain offenses under the Companies Act, aiming to reduce punitive measures and promote ease of doing business.
  • ROC/RD orders have increased scrutiny and enforcement of compliance requirements for corporations.

The Group Leader effectively addressed audience queries, providing clear explanations and practical insights on navigating complex compliance issues.

4. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting was held on 27th September 2024, via Zoom.

Group leader, CA Chaitanya Vakharia, in consultation with Group Mentor, CA Ashit Shah, prepared six case studies covering various contentious issues around the filing of the GST Annual Return in GSTR-9 and Annual Reconciliation in GSTR 9C for FY:2023–2024.

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  • Reporting of turnover in Table 5A of GSTR 9C
  • Applicability for filing GSTR 9 and GSTR 9C for 2023-24
  • Issues in filing annual returns after cancellation of GSTIN
  • Reporting of ITC in table 6B of GSTR 9
  • Additional reporting in GSTR 9 if not reported / wrongly reported in GSTR 1 and GSTR 3B
  • Claim of ITC in cases of payments to vendors beyond 180 days

Around 80+ participants from all over India benefitted while taking active part in the discussion.

5. Finance, Corporate & Allied Law Study Circle —Professionals Be Aware of PMLA Provisions, held on Wednesday, 23rd October, 2024 @ Hybrid.

PMLA is an important legislation, at times linked to national security, and Group Leader CA Kinjal Shah dealt with the applicability of PMLA provisions to the professionals such as chartered accountants, company secretaries, and cost accountants in a lucid manner. He explained the origin of PMLA, offence of money laundering, proceeds of crime, rationale for bringing in CAs as reporting entities and some of the key FAQs issued by ICAI. The obligations were explained with the help of a work flow chart analysing the procedure. Unlike other reporting entities, CA, CS, CMA are required to report to their respective institute who in turn reports to FIU-Ind. The meeting was well appreciated by 85+ study circle participants.

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQy9TNdSjCo

6. Suburban Study Circle meeting – Inheritance and Succession Planning Held on Sunday, 20th October, 2024, @ Hotel Golden Delicacy, Borivali.

Succession laws dictate how assets are distributed upon an individual’s demise. In India, these laws are influenced by religious and personal status. Group Leader CA Toral Shah discussed that planning effectively through wills and private trusts can help avoid disputes and ensure a smooth transfer of assets to the next generation.
Key Takeaways of the meeting were:

Intestate Succession (Without a Valid Will):

  • If no will is created, assets are distributed as per legal guidelines:
  • Hindus, Jains, Sikhs, and Buddhists: Governed by the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
  • Muslims are governed by Sharia Law.
  • Christians, Parsis, and Jews are governed by the Indian Succession Act, 1925.
  • If a case is not covered under the Indian Succession Act, it may be governed by the Hindu Succession Act.

Private Trusts:

– Private trusts are set up to manage and safeguard assets for beneficiaries, often used for estate planning and tax benefits.

– Provides asset protection and can reduce inheritance tax liabilities.

– Ensures that minors or vulnerable dependents are cared for, as specified by the trust’s terms.

– Offers greater control over how and when assets are distributed.

– `Laws governing private trusts in India include the Indian Trusts Act, 1882.

Group Leader effectively addressed audience queries regarding will preparations, gifts and she gave practical insights on navigating complex compliance issues. Overall 30+ participants attended the discussion.

7. Lecture Meeting on Hon’ble Supreme Court’s decision in case of Safari Retreats Pvt Ltd, held on Wednesday, 16th October, 2024, @ Zoom.

The learned faculty Sr. Adv. V. Sridharan explained the facts and the applicability of the very important and recent decision of the Apex court on availability of ITC for construction of immovable property. He explained how the apex court has differentiated the definition of ‘Plant and Machinery’ given in the explanation appended to section 17 of the CGST ACT applies to the expression ‘Plant or Machinery’ used in clause (d) of sub-section 5 of section 17. The difference of ‘and’ and ‘or’ becomes crucial too. He explained the important terms ‘own account’, ‘Plant’, ‘ITC – a right’, ‘Functionality test of a plant’ interpreted in the decision. He analysed the judgement in terms of its impact and way forward. The lucid analysis benefited all the 275+ participants attending the lecture meeting.

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lXEXnTBG9ZQ

8. NFRA Interaction – Evolving Assurance Landscape event held on Friday 4th October, 2024, Venue: Jio World Convention Centre

Topic 1: NFRA Interaction – Points Discussed:

  • Dr. Ajay Bhushan Prasad Pandey, Chairman, NFRA briefed the participants about the history and need for National Financial Reporting Authority (NFRA). He also explained the expectations of NFRA from the Auditors and Chartered Accountants.
  • The other two speakers, Mr. Shyam Tonk, Executive Director, NFRA and Mr. Vidyadhar Kulkarni, Principal Consultant, NFRA discussed the recent disciplinary orders of NFRA against Chartered Accountants, the outcomes and important pointers to be noted for future audit assignments.

Topic 2: Panel Discussion on Evolving Assurance Landscape

Panellists: Dr. Ajay Bhushan Prasad Pandey, CA Mukund Chitale and CA Manoj Fadnis

Moderated by CA Himanshu Kishnadwala and CA Amit Majumdar.

Points Discussed:

  • Proposed Revision in SA 600 “Using the work of other auditor” by NFRA
  • Recent circular dt. 3rd October, 2024 by NFRA on the role of principal auditor and other auditors in group audit and consolidated accounts.
  • Other developments and challenges faced by Chartered Accountants in the Audit practice area.

This meeting was well received by 80+ participants.

9. AI Co-Pilot and Chatbot for Professional Services Firms held on Tuesday, 10th September, 2024 @ Zoom.

In recent years, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has rapidly advanced, offering sophisticated Language Learning Models (LLMs) accessible to the general public. For Chartered Accountancy Practitioners and Professional Services Firms, leveraging AI tools can significantly enhance efficiency, streamline processes, and improve client service.

The key takeaways of the meeting were that Co-Pilot and Co-Pilot Studio can automate routine tasks, such as data entry, financial analysis, and report generation. AI can help streamline your practice, saving time, and reducing manual effort. It can improve workflow, client interactions, and overall service quality. The speakers also explored how chatbots can transform customer support and internal communication. They conducted a live demonstration of the step-by-step process for building and deploying a chatbot and customising it to address specific business needs.

Speakers:

Mr. Ajitabh Dwivedi and Mr. Nishant Gupta from Microsoft and Mr. Devesh Aggarwal from Compusoft. The session received an overwhelming response from 265+ participants across the country.

II. Other Society initiatives:

1. Letter of understanding (LOU) signed with National Institute of Securities Market (NISM) at NISM, BKC:

NISM is a non-profit organisation established by SEBI and carries out capacity-building activities enhancing quality standards in securities markets. BCAS signed LOU with NISM on 22nd November, 2024 marking a new beginning of this strategic collaboration aimed at fostering financial literacy, strengthening capital markets through research initiatives and deepening the academia — professional interface. The LOU signing was followed by a fireside chat on the topic of ‘Bridging the Trust Deficit in Financial Markets- The Role of Professionals in Strengthening Investor Protection and Market Transparency’ amongst CA Anand Bathiya, President and Shri Sunil Kadam, Registrar of NISM, moderated by CA Deepak Trivedi, Chief General Manager, Partnerships & Marketing Development. The session was organized by Finance, Corporate & Allied Laws Committee of BCAS. The momentous event ended with several thoughtful ideas which shall foster relations between both the organisations for laying a foundation of trust and knowledge sharing.

2. Interactive Discussion with Hon’ble Member (Tax Payer Services & Revenue), CBDT on 18th November, 2024 at Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai.

BCAS was invited as one of the stakeholders for an interactive session- ‘Tax Focus Forum’ with Hon’ble Member of CBDT, Shri HBS Gill and his officers. The objective of the meeting was to get feedback, understand the pulse of the community and foster a two-way communication on the roles and expectations in a transparent manner and in a trust-building atmosphere. The forum was attended by CA (Adv.) Kinjal Bhuta, Jt. Secretary and CA Jagdish Punjabi, Managing Committee Member. The Society presented the Forum with some pertinent compliance-related issues faced by the taxpayers and professionals currently and received an encouraging response from the Hon’ble Member, CBDT.

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Non-Profit Organisation Conclave held on 9th October, 2024, Venue: Walchand Hirachand Hall IMC, Churchgate.

This event was s organised by the Finance, Corporate, and Allied Laws Committee along with the Internal Audit Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) jointly with The Chamber of Tax Consultants and supported by the Rotary Club, which was attended by approximately 125 participants.

The Conclave encompassed a series of interactive sessions that provided a comprehensive view of managing and administering a Non-Profit Organization. A brief summary of the sessions is as under.

Topic Session Summary Faculty
Keynote Discussion Enlightening discussion focusing on Mr. Rajiv Mehta’s journey as an inspiring trustee spearheading multiple charitable projects and simultaneous impact generated for charitable purposes. Mr. Rajiv Mehta

( Managing Trustee, Ratna Nidhi Charitable Trust )

in conversation with

CA Shariq Contractor

 

Corporate Social Responsibility – A practical guide Informative lecture on the rules and practices affecting the Corporate Social Responsibility sector Ms. Savitri Parekh

(Company Secretary, Reliance Industries Ltd.)

Panel 1: Sharing Best Practices A thought-provoking discussion connecting professionals from diverse NPO backgrounds to share their views and experiences. Panelist 1: Mr. F.N. Subedar

(Trustee, Lady Meherbai D. Tata Education Trust)

Panellist 2: DG Chetan Desai

(Governor, Rotary District 3141)

Panellist 3: Mr. Satyajit Bhatkal

(Chief Executive Officer, Paani Foundation)

————————————————

Moderator: CA Naushad Panjwani

Compliances for NPOs under myriad laws Instructive session highlighting the multiple compliances and relevant issues faced by an NPO. CA Dr. Gautam Shah
Practical Challenges affecting our FCRA Registrations  An illuminating talk that provided a knowledgeable insight into the nuances of FCRA Laws. CA Anjani Sharma
Panel 2: The Change in Laws and how Internal Audit can step in to A contemporary session highlighting the need and importance of introducing Internal Audit Panelist 1: Mr. Noshir Dadrawalla

(Trustee, Centre of Advancement of Philanthropy)

meet up with the compliances into the regulatory purview of NPOs. Panelist 2: Mr. Anil Nair

(CEO & ED, St Jude India Child Care Centers)

 

Panelist 3: CA Atul Shah

————————————————

Moderator: CA Nandita Parekh

Critical Issues relating to Income Tax Laws affecting NPOs A descriptive lecture providing issues faced by NPOs under Income Tax Laws CA Anil Sathe

2. Student Study Circle on Transfer Pricing Audit from an Article’s Perspective held on 7th October, 2024, via Zoom.

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organized a Students’ Study Circle on “Transfer Pricing Audit from an Article’s Perspective” on Monday, 7th October, 2024. The session was led by Mr Heet Jain, a CA Final student, who delivered a comprehensive presentation on the fundamentals and key regulations governing Transfer Pricing in India. His presentation covered a wide range of topics, including essential definitions, various transfer pricing methods, and an overview of the audit processes and their approach. He also shared practical experiences to help beginner article students navigate the complexities of Transfer Pricing Audits.

CA Niraj Chheda, the mentor for the session, provided valuable insights and guidance throughout, offering expert interventions as needed. The study circle saw active participation from students across India.

50 participants attended the discussion, and it was well received.

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IkvILZgRmY&t=2s

3. Seminar on ‘The New Criminal Laws — Experts’ Overview’ held on 27th September, 2024, Venue: Runanubandha Hall, Yashwantrao Chavan Centre, Mumbai.

The Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Committee of BCAS organised a seminar titled “The New Criminal Laws — Experts’ Overview”, which was attended by approximately 50 participants.

The event featured an in-depth discussion of three recently introduced legislations: the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA). Senior Counsel Adv. Amit Desai presented a comprehensive analysis, focusing on the implications of the new provisions on the criminal justice system and advocating for a balanced approach.

Adv. Ekta Tyagi and Adv. Vikrant Negi followed with a legal overview of these laws that addressed various procedural aspects like filing police complaints, evidence scrutiny, etc. They emphasized the need for clarity to safeguard victims’ rights while maintaining the integrity of law enforcement. The seminar concluded with a discussion between Adv Anand Desai and Shri D. Sivanandhan, former Police Commissioner of Mumbai, exploring the relationship between legal reforms and effective policing. They underscored the importance of collaboration and adequate training in implementing these laws successfully. Overall, the seminar provided a crucial platform for understanding the complexities of the BNS, BNSS, and BSA and the collaborative efforts necessary for their effective application.

4. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting was held on 27th September 2024 via Zoom.

Group leader, CA Tanvi Gupta, in consultation with Group Mentor, Adv Harsh Shah, prepared 5 case studies covering various contentious issues around block credits under GST [excluding clauses (c) & (d) of Section 17(5)], which was attended by approximately 70 participants.

The presentation covered a detailed discussion on the following aspects:

i. Availability of ITC on motor vehicles under various scenarios.

ii. Availability of ITC on employee welfare expenses.

iii. ITC eligibility of sales promotion expenses.

iv. Availability of ITC on CSR spending is over and above the mandatory 2% as per the Companies Act, 2013.

v. Availability of ITC on RCM payments/payments made pursuant to investigation/adjudication proceedings u/s 74 of CGST Act

vi. Availability of ITC on payments to be made u/s 74A of CGST Act, especially for fraud cases.

vii. Reversal of ITC on account of normal loss, abnormal loss, goods lost in transit, goods written off, etc.

5. International Economics Study Group — Economic & Security challenges to India from recent Geopolitical events held on 11th September, 2024 Via Zoom.

Group Leader CA Harshad Shah discussed about India’s strategic and economic landscape being reshaped by recent geopolitical developments in its neighborhood, such as instability in Bangladesh, marked by political strife and the rise of Islamist factions which potentially threatens India’s security, particularly in West Bengal & Assam.

He also touched upon escalating tensions between Iran & Israel, which complicate India’s foreign policy due to its energy ties with Iran and growing defense cooperation with Israel, which could disrupt India’s energy security and challenge its diplomatic balance in the Middle East. Further, the Ukraine-Russia war has impacted India by disrupting global supply chains, affecting key imports like oil & fertilizers. Additionally, the outcome of the U.S. elections could significantly affect India’s economic and security landscape, with potential shifts in U.S. foreign policy, Indo-Pacific strategy, trade relations, visa and immigration policy, and technology partnerships adding uncertainty to India-U.S. ties.

6. Webinar on Tax Audit was held on 9th September, 2024 via Zoom.

The Direct Tax Committee of the BCAS organized a webinar on recent changes relating to Tax Audits causing immense confusion in reporting to address the various nuances, including a —practical way to handle clauses 21, 22, 34, and 44 of Form 3CD. Approximately 250 participants attended this webinar.

In the first session, Adv Krupa Gandhi addressed the issue of expenditure incurred to provide any benefit or perquisite. She gave lucid examples of freebies given by Pharma companies, differentiated between Club expenses incurred for personal purposes and expenditures at Belvedere Club/ Taj Club, etc. She clarified the provisions relating to expenditure incurred for any offence or purpose which is prohibited by law or penalty or fine for violation of any law and compounding.

In the second session, CA Yogesh Amal explained major issues with respect to the bifurcation of expenditure as per GST — Expenditure relating to goods or services exempt from GST, entities falling under the composition scheme, etc. He also touched upon the various clauses of Form 3CD and explained the applicability of Form 3CA-3CB. He shared practical insights on a few issues faced by the participants and also replied to various queries raised by the participants, clearing doubts on section 40A(7), GST, Offence, penalties, MSME, and MRL.

7. Webinar on Computation of Total Income of Charitable Trusts and Filing of ITR 7 held on 21st August 2024 via Zoom.

The The Taxation Committee of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society, jointly with the IMC Chamber of Commerce & Industry, organised a Webinar on the Computation of Total Income of Charitable Trusts and Filing of ITR-7, which approximately 380 participants attended.

CA Gautam Nayak began the session by outlining the key provisions governing the computation of total income for charitable trusts and institutions. He highlighted the importance of understanding the exemption under Sections 11 and 12 of the Income Tax Act, which apply to charitable and religious trusts. He discussed the specific conditions that must be met for these exemptions to be valid, such as proper utilization of funds and the maintenance of books of accounts. He also touched upon recent amendments and clarifications issued by the CBDT, stressing the need for charitable trusts to remain compliant with evolving tax laws to avoid penalties or disqualification from availing exemptions.

Following this, CA Ashok Mehta gave a comprehensive overview of ITR 7, the income tax return form used by charitable trusts and other institutions. He explained the step-by-step process involved in filing the form and highlighted common challenges faced by trustees and chartered accountants in the process. He emphasized that it is crucial to ensure accuracy in reporting sources of income, application of funds, and other statutory details to avoid complications and also discussed several nuances, such as the reporting of exempt income, donations, and the requirement for filing audited financial statements.

The webinar provided attendees with an in-depth understanding of the intricacies involved in the computation of income and the filing of tax returns for charitable institutions and underscored the importance of compliance to maintain the trust’s exemption status.

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ahe3ZcciOAw

 

Learning Events at BCAS

1. Workshop on Public Speaking for Professionals: Strategies to Enhance Your Career and Influence held on 31st August, 2024, Venue: BCAS

The HRD Committee of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised an engaging workshop conducted by faculty CA Hrudyesh Pankhania.

The workshop focused on effective communication techniques, providing practical strategies for enhancing career growth and professional influence through public speaking. It featured a range of interactive activities, including impromptu speaking exercises, role-playing, and group discussions, fostering a lively and engaging learning environment. A total of 54 participants attended the workshop, and they had the opportunity to practice their speaking skills in a supportive setting, receiving personalised feedback from the speaker.

The interactive format encouraged participants to share their experiences, helping to build confidence and improve their public speaking abilities.

2. Direct Tax Laws’ Study Circle meeting on the topic of Capital Gains Amendments in Finance (No.2) Act, 2024, held on 29th August, 2024. Venue: Zoom Platform.

Group Leader — CA Krishna Upadhya provided insights into the recent significant changes impacting the capital gains tax structure and related provisions by the Finance (No.2) Act, 2024. The discussion was attended by 54 members, and it was well received. Some key takeaways were:

  • Period of holding for various capital assets, such as listed/unlisted securities, immovable property, and debentures, comparing the rules before and after the amendments in the Finance (No.2) Act 2024.
  • Capital gains tax rates for different assets, highlighting the changes in rates before and after the amendments and their impact on long-term and short-term gains.
  • Amendment to Taxation of Buy-Back of Shares: Prior to the amendment, buy-back of shares was exempt for shareholders under section 10(34A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, with taxes paid by the company under section 115QA.
  • Post-amendment, buy-back is treated as a taxable transfer, with TDS under section 194.
  • The benefit of grandfathering provisions for land/buildings purchased before 23rd July, 2024, ensuring tax benefits for transfers of such assets.
  • New proviso to section 194-IA of TDS on sale of immovable property: The threshold of ₹50 lakhs for TDS is now based on the total property value, not per seller. If the sale value exceeds ₹50 lakh, TDS under Section 194-IA applies, regardless of the number of sellers.

3. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle on Notices u/s 73 & 74 held on 26th August, 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform.

Group leader, Adv Rushil Shah, in consultation with Group Mentor, Adv Vinaykumar Jain, prepared 6 case studies covering various contentious issues around notices under GST.

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  • Multiple tax periods under one notice.
  • Multiple notices for the same tax period.
  • Notices issued by multiple officers (parallel proceedings).
  • Issuance of the same notice on different dates and in different modes.
  • Interplay of section 75 (2) in 73 vs 74 cases.
  • Notices for fake invoices

Around 80 participants from all over India benefitted while taking an active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of the group leader & group mentor.

4. ‘CA Pariksha Pe Charcha’ held on 24th August 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform.

The Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organized a special program to guide and support CA students preparing for the exams. The keynote address was delivered by CA Nilesh Vikamsey, who emphasized the importance of resilience in achieving success and provided strategies for effectively dealing with failures. CA Umesh Sharma discussed various practical exam preparation strategies and clarified doubts about the ICAI evaluation process. He also highlighted the role of AI and other technological tools in enhancing study methods.

Following this, a panel discussion took place where top CA rankers from the May 2024 exams — CA Shivam Mishra, CA Ghilman Saalim Ansari, and CA Kiran Manral shared their personal experiences, detailed their study techniques, and discussed approaches to overcoming the challenges faced during their exam journey. The panel was ably moderated by CA Vedant Gada, a committee member, the session saw active participation from 76 students across the country and was well-received.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuxNHjd1s_0&t=434s

QR Code:

5. FEMA Study Circle meeting on “Bank Account & Demat of Shares Mandate for R to NR and NR to R under FEMA” held on 23rd August, 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform.

The study circle meeting was led by Group Leader — CA Divya Jokhakar. She highlighted the nuances around the topic. In the context of FEMA (Foreign Exchange Management Act), the mandate for a bank account and Demat account transition from Resident (R) to Non-Resident (NR) and back to Resident (R) involves specific regulatory requirements. When an individual’s status changes from Resident to Non-Resident, they must re-designate their savings bank account to a Non-Resident Ordinary (NRO) account or open a Non-Resident External (NRE) account. The Demat account must also be converted to a Non-Resident Demat account.

Upon becoming a Resident again, the NRO/NRE accounts should be re-designated as resident savings accounts. Similarly, the Non-Resident Demat account should be converted back to a Resident Demat account. It was also discussed that it is important to note that any investments made while being a Non-Resident must adhere to FEMA regulations, and compliance with tax laws is crucial during these transitions to avoid penalties. Proper documentation and timely communication with the bank and Depository Participants (DPs) are essential for smooth transitions. The study circle meeting was attended by 74 participants and was well received.

6. Felicitation of Chartered Accountancy pass-outs of the May 2024 Batch — “प्रोfessional Career — The Road Ahead”, held on 3rd August, 2024 Venue: Walchand Hirachand Hall — IMC.

In line with the spirit of celebrating achievements while preparing for future endeavors, the Seminar, Membership & Public Relations (SMPR) Committee of the BCAS organized a special session to honor the achievers of the May 2024 CA Final examinations and provide them with valuable guidance for their professional journey. This annual event serves as both a celebration and a platform for emerging professionals to gain insights from distinguished mentors.

The session, titled “Journey to Professional Excellence: Insights from Leading Minds,” featured two prominent Chartered Accountants: CA Raman Jokhakar and CA Gautam Shah. The event was marked by a significant turnout, with 264 newly qualified Chartered Accountants attending the event, including AIR 3 — CA Ghilman Saalim Ansari.

CA Chirag Doshi, Chairman of the SMPR Committee, inspired the attendees to embrace the myriad opportunities available to them in his opening remarks. He also provided an overview of the Committee’s activities, highlighting programs where young professionals take the lead. The speakers addressed a common question among new pass-outs—whether to pursue a career in industry or practice. CA Raman Jokhakar shared valuable insights on the importance of professionalism, emphasizing that conduct often outweighs mere qualification. CA Gautam Shah offered a detailed account of his career in practice, sharing practical experiences. CA Ghilman Saalim Ansari briefly shared his inspiring CA journey. The session concluded with a celebratory cake-cutting ceremony, recognizing the achievements of the new Chartered Accountants.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f59BCkdfznw

QR Code:

7. Lecture meeting on Direct Tax Law provisions of the Finance (No.2) Bill, 2024 Held on 27th July, 2024 at Yogi Sabagrah, Dadar.

The Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2024 introduced various direct tax law provisions, including changes in tax rates, capital gains, and withholding requirements for partnerships. While it aims for simplification, concerns arise over potential complications and inequities. Notably, the withdrawal of the Equalization Levy and Angel Tax provisions reflects a shift in tax policy. This public lecture meeting is the most awaited by our members, CA Fraternity, professionals, and the public at large; we had CA Shri Pinakin Desai addressing the participants with his first-hand views on the Finance Bill. He rated the budget as a satisfactory budget overall, which contains positive aspects and points requiring further attention or simplification.

Youtube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iweDyhhFqNw

QR Code:

Society News

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS

1. Suburban Study Circle meeting on the topic of Recent Changes in GST as per 53rd GST Council Meeting & Union Budget 2024. Held on 2nd August, 2024; Venue: Bathiya & Associates LLP, Andheri

The Group Leader, CA Mrinal Mehta, crafted a detailed presentation that addressed the recent changes through which group had insightful discussions. He shared his views on the following:

  • Changes in GST Tax Rates
  • Clarifications on services
  • Waiver of interest and penalty
  • Monetary limit for appeals and reduction in pre-deposit amount
  • Input Tax Credit – Section 16(4)
  • Clarifications on corporate guarantee and
  • Other amendments and clarifications

The session saw active engagement from 20 participants.

2. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle on Interpreting section 16 (4) of CGST Act, 2017. Held on 29th July, 2024; Venue: Zoom Platform

Group leader, CA Saurabh Jain, in consultation with Group Mentor, CA Rishabh Singhvi, prepared case studies covering various contentious issues around section 16 (4) of the CGST Act, 2017 and also dealt with the recent amendments proposed.

The presentation covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  • Whether section 16 (4) time limit applies to taking of credit in books of accounts or GSTR-3B
  • Whether the conditions imposed u/s.16 (4) are a substantial condition or procedural condition?
  • Whether the time limit prescribed u/s. 16 (4) applies to claim of ITC of tax paid on import of goods
  • Whether the time limit prescribed u/s 16 (4) applies to claim of ITC of tax paid on RCM (registered/unregistered)
  • How to interpret section 16 (4) in terms of ISD credits
  • Whether section 16 (4) applies in cases where the supplier has filed his GSTR-1 after the time limit prescribed therein

Around 60 participants from all over India benefitted while taking active part in the discussion. Participants appreciated the efforts of group leader& group mentor.

3. Lecture meeting on Direct Tax Law provisions of the Finance (No.2) Bill, 2024. Held on 27th July, 2024 at Yogi Sabagrah, Dadar

The Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2024 introduced various direct tax law provisions, including changes in tax rates, capital gains, buy-back of shares, charitable trusts, withholding requirements for partnerships, etc. While it aims for simplification, concerns arise over potential complications and inequities. Notably, the withdrawal of the Equalization Levy and Angel Tax provisions reflects a shift in tax policy. This public lecture meeting is the most awaited by our members, CA Fraternity, professionals and public at large. CA Pinakin Desai addressed the participants on the important provisions of the Finance (No. 2) Bill, 2024. He rated the budget as a satisfactory and also highlighted few points requiring further attention and simplification.

Some of the prominent takeaways and viewpoints from his lecture were:

  • The withdrawal of the Equalization Levy signals a strategic move towards implementing pillars one and two, indicating a shift in approach to international tax challenges.
  • Changes in tax rates and increase in standard deductions for salaried employees and a reduction in tax rates for foreign companies and capital gains aim to address equity in taxation.
  • Significant changes to capital gains taxation, which can impact both individual and corporate taxpayers. Listed securities of holding is now uniform with other securities and will turn long-term in 12 months. Short-term capital gains tax on listed securities has increased from 15% to 20%. These changes aim to simplify the capital gains tax framework but could lead to complexities and inequities for certain taxpayers.
  • The ease of doing business needs to be re-evaluated to ensure fairness for both residents and non-residents. Current provisions may impose undue burdens, particularly on partnership firms and their tax obligations.
  • The tax withholding obligations for partnership firms can lead to financial strain, especially when remuneration exceeds deductible amounts. This situation may result in penalties for non-compliance.
  • The new buy-back provisions effective from 1st October, 2024, classify buy-back payments as dividend income for shareholders, regardless of the company’s profit status. Shareholders face a challenge as the buy-back income is treated as dividends, with no deductions allowed for the cost of shares. This could lead to capital losses instead.
  • Reassessment proceedings for tax can now be conducted within a shorter period of five years, impacting how companies manage their tax strategies. This change emphasises the importance of timely compliance.
  • Significant steps are taken for charitable trusts by removing adverse provisions, particularly regarding mergers and exit tax. It alleviates previous concerns and fosters collaboration between trusts.
  • A significant change in the Black Money Act mandates that residents disclose foreign assets, with strict penalties for non-compliance, emphasizing the importance of transparency.
  • Amendments regarding tax refunds indicate a shift towards stricter compliance and potential delays for taxpayers.

The Lecture meeting was attended by around 350 participants at the venue, and have more than 18,000 viewers on YouTube. It was highly appreciated by the participants.

The readers can view the entire meeting at the following link:

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iweDyhhFqNw

4. ITF Study Circle Meeting on “Pillar Two – Basics” Held on 22nd July, 2024; Venue: Zoom Platform

The group leader – K. Prasanna deliberated on the following topics:

  • Need of Pillar-2 and its developments in the International arena.
  • Conditions relating to the applicability of Pillar-2 – Globe rules.
  • Various concepts surrounding the Globe rules such as IIR, UTPR etc. with practical scenarios and case studies.

During the study circle meeting, the participants raised questions about their specific concerns. The session was highly informative and was a good base to start in-depth study and was attended by 55 participants.

5. Webinar on Filing of Income Tax Returns for AY 2024-25 Held on 2nd July, 2024; Venue: Zoom Platform

The Direct Tax Committee of BCAS organised a “Webinar on Filing of Income Tax Returns for AY 2024-25. CA Akshar Panchamia, the first speaker covered ITRs 1, 2, 3 and 4 wherein he explained the applicability of these ITRs to applicable assesses. There were some important amendments in the ITR like choosing the tax regime, mentioning the type of Bank Account, quoting the MSME number etc. which were highlighted. He also demonstrated instances where the details need to be mentioned correctly to avoid any undue disallowances. Schedule FA – Foreign Asset which is mainly applicable for Resident and Ordinarily Resident was explained in detail in his presentation.

CA Ronak Rambhia covered the ITRs 5, 6 and 7 wherein he explained the due dates applicable to each assessee. The pre-requisites while preparing the Tax Returns like the Annual Accounts, Audit Report, Bank details, registration numbers, GST Turnovers, etc. were taken into consideration along with important schedules like Schedule VDA — Virtual Digital Asset, SH-1 — Shareholders details, AL-1 — Asset Liability, etc.

The webinar gave the viewers practical insights about the Income Tax return filings, the latest amendments reflected in the forms and best practices to avoid mismatch in the ITR processing. Webinar was attended by around 280 participants.

YouTube Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X7qmz3H5HUY

6. 75 Hours Long Duration Study Course on Auditing Standards on the 75th Anniversary of BCAS Held in June from 14th March, 2024 to 14th June, 2024, Venue: Zoom Platform

BCAS has always been pioneer in equipping its members in particular and other stakeholders at large. To Commemorate 75th Year of existence of BCAS and to celebrate its Diamond Jubilee, Accounting & Auditing Committee organised a well-designed 75-hour long duration study course spanning more than 12 weeks. The Course was mainly held on Fridays and Saturdays for 3 hours each day totaling to 75 hours.

The main objective of designing this long duration course was to deep dive into the subjects affecting the audit fraternity and provide platform to the members in Industry and Practice to come together. It was focused on the practical challenges which crops up while implementing the complicated Accounting Standards. The course was segregated into three equal segments.

  • AS
  • IndAS
  • Assurance Standards

The course also included topics on Companies Act provisions, CARO, Schedule II, III, CSR, FRRB / NFRA observations, etc. The segments / modules were designed to give practical case study based insights to the participants on various topics.

The various sessions of the course generated lot of interactions between the participants and the respective faculties. The three month’s duration course was attended by 136 participants and was well received and the overall feedback from the participants was encouraging. The Participants were awarded Certificate of Participation for attending the course.

7. Corporate & Commercial Law Study Circle – Oppression & Mismanagement Held on 30th May, 2024; Venue: Zoom Platform

The Group leader – CS Gaurav Kumar explained the meaning of oppression and mismanagement, difference between oppression and mismanagement, the relevant provisions of the Companies Act 2013. The speaker discussed modes, methods and possible reasons of oppression and mismanagement, and discussed landmark case laws giving understanding of the relevant nitti-gritties.

He also touched upon arbitration as a possible alternative to prolonged and expensive litigation process. He enlightened the participants with the preventive measures to reduce the possibility of oppression and mismanagement. He threw light on the role a CA can play in the matters relating to oppression and mismanagement. Around 60 participants attended the meeting and it was well appreciated.

  1. Other Events & News:

BCAS Foundation’s Tree Plantation Drive 2024

On 4th August, 2024, the BCAS Foundation, in partnership with Keshav Srushti, organised the Miyawaki Forest Project 2024 at Ismail Yusuf College, Jogeshwari East. This initiative focused on environmental sustainability through the Miyawaki technique, a method that fosters rapid growth of dense, native forests.

Trustees of BCAS Foundation, spoke about the Foundation’s dedication to social and environmental causes, stressing the significance of projects that yield long-term benefits. The event was graced by CA Rashmin Sanghvi as the Chief Guest. A longstanding advocate for environmental causes within the BCAS Foundation, CA Sanghvi has been instrumental in driving such initiatives.

Neelkantan Aiyyar, Joint Secretary of Keshav Srushti, kicked off the event with an insightful briefing on the Miyawaki technique, emphasising its ecological benefits, such as enhanced carbon absorption and biodiversity support. Following this, Satish Modh, President of Keshav Srushti, highlighted the organisation’s commitment to nature conservation and rural development.

A special session followed, where participants engaged in a Bhu Devs Pooja to honour the Earth, followed by symbolic plantations. Around 100 saplings were planted during this session, with many of the trees planted by children. This act of nurturing young minds alongside young trees was a powerful reminder of the legacy we leave for the future. The event concluded with a sumptuous lunch, the sense of accomplishment and camaraderie was palpable, with participants leaving with a deeper understanding of their role in preserving the environment and a commitment to future initiatives.

Intervention on behalf of BCAS at Ad Hoc Committee Meeting for United Nations Framework Convention:

CA Radhakishan Rawal, core group committee member of International Tax Committee of BCAS, had an opportunity to place his views as a representative of BCAS and participate in the discussions at the Second Session of the Ad Hoc Committee to Draft Terms of Reference (ToR) for United Nations Framework Convention on International Tax Co-operation at a 15 days session held in New York. The ToR was approved by majority (110 in favour, 8 against and 44 abstaining member states). This is treated as a historical development but a small step of a long journey for establishing an inclusive and fair system of international taxation.

Learning Events at BCAS:

SOCIAL OUT-REACH INITIATIVES:

Round Table discussions on Viksit Bharat:

The Finance, Corporate and Allied Laws Committee (FC&AL) of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) organized two round table discussions on Viksit Bharat: Ideas and Suggestions in July 2024. The aim was to gather insights from experienced Chartered Accountants and promising young professionals to contribute to Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi’s vision to make a Viksit Bharat by 2047. The first round table discussion was held on Saturday 6th July 2024 at the International Fiscal Association – India Branch in BKC, Mumbai where eminent Chartered Accountants shared their perspectives on various aspects of public policy and economic development crucial for India’s progress. The second roundtable discussion took place on Saturday 20th July 2024 at ATLAS SkillTech University, Mumbai. This event brought together top-ranking CA Finals and Intermediate students, along with MBA students, to provide a fresh perspective on India’s future.

MOU with Bombay Industries Associations (BIA):

The Society entered into a collaboration agreement with BIA on 18th July 2024 under which both bodies of eminence will mutually collaborate by leveraging strengths and enabling commerce. In this one of its kind partnership, both organizations, with 75 years of history, will combine their resources and capabilities towards collaborative learning opportunities, advocating for ease-of-businesses, offering policy suggestions, and engaging members from both associations with an aim to reinforce the overall economic structure.

BCAS Membership Survey:

Our members are at the centre of everything we plan and do. The Society believes in delivering high-quality professional experience for our members and community at large. Keeping that in mind, BCAS conducted a Membership Survey on 16th July, 2024 and received an overwhelming response. We thank our beloved members for participating in the survey. Some of the statistics of the survey are as follows:

  •  Relevance of Topic at BCAS Learning Events —Average rating 4.4
  •  Quality of Speakers and Content at BCAS Learning Events: Average rating 4.3
  •  Format of BCAS Learning Events- Average rating 4.1
  •  Venue, Food, and other logistics at BCAS Learning Events — Average rating 3.9
  •  Pricing for BCAS Learning Events — Average rating 3.9

The Society has also received many well thought suggestions from the members in the survey, and we shall strive to take that into consideration in our future activities.

Social Media Reach:

The Society has been striving to increase its reach to professionals and society and large and social media has been one of the relevant tools of current times to achieve the same. We are happy to announce that we have crossed 10,000 followers on Linkedin. Our Whatsapp channel is also live and within two days we have crossed 1000 followers. With these, our overall social media spread has reached 57,189 followers and counting.

BCAS WhatsApp Chatbot:

In a constant endeavour to bring ease to our members, the Society is delighted to introduce its own Whatsapp Chatbot. Now, all our members and non-members can access and register for BCAS events and other activities through the ease of WhatsApp. Readers can explore the chatbot by sending a simple Hi on the chatbot number — 9082634642 to get started.

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS:

1. 76th Founding Day Lecture Meeting on Viksit Bharat — Role of Accounting and Finance Professionals held on 6th July, 2024 at ITC Grand Central Hotel Parel.

The 76th Foundation Day of the Society was marked by a significant event, featuring an interactive talk with the esteemed Padma Bhushan Shri K. V. Kamath. The topic, ‘Viksit Bharat — Role of Accounting and Finance Professionals,’ is a testament to the evolving landscape of India’s economy and the pivotal role that accounting and finance professionals play in it. Shri Kamath, with his extensive experience spanning over five decades, provided invaluable insights into India’s journey towards becoming a developed nation. As an inter-generational witness of India’s transformation, his dialogue with CA Raman Jokhakar, past president of the Society, highlighted the transformative changes that technology brought and the contribution of the Country’s infrastructure development plan, reflecting on the progress and the road ahead for India. He broadly spoke about the following.

Role of CAs: Since his early days at ICICI in 1971, Shri Kamath has witnessed first-hand the pivotal role of Chartered Accountants in shaping financial strategies and strengthening accounting practices. He reminisced about his experience in 1980, when he was leading a standalone division at ICICI acknowledging how chartered accountants assumed the role of technology architects in bringing technology to ICICI. Shri Kamath stated that people in the accounting and finance professions have to be leaders in absorbing and leveraging technology in a bigger way. According to Shri Kamath, the role of Chartered Accountants is going to be closely interwoven with technology for in the next 25 years, it will be difficult to differentiate between where the accounting stops and the technology comes in. He further stated that CA’s are the conscious keepers for the companies, Government and the public at large. That role is going to be more important as we go along with the new technology. He also emphasized the necessity of setting one’s mind on skilling and upskilling and getting everybody’s mindset aligned towards the technology part of the profession.

Learnings from the past: Talking about his learnings from driving and executing IT in ICICI, he said that the integration of technology into ICICI Bank’s operations between 2000 and 2005 marked a transformative era in Indian banking. The introduction of ATMs and the centralization of back-office operations, along with the establishment of call centres, significantly reduced the volume of in-branch transactions. He acknowledged that between 2020 and today, it has virtually revolutionized the way payments are made by individuals and corporations NPCI and QR technologies are taking over.

Characteristics of Viksit Bharat: On being asked about the characteristics/features of Viksit Bharat, he said that Viksit Bharat envisioned as a developed India, is characterized by its focus on rapid infrastructural growth, mirroring the transformative journeys of Japan, the Asian Tigers, and China. This vision is embodied in Mumbai’s current infrastructure projects like MTHL (Atal Setu), Eastern Freeway, and various metro and coastal road projects. According to Shri Kamath this seamless development will happen in every city, and town and will pervade down to every village and that according to Shri Kamath, will be a very visible sign of Viksit Bharat. He further explained that the infrastructure becomes the first building block as it adds to GDP during the implementation phase becoming the first ‘virtuous cycle’ leading to economic utilization of the said infrastructure in the next 15-20 years. With the fruits of infrastructure reaching every corner of the country, wealth will increase which will lead to more consumption leading to a second virtuous cycle.

Growth Rate and Per Capita Income: Speaking about the 10 per cent aspirational growth rate, and higher per capita income, Shri Kamath highlighted that given the size of the population, India has no challenge to put up new infrastructure for the next 25 years and put the same to utility. The country has had an agenda for over 20 years that provides momentum for sustainable development. The mark of 8-10 per cent is the combination of growth driven by infrastructure, consumption and other constituents like services, agriculture etc. In his view, the country should have a goal of achieving a growth rate of 8 per cent and a 25 trillion economy by 2047. According to him, funding is not a challenge today. It’s also not true to say that the private-sector capex cycle is not happening. With improvement in cash equivalence, and with very minimum access to borrowings, companies are now investing in themselves on a just-in-time basis without waiting for demand to develop. The new indicator of capital expenditure is therefore the increase in the gross fixed assets and capital working progress and not bank lending.

YouTube Link:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OxSpLouU8Iw

QR Code:

2. Suburban Study Circle meeting held on Friday, 12th July, 2024 @ Bathiya & Associates LLP Andheri.

The meeting was held on Friday, 12th July, 2024 at Bathiya & Associates LLP Andheri. The meeting was led by Group Leader — CA Amit Purohit. CARO 2020 represents a significant shift in the audit reporting landscape, with enhanced requirements aimed at improving transparency and accountability. While these changes present challenges, they also offer opportunities for auditors to add value through more detailed and insightful reporting.

Key discussions in the meeting were about:

  •  Property, Plant, and Equipment: Detailed disclosure regarding title deeds, revaluation, and proceedings involving Benami Property.
  •  Inventory and Working Capital: Reporting on discrepancies of 10 per cent or more in the aggregate of each class of inventory.
  •  Loan Advances and Guarantees: Scrutiny of loans, guarantees, and advances to related parties, including reporting on terms, conditions, and repayment status.
  •  Fraud Reporting: Specific requirements to report any fraud noticed or reported during the year, including actions taken by the auditor. Ensuring the accuracy and completeness of data, especially for inventory and property, can be challenging.
  •  Internal Audit System: Reporting on the existence and effectiveness of an internal audit system. The detailed nature of the new requirements means auditors must perform more comprehensive and in-depth audits.
  •  Maintaining detailed documentation to support the new disclosures is essential but time-consuming.

The group leader shared practical insights to help auditors navigate these challenges and emphasized the importance of ongoing learning and adaptability in the ever-evolving field of audit and assurance.

3. International Economics Study Group meeting on the topic of ‘Analysing Parliament Election Results of 2024’

The meeting was held on Tuesday, 2nd July 2024 through a Virtual platform by Group Leaders CA Harshad Shah and CA Pramod Jain. The unexpected outcome of India’s 2024 election has reasserted the unpredictable nature of its politics — and the strength and resilience of our democracy. The BJP’s significant drop of 63 seats marked a return to coalition politics, presenting significant challenges in parliament. The passage of bills will require substantial compromise, a stark contrast to the previous government’s majority passing. There is no clear sign of pan-India anti-incumbency, especially on the economic front. Mr Jain shared his views on inequality, highlighting ten areas of disparities. He questioned whether Indian democracy will ever mature and emphasized the role of professionals as the “fifth pillar” for the success of Indian democracy.

4. Lecture Meeting on ‘Obligations of Chartered Accountants under PMLA’.

The lecture meeting on “Obligations of Chartered Accountants under PMLA” jointly with the National Institute of Securities Market (NISM) was held virtually on Friday 28th June 2024. More than 200 participants attended the webinar. The lecture was delivered by Mr. Krishnan Vishwanathan. The key takeaways of the session are:

  •  Under PMLA it is an offence to assist in money laundering, and accountants may be responsible for detecting and preventing it, especially regarding predicate offences like bribery.
  •  Only those professionals holding a Certificate of Practice from ICAI, CWA, or ICSI and conducting activities like managing client money or property are obligated to comply with PMLA.
  •  Documentation of AML policies and procedures is crucial to avoid penalties, and these include client acceptance methodologies.
  •  Procedures for periodic reviews and client’s due diligence are essential under PMLA.
  •  Extra caution is needed when dealing with clients in Tax Havens due to the increased risk of money laundering and tax evasion. One has to be aware of beneficial ownership structures, shell companies, and politically exposed persons (PEPs).
  •  Reporting to the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) is required, but only for truly suspicious activities with documented justification to avoid overwhelming the authorities.
  • Training for employees and maintaining records for five years are mandatory.
  •  Chartered Accountants can play a role in identifying proceeds of crime like unexplained cash or suspicious accounting entries.
  •  Chartered Accountants need to be cautious when offering professional services, especially certifications or acting as collection centres, to avoid indirectly facilitating money laundering.

BCAS Lecture Meetings are high-quality professional development sessions which are open to all to attend and participate. The readers can view the lecture meeting at the below-mentioned link/code:

YouTube Link:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJDX-mic1tw&t=19s

QR Code:

5. FEMA Study Circle Jointly with ITF Study Circle meeting on ‘Cross Border Structuring for Individuals — FEMA and Tax Implications’

The meeting was held on 13th June, 2024, at BCAS in hybrid format. The following relevant points were discussed in the meeting by the group leader — CA Bhavya Gandhi:

  •  Key considerations for cross-border structuring include compliance with FEMA regulations and adherence to Indian tax laws.
  •  Outbound investments must follow the Liberalized Remittance Scheme (LRS) limits and reporting requirements.
  •  Tax residency status of the individual significantly impacts global income tax liabilities.
  •  Proper documentation and valuation are essential to avoid penalties and ensure legal compliance.
  •  Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA) should be leveraged to minimize tax burdens.
  •  Repatriation of funds to India requires careful planning to ensure compliance with both FEMA and tax regulations.
  •  Estate planning and inheritance tax implications must be considered in cross-border structuring.
  •  Continuous monitoring and review of the structure are necessary to adapt to any regulatory or tax law changes.

The meeting was attended by 79 members and was well appreciated.

6. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Income Tax Aspects of Redevelopment of Society”.

The meeting was held on 05th May and 23rd May, 2024 at Golden Delicacy, Borivali (W)led by CA Sharad Sheth as Group Leader and chaired by CA Nihar Jambusaria and discussions were spread over two sessions.

Group Leader prepared an interesting list of various situations arising in the redevelopment of the Housing Society and shared their views on the following:

  •  When does the transfer of capital assets arises.
  •  Income tax liability on transfer of tenancy right.
  •  When does the benefit of section 45(5A) be availed.
  •  When can exemptions under sections 54 and 54F be claimed.
  •  Analysis of various caselaws on the relevant topic.

The session was thought-provoking with comprehensive discussion on practical issues faced. The session saw lively engagement from 55 + participants and the interactive nature of the discussion enriched the experience of everyone involved.

7. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle on ‘Export Driven Custom’s Schemes — MOOWR, AEO — Benefits from Customs Perspectives’

The meeting was held virtually on Thursday, 23rd May 2024. The key discussions are done by the Group Leader — CA. Shravan Gehlot, Chennai and Group mentor —Adv. Vikram Naik, Mumbai were as follows:

  •  Manufacturing & Other Operations in Warehouse (MOOWR)
  •  The application and registration process for availing the benefits and covered the key benefits, customs norms for activities in the warehouse and who must opt for the same.
  •  The Authorised Economic Operator (AEO) scheme.
  •  The AEO road map in India since 2001, eligibility criteria, benefits for importers as well as exporters, Customs clearance norms, registration & post registration compliances and other key considerations.
  •  The professional opportunities for the Chartered Accountants in the MOOWR and AEO Scheme.

Around 50 participants all over India benefitted while taking an active part in the discussion on the 2 FTP Customs Schemes.

8. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle meeting on ‘Issues in Logistic Sector’

The meeting was held virtually on Tuesday, 14th May 2024 Group leader — CA. Darshan Ranavat had prepared case studies and a presentation covering various issues & challenges faced by taxpayers in the Logistic Sector under the GST law. The session was mentored by CA. A R Krishnan. The case studies covered the following aspects for detailed discussion:

  1.  Taxability of clearing & forwarding agents including the claim of pure agent benefits.
  2.  Issues relating to classification and RCM concerning the vessel charter business.
  3.  Issues relating to classification and place of supply concerning the freight forwarding business.
  4.  Issues relating to services provided by GTA to GTA.
  5.  Specific issues in services provided to SEZ

Around 65 participants all over India benefitted by taking an active part in the discussion.

Learning Events at BCAS

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS

1. Power Summit 2024 | 28th & 29th June, 2024 | Hotel Fountainhead and Imaginarium AliGunjan, Alibaug

Human Resource Development Committee of BCAS organised a two-day residential program “The Power Summit 2024” on 28th and 29th June, 2024 at Hotel Fountainhead and Imaginarium AliGunjan, Alibaug. This was the 8th season of the Power Summit with the first one being held in 2011.

Much before the last date for early bird was to end, the registrations for the Summit were full. There were many members who had even listed down their names in the Wait List. Such an overwhelming response in itself is a strong testimony of the popularity of the Power Summit amongst our members.

The Power Summit hosted 88 participants from 15 different cities. We witnessed a mixed age group of audience with members in their twenties to experienced patrons and seniors. This diversity added to the charm of the Summit. The Summit had 8 eminent faculties. The program was curated and anchored by a team of 3 esteemed members — CA Nandita Parekh, CA Ameet Patel and CA Vaibhav Manek.

This is the second year in which we continued to hold this program in residential format. The benefits in residential format was truly reaped and cherished by the participants. They got added networking opportunities and chance to have casual interactions with the faculties some of whom were present through the entire duration of the program.

The theme for the Power Summit was “Walk the Talk | Leverage AI, Technology, Capital & Collaboration”. All the sessions had been strategically crafted around this theme.

The presentations by the faculties over the two days were creative, intriguing and intertwined in a way that all the participants came back with good food for thought and also a zeal to walk forward on the growth trajectory.

The program on Day 1 started with a panel discussion on the topic of Leadership Quotient for CA Firms. CA Hitesh Gajaria and CA Milan Mody shared their journeys as panellists and candidly explained the challenges of leading a CA firm. The session was moderated by CA Nandita Parekh.

In the next session, CA J. K. Shah shared his entrepreneurial journey and inspiring everyone by touching upon the values of Courage, Conviction and Commitment.

The next session was creatively crafted by CA Vaibhav Manek in the form of a Workshop. A mock Merger Lab had been organized wherein 4 CA Firms from amongst the participants were selected and divided in group of two firms each in advance. Each group was asked to stimulate a scenario wherein they have approached each other for a potential merger. The discussions that they would have carried out in a closed meeting room was stimulated and held on stage for all the participants to observe. This gave everybody an exposure on how the real-life merger discussions take place.

The last session for the day was a power packed session on Partnering with Technology for Growth by CA Lalit Valecha and CA Rajeev Sharma. They shared their experiences and introduced the Technology Best practices for CA Firms. This session continued late into the evening and yet saw a packed house till the very end.

While Day 1 of the Summit was hosted at Hotel Fountainhead, the Day 2 of Summit was hosted at Imaginarium AliGunjan. Imaginarium AliGunjan is a state-of-the-art research facility developed by Nishith Desai Associates in Alibaug. The philosophy of Blue Sky with which the research centre has been developed inspired our participants and added to their zeal for sessions to be hosted on this Day.

Day 2 began with a session by CA Aniket Talati. He shared insightful statistics around the composition of our current fraternity and the direction in which our fraternity and the profession is moving. He also reminded the participants about the Prime Minister’s wish to have large Indian firms emerging from amongst the existing firms.

The next session was by CA Dinesh Kanabar who shared his own journey and experiences of how one can navigate or sail through the Winds of Change.

The last session of the Summit focused on the new age HR practices for professional services firms. The session was led by Pakzad Nussirabad who has headed the HR function in various organisations in the past including a CA firm. He gave useful inputs to the participants on people management and how to face the challenges of a multi generational workforce.

The Power Summit was concluded with the closing bell session from CA Nandita Parekh, CA Ameet Patel and CA Vaibhav Manek summarising the learnings of the two days and motivating everyone to carry on the energy and zeal and take necessary action on their growth trajectory. They also thanked the convenors and other members of the HRD Committee for the excellent work done in organising the Summit.

The interest of the participants was evident in terms of the involved discussions and the large number of questions raised during and after each session and also during the casual networking interactions.

The Summit succeeded in generating a lot of interest amongst the participants thereby motivating them to strategically plan for their growth. The participants were extremely thankful to the organising team for the excellent work done by them and for providing a top-quality program to them. All the participants graciously shared their Testimonies and Gratitude over WhatsApp group and Social Media platforms.

2. Webinar on Use of Technology for Practice Management in CA Firm held on 18th May, 2024 Zoom Online Meeting

The Technology Initiatives Committee of BCAS conducted a Webinar on “Webinar on Use of Technology for Practice Management in CA Firm” on 18th May, 2024. The webinar was aimed enlightening the participants on how to improve a CA Firm’s practice management techniques through the use of technology.

The webinar began with CA Rahul Bajaj explaining the dashboard of the Practice Management Software BIZALYS. He demonstrated the features of the cloud based software like minimal data entry, auto work flow reports, automated reminders to clients and staff, branch and team management, document management, departmental hearing notices management, billing and receivables, appointment, library base etc. The speaker also answered multiple questions and addressed doubts of the participants.

In the second part of the webinar Mr Kshitiz Bharti, explained the features of MyTasksoftware. He demonstrated the management problems faced by the practicing professional firms and the benefits of using technology with enhanced tracking and control. He further elaborated the unique offerings of the software like Income Tax Return Status checker, geo location based attendance, client portal, GST return status tracker etc.

Key takeaways for the participants from the webinar:

  • With increasing complexity in the various laws of the land and with multiple due dates to be taken care of, it is risky to continue to rely on manual ways of managing one’s practice.
  • Various practice management software available in the market enable CAs to put in place proper processes and rules for carrying out each task in each assignment that the firm takes up
  • Exploring the latest trends and advancements in CA practice management software.
  • Understanding how automation can enhance productivity and reduce manual errors.
  • Demonstration of the features and dashboards of the software
  • Real-life case studies showcasing the transformative impact of software’s on CA Firm operations.

The webinar had 100+ participants from more than 35 cities.

3. ITF Study Circle Meeting held on Friday, 17th May, 2024 in Hybrid mode at BCAS.

Discussion on Case Study 1 of the ITF Conference Paper II: Unraveling GAAR, SAAR, PPT and LOB – Overlap and Intricacies by CA H Padamchand Khincha. The meeting was attended by approximately 28 participants.

The International Tax and Finance Study Circle organised a meeting (hybrid mode) on 17th May, 2024 to discuss the implications and different viewpoints of Case Study 1 of the ITF Conference Paper II

  • The basic facts of the Case Study were summarised.
  • Discussions began on various questions in the Case Study.
  • Several members expressed divergent views on various issues.
  • Various rulings and interpretations with respect to GAAR provisions were discussed.
  • Some members shared their experiences dealing with GAAR provisions.
  • Divergent views on different issues were well summarised.

Speaker: CA Rohit Jethani

4. Workshop on Positive Parenting held virtually on 21st April, 2024, 28th April, 2024 and 5th May, 2024.

The Human Resources Development Committee organised a workshop on “Positive Parenting” on 21st April, 28th April and 5th May, 2024. It was attended by 48 participants.

The faculty, Rev Fr Patrick D’Mello, Dr Janice Morais and Dr Sheryl John showed how parents can enjoy with their kids at the same time bring out the best in them.

The takeaways from the workshop are briefly given below:

1. “A child is the beauty of God’s presence in the world, the greatest gift to a family.” – Mother Teresa

2. The old ways of disciplining — shouting, correcting, spanking, punishing don’t work. They impact the children negatively. They are replaced by new ways — positive incentives, contracts, empathy, environmental control, curiosity questions, ‘and’ and not ‘but’.

3. The parenting process — holding, reassuring and letting go has to be age appropriate.

4. Various problems can be solved by “connect” and “skill-building” techniques

5. How to deal with internet addiction, excessive video games, and gadgets.

6. Spend time with children on activities that will have beneficial effects for their growth and success.

7. Positive parents nurture, discipline and respect their children
8. Universal problems like excessive mobile use, no motivation, disrespect & lying were discussed and the ways to deal with them were shown.

9. Important to be aware of the common mental health problems and seek help for the same.

10. Understanding that annoying and irritating behaviour are not misbehaviour.

11. Encourage children to express themselves and not to whine.

A lot was taught, enabling parents to use new strategies to get children to become more disciplined and grow to their full potential.

5. CAMBA Certified Management Programme for CAs held on 12th to 14th April, 2024 @ ATLAS SkillTech University Mumbai

These represent CAMBA — a certified Management Programme for CAs organised by BCAS in association with the ATLAS SkillTech University, mentored by CA Naushad Panjwani and designed by Dr Chetana Asbe. Approximately 90 participants from over 20 cities attended 10+ enjoyable sessions.

It was a unique program where CAs from across the country gathered not to enhance their technical skills but to dive into the nuances of personal and professional growth. From 12th to 14th April, 2024, participants embarked on an immersive journey designed to stretch their minds and broaden their perspectives. Sessions spanned topics like ‘AI for non-technical professionals’, ‘Leadership Ascendancy’ and ‘Design thinking for goal setting’. What truly set CAMBA apart was its hands-on, experiential approach to learning. Attendees didn’t just passively absorb information; they actively engaged in real-world scenarios, solving challenges, and refining their skills in real-time.

But it wasn’t all business. In between sessions, participants bonded over unique experiences like a Heritage City Bus Tour and a delightful Food Crawl, fostering connections that transcended professional boundaries.

A standout feature was the Speed Mentoring sessions, where eager young professionals had the invaluable opportunity to tap into the wisdom of seasoned experts, gaining insights that textbooks alone could never offer.
CAMBA wasn’t just a program; it was a holistic journey of growth, camaraderie, and enlightenment — an experience that left participants not just better professionals, but better equipped to navigate the ever-evolving landscape of the professional world with poise and confidence.

6. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Issue-based study and discussion on Section 44AD & 44ADA” on 7th June, 2024 at C/o Bathiya & Associates LLP, Andheri (E), Mumbai.

Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Issue-based study and discussion on Section 44AD & 44ADA”, was led by CA Viral Shah as Group Leader under the Guidance of CA Ketan Vajani.

In a comprehensive and insightful session, CA Viral Shah, under the chairmanship of CA Ketan Vajani, elucidated the intricacies of Sections 44AD and 44ADA of the Income Tax Act. The session focused on the provisions, applicability, and critical issues related to these sections, which are designed to simplify the taxation process for small businesses and professionals. The meeting was attended by approximately 20 participants. They shared their views on the following:

  • Overview of Sections 44AD and 44ADA
  • Eligibility and Conditions
  • Computation of Income
  • Advantages and Limitations
  • Practical Scenarios and Case Studies
  • Recent Amendments and Judicial Pronouncements

During the course of an engaging question-and-answer segment, participants raised queries about specific concerns and received expert advice from CA Viral Shah and CA Ketan Vajani.

The session was highly informative, providing attendees with a thorough understanding of Sections 44AD and 44ADA. Both speakers effectively highlighted the benefits of these presumptive taxation schemes while also cautioning about potential issues, ensuring that professionals and small business owners are better equipped to make informed decisions regarding their tax filings.

Society News

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS

1. FEMA Study Circle meeting – “Compounding under FEMA and Practical aspects” by CA Hardik Mehta was held on 16th May, 2024 @Zoom which was attended by approximately 118 participants, wherein the following was covered:

(i) Overview of FEMA Compounding Provisions:

  •  Explanation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) and its objectives.
  •  Understanding the concept of compounding as an alternative to litigation for resolving contraventions under FEMA.

(ii) Eligibility for Compounding:

  •  Criteria for entities and individuals eligible to apply for compounding.
  •  Types of contraventions that can be compounded under FEMA.

(iii) Application Process:

  •  Step-by-step process for filing a compounding application with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).
  •  Key documents and information required for the application.

(iv) Authorities Involved:

  •  Role of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in the compounding process.
  •  Jurisdiction and powers of the compounding authorities.

(v) Calculation of Penalties:

  •  Methods and principles used by the RBI to calculate the penalties for various contraventions.
  •  Factors considered in determining the quantum of the penalty.

(vi) Timeline and Procedure:

  •  Expected timelines for the processing of compounding applications.
  •  Detailed procedure followed by the RBI fromreceipt of application to the issuance of compounding orders.

(vii) Common Contraventions and Case Studies:

  •  Discussion of frequently observed contraventions under FEMA, such as delayed reporting of foreign investments and non-compliance with ECB guidelines.
  •  Analysis of recent case studies and RBI orders to understand the practical application of compounding provisions.

(viii) Benefits of Compounding:

  •  Advantages of opting for compounding over litigation, including faster resolution and avoidance of prolonged legal battles.
  •  Impact on the company’s or individual’s compliance record.

(ix) Post-Compounding Compliance:

  •  Obligations and steps to be followed by the applicant post-compounding to ensure full compliance.
  •  Monitoring and reporting requirements after the compounding order is passed.

(x) Practical Challenges and Solutions:

  •  Discussion of practical challenges faced by entities in the compounding process

2. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle meeting on Taxation of LLPs by CA Chirag Wadhwa was held on Tuesday, 30th April, 2024 @Zoom, which was attended by approximately 77 participants, wherein the following was discussed:

1. Concepts of Limited Liability Partnerships

2. Detailed comparison of Company vs. LLP with respect to:

i. Compliance Procedures

ii. Regulatory Requirements

3. Comparison between Firms and LLP’s and FAQ’s relating to the same.

4. Income-tax implications in case of LLPs in respect of:

i. Deduction w.r.t Partner’s remuneration

ii. Carry forward of losses

iii. Assessment of LLPs

iv. Applicability of Alternate Minimum Tax to LLPs

5. Detailed explanation relating to conversion of Partnership Firm to an LLP and conversion of Company along with explanation relating to definition of “Transfer” as per Section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, w.r.t conversion of a Company to an LLP.

The speaker concluded the session by sharingpractical experiences and challenges faced on conversion to LLP and transfer to LLP. The session wasinteractive and gave comprehensive understanding of the topic.

3. “Blood Donation & Organ Donation Awareness Drive” on 25th April, 2024

On Thursday, 25th April, 2024, the BCAS Foundation, jointly with the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development Committee of BCAS, held the annual “Blood Donation Drive”, enlisting the support of Tata Memorial Hospital (TMH) together with a campaign on awareness for organ and skin donation.

National Service Scheme (NSS) students (from Vidyalankar School of Information Technology) were deputed around the vicinity (including Churchgate Station), with placards to create awareness amongst the general public and commuters. Interested would-be donors were escorted to BCAS by the students.

Doctors and technicians from TMH screened 63 potential donors (including 31 brought in by the NSS students) through the detailed questionnaire filled in by them. Contrary to popular belief, patients diagnosed with cholesterol, thyroid, blood pressure issues could also donate blood, provided they met certain criteria. 43 units of blood were collected from eligible donors, which also included the President, Trustee of BCAS Foundation and few Past Presidents, BCAS members and staff.

To create awareness and dispel the myths about organ donation, an “Organ Donation Awareness Drive”, supported by Project Mumbai’s ‘Har Ghar Hai Donor’ initiative was also held. A separate desk was also provided to the Rotaract Club of Bombay North (RCBN) Skin Bank to advocate the noble act of donating skin. RCBN Skin Bank caters to the needs of the National Burns Centre (NBC), amongst others.

Through their noble act, each of the donors BeCame an Asli Superhero!

4. International Economics Study Group — “Analysing current Geopolitical & economic challenges” by CA Harshad Shah held on Monday, 22nd April, 2024 @Zoom which was attended by approximately 24 persons

In a world already embroiled in conflicts, from the volatile landscapes of Ukraine and Gaza to the tense standoff between Iran & Israel, the looming specter of confrontation casts a dark shadow over global stability. As geopolitical tensions escalate, their reverberations echo through international markets. The resulting volatility poses a significant risk, potentially triggering widespread repercussions that could have a ripple effect across economies worldwide. Adding to these geopolitical anxieties are the formidable economic challenges (stubborn inflation & unsustainable debt) confronting the world’s two largest economies, USA and China. Despite these daunting hurdles, financial markets in key regions such as the USA, Europe, Japan & India continue their upward trajectory,scaling unprecedented heights. Meanwhile, India finds itself at a crucial juncture as it navigates through a General Election. With political temperatures soaring, the spotlight is on the election manifestos of major political parties and their potential impacts on the Indian economy.

5. FEMA Study Circle meeting — “Recent updates in FEMA; Case studies in Overseas Investment — Part 1 & 2” by Naisar Shah and moderated by Harshal Bhuta was held on 16th& 22nd April, 2024 @Zoom, which was attended by approximately 111 participants, wherein the following was discussed:

The session was bifurcated into two events on two different dates

– Manner of Receipts and Payments under FEMA

– Direct Listing of Shares in Overseas Markets

– Listing on equity shares in permissible jurisdiction

– FAQs issued by Government

– Direct listing v/s depository receipts?

– Status of an unlisted public company will change upon direct listing

– Minimum public shareholding requirement?

– Resident HNIs investing indirectly?

– NRIs investing through FPI v/s. NRI investing directly

– Investment by Foreign Citizens

– CA valuation permitted even in cases where the book-building process would be done by a merchant banker

– FPI v/s. direct listing

6. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle Meeting on Issues in Real Estate Sector by Group Leader CA Raghavender Kuncharapu and CA Sanket Shah was held on Monday, 22nd April, 2024 @Zoom which was attended by approximately 95 participants

Group leaders had prepared case studies and presentation covering various issues & challenges faced by taxpayers in Real Estate Sector under the GST law. The case studies covered the following aspects for detailed discussion on the following:

  1.  GST Registration
  2. Reversal of Input Tax Credit under Rule 42 in regard to commercial-cum-residential projects
  3.  Reverse Charge Mechanism (80:20 Rule)
  4.  Valuation, Time of Supply and GST Rate in case of RCM on following transaction:

– Transfer of Development Rights under residential redevelopment project

– Transfer of Development Rights by agriculturist

– Development agreement for shopping mall

– Additional FSI / TDR Purchase

– Buy TDS Scrip / Certificate

Participants appreciated the efforts of group leader.

7. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle meeting on Section 9B & Section 45(4) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 by Adv. Shashi Bekal was held on Friday, 12th April 2024 @Zoom, which was attended by approximately 90 participants, wherein the following points were discussed:

  1.  Difference between Partnership Firms and Limited Liability Partnerships.
  2.  Detailed analysis of section 9B of the Act, reason for its introduction, along with various frequently asked questions and his views thereon.
  3.  Detailed analysis and understanding of Section 45(4) of the Act and comparison of the same with the old provision.
  4.  FAQ’s on section 45(4) of the Act, 1961 along with methodology of computing gains as per the said section.
  5.  Interplay between section 9B and Section 45(4) ofthe Act.

The speaker’s thorough analysis of Sections 9B and 45(4) of the Act shed light on various critical aspects, offering valuable insights into their implications. The session provided clarity on the technical intricacies of these provisions and highlights their significance in taxation.

8. RRR – Read, Remember, Renew Yourself held on Saturday, 6th April, 2024 @BCAS

The Human Resources Development Committee organised a Workshop on the topic “RRR – Read Remember Renew Yourself” on 6th April, 2024, which was attended by 36 participants.

Faculty Mr. Pavan Bhattad, taught the techniques of reading and remembering.

The key takeaways from the workshop are given below:

  1.  Hardly one percent people read. If you are in those 1 per cent, it is a great thing.
  2.  Taking a book and going through it is not reading. You should be able to filter what is useful and implement the knowledge you get from the book.
  3.  Through reading we get ready knowledge gained by writers who write in various publications based on their reading, experience, research, experiments, etc. Reading gives you opportunity to grow beyond these writers. For every challenge, aspiration, goal in life there is a book for it.
  4.  Reading purposefully helps us to renew ourselves through implementing the learning from reading.
  5.  Techniques to remember what we read.
  6.  Faster we read the better we understand, still sometimes we are told to read slowly and carefully because it is important. This makes us infer that we have to read slowly, else we will not understand. Faster we read we get the gist.

9. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Case Studies – Interplay Between Income Tax and GST” by CA Gaurav Save and CA Kinjal Bhuta as Group Leaders in two sessions was held on 31st January and 19th March, 2024 at c/o Bathiya & Associates LLP, Andheri (E), which was attended by 10 participants.

The Group Leaders prepared very interesting case-studies through which group had very insightful discussions. They shared their views on the following:

  •  Justification of addition under section 69A.
  •  GST liability on transfer of tenancy right.
  •  Defense strategies for reassessment cases.
  •  Defense against GST mismatch notices, especially regarding NGTP credits.
  •  Inclusion of GST turnover in gross receipts calculation.
  • Applicability of sections 44AD or 44ADA for taxation.
  •  Audit requirement under section 44AB considering practice income and F&O losses.
  •  Availability of GST records to income tax authorities and AO’s access during assessments, etc.

The session was thought-provoking, grounded in real-world application, and comprehensively addressed various perspectives, with plentiful examples drawn from both practical experience and logical reasoning. This approach greatly enhanced the group’s comprehension and engagement with the subject matter.

The session saw lively engagement from the participants, with numerous questions raised and effectively addressed by the group leaders. The interactive nature of the discussion enriched the experience for everyone involved.

10. Half day Seminar on Restructuring of Family Owned Businesses (BCAS jointly with IMC & CTC) held on Friday, 15th March, 2024 @IMC.

First Session: Family-owned Business –Succession / Estate planning (Live case studies) – Including to cover conversion from firm / LLP / Companies – Private Trust etc.

Taxation Committee organised a Half Day Seminar on Restructuring of Family owned businesses at Walchand Hirachand Hall in a hybrid mode.

There was an introduction given by the representatives from all the three organisations.

Moderator CA Anil Sathe started the proceedings after the brief introduction of the panelists. All the three panelists touched upon the brief aspects of the need for restructuring in the family-owned businesses.

CA Sweta Shah explained the various scenarios which the family-owned business groups faces while restructuring for different reasons. She highlighted the reasons beyond tax for such restructurings involving Estate and Succession Planning.

CA Amrish Shah touched upon tax nuances and also the popular structures most organisations adopt in Estate and Succession Planning. Trust as a vehicle was also discussed in detail.

CA Anup Shah explained some of the finer aspects involving corporate and other allied laws. He also explained the situations in case of foreign assets and cross-border issues under FEMA and tax. He also answered queries on HUF and its partition.

Second Session: Restructuring of Businesses – including getting ready for IPO and fund-raising and for that purpose undertaking Merger / Demerger, Slump Sale to carve out core business vs Investments vs separating Brands / Patents, etc. (live Case Studies) In the second session, there were six different case studies which were discussed by the eminent panelists.

All three panelists CA Ketan Dalal, CA Pranav Sayta, and CA Girish Vanvari were very candid in their views on the case studies which involved some real life cases.

They also explained the issues which one can face in case of mergers and demergers without any substantial reason except tax benefit. GAAR and its implications were discussed in detail.

They also emphasised the need for simple structures and avoid complex ones as they can be litigation prone. There
was also a couple of case studies which dealt with cross border mergers and demergers. They explained the implications of reverse mergers and issues arising from them.

Last Session: Family Governance and need for family constitution- Impact on private vs public companies – Binding nature – can it over-ride AOA etc.

Last session was by CA Dinesh Kanabar on the various aspects of Governance of family owned businesses. His presentation was very lucid and covered most of the aspects regarding governance of family owned businesses.

He explained through various examples of both private and public companies the importance of the family constitution and the group abiding by the same.

The entire half-day seminar was well received by both physical and virtual participants. There was an overwhelming response of 200-plus registrations for the same.

This session was chaired by CA Rajan Vora.

11. Full Day Workshop on Bank Audit held on Friday, 15th March, 2024 @BCAS, attended by 52 participants.

(Jointly organised by the Accounting & Auditing & Seminar Committee)

  •  A full-day workshop was conducted to appreciate the intricacies of Central Statutory Audit and how one should approach the same.
  •  There were five sessions concluding with a Panel Discussion.
  •  The first session topic was How to Prepare for a Bank Audit which highlighted key points in audit planning, do’s & don’ts and important reference material.
  •  The second session was on Embracing Digital Transformation in Bank Audits” which highlighted the journey of auditing in digitalised environment.
  •  The third session was on “Verification of Advances” in which critical aspects such as IRAC norms were discussed while auditing bank’s advances.
  •  The fourth session was on “Finalization, Reporting and Practical Challenges for audit for FY 2023-2024“ wherein all critical points and practical challengesfaced by auditors while closing FY24 audits were discussed.
  •  The last session was on “Frauds reporting including NFRA responsibilities” wherein various reporting responsibilities were discussed.
  •  The panel discussion was conducted around changing role of bank audit and expectations from auditors.

Speakers: CA Sandeep Welling, CA Ashutosh Pednekar, CA Vipul Choksi, CA Manish Sampat, CA Priyanka Palav, CA Sushrut Chitale, CA Mukund Chitale, CA Jayant Gokhale, CA Ketan Vikamsey.

Society News

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS

1. Report on the Members’ HRD Study Circle Meeting held on 11th April, 2024

HRD Study Circle organised a lecture meeting which was attended by 142 participants on the topic ‘8 S Model for success guided by Mahabharata and life of Lord Krishna’. Speaker CA Hitendra Gandhi who is a post graduate in comparative Religions & World University drew a parallel between the ancient knowledge system and the present system of business and governance. He explained that the relevance of each ‘S’ in his model with reference to the modern concepts and theories of business and entrepreneurship. He presented a chart as given below explaining the link between ancient knowledge and modern theory.

He narrated several anecdotes from the Mahabharata and life of Lord Shri Krishna that has inspired generations to succeed in their endeavors. In his opinion the bestpart was that if one delves little deeper, each of this anecdote can be directly related to one of the ‘S’ in his model.

The Chairman Mihir Sheth summarised by saying that every Epic cuts through the prism of time. Though all essential components of storytelling such as Content, Characters, Crisis and Conclusion are common, what differentiates Epic from the ordinary tale is its ability to leave its audience with timeless learning from each of the component -not just the predictably mundane conclusion.

2. Women’s Day Celebrations 2024 “Present Positive = Future Ready” on Thursday, 28th March, 2024 at BCAS Hall by Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee

A specially curated evening to celebrate International Women’s Day was organised under the aegis of the SPR&MD Committee. The event attracted a full house of 60+ participants (including some erudite men too).

The evening commenced with high tea for all those gathered. Chairman, CA Uday Sathaye welcomed the audience and touched upon the origin of this day, and the BCAS context for celebrating this event. In a departure from tradition, the First Lady of BCAS, Ms Khushboo Chirag Doshi addressed those gathered, taking them through the many challenges that women have, since times immemorial, bravely weathered and overcome with grit and determination. The discussion with the two speakers, Ms Naz Chougley and Ms Rupal Tejani was moderated by CA Ashwini Chitale and CA Preeti Cherian.

In her presentation, Ms Chougley elaborated on the techniques behind filling one’s life with joy and happiness. She briefed the audience on Ho’oponopono, the Hawaiian practice of reconciliation and forgiveness which aims to bring about healing, understanding, and connection within oneself and with others. She touched upon the importance of concentrating on one’s breath work, focusing on what one wants (rather than on whatone doesn’t), creating intentions by aligning thoughts, feelings and beliefs, expressing gratitude andappreciation. She also spoke of the benefits of practising CTC (cut the crap) and MYOB (mind your own business) when one is being dragged into vibrations which are negative and harmful. During her talk, she led the audience through exercises such as inner child healing and meditation.

Ms Tejani shared her journey of finding her calling, the enterprising streak that she harbours leading her to successfully cultivate saffron bulbs in the climes of Mahabaleshwar! She elaborated on the immense satisfaction she derives from witnessing the cascading benefits of an empowered local community (especially the women folk) that she employs. Her venture has successfully tied up with local farmers and taught them eco-friendly and sustainable practices, resulting in superior quality of produce.

Both speakers deftly handled floor questions during their talk. A round of rapid-fire questions and a contest by Ms Tejani designed to gauge the participants’ understanding of fruits and vegetables raised the level of excitement in the air. The winners were gifted bountiful hampers sponsored by Ms Tejani.

The vote of thanks was proposed by the Second Lady of BCAS, Ms Silky Anand Bathiya. In keeping with the theme, the entire event was aptly captured in the lens of a professional lady photographer. Ms Kanika Nadkarni. As a parting gift, each and every member in the audience left the venue with a box of lush golden berries sourced from Ms Tejani’s farm in Mahbaleshwar.

3. Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Critical Issues under GST” on Wednesday 20th March, 2024 at Bathiya& Associates LLP, Andheri (E)

Suburban Study Circle Meeting on “Critical Issues under GST”, was conducted by CA Payal (Prerna) Shah as a Group Leader, was attended by 10 participants.)

Group Leader CA Payal prepared very thought-provoking case-studies through which the group had veryinsightful discussions. She shared her views on the following:

  •  ITC availment – How does one avail ITC? By recording in books or in return?
  •  ITC reversal and re-availment
  •  Cross-charge
  •  Input Service Distributor vs. Cross-charge.
  •  Classification & interplay of Customs and GST

The session was knowledgeable, practical and all the views were very well covered with numerous examples and reasoning to make it enriching for the group to understand it better.

The session had wonderful interactive participationfrom the group. There were large number of queriesfrom the participants which were addressedsatisfactorily by the group leader. CA Payal’scommand on the subject was well appreciated by the group.

4. Students Study Circle – Bank Branch Audit from article’s perspective held on Wednesday, 20th March, 2024 at Zoom.

The BCAS Students Forum, under the auspices of the HRD Committee, organised an interactive session with students on bank branch audit from an article’s perspective. The session took place on Wednesday, 20th March, 2024, from 6:00 PM to 8:00 PM via Zoom meeting.

The Students Forum invited CA Rishikesh Joshi (Mentor) and Ms Sonal Sodhani (Group Leader) to provide guidance on bank branch audit.

CA Raj Khona, a member of the HRD Committee, along with student volunteers, warmly welcomed the speakers and student participants with their kind words. They also provided briefings about the session.

After that, Group Leader Ms Sonal Sodhanitook over the session and shared her knowledge on the topic, which focused on bank branch audit from an article’s perspective. The session mainly covered key aspects such as planning a bank branch audit, the long form of audit report,returns and certificates, and closing & documentation of data during branch audits. Additionally, Ms Sodhani provided a brief overview of Schedule 9 Advances of Bank Financial Statements. Mentor CA. Rishikesh Joshi guided the student participants between the topics, offering deep insights and knowledge on the audit of bank branches to provide more clarity on important topics.

The Student Volunteers thanked the speakers and attendees for the session. About 400 students were benefited from this session, and their feedback was very positive.

Link to access the session:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3F4P50GJ01M

QR Code:

 

5. Students Study Circle on Income Tax held on Monday, 19th February, 2024 on Zoom platform

Mr Vineet Jain, mentored by CA Sharad Sheth, led discussions on critical aspects of taxation, including Faceless Assessments, Penalty Proceedings, and CIT (A), elucidating the evolving landscape of income tax assessments. The session was attended by approximately 176 participants.

Emphasising strategic utilisation, Vineet demonstrated the application of judicial decisions and case laws for effective tax planning and compliance.

A practical walk through of the Income Tax Portal was provided, enabling participants to adeptly respond to notices and navigate the digital platform.

Dispelling prevalent misconceptions, Vineet addressed myths surrounding tax litigations, ensuring participants were equipped with accurate information.

The webinar, conducted on 19th February, 2024, on Zoom platform from 6 pm to 8 pm, served as a comprehensive guide, offering valuable insights and empowering attendees in the field of taxation.

Link to access the session:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uw8noZxw190

QR Code:

Learning Events at BCAS

1. HR Conclave was held on 16th March, 2024 in Hybrid Mode @ BCAS.

The HR Development Committee orchestrated a highly informative and engaging HR Conclave on Saturday, 16th March, 2024, meticulously designed to unravel the intricacies of managing human resources within professional services firms. This one-day event, offered in a hybrid format, brought together esteemed industry experts and HR practitioners to delve into various facets of HR management. 49 participants from 7 cities participated in the event.

Among the distinguished speakers was Ms. Falguuni Sheth, who kicked off the day with an insightful session titled “Well Chosen is Half Done,” emphasising the strategic underpinnings of HR management and its alignment with organisational objectives. Following this, CA Saroj Maniar and Ms. Priya Sawant shared invaluable perspectives in their session “Courtship cues. Employee engagements that lead to a long-term marriage,” shedding light on practical approaches to bolstering employee engagement and fostering enduring professional relationships.

The conclave also delved into the critical domain of performance appraisals and feedback, with CA Mehul Shah leading a session titled “Appraisals and Feedback – appreciate the strengths, help in bridging the gaps.” This session provided attendees with actionable insights into conducting fair and constructive performance assessments, essential for nurturing employee growth and development. Furthermore, Ms. Deepti Sheth facilitated a thought-provoking discussion on gracefully managing employee exits in her session “Grace in goodbyes – parting need not be painful,” highlighting the significance of maintaining positive relationships even during times of transition.

A panel discussion on “Remote Working – A reality or just another topic for Over the Coffee discussions,” moderated by CA Dhruv Shah and featuring panelists CA Samit Saraf, CA Sushrut Chitale, and CA Mitesh Katira, a comprehensive exploration of the dynamics, challenges, and opportunities associated with remote work in the professional services landscape. Throughout the day, participants were equipped with practical insights, actionable solutions, and e-kits containing over 150 HR templates, enriching their understanding and empowering them to navigate the complex terrain of HR management effectively. As the event concluded, attendees departed with a deeper understanding of strategic HR management, employee engagement, performance evaluation, effective communication strategies, and the nuances of remote working, poised to drive positive change within their respective organisations.

2. Indirect Tax Laws Study Circle on “Classifications in GST” was held on 14th March, 2024 in Online Mode.

Group leader CA Tapas Ruparelia along with mentor CA S S Gupta had prepared case studies and a presentation covering various issues & challenges faced by taxpayers in regard to the Classification under the GST law. Around 45 participants from all over India benefitted while taking an active part in the discussion. The case studies covered the following aspects for a detailed discussion on the place of supply:

1. Whether an assessee can adopt different classifications for the same product under customs and GST? If a particular classification under which goods are cleared with Customs is disputed, can the GST department also insist that the correct classification sought (for which an appeal has been filed with GST authorities) should be applied for GST as well?

2. Whether raw materials, being chemicals for the pharmaceutical sector qualify as “bulk drugs” or “drugs” to decide classification under Schedule I (5 per cent) or Schedule III (18 per cent)?

3. Whether GST on the interest component of EMI on Credit Card loans liable to GST or is exempted, being interest on loans and advances?

4. Whether renting of e-bikes, where charges are levied on a use basis, is classifiable under “rental services of transport vehicles” taxable at the standard rate of 18 per cent or as “leasing or rental service without operators” in which case, the GST Rate applicable to the e-bikes would be applicable to the service?

5. Whether services provided by naturopathy centres qualify as health care services and are eligible for exemption?

3. The Webinar on “Recent CBDT Circulars in relation to Charitable Trusts and Institutions” was held on 9th March, 2024 in Online Mode.

The Taxation Committee organised a Webinar on Recent CBDT Circulars in relation to Charitable Trusts and Institutions.

CA Ashok Mehta broadly explained the two CBDT critical Circulars in relation to Charitable Trusts and Institutions-

(1) Circular No. 2/2024, dated 5th March, 2024

(2) Circular No. 3/2024, dated 6th March, 2024

The Speaker highlighted the fact that the CBDT has observed instances where trusts and institutions submitted the wrong audit report form (Form No. 10B or 10BB) for the A.Y. 2023-24. To address this, the CBDT has granted an extension for corrective measures. If a trust or institution has submitted Form No. 10B where Form No. 10BB was applicable, or vice versa, on or before 31st October, 2023, the trust is now permitted to rectify this by submitting the correct audit report in the applicable Form No. 10B or 10BB for the A.Y. 2023-24 on or before March 31, 2024.

The Speaker welcomed the Clarificatory Circular No.3/2024 dated 6th March, 2024 pertaining to inter-trust donations which allows the entire donation to be treated as an application of income and not restricted to only 85 per cent of the donation given.

Link to access the session: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SkbpXjcXFeI&t=2s

 

4. The Human Resource Development Committee organised “CA Pariksha Pe Charcha” on 2nd March, 2024 in Online Mode.

The event, “CA Pariksha Pe Charcha,” organised by the BCAS Human Resource Development Committee, was a two-hour session held via Zoom, focusing on strategies for success in CA examinations and dealing with failures. The event aimed to guide CA aspirants and provide them with the motivation and tactics needed to excel in their exams.

CA Pritam Mahure led the first hour with a talk on how to achieve success in CA Exams and cope with failures, sharing insights and practical advice.

The second hour featured a panel discussion with Chartered Accountants who have achieved top ranks in recent CA exams. They discussed their experiences, study techniques, and personal journeys.

The interactive session provided attendees with an opportunity to gain valuable knowledge and ask questions about the CA exam process.

Panelists:

CA Akshay Jain (AIR 1 May 2023)

CA Kalpesh Jain (AIR 2 May 2023)

CA Sanskruti Parolia (AIR 2 Nov 2023)

CA Shruti Parolia (AIR 8 Nov 2023)

Moderator: CA Kartik Srinivasan

Link to access the session: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMRGAm8Je4c&t=3s

5. A Panel Discussion “Future Ready Finance Professionals” was held on 1st March, 2024 @ JBIMS Auditorium.

The HRD Committee, in collaboration with Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of Management Studies (JBIMS), organised a discussion on “Future Ready Finance Professionals” on 1st March, 2024 at the JBIMS Auditorium. The event featured a distinguished panel of CFOs from various esteemed organisations, which comprised of CA Sajal Gupta from Rustomjee Group, CA Pinky Mehta from Aditya Birla Capital, Mr. Ramesh Subramanyam from Hinduja Group, and CA NaozodSirwalla from HDFC AMC Ltd, moderated by Dr. CA. Sahrdul Shah. The discussion provided profound insights into the multifaceted responsibilities of CFOs in contemporary business environments.

The panel emphasised the strategic orientation increasingly demanded of CFOs, underscoring the imperative for Chartered Accountants to lead with foresight and agility. Addressing a diverse array of topics, including technological innovation, ethical governance, and sustainability, the panel highlighted the critical role Chartered Accountants play in driving organisational success through astute financial stewardship.

Emphasising the indispensable nature of continuous learning and adaptation, the discussion urged Chartered Accountants to remain abreast of technological advancements and emerging trends. Moreover, it stressed the significance of ethical integrity and professional responsibility in upholding the highest standards of financial practice.

With a focus on preparing Chartered Accountants to navigate the complexities of the modern business landscape, the event served as a platform for knowledge exchange and networking, empowering finance professionals to chart a course toward future readiness.

In summary, the event provided invaluable insights into the evolving role of Chartered Accountants as strategic partners in organisational growth and sustainability. Through collaborative dialogue and shared expertise, the panel reaffirmed the indispensable contributions of Chartered Accountants to the finance profession and underscored their pivotal role in shaping a prosperous future.

6. Direct Tax Laws Study Circle meeting was held on 1st March, 2024 in Online Mode.

CA Manish Dafria covered the newly introduced Section 43B(h) of the Income Tax Act; 1961 (“the Act”)– Analysis and Impact, wherein the speaker provided his perspective and a detailed analysis and shed light on its various aspects as indicated below:

1. The conditions laid down for the applicability of Section 43B(h) of the Act.

2. Classification of enterprises based on the definitions mentioned in the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (MSMED Act).

3. Time limit as mentioned in Section 15 of the MSMED Act and with the relevant definitions.

4. Clarifications to issues namely:

i. Whether the amount payable to enterprises on account of Capital Expenditure would attract disallowance u/s 43B(h) of the Act.

ii. Whether amounts payable to traders / retailers would attract disallowance u/s 43B(h) of the Act.

iii. Applicability of 43B(h) to charitable organisations for determining “Application of Income”.

iv. Whether the GST component of the expenditure would be included in the amount to be disallowed u/s 43B(h) of the Act.

v. Whether 43B(h) would apply to assessees opting for declaring presumptive income u/s 44AD of the Act.

7. The 21st Leadership Camp “Empowering Relationship” was held on 16th–18th February, 2024 @ Leslie Sawhney Training Centre, Devlali by the Human Resource Development Committee.

The 21st Leadership camp on the topic, ‘Empowering Relationship’ was held at Leslie Sawhney Training Centre at Devlali between 16th and 18th February, 2024. Twenty-three participants which included 7 couples and 9 individuals participated in the programme.

The Trainers: Dr. Sudarshan Iyengar (Retired Vice Chancellor of Gujarat University) and Dr. Ashwin Zalathe, guide and mentors.

In his introductory remarks, the Chief Administrator of the venue, Major General (Retd) Pithawalla shared the real-life experience from his days in the Army. He emphasised that in the Military, as a leader one has to empower the relations with the team as dependability is one of the most critical criteria looked upon in every team member.

Important takeaways to empower the relationship are summarised here.

  • Complete attention to the person not just hearing but listening to him
  • Introspection and reflection: Introspect as to what happened and how one can improve the relations. Express unconditional love.
  • In any interaction conflict is bound to be there. Expectation and attachment result in a gap in relations.
  • Express gratitude to all you interact with including five elements of the Universe.
  • Understand the reasons that bring conflict and neutralise them with opposites. Fourteen reasons for conflict were identified. For instance one of the reasons for conflict is selfishness then neutralising it by unconditional love.
  • Other important concepts discussed were Attitude (values), behaviour (attitude in action) and situation (context) in relations and conflicts.
  • Learn to appreciate yourself through your words and actions. A Word without money is cheap, but money without a word is vulgar.

In the concluding session, questions were raised as to whether conflict is necessary. And the views echoed the sentiment that conflicts could be appropriate for understanding of the matter. One can always channelise the conflict into the opportunity for growth, love, and respect.

The camp concluded with a Vote of thanks and thrilling real life story of his war experience by Major General (Retd.) Cyrus Pithawalla about how the empowered relationship between the army teammates helped avert the major terror attack on India despite almost fatal injuries.

Learning Events at BCAS

LEARNING EVENTS AT BCAS

1. The webinar on “The (AI)mazing Future of CA Services: Guide to AI & Chat GPT Implementation” conducted by the Technology Initiatives Committee was held on 17th February, 2024, in Online Mode.

The webinar was conducted to provide Chartered Accountants and their teams with invaluable insights into the successful integration of AI in accounting, data analysis, auditing and more.

It began with CA Dungarchand C Jain explaining to the participants the features of ChatGPT — how it works, comparative analysis of GPT-3.5 (free) and GPT-4 (paid) versions, etc. He also explained the limitations of ChatGPT, how to write prompts and additional plugins. The live demonstration of queries posted to ChatGPT and how it could be used for day-to-day operations by a CA firm was well appreciated by the participants.

In the second part, CA Nikunj Shah explained the use of ChatGPT for data analysis, including, trend identification, and anomaly detection, to derive actionable insights from financial data. He further emphasised that AI-driven audit technologies can automate compliance checks, identify potential risks and enhance the accuracy and reliability of audit procedures.

Both the speakers are members of the Technology Initiatives Committee.

The webinar had 235+ participants from more than 40 cities. The webinar ended with a well-deserved vote of thanks to the speakers and all the participants.

2. The workshop on “GST Skilling up – Writing, Responding and Representing” was held on 9th and 16th February, 2024 @ BCAS.

An impressive two-and-a-half-day physical workshop with faculties CA Raman Jokhakar and CA Tejal Mehta was designed to provide practical experience in drafting and representation skills. There were about 35 participants.

The speakers explained how to draft letters / replies / emails in short without using long sentences and being repetitive and using plain and simple language so that what is desired to be conveyed is properly conveyed. They also explained to the participants the dos and don’ts of appearing before a Revenue Officer and how to make their representation impactful.

It also included a mock Role Play where the participants were required to prepare a reply to a Show Cause Notice / ASMT-10 notice and represent their case before a Revenue Officer. At the end of this, the mistakes or shortcomings in their drafting / representation were explained, and how best they could have been avoided.

The participants were issued a Certificate for participating in the workshop.

The faculties were ably supported by CA Vikram Mehta and Shannel Jacinto.

3. Indirect Tax Study Circle Meeting on “GST Case Studies on Place of Supply” was held on 15th February, 2024, in Online Mode.

Group leader CA Rishabh Mishra dealt with the case studies and gave a presentation covering various issues and challenges faced by taxpayers in regard to the Place of Supply under the GST law and was guided by Group Mentor CA Jigar Doshi. The case studies covered the following aspects for a detailed discussion on the place of supply:

  • Separate contracts for the supply of materials and supply of allied services like transportation, insurance, etc., including issues due to cross-fall breach clauses.
  • Testing services in relation to goods sent to India by overseas entities with options of sending the goods back or kept in India. Testing of pre-designed software for holding co. was also discussed.
  • Services of soliciting subscribers to the issue of securities by overseas managers for Indian entities.
  • Place of supply in relation to immovable property in India to a service recipient outside India for the development of 3D models.
  • Turnkey project for design, development, construction, supply, and installation of plant, machines, solar power, packing lines, residential quarters, canteen, guest house, etc.
  • Services of conducting a market survey, assistance in marketing events, advertising policy, appointment of distributors, etc., on cost-plus basis by an Indian Subsidiary to a Foreign Holding company.
  • Works contract services provided by an Indian entity to a foreign entity in a foreign land through outsourcing to another Indian entity with the foreign branch.

4. Felicitation of Young CAs of November 2023 Examination & Fireside Chat on the topic “Get Future Ready” was held on 20th January, 2024, at the BCAS Hall by the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee.

A special event was organised for the freshly qualified Chartered Accountants of the November 2023 examination under the aegis of the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee. The event attracted a full house of 150 participants.

The evening commenced with the esteemed speakers addressing the young champions on the subject, ‘Get Future Ready’. The first speaker, Past President of the BCAS, CA Ameet Patel candidly shared his views on a wide range of subjects — how to find the right fit in the initial years, the steps one can take to build on and solidify one’s repertoire, how it’s ok to change tracks if things are not working out, the very critical role that BCAS can play in shaping one’s future, and the importance of networking, developing a hobby, cultivating a passion, etc.

The second speaker, Ms. Dipika Singh spoke about the significance of investing in oneself, owning the room, projecting the right body language, radiating confidence, creating interesting content and posting it on the right platforms, getting noticed in a crowd and creating and nurturing a brand within oneself.

This was then followed by an interesting round of floor questions for both speakers. The evening ended with the felicitation ceremony. Labdhi Sanghvi securing All India Rank 47 was the first to be felicitated and was then invited to share his thoughts. The event showcased the vibrancy of the participants, many of whom showed great interest in signing up to be members of the BCAS.

Link to access the session: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U4jUpZ0X4OY&t=870s

5. Full Day Seminar on “Charitable Trusts – A Tax, Regulatory & Management Perspective” held on Friday, 19th January, 2024 @ BCAS

The successful full-day event commenced with a compelling keynote address by Shri C V Pavana Kumar, CIT (Exemptions) Mumbai, setting the tone for the day by addressing the pivotal role of Charitable Trusts in India in societal development, the Department’s technology and tax initiatives, the relevance and context of the recent changes in the tax regime relating to Charitable Trusts, and the importance of navigating the associated challenges by learned professionals and assessee.

It was followed by a power-packed Panel Discussion by CA Anil Sathe, and Mr. Noshir Dadrawala, CA (Dr.) Gautam Shah, moderated by CA Gaurav Save. The session not only provided a practical approach to the Litigation issues regarding Charitable / religious Trusts, but also provided a comprehensive overview of common errors encountered in ITR-7 filings and shed light on challenges pertaining to sections 10B, 10BB and FCRA compliance.

Thereafter, CA Suresh Kejriwal took the participants through the recent amendments to the Foreign Contribution Regulations Act, posing additional cautious compliance responsibilities.

CA (Dr.) Gautam Shah enlightened the gathering about the procedural requirements under the Maharashtra Public Charitable Trusts law and also talked about patiently dealing with the Charity Commissioner’s office.

The participants also benefitted from a comprehensive presentation on the emerging concept of Social Stock Exchange by Mr. Hemant Gupta. He discussed the nitty-gritty, emphasising how this platform can be a game-changer for charitable organizations, providing a new dimension to fundraising and visibility.

The same was followed by an enriching session by Mr. Noshir Dadrawala on Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) compliance. He coined the mantra “Comply Strictly (by) Rules”, emphasising compliance with CSR provisions and highlighting the far-reaching implications of non-compliance.

The event concluded with an informative presentation by CA Deven B Shah on the maintenance of Books of Accounts by Charitable Organizations in accordance with Rule 17AA of Income Tax Rules, well-equipping the participants with the vital, differentiating aspects thereof.

Each session suitably dealt with and addressed the queries of the participants.

This event was a collaborative effort to empower the charitable sector, offering a holistic perspective on navigating the legal, tax and management intricacies associated with Charitable Organizations in India. We extend our gratitude to all participants, speakers and organizers for contributing to the success of this enriching and informative day.

6. Corporate & Commercial Law Study Circle Meeting “SBO and Demat of securities – Need of the hour” was held on 16th January, 2024, in Online Mode.

Speaker CS Sudhakar Saraswatula addressed the participants on the provisions relating to Significant Beneficial Ownership, as have been notified for Limited Liability Partnerships. He further discussed the inception and rationale behind the SBO provisions and the compliance requirements thereof. Certain challenges faced in the implementation of SBO provisions and its practical approach were also shared.

The discussion further shaped to how private companies other than small companies are also now mandated with the compulsory dematerialisation of securities within the given time frame, along with other related matters such as the holding of securities by the promoters of / issue of securities by unlisted public companies, conversion of share warrants held in physical form, action points for demat of securities by private companies as well as security holders and penal provisions for non-compliance.

7. आDaan-प्रDaan (Season 3) — “Speed mentoring program for Chartered Accountants” was held by the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee in Online Mode.

Conducted during November and December, the program provided a platform for invaluable guidance and support from 25 mentors, where an impressive 28 mentees engaged in the first round of season 3 — with 17 hailing from 10 different states across India, showcasing the program’s ability to transcend geographical boundaries and empower CAs nationwide.

Throughout the sessions, mentees delved into various aspects of professional life, seeking insights on practice management, people management, growth strategies, guidance for changing careers, essential skill acquisitions, etc. Mentors, drawn from a rich tapestry of practicing Chartered Accountants and industry stalwarts, offered guidance tailored to the mentees’ aspirations and challenges, enabling mentees to navigate critical decision points with confidence and clarity.

The heartwarming display of gratitude through generous donations to the BCAS Foundation by the mentees exemplified the tradition of Guru Dakshina, reinforcing the bond between mentors and mentees in the CA community.

With heartfelt appreciation extended to all participants and mentors, the ‘आDaan-प्रDaan’ initiative continues to pave the way for growth, excellence and collaboration within the profession. The Committee is planning to conduct the second round of season 3 shortly.

Society News

Human Development Study Circle Meeting on
“Business Environment in India – Evolution, Opportunities, Challenges” held on
10th January, 2017

Human Development and Technology Initiatives Committee  (HDTI) of BCAS conducted a Human Development
Study Circle Meeting on “Business Environment in India – Evolution,
Opportunities, and Challenges” on 10th January, 2017 at BCAS
Conference Hall. 

Dr. Anil Naik, a Management Consultant, MBA from IIM Calcutta
and winner of many prestigious awards, having wide experience in Industry and
also visiting faculty at top Management Institutes in India and Abroad, gave
the presentation and covered the following topics- .

1.  Evolution of Business Environment in India
since 1991.

2.  Challenges of the Indian businesses to be seen
for :

• Family Owned & Family Managed Businesses

• Family Owned Professionally Managed Businesses

• Corporate Sector consisting of Indian
Companies, Foreign Companies operating in India and Collaborations of Indian
& Foreign Companies.

3.  He also cited the examples of companies
operating in India like Tata Motors, Kodak, Shapoorji Pallonji, Ballarpur
Industries and Kirloskar, etc.

The major basic issues discussed were:

·        
Major changes in Transportation Industry and
many others.

·        
Factors for success i.e. Adaptability to new
technology, Personality Skills, Pursuing Aspirations etc.

·     Stark realities of dynamic environment – No more
secrets, security is uncertain, Allegiance, Time is short – we need to run fast
to take up right opportunities at right time at great speed, Order of today’s
time is not clear – international business, supremacy of product plays vital
role.

·    India has 16 cultures. Cultural Differences.
Internal Culture of the organisation matters. Asian culture v Globalised
scenario. Adopting right mix of culture is challenge of today’s times.

·        
Business environment is Dynamic, turbulent and
unstable. How to become flexible. Opportunities for organic flexibility,
adaptability, innovation, accepting change and uncertainty are natural state of
things in the current environment.

·        
Ensure that institutions have capacity to serve.
Employees’ skills, motivation and capabilities play an important role.

Inescapable reality of new economy – 1) Seek and create
breakthrough changes. 2) Outsiders see it first 3) Right balance between
incremental improvement and radical innovation 3) Shortage of resources is not
necessarily serious, but shortage of imagination is certainly fatal 4) Nothing
lasts forever under its original momentum 5) Success contains the seed of its
own destruction 6) Primary challenge of leadership today is to create adaptive
organisation which has a built in capability to renew itself over and over
again.

The meeting was very fruitful and the participants benefitted
a lot from the Speaker’s rich experience.

Workshop on Merger & Acquisition held on 27th & 28th
January 2017

Corporate & Allied Laws Committee [‘C&ALC’] organised
a two days’ Workshop on Mergers & Acquisition at Hotel St. Regis, Lower
Parel, Mumbai. The event received an overwhelming response.

86 participants attended the workshop out of which almost 30
participants were from industry. Further, around 32 were outstation
Participants from cities like Ahmedabad, Vadodara, Hyderabad, Chennai and
Nagpur.

CA. Chetan Shah, President, welcomed the participants. CA.
Kanu S. Chokshi, Chairman of C&ALC gave a brief idea on the necessity of
such programme.

The Workshop was inaugurated by Dr. Lalit Kanodia, Chairman,
Datamatics Group. Eminent faculties addressed the participants on the relevant
topics along with their presentations. A 
booklet of the presentations made by various speakers at the workshop was
provided to the participants.  The event
was conceptualised by CA. Naushad Panjwani, Past President of BCAS, with the
help of Dr. Anup Shah. CA. Naushad Panjwani also shared his thoughts on certain
mergers at the said workshop. Advocate Praveen Veera chaired the session on
‘Stamp duty’ and CA. Shrenik Baid shared the dais along with CA. Kanu S.
Chokshi during the session on ‘Accounting Implications’.

The sessions of the said workshop on Merger & Acquisition
are summarised below:

Session I: Keynote Address – “Key negotiating
techniques used by buyers and sellers in a Merger & Acquisition
transaction” by Dr.Lalit Kanodia – Chairman, Datamatics Group
.

Dr. Lalit Kanodia

He inaugurated the workshop and shared his practical
experiences in Merger and acquisition.

Session II: Alternative Disputes Resolution in
Merger & Acquisition by CA. Suresh Kotak –Chairman, Kotak Group.


CA. Suresh Kotak

He addressed the participants.& talked about steps taken
in area of ADR

Session III: Stamp Duty by Dr. Anup Shah, CA.
Pravin P. Shah & Co.

 

CA. Anup P. Shah

He covered various implications of  stamp duty under different modes of mergers
& acquisition. He also analysed stamp duty on CD, Debentures, Gift etc.

Session IV: Companies Act & Bankruptcy Law by
Adv. Sharad Abhyankar – Sr. Partner, Khaitan & Co.
 

Adv. Sharad Abhyankar

He analysed
transaction charges, some of the procedural aspects and gave a mapping in
Merger & Acquisition. He also gave an overview of Insolvency and bankruptcy
code in relation to Merger & Acquisition.

Session V: SEBI Takeover Regulations by Adv. Akil Hirani –
Managing Partner, Majumdar & Co.


Adv. Akil Hirani

He took the participants through takeover code and insider
trading regulations with respect to, an open offer, in case of Merger &
Acquisition.

Session VI: Legal Due Diligence by Adv. Tushar Ajinkya.

Adv.Tushar Ajinkya

He highlighted the Due Diligence aspects with the typical
structure requirement, key areas to be checked, IPR and litigation issues.

Session VII: Financial due Diligence by CA. Rajesh
Khairajani – KNAV.


CA. Rajesh Khairajani

He touched upon various facets of financial due diligence on
both, buyer and seller side, inter alia, emphasising upon physical verification
of assets in  Merger & Acquisition
deal.

Session VIII: FEMA & Cross Border by CA. T. P. Ostwal,
T. P. Ostwal & Associates.


CA.T. P. Ostwal

He explained salient
features of various treaties of India & Mauritius /Cyprus/Switzerland; and
choice of jurisdiction. He also took 
participants through Automatic route vis-à-vis Approval route;

Session IX: Strategy & Value Creation by
Mr. Sudhir Valia – Executive Director, Sun Pharma.


Mr. Sudhir Valia

He shared his rich experience  in guiding participants as to how to proceed
for Merger & Acquisition.

Session X: Income Tax-Domestic/ International (in case of
cross border) by
CA. Hiten Kotak & CA. Falguni Shah.


CA. Hiten Kotak


CA. Falguni Shah

The speakers explained the funding structures – Key
consideration, recapitalisation and repatriation and indirect transfer and tax
thereon with practical examples.

Session XI: Accounting
Implications by CA. Himanshu Kishnadwala, CNK & Associates.


CA. Himanshu Kishnadwala

He gave an overview of provisions relating to M & A
contained in Companies Act 2013 and SEBI Regulations. He also dealt with the
applicability of Accounting Standard and Ind AS to Merger & Acquisition and
explained Accounting in Merger & Acquisition with an illustration.

Session XII: A typical Merger & Acquisition
process by CA. Sridhar Swamy
.

CA. Sridhar Swamy

He explained the nitty-gritty of the Merger & Acquisition
process including identification and understanding buyer, process documents and
presentation to the Management. He also briefly explained legal documentation
in Merger & Acquisition.

Session XIII: Post Merger Integration by CA. Mitil
Chokshi.


CA. Mitil Chokshi

He drew attention of the participants to the difficulties
faced in integration Post Merger, some of the important factors peculiar to
each industry which could result in a possible threat to success of a Merger
& Acquisition deal. He also shared his experience regarding solution on
some of difficulties in Merger & Acquisition deals handled by him.

CA. Manish Reshamawala, Convener, with his untiring efforts
coordinated the programme with the support of CA. Preeti Oza, Convener. The
participants benefitted from the rich experience of the Speakers.

Experts chat @ bcas on “Internal audit 2017: global trends
and outlook” held on 30th January, 2017

An experts chat on “Internal Audit: Global Trends and
Outlook” was held at the BCAS Conference Hall on 30th January, 2017.

The program commenced with the signing of a Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU) between BCAS and the Institute of Internal Auditors –
Bombay Chapter (IIABC). This MOU will enable BCAS and IIABC to jointly
collaborate and develop mutually beneficial programs in the field of internal
audit, projects and activities for its members in the field of internal audit,
as well as to offer members of both parties to attend programs of each other.

President CA. Chetan Shah,
on behalf of BCAS and President CA. Sunil Gaitonde, on behalf of the Institute
of Internal Auditors – Bombay Chapter (IIABC) did the honours.

President CA. Chetan Shah then welcomed Mr. Richard F.
Chambers, the President and Chief Executive Officer of The Institute of
Internal Auditors (IIA), the global professional association and
standard-setting body for internal auditors. The IIA serves more than 1, 85,000
members in over 170 countries and territories and is the internal audit
profession’s most widely recognised advocate, educator, and provider of
standards, guidance, and certifications.

L to R : Mr. Richard F. Chambers in the fireside chat with CA. Nandita Parekh

Mr. Chambers made a detailed presentation on the emerging
trends in internal audit, more particularly, the reporting structure, critical
focus areas, need to understand the audit culture of the organisation,
cyberspace audit, audit of big data. His talk was generously interspersed with
interesting statistics and results of survey done by Internal Audit Foundation,
across various continents and organisations.

Mr. Chambers shared a list of five strategies for every
internal auditor to equip himself with:

·        
Respond to the voice of the customer

·        
Strive for agility

·        
Transform your talents

·        
Revolutionise your processes

·        
Elevate your image’

Mr. Chambers’ presentation was followed by an engaging
fireside chat, which was moderated by CA Nandita Parekh, a senior member of the
Core group with expertise in the area of internal audit.

Mr. Chambers candidly answered questions on matters including
how to earn a seat at the (management) table, need for an internal auditor to
adjust the sails (i.e. the audit scope) to steer through the external and
internal changes, etc.

Questions posed by participants were also answered by Mr.
Chambers.  

The event witnessed an impressive turnout and was also
available for viewing through live streaming. The live streaming facility was
made available to members of IIA and IIABC.

“Public Lecture Meeting on Direct Tax Provisions of the
Finance Bill 2017” held on 7th February, 2017

The 52nd Lecture Meeting of the Society on the
Direct Tax Provisions of the Finance Bill 2017 by Senior Advocate Shri S.E.
Dastur was held at Yogi Sabhagruha, Dadar. This was 29th consecutive
year of address by Shri. S. E. Dastur.

Mr. S. E. Dastur (Speaker)

The lecture meeting was streamed live and was witnessed by
more than 15,000 persons including online viewers. President CA. Chetan Shah
welcomed and introduced the speaker Shri S. E. Dastur citing that his
intellectual charm is what makes this session special. He Shah also touched
upon the concept of liberalisation and digital revolution.

Shri Dastur started his speech by detailing the memories of
the previous budgets since 1948-49. He talked about the Finance Minister’s
speech having laid emphasis on the digital economy. He discussed the various
new insertions in areas of capital gains, changes in assessment and
reassessment procedures. He also explained the concept of primary and secondary
adjustment under transfer pricing.

After covering all significant provisions the eminent speaker
dealt with other amendments. He also covered provisions under the Companies Act
and Accounting Standards, the taxability of carbon credits. He commented on the
amendments to the Search provisions under section 132.

The audience was spell bound by his speech. His lucid
analysis of the provisions benefitted all those who witnessed his presentation.
The meeting ended with a huge round of applause and appreciation by the
participants.

FEMA Study Circle Meeting held on 8th February,
2017

FEMA Study Circle Meeting was held on the topic of
“Investment by Foreign Venture Capital Investor (FVCI) and in Real Estate
Investment Trust (REIT)” on 8th February, 2017 at BCAS Conference
Hall. The meeting was chaired by CA Shabbir Motorwala and led by CA Amit Dhoot,
CA. Monica Wadhwa and CA. Rashmi Shetty. It was great to have such
knowledgeable bench of leaders.

The speakers took participants not only through important
FEMA provisions applicable to Investment by FVCI and REIT but also issues
related to structuring, SEBI registration, important conditions etc.
which gave participants a 360 degree perspective of the subject. They also
explained the advantage of FVCI over FDI.

For investment in REIT, the speaker explained the challenges
why REIT is not yet picking up pace in India and how can India learn from other
countries.

The chairman shared his practical experience which was an
icing on the cake!

CPR workshop with medical camp held on 11th February, 2017

CPR (Cardio Pulmonary Resuscitation) training workshop with
medical camp was held jointly with Asian Heart Institute ( which stood as the
‘India’s Best Private Cardiac Hospital’ for two years in a row) on 11th
February, 2017 at BCAS conference Hall. Around 65 participants including members
and their families availed benefit of the workshop. The medical camp covered
the health checkup for random blood sugar, blood pressure, ECG and consultation
by doctor from Asian Heart Institute.


Participants in the CPR Workshop

The doctors conducted CPR workshop for the participants
enrolled and provided practical training for CPR in case of medical emergency
arising out of cardiac arrest which was very useful for understanding the
subject.

The doctors involved in the workshop were experts in their
field which helped in conducting the workshop successfully.

Report on Three Days 7th Residential Study Course
(RSC) on IndAS held on 16th -18th February, 2017

IndAS is being implemented in India in phases. FY 2016-17 is
the first year of applicability for phase I companies with comparatives for FY
2015-16. Several challenges are being faced by companies in this implementation
effort, more particularly on fair value, financial instruments, business
combinations and so on.

BCAS has always been in the forefront to assist professionals
to face challenges and be equip them to implement such changes. The 7th
BCAS IndAS Residential Study Course was planned by the Accounting and Auditing
Committee to address the implementation challenges being faced as well as to
impart knowledge of implementing IndAS to the professionals to have a smooth
transition for the corporate sector.

The RSC was organised from 16th to 18th
February, 2017 at Ras Resorts, Silvassa. This year’s RSC was structured with
three sessions based on case studies prepared by three eminent professionals
covering different aspects of IndAS implementation. These case studies based
papers involved group discussions through three groups formed amongst the
participants, led by knowledgeable group leaders. There were two more papers
for presentation by eminent faculty which were on other accounting standards
applicable to corporate and non-corporate entities viz. Accounting Standards
for non-IndAS companies and ICDS vs. IndAS. Another unique feature of this
year’s RSC was a Panel Discussion on Ind AS 109 – Financial Instruments –
Implementation Issues.

Immediately after the reporting of the delegates in the
morning, there was a group discussion on the first paper by CA. Arvind Daga on
“Case Studies on Business Combinations/Consolidation”. The case studies were
highlighting the various complexities involved in carrying out accounting for
business combinations and consolidation as well as the evaluation of the
relevant consolidation standard in specific circumstances.

CA. Arvind Daga

Later, post lunch, there was the inaugural session. The
session commenced with the inaugural address by the President of BCAS, CA.
Chetan Shah. He conveyed his satisfaction about the response received to the
course from all over India and was particularly happy to have a strong
participation from industry. Later, the Chairman of the Committee CA. Himanshu
Kishnadwala gave introductory remarks on the design and structure of the course
and the purpose of selection of the topics for group discussion as well as
presentation and panel discussion.

CA. Paresh Clerk

Immediately after the inaugural session, there was the
presentation on the first paper by CA. Arvind Daga, who aptly dealt with the
case studies and also covered the issues raised during the group discussion in
very immaculate manner. Thereafter, CA. Paresh Clerk took the participants
through a Presentation paper on “Accounting Standards for Non-IndAS Companies”,
where he dealt with the major changes in some of the standards to bring them
ont par with IndAS for recognition and measurement.

CA. Anand Subramanian

Second day started with group discussion on paper by  CA. Anand Subramanian on “Case Studies on
Real Estate/Infrastructure Companies”. The case studies highlighted the
intricate issues arising from Service Concession Arrangements as well as
Construction Contracts which is of utmost importance for recognition of revenue
for such companies. Later, he, made a presentation on his paper and shared his
vast experience, which was of immense value to the participants.


CA. Sudhir Soni

Post lunch there was group discussion on paper by CA. Sudhir
Soni on “Case Studies on Revenue Recognition – Impact on Different Sectors”.
The case studies dealt with typical situations in retail and pharma sectors and
also some other related issues.

During the evening at the request of BCAS, the newly elected
President of ICAI, CA. Nilesh Vikamsey addressed the participants’ through
skype, as,  though he would have wished
to, time constraints did not make it feasible for him to be physically present.
The three way Skype call wherein CA. Nilesh Vikamsey, President of BCAS CA.
Chetan Shah and the participants participated live was the first such effort by
BCAS. CA. Chetan Shah welcomed CA. Nilesh Vikamsey and CA. Himanshu Kishnadwala
also updated him about the conference. Later, CA. Nilesh Vikamsey addressed the
participants and briefed them about some IndAS implementation issues and how
ICAI is addressing them.

He also updated the participants regarding the efforts of
ICAI to be partners in nation building and also commended BCAS for its
activities which are complementing the efforts of ICAI towards the profession.

In the evening, there was a brief and crisp presentation on
the case studies by CA. Sudhir Soni which also provided expert insights to the
case studies.


CA. Gautam B. Doshi

Last day commenced with a Presentation on “ICDS Vs IndAS” by
CA. Gautam Doshi. In his immaculate style he provided bird’s eye view of the
major differences between ICDS and IndAS. Though not included in the original
schedule, at the request of the organisers, he also dealt with the impact of
MAT on IndAS financials on the basis of the proposed amendments to Income Tax
Act as per Budget 2017 for corporate preparing IndAS financials for the FY
2016-17.

Last session was a unique one, introduced for the first time
in IndAS RSC, which was Panel discussion on “IndAS 109- Financial Instruments –
Implementation Issues”. The panelists were CA. Gautam Doshi and CA. Charanjit
Attra. The discussion was ably moderated by Ashutosh Pednekar. The session was
appreciated by many participants as the posers which were discussed were very
relevant for banking, finance as well as insurance companies.

The concluding session was presided over by CA. Himanshu
Kishnadwala and he acknowledged contribution of the faculty as well as active
participation of all for the success of the RSC. Some of the participants gave
their views on the course and conveyed their satisfaction at the format and
structure of the course.

Interactive Session with Students for Success in CA Exams
held on 18th February, 2017

HDTI committee jointly with Rajasthan Vidhyarthi Gruh (RVG
Hostel) organised half day programme for students on 18th February
2017 at RVG Hostel, Andheri. Joint Secretary Sunil Gabhawalla welcomed the
participants.

 

L to R: CA. Sunil Gabhawalla, CA. Mukesh Trivedi and CA. Srinivas Joshi

In the first session, CA. Srinivas Joshi discussed about ICAI
Exams with the help of PowerPoint presentation, which included expectation from
students’ and their performance. Being past Central Council member of ICAI, and
having vast first-hand experience as a Member of Examination committee, he
shared in detail, information with insights as to how ICAI exams are conducted,
how confidentiality and professionalism is maintained, what quality and level
of knowledge is expected from students, balanced, consistent and 100 percent
advance study, writing habit, group discussion, problems solving, overcoming
and controlling time wasters, etc. were important guidance factors.

He also guided students on various important topics viz. how
to study, prepare, plan and manage time before the exams, how to actually write
papers, how to ensure success while writing papers and many other important
issues. Students received his presentation very well. Many doubts and incorrect
impressions were cleared.

Second session commenced with personal experience and tips
shared by three successful CAs. Piyush Lohia, Chinmay Dharap and Harshal Gupta
passing with 2nd, 5th and 34th rank
respectively in final exam of ICAI.

Young CA. Mudit Yadav, a success coach, TEDx speaker and a
motivator shared his personal journey from ordinary school and college career
to qualified CA effectively, with emotions and humour. He encouraged all students
to appear and prepare for CA exams with mindset, resolution and planning.

Convenor CA. Mukesh Trivedi proposed vote of thanks and CA.
Bharat Oza presented memento to the speaker.

Overwhelmingly satisfied and better guided, all Students
carried home clarity and insights with positive resolution to succeed in CA
exams.

About 70 students attended the programme.

BCAS joined hands as a knowledge partner with the Finance
and Investment Cell of Narsee Monjee College of Commerce and Economics for
their event “Insight Conclave 2017” held on the 18th & 19th
February 2017.

Insight Conclave 2017, NM College’s first ever business,
finance and economics meeting was held on 18th and 19th
of February 2017. Though it was the first year of the fest, it turned out to be
a huge success on account of its innovative events and outstanding speaker
sessions. BCAS joined hands as a knowledge partner for the Event.

The first day, 18th February, started with
Parliamentary Debate, which was based on the format of the Asian Parliamentary
Debate.This was followed by the main highlight of the day, THE PANEL
DISCUSSION, which was covered by CNBC Awaaz’s show “Pehla Kadam” and anchored
by the host of the show himself, Mr. Anil Singhvi, a CA himself. As the day
progressed, various events based on the lines of Finance and Business like
Moneyball, Newton’s Cradle, Empire and Corporate Restructuring took place.
Alongside, a special session in association with BCAS was organised which was
very well hosted by CA. Ameet Patel, Chairman of Taxation Committee at BCAS.
Apart from this there were eminent speakers from various fields. CA. Vaibhav
Manek talked upon the future of the profession.

The participants was really excited about the event ‘Coffee
with Luminary’, where Mr. Ambareesh Murty, founder and CEO of the online
furniture retail company, Pepper fry and Mr. Mahesh Murthy, the founder of
Pinstorm were invited. The most awaited event THE YOUTUBER’S WAY, had Mr. Sahil
Shah, member of the very famous East India Comedy that was a great end to the
day one of the event.

The second day was amazing, with exciting personalities and
series of Conclave along with brainstorming events awaiting the students. The
events targeted various sectors like the event Airwars which was based on the
pricing strategy of the airline sector. Other than this, an event named
Gaflawas also hosted where the participants had to defend themselves and their
company from the false allegations made against them.The Business Conclave had various
interesting and engrossing segments of which Pioneering Professions was one. It
saw speakers like Mr. Trishneet Arora, CEO of TAC Securities, Mr. Dhruv
Sitwala, two times Asian Billiards Champion and Mr. Neil D’Silva, the global
storyteller. Other segments had the speaker’s discussion on Disruption-is it
the new normal? which was conducted by Mr. Nayan Shah, founder Mayfair Housing
& Jitendra Gupta, founder Citrus Pay.

The day ended with a motivational speech by Ms.
Arunima Sinha, World’s First Amputee to climb Mt. Everest and has also climbed
the seven highest peaks. She described about her ill-fated train trip, the hell
that followed, why she decided to climb the Everest and how it is in the worst
tragedies that the human spirit learns to soar. It was a great motivation for
the students to learn about such life lessons from the heroine herself.

Golden Jubilee Residential Refresher Course Technical Sessions


A Report

Golden Jubilee Residential
Refresher Course (GJRRC) of Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS) was
held at ITC Rajputana Palace Hotel, Jaipur from 19th January 2017 to
22nd January 2017. In all, 278 members from 40 cities of India
participated to witness this Golden Event.

On the First day, CA. Chetan Shah, President BCAS
welcomed the participants of GJRRC. He introduced CA. Pinakin Desai,
Past President of BCAS who enriched many members with his profound knowledge
and has presented 28 papers in RRCs. He acknowledged the efforts of Seminar
Committee for raising number of participants from 225 to 270 to accommodate
maximum members. He highlighted the VISION of the Society to make optimum use
of technology and innovation to reach out to members across India. He also
informed that BCAS has been selected to impart training on GST with NACEN, as
an “Accredited Training Partner” to the Government of India.

CA. Uday Sathaye, Chairman Seminar Committee welcomed everybody and
explained the importance of RRCs. He compared RRC to a Guru. He acknowledged
contribution of Paper writers, Group Leaders and Members in making RRCs a
success and highlighted the relationship that has been developed over many
years particularly with participants from cities other than Mumbai. He
appreciated the response from outstation members which is increasing every
year. He also shared his thoughts about CA. Pinakin Desai’s contribution
in RRCs.

CA. Pinakin Desai, Past President of BCAS inaugurated
GJRRC. He mentioned that in the past, Group Discussion alone used to expose
what is happening around. Now the scenario has changed. There is a change in
subjects, method of Auditing and Complex Laws are in force. It has become a
necessity that professionals must be techno savvy. Tax department is tightening
the controls, resulting in the task of professionals becoming difficult.
Compliance of tax laws is becoming burdensome. He concluded with a clear
message that there is a need to be updated on every front in profession
including technology.

The first technical session was chaired by CA. Mayur
Nayak,
Past President of BCAS. CA. T. P. Ostwal answered issues
raised by members during Group Discussion on his paper titled Case Studies
on Recent Developments and Issues in Cross border Taxation.

In his inimitable style covering day to day issues in the
fields of Equalization Levy, Transfer Pricing, Indirect Transfers, Residential
Status, Place of Effective Management and Taxability of the Overseas Dividends
in the hands of the Indian shareholders, he dealt with the questions raised in
the case studies along with issues communicated by group leaders and provided
solutions to the problems.

On the Second day, 20th January, 2nd technical
session was chaired by CA. Raman Jokhakar, Past President of BCAS. CA.
Himanshu Kishnadwala
presented paper titled Ind-AS Implementation
Issues.

The speaker after initially giving a background on
applicability of IndAS in India and carve-outs from IFRS, dealt with some
issues on IndAS implementation faced by Phase I companies. He also covered the
notification issued by MCA for companies not covered under IndAS and who need
to follow the ‘upgraded’ standards from 1st April 2016 onwards.

The Third technical session was chaired by CA. Ashok
Dhere,
Past President of BCAS. CA. Pinakin Desai answered issues
raised by members during Group Discussion on his paper titled Significant
Recent Controversies/Developments under the Income Tax Act – Case Studies.

The paper writer in his inimitable style explained the
various nuances in interpretation of tax laws. The case studies were extremely
relevant in everyday practice, and the presentation was extremely useful to all
the participants. In all, the paper as well as the lucid explanations of the
paper writer, was a rich and rewarding experience for the delegates.

In the evening, all participants visited Chokhi Dhani, a
theme village resort in the outskirts of Jaipur city.Everybody enjoyed the
activities in Chokhi Dhani followed by sumptuous and tasty Rajasthani dinner.
It was really a memorable evening.

On the Third day, 21st January, the fourth
technical session was chaired by CA. Govind Goyal, Past President of
BCAS. CA. Madhukar Hiregange presented paper titled Role &
Responsibilities of CAs in GST Regime.

He enlightened the participants on the opportunities
available to the chartered accountants in the pre and post implementation of
GST, in the fields like Operational Consultancy, Network Support and
Infrastructure, Accounting, Compliance, Transitional Support including
Audits/Assurance areas. He felt that Chartered Accountants are in a better
position to assess the impact of GST on their clients. He enlightened the
members as regards various efforts and initiatives taken by ICAI by
contributing in the law making process. He said this is a Golden Opportunity
for professionals by tracking development at Industry level and creating
awareness by advising their clients.

The Fifth technical session was chaired by CA. Anil Sathe,
Past President of BCAS. CA. Saurabh Soparkar answered issues raised by
members during Group Discussion on his paper titled Re-opening and Revision
of Assessments.

The learned speaker, through various case studies, explained
that while the assessment was a concept that was not new to tax practitioners,
it had attained significant importance in the last decade. He mentioned that
earlier, assessments were the norm and reassessments were an exception. However
in the recent past, the Income tax Department embarked on reassessments in a
large number of cases, either on account of the scrutiny being inadequate at
the time of assessment or on account of receipt of information,
post-assessment. Judicial forums, particularly the high Courts and the apex
court, looked at reassessments very seriously and unless the threshold
conditions were satisfied, did not permit the Department to have a second
innings. The Speaker mesmerised the audience with his command over the subject.
His analysis of the various judicial pronouncements was also extremely useful.

Golden Jubilee Function

On 21st evening, everyone was waiting eagerly for
the special celebration of the Golden Jubilee RRC. The function was organised
in a different way this year as compared to similar evening functions at the
RRCs in the past. CA. Nandita Parekh & CA. Ameet Patel, past president of
the BCAS jointly compered the event. They began by welcoming the Chief Guest Mr.
T. N. Manoharan, Past President of ICAI and Guest of Honour Mr. Nilesh
Vikamsey, Vice President of ICAI.
Both the guests addressed the gathering.
Mr Manoharan spoke about his experiences at the past RRCs and he also spoke
about the special qualities of the RRCs organised by the BCAS. He also spoke
about the role played by bodies like BCAS in the development of the CA
profession. Mr Nilesh Vikamsey too complimented the BCAS on the golden jubilee
of the RRC. He spoke about the recent initiatives taken by the ICAI for its
members. He also cautioned the delegates about the threat of disruption that
technology is likely to cause amongst the professionals in the country. He also
gave examples of how the ICAI has quickly responded to the expectations from
the Government on various fronts. Both the guests set the right tone for a
memorable celebration of the GJRRC.

Thereafter, the past chairmen of the Seminar Committee –
CA. Pranay Marfatia
, CA. Govind Goyal & CA. Rajesh S. Shah
were felicitated for their contribution to the RRC. The delegates also
remembered the contribution of Nayan Parikh, another past chairman who could
not remain present on account of health reasons. Rajeev Shah, convenor of the
committee was felicitated for being a convenor of the committee for 10 years.
Vice President of the Society  CA.
Narayan Pasari
presented his views.

CA. Uday Sathaye, Chairman, Seminar Committee was then
felicitated for his contribution in all RRCs. He has been chairman for 10 RRCs
including GJRRC which is the highest number of chairmanship of Seminar
Committee. He mentioned that the members of the Seminar Committee take each RRC
as a separate programme with a mission and challenge. He elaborated that the
success of RRCs is achieved with effective Team Management, Planning,
Assessment of Risk, Crisis Management and Negotiation skills. He gave many
examples from earlier RRCs where members of the Seminar Committee have overcome
various difficulties to provide comfort to the participants. He acknowledged
valuable support of all previous chairmen of seminar committee namely Late CA.
Shailesh Kapadia, CA. Nayan Parikh, CA. Pranay Marfatia, CA. Govind Goyal and
CA. Rajesh Shah. All of them had always provided guidance and had actively
participated in all RRCs. He also highlighted the changing face of RRC over
last 30 years in terms of Group Discussion, Participation of Members etc. He
concluded his views on a positive note that this wonderful relationship will
continue with the support of the members attending RRCs in future.

Thereafter, several members were called upon to share their
experiences of the past RRCs. Some who had come for the first time also spoke
about their experience of the GJRRC.

Past Presidents and Office Bearers at GJRRC

The event was made all the more memorable by an Army Band
which marched into the hall in full splendour and performed some tunes which
were enjoyed by all. The delegates were awed by the ceremonial band.

The event was interspersed with humour and wit and all the
delegates had an enjoyable time.

This celebration function was very ably hosted by CA. Nandita
Parekh and CA. Ameet Patel, Past President of BCAS.

The finale of the GJRRC was the Panel Discussion on last day
i.e. 22nd January. This was the first time that such a session was
held at the RRC. The experiment was highly successful. The session was chaired
by CA. T. N. Manoharan. The panelists were CA. Pradip Kapasi,
Past President of BCAS, CA. Gautam Doshi, Past Chairman of WIRC of ICAI, CA.
Dinesh Kanabar
and CA. Sunil Gabhawalla, Joint Secretary of BCAS.
The discussion was moderated by CA. Shariq Contractor, Past President of
BCAS and CA. Jayant Gokhale, Past Central Council member of ICAI.

The panelists discussed five case studies which covered a
wide range of topics. The large number of issues from the field of Accounting,
Direct Tax, Indirect Tax, International Tax, FEMA, Stamp Duty etc. were
covered extensively by the panelists.

In the concluding session, CA. Uday Sathaye,
Chairman Seminar Committee and CA. Chetan Shah, President BCAS thanked
everybody for making GJRRC a great success. GJRRC concluded with a commitment
to meet again next year.


Seminar Committee and Office Bearers at GJRRC

Society News

BEPS Study Circle Meetings held
on 7th and 22nd December 2016

International Taxation Committee of BCAS organized 2 BEPS
Study Circle Meetings on 7th and 22nd December, 2016 at
BCAS Conference Hall. CA. Rashmin Sanghvi led the discussion on BEPS Action
Plan 1 thereby addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy.

The first meeting of BEPS Study Circle was held on 7th December,
2016 to explain the objective of the meeting. President CA. Chetan Shah,
Chairman of International Taxation Committee CA. Gautam Nayak, CA. Rashmin
Sanghvi and CA. T. P. Ostwal explained the motive and importance of study
circle in studying the subject of future importance.

OECD/G20 have brought out BEPS Action reports. Countries are
obligated to take measures considering that the erstwhile ways of International
tax practice will not hold good. The Multilateral instrument to amend the DTAs
is expected to be ratified by the countries by June 2017. It is better to plan
with the objective to study the BEPS reports and understand what will be the
implications. 

The 2nd meeting was held on 22nd
December to take the discussions forward on BEPS Action Plan-1. In both the
meetings, CA. Rashmin Sanghvi made the presentation and explained the
provisions of the challenges existing in Taxation of Digital Transactions and
the Equalisation Levy being levied by Indian Government to tackle the same. He
further emphasised that current International Tax rules require the presence in
the country of source, to enable that country to tax the income. E-commerce
companies do not pay tax in country of source as they do not have their
presence in the country of source. Due to sophisticated tax planning, they also
do not pay tax in country of residence. Mr. Sanghvi also informed that the
world is debating on how to tax such companies and that the Digital Economy is
the only report where there are no specific recommendations. The report gives
three alternatives – bringing in the concept of Significant Economic Presence,
TDS and Equalisation Levy. India has adopted Equalisation Levy and other
countries are also studying the Indian law.

Members debated the basic principles for equitable taxation
of Digital transactions between country of residence of entity and country of
revenue. Equalisation Levy by India has some difficulties as tax is being
collected from Indian residents and not from non-residents. Members discussed
the alternatives to reduce the difficulties.

The meeting was very informative, participative and was
appreciated by members.

Direct Tax Law Study Circle
Meeting on “Appellate Proceedings & Penalty Pro-ceedings”

The Taxation Committee of BCAS conducted Direct Tax Law Study
Circle Meeting on “Appellate Proceedings & Penalty Proceedings” on 5th
January 2017 at BCAS Conference Hall.

The meeting was chaired by CA. Ronak Doshi. The Group leader,
CA. Jhankhana Thakkar meticulously explained the procedural aspects during
appellate proceedings.

During the course of discussion, emphasis was placed on
practical aspects while drafting appeal including stay application before each
level of appellate authorities mentioned below:

    Appeal to Commissioner of Income-tax
(Appeals)

    Dispute Resolution Scheme, 2016 (since
filing date was extended to 31 January 2017)

    Dispute Resolution Panel

    Income-tax Appellate Tribunal

    Proceedings for stay of demand.

She reiterated that due care needs to be taken while drafting
appeal, covering technical issues as well the merits of the case, based on
authorities’ impression on submissions filed by assessee.

However, due to paucity of time, Penalty Proceedings were not
taken up for discussion which would be covered up in the next study circle
meeting.

The members benefitted from the meeting and thanked Taxation
Committee for organising the meeting on such interesting subject.

Lecture Meeting on “Important
Case Laws of 2016 on Service Tax”

Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society organised a lecture
meeting on “Important case laws of 2016 on Service Tax” on 11th January
2017 at BCAS Conference Hall which was addressed by the speaker CA. A. R.
Krishnan.