Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

28th International Tax And Finance Conference

Gathered at the luxurious The Corinthians Resort and Club Pune, the 28th International Tax and Finance (ITF) Conference unfolded from 4th to 7th of April, 2024, showcasing a remarkable turnout of over 270 participants, including distinguished faculties and special invitees. Hosted under the esteemed banner of the International Taxation Committee of BCAS, this conference stood as a beacon for professionals in the intricate realm of international tax and finance, offering an immersive platform for knowledge exchange, idea sharing, and invaluable networking opportunities.

The Conference covered the following:

DYNAMIC ENGAGEMENTS

The participants were divided into four groups, each group ably led by group leaders (aggregating to 24, across the three papers) who helped generate an in-depth discussion of the case studies from the papers. The paper writers visited each group to witness the brainstorming sessions.

An overview of each of the sessions follows:

Day 1: 4thApril, 2024 — Opening Horizons

President CA Chirag Doshi and Chairman CA Nitin Shingala set the stage ablaze with their visionary remarks, unveiling BCAS’ ambitious initiatives and insights into India’s burgeoning international trade landscape. The inauguration, graced by luminaries including Key Note Speaker Shri Anand Deshpande and esteemed past presidents, was adorned with the ceremonial lighting of the lamp, symbolising the enlightenment to come.

 

Shri Anand Deshpande’s keynote address, an illuminating exploration into the transformative potential of AI in the accounting and taxation domain, captivated the audience with real-life applications and visionary perspectives.

 

A spirited Group Discussion on Cross-BorderStructuring of Family-owned Enterprises Income Tax and FEMA Intersection, complemented by a comprehensive presentation by Rutvik R. Sanghvi, ignited intellectual fervour under the adept moderation of CA Pinakin Desai.

Day 2: 5th April, 2024 — Navigating Complexity

The day commenced with an engaging Group Discussion on Unravelling GAAR, SAAR, PPT, and LOB — Overlap and Intricacies). The discussion was engaging and informative, with participants actively sharing their experiences and insights on the subject matter.

Following the GD, CA Shishir Lagu’s elucidation on USA Taxation further enriched the discourse, shedding light on multifaceted compliance and legal challenges with respect to the topic.

The unveiling of CA Padamchand Khincha’s exhaustive paper (spread into two parts), navigating the labyrinth of tax intricacies, facilitated a deeper understanding of regulatory overlaps, expertly chaired by CA Kishore Karia.

Day 3: 6th April, 2024 — Insightful Dialogues

Participants delved into riveting Case Studies in International Tax, followed by Adv. Aditya Ajgaonkar’s profound discourse on the Interplay of the Black Money Act and PMLA in International Taxation, illuminating the legal landscape.

A captivating Panel Discussion on Transfer Pricing, chaired by CA TP Ostwal and featuring distinguished panellists CA Vijay Iyer, Mr Bhupendra Kothari and Ms Monique Herksen (online), explored industry-specific challenges and global trends, including pertinent topics such as Carbon Credits and ESG, underscoring the evolving dynamics of international tax compliance.

Day 4: 7thApril, 2024 — Culminating Reflections

The conference reached its pinnacle with a stimulating Panel Discussion on Case Studies in International Tax, moderated by CA Hitesh Gajaria, where panellists, CA Vishal Gada, Ms Malathi Sridharan & Mr R.S Syal dissected intricate scenarios with precision and insight, leaving attendees enriched with practical wisdom and strategic insights. The discussion was centered around six case studies.

CONCLUDING NOTES

Under the visionary leadership of Chairman CA Nitin Shingala and Co-Chairman CA Chetan Shah, along with the dedicated efforts of Chief Conference Director CA Divya Jokhakar and Co-Director CA Naman Shrimal and their tireless team, the 28th ITF Conference concluded triumphantly, leaving an indelible mark on the global tax discourse and garnering enthusiastic acclaim from all quarters.

Other members of the core team were CA Jagat Mehta, CA Siddharth Banwat, CA Mahesh Nayak, CA Anil Doshi and CA Deepak Kanabar.The ITF Conference ended on a high note and received encouraging response and feedback from the participants.

 

Report on BCAS 57th Residential Refresher Course

The 57th Residential Refresher Course (RRC) organised by the Seminar, Public Relations & Membership Development Committee (SPR & MD) held at Mahabaleshwar from 22nd to 25th February, 2024, marked another significant event in the annals of BCAS. Against the backdrop of BCAS’ 75-year journey, the 57th RRC embraced the theme of “Back to the Roots,” underscoring a commitment to foundational principles that underpin the BCAS’ ethos amidst evolving dynamics. Notably, this marked the 19th RRC hosted at Hotel Dreamland (coinciding with the Hotel’s 80th year) — a testament to enduring partnerships and shared milestones.

With 140 delegates from diverse regions across the country converging at Hotel Dreamland, the stage was set for an enriching experience over four days. The composition of attendees mirrored a balanced mix of youth, experienced professionals, and seasoned experts. This blend promised a diverse exchange of ideas and perspectives, enriching the collective learning experience.

At the inaugural session, CA Uday Sathaye, Chairman of the SPR & MD Committee, set the tone for the event by extending a warm welcome to all attendees and reflecting on the legacy of the past 56 RRCs. He shared nostalgic anecdotes about the long-standing association of RRCs with Mahabaleshwar and Hotel Dreamland. Additionally, he provided an overview of the program scheduled and various other statistics of delegates.

The inauguration witnessed the lighting of the ceremonial lamp by the esteemed Chief Guest, Shri Harshu Ghate, alongside the Committee Chairman, Past Presidents, Office Bearers and Committee Convenors. Shri Ghate, a distinguished Chartered Accountant and Company Secretary, who co-founded & established ESOP Direct as a thought leader & market leader, brought insightful perspectives to the forefront during his presentation on “CA Profession & Entrepreneurship.” His emphasis on cultivating a corporate mindset within firms resonated strongly, urging delegates to envision and build institutions with enduring value having separate identity from its founders which he aptly described as ‘infinite game.’

As the event was unveiled against the scenic backdrop of Mahabaleshwar, it served not only as a platform for knowledge dissemination and camaraderie but also as a celebration of the BCAS’ resilience and adaptability over the years.

The inaugural session was followed by a panel discussion on ‘Multi-Disciplinary Issues on Charitable Trusts’ that delved deep into the intricacies of charitable trusts, encapsulating a comprehensive 360-degree view on prevalent issues in Income Tax, GST, and Charity Law.

The session moderated by CA Mandar Telang and CA E. Chaitanya, provided a symphony of insights from CA (Dr) Gautam Shah, CA S.S. Gupta and CA Sonalee Godbole, addressed critical issues ranging from the application of principal repayments to the doctrine of Mutuality and the compliance regime applicable to Charitable Trusts. Past President CA Anil Sathe, the Chairman of the session, steered the discussion with finesse, supplementing the speakers with his expertise in direct taxes. As queries from participants punctuated the dialogue, the panellists adeptly elucidated each concern, leaving no stone unturned in ensuring clarity and comprehension.

The second day of the RRC witnessed a poignant exchange of ideas as members convened early for group discussions at various breakout venues led by group leaders CA Chaitee Londhe, CA Chintan Shah, CA Chirag Haraniya, and CA Manish Dafria. The focal point of these discussions were the thought-provoking case studies on ‘Taxation Issues in Respect of Non-Resident Indians’ curated by CA Kishore Phadke. In an atmosphere charged with intellectual fervour, participants delved deep into the nuances of the case studies, engaging in spirited deliberations and constructive dialogue. Case-studies in Direct Taxes is an annual feature of the RRC and is an endeavour to make it a great learning experience for all.

As the day unfolded, the RRC members navigated through a myriad of interesting dialogues as the group discussion was followed by the panel discussion on a very relevant topic- ‘Scaling up Professional Practice in a Challenging World’ that was enriched by the insightful contributions of distinguished panellists Past President CA Shariq Contractor and CA Milin Mehta, under the adept chairmanship of Past President CA Narayan Pasari, adding a touch of seasoned wisdom to the proceedings. The session, skilfully moderated by CA Sushrut Chitale, was marked by the exchange of intriguing experiences pertaining to the augmentation of CA practice.

The panel discussed strategies for CA firms to enhance market position and topics such as succession planning, the imperative of scaling up, partner remuneration structures, and others ensued. It was collectively acknowledged by the panel that there exists no singular correct approach to scale up and for a firm to work, and that varied strategies may be warranted based on unique circumstances. Furthermore, deliberations touched upon the significance of human resource management, effective delegation of tasks, and the willingness to part ways with clients not aligned with the firm’s vision or scale.

Following the panel discussion, CA Kishore Phadke offered elaborate responses for case studies concerning taxation issues for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) which were discussed by participant groups in the morning. Insights on interpretation challenges regarding split residential status, tax implications of work-from-home policies, taxation of unpaid salaries earned as a non-resident but received upon becoming a resident, ramifications under the Black Money Act, influence of citizenship on stateless individuals, taxation of passive income earnings for NRIs within the context of the India-UAE Tax Treaty, etc. were shared at length. This session was expertly chaired by Past President Dr. CA Mayur Nayak.

As the day moved ahead, participants across age groups engaged in evening leisure pursuits/ recreational activities such as cricket and badminton, fostering camaraderie and relaxation. The group later proceeded to the picturesque Mystic Valley for extended delight. Morning discussion groups transitioned into competitive teams for fun-filled activities such as hula hoop passing, dog and bone, and musical chairs, amidst the scenic backdrop of the sunset, accompanied by participant-performed songs;, the atmosphere was imbued with a sense of serenity and camaraderie, creating lasting memories.

The eventful day culminated with an engaging session featuring eight esteemed Past Presidents — CA Ameet Patel, CA Anil Sathe, CA Ashok Dhere, Dr. CA Mayur Nayak, CA Narayan Pasari, CA Pranay Marfatia, CA Rajesh Muni and CA Uday Sathaye; offering a unique opportunity for a reflective dialogue titled ‘Back to the Roots – A Journey Through Time’. During this distinctive tête-à-tête, they reminisced about their experiences attending, presiding over, chairing, and deriving value from RRCs. They shared insights into various aspects such as event statistics, amusing anecdotes, memorable moments, unusual participant requests, revered speakers, attendance records, inaugural years of participation, esteemed chief guests during their tenure, and cherished the RRCs. The session was orchestrated by Convenor CA Preeti Cherian.

After a day of bonding and networking, the third day commenced with intensive brainstorming at group discussions for case studies on Direct Taxation that enthralled participants on a Saturday morning. Divided into four groups led by group leaders CA Atul Suraiya, CA E. Chaitanya, CA Kinjal Bhuta, and CA Shaleen Patni, group discussions continued even during breaks, reflecting the delegates’ enthusiasm. CA Jagdish Punjabi’s meticulously compiled case studies on pertinent and complex direct tax practitioner challenges formed the centrepiece of these discussions. The dynamic discussions underscored the collective zeal to unravel complex challenges and chart a course towards innovation and progress.

The subsequent session featured a Paper Presentation titled ‘Global Opportunities for CAs in India’ with a specific focus on the USA and UAE, delivered by CA (Dr) Mitil Chokshi and proficiently chaired by Past President CA Ameet Patel infusing a dash of knowledgeable insights into the proceedings. CA Mitil elucidated on the multitude of opportunities available to Indian Chartered Accountants (CAs) for servicing clients in the UAE and USA. He provided a comprehensive overview of the process involved in establishing a practice in these jurisdictions, including insights into expected setup costs, types of services offered, and supplemented his discourse with pertinent case studies. Additionally, he articulated strategies for CAs to procure work in these domains, thereby encouraging diversification into new business lines and harnessing the vast potential inherent in non-traditional sectors.

Following lunch on the third day, CA Satish Shenoy delivered a compelling paper presentation titled ‘Internal Audit – Thriving in the Co-sourcing Space’, proficiently chaired by Past President CA Rajesh Muni. CA Satish adeptly emphasised the essential qualities and guiding principles for auditors, emphasising adaptability in the digital era, introducing the ABCD framework (Automation, Blockchain, Cybersecurity, and Deep Data Analytics).
His engaging presentation included insightful dos and don’ts of auditing, accompanied by humorous songs relevant to audit scenarios, keeping the audience captivated. Overall, CA Satish’s presentation effectively conveyed his vision for thriving in the co-sourcing landscape.

The third day concluded with leisure activities, as participants engaged in an exhilarating treasure hunt followed by indulging in some retail therapy and leisurely strolls along the lanes of Mahabaleshwar in the evening while relishing the strawberries and other delectable dishes. The evening culminated with a delightful gala dinner by the poolside, providing a perfect ending to the day’s events.

On Sunday, the final day marked the last technical session of the event, featuring CA Jagdish Punjabi’s discussion on the direct tax case studies. This session was chaired by Past President CA Ashok Dhere exemplifying his seasoned leadership. CA Jagdish’s thorough deliberation on the case studies, covering topics such as capital gains, exemptions under sections 54 and 54F, property redevelopment taxation, rectification proceedings, penalty provisions under section 270A, presumptive taxation under section 44AD, and revision proceedings under sections 263 and 264, provided a comprehensive review of the Income Tax Act, 1961, akin to revisiting fundamental principles.

Overall, the breakout sessions served as crucibles of thought, igniting innovative perspectives, and fostering a culture of collaborative learning.

The 57th RRC also featured T20 sessions for the first time, inspired by the GST RRC, introducing a novel concept whereby first-time participants were allotted 20 minutes each to present on a topic. All three T20 sessions garnered positive reception from the audience.

Session 1 focused on “Financial Statements — a better way,” presented by CA Namit Bhambri. CA Namit elucidated on innovative techniques for enhancing financial statements using Excel efficiently. Additionally, he demonstrated SQL queries applicable in Tally software to facilitate effective management of ledger groupings during financial statement preparation.

Session 2 focused on “Recent Amendments in ITR Forms,” presented by CA Aditya Pradhan. CA Pradhan delivered a succinct and informative presentation regarding the latest amendments in the ITR forms, pertinent for the forthcoming tax return filing season.

In Session 3, titled “Unique Features of GST,” CA Payal (Prerna) Shah delivered an informative and comprehensive presentation highlighting key aspects of GST, providing attendees with valuable insights into the intricacies of the taxation system.

To commemorate the 75th year of BCAS, the office staff was graciously invited to Mahabaleshwar for a weekend getaway during the RRC. It was an opportunity for them to unwind, have fun, and finally experience firsthand the event they tirelessly work on but have never had the chance to attend.

The event reached its conclusion with Chairman CA Uday Sathaye delivering formal closing remarks. President CA Chirag Doshi extended his heartfelt congratulations to all participants for their contributions to another successful event, coinciding with BCAS’ 75th year celebrations. Reflecting on the recent three-day mega-conference, “Reimagine,” he fondly recalled the cherished memories and acknowledged the many unsung heroes who have played pivotal roles in BCAS’ journey. In particular, he highlighted the significant contribution of one such unsung hero — a respected senior gentleman, who generously contributed to BCAS including the 75th year as a gesture of giving back, citing how BCAS had played a crucial role in his formative years, attending the RRCs and learning from esteemed figures like CA Pradyumna Shah, CA Pinakin Desai and more. These experiences had greatly benefited him, honing his understanding, and instilling the confidence to develop a flourishing career.

As the event drew to a close, attendees reminisced about the fruitful exchanges and meaningful connections forged during the gathering. Delegates also provided heartwarming feedback and offered constructive suggestions. In celebration of the platinum jubilee of BCAS, attendees who had participated in 25 or more RRCs, as well as those under 40 who had attended five or more RRCs, were honoured with tokens of appreciation. The event exemplified a collective dedication to academic excellence and professional development. With hearts full of gratitude and minds enriched with new insights, participants departed, carrying with them not only cherished memories but also a renewed sense of camaraderie and commitment to excellence in their professional journeys. The contributions to the success of the RRC also goes to Convenors of the Committee CA Kinjal Bhuta, CA Manmohan Sharma, CA Preeti Cherian and CA Rimple Dedhia. We now move on till we meet next year for the 58th RRC.

 

27th International Tax and Finance Conference

Held at The Leela in Gandhinagar, Gujarat, the 27th International Tax and Finance (ITF) Conference was the first ITF Conference to be held in the month of April. Held from 6th April, 2023 to 9th April, 2023, this Conference received an overwhelming response with about 250 participants (including faculties and special invitees) attending the conference. As a flagship program of the International Taxation Committee of BCAS, the ITF Conference was designed to provide an all-encompassing platform for professionals in the field of international tax and finance to share knowledge, exchange ideas, learn from industry experts and network with peers.

The 27th ITF Conference comprised of:

Paper for Presentation Faculties
1. Intricacies of New UAE Tax Regime Chairman: CA T P Otswal

Presenter: CA Nirav Shah

2. Family Offices and Private Investment set-up in a globalised world (including cross border trust and structuring issue) CA Gautam Doshi
3. FEMA Issues in Overseas Investment Rules, LRS and Inheritance issues for Foreign Assets CA Anup Shah
Paper Presentation for Group Discussion (GD) Faculties
1. Tax Treaty and MLI Interpretation and Interplay Chairman: CA Kishor Karia,

Paper Writer: CA Ganesh Rajgopalan

2. Taxation of Foreign Income – Computation, Disclosure and Credits of Foreign Tax Chairman: CA Padamchand Khincha

Paper Writer: CA P V Srinivasan

Paper for Group and Panel Discussion Faculties
1. Case studies in International Tax (including structuring and allied issues) Chairman: CA Pranav Sayta

 

Panellist:

Pitambar Das, CCIT, International Tax

Saurabh Soparkar, Sr Advocate

Sunil Gupta, Head – Direct Tax, Reliance Industries Ltd

Deviating from its past practice, this ITF had a group discussion on case studies discussed by the panel. The participants were divided into four groups, each group ably led by group leaders (aggregating to 25 across the three papers) who helped generate an in-depth discussion of the case studies from the papers. The paper writers visited each group to witness the brainstorming sessions.

DAY 1: 6th APRIL, 2023

President CA Mihir Sheth gave his opening remarks and explained the BCAS’ activities and its new initiatives. Chairman of the International Taxation Committee CA Nitin Shingala made the introductory remarks.

The Conference was inaugurated by the President CA Mihir Sheth, Chairman CA Nitin Shingala, Special Invitee Injeti Srinivasa, Past Presidents Dr. CA Mayur Nayak, CA Gautam Nayak, CA Kishor Karia and CA Shariq Contractor by lighting the traditional lamp.

In his Keynote Address, Mr. Injeti Srinivasa, Head, IFSCA gave an insightful presentation on the state of the Indian economy and the promising trends that lie ahead. He expounded the significance of the Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (GIFT) and its role in elevating India’s status as a global financial powerhouse.


Following Srinivasa’s keynote address, Mr. Dipesh Shah, Executive Director (Development), IFSCA delivered an informative and insightful presentation on various facets of GIFT City and its role in bolstering India’s position as a global financial centre.

The delegates were engaged in a stimulating GD on Tax Treaty and MLI – Interpretation and Interplay followed by presentation on the same topic by paper writer CA Ganesh Rajgopalan who provided an in-depth analysis of the topic, exploring various intricacies and nuances involved and addressed various points that emanated from the GD. The session was chaired by CA Kishor Karia, who expertly moderated the discussion in absence of CA Pinakin Desai.

DAY 2: 7th APRIL, 2023

The day began with a GD on case studies in International Tax (including structuring and allied issues). The session was engaging and informative, with participants actively sharing their experiences and insights on the subject matter. Following the GD, CA Anup Shah spoke on FEMA issues in Overseas Investment Rules, LRS, and Inheritance issues for Foreign Assets highlighting complex issues involved in these Regulations.

Later, CA Nirav Shah delivered a session on Intricacies of New UAE Tax Regime. His presentation was thorough and detailed, covering various aspects of the new regime, including its impact on businesses and investors operating in the UAE. This was expertly moderated by CA T P Otswal.

The visit to GIFT City was a highly insightful and fruitful experience for the conference delegates. Participants visited INX (BSE of GIFT City), Waste Management System and Utility Centre. The visit was expertly guided by the GIFT City officials, who provided valuable insights into the various initiatives and policies that are being implemented to promote business growth and development within the GIFT City.


The visit was followed by a session delivered by Sandip Shah, Executive Director, FSCA. His session provided the delegates with a detailed and insightful overview of the geographical location of the GIFT City and various types of business opportunities that exists. This season was chaired by Dr. CA Mayur Nayak.

DAY 3: 8th APRIL, 2023

The day began with GD on paper on Taxation of Foreign Income – Computation, Disclosure and Credit of Foreign Taxes written by CA P. V. Srinivasan.

Following this, CA Gautam Doshi delivered an insightful session on Family Offices and Private Investment set-up in a globalised world (including cross border trust and structuring issue). CA Chetan Shah chaired this season.

Then, CA P V Srinivasan made a comprehensive presentation of his paper on Taxation of Foreign Income – Computation, Disclosure and Credit of Foreign Taxes. This session was chaired by CA Padamchand Khincha.

An evening talk – Non-taxing Dialogues – was organised which was moderated by CA Shariq Contractor. The faculty – CA T P Otswal and CA Hitesh Gajaria – relived their initial days of international tax and shared their invaluable experiences of their professional lives.

After several intensive study sessions, the organising committee of the conference took a much-needed break and organised a fun-filled karaoke and antakshari event for the delegates. The event provided a much-needed opportunity for the delegates to unwind, relax, and connect with one another in a casual and light-hearted atmosphere.

DAY 4: 9th APRIL, 2023

The morning session began with a highly informative and thought-provoking panel discussion on Case studies in International Tax (including discussions on structuring and allied issues). The panel comprised of Pitambar Das, CCIT, International Tax; Saurabh Soparkar, Sr. Advocate and Sunil Gupta, Head-Direct Tax, Reliance Industries Ltd and was moderated by CA Pranav Sayta. The discussion centered around six case studies, which were thoroughly analysed and dissected by the panelists.

CONCLUDING REMARKS

The ITF was held under the guidance of CA Nitin Shingala, Chairman, International Taxation Committee and CA Chetan Shah, Co-Chairman. CA Jagat Mehta was the Chief Conference Director. He was ably assisted by CA Divya Jokhakar as the Joint Conference Director, who minutely supervised all the sessions personally and devoted a tremendous amount of time and effort to make it the resounding success. Contribution by CA Utsav Hirani from Ahmedabad was significant in various aspects of the Conference. CA Mukesh Khandwala and CA Darshit Mehta played a pivotal role for visit to GIFT City.

Other members of the core team included CA Rutvik Sanghvi, CA Siddharth Banwat, CA Mahesh Nayak, CA Anil Doshi and CA Deepak Kanabar. The ITF Conference ended on a high note and received encouraging response and feedback from the participants.

74th Annual General Meeting and 75th Founding Day

The 74th Annual General Meeting of the BCAS was held on Thursday, 6th July, 2023 at MCA The Lounge, Wankhede Stadium, Marine Drive, Churchgate, Mumbai 400 020.

The President, CA Mihir Sheth, took the chair and called the meeting to order. All the business as per the agenda contained in the notice was conducted, including the adoption of accounts and the appointment of auditors.

CA Kinjal Shah, Hon. Joint Secretary, announced the results of the election of the President, the Vice-President, two Honorary Secretaries, the Treasurer and eight members of the Managing Committee for 2023-24.

The following members were elected unopposed for the year 2023-24:

President                     CA Chirag Doshi

Vice-President            CA Anand Bathiya

Hon. Joint Secretary   CA Zubin Billimoria

Hon. Joint Secretary   CA Mandar Telang

Treasurer                     CA Kinjal Shah

 
       MANAGING COMMITTEE
           ELECTED MEMBERS
 

CA Anand Kothari     CA Bhadresh Doshi

CA Divya Jokhakar    CA Hardik Mehta

CA Jagdish Punjabi    CA Kinjal Bhuta

CA Rutvik Sanghvi    CA Mrinal Mehta

CA Mahesh Nayak

CO-OPTED MEMBERS

 

CA Dushyant Bhat    CA Preeti Cherian
CA Samit Saraf         CA Siddharth Banwat
CA Sneh Bhuta         CA Vishesh Sangoi
               EX-OFFICIO

(Outgoing President)           CA Mihir Sheth

Member (Editor – BCAJ)     Dr CA Mayur Nayak

 

Dr CA Mayur Nayak, Editor of the BCAJ, announced the ‘Jal Erach Dastur Awards’ for the Best Article and Best Feature appearing in the BCA Journal during 2022-23. The ‘Best Article Award’ went to Adv. Hardeep Singh Chawla, for his article ‘Revisiting Non-Discrimination Clause of The India – US Tax Treaty in Light of India’s Corporate Tax Rate Reduction’. The ‘Best Feature Award’ went to CA Yazdi Tantra for ‘Tech Mantra’. The Editor then announced the ‘S V Ghatalia Foundation Award’ for the “Best Article on Audit”. The award went to CA Deepa Agarwal for the article ‘Sustainability Reporting and Assurance’, and to CA Rajendra Ponkshe for the article ‘Vulnerability Assessment: A Tool For Internal Audit’.

Before the conclusion of the AGM, members, including Past Presidents of the BCAS, were invited to share their views and observations about the Society.

The July 2023 special issue of the BCA Journal on Economic Development in India was released by the guest of honour Mr Sajjan Jindal.

At the end of the formal AGM proceedings, the 75th Founding Day Lecture was delivered to a packed auditorium. Members and attendees benefitted from the astute deliberation on India @2030 by Mr Sajjan Jindal. The meeting formally concluded with CA Zubin Billimoria thanking the speaker for sharing his visionary thoughts on a relevant topic with the attendees.

[The video of the lecture can be accessed on the BCAS YouTube Channel, and a Report on the Founding Day lecture is provided in the ‘Society News’ section of this journal.]

OUTGOING PRESIDENT’S SPEECH

 

MIHIR SHETH: Exactly one year back, I made a solemn pledge to deliver you on certain promises. Now, when I take a final bow, it is time to review how this pledge has been redeemed; to reflect on how well the promises have been fulfilled. But before I get on with that, let me tell you the inspiration behind those promises. The inspiration came from the quote by Mirza Galib which says…….  Highly motivated by it, we let ourselves go unrestrained in deciding our goals. The idea was to set the task tall and then give blood and soul to achieve it no matter whether we succeed or not. As they say in Gujarati,  … From that standpoint, I am happy to say that in this one year, we have tried to give best to ensure that those wishes — some of them indeed wild — translate into reality.

Before I get on with the activities and the initiatives of the last financial year, let me acknowledge the three biggest takeaways from BCAS in my life. I have reckoned that this is the institution that has made my life richer, fulfilled and accomplished. Hence, I will be failing in my duty to express my gratitude if I do not acknowledge it.

The three takeaways I mentioned are:

a) Power of Volunteering & Selfless Giving, b) Power of Networking, and c) Power of Perfection.

Let me tell you how each one influenced me.

Power of Volunteering-Selfless Giving

 

BCAS has taught me what the power of true volunteering and selfless giving means. Rarely would you find an institution where so many volunteers give so much back to the profession. It reminds me of a Sanskrit subhashita:

This is when I realised that in giving, you receive… and indeed, I have received so much love, respect and help from people I did not know earlier that it ties me down to this belief that only by giving, you prosper in terms of friends, values and even material success.

That brings me to the Power of Networking…

Power of Networking
One thing I learned from the BCAS is that real power is in network and not net worth. This is an institution where there is no professional rivalry despite the best of the best in the profession working together; name one institution where the tallest in the profession meets the smallest and mentors him in the most avuncular way. This is an institution which gives you a platform to build a network of true friends. Today, unfortunately, we are living in an era of Facebook and Instagram, where we have lost the meaning of friendship. As someone has rightly said in Gujarati that Facebook BCAS is the institution where you make friends for life. These are the real friends who will stand by you come whatever it may. The opportunity to network that BCAS provides across platforms is amazing and has definitely contributed to my personal progress, even without seeking the same.

Power of Perfection
This is the third thing I have to acknowledge BCAS for. What one learns is the Power of exploring the depth of the matter, howsoever difficult it may sound. This is something one has to learn from the BCAS. Its tireless pursuit for quality, never say die attitude to improve its own standards, and challenge its own benchmarks for better, is the learning I will ever cherish. When I see many stalwarts tirelessly toil to make their events the best, their publications the hallmark, I feel perhaps this is the real meaning of Mansi Ekam, Vachasi Ekam, Karyeshu Ekam. It is this single-minded focus on perfection that has helped BCAS reach its pinnacle.

With this background, let me give you a brief snapshot of the activities and initiatives. The theme for the year was EASE, and hence, we focused our attention to see how EASE could be provided for accessing knowledge, embracing emerging opportunities, and ease for networking and reskilling.

I am happy to state that with the active support of all Committees, we had a busy year with activities aligned to the theme. During the year, not only all the flagship events like RRCs, RSCs, budget lecture and long-term courses were organised successfully but also, some bespoke events were held on diverse topics such as Artificial Intelligence, Audit Quality Maturity Model (AQMM), Metaverse, Power Summit, Leadership Chanakya Way, Chat GPT, Forensic Accounting & Auditing, Capital Market and Investments. Apart from these, Mentorship and Students Felicitation Programs, Jal Erach Dastur Students’ Talent Program etc., were all received with tremendous response. Under the auspices of the BCAS Foundation, apart from blood donation and Tree plantation, etc., we also focused on the education of underprivileged children and 25 digital classrooms were set up with preloaded education software. The recipients very well appreciated this. Also, there were six representations made to the various government departments.

I request you to look at the list of the events and activities given in the Annual Report.

There were also several other initiatives taken to ensure that the expectations of the theme are reasonably met.

Some of the important initiatives taken to meet the stated objectives were:

ISO 9001:2015: We were successful in getting BCAS certified as an ISO 9001:2015 compliant organisation.

Hybrid Facility: In response to the demand of giving access to knowledge to the audience across the country, BCAS equipped its auditorium with a state-of-art hybrid event setup. With this facility, it can now offer members facility for attending the event either virtually or physically. While the facility for virtual attendance helped save the travelling time of the members; gave access to the audience across the country, an option also to be able to attend the event physically provided a networking opportunity to those who wished to avail the benefit of expanding their circle.

Social Media: With our focused efforts BCAS Social Media platform has reached 50k+ followers.

Engagement with other Associations: During the year, we had an opportunity to engage with the Coimbatore CA Association, Tirupur CA Association, Nanded CA Association, Karnataka State CA Association, Shri Vile Parle Kelavani Mandal, Bombay Industries Association, and The Auditors Association of Southern India for sharing knowledge. By collaborating with these associations, BCAS has expanded its reach and impact in the profession, education institutions and industry.

The BCAS also signed an MoU with the Institute of Risk Management (IRM) India to felicitate its members to attend courses offered by the IRM at an affordable price. As a result, this year, BCAS has conducted its first workshop on Enterprise Risk Management.

Knowledge Partnerships: We associated with Utpal Sanghavi School for Financial Literacy programme as a knowledge partner. Also tied up with Mithibai College and M. L. Dahanukar College of Commerce to conduct a Professional Accountancy Course.

Library: BCAS library has recently been updated with new features to enhance members’ experience with a range of new books.

Website & Mobile App: The new beta BCAS website, in tune with the current trends, was launched. It will provide members/professionals ease of navigation. The BCAS also developed a mobile application that will facilitate seamless access to the members for various functions.

Expanding the reach at Suburbs: BCAS expanded its reach for knowledge dissemination by arranging a lecture meeting in the suburbs as an experiment and has also encouraged the Suburban study circle. It is expected to help the professionals based in suburbs to easily access the knowledge resource provided by BCAS.

Office: During the year, it was decided to shift the administrative office of the BCAS from its existing location in the basement of the Churchgate Chambers to the first floor of the same building. The new office is more compact in size but is more in tune with the changed reality. It was observed by us that with the hybrid facility for holding events, the load of physical attendance at the Jolly Bhavan has been substantially subdued. This opened up the possibility of optimising the space by rearranging the staff between the two offices. Hence, it was found that the current large office could be dispensed with in exchange for a smaller office. This move will save the cost of Rs. 1.31 crore in the next five years of leave & license fees.

Course Play (e-Learn platform): BCAS enhanced its focus on the unique initiative of “e-Learn” through course play. We updated the platform consistently in consultation with the Chairmen of the committees to disseminate knowledge at the convenience of members/ professionals by paying a small fee. We have, in seven months, collected more than Rs. 2 lakh from this initiative, with 143 participants taking the benefit. I must make special reference to Kinjal Bhuta for her stellar contribution in making this project a success.

Podcasts: For the first time, BCAJ, in its August 2022 issue, incorporated the Podcast feature for the special pages to commemorate the 75th year of India’s independence. It received a good response.

Digitisation of Journals: We now have the digital repository of the BCA Journal since its inception, i.e., from the year 1969. The content is complimentary to all in tune with the BCAS philosophy that knowledge does not have boundaries.

Publication: Apart from the Budget booklet and Referencer, which are published every year, this year saw the publication of the much-awaited book FAQs on Charitable Trust. It has received a very encouraging response, with almost 2000 copies booked in the very first month.

Well. All this is about the year gone by. Let me give you a snippet of the year ahead. BCAS is entering the 75th year of its foundation, and this historical feat holds a special place in the heart of all its members. The sheer fact of our society’s meaningful existence for more than seven decades and its successful transformation into a modern, progressive, and digital institution, speaks a lot about it. Appreciating the importance of the milestone, there are some great plans to celebrate the Platinum Jubilee with programmes befitting the occasion. Several events are planned on the bespoke themes throughout the year, culminating with a Mega Event in the month of January 2024. There will also be a special entertainment programme for the members to participate on this joyful occasion. We are surely looking at the exciting year ahead. Incoming President Chirag will touch upon those in detail.

Let me come to the most important part of my speech. Big Thank YOU.

I thank all PPs, my OB colleagues Chirag, Anand, Kinjal and Zubin, for enthusiastically helping me pursue the promised goals. Thank you, all Chairmen and Co-Chairmen of the Committees, Trustees of the BCAS Foundation, Seniors, Managing Committee Members, Editors, CG members, entire BCAS staff, our vendors and esteemed service providers, printers, and our youth brigade for enthusiastically taking up various initiatives. I also thank Office Bearers of all sister organisations for supporting the joint programmes. My special thanks to our octogenarian member CA Anil Desai who has contributed Rs 50 lakhs to the BCAS during the year, which makes a total of Rs 75 lakhs of contribution in the last three years. I can only say one thing, sir, you inspire us to work harder.

This brings me to the last part of my speech. When I reflect on my journey at the BCAS, I have realised how true Frederique Nietzsche was when he said, “These are the ways in which men part. If you strive for the peace and pleasures of soul then believe, if you want to be a devotee of the truth then enquire.” Ladies & Gentlemen, I chose the path of enquiry because I realised that every enquiry starts in doubt and fulfils the need. And from that standpoint, let me tell you that this institution has fulfilled my need abundantly….generously. This is what has prompted me to give my best. Whether I have succeeded or not, only you can say. As Gujarati shayar Mariz, said,

So, I hope I can see the glint of satisfaction in your eyes that I have met your expectations.

I wish Chirag and his team of OBs great luck.

Thank you and goodbye.

 

INCOMING PRESIDENT’S SPEECH

 

CA CHIRAG DOSHI: Respected Past Presidents, Outgoing President Mihir Sheth, Incoming VP Anand Bathiya, Jt. Secretaries Zubin and Mandar, Treasurer Kinjal, Managing Committee members, Seniors, Distinguished invitees from the sister organisations, Press, core group members, my Yuva Shakti, ladies, and gentlemen.I stand before this august audience today with immense pride and profound gratitude as we have assembled together here to celebrate a momentous occasion — the 75th Founding Day of our esteemed society, THE BOMBAY CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS’ SOCIETY. It is a milestone that fills our hearts with joy, reflecting upon the remarkable journey we have undertaken together in service to our profession and to society at large.

This is a momentous occasion that calls for reflection, celebration, and anticipation. It is an opportunity for us to acknowledge the achievements, contributions, and resilience of our association and its members over the years. It is a time to honour the legacy of excellence that has been our guiding principle throughout this incredible journey.

As we look back on the past 74 years, we are reminded of the visionaries and trailblazers who founded this association on 6th July 1949, with a membership of 29 members. Their commitment to professionalism, integrity, and ethical practices laid the foundation for our society’s success. We owe a debt of gratitude to those visionary individuals who had the foresight to establish an association that would become synonymous with excellence in knowledge sharing in the fields of tax and accountancy.

Friends, the accountancy profession has witnessed significant transformations over the past 74 years. Technological advancements, regulatory changes, globalisation, and dynamic economic landscapes have presented new challenges and opportunities. As an association, we have always adapted and evolved better to meet these changing demands, equipping our members with the necessary skills and knowledge to navigate the dynamic and complex financial landscapes.

Our commitment to continuous learning and professional development has been paramount to our success. We have invested in robust educational programs, training initiatives, and research endeavours to ensure that our members remain at the forefront of industry and regulatory developments. By embracing lifelong learning, our association has enabled our members to stay relevant, adapt to emerging trends, and maintain the highest standards of professional competence.

As we celebrate our 75th year, we must acknowledge the invaluable contributions of our members, past and present. It is the collective effort, dedication, and expertise of our members that have propelled our association to this remarkable milestone. Our members have demonstrated exceptional professionalism, leadership, and commitment to excellence, setting benchmarks for the profession and inspiring future generations.

Looking ahead, the path before us is filled with novel opportunities and challenges. We must embrace innovation so as to ride the technological developments and adapt to change so that we are sought-after professionals for guiding businesses in an ever-evolving regulatory environment. By staying ahead of the curve, we will continue to be at the forefront as the think tank of the accounting profession, driving positive change and making a significant impact.

My Journey

Dr APJ Abdul Kalam, the beloved former President of India, once remarked, “Dream, dream, dream. Dreams transform into thoughts, and thoughts result in action.”My journey at BCAS started in 2010 when one of the members late CA Manesh Gandhi, introduced me to CA Mukesh Trivedi, a core group member who introduced me to BCAS. I was invited by the Accounting and Auditing Committee to speak on the topic of IFRS implementation in India, and then I was invited to be a part of the committee. BCAS has played a significant role in my professional and personal development through active participation in various committees over the period of the last 13 years. In my journey at BCAS, I have delivered several lectures, contributed to Journals and Referencer of BCAS, and organised various RRCs, including youth RRC, non-technical events like Jhankar, Cricket, and much more.

Over the years, I have imbibed learnings from seniors of our profession at BCAS. I would request young CAs to be part of BCAS, and with your contribution and dedication, you can also achieve your dreams.

I take this opportunity to thank all my seniors who have always been pillars of support. I especially acknowledge, Past president Himanshu Kishnadwala, Shariq Contractor, Uday Sathe, Narayan Pasari, Nitin Shingala, Naushad Panjwani, Manish Sampat, the Presidents I worked with Abhay Mehta, Suhas Paranjape, Mihir Sheth, OB team Anand, Kinjal, Zubin. Thanks to my family for always supporting me, my Dad and my Mom, my wife Khushboo and my daughter Jhalak, thanks to my ex-partner, Pankaj Jain, for all his support during my initial years at BCAS, my friend Raj Mullick, colleagues at my office – Anirudh, Jay, Mohit, Richi Yash and my youth supporters…

Friends, coming to my today’s task of unveiling the logo of the 75th year and the plan for the forthcoming years.

The Logo depicts multiple elements of our Society, the Book at the top signifies the symbol of knowledge sharing, the tree represents the BCAS as a community/family, and the globe represents the overall development of professionals, which is the vision and mission of the Society.

The blue colour in the logo represents BCAS’s commitment to professionalism, expertise in financial matters, and maintaining high ethical standards, and the green colour symbolise financial prosperity, trustworthiness, and a focus on sustainable business practices.

One change we have made this year is to do away with the President’s yearly theme and to come up, jointly with the team by the Team Office Bearers, with a five-year plan for BCAS.

1. BCAS’s Five-Year Plan: REACH

a.    Increased Members, Leaners & Followers – Friends, we plan to increase our membership by organising more programs for members only and also plan to increase our reach on social media handles through various initiatives which shall be taken by BCAS through its technology initiative committee.b.    Geographic reach – We plan to reach 75 cities in person and also invite 75 BCAS Sherpas, one from each city, who would be entrusted with the task of coordinating the events in their cities and spreading various other initiatives of BCAS.

c.    Journal readership scale-up – Journal is one of the prestigious publications of BCAS with a wide readership. BCAS, in its coming year, would take many more initiatives to disseminate knowledge through its monthly journal.

2. PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT

a.    Contemporary learning / event formats with relevant topics – More focused topics with the quarterly, theme-based approach.b.    Publications and Research – A research sub-committee is formed, and at least four to five research-based papers shall be issued in the coming year.

c.    Digital learning and crowdsourcing queries – BCAS is planning to come up with a strong digital library and also a community application dedicated to its members, establishing a digital platform or forum where members can post queries, seek advice and engage in knowledge-sharing discussions, job search and vacancy sharing and much more.

3. NETWORKING

a.    Embedded networking opportunities – We shall have many more networking opportunities embedded in our key programs and also the MEGA event planned for platinum jubilee celebrations.

b.    Digital networking initiative – BCAS community application will be launched.

c.    Enhanced engagement with industry / professional associations – We shall be reaching out to various Industry Associations like BIA, ASSOCHAM, FICCI, IMC, etc. and also many other professional organisations in India and abroad to have more engagement of our members with the outside world.

4. ADVOCACY

a.    Dedicated platform for focused advocacy.b.    Research-based advocacy – A sub-committee has been formed to do research-based advocacy.

c.    Engaging with regulators and tax authorities – Proactively engage with regulatory bodies, tax authorities, and government agencies to build relationships based on mutual respect and understanding.

5. YUVA SHAKTI

a.    Formalising the BCAS youth platform – BCAS community application.b.    Curated youth events (mixers, boot camps, hackathon, etc.) – Youth mixers and more events.

c.    Embedding more youth in the BCAS cadre/community – The average age of committees, OBS, and Managing committee.

6. CHARTEREDS’ FOR CHANGE

a.    Focussed efforts on financial literacy, education, etc.b.    Supporting CA students – Reading room, scholarships.

c.    Enabling NGOs.

BCAS theme for the next four quarters

1.    Technology and other updates (July to September).2.    Change – Leaders – Charity (October to December).

3.    Future Ready – Innovation, Growth & Succession (January to March).

4.    Partnering in Business Growth – Industry Focus (March to June).

BCAS MEGA event – 4th, 5th, 6th January, 2024 – ReImagine!!

On 6th July this year, BCAS completes 74 years of service to the community of Chartered Accountants and society at large and enters its 75th year. To celebrate this landmark year, events and initiatives will take place throughout the year. The jewel in the crown will be a grand three-day mega event on ReImagining the profession, which will be held at the prestigious JIO World Centre, Mumbai, on 4th, 5th, and 6th January, 2024.The three days of Manthan will include public eventsand community activities, as well as moments of reflection on BCAS’s 75 years of service. An exciting series of programs covering the future dynamics of the professionals, including a thought-provoking line-up of presentations, panel discussions, fireside chats, interviews, and leadership talks, will be the highlight of the event. There will also be cultural performances tostimulate your senses. The Celebrations will providea platform for knowledge dissemination, professional growth, and networking opportunities to make you future ready.

I would conclude my speech by saying that, as we all start the celebration for our 75th anniversary, let us take a moment to appreciate the remarkable journey we have undertaken together. Let us honour the visionaries who laid the foundation, the members who have contributed their expertise and dedication, and the countless individuals and organisations who have placed their trust in us. Let us also rekindle our commitment to the values that have guided us thus far — integrity, excellence, and lifelong learning. Let us renew our dedication to creating an environment that promotes intellectual growth, ethical leadership, and social responsibility.

Our association’s legacy of excellence will continueto guide us as we embark on the next chapter of our journey, the AMRIT KAAL, shaping the future of the accounting profession and making a lasting impact on the world.

Thank you, and let us celebrate this significant milestone with joy, gratitude, and a renewed commitment to our shared values.

Long live the Bombay Chartered Accountants Society!

JAI HIND

BCAS 56th Residential Refresher Course

 

The flagship event of the Bombay Chartered Accountants’ Society (BCAS), the Residential Refresher Course (RRC), was held at Coimbatore or Kovai as it is called in the local language, from Thursday, 23rd February, 2023 to Sunday, 26th February, 2023..

The preparations for the RRC commenced in July 2022 with the formation of the Seminar, Public Relations and Membership Development (SPR&MD) Committee for 2022-23. Countless calls and meetings followed, even a recce to finalise the venue – after all, the 56th RRC was a special one. The previous RRC (the 55th RRC) had been a hybrid one (given that many of the participants were shy of travelling since the economy was slowly opening up after the onslaught caused by the global pandemic). The Committee was also conscious of the fact that they needed to deliver a program that was contemporary, relevant, and thought-provoking. The time-tested mix of panel discussion, paper presentations and group discussions were successfully adopted.

In Hindi, 56 is ‘chhappan’. The word evokes the memory of Chhappan Bhog, the special prasad offered to Lord Krishna during the Janmashtami festival. The preparation of the Chhappan Bhog is, by itself, an homage paid to the Divine. With great reverence and veneration, the bhog is lovingly cooked by the devotees with their hands – the rasas in the fingers slowly blending into the food. It is said that our five fingers have five rasas – sweet, salty, sour, spicy and savory. To the uninitiated, rasa is basically a source of emotion – it brings joy, brings back memories and opens up conversations.

To the participants of the 56th RRC this year – 138 participants drawn from 20 states and 38 cities – the event was akin to a Chhappan Bhog. Many of these participants have been devout bhakts of this annual pilgrimage, and the RRC gave them an opportunity to rekindle old friendships and reminisce over the past editions. For the first timers, the RRC gave a chance to experience the charm and bonhomie of this much-awaited event. Another unique feature was the four couple participants.

The excitement in the air on the 23rd February was palpable as delegates poured in from all corners of the country. Day 1 began with the inaugural session, with the CA Kinjal Bhuta, Convenor, SPR&MD Committee, welcoming everyone CA Mihir Sheth, President, BCAS officially opening the RRC. This was followed by an address by CA Chirag Doshi, Vice President, BCAS who spoke about the benefits of groups, associations, and local communities in the profession. CA Narayan Pasari, Chairman, SPR &MDSPR spoke about the relevance of the RRC, selection of its venue, detailed schedule and statistics of the RRC. The esteemed Chief Guest and Past President, CA Uday Sathaye, regaled the audience on the previous RRCs and how his involvement over the past decades has taught him precious life lessons, which have in turn contributed to his professional successes as well. He further noted how his passion for BCAS has led him to be crowned with the moniker, ‘BCAS che ladke vyaktimatva’ (the lovable personality at BCAS). The inaugural session was also graced by the presence of the Past President of ICAI, CA G Ramaswamy and the Officer Bearers of The Auditors’ Association of Southern India (TAASI) and SIRC members.

The inaugural session was followed by the curtain-raiser, the presentation paper on the contemporary topic “Handholding Startups – An emerging area of practice” by CA Eshank Shah. The session was chaired by CA Priya Bhansali. This was followed by a group discussion on “Case Studies in Direct Taxes” which saw the break-out groups discuss threadbare challenging and compelling case studies.

Day 2 saw the break-out groups continue their deliberations, followed by the erudite Adv. K.K. Chythanya who discussed the intricacies of the case studies at great length. The session was chaired by CA Phalguna Kumar Enukondla. Post a sumptuous lunch, the eager delegates set out to pay obeisance to Lord Shiva at the Perur Pateeswarar Temple. The temple traces its origins to the 2nd century CE, making it one of the oldest temples in the state and also India. This was followed by a visit to the Isha Foundation. Thanks to local participant, CA V Ramnath, both the visits went off smoothly. A special mention must be made of the Coimbatore team of Yuva participants, ably led by CA R Harish, who took it upon themselves to assist all the other delegates during the entire visit.

Day 3 witnessed the participants appreciate the complexities in the paper presentation on the topic “Additional Reporting Intricacies – Special focus on CARO, IFC & NOCLAR” by CA Mohan Lavi, ably chaired by CA Zubin Billimoria. Post lunch, the break-out groups gathered for yet another stimulating group discussion on the topic “Case Studies in penalty and prosecution in Direct & Indirect Taxes”. The evening ended with an engrossing brains trust session on multi-disciplinary areas of practice. The intellectual team comprising Past President CA Anil Sathe, CA Chinnsamy Ganesan, CA Rutvik Sanghvi and Past President CA Sunil Gabhawalla had a very engaging discussion, where they presented their individual views on the case studies at hand. The session was ably moderated by CA Kinjal Bhuta and CA Mandar Telang. The evening ended with some first-time participants sharing their feelings about the RRC. Post dinner, the young at heart and in age found themselves on the dance floor, grooving to the beat of the music which transcended all borders.

Day 4 commenced with Adv. Raghvan Rambhadran giving his replies on the topic, “Case Studies in penalty and prosecution in Direct & Indirect Taxes”. The session was chaired by CA Sanjeev Lalan. This was followed by the Presentation Paper, “Practice Automation Tools” by CA Druman Patel, ably chaired by CA Chirag Doshi. In the concluding session, Chairman Narayan Pasari once again acknowledged all those who had worked towards delivering a successful RRC, especially Committee member and local participant, CA Priya Bhansali who played an active role in making all the logistic arrangements. Apart from others, the ever energetic four Convenors – CA Kinjal Bhuta, CA Mrinal Mehta, CA Manmohan Sharma, and CA Preeti Cherian deserve credit – they were ably guided by Past President CA Uday Sathaye.

And as the curtains came down on yet another successful RRC, one was reminded of the passion that courses through the veins of the die-hard RRC fans, and the beautiful doha composed by the 15th century mystic poet and saint, Kabir:

“कबीरा कुंआ एक हैं, पानी भरैं अनेक। बर्तन में ही भेद है, पानी सबमें एक।।.”

 Meaning –

Kabira, the well is but one, from which many draw water,

Only the pots differ, the water they hold within is the same.

In the context of the RRC, the ‘well’ can be likened to the inexhaustible source of knowledge that the BCAS is – where the thirsty gather and meet; the ‘pots’ represent the diversity among the participants – drawn as they are from different corners of the country; and the ‘water’ is the knowledge that the participants and stakeholders of the RRC partake and emerge invigorated with.

 

Report On the 26th International Tax and Finance (ITF) Conference, 2022

The International Taxation Committee of BCAS conducted the 26th ITF Conference at Hotel Ananta and Resorts, Udaipur, from 4th to 7th August, 2022 – the first ITF Conference post-pandemic and the first to be held in a hybrid format. The total number of participants, including 30 online delegates, touched the 250 mark.

In line with the tradition, this year’s Conference, too, was designed to include various contemporary and practically relevant topics for the international tax practitioner. Eminent personalities and experts graced the Conference and shared their invaluable thoughts and experiences in their respective areas of expertise.

The participants were divided into four groups, each group ably led by group leaders who helped generate in-depth discussions of the case studies from the papers. The paper writers visited each group to witness the group discussion.

DAY 1

President CA Mihir Sheth gave his opening remarks and explained BCAS’s activities and various new initiatives. Immediate Past Chairman of the International Taxation Committee, Dr. CA Mayur B. Nayak, welcomed delegates and gave his introductory remarks. The Conference began with the lighting of the traditional lamp by the dignitaries.

 

Lighting of Traditional Lamp

Before the inaugural session, the participants had Group Discussion (GD) on “Cross Border Merger, Demergers and Restructuring – Tax and Regulatory Aspects”. CA Girish Vanvari addressed various points that emanated during the GD and provided his thoughts on the case studies. The session was chaired by the Past President, CA Gautam Nayak. It was followed by a special address by CA Padamchand Khincha, who introduced his paper and spoke about various issues relating to cross-border employment. Past President CA Kishor Karia chaired the session.

 

DAY 2

The day began with a GD on the paper written by CA Himanshu Parekh and CA Gaurav Mittal on “Select Controversies / Emerging trends in International Taxation”.CA Geeta Jani made a presentation on “BEPS 2.0 – GloBE Rules and Pillar 2 – Case Studies”. She explained various aspects of the subject in detail, including conceptual explanations, practical points for consideration, etc. Dr. CA Mayur Nayak chaired the session and provided insights on the issues.


CA Himanshu Parekh,
 while dealing with his paper “Select Controversies / Emerging trends in International Taxation”, explained the case studies on which the groups had detailed discussions. He addressed various points in his presentation that emanated from the discussion. His session was chaired by the Committee member CA Sushil Lakhani.The last session of the day was the panel discussion on “Cross Border Swift Payment Mechanism and its Importance, Rupee Rubble Payment System, Digital Currency and its Future”. The panel consisted of Shri Gopalaraman Padmanabhan, Shri Mahalingam Gurumoorthy, and Prof. Ananth Narayan. It was chaired by CA Dilip J. Thakkar and moderated by CA Sunil Kothare. The panel shared its thoughts and gave insights on specific issues revolving around the Payment System and allied topics. The entire panel discussion was in virtual mode and was well received by the participants.The day ended with an entertainment program comprising the Folk Dance of Rajasthan, Miming, and Mimicry.
DAY 3
The day began with a Group Discussion on the paper written by CA Padamchand Khincha, CA P Shivanand Nayak and CA Bibhuti Ram Krishna on “Cross Border Remuneration, Employment Benefits & Pensions – Case Studies”.Subsequently, there was a panel discussion on “Case Studies in International Taxation”. The panel consisted of Shri Ajay Vohra, Senior Advocate, Shri Ameet Shukla, Member ITAT, and Shri Sanjeev Sharma, Principal Director (Investigation). It was chaired and Moderated by CA Pranav Sayta. The panel covered various case studies which had practical relevance. The frank and thorough exchange of views among the panellists, ably supplemented by the Chairman’s remarks and probing queries, made the discussion very interesting and elaborate and provided much food for thought to the participants. The panel discussion was based on case studies prepared by various volunteers.Post that, more than 110 members joined for the Darshan of Lord Shrinathji at the Nathdwara Temple. This was followed by the gala dinner and a live orchestra. Some members also showcased their talent in singing, reciting poems and dancing.
DAY 4
The day began with the release of the August 2022 special issue of the BCA Journal, consisting of special pages on Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav and poems on this theme. The unique issue was released at the hands of Past President and member of the BCAJ Editorial Board, CA Kishor Karia.

Release of the August 2022 issue of BCA Journal

Thereafter, a panel discussion was held on “Transfer Pricing – Global Developments”. The panel consisted of CA Bhavesh Dedhia, CA Karishma Phatarphekar, and CA Paresh Parekh and was chaired and Moderated by CA T. P. Ostwal. It was a technically rich discussion, as the panellists discussed issues from different perspectives.After the Panel Discussion, CA Padamchand Khincha dealt with his paper on “Cross Border Remuneration, Employment Benefits & Pensions – Case Studies”. He had a detailed discussion on his paper and answered various issues raised by the  Group Leaders based on the discussions in their respective groups. CA Kishor Karia ably chaired the session.

 

CONCLUDING REMARKS

With the in-person (or physical) ITF Conference being held after two years, the participants enjoyed comradeship and networking.The ITF Conference was held under the guidance of Dr. CA Mayur Nayak. CA Natwar Thakrar, as the Chief Conference Director, ably assisted by CA Jagat Mehta, Joint Conference Director, put in a lot of effort to make the Conference successful. The contribution by CA Kishore Pahuja from Udaipur was significant  in various aspects, including arrangement for the Nathdwara visit and organising the entertainment programmes.Other members of the Core Team were CAs, Anil Doshi, Chaitanya Maheshwari, D. S. Sharma, Deepak Kanabar, Divya Jokhakar, Ganesh Rajagopalan, Kartik Badiani, Naman Shrimal, Tarunkumar Singhal, Utsav Hirani and Ujwal ThakrarCA Deepak R. Shah, Past President of the Society, helped in negotiations with the hotel. Many other volunteers made laudable contributions to make the Conference a landmark event for BCASCA Nitin Shingala, Chairman of the Committee, chaired the concluding session wherein some members who attended the ITF conference for the first time shared their experiences and expressed satisfaction with all aspects of the Conference, especially enriching papers, GDs, Panel Discussions, arrangements at the venue, comradeship, and networking.The 26th ITF Conference ended on a high note and received encouraging responses and feedback from the participants.

TWO SETS OF STARS LIGHT UP THE 50TH BIRTHDAY CELEBRATIONS OF BCAJ

There were two sets of stars at the launch of the Golden Jubilee issue of the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal (BCAJ) – on the one hand were five young music students at the Symphony Orchestra of India, NCPA, and on the other hand were stalwarts who had consistently contributed to the Journal for decades.

The glittering event was held on Wednesday, 6th March, 2019 in the C.K. Nayudu Hall of the Cricket Club of India and attracted a full house of office-bearers, eminent chartered accountants, committed contributors and unabashed admirers of the BCAJ. When the special commemorative issue was formally released, there was prolonged applause, bursting of balloons and a shower of confetti.

BCAJ Editor Raman Jokhakar, who was the master of ceremonies, started by welcoming the guests and introducing the young musicians at the ‘Birthday Celebrations of the BCA Journal’. First off, Gauri Khanna played Air Pergolesi and Dance Jenkenson on the cello. She was followed by Pranaya Jain on the flute rendering Rondo Mozart. Leah Divecha on the violin and Tivona Murphy D’Souza (D-Bass) rendered the popular Bollywood number “Senorita”. And Sangeeta Jokhakar ended the performance with a Bollywood medley and a cavatina by J. Raff on the violin. The budding, young musicians (some of whom will become the stars of tomorrow) and their teachers were felicitated with bouquets and mementoes.
Next, Raman invited the chief guest, Sunil Nair, Mumbai Resident Editor of the Times of India and BCAS President Sunil Gabhawalla to the dais. He stressed that the purpose of the celebration was to honour and acknowledge those who had contributed to the BCAJ for long and enabled it to reach the fabulous figure of fifty. He also quoted Steve Jobs who had said, “One way to remember who you are is to remember who your heroes are.”

Thereafter, the President spoke about the service provided by the Journal and acknowledged the scores of dedicated people who had nurtured it for years. He then introduced the chief guest.

Sunil Nair, who spoke on the “Future of the Print Media”, gave a brief and informative talk. He spoke about similarities in the roles of auditors and the press. He stressed the need for independence of media and also spoke about the future trends in media by embellishing his points with statistics.

He was astounded by the fact that the BCAJ had been published without a break for fifty long years and depended totally on subscriptions. Another unique achievement was that it was being brought out by chartered accountants who stole time from their professions to publish it on a voluntary basis. Warming up, he was candid enough to admit that although The Times of India was the biggest English language newspaper in the world, of late it had slid to the third position overall in terms of copies sold in India. The first two positions were now held by Hindi news dailies and the Times was no longer the highest-selling daily in the land. The silver lining, according to him, was that overall the circulation of newspapers in India was on the upswing – whereas in the rest of the world it was seeing a pronounced fall.

In other words, he stressed, the printed word still carried weight, and although television, the internet and other electronic forms of dissemination of news were becoming popular all over the world, they had still to make any huge impact in India. This was probably because of the late “blooming” of the Indian economy. Nair’s talk was well received and he was presented with a memento by Vice-President Manish Sampat.
Raman then spoke about the early days when editing DID NOT involve backspace, select, delete, cut, copy, paste. He stated that instead of a big bang special issue, the Editorial Board had decided to carry Golden Pages throughout the year which contained Interviews, Views and Counterviews and Special Articles (32 in number) amongst other regular features.

Just before the release of the last issue of Volume 50, past Editors Ashok Dhere, Gautam Nayak, Sanjeev Pandit and Anil J. Sathe along with Editorial Board members Kishor Karia and Anup Shah were invited to be part of the team to release the special issue. The twelfth issue of Volume 50 was then released by them.

The next segment consisted of honouring the Editors and the authors, writers and columnists of existing features. Raman started off with the words of Khalil Gibran: “You give little when you give of your possessions. It is when you give of yourself that you truly give.” What Gibran meant was giving of one’s time, because one’s time was one’s life. He also spoke about the past eight Editors and acknowledged the presence of the family members of the Late B.V. Dalal, the Late Ajay Thakkar and the Late Narayan Varma who served as Publisher for a long time. He also regretted the absence of K.C. Narang who was indisposed on that day.

Four past Editors, Ashok Dhere, Gautam Nayak, Sanjeev Pandit and Anil Sathe, were felicitated by the chief guest with a special memento designed for the event for their diligent, meticulous, persistent and focused contribution to the BCAJ. The words on the mementoes read: “In appreciation of your long and outstanding contribution to the BCA Journal…”

There was special applause when President Sunil took the mike in between and requested the chief guest (himself a resident Editor) to present a trophy to the BCAJ Editor, Raman.

In a touching gesture, Raman did not overlook those of his predecessors who were no longer with us. Thus, bouquets were presented to Mrs. Dalal, Mrs. Thakkar and Mrs. Varma, spouses of late Editors and Publisher.

Moving on, Raman spoke about a set of Japanese people called TAKUMI, which stood for artisans. This word could be written in many different ways in Kanji characters and each one of them gave different meanings – adroit, eminent, clear and so on. It is said that the intensity of the Takumis’ work borders on obsession – they are precise, absorbed and meticulous. These people are real experts. One of their characteristics is – Ganbaru – or to persevere, to stay firm by doing one’s best, with obsessive attention to detail. All of this is considered to be a unique talent in Japan.

The twenty five feature writers of the BCAJ, he stated, are perhaps best described by these two words: They are “Takumis” or artisans whose hands dance and flow in concert, designing and creating a new form each month.

Each of the features was introduced with a brief history, how it was curated and who were the people who wrote them. Each of the feature writers was then presented with a trophy as a mark of appreciation and regard for their consistency, quality and length of voluntary service to the Journal. It was notable that some feature writers had been contributing for more than 30 years on a monthly basis.

In an interesting twist, the trophies were not presented by the chief guest or by the Editor. Rather, the past Editors and President were called upon to make the presentations. Editor Raman, who compered the event, included not only facts and anecdotes during the presentations, but also sprinkled a fair dose of humour on the proceedings. He requested Gautam Nayak to present the trophy to the other Nayak — Mayur. Similarly, one Anil (Sathe) was asked to present a trophy to another Anil (Doshi). A round of applause greeted Anup Shah when Raman pointed out that when he had started off as a contributor, he was called CA. Anup Shah, but after nearly two hundred columns he had now become Dr. Anup Shah.

The presentation included a specially-designed trophy to all the regular contributors who had been writing for more than five years for the features concerned. Each trophy contained a sketch of the feature writer himself, along with a citation mentioning the feature. More than 40 trophies were ready for distribution.

Raman also recognised those involved in bringing out the Journal : V.K. Sharma, the Knowledge Manager, and Ms. Navina Vishwanathan, the Assistant Knowledge Manager, Anmol Purohit and the BCAS team. The printers, M/s Spenta Multimedia, were also present and each of the team members was acknowledged with a round of applause.

And then it was time to cut the ceremonial cake. It was a huge cake, to put it mildly, and it required the efforts of Raman, Sunil and some of the past Editors to cut it. The icing on top of the cake was designed to look like the cover of the issue that was released on the occasion.

Apart from the Editors, office-bearers and authors, the C.K. Nayudu Hall also saw the presence of some of the chartered accountants whose absorbing life stories featured in the article “Kaleidoscopic View” in the Golden Jubilee issue. Among them were Motichand Gupta, now Senior Manager for Taxation with Ion-Exchange (India) Ltd.; Ms. Nandini Shankar, CA, violinist and music teacher; Kisan Daule, who established his own practice after serving Transworld Shipping for 20 years (he retired as Senior GM); and Brij Mohan Chaturvedi, who is the third generation in a family having five generations in the CA world (he was accompanied by his granddaughter Tina, who is the fifth-generation CA in the Chaturvedi family).

A sumptuous repast was laid out for the guests who partook of it with great delight. As the eventful night came to an end, the hosts and the guests headed home carrying pleasant memories of an evening well spent.

49TH RESIDENTIAL REFRESHER COURSE (RRC ) OF BOMBAY CHARTERED ACCOUN TANTS SOCIETY (BCAS)

fiogf49gjkf0d

49th Residential Refresher Course (RR C) of Bombay Chartered Accountants Society (BCAS) was held between 22nd January, 2016 and 25th January, 2016 at Novotel Imagica, Khopoli.

Mr. Raman Jokhakar, President of BCAS welcomed the participants and highlighted the activities of BCAS.

Mr. Uday Sathaye, Chairman, Seminar Committee gave an idea, to the participants about the 49th RRC and then introduced the Chief Guest Mr. Narendra Sarda, Past President of ICAI.
After lighting of lamp, the inaugural speech was delivered

by Narendrabhai. He dealt with the subject “Identifying, Evaluating & Mitigating Risk in CA Profession”. He presented his views considering the present scenario particularly, the extensive regulations imposed by regulators which were required to be followed by Chartered

Accountants. He explained the need for more planning and elaborate reporting to minimize risk. He emphasized the adoption of technology for survival. Both Internal and External risks were explained by him. His extempore speech in his unique style of presentation without referring to a paper was appreciated by the audience. It was indeed a great experience to learn from Mr. Narendra Sarda.

Mr. Rajesh Kadakia then replied to the issues raised by the group leaders during the course of discussion on his paper Charitable Institutions-Tax issues. He explained in his very lucid style, the various nuances of the provisions of section 11 to 13 of the Incometax Act. He pointed out that these provisions were virtually a self-contained code, and it was necessary to understand them thoroughly before dealing with taxation of charitable trusts.

The session was chaired by Mr. Pranay Marfatia, Past President of BCAS.

23rd January 2016


On 23rd January, 2016 Advocate Shailesh Sheth presented his paper on “Goods and Services Tax (GST)”. He dealt with the subject in depth and voluntarily continued the session in the evening to clarify the doubts of the members.

The session was chaired by Mr.. Govind Goyal, Past President of BCAS.

Mr. Jayesh Gandhi then elaborated “Audit Issues under Companies Act, 2013”. His Audit experience and knowledge added value to his presentation. He dealt with the various controversies arising out of the provisions of the Companies Act 2013. He pointed out that the new provisions had increased the responsibilities on auditors.

The session was chaired by Mr. Ashok Dhere, Past President of BCAS.

24th January 2016


On 24th January, 2016 Mr. Sanjeev Pandit, Past President of the Society made a presentation on “ICDS – Ease of Doing Business”. He explained the various controversies arising out of the new computation standards. He felt that the mandatory compliance with these standards would increase litigation rather than reducing it.

The session was chaired by Mr. Rajesh Shah, Past President of BCAS.

Thereafter, Mr. Jayant Gokhale dealt with “Issues and Pitfalls in Audit as per SAs (Standards on Auditing)”. His presentation on the subject was really an eye opener. Being an Auditor, many times, we miss Auditing Standards while reporting. The points discussed by him based on his experience as Former Central Council Member and Member on Accounting Standard Board was beneficial to the members. His presentation will be remembered in times to come.

The session was chaired by Mr. Rajesh Muni, Past President of BCAS. The evening was made special by Shri Mahesh Dubey. He presented Hindi Poetry. He covered many issues in a poetic manner to convey the feelings of people at large about politicians etc. Not only his presentation but the composition of poetry was also superb & meaningful.
 
25th January 2016


On 25th January, 2016 Mr. Gautam Nayak, presented his views on “Issues under Section 14A 56(2) (vii) (viia) and (viib) of Income-tax Act, 1961”. He replied to the queries raised by members during group discussion. Though the provisions of section 14A and section 56 have been on the statute book for some time the controversies and litigation showed no sign of abating. He explained to the members as to what care one needed to take to mitigate tax risks arising out of these provisions.

The session was chaired by Mr. Anil Sathe, Past President of BCAS.

Some of the members who attended the RRC for the first time gave an encouraging feedback and made suggestions about the 50th RRC to be organized next year.

RRC concluded with some of the enthusiastic members visiting the theme park adjacent to the venue. Overall, it was a very successful programme, like every year

2ND YOU TH RESIDENTIAL REFRESHER COURSE (YRRC ) OF BCAS HELD AT THE BYKE RESORT, GOA FEBRUARY 19-22, 2015

fiogf49gjkf0d
The 2nd YRRC of BCAS was organized under the aegis of the Membership and Public Relations (MPR) Committee in the young and beautiful city of Goa. The young chartered accountants attending the YRRC constituted a mix of practicing and industrybased chartered accountants. The diversity of work backgrounds and geographical affinities of the participants coupled with the informal locale added fresh colours to the YRRC.

Designed with the intent to share knowledge in an unconventional manner using a youth-friendly approach, the YRRC was a mix of interactive workshops, group discussions, presentations, networking and entertainment spread over a wide range of topics of professional interest. While the days were filled with technical sessions, evenings provided opportunities to unwind by the beach with music, networking, singing and dancing.

Most of all, the YRRC provided a platform to its participants to learn from an elite group of speakers in a rather closed and personal setting and to interact and network with them at an informal level.

Summarised below is a snapshot of the technical sessions.

DAY 1 Thursday, 19th February 2015

Inauguration Session by Chairman of the MPR Committee – Mr. Naushad Panjwani

Chairman, Mr. Naushad Panjwani, inaugurated the YRRC by extending a warm welcome to all the participants and set the tone and momentum for the 4 days of the event.

SESSION 1
INTERACTIVE WORKSHOP – CLIENT PITCHING

Speaker: Mr. Vaibhav Manek

Mr. Manek, author of the book ‘CA Firm of the Future’, explained in detail concepts such as mission, vision and values of a CA firm, clients development process, marketing strategies, balanced scorecard, marketing funnel, etc. He carried out exercises with the participants to demonstrate how to have effective marketing strategies and how to prepare for client presentations.

SESSION 2 PRESENTATION – MAKE YOUR MONEY WORK FOR YOU

Speaker: Mr. Sunil Jhaveri

Mr. Jhaveri, an expert at financial planning, explained the various investment avenues which young professionals could avail of to get into the habit of investing early and investing smart. He shared the mantras to make goal-oriented investments.

DAY 2 Friday, 20th February 2015

Session 1 – group discussion – rea l estate , reits and aifs – issues in accountin g, taxation & fema
Speaker: Mr. Anup Shah


During the group discussion led by Ms. Kinjal Bhuta, the participants discussed the posers raised by the Paper Writer, Mr. Anup Shah. The discussion revolved around the relatively newer concepts of REITs and AIFs and the various taxation and accounting issues in the subject. The speaker delved deep into the concepts of REITs and AIFs. He highlighted the controversies in accounting and taxation of these instruments and spoke about his expectations from the Budget on the subject. All the participants’ queries were satisfactorily answered.

SESSION 2 – PRESENTATION – OPPORTUNITIES IN MULTI-CHANNEL RETAIL
Speaker: Mr. Kumar Rajagopalan

Mr. Rajagopalan, CEO of the Retailers Association of India, spoke on career opportunities for CAs in the multichannel retail segment. His detailed analysis of the retail segment in India provided great insights to participants to the retail business world. He highlighted the various stages in the retail industry which a CA can service. He also brought to light some of the niche areas where a CA’s professional expertise could be put to use. Newer exciting career avenues for practicing as well as industry-based CAs were brought to the fore.

SESSION 3 – INTERATIVE WORKSHOP – BUSINESS ETIQUETTES
Speaker: Ms. Shital Kakkar

Ms. Kakkar, one of India’s best known corporate etiquettes trainer, spoke to the participants about the musthave etiquettes in a business environment. In a world which is getting increasingly polished by the day, proper professional behavior and courtesies go a long way in making good first impression and retaining it for the longer term. Through activities and exercises, she brought out the tricks to making good impressions and to avoid a business faux pas.

DAY 3 Saturday, 21st February 2015

SESSION 1 – BASE EROSION AND PROFIT SHIFTING
Speaker: Mr. Tilokchand P. Ostwal

Well renowned in the world of international taxation and transfer pricing, Mr. Ostwal explained to the participants about the upcoming Base Erosion and Profit Shifting project of the OECD and its impact on India. He shared some of the more commonly arising issues for India, his views of the same and the Governments’ actions/inactions to resolve. This was a great opportunity for the young CAs to get introduced to a project which the world has its spotlight on.

Sight-seeing, dinner & entertainment

Post the afternoon siesta, participants embarked on the Goa sight-seeing trip organised by BCAS to explore the bounties Goa had to offer.

DAY 4 Sunday, 22nd February 2015

SESSION 1 – PRACTICAL ASPECTS OF DUE DILIGENCE
Speaker: Mr. Akshay Kapur

Mr. Kapur discussed different types of due diligence that exist in a business scenario. Mr. Kapur took the participants through the process flow in the life cycle of a deal and stage at which due diligence has a role to play. He explained with examples how a due diligence finding could make or break a deal. He discussed case studies based on issues he had come across during the course of his career in the field.

SESSION 2 – BUSINESS OF MOVIES & OPPORTUNITIES FOR CAs
Speaker: Mr. Komal Nahta


Mr. Nahta, editor and publisher of “Film Information” and a television show host, joined the participants for the last session of the YRRC to share insights into the glitzy and glamour world of the movie business. He explained how the movie industry trades and the revenue models peculiar to the industry. Mr. Nahta shared some ideas as to how a young CA could make headway in seeking clients from the movie industry.

The YRRC ended on a happy note with vote of thanks to the organisers and the participants.

levitra

48TH RESIDENTIAL REFRESHER COURSE (RRC ) OF BOMBAY CHARTERED ACCOUN TANTS SOCIETY (BCAS)

fiogf49gjkf0d

Venue: Hotel Ananta Spa and Resort, Udaipur Dates: 8th January, 2015 to 11th January, 2015

The Residential Refresher Course is one of the flagship events of the BCAS. This year, the 48th RRC was held at Udaipur aptly called the city of lakes. More than 200 delegates from all over India converted Hotel Ananta for 4 days into a knowledge club. The Resort, nestled between the majestic Aravalli Mountains, dotted with flowering trees visited by birds of bright hues, crisp cool weather and mouth-watering cuisine, was a perfect backdrop for learning and networking.

DAY 1

Group Discussion of Mr. Sunil B. Gabhawalla’s paper titled “Issues in CENVAT Credit and Reverse Charge Mechanism under Service Tax”. The group leaders were Mr. Ganesh Prabhu Balkrishnan, Ms. Manju L. Navandar, Mr. Saurabh P. Shah, Mr. Rajesh R. Shah and Mr. Manmohan Sharma. Case Studies in Directors remuneration, Reimbursement of expenses to consultants, Sponsorships and Live Telecasts, Housekeeping services, Security services and the like, were heatedly discussed and consensus was sought to be reached for the answers in the groups.

This was followed by the Inauguration of the RRC by lighting of the lamp at the hands of chief guest, Dr. Adish C. Aggarwala. He also gave the key note address. Dr. Adish C. Aggarwala is also a Government Counsel in the Supreme Court and Delhi High Court. He was joined on the dais by the Chairman of the Seminar Committee Mr. Rajesh S. Shah, President Mr. Nitin P. Shingala, Vice President Mr. Raman H. Jokhakar along with the two Convenors, Mr. Bharat K. Oza and Mr. Salil B. Lodha.

The first technical session was by Mr. Khusroo Panthaky. He made a brilliant presentation on the topic “Companies Act, 2013- Provisions related to Accounts, Audit & Auditors – Issues and Implementation Challenges”. His presentation was peppered with humour and factual cases. He expressed concern of falling standards of audit and justified the statutory limit of signing 20 audits per signatory, which he advised must be adhered to not only in letter but also in spirit. This session was chaired by Mr. Nitin Shingala, President of the Society

DAY 2

Group Discussion of Mr. Pradip Kapasi’s paper on “Taxation of Some Entity Related Issues (Private Trust, HUF, AOP, Firm, Succession, Company). The group leaders had a tough time touching on all the issues in the paper and moreover, as often the group was divided on their opinions. The group leaders were Mr. Chintan J. Shah, Ms. Meghna Sarang, Mr. Pankaj Agarwal, Mr. Phalgune K. Enukondla, Mr. Sidhartha B.Karani and Mr. Vinod Kumar Jain.

Mr. Sunil Gabhawalla, in the second technical session, gave answers to the posers in his paper on reverse charge mechanism and cenvat credit. He replied to all the queries put to him by the group leaders who had compiled them after the group discussions. This session was chaired by Mr. Udaya V. Satahye, Past President of the Society

Mr. Pradip Kapasi in the third technical session, replied to the queries raised from the group discussion of his paper. In his inimitable style, he expained the complex provisions of Trusts, HUF, AOP, BOI, Business Trusts etc. This session was chaired by Mr. Ameet Patel, Past President of the Society.

The participants visited Nathdwara for Shreenathji Darshan that evening. The excellent arrangements made by BCAS for special Darshan gladdened the hearts of all those who felt they would always remember this 48th RRC for this wonderful experience.

DAY 3

Group Discussion of Mr. Milin Mehta’s paper on “Concept of deemed income and deemed gains -u/s. 56(2) (vii), (viia) and (viib), s. 69, s. 43CA & s. 50C”. The topic was very relevant and generated vibrant discussions in the groups. The Group Leaders were Mr. Bhavin R. Shah, Mr. Bipin K. Karani, Mr. Chetan Dhabalia, Mr. Neelesh Vithalani and Mr. Nimesh K. Chotani.

During the fourth Technical Session, Mr. Bhagirat Merchant presented his paper on ‘Strategic intent on Mergers and Acquisitions’. Being a Past President of the Bombay Stock Exchange, the highlight of his presentation was the

candid analysis of the recent M & A activities. His depth of hands-on knowledge and long standing experience with the Indian capital market made the presentation very interesting and thought provoking. His view that to ensure success in M & A activity, one has to look beyond accounting, legal and financial issues and consider corporate culture was an eye opener to all the participants. This session was chaired by Mr. K. C. Narang, Past President of the Society.

Thereafter, in the fifth technical session, Mr. Milin Mehta replied to all the queries raised by the participants during the group discussions. The paper writer’s exposure and his in-depth analysis made his talk very useful and interesting to the participants. He referred to various court decisions and explained the grey areas to the satisfaction of all. This session was chaired by Mr. Anil J. Sathe, Past President of the Society.

Later, the participants went for a city tour of Udaipur, visiting several places of interest of this heritage city.

In the evening, an entertainment program was organised for the participants. Rajasthani folk artists charmed all the delegates with their great music and breathtaking performances and the delegates were treated to a mouth watering traditional Rajasthani cuisine for dinner.

DAY 4

The final day had the Brain Trust Meeting with two stalwarts, Senior Advocate Mr. Saurabh Soparkar and Mr. Rajan Vora on Critical Income Tax issues including of Domestic and International Taxation. Mr. Ashok K. Dhere, Past President of the Society, chaired this technical session. Both the trustees very ably dealt with all the questions raised. They started by explaining the case study, questions arising, probable answers and court cases that could be relied upon.

They also explained controversies surrounding some issues, conflicting judgments and giving their interpretation of the same. Trustees gave a holistic view of various provisions and willingly shared their knowledge and expertise with the participants.

In the concluding session, the Chairman of the Seminar Committee Mr. Rajesh S. Shah thanked the delegates for their co-operation and active participation. He thanked the paper writers, brain trustees and BCAS staff. He specially thanked the President for his wholehearted support. He also thanked all the Group Leaders whose efforts were one of the key drivers for success of the conference. The Chairman thanked all the agencies especially the Resort management and the staff, for their help and support for the success of this RRC. A few first time participants and out-station participants expressed their thoughts, experience and suggestions about RRC. The President of the Society, Mr. Nitin Shingala thanked everybody for making this RRC memorable. He also thanked Chairman of the Seminar Committee Mr. Rajesh S. Shah and his team for carrying out this herculean task successfully.

Participants departed after lunch to their respective destinations by cherishing the memories of the 48th RRC and with a promise to meet again next year at the 49th RRC.

For more photoghraphs of the 48th RRC, Udaipur, please visit bcasglobal facebook page.

levitra

A Report on 8th Residential Study Course on Service Tax & VAT

fiogf49gjkf0d
The Indirect Taxes and Allied Laws committee of the BCAS had organised the 8th Residential Study Course on Service Tax & VAT (RSC) from Friday 13th June, 2014 to Sunday 15th June, 2014 at Khanvel Resort, Silvassa. In all 139 delegates from 25 cities of 11 States attended this keenly awaited Study Course, devoted to indirect taxes. This RSC was attended by many young chartered accountants including 15 lady participants. Many of them attended for the first time.


L to R : Mr. Naushad A. Panjwani (President), Mr. Shailesh Sheth, Mr. Sunil B. Gabhawalla, Mr. Govind G. Goyal

The Course comprised of group discussion on three case study papers and two presentation papers by eminent faculties.


L to R : Mr. Naushad A. Panjwani, Mr. Nitin P. Shingala, Mr. Kaustuv Sen,Mr. Suhas S. Paranjpe

The Course began with a welcome address by Nitin Shingala, Vice President of the Society. Thereafter, Govind Goyal, Chairman of the Committee, presented his opening remarks and Naushad Panjwani, the President, shared his experience with the officials of the Revenue Department from the Ministry of Finance and updated the members about the revenue’s current perception about the defaulting tax payers including expectations of Finance Ministry’s from our CA fraternity. Suhas Paranjpe, convenor, proposed vote of thanks.

Advocate Kaustuv Sen presented his paper in the first technical session, in which he discussed various issues concerning ‘Service Tax Implications on Cross Border Transactions.’ In his paper, he elaborately discussed various practical issues. Advocate Shailesh Sheth chaired the session and touched upon all the issues discussed by the paper writer in a very lucid manner. Members got the benefit of hearing two experts on the same platform. Saurabh Shah presented vote of thanks.


L to R: Mr. Shailesh Sheth,Mr. V. Sridharan, Mr. Saurabh P. Shah, Mr. Rajeev Luthia

On the second day, Senior Advocate V. Sridharan explained certain important judgements of House of Lords and ECJ with its relevance in interpreting Indian Tax Laws. The session was interactive as well as informative. Sunil Gabhawalla chaired the session. Rajeev Luthia thanked the speaker and the chair.


L to R: Mr. Sunil B. Gabhawalla, Mr. A.R. Krishnan, Mr. N. Venkataraman, Ms. Bhavana G. Doshi

Thereafter, Senior Advocate N. Venkataraman presented his paper on various critical issues dealing with ‘Taxation of Works Contract Transactions’ and discussed case studies in the light of various judgements including landmark cases of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. A. R. Krishnan, the chairman of the session, summarised various issues addressed by learned paper writer. Sagar Shah performed the pleasant task by thanking the speaker and the chair.


L to R: Mr. Sagar N. Shah, Mr. Bharat K. Oza, Mr. Uday V. Sathaye, Mr. Bakul B. Modi

The technical discussion was followed by refreshing group activities in the evening. Young members played cricket while many others visited Dudhani Lake and enjoyed boating. The day ended with delicious food and a musical night.


L to R: Mr. V. Raghuraman, Mr. Mandar U. Telang

On the third day, Bhavana Doshi gave a presentation on ‘Intangible-Indirect Issues.’ Based on her wide experience, she made her session lively wherein many participants openly interacted. Uday Sathaye, past-President, chaired the session. Bharat Oza presented a vote of thanks.

levitra

44TH RESIDENTIAL REFRESHER COURSE (RRC) OF BOMBAY CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS’ SOCIETY (BCAS)

44th RRC of BCAS was held at Matheran during 22nd to 25th January 2011 at Hotel Usha Askots and Hotel Byke.

Participants reached Matheran by lunch time on 22nd January 2011, after having fun of travelling through mountains upto Dasturi and then walking through enjoyable & cool forest. Some of them took narrow-gauge train to reach Matheran avoiding the walk.

DAY 1:  INAUGURAL SESSION

Mr. Mayur Nayak President of the Society welcomed the members. He explained the need to think in different way in the present situation and for that purpose chartered accountants need to know importance of Group Leading and Group Discussion. He mentioned how this is helpful in career path. For the benefit of the outstation members attending the RRC, he narrated Society’s activities which are conducted through out the year.

Mr. Uday Sathaye Chairman of the Seminar Committee in his opening remarks, highlighted other activities of the Seminar Committee which are gaining popularity and success like study tours in the form of interactive meetings with Industry in various parts of the Country. He mentioned about the subjects chosen for the RRC and thanked all the Paper Writers for giving justice to the subjects. He reitirated the need of having many Group Leaders and not only listeners.
RRC was inaugurated by Mr. K. C. Narang, Past President of the Society, by lighting of the traditional lamp. He expressed his views in regard to various issues which have arisen on account of the current trend of giving importance to material aspects of life. He felt that even though change is an accepted part of life, departure from certain age old principles is unnecessary. In his opinion, while one should welcome good things from the Western part of the world, one should not follow them blindly without considering the Indian Ethos.
In the inaugural session Mr. Mukund Chitale, Past President of ICAI was felicitated for his appointment as the Chairman of National Advisory Committee on Accounting Standards (NACAS). It is indeed a great acheivement and honour.
Mr. Pradip Thanawala Vice President of the Society proposed Vote of Thanks.After the inaugural session Mr. Sourabh Soparkar, advocate in his presentation covered various issues relating to Mergers, Demergers and Acquisitions. His clinical analysis on the controversies in relation to business restructuring was unique. He also dealt with some aspects of individual taxation with respect to agricultural land. His presentation was very well received by the participants.

This session was chaired by Mr. Kishor Karia, Past President of the Society.

The day ended with tasty dinner.

Day : 2

After the breakfast, participants discussed the paper written by Mr. K.C. Devdas, chartered accountant on Recent Judgments in Direct Taxes. The Group Discussion was followed by a presentation paper.

Mr. Mukund Chitale Past President of ICAI presented his views on Opportunities and Concerns in Bank Audit. He explained about the wide range of opportunities available to the Chartered Accountants in the Banking Industry. He pointed out that the regulators, the stake holders and general public expect level of comfort and for that purpose they look at audit reports. He explained how risk factors should be considered while carrying out various assignments. His command over the subject and presentation skills made the session very lively.This session was chaired by Mr. Uday Sathaye, Past President of the Society.

Thereafter the Mr. K. C. Devdas, chartered accountant analyzed the implications and rationale of various Tribunal, High Court, and Supreme Court Judgments. He explained that every decision of the judgment forum is with respect to a set of facts and it is important for readers to appreciate these facts before using the judgment for any purpose. He also felt that retrospective amendments, to unsettle the settled position of law, should be avoided as it causes hardship to innocent tax payers.

This session was chaired by Mr. Anil Sathe, Past President of the Society.

In the evening participants enjoyed an entertainment program before the dinner.

Day 3:

After the breakfast, some of the participants discussed the paper written by Mr. Sunil Gabhawalla, chartered accountant on Case Studies in Service Tax and others discussed paper written by chartered accountant Mrs. Geeta Jani ,on Case Studies in International Taxation. For the first time two papers were discussed simultaneously considering the era of specialisation and requirement of focused study. After the Group Discussion, both the Paper Writers dealt with their respective subjects simultaneously at different locations.

Mrs. Geeta Jani dealt with various cases on International Taxation which are of relevance to participants in their day to day practice. She also dwelt upon the possible scenario, once the Direct Taxes Code became a law. She also discussed possible impact of Controlled Finance Corporations (CFC) Regulations, a concept which is new India.

This session was chaired by Mr. Rajesh Kothari, Past President of the Society.

Mr. Sunil Gabhawala dealt with Case Studies in Service Tax making his presentation very interesting and satisfied the participants by resolving issues raised during the Group Discussion. Service Tax today is gaining importance with more services being added to the Service Tax net. Issues raised by him are of significance to all. His depth of knowledge in Service Tax and masterly analysis was indeed a treat for the participants.This session was chaired by Mr. Govind Goyal, Past President of the Society.

Thereafter Mr. Khurshed Pastakia, chartered accountant presented paper on IFRS – Recent Developments. He informed the participants about the impact of IFRS on

Indian Economy. He was of the view that though there would be a number of issues in implementation of certain standards, given the fact that India is committed for convergence of IFRS, these should be overcome by continuous dialogue between the Industry, the Profession and the Regulators.

This session was chaired by Mr. Ashok Dhere, Past President of the Society.

In the evening an unique and innovative programme — RRC Nostalgia was held for the first time in the history of RRC. In this program views of three Past Presidents of the Society, were presented namely Mr. Pradyumnabhai Shah, Mr. Hemendra Shah and Mr. C. C. Dalal, as recorded through video. They had attended the First RRC of the Society at Matheran. Other Past Presidents present at the 44th RRC also presented their views and shared some memories of RRCs in the past. Almost all Past Presidents were of

the opinion that Group Discussion with active participation by all participants is the foundation of RRC. This is the Motto of RRC right from the beginning which should not be forgotten in the current times of presentation of papers on screen. This message is very important for the mutual benefit of all professionals irrespective of their age. Few participants from the audience added glory to the programme by sharing their thoughts.

This programme was ably anchored by Mr. Ameet Patel, Past President of the Society.

The day ended with Gala Dinner and Musical Evening.

Day 4:

After the breakfast the participants discussed the paper written by Mr. Pradip Kapasi, chartered accountant on Capital Gains – Some Current Issues. The Group Discussion was followed by his presentation on the subject. He dealt with some burning issues affecting the general tax paying assesses. He analysed in great detail vigours of section 50C of the Income-tax Act. He explained various precautions that are necessary to be taken to mitigate the problems caused by the deeming fictions contained in section 45 (2), 45 (3) and 45 (4). His command over the topic and flawless analysis resulted in participants giving him a very patient hearing.

This session was chaired by Mr. Pradeep Shah, Past President of the Society.

In concluding session Mr. Uday Sathaye, Chairman Seminar Committee took an overview of the RRC and recognised the contribution made by everybody in general and Mr. Nayan Parikh, Past President of the Society in particular for his innovative idea of design of Paper Book which was appreciated by all the participants. Mr. Mayur Nayak, President of the Society thanked everybody for making the RRC memorable in the history of Society. Participants departed after lunch to their respective destinations with a commitment to meet again next year at 45th RRC.