Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

January 2011

What will India do with UNSC membership ?

By Raman Jokhakar, Tarunkumar Singhal
Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 3 mins
fiogf49gjkf0d

New Page 1

31. What will India do with UNSC membership ?


Now that India has been
elected as a non-permanent member of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC),
for a two-year term, the Government and India’s diplomatic and strategic policy
community have to decide what to do with it. There is no doubt that India has
come a long way from the ignominious defeat of 1996, when India lost the UNSC
Asian seat to Japan 40 : 142 votes, winning this time 187 : 5 votes. India’s
economic rise in the past decade and its new strategic relationships with
several major and rising powers have all contributed to this impressive vote in
its favour. However, getting into the Security Council is only the first step.
India’s problem is that on many vital global and regional issues, there is no
genuine national consensus at home. Given the weakness of inherently fractious
and myopic coalition politics, there is always the danger that on vital issues,
the Government may find its hands and feet tied when it comes to taking a
position at the UNSC.

Hence, now that India is a
UNSC member, the Government should pro-actively seek to build a national
consensus on foreign policy issues of vital concern to India. In a democracy,
there will always be some critics of Government. That is both a necessary and
valuable aspect of a democracy. However, within the national mainstream, there
has to be some consensus on important international and regional issues where
India would be required to articulate its views at the UNSC. Apart from building
political consensus on international issues, the Government must also revitalise
and strengthen its foreign policy machinery. India has one of the smallest
foreign offices among major and rising powers. Its institutional capacity and
capability for diplomacy has not kept pace with the challenges of the new
post-Cold War and increasingly multipolar world that India now deals with.
Increasing recruitment at the entry level will not suffice. India needs a
quantum increase in manpower and intellectual capability in its foreign policy
machinery in a short period of time. This can only come from lateral entry of
professionals from other walks of life into diplomatic service. This challenge
will become even more pressing once India takes over the UNSC Asia seat from
Japan.

(Source : The Business
Standard, dated 14-10-2010)

(Comment : We also
need lateral entry of professionals in other areas of policy making !).

You May Also Like