Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

July 2014

President’s Page – Readers Respond

By
Reading Time 6 mins
fiogf49gjkf0d

We have had the privilege of going through the ‘President’s Page’ before it is published in the journal.

This year, the year of Naushad Panjwani’s ‘President’s Page’, amazed us with the style and contents thereof. The write-ups were extremely relevant and well put together, especially the last one of June, 2014. In regard to the ‘President’s Page,’ many readers have sent in words of appreciation. It is not possible to publish all of them. As a farewell to him, we are publishing a few responses.

We, at the editorial board, have always welcomed feedback whatever its nature. We welcome the bouquets but are prepared to receive the brickbats as well.

We hope this will encourage readers to respond to the journal.

Anil Sathe                                                                                                Narayan Varma Editor                                                                                                               Publisher

September 2013
You have echoed our thoughts and what generally a common literate Indian feels these days. We don’t feel any special on 15th August every year. But as you rightly said, we are no less patriotic even. However, the general political scenario has brought this apathy towards the nation and its governing people. And there seem to be no ray of hope in the near future for a desired change. But there is another side! There are our youth, our young generation, our young intelligent Indian minds residing abroad and in India who certainly have a different view of the things, of the national problems. The need of the hour is somebody to lead this revolution. The intelligent, good, conscientious people are doing wonders where they are standing. The ‘do good’ effect has to be consolidated and brought forward/in front, so that the others could be inspired. Let us do our bit and hope to build a nation. Thanks for reminding.

— Shubha Gupta


OCTOBER 2013

That was a lovely message. I would like to add that these days, sorry is less accepted. It is better to be safe than sorry, since in certain circumstances, sorry may or may not fetch forgiveness. Also, where deadlines are to be met, it is ‘do or die’ or ‘perform to meet deadline or pay interest and penalty and sometimes may attract even prosecution.” We need to look into such drastic laws and give better justice by giving the defendant a chance to get waiver of penalty and prosecution. We are heading for non compassionate and inhuman treatment. Can the BCAS do something to reverse the harsh impact of changes in laws?

— Gracy Mendes

NOVEMBER 2013
All together a new way of looking into age old issues – very interesting. The thought process was developing in a very intriguing but positive manner. But the end was sort of very pessimistic, doomed. You suggested a solution which you yourself have ruled out. Can we not find a shrewed way out using some ‘chanayak niti’? Being a leader, there should be a more concrete end to the discussion. The questions should not be left hanging I suppose… may be encouraged for further debate! That’s my view

— Shubha Gupta

JANUARY 2014, February 2014
Liked your message as President of BCAS. Your thoughts penned are aligned well with your love for Hindi movies. I do agree that it has been a utter chaos in last three years as far as policymaking is concerned. However, an appeal to our countrymen and especially the young voting class that you mentioned, to keep virtues and values of Indian Culture in mind disguise of rational thinking. I may not be as good as you, but the best way to express myself in form of a hindi movie sher from a ghazal from the movie Umrao Jaan:

“Maana ke doston ko nahin dosti ka paas
Lekin yeh kya keg air ka ehsaan lijiye
Wishing you all the success.”
— Prakash Udeshi

MARCH 2014
A positive note. I am sure, over time, new dishes will surface from A. P. and Telangana to add to your list of favourites. And before the bifurcation takes effect sometime in June, let BCAS host a programme which will include a united A. P. meal. If required, my daughter who is possibly a foodie like you, will assist you in organising such a dinner .

— Puloma/Dushyant Dalal

APRIL 2014
You have given a beautiful and inspiring article to students appearing for the exams. My son is appearing for the CA Final and there is lot of stress and anxiety. This article comes at a right time and will provide a tonic for him. We all have gone through the same phase and now know the value of it. Thanks again.

— Sudhir Avhad

MAY 2014
Naushad, in the current dispensation, I am with the SC. When the Parliament does not function (since the Bofors days), executive has no regard for law and the PM is dysfunctional for a decade, SC’s activism is justified. People are happy with Sahara developments. Our top judicial brains are defending him without answering from where he got the money to repay and how can one repay 20K without recording in the books?

All the cream of our society has made India a ‘Banana republic.’ They now fear only the SC; they don’t fear God!

— Tarunkumar Singhal


JUNE 2014

An excellent piece to be read by every citizen of this country. Beautiful parting speech. Words fail to compliment you. Wish you good luck

— K. Sankaranarayanan

You May Also Like