Loss – Set-off – Section 74 r.w.s. 50 – A. Y. 2005- 06 – Where deemed short-term capital gain arose on account of sale of depreciable assets that was held for a period to which long-term capital gain would apply, said gain would be set-off against brought forward long-term capital losses and unabsorbed depreciation

The respondent-assessee had for the subject assessment year inter alia disclosed an amount of Rs.7.12 crore as deemed short-term capital gain u/s. 50. This deemed short-term capital gain arose on account of the sale of depreciable assets. This deemed short-term capital gain was set-off against brought forward long-term capital losses and unabsorbed depreciation.

The Assessing Officer held that in view of section 74, such set-off on short-term capital gain against the longterm capital gain was not permitted. Thus, disallowed the set-off of brought forward long-term capital losses and unabsorbed depreciation against the deemed shortterm capital gain of Rs.7.12 crore. The Commissioner (Appeals) and the Tribunal allowed the assessee’s claim.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Bombay High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i) The deeming fiction u/s. 50 is restricted only to the mode of computation of capital gains contained in sections 48 and 49. It does not change the character of the capital gain from that of being a long-term capital gain into a short-term capital gain for purpose other than section 50. Thus, the respondentassessee was entitled to claim set-off as the amount of Rs. 7.12 crores arising out of sale of depreciable assets which are admittedly on sale of assets held for a period to which long-term capital gain apply. Thus, for purposes of section 74, the deemed short-term capital gain continues to be long-term capital gain.

ii) Moreover, it appears that the revenue has accepted the decision of the Tribunal in Komac Investments & Finance (P.) Ltd. vs. ITO [2011] 132 ITD 290/13 taxmann.com. 185 (Mum.) as no appeal was apparently being filed from that order.”