International transactions – Draft assessment order – Procedure to be followed – Mandatory – Tribunal in appeal from final assessment order remanding matter to Assistant Commissioner / TPO – A.O. straightaway passing final order – Not valid – A.O. bound to have passed draft order first – Order quashed and matter remanded

International transactions – Draft assessment order – Procedure to be followed – Mandatory – Tribunal in appeal from final assessment order remanding matter to Assistant Commissioner / TPO – A.O. straightaway passing final order – Not valid – A.O. bound to have passed draft order first – Order quashed and matter remanded

For the A.Y. 2009-10, pursuant to the report of the Transfer Pricing Officer, the Assistant Commissioner passed a draft assessment order against which the assessee filed an application before the Dispute Resolution Panel u/s 144C. Pursuant to the order of the Dispute Resolution Panel, the Assistant Commissioner passed an assessment order u/s 144C read with section 143(3). On appeal to the Tribunal, the Tribunal remanded the case back to the Assistant Commissioner / Transfer Pricing Officer. Thereafter, pursuant to the order of the Transfer Pricing Officer on remand by the Tribunal, the Assistant Commissioner passed the final order.

The assessee filed a writ petition contending that such final order being not preceded by a draft assessment order was without jurisdiction. The Madras High Court allowed the writ petition and held as under:

‘i) When the law mandated a particular thing to be done in a particular manner, it had to be done in that manner. The final assessment order u/s 144C read with section 143(3) had been passed without jurisdiction.

ii) Once the case was remitted back to the Assistant Commissioner / Transfer Pricing Officer, it was incumbent on their part to have passed a draft assessment order u/s 143(3) read with section 92CA(4) and section 144C(1). They could not bypass the statutory safeguards prescribed under the Act and deny the assessee the right to file an application before the Dispute Resolution Panel.

iii) The final order is quashed and the case remitted back to the Assistant Commissioner to pass a draft assessment order.’