Renew Your Membership by 31st October 2024! Renew Now!

April 2024

Income from other sources — Shares received at price higher than market value — Determination of fair market value — Change in prescribed formula with effect from 1st April 2018 — Formula that prevails during relevant A.Y. 2014–15 applicable — Application of amended formula as on date of assessment order by AO — Not sustainable.

By K B Bhujle | Ritu Punjabi, Advocates
Reading Time 2 mins

91 Principal CIT vs. Minda Sm Technocast Pvt. Ltd.

[2024] 460 ITR 7 (Del.)

A.Y.: 2014–15

Date of Order: 4th August, 2023

S. 56(2)(via) of ITA 1961: Rule 11UA of IT Rules 1962

Income from other sources — Shares received at price higher than market value — Determination of fair market value — Change in prescribed formula with effect from 1st April 2018 — Formula that prevails during relevant A.Y. 2014–15 applicable — Application of amended formula as on date of assessment order by AO — Not sustainable.

The assessee purchased 48 per cent of the equity of a company from three entities at a price of ₹5 per share. For the A.Y. 2014–15, the assessee submitted the valuation report of a chartered accountant who had determined the value of the shares at ₹4.96 per share in terms of rule 11UA of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, as applicable in the period in issue, i.e., the A.Y. 2014–15. The Assessing Officer valued the shares at ₹45.72 per share, taking into account rule 11UA of the Rules, as on the date when the order was passed and added the difference to the income of the assessee.

Read More

Download PDF

You May Also Like

Block assessment — Procedure — Notice u/s 143(2) — Condition precedent for block assessment — Failure to issue notice u/s 143(2) — Not a curable defect u/s 292BB.

Reassessment — Notice after three years — Limitation — Change in law — Effect of decision of Supreme Court in Ashish Agarwal — Conditions prescribed under amended provisions of section 149(1)(d) for extended period of limitation — Notices issued beyond limitation period stipulated under amended provisions of section 149(1)(a) not satisfying prescribed conditions — Barred by limitation. Reassessment — Notice after three years — Limitation — CBDT Instructions dated 11th May, 2022 — Validity — Instruction vague about “original date when such notices were to be issued” — Instruction to the extent it propounded “travel back in time” theory unsustainable.