Export profit : Deduction u/s. 80HHC of I. T. Act, 1961 : Export turnover and total turnover : Export sale price to be modified as per the approval by the RBI for including in the export turnover.

[CIT vs. M/s. Polycot Corporation (Bom); ITA No.
1241 of 2008: Dated 23.01.2009.]

In the appeal filed by the Revenue against the order of the
Tribunal, the Department had raised the following question :

“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the
case and law, is the Hon’ble ITAT right in directing the A.O. to compute the
deduction u/s. 80HHC of the Act after the books of account having been
closed/made up with the total export turnover ascertained, holding that the
reduction in the invoice amount having been approved by the RBI, the
original sales price stands modified to this extent and such modified price
only should be included as part of export turnover ?”

The Bombay High Court held as under :

“i) To avail of the benefit of Section 80HHC the proceeds
have to be brought into India within the time prescribed i.e., six
months or such extended period as may be allowed. In the instant case the
RBI granted time up to 30th June, 2001. The proceeds were brought into India
on 30 June, 2001.

ii) Here we may set out the areas of disagreement between
the Revenue and the assessee. It is the contention of the assessee that
while working out total turnover what will have to be considered is the
revenue which has been brought in during the course of that financial year
and if any moneys in respect of export proceeds have come subsequent to the
order of assessment, they will have to be considered in the said financial
year.

iii) The other factual aspect of the matter is that the
buyer proposed deduction in the export price, the respondents agreed to the
same after taking approval of the RBI to the extent of 30%. The respondents
are a totally export oriented unit. Moneys, therefore, in terms of the
approval granted by the RBI were brought in during the period as extended.

iv) The Tribunal in its order observed that once the RBI
has agreed to deduction in the invoice amount, the original sales price
stands modified and such modified price only should be taken as actual
export value. It is further observed that such adjusted export value should
only be included in the export turnover and the total turnover.

v) The contention of the Revenue was that, that should be
excluded from the export turnover.

vi) In our opinion, considering the facts and the
provisions of Section 80HHC, we cannot find fault with the conclusion
arrived at by the learned Tribunal.”