Deductions u/s.80-IB — Conditions stipulated U/ss.(2) of S. 80-IB are to be fulfilled only if eligible assessee is an industrial undertaking within meaning of Ss.(3) to Ss.(5) of said section — Where assessee was engaged in business of carrying out scient

Enem Nostrum Remedies (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT

A.Ys. : 2003-04 and 2004-05

Dated : 28-8-2008

Deductions u/s.80-IB — Conditions stipulated U/ss.(2) of S.
80-IB are to be fulfilled only if eligible assessee is an industrial
undertaking within meaning of Ss.(3) to Ss.(5) of said section — Where
assessee was engaged in business of carrying out scientific research and
development and was not an industrial undertaking and had been approved by
Government of India, for claiming benefit of deduction u/s.80-IB(8A),
conditions of Ss.(2) of S. 80-IB were not required to be fulfilled by it.

 

The assessee-company had been approved as an R&D company by
the department of scientific and industrial research. It claimed deduction
u/s.80-IB(8A). The Assessing Officer denied the deduction u/s.80-IB(8A) by
observing that :

(1) The assessee had not claimed deduction u/s.80-IB(8A)
in the initial year,

(2) Subsequent claim made by it in the relevant
assessment years could only lead to the surmise that its business was formed
by splitting up, or the reconstruction of a business already in existence;

(3) The certificate by the Chartered Accountant in Form
10CCB was not produced.

 

On appeal, the Commissioner (Appeals) held that the
assessee did not fulfill the conditions of S. 80-IB(2)(iii) as it was not
manufacturing or producing any article or thing, and, accordingly, upheld the
view of the Assessing Officer on a different count.

On second appeal by the assessee, the Tribunal held that :

(1) The four conditions stipulated U/ss.(2) of S. 80-IB
are to be fulfilled only if the eligible assessee is an industrial
undertaking within the meaning of S. (3) to S. (5) of said Section, as the
case may be.

(2) If the assessee is not an ‘industrial undertaking’
but is otherwise eligible for deduction under any of other sub-sections of
S. 80-IB, then there is no requirement for importing the conditions
stipulated in Ss.(2) of S. 80-IB which are applicable to industrial
undertakings.

(3) Since in the instant case, the assessee was engaged
in the business of carrying out scientific research and development and had
been approved by the Government of India, for claiming the benefit of
deduction u/s.80-IB(8A), the conditions of Ss.(2) of S. 80-IB were not
required to be fulfilled by it.

Based on the above observations, the Tribunal directed the
Assessing Officer to allow deduction as claimed by the assessee.