Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

July 2012

Corporate anonymity — Incorporation with limited liability is a privilege. It should not include anonymity.

By Tarunkumar Singhal, Raman Jokhakar, Chartered Accountants
Reading Time 2 mins
fiogf49gjkf0d
Limited liability — A commercial venture that protects its shareholders from personal bankruptcy —is one of the greatest wealth-creating inventions of all time. The law allows companies to borrow money, to take risks and to make contracts as if they were people, but without the human beings who own it going bust if things go wrong, as they would in an unlimited partnership.

Limited liability allowed Elizabethan adventurers to finance voyages to spice islands; it allows Silicon Valley technologists now to make similarly risky bets. But limited liability is a concession — something granted by society because it has a clear purpose. It is unclear why in parts of the world anonymity became part of the deal. Efforts to withdraw that unjustified perk deserve to succeed. In dozens of jurisdictions, from the British Virgin Islands to Delaware, it is possible to register a company while hiding or disguising the ultimate beneficial owner.

This is of great use to wrongdoers, and a huge headache for those who pursue them. Anonymously owned companies can buy property, make deals (and renege on them), launch intimidating lawsuits, manipulate tenders — and disappear when the going gets tough. Those who seek redress run into baffling bureaucracy and a legal morass. Seeking real names and addresses means dealing with lawyers and accountants who see it as their job to shield their clients from nosy outsiders.

Owning up

Reform ought to be simple. Anyone registering a limited company should have to declare the names of the real people who ultimately own it, wherever they are, and report any changes.

Lying about this should be a crime. Some dodgy places will try to hold out. But anti-money-laundering rules show international co-operation can work. You can no longer open an account at a respectable bank merely with a suitcase of cash. Let the same apply to starting a limited company.

You May Also Like