[CIT v. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti (2012) 348 ITR 566 (SC)]
Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, a market committee incorporated and registered u/s. 12 of the Uttar Pradesh Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964 (“the 1964 Adhiniyam” for short), carried out its activities in accordance with section 16 of the 1964 Adhiniyam, under which it is required to provided facilities for sale and purchase of specified agricultural produce in the market area. The members of the said market committee consisted of producers, brokers, agriculturists, traders, commission agents and arhatiyas. The source of income of the assessee was in the form of receipt collected as market fee from buyers and their agents, development cess on sale and purchase of agricultural products and licence fees from traders. U/s. 17(iv), the Mandi Samiti has to utilise the market committee fund the purpose of the 1964 Adhiniyam.
Under the 1964 Adhiniyam, broadly there are two distinct entities or bodies. One is Mandi Samiti (assessee) and the other is Mandi Parishad.
Section 26A of the 1964 Adhiniyam deals with establishment of the Mandi Parishad (Board). Under the 1964 Adhiniyam, the Board shall be a body corporate. Section 26A, inter alia, states that the Mandi Parishad (Board) shall have its own fund which shall be deemed to be a local fund and in which shall be credited all monies received by or on behalf of the Board, except monies required to be credited in the State Marketing Development Fund u/s. 26PP. U/s. 26PP, the State Marketing Development Fund has been established for the Mandi Parishad (Board) in which amounts received from the market committee u/s. 19(5) shall be credited. Section 19(5), inter alia, states that every market committee shall, out of its total receipts realised as development cess, shall pay to the Mandi Parishad (Board) contribution at a specified rate. The said payment from the Market Committee (Mandi Samiti) shall be credited to the State Marketing Development Fund u/s. 26PP. The State Marketing Development Fund shall be utilised by the Mandi Parishad (Board) for purposes indicated u/s. 26PP(2). Section 26PPP deals with establishment of Central Mandi Fund to which amounts specified in s/s. (1) shall be credited. Section 26PPP(2), inter alia, states that the Central Mandi Fund shall be utilised by the Mandi Parishad (Board) for rendering assistance to financially weak and underdeveloped market committees; that the funds would be used for construction, maintenance and repairs of link roads, market yards and other development works in the market area and such other purposes as may be directed by the State Government or the board.
The short question that arose before the Supreme Court was, whether transfer of amounts collected by Mandi Samiti to Mandi Parishad would constitute application of income for charitable purposes.
The Supreme Court noted that, both the Mandi Samiti and the Mandi Parishad were duly registered u/s. 12AA of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the 1961 Act”, for short). That, after the amendment of section 10(20) and section 10(29) by the Finance (No.2) 2 of 2002 with effect from 1st April, 2003, the words “local authority” had lost its restricted meaning and, therefore, the assessee (market committee) had to satisfy the conditions of section 12AA read with section 11(1)(a) of the 1961 Act, like any other body or person.
According to the learned senior counsel for the Department, in view of the said amendment, vide the Finance (No.2) Act of 2002, the assessee had to show that, during the relevant assessment year, income had been derived from property held under trust and that the said income stood applied to charitable purposes. According to the learned counsel, if one analysed the scheme of the 1964 Adhiniyam, it would become clear that the amounts transferred by the assessee to the Mandi Parishad could not constitute application of income for charitable purposes within the meaning of section 11(1)(a) of the 1961 Act in view of the fact that the assessee (Mandi Samiti) was only a conduit which collected Mandi shulk (fees) whereas utilisation of the said Mandi shulk was not by the assessee but is made by another entity, i.e., Mandi Parishad whose accounts were not verifiable and, therefore, according to the Department, such income would not get the benefit of exemption u/s. 11(1)(a) of the 1961 Act.
The Supreme Court held that u/s. 19(2) of the 1964 Adhiniyam, all expenditure incurred by the assessee in carrying out the purposes of the 1964 Adhiniyam (which includes advancing credit facilities to farmers and agriculturists as also construction of development works in the market area) had to be defrayed out of the market committee fund and the surplus, if any, had to be invested in such manner as may be prescribed. This was one circumstance in the 1964 Act to indicate application of income. Similarly, u/s. 19B(2) of the 1964 Adhiniyam, the assessee was statutorily obliged to apply the market development fund for the purposes of development of the market area. U/s. 19B(3), the assessee was statutorily obliged to utilise the amounts lying to the credit in the market development fund for extending facilities to the agriculturists, producers and payers of market fees. The market development fund was also to be statutorily utilised for development of market yards. Similarly, all contributions received by the market committee (Mandi Samiti) from the members u/s. 19(5) were to be statutorily paid by the market committee (assessee) to the Uttar Pradesh State Marketing Development Fund. These provisions indicated application of income of the assesee to the statutory funds set up under the 1964 Adhiniyam. According to the Supreme Court, keeping in mind the statutory scheme of the 1964 Adhiniyam, whose object falls u/s. 2(15) of the 1961 Act, there was no doubt that the assessee satisfied the conditions of section 11(1)(a) of the 1961 Act. The income derived by the assessee (which was an institution registered u/s. 12AA of the 1961 Act) from its property had been applied for charitable purposes, which includes advancement of an object of general public utility.
