Capital gain vs. Business income – A. Y. 2006-07 – Profit from purchase and sale of shares – Assessee not registered with any authority or body to trade in shares – Entire investment made out of assessee’s own funds – Purchase and sale of shares were for investment accepted by Department for earlier years – Gain from purchase and sale of shares cannot be taxed as business income

The
assessee company was incorporated in the year 1996 and the assessments
for the A. Ys. 2001-02 to 2005-06 had attained finality with the
Department, accepting the declaration made by the assessee, that it was
engaged in purchase and sale of shares as an investment. For the A. Y.
2006-07, the assessing Authority treated the short term capital gains
from purchase and sale of shares as income from business, and levied tax
at 30% instead of 10%, on the ground that the assessee was engaged in
the business of general trading in shares. The Tribunal allowed the
assessee’s claim that it is short term capital gain.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“i)
The assessee was not registered with any authority or body, such as
the Securities and Exchange Board of India to carry on trading in
shares. The entire investments were made out of the assessee’s own funds
and no material was placed on record by the Department to come to a
different conclusion.

ii) The factual finding by the Tribunal
was on a proper appreciation of facts. The Department could not change
its stand in subsequent years without change in material. The order was
passed by the Tribunal based on appreciation of documents and recording
reasons, which were not considered by the Assessing Authority as well as
the first Appellate Authority. The contention of the Department that
the assessee was dealing in stockin- trade and not investment, could not
be accepted and no substantial question of law arose for
consideration.”