51 Loss – Carry forward and set off – Section 72(1) – A. Y. 2005-06 – Loss of current year and carried forward loss of earlier year from non-speculative business can be set off against profit of speculative business of current year

The assessee filed Nil return for A. Y. 2005-06, after setting off loss of the earlier year to the extent of profit. The Assessing Officer computed the total income at Rs. 2,17,46,490, treating the share trading business as speculative profit to an amount of Rs. 3,84,09,932. The Commissioner (Appeals) enhanced the income and held that the amount of Rs. 3,84,09,932 was to be taxed and the business loss of Rs. 1,66,63,443 was to be carried forward after verification by the assessing authority. The Tribunal allowed the assessee’s appeal and directed the Assessing Officer to allow the set off of loss from non-speculative business against profit from speculative business.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Department contended that section 72(1) provided that the non-speculative business loss could be set off against “profit and gains, if any, of any business or profession” carried on by the assessee and was assessable in that assessment year, and when it could not be so set off, it should be carried forward to the following assessment year.

The Allahabad High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal and held as under:

“The order of the Tribunal, based on material facts and supported by the decisions of Supreme Court and the High Court, need not be interfered with. The appeal filed by the Department is accordingly dismissed.”