By G. G. Goyal | Chartered Accountant
C. B. Thakar | Advocate
fiogf49gjkf0d
Sales Tax — Power of Appellate Authority — Penalty — Cannot be levied for the first time by Appellate Authorities — Section 36(2)(C), 55 and 57 of BST Act — Section 9(2A) of CST Act.
Facts:
The appellant, manufacturer of computers, was assessed for the period from 1st May, 1986 to April 30, 1987 under the CST Act, 1956. The appellant filed appeal against the assessment order before the Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax (Appeal) who allowed the appeal partly and imposed penalty u/s.9(2A) of the CST Act r.w.s. 36(2)(C), Explanation (2) of the BST Act, after giving opportunity of hearing to the appellant, for failure to file returns in time, by passing separate order. The appellant filed appeal before the Tribunal against such penalty order. The Tribunal confirmed the order of penalty passed by the DC (Appeal). The Tribunal, at the instance of the appellant and as per direction of the Court, referred substantial question of law before the Bombay High Court.
Held:
The High Court, considering provisions of section 36(2)(C) and section 55 of the Act, held that as per section 55(6)(a) and (b) of the Act, the Appellate Authority concerned did not have any power of imposing penalty for the first time and expression ‘confer or cancel such order or very it, so as to either enhance or to reduce the penalty’ employed in section 55(6)(b), neither covered the power to impose a fresh penalty for the first time nor did it confer any power upon the Appellate Authority to pass any order of penalty while deciding the appeal. Further it held that on the correct interpretation of section 36(2)(c) of the Act the Tribunal was not justified in holding that the DC (Appeal) in exercise of Appellate power had jurisdiction to initiate action for imposing penalty for the first time.
