Gift Or Will Or Settlement – What’s The Difference?

INTRODUCTION

Is a Gift Deed the same as an Instrument of Settlement, and are both of them the same as a Will? The answer is a resounding No!! However, what are the metrics used to distinguish one instrument from another? What tests would the Courts apply to decipher this question? The answers to all these questions and many others were given by the Supreme Court in its decision in the case of N. P. Saseendran vs.N. P. Ponnamma, CA No.4312/2025 Order dated 24^th March, 2025. This decision can be considered somewhat a landmark decision since it has laid down various tests and has threadbare analysed 21 other landmark Supreme Court judgements on this point. This Article seeks to analyse the salient points of this judgement.

FACTS OF THE CASE

In Saseendran’s case (Supra), a father executed an instrument of settlement transferring his immovable property in favour of his daughter but at the same time reserving life interest for himself. He reserved the right to income generated from the property and also during his wife’s lifetime. He also had the right to mortgage the property up to a certain amount. Possession was transferred to his daughter. The daughter donee got the registration of the instrument done. After a period of 7