Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

April 2024

Sec. 40A(2)(b).: Disallowance u/s 40A(2)(b) is not justified on merely estimating that more income should have been earned from subcontracting without bringing any comparable figures.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant
Devendra Jain, Advocate
Reading Time 3 mins

68 Tapi JWIL JV vs. Income-tax Officer

[2023] 108 ITR(T) 27 (Delhi - Trib.)

ITA NO. 6722 (DELHI) OF 2018

A.Y.: 2014-15

Date of Order: 16th October, 2023

Sec. 40A(2)(b).: Disallowance u/s 40A(2)(b) is not justified on merely estimating that more income should have been earned from subcontracting without bringing any comparable figures.

FACTS

M/s TAPI Prestressed Products Ltd. (‘TPPL’) and M/s JITF Water Infrastructure Ltd. (‘JWIL’) had entered into an agreement to form a Joint Venture (JV) with the specific purpose of bidding for construction of 318 MLD 70 MGD Sewage Pumping Station etc. on design, build and operate basis. The contract was awarded by Delhi Jal Board to the assessee JV. TPPL had executed the work and raised bills for ₹15,02,04,381/- to the assessee JV. The assessee JV had raised bills for ₹15,52,33,963/- to Delhi Jal Board. The assessee JV had filed its ITR declaring total income of ₹1,75,600/-.

The AO had passed the assessment order u/s 143(3) in the status of AOP, determining the total income at

Read More
Download PDF

You May Also Like

Sec. 69B.: Where the assessee has provided the necessary explanation about the nature and source of unrecorded transactions / assets and the necessary nexus with assessee’s business income has been established, such unrecorded transactions cannot be considered as unexplained and thus, deeming provisions of section 69B cannot be invoked.

Article 5 of India-Singapore DTAA — For computation of duration of Service PE, only time spent in India needs to be considered. Presence in India should not include days during which employees did not render any services to the client such as days of vacation and business development. Further, presence should be computed based on solar days i.e. day on which more than one employee is present in India should be counted as one day.