Subscribe to the Bombay Chartered Accountant Journal Subscribe Now!

March 2024

No exemption under section 54F is allowable in respect of a building which was predominantly used for religious purposes. Section 54F does not allow pro-rata exemption.

By Jagdish T Punjabi, Chartered Accountant
Devendra Jain, Advocate
Reading Time 2 mins

59 ACIT vs. Shri Iqbal Ali Khan

ITA No.: 505 / Hyd / 2020

A.Y.: 2013-14

Date of Order: 12th January, 2024

Section: 54F

No exemption under section 54F is allowable in respect of a building which was predominantly used for religious purposes.

Section 54F does not allow pro-rata exemption.

FACTS

The assessee sold two properties for a total consideration of ₹8.81 crores, resulting in capital gain of ₹7.21 crores.

He claimed exemption under section 54F to the extent of ₹5.47 crores, by constructing a building consisting of ground floor plus three floors in Hyderabad.

The assessee had not taken any municipal permission before starting the construction.

However, subsequently, in the application forregularization dated 31st December, 2015 filed with the municipal authorities, it was stated that the property consisted of a mosque, orphanage school and staff quarters.

The Assessi

Read More
Download PDF

You May Also Like

Where the assessee transferred 62 per cent of the land to a developer in exchange for 38 per cent of the developed area to be constructed over time under an unregistered joint development agreement / irrevocable power of attorney, the transaction was liable to capital gain under section 2(47)(vi) in the year of the agreement.

Where pursuant to a scheme of arrangement and restructuring, assessee’s shareholding in a company was reduced, long-term capital loss arising to assessee on account of reduction of capital has to be allowed even if no consideration is paid to the assessee.