ETHICS AND U

Shrikrishna: Arjun, are you reading something? Shall we meet later?

Arjun: Bhagwan, please don’t say so. There is nothing more important in
my life than meeting you! Good that you came.

Shrikrishna: Why? What are you reading? I rarely see you referring to any book. Oh!
It’s a dictionary!

Arjun: Yes. Looking for a very strange word. I referred to three dictionaries,
but did not find it. It is an English word NOCLAR.

Shrikrishna: Where did you come across it?

Arjun: Yesterday, in some CPE seminar everybody around was talking about it.
They said it is very serious. Something like a disease.

Shrikrishna: (laughs) It is not a disease, but it will certainly make one Un-easy.

Arjun: What is it about? Is it going to add to our thankless burdens?

Shrikrishna: Yes, to some extent. It depends on how you take it.

Arjun: But why is that word not there in any dictionary?

Shrikrishna: Dear Paarth, it is only an acronym like your CARO. It means your
response to ‘Non-Compliances with Laws and Regulations’.

Arjun: Oh! Interesting. But wherever we go for audit, we see nothing but
non-compliance only. Anyway, what are we supposed to do then?

Shrikrishna: See, you know IESBA?

Arjun: Who is this ‘Yesba’?

Shrikrishna: (smiles) He is not a
person but a body – called International Ethics Standards Board for
Accountants. They issue guidelines for the Public Accountants (PA’s).

Arjun: Yes, our ICAI also has an ESB. What next?

Shrikrishna: While doing the audit or any other work of a company, if you come
across any non-compliance with any law or regulation which is of a very serious
nature, or which is illegal, then the question is how does a PA respond to it?
Whether he should act as a whistle-blower and expose the illegalities, or just
keep quiet?

Arjun: To tell you the truth, all these years, we CA’s have been keeping quiet
only. We never had the courage to speak out. That is why we are taken for a
ride.

Shrikrishna: I understand. You have a fear that you will lose your client. There is
a feeling of insecurity among the practising accountants like you. But remember
that NOCLAR applies not only to practising CAs, but it also covers the
accountants in employment.

Arjun: Baap-re! This is even more dangerous. Many accountants will have
to quit their jobs.

Shrikrishna: As an enlightened citizen and professional you cannot turn a blind eye
to the illegalities.

Arjun: That is exactly what Dhrutarashtra Uncle did in Mahabharata. If
he had done his duty conscientiously, the entire war and disaster could have
been avoided.

Shrikrishna: Wah, Arjun. What an apt example! That means you have understood
what NOCLAR is… I don’t have to explain it to you any further.

Arjun: No, Bhagwan, you can’t leave just like that. Please tell me what
exactly we are supposed to do? Since when will it be applicable? Where is it to
be reported? Does it cover fraud, corruption and bribery? Does it also include
money laundering? You need to tell me all this.

Shrikrishna: (smiles) Yes, dear. We need to discuss it in detail. All accountants
are now worried as to how they should tackle this. It will be very embarrassing
for anyone to expose the illegalities of the clients. It will be a serious threat
to the client as well as to the accountant.

Arjun: If it is so damaging then why bring this regulation at all.

Shrikrishna: Remember, Arjun, your
client as well as you yourself are a part of the society and the country. A company may have its vested self-interest in doing illegal acts. You as
auditors or service providers are indirect beneficiaries of the client’s business. But one must see whether such
illegal or irregular acts can be sustained by a client for a long time. Some
day or the other, the irregularities are bound to get exposed. Such acts cause
irreparable damage to the society and the country. If educated professionals
like you overlook or ignore these things, then you are breaching the trust
reposed in you. If such things continue, the social atmosphere will continue to
worsen.

Arjun: I agree. Is this the reason why some big firms are giving up a few
audit assignments? This is all very interesting. Tell me further.

Shrikrishna: I’m in a hurry. You please read it yourself. We will discuss it again
next time.

Om Shanti

This dialogue
is based on the new concept emerging in the profession – NOCLAR.