July 2023
Search and seizure — Assessment in search cases — Effect of insertion of section 153D by Finance Act, 2007 — CBDT circular dated 12th March, 2008 and Manual of Office Procedure laying down the condition of approval of draft order of Commissioner — Circular and Manual binding on Income-tax authorities — Approval granted without application of mind — Order of assessment — Not valid.
25. ACIT Vs. Serajuddin and Co.
[2023] 454 ITR 312 (Orissa)
A. Ys.: 2009-10
Date of order: 15th March, 2023
Sections: 153A and 153D of ITA 1961.
Search and seizure — Assessment in search cases — Effect of insertion of section 153D by Finance Act, 2007 — CBDT circular dated 12th March, 2008 and Manual of Office Procedure laying down the condition of approval of draft order of Commissioner — Circular and Manual binding on Income-tax authorities — Approval granted without application of mind — Order of assessment — Not valid.The search and seizure operation was carried out in the case of assessee and various other persons and concerns of the assessee. Subsequently, assessments were completed and orders were passed under section 143(3)/144/153A after making various additions/disallowances.
The assessment orders were challenged in appeal. One of the grounds for challenge was in respect of non-compliance with section 153D which required prior approval of the Additional Commissioner (Addl. CIT). Further, the approval had been granted in a mechanical manner without application of mind. The CIT(A) observed that a consolidated approval order given by the Addl. CIT for A.Ys. 2003-04 to 2009-10 and therefore held, partly allowing the appeal, that it was not necessary for the AO to mention the fact of approval in the body of the assessment order. The Tribunal concluded that the approval was granted without appli
