46. CIT vs. Reliance Industries Ltd. [2020] 423 ITR 236 (Bom.) Date of order: 15th January, 2019
Deemed income – Section 41(1) of ITA, 1961 – Remission or cessation of
trading liability – Condition precedent for application of section 41(1) –
Deduction must have been claimed for the liability – Gains on repurchase of
debenture bonds – Not assessable u/s 41(1)
The
assessee had issued foreign currency bonds in the years 1996 and 1997 carrying
a coupon rate of interest ranging between 10 and 11% and having a maturity
period of 30 to 100 years. The interest was payable half-yearly. According to
the assessee, on account of the attack on the World Trade Centre in the USA on
11th September, 2001, the financial market collapsed and the
investors of debentures and bonds started selling them which, in turn, brought
down the market price of such bonds and debentures which were traded in the
market at less than the face value. The assessee, therefore, purchased such
bonds and debentures from the market and extinguished them. In the process of
buyback, the assessee gained a sum of Rs. 38.80 crores. The A.O. treated this
as assessable to tax in terms of section 41(1) and made addition accordingly.
The
Commissioner (Appeals) deleted the addition. The Tribunal confirmed the
decision of the Commissioner (Appeals).
On
appeal by the Revenue, the Bombay High Court upheld the decision of the
Tribunal and held as under:
‘i) For
applicability of section 41(1), it is a sine qua non that there should
be an allowance or deduction claimed by the assessee in any assessment year in
respect of loss, expenditure or trading liability incurred. Then, subsequently,
during any previous year, if the creditor remits or waives any such liability,
the assessee is liable to pay tax u/s 41(1).
ii) It
was not the case of the Revenue that in the process of issuing the bonds the
assessee had claimed deduction of any trading liability in any year. Any
extinguishment of such liability would not give rise to applicability of
sub-section (1) of section 41.’
