TDS – Fees for technical services- Section 194J – Assessee purchasing and selling electricity – Transmission of electricity by State Power Transmission Corporation – Not technical services – Tax not deductible u/s. 194J on amount paid for such transmission –

ACIT vs. Gulbarga Electricity Supply Co. Ltd.- 387 ITR 484
(Karn):

The
assessee was in the business of buying and selling of electricity. The assessee
purchased electricity from the generators of the Karnataka Power Corporation
etc. and sold it to different categories of consumers in its jurisdiction. The
power from the generation point to the customers was  transmitted 
through  the  transmission 
network  of the Corporation. The
Assessing Officer found that the assessee had made payment of transmission charges
to the Corporation, without deducting tax at source thereon. He held that the
assessee was an assessee in default u/s. 201(1) of the income-tax act, 1961 in
respect of payment of transmission charges u/s. 194J. The Commissioner
(appeals) and the tribunal set aside the order.

On
appeal by the revenue, the Karnataka High Court upheld the decision of the Tribunal
and held as under:

“i)
 The 
provisions of section 194J  of the
act, was not attracted in the present case and the assessee was not liable to
deduct the tax at source from the payment of transmission charges made to the
Corporation and the order of the Assessing Officer was rightly set aside by the
tribunal.

ii)  Accordingly, appeal of the revenue is
dismissed.”