Section 254 — Ex-parte order passed for non-appearance as the assessee’s representative went to attend phone call when the matter came up for hearing – Whether reasonable and sufficient ground for non-appearance — Held : Yes.

11. Ajanta Offset & Packaging Ltd. vs. DCIT

ITAT
Delhi Bench ‘Friday’ New Delhi

Before I. P. Bansal (J.M.) and R. C. Sharma (A.M.)

MA No.459/D/08 in ITA No.1510/Del./2007

A. Y.
2001-02. Decided on 27.03.2009

Counsel for Revenue/Assessee : V. P. Gupta and Basant Kumar/B. K. Gupta

 

Section 254 — Ex-parte order passed for non-appearance as
the assessee’s representative went to attend phone call when the matter came
up for hearing – Whether reasonable and sufficient ground for non-appearance —
Held : Yes.

Per I. P. Bansal

Facts :

Vide
miscellaneous application the assessee has sought recall of the ex-parte
order passed by the Tribunal. According to the assessee, its director was
present in the Court for taking adjournment, as the counsel of the assessee
was busy in the High Court waiting for his turn. When the case of the assessee
was to come for hearing, the director had gone out of the Courtroom to attend
to the phone call and when he came back, the case was already decided as
ex-parte.

Held :

The
Tribunal was satisfied with the explanation and held that the assessee was
prevented by reasonable and sufficient cause for non-appearance before the
Tribunal. Accordingly, as per Rule 24 of the Appellate Tribunal Rules, 1983,
the ex-parte order passed was set aside.

Note :

All the decisions
reported above are selected from the website www.itatindia.com.