TDS : Fees for technical services : Ss.9(1)(vii) & 195 : Payment for use of Internet bandwidth is not fees for technical services : No obligation to deduct tax at source from payment.

[CIT v. Estel Communications (P) Ltd., 217 CTR 102
(Del.)]

The assessee was using Internet bandwidth of US party,
Teleglobe, for providing access to its subscribers. For the services
rendered by the assessee to the subscribers in India, it levies a charge and
out of this, some amount is paid to the US party. The Assessing Officer
invoked the provisions of S. 9(1)(i) and S. 9(1)(vii) of the Income-tax Act,
1961 and held that the assessee is liable to deduct tax at source from the
payments made to the US party. The Tribunal held that the assessee is not
liable to deduct tax at source.

On appeal by the Revenue, the Delhi High Court upheld the
decision of the Tribunal and held as under :

“(i) The Tribunal considered the agreement that had been
entered into by the assessee with Teleglobe and came to the conclusion that
there was no privity of contract between the customers of the assessee and
Teleglobe. In fact, the assessee was merely paying for an Internet bandwidth
to Teleglobe and then selling it to the customers.

(ii) The use of Internet facility may require
sophisticated equipment, but that does not mean that technical services were
rendered by Teleglobe to the assessee. It was a simple case of purchase of
Internet band width by the assessee from Teleglobe. No technical services
were rendered by Teleglobe to the assessee.

(iii) The Tribunal has rightly dismissed the appeal after taking into
consideration the agreement between the assessee and Teleglobe and the
nature of services provided by Teleglobe to the assessee.”